Federal Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance and Supplemental Security Income for the Aged, Blind, and Disabled; Standards of Conduct for Claimant Representatives

Federal RegisterAug 4, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SOCIAL SECURITY ADMINISTRATION

20 CFR Parts 404 and 416

[Regulations Nos. 4 and 16]

RIN 0960-AD73

Federal Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance and

Supplemental Security Income for the Aged, Blind, and Disabled;

Standards of Conduct for Claimant Representatives

AGENCY: Social Security Administration.

ACTION: Final rules.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: We are amending our rules governing representation of

claimants seeking Social Security or supplemental security income (SSI)

benefits under title II or XVI of the Social Security Act (the Act), as

amended. The final rules establish standards of conduct and

responsibility for persons serving as representatives and further

define our expectations regarding their obligations to those they

represent and to us. The final rules include statutorily and

administratively imposed requirements and prohibitions.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This regulation is effective September 3, 1998.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Robert J. Augustine, Legal Assistant,

Office of Process and Innovation Management, Social Security

Administration, 6401 Security Boulevard, Baltimore, MD 21235, (410)

966-5121. For information on eligibility or claiming benefits, call our

national toll-free number, 1-800-772-1213.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

Prior regulations governing representatives' conduct

(Secs. 404.1740, et seq. and 416.1540, et seq.) under titles II and

XVI, of the Act, primarily reiterate various statutory provisions set

forth in the Act. Sections 404.1745 and 416.1545 also provide that a

representative may be suspended or disqualified from practice before

the Social Security Administration (SSA) if he or she has violated

those rules, been convicted of a violation of sections 206 or

1631(d)(2) of the Act, respectively, or ``otherwise refused to comply

with our rules and regulations on representing claimants in dealings

with us.'' This is consistent with sections 206(a)(1) and 1631(d)(2) of

the Act, which provide that the Commissioner of Social Security (the

Commissioner) may ``suspend or prohibit from further practice before

him any such person, agent, or attorney who refuses to comply with the

Commissioner's rules and regulations * * *'' (Section 206(a)(1) is

[[Page 41405]]

incorporated into title XVI of the Act by section 1631(d)(2)(A) of the

Act.) Since their inception, the regulations have reflected the

Commissioner's (formerly the Secretary of Health and Human Services')

broad authority over matters involving representatives' activities in

their dealings with us.

These final rules are based on the notice of proposed rulemaking

(NPRM) published in the Federal Register on January 3, 1997 (62 FR

352). Specifically, they provide enforceable standards governing

aspects of practice, performance and conduct for all persons who act as

claimants' representatives. The final rules also recognize the

increased participation of compensated representatives in the

adjudicative process, the special circumstances presented by SSA's

nonadversarial administrative process including its hearings, and

statutory changes, such as the anti-fraud provisions of the Social

Security Independence and Program Improvements Act of 1994, Public Law

(Pub. L.) 103-296. The prior regulations pertaining to representatives'

conduct had been largely unchanged since their promulgation in 1980,

and no longer adequately addressed our experience concerning the

extensive participation of representatives in the claims process.

We take seriously our statutory responsibility to ensure that

claimants are represented properly during the claims process.

Therefore, we are publishing these rules to improve the efficiency of

our administrative process and to ensure that claimants receive

competent services from their representatives. While we recognize that

most representatives do a conscientious job in assisting their clients,

our experience has convinced us that there are sufficient instances of

questionable conduct to warrant promulgation of additional regulatory

authority. The prior regulations did not address a representative's

responsibility to adequately prepare and present the claimant's case

among other deficiencies. These final rules correct these omissions and

are necessary to protect the claimant and the adjudicative process from

those individuals who are incapable of providing, or unwilling to

provide, meaningful assistance in expeditiously resolving pending

claims.

Although there are disparities in the levels of skill, experience,

education and professional status among those who serve as

representatives, we believe all such individuals must be bound by the

same set of rules. In determining the appropriate standards, we

considered the requirements and intent of the Act and its implementing

regulations, administrative law principles applicable to adjudication

and the American Bar Association's (ABA's) Model Rules of Professional

Conduct and Model Code of Professional Responsibility.

There are comparable rules in part 410, subpart F (Secs. 410.684,

et seq.) governing representative conduct under the Black Lung benefits

program. We are not revising those rules, however. Executive Order

12866, Regulatory Planning and Review, issued by the President on

October 4, 1993 (58 FR 51735), provides that ``Federal agencies should

promulgate only such regulations as are required by law, are necessary

to interpret the law, or are made necessary by compelling public need *

* *.'' Because we process a very small number of claims involving Black

Lung benefits, and the concerns giving rise to these rules have not

affected those claims, there is no compelling need to revise the Black

Lung rules.

We expect that the final rules will further clarify the obligations

of representatives to provide competent representation of their

clients, in accordance with the procedural and evidentiary requirements

of the claims process. Moreover, the final rules constitute official

notice concerning our requirements and prohibitions.

In drafting the proposed rules, we obtained information from

various sources to address the concerns of claimants and others with a

stake or interest in the issue of claimant representation; for example,

we conducted focus groups with claimants and beneficiaries as part of

our disability process redesign initiative. Participants in the public

dialogue conducted in conjunction with our redesign initiative

frequently noted the lack of timely or effective assistance on the part

of claimants' representatives. We also used information gathered in

investigating nearly 600 complaints involving misconduct by

representatives from 1988 to 1997. In light of complaints about the

quality and effectiveness of representatives' services, the Disability

Process Redesign Team included within its recommendations provisions

aimed at representatives' performance.

In addition, in February 1995 we requested comments on a draft

proposal from 33 separate groups and organizations drawn from the

attorney and non-attorney claimant representative community. These

groups included professional organizations, interest groups, think

tanks, legal services organizations, and various private representative

organizations. We received 92 responses to this informal request. Many

were supportive, especially regarding the need to provide standards for

non-attorney representatives. Many, however, were opposed to more

regulation of their professional conduct. We carefully considered all

the views and concerns in formulating the proposed rules, which we

published in the Federal Register on January 3, 1997. Similarly, we

considered the public comments received on the proposed rules, in

formulating these final rules.

Regulatory Provisions

These final regulations revise Secs. 404.1740, 404.1745, 404.1750,

404.1765, 404.1770, 404.1799, 416.1540, 416.1545, 416.1550, 416.1565,

and 416.1599.

We revised Secs. 404.1740(a) and 416.1540(a) to explain the purpose

and scope of these rules which are intended to ensure that

representatives provide competent services to their clients and comport

themselves in accordance with our rules and standards. Accordingly, the

rules set forth affirmative duties and prohibited actions that shall

govern the relationship between the representative and the Agency.

We revised Secs. 404.1740(b) and 416.1540(b) to include affirmative

duties, which are certain obligations that a representative must

actively perform in his or her representation of claimants in matters

before us. We expect these affirmative duties to promote competence,

diligence, and timeliness in assisting the claimant to meet the burden

of proving eligibility for benefits.

We have not changed the regulations concerning our existing duties

and responsibilities with regard to developing the record and obtaining

evidence nor have we changed our expectations concerning what will be

required of claimants (see Secs. 404.1512 and 416.912 concerning

disability and blindness claims). Therefore, we will continue to carry

out our existing responsibilities in this regard. Under these rules,

however, representatives will be expected to assist claimants in

meeting their obligations with respect to submitting information and

evidence and responding to our requests in conformity with our existing

regulations.

New Secs. 404.1740(b)(1) and 416.1540(b)(1) clarify that a

representative should act with reasonable promptness to obtain and

submit to us the information and evidence that the claimant wants the

decision maker to consider in ruling on a claim. Based on the comments

we received on the proposed rules we published, we revised the wording

of

[[Page 41406]]

these sections to more closely track other existing regulatory

requirements. In disability and blindness claims, the new provisions

include the obligation to assist the claimant in complying with

Secs. 404.1512(a) and 416.912(a) which require claimants to bring

information and evidence to our attention and to furnish medical and

other evidence to us.

New Secs. 404.1740(b)(2) and 416.1540(b)(2) require that the

representative assist the claimant in complying, as soon as

practicable, with our requests for information or evidence. In

disability and blindness claims, this includes the obligation to assist

the claimant in providing, upon our request, evidence pursuant to

Secs. 404.1512(c) and 416.912(c).

Based on the public comments we received, we deleted proposed

Secs. 404.1740(b)(2)(i) and 416.1540(b)(2)(i), which would have

required that the representative provide, upon request, information

regarding the claimant's medical treatment, vocational factors or other

specifically identified matters, or provide notification that the

claimant does not consent to release the information. We also deleted

proposed Secs. 404.1740(b)(2)(ii) and 416.1540(b)(2)(ii), which would

have required that the representative provide, upon request, all

evidence and documentation pertaining to specifically identified issues

which the representative or claimant already has or may readily obtain.

We deleted these proposed requirements to more closely track the

existing regulatory requirements that explain a claimant's duties and

responsibilities with regard to submitting evidence and providing

information.

In new Secs. 404.1740(b)(3) and 416.1540(b)(3), we set forth

minimum requirements governing the competency, diligence and behavior

of representatives in their dealings with us. Based on the comments we

received, we revised these sections to more closely track the language

of model codes concerning competency and diligence of representatives.

In new Secs. 404.1740(b)(3)(i) and 416.1540(b)(3)(i), we establish

an affirmative duty of competency. This includes the requirement that a

representative know the significant issue(s) in a claim and have a

working knowledge of the applicable provisions of the Act, the

regulations and the Rulings. A representative should also know how to

obtain and submit evidence regarding the claim.

In new Secs. 404.1740(b)(3)(ii) and 416.1540(b)(3)(ii), we require

that the representative act with reasonable diligence and promptness.

This includes providing prompt and responsive answers to our requests

and communications pertaining to the pending claim. A representative

may not ignore official communications.

We deleted proposed Secs. 404.1740(b)(3)(iii) and

416.1540(b)(3)(iii), which would affirmatively have required

cooperation in developing the record. We believe that cooperation is

inherent in competency and diligence, and that representatives should

cooperate with us in such matters as releasing medical records,

scheduling consultative examinations and scheduling conferences or

hearing dates. Therefore, a separate rule would be redundant.

In revised Secs. 404.1740(c) and 416.1540(c), we describe

prohibited actions, which are certain acts or activities that a

representative must avoid. In part, the prohibited actions incorporate

various statutory provisions set forth in the Act and other

legislation.

We based new Secs. 404.1740(c)(1) and 416.1540(c)(1) on the

prohibitions (e.g., threatening or coercing a claimant) set forth in

Secs. 206(a)(5) and 1631(d)(2) of the Act, and these sections are self-

explanatory. A representative's honest mistake would not be construed

as knowingly misleading a claimant. In determining whether a

representative knowingly misled a claimant, we will consider whether

the action involved matters that the representative should have known

were untrue.

We based new Secs. 404.1740(c)(2) and 416.1540(c)(2) on the

provisions of sections 206(a) and (b) and 1631(d)(2) of the Act which

provide briefly that representatives are eligible for reasonable fees

for representing a claimant, and these sections apply to all fee

collections. With regard to section 206(a)(4) of the Act, we will

assume, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, that work performed

by support staff in a law office is performed under the supervision of

an attorney, thereby permitting the attorney to validly claim direct

payment from past-due benefits for those services in a title II claim.

This assumption will not apply, however, when a person other than an

attorney appears alone at a hearing to provide representation on behalf

of a claimant. In those cases, the person appearing alone at the

hearing shall be considered the representative and will be required to

file a fee petition or fee agreement for his or her services, and will

not be entitled to receive direct payment from past-due title II

benefits for the representation at the hearing.

Generally, we based new Secs. 404.1740(c)(3) and 416.1540(c)(3) on

the criminal prohibitions in 18 U.S.C. 1001 and the provisions

governing civil monetary penalties and assessments set forth in section

1129 of the Act. These sections are self-explanatory.

New Secs. 404.1740(c)(4) and 416.1540(c)(4) are directed against

practices where improper acts or omissions by the representative,

without good cause, have the effect of unreasonably delaying the

disposition of a claim for benefits.

We based new Secs. 404.1740(c)(5) and 416.1540(c)(5) on the

provisions of section 1106 of the Act, which prohibit disclosure by any

person of information obtained by the Agency in conjunction with a

claim, except as may be authorized by regulations prescribed by us. The

intent is to prohibit disclosure of information regarding a claimant

without the claimant's consent.

In new Secs. 404.1740(c)(6) and 416.1540(c)(6), we prohibit a

representative from offering or giving anything of value to persons

involved in the adjudication of a claim except as remuneration to a

witness for legitimate expenses or for services rendered. The intent is

to prevent the appearance of influencing, or attempting to influence,

the disposition of a claim by bestowing gifts or favors on individuals

in a position to materially affect the outcome of the adjudication of a

claim.

New Secs. 404.1740(c)(7) and 416.1540(c)(7) apply to conduct

undertaken during the course of oral proceedings which is disruptive

and detrimental to due process and the administration of justice.

In new Secs. 404.1740(c)(7)(i) and 416.1540(c)(7)(i), we prohibit

repeated absences from or persistent tardiness at scheduled proceedings

without good cause because such conduct adversely affects claimants,

diminishes the ability of the Agency to operate efficiently and harms

other applicants by disrupting schedules and work flow.

In new Secs. 404.1740(c)(7)(ii) and 416.1540(c)(7)(ii), we address

deliberate acts which have the effect of disrupting the proceedings or

diverting the attention of the participants from the purpose of the

hearing to matters irrelevant to the merits of the case.

New Secs. 404.1740(c)(7)(iii) and 416.1540(c)(7)(iii) are based in

part on the provisions of sections 206(a)(5) and 1631(d)(2) of the Act,

18 U.S.C. 111 and 28 CFR 64.2(x) and (aa). These provisions prohibit

threatening or intimidating conduct directed at the participants in an

oral proceeding or the employees assigned to our offices, which has the

effect of disrupting the proceeding. We will not tolerate actual or

implied threats of violence.

[[Page 41407]]

In revised Secs. 404.1745 and 416.1545, we explain that we may

begin proceedings to suspend or disqualify a person who does not meet

our qualifications for a representative or who violates our rules and

standards governing representatives in their dealings with us.

We modified Secs. 404.1750(a) and (d), 404.1765(a) and (e),

404.1799(c) and (e), 416.1550(a) and (d), 416.1565(a) and (e), and

416.1599(c) and (e), to reflect current Agency official titles and

organizational changes.

We revised Secs. 404.1765(g)(3) and 416.1565(g)(3) to remove the

first word ``not'' from each paragraph. This corrects errors made when

the regulations on representation of parties were reorganized,

renumbered and republished on August 5, 1980 (45 FR 52078). When the

original regulation was published as Sec. 404.983(f) on April 26, 1969

(34 FR 6973, 6974), it provided that ``[i]f the individual has filed an

answer and if the hearing officer believes that there is relevant and

material evidence available which has not been presented at the

hearing, the hearing officer may at any time prior to the mailing of

notice of the decision, or submittal of a recommended decision, reopen

the hearing for the receipt of such evidence.'' This is consistent with

the preceding language in Sec. 404.983(f), which states that if a

representative ``has filed no answer he shall have no right to present

evidence * * * .''

In the 1980 final rule, the former Sec. 404.983(f) was renumbered

as Sec. 404.1765(f), with a parallel title XVI provision at

Sec. 416.1565(f). Paragraph (f)(2) addressed representatives who do not

answer charges and paragraph (f)(3) addressed those who do. Paragraph

(f)(3) (45 FR 52078, 52093, 52108) contained a misprint, however, which

read, ``If the representative did not file an answer to the charges * *

* .'' Thus, paragraphs (f)(2) and (f)(3) were inconsistent and

conflicting. Subsequently, in 1991, paragraph (f) of Secs. 404.1765 and

416.1565 was redesignated as paragraph (g) (56 FR 24129, 24131, 24132).

The 1980 misprint substantively changed the meaning of current

paragraph (g)(3). As specifically explained in the preamble to the 1980

rules, however, SSA never intended to make any substantive changes to

the regulations. The regulations were rewritten for the purpose of

reorganizing and restating them more clearly in simpler language. The

misprint has created confusion in the representative disciplinary

process. Consequently, we are taking this opportunity to correct the

error to reflect the original intent of the regulations.

We also are correcting another minor misprint in the prior

Sec. 404.1765(g)(3) by making ``decisions'' singular for correctness

and consistency with Sec. 416.1565(g)(3).

Finally, we are amending Sec. 404.1770, paragraphs (a)(3) and

(b)(3), to correct a publication error that occurred after paragraph

(a)(3) was revised in 1991. As correctly published in final rules on

May 29, 1991 (56 FR 24129, 24132), paragraph (a)(3) was revised to show

that the hearing officer shall mail a copy of the decision to the

parties at their last known addresses. When codified in the 1992 volume

of the Code of Federal Regulations, however, the revised language of

paragraph (a)(3) was erroneously placed in paragraph (b)(3),

superseding that existing language addressing the effect of a final

decision imposing a suspension upon a representative. This correction

accurately reflects the language and purpose of paragraphs (a)(3) and

(b)(3) and brings Sec. 404.1770 into conformity with its equivalent

Sec. 416.1570.

Public Comments

When we published the NPRM, we provided the public a 60-day comment

period. We received comments from over 70 individuals and

organizations. These included comments referred to us by members of

Congress, and comments from legal services organizations, the American

Bar Association (ABA), the National Organization of Social Security

Claimants' Representatives (NOSSCR), the Association of Administrative

Law Judges, Inc., and other associations of attorneys, and non-attorney

representatives. We also received comments from individual attorneys,

non-attorney representatives, Administrative Law Judges (ALJs) and

other SSA employees.

Many of the commenters raised concerns that they or previous

commenters raised informally with regard to our draft proposal in

February 1995. Many commenters were opposed to our promulgating any

additional regulations at all concerning representatives. However, we

also received comments from individuals who believed that there is a

need for clarifying regulations and who were supportive of our proposed

rules. Other commenters expressed the idea that we should not regulate

attorneys who practice before us, but should instead regulate non-

attorneys. On the other hand, many non-attorney representatives

supported the idea of uniform national standards for both attorney and

non-attorney representatives.

The greatest concern was with regard to our proposed requirements

concerning the submission of evidence and responding to our requests

for information. In response to these comments and as we have indicated

below, we revised these requirements extensively to conform to other

existing regulations. We have summarized and addressed these statements

in the comments and responses below with the other substantive comments

received.

The ABA expressed substantial reservations about our proposed

standards. The ABA continued to believe, as it did in 1995, that some

of the rules, especially those dealing with disclosure of medical

information and the duty of advocacy for one's client, were far too

broad and that enforcement would place the Agency in the troublesome

position of attempting to override a lawyer's sworn duty to obey the

Rules of Professional Conduct of the jurisdiction in which the lawyer

is licensed to practice. The ABA believed that the proposed rules

continued to include provisions that could give rise to serious ethical

conflicts. The ABA voiced particular objections to our proposal to

place duties on representatives to obtain and submit certain evidence

by certain dates.

NOSSCR raised concerns involving the primacy of State bar rules for

most attorneys, the duty to obtain specific evidence, the duty to

submit evidence by certain dates, and the vagueness of the conduct

deemed overzealous. NOSSCR also objected to what they interpreted as

our attempt to close the record through the use of deadlines. NOSSCR

believed that there was no sound basis for our proposed rules as

drafted and that, in effect, they should not be promulgated. This was a

position taken by other associations of attorneys and individual

attorneys as well.

As we have explained below, in response to the ABA's and NOSSCR's

comments and other comments we have received, we have revised the

particular provisions that generated the most concern to make them

track SSA's other existing regulations. We believe this removes the

areas of greatest concern. For the reasons discussed below, we have not

adopted the suggestion to refer complaints about attorneys to State bar

licensing authorities for appropriate disposition. We have made other

changes to address the objections with regard to wording of particular

provisions and vagueness.

Because some of the comments were quite detailed, we had to

condense, summarize or paraphrase them. We

[[Page 41408]]

have, however, tried to summarize the commenters' views accurately and

respond to all of the significant issues raised by the commenters that

are within the scope of the proposed rules. As we discuss below in

responding to the comments, we have made revisions and additions to the

proposed rules to clarify their intent.

Comment: Some commenters questioned our authority to promulgate

these regulations. One commenter stated that the Act does not

contemplate that SSA would impose standards such as these where such

standards are already set out in State laws that regulate the conduct

of attorneys and others who do business within those states. According

to this commenter, there is no justification for ignoring the regional

differences between states that are a necessary and direct result of

our constitutional system. This commenter also stated that these

regional differences are tolerated in other settings such as the

Federal courts.

Response: The Commissioner has broad rulemaking authority under

sections 205 and 1631 of the Act to promulgate necessary and

appropriate rules, regulations and procedures to carry out the

provisions of titles II and XVI and under sections 206 and 1631(d)(2)

of the Act to ``suspend or prohibit from further practice before him

any such person, agent, or attorney who refuses to comply with the

Commissioner's rules and regulations or who violates any provision of

this section for which a penalty is prescribed.'' It is the

Commissioner who is ultimately responsible for providing decisionmaking

that is timely and efficient and results in an accurate disposition of

a claim. As stated above, these regulations are necessary to address

actual and potential problems impacting the efficiency and integrity of

the administrative process resulting from the participation of

representatives in the claims process and to ensure that claimants'

eligibility for benefits is not prejudiced by ineffective assistance of

their representatives.

In Sperry v. State of Florida, 373 U.S. 379 (1963), Florida sought

to enjoin a non-attorney registered to practice before the United

States Patent Office from preparing and prosecuting patent applications

in Florida because he was not a member of the Florida bar. The Supreme

Court held that the Federal government has pre-emptive powers over

states' legislative and judicial authorities when acting under valid

Federal regulation.

Based on the Commissioner's broad rulemaking authority and the

Federal government's pre-emptive powers, we believe that we have the

authority to promulgate these regulations on a nationwide basis, and

they would supersede any inconsistent state or local rules.

Comment: Many commenters questioned the need for additional

regulations governing the conduct of representatives.

Response: The goal of these regulations is to provide the public,

especially claimants' representatives and claimants, with a uniform,

clearly articulated set of rules that representatives are expected to

follow in representing claimants before SSA. In so doing, we are

informing the public of how we will carry out our statutory obligations

in regard to claimant representation.

We carefully considered the need to provide enforceable standards

governing the practice, performance, and conduct of all persons who act

as claimants' representatives. Under the prior regulations, we were

unable to address some conduct by claimants' representatives that we

believed was inappropriate. For example, under the prior regulations,

we could not address a representative's misconduct during a hearing or

failure to adequately prepare and present the claimant's case.

Moreover, various sources, including claimants, have complained to SSA

and expressed concern about the quality and effectiveness of claimants'

representation. Based on these needs, and our statutory duty to protect

claimants from claimants' representatives who do not comply with Social

Security laws and regulations, we believe that the standards of conduct

for representatives are necessary and that such standards clearly are

in the public interest.

Comment: The majority of responding attorneys, as well as the ABA

and other organizations, complained that, since attorneys' conduct

already is governed by their individual State bar codes of conduct and

ethics rules, separate SSA standards of conduct are redundant and are

an unnecessary infringement on State bar jurisdiction over attorneys.

The ABA and several individuals suggested that SSA establish a system

by which complaints can be referred to State bar disciplinary

authorities when we suspect misconduct. The ABA supported SSA's concern

that all representatives be held to certain standards of practice and

conduct, but strongly advised that such standards comport with the ABA

Model Rules, and that they be applied only to those representatives who

would not otherwise be subject to the legal profession's rules of

conduct. One individual recognized that State bar rules are not

applicable to representatives who are not attorneys, but opined that

there are not enough non-attorney representatives to warrant standards

of conduct for non-attorneys.

Some attorney commenters suggested that non-attorney

representatives should be required to comply with State bar rules or

the ABA Model Code. A few attorneys suggested that non-attorneys be

barred from representing claimants before SSA. However, a few

commenters specifically agreed with us that both attorneys and non-

attorneys should have their conduct evaluated by the same criteria.

Response: Bar rules differ in language and format among the 50

States, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico and the U.S. territories

and island possessions. As the administrator of a national program,

however, SSA should not be expected or required to apply local rules,

or local interpretations of the rules, to problems that require

national uniformity. If we applied local rules or local interpretations

rather than a national standard, it is conceivable that attorneys in

one area could be subject to discipline by SSA for conduct that another

jurisdiction would not find actionable, or vice versa. We do not

believe it benefits the attorneys, the claimants or SSA to have this

type of inconsistency in carrying out the Commissioner's statutory

obligation to regulate the conduct of representatives in administering

a nationwide program.

Moreover, attorneys often represent claimants in jurisdictions

other than those in which they are licensed to practice law. In those

instances, it would be unclear which jurisdiction's rules would apply,

which could lead to inconsistent application of the rules among

attorneys practicing in the same geographical area.

Furthermore, non-attorney representatives are not subject to any

rules of conduct for representatives similar to bar rules. Contrary to

one comment, individual non-attorney representatives and representative

organizations represent a substantial number of claimants. Within the

last eight years, suspension/disqualification actions against non-

attorneys comprised approximately 36 percent of SSA's representative

disciplinary actions. Therefore, it is essential to provide rules that

will govern the conduct of non-attorneys who practice before us.

Moreover, it is only fair and equitable to hold all representatives who

practice before us to the same standards.

In addition, applying our rules to only non-attorney

representatives is incompatible with the Commissioner's

[[Page 41409]]

statutory obligation to regulate the conduct of all representatives in

order to ensure that claimants are being represented competently and

fairly. Finally, we note that contrary to the suggestion that non-

attorneys be prohibited from acting as representatives, the Act allows

such representation.

Comment: Some commenters stated that there should be testing or

certification of representatives. Another commenter stated that SSA

should publish standards concerning the character, background, and

qualifications of non-attorney representatives.

Response: We have considered the possibility of testing or other

formal certification procedures for non-attorney representatives, but

we have determined that the idea is not feasible at this time. SSA

currently has standards for non-attorney representatives in

Secs. 404.1705 and 416.1505.

Any individual who provides services as a representative for a fee

shall be expected to demonstrate, in the performance of those services,

sufficient knowledge of the claims process to be of assistance to the

claimant. Ignorance of substantive provisions of law or procedural

requirements shall not be considered a mitigating factor for acts or

omissions which impede or disrupt the efficient and orderly disposition

of a claim.

Comment: One commenter offered that since no other Federal agency

has a code of conduct for representatives, it is unnecessary for SSA to

have one.

Response: We disagree with the premise of the comment and the

conclusion. The Internal Revenue Service has rules for practice before

it. See 31 CFR, Part 10. We also note that on November 25, 1997, the

Merit Systems Protection Board published an interim rule concerning

misconduct by representatives (62 FR 62689) which was finalized

recently at 63 FR 35499 (June 30, 1998). Furthermore, on January 20,

1998, the Department of Justice, Immigration and Naturalization Service

and the Executive Office for Immigration Review, published an NPRM to

change the rules and procedures concerning professional conduct for

practitioners, which includes attorneys and representatives (63 FR

2901). Moreover, whether other agencies have codes of conduct should

not be determinative. SSA has a responsibility to protect and preserve

our administrative processes, and by law may take any reasonably

necessary action in support of that obligation.

Comment: A few individuals commented on the issue of payment of

fees to non-attorneys and suggested that the prohibition against direct

payment of fees to non-attorneys should be removed. One commenter

suggested that non-attorneys should be required to sign retainer

agreements prior to representing claimants and should also be required

to submit itemized fee statements to SSA.

Response: These issues go beyond the purpose of these rules. The

intent in drafting these regulations was not to change the existing

statutory and regulatory provisions regarding payment of fees. However,

as stated in the NPRM, SSA is currently considering separate

regulations to address the issues of authorization, direct payment and

administrative review of fees for representation.

Comment: Other commenters suggested that a representative engaging

in prohibited or obstructive conduct be penalized by reduction in the

amount of the fee authorized.

Response: This issue also is not the subject of these rules. We may

address this issue in the separate regulations referred to in the

previous response.

Comment: We received various comments regarding the number of

complaints of misconduct by claimants' representatives investigated by

the Office of Hearings and Appeals. Several commenters believed that

the small number of complaints did not indicate a need for our proposed

standards of conduct for representatives. Another commenter stated that

our statistics underestimate the problem of inadequate representation

of claimants.

Response: Although we realize that most representatives do a

conscientious job in assisting their clients, we believe that there are

sufficient instances of misconduct to justify these standards of

conduct based on the referrals and complaints we have received. We also

observe, however, that many of the complaints we receive involve

misconduct by claimants' representatives that could not be addressed

under the prior regulations but can be addressed under these standards

of conduct. In addition, we anticipate that our standards of conduct

will result in more referrals of representative misconduct to the

Office of Hearings and Appeals.

Comment: Some commenters believed that SSA's decision to seek

discipline of a claimant's representative will be based on the Agency's

workload and will not be applied uniformly.

Response: Our decision to seek discipline of a claimant's

representative will be based solely on a representative's misconduct,

not SSA's workload. We also believe that the rules provide a strong

basis for uniform application of such actions and recognize our

obligation to effectively implement them in an even-handed, consistent

manner. Moreover, we believe that the rules clearly focus on the

responsibilities of a claimant's representative, including avoiding

unjustifiable delays that harm the processing of the claim. The rules

apply to claimants' representatives in all stages of our process and

all aspects of their representation before us.

Comment: Several commenters pointed out the delays in our

administrative decisionmaking process. Generally, observing that SSA is

under no time constraints in processing cases, they expressed the

belief that the delays result from Agency actions rather than

representative misconduct.

Response: The time it takes to decide claims in the administrative

process is influenced by many factors. We believe that our new rules

will enhance our efforts to improve the efficiency and timeliness of

our adjudication process. At the same time, in fairness, we will not

hold representatives accountable for matters solely within the control

of the Agency.

Comment: A few individuals observed that the new regulations would

put an unnecessary administrative burden on SSA and would create a new

bureaucracy. Others suggested that the rules would also place an

unwarranted burden on representatives and would have a chilling effect

upon representation.

Response: Although, as noted previously, these regulations may

result in our receiving additional complaints of misconduct, the

complaints will be handled by the same staff and in the same manner as

complaints filed under the prior regulations. As we have stated below

in response to similar comments, we do not believe that these

regulations place an unwarranted burden on representatives or

discourage representation. Instead, we believe that these rules will

improve the efficiency of our administrative process.

Comment: Several commenters complained about claimants'

representatives' lack of access to claim files, lost records, lack of

response from SSA to inquiries, and delay in obtaining records from

SSA.

Response: We agree that these issues are relevant, but they are

not directly related to the subject matter of these rules. We will, of

course, consider such extenuating circumstances in deciding whether

there was inappropriate delay or failure to adequately prepare and

present the claimant's case. As noted below, we will not hold a

representative

[[Page 41410]]

accountable for matters beyond his or her control.

Comment: Several commenters expressed concern that SSA employees,

including ALJs, may abuse the process by improperly finding violations

of the standards of conduct or by making unreasonable demands on

representatives.

Response: We believe that the internal checks and balances within

our operating procedures provide adequate safeguards against abuse of

discretion and/or arbitrary action. Furthermore, we note that the

determination on whether to file a complaint against a representative

for violating these regulations will be made by the Deputy Commissioner

for Disability and Income Security Programs (or other official the

Commissioner may designate), or his or her designee (hereinafter Deputy

Commissioner or designee), rather than by any other employee, including

an ALJ. Even after a complaint is served, a representative is entitled

to file an answer and petition for withdrawal of the complaint.

Thereafter, the accused party has a right to a full evidentiary

hearing, and a right to request review of the resulting decision. In

view of these elaborate safeguards, administered at each step by

independent decision makers, it is unlikely that an honest mistake or a

reasonable misunderstanding on the part of a representative would

result in sanctions.

Comment: Other commenters intimated that we are proposing these

rules to punish representatives or decrease the rate of representation.

Response: SSA neither encourages nor discourages representation.

Our sole purpose in proposing these regulations is to carry out our

statutory obligation to ensure that representatives, when utilized,

meet certain standards in their dealings with claimants and with us.

Comment: Other commenters suggested a code of conduct for SSA

employees, including ALJs.

Response: The suggestion is outside the scope and purpose of these

rules. All SSA employees, including ALJs, must conform their conduct to

government-wide standards of conduct. Any member of the public who

believes that any SSA employee has violated these standards should

report these violations to us. Additionally, we also have existing

procedures to address allegations of bias or misconduct on the part of

ALJs.

Comment: Several individuals commented on the issue of SSA's

ability to contact the claimant directly. One representative stated

that the proposed standards of conduct fail to point out what rules

apply to SSA employees who contact and, according to this commenter,

allegedly intimidate claimants although these claimants may be

represented. One attorney stated that in other legal matters such as

criminal or civil actions, it is improper to contact the client

directly. Another commenter stated that it was not true that SSA may

not contact a represented claimant directly. This individual stated

that SSA may do so in cases of fraud or similar fault or to resolve

discrepancies, and must do so to provide and explain rights and

responsibilities in connection with the filing of a claim.

Additionally, this individual observed that representatives should be

aware that SSA can and will make such contacts.

Response: SSA's general policy is that SSA makes all contacts with

a represented claimant in connection with prosecution of a claim

through, or with the permission of, the appointed representative.

However, SSA may contact the claimant directly: if the representative

asks SSA to deal directly with the claimant; or if SSA's records

indicate that the claimant is represented, but there is insufficient or

conflicting information regarding who the claimant's representative is;

or if an appointed representative's authority may have expired, but

there is insufficient information in the file or on the system to make

this determination accurately; or if the issue involves a possible

violation by the representative or the claimant. Also, because an

appointed representative's authority ordinarily does not extend to

signing an application on behalf of a claimant, SSA frequently does

have direct contact with a claimant during the claims-filing process.

Contacts other than as explained above are not in accordance with our

procedures, and we would certainly want to be told about employee

improprieties, such as alleged intimidation.

Comment: Several ALJs in one hearing office and the Association of

ALJs requested an additional rule dealing with withdrawal of

representation by representatives shortly before or on the date of the

hearing. They indicated that in no court may a representative withdraw

from a case without leave of court and that the absence of such a

requirement for SSA hearings results in additional delay and a waste of

time and money. These commenters propose a rule requiring the

representative to show good cause for withdrawal, or by allowing

withdrawal no later than six days after notice of hearing is issued

without having to show good cause.

Response: SSA's decisionmaking process is nonadversarial and

informal, and claimants do not require representation. The decision to

have a representative is the claimant's, and SSA neither encourages nor

discourages representation. A claimant may revoke the appointment of a

representative at any time. Likewise, a representative may withdraw

from representing a claimant at any time. Any rule limiting the

withdrawal of a representative would contravene SSA's basic policy on

representation. If a claimant still desires representation after his or

her representative withdraws, we will allow the individual time to

secure a new representative before we adjudicate the claim.

Comment: One ALJ suggested that SSA by regulation, or Congress

through statute, provide SSA ALJs with some form of limited contempt or

sanction powers to control the conduct of representatives and claimants

in addition to the proposed rules. The ALJ mentioned that recently

enacted legislation gave immigration judges the authority to sanction

by civil money penalty any action or inaction in contempt of the

judge's proper exercise of authority. The ALJ also cited a proposal to

give Department of Health and Human Services Departmental Appeals Board

ALJs sanction powers in civil monetary penalty cases. Another commenter

suggested that Secs. 404.1740(b) and 416.1540(b) should place an

affirmative duty on representatives to comply with prehearing orders.

According to this commenter, the regulation should indicate that the

ALJ has authority to issue and expect compliance with such prehearing

orders.

Response: SSA ALJs do not have contempt powers or sanction

authority, and we do not have legislation similar to that cited by the

commenter. SSA ALJs, on their own initiative, will not have the

authority to enforce these rules. Instead, as noted above, the

determination on whether to file a complaint against a representative

will be made by the Deputy Commissioner or designee. Finally, we

believe that giving contempt or sanction authority to ALJs does not

seem necessary or appropriate to SSA's informal, nonadversarial

proceedings which deal primarily with disability and retirement issues.

Comment: A frequent comment concerning the February 1995 draft was

that the proposed standards used terms that were too vague and

ambiguous, such as ``timely,'' ``diligence,'' ``as soon as possible''

and ``matters at issue.'' To be responsive to these concerns and

further clarify our requirements in the

[[Page 41411]]

NPRM, we modified the language that was most often identified as

ambiguous. However, we received comments on the NPRM that some of the

language continued to be vague and ambiguous.

Response: We have made further revisions to address these concerns

and, in some instances, have added language similar to that in model

codes of conduct. Attorneys are familiar with model code language, and

these codes have a long interpretive history of similar provisions and

language which can be used as guidance for both attorneys and non-

attorneys.

Comment: Some commenters found the entire substance of the proposed

standards to be ambiguous, although one believed they were drawn too

narrowly and should be expanded. Several argued that the proposals did

not provide adequate notice to representatives of the exact types of

conduct we would find to be in violation of these regulations.

Response: We believe that the rules, as revised, define with

sufficient specificity the types of conduct subject to regulation.

Similar to other standards of conduct (e.g., the ABA Model Rules),

these regulations do not list every act or omission which might

constitute a violation. Such a listing would be inappropriate to a

regulation and would be virtually impossible to complete given the

limitless factual situations involved in representing claimants.

Rather, we intend to deal with each complaint on a case-by-case basis

to determine whether, under the attending circumstances, a

representative engaged in actionable misconduct. In making this

determination we will evaluate whether a reasonable person, in light of

all the circumstances, would consider the act or omission violative of

the rule in question. Once it is determined that a formal complaint is

warranted, the Deputy Commissioner or designee reviews the proposal

independently from the investigative component and makes a decision

whether to file a complaint. Moreover, the individual or individuals

identifying the misconduct, whether an ALJ or other employee, will not

be the sanctioning authority or initiate the formal complaint.

Comment: The majority of the commenters objected to the revised

wording of proposed Secs. 404.1740(b)(1) and 416.1540(b)(1) which

required the representative to ``[p]romptly obtain all information and

evidence which the claimant wants to submit in support of the claim and

forward the same for consideration as soon as practicable, but no later

than the due date designated by the Agency, except for good cause

shown.'' Many commenters believed that this rule was overly broad and

would put an undue burden on representatives. They also believe that

these requirements and the ones contained in Secs. 404.1740(b)(2) and

416.1540(b)(2) are procedural rules which are inappropriate for ethical

standards governing the conduct of representatives.

Several representatives noted that they do not submit evidence

until the case is at the ALJ level because, according to them, so few

claims are allowed at the initial and reconsideration levels. Other

commenters noted that rather than improving the efficiency of the

process, this rule would add procedural barriers to the process by

setting up vague, unspecified deadlines by which all evidence must be

submitted.

A few commenters stated that ``evidence which the claimant wants to

submit in support of the claim'' should be defined. One commenter noted

that this requirement is impractical because claimants often want their

representatives to obtain and submit evidence that is 15 or 20 years

old or do not remember relevant information. Another commenter observed

that evidence is often incrementally discovered over a period of time

so that it is not reasonable to require that all evidence be submitted

by a specific date. An additional commenter pointed out that because

SSA is not required to complete any step of the administrative

decisionmaking process by a set deadline, it would be impossible for

the representative to decide when to request and submit the evidence

that would give the best chance of obtaining an award of benefits.

A number of commenters objected to the requirement that evidence be

submitted ``as soon as practicable'' or by the ``due date'' set by the

Agency. They believe that these terms are vague and lack the

specificity required in a rule governing conduct. One individual asked

whether there was any way to state a specific event or method for

determining due dates and noted that the proposed rules did not provide

any direction to SSA personnel as to how to select due dates. Several

commenters, including NOSSCR, stated that mandating due dates for

submission of evidence is equivalent to closing the record in

contravention of current law. One commenter noted that if the due date

is prior to the date of the adjudicator's determination, good cause

would have to exist as a matter of law to allow submission of evidence

related to the time period between the due date and the decision date.

Otherwise the result would be to close the record prior to the date of

the determination. Several commenters also observed that the term

``good cause'' is undefined, and there is no mechanism for determining

when good cause would apply.

Response: The claimant has a right to receive benefits under the

Act only after establishing that he or she satisfies the underlying

statutory and regulatory requirements. The NPRM envisioned that under

the new disability process, claimants would be expected to take a more

active role in establishing entitlement or eligibility for Social

Security benefits. The representative, as the designated agent of the

claimant, would likewise be called upon to play an even greater role in

assisting the claimant in processing the claim.

However, because SSA has not yet fully evaluated changes in the

role that the claimant will have to play, we have revised the language

concerning the duty of representatives in this area to conform with the

current regulatory requirements placed on claimants in general, and on

disability claimants in particular in Secs. 404.1512 and 416.912.

We note that in promulgating these rules, we have not changed our

existing duties and responsibilities with regard to developing the

record and obtaining the evidence necessary to adjudicate disability

and blindness claims. See section 223(d)(5)(B) of the Act and

Secs. 404.1512 and 416.912 and 404.1614 and 416.1014. Moreover, we are

not shifting the duty to claimants or representatives to develop the

record. Instead, these rules are intended to ensure that a

representative will assist the claimant in complying with his or her

responsibilities to provide us information and evidence under our

regulations. Although this requirement has not been previously included

in the regulations, we believe that this assistance is an integral part

of representation and has always been our expectation.

Accordingly, we have revised Secs. 404.1740(b)(1) and

416.1540(b)(1) to clarify that the representative will be expected to

assist the claimant in submitting the evidence that the claimant wishes

to have considered by SSA. In deleting the requirement that the

evidence be submitted by a specific due date, we have acknowledged the

possible difficulties that claimants and representatives may face in

obtaining evidence. Furthermore, although we did not intend the rules

to have the effect of closing the record, some individuals have

mistakenly interpreted the due date requirement as an improper attempt

to achieve that goal. Therefore, deletion of the due date requirement

[[Page 41412]]

should remove any confusion regarding this issue.

Nevertheless, we expect the representative to assist the claimant

in submitting evidence on a timely basis. This means that the

representative should make a reasonable effort to promptly obtain and

organize the available, supporting evidence and submit it to SSA for

the earliest possible consideration. Every claimant is entitled to the

earliest possible decision on as complete a record as possible at every

stage of our process. SSA's commitment to claimant service relies on

the availability of necessary evidence at the earliest possible stage

in the process so that we can make an accurate and fair determination

without delay caused by the need to obtain additional evidence.

In assessing any allegation raised against a representative

regarding failure to assist the claimant under these rules, we will

consider the efforts taken to assist the claimant in submitting

evidence. The rules apply both to disability and nondisability claims,

with additional rules applying to disability claims. A representative

will be expected to make reasonable, not extraordinary, efforts to

obtain and submit evidence on a timely basis. We recognize that in

providing representational services to a claimant, the representative

may advise the claimant concerning the need to submit particular

evidence. Also, we recognize that some claimants may be unable to

effectively consult with their representatives regarding what evidence

should be submitted and that the representative may be required to act

on the claimant's behalf to ensure that the relevant evidence is

available to the adjudicator. In addition, we have added to these

regulations a reference to ``good cause'' when a representative is

unable to submit such evidence (as defined in Secs. 404.911(b) and

416.1411(b)), to provide examples of situations in which good cause may

exist. ``Good cause'' will be determined in the administrative

proceeding initiated by the Deputy Commissioner or designee to consider

whether there was misconduct by the representative.

Comment: The majority of commenters objected to the affirmative

duties specified in Secs. 404.1740(b)(2) and 416.1540(b)(2) on the

basis that SSA was attempting to improperly delegate to claimants and

representatives its own duty to develop the record, which could place

representatives at the mercy of arbitrary or unreasonable SSA requests

for information. Specifically, a number of commenters observed that

this rule conflicts with SSA's duty to develop the record pursuant to

sections 223(d)(5)(B) and 1614(a)(3)(H) of the Act and Secs. 404.1512

and 416.912. Other commenters cited possible conflicts with

Secs. 404.1519a and 416.919a, and one commenter cited a possible

conflict with Social Security Ruling 96-2p. A few commenters observed

that the duty to develop the record must remain with SSA because the

proceedings are nonadversarial, and the focus is on claimants who are

seeking benefits when they are vulnerable. Several commenters also

pointed out that the language did not allow for discretion in

situations involving uncooperative treating physicians and

uncooperative or uneducated claimants.

Several commenters took exception to the statement in the NPRM that

under the proposed redesigned disability process, claimants and

representatives would be expected to take a more active role in

developing the record. They believed that the proposed rules imposed

new requirements on representatives when the duties placed on claimants

themselves have not been changed. A few commenters also noted that

applying different standards to represented and unrepresented claimants

with regard to the rules for submission of evidence would violate equal

protection.

Noting some improvement from the February 1995 draft, the ABA and

other commenters nevertheless believed that the proposed rules were

vague and overly broad and interpreted them as giving Agency staff the

right to demand that the representative produce copies of almost any

client information and records, at any time after the claim was filed,

with no effort to limit the scope, the relevance or the frequency of

the requests. The ABA and a number of other commenters noted that

frequent demands for repeated updating of the medical information from

each treating physician would cause unnecessary expense to claimants

and inconvenience to the party from whom the information is sought. A

few commenters expressed confusion about the meaning of the term ``may

readily obtain'' and questioned whether representatives would also be

required to obtain consultative examinations that are now obtained by

SSA. Citing the time taken to decide claims in SSA's administrative

process, a number of commenters observed that they may be forced to

update evidence on a regular basis while waiting up to a year or more

for a determination on the claim.

As with regard to Secs. 404.1740(b)(1) and 404.1540(b)(1), a number

of commenters objected to the requirements that evidence be submitted

``as soon as practicable'' or by the ``due date'' set by the Agency on

the basis that these terms are vague and undefined. They also believe

that setting deadlines for submission of evidence requested by SSA

would result in improper closure of the record.

Response: As we did with regard to Secs. 404.1540(b)(1) and

416.912(b)(1) above, we have revised the language concerning the duty

of representatives in this area to conform with our current regulatory

requirements for both disability and nondisability claims in general,

and in particular the requirements in disability and blindness claims

placed on claimants in Secs. 404.1512 and 416.912. Therefore, we have

revised this rule to clarify that the representative is required to

assist the claimant in complying, as soon as practicable, with our

requests for information and evidence at any stage of the

administrative decisionmaking process pursuant to Secs. 404.1512(c) and

416.912(c). This includes the obligation to provide evidence regarding

the items listed therein. In our view, the provisions of

Secs. 404.1740(b)(2) and 416.1540(b)(2) require the representative to

comply with our requests made under statutory authority for full and

accurate disclosure of material facts to the same extent that the

claimant is required to do so.

As stated above, we have not changed our existing duties and

responsibilities with regard to developing the record and obtaining the

evidence necessary to adjudicate claims, nor are we shifting any duty

to claimants or representatives to develop the record. These rules are

intended to ensure that a representative will assist the claimant in

complying with his or her responsibilities under our regulations.

As we did in Secs. 404.1740(b)(1) and 416.1540(b)(1), we have

deleted the requirement that the information and evidence be submitted

by the ``due date'' designated by the Agency. However, as noted above,

we do expect the representative to assist the claimant in submitting

the evidence and information requested by SSA on a timely basis. This

means that the representative should make a reasonable effort to obtain

and organize the available evidence and submit it to SSA for the

earliest possible consideration. This will facilitate our goal to

ensure that we make a correct determination at the earliest stage of

the process.

In assessing any allegation raised against a representative

regarding failure to assist the claimant in complying with our request

for information, we will consider the reasonableness of the request,

the relevance of the information requested, and any factors that may

[[Page 41413]]

interfere with the procurement of requested information. For example,

if a representative has made several attempts to obtain the requested

information from the claimant or another source without receiving a

response, we will likely determine that such efforts are in compliance

with our rules.

Comment: Many commenters raised the issue of who must pay to obtain

medical records. A number of individuals cited the high costs of

obtaining medical records from physicians and hospitals and noted that

many claimants would be unable to pay such costs. Some attorneys

expressed concern that they may be required to advance funds for

records and that this may be in contravention of State bar rules.

Response: We are not changing our existing rules concerning payment

for evidence. We will continue to pay for the medical records that we

need to adjudicate claims pursuant to our existing regulations.

Comment: Many of the attorney commenters on the February 1995 draft

stated that compliance with proposed Secs. 404.1740(b)(2) and

416.1540(b)(2), which in the February 1995 draft asked representatives

to ``[p]romptly comply, at every stage of the administrative review

process, with our requests for information and evidence,'' might place

them in violation of their own State bar rules requiring zealous

advocacy and protection of confidential client information. As stated

in the NPRM, based on these preliminary comments, we modified proposed

Secs. 404.1740(b)(2) and 416.1540(b)(2) to permit representatives to

protect a client's confidentiality by notifying SSA that ``the claimant

does not consent to release of some or all of the [requested]

material.'' This language in the NPRM caused many commenters, including

the ABA, to state that the proposed revision would ``red flag'' this

evidence and permit ALJs and SSA to draw adverse inferences based on

the statement of the claimant's declination to release the material.

The commenters believed that this issue raised serious ethical concerns

and observed that notifying SSA of the claimant's refusal to submit

evidence could subject them to sanction by their State bar associations

for failing to protect the confidences and secrets of their clients.

Specifically, one commenter noted that this provision would put

attorneys at odds with the State Bar of Georgia's Standard #28 which

provides that ``[a] lawyer may not reveal the secrets and confidences

of a client.'' Similarly, another commenter cited a conflict with

California Business and Professional Code section 6068 subsection (e),

which requires an attorney ``to maintain inviolate the confidence, and

at every peril to himself or herself to preserve the secrets, of his or

her client.'' Additionally, the ABA cited a potential conflict with

Model Rule 1.6 which prohibits an attorney from revealing client

information without the client's consent.

Conversely, a number of commenters, notably ALJs, felt that the

proposed revision would create a privilege from disclosure for

claimants where none was intended and no privilege currently exists.

The ALJs found this to be extremely troublesome and noted that it would

result in decisions that are based on an incomplete evidentiary record.

Additionally, one commenter observed that it is unrealistic to

expect a representative to engage in a consultation with the claimant

in the short timeframe in which the claimant would be expected to

exercise an informed decision on whether to release or withhold

information. Other commenters noted that some medical and psychiatric

reports are stamped with clear warnings that they should not be

disclosed to the claimant. Therefore, it could be harmful if the

representative was required to discuss such a report with the claimant

to determine if the claimant would give consent for release.

Response: Because of the confusion and ethical concerns surrounding

this proposed language, we have removed it from the final regulations

and inserted language which reflects the currently existing regulatory

requirements concerning the claimant's and the representative's

obligations in terms of responding to our requests. As explained above,

in disability and blindness claims, this language is in conformity with

the existing requirements of Secs. 404.1512 and 416.912.

Comment: Some commenters expressed concerns about how proposed

Secs. 404.1740(b)(3)(i) and 416.1540(b)(3)(i), which deal with a

representative's duty to be cognizant of the matters at issue, as well

as evidentiary and procedural requirements, would be applied. They

specifically posed questions about whether lack of knowledge of one

procedural rule or disagreement with an ALJ over the application of a

particular standard or rule would be enough to cause a complaint to be

filed against a representative.

Response: We revised Secs. 404.1740(b)(3)(i) and 416.1540(b)(3)(i)

to clarify our expectations regarding the knowledge and preparation

required to represent claimants before us. We based this revision on

ABA Model Rule 1.1 which requires competent representation. We also

added language specifying that a representative should know the

significant issue(s) in a claim and have a working knowledge of the

applicable provisions of the Act, the regulations and the Rulings.

However, this does not mean that a representative has to know every

provision.

Furthermore, we will deal with each complaint on a case-by-case

basis to determine whether a representative engaged in actionable

conduct. We will determine whether a reasonable person, in light of all

the circumstances, would consider the act or omission violative of the

section of the regulation in question.

Comment: One commenter was confused about the meaning of

Secs. 404.1740(b)(3)(ii) and 416.1540(b)(3)(ii) and asked whether

``information pertinent to the processing of the claim'' would require

a representative to investigate issues such as whether the claimant was

engaging in part-time work.

Response: We revised this section to clarify the requirement that

the representative must promptly respond to our requests for

information concerning the claim. We based this revision on ABA Model

Rule 1.3 which requires reasonable diligence and promptness. In

applying this rule, we will not expect the representative to

investigate the claim or to obtain information that is not readily

available. Instead, the rule is intended to ensure that representatives

are responsive to our inquiries so that the processing of the claim

will not be delayed pending a response from the representative on the

claimant's behalf. There is no time limit on when responses must be

provided, but a representative should promptly respond. Furthermore,

``information pertinent to processing the claim'' means the information

and evidence that the claimant, with the assistance of the

representative, as required, should submit under the current statutory

and regulatory requirements.

Comment: One commenter believed that Secs. 404.1740(b)(3)(iii) and

416.1540(b)(3)(iii) may raise an ethical problem for an attorney who

may be put in the position between demonstrating good cause by showing

that the claimant is unavailable and possibly uncooperative or risking

a finding by SSA that the attorney is acting unethically.

Response: We deleted this section from the final regulations

because we believe that cooperation by the

[[Page 41414]]

representative is inherent in the competent and diligent representation

of a claimant. With regard to a showing of ``good cause,'' this would

occur in a proceeding separate from the claims process. Therefore, it

would not impair the representative's ethical duty to his or her

client.

Comment: The ABA commented that although Secs. 404.1740(c) and

416.1540(c) were an improvement over the earlier draft and began to

define the conduct that would be considered objectionable, the proposed

rules were still vaguely worded.

Response: As discussed below, where appropriate, we have revised

the provisions of these sections to clarify the conduct that we will

consider to be inappropriate.

Comment: An ALJ expressed concern about misstatements of fact or

occurrences by representatives in their arguments before the Appeals

Council. The ALJ suggested that we add a provision to Secs. 404.1740(c)

and 416.1540(c) prohibiting a representative from making any incorrect

statement about a proceeding or persons involved in a proceeding before

SSA. The ALJ further suggested that this provision should make it clear

that a ``material fact within our jurisdiction'' is to be read much

more broadly than facts affecting the outcome of the case and should

also include matters such as the conduct of the hearing, performance of

the ALJ and other SSA personnel and the testimony of impartial

witnesses.

Response: We decided not to adopt this suggestion. We believe that

the language of Secs. 404.1740(c)(3) and 416.1540(c)(3) adequately

addresses our intent to prevent false statements concerning a claim at

any stage in our process. Furthermore, if we added such a provision, we

believe that SSA could be subject to disputes concerning the actual

``correctness'' of statements made about SSA personnel, including ALJs.

In order to more closely track the statutory requirements, we revised

this section to add a prohibition against ``misleading'' statements.

Comment: One commenter objected to Secs. 404.1740(c)(1) and

416.1540(c)(1) on the basis that these sections conflict with

Secs. 404.1740(b)(2)(i) and 416.1540(b)(2)(i), which require the

representative to ask for the client's consent to release the evidence

needed for adjudication. The commenter believed that requesting the

claimant's consent would be the equivalent of coercing the claimant by

using the representative's relationship with the claimant to direct a

decision or action by the claimant.

Response: For the reasons discussed in our response above, we have

deleted Secs. 404.1740(b)(2)(i) and 416.1540(b)(2)(i) from the final

regulations. A representative would never have been required to coerce

a claimant in order to comply with any of the affirmative duties

specified in the rules, and our deletion of these sections should

clarify the matter. We also note that Secs. 404.1740(c)(1) and

416.1540(c)(1) are based on the prohibitions set forth in section

206(a)(5) of the Act and are self-explanatory.

Comment: We received comments which indicated the perception that

Secs. 404.1740(c)(2) and 416.1540(c)(2) would somehow change the

statutory, regulatory and administrative authorities and requirements

for submitting, evaluating and paying requests for approval of fees

under the fee petition or fee agreement procedures.

Response: That is not the import or intent of these sections. As we

stated in the NPRM, these sections are based on the provisions of

sections 206(a) and (b) and 1631(d)(2) of the Act and apply to all fee

collections.

Comment: With regard to Secs. 404.1740(c)(4) and 416.1540(c)(4),

the ABA and other commenters stated that while SSA should not tolerate

improper delays, representatives should not be subjected to sanction

while acting in good faith and for purposes other than delay. The ABA

noted that this rule fails to set forth a standard by which to measure

the reason for the delay. Other commenters noted that the use of the

word ``negligent'' is inappropriate and could subject a representative

to sanction for missing only one deadline or by missing a deadline by

only one day. One individual suggested that we add language prohibiting

conduct resulting in delay for a significant period of time. Another

commenter noted that this section creates a prohibited action which is

beyond the control of the representative because all time limits are

under the exclusive control of SSA. One commenter suggested that we

define good cause to include any basis upon which a representative

negligently or inadvertently failed to complete a required action.

Another commenter stated that the ALJ has the sole authority to

determine whether good cause would apply. An additional commenter

suggested that we include language from the preamble indicating how

these sections will be applied to the final regulations.

Response: We revised these sections to clarify that representatives

through their own actions or omissions should not unreasonably delay

the processing of a claim. In addition, we deleted ``willfully or

negligently'' and added a reference to Secs. 404.911(b) and 416.1411(b)

which set forth examples of ``good cause.'' Furthermore, we reiterate

that SSA does not intend to penalize representatives for reasonable or

justifiable delays or delays that may occur even when reasonable care

is taken in preparing the claim.

In determining whether a representative has violated this rule, we

will look at the gravity of the representative's conduct, the

consequences to the claimant, whether the behavior represents a pattern

or practice and other factual circumstances related to the matter. This

section is intended to prohibit intentional conduct or conduct that

evinces a failure to apply a reasonable standard of care in

representing the claimant, e.g., conduct that results in an

unreasonable delay, not a minor wait. We also note that representatives

will not be held accountable for delays in our administrative

decisionmaking process. Additionally, as stated above, the

determination of whether to file a complaint for violation of this or

any other regulation governing the conduct of representatives will be

made by the Deputy Commissioner or designee.

Comment: A few individuals and the ABA expressed concern about the

intent of Secs. 404.1740(c)(5) and 416.1540(c)(5). The commenters

questioned whether this rule would apply to information about the

claimant or other persons and whether it would allow the representative

to release the claimant's medical reports to the claimant's treating

source. Another commenter believed that this rule was an attempt to

interfere with the attorney-client relationship. The same individual

also opined that this rule runs contrary to the provisions of the

Privacy Act and the recent amendments to the Freedom of Information

Act.

Response: Similar language was included in the prior regulations at

Secs. 404.1740(d) and 416.1540(d). This rule is based on section 1106

of the Act, which prohibits disclosure by any person of information

obtained from the Agency in conjunction with a claim, except as may be

authorized by our regulations or as otherwise determined by Federal

Law. It is intended to prevent a representative from improperly

disclosing information received from SSA, without the claimant's

consent, in contravention of our regulations. We have deleted the

reference to information about another person to clarify that

disclosure is warranted only

[[Page 41415]]

with the consent of the claimant or as otherwise authorized by Statute

or our regulations.

Comment: One commenter was confused about the meaning of

Secs. 404.1740(c)(6) and 416.1540(c)(6) and questioned whether these

sections would prohibit actions such as a law firm's discussing

possible employment opportunities with SSA employees or social

interactions between ALJs and private attorneys outside of work hours.

Response: This rule is intended to prevent the fact or appearance

of attempting to influence the disposition of a claim by offering or

giving something of value to an individual in a position to materially

affect the outcome of the case. It is not intended to apply to conduct

unrelated to the adjudication of claims.

Comment: Several commenters, including the ABA and NOSSCR, objected

to Secs. 404.1740(c)(7) and 416.1540(c)(7) on the basis that these

sections are vague and would interfere with an advocate's ability to

zealously represent his or her client. The commenters believe that this

rule does not provide an objective standard indicating what is

permissible and what is not. The ABA also observed that the proposed

limitations raised First Amendment concerns regarding freedom of

speech.

A few commenters noted that it may be appropriate for an attorney

to ``threaten'' to appeal an ALJ's decision and to point out errors

made by the ALJ during the hearing. A few individuals also opined that

a representative who points out matters of ignorance or impropriety by

the ALJ may be subject to allegations of discourteous behavior by the

same ALJ. Another commenter observed that this rule is unnecessary

because in most cases, the parties act appropriately.

Response: In response to these concerns, we modified the language

in Secs. 404.1740(c)(7)(iii) and 416.1540(c)(7)(iii) to prohibit

threatening or intimidating language or conduct ``which results in a

disruption of the orderly presentation and reception of evidence.'' We

realize that zealous advocacy may require vigorous argument and that it

may be appropriate for an advocate to point out errors during the

proceeding or to take exception to the conduct of the proceeding. This

rule is not intended to interfere with or limit an advocate's ability

to argue the case on behalf of his or her client if done in a

professional manner. Instead, this provision is intended to address

blatantly offensive or disruptive conduct or language that prevents the

adjudicator from conducting the proceeding in a manner that results in

a full examination of the evidence and the testimony presented. We must

ensure that the proceeding is conducted in an appropriate manner and is

not disrupted by individuals who engage in conduct or language which

prevents the full consideration of the issues to be decided.

In determining whether a representative has violated this rule, we

will look at the totality of the circumstances, including the

egregiousness of the conduct, its impact on the claimant or the Agency,

possible provocation and whether the behavior reflects a pattern or

practice. By setting a threshold of disruption of the proceeding, we

have set a standard high enough to avoid infringing on zealous, strong

advocacy. Finally, to address concerns that ALJs or other individuals

may improperly find violations of this provision, we again note that

ALJs will not make the determination of whether to file a complaint

against a representative and that instead, the decision will be made by

the Deputy Commissioner or designee.

Comment: A few individuals asked questions such as whether a

representative can request instructional advice from SSA to avoid

violating these rules or question our determination to file a

complaint.

Response: In order to ensure that representatives understand these

rules and comply with them, we welcome requests for information and

guidance from individual representatives. Furthermore, as under our

current procedures, representatives will be given an opportunity to

respond to charges that they have violated these rules. In many cases,

we should be able to resolve the problem through informal means such as

written or oral counselling of the representative, making a formal

complaint unnecessary. In some cases, a representative may not be aware

that his or her conduct has resulted in a violation of these

regulations and once advised of the violation will conform with our

rules. As under the current regulations, if the Deputy Commissioner or

designee determines that a complaint should be filed against a

representative, the Deputy Commissioner or designee will send the

representative a notice containing a statement of the charges that

constitute the basis for the proceeding. The representative will have

30 days to file an answer stating why he or she should not be

disqualified from acting as a representative. The representative will

also have the opportunity for a hearing on the charges.

Accordingly, for the reasons set out above, the proposed rules are

being published as final rules with the revisions as noted.

Regulatory Procedures

Executive Order 12866

We have consulted with the Office of Management and Budget (OMB)

and determined that these rules do not meet the criteria for a

significant regulatory action under Executive Order 12866. Thus, they

were not subject to OMB review.

Regulatory Flexibility Act

We certify that these regulations will not have a significant

economic impact on a substantial number of small entities. The

provisions of the rules that involve entities were developed to allow

them to provide representational services without generating any

supplemental reporting requirements. These rules will not result in any

increased legal, accounting or consulting costs to small businesses or

small organizations, will not adversely affect competition in the

marketplace, or create barriers to entry on the part of small entities.

In fact, these rules may facilitate such entry into the representation

sphere. The regulations will provide uniform standards applicable to

all entities who engage in the business and tend to disqualify the

unscrupulous and the incompetent practitioners, thereby expanding

demand for others willing and able to perform the service. Therefore, a

regulatory flexibility analysis as provided in the Regulatory

Flexibility Act, as amended, is not required.

Paperwork Reduction Act

These regulations impose no reporting/recordkeeping requirements

necessitating clearance by OMB.

(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Program Nos. 96.001,

Social Security-Disability Insurance; 96.002, Social Security-

Retirement Insurance; 96.004, Social Security-Survivors Insurance;

96.006, Supplemental Security Income)

List of Subjects

20 CFR Part 404

Administrative practice and procedure, Blind, Disability benefits,

Old-Age, Survivors and Disability Insurance, Reporting and

recordkeeping requirements, Social Security.

20 CFR Part 416

Administrative practice and procedure, Aged, Blind, Disability

benefits, Public assistance programs, Supplemental Security Income

(SSI),

[[Page 41416]]

Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

Dated: July 24, 1998.

Kenneth S. Apfel,

Commissioner of Social Security.

For the reasons set forth in the preamble, part 404, subpart R, and

part 416, subpart O, chapter III of title 20 of the Code of Federal

Regulations are amended as set forth below.

PART 404--FEDERAL OLD-AGE, SURVIVORS AND DISABILITY INSURANCE

(1950-- )

Subpart R--[Amended]

1. The authority citation for subpart R of part 404 continues to

read as follows:

Authority: Secs. 205(a), 206, and 702(a)(5) of the Social

Security Act (42 U.S.C. 405(a), 406, and 902(a)(5)).

2. Section 404.1740 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 404.1740 Rules of conduct and standards of responsibility for

representatives.

(a) Purpose and scope. (1) All attorneys or other persons acting on

behalf of a party seeking a statutory right or benefit shall, in their

dealings with us, faithfully execute their duties as agents and

fiduciaries of a party. A representative shall provide competent

assistance to the claimant and recognize the authority of the Agency to

lawfully administer the process. The following provisions set forth

certain affirmative duties and prohibited actions which shall govern

the relationship between the representative and the Agency, including

matters involving our administrative procedures and fee collections.

(2) All representatives shall be forthright in their dealings with

us and with the claimant and shall comport themselves with due regard

for the nonadversarial nature of the proceedings by complying with our

rules and standards, which are intended to ensure orderly and fair

presentation of evidence and argument.

(b) Affirmative duties. A representative shall, in conformity with

the regulations setting forth our existing duties and responsibilities

and those of claimants (see Sec. 404.1512 in disability and blindness

claims):

(1) Act with reasonable promptness to obtain the information and

evidence that the claimant wants to submit in support of his or her

claim, and forward the same to us for consideration as soon as

practicable. In disability and blindness claims, this includes the

obligations to assist the claimant in bringing to our attention

everything that shows that the claimant is disabled or blind, and to

assist the claimant in furnishing medical evidence that the claimant

intends to personally provide and other evidence that we can use to

reach conclusions about the claimant's medical impairment(s) and, if

material to the determination of whether the claimant is blind or

disabled, its effect upon the claimant's ability to work on a sustained

basis, pursuant to Sec. 404.1512(a);

(2) Assist the claimant in complying, as soon as practicable, with

our requests for information or evidence at any stage of the

administrative decisionmaking process in his or her claim. In

disability and blindness claims, this includes the obligation pursuant

to Sec. 404.1512(c) to assist the claimant in providing, upon our

request, evidence about:

(i) The claimant's age;

(ii) The claimant's education and training;

(iii) The claimant's work experience;

(iv) The claimant's daily activities both before and after the date

the claimant alleges that he or she became disabled;

(v) The claimant's efforts to work; and

(vi) Any other factors showing how the claimant's impairment(s)

affects his or her ability to work. In Secs. 404.1560 through 404.1569,

we discuss in more detail the evidence we need when we consider

vocational factors; and

(3) Conduct his or her dealings in a manner that furthers the

efficient, fair and orderly conduct of the administrative

decisionmaking process, including duties to:

(i) Provide competent representation to a claimant. Competent

representation requires the knowledge, skill, thoroughness and

preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. This includes

knowing the significant issue(s) in a claim and having a working

knowledge of the applicable provisions of the Social Security Act, as

amended, the regulations and the Rulings; and

(ii) Act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a

claimant. This includes providing prompt and responsive answers to

requests from the Agency for information pertinent to processing of the

claim.

(c) Prohibited actions. A representative shall not:

(1) In any manner or by any means threaten, coerce, intimidate,

deceive or knowingly mislead a claimant, or prospective claimant or

beneficiary, regarding benefits or other rights under the Act;

(2) Knowingly charge, collect or retain, or make any arrangement to

charge, collect or retain, from any source, directly or indirectly, any

fee for representational services in violation of applicable law or

regulation;

(3) Knowingly make or present, or participate in the making or

presentation of, false or misleading oral or written statements,

assertions or representations about a material fact or law concerning a

matter within our jurisdiction;

(4) Through his or her own actions or omissions, unreasonably delay

or cause to be delayed, without good cause (see Sec. 404.911(b)), the

processing of a claim at any stage of the administrative decisionmaking

process;

(5) Divulge, without the claimant's consent, except as may be

authorized by regulations prescribed by us or as otherwise provided by

Federal law, any information we furnish or disclose about a claim or

prospective claim;

(6) Attempt to influence, directly or indirectly, the outcome of a

decision, determination or other administrative action by offering or

granting a loan, gift, entertainment or anything of value to a

presiding official, Agency employee or witness who is or may reasonably

be expected to be involved in the administrative decisionmaking

process, except as reimbursement for legitimately incurred expenses or

lawful compensation for the services of an expert witness retained on a

non-contingency basis to provide evidence; or

(7) Engage in actions or behavior prejudicial to the fair and

orderly conduct of administrative proceedings, including but not

limited to:

(i) Repeated absences from or persistent tardiness at scheduled

proceedings without good cause (see Sec. 404.911(b));

(ii) Willful behavior which has the effect of improperly disrupting

proceedings or obstructing the adjudicative process; and

(iii) Threatening or intimidating language, gestures or actions

directed at a presiding official, witness or Agency employee which

results in a disruption of the orderly presentation and reception of

evidence.

3. Section 404.1745 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 404.1745 Violations of our requirements, rules, or standards.

When we have evidence that a representative fails to meet our

qualification requirements or has violated the rules governing dealings

with us, we may begin proceedings to suspend or disqualify that

individual from acting in a representational capacity before us. We may

file charges

[[Page 41417]]

seeking such sanctions when we have evidence that a representative:

(a) Does not meet the qualifying requirements described in

Sec. 404.1705;

(b) Has violated the affirmative duties or engaged in the

prohibited actions set forth in Sec. 404.1740; or

(c) Has been convicted of a violation under section 206 of the Act.

4. Section 404.1750 is amended by revising paragraphs (a) and (d)

to read as follows:

Sec. 404.1750 Notice of charges against a representative.

(a) The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and Income Security

Programs (or other official the Commissioner may designate), or his or

her designee, will prepare a notice containing a statement of charges

that constitutes the basis for the proceeding against the

representative.

* * * * *

(d) The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and Income Security

Programs (or other official the Commissioner may designate), or his or

her designee, may extend the 30-day period for good cause.

* * * * *

5. Section 404.1765 is amended by revising paragraph (a), the

second sentence of paragraph (e), and paragraph (g)(3) to read as

follows:

Sec. 404.1765 Hearing on charges.

(a) Scheduling the hearing. If the Deputy Commissioner for

Disability and Income Security Programs (or other official the

Commissioner may designate), or his or her designee, does not take

action to withdraw the charges within 15 days after the date on which

the representative filed an answer, we will hold a hearing and make a

decision on the charges.

* * * * *

(e) Parties. * * * The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and

Income Security Programs (or other official the Commissioner may

designate), or his or her designee, shall also be a party to the

hearing.

* * * * *

(g) * * *

(3) If the representative did file an answer to the charges, and if

the hearing officer believes that there is material evidence available

that was not presented at the hearing, the hearing officer may at any

time before mailing notice of the hearing decision reopen the hearing

to accept the additional evidence.

* * * * *

6. Section 404.1770 is amended by revising the first sentence of

paragraph (a)(3) and paragraph (b)(3) to read as follows:

Sec. 404.1770 Decision by hearing officer.

(a) * * *

(3) The hearing officer shall mail a copy of the decision to the

parties at their last known addresses. * * *

(b) * * *

(3) If the final decision is that a person is suspended for a

specified period of time from being a representative in dealings with

us, he or she will not be permitted to represent anyone in dealings

with us during the period of suspension unless authorized to do so

under the provisions of Sec. 404.1799.

7. Section 404.1799 is amended by revising the first sentence of

paragraph (c) and the second sentence of paragraph (e) to read as

follows:

Sec. 404.1799 Reinstatement after suspension or disqualification--

period of suspension not expired.

* * * * *

(c) The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and Income Security

Programs (or other official the Commissioner may designate), or his or

her designee, upon notification of receipt of the request, shall have

30 days in which to present a written report of any experiences with

the suspended or disqualified person subsequent to that person's

suspension or disqualification. * * *

* * * * *

(e) * * * It shall also mail a copy to the Deputy Commissioner for

Disability and Income Security Programs (or other official the

Commissioner may designate), or his or her designee.

* * * * *

PART 416--SUPPLEMENTAL SECURITY INCOME FOR THE AGED, BLIND, AND

DISABLED

Subpart O--[Amended]

8. The authority citation for subpart O of part 416 continues to

read as follows:

Authority: Secs. 702(a)(5) and 1631(d) of the Social Security

Act (42 U.S.C. 902(a)(5) and 1383(d)).

9. Section 416.1540 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 416.1540 Rules of conduct and standards of responsibility for

representatives.

(a) Purpose and scope. (1) All attorneys or other persons acting on

behalf of a party seeking a statutory right or benefit shall, in their

dealings with us, faithfully execute their duties as agents and

fiduciaries of a party. A representative shall provide competent

assistance to the claimant and recognize the authority of the Agency to

lawfully administer the process. The following provisions set forth

certain affirmative duties and prohibited actions which shall govern

the relationship between the representative and the Agency, including

matters involving our administrative procedures and fee collections.

(2) All representatives shall be forthright in their dealings with

us and with the claimant and shall comport themselves with due regard

for the nonadversarial nature of the proceedings by complying with our

rules and standards, which are intended to ensure orderly and fair

presentation of evidence and argument.

(b) Affirmative duties. A representative shall, in conformity with

the regulations setting forth our existing duties and responsibilities

and those of claimants (see Sec. 416.912 in disability and blindness

claims):

(1) Act with reasonable promptness to obtain the information and

evidence that the claimant wants to submit in support of his or her

claim, and forward the same to us for consideration as soon as

practicable. In disability and blindness claims, this includes the

obligations to assist the claimant in bringing to our attention

everything that shows that the claimant is disabled or blind, and to

assist the claimant in furnishing medical evidence that the claimant

intends to personally provide and other evidence that we can use to

reach conclusions about the claimant's medical impairment(s) and, if

material to the determination of whether the claimant is blind or

disabled, its effect upon the claimant's ability to work on a sustained

basis, pursuant to Sec. 416.912(a);

(2) Assist the claimant in complying, as soon as practicable, with

our requests for information or evidence at any stage of the

administrative decisionmaking process in his or her claim. In

disability and blindness claims, this includes the obligation pursuant

to Sec. 416.912(c) to assist the claimant in providing, upon our

request, evidence about:

(i) The claimant's age;

(ii) The claimant's education and training;

(iii) The claimant's work experience;

(iv) The claimant's daily activities both before and after the date

the claimant alleges that he or she became disabled;

(v) The claimant's efforts to work; and

(vi) Any other factors showing how the claimant's impairment(s)

affects his or her ability to work, or, if the claimant is a child, his

or her functioning. In

[[Page 41418]]

Sec. Sec. 416.960 through 416.969, we discuss in more detail the

evidence we need when we consider vocational factors; and

(3) Conduct his or her dealings in a manner that furthers the

efficient, fair and orderly conduct of the administrative

decisionmaking process, including duties to:

(i) Provide competent representation to a claimant. Competent

representation requires the knowledge, skill, thoroughness and

preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. This includes

knowing the significant issue(s) in a claim and having a working

knowledge of the applicable provisions of the Social Security Act, as

amended, the regulations and the Rulings; and

(ii) Act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a

claimant. This includes providing prompt and responsive answers to

requests from the Agency for information pertinent to processing of the

claim.

(c) Prohibited actions. A representative shall not:

(1) In any manner or by any means threaten, coerce, intimidate,

deceive or knowingly mislead a claimant, or prospective claimant or

beneficiary, regarding benefits or other rights under the Act;

(2) Knowingly charge, collect or retain, or make any arrangement to

charge, collect or retain, from any source, directly or indirectly, any

fee for representational services in violation of applicable law or

regulation;

(3) Knowingly make or present, or participate in the making or

presentation of, false or misleading oral or written statements,

assertions or representations about a material fact or law concerning a

matter within our jurisdiction;

(4) Through his or her own actions or omissions, unreasonably delay

or cause to be delayed, without good cause (see Sec. 416.1411(b)), the

processing of a claim at any stage of the administrative decisionmaking

process;

(5) Divulge, without the claimant's consent, except as may be

authorized by regulations prescribed by us or as otherwise provided by

Federal law, any information we furnish or disclose about a claim or

prospective claim;

(6) Attempt to influence, directly or indirectly, the outcome of a

decision, determination or other administrative action by offering or

granting a loan, gift, entertainment or anything of value to a

presiding official, Agency employee or witness who is or may reasonably

be expected to be involved in the administrative decisionmaking

process, except as reimbursement for legitimately incurred expenses or

lawful compensation for the services of an expert witness retained on a

non-contingency basis to provide evidence; or

(7) Engage in actions or behavior prejudicial to the fair and

orderly conduct of administrative proceedings, including but not

limited to:

(i) Repeated absences from or persistent tardiness at scheduled

proceedings without good cause (see Sec. 416.1411(b));

(ii) Willful behavior which has the effect of improperly disrupting

proceedings or obstructing the adjudicative process; and

(iii) Threatening or intimidating language, gestures or actions

directed at a presiding official, witness or Agency employee which

results in a disruption of the orderly presentation and reception of

evidence.

10. Section 416.1545 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 416.1545 Violations of our requirements, rules, or standards.

When we have evidence that a representative fails to meet our

qualification requirements or has violated the rules governing dealings

with us, we may begin proceedings to suspend or disqualify that

individual from acting in a representational capacity before us. We may

file charges seeking such sanctions when we have evidence that a

representative:

(a) Does not meet the qualifying requirements described in

Sec. 416.1505;

(b) Has violated the affirmative duties or engaged in the

prohibited actions set forth in Sec. 416.1540; or

(c) Has been convicted of a violation under section 1631(d) of the

Act.

11. Section 416.1550 is amended by revising paragraphs (a) and (d)

to read as follows:

Sec. 416.1550 Notice of charges against a representative.

(a) The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and Income Security

Programs (or other official the Commissioner may designate), or his or

her designee, will prepare a notice containing a statement of charges

that constitutes the basis for the proceeding against the

representative.

* * * * *

(d) The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and Income Security

Programs (or other official the Commissioner may designate), or his or

her designee, may extend the 30-day period for good cause.

* * * * *

12. Section 416.1565 is amended by revising paragraph (a), the

second sentence of paragraph (e), and paragraph (g)(3) to read as

follows:

Sec. 416.1565 Hearing on charges.

(a) Scheduling the hearing. If the Deputy Commissioner for

Disability and Income Security Programs (or other official the

Commissioner may designate), or his or her designee, does not take

action to withdraw the charges within 15 days after the date on which

the representative filed an answer, we will hold a hearing and make a

decision on the charges.

* * * * *

(e) Parties. * * * The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and

Income Security Programs (or other official the Commissioner may

designate), or his or her designee, shall also be a party to the

hearing.

* * * * *

(g) * * *

(3) If the representative did file an answer to the charges, and if

the hearing officer believes that there is material evidence available

that was not presented at the hearing, the hearing officer may at any

time before mailing notice of the hearing decision reopen the hearing

to accept the additional evidence.

* * * * *

13. Section 416.1599 is amended by revising the first sentence of

paragraph (c) and the second sentence of paragraph (e) to read as

follows:

Sec. 416.1599 Reinstatement after suspension or disqualification--

period of suspension not expired.

* * * * *

(c) The Deputy Commissioner for Disability and Income Security

Programs (or other official the Commissioner may designate), or his or

her designee, upon notification of receipt of the request, shall have

30 days in which to present a written report of any experiences with

the suspended or disqualified person subsequent to that person's

suspension or disqualification. * * *

* * * * *

(e) * * * It shall also mail a copy to the Deputy Commissioner for

Disability and Income Security Programs (or other official the

Commissioner may designate), or his or her designee.

* * * * *

[FR Doc. 98-20760 Filed 8-3-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4190-29-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.