Air Bag On-Off Switches

Federal RegisterAug 27, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

49 CFR Part 595

[NHTSA-98-4342]

RIN 2127-AH25

Air Bag On-Off Switches

AGENCY: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA),

Department of Transportation (DOT).

ACTION: Final rule: response to petitions for reconsideration.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This document responds to the petitions for reconsideration

and letters seeking non-rulemaking action that NHTSA received in

response to its final rule exempting motor vehicle dealers and repair

businesses from the statutory prohibition against making Federally-

required safety equipment inoperative so that they could install air

bag on-off switches for vehicles owned or operated by individuals

within discrete risk groups. This document denies the petitions for

reconsideration. NHTSA will, however, change its current policy with

regard to one of the three issues raised in the letters seeking agency

action not requiring a rulemaking procedure.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For information about air bag on-off

switches and related rulemaking, call the NHTSA Hotline at 1-800-424-

9393; in the D.C. area, call 202-366-0123. In addition, visit the NHTSA

Web site at http://www.nhtsa.dot.gov/airbags/. Among the available

materials are descriptions of the procedures for requesting

authorization to obtain an on-off switch and a list of questions and

answers about air bags and on-off switches. There are also crash videos

showing what happens in a crash to a belted, short-statured dummy whose

driver air bag is turned off.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Table of Contents

I. Background

II. Letter from National Association of Independent Insurers

III. Letter from National Association of Pediatric Nurse Associates

and Practitioners, Inc.

IV. Petition from Mitsubishi Motors R&D of America

V. Petition from American Car Rental Association

VI. Petitions from Members of the General Public

I. Background

On November 18, 1997, the National Highway Traffic Safety

Administration, Department of Transportation, issued a final rule which

allows for the installation of air bag on-off switches under limited

conditions. (62 FR 62406) Effective January 19, 1998, the rule exempts

motor vehicle dealers and repair businesses from the statutory

prohibition against making federally-required safety equipment

inoperative so that they may install, subject to certain conditions,

retrofit manual on-off switches for the air bags of vehicle owners

whose request is authorized by NHTSA. To obtain such authorization,

vehicle owners must submit a request form to NHTSA on which they have

certified that they have read an agency information brochure about air

bag benefits and risks and that they or a user of their vehicle is a

member of one of the risk groups specified by the agency. The agency

began processing and granting requests December 18, 1997.

NHTSA received 20 petitions for reconsideration of the final rule.

Sixteen of these petitions are from members of the general public, and

the other four are from organizations. The content of two of the

organizational petitions, those from the National Motorists Association

and the National Motorists Association, New Jersey Chapter, is very

similar to that of the petitions from the general public. Accordingly,

they are discussed together with the general public petitions. All

other organizational petitions are addressed separately. NHTSA also

received two letters that were characterized as petitions for

reconsideration but which did not seek any rulemaking action from the

agency. Each of the letters are addressed separately.

II. Letter From National Association of Independent Insurers

In the preamble to the Final Rule, NHTSA stated that it would

continue to

[[Page 45756]]

authorize deactivation of air bags under very limited circumstances

when an on-off switch was not available for a given vehicle make and

model. NHTSA stated that it would publish the vehicle identification

numbers (VIN) of vehicles whose air bags have been deactivated pursuant

to an agency letter permitting such action. The agency indicated that

it would take this action out of concern about the impermanence of

labels alerting the occupants of a vehicle that one or both of its air

bags had been deactivated. The agency did not, however, state where

this list would be kept or how often it would be updated.

The National Association of Independent Insurers (NAII) submitted a

document that was described as a petition for reconsideration and that

asked NHTSA to clarify the manner of VIN publication, to publish the

VINs of vehicles with on-off switches, and to make available to

insurers the names of the owners of vehicles with on-off switches or

deactivated air bags.1 Since the actions requested by NAII

are not rulemaking actions, the agency is treating the document as a

letter instead of a petition for reconsideration. NHTSA is taking some

of the actions requested by NAII, but declines to take the remaining

actions.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ NAII maintained that they need the names of switch

applicants because VINs are often incorrectly transcribed.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The agency agrees that it is desirable to advise the public where

it can find out whether a particular vehicle has deactivated air bags

as well as how often such information will be updated. The list of VINs

for vehicles known by the agency to have had one or both of their air

bags deactivated will be located at the NHTSA web site (http://

www.nhtsa.dot.gov) and will be updated weekly. NHTSA cautions that this

list will be incomplete. The vast majority of agency letters sent to

date granting permission for deactivation were sent prior to issuance

of the final rule. Prior to that time, the agency did not require

persons requesting permission for deactivation to provide the VIN of

their vehicle. NHTSA has sent new letters asking the recipients of

those pre-final rule deactivation permission letters to provide the VIN

of any vehicle that has had one or both of its air bags deactivated

pursuant to the permission letter and to indicate which air bag was

deactivated. The percentage of these letters for which the agency

receives responses will depend upon the good will of each individual

owner receiving the request, since NHTSA cannot legally compel a

response.

NHTSA has decided against making the VINs for vehicles with on-off

switches available to the public as general information. NHTSA does not

believe that any interest is served by making such a list available.

The regulatory text requires that on-off switch telltales be clearly

visible to the front seat occupants. Accordingly, a quick vehicle

inspection should alert any interested party to the presence of an on-

off switch. While insurers may not regularly inspect the vehicles that

they insure, as NAII asserted, insurers can require applicants or

policyholders to state whether they have an on-off switch before the

policy is issued or renewed. At that time, the insurer can decide

whether to provide a discount for the air bag. NHTSA notes that for

those individuals who are at heightened risk from a deploying air bag,

the safety benefits contemplated by insurers in providing an air bag

discount may not apply.

NHTSA will not provide insurers or any other members of the public

with information identifying the owner of any vehicles listed on its

web site. NHTSA believes that revealing such information would be a

violation of the Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. section 552a). Accordingly,

NAII's request that they be allowed to verify the ownership of vehicles

is declined.

III. Letter From National Association of Pediatric Nurse Associates

and Practitioners, Inc.

Under the final rule, NHTSA continues to grant requests for air bag

deactivation for vehicles where the vehicle manufacturer has not

produced an on-off switch. The criteria for deactivation, however, are

stricter than the criteria for installation of an on-off switch since

deactivation is a permanent measure that cannot be easily reversed. For

example, the deactivation criteria are stricter than their on-off

switch counterpart in requiring that medical conditions be documented

by a physician and that the physician state that the risk of deployment

outweighs the risk of potentially impacting the steering wheel or

dashboard.

The National Association of Pediatric Nurse Associates and

Practitioners asks NHTSA to allow pediatric nurse practitioners to

recommend air bag deactivation if such deactivation is in the best

interests of their patient. Since the criteria governing deactivation

were not part of the regulation adopted in the final rule, NHTSA has

treated the Association's ``petition'' as a simple request for a policy

change.

NHTSA recognizes that pediatric nurse practitioners serve an

important role in the medical community, particularly in medically

under-served areas, where they may provide the majority of medical care

for their patients. NHTSA also believes that nurse practitioners are

qualified to determine whether a child's medical condition warrants

riding in the front seat. Accordingly, NHTSA believes the Association's

request is reasonable and has decided to accept medical documentation

from pediatric nurse practitioners.

IV. Petition From Mitsubishi Motors R&D of America

Mitsubishi Motors filed a petition for reconsideration seeking to

have NHTSA's approval of a request for an on-off switch or deactivation

conditioned on a guarantee by the owner that he or she will have the

switch removed or the air bag reconnected prior to selling the vehicle.

Mitsubishi contends that this is the only way to ensure that only those

individuals within one of the specified risk groups loses the potential

benefits of the air bag.

NHTSA is denying Mitsubishi's request because even if the agency

amended the final rule to condition its approval of owner requests for

an on-off switch upon the owner's promising to remove the switch, the

agency could not enforce such a promise.

NHTSA can place limitations on the circumstances in which dealers

and repair businesses are exempted from the make inoperable

prohibition. Indeed, in the final rule, the agency specified that it

would not approve switch requests unless the requestor provided certain

information and made certain statements. For example, it specified that

the requesters must certify that they had read the agency's information

brochure and that they or a user of their vehicle is a member of one of

the identified risk groups.

However, the agency cannot condition its approval of requests upon

the subsequent restoration of the air bags to their original condition

prior to resale. The most it could do would be to condition its

approval upon the receipt of a promise to make such restoration. Since

such a promise could not realistically be enforced against the vehicle

owner and would not serve as a limitation on the exempted dealers or

repair businesses, the only covered entities under the applicable

statute, there would be no assurance that requiring such a promise

would ultimately lead to the restoration of the air bags to their

original condition.

[[Page 45757]]

NHTSA believes the final rule, as drafted, provides adequate notice

of the presence of an on-off switch. The required telltale must be

illuminated and visible to the driver when the driver-side air bag is

turned off and to all front seat occupants when the passenger-side air

bag is turned off. NHTSA does not believe there will be a significant

amount of misuse in the secondary market, although it acknowledges that

nothing in the final rule would preclude an individual who is not at

risk from a deploying air bag from purchasing a used vehicle that has a

switch and then turning the air bag off.

V. Petition From the American Car Rental Association

In the final rule permitting vehicle owners to apply to the agency

for permission to have an on-off switch installed by a dealer or repair

business, NHTSA did not differentiate between owners of individual

vehicles and owners of vehicle fleets.

The American Car Rental Association (ACRA) has asked NHTSA to

modify its final rule to prohibit short-term car rental companies from

having on-off switches installed in the vehicles in their rental

fleets. ACRA states that it cannot ensure that individuals who are not

at risk from a deploying air bag will not misuse an on-off switch.

NHTSA is denying ACRA's petition because it believes that a rental

fleet owner should be able, if it so wishes, to obtain permission to

have on-off switches installed in at least some of its vehicles. It

would be reasonable for a fleet owner to make such a request if it

believes that a sufficient percentage of its rental population falls

within the specified risk groups.

The agency emphasizes that under the final rule, no vehicle owner,

whether a company or an individual, is required to have an on-off

switch installed. Each decision by a vehicle owner to request

permission to have a switch installed should only be made after a

careful consideration of the risks involved in having an air bag

unavailable in the event of a crash. If rental car companies believe

that it would not be appropriate to have vehicles with on-off switches

available for their customers who are at risk from an air bag, then

they can decide not to request permission for their installation.

Alternatively, if they decide that they want to provide at-risk

individuals with a vehicle with an on-off switch, then they may decide

that it is worthwhile to request a switch for some portion of their

fleet.2 In either case, NHTSA believes this is a decision

that can only be reached by the rental companies. NHTSA continues to

believe that traditional contract remedies and business relationships

will allow for adequate policing of on-off switch use. This is why

NHTSA did not exclude leased vehicles or fleet vehicles from the on-off

switch rule.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\2\ NHTSA encourages rental companies to provide information to

renters of such vehicles with on-off switches so they understand the

circumstances under which it would be appropriate to use the switch.

Rental companies could choose to provide renters with a copy of the

NHTSA publication Air Bags and On-Off Switches, Information for an

Informed Decision.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

VI. Petitions From Members of the General Public

NHTSA received 16 petitions from members of the general public as

well as a petition from the National Motorists Association and the New

Jersey chapter of the National Motorists Association. All of these

petitions raised the same issues and will accordingly be responded to

together. While 28 separate issues were raised in these petitions, many

of the issues can be grouped together and have been so grouped here.

Membership in a Risk Group

The petitioners claim that the Government ignored the safety of

individuals at risk from air bags, notably children and short-statured

females, by creating discrete risk groups that would be eligible for

on-off switches rather than allowing deactivation on demand. NHTSA

disagrees.

NHTSA believes its final rule appropriately responded to the risk

that passenger-side air bags can pose to children. The final rule

allows anyone who needs to carry children in the front seat to apply

for and receive an on-off switch. Thus, petitioners' contention that

the final rule places children at risk is incorrect. Even individuals

who only occasionally must drive with children in the front seat can

obtain permission for a switch.

Petitioners imply that it is only the air bag which makes the front

seat dangerous for children. NHTSA notes that it is preferable to have

children sit in the back seat whenever possible since crash data

demonstrate that is the safest location, regardless of whether the

vehicle is equipped with an air bag. While a significant number of

people still choose to allow their children to sit in the front seat,

most do so by choice, not necessity.3

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ Cf., Jack Edwards, Kaye Sullivan, ``Where Are All the

Children Seated and When Are They Restrained?'', SAE Technical Paper

971550 (1997).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Likewise, the agency disagrees with petitioners' contention that

switches or deactivation on demand should be allowed because children

are often improperly restrained. Allowing deactivation on demand would

be inappropriate because it would allow people who are not at risk to

obtain and use switches to turn off their air bags, thus decreasing

their safety. The approach adopted by the agency makes it necessary for

vehicle owners to focus on and evaluate the factors that create risk

and encourages them to take steps to reduce that risk. The final rule

helps to prevent air bag fatalities involving children since the rule

allows an on-off switch for anyone who must carry children in the front

seat. However, allowing widespread deactivation, apart from not adding

any additional safety benefit, could send the conflicting message that

children do not need to be restrained as long as they are not in front

of an air bag. Further, as noted above, encouraging front seat use

would reduce child safety since, even in the absence of an air bag, the

front seat is significantly less safe than the back seat.

Petitioners' contention that air bags will cause unreported deaths

because short-statured individuals will be unable to control their

vehicles after moving their seats back to obtain ten inches is also

apparently based on a misreading of the final rule. NHTSA stated that

most individuals can achieve the desired ten-inch distance by slightly

modifying their driving posture, and still maintain a safe, comfortable

driving position. For those individuals who cannot comfortably drive

ten inches or more from their air bag, NHTSA recommends they consider

having an on-off switch installed.

Contrary to petitioners' contention, NHTSA believes that vehicle

owners will carefully read the agency's information brochure and then

carefully assess whether they or any user of their vehicle is really at

risk from the vehicle's air bags. The agency expects that the owners

who request permission for an on-off switch will be people who can

legitimately certify membership in a risk group. Anyone who must

transport children in the front seat is eligible for an on-off switch.

Likewise, people who suffer from a medical condition which they believe

places them at risk from a deploying air bag, or people who are unable

to get 10 inches or more from the air bag cover, regardless of their

height, are eligible for an on-off switch.

NHTSA fully considered allowing persons to deactivate their air

bags without having to show or claim actual risk. The agency decided

that public safety interests dictate that individuals who do not fall

within one of the specified risk groups should not be

[[Page 45758]]

allowed to have an on-off switch installed. Particularly given the

evidence of misperception of risk by a significant number of vehicle

owners, NHTSA does not believe that an individual's belief that he or

she has the right to choose whether to have an air bag outweighs

society's interest in avoiding death and serious injury and the

enormous public expense associated with unnecessary injury.

Risk of Injury and Death

Petitioners claim that NHTSA's regulatory evaluation indicates that

30 percent of individuals impacted by air bags will receive an injury

so that the other 70 percent of that population will avoid injury.

Petitioners aver that this level of injury is excessive. The agency

believes that the significance of this level of injury cannot be

properly assessed in a vacuum. The alternative of what would happen to

a vehicle occupant in the absence of an air bag must be considered. In

moderate to severe crashes, even belted occupants, especially drivers,

will strike their head, neck and chest against the interior of their

vehicle in the absence of an air bag. Consequently, the injuries

prevented by air bags are typically substantially more serious than the

injuries that air bags cause. Further, petitioners do not take into

consideration the significant reduction in fatalities which are not

represented in the table cited by petitioners.

Contrary to petitioners' assertion, the Government is not mandating

that the American public accept a 4 percent risk of death by requiring

air bags on all new vehicles. The risk of death cannot be based on a

comparison of lives saved versus lives lost. The evaluation of risk

must be based on a comparison of total deployments (over 2.1 million)

versus lives lost. This risk is less than 0.005 percent. Moreover, for

those persons for whom the risk is relatively high, the rule allows the

installation of an on-off switch.

The comparison of lives saved to lives lost is instructive. The

most recent data (June 1, 1998) indicate that while 105 persons have

been killed by air bags, 3,148 persons have been saved. Therefore, a

person is 31 times more likely to be saved by an air bag than killed by

an air bag. Further, the ratio could be even higher in the future since

the 31:1 ratio is based on there being no change in occupant behavior

or improvements in air bag design due to NHTSA's Final Rule allowing

depowered air bags (62 FR 12960). The vast majority of the 105 air bag

deaths could have been prevented through simple behavior modification,

namely wearing a safety belt and moving the children to the back seat.

NHTSA does recognize that not all risk can be eliminated through

behavioral changes since there may occasionally be factors beyond the

driver's control. In those instances, NHTSA allows the installation of

an on-off switch.

NHTSA's estimates of air bag effectiveness were based on two

separate analyses. The first was developed by comparing fatality rates

of drivers with air bags to passengers without air bags in the same

vehicle. These rates were compared to those of older vehicles of the

same make and model without driver or passenger air bags. This approach

is called ``double pair comparison analysis'' and is widely used in

effectiveness evaluations. The second analysis, which also used double

pair comparison methodology, involved comparing fatality rates of

frontal and non-frontal impacts of air bag vehicles to non-air bag

vehicles. Both methods produced similar results. Neither of the methods

took the occupant's safety belt use into consideration (i.e., the

estimates were based on the experience of all occupants, regardless of

whether they used safety belts). Thus, possible errors in the reporting

of safety belt use would have had no effect on these estimates.

Regarding the suggestion by petitioners that air bags might provide a

net negative benefit for major population groups, these groups are the

ones that are specifically allowed to install on-off switches. Persons

outside these groups are statistically safer with air bags than without

them.

Costs Associated With the Final Rule

Petitioners state that NHTSA has grossly underestimated the cost of

on-off switches in evaluating the actual cost of installation, in

evaluating the time value of the consumer, and in determining the

overall cost based on the number of people who will have a switch

installed. Cost was not the deciding factor in issuing the final rule.

Safety was the paramount concern in the decision-making process.

NHTSA notes that it lacks the authority to control the amount that

dealers and repair businesses charge to install an on-off switch.

However, since installation is a purely voluntary expense, each

individual can decide whether he or she believes the risk of deployment

justifies the accompanying expense. Finally, regardless of the amount

charged to consumers, NHTSA continues to believe that a simple on-off

switch could be installed for $38 to $63 based on the amount of work

required to install the device and the hardware necessary to create a

device.

Petitioners contend that the hourly rate of $9.20, the figure that

NHTSA used to place a value on the time members of the public who read

the brochure and complete the form, should be higher since owners of

air bag-equipped vehicles are wealthier than the average American.

NHTSA's figure was based on guidance developed by the Department of

Transportation for valuing travel time when evaluating regulatory

alternatives. The figure is based on a combination of personal or

leisure time and time spent at work and represents the wage scale of a

wide variety of employees. NHTSA notes that most people would not need

to take off work to read the information brochure and fill out the

form. Accordingly, the figure of $9.20 may be slightly higher than the

true value of the time that an individual would spend for those

purposes. Nevertheless, NHTSA believes an hourly rate of $9.20 is

reasonable.

As to the overall cost of the final rule, NHTSA believes that the

overall costs are irrelevant to an individual's decision to request

permission for and purchase a switch. Individuals either will or will

not install an on-off switch, regardless of the final rule's cost to

the entire population.

NHTSA's estimate of 80,000 installations per year represented its

best estimate as of the time the rule was issued. Current demand for

on-off switch authorizations has averaged 189 requests per day. If

demand were to remain constant throughout the year, actual demand would

be approximately 69,000 installation requests per year. However, NHTSA

does not believe that demand will continue at current rates. The

issuance of the final rule is still a fairly recent event, having

become effective on January 19, 1998. Significant media coverage

accompanied both the issuance of the final rule and its implementation.

Further, it was natural that there be an initial surge in requests

since the majority of individuals who are concerned with deploying air

bags were likely to request a switch as soon as the option became

available. As time passes and the issuance and media coverage become

more distant events, NHTSA believes that demand will also fall. The

agency anticipates that future requests will tend to be limited to

individuals either buying a new vehicle or having an additional child

who cannot be accommodated in the back seat.

Misuse

Petitioner claims that NHTSA's statement in its final rule that it

has not seen, and does not expect, a significant

[[Page 45759]]

amount of misuse is a tacit acknowledgment by the agency that it has no

reasonable basis for requiring membership in a risk group.

Petitioner mischaracterizes the issue. The agency's position on

misuse is that past experience indicates some relaxation of its

previous limitations on on-off switches is justified, not that switch

misuse is not a potential problem under any circumstances.

As an initial matter, any deactivation, or switching off, of an air

bag by or for an individual who does not fall within the specified risk

groups constitutes misuse. That individual is safer with an air bag

than without one. Accordingly, allowing all members of the general

public to have on-off switches installed, regardless of risk, can only

increase the potential for misuse.

Additionally, NHTSA allowed broader criteria for retrofit switches

than for switches installed prior to first sale in certain vehicles

based in part on its experience with those switches. Prior to the

publication of the final rule at issue here, on-off switches were

limited to the passenger side of vehicles with no back seat or a back

seat that could not accommodate a child restraint (OEM rule) (49 CFR

571.208 S4.5.4). Under that rule, potential misuse is limited to adult

passengers since no switch is available for the driver side air bag and

all children under age 12 fall within a risk group prescribed by the

retrofit final rule.

NHTSA is unaware of any circumstances in which an adult passenger

has been killed or seriously injured in one of these vehicles because

the air bag had been switched off, although it does know of an infant

fatality where the passenger-side air bag had been left on. This

apparent lack of significant misuse in a limited portion of the overall

air bag-equipped fleet persuaded NHTSA that some relaxation of the

existing requirements, when accompanied by a process designed to inform

vehicle owners of actual risk, was justified.

The agency notes that under the OEM rule, all switch-eligible

vehicles have either no back seat or only a small seating area.

Accordingly, children in most of these vehicles have no choice but to

sit in the front seat. As NHTSA has repeatedly cautioned, the back seat

is safest for all passengers and particularly for small children. NHTSA

remains concerned that allowing switches for individuals who do not

meet one of the specified criteria only increases the possibility that

children who could more safely ride in the back seat will be placed in

greater danger simply because the passenger-side air bag has been

turned off.

The Agency's Evaluation of Comments

Petitioners contend that NHTSA failed to take into account the

comments from some 600 members of the general public as well as the

National Transportation Safety Board and the Insurance Institute for

Highway Safety (IIHS). This is incorrect. NHTSA considered all comments

in making its decision. However, the agency's decision was based upon

safety considerations instead of what appeared from the comments to be

the most popular decision.

Further, the final rule may be more popular than suggested by the

petitioners. Many of the private citizens who submitted comments on the

rulemaking may fall within a specified risk group since the primary

complaint was short stature. If these individuals are unable to get at

least ten inches from the center of their steering wheel while sitting

comfortably, they are eligible for an on-off switch. As to the

commenters' attitude toward on-off switches, the degree of their

support is uncertain since most commenters did not address on-off

switches. Of those who did discuss on-off switches, the majority

supported on-off switches as at least an option to deactivation.

Physician's Report

Petitioners claim that the medical panel did not consider two

investigations concerning ``air bag exhaust fire'', a newspaper report

of an air bag-related fire, and two anecdotal reports of near-

asphyxiation from air bags when it reported that a driver's

supplemental oxygen did not justify air bag disconnection. NHTSA's

Office of Defects Investigation investigated the two reports of ``air

bag exhaust fire'' and concluded that there was no indication the air

bags in question caused the burns complained of in the consumer

complaints to NHTSA. One of the investigations did note that air bag

exhaust does reach temperatures high enough to ignite some fabrics, but

that the temperatures did not remain at those levels for a sufficient

period of time to create a fire hazard (PE97-014). In neither

investigation did the vehicle owner claim that sparks or flames were

emitted from the air bag. In any event, if an individual's treating

physician believes that supplemental oxygen is a concern, regardless of

the analysis reached by the medical panel, the patient is able to

obtain an on-off switch under the final rule's criteria.

Petitioners' claim regarding potential diminution in quality of

life from air bag injuries does not justify allowing deactivation on

demand. Particular concern was raised about potential hearing and

vision loss. Injury patterns culled from the National Analysis Sampling

System (NASS), as well as all available medical literature, including

the University of Michigan report cited by petitioners, were reviewed

by the medical panel. None of the available data or literature revealed

significant injury to the eyes or hearing loss as a result of air bag

deployments.

The medical panel considered all known literature on hearing and

vision loss related to air bag deployments. It stated that potential

loss of hearing could not be isolated to air bag deployment and that

the air bag was no more likely to cause a serious eye injury than

impacting the dashboard or steering wheel. Even if these types of

injuries were occurring on a regular basis, like arm injuries, the

level of injury is incremental and significantly less than the types of

injuries which air bags are preventing. The vast majority of injuries

caused by air bags are both minor and temporary.4

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\4\ NASS analysis did reveal a substantial increase in arm

injuries as a result of air bag deployment.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Petitioners' claimed that air bags should be voluntary because

individuals are allowed to withhold consent for all other forms of

medical treatment. This comment raises issues not only beyond the scope

of this rulemaking, but beyond the agency's authority given the

statutory mandate for air bags. Nevertheless, the agency notes that air

bags are a preventative measure similar to many medical therapies which

significantly impact public health. Thus, children are required to be

vaccinated before they can enter school, municipalities are required to

provide a safe source of drinking water, and the American food supply

is subjected to stringent controls to protect the public health.

Deactivation

In the preamble to the final rule, NHTSA stated that it would

continue to grant requests for permanent deactivation when no vehicle

manufacturer switch is available and when the applicant meets certain

criteria. These criteria are more limited than those for which a switch

is authorized. The agency notes that the final rule allows the

installation of non-vehicle manufacturer switches and that such

switches are available. Petitioner claims that NHTSA's policy places

individuals at undue risk, alleging vehicle manufacturers may decide

not to manufacture switches for all vehicle

[[Page 45760]]

makes and models, and that deactivation is cheaper than switches.

NHTSA's decision to impose more stringent criteria on air bag

deactivation is reasonable, given the permanent nature of deactivation.

Deactivation renders an air bag unavailable to help anyone in a crash.

In contrast, the on-off switch allows a driver to turn the air bag on

or off, depending on the risk faced by the individual seated in front

of the air bag. This flexibility is important in the case of a vehicle

whose users include a mix of people at risk and people not at risk. For

example, one member of a couple may have a medical condition which

prevents him or her from achieving a 10-inch distance from the air bag,

while the other can achieve that distance. Likewise, a family may only

have to transport children in the front seat on rare instances, such as

when they have to transport a neighbor's child and they have

insufficient room in the back seat for all of the children. The

presence of an on-off switch would make that air bag available to every

individual who is not at risk while the air bag could be turned off for

those at risk. In contrast, deactivation renders an air bag unavailable

to everyone, regardless of risk.

While deactivation may be cheaper than an on-off switch, cost was

not the agency's main consideration. Safety was the overriding factor.

Further, since the cost of both deactivation and on-off switches is

ultimately market-based, NHTSA cannot assess the differences in cost

with any specificity. NHTSA believes that its estimation of on-off

switch cost should not be an overwhelming deterrent to anyone who needs

a switch. Cost concerns aside, one is significantly more likely to find

a company willing to install an on-off switch than deactivate an air

bag. Liability concerns on the part of dealers and repair businesses

have rendered permanent deactivation more difficult to get performed

than installation of a switch. As for petitioner's claim that

deactivation more certainly turns off an air bag than an on-off switch

does, manufacturers, dealers and repair businesses have every incentive

to produce and install a safe switch since the final rule does not

waive civil liability for defective switches or negligent installation.

Further, the agency notes that there are potential risks associated

with deactivation. Labels can be removed, either purposely or

inadvertently. An occupant expecting air bag protection may

unexpectedly find that he or she has none in a crash. Many deactivated

air bags will likely not be reactivated prior to resale since there is

no incentive to reactivate, and since NHTSA does not have the authority

to require reactivation. Consequently, any decision to reactivate, as

well as to inform a potential secondary purchaser of the air bag's

inoperable status, will depend entirely on the good will of the

vehicle's owner.

Depowered and Advanced Air Bag Systems

Petitioners argued that deactivation or on-off switches should

remain available to owners of vehicles with depowered air bags and

advanced air bags. Under the final rule, on-off switches will be

available for vehicles with depowered air bags. As the agency stated in

the final rule:

As to depowered air bags, NHTSA anticipates that they will pose

less of a risk of serious air bag injuries than current air bags.

However, the agency will wait and accumulate data on depowered air

bags before making a final decision on this issue. The agency may

revisit this issue in a future rulemaking if data indicate that

cutoff switches are not appropriate in vehicles with depowered air

bags. For the present, the exemption will apply to vehicles with

depowered air bags.

As to advanced air bags, NHTSA did not decide in the final rule

whether retrofit on-off switches would be permitted for vehicles with

those air bags. The agency did say that it continued to believe, based

on safety considerations, that it should prohibit dealers and repair

businesses from retrofitting advanced air bag vehicles with cutoff

switches. However, since advanced air bags were not expected for

several years, there was no immediate need to make a decision. The

agency said that it would address this issue in its proposal on

advanced air bags.

Process for Receiving Authorization To Have an On-Off Switch Installed

Petitioners argued that the actual number of eligible individuals

who will be able to have an on-off switch installed is too low because

of the authorization process established by the agency. The agency

disagrees. NHTSA defined the eligible risk groups to avoid the need for

ad hoc decision making and to expedite the authorization process. The

amount of time necessary to read the information brochure and fill out

the request form (approximately 30 minutes) is nominal when compared to

the significant safety benefit at issue. Likewise, the amount of time

required to process a request, currently one or two days, is

reasonable, given the benefit that air bags provide to the vast

majority of the general public. Further, NHTSA's streamlined process

minimizes the amount of time that an at-risk individual must wait

before receiving authorization to have an on-off switch installed.

Request for Reconsideration

Based on the foregoing, NHTSA is denying petitioners' request that

on-off switches be available on request and without certification of

membership in a risk group. As noted above, the risk of serious injury

or death is small and the benefit of air bags is large. NHTSA will

continue to require vehicle owners to submit the completed on-off

switch request forms to the agency for processing. Petitioners' request

that the agency allow deactivation on request is likewise denied.

Authority: 49 U.S.C. 322, 30111, 30115, 30117, and 30166;

delegation of authority at 49 CFR 1.50.

Issued: August 20, 1998.

L. Robert Shelton,

Associate Administrator for Safety Performance Standards.

[FR Doc. 98-22832 Filed 8-26-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-59-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Air Bag On-Off Switches · 63 FR 45755 | Frix