Guidance Under Subpart F Relating to Partnerships and Branches

Federal RegisterMar 26, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY

Internal Revenue Service

26 CFR Parts 1 and 301

[TD 8767]

RIN 1545-AWO7

Guidance Under Subpart F Relating to Partnerships and Branches

AGENCY: Internal Revenue Service (IRS), Treasury.

ACTION: Temporary and final regulations.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This document contains regulations relating to the treatment

under subpart F of certain payments involving branches of a controlled

foreign corporation (CFC) that are treated as separate entities for

foreign tax purposes or partnerships in which CFCs are partners. These

regulations are necessary to provide guidance on transactions relating

to such entities. These regulations will affect United States

shareholders of controlled foreign corporations. The text of these

temporary regulations also serves as the text of the proposed

regulations published elsewhere in this issue of the Federal Register.

DATES: Effective date: These regulations are effective March 23, 1998.

Applicability date: For dates of applicability see Secs. 1.904-

5T(o), 1.954-1T(c)(1)(i)(E), 1.954-2T(a)(5)(iii) and (a)(6)(ii), 1.954-

9T(d) and 301.7701-3T(f) of these regulations.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Valerie Mark, (202) 622-3840 (not a

toll-free number).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

I. In General

In these temporary regulations and in proposed regulations

published elsewhere in this issue of the Federal Register, the Treasury

and IRS set forth a framework for dealing with issues posed by the use

of certain entities that are regarded as fiscally transparent for

purposes of U.S. tax law, with regard to the application of subpart F

of the Internal Revenue Code.

Subpart F was enacted by Congress to limit the deferral of U.S.

taxation of certain income earned outside the United States by foreign

corporations controlled by U.S. persons. Limited deferral was retained

after the enactment of subpart F to protect the competitiveness of

controlled foreign corporations (CFCs) doing business overseas. See S.

Rep. No. 1881, 87th Cong., 2d Sess. 78-80 (1962). This limited deferral

furthers the objective of allowing a CFC engaged in an active business,

and located in a foreign country for appropriate economic reasons, to

compete in a similar tax environment with non-U.S.-owned corporations

located in the same country.

Conversely, one of the purposes of subpart F is to prevent CFCs

from converting active income that is not easily moveable and is earned

in a jurisdiction in which a business is located for non-tax reasons,

into passive, easily moveable income that is shifted to a lower tax

jurisdiction primarily for tax avoidance. Moreover, when subpart F was

first enacted it was realized that related person transactions can be

easily manipulated to reduce both United States and foreign taxes.

Consequently, in enacting subpart F, Congress provided that

transactions of CFCs that involve related persons generally give rise

to subpart F income with certain enumerated exceptions.

Hybrid branches, which, by definition, are not regarded as fiscally

transparent under foreign law, are particularly well suited to the type

of tax avoidance described above. In light of the recent proliferation

of hybrid branches, Treasury and the IRS believe that it is appropriate

to consider the issues related to transactions involving hybrid

branches, or other hybrid entities, under subpart F.

The use of partnerships that are fiscally transparent for U.S. tax

purposes raises additional issues in the context of subpart F that are

similar to those raised in connection with hybrid branches. Such

partnerships may or may not be fiscally transparent under foreign law.

(Other fiscally-transparent entities, such as grantor trusts, will be

the subject of guidance issued in conjunction with the finalization of

regulations under section 672(f).)

The entity classification regulations of Secs. 301.7701-1 through

301.7701-3 (the check-the-box regulations) make entity classification

generally elective, in part so that taxpayers can choose a tax status

that is consistent with their business objectives. This administrative

provision was not intended to change substantive law. Particularly in

the international area, the ability to more easily achieve fiscal

transparency can lead to inappropriate results under certain

substantive international provisions of the Code. Thus, the Treasury

and the IRS believe that it is necessary to provide additional guidance

regarding the use of hybrid entities in the international context. See

[[Page 14614]]

preamble to TD 8697, 61 FR 66585 (December 18, 1996).

II. Hybrid Branches

As announced in Notice 98-11 (1998-6 I.R.B. 13), the Treasury and

the IRS understand that certain taxpayers are using arrangements

involving hybrid branches to circumvent the purposes of subpart F

(sections 951 through 964 of the Code). These arrangements generally

involve the use of deductible payments to reduce the taxable income of

a CFC under foreign law, thereby reducing that CFC's foreign tax and,

also under foreign law, the corresponding creation in another entity of

low-taxed, passive income of the type to which subpart F was intended

to apply. Because of the structure of these arrangements, however,

taxpayers take the position that this income is not taxed under subpart

F. Treasury and the IRS have concluded that use of these hybrid branch

arrangements is contrary to the policies and rules of subpart F.

U.S. international tax policy seeks to balance the objective of

neutrality of taxation between domestic and foreign business

enterprises (seeking neither to encourage nor to discourage one over

the other), while keeping U.S. business competitive. Subpart F strongly

reflects and enforces that balance, while the arrangements described

above involving hybrid branches upset that balance.

Explanation of Provisions

Under these temporary regulations, hybrid branch payments, as

defined in the regulations, between a CFC and its hybrid branch, or

between hybrid branches of the CFC may give rise to subpart F income.

When certain conditions are present, the non-subpart F income of the

CFC, in the amount of the hybrid branch payment, is recharacterized as

subpart F income of the CFC. Those conditions include that: the hybrid

branch payment reduces the foreign tax of the payor; the hybrid branch

payment would have been foreign personal holding company income if made

between separate CFCs; and there is a disparity between the effective

rate of tax on the payment in the hands of the payee and the

hypothetical rate of tax that would have applied if the income had been

taxed in the hands of the payor. Treasury and the IRS are considering

applying similar principles with respect to the foreign base company

services income rules of section 954(e). Comments are requested on this

issue. Any regulations promulgated on this issue will be prospective.

Policies underlying subpart F would also be avoided in certain non-

hybrid branch transactions that do not reduce the tax of the payor.

Treasury and the IRS invite comments on the extent to which rules

should be provided to address such transactions. Any regulations

promulgated on this issue will be prospective. Comments are also

requested regarding the application of these rules to dividend and

other equity distributions.

The temporary regulations make clear that the CFC and the hybrid

branch, or the hybrid branches, are treated as separate corporations

only to recharacterize non-subpart F income as subpart F income in the

amount of the hybrid branch payment, and to apply the tax disparity

rule of Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(5)(iv). For all other purposes (e.g., for

purposes of the earnings and profits limitation of section 952), a CFC

and its hybrid branch, or hybrid branches, are not treated as separate

corporations.

The temporary regulations provide that the amount recharacterized

as subpart F income is the gross amount of the hybrid branch payment

limited by the amount of the CFC's earnings and profits attributable to

non-subpart F income. This amount is the excess of current earnings and

profits over subpart F income, determined after the application of the

rules of sections 954(b) and 952(c) and before the application of these

temporary regulations. To the extent that the full amount required to

be recharacterized under this provision cannot be recharacterized

because it exceeds earnings and profits attributable to non-subpart F

income, there is no requirement to carry such amounts back or forward

to another year.

For purposes of determining the amount of taxes deemed paid under

section 960, the amount of non-subpart F income recharacterized as

subpart F income is treated as attributable to income in separate

foreign tax credit baskets in proportion to the ratio of non-subpart F

income in each basket to the total amount of non-subpart F income of

the CFC for the taxable year.

The temporary regulations provide that, under certain

circumstances, the recharacterization rules will also apply to a CFC s

proportionate share of any hybrid branch payment made between a

partnership in which the CFC is a partner and a hybrid branch of the

partnership, or between hybrid branches of such a partnership. When the

partnership is treated as fiscally transparent by the CFC's taxing

jurisdiction, the recharacterization rules are applied by treating the

hybrid branch payment as if it had been made directly between the CFC

and the hybrid branch, or as though the hybrid branches of the

partnership had been hybrid branches of the CFC, as applicable. If the

partnership is treated as a separate entity by the CFC's taxing

jurisdiction, the recharacterization rules are applied to the

partnership as if it were a CFC. Comments are requested on whether the

rule for such non-fiscally transparent partnerships should be relaxed

in the case of small ownership interests.

The temporary regulations provide that income will not be

recharacterized unless there is a disparity between the effective rate

at which the hybrid branch payment is taxed to the payee and a

hypothetical tax rate that measures the tax savings to the payor from

the deductible payment. This provision is similar to the rule in

Sec. 1.954-3(b), and adopts the same percentage tests as contained in

that provision. The regulations also provide a special high tax

exception applicable to the hybrid branch payment that is similar to

the one contained in section 954(b)(4). Comments are invited on whether

the rules of Sec. 1.954-9T could cause inappropriate multiple

recharacterizations where the hybrid branch payments are made through a

series of related hybrid entities.

The temporary regulations provide that if these provisions affect

an entity that has elected under Sec. 301.7701-3(c) to be treated as an

entity disregarded as separate from its owner, such an entity may elect

to be classified as a corporation, provided it fulfills certain

requirements, notwithstanding the sixty-month limitation in that

section.

III. Related Provisions

These temporary regulations provide rules, contained in Sec. 1.954-

1T(c)(1)(i)(B), to prevent expenses, including related person interest

expense which would normally be allocable under section 954(b)(5) to

subpart F income of a CFC, from being allocated to a payment from which

the expense arises. The allocation limit applies: (i) to the extent

such payment is included in the subpart F income of the CFC; (ii) if

the expense arises from any payment by the CFC to a hybrid partnership

in which the CFC is a partner; and (iii) if the payment reduces foreign

tax and there is a significant disparity in tax rates between the payor

and payee jurisdictions.

These temporary regulations also address the application of the

related person exceptions to the foreign personal holding company

income rules in the context of partnership distributive shares and

transactions involving hybrid branches. Under section 954(c)(3),

foreign personal

[[Page 14615]]

holding company income does not include certain interest, dividends,

rents and royalties received from related corporations. These

exceptions apply, in the case of interest and dividends, when the

related corporate payor is organized in the country in which the CFC is

organized and uses a substantial part of its assets in a trade or

business in that country and, in the case of rents and royalties, when

the rent or royalty payment is made for the use or privilege of using

property within the CFC's country of incorporation.

The rules regarding the application of the related person

exceptions with respect to a CFC partner's distributive share of

partnership income are part of the broader set of rules addressing

distributive share issues in the context of subpart F contained in the

proposed regulations published elsewhere in this issue of the Federal

Register. Certain rules relating to the related person exception with

respect to a CFC partner's distributive share of partnership income,

and certain rules relating to the related person exception with respect

to hybrid branches, however, are included in these temporary

regulations because they address a fact pattern similar to the one to

which the hybrid branch payment rules apply. No inference is intended

as to the treatment under existing law of such arrangements in relation

to the related party exceptions.

Under these rules, if the partnership receives an item of income

that reduces the income tax of the payor, the related person exceptions

of section 954(c)(3) apply to exclude the income from the foreign

personal holding company income of the CFC partner only where: the

exception would have applied if the CFC earned the income directly

(testing relatedness and country of incorporation at the CFC partner

level); and either the partnership is organized and operates in the

CFC's country of incorporation, the partnership is treated as fiscally

transparent in the CFC's countries of incorporation and operation, or

there is no significant disparity between the effective rate of tax

imposed on the income and the rate of tax that would be imposed on the

income if earned directly by the CFC partner.

The rules applying the related person exceptions with respect to

hybrid branches address transactions illustrated in the first example

of Notice 98-11 (1998-6 I.R.B. 13). These rules apply to payments by a

CFC to a hybrid branch of a related CFC. Under these rules, the related

person exceptions will apply to exclude the payments from the foreign

personal holding company income of the recipient CFC only if the

payment would have qualified for the exception if the hybrid branch had

been a separate CFC incorporated in the jurisdiction in which the

payment is subject to tax (other than a withholding tax).

IV. Effective Date.

These regulations are effective March 23, 1998. For dates of

applicability see Secs. 1.904-5T(o), 1.954-1T(c)(1)(i)(E), 1.954-

2T(a)(5)(iii) and (6)(iii), 1.954-9T(d) and 301.7701-3T(f) of these

regulations.

Special Analyses

It has been determined that this Treasury decision is not a

significant regulatory action as defined in Executive Order 12866.

Therefore, a regulatory assessment is not required. It has also been

determined that section 553(b) of the Administrative Procedures Act (5

U.S.C. chapter 5) does not apply to these regulations and, because the

regulation does not impose a collection of information on small

entities, the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. chapter 6) does not

apply. Pursuant to section 7805(f) of the Internal Revenue Code, these

temporary regulations will be submitted to the Chief Counsel for

Advocacy of the Small Business Administration for comment on their

impact on small business.

Drafting Information

The principal author of these regulations is Valerie Mark, of the

Office of the Associate Chief Counsel (International). Other personnel

from the IRS and Treasury Department also participated in the

development of these regulations.

List of Subjects

26 CFR Part 1

Income taxes, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

26 CFR Part 301

Employment taxes, Estate taxes, Excise taxes, Gift taxes, Income

taxes, Penalties, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

Adoption of Amendments to the Regulations

Accordingly, 26 CFR parts 1 and 301 are amended as follows:

PART 1--INCOME TAXES

Paragraph 1. The authority citation for 26 CFR part 1 continues to

read in part as follows:

Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *

Par. 2. In Sec. 1.904-5, paragraph (o) is amended by adding a

sentence at the end to read as follows:

Sec. 1.904-5 Look-through rules as applied to controlled foreign

corporations and other entities.

* * * * *

(o) * * * Paragraph (k)(1) of this section does not apply on or

after March 23, 1998. For rules applicable on or after March 23, 1998,

see Sec. 1.904-5T(k)(1).

Par. 3. Sec. 1.904-5T is added to read as follows:

Sec. 1.904-5T Look-through rules as applied to controlled foreign

corporations and other entities (temporary).

(a) through (j) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see Sec. 1.904-

5(a) through (j).

(k) Ordering rules--(1) In general. Income received or accrued by a

related person to which the look-through rules apply is characterized

before amounts included from, or paid or distributed by, that person

and received or accrued by a related person. For purposes of

determining the character of income received or accrued by a person

from a related person if the payor or another related person also

receives or accrues income from the recipient and the look-through

rules apply to the income in all cases, the rules of paragraph (k)(2)

of this section apply. Notwithstanding any other provision of this

section, the principles of Sec. 1.954-1T(c)(1)(i) will apply to any

expense subject to that subparagraph.

(k)(2) through (n) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see

Sec. 1.904-5(k)(2) through (n).

(o) Effective date. Section 1.904-5T(k)(1) applies on or after

March 23, 1998. For rules prior to March 23, 1998, see Sec. 1.904-

5(k)(1).

Par. 4. Section 1.954-0(b) is amended by revising the paragraph

heading and the entry for Sec. 1.954-0(b) in the list to read as

follows:

Sec. 1.954-0 Introduction.

* * * * *

(b) Outline of Secs. 1.954-0, 1.954-1 and 1.954-2.

Sec. 1.954-0 Introduction.

* * * * *

(b) Outline of Secs. 1.954-0, 1.954-1, and 1.954-2.

* * * * *

Par. 5. Section 1.954-1 is amended by adding a new paragraph

(c)(1)(iv) to read as follows:

Sec. 1.954-1 Foreign base company income.

* * * * *

(c) * * *

(1) * * *

(iv) Effective date. Paragraph (c)(1)(i) of this section does not

apply to all

[[Page 14616]]

amounts paid or accrued on or after March 23, 1998 except for amounts

paid or accrued pursuant to arrangements entered into before March 23,

1998 and not substantially modified (including, for example, by

expansion of the arrangement (whether by exercise of an option or

otherwise) such as by an increase in the amount of or term of any

borrowing, leasing or licensing constituting the arrangement, changes

in direct or indirect control of any entity that is a party to the

arrangement, or any similar measure which materially increases the tax

benefit of the arrangement) on or after March 23, 1998. For rules

applicable on or after March 23, 1998, see Sec. 1.954-1T(c)(1)(i).

Par. 6. Section 1.954-1T is added to read as follows:

Sec. 1.954-1T Foreign base company income (temporary).

(a) through (c)(1)(i) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see

Sec. 1.954-1(a) through (c)(1).

(c)(1)(i) Deductions against gross foreign base company income--(A)

In general. [Reserved]. For further guidance, see Sec. 1.954-

1(c)(1)(i).

(B) Special rule for deductible payments to certain non-fiscally

transparent entities. Notwithstanding any other provision of this

section, except as provided in paragraph (c)(1)(i)(C) of this section,

an expense (including a distributive share of any expense) that would

otherwise be allocable under section 954(b)(5) against the subpart F

income of a controlled foreign corporation shall not be allocated

against subpart F income of the controlled foreign corporation

resulting from the payment giving rise to the expense if--

(1) Such expense arises from a payment between the controlled

foreign corporation and a partnership in which the controlled foreign

corporation is a partner and the partnership is not regarded as

fiscally transparent, as defined in Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(7), by any country

in which the controlled foreign corporation does business or has

substantial assets; and

(2) The payment from which the expense arises would have met the

foreign tax reduction test of Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(3) and the tax disparity

test of Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(5)(iv) if those provisions had been applicable

to the payment.

(C) Limitations. Paragraph (c)(1)(i)(B) shall not apply to the

extent that the controlled foreign corporation partner has no income

against which to allocate the expense, other than its distributive

share of a payment described in paragraph (c)(1)(i)(B) of this section.

Similarly, to the extent an expense described in paragraph (c)(1)(i)(B)

of this section exceeds the controlled foreign corporation partner's

distributive share of the payment from which the expense arises, such

excess amount of the expense may reduce subpart F income (other than

such payment) to which it is properly allocable or apportionable under

section 954(b)(5).

(D) Example. The following example illustrates the application of

paragraph (c)(1)(i)(B) and (C) of this section:

Example. CFC, a controlled foreign corporation in Country A, is

a 70 percent partner in partnership P, located in Country B. Country

A's tax laws do not classify P as a fiscally transparent entity. The

rate of tax in country B is 15 percent of the tax rate in country A.

P loans $100 to CFC at a market rate of interest. In year 1, CFC

pays P $10 of interest on the loan. The interest payment would have

caused the recharacterization rules of Sec. 1.954-9T to apply if the

payment were made between the entities described in Sec. 1.954-

9T(a)(2). CFC's distributive share of P's interest income is $7,

which is foreign personal holding company income to CFC under

section 954(c). Under paragraph (c)(1)(i)(B) of this section, $7 of

the $10 interest expense may not be allocated against any of CFC's

subpart F income. However, to the extent the remaining $3 of

interest expense is properly allocable to subpart F income of CFC

other than its distributive share of P's interest income, this

expense may offset such other subpart F income.

(E) Effective date. Paragraph (c)(1)(i)(B), (C) and (D) of this

section shall apply to all amounts paid or accrued on or after March

23, 1998, except for amounts paid or accrued pursuant to arrangements

entered into before March 23, 1998 and not substantially modified

(including, for example, by expansion of the arrangement (whether by

exercise of an option or otherwise) such as by an increase in the

amount of or term of any borrowing, leasing or licensing constituting

the arrangement, changes in direct or indirect control of any entity

that is a party to the arrangement, or any similar measure which

materially increases the tax benefit of the arrangement) on or after

March 23, 1998. For rules applicable to amounts paid or accrued

pursuant to arrangements entered into before March 23, 1998, see

Sec. 1.954-1.

(c)(1)(ii) through (f) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see

Sec. 1.954-1(c)(1)(ii) through (f).

Par. 7. Section 1.954-2T is added to read as follows:

Sec. 1.954-2T Foreign personal holding company income (temporary).

(a)(1) through (4) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see

Sec. 1.954-2(a) through (4).

(5) Special rules applicable to distributive share of partnership

income--(i) Application of related person exceptions where payment

reduces foreign tax of payor. If a partnership receives an item of

income that reduced the foreign income tax of the payor (determined

under the principles of Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(3)), to determine the extent

to which a controlled foreign corporation's distributive share of such

item of income is foreign personal holding company income, the

exceptions contained in section 954(c)(3) shall apply only if--

(A)(1) Any such exception would have applied to exclude the income

from foreign personal holding company income if the controlled foreign

corporation had earned the income directly (determined by testing, with

reference to such controlled foreign corporation, whether an entity is

a related person, within the meaning of section 954(d)(3), or is

organized under the laws of, or uses property in, the foreign country

in which the controlled foreign corporation is created or organized);

and

(2) The distributive share of such income is not in respect of a

payment made by the controlled foreign corporation to the partnership;

and

(B)(1) The partnership is created or organized, and uses a

substantial part of its assets in a trade or business in the country

under the laws of which the controlled foreign corporation is created

or organized (determined under the principles of Sec. 1.954-2(b)(4));

(2) The partnership is regarded as fiscally transparent, as defined

in Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(7), by all countries under the laws of which the

controlled foreign corporation is created or organized or has

substantial assets; or

(3) The income is taxed in the year when earned at an effective

rate of tax (determined under the principles of Sec. 1.954-1(d)(2))

that is not less than 90 percent of, and not more than five percentage

points less than, the effective rate of tax that would have applied to

such income under the laws of the country in which the controlled

foreign corporation is created or organized if such income were earned

directly by the controlled foreign corporation partner from local

sources.

(ii) Certain other exceptions applicable to foreign personal

holding company income. [Reserved].

(iii) Effective date. Paragraph (a)(5)(i) of this section shall

apply to all amounts paid or accrued on or after March 23, 1998, except

for amounts paid or accrued pursuant to arrangements entered into

before March 23, 1998 and

[[Page 14617]]

not substantially modified (including, for example, by expansion of the

arrangement (whether by exercise of an option or otherwise) such as by

an increase in the amount of or term of any borrowing, leasing or

licensing constituting the arrangement, changes in direct or indirect

control of any entity that is a party to the arrangement, or any

similar measure which materially increases the tax benefit of the

arrangement) on or after March 23, 1998.

(6) Special rules applicable to exceptions from foreign personal

holding company income treatment in circumstances involving hybrid

branches--(i) In general. In the case of a payment between a controlled

foreign corporation (or its hybrid branch, as defined in Sec. 1.954-

9T(a)(6)) and the hybrid branch of a related controlled foreign

corporation, the exceptions contained in section 954(c)(3) shall apply

only if the payment would have qualified for the exception if the payor

were a separate controlled foreign corporation created or organized in

the jurisdiction where foreign tax is reduced and the payee were a

separate controlled foreign corporation created or organized under the

laws of the jurisdiction in which the payment is subject to tax (other

than a withholding tax).

(ii) Exception where no tax reduction or tax disparity. Paragraph

(a)(6)(i) of this section shall not apply unless the payment would have

met the foreign tax reduction test of Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(3) and the tax

disparity test of Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(5)(iv) if those provisions had been

applicable to the payment.

(iii) Effective date. The rules of this section shall apply to all

amounts paid or accrued on or after January 16, 1998, except for

amounts paid or accrued pursuant to arrangements entered into before

January 16, 1998, and not substantially modified (including, for

example, by expansion of the arrangement (whether by exercise of an

option or otherwise) such as by an increase in the amount of or term of

any borrowing, leasing or licensing constituting the arrangement,

changes in direct or indirect control of any entity that is a party to

the arrangement, or any similar measure which materially increases the

tax benefit of the arrangement) on or after January 16, 1998.

(b) through (h) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see Sec. 1.954-

2(b) through (h).

Par. 8. Section 1.954-9T is added to read as follows:

Sec. 1.954-9T Hybrid branches (temporary).

(a) Subpart F income arising from certain payments involving hybrid

branches--(1) Payment causing foreign tax reduction gives rise to

additional subpart F income. The non-subpart F income of the controlled

foreign corporation will be recharacterized as subpart F income, to the

extent provided in paragraph (a)(5) of this section, if--

(i) A hybrid branch payment, as defined in paragraph (a)(6) of this

section, is made between the entities described in paragraph (a)(2) of

this section;

(ii) The hybrid branch payment reduces foreign tax, as determined

under paragraph (a)(3) of this section; and

(iii) The hybrid branch payment is treated as falling within a

category of foreign personal holding company income under the rules of

paragraph (a)(4) of this section.

(2) Hybrid branch payment between certain entities--(i) In general.

Paragraph (a)(1) of this section shall apply to hybrid branch payments

between--

(A) A controlled foreign corporation and its hybrid branch;

(B) Hybrid branches of a controlled foreign corporation;

(C) A partnership in which a controlled foreign corporation is a

partner (either directly or through one or more branches or other

partnerships) and a hybrid branch of the partnership; or

(D) Hybrid branches of a partnership in which a controlled foreign

corporation is a partner (either directly or through one or more

branches or other partnerships).

(ii) Hybrid branch payment involving partnership--(A) Fiscally

transparent partnership. To the extent of the controlled foreign

corporation's proportionate share of a hybrid branch payment, the rules

of paragraphs (a)(3), (4) and (5) of this section shall be applied by

treating the hybrid branch payment between the partnership and the

hybrid branch as if it were made directly between the controlled

foreign corporation and the hybrid branch, or as if the hybrid branches

of the partnership were hybrid branches of the controlled foreign

corporation, if the hybrid branch payment is made between--

(1) A fiscally transparent partnership in which a controlled

foreign corporation is a partner (either directly or through one or

more branches or other fiscally transparent partnerships) and the

partnership's hybrid branch; or

(2) Hybrid branches of a fiscally transparent partnership in which

a controlled foreign corporation is a partner (either directly or

through one or more branches or other fiscally transparent

partnerships).

(B) Non-fiscally transparent partnership. To the extent of the

controlled foreign corporation's proportionate share of a hybrid branch

payment, the rules of paragraphs (a)(3) and (4) and (a)(5)(iv) of this

section shall be applied to the non-fiscally transparent partnership as

if it were the controlled foreign corporation, if the hybrid branch

payment is made between--

(1) A non-fiscally transparent partnership in which a controlled

foreign corporation is a partner (either directly or through one or

more branches or other partnerships) and the partnership's hybrid

branch; or

(2) Hybrid branches of a non-fiscally transparent partnership in

which a controlled foreign corporation is a partner (either directly or

through one or more branches or other partnerships).

(C) Examples. The following examples illustrate the application of

this paragraph (a)(2)(ii).

Example 1. CFC, a controlled foreign corporation in Country A,

is a 90 percent partner in partnership P, which is treated as

fiscally transparent under the laws of Country A. P has a hybrid

branch, BR, in Country B. P makes an interest payment of $100 to BR.

Under Country A law, CFC's 90 percent share of the payment reduces

CFC's Country A income tax. Under paragraph (a)(2)(ii)(A) of this

section, the recharacterization rules of this section are applied by

treating the payment as if made by CFC to BR. Ninety dollars of

CFC's non-subpart F income, to the extent available, and subject to

the earnings and profits and tax rate limitations of Sec. 1.954-

9T(a)(5), is recharacterized as subpart F income.

Example 2. CFC, a controlled foreign corporation in Country A,

is a 90 percent partner in partnership P, which is treated as

fiscally transparent under the laws of Country A. P has two branches

in Country B, BR1 and BR2. BR1 is treated as fiscally transparent

under the laws of Country A. BR2 is a hybrid branch. BR1 makes an

interest payment of $100 to BR2. Under paragraph (a)(2)(ii)(A) of

this section, the payment by BR1, the fiscally transparent branch,

is treated as a payment by P, and the deemed payment by P, a

fiscally transparent partnership, is treated as made by CFC. Under

Country A law, CFC's 90 percent share of BR1's payment reduces CFC's

Country A income tax. Ninety dollars of CFC's non-subpart F income,

to the extent available, and subject to the earnings and profits and

tax rate limitations of Sec. 1.954-9T(a)(5), is recharacterized as

subpart F income.

(3) Application when payment reduces foreign tax. For purposes of

paragraph (a)(1) of this section, a hybrid branch payment reduces

foreign tax when the foreign tax imposed on the

[[Page 14618]]

income of the payor or any owner of the payor is less than the foreign

tax that would have been imposed on such income had the hybrid branch

payment not been made, or the hybrid branch payment creates or

increases a loss or deficit or other tax attribute which may be carried

back or forward to reduce the foreign income tax of the payor or any

owner in another year (determined by taking into account any refund of

such tax made to the payor, payee or any other person).

(4) Hybrid branch payment that is included within a category of

foreign personal holding company income--(i) In general. For purposes

of paragraph (a)(1) of this section, whether the hybrid branch payment

is treated as income included within a category of foreign personal

holding company income is determined by treating a hybrid branch that

is either the payor or recipient of the hybrid branch payment as a

separate wholly-owned subsidiary corporation of the controlled foreign

corporation that is incorporated in the jurisdiction under the laws of

which such hybrid branch is created, organized for foreign law

purposes, or has substantial assets. Thus, the hybrid branch payment

will be treated as included within a category of foreign personal

holding company income if, taking into account any specific exceptions

for that category, the payment would be included within a category of

foreign personal holding company income if the branch or branches were

treated as separately incorporated for U.S. tax purposes.

(ii) Extent to which controlled foreign corporation and hybrid

branches treated as separate entities. For purposes other than the

determination under paragraph (a)(4)(i) of this section, a controlled

foreign corporation and its hybrid branch, a partnership and its hybrid

branch, or hybrid branches shall not be treated as separate entities.

Thus, for example, if a controlled foreign corporation, including all

of its hybrid branches, has an overall deficit in earnings and profits

to which section 952(c) applies, the limitation of such section on the

amount includible in the subpart F income of such corporation will

apply. Similarly, for purposes of applying the de minimis and full

inclusion rules of section 954(b)(3), a controlled foreign corporation

and its hybrid branch, or hybrid branches shall not be treated as

separate corporations. Further, a hybrid branch payment that would

reduce foreign personal holding company income under section 954(b)(5)

if made between two separate entities will not create an expense if

made between a controlled foreign corporation and its hybrid branch, a

partnership and its hybrid branch, or hybrid branches.

(5) Recharacterization of income attributable to current earnings

and profits as subpart F income--(i) General rule. Non-subpart F income

of a controlled foreign corporation in an amount equal to the excess of

earnings and profits of the controlled foreign corporation for the

taxable year over subpart F income, as defined in section 952(a), will

be recharacterized as subpart F income under paragraph (a)(1) of this

section only to the extent provided under paragraphs (a)(5)(ii) through

(vi) of this section.

(ii) Subpart F income. For purposes of determining the excess of

current earnings and profits over subpart F income under paragraph

(a)(1) of this section, the amount of subpart F income is determined

before the application of the rules of this section but after the

application of the rules of sections 952(c) and 954(b). Further, such

amount is determined by treating the controlled foreign corporation and

all of its hybrid branches as a single corporation.

(iii) Recharacterization limited to gross amount of hybrid branch

payment--(A) In general. The amount recharacterized as subpart F income

under paragraph (a)(1) of this section is limited to the amount of the

hybrid branch payment.

(B) Exception for duplicative payments. [Reserved].

(iv) Tax disparity rule--(A) In general. Paragraph (a)(1) of this

section will apply only if the hybrid branch payment falls within the

tax disparity rule. The hybrid branch payment falls within the tax

disparity rule if it is taxed in the year when earned at an effective

rate of tax that is less than 90 percent of, and at least 5 percentage

points less than, the hypothetical effective rate of tax imposed on the

hybrid branch payment, as determined under paragraph (a)(5)(iv)(B) of

this section.

(B) Hypothetical effective rate of tax--(1) In general. The

hypothetical effective rate of tax imposed on the hybrid branch payment

is--

(i) For the taxable year of the payor in which the hybrid branch

payment is made, the amount of income taxes that would have been paid

or accrued by the payor if the hybrid branch payment had not been made,

less the amount of income taxes paid or accrued by the payor; divided

by

(ii) The amount of the hybrid branch payment.

(2) Hypothetical effective rate of tax when hybrid branch payment

causes or increases loss or deficit. If the hybrid branch payment

causes or increases a loss or deficit of the payor for foreign tax

purposes, and such loss or deficit can be carried forward or back, the

hypothetical effective rate of tax imposed on the hybrid branch payment

is the effective rate of tax that would be imposed on the taxable

income of the payor for the year in which the foreign law payment is

made if the payor's taxable income were equal to the amount of the

hybrid branch payment.

(C) Examples. The application of this paragraph (a)(5)(iv) is

illustrated by the following examples.

Example 1. In 1998, CFC organized in Country A had net income of

$60 from manufacturing for Country A tax purposes. It also had a

branch (BR) in Country B. BR is a hybrid entity under paragraph

(a)(1) of this section. CFC made a payment of $40 to BR, which was a

hybrid branch payment under paragraph (a)(6) of this section, and

was treated by CFC as a deductible payment for Country A tax

purposes. CFC paid $30 of Country A taxes in 1998. It would have

paid $50 of Country A taxes without the deductible payment. Country

A did not impose any withholding tax on the $40 payment to BR.

Country B also did not impose a tax on the $40 received by BR.

Therefore, the effective rate of tax on that payment is 0%.

Furthermore, the hypothetical effective rate of tax on the $40

hybrid branch payment is 50% ($50-$30/$40). The effective rate of

tax (0%) is less than 90% of, and more than 5 percentage points less

than, this hypothetical rate of tax of 50%. As a result, the $40

hybrid branch payment falls within the tax disparity rule of this

paragraph (a)(5)(iv).

Example 2. Assume the same facts as in Example 1, except that

CFC has a loss of $100 for the year for Country A tax purposes.

Under Country A law, CFC can carry the loss forward for use in

subsequent years. CFC paid no Country A taxes in 1998. The rate of

tax in Country A is graduated from 20% to 50%. If the $40 hybrid

branch payment were the only item of taxable income of CFC, Country

A would have imposed tax at an effective rate of 30%. The effective

rate of tax (0%) is less than 90 percent of, and more than 5

percentage points less than, the hypothetical effective rate of tax

(30%) imposed on the hybrid branch payment. As a result, the $40

hybrid branch payment falls within the tax disparity rule of this

paragraph (a)(5)(iv).

Example 3. Assume the same facts as in Example 1, except that

Country B imposes tax on the $40 hybrid payment to BR at an

effective rate of 50%. The effective rate of 50% is equal to the

hypothetical effective rate of tax. As a result, the hybrid branch

payment does not fall within the tax disparity rule of this

paragraph (a)(5)(iv) and, thus, the recharacterization rules of

paragraph (a)(1) of this section do not apply. See also the special

high tax exception of paragraph (a)(5)(v) of this section.

(v) Special high tax exception--(A) In general. Paragraph (a)(1) of

this section shall not apply if the non-subpart F income

recharacterized as subpart F

[[Page 14619]]

income under this section was subject to foreign income taxes imposed

by a foreign country or countries at an effective rate that is greater

than 90 percent of the maximum rate of tax specified in section 11 for

the taxable year of the controlled foreign corporation.

(B) Effective rate of tax. The effective rate of tax imposed on the

net amount of the hybrid branch payment is determined under the

principles of Sec. 1.954-1(d)(2) and (3). See paragraph (c) of this

section for the application of section 960 to amounts recharacterized

as subpart F income under this section.

(vi) No carryback or carryforward of amounts in excess of current

year earnings and profits limitation. To the extent that some or all of

the amount required to be recharacterized under this section is not

recharacterized as subpart F income because the hybrid branch payment

exceeds the amount that can be recharacterized, as determined under

paragraph (a)(5)(i) of this section, this excess shall not be carried

back or forward to another year.

(6) Definitions. For purposes of this section--

Entity means any person that is treated by the United States or any

jurisdiction as other than an individual.

Hybrid branch means an entity that--

(i) Has a single owner (including ownership through branches) that

is either a controlled foreign corporation or a partnership in which a

controlled foreign corporation is a partner (either directly or

indirectly through one or more branches or partnerships);

(ii) Is treated as fiscally transparent by the United States; and

(iii) Is treated as non-fiscally transparent by the country in

which the payor entity, any owner of a fiscally-transparent payor

entity, the controlled foreign corporation, or any intermediary

partnership is created, organized or has substantial assets.

Hybrid branch payment means the gross amount of any payment

(including any accrual) which, under the tax laws of any foreign

jurisdiction to which the payor is subject, is regarded as a payment

between two separate entities but which, under U.S. income tax

principles, is not income to the recipient because it is between two

parts of a single entity.

(7) Fiscally transparent and non-fiscally transparent. For purposes

of this section an entity shall be treated as fiscally transparent with

respect to an interest holder of the entity, if such interest holder is

required, under the laws of any jurisdiction to which it is subject, to

take into account separately, on a current basis, such interest

holder's share of all items which, if separately taken into account by

such interest holder, would result in an income tax liability for the

interest holder in such jurisdiction different from that which would

result if the interest holder did not take the share of such items into

account separately. A non-fiscally transparent entity is an entity that

is not fiscally transparent under this paragraph (a)(7).

(b) Election to change classification--(1) In general. If a hybrid

branch subject to the provisions of paragraph (a) of this section is an

entity that has made an election under Sec. 301.7701-3(c)(1) of this

chapter to be disregarded as an entity separate from its owner, such

entity may elect to change its classification to that of an association

taxable as a corporation, under the procedures described in

Sec. 301.7701-3(c) of this chapter, without regard to the limitation of

Sec. 301.7701-3T(c)(1)(iv) of this chapter, but only if such election

is made on or before the last day of the first taxable year beginning

on or after January 1, 1998. An election made pursuant to this

paragraph (b)(1) is effective as of the first day of such taxable year.

The 75 day limitation on retroactivity in Sec. 301.7701-3(c)(1)(iii) of

this chapter does not apply.

(2) Limitation. An entity can elect to change its classification

under the provisions of this paragraph only one time.

(c) Application of section 960--For purposes of determining the

amount of taxes deemed paid under section 960, the amount of non-

subpart F income recharacterized as subpart F income under this section

shall be treated as attributable to income in separate categories, as

defined in Sec. 1.904-5(a)(1), in proportion to the ratio of non-

subpart F income in each such category to the total amount of non-

subpart F income of the controlled foreign corporation for the taxable

year.

(d) Effective dates--(1) Hybrid branches of controlled foreign

corporations. With respect to hybrid branch payments described in

paragraph (a)(2)(i)(A) and (B) of this section, the rules of this

section shall apply to all amounts paid or accrued on or after January

16, 1998, except for amounts paid or accrued pursuant to arrangements

entered into before January 16, 1998, and not substantially modified

(including, for example, by expansion of the arrangement (whether by

exercise of an option or otherwise) such as by an increase in the

amount of or term of any borrowing, leasing or licensing constituting

the arrangement, changes in direct or indirect control of any entity

that is a party to the arrangement, or any similar measure which

materially increases the tax benefit of the arrangement) on or after

January 16, 1998.

(2) Hybrid branches of partnerships in which controlled foreign

corporations are partners. With respect to hybrid branch payments

described in paragraph (a)(2)(i)(C) and (D) of this section, the rules

of this section shall apply to all amounts paid or accrued on or after

March 23, 1998, except for amounts paid or accrued pursuant to

arrangements entered into before March 23, 1998 and not substantially

modified (including, for example, by expansion of the arrangement

(whether by exercise of an option or otherwise) such as by an increase

in the amount of or term of any borrowing, leasing or licensing

constituting the arrangement, changes in direct or indirect control of

any entity that is a party to the arrangement, or any similar measure

which materially increases the tax benefit of the arrangement) on or

after March 23, 1998.

PART 301--PROCEDURE AND ADMINISTRATION

Par. 9. The authority citation for 26 CFR part 301 continue to read

in part as follows:

Authority: 26 U.S.C. 7805 * * *

Par. 10. In Sec. 301.7701-3, paragraph (f)(1) is amended by adding

a sentence at the end to read as follows:

Sec. 301.7701-3. Classification of certain business entities.

* * * * *

(f)(1) * * * Paragraphs (a), (c)(1)(iv) and (f) of this section do

not apply on or after March 23, 1998. For rules applicable on or after

March 23, 1998, see Sec. 301.7701-3T(a), (c)(1)(iv) and (f).

Par. 11. Section 301.7701-3T is added to read as follows:

Sec. 301.7701-3T Classification of certain business entities

(temporary).

(a) In general. A business entity that is not classified as

corporation under Sec. 301.7701-2(b)(1), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7), or

(8) (an eligible entity) can elect its classification for federal tax

purposes as provided in this section. An eligible entity with at least

two members can elect to be classified as either an association (and

thus a corporation under Sec. 301.7701-2(b)(2)) or a partnership, and

an eligible entity with a single owner can elect to be classified as an

association or to be disregarded as an entity separate from its owner.

Paragraph (b) of this section provides a default classification for an

eligible entity that does not make an election.

[[Page 14620]]

Thus, elections are necessary only when an eligible entity chooses to

be classified initially as other than the default classification or

when an eligible entity chooses to change its classification. An entity

whose classification is determined under the default classification

retains that classification (regardless of any changes in the members'

liability that occurs at any time during the time that the entity's

classification is relevant as defined in paragraph (d) of this section)

until the entity makes an election to change that classification under

paragraph (c)(1) of this section. Paragraph (c) of this section

provides rules for making express elections. Paragraph (d) provides

special rules for foreign eligible entities. Paragraph (e) of this

section provides special rules for classifying entities resulting from

partnership terminations and divisions under section 708(b). Paragraph

(f) of this section sets forth the effective date of this section and a

special rule relating to prior periods. An entity that has elected to

be disregarded as an entity separate from its owner may nevertheless be

treated as a corporation for the limited purposes of Sec. 1.954-

9T(a)(4)(i) of this chapter.

(b) through (c)(1)(iii) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see

Sec. 301.7701-3(b) through (c)(1)(iii).

(c)(1)(iv) Limitation. If an eligible entity makes an election

under paragraph (c)(1)(i) of this section to change its classification

(other than an election made by an existing entity to change its

classification as of the effective date of this section), the entity

cannot change its classification by election again during the sixty

months succeeding the effective date of the election. However, the

Commissioner may permit the entity to change its classification by

election within the sixty months if more than fifty percent of the

ownership interests in the entity as of the effective date of the

subsequent election are owned by person that did not own any interests

in the entity on the filing date or on the effective date of the

entity's prior election. See Sec. 1.954-9T(b) of this chapter, for

circumstances under which certain eligible entities may make an

election to change their classification within the sixty-month period.

(c)(1)(v) through (e) [Reserved]. For further guidance, see

Sec. 301.7701-3(c)(1)(v) through (e).

(f) Effective date. Section 301.7701-3T(a) and (c)(1)(iv) applies

on or after March 23, 1998. For rules prior to March 23, 1998, see

Sec. 301.7701-3(a) and (c)(1)(iv).

Michael P. Dolan,

Deputy Commissioner of Internal Revenue.

Approved:

Donald C. Lubick,

Assistant Secretary of the Treasury.

[FR Doc. 98-7891 Filed 3-23-98; 12:58 pm]

BILLING CODE 4830-01-U

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Guidance Under Subpart F Relating to Partnerships and Branches · 63 FR 14613 | Frix