Determinations Under Section 304 of the Trade Act of 1974: European Communities' Banana Regime

Federal RegisterFeb 18, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

OFFICE OF THE UNITED STATES TRADE REPRESENTATIVE

[Docket No. 301-100]

Determinations Under Section 304 of the Trade Act of 1974:

European Communities' Banana Regime

agency: Office of the United States Trade Representative.

action: Notice of determinations, termination and monitoring.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

summary: The United States Trade Representative (USTR) has determined

that certain acts, policies and practices of the European Communities

(``EC'') that discriminate against U.S. banana marketing companies and

distort international banana trade violate, or otherwise deny benefits

to which the United States is entitled under, the General Agreement on

Tariffs and Trade (GATT) 1994 and the General Agreement on Trade in

Services (GATS). This determination is based on the report of a dispute

settlement panel convened under the auspices of the World Trade

Organization (WTO) at the request of the United States, Ecuador,

Guatemala, Honduras, and Mexico and the report of the WTO Appellate

Body reviewing the panel report. The Appellate Body report and the

panel report, as modified by the Appellate Body report, (``the WTO

reports'') were adopted by the WTO Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) on

September 25, 1997. Following the adoption of the reports by the DSB

and during a WTO arbitration hearing convened on December 17, 1997 to

establish ``the reasonable period of time'' for the EC to implement the

WTO reports, the EC stated its intention to comply with its

international obligations and to implement all the rulings and

recommendations in the WTO reports within a ``reasonable period of

time,'' that is, by January 1, 1999. In light of the foregoing, the

USTR will not take action under section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974

(``the Trade Act'') at this time and has terminated this investigation.

However, the USTR will monitor the EC's implementation of the WTO

reports, and will take action under section 301(a) of the Trade Act if

the EC does not come into compliance.

effective date: February 10, 1998.

addresses: 600 17th Street, NW., Washington, DC 20508.

for further information contact: Rachel Shub, Associate General Counsel

(202) 395-7305; William Kane, Associate General Counsel (202) 395-6800;

or Ralph Ives, Deputy Assistant U.S. Trade Representative, (202) 395-

3320.

supplementary information: On September 27, 1995, the USTR initiated an

investigation under section 302(b) of the Trade Act (19 U.S.C. 2412(b))

regarding the EC's regime for the importation, sale and distribution of

bananas and requested public comment on the issues raised in the

investigation and the determinations to be made under section 304 of

the Trade Act. 60 FR 52026 of October 4, 1995. This investigation

specially concerned EC Council Regulation No. 404/93 and related

measures distorting international banana trade and discriminating

against U.S. marketing companies importing bananas from Latin America,

including a restrictive and discriminatory licensing scheme designed to

transfer market share in the wholesale distribution sector from U.S.

banana marketing firms to firms of EC or African, Caribbean and Pacific

(``ACP'') nationality.

As required under section 303(a) of the Trade Act, the United

States held consultations with the EC under the procedures of the WTO

Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of

Disputes (DSU). After holding a first set of consultations with the EC

on October 26, 1995, the United States and the governments of

Guatemala, Honduras and Mexico decided to delay the request for a

dispute settlement panel until Ecuador, the world's largest banana

exporter, had completed its accession and could join the dispute

settlement proceeding. Pursuant to a new request filed jointly by the

governments of Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, Mexico and the United

States (``Complaining parties''), a second set of WTO consultations

with the EC was held on March 14, 1996. A dispute settlement panel was

established on May 8, 1996.

Pursuant to Section 304(a)(1)(A) of the Trade Act (19 U.S.C.

2414(a)(1)(A)), the USTR must determine in this case whether any act,

policy or practice of the EC violates, or otherwise denies benefits to

which the United States is entitled under, any trade agreement. If that

determination is affirmative, the USTR must take action under section

301 of the Trade Act (19 USC 2411), subject to the specific direction

of the President, if any, unless the USTR finds that one of the

circumstances set forth in section 301(a)(2)(B) exists.

Reasons for Determinations

(1) EU Acts, Policies and Practices

The WTO panel in this case circulated its report on May 22, 1997.

It included numerous findings that the EC banana regime is inconsistent

with the EC's WTO obligations. The EC appealed all of the panel's

adverse findings, and the Complaining Parties cross-appealed three. On

September 9, 1997, the Appellate Body issued its report confirming all

the major panel findings against the EC regime, and reversing the panel

report on two issues that had been decided in the EC's favor (agreeing

with the Complaining parties). On September 25, 1997, the DSB adopted

the Appellate Body and the panel report (as modified by the Appellate

Body report). The WTO reports include findings that the following EC

measures violate the EC's obligations under various provisions of the

GATT 1994 and/or the GATS: The EC's discriminatory allocation of shares

of its market to certain ACP countries and to certain countries

signatory to the Banana Framework Agreement; (2) the EC's

discriminatory rules for reallocating annual country shares in the

event of a country's shortfall; (3) the EC's discriminatory

distribution to EC and ACP banana distribution companies of ``Category

B'' licenses to import bananas from non-EC, non-ACP countries (mainly

Latin America); (4) the EC's requirements for obtaining licenses to

import from Latin America, which impose burdens not imposed on imports

from ACP counties; (5) the EC's distribution of licenses to ripeners in

the EC, which discriminates against U.S. and Latin America firms in

favor of EC firms; (6) the EC's discriminatory export certificate

requirements; and (7) the EC's distribution to EC and ACP banana

distribution companies of additional licenses, so-called ``hurricane

licenses,'' to import from Latin America. (The Complaining parties did

not challenge

[[Page 8249]]

the EC's preferential tariffs for ``traditional'' ACP bananas.)

Thus, based on the results of the WTO dispute settlement

proceedings, the public comments received and appropriate

consultations, the USTR has determined that certain acts, policies and

practices of the EC violate, or otherwise deny benefits to which the

United States is entitled under, GATT 1994 and the GATS.

(2) U.S. Action

At a meeting of the DSB on October 16, 1997, the EC stated that it

would ``fully respect its international obligations with regard to this

matter'' and would require a ``reasonable period of time to do so.'' On

December 17, 1997, at a WTO arbitration hearing requested by the

Complaining parties to determine the ``reasonable period of time''

pursuant to Article 21.3 of the DSU, the EC made it clear that the

``reasonable period of time'' it requested, i.e., until January 1,

1999, is for the purpose of implementing all the recommendations and

ruling of the DSB adopted on September 25. On January 7, 1998, the WTO-

appointed arbitrator circulated his determination that the period until

January 1, 1999, would be the ``reasonable period of time'' for the EC

to implement the DSB rulings and recommendations.

On the basis of the foregoing, the USTR finds that the EC's

undertaking to implement all of the rulings and recommendations of the

WTO reports within the established reasonable period of time pursuant

to Article 21.3 of the DSU constitute for the purposes of section

301(a)(2)(B)(i) the taking of satisfactory measures to grant the rights

of the United States under the GATT 1994 and GATS. Therefore, pursuant

to section 301(a)(2) the USTR will not take action under section 301 of

the Trade Act at this time and has terminated this investigation.

However, pursuant to section 306 of the Trade Act, the USTR will

monitor the EC's implementation of the WTO reports and will take action

under section 301(a) of the Trade Act if the EC does not come into

compliance.

Irving A. Williamson,

Chairman, Section 301 Committee.

[FR Doc. 98-3919 Filed 2-17-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3190-01-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.