Karnal Bunt Regulated Areas

Federal RegisterJun 2, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service

7 CFR Part 301

[Docket No. 96-016-24]

RIN 0579-AA83

Karnal Bunt Regulated Areas

AGENCY: Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, USDA.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: We are adopting as a final rule, with changes, an interim rule

that amended the Karnal bunt regulations by modifying the criteria for

classifying regulated areas and by modifying the classification of

restricted areas. The interim rule required that a bunted wheat kernel

be found in or associated with a field within an area before that area

would be designated as a regulated area. The interim rule also

established separate restricted areas for seed and for regulated

articles other than seed. The actions taken in the interim rule were

necessary because tests currently available for use in identifying

spores do not allow us to differentiate between small numbers of Karnal

bunt spores and the spores of an as yet unnamed, but widely

distributed, ryegrass smut. The interim rule had the effect of removing

some areas in Arizona and California from the list of regulated areas

and relieving restrictions on the movement of grain and other regulated

articles from additional areas in Arizona, California, New Mexico, and

Texas.

EFFECTIVE DATE: June 2, 1999.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mr. Mike Stefan, Operations Officer,

Domestic and Emergency Operations, PPQ, APHIS, 4700 River Road Unit

134, Riverdale, MD 20737-1236, (301) 734-8247.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Karnal bunt is a fungal disease of wheat

(Triticum aestivum), durum wheat (Triticum durum), and triticale

(Triticum aestivum X Secale cereale), a hybrid of wheat and rye. Karnal

bunt is caused by the smut fungus Tilletia indica (Mitra) Mundkur and

is spread by spores, primarily through the movement of infected seed.

In the absence of measures taken by the U.S. Department of Agriculture

(USDA) to prevent its spread, the establishment of Karnal bunt in the

United States could have significant consequences with regard to the

export of wheat to international markets. The regulations regarding

Karnal bunt are set forth in 7 CFR 301.89-1 through 301.89-14.

In an interim rule effective on April 25, 1997, and published in

the Federal Register on May 1, 1997 (62 FR 23620-23628, Docket No. 96-

016-19), we amended the Karnal bunt regulations by modifying the

criteria for classifying regulated areas. We required that a bunted

wheat kernel be found in or associated with a field within an area

before that area would be designated as a regulated area. In that

interim rule, we also modified the classification of restricted areas

by establishing separate restricted areas for seed and for regulated

articles other than seed.

We solicited comments concerning the interim rule for 60 days

ending June 2, 1997. We received 13 comments by that date. They were

from five State agricultural agencies, three associations representing

grain growers and processors, a food corporation, a grain handler, a

wheat grower, and a scientific society. One of the commenters fully

supported the interim rule as written. The remaining 12 commenters

expressed concerns or made suggestions regarding certain aspects of the

interim rule, although 8 of those commenters did offer their support

for the changes contained in the interim rule. The issues raised by

those 12 commenters are discussed in detail below.

Comment: The definition of infestation (infected) in Sec. 301.89-1

of the regulations states that an area is infected if any stage of the

fungus Tilletia indica (Mitra) Mundkur is present. Section 301.89-3(e)

lists several criteria that are used to classify regulated areas, with

the classification of regulated areas being based on the discovery of

bunted kernels. If the discovery of bunted kernels is now the criterion

on which an area is regulated, rather than the detection of spores,

should the definition of infestation (infected) be modified to reflect

that change?

Response: If the discovery of bunted kernels was the sole criterion

on which an area's regulatory status was based, it would be appropriate

to modify the definition of infestation (infected) as suggested by the

commenter. However, Sec. 301.89-3(e) still provides for the designation

of regulated areas based on the detection of spores in a field when

that field is found to be associated with grain at a handling facility

containing a bunted wheat kernel. Therefore, it would be inaccurate to

base the definition of infestation (infected) only on the detection of

bunted kernels.

Comment: Is the designation of regulated areas in Sec. 301.89-3(f)

valid only for the 1996-1997 crop production year? Since those

regulated areas differ from those regulated in the 1995-1996 crop year,

will the 1996-1997 regulated areas be modified for the 1997-1998 crop

year? If so, what criteria will be used to define those areas?

Response: We do not intend to update the list of regulated areas in

Sec. 301.89-3(f) on a ``crop year'' basis as envisioned by the

commenter. Rather, we will continue to amend the list of regulated

areas when the situation warrants, removing areas from the list when we

determine that it is no longer necessary to regulate them to prevent

the spread of Karnal bunt and adding new areas to the list based upon

the detection of Karnal bunt. The criteria used to define regulated

areas are found in Sec. 301.89-3.

Comment: In Sec. 301.89-3(d), we would suggest that State plant

regulatory officials be included in the written notification of the

designation of an area as a regulated area. It is vital that State and

Federal agencies interact closely with industry on this issue.

Response: Paragraph (d) of Sec. 301.89-3 deals with the temporary

designation of a nonregulated area as a regulated area. Because the

movement of regulated articles from the temporarily designated

regulated area will be subject to the regulations, the written

notification is directed to the person most immediately affected by the

designation of an area as a regulated area, i.e., the owner or person

in possession of the land or, in the case of

[[Page 29542]]

publicly owned land, the person responsible for the management of the

land. The notification of State plant regulatory officials in such

cases is handled by the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service

(APHIS) State Plant Health Director in each State and through updates

to the National Agricultural Pest Information Service database that is

maintained by the joint APHIS/State Cooperative Agricultural Pest

Survey. We do not, therefore, believe that it is necessary to include

State officials in the notification provisions of Sec. 301.89-3(d) to

ensure that they receive timely notice of the temporary designation of

nonregulated areas as regulated areas.

Comment: Intensive surveys should be conducted to ensure continued

confidence in the freedom of areas released from regulation and areas

outside the regulated area. It would be scientifically invalid to

assume that the bunted kernel fields now regulated will be the only

fields in which viable Karnal bunt spores may exist. The needs of the

wheat industry in the Southwest should be considered in APHIS'

regulatory decisionmaking, but the credibility of the U.S. export

certification program must be maintained for the benefit of the entire

nation. A thorough survey program will validate the regulatory program

and ensure continued confidence in our exports.

Response: We agree with the commenter's position regarding the need

for maintaining adequate delimiting surveys and detection programs. Our

work in that respect continues on two fronts. First, there are the

survey and detection activities that are carried out as part of the

regulatory program within those areas of Arizona, California, New

Mexico, and Texas that have been designated as regulated areas. In

addition to the regulatory program, we are also conducting an ongoing

National Survey of all wheat production areas in the United States in

order to gather information about the presence or absence of Karnal

bunt. The phytosanitary requirements of some of our trading partners

necessitate the collection of documentable evidence that production

areas are not infested at detectable levels. Without that

documentation, we cannot provide the certifications that allow wheat to

be sold into certain foreign markets. The intensity of this survey will

provide a high level of confidence that Karnal bunt is not detectable

in those parts of our wheat production system that contribute to the

export trade. As well as identifying areas that are free of Karnal bunt

infestations, the National Survey will provide information about

potential infections in new areas. By the end of 1997, the National

Survey had covered all wheat growing areas of the United States where

Karnal bunt had not previously been detected. In the National Survey,

composite wheat samples are collected at county elevators, feed mills,

seed laboratories, and seed trade and research locations. During 1996,

the first year Karnal bunt was known to be present in the United

States, 15,000 samples were collected and processed. By the end of

1997, over 11,000 additional composite samples had been collected, in

proportion to wheat production, from wheat-producing areas where Karnal

bunt had not been detected. We believe that our ongoing regulatory

program and National Survey activities provide the assurances sought by

the commenter and by our trading partners regarding the Karnal bunt

status of areas released from regulation and areas outside the

regulated areas.

Comment: APHIS should use the selective sieve technique, rather

than a bunted kernel search technique, to check samples from the pre-

release survey. The selective sieve technique can be used to eliminate

samples that do not require further inspection so that efforts can be

concentrated on those samples that do. In addition, all samples should

be processed in a timely manner, rather than being processed as time

allows.

Response: We have not limited ourselves to using any one method of

examining samples, and we do not believe it is necessary to do so. In

order to make the best use of our resources, we use the methodology

best suited to the situation and operational circumstances at hand.

Currently, the bunted kernel search technique is used in our survey

activities in the regulated areas. The selective sieve technique, which

involves the washing of grain samples and the subsequent examination of

only those samples from which spores were collected, cannot be

performed in the field. The bunted kernel search technique can be

performed expeditiously in the field. Therefore, while the selective

sieve technique may meet our operational needs in other situations, it

does not meet the need for quick results in the field test situation.

Comment: The current seed treatment requirement is a costly

procedure that could be a marketing problem within California and

abroad if it is determined that excess chemicals were used in the

production of California wheat. APHIS should review the efficacy of the

required seed treatments, their adverse effects on germination, and

whether the prescribed use of carboxin thiram and

pentachloronitrobenzene is consistent with the labeling of those

chemicals.

Response: We are satisfied that the use of carboxin thiram and

pentachloronitrobenzene as a double-fungicide treatment under

Sec. 301.89-13(d) is consistent with the labeling of those chemicals.

With regard to their effects on germination, preliminary data from

research gathered by APHIS' Karnal bunt regulatory program staff and

the Arizona Department of Agriculture suggested that the double-

fungicide treatment may negatively affect germination in some varieties

of seed. Specifically, this research data indicated that for the seed

varieties tested, double-treated seed may germinate at a lower rate

than untreated seed in some cases. However, as a result of our

continuing efficacy research, three single-fungicide treatment options

have been made available for seed originating in a regulated area that

will be planted within a regulated area. Those single-fungicide

treatments were added to Sec. 301.89-13(d) by an interim rule that was

effective on November 28, 1997, and published in the Federal Register

on December 5, 1997 (62 FR 64263-64265, Docket No. 96-016-27). In

answer to the commenter's concerns, the single-fungicide treatments now

available will reduce the cost of seed treatment and lessen the level

of chemicals used in the production of wheat. Further, we anticipate

that single-treated seeds may in some cases have germination rates

slightly higher than double-treated seeds. It should be noted, however,

that many factors affect germination, and it is not possible to

attribute increase or decrease in germination only to seed treatments.

Comment: The presence of regulated areas within California has

resulted in Mexico placing restrictions on the importation of wheat

from all wheat-producing areas of California. APHIS should ensure that

California wheat produced outside the regulated areas receives the same

consideration by our trading partners as wheat produced elsewhere in

the United States.

Response: APHIS routinely seeks to answer any concerns raised by

our trading partners regarding the phytosanitary status of U.S.-grown

agricultural commodities. Addressing concerns related to Karnal bunt

has been a part of our activities since the disease was first detected

in this country. Since that initial detection, APHIS has been able to

maintain export markets for U.S. wheat in more than three dozen

countries with concerns about Karnal bunt. In an instance such

[[Page 29543]]

as that brought up by the commenter, APHIS will act to address the

concerns of our trading partners and will seek the removal of any

unjustifiable phytosanitary restrictions.

Comment: The move by APHIS to regulate areas based on their

association with bunted kernels was a good one. However, the

restrictions placed on wheat grown as seed in the regulated area is not

consistent with that approach. If wheat seed grown in a regulated area

was found to contain spores (and is thus ineligible for planting), the

seed could be designated as grain and moved out of the regulated area

without restriction if it was grown in the area outside the

surveillance area. On the other hand, if grain to be moved from within

a surveillance area is found to have spores, it must move under a

limited permit. If testing cannot positively determine the presence of

Karnal bunt on the basis of spores alone, then none of this seed or

grain can be considered infected.

Response: We explained in the interim rule that grain from a

surveillance area found to contain spores must be moved under a limited

permit because it originated in an area that includes at least one

field in which a bunted wheat kernel had been detected, and that the

link to bunted wheat kernels gave us reason to believe that grain

containing spores was at greater risk for being infected with Karnal

bunt. We agree with the commenter's observation that current testing

methods cannot be used to determine the presence of Karnal bunt on the

basis of spores alone. It was that fact that led to the interim rule's

amendments to the Karnal bunt regulations to require that an area or

regulated article be associated with a bunted kernel before regulatory

restrictions would be applied. Following the publication of the interim

rule, we further amended the regulations (63 FR 50747-50752, Docket No.

96-016-32, published September 23, 1998) to allow the certified

movement of grain for uses other than seed if the grain was tested

prior to movement from the field, or before being commingled with other

grain, and found free of bunted kernels only, rather than Karnal bunt

spores and bunted kernels.

Comment: APHIS should recognize that Karnal bunt is a minor

disease--it is more a quality or grading issue than it is a quarantine

pest issue--and should remove its importation and interstate movement

restrictions and encourage our trading partners to adopt the same view.

Response: Given the continuing international perception of Karnal

bunt as a quarantine pest issue, we do not believe that it would serve

the interests of American agriculture to unilaterally remove our

regulatory restrictions through which we seek to prevent the

introduction and dissemination of Karnal bunt. The position that Karnal

bunt is a grading issue rather than a quarantine issue is one that has

been discussed in international trade and scientific circles, but until

such time as our trading partners view the disease as a grading issue,

we believe that it will be necessary to continue our Karnal bunt-

related regulatory activities and restrictions in order to protect our

international agricultural standing.

Comment: The Palo Verde Valley of California should not be a

surveillance area. The bunted kernels found in storage there were found

in facilities that were not cleaned prior to the storage of the 1996

crop, and no bunted kernels were found in any trucks hauling the

valley's 1996 crop. Given the low spore counts, it is unlikely any

bunted kernels could now be found.

Response: As we stated in the interim rule, the regulatory status

of the Palo Verde Valley is based on the presence of fields within the

valley that are considered to be positive for Karnal bunt. Those fields

had not been examined individually for bunted wheat kernels during the

1996 surveys, but they were found to contain spores. Further, grain

from those fields was part of a commingled lot of grain at a storage

facility that was found to contain bunted wheat kernels. However,

because the grain in that commingled lot came from several sources, the

bunted kernels could not be traced back to any individual field or

fields. It is the combination of spores in the fields and bunted wheat

kernels in grain associated with the fields that gives us reason to

believe that those fields are affected with Karnal bunt. At the present

time, we believe that regulatory restrictions on the Palo Verde Valley

should remain in place because we do not possess sufficient data that

would allow us to change our conclusion that those fields, and the

areas that surround them, are associated with Karnal bunt. Although the

programmatic classification of ``surveillance area'' was removed in a

final rule effective on April 28, 1999, and published on May 4, 1999

(64 FR 23749-23754, Docket No. 96-016-36), we retained the Palo Verde

Valley as a regulated area for the same reasons that the area was

designated as a surveillance area in the interim rule. However, we will

continue to reevaluate the regulatory status of areas, including the

Palo Verde Valley, as additional information becomes available.

Comment: If seed treatment is truly effective and significantly

reduces the possibility of spreading Karnal bunt, then seed treatment

should be required for all seed planted in the United States.

Similarly, if the treatment is effective, then treated seed from a

regulated area should be approved for planting outside the regulated

areas.

Response: With regard to requiring treatment for all seed planted

in the United States, we believe that it would be an unjustifiable

burden from a risk standpoint to require the treatment of seed that has

no association with Karnal bunt. As for the commenter's suggestion

about allowing treated seed from a regulated area to be planted outside

the regulated areas, we did amend our regulations on September 23, 1998

(63 FR 50747-50752, Docket No. 96-016-32) to allow, among other things,

commercial lots of treated seed from that portion of the restricted

area for seed lying outside the surveillance area to be moved outside

the regulated area for planting. However, that provision was rendered

unnecessary, and was therefore removed, by a subsequent final rule

effective on April 28, 1999, and published on May 4, 1999 (64 FR 23749-

23754, Docket No. 96-016-36). The May 1999 final rule removed the

programmatic classification of ``restricted area for seed'' and

released nearly all of the areas that had been designated as such from

regulation, thus making it possible for seed to be moved from those

areas without restriction.

Comment: Paragraph (f) of Sec. 301.89-3 of the interim rule states

that the areas listed in the section are designated as ``regulated

areas,'' and that those regulated areas are designated as either

``restricted areas'' or ``surveillance areas.'' Paragraph (a) of

Sec. 301.89-5 of the interim rule states that any regulated article

(i.e., certain articles from a regulated area) may be moved into or

through an area that is not regulated only if moved under certain

conditions. That restriction on the movement of regulated articles

would seem to apply to the movement of grain from any part of the

regulated area, but it appears that this is not the intent of the

interim rule. As explained in the interim rule, grain is a regulated

article, but its movement is restricted only from a surveillance area

and not from the entire regulated area, which includes the restricted

area for seed that extends beyond the surveillance area.

Response: The commenter is correct. The intent of the interim rule

was that:

Grain (wheat, durum wheat, and triticale) may not be grown

in a

[[Page 29544]]

restricted area for regulated articles other than seed. Because grain

may not be grown in such an area, there was no need to provide for the

movement of grain from a restricted area for regulated articles other

than seed. This was spelled out in the interim rule.

Grain may be grown in a surveillance area, and may be

eligible for movement from a surveillance area with a certificate under

the conditions set forth in Sec. 301.89-6(b). This, too, was spelled

out in the interim rule.

Outside the surveillance area, grain may be grown in the

restricted area for seed and may be moved from that area without a

certificate or limited permit. This was not made clear in the interim

rule and, as noted by the commenter, Sec. 301.89-5(a) does not provide

for the movement of grain from a restricted area for seed.

Although the commenter was correct in noting that the interim rule

did not provide for the movement of grain from a restricted area for

seed, we are not making any changes to the regulations as a result of

that comment. Such a change is now unnecessary due to the changes made

in a final rule that was effective on April 28, 1999, and published in

the Federal Register on May 5, 1999 (64 FR 23749-23754, Docket No. 96-

016-36), which removed the restricted area for seed classification.

Comment: APHIS' move to require only a single test for grain moved

from a surveillance area was a good one, but the single test that is

required should be for bunted kernels and not spores. It is illogical

to have a bunted kernel standard for establishing regulated areas and a

``one spore and you're out'' standard for moving grain and other

regulated articles. Placing restrictions on the movement of grain based

on the presence of spores that are assumed--but not proven--to be

associated with Karnal bunt holds growers to standards that are

stricter than the disease demands. In that same vein, there is no

explanation in the interim rule as to why double testing is still

required for the movement of grain out of a restricted area.

Response: As we noted in the response to another comment, our

September 23, 1998, final rule amended the regulations to allow the

certified movement of grain for uses other than seed if the grain is

tested prior to movement from the field, or before being commingled

with other grain, and found free of bunted kernels only, rather than

Karnal bunt spores and bunted kernels. Regarding the commenter's

reference to double-testing for the movement of grain from a restricted

area, that requirement, which had been found in Sec. 301.89-6(d), was

removed by the interim rule.

Comment: The interim rule contains an open-ended prohibition on the

planting of wheat in restricted areas for regulated articles other than

seed, i.e., the prohibition is not limited to a single crop season.

Although it may not have been the intent of the interim rule, it

appears that a significant amount of farm acreage could be permanently

barred from growing wheat. APHIS should adopt a timetable for the

release of those areas from regulation.

Response: In a final rule effective on April 28, 1999, and

published on May 4, 1999 (64 FR 23749-23754, Docket No. 96-016-36), we

removed the prohibition on the planting of Karnal bunt host material in

those fields that had been designated as restricted areas for regulated

articles other than seed, thus answering this commenter's concerns.

Comment: If APHIS is considering Mexico's request that the Mexicali

Valley be declared free from Karnal bunt, then APHIS should also

consider the adjacent areas in Yuma County, AZ, as free from Karnal

bunt, since the two areas can be viewed as comprising a single

``distinct, definable area'' as that term is defined in Sec. 301.89-1.

Response: Given that an international border lies between Mexico's

Mexicali Valley and the adjacent areas of Yuma County, AZ, and given

that restrictions are in place regarding the movement of Karnal bunt

host material between the United States and Mexico, we do not believe

that it is appropriate to consider the Mexicali Valley and Yuma County,

AZ, as a single ``distinct, definable area.'' Rather, Mexico's request

regarding the Karnal bunt status of the Mexicali Valley was evaluated

on its own merits, as should any decision regarding the regulatory

status of Yuma County, AZ.

Other Comments

In addition to the issues discussed above, several commenters

questioned the continuing regulatory status of areas in New Mexico. Two

commenters noted that Karnal bunt has been linked to New Mexico only

through the 106 fields identified as having been planted with

potentially contaminated seed. One of those commenters stated that

those 106 fields should be the only regulated areas in New Mexico--

i.e., there should be no restricted areas for seed in the State--while

the other commenter took the position that even those 106 fields should

be released from regulation because the wheat in those fields was

destroyed before heading out and no bunted kernels have been detected

in New Mexico in the course of subsequent testing. Other commenters

asked that specific fields in New Mexico be removed from regulation due

to their isolation from other farm areas and the lack of evidence--

other than the contaminated seed that was planted there--pointing to

the presence of Karnal bunt in New Mexico.

Even though the wheat in those 106 fields was plowed down and

destroyed before heading out, available information regarding Karnal

bunt indicates that viable T. indica inoculum could persist in the soil

for several years. Therefore, we believe that it is necessary for those

fields to continue to be designated as regulated areas. We have,

however, removed the regulatory restrictions that applied to the areas

surrounding those fields, which had been designated as restricted areas

for seed. As noted elsewhere in this document, the ``restricted area

for seed'' classification was eliminated by a final rule that was

effective on April 28, 1999, and published on May 4, 1999 (64 FR 23749-

23754, Docket No. 96-016-36), so those 106 individual fields are now

the only regulated areas in New Mexico. We will continue to reevaluate

the regulatory status of those fields in New Mexico, as well as the

regulated areas in other States. As we continue to accumulate negative

survey data, we will be in a better position to make and defend

decisions regarding the further release of areas from regulatory

restrictions.

Three of the commenters raised the issue of compensation. The issue

of compensation was not raised in the interim rule and is, therefore,

outside the scope of this final rule. Rather, compensation has been,

and will continue to be, addressed in separate rulemakings that focus

exclusively on that issue.

Changes Made in This Document

In the interim rule, we amended the regulations by redesignating

footnotes 2 through 6 as footnotes 1 through 5, respectively. When we

redesignated footnote 3 as footnote 2, we should have amended the text

of what is now footnote 5, which refers the reader to footnote 3, to

reflect the redesignation of footnote 3. We are correcting that

omission in this document.

Since the interim rule that is the subject of this document became

effective, we have published two other rulemakings in the Federal

Register that amended the provisions established in the interim rule.

This document does not affect those rulemakings. The provisions of

those rulemakings are:

[[Page 29545]]

In the interim rule, we revised paragraphs (e) and (f) of

Sec. 301.89-3. Those two paragraphs were revised again by a final rule

effective on April 28, 1999, and published on May 4, 1999 (64 FR 23749-

23754, Docket No. 96-016-36).

In the interim rule, we revised Sec. 301.89-4. That

section was revised again by the May 1999 final rule.

In the interim rule, we revised paragraph (b) of

Sec. 301.89-6. That paragraph was revised again by a final rule

published and effective on September 23, 1998 (63 FR 50747-50752,

Docket No. 96-016-32), and that September 1998 revision was further

amended by the May 1999 final rule.

In the interim rule, we amended Sec. 301.89-6 by removing

and reserving paragraph (d). In the September 1998 final rule, we added

a new paragraph (d) to Sec. 301.89-6. Then, in the May 1999 final rule,

we removed the paragraph (d) that had been added by the September 1998

final rule and redesignated paragraph (e) as paragraph (d).

Therefore, for the reasons set forth in the interim rule and in

this document, we are adopting the provisions of the interim rule as a

final rule with the change discussed in this document.

This final rule also affirms the information contained in the

interim rule concerning Executive Orders 12372 and 12988 and the

Paperwork Reduction Act.

Executive Order 12866 and Regulatory Flexibility Act

This rule has been reviewed under Executive Order 12866. The rule

has been determined to be significant for the purposes of Executive

Order 12866 and, therefore, has been reviewed by the Office of

Management and Budget.

This document adopts as a final rule, with one change, an interim

rule that amended the Karnal bunt regulations by modifying the criteria

for classifying regulated areas and by modifying the classification of

restricted areas. The interim rule required that a bunted wheat kernel

be found in or associated with a field within an area before that area

would be designated as a regulated area. The interim rule also

established separate restricted areas for seed and for regulated

articles other than seed. The actions taken in the interim rule had the

effect of removing some areas in Arizona and California from the list

of regulated areas and relieving restrictions on the movement of grain

and other regulated articles from additional areas in Arizona,

California, New Mexico, and Texas.

In the interim rule, we stated that we were taking those actions on

an expedited basis in order for the amended regulations to be in place

prior to the spring wheat harvest in the affected States, and that the

need to publish the interim rule on an expedited basis made compliance

with section 603 and timely compliance with section 604 of the

Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 603 and 604) impracticable.

The interim rule substantially reduced the amount of acreage

regulated for Karnal bunt, which meant that regulated articles like

grain, seed, and straw from the areas released from regulation could be

moved without restriction. The interim rule also eased restrictions on

the movement of grain and other regulated articles from those areas

that remained under regulation. Given those changes, we stated our

expectation that the interim rule would have a significant deregulatory

impact on affected entities. We further stated that, because the

majority of the affected entities in the regulated areas have been

determined to be small entities, we would discuss the issues raised by

section 604 of the Regulatory Flexibility Act in our Final Regulatory

Flexibility Act Analysis. That Final Regulatory Flexibility Act

Analysis, which also serves as our cost-benefit analysis, is set forth

below.

Entities Affected

The Regulatory Flexibility Act requires that agencies assess the

impact of regulations on small businesses, organizations, and

governments. We have assumed that the majority of the wheat producers

in the regulated area would be classified as small entities, based on

criteria established by the Small Business Administration (SBA) that

defines a ``small'' wheat producer as one having annual sales of less

than $500,000. We have also assumed that the economic impacts on all

wheat producers would tend to be lower over time, especially if wheat

production and marketings increase in the regulated area in response to

the deregulatory effects of the interim rule. The economic impact of

the interim rule on seed producers, however, depends largely on the

degree to which foreign and domestic markets are willing to accept seed

produced in areas that had been regulated for Karnal bunt.

The interim rule greatly reduced the number of nonpropagative wheat

(i.e., grain) growers operating under regulatory constraints. Prior to

the effective date of the interim rule, there were an estimated 598

growers affected by the regulations (236 in California, 310 in Arizona,

40 in New Mexico, and 12 in Texas). Once the interim rule became

effective, the number of affected growers dropped to 93, a decline of

84.4 percent. Of those remaining affected growers, 56 were located in

restricted areas for seed (29 in Arizona, 2 in California, 23 in New

Mexico, and 2 in Texas) and 37 were located in surveillance areas (20

in Arizona, 17 in California, and none in New Mexico and Texas).

Although nonpropagative wheat (grain) growers are the entities

primarily affected by the interim rule, there are other businesses that

provide supplies and that harvest, transport, and process wheat grown

in the regulated areas that were also affected by the interim rule.

These entities include harvesters and grain trucks, grain storage and

load-out facilities, railroad companies, grain handlers and marketers,

seed producers and seed companies, seed research firms and

universities, millers and other users of milling grain and millfeed,

straw producers and users, and other entities involved in providing

supplies to wheat growers and services to market and process their

production.

Rationale for and Benefits of Regulation

Upon detection of Karnal bunt in the southwestern United States in

the spring of 1996, quarantine and emergency actions were immediately

imposed by APHIS in order to prevent the interstate spread of the

disease to noninfected wheat producing areas in the country, which

would have had serious economic impact on the $4 billion wheat export

market,1 given that 50 percent of exports were to countries

that maintain restrictions against wheat imports from countries where

Karnal bunt is known to occur. These actions included designating areas

where Karnal bunt had been detected as regulated areas from which the

movement of Karnal bunt host material was restricted or prohibited.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ About 1.2 billion bushels of wheat was exported from the

United States in 1995, at a value of $4 billion.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

In addition to the quarantine, the Karnal bunt program consisted of

a National Survey component in which samples of wheat from fields

throughout the United States were collected and tested for Karnal bunt.

The National Survey program provided assurances to wheat importing

countries that fields outside the regulated areas were monitored for

the disease. Countries that are willing to accept wheat from the

regulated areas are assured that grain grown in those areas has been

tested and found negative for the disease. Through these means, the

Federal Karnal bunt program served to maintain and preserve the

economic viability of

[[Page 29546]]

the U.S. wheat export market. The main benefit of the regulatory

program, therefore, can be viewed as the avoidance of the potentially

significant losses to the wheat export market that would likely have

occurred in the absence of regulation. Without Federal regulation, it

is conceivable that farm income both within and outside the regulated

areas could have been further jeopardized.

As additional information from sampling and testing became

available, the Agency was able to ease the initial quarantine, which

was necessarily broad due to the lack of data available at the time as

to the extent of the infestation. Our subsequent modifications to the

classification criteria for regulated areas and the classification of

restricted areas, and the relief from restrictions that accompanied

those changes, are the focus of this analysis. As a result of those

modifications to the program, the Agency has been able to continue to

assure importing countries that U.S. grain exports are coming from

areas where Karnal bunt is not known to exist, but at a lower cost to

producers and handlers than had been possible under the initial

quarantine.

Changes in Planted Acreage

When Karnal bunt was first detected in the United States in March

1996, APHIS responded by placing nearly 1.7 million acres of

agricultural land, including approximately 330,149 acres of wheat,

under regulation through a series of interim rules in order to prevent

the further spread of the disease. After gathering additional

information through sampling, testing, and research, we published a

final rule in the Federal Register on October 4, 1996 (61 FR 52189-

52213, Docket No. 96-016-14), that amended the Karnal bunt regulations

that had been established in that series of interim rules.

The October 1996 final rule established criteria for levels of

risk, the movement of regulated articles, and the planting of seed from

Karnal bunt host crops, and divided the regulated areas into

surveillance areas and restricted areas. Under the October 1996 final

rule, wheat could not be grown within the restricted areas (which

amounted to about 16,859 acres), but grain could be grown in and moved

from the surveillance areas (which amounted to about 207,670 acres of

wheat grown for grain) if the grain was tested for spores and found

negative. The final rule also prohibited the movement of commercial

wheat seed from anywhere in a regulated area (i.e., both restricted

areas and surveillance areas). On April 3, 1997, we published in the

Federal Register (62 FR 15809-15819, Docket No. 96-016-18) the

regulatory flexibility analysis prepared for the October 1996 final

rule. While the October 1996 final rule did not reduce the size of the

regulated area, it did ease restrictions on the movement of grain grown

in regulated areas.

The May 1997 interim rule (Docket No. 96-016-19) that is the

subject of this final rule reduced the size of the area regulated for

Karnal bunt and further eased restrictions on the movement of grain and

other regulated articles from those areas that remained under

regulation, so its long-term economic effect is expected to be

positive. The changes contained May 1997 interim rule were made

possible in large part by research that led the Agency to conclude the

detection of a bunted wheat kernel--and not spores alone--was necessary

to confirm the presence of Karnal bunt in an area or article. The shift

to this bunted kernel standard had an immediate positive effect on the

States of Alabama, Florida, Georgia, and Tennessee, where grain in a

number of storage facilities had been found to be contaminated with

spores that appeared to be Karnal bunt spores, and on South Carolina,

where seed from a seed lot contaminated with those spores had been

planted. Because no bunted kernels were detected in those storage

facilities or the seed lot, it was not necessary to place those areas

under regulation.

Under both the October 1996 final rule and the May 1997 interim

rule, the movement of grain from a surveillance area is subject to

restrictions. However, in the interim rule, the size of the

surveillance areas was greatly reduced by limiting the size of the

surveillance area to an approximately 3-square-mile buffer around

restricted fields, with the remainder of the former surveillance area

being designated as a restricted area for seed from which grain could

move without a certificate or limited permit. Thus, the interim rule

reduced the size of the areas from which the movement of grain was

subject to restrictions by about 95 percent, from 207,670 acres to

9,806 acres. By requiring that an area or article be associated with a

bunted kernel (and not just spores), the interim rule eliminated the

need to expand the regulated area into the five southeastern States

where Karnal bunt-like spores had found and into any other area of the

United States where such spores might have been found in the future.

The interim rule also allowed grain grown in restricted areas for seed

lying outside surveillance areas (which amounted to 91,924 acres of

grain in the 1996-1997 crop season) to be moved without a certificate

or limited permit. This represented an increase of more than 44 percent

in the amount of grain eligible for unrestricted movement.

Additional positive impacts are expected to occur as a result of

the reduction in the size of the areas in which the growing of wheat is

prohibited. The restricted area acreage fell from 16,859 acres under

the October 1996 final rule to 13,519 acres under the May 1997 interim

rule, a reduction of nearly 20 percent. Table 1 summarizes the changes

in regulatory designations and regulated acreage in the 1995-1996 and

1996-1997 crop seasons.

Table 1.--Acreage in Regulated Areas Under 1995-96 Regulations and Under the May 1997 Interim Rule

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Regulated acreage by state

Year Regulatory designation ---------------------------------------------------- Total

AZ CA NM TX

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1995-96............ Total planted wheat 181,339 137,870 10,235 705 330,149

acreage in regulated

areas.

Total agricultural acreage 928,542 500,000 215,000 35,000 1,678,542

in regulated areas.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1996-97 Acreage Regulated Under the October 4, 1996, Final Rule (Docket No. 96-016-14)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1996-97............ Acreage in which wheat 9,200 3,200 3,990 469 16,859

planting prohibited

(restricted areas).

Total planted wheat 105,800 98,010 3,327 533 207,670

acreage in regulated

areas.

Total agricultural acreage 928,542 500,000 215,000 35,000 1,678,542

in regulated areas.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[[Page 29547]]

1996-97 Acreage Regulated Under the May 1, 1997, Interim Rule (Docket No. 96-016-19)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1996-97............ Acreage in which wheat 5,947 3,113 3,990 469 13,519

planting prohibited

(restricted areas for

regulated articles other

than seed).

Planted wheat acreage in 7,023 2,783 0 0 9,806

surveillance areas.

Planted wheat acreage in 81,977 6,087 3,327 533 91,924

restricted areas for seed.

Total planted wheat 89,000 8,870 3,327 533 101,730

acreage in regulated

areas.

Total agricultural acreage 875,000 301,772 215,000 35,000 1,426,772

in regulated areas.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Although the May 1997 interim rule further reduced the size of the

area regulated for Karnal bunt, there was an observed reduction in

1996-1997 wheat plantings. While those reductions were likely due in

part to planting decisions influenced by the continuing Karnal bunt

regulatory program, we do not believe that the reductions can be

attributed entirely to Karnal bunt regulations. Accordingly, the

analysis of impacts addresses certain factors that could explain the

observed changes in plantings in the affected areas.

Impact of Karnal Bunt Regulations and Other Factors on Wheat Acreage

Reductions in 1996-1997

Propagative (seed) and nonpropagative (grain) wheat acreage in the

regulated area in the 1995-1996 crop season had been planted and was at

various preharvest stages when Karnal bunt was first detected in early

March 1996. The initial regulatory action, therefore, mainly affected

wheat marketings and not wheat production. Production in the regulated

areas had increased from the 1994-1995 crop season due to expected

higher prices fueled by strong export demand (California Farmer,

``Scion of the Irrigated West,'' mid-March 1996, p. 14). However, by

the time the 1995-1996 crop was marketed, wheat prices had dropped

nationwide due to a number of reasons, including record increases in

planted spring wheat acreage in the Midwest (Agricultural Outlook,

USDA, Economic Research Service, August 1996). Due to lower prices and

the changed regulatory environment, in addition to the risk of being

infected with Karnal bunt, planted wheat acreage in the regulated areas

was expected to be lower in the 1996-97 crop season. Assuming an

average 25 percent decline in wheat prices in the regulated areas from

1995 to 1996, it is estimated that 1996-1997 planted wheat acreage in

the regulated areas should have totaled 280,627 acres, a decline in

planted acreage of almost 15 percent based solely on producer reaction

to lower prices.2 The past average ratio of planted

propagative to nonpropagative wheat acreage in the regulated area

suggests that 14,031 acres of this planted acreage would have been

devoted to seed production. Thus, the planted acreage totals for grain

and seed production that would have been expected in 1997, based

entirely on lower expected prices, are 266,595 and 14,031 acres,

respectively (Table 2).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\2\ This estimate is produced using a standard planted acreage

to price response function for wheat set at 0.6 (a 10 percent

decrease in wheat price elicits a 6 percent decline in planted wheat

acreage) multiplied by the estimated average 25 percent decrease in

wheat prices in the regulated areas.

Table 2.--1995-96 and 1996-97 Actual Planted Wheat Acreage in the Regulated Area and 1997 Acreage Estimate as a

Result of Lower Prices

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Estimated acreage in:

Scenario --------------------------------------

Total Wheat Grain Seed

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Actual 1995-1996......................................................... 330,149 313,642 16,507

1996-1997 estimated acreage as a result of lower prices.................. 280,627 266,595 14,031

Actual 1996-1997......................................................... 101,730 97,865 3,865

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Acreage change as compared with

actual 1996 acreage:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Estimated decrease in 1997 acreage due to lower prices................... -49,522 -47,047 -2,476

(-15%) (-15%) (-15%)

Actual decrease in 1997 acreage.......................................... -228,419 -215,777 -12,642

(-70%) (-69%) (-77%)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Difference Between Estimated Lower Price 1997 Acreage and Actual 1997:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Lower price acreage minus actual 1997 acreage............................ -178,897 -168,730 -10,166

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The actual total planted wheat acreage in the regulated areas for

the 1996-1997 crop season is estimated at 101,730 acres, which is a 70

percent decrease from the 330,149 planted acres in the 1995-1996 crop

season (a far larger decrease than the 15 percent reduction that, as

noted above, would have been expected due solely to lower prices).

Planted wheat seed acreage showed a greater decline, falling by 12,642

acres or more than 77 percent. Evidently,

[[Page 29548]]

grain and seed producers cut back production due to reasons other than

lower prices, such as the presence of Federal regulations and the

threat of Karnal bunt infection.

Because only 49,522 acres (22 percent) of the actual 228,419-acre

decline in total 1996-1997 planted wheat acreage in the regulated area

can be explained as occurring in response to lower prices, there is the

implication that the remaining 178,897 acres of planted wheat acreage

were dropped due to factors unrelated to price. Attention is now

focused on explaining this non-price-generated 178,897-acre (168,730

acres of grain, 10,166 acres of seed) decrease in planted wheat acreage

in the regulated area.3

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ Comparing the expected amount of planted wheat seed acreage

(14,031) that would have been expected as a result of lower prices

with the actual 1997 planted wheat seed acreage (3,865) gives a

total of 10,166 fewer acres of seed left unexplained by lower prices

in 1997. Deducting the 10,166 fewer acres of wheat seed from the

total wheat acreage decrease left unexplained by lower prices in

1997 produces a non-price-generated drop of 168,730 acres of grain.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Of the 168,730-acre non-price-generated decline in grain acreage,

Federal regulations that prohibit wheat planting in restricted areas

can explain acreage reductions of 13,519 acres (see Table 1). Assuming

that half of this restricted area acreage would have been rotated out

of wheat production in 1996-1997 in any case, it is estimated that

Federal planting restrictions reduced grain acreage by about 6,760

acres (Table 3). A certain amount of wheat seed would have been needed

to produce wheat on this restricted area acreage; this associated seed

acreage is estimated at 125 acres.4 Deducting the impact of

planting restrictions on grain and its associated seed production needs

from the total non-price-generated acreage reductions leaves a cutback

of 162,095 acres of grain and 10,042 acres of seed left unexplained by

lower prices.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\4\ This assumes that 1 acre of wheat seed produces enough clean

propagative seed to plant 54 acres.

Table 3.--Non-Price-Generated Acreage Shifts in the Regulated Area, 1996-

97 Crop Season

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Acreage reductions associated with

the Interim Rule in 1996-97:

Item --------------------------------------

Total Grain Seed

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Total non-price-generated acreage 178,897 168,730 10,166

reduction.......................

Reduction due to planting -6,760 -6,635 -125

restrictions....................

--------------------------------------

Total...................... 172,137 162,095 10,042

------------------------------------------------------------------------

The estimated 1996-97 grain and seed acreage reductions are assumed

to have occurred as a result of several non-price factors, including

reduced interest from buyers outside the regulated area and possible

Karnal bunt-related production and marketing concerns. This planted

wheat acreage cutback may have resulted from a combination of producer

reaction to lower demand for wheat--both domestically and in foreign

markets--and grower reluctance to plant wheat due to the possibility of

becoming infected with Karnal bunt. No attempt is made to estimate the

relative influence among these non-price factors on the remaining

planted grain and seed wheat acreage reductions.

Potential Economic Losses in 1996-97 Due to Reduced Planted Acreage

The potential economic losses resulting from lost sales of wheat

grain and seed due to the non-price-generated acreage reductions

described in the previous paragraphs are presented below. These

potential economic losses are broken down into three categories: (1)

Losses associated with the prohibition on planting wheat in restricted

areas; (2) losses in gross value of grain and associated seed; and (3)

losses resulting from reduced seed sales.

Losses Associated With the Prohibition on Planting Wheat in Restricted

Areas

The gross economic losses resulting from the prohibition on

planting wheat on the 6,635 acres in the restricted areas is estimated

at $3 million for the 1996-1997 crop season.5 This gross

loss implies a net wheat income reduction of $1.5 million.6

To offset those losses, other crops with historically high returns,

such as barley, could be grown as replacement crops in the restricted

areas. Assuming the substitution of barley, which yields returns of

about 80 percent of that of wheat, gross economic losses to wheat

producers are reduced to $0.6 million, and the associated net loss to

producers on these barley sales would be even lower, at $0.35 million.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\5\ The calculation of the value of wheat grain is based on the

assumption that an acre of wheat yields 100 bushels of grain, and a

bushel of grain is valued at $4.50 per bushel.

\6\ This net income calculation is made using the same net

income to gross income proportion used in the Karnal Bunt Regulatory

Flexibility Analysis published in the Federal Register on April 3,

1997 (62 FR 15809-15819, Docket No. 96-016-18).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Losses in Gross Value of Grain

The loss in gross value of the remaining non-price-generated wheat

grain acreage reduction of 162,095 acres is estimated at $72.9 million.

Again, if we assume the substitution of barley for wheat on this

acreage, gross grower losses are lowered to $14.6 million and the

corresponding net losses to growers would be even lower, estimated at

around $7.3 million.

Losses Resulting From Reduced Seed Sales

The entire amount of non-price-generated wheat grain acreage

reductions and their associated needed wheat seed production was

totally accounted for in the loss calculations above. Some of the

additional seed acreage reductions were left unaccounted for because

the acreage reductions were proportionately greater for wheat seed than

for wheat grain. These remaining wheat seed acreage reductions of

10,042 acres have an associated gross and net grower economic loss of

$7.6 and $3.7 million, respectively. This planted seed acreage cutback

probably was due primarily to seed producers reacting to lower seed

demand in export markets.

Reduced Surveillance Area

The interim rule reduced the acreage in surveillance areas, which

reduces the amount of potential economic losses to growers and handlers

of grain. That reduction is based on the assumption that 15 percent of

production in a surveillance area will be found to be infected with

Karnal bunt, and that the value of such Karnal bunt positive wheat is

reduced by $0.60 per bushel. Thus, under the October 1996 final rule,

which included 207,670 acres of

[[Page 29549]]

surveillance area, there was a potential economic loss, due to the

$0.60 per-bushel decline in market value, of $1.9 million. With the

interim rule's reduction of surveillance areas to 9,806 acres, this

potential loss is reduced to under $100,000.

Summary of Potential Economic Losses in the Regulated Area in 1996-1997

Planted wheat acreage in the regulated areas in 1997 showed a drop

of over 70 percent from 1996. Growers cut back wheat production due to

a host of factors, including expected lower prices, the presence of

Federal regulations, and the threat of Karnal bunt. Standard economic

models correlating acreage changes to price changes explain only about

22 percent of the actual acreage reduction from 1995-96 in the

regulated area. It is assumed that the remaining 178,897 acres were

dropped from wheat production due to nonprice factors. One of these

factors was the prohibition on planting wheat in fields designated as

restricted areas for regulated articles other than seed. This drop in

grain production and its associated seed acreage produced an estimated

net income loss to growers of about $0.35 million in 1996-

97.7 However, much of this loss would have been incurred

with or without the interim rule, as the number of fields in which

wheat could not be grown was largely unchanged by the interim rule.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\7\ These losses assume that a large part of the reduced wheat

acreage was planted into barley in 1997 so that barley receipts

offset gross and net wheat income losses by almost 80 percent.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Reductions in grain demand ($7.3 million) and its associated seed

acreage ($3.7 million) generated net losses to growers of about $11

million, even with the reduction in the size of the regulated area

resulting from the interim rule (see table 4). It should be noted that

these losses are estimated annual losses in the 1996-1997 crop season.

The amount of losses that may be incurred in the future will be

affected by changes in the size of the regulated areas and the presence

or absence of regulatory restrictions on the planting and movement of

Karnal bunt host crops within the regulated areas.

Table 4.--Potential Economic Losses in the 1996-1997 Crop Season Due to

Reduced Planted Acreage

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gross value

Loss in value associated with: ($ Net value

million) ($ million)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Prohibition on wheat planting in restricted 0.6 0.35

areas for regulated articles other than seed

Reduced wheat grain acreage.................. 14.6 7.3

Reduced seed planting and sales.............. 7.6 3.7

Total.................................. 22.8 11.35

------------------------------------------------------------------------

The area in which the interim rule may have reduced losses is in

its reduction in the acreage designated as surveillance areas. As

explained previously in this analysis, the reduction in the acreage

designated as surveillance areas could be expected to lower potential

Karnal bunt-positive wheat value losses from $1.9 million to $0.1

million.8 The reduction in the acreage designated as

surveillance areas may cause some price strengthening in the short run,

but most likely this change will be more beneficial in the future. The

same is true for the reduction in the acreage designated as restricted

areas for seed--little short-run relief was expected, but future

production shifts may significantly reduce the effect of regulations.

No quantitative estimate for 1997 is made on either of these two

possible market adjustments.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\8\ Compensation in these areas could further reduce the

economic effect on producers and handlers.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Federal Compensation To Mitigate Losses

In order to alleviate some of the economic hardships and to ensure

full and effective compliance with the regulatory program, compensation

to mitigate certain losses described above was offered to producers and

other affected entities in the regulated area. The rationale for the

use of compensation was that the emergency actions taken by the Agency

to prevent further spread of Karnal bunt disrupted normal production

and marketing activities in regulated areas. Producers and other

affected individuals had little time or ability to avoid the unexpected

costs or pass those costs on to others in the marketing chain. The

impact was particularly severe on the wheat industry in the regulated

area because much of the crop was grown under contract at specified

amounts and prices.

The Agency compensation plan reflected the fact that while

significant benefits of regulation (in terms of the avoidance of

greater losses in the export market) accrue to producers outside the

regulated areas, the regulatory burden fell disproportionately on those

within the regulated area. Compensation would therefore be appropriate

where a small number of parties necessarily bear a disproportionate

share of the burden of providing such benefits.

For comparison purposes, when Karnal bunt was first detected in the

1995-1996 crop season, compensation was paid for the plow-down of

fields in New Mexico and Texas that were planted with seed containing

bunted wheat kernels, loss in value of wheat testing positive for

Karnal bunt to producers and handlers, loss in value of wheat testing

negative for Karnal bunt to producers and handlers, cost of millfeed

treatment, cleaning and disinfecting of grain storage facilities, and

wheat inventories from past crop season (for further details, see

docket No. 96-016-20, published in the Federal Register on May 6, 1997,

62 FR 24753-24765). Compensation funding of nearly $40 million was made

available to the Agency through budget apportionment for losses

suffered in the 1995-96 crop year. As of December 31, 1998, about $33

million has been paid in compensation: $18.5 million to producers and

handlers who suffered losses from the sale of their 1996 wheat crop,

$8.5 million to seed and straw producers and handlers, and $3 million

in claims for custom harvesters, millfeed treatment, storage facility

decontamination).9

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\9\ The remaining $3 million of the $33 million total is

accounted for by outstanding claims that have been reviewed and

approved by the Farm Service Agency, but that are not reflected in

the three subtotals.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

For the 1996-97 crop season, the crop year pertinent to the

regulatory changes addressed in this final rule, compensation was

limited to certain growers and handlers within the regulated area for

grain that tested positive for bunted wheat kernels, flour millers who

choose to handle positive wheat, and growers and handlers of grain or

seed in areas where Karnal bunt was discovered outside the regulated

[[Page 29550]]

area (63 FR 31593-31601, Docket No. 96-016-29, published June 10,

1998). Of the $3.6 million apportioned for compensation for 1997 crop

losses, less than $50,000 in compensation has been paid. Due to the

small number of positive finds, total losses are not expected to exceed

$200,000.

In conclusion, the lifting of certain restrictions as a result of

the interim rule was expected to only marginally reduce the 1997

economic effect on production and marketing for most wheat in the

regulated areas. Planting for the May/June 1997 harvest was already

complete when the interim rule was published, so growers could not

react to the change in regulations by making different planting

decisions. However, the reduction in the acreage designated as

surveillance areas could be expected to lower potential Karnal bunt-

positive wheat value losses from $1.9 million to $0.1 million. Thus,

benefits of $1.8 million in 1997 could be realized as a result of the

interim rule, based on a lower incidence of Karnal bunt-positive grain,

which reduces the losses associated with the lower value of Karnal

bunt-positive grain. Compensation in these areas could further reduce

the economic effect on producers and handlers. Payments for the 1996-

1997 crop season are not expected to exceed $200,000 due to the small

number of positive finds.

Alternatives Considered

The only significant alternative to the interim rule would have

been to retain the classification criteria provided by the Karnal bunt

regulations established in the October 1996 final rule. In that final

rule, levels of risk were assigned to areas based on their proximity to

fields in which Karnal bunt spores were detected during preharvest

samples or in which contaminated seed was planted. Under those

criteria, it is unlikely that any of the significant reductions in the

size of the regulated areas and the number of affected growers achieved

by the May 1997 interim rule could have been accomplished. In addition,

maintaining those criteria would likely have resulted in the placement

of regulatory restrictions in the States of Alabama, Florida, Georgia,

and Tennessee, where grain in a number of storage facilities had been

found to be contaminated with spores that appeared to be Karnal bunt

spores, and in South Carolina, where seed from a seed lot contaminated

with those Karnal bunt-like spores had been planted. However, given our

conclusion that the detection of spores alone does not allow us to make

a conclusive determination that Karnal bunt disease is present in an

area or article, that alternative was rejected. By rejecting that

alternative, APHIS was able to prevent the enormous cost impacts on

producers and eliminate the need for large compensation payments while

continuing to assure importing countries that U.S. wheat exports are

coming from areas where Karnal bunt is not known to exist.

List of Subjects in 7 CFR Part 301

Agricultural commodities, Plant diseases and pests, Quarantine,

Reporting and recordkeeping requirements, Transportation.

Accordingly, the interim rule amending 7 CFR part 301 that was

published at 62 FR 23620-23628 on May 1, 1997, is adopted as a final

rule with the following change:

PART 301--DOMESTIC QUARANTINE NOTICES

1. The authority citation for part 301 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 7 U.S.C. 147a, 150bb, 150dd, 150ee, 150ff, 161, 162,

and 164-167; 7 CFR 2.22, 2.80, and 371.2(c).

Sec. 301.89-9 [Amended]

2. In Sec. 301.89-9, in paragraph (a), the text of footnote 5 is

amended by removing the words ``footnote 3'' and adding the words

``footnote 2'' in their place.

Done in Washington, DC, this 25th day of May 1999.

Joan M. Arnoldi,

Acting Administrator, Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service.

[FR Doc. 99-13793 Filed 6-1-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3410-34-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.