National Weather Service Modernization and Associated Restructuring

Federal RegisterDec 18, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration

National Weather Service Modernization and Associated

Restructuring

AGENCY: National Weather Service (NWS), NOAA, Commerce.

ACTION: Notice of final Certification of no degradation in service for

the Combined Consolidation and/or Automation and Closure of 52 Weather

Service Offices (WSO).

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: On November 30, 1998, the Under Secretary for Oceans and

[[Page 70102]]

Atmosphere approved and transmitted 21 office consolidation, 51 office

automation, and 52 office closure certifications to Congress. Pub. L.

102-567 requires such final certifications of no degradation in service

be published in the Federal Register. This notice is intended to

satisfy the requirements of Public Law 102-567.

EFFECTIVE DATE: December 18, 1998.

ADDRESSES: Requests for copies of the final certification packages

should be sent to Tom Beaver, Room 11426, 1325 East-West Highway,

Silver Spring, Maryland 20910.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Tom Beaver at 301-713-0300 ext. 141.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Charleston, West Virginia, Automation

and Closure certifications were proposed in the January 7, 1997,

Federal Register, and the 60-day public comment period closed on March

10, 1997. No public comments were received. The following

certifications were proposed in the April 11, 1997, Federal Register

and the 60-day public comment period closed on June 10, 1997.

Bridgeport, CT--Automation/Closure

Indianapolis, IN--Automation/Closure

Kansas City MO--Automation/Closure

Lansing, MI--Automation/Closure

Lincoln, NE--Automation/Closure

Louisville, KY--Automation/Closure

Milwaukee, WI--Automation/Closure

Newark, NJ--Automation/Closure

Rockford, IL--Automation/Closure

Abilene, TX--Consolidation

International Falls, MN--Consolidation

Madison, WI--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Peoria, IL--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Rochester, NY--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Tucson, AZ--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Six public comments were received pertaining to WSO International

Falls, Minnesota, and two pertaining to WSO Lincoln, Nebraska. These

comments and the NWS response are set forth here for reference.

Comments on International Falls: 1. A public comment from Gary

Davison, City Clerk, International Falls stated, ``The City had fought

for years to keep the weather station here, because there was a large

concern the forecasts would not be accurate from Duluth. The City had

legislators supporting them for the same reason, and we are very

disappointed with the final consolidation, and as expected, the

forecasts are not accurate at all. We have a large vacation area here

and it is very disappointing that the forecasts are so unreliable.''

2. A public comment from Tom West, President, International Falls

Chamber of Commerce. His comments included the following, ``* * *

NEXRAD coverage over Int'l Falls and the north central portion of

Minnesota is at and beyond the extreme limit of NEXRAD capabilities.

NWS maps indicate that Int'l Falls is barely in the 10,000 ft. coverage

level and areas west of Int'l Falls and east of Lake of the Woods are

not covered at this level at all. Considering that much of our severe

weather comes from the northwest, and the large bodies of water heavily

used for recreational purposes are within that area, it is critical to

upgrade rather than degrade weather services.'' Although not relevant

to this consolidation certification, he also commented that the

Automated Surface Observing System (ASOS) was unreliable and that the

trained contract observers were ``at a level well below that which has

been provided in the past.''

3. A public comment from Paul Nevanen, Director, Minnesota Cold

Weather Resource Center. His comments included much of the same

information about NEXRAD as stated by Tom West plus he added, ``Also,

during winter severe events, many significant types of weather develop

below the 10,000 foot threshold. This is compounded by the fact that

the Duluth NWS office was originally to be staffed by 10 forecasters.

This level of staffing has not be [sic: been] met and the current level

of 6 will be strained during the severe weather season. * * * This is

the only area east of the Rocky Mountains that is not covered at the

10,000 foot threshold.'' He also included comments on perceived

problems with ASOS which are not relevant to the consolidation

certification.

4. The fourth public comment was from Jack E. Murray, Mayor,

International Falls. Like the previous two comments Mr. Murray

commented on lack of NEXRAD coverage and lack of full staffing at

Duluth. He added, ``I can tell you that the NWS no longer has the

confidence that existed in this area for so many years. * * * There

were a lot of promises made about the capabilities of the

modernization. We certainly haven't seen this effect in our area.''

5. The Honorable Irv Anderson, State Representative, Minnesota

House of Representatives was the fifth commentor. Mr. Anderson's

comments included, ``By not providing the radar coverage level the rest

of the country receives (most of the country enjoys multiple radar

coverage) compounded by removing trained NWS personnel constitutes a

degradation of service. * * * The modernization process has been one

which seems to be filled with antagonism, when, in fact we are both

seeking the same goal--better, more technologically advanced weather

services for all our citizens. The NWS has set criteria, sited offices

and radar units, but has never successfully addressed the concerns of

the taxpayers of the northern border area of Minnesota. * * * I urge

the National Weather Service to work with the people of northern

Minnesota to correct this oversight by maintaining a 24 hour NWS manned

station in International Falls and siting a NEXRAD unit there.''

6. The sixth public comment was from James A. Sanders, Acting

Superintendent, Voyager National Park, International Falls. He states,

``Since the closure of the International Falls Weather Service Station,

we have not had a reliable forecast for our local conditions or the

approach of severe weather from the northwest. The safety of visitors,

residents, and employees has been directly dependent on the

International Falls Weather Service Station. The relocation of their

duties to Fargo and Duluth has drastically reduced the reliability and

accuracy of the local forests [sic: forecasts] we receive and increased

the risk to all people working and enjoying the out-of-doors in this

area.''

NWS Response: NWS agrees WSR-88D coverage is about 10,000 feet in

northwest Minnesota. International Falls was one of the 32 areas of

concern that was studied by the Secretary's Report Team. The Team

concluded, ``* * * that there is no degradation in radar coverage in

the International Falls area as a result of the NWS Modernization.

Coverage from surrounding WSR-88Ds in Duluth and Grand Forks will

provide radar data for the International Falls area which is equivalent

or better to the current radar information available from the Duluth

WSR-74C and the Fargo WSR-74S.''

The Duluth office is currently (July 1997) staffed with the

required forecasters and supervisors for Stage 1 operations. Five

additional forecasters will be added in 1998 when Duluth receives its

Advanced Weather Interactive Processing System (AWIPS). (AWIPS was

installed in January 1998 and the 5 additional forecasters were in

place in March 1998.)

The Duluth office is working closely with the U.S. Park Service

(USPS) to improve forecasts and warning products for Voyageur's

National Park (VNP). The forecasts for this area have always been

prepared by the Duluth office and

[[Page 70103]]

consolidating the warning services from international Falls to the

Duluth office has had no impact on the forecasts. Additional effort and

coordination with personnel from VNP continues. On July 11, 1997, the

acting Meteorologist in Charge (MIC) and the Weather Coordination

Officer traveled to VNP and met with USPS staff. The following actions

were initiated.

(a) NWS and USPS will work together to improve the reception of

NOAA Weather Radio in the park. Currently, the eastern portion of the

park is beyond the effective range of the current antenna. The USPS is

looking into ``gifting'' a transmitter to the NWS. This transmitter

would be located in VNP.

(b) NWS will continue the lake wind study to improve forecasts in

the future.

(c) The Duluth Fire Weather Forecaster will coordinate with the

Canada's atmospheric Environmental Scientists (AES) fire weather

forecaster for the region.

(d) The Duluth office will obtain all available surface weather

observations in the VNP area. A new observation was initiated at the

Visitors Center providing information in a data-void area. (Local

products began including specific reference to VNP on September 2,

1998.)

(e) NWS will continue to pursue the acquisition of radar data from

Canada's AES to supplement the data from the NEXRAD Weather Service

Office Duluth WSR-88D. (Duluth began receiving Canadian radar data on

October 2, 1998.)

Addendium to Reply: AWIPS was installed at the future Duluth

Weather Forecast Office (WFO) on January 9, 1998, and is operating

using Build 3.0 software. Currently (February 1998), all but two senior

meteorologists required for modernized operations are in place at

Duluth. The two senior meteorologists have been selected and one is

scheduled to arrive on March 1 and the second will arrive at Duluth on

March 15, 1998, (Both were in place on March 15, 1998). Current

(January 1998) meteorologist staffing at Duluth consists of:

1 Meteorologist in Charge,

1 Warning Coordination Meteorologist (WCM),

1 Science and Operations Officer (SOO),

3 Senior Meteorologists (remaining 2 were in place on March 15, 1998),

3 Journey Level Meteorologists, and

2 Meteorologist Interns (MI),

11 Meteorologists + 2 more on March 15, 1998, = total 13.

The remaining staff includes:

1 Data Acquisition Program Manager,

4 Hydrometeorological Technicians,

1 Electronic Systems Analyst,

2 Electronics Technicians, and

1 Administrative Assistant.

Comments on Lincoln, Nebraska: Two public comments were received,

one from Mr. Les Myers, Jr. and a second from Mr. William E. Whitney. A

public comment from Les Myers, Jr., Lincoln-Lancaster County Emergency

Services, stated his concern over the ``closing of any National Weather

Service Offices.'' He said it was his opinion services had

``deteriorated tremendously since the closing of the Lincoln Weather

Service office and the transfer of responsibility to the Omaha office

located in Valley, Nebraska.'' Mr. Myers listed several instances where

warnings had been issued without previous watches and identified

notification problems to emergency services by stating, ``I found that

long-standing policies have become unknown recently.'' He concluded

with, ``Service in severe weather situations has deteriorated

measurably to Lincoln and Lancaster County and the above information

testifies to that fact.''

NWS Response: The MIC of the Omaha NEXRAD Weather Service Forecast

Office (NWSFO) arranged for the Emergency Managers to visit NWSFO Omaha

and for key members of NWSFO Omaha to visit the Lincoln-Lancaster

County Emergency Operations Center (EOC).

--June 24, 1997, Carol Whitfoth, Assistant Coordinator of Lincoln-

Lancaster County Emergency Services visited and received a briefing and

tour of the NWSFO Omaha facility.

--June 30, 1997, NWSFO Omaha personnel, Steve Byrd (SOO), Brian

Smith (WCM), and David Theophilus (MIC) visited and received a briefing

and toured the EOC.

--July 9, 1997, Les Myers, Jr., and Jason Orth from EOC visited,

received a briefing, and toured NWSFO Omaha.

The results of these meetings were positive, gave each of the

office staffs a better appreciation for the operations at the other

office, and resolved the communications problems. The issuance of

tornado warnings for specific parts of the counties and the actual

dividing lines to split the counties into sections (i.e., northeast

Lancaster, southern Lincoln, etc.) were reviewed and agreed upon. Both

parties agreed to work more closely together to ensure proper and

timely issuance of severe weather statements to the public. Dave

Theophilus (MIC) asked if a member of NWSFO Omaha could be included on

the County Disaster Committee. EOC personnel said they would consider

the offer. These coordination meetings have already paid dividends. On

July 8, 1997, Steve Byrd (SOO) had given Mr. Myers advance notice of

possible non-supercell funnel clouds in Lancaster County. Mr Myers said

he really appreciated the call. Both agencies are satisfied the

previously identified problems have been resolved and the agencies are

working together to ensure timely relay of severe weather information.

A second public comment from William Whitney, Assistant Director

State of Nebraska Emergency Management Agency (NEMA), said, ``This

closure plus other features of the National Weather Service (NWS)

modernization in Nebraska has caused a significant degradation of

service * * *''. Mr. Whitney described several misunderstood aspects of

the modernization. First, he did not understand what services would be

provided from the Omaha office when WSO Lincoln was ``automated at FAA

Weather Observation Service Level B,'' nor did he understand ``the

relationship between the current Valley WSO and the Omaha WFO.''

Second, the modernization is not as responsive as the previous

organization when ``one meteorologist was responsible for forecasting

warning and preparedness throughout the State.'' Currently, ``we are

forced to coordinate statewide matters with as many as six individual

WSOs.'' Third, ``The Valley WSO originally was built in the Lower

Platte River 100 year flood plain contrary to Presidential Executive

Order 11988.'' Fourth, ``After several years we still cannot understand

why it is ``better'' to deal with four different hydrologists

especially when their areas of responsibility do not correspond to our

river basins.'' Finally, WSO Lincoln used to advise us directly when

severe weather was forecast or imminent and this was continued by the

Valley office but we are now told that NWS ``can no longer provide this

service.''

NWS Response: Further discussion and communication with Mr. Whitney

have clarified any misunderstandings. Automation at FAA Weather

Observation Service Level B means the ASOS will provide the primary

observations and be backed up by observer trained FAA personnel at

Lincoln. These individuals also are responsible for augmenting the ASOS

observations for: Thunderstorm occurrence, tornadic activity, hail,

virga, volcanic ash, tower visibility, long-line runway visual range,

freezing drizzle, ice pellets, snow depth on ground, snow increasing

rapidly remark, thunderstorm/lightning location remark, and observed

significant weather not at station. The official name of the office

[[Page 70104]]

is Omaha although the office is actually located at Valley, Nebraska.

The Omaha office started as a WSFO, then became a NWSFO when the WSR-

88D was declared operational and will be a WFO after AWIPS becomes

operational. There are six WCMs in Nebraska, each with a designated

area of responsibility. One WCM is responsible for coordinating

activities and coordinating with the NEMA. During siting of the office,

NWS believed construction of the Union Dike would remove the area from

the flood plain. Unfortunately this did not occur. However, the office

has been elevated three feet above the 100-year flood level. Although

there are four hydrologists spread among the six weather offices, two

hydrologists are responsible for 88 of the 93 counties in Nebraska. In

1997, NWSFO Sioux Falls provided information about the Missouri River

upstream from Gavins Point Dam that had not been available in prior

years. NWSFO Omaha ensured this information reached NEMA. NWS will

continue to work with NEMA to ensure river basin responsibility matches

closely with county areas of responsibility and simplify notification

of flood events. To be effective, communication of severe weather

events to emergency management agencies must be rapid and reliable. On

March 10, 1997, Dave Theophilus (MIC) met with Mr. Whitney and his

staff to discuss severe weather warning notification, and especially

after hours notification. They developed several ways to better

distribute the required information. NEMA agreed to adopt a paging

system and NWS personnel agreed to continue the present coordination

method indefinitely. NWS believes all issues have been resolved.

The Modernization Transition Committee (MTC) at its June 25, 1997,

meeting concluded these actions would not result in any degradation of

service and endorsed the certifications.

The following certifications were proposed in the July 14, 1997,

Federal Register and the 60-day public comment period closed on

September 12, 1997.

Colorado Springs, CO--Automation/Closure

Des Moines, IA--Automation/Closure

Dubuque, IA--Automation/Closure

Elkins, WV--Automation/Closure

Las Vegas, NV--Automation/Closure

Minneapolis, MN--Automation/Closure

Portland, OR--Automation/Closure

San Francisco, CA--Automation/Closure

Spokane, WA--Automation/Closure

Casper, WY--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Huron, SD--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Rochester, MN--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Waterloo, IA--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Yakima, WA--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Yuma, AZ--Closure

No negative public comments were received. The MTC, at its

September 24, 1997, meeting, concluded these actions would not result

in any degradation of service and endorsed the certifications.

The following certifications were proposed in the October 2, 1997,

Federal Register and the 60-day public comment period closed on

December 1, 1997.

Abilene, TX--Automation/Closure

Concordia, KS--Automation/Closure

Ely, NV--Automation/Closure

Havre, MT--Automation/Closure

International Falls, MN--Automation/Closure

Santa Maria, CA--Automation/Closure

Tupelo, MS--Automation/Closure

Valentine, NE--Automation/Closure

Wichita Falls, TX--Automation/Closure

Winnemucca, NV--Automation/Closure

Alamosa, CO--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Alpena, MI--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Houghton Lake, MI--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Kalispell, MT--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Lander, WY--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Norfolk, NE--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Sault Ste Marie, MI--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Scottsbluff, NE--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

Sheridan, WY--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

St. Cloud, MN--Consolidation/Automation/Closure

One negative public comment was received for each Alamosa, Alpena,

Houghton Lake, Kalispell, Norfolk, and St. Cloud. Fourteen public

comments were received for Valentine. These comments and the NWS

responses are set forth here for reference.

Comment on Alamosa, Colorado: One public comment received from Mr.

Steven E. Vandiver, Division Engineer, Division of Water Resources,

Water Division Three. Mr. Vandiver's comments were mainly concerned

with what he felt to be a lack of complete radar coverage. His comments

included, ``There has historically been a NWS office at the Bergman

Field Airport in Alamosa * * * and service is now provided out of

Pueblo, Colorado. I do not feel that product is necessarily better than

what has historically been available from staff locally just because of

the modernization * * *. The ring of mountains which surround this

intermountain region do not allow the radars to pick up most storms. We

have had increasing numbers of unusual weather, including tornadoes,

funnel clouds, hail events, and severe windstorms. At least when

personnel were stationed at the NWS office here, they could give visual

reports of these events and worked closely with observers to give

timely updated data * * *. The area that is missed by the three radars,

even as evidenced by the coverage maps, is one of the highest

precipitation areas in the Rocky Mountain range. Our agency uses

rainfall and snowfall data to forecast resulting runoff and flooding

possibilities * * *. These comments are by no means a reflection of the

excellent staff and their efforts in the Pueblo NWS office. Bill

Fortune and his crew have bent over backwards to serve this area and

provide the best information possible. They have generated special

products to meet specific needs of our agency and have done an

excellent job.''

NWS Response: NWS agrees the NEXRAD coverage is not complete over

south-central Colorado. However, when compared to the pre-modernized

coverage, the NEXRAD coverage from three radars in Colorado is improved

over the single pre-modernized radar located near Limon. Warning

verification statistics for severe weather show improvement. For severe

weather, the probability of detection improved from 4 percent pre-

modernized, to 42 percent under modernization. The Pueblo office is

developing new products to meet customer needs. We are confident these

new products will continue to improve with the modernization.

Comment on Alpena, Michigan: One public comment received from Mr.

Jeff Welch, President, Welch Aviation. Mr. Welch stated, ``I am not in

favor of the Alpena, MI (APN) ASOS being certified * * *. In the

interest of flight safety, I respectfully request that you do not

certify the ASOS at Alpena, MI.'' In between, he listed a series of

ASOS observations which resulted in a missed approach.

NWS Response: NWS reviewed the ASOS performance with Mr. Welch. He

agreed the ASOS was performing accurately and all current information

was available on the ground-to-air (GTA) radio. NWS provided Mr. Welch

with more information on how to obtain weather via the GTA radio and an

explanation about the additional meteorological discontinuity sensor.

[[Page 70105]]

Comment on Houghton Lake, Michigan: One public comment was received

from Mr. Robert E. Howey concerning access to NEXRAD data from the

Grand Rapids WSR-88D. Mr. Howey stated, ``The Modernization Transition

Committee can rest assured that my concern was addressed by the

Meteorologist In Charge at the Grand Rapids office, but my concerns

were certainly not resolved. The Grand Rapids' web page for radar

coverage refers to the National Weather Service Policy and Guidelines

on Server Content for Internet Use. Upon deciphering the reference, we

users discover that our only access to NEXRAD weather radar coverage of

our country is through something called UCAR. Whatever or wherever that

is, it is slower and more prone to interruption than if I could be

accessing the splendid radar information being collected and

distributed by Grand Rapids station, which incidentally, displays a

pleasingly high degree of excellence.''

NWS Response: The NWS advised Mr. Hawley distribution of NEXRAD

data was available through any of four NEXRAD Information Dissemination

Service (NIDS) vendors.

Comment on Kalispell, MT: One public comment was received from

Monte M. Eliason, Airport Manager, Flathead Municipal Airport

Authority. Mr. Eliason's comments included, ``* * * As we have

previously documented and stated, and ASOS cannot replace a manned

weather service office without serious degradation of service. The

government is wrong by any measure in a finding otherwise * * *. The

terminal area reports by ASOS, frequently lack the timely accuracy and

broader picture of approaching weather such as thunderstorms, freezing

rain, or area mountaintop obscuration.''

NWS Response: NWS reviewed ASOS performance at Kalispell and

determined it met specified standards. During the last year there have

been 35 ASOS outages, and average repair times have been 15 minutes.

Both the freezing rain sensor and the lightning sensor are operational.

Video cameras were installed in June 1997 to visually depict local

conditions, including the mountain obscurations. Forecasters have

access to the video camera displays, and the images are also available

on the Internet. Airport service level classifications were determined

by the FAA. Kalispell was designated as a Service Level D site meaning

it can operate with a stand-alone ASOS.

In the summer of 1997, the Aircraft Owners and Pilots Association

Air Safety Foundation (ASF) requested information from a random

selection of pilots living in proximity to 25 service level D ASOS

sites. The data collection was to determine pilot acceptance and use of

ASOS. Requests were mailed to 10,000 pilots, and 1,027 responses were

received.

Final conclusions of the ASF study, endorsed by the MTC, were that

ASOS is representative and meets the needs of the identified service

level D sites without degrading services.

Comment on Norfolk, Nebraska: One public comment was received from

the Norfolk Airport Authority and was signed by Doris A. Kingsbury,

Chairman; Gerald Arkfeld, Vice Chairman; Robert L. Carlisle, Secretary;

Daniel E. Geary, Member; and Charles W. Balsiger, Member. They objected

to the proposed automation. Their comments included, ``The Norfolk

Airport Authority strongly objects to the National Weather Service

proposal to certify the automation of surface observations at Karl

Stefan Memorial Airport, Norfolk, NE * * *

1. The system still makes significant errors regarding ceiling and

visibility which must be corrected by the contract observer.

2. The system does not detect and reliably report freezing

precipitation.

3. The system does not reliably report thunderstorms.

4. The system cannot detect and report rapidly changing local

adverse weather conditions.

5. No provision has been identified for backup observations should

the system fail, which would render the airport unusable to FAR Part

121 and 135 air carriers.

We fail to see how the system as it presently exists can be

considered ``equal or better service'' and we further fail to see how

this can be considered a safety enhancement to aviation. The previous

system of human observers had no problem dealing with weather

observations especially as regards rapidly changing weather events.

From an aviation standpoint, the present system is poor at best. The

augmentation of the system by contract observers makes the system

acceptable, since there is a good chance that between the system and

the contract observer the reported weather will be fairly accurate.''

NWS Response: In the summer of 1997, the ASF requested information

from a random selection of pilots living in proximity to 25 service

level D ASOS sites. The data collection was to determine pilot

acceptance and use of ASOS. Requests were mailed to 10,000 pilots, and

1,027 responses were received.

Final conclusions of the ASF study, endorsed by the MTC, were that

ASOS is representative and meets the needs of the identified service

level D sites without degrading services.

Comment on St. Cloud, Minnesota: One public comment was received

from Brian D. Ryks, A.A.E., Airport Manager, St. Cloud Regional

Airport. Mr. Ryks stated, ``Although the ASOS has been fairly reliable

during good weather conditions, there have been numerous occasions when

outages have occurred or data recorded by the System has not been

accurate during adverse weather. Fortunately, during these periods,

augmentation from weather observers stationed at the Airport have

prevented a loss of air service for our users * * * it is critical we

maintain an augmented system consisting of both observers and the ASOS.

An augmented system will ensure the highest degree of safety and

reliability available to the traveling public and users of the airport

* * * .''

NWS Response: NWS reviewed ASOS performance at St. Cloud and

determined it met specified standards. Airport service level

classifications were determined by the FAA. St. Cloud was designated as

a Service Level D site which means it can operate with a stand alone-

ASOS.

In the summer of 1997, the ASF requested information from a random

selection of pilots living in proximity to 25 service level D ASOS

sites. The data collection was to determine pilot acceptance and use of

ASOS. Requests were mailed to 10,000 pilots, and 1,027 responses were

received.

Final conclusions of the ASF study, endorsed by the MTC, were that

ASOS is representative and meets the needs of the identified service

level D sites without degrading services.

Comments on Valentine, Nebraska: Fourteen public comments were

received concerning the automation certification of WSO Valentine,

Nebraska. Eleven of the letters were exactly the same and the comments

from those letters included, ``Due to government cut backs in spending,

the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), and the National Weather

Service (NWS), has decided not to man Automated Surface Observing

Systems (ASOS) stations around the U.S. except those with towers * * *

. Augmentation of the Valentine ASOS station has proven to be essential

to pilots flying into the area. People who have landed at the Valentine

airport have expressed their appreciation to the airport officials for

having a manned sight at Miller Field due to the isolation of the area

* * * . There have been instances of the ASOS reporting total overcast

skies and

[[Page 70106]]

low landing minimums, deterring flights from landing, when there were

only scattered skies that happened to be over the sensors, or

reversely, not reporting very low landing minimums causing aircraft to

fly into dangerous situations. Now, not only do we have to worry about

such inaccuracies in landing minimums, but the newly installed,

untested, Thunderstorm sensor is a concern * * * . Many doctors who

serve this area fly into Valentine to provide much needed health care

and training * * * . What cut in spending is so imperative that it

should jeopardize peoples lives * * * .'' One letter included 14

signatures which in part stated, ``The community of Valentine protests

the full automation of service which the FAA and NWS feel can be

observed from North Platte, Ne. will not work.''

A public comment from Curtis Price, Jr., President, C. Price &

Associates stated, ``C. Price & Associates is the current contractor

for the weather observation support services at Miller Field, Valentine

Nebraska. We would like to register a protest against the proposed

Recommendation for Automation and Closure of this site * * * it has

been our experience that the current method of taking readings is far

superior to the proposed ASOS method. We have documented several

instances at other sites, where the ASOS system has been inadequate * *

*.'' Finally, a public comment from Dean Jacobs, Executive Director,

Valentine Chamber of Commerce stated, ``* * * We consider augmentation

of the Valentine ASOS station essential * * *. The people of this area

need and deserve the most accurate weather reports for their safety and

the safety of their passengers. The very reason for PL 102-567 (the

weather service modernization bill), which protects weather stations

form degradation [sic: from degradation] of service * * *.''

NWS Response: NWS reviewed ASOS performance at Valentine and

determined it met specified standards. The thunderstorm sensor is

operational. Airport service level classifications were determined by

the FAA. Valentine was designated as a service level D site meaning it

can operate with a stand-alone ASOS.

In the summer of 1997, the (ASF) requested information from a

random selection of pilots living in proximity to 25 service level D

ASOS sites. The data collection was to determine pilot acceptance and

use of ASOS. Requests were mailed to 10,000 pilots, and 1,027 responses

were received.

Final conclusions of the ASF study, endorsed by the MTC, were that

ASOS is representative and meets the needs of the identified service

level D sites without degrading services.

The MTC, at its December 10, 1997, meeting, concluded these actions

would not result in any degradation of service and endorsed the

certifications.

The Astoria, Oregon, and Lexington, Kentucky, Automation and

Closure Certifications were proposed in the January 9, 1998, Federal

Register, and the 60-day public comment period closed on March 10,

1998. No public comments were received for Lexington. The MTC, at its

March 18, 1998, meeting, concluded these actions would not result in

any degradation of service and endorsed the certifications. Three

public comments were received for Astoria. These comments and the NWS

response are set forth here for reference.

Comments on Astoria, OR: Three public comments were applicable to

the proposed Astoria automation and closure certification.

First, a letter dated April 24, 1997, was received from the

Columbia River Pilots. The letter states, ``The proposed closure of the

Astoria weather station will degrade the quality of available weather

information and hamper our ability to provide safe and timely service

to vessels calling in the Columbia River at both Oregon and Washington

ports.''

Second, a letter dated June 3, 1997, was received from

Representative Elizabeth Furse stating, ``Enclosed is a copy of Senate

Concurrent Resolution 8, recently adopted by both the Senate and the

House of the Oregon legislature which requests that closure proceedings

of the station be reversed.''

Third, a letter dated January 29, 1998, signed by Ron Larsen,

Airport manager; George Waer, Columbia River Bar Pilots; and John

Raichl, Clatsop County Sheriff, commented on their concerns about the

ASOS. They stated, ``The Portland office has been helpful and

concerned. They established a working relationship with the Columbia

River Bar Pilots that seems to meet the Bar Pilots needs. In addition

they placed remote cameras on the airport to help observe actual

conditions that ASOS may or may not report. However, ASOS is still

reporting conditions that are not accurate over the entire airport

caused by the lack of remote sensors.''

NWS Response: At a March 18, 1998, meeting, the NWS advised the MTC

it had worked with the Bar Pilots and all issues were resolved.

Additional communications links to the Portland office have been

established with the Astoria community. NWS reported ASOS system

limitations will not permit the addition of a second set of

discontinuity sensors as requested by the Astoria airport manager. The

MTC directed NWS to compare the number of surface observation remarks

for a 1-year period before ASOS was installed to the number of remarks

for a 1-year period after ASOS and its discontinuity sensor was

installed.

At the June 18, 1998, meeting, NWS presented results of the

comparisons to the MTC. The comparison showed more remarks have been

reported with ASOS than prior to ASOS. The comparison also showed the

ASOS ceiling discontinuity sensor is located in the proper quadrant to

detect lower ceilings. However, the visibility discontinuity sensor

would be more effective if moved to the northeast quadrant. The ASOS

permits splitting of the ceiling and visibility discontinuity sensors.

This option was offered to the airport manager, but he prefers to keep

both discontinuity sensors together in the northwest quadrant. After

reviewing the before and after comparison, the MTC concluded there was

no safety impact to aviation operations at the airfield, and the

current ASOS and discontinuity sensor provided an accurate observation

for the airfield.

The Honolulu Automation and Closure certifications were proposed in

the April 9, 1998, Federal Register, and the 60-day public comment

period closed on June 8, 1998. No public comments were received for

Honolulu. The MTC, at its June 18, 1998, meeting concluded these

Astoria and Honolulu actions would not result in any degradation of

service and endorsed the certifications.

After consideration of the public comments received and the MTC

endorsements, the Under Secretary for Oceans and Atmosphere approved

these 52 combined consolidation and/or automation and closure

certifications finding there would not be any degradation of service.

The Under Secretary transmitted a list of the approved certifications

to Congress on November 30, 1998. Certification approval authority was

delegated from the Secretary of Commerce to the Under Secretary in June

1996. The NWS is now completing the certification requirements of

Public Law 102-567 by publishing this notice of the final consolidation

and/or automation and closure certifications in the Federal Register.

[[Page 70107]]

Dated: December 14, 1998.

John J. Kelly, Jr.,

Assistant Administrator for Weather Services.

[FR Doc. 98-33551 Filed 12-17-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3510-KE*-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.