Excess Flow ValveCustomer Notification

Federal RegisterFeb 3, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

49 CFR Part 192

[Docket PS-118A; Amendment 192-82]

RIN 2137-AC55

Excess Flow Valve--Customer Notification

AGENCY: Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA), DOT.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This final rule requires operators of natural gas distribution

systems to provide certain customers with information about excess flow

valves (EFV's). Specifically, customers of new and replaced single

residence service lines must be provided written notification about the

availability of these valves meeting DOT-prescribed performance

standards, and related safety benefits and costs. If a customer

requests installation, the rule requires an operator to install the EFV

if the customer pays all costs associated with installation. EFVs

restrict the flow of gas by closing automatically if a service line

breaks, thus, mitigating the consequences of service line failures.

This regulation would enhance public awareness of the potential safety

benefits from installing an EFV.

DATES: This final rule takes effect February 3, 1998.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mike M. Israni, telephone (202) 366-

4571, or e-mail: [email protected], regarding the subject matter

of this final rule, or the Dockets Unit (202) 366-4453 for copies of

this final rule or other material in the docket referenced in this

rule.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

During routine excavation activities, excavators often sever gas

service lines causing loss of life, injury, or property damage by fire

or explosion. EFVs restrict the flow of gas by closing automatically if

a service line breaks, and mitigate the consequences of service line

failures. Despite efforts, such as damage prevention programs, to

reduce the frequency of excavation-related service line incidents on

natural gas service lines, such incidents persist and result in death,

injury, fire, or explosion. Because damage prevention measures are not

foolproof, RSPA has sought an appropriate means to mitigate the

consequences of these incidents. The National Transportation Safety

Board (NTSB) and others have recommended EFVs to mitigate the

consequences of such incidents, thus, saving lives and lessening the

extent of property damage.

By having an operator inform its customers of the availability of

EFVs for installation at a cost and the resultant safety benefits,

customers can decide if they want the operator to install an EFV on the

service line. Notification giving information on EFVs may encourage EFV

use and, by encouraging such use, may lead to reduced fatalities,

injuries, and property damage that can result from excavation-related

incidents on gas service lines.

Statutory Requirement

In 49 U.S.C. 60110 Congress directed the Department of

Transportation (DOT) to issue regulations requiring operators to notify

customers in writing about EFV availability, the safety benefits

derived from installation, and costs associated with installation,

maintenance, and replacement. The regulations were to provide that,

except where installation is already required, if the customer requests

installation, an operator must install an EFV that meets

[[Page 5465]]

prescribed performance criteria, if the customer pays all costs

associated with installation.

Before DOT prescribed notification regulations, the statute

required DOT to issue regulations prescribing the circumstances where

operators of natural gas distribution systems must install EFVs, unless

DOT determined that there were no circumstances under which EFVs should

be installed.

RSPA is the administration within DOT responsible for implementing

laws addressing pipeline safety.

RSPA published a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) (Notice 2; 58

FR 21524; April 21, 1993) (``Excess Flow Valve Installation on Service

Lines''), proposing to require that EFVs be installed on single-

residence gas service lines. During the rulemaking process we reviewed

technical information, sought advice from state safety representatives,

and analyzed available operational data. RSPA determined, primarily for

cost reasons, that there were no circumstances where RSPA should

require EFV installation. As required by the statute, RSPA reported

this determination to Congress on April 4, 1995. A copy of this report

is available in the docket. As further required by 49 U.S.C.

Sec. 60110, we developed performance standards for EFVs (industry

standards were not then available) to ensure that an EFV installed in a

single-residence gas service line operates reliably and safely. These

performance standards were published as a final rule [61 FR 31449; June

20, 1996].

AGA Petition and Pre-NPRM Meetings

The American Gas Association (AGA) submitted a petition for a

rulemaking on EFV customer notification in which it identified several

issues it believed we should discuss in a notification rule. RSPA

considered AGA's petition (on file in the docket) in developing the

notice of proposed rulemaking. To gain further information before

developing a proposed notification rule, RSPA met with representatives

of AGA, the American Public Gas Association (APGA), NTSB and the Gas

Safety Action Council (GASAC) on August 2 and September 6, 1995. We

discussed AGA's petition and these meetings in the NPRM.

NPRM

RSPA published an NPRM (61 FR 33476; June 27, 1996), proposing

requirements for excess flow valve customer notification. The comment

period closed August 26, 1996. Commenters included industry

associations, local distribution companies, consultants, city and state

agencies, and a federal safety agency.

Advisory Committee Review

In November 1996, RSPA briefed the Technical Pipeline Safety

Committee (TPSSC) on the status and the comments received on this

rulemaking. In December 1996, we sent letter ballots to the TPSSC

members to vote on the proposed rule and the regulatory evaluation.

(The TPSSC is required to serve as a peer review panel and review the

costs and benefits associated with any proposed regulatory standard in

accordance with 49 USC 60102 (b)(3)). We received 11 out of 15 ballots.

These 11 members voted to adopt the NPRM and Regulatory Evaluation.

Seven members had comments, which are addressed below.

The Final Rule

The final rule establishes a new section in the pipeline safety

regulations, Sec. 192.383, ``Excess flow valve Customer Notification.''

The rule requires written notification of customers with natural gas

service lines where EFVs meeting prescribed performance criteria can be

installed. To be consistent with the final rule that prescribed

performance standards for EFVs installed on single-residence service

lines operating continuously throughout the year at a pressure not less

than 10 psig, this rule limits the scope of customer notification to

those customers. Of those single-residence services, the rule further

limits written notification to new and replaced service line customers.

Definitions

RSPA defines a replaced service line as a natural gas service line

where the fitting that connects the service line to the main is

replaced or the piping connected to this fitting is replaced.

RSPA defines the service line customer an operator must notify as

the person who pays the gas bill, or where service has not yet been

established, the person requesting service. Under this definition, the

person who pays the gas bill may be the tenant, the owner, or a third

party. In cases where service has not yet been established, such as a

new subdivision or cluster of homes, the person requesting new service

may be the home builder.

What to Put in the Written Notice

This rule requires that the notification contain the minimum amount

of information the statute requires. An operator may decide how to word

that information as long as sufficient information is given to provide

the customer a basis to decide whether to pay for EFV installation. The

notice must gear the explanations to the gas consumer, not an engineer.

--Meets DOT Performance Standards

An explanation that an excess flow valve meeting minimum DOT-

prescribed performance standards is available for the operator to

install on the service line if the customer pays the cost of

installation. The explanation must make clear to the customer that EFV

installation is not mandatory, but that if the customer requests

installation and pays all costs associated with installation, the

operator will install an EFV.

--Safety Benefits

An explanation of the potential safety benefits of installing an

EFV, to include that an EFV is designed to shut off the flow of natural

gas automatically if the service line breaks.

--Cost Associated With Installation, Maintenance, and Replacement

An explanation that if the customer requests the operator to

install an EFV, the customer bears all costs associated with

installation, and what those costs are. In addition, the notice must

alert the customer that costs for maintaining and replacing the EFV may

be incurred, and what those costs would be, to the extent known.

Additional Information in the Written Notice

The final rule does not require an operator include additional

information, such as EFV manufacturers' brochures and a consumer

group's telephone number, in the notification. Although we are not

requiring such information to be included, we encourage operators to

include any information that aids a customer's decision making.

When Notification and Installation Must be Made

The final rule requires that one year after the final rule is

published, an operator must notify each service line customer of a new

service line (single-residence service line that operates at a pressure

not less than 10 psig) when the customer applies for service. On

replaced service lines, an operator must notify each customer (single-

residence service line operating at a pressure not less than 10 psig)

when the operator determines the service line will be replaced. If a

customer requests installation, the operator must install the EFV at a

mutually agreeable date.

[[Page 5466]]

What Records Are Required

The final rule requires that an operator must make certain records

available for inspection:

(1) A copy of the notice currently in use; and

(2) Evidence that notices have been sent to the service line

customers (new and replaced single-residence service lines operating at

a pressure not less than 10 psig) within the previous 3 years.

When Notification is Not Required

In the NPRM, we sought comment from operators, state pipeline

safety agencies, their representative associations and others on the

issue of a state or locality preventing an operator from charging the

customer for EFV installation costs. We also sought comment on whether

the waiver process in such a situation would be too burdensome. We did

not receive any comment. Thus, in RSPA's judgment the regulatory waiver

process now in place may be used if a State or local authority prevents

or restricts the gas utility from accepting a customer's payment for

EFV installation costs. Similarly, if an operator believes that in a

particular situation, compliance would be infeasible, impractical or

unreasonable, the operator may apply for a regulatory waiver.

The final rule describes certain limited circumstances where an

operator would not have to notify a customer.

Service lines where the operator will install an excess

flow valve voluntarily or where the state or local jurisdiction

requires installation.

If excess flow valves meeting the prescribed performance

standards are not available to the operator.

Where an operator has prior experience with contaminants

in the gas stream that could interfere with an EFV's operation, cause

loss of service to a residence, or where installing an EFV would

interfere with necessary operation or maintenance activities, such as

blowing liquids from the line.

In emergency and short time notice replacement situations

where an operator cannot notify a customer before replacing a service

line. Examples of these situations would be where an operator has to

quickly replace a service line because of

--third party excavation damage

--Grade 1 leaks, as defined in the Appendix G-192-11 of the Gas Piping

Technology Committee (GPTC) Guide for Gas Transmission and Distribution

Systems,

--a short notice service line relocation request

We have allowed an exemption from notification when an operator

must quickly replace a service line because of third party damage.

Although the impetus for this notification rule was to mitigate the

consequences of service line failures, particularly, when caused by

third party excavators, we recognize that in such an emergency, an

operator may not be able to notify a customer. Nonetheless, although

not required to do so, we urge operators to make their best efforts to

notify customers in emergency situations, so that the consequences of

any future failures may be mitigated.

Discussion of Comments

RSPA received 49 comments in response to the NPRM. Commenters

included two industry associations (AGA, New England Gas Assoc.), 37

local distribution companies, two consultants, seven city and state

agencies, and one federal safety agency (NTSB). In addition, we

received comments from TPSSC members. Of these comments, 12 were

opposed to issuing any notification rule, and the remaining commenters

directed their remarks to specific issues.

General Comments--Twelve commenters were opposed to issuing the

rule. They questioned the reliability, the benefit versus costs, and

the suitability of EFVs to handle the majority of leaks encountered in

a gas distribution system. They argued that our focus should be on

preventing third-party damage, that incidents involving the type of

failures where an EFV is effective are infrequent, and that because

most operators design their load systems for future use, EFVs would

severely restrict load growth.

Two commenters said the typical customer is not well versed in gas

industry technology, safety matters or frequency of service line

failures, and may even be confused when asked to make a decision on

EFVs. Two commenters suggested that verbal notification may be

sufficient.

NTSB pointed out that the statute placed no limits on the type of

customer who should receive notification. NTSB recommended we require

notice of EFV availability to all residential and commercial customers

with service lines that have operating parameters compatible with any

commercially available EFV.

Response--RSPA is following its statutory mandate to prescribe

regulations requiring operators to notify customers in writing about

EFV availability, the safety benefits derived from installation, and

costs associated with installation, maintenance and replacement, and

requiring operators to install an EFV at the customer's request if the

customer pays the installation costs. We considered all comments in

developing final regulations.

If notification contains this minimum amount of information, and is

written for an average gas customer, the customer should be able to

decide whether it wants an EFV installed. If a customer has questions,

an operator should be able to provide knowledgeable personnel who can

explain technical information to a customer's satisfaction to enable

the customer to make a well-reasoned decision about installation.

RSPA determined that it would neither be practical nor cost

beneficial for operators to notify all single-residence customers.

Determining whether EFVs can be installed on existing lines presents

difficulties (such as lack of relevant records and historical data) not

encountered on new and replaced lines. Furthermore, RSPA's economic

evaluation shows that requiring notification to all single-residence

customers would result in substantially higher costs with marginal

safety benefits due to the increased time an operator would have to

spend in responding to customer inquiries and determining operating

conditions on existing lines. Because of the increased installation

costs to retrofit an existing line, it would be unlikely that many

existing customers would choose to pay the costs of installation.

Nonetheless, RSPA encourages operators to consider expanding

notification to all single-residence customers.

RSPA will consider extending the scope of notification to

hospitals, schools, commercial enterprises, and apartment buildings

after EFV standards and guidelines are published by the American

Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) F17.40 committee and the

American National Standards Institute (ANSI)/Gas Piping Technology

Committee (GPTC) Z380.

Comments on Cost/Benefit Study--Five commenters said that we had

underestimated the costs to comply with the rule. They explained that

the cost of developing a utility-specific notice will be significant

because of the legal, safety, and customer issues involved, and that we

should consider $35 to $45 per hour as the cost to develop and review

the notice. Commenters said many calls would need an engineer or a

supervisor to talk to the customer. AGA said the study had failed to

address who would incur the costs if the customer wants the EFV

removed, or if a properly installed EFV later malfunctions and cuts off

service.

[[Page 5467]]

Advisory Group: One member pointed out that postage costs were not

included in the total cost to notify all existing residential

customers. This member suggested including the estimated number of

customers who would request an EFV in each case, and a cost comparison

of excavation costs for new and existing customers.

Response--RSPA has revised its final economic evaluation in light

of the comments to include the labor costs of preparing and mailing the

notice, and the costs of fringe benefits in the hourly costs. In

addition, we revised the salary estimates of the person responding to

customer inquiries to accommodate concerns that answering such

inquiries may require technical expertise.

RSPA did not include postage costs in its estimate of the cost to

notify existing customers because the notification could be included

with the customer's monthly bill. We also did not estimate the number

of customers who might request an EFV because we have no relevant data.

The cost/benefit study did explain in comparing the costs to notify new

and replaced customers versus existing customers that existing

customers requesting EFV installation might have to pay $500 or more

for installation mostly due to excavation cost. The cost/benefit study

is described later in this document and is available in the docket.

Proposed Section 192.383(a)--(68.9 kPa (10 psig) Threshold)--Six

commenters said that a 68.9 kPa (10 psig) threshold for installing an

EFV should not be used as a notification threshold. NTSB said that EFVs

should be made available to customers having service lines that operate

at pressures as low as 34.5 kPa (5 psig). The other commenters did not

want the 68.9 kPa (10 psig) threshold because if the service line

pressure for each customer is not recorded, it would be difficult to

know if the line pressure will drop below 68.9 kPa (10 psig). Some

commenters suggested that a minimum pressure threshold should be left

to the operator's judgment.

Response--We proposed that an operator notify a customer of a new

or replaced service line that operates at a pressure not less than 68.9

kPa (10 psig) because this is the pressure threshold we had established

for EFV installation in the performance standards. We explained our

reasons for setting this threshold in that final rule [61 FR 31449;

June 20, 1996].

The final rule continues to limit notification to new and replaced

service lines meeting the 10 psig threshold. In making this decision,

we also considered that:

--Most households in the United States receive natural gas from their

service lines between 68.9 kPa (10 psig) to 413.4 kPa (60 psig).

--DOT's incident report data indicates that services in the 34.5 kPa (5

psig) to 68.9 kPa (10 psig) pressure range are unlikely to experience

incidents from outside force damage. (A survey of incidents from 1984

to 1992 shows that one out of 212 reportable incidents occurred due to

outside force damage).

Comments on Section 192.383(a)--(Service Lines Covered Under This

Rule)--One commenter asked if customer-owned service lines were

covered. Another commenter said that the proposed rule was unclear

whether notification should be sent to two customers if both are

supplied from the same service line.

Response--This rule applies to service lines serving a single

residence. One service line serving two or more residents would not be

covered. Customer-owned service lines operating at or above the 10 psig

pressure requirement are included unless one of the notification

exemptions applies.

Proposed Sections 192.383(a)(1), (a)(3) and (b)--(Costs Associated

With EFV Installation)--We proposed that if a customer requested EFV

installation, the customer pay the costs associated with installation

and defined those costs as the direct costs (parts and labor) of

installation. We also proposed that an operator must install an EFV if

the customer agrees to pay all installation costs.

AGA said that Congress clearly intended for the customer to incur

all costs including operation and maintenance. Several commenters

stated that we must follow Congress's intent to require customers pay

for operating and maintaining the EFV, in addition to the installation

costs. Some commenters said that costs must include all incremental

parts, labor and maintenance. They said costs such as repair,

resetting, replacement, and deactivation can be substantial. Three

commenters argued that we have no authority to mandate a costing

methodology because that authority lies with the state public utility

or commission. Some commenters complained that direct costs had not

been clearly defined.

NTSB commented that the language in the proposed rule requiring

customers to pay replacement costs is inconsistent with the preamble's

discussion that operators recoup only the direct costs of installation.

NTSB also pointed out that the experience of the two largest users of

EFVs, who had not had any design-related EFV failure in the last 20

years, supported not including replacement costs.

Advisory Group: Two members said costs should include indirect

costs of installing or replacing the EFV, including maintenance and

replacement costs. One member said costs incurred due to false closure

or other inappropriate operation should be included.

Response--The statute requires that an operator notify its

customers of the costs associated with installation, maintenance and

replacement but that the operator install an EFV if the customer pays

the installation costs. In following this mandate, we are requiring

that an operator notify its customers that costs for maintaining and

replacing an EFV could be incurred after installation and what those

costs are, to the extent known. The notice must also explain that if

the customer requests installation, the customer has to pay the

installation costs at that time, and what those costs are.

RSPA recognizes that the regulatory authority to price gas lies

with state and local public utility commissions. We believe that public

utility commissions will recognize that EFV installation, maintenance

and replacement costs are legitimate costs and allow operators to

charge for those services, to the same extent they are allowed to

charge for other service line services. Nonetheless, we believe that to

carry out the statutory requirements, we should define some of the

costs.

The proposed rule defined installation costs as direct costs (parts

and labor) of installing an EFV. We proposed a limit on what an

operator could recoup for installing an EFV so that an EFV would not be

cost prohibitive. We believe Congress intended gas customers to have a

reasonably priced extra safety protection. In finalizing this rule we

have attempted to clarify the installation costs that an operator

should recoup. Installation costs of an EFV are costs directly

connected with installation of EFVs, for example, costs of parts,

labor, inventory and procurement.

Although the statute was amended to allow an operator to notify its

customers about installation, maintenance and replacement costs, a

customer only has to pay installation costs to have an EFV installed on

its service line. Thus, we believe that an operator may later recoup

maintenance and replacement costs only if such costs are ever incurred.

These costs are not to be included in the initial installation costs.

[[Page 5468]]

Proposed section 192.383(a)(2)--(Potential Safety Benefits)--The

NPRM proposed that notification include an explanation of potential

safety benefits. Eight commenters said that the NPRM did not address

the potential hazards from EFVs, which could subject an operator to

liability if the EFV fails to perform to a customer's satisfaction. One

commenter suggested notification include that an EFV is not designed to

protect against slow leaks, system over pressure, or leaks inside the

house.

We further proposed that the explanation of safety benefits include

that an EFV is designed to shut off the flow of the natural gas when

the service line is ruptured. A commenter suggested changing the

wording to ``in the event'' the service line is severed, because ``when

the service line is ruptured'' implies that a service line will

rupture. This commenter also suggested that the term ``rupture'' be

replaced with ``severed'', as ``rupture'' is also used for material

failures, such as a crack in polyethylene pipe.

Advisory Group--One member suggested replacing ``service line is

ruptured'' with ``damaged service line conditions cause its closure.''

Another member said the wording ``designed to shut off the flow'' is

not accurate as an EFV may not totally shut off flow.

Response--The statute requires notification to include EFV

benefits. The statute does not preclude an operator from putting in EFV

limitations (for example, that an EFV does not protect against slow

leaks due to corrosion, threaded joints, or leaks beyond the meter

assembly).

We have changed ``rupture'' to ``break'', and ``when'' to ``if the

service line breaks'' in the final rule. However, we have retained the

phrase ``designed to shut off'' because it is a performance standard

requirement for the valve.

Proposed Section 192.383(a)(4)--(Notification Language)--The NPRM

proposed that notification be ``in sufficient detail'' and ``in

language easily comprehensible.'' Two commenters said this is a

subjective standard that does not enable the operator to distinguish

between acceptable and deficient language.

Response--We have revised this requirement. We continue to use

performance-based language to ensure that notices are written for the

average customer, not for persons with specialized technical expertise.

Comments on Additional Information That Should be in the Notice--

One commenter said notification should include information that

excessive consumption may cause the EFV to activate. This commenter

said the operator should not give the customer any warranties about an

EFV's operation. One commenter said that gas operators should, in

addition to third party damage, describe all conditions, such as,

earthquakes, lightning strikes, ground subsidence caused by changing

weather conditions, and vandalism, which may cause a pipeline to

rupture.

Response--RSPA disagrees that excessive consumption may cause an

EFV to activate. If the valve meets the DOT performance standards and

is chosen properly based on the service line consumption, then the

valve will not activate unless consumption exceeds 50% above the

maximum flow, an unlikely event. We have used the phrase ``if the

service line breaks'' to acknowledge that other conditions may cause a

service line failure. However, we leave to the operator's discretion

whether to describe all conditions that may cause a pipeline to fail.

Proposed Section 192.383(a)(5)--(Comments on Definitions of

Replaced Service Line & Service Line Customer)--Twenty six commenters

requested further clarification of the proposed ``replaced'' service

line and ``service line customer'' definitions.

Replaced Service Line--We proposed a ``replaced'' service line as

one in which a section of pipe is replaced between the gas main and

meter set assembly. Two commenters suggested a ``replaced'' service

line should be as where a fitting connecting the service line to the

main is replaced or when the service is replaced completely from the

main to the meter assembly. One commenter suggested a ``replaced'' line

as one where at least 50% of the service line is being replaced. AGA

recommended that a ``replaced'' service line refer to a natural gas

service line in which the fitting that connects the service line to the

main is replaced or the piping connected to this fitting is replaced.

Advisory Group--Two members recommended we use AGA's definition of

``replaced'' service line.

Service Line Customer--We proposed that a ``service line

customer'', the person the operator should notify, should be the person

paying the gas bill or where the service was not yet established, the

owner of the property. AGA suggested that where service has not yet

been established, the service line customer should be the person

requesting service. Two commenters suggested the person notified should

be the person requesting service, or where gas service exists and the

residence is vacant, the owner of the property. One commenter said the

person notified should be the builder, not the owner of the property

who signs for new service.

NTSB said the proposed definition does not allow persons at risk,

specifically renters in new housing subdivisions, to decide whether an

EFV should be installed. NTSB said that because our definition limited

operators to notifying builders in new housing subdivisions, we should

require notification of both renters and the owners of the rented

buildings.

Some commenters said the proposed wording could be misread to

suggest all customers must be notified. Commenters suggested using

``each applicable customer'' and define ``applicable customer'' as

those customers meeting the criteria in 192.383 (a). AGA and other

commenters suggested adding another definition to clarify which

customers should be notified.

Response--We have revised the ``replaced'' service line and

``service line customer'' definitions. We have also re-written the

regulation for clarity, to eliminate any confusion over which gas

customers must be notified. NTSB's comment that both renters and owners

be notified would create conflict if one wanted an EFV installed and

the other did not. Proposed section 192.383(a)(5) is changed to section

192.383(b) in the final rule.

Proposed Section 192.383(c)--(30 Day Notification and One Year

Implementation Requirements)--Practically all commenters expressed

concern about the proposed requirement that an operator notify each

customer thirty days before a new or replaced service line is

installed. They said thirty days was impractical and unduly burdensome.

Commenters explained that operators currently schedule and complete

regularly planned service line installations in less than 30 days.

Moreover, operators replace service lines immediately for public safety

and good customer service. Some commenters suggested allowing an

operator to establish its own criteria for when to notify. One

commenter said that we did not clearly state how many times the service

line customer should be notified.

NTSB said the one-year implementation period is too long, and that

six months is more than adequate for the industry to prepare for

compliance. NTSB explained that EFVs are commercially available and

that industry associations are already developing guidance to help

operators draft appropriate notices.

Advisory Group--Two members recommended a 5 to 10 day notification

[[Page 5469]]

period as more appropriate than the proposed 30 days.

Response--RSPA agrees that 30 days advance notification is

impractical and has revised this requirement. Now an operator must

notify a new service line customer (single residence with service line

pressure not less than 10 psig) of EFV availability when that customer

applies for service. A customer having its service line replaced

(single residence with service line pressure not less than 10 psig)

must be notified of EFV availability when the operator determines the

service line will be replaced. If the customer requests installation,

an operator must install the EFV at a mutually agreeable date. In

either case, a customer has to be notified only once.

We have kept the one-year implementation period. We disagree that a

six-month implementation period is adequate for operators to notify

customers. One year is more appropriate for operators to learn which

customers to notify, to draft notices, and to instruct personnel to

handle inquiries.

Proposed Section 192.383(d)-(Recordkeeping)--Six commenters

objected to the proposal that operators keep proof that notices have

been sent to customers within the previous 3 years. They said that

maintaining a list of notified persons will be burdensome and

cumbersome, driving up the record keeping cost. Some commenters

suggested changing ``proof'' to ``evidence.''

Advisory Group--One member argued against any record keeping

requirement because of the difficulty in tracking who was notified.

Response--To check compliance, RSPA and State inspectors will need

to view a copy of the notice operators send customers and evidence that

notices have been sent to customers. This evidence may relate to the

overall notification process, and need not be customer-specific. For

example, a record showing the approximate dates notices are mailed or a

written procedure for the notification process would be evidence

notices have been sent. Therefore, we have not changed the proposed

record keeping requirement.

Proposed Section 192.383(e)--(Exemptions from Notification

Requirements)--In the NPRM, we sought comment and information on

situations where an operator may not be able to notify a customer

before replacing a service line. Seventeen commenters responded to this

issue. Several commenters said that many repairs made to services to

repair minor damage or eliminate leaks involve replacing a short

section of line and not exposing the main, and should be exempt from

the notification rule. The majority emphasized that notification

requirements should not apply to emergency and short notice

replacements, such as when a line has to be replaced because of:

--third party excavation damage

--Grade 1 leaks, as defined in the Appendix G-192-11 of the Gas Piping

Technology Committee guide for gas transmission and distribution

systems (A leak that represents an existing or probable hazard to

persons or property, and requires immediate repair or continuous action

until the conditions are no longer hazardous.)

--a short notice service line relocation request (a short notice

request from the customer or a utility to relocate the service line due

to, for example, a main being relocated, to prevent interference with

new construction, the widening of a street.)

In addition, AGA and three other commenters urged us to exempt a

service line where the regulator/meter assembly is within 3.66m (12

feet) of the main. They reasoned that because third party damage on

shorter service lines is uncommon, an EFV will not serve any purpose.

One operator said it would not be prudent to put an EFV in any part

of the system if contaminants have shown up in other areas of the

system. Another commenter said an operator should not have to send

notification if it found EFV installation impractical.

Advisory Group--Two members recommended adopting an emergency and

short notice exemption. One member recommended exempting notification

for service lines less than 3.66m (12ft), because third party damage is

unlikely on short lines. One member suggested exempting installation in

``impractical or infeasible'' circumstances. Another member said it was

unclear whether a waiver was required for a specified exemption.

Response--We have amended the notification exemptions to

accommodate certain emergency and short notice situations. As explained

previously, although we are not requiring notification in those

situations, we encourage operators to make their best efforts to notify

customers. The consequences of any future service line failures may be

mitigated if an EFV is installed. We have not adopted a short line

exemption. We believe that because an operator is unlikely to have

advance knowledge of a service line's length, creating an exemption for

short lines would serve little purpose. While we recognize that on

short service lines an EFV may offer little or no protection, because

third party damage is unlikely, we believe the customer should decide

whether it wants an EFV installed. An operator may decide whether to

include information about short line protection.

Although we allow an exemption when an operator has experienced

contaminants in the gas stream, we disagree that EFVs should not be

installed throughout the entire distribution system if contaminants

have shown up in other areas of the system. These are probably isolated

instances, unless the operator can demonstrate otherwise.

RSPA believes the listed exemptions should cover most situations.

If in a particular instance, an operator believes it should not notify

customers because EFV installation would be infeasible, impractical, or

unreasonable, the operator may apply for a regulatory waiver.

Comments on Rearranging Sections--Three commenters recommended we

rearrange sections for clarity.

Response--RSPA has rewritten and rearranged the final rule for

clarity.

Regulatory Analyses and Notices

Executive Order 12866 and DOT Regulatory Policies and Procedures

This final rule is not considered a significant regulatory action

under section 3(f) of Executive Order 12866 and, therefore, was not

subject to review by the Office of Management and Budget. The final

rule is not considered significant under the regulatory policies and

procedures of the Department of Transportation (44 FR 11034; February

26, 1979).

A regulatory evaluation has been prepared based on the estimated

expense involved in developing and sending customer notification to new

and replaced single-residence service line customers.

RSPA has determined that large and moderate-sized gas operators

will develop their own customer notice. This should take approximately

40 hours at approximately $40 an hour or a one-time cost of $1,600 per

company (40 hours x $40 per hour = $1,600). RSPA estimates in its

regulatory evaluation (based on analysis done for an earlier rulemaking

on customer-owned service lines) that there are 106 large gas operators

and 145 moderate-sized gas operators. Therefore, the cost to the

industry to develop the required notice will be a one-time cost of

$401,600 (251 x $1,600).

The cost of mailing this notice will be $0.32 plus the estimated

$0.1 copying

[[Page 5470]]

cost for a one-page notice, for a total cost of $0.42 per customer. If

there are 900,000 new or replaced customers annually, the cost of

postage for this notice is $378,000 (900,000 x .42 mailing) per year.

In our draft economic evaluation, we did not account for the labor cost

it takes to mail the notice. One operator suggested 5 minutes per

notice by an employee making $11 per hour with an additional 60% for

fringe benefits, which calculates to $1,320,000 (900,000 x $11 x

1.6 x 1\1/2\ = $1,320,000). The total cost of postage plus labor

would be $1,698,000 annually ($378,000 + $1,320,000 = $1,698,000).

Assuming 10% of all notified customers were to call operators for

more information would result in 90,000 phone calls. Each call lasting

on average five minutes would amount to 7,500 hours (90,000 x 5/60

hrs) spent answering customer inquiries. In the draft evaluation, we

estimated the hourly wage for the person answering telephone inquiries

would be $15 an hour. One commenter suggested that the person answering

telephone inquiries should be an engineer. To reflect that a person

with more technical expertise may need to answer a customer's inquiry,

we increased the hourly salary estimate to $25 per hour plus benefits.

If the employee responsible for answering were paid $25 per hour plus

60% for fringe benefits, the additional cost of these conversations

would be $300,000 (75,000 x $25 x 1.6) per year. The total cost to

the industry will be the one time cost of developing the notice,

$401,600, and the additional cost per year of mailing and handling

inquiries, $1,998,000 ($300,000 + $1,698,000 = $1,998,000).

As discussed in the Regulatory Evaluation, the American Public Gas

Association (APGA), which represents municipal gas distribution

companies (the bulk of small operators), has agreed to assist small and

medium-sized operators in developing a generic EFV notification. RSPA

also believes that EFV manufacturers, as well as other large companies

and state gas associations, are likely to assist smaller gas operators

in developing an EFV notice. RSPA believes that, with this help, small

and medium-sized operators will choose to use a generic notification

rather than incur the cost of developing their own notice. However,

even with the cost of notice reproduction, mailing, and handling phone

inquiries as described above, we estimate that the cost of developing

the required notice will be minimal for small and medium-sized

operators.

We considered requiring notification of the availability of EFVs to

all customers, not simply new and replaced customers. We rejected this

alternative as not being cost-beneficial for two reasons. First, the

cost of this rule would be an additional $5.36 million (53.6 million

customers x $.10 per copy) just for copying the notice. In addition,

assuming 10% of all notified customers were to telephone operators for

more information, that would result in 5.36 million additional phone

calls. Each call lasting five minutes would amount to 446,666 hours

(5.36 million x 5/60 hours). If the employees responsible for

answering these inquiries were paid a salary of $25 per hour plus 60%

for fringe benefits, the additional cost of handling inquiries would be

$17.97 million (5.36M x \1/12\ x 1.6 x $25=$17.97M) to the

industry. Therefore, the total cost of notifying existing customers

would be additional $23.33 million ($5.36M + $17.97M). Second, there

would be marginal safety benefit as few existing service line customers

would be likely to request EFV installation that could cost more than

$500 per service line, mainly due to the excavation costs associated

with such installation. Therefore, RSPA concludes that requiring

operators to notify all existing customers would cost significantly

more and would provide little additional benefit to the public.

Benefits

The main benefit of this regulation is that new and replaced

service line customers will be provided with the necessary information

for them to decide whether they should request that an EFV be installed

on their service line. Other expected benefits from this rule are

increased EFV use, which could reduce the fatalities, injuries and

property damage that can result from excavation-related incidents on

gas service lines.

Although the total benefits of this rule cannot be estimated, RSPA

has analyzed incidents (March 1991-February 1994) involving 2

fatalities and 16 injuries which may have been prevented with the

installation of an EFV. Further, the average property damage from 30

reportable incidents (March 1991-February 1994) involving service lines

where EFV may have mitigated the accident was estimated to be $14,082

per incident (1993 dollars). Updating this for November 1997 dollars

the average property damage per incident is estimated to be $15,739 per

incident.

Conclusion

Based on the findings of this evaluation this rule should have

minimal economic impact on industry and the public. The regulatory

evaluation is available for review in the docket.

Regulatory Flexibility Act

The Federal Government is required to determine the impact of its

regulations on small entities. Based on the regulatory evaluation, RSPA

has determined that the rule will not have a significant impact on a

substantial number of small entities. Approximately 1,600 natural gas

distribution operators will be affected by this rule. APGA, the trade

association of the majority of small operators, has indicated it will

assist operators in preparing a notification. Additionally, EFV

manufacturers have also offered to assist operators. It is also likely

that regional gas associations and large operators will assist smaller

operators in developing the appropriate notification. All these actions

will serve to minimize the costs to small operators because small

operators are apt to use a generic notice created by one of these

groups rather than incur the expenses of developing their own notice.

Paperwork Reduction Act

This final rule contains information collections that have been

submitted for review by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) under

section 3507(d) of the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (Pub. L. 104-

13). RSPA has made some adjustments to its hourly and cost paperwork

burden estimates based on comments it received to its draft economic

evaluation. If any commenters have additional concerns that have not

previously been submitted, they may submit their comments directly to

OMB.

Interested persons are invited to comment on the collection of

information. Comments should address:

(1) The necessity and utility of the information collection for the

proper performance of the agency's functions; (2) the accuracy of the

agency's burden estimates, including the validity of the methodology

and assumptions used; (3) ways to enhance the quality, utility, and

clarity of the information to be collected; and (4) ways to minimize

the information collection burden on the respondents, including the use

of automated, electronic, mechanical, or other technological collection

techniques.

Administration: Department of Transportation, Research and Special

Programs Administration;

Title: Excess Flow Valves: Customer Notification

Need for Information: By notifying customers that they may have an

excess flow valve installed on their line at cost, some of the

consequences of service line

[[Page 5471]]

failures (fatalities, injuries and property damage) could be mitigated.

Summary: Operators must demonstrate that they have sent the EFV

notification to their customers.

Proposed Use of Information: The notification will advise customers

that they may request an excess flow valve be installed on their

service line at their own expense. Also, by keeping proof that

notification was sent, RSPA will be able to ascertain that operators

are complying with this regulation.

Frequency: Occasionally, once for each new and renewed customer.

Number of Respondents: 1,590.

Estimate of Burden: 92,540 hours.

Respondents: Natural Gas Distribution Operators.

Estimated Total Annual Burden on Respondents: 58.2 hours (first

year) 51.9 hours each subsequent year.

Comments on the information collection requirements should be

submitted within 30 days of the publication of this notice to: the

Office of Management and Budget, Office of Information and Regulatory

affairs, New Executive Office Building, 725 17th St., NW Washington,

D.C. 20503, Att.: Desk Officer RSPA. Persons are not required to

respond to a collection of information unless it displays a currently

valid OMB control number.

Federalism

This rule will not have substantial effects on states, on the

relationship between the federal government and the states, or on the

distribution of power and responsibilities among the various levels of

government. Therefore, in accordance with E.O. 12612 (52 FR 41685;

October 30, 1987), RSPA has determined that this rule does not have

sufficient federalism implications to warrant preparation of a

Federalism Assessment.

Unfunded Mandates Reform Act

This rule does not impose unfunded mandates under the Unfunded

mandates reform Act of 1995. It does not result in costs of $100

million or more to either State, local, or tribal governments, in the

aggregate, or to the private sector, and is the least burdensome

alternative that achieves the objective of the rule.

List of Subjects in 49 CFR Part 192

Pipeline safety, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

In consideration of the foregoing, RSPA amends 49 CFR Part 192 as

follows:

PART 192--[AMENDED]

1. The authority citation for Part 192 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 49 U.S.C. 5103, 60102, 60104, 60110, and 60118; 49

CFR 1.53.

2. Part 192 is amended by adding Sec. 192.383 to read as follows:

Sec. 192.383 Excess flow valve customer notification.

(a) Definitions. As used in this section:

Costs associated with installation means the costs directly

connected with installing an excess flow valve, for example, costs of

parts, labor, inventory and procurement. It does not include

maintenance and replacement costs until such costs are incurred.

Replaced service line means a natural gas service line where the

fitting that connects the service line to the main is replaced or the

piping connected to this fitting is replaced.

Service line customer means the person who pays the gas bill, or

where service has not yet been established, the person requesting

service.

(b) Which customers must receive notification. Notification is

required on each newly installed service line or replaced service line

that operates continuously throughout the year at a pressure not less

than 68.9 m (10 psig) and that serves a single residence. On these

lines an operator of a natural gas distribution system must notify the

service line customer once in writing.

(c) What to put in the written notice. (1) An explanation for the

customer that an excess flow valve meeting the performance standards

prescribed under Sec. 192.381 is available for the operator to install

if the customer bears the costs associated with installation;

(2) An explanation for the customer of the potential safety

benefits that may be derived from installing an excess flow valve. The

explanation must include that an excess flow valve is designed to shut

off the flow of natural gas automatically if the service line breaks;

(3) A description of installation, maintenance, and replacement

costs. The notice must explain that if the customer requests the

operator to install an EFV, the customer bears all costs associated

with installation, and what those costs are. The notice must alert the

customer that costs for maintaining and replacing an EFV may later be

incurred, and what those costs will be, to the extent known.

(d) When notification and installation must be made.

(1) After February 3, 1999 an operator must notify each service

line customer set forth in paragraph (b) of this section:

(i) On new service lines when the customer applies for service.

(ii) On replaced service lines when the operator determines the

service line will be replaced.

(2) If a service line customer requests installation an operator

must install the EFV at a mutually agreeable date.

(e) What records are required.

(1) An operator must make the following records available for

inspection by the Administrator or a State agency participating under

49 U.S.C. 60105 or 60106:

(i) A copy of the notice currently in use; and

(ii) Evidence that notice has been sent to the service line

customers set forth in paragraph (b) of this section, within the

previous three years.

(2) [Reserved]

(f) When notification is not required.

The notification requirements do not apply if the operator can

demonstrate--

(1) That the operator will voluntarily install an excess flow valve

or that the state or local jurisdiction requires installation;

(2) That excess flow valves meeting the performance standards in

Sec. 192.381 are not available to the operator;

(3) That an operator has prior experience with contaminants in the

gas stream that could interfere with the operation of an excess flow

valve, cause loss of service to a residence, or interfere with

necessary operation or maintenance activities, such as blowing liquids

from the line.

(4) That an emergency or short time notice replacement situation

made it impractical for the operator to notify a service line customer

before replacing a service line. Examples of these situations would be

where an operator has to replace a service line quickly because of--

(i) Third party excavation damage;

(ii) Grade 1 leaks as defined in the Appendix G-192-11 of the Gas

Piping Technology Committee guide for gas transmission and distribution

systems;

(iii) A short notice service line relocation request.

Issued in Washington, D.C. on January 27, 1998.

Kelley S. Coyner,

Acting Administrator .

[FR Doc. 98-2496 Filed 2-2-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.