Technical Assistance for Public Participation (TAPP) in Defense Environmental Restoration Activities

Federal RegisterFeb 2, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE

Office of the Secretary

32 CFR Part 203

RIN 0790-AG14

Technical Assistance for Public Participation (TAPP) in Defense

Environmental Restoration Activities

AGENCY: Office of the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for

Environmental Security (DUSD(ES)), DOD.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Pursuant to the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) of

1996, the Department of Defense (DoD) is finalizing a rule to provide

technical assistance to local community members of Restoration Advisory

Boards (RABs) and Technical Review Committee (TRCs). RABs and TRCs are

established to review and comment on DoD environmental restoration

activities at military installations and formerly used defense sites

within the United States and its territories.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This rule is effective February 2, 1998.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Patricia Ferrebee or Marcia Read, Office of the Deputy Under Secretary

of Defense for Environmental Security, 3400 Defense Pentagon,

Washington, D.C., 20301-3400, telephone (703) 697-5372 or (703) 697-

7475.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The official record for this rulemaking is

kept in a paper format. Accordingly, DoD has transferred all electronic

or digital comments received into paper form and placed them into the

official record, with all of the comments received in writing.

The Department of Defense's responses to comments have been

incorporated in a response to comments document, which has been placed

into the official record for this rulemaking. The major comments and

responses are discussed in the Response to Comments section of this

preamble.

Any person wishing to review the official record, or be provided

copies of documents in the official record, for this rulemaking should

contact Patricia Ferrebee at Office of the Deputy Under Secretary of

Defense for Environmental Security, 3400 Defense Pentagon, Washington,

D.C. 20301-3400, in writing, or by telephone at (703) 697-5372.

Preamble Outline

I. Legal Authority

II. Background

III. Summary of Significant Changes from Proposed Rule

IV. Description of the Final Rule and Responses to Major Comments

A. TAPP Process

B. Eligible Applicants

C. Eligible Activities

D. Technical Assistance for Public Participation Provider

Qualifications

E. Submission of Application

F. Appeals Process

V. Administrative Requirements/Compliance with Executive Order

A. Regulatory Impact Analysis Under Executive Order 12866

B. Regulatory Flexibility Analysis

C. Paperwork Reduction Act

D. Unfunded Mandates

I. Legal Authority

This rule is issued under the authority of Section 2705 of Title

10, United States Code. Subsections (c) and (d) of Section 2705

encourage the Department of Defense to establish either a Technical

Review Committee (TRC) or Restoration Advisory Board (RAB) to review

and comment on DoD actions at military installations undertaking

environmental restoration activities. Section 2705(e) permits the

Department of Defense to obtain, from private sector sources, technical

assistance to help TRCs and RABs better understand the scientific and

engineering issues underlying an installation's environmental

restoration activities. TRCs and RABs may request this assistance only

if:

(1) The TRC or RAB demonstrates that the Federal, State, and local

agencies responsible for overseeing environmental restoration at the

installation and DoD personnel do not have the technical expertise

necessary for achieving the objective for which the technical

assistance is to be obtained; or

(2) The technical assistance--

(a) Is likely to contribute to the efficiency, effectiveness, or

timeliness of environmental restoration activities at the installation;

and

(b) Is likely to contribute to community acceptance of

environmental restoration activities at the installation.

Funding for this technical assistance program will come from the

Environmental Restoration Accounts established for Army, Navy, and Air

Force for operating installations, and from the DoD Component's base

closure account for transferring or closing installations. For Defense

Agencies the Defense-Wide environmental restoration account will be the

source of funds for assistance at operating installations. The

Environmental Restoration Account for Formerly Used Defense sites will

fund technical assistance at formerly used defense sites.

[[Page 5256]]

II. Background

Over the past several years, the Department of Defense has

participated as a member of the Federal Facilities Environmental

Restoration Dialogue Committee (FFERDC). This committee, comprised of a

wide range of stakeholders, was chartered by the Environmental

Protection Agency (EPA) to develop consensus policy recommendations for

improving environmental restoration at Federal facilities. In February

1993, the FFERDC issued the ``Interim Report of the FFERDC:

Recommendations for Improving the Federal Facilities Environmental

Restoration Decision-Making and Priority-Setting Processes.'' This

report recommended that Federal agencies become more proactive in

providing information about restoration activities to stakeholders and

that citizen advisory boards be established to provide advice to

government agencies that conduct restoration at Federal facilities.

This report also suggested the initiation of technical assistance

funding.

The Department of Defense has issued policy for establishing RABs

at its installations and formerly used defense sites. On September 9,

1993, the Department of Defense issued policy for establishing RABs at

installations designated for closure or realignment under the BRAC Acts

of 1988 and 1990 where property will be available for transfer to the

community. On April 14, 1994, the Department of Defense issued RAB

policy for non-closing installations as part of Management Guidance for

Execution of the FY94/95 and Development of the FY96 Defense

Environmental Restoration Program (DERP). The policy called for the

establishment of RABs at DoD installations where there is sufficient,

sustained community interest. Criteria for determining sufficient

interest are: (1) a government agency request that a RAB be formed; (2)

fifty local residents sign a petition requesting that a RAB be formed;

(3) an installation determines that a RAB is needed; or (4) the closure

or realignment of an installation involves the transfer of property to

the community. On September 27, 1994, the Department of Defense and EPA

issued joint RAB guidelines on how to develop and implement a RAB.

Finally, on August 6, 1996, the Department of Defense proposed

regulations governing the characteristics, composition, and

establishment of RABs pursuant to the National Defense Authorization

Act (NDAA) for 1995 (61 FR 40764-40772).

The proposed of a RAB is to bring together people who reflect the

diverse interests within the local community, enabling an early and

continual flow of information among the affected community, the

Department of Defense, and environmental oversight agencies.

Recognizing the importance of citizen participation in the

environmental restoration process, Congress authorized the provision of

technical assistance to aid public participation in Section 326 of

NDAA-95. In response to this authority, the Department of Defense

published a Notice of Request for Comments (May 24, 1995, 60 FR 27460-

27463) on alternative methods for funding technical assistance. In

1996, Congress revised this authority in Section 324 of NDAA-96. This

final rule establishes regulations for DOD Components to provide

technical assistance to RABs and TRCs, and details the specific

requirements for obtaining this assistance consistent with this new

authority. Proposed regulations regarding the characteristics,

composition, and establishment of RABs were previously published on

August 6, 1996 (61 FR 40764-40772).

The Department of Defense published a proposed rule, Technical

Assistance for Public Participation (TAPP) in Defense Environmental

Restoration Activities, on December 27, 1996 (61 FR, 68174-68197).

Public comments on this proposed rule were considered and, where

appropriate, incorporated into this final rule.

III. Summary of Significant Changes From Proposed Rule

The substance of this final rule does not differ significantly from

the proposed rule published on December 27, 1996. Principal among the

changes is the addition of an appeals process, described more fully in

Section IV of this preamble and located in Section 203.19 of the final

rule. Because of devolvement of the Defense Environmental Restoration

Account, the authority to grant waivers, in section 203.4, has been

delegated to the DoD Component Secretary, or equivalent, for the

installation in question. In addition, the Department of Defense has,

in section 203.10, clarified the types of projects that will be

eligible for TAPP funding.

IV. Description of the Final Rule and Responses to Major Comments

This rule finalizes the proposed rule ``Technical Assistance for

Public Participation (TAPP) in Defense Environmental Restoration

Activities'' (61 FR, 68174-68197). This section explains the DoD's

final action, based on the rationale presented in the proposed rule and

the DoD's review of the public comments.

To facilitate the reader's review of this final rule and to

streamline the overall structure, this section also contains the DoD's

responses to the most significant comments after each of the topics

discussed. If a particular section does not contain a response to

comment section, then either no comments were received on that topic,

or the Department of Defense has chosen to place its response in the

background document entitled ``Technical Assistance for Public

Participation Response to Comments Background Document.'' This

background document contains a complete discussion of the DoD's

responses to comments and can be found in the docket for this

rulemaking. This document provides a complete record of the public

comments followed by the DoD's responses.

A. TAPP Process

An overview of the process by which community members of RABs and

TRCs can obtain technical assistance is provided in Sections 203.4 and

203.5 of the final rule. The process begins with an evaluation by the

community members of RABs and TRCs of their technical assistance needs

and whether these needs can be met by existing avenues of support.

These other available sources of assistance can include the

installation's restoration contractors, installation or other DoD

personnel, RAB or TRC members, volunteer sources from within the

community, or state, local, or federal personnel responsible for the

oversight of restoration activities at the installation. If these

sources cannot provide the needed assistance, or if the selection of an

alternate provider will contribute to environmental restoration

activities and the community acceptance of such activities, the

community members of RABs and TRCs may submit to the installation a

request for technical assistance. This request should specify in as

much detail as possible the type of assistance requested, the timeframe

for which the assistance is required, and, if known, one or more

potential providers.

Based upon the details provided in the request, the installation

commander or other designated authority will determine whether the

project meets the eligibility requirements outlined in this final rule.

If the project is not approved, the RAB/TRC will receive a written

explanation for that decision. If the project is approved, the

installation commander will forward the application to the appropriate

contracting authority. The contracting authority will issue

[[Page 5257]]

purchase orders to obtain the desired technical assistance subject to

certain funding limitations. If multiple purchase orders are needed to

assist community members of a particular RAB or TRC, the combined sum

of these purchase orders cannot exceed $100,000 or, during any one

year, the lesser of $25,000 or 1 percent of the installation's

projected environmental restoration cost-to-complete. Note that these

limitations refer to the maximum allowable technical assistance funding

per RAB/TRC. Resources available within a given year may vary. In

addition, the funds to support RABs and TRCs and now TAPP derive from

the same budget that funds installation environmental investigations

and cleanup.

The government is required to follow the rules and regulations for

purchase orders as outlines in the Federal Acquisition Regulations

(FAR) (48 CFR Part 13). As a result, the government cannot direct

awards to a specified supplier unless the procurement is under $2,500,

and then only if the cost is comparable to other suppliers. For

procurements over $2,500 but under $100,000, the acquisition is

reserved for small businesses, unless there is a reasonable expection

that small businesses could not provide the best scientific and

technological sources consistent with the demands of the proposed

acquisition for the best mix of cost, performance, and schedules.

Furthermore, the award must be on a competitive basis. The Department

of Defense will solicit bids from those providers meeting the criteria

and will select a provider offering the best value to the government.

Should the procurement process identify a qualified respondent other

than the proposed provider(s) identified by the RAB/TRC, or fail to

identify any qualified respondents, the RAB/TRC will be consulted prior

to the award of a purchase order. If the Department of Defense

determines that the TAPP request represents an eligible project for

which no funds are available, it will ask the RAB or TRC to specify

whether the project should be reconsidered upon the availability of

additional funds.

Community members of RABs and/or TRCs must comply with the

reporting requirements established in Section 203.14 of this rule.

Response to Comments

One commenter indicated that the language in the proposed rule

seems to indicate that support is only to be provided for projects that

will assist in improving public support of DoD cleanup projects. The

commenter noted that the public may have alternate viewpoints on such

issues as: the need for cleanup, risk levels, technology to be used,

etc.

The commenter believes that support should be provided to explore

these issues as well, not just projects which validate DoD decisions.

In response, the Department of Defense intends that support be

provided to allow the RAB/TRC members to better understand and provide

input into DoD's decision process, and does not agree with the

commenter that the rule implies that support will be provided only for

projects that validate DoD's position.

Some commenters expressed concern that approval for TAPP projects

goes through the installation commander.

In response, the installation commander has ultimate authority for

the installation restoration program at his/her installation, and the

Department of Defense feels it is the responsibility of that commander

(or other service-designated authority) to make the decisions affecting

the installation's cleanup budget and its ability to meet cleanup goals

and requirements. Each installation commander or designated authority

will receive guidance to help determine approval processes for

potential TAPP projects. In the event the RAB does not agree with the

decision of the installation commander, it can appeal the decision

through the appeals process outlined in section 203.19 of this final

rule.

Several commenters questioned the funding process to be used. For

instance, one commenter inquired whether RABs would have access to a

full year's allowance (presumably meaning the full annual funding

amount of $25,000 or 1% of the installation's total projected

environmental restoration cost-to-complete), even if the first project

is less than that amount. Other commenters wanted to clarify whether

approval would be subject to available funding, or if there was instead

a ``guarantee'' of support. Finally, several commenters stated that

TAPP support should be readily available, or projects could suffer

while waiting.

When RABs/TRCs identify a need for technical assistance, the

Department of Defense will program funds for TAPP support. The sources

of TAPP funding are the Environmental Restoration Accounts established

for the DoD Components. Therefore, it competes with study, cleanup, and

even RAB funding. The installations, with input from their RAB/TRCs,

will have to determine how tradeoffs will be made between these

important activities. It is DoD's intention that once a project is

identified and approved, the procurement of a provider will occur as

quickly as possible to avoid potential impacts on installation

schedules. However, procurement of the assistance provider is subject

to availability of funds.

Each DoD Component will establish procedures for TAPP funding. They

will not automatically set aside $25,000 or 1% of the installation's

total projected environmental restoration cost-to-complete for each

RAB/TRC for TAPP each year, because some RABs/TRCs may not need TAPP

support. There are no restrictions to having more than one TAPP project

a year as long as the annual limit of $25,000 or 1% of the

installation's total projected environmental cost-to-complete is not

exceeded.

Commenters questioned whether the criteria established for

obtaining technical support can ever be met. For example, the first

criteria states that TRCs and RABs may request assistance only if they

demonstrate that the Federal, State, and local agencies responsible for

overseeing environmental restoration at the installation do not have

the technical expertise necessary for achieving the objective. The

commenter believes this argument will be difficult to make.

Additionally, the commenter wants to know what is required to show that

support isn't available through these sources? The commenter continued

in his argument that the criteria for obtaining assistance were

unlikely to be met. He stated that the criteria regarding enhancing the

timeliness of restoration activities at the installation is certainly

not helped by the involvement of a new contractor. Finally, the

commenter stated that the final criterion that the technical assistance

will contribute to community acceptance of the installation's

restoration activities, is likely not to be met by bringing in outside

opinion.

In response, the criterion cited by the commenter was imposed by

the NDAA of 1996 and are intended to conserve limited resources for

TAPP funding and to encourage the use of all available resources. The

Department of Defense anticipates that much of the technical expertise

required by RABs will be available through existing installation

environmental restoration contractors or through the regulatory and/or

installation or other DoD personnel working on the program. The

Department of Defense encourages the use of these resources to the

maximum extent possible, and notes that commenters from some RABs were

quite

[[Page 5258]]

vocal in their support for these avenues of support. Other sources of

support, such as volunteer services from local universities or other

experts or assistance from states and local health and environmental

organizations, should also be considered to preserve limited TAPP

resources. However, there may be circumstances, such as specific

knowledge of local environmental conditions or knowledge of an

alternative technology, which require expertise not available through

Federal, State, or local oversight agencies. In these instances, the

only requirement is that the RAB provide a statement in their request

for technical assistance that states why their requirements cannot be

met by those agencies. The Department of Defense also points out that

the criterion noted above is one of two criteria for obtaining

assistance, either one of which is sufficient. The full text of the

second criterion cited by the commenter refers to enhancing the

efficiency, effectiveness, or timeliness of environmental restoration

activities. To that end, the Department of Defense believes that an

informed RAB membership is better able to contribute to the restoration

program than one unfamiliar with technical details.

Finally the Department of Defense believes that community

acceptance may be enhanced through the contributions of outside sources

of expertise, particularly when that source can verify to the community

that the proposed restoration activities advocated by the Department of

Defense are appropriate. Community acceptance is greatly influenced by

community understanding. Technical assistance is intended to increase

the RAB's understanding of the DoD environmental restoration program so

that they may make meaningful contributions to the process. As RAB

input is incorporated into the restoration program, environmental

restoration becomes a cooperative effort involving all stakeholders.

Carefully defining the type of assistance needed will limit the

possibility that the introduction of a new contractor will hinder

rather than enhance community understanding.

B. Eligible Applicants

Eligible applicants for TAPP are community members of RABs or TRCs

established in accordance with 32 CFR part 202 (61 FR 40764-40772).

Furthermore, the RABs or TRCs must have at least three community

members to ensure community interests are broadly represented. The

applicant must certify that the request represents the wishes of a

simple majority of the community members of the RAB or TRC.

Certification includes, but is not limited to, the results of a roll

call vote of community members of the RAB or TRC documented in the

meeting minutes.

Response to Comments

Commenters requested clarification on the definition of community

members of RABs or TRCs, specifically whether state and local

government officials could be considered community members for purposes

of this final rule.

The Department of Defense considers state and local government

employees on the RAB or TRC to have full membership in that body.

However, for purposes of determining TAPP projects, the Department of

Defense intends that RAB/TRB community members be limited to residents

of the community affected by or potentially affected by the

installation. In situations where community residents are also members

of the Federal, state or local government, their participation in the

TAPP process would not be excluded, provided they were not expressing

opinions clearly derived from their status as government employees. As

with the proposed RAB rule, however, the Department of Defense intends

that the actual operations of individual RABs and TRCs be determined

largely by the participants, and encourages each organization to

develop its own guidelines for determining both membership at large and

the subset of community members eligible to assist in the development

of TAPP projects.

C. Eligible Activities

TAPP procurements should be pursued by the RAB or TRC only to the

extent that Federal, State, or local agencies responsible for

overseeing environmental restoration at the facility do not have the

necessary technical expertise for the proposed project, or the proposed

technical assistance will contribute to the efficiency, effectiveness,

or timeliness of environmental restoration activities at the

installation and is likely to contribute to community acceptance of

those activities.

The list of eligible activities, section 203.10, of this final rule

has been expanded to clarify eligible projects and provide examples.

The final rule now provides that eligible projects include those

projects designed to:

(1) Interpret technical documents, such as installation restoration

program site investigation, engineering, and decision documents; risk

assessments, including baseline and ecological risk assessments

conducted by the installation; and health assessments, such as those

conducted by Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR).

(2) Assess technologies.

(3) Participate in relative risk evaluations.

(4) Understand health implications.

(5) Provide technical training, where appropriate.

Response to Comments

Several commenters wanted the list of eligible projects expanded to

include some form of community outreach and the ability to generate new

or primary data. In response, DoD believes community outreach should

not be a part of the TAPP program. Community outreach is a fundamental

part of an installation's community relations program, and should be

conducted within the context of that program. One mechanism used

successfully by many installations is the development and publication

of fact sheets or newsletters, providing important information to the

general public about the installation's restoration program. This

activity is funded by the installation's environmental restoration and

Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) funding, which covers

administrative costs incurred by the RABs. The Department of Defense

believes that the goal of the TAPP program is to enhance participation

through increased understanding of the technical issues of the cleanup

program, and maintains that the limited funding available for that

purpose should be directed at that goal.

The generation of new data is the responsibility of the lead

agency--in this case the Department of Defense. Furthermore, the

Department of Defense works closely with the regulatory agencies to

develop investigation strategies to ensure potential hazards are

adequately characterized. This consultation and coordination is an

important part of the partnership the Department of Defense maintains

with regulatory agencies as cleanup proceeds. If the RAB identifies a

circumstance where additional data collection may be necessary, these

concerns should be communicated to the Department of Defense, where the

final decisions on the restoration program reside, or to the

appropriate regulatory agencies if the Department of Defense is not

responsive.

D. Technical Assistance for Public Participation Provider

Qualifications

The Department of Defense has determined that the technical

assistance

[[Page 5259]]

providers must possess certain minimum credentials. These include:

(1) Demonstrated knowledge of hazardous or toxic waste issues and/

or laws.

(2) Academic training in a relevant discipline (e.g., biochemistry,

toxicology, environmental sciences, engineering).

(3) Ability to translate technical information into terms

understandable by lay persons.

In addition, technical assistance providers should posses the

following credentials to ensure they will be qualified to assist the

community members of RABs and TRCs in understanding the environmental

restoration program:

(1) Experience working on hazardous or toxic waste problems.

(2) Experience in making technical presentations.

(3) Demonstrated writing skills.

(4) Previous experience working with affected individuals or

community groups or other groups of individuals.

The technical assistance provider's qualifications will vary

according to the type of assistance to be provided. Community members

of the RAB/TRC may suggest additional provider qualifications as part

of the application for technical assistance. These additional

qualifications may be used by the Department of Defense to target the

most appropriate providers during the procurement process. Examples of

such criteria could include prior work in the area, knowledge of local

environmental conditions or laws, specific technical capabilities, or

other relevant expertise.

Response to Comments

One commenter noted that non-profits and universities should be

eligible TAPP contractors.

In response, it was not the Department of Defense's intent to

exclude qualified TAPP providers from eligibility, in either the

proposed TAPP rule or this final rule. However, the use of purchase

orders to obtain support does require the Department of Defense to

follow procurement policies outlined in the FAR (48 CFR Part 13).

Purchase orders are generally reserved for small businesses unless one

of several situations apply. In circumstances where small businesses

cannot be identified that meet the criteria for procurement, a contract

can be awarded to a qualified bidder that is not a small business.

Examples of such circumstances include situations where conflict of

interest precludes otherwise acceptable small businesses from

participation, where knowledge of specific technical capabilities or of

specific proprietary technologies is required. The Department of

Defense recognizes that in many instances, RAB requirements for support

will specify criteria for the potential provider that may be met only

by non-profits or universities, and envisions no difficulties in

awarding procurements to these types of institutions. As part of the

guidance under development for this program, the Department of Defense

will provide information to assist RABs and the DoD contracting

officers in determining appropriate circumstances for contracting with

technical assistance providers that are not small businesses.

E. Submission of Application

The applicant must submit a TAPP application to begin the TAPP

procurement process. The application form is included as Appendix A of

this part and can be obtained from the DoD installation, the military

department headquarters, or directly from the Department of Defense,

Office of the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Environmental

Security, 3400 Defense Pentagon, Washington, D.C. 20301-3400, telephone

(703) 697-5372 or (703) 697-7475.

The applications will not be considered complete until the

following data elements have been entered into the form:

(a) Installation.

(b) Source of TAPP request (name of RAB or TRC).

(c) Certification of majority request.

(d) RAB/TRC contact point for TAPP project.

(e) Project title.

(f) Project type (e.g., data interpretation, training, etc.).

(g) Project purpose and description (descriptions, time and

locations of products or services desired).

(h) Statement of eligibility of project.

(i) Proposed provider, if known.

(j) Specific qualifications or criteria for provider.

Response to Comments

A few commenters argued that the application process is to complex.

They noted that support might be required just to prepare the project

description and/or the application.

The principal requirement for the RABs in applying for technical

assistance is too develop a project that meets their needs in

understanding some aspect of the installation's restoration program.

Once this need has been communicated to the Department of Defense, the

government assumes the responsibilities for obtaining and monitoring

the performance of the technical assistance provider. The application

form merely formalizes the process the RABs should go through to

develop their project requirements. Additional details, such as

information about a potential technical assistance provider, are

optional and are only intended to help speed up the procurement

process.

Other commenters stated that RABs and TRCs should have access to

additional support, either through an additional purchase order or

through access to third party expertise, such as could be provided by

Technical Outreach Services to Communities (TOSC) providers, in order

to determine the requirements for their TAPP project. (TOSC is a

program of the Environmental Protection Agency's Hazardous Substance

Research Centers to provide information, technical and educational

training, workshops, and site assistance for communities and RABs

dealing with hazardous substance issues.)

In response, the Department of Defense believes the RABs, in

concert with other members of the public, if necessary, are best

positioned to determine their needs for technical support. The

Department of Defense, State, and local government members of the RAB

will be available for support in developing and preparing a TAPP

request, should the RAB community members desire their input.

Furthermore, guidance to assist communities and DoD installations with

this program is currently under development by the Department of

Defense and will be available to RAB members.

One commenter stated that preparation of the TAPP request imposes

too much burden on the RAB with no reimbursement for time and effort.

The commenter believed that this effort should be an eligible expense.

The Department of Defense reiterates that the TAPP request merely

puts in writing the desires of the community members of the RAB to

procure technical assistance. As such, the principal required

information is a description of the proposed project. The Department of

Defense has minimized the burden to community members of RABs/TRCs by

developing a short application form and performing the contract

administration.

F. Appeals Process

Although not specifically raised as an issue by commenters, the

Department of Defense recognizes that disputes can arise at several

junctures in the TAPP process. Three situations in which disagreements

could occur are:

[[Page 5260]]

(a) The RAB/TRC may dispute the findings of the installation

commander that the proposed TAPP project is ineligible, either because

of the failure of the RAB to adequately consider alternate sources of

assistance or because the project does not meet the eligibility

criteria established in the final rule.

(b) The RAB may dispute the findings of the contracting officer

that (1) the preferred provider is inadequate, (2) the preferred

provider is not cost effective, or (3) other providers identified in

the acquisition process more clearly meet the requirements of the task.

(c) After the selection of a provider, a dispute can arise because

the government contracting officer and the RAB/TRC do no agree that the

provider has met the terms of the procurement. In this situation, the

process outlined in the FAR (48 CFR Part 46) would apply.

There is a sincere desire by the Department of Defense to avoid

disputes and to foster an atmosphere of cooperation between the RAB or

TRC and the installation. Each DoD Component has a hierarchical

organizational structure with clearly defined chains-of-command. In the

event that disputes do occur, appeals will be considered within the

chain-of-command, and, in general, will be resolved at the lowest

possible level. The highest level of appeal will be at the DoD

Component Deputy Assistant Secretary level with authority over the

environmental restoration and BRAC environmental programs. In all

cases, inherently governmental functions, such as records of decision,

are not subject to appeal, and issues regarding contracting must be

governed by the FAR (48 CFR Part 37).

V. Administrative Requirements/Compliance With Executive Order

A. Regulatory Impact Analysis Under Executive Order 12866

Under Executive Order 12866 (October 4, 1993, 58 FR 51735), the

Department of Defense must determine whether this regulatory action is

``significant'' and therefore subject to review by the Office of

Management and Budget (OMB) and the requirements of the Executive

Order. Under Section 3(f), the order defines a ``significant regulation

action'' as an action that is likely to result in a rule: (1) Having an

annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more, or adversely and

materially affecting a sector of the economy, productivity,

competition, jobs, the environment, public health or safety, or State,

local or tribal governments or communities (also referred to as

``economically significant''); (2) creating serious inconsistency or

otherwise interfering with an action taken or planned by another

agency; (3) materially altering the budgetary impacts of entitlement,

grants, user fees, or loan programs or the rights and obligations or

recipients thereof; or (4) raising novel legal or policy issues arising

out of legal mandates, the President's priorities or the principles set

forth in this Executive Order.

Pursuant to the terms of this Executive Order, the OMB has

determined this rule is a ``significant regulatory action'' because it

may raise novel legal or policy issues. As such, this action was

submitted to the OMB for review, and any comments or changes made in

response to the OMB suggestions or recommendations will be documented

in the public record.

B. Regulatory Flexibility Analysis

The Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 requires that agencies

evaluate the effects of rules for three types of small entities:

(1) Small Businesses (as defined in the Small Business

Administration regulations);

(2) Small organizations (independently owned, non-dominant in their

field, non-profit); and

(3) Small government jurisdictions (serving communities of less

than 50,000 people).

The Department of Defense has considered the interests of small

businesses and small organizations by means of the use of purchase

orders to obtain technical assistance. As stated in the FAR (48 CFR

Part 13), those purchase orders under $100,000 are reserved for small

businesses, unless it can be demonstrated that small businesses are

unable to provide the necessary service or product. Only a limited

number of small non-profit organizations are expected to be affected by

this program as it is likely that only those non-profit organizations

located near Department of Defense installations with ongoing

environmental restoration programs will, in most cases, provide the

requested technical assistance. The Department of Defense was careful

not to impose additional reporting requirements on the public and to

stay within the reporting requirements quota for procurements. In

keeping with the Simplified Acquisition Procedures (SAP), the

Department of Defense has sought to increase the dollar amount of small

purchase orders to simplify the procurement process. The Department of

Defense has deliberately written the regulations to encourage small

entities to apply. Given the limited funding available to this program

and the process outlined of Section 203.4 of this final rule, it is not

expected that this rulemaking will have a significant economic impact

on a substantial number of small entities and, therefore, no Regulatory

Flexibility Analysis is necessary.

C. Paperwork Reduction Act

Pursuant to the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995, the reporting and

record keeping provisions of this final rule were submitted to the OMB

for review under Section 3507(d) of the Act.

The collection of information is necessary to identify products or

services requested by community members of RABs/TRCs to aid in their

participation in the Department of Defense's environmental restoration

program, and to meet Congressional reporting requirements.

Respondents are community members of restoration advisory boards or

technical review committees requesting technical assistance to

interpret scientific and engineering issues regarding the nature of

environmental hazards at an installation. This assistance will help

communities in participating in the cleanup process. The information,

directed by 10 U.S.C. 2705, will be used to determine the eligibility

of the proposed project, begin the procurement process to obtain the

requested products or services, and determine the satisfaction of

community members of RABs/TRCs receiving the products and services.

D. Unfunded Mandates

Title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995 (UMRA), Pub.

L. 104-4, establishes requirements for Federal agencies to assess the

effects of the regulatory actions on State, Tribal, and local

governments and the private sector. Under section 202 of the UMRA, the

Department of Defense generally must prepare a written statement,

including a cost-benefit analysis, for proposed and final rules with

``Federal mandates'' that may result in expenditures to State, local,

and Tribal governments, in the aggregate, or to the private sector, of

$100 million or more in any one year. When a written statement is

needed, section 205 of the UMRA generally requires the Department of

Defense to identify and consider a reasonable number of regulatory

alternatives that achieve the objectives of the rule. The provisions of

section 205 do not apply when they are inconsistent with applicable

law. Moreover, section 205 allows the Department of Defense to adopt an

[[Page 5261]]

alternative other than the least costly, most cost-effective, or least

burdensome alternative if the Secretary publishes with the final rule

an explanation why that alternative was not adopted. Before the

Department of Defense establishes any regulatory requirements that may

significantly or uniquely affect small governments, including Tribal

governments, it must have developed under section 203 of the UMRA a

small government agency plan. The plan must provide for notifying

potentially affected small governments, giving them meaningful and

timely input into the development of the Department of Defense's

regulatory proposals with significant Federal intergovernmental

mandates, and informing, educating, and advising them on compliance

with the regulatory requirements.

The Department of Defense has determined that this rule does not

contain a Federal mandate that may result in expenditures of $100

million or more for State, local, and Tribal governments, in the

aggregate, or the private sector in any one year. Thus, today's rule is

not subject to the requirements of sections 202 and 205 of the UMRA.

List of Subjects in 32 CFR Part 203

Administrative practice and procedure, Technical assistance, Public

assistance programs, Environmental protection, Federal buildings and

facilities, Organization and functions (Government agencies).

Title 32 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Chapter I, Subchapter

M, is amended to add part 203 to read as follows:

PART 203--TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE FOR PUBLIC PARTICIPATION (TAPP) IN

DEFENSE ENVIRONMENTAL RESTORATION ACTIVITIES

Sec.

203.1 Authority.

203.2 Purpose and availability of referenced material.

203.3 Definitions.

203.4 Major components of the TAPP process.

203.5 TAPP process.

203.6 Cost principles.

203.7 Eligible applicants.

203.8 Evaluation criteria.

203.9 Submission of application.

203.10 Eligible activities.

203.11 Ineligible activities.

203.12 Technical assistance for public participation provider

qualifications.

203.13 Procurement.

203.14 RAB/TRC reporting requirements.

203.15 Method of payment.

203.16 Record retention and audits.

203.17 Technical assistance provider reporting requirements.

203.18 Conflict of interest and disclosure requirements.

203.19 Appeals process.

Appendix A to Part 203--Technical Assistance for Public

Participation Application Request Form

Authority: 10 U.S.C. 2705.

Sec. 203.1 Authority.

Part 203 is issued under the authority of section 2705 of Title 10,

United States Code. In 1994, Congress authorized the Department of

Defense (DoD) to develop a program to facilitate public participation

by providing technical assistance to local community members of

Restoration Advisory Boards (RABs) and Technical Review Committees

(TRCs) (section 326 of the National Defense Authorization Act for

Fiscal Year 1995, Pub.L. 103-337). In 1996, Congress revised this

authority (section 324 of the National Defense Authorization Act for

Fiscal Year 1996, Pub.L. 104-112). It is pursuant to this revised

authority, which is codified as new subsection (3) of section 2705,

that the Department of Defense issues this part.

Sec. 203.2 Purpose and availability of referenced material.

(a) This part establishes the Technical Assistance for Public

Participation (TAPP) program for the Department of Defense. It sets

forth policies and procedures for providing technical assistance to

community members of TRCs and RABs established at DoD installations in

the United States and its territories. This part sets forth the

procedures for the Department of Defense to accept and evaluate TAPP

applications, to procure the assistance desired by community members of

RABs and TRCs, and to manage the TAPP program. These provisions are

applicable to all applicants/recipients of technical assistance as

discussed in Sec. 203.4 of this part.

(b) Any reference to documents made in this part necessary to apply

for TAPP (e.g., the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) Circulars or

DoD forms) are available through the DoD installations, the military

department headquarters, or from the Department of Defense, Office of

the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Environmental Security

(DUSD(ES)), 3400 Defense Pentagon, Washington, DC 20301-3400.

Sec. 203.3 Definitions.

As used in this part, the following terms shall have the meaning

set forth:

Affected. Subject to an actual or potential health or environmental

threat arising from a release or a threatened release at an

installation where the Secretary of Defense is planning or implementing

environmental restoration activities including a response action under

the Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act

as amended (CERCLA), corrective action under the Resource Conservation

and Recovery Act (RCRA), or other such actions under applicable Federal

or State environmental restoration laws. This would include actions at

active, closing, realigning, and formerly used defense installations.

Examples of affected parties include individuals living in areas

adjacent to installations whose health is or may be endangered by the

release of hazardous substances at the facility.

Applicant. Any group of individuals that files an application for

TAPP, limited by this part to community members of the RAB or TRC.

Application. A completed formal written request for TAPP that is

submitted to the installation commander or to the identified decision

authority designated for the installation. A completed application will

include a TAPP project description.

Assistance provider. An individual, group of individuals, or

company contracted by the Department of Defense to provide technical

assistance under the Technical Assistance for Public Participation

program announced in this part.

Assistance provider's project manager. The person legally

authorized to obligate the organization executing a TAPP purchase order

to the terms and conditions of the DoD's regulations and the contract,

and designated by the provider to serve as the principal contact with

the Department of Defense.

Community Co-chair. The individual selected by the community

members of the RAB/TRC to represent them.

Community member. A member of the RAB or TRC who is also a member

of the affected community. For the purpose of this part, community

members do not include local, State, or Federal government officials

acting in any official capacity.

Community point of contact. The community member of the RAB or TRC

designated in the TAPP application as the focal point for

communications with the Department of Defense regarding the TAPP

procurement process. The community point of contact is responsible for

completing the reporting requirements specified in Sec. 203.14 of this

part.

Contact. A written agreement between the installation or other

instrumentality of the Department of Defense and another party for

services or supplies necessary to complete the TAPP project.

[[Page 5262]]

Contracts include written agreements and subagreements for professional

services or supplies necessary to complete the TAPP projects,

agreements with consultants, and purchase orders.

Contracting officer. The Federal official designated to manage the

contract used to fulfill the TAPP request by the RAB or TRC.

Contractor. Any party (e.g., Technical Assistance Provider) to whom

the installation or other instrumentality of the Department of Defense

awards a contract. In the context of this part, it is synonymous with

assistance provider.

Cost estimate. An estimate of the total funding required for the

assistance provider to complete the TAPP project.

DoD Component. The military services including the Army, Navy,

Marine Corps, and Air Force and those defense agencies with an

environmental restoration program.

DoD Component Deputy Assistant Secretary. The individual in the

office of the Secretary of the Army, Navy, Air Force responsible for

making environmental decisions for their component or the director of

the Defense Agencies.

DoD Installation. A facility that is controlled or operated or

otherwise possessed by a department, or agency of the United States

Department of Defense within the United States and its territories. In

the context of this part, formerly used defense sites (FUDS) are

included within the definition of a DoD Installation.

DoD RAB Co-chair. The individual selected by the installation

commander, or equivalent, to serve as the installation co-chair of the

RAB, represent DoD's interests, serve as liaison with community RAB

members, and advocate RAB concerns within the installation staff.

EPA. The United States Environmental Protection Agency.

Firm fixed price contract. A contract wherein funding is fixed,

prior to the initiation of a contract, for an agreed upon service or

product.

Formerly Used Defense Site (FUDS). A site that has been owned by,

leased to, possessed by, or otherwise under the jurisdiction of the

Department of Defense. The FUDS program does not apply to those sites

outside U.S. jurisdiction.

Purchase order. An offer by the Government to buy supplies or

services from a commercial source, upon specified terms and conditions,

the total cost of which cannot exceed the small purchase limit of

$100,000. Purchase orders are governed by Federal Acquisition

Regulations (FAR) (48 CFR part 13), and the Simplified Acquisition

Procedures (SAP).

Restoration Advisory Board (RAB). The RAB is a forum for

representatives of the Department of Defense, local community, and EPA

and/or State, local, and tribal officials to discuss and exchange

information about the installation's environmental restoration program.

The RAB provides stakeholders an opportunity make their views known,

review progress and participate in dialogue with the decision makers.

Statement of Work. That portion of a contract which describes the

actual work to be done by means of specifications or minimum

requirements, quantities, performance dates, time and place of

performance, and quality requirements. It is key to any procurement

because it is the basis for the contractor's response and development

of proposed costs.

TAPP approval. Signifies that the Department of Defense has

approved the eligibility of the proposed TAPP project and will, subject

to the availability of funds, undertake an acquisition to obtain the

services specified in the TAPP application submitted by the RAB or TRC.

The government will conduct the acquisition in accordance with all of

the applicable rules and requirements of the FAR and the SAP. Approval

does not constitute an agreement to direct an award to a specific

source if such an action would be contrary to the FAR.

TAPP project description. A discussion of the assistance requested

that includes the elements listed in Section 203.10 of this part. The

project description should contain sufficient detail to enable the

Department of Defense to determine the nature and eligibility of the

project, identify potential providers and estimate costs, and prepare a

statement of work to begin the procurement process.

Technical assistance. Those activities specified in Sec. 203.10 of

this part that will contribute to the public's ability to provide input

to the decision-making process by improving the public's understanding

of overall conditions and activities. Technical assistance may include

interpreting technical documents; assessing technologies; participating

in relative risk evaluations, understanding health implications; and,

training.

Technical assistance does not include those activities prohibited

under Section 203.11 of this part, such as litigation or underwriting

legal actions; political activity; generation of new primary data such

as well drilling and testing, including split sampling; reopening final

DoD decisions or conducting disputes with the Department of Defense; or

epidemiological or health studies, such as blood or urine testing.

Technical Review Committee (TRC). A group comprised of the

Department of Defense, EPA, State, and local authorities and a public

representative of the community formed to meet the requirements of 10

U.S.C. 2705(c), the Department of Defense Environmental Restoration

Program. Primarily functioning to review installation restoration

documents, these committees are being expanded and modified at

installations where interest or need necessitates the creation of a

RAB.

Sec. 203.4 Major components of the TAPP process.

(a) The Department of Defense will issue purchase orders to

technical assistance, facilitation, training, and other public

participation assistance providers subject to the purchase limit per

order as resources continue to be available. If multiple purchase

orders are needed to assist community members of a particular RAB or

TRC, the combined sum of these purchase orders cannot exceed $100,000

or, during any one year, the lesser of $25,000 or 1 percent of the

installation's total projected environmental restoration cost-to-

complete. Note that these limitations refer to the maximum allowable

technical assistance funding per RAB/TRC. Resources available within a

given year may vary. These limitations apply unless a waiver is granted

by the DoD Component Secretary or equivalent for the installation in

question. The $100,000 total and $25,000 annual limitations may be

waived, as appropriate, to reflect the complexity of response action,

the nature and extent of contamination at the installation, the level

of activity at the installation, projected total needs as identified by

the TAPP recipient, the size and diversity of the affected population,

and the ability of the TAPP recipient to identify and raise funds from

other sources.

(b) Community members of the RAB/TRC will provide a description of

the services requested (TAPP Project Description) and, if desired, the

names of one or more proposed technical assistance providers to the DoD

RAB Co-Chair, who will ensure the application is submitted to the

installation commander or other designated authority and to the

appropriate DoD contracting office. Technical assistance providers

proposed by the community members of a RAB or TRC at each DoD

installation that meets the minimum set

[[Page 5263]]

of organizational qualifications guidelines provided by the Department

of Defense in Sec. 203.12 of this part will be added to the governments

list of bidders for the proposed procurement.

Sec. 203.5 TAPP process.

This section provides an overview of the TAPP process. Specific

details referred to in this section can be found in subsequent sections

of this part.

(a) TAPP funding. Funding for this TAPP program will come from the

Environmental Restoration Accounts established for Army, Navy, and Air

Force for operational installations. The funding for Defense Agencies'

operating installations will be from the Defense-Wide Environmental

Restoration Account. Funding will be from the component's base closure

account for transferring or closing installations. Funding for Formerly

Used Defense Sites will come from the Environmental Restoration Account

established for Formerly Used Defense Sites. After justification of the

TAPP proposal, each DoD Component will make funds available from their

individual installation's environmental restoration or BRAC accounts,

considering a number of factors related to the restoration program at

the installation and its impact upon the community. These factors

include, but are not limited to:

(1) Closure status.

(2) Budget.

(3) Installation restoration program status.

(4) Presence (or absence) of alternate funding.

(5) Relative risk posed by sites at the installation.

(6) Type of task to be funded.

(7) Community concern.

(8) Available funding.

(b) Identification of proposed TAPP project. Eligible applicants of

RABs and TRCs, established in Sec. 203.7 of this part, should determine

whether a TAPP project is required to assist the community members of

the RAB or TRC to interpret information regarding the nature and extent

of contamination or the proposed remedial actions. Eligibility

requirements for TAPP projects are described in Secs. 203.10 and 203.11

of this part. In keeping with the requirements of 10 U.S.C. 2705(e),

the RAB or TRC must be able to demonstrate that the technical expertise

necessary for the proposed TAPP project is not available through the

Federal, State, or local agencies responsible for overseeing

environmental restoration at the installation, or that the selection of

an independent provider will contribute to environmental restoration

activities and the community acceptance of such activities. In

addition, the Department of Defense encourages the RAB or TRC to seek

other available sources of assistance prior to submitting a request for

TAPP in order to preserve limited resources. These sources include

DoD's installation restoration contractor, or other DoD contractors or

personnel, EPA or state regulatory personnel, volunteer services from

local universities or other experts, or assistance from state and local

health and environmental organizations.

(c) TAPP project request. The RAB or TRC should notify the

installation of its intent to pursue TAPP upon the determination that

other sources of assistance are unavailable or unlikely to contribute

to the community acceptance of environmental restoration activities at

the installation and should prepare a formal request specifying the

type of assistance required and, if desired, one or more sources for

this assistance. Details concerning this request are stated in

Sec. 203.9 of this part. The RAB or TRC must certify to the Department

of Defense that the TAPP request represents a request by a majority of

the community members of the RAB or TRC. The RAB or TRC should ensure

that the request meets the eligibility requirements specified in

Secs. 203.10 and 203.11 of this part. Furthermore, the RAB or TRC may

outline additional criteria for the Department of Defense to consider

in the selection of a provider (such as knowledge of local

environmental conditions or specific technical issues, a prior work

history within the study area which has relevant specific circumstances

or unique challenges, or other relevant expertise or capabilities),

keeping in mind that providers must meet the minimum technical

qualifications outlined in Sec. 203.12 of this part. The formal request

should be submitted to the installation commander or designated

decision authority, either directly, or through the DoD RAB Co-chair.

The installation commander, or other designated decision authority,

will review the proposed project to determine whether the proposed

project conforms to the eligibility requirements. If the installation

commander, or other designated authority, fails to approve the project

request, the rationale for that decision will be provided to the RAB/

TRC in writing.

(d) Purchase orders. Upon receipt of a completed TAPP request, the

installation will begin the procurement process necessary to obtain the

desired services by means of a purchase order or will forward the

request to the contracting authority designated by the DoD Component to

act for that installation. The government is required to follow the

rules and regulations for purchase orders as outlined in the FAR (48

CFR part 13). As a result, the government cannot direct awards to a

specified supplier unless the procurement is under $2,500, and then

only if the cost is comparable to other suppliers. For procurements

over $2,500 but under $100,000, the acquisition is reserved for small

businesses, unless there is a reasonable expectation that small

businesses could not provide the best scientific and technological

sources consistent with the demands of the proposed acquisition for the

best mix of cost, performance, and schedules. Furthermore, the award

must be on a competitive basis. In addition to proposing potential

providers, the application for technical assistance may indicate

specific criteria or qualifications that are deemed necessary by the

RAB/TRC for the completion of the project to their satisfaction. This

information will be used to assist the Department of Defense in

preparing a bidders list. The Department of Defense will solicit bids

from those providers meeting the criteria and will select a provider

offering the best value to the government. Should the procurement

process identify a qualified respondent other than the proposed

provider(s) identified by the RAB/TRC or fail to identify any qualified

respondents, the RAB/TRC will be consulted prior to the award of a

purchase order. If the Department of Defense determines that the TAPP

request represents an eligible project for which no funds are

available, it will ask the RAB or TRC to specify whether the project

should be reconsidered upon the availability of additional funds.

(e) Reporting requirements. The applicant must assure that copies

of delivered reports are made available to the Department of Defense

and must comply with the reporting requirements established in

Sec. 203.14 of this part.

Sec. 203.6 Cost principles.

(a) Non-profit contractors must comply with the cost principles in

OMB Circular A-122. Copies of the circular may be obtained from EOP

Publications, 725 17th NW, NEOB, Washington, DC 20503.

(b) For-profit contractors and subcontractors must comply with the

cost principles in the FAR (48 CFR part 31).

Sec. 203.7 Eligible applicants.

Eligible applicants are community members of RABs or TRCs.

Furthermore, the RABs or TRCs must be

[[Page 5264]]

comprised of at least three community members to ensure community

interests are broadly represented. The applicant must certify that the

request represents the wishes of a simple majority of the community

members of the RAB or TRC. Certification includes, but is not limited

to, the results of a roll call vote of community members of the RAB or

TRC documented in the meeting minutes. Other requirements of the

application are detailed in Sec. 203.9 of this part.

Sec. 203.8 Evaluation criteria.

The Department of Defense will begin the TAPP procurement process

only after it has determined that all eligibility and responsibility

requirements listed in Secs. 203.6, 203.7, and 203.9 of this part are

met, and after review of the specific provider qualifications as

submitted in the narrative section of the application. In addition, the

proposed TAPP project must meet the eligibility criteria as specified

in Secs. 203.10 and 203.11 of this part. Projects that fail to meet

those requirements relating to the relevance of the proposed project to

the restoration activities at the installation will not be approved.

Sec. 203.9 Submission of application.

The applicant must submit a TAPP application to begin the TAPP

procurement process. The application form is included as appendix A of

this part and can be obtained from the DoD installation, the DoD

Component headquarters, or directly from the Department of Defense,

Office of the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Environmental

Security, 3400 Defense Pentagon, Washington, D.C. 20301-3400. The

applications will not be considered complete until the following data

elements have been entered into the form:

(a) Installation.

(b) Source of TAPP request (names of RAB or TRC).

(c) Certification of majority request.

(d) RAB/TRC contact point for TAPP project.

(e) Project title.

(f) Project type (e.g. data interpretation, training, etc.).

(g) Project purpose and description (descriptions, time and

locations of products or services desired).

(h) Statement of eligibility of project.

(i) Proposed provider, if known.

(j) Specific qualifications or criteria for provider.

Sec. 203.10 Eligible activities.

(a) TAPP procurements should be pursued by the RAB or TRC only to

the extent that Federal, State, or local agencies responsible for

overseeing environmental restoration at the facility do not have the

necessary technical expertise for the proposed project, or the proposed

technical assistance will contribute to the efficiency, effectiveness,

or timeliness of environmental restoration activities at the

installation and is likely to contribute to community acceptance of

those activities.

(b) TAPP procurements may be used to fund activities that will

contribute to the public's ability to provide advice to decision-makers

by improving the public's understanding of overall conditions and

activities. Categories of eligible activities include the following:

(1) Interpret technical documents. The installation restoration

program documents each stage of investigation and decision-making with

technical reports that summarize data and support cleanup decisions.

Technical assistance may be provided to review plans and interpret

technical reports for community members of RABs and TRCs. These reports

include, but are not limited to:

(i) Installation restoration program site studies, engineering

documents, such as site inspections, remedial investigations,

feasibility studies, engineering evaluation and cost analyses, and

decision documents (including records of decision);

(ii) Risk assessments, including baseline and ecological risk

assessments conducted by the installation; and

(iii) Health assessments, such as those conducted by the Agency for

Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR).

(2) Assess technologies. Technical assistance may be provided to

help RAB/TRC community members understand the function and implications

of those technologies selected to investigate or clean up sites at the

installation.

(3) Participate in relative risk site evaluations. Technical

assistance may be provided to help RAB/TRC community members contribute

to the relative risk evaluation process for specific sites.

(4) Understand health implications. Technical assistance may be

provided to help RAB/TRC community members interpret the potential

health implications of cleanup levels or remedial technologies, or to

explain the health implications of site contaminants and exposure

scenarios.

(5) Training, where appropriate. Technical trainers on specific

restoration issues may be appropriate in circumstances where RAB/TRC

members need supplemental information on installation restoration

projects.

Sec. 203.11 Ineligible activities.

The following activities are ineligible for assistance under the

TAPP program:

(a) Litigation or underwriting legal actions, such as paying for

attorney fees or paying for a technical assistance provider to assist

an attorney in preparing legal action or preparing for and serving as

an expert witness at any legal proceeding regarding or affecting the

site.

(b) Political activity and lobbying as defined by OMB Circular A-

122.

(c) Other activities inconsistent with the cost principles stated

in OMB Circular A-122, ``Cost Principles for Non-Profit

Organizations.''

(d) Generation of new primary data, such as well drilling and

testing, including split sampling.

(e) Reopening final DoD decisions, such as the Records of Decision

(see limitations on judicial review of remedial actions under the

Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act

(CERCLA) Section 113(h)) or conducting disputes with the Department of

Defense).

(f) Epidemiological or health studies, such as blood or urine

testing.

(g) Community outreach efforts, such as renting a facility and

conducting public meetings, or producing and distributing newsletters.

Sec. 203.12 Technical assistance for public participation provider

qualifications.

(a) A technical assistance provider must possess the following

credentials:

(1) Demonstrated knowledge of hazardous or toxic waste issues and/

or laws.

(2) Academic training in a relevant discipline (e.g., biochemistry,

toxicology, environmental sciences, engineering).

(3) Ability to translate technical information into terms

understandable to lay persons.

(b) A technical assistance provider should possess the following

credentials:

(1) Experience working on hazardous or toxic waste problems.

(2) Experience in making technical presentations.

(3) Demonstrated writing skills.

(4) Previous experience working with affected individuals or

community groups or other groups of individuals.

(c) The technical assistance provider's qualifications will vary

according to the type of assistance to be provided. Community members

of the RAB/TRC may suggest additional provider

[[Page 5265]]

qualifications as part of the application for technical assistance.

These additional qualifications may be used by the Department of

Defense to target the most appropriate providers during the procurement

process. Examples of such criteria could include prior work in the

area, knowledge of local environmental conditions or laws, specific

technical capabilities, or other relevant expertise.

Sec. 203.13 Procurement.

Procurements will be conducted as purchase orders in accordance

with the FAR (48 CFR part 13). Under these procedures, procurements not

exceeding $100,000 are reserved exclusively for small businesses, and

will be conducted as competitive procurements. Procurements below a

value of $2,500 are considered ``micro-purchases.'' These procurements

do not require the solicitation of bids and may be conducted at the

discretion of the contracting officer.

Sec. 203.14 RAB/TRC reporting requirements.

The community point of contact of the RAB or TRC must submit a

report, to be provided to the installation and to DUSD(ES), to enable

the Department of Defense to meet DoD reporting requirements to

Congress. This report should include a description of the TAPP project,

a summary of services and products obtained, and a statement regarding

the overall satisfaction of the community member of the RAB or TRC with

the quality of service and/or products received.

Sec. 203.15 Method of payment.

The SAP set forth in FAR (48 CFR part 13) require purchase orders

to be conducted on a firm-fixed-price basis, unless otherwise

authorized by agency procedures. The Department of Defense anticipates

all TAPP awards to be firm-fixed-price procurements.

Sec. 203.16 Record retention and audits.

The recipient technical assistance providers shall keep and

preserve detailed records in connection with the contract reflecting

acquisitions, work progress, reports, expenditures and commitments, and

indicate the relationship to established costs and schedules.

Sec. 203.17 Technical assistance provider reporting requirements.

Each technical assistance provider shall submit progress reports,

financial status reports, materials prepared for the RAB/TRC, and a

final report to the DoD installation for the TAPP project as specified

by the specific purchase order agreement. The final report shall

document TAPP project activities over the entire period of support and

shall describe the achievements with respect to stated TAPP project

purposes and objectives.

Sec. 203.18 Conflict of interest and disclosure requirements.

The Department of Defense shall require each prospective assistance

provider on any contract to provide, with its bid or proposal:

(a) Information on its financial and business relationship with the

installation, RAB/TRC members, or any/all potentially responsible

parties (PRPs) at the site, and with their parent companies,

subsidiaries, affiliates, subcontractors, contractors, and current

clients or attorneys and agents. This disclosure requirement

encompasses past and anticipated financial and business relationships,

including services related to any proposed or pending litigation, with

such parties.

(b) Certification that, to the best of its knowledge and belief, it

has disclosed such information or no such information exists.

(c) A statement that it shall disclose immediately any such

information discovered after submission of its bid or after award. The

contracting officer shall evaluate such information and shall exclude

any prospective contractor if the contracting officer determines the

prospective contractor has a potential conflict of interest that is

both significant and cannot be avoided or otherwise resolved. If, after

award, the contracting officer determines that a conflict of interest

exists that is both significant and cannot be avoided or resolved, the

contract will be terminated for cause.

(d) Contractors and subcontractors may not be technical assistance

providers to community members of RABs/TRCs at an installation where

they are performing cleanup activities for the Federal or State

government or any other entity.

Sec. 203.19 Appeals process.

DoD Components will establish an appeals process to settle

potential disputes between the Department of Defense and the public

regarding certain decisions arising out of the TAPP process. The

Department of Defense recognizes that the RAB/TRC may disagree with the

findings of the installation commander that a proposed TAPP project is

ineligible, either because of the availability of alternate sources of

assistance or because the project does not meet the eligibility

criteria established in this part. It is in the best interests of the

Department of Defense and the community members of RABs and TRCs to

anticipate and avoid disputes and to work cooperatively to resolve

potential differences of opinion. However, in certain circumstances,

the RAB/TRC community members may feel that their needs were not

adequately served by the decisions of the Department of Defense. In

this instance, the hierarchical structure and chain-of-command within

each DoD Component will serve as the avenue for appeal. Appeals will be

considered within the chain-of-command, and, in general, will be

resolved at the lowest level possible. The highest level of appeal will

be at the DoD Component Deputy Assistant Secretary level with authority

over the DERP and BRAC environmental programs. Inherently governmental

functions, such as the procurement process governed by the FAR, are not

subject to appeal.

BILLING CODE 5000-04-M

[[Page 5266]]

[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR02FE98.006

[[Page 5267]]

[GRAPHIC] [TIFF OMITTED] TR02FE98.007

BILLING CODE 5000-04-C

[[Page 5268]]

Dated: January 27, 1998.

Patricia L. Toppings,

Alternate OSD Federal Register Liaison Officer, Department of Defense.

[FR Doc. 98-2394 Filed 1-30-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 5000-04-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.