Payment of Premiums

Federal RegisterApr 27, 1999

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

PENSION BENEFIT GUARANTY CORPORATION

29 CFR Part 4007

RIN 1212-AA82

Payment of Premiums

AGENCY: Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation.

ACTION: Proposed rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The PBGC is proposing to amend its regulation on Payment of

Premiums to encourage self-correction of premium underpayments. The

amendments make it easier to qualify for ``safe-harbor'' relief from

late payment penalty charges and codify the PBGC's current premium

penalty policy (under which the penalty charge is lowered from 5% per

month to 1% per month if a premium payor corrects an underpayment

before PBGC notification).

DATES: Comments must be received on or before June 28, 1999.

ADDRESSES: Comments may be mailed to the Office of the General Counsel,

Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation, 1200 K Street, NW., Washington,

DC 20005-4026, or delivered to Suite 340 at the above address. Comments

also may be sent by Internet e-mail to [email protected]. Comments

will be available for public inspection at the PBGC's Communications

and Public Affairs Department, Suite 240.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Harold J. Ashner, Assistant General

Counsel, or Catherine B. Klion, Attorney, Office of the General

Counsel, PBGC, 1200 K Street, NW., Washington, DC 20005-4026; 202-326-

4024. (For TTY/TDD users, call the Federal relay service toll-free at

1-800-877-8339 and ask to be connected to 202-326-4024.)

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

Late Payment Penalties

Section 4007 of ERISA authorizes the PBGC to assess a late payment

penalty charge for failure to pay premiums on time. Under the PBGC's

regulation on Payment of Premiums (29 CFR part 4007), the penalty

accrues at the rate of 5% of the unpaid amount each month, subject to a

floor of $25 on the total penalty amount. The total penalty amount may

not exceed 100% of the premium that is not timely paid. The PBGC may

grant a waiver of all or a portion of the penalty (e.g., upon a

demonstration of good cause). The regulation also requires the payment

of interest on premium underpayments.

On December 2, 1996 (at 61 FR 63874), the PBGC published a policy

statement in which it adopted a two-tiered policy on penalties for late

payment of premiums due for 1996 and later plan years. This policy,

which lowers penalties from 5% per month to 1% per month if a premium

payor corrects an underpayment before PBGC notification, is designed to

encourage self-correction.

Premium Due Dates

A plan's premium due dates depend upon whether the plan is

``small'' or ``large.'' Under the current regulation, the determination

of whether a plan is ``small'' or ``large'' is based on the actual

number of participants for whom premiums were payable for the prior

year. This number is not necessarily the number of participants that

was reported on the PBGC Form 1 for the prior year.

Small Plans

A small plan is a plan with fewer than 500 participants for the

prior year. For

[[Page 22590]]

1999 and later plan years, the premium filing due date for small plans

for both the flat-rate premium (for single-employer and multiemployer

plans) and the variable-rate premium (for single-employer plans) is the

fifteenth day of the tenth full calendar month in the premium payment

year (see 63 FR 68684, Dec. 14, 1998). For calendar year plans, this

date is October 15. (For convenience, the discussion in this preamble

assumes that all plans are calendar year plans.)

Large Plans

For large single-employer and multiemployer plans (those with 500

or more participants for the prior year), the due date for the flat-

rate premium is the last day of the second full calendar month in the

premium payment year (February 28). If the number of participants for

whom premiums are payable for the premium payment year is not known by

February 28, the plan administrator must make an ``estimated'' payment

by February 28 and a ``reconciliation'' payment by October 15. The due

date for the variable-rate premium for large single-employer plans is

also October 15.

Premium Forms

The plan administrator ordinarily makes the February 28 filing on

PBGC Form 1-ES and must make the October 15 filing (for both large and

small plans) on PBGC Form 1.

Safe-harbor Rules

The participant count for the premium payment year is generally

determined as of the last day of the plan year preceding the premium

payment year. Because plan administrators often do not know the exact

participant count for the premium payment year by February 28 of the

premium payment year, the regulation provides a safe harbor from late

payment penalty charges, provided certain requirements are met. (There

is no safe harbor from late payment interest charges.)

A plan administrator must do two things to qualify for the safe

harbor and therefore avoid late payment penalty charges:

By February 28 of the premium payment year, the plan

administrator must pay the lesser of: (1) 90% of the flat-rate

premium due for the premium payment year; or (2) 100% of the flat-

rate premium that would be due for the premium payment year, if that

amount were determined by multiplying the actual participant count

for the prior year by the flat premium rate for the premium payment

year.

By October 15 of the premium payment year, the plan

administrator must pay any remaining portion of the flat-rate

premium for the premium payment year.

For example, assume that a single-employer plan has 600

participants for 2000 and 700 participants for 2001. In order to meet

the safe-harbor requirements for 2001, the plan administrator must make

an estimated payment by February 28, 2001, of at least $11,400. This

amount is the lesser of 90% of the flat-rate premium due for 2001 (700

x $19 x 90% = $11,970) or 100% of the flat-rate premium for 2000

(600 x $19 x 100% = $11,400). (The examples in this preamble use

the current single-employer plan flat-rate premium of $19 per

participant for all plan years.) The plan administrator also must make

a reconciliation payment by October 15, 2001, equal to the difference

between the February 28, 2001, payment and the full flat-rate premium

of $13,300 (700 x $19) due for 2001. Assuming that, by February 28,

2001, the plan administrator had paid the $11,400--the minimum amount

to qualify for safe-harbor relief--the plan administrator must pay the

difference of $1,900 ($13,300-$11,400) by October 15, 2001.

Proposed Amendment--Safe-Harbor Rules

The PBGC is proposing to expand its current safe-harbor rules to

encourage self-correction in three situations. The relief applies only

to penalty charges. It does not affect the interest that would accrue

on any underpayment of the flat-rate premium.

500-participant Threshold for PBGC Form 1-ES

Current Regulation.

Whether an estimated payment is due by February 28 depends on the

actual participant count for the prior year, not the participant count

that was reported on the prior year's Form 1.

For example, assume that a plan administrator of a plan that had

always had fewer than 500 participants reports 490 participants on the

plan's 2000 PBGC Form 1, which is filed on October 16, 2000 (because

October 15, 2000, is a Sunday). Based on the reported participant count

of 490 for 2000, the plan administrator does not make an estimated

payment for 2001 by February 28, 2001, but pays the plan's full flat-

rate premium for 2001 on October 15, 2001. Subsequently, the plan

administrator discovers that the participant count that should have

been reported for 2000 is 510. On November 15, 2001, the plan

administrator files an amended PBGC Form 1 for 2000 with the additional

flat-rate premium due for the 20 participants ((510-490) x $19 =

$380). The PBGC would assess penalty and interest charges on the $380

payment for the period October 16, 2000, through November 15, 2001. In

addition, because the actual participant count for 2000 is 500 or more,

the PBGC also would assess penalty and interest charges for the period

March 1 through October 15, 2001 on the full flat-rate premium for 2001

(reflecting the fact that the plan's full flat-rate premium for 2001

was due February 28, 2001).

Amendment

Under the amendment, whether the PBGC would assess a late payment

penalty charge for failure to make an estimated payment for the premium

payment year by February 28 of the premium payment year would be

determined based on the lesser of (1) the number of participants

reported for the prior year, or (2) the actual number of participants

for the prior year. Thus, PBGC would not assess a penalty charge for

failing to make an estimated payment for the premium payment year by

February 28 of the premium payment year if the number of participants

reported for the prior year is fewer than 500. For this purpose, the

number of participants reported for the prior year would be the number

of participants last reported for the prior year (on the PBGC Form 1 or

an amended PBGC Form 1) by February 28 of the premium payment year. The

relief would apply only to penalty charges. The PBGC would continue to

assess interest on any underpayment of the flat-rate premium for the

period March 1 of the premium payment year through the date of payment.

Because the plan administrator in the example reported fewer than

500 participants on the plan's 2000 Form 1, the PBGC would not assess a

penalty charge (for the period March 1 through October 15, 2001) for

failing to make an estimated payment for 2001 by February 28, 2001. The

PBGC still would assess interest on the flat-rate premium for 2001 for

the period March 1 through October 15, 2001. (The change would not

affect the penalty and interest charges assessed for the period October

16, 2000, through November 15, 2001, on the $380 late payment for the

20 participants for 2000.)

Estimate Based on Prior Year's Form 1 Participant Count

Current Regulation

A plan can lose safe-harbor relief if the plan administrator, in

computing the estimated flat-rate premium payment due on February 28 of

the

[[Page 22591]]

premium payment year, relies on a participant count reported on the

prior year's PBGC Form 1 that is later determined to be too low. For

example, assume that the plan administrator of a single-employer plan

reports 600 participants on the plan's 2000 PBGC Form 1, which is filed

on October 16, 2000. On February 28, 2001, the plan administrator makes

an estimated payment for 2001 equal to 100% of the flat-rate premium

for 2000 (600 x $19 x 100% = $11,400). On October 15, 2001, the

plan administrator reports 800 participants on the plan's 2001 Form 1

and makes a reconciliation payment of $3,800 (800 x $19-$11,400). The

PBGC would assess interest on the $3,800 reconciliation payment for the

period March 1 through October 15, 2001.

Subsequently, the plan administrator discovers that 700

participants should have been reported for 2000 and, on November 15,

2001, files an amended PBGC Form 1 for 2000 with the additional flat-

rate premium of $1,900 due for the 100 participants (100 x $19). The

PBGC would assess penalty and interest charges on the $1,900 payment

for the period October 16, 2000, through November 15, 2001. Under the

current regulation, the plan would lose safe-harbor relief for 2001

because the payment of $11,400 made on February 28, 2001, is neither at

least 100% of the flat-rate premium for 2000 (700 x $19 x 100% =

$13,300) nor at least 90% of the flat-rate premium for 2001 (800 x

$19 x 90% = $13,680). Thus, under the current regulation, in addition

to interest, the PBGC would assess a penalty charge on the $3,800

reconciliation payment for the period March 1 through October 15, 2001.

Amendment

Under the amendment, the PBGC would determine whether the estimated

payment reflected at least 100% of the prior year's participant count

by using the lesser of: (1) the number of participants reported on the

prior year's PBGC Form 1 or amended PBGC Form 1 (filed by February 28

of the premium payment year); or (2) the actual number of participants

for the prior year. Thus, in the example, the plan would not lose safe-

harbor relief for 2001 even though the plan administrator later files

an amended 2000 PBGC Form 1 reporting 700 participants. The amendment

would affect only penalty charges. It would not affect the interest

assessed on the $3,800 reconciliation payment for the period March 1

through October 15, 2001.

PBGC Form 1 Reconciliation Payment Underpaid or Late

Current Regulation

A plan also loses safe-harbor relief when the plan administrator

timely pays the appropriate estimated payment with the PBGC Form 1-ES

but fails to make the full PBGC Form 1 reconciliation payment on time.

This can occur, e.g., if the plan administrator bases the

reconciliation payment on a participant count that is too low or makes

the reconciliation payment late.

For example, assume that the plan administrator of a single-

employer plan reports 800 participants on the plan's 2000 PBGC Form 1,

which is filed on October 16, 2000. On February 28, 2001, the plan

administrator makes an estimated payment for 2001 of 100% of the flat-

rate premium for 2000 (800 x $19 x $100% = $15,200). On October 15,

2001, the plan administrator reports a participant count of 900 for

2001 and makes a reconciliation payment of $1,900 (900 x

$19-$15,200). The PBGC would assess interest on the $1,900 payment for

the period March 1 through October 15, 2001.

Subsequently, the plan administrator discovers that the participant

count that should have been reported for 2001 is 910 and, on November

15, 2001, files an amended PBGC Form 1 for 2001 with an additional

flat-rate premium of $190 (10 x $19 = $190) for the 10 participants.

The PBGC would assess penalty and interest charges on the $190 payment

for the period October 16 through November 15, 2001. Under the current

regulation, the plan would lose safe-harbor relief because it did not

make a timely PBGC Form 1 reconciliation payment in full. Thus, the

PBGC would also assess a penalty charge on $2,090 (910 x

$19-$15,200)--the amount by which the flat-rate premium for 2001 of

$17,290 (based on the amended November 15, 2001, PBGC Form 1) exceeds

the February 28, 2001, payment of $15,200--for the period March 1

through October 15, 2001 .

Amendment

Under the amendment, payment of any balance of the flat-rate

premium due for the premium payment year by October 15 of the premium

payment year would no longer be a prerequisite for qualifying for safe-

harbor relief. Thus, in the example, the PBGC still would assess

penalty and interest charges on the $190 payment (due for the

additional 10 participants) for the period October 16 through November

15, 2001. But the plan would not lose safe-harbor relief and therefore

would not be assessed a penalty charge for the period March 1 through

October 15, 2001, on $2,090--the amount by which the flat-rate premium

for 2001 (based on the amended November 15, 2001, PBGC Form 1) exceeds

the February 28, 2001, payment. The amendment would not affect the

interest assessed on that amount for the period March 1 through October

15, 2001.

Proposed Amendment--Late Payment Penalty Rate

Based on its experience, the PBGC proposes to codify its December

2, 1996, policy statement, in which it announced its current two-tiered

penalty rate policy for 1996 and later plan years. Under this policy,

which is designed to encourage self-correction, the PBGC assesses a

penalty of 1% per month if the premium is paid on or before the date

the PBGC issues a written notice that there is or may be a premium

delinquency. If the premium is paid after the PBGC notification date,

the penalty rate is 5% per month for all months. The minimum total

penalty continues to be $25, and the penalty continues to be limited to

100% of the unpaid premium. PBGC notification may take various forms,

including a premium bill, a letter initiating a premium compliance

review (i.e., an audit), or a letter questioning a failure to make a

premium filing. The amendment clarifies that the 5% rate applies (for

all months) to all persons liable for premiums for the plan (i.e., the

plan administrator and, for a single-employer plan, each contributing

sponsor and each member of any contributing sponsor's controlled group)

once this notice is issued to any of those persons.

Miscellaneous

The proposed regulation clarifies that the penalty waiver for

premium underpayments paid within 30 days after the date of a PBGC bill

applies only to penalty charges accruing after the date of the bill.

The current regulation provides that the PBGC may waive all or part

of a late payment penalty charge upon a demonstration of ``good

cause.'' The PBGC is proposing to change the standard to ``reasonable

cause'' to be consistent with the standard in the PBGC's policy

statements on penalties under section 4071 of ERISA (relating to

penalties for failure to provide required information on time). This is

only a change in terminology that is not intended to alter the

substantive requirements for this waiver.

Applicability

The amendment to the safe-harbor rules would apply to PBGC

[[Page 22592]]

determinations issued on or after the effective date of the final rule

with respect to premiums for 1999 and later plan years. The amendment

to the late payment penalty rate would apply to PBGC determinations

issued on or after the effective date of the final rule with respect to

premiums for 1996 and later plan years.

Compliance With Rulemaking Guidelines

The PBGC has determined that this action is not a ``significant

regulatory action'' under the criteria set forth in Executive Order

12866.

This rule would provide relief from premium penalties. The relief

would be limited to a percentage--generally small--of a plan's premium.

While this rule would result in a positive economic impact for some

small entities, the number of small entities for which the impact would

be significant would not be substantial. The PBGC therefore certifies

under section 605(b) of the Regulatory Flexibility Act that this rule

would not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of

small entities. Accordingly, sections 603 and 604 of the Regulatory

Flexibility Act do not apply.

List of Subjects in 29 CFR Part 4007

Penalties, Pension insurance, Pensions, Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements.

For the reasons set forth above, the PBGC proposes to amend 29 CFR

part 4007 as follows.

PART 4007--PAYMENT OF PREMIUMS

1. The authority citation for part 4007 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 29 U.S.C. 1302(b)(3), 1301(a), 1306, 1307.

2. Section 4007.8 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 4007.8 Late payment penalty charges.

(a) Penalty charge. If any premium payment due under this part is

not paid by the due date under Sec. 4007.11, the PBGC will assess a

late payment penalty charge as determined under this paragraph (a),

except to the extent the charge is waived under paragraphs (b) through

(g) of this section. The charge will be no more than 100% of the unpaid

premium. The charge will be based on the number of months (counting any

portion of a month as a whole month) from the due date to the date of

payment and is subject to a floor of $25 (or, if less, the amount of

the unpaid premium).

(1) Penalty rate for post-1995 premium payment years. This

paragraph (a)(1) applies to the premium for any premium payment year

beginning after 1995. The penalty rate is--

(i) 1% per month (for all months) on any amount of unpaid premium

that is paid on or before the date the PBGC issues a written notice to

any person liable for the plan's premium that there is or may be a

premium delinquency (e.g., a premium bill, a letter initiating a

premium compliance review, or a letter questioning a failure to make a

premium filing); or

(ii) 5% per month (for all months) on any amount of unpaid premium

that is paid after that date.

(2) Penalty rate for pre-1996 premium payment years. This paragraph

(a)(2) applies to the premium for any premium payment year beginning

before 1996. The penalty rate is 5% per month (for all months) on any

amount of unpaid premium.

(b) Hardship waiver. The PBGC may grant a waiver based upon a

showing of substantial hardship as provided in section 4007(b) of

ERISA.

(c) Reasonable cause waiver. The PBGC may, upon any demonstration

of reasonable cause, waive all or part of a late payment penalty

charge.

(d) Waiver on PBGC's own initiative. The PBGC may, on its own

initiative, waive all or part of a late payment penalty charge.

(e) Grace period. With respect to any PBGC bill for a premium

underpayment, the PBGC will waive any late payment penalty charge

accruing after the date of the bill, provided the premium underpayment

is paid within 30 days after the date of the bill.

(f) Safe-harbor relief for certain large plans. This waiver applies

to the premium for any premium payment year beginning after 1998 in the

case of a plan for which a reconciliation filing is required under

Sec. 4007.11(a)(2)(iii). The PBGC will waive the penalty on any

underpayment of the flat-rate premium for the period that ends on the

date the reconciliation filing is due if fewer than 500 participants

are reported for the plan year preceding the premium payment year

(determined in accordance with paragraph (h) of this section).

(g) Safe-harbor relief for plans that make minimum estimated

payment. This waiver applies in the case of a plan for which a

reconciliation filing is required under Sec. 4007.11(a)(2)(iii). The

PBGC will waive the penalty on any underpayment of the flat-rate

premium for the period that ends on the date the reconciliation filing

is due if, by the date the flat-rate premium for the premium payment

year is due under Sec. 4007.11(a)(2)(i), the plan administrator pays at

least the lesser of--

(1) 90% of the flat-rate premium due for the premium payment year;

or

(2) 100% of the flat-rate premium that would be due for the premium

payment year if the number of participants for that year were the

lesser of--

(i) The number of participants for whom premiums were required to

be paid for the plan year preceding the premium payment year; or

(ii) In the case of a premium payment year beginning after 1998,

the number of participants reported for the plan year preceding the

premium payment year (determined in accordance with paragraph (h) of

this section).

(h) Reported participant count. For purposes of paragraphs (f) and

(g)(2)(ii) of this section, the number of participants reported for the

plan year preceding the premium payment year is the number of

participants last reported under this part to the PBGC (for the plan

year preceding the premium payment year) by the date the flat-rate

premium for the premium payment year is due under

Sec. 4007.11(a)(2)(i).

Issued in Washington, DC, this 21st day of April, 1999.

David M. Strauss,

Executive Director, Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation.

[FR Doc. 99-10451 Filed 4-26-99; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 7708-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.