Application by National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc. for a Preemption Determination as to New York Department of Environmental Conservation Requirements on Gasoline Transport Vehicles

Federal RegisterJun 2, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

[Docket No. RSPA-98-3599 (PDA-19(R))]

Application by National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc. for a

Preemption Determination as to New York Department of Environmental

Conservation Requirements on Gasoline Transport Vehicles

AGENCY: Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA), DOT.

ACTION: Public Notice and Invitation to Comment.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Interested parties are invited to submit comments on an

application by the National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc. (NTTC) for an

administrative determination whether Federal hazardous material

transportation law preempts certain requirements of the New York

Department of Environmental Conservation applicable to gasoline

transport vehicles.

DATES: Comments received on or before July 17, 1998, and rebuttal

comments received on or before August 31, 1998, will be considered

before an administrative ruling is issued by RSPA's Associate

Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety. Rebuttal comments may

discuss only those issues raised by comments received during the

initial comment period and may not discuss new issues.

ADDRESSES: The application and all comments received may be reviewed in

the Dockets Office, U.S. Department of Transportation, Room PL-401, 400

Seventh Street, SW, Washington, DC 20590-0001. The application and all

comments are also available on-line through the home page of DOT's

Docket Management System, at ``http://dms.dot.gov.''

Comments may be submitted to the Dockets Office at the above

address. Three copies of each written comment should be submitted.

Comments may also be submitted by E-mail to

``[email protected].'' Each comment should refer to the Docket

Number set forth above. A copy of each comment must also be sent to (1)

Mr. Clifford J. Harvison, President, National Tank Truck Carriers,

Inc., 2200 Mill Road, Alexandria, VA 22314, and (2) Mr. John P. Cahill,

Commissioner, Department of Environmental Conservation, State of New

York, 50 Wolf Road, Albany, NY 12233. A certification that a copy has

been sent to these persons must also be included with the comment. (The

following format is suggested: ``I certify that copies of this comment

have been sent to Messrs. Harvison and Cahill at the addresses

specified in the Federal Register.'')

A list and subject matter index of hazardous materials preemption

cases, including all inconsistency rulings and preemption

determinations, are available through the home page of RSPA's Office of

the Chief Counsel, at ``http://rspa-atty.dot.gov.'' A paper copy of

this list and index will be provided at no cost upon request to Ms.

O'Berry, at the address and telephone number set forth in For Further

Information Contact below.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Donna L. O'Berry, Office of the Chief

Counsel, Research and Special Programs Administration, U.S. Department

of Transportation, Washington, DC 20590-0001 (Tel. No. 202-366-4400).

[[Page 30033]]

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Application for a Preemption Determination

NTTC has applied for a determination that Federal hazardous

material transportation law, 49 U.S.C. 5101 et seq., preempts New York

Codes, Rules and Regulations (NYCRR) Sections 230.4(a)(3) and 230.6(b)

and (c). These provisions were issued by the New York State Department

of Environmental Conservation and concern marking and recordkeeping and

reporting requirements applicable to vehicles used to transport

gasoline. Part 230 of NYCRR pertains to gasoline-dispensing sites and

transport vehicles. The text of NTTC's application and a list of the

attachments are set forth in Appendix A. A paper copy of the

attachments to NTTC's application will be provided at no cost upon

request to Ms. O'Berry, at the address and telephone number set forth

in For Further Information Contact above.

Marking. Section 230.4(a)(3) provides as follows:

(a) No owner or operator of a gasoline transport vehicle subject

to the Part will allow said vehicle to be filled or emptied unless

the gasoline transport vehicle:

(3) displays a marking, near the U.S. Department of

Transportation certificate plate, in letters and numerals at least

two inches high, which reads NYS DEC and the date on which the

gasoline transport vehicle was last tested.

NTTC asserts this section is preempted because the requirement is

not substantively the same as requirements in 49 CFR 180.415 for

marking cargo tank motor vehicles used to transport hazardous

materials.

Recordkeeping and Reporting. NTTC challenges subsections (b) and

(c) of Section 230.6. That section provides as follows:

(a) The owner of any gasoline transport vehicle subject to this

Part must maintain records of pressure-vacuum testing and repairs.

The records must include the identity of the gasoline transport

vehicle, the results of the testing, the date that the testing and

repairs, as needed were done, the nature of needed repairs and the

date of retest where appropriate.

(b) A copy of the most recent pressure-vacuum test results, in a

form acceptable to the commissioner, must be kept with the gasoline

transport vehicle.

(c) Records acceptable to the commissioner must be retained for

two years after the testing occurred, and must be made available to

the commissioner or his representative on request at any reasonable

time.

NTTC claims that subsections (b) and (c) are preempted under the

``obstacle'' test. NTTC compares the requirements to maintain test

results with the vehicle with 49 CFR 180.417(a)(2). That Federal

regulation requires a motor carrier who is not the owner of the cargo

tank motor vehicle to retain a copy of the vehicle certification report

at its principal place of business or, upon approval from the Federal

Highway Administration, at a regional or terminal office. NTTC also

compares the requirement to retain test records for two years after

testing occurs with Section 180.417(c)(2), which requires retention for

the time the cargo tank is in the carrier's service, plus one year.

NTTC asserts that New York's regulation requiring documents to be

retained in vehicles creates an unnecessary delay by forcing a carrier

to maintain and reproduce documents and ensure that copies are placed

in vehicles that are moved from State to State. NTTC further contends

that this regulation could create a multiplicity of non-uniform

restrictions that could potentially compromise safety if it is

replicated by other jurisdictions.

II. Federal Preemption

Section 5125 of Title 49 U.S.C. contains several preemption

provisions that are relevant to NTTC's application. Subsection (a)

provides that--in the absence of a waiver of preemption by DOT under

section 5125(e) or specific authority in another Federal law--a

requirement of a State, political subdivision of a State, or Indian

tribe is preempted if

(1) Complying with a requirement of the State, political

subdivision or tribe and a requirement of this chapter or a

regulation issued under this chapter is not possible; or

(2) The requirement of the State, political subdivision, or

Indian tribe, as applied or enforced, is an obstacle to the

accomplishing and carrying out this chapter or a regulation

prescribed under this chapter.

These two paragraphs set forth the ``dual compliance'' and ``obstacle''

criteria which RSPA had applied in issuing inconsistency rulings before

1990, under the original preemption provisions in the Hazardous

Materials Transportation Act (HMTA). Pub. L. 93-633 section 112(a), 88

Stat. 2161 (1975). The dual compliance and obstacle criteria are based

on U.S. Supreme Court decisions on preemption. Hines v. Davidowitz, 312

U.S. 52 (1941); Florida Lime & Avocado Growers, Inc. v. Paul, 373 U.S.

132 (1963); Ray v. Atlantic Richfield, Inc., 435 U.S. 151 (1978).

Subsection (b)(1) of 49 U.S.C. 5125 provides that a non-Federal

requirement concerning any of the following subjects, that is not

``substantively the same as'' a provision of Federal hazardous

materials transportation law or a regulation prescribed under that law,

is preempted unless it is authorized by another Federal law or DOT

grants a waiver of preemption:

(A) The designation, description, and classification of

hazardous material.

(B) The packing, repacking, handling, labeling, marking, and

placarding of hazardous material.

(C) The preparation, execution, and use of shipping documents

related to hazardous material and requirements related to the

number, contents, and placement of those documents.

(D) The written notification, recording, and reporting of the

unintentional release in transportation of hazardous material.

(E) The design, manufacturing, fabricating, marking,

maintenance, reconditioning, repairing, or testing of a packaging or

a container represented, marked, certified, or sold as qualified for

use in transporting hazardous material.

These preemption provisions in 49 U.S.C. carry out Congress's view

that a single body of uniform Federal regulations promotes safety in

the transportation of hazardous materials. In considering the HMTA, the

Senate Commerce Committee ``endorse(d) the principle of preemption in

order to preclude a multiplicity of State and local regulations and the

potential for varying as well as conflicting regulations in the area of

hazardous materials transportation.'' S. Rep. No. 1102, 93rd Cong. 2nd

Sess. 37 (1974). When it amended the HMTA in 1990, Congress

specifically found that:

(3) Many States and localities have enacted laws and regulations

which vary from Federal laws and regulations pertaining to the

transportation of hazardous materials, thereby creating the

potential for unreasonable hazards in other jurisdictions and

confounding shippers and carriers which attempt to comply with

multiple and conflicting registration, permitting, routing,

notification, and other regulatory requirements,

(4) Because of the potential risks to life, property, and the

environment posed by unintentional releases of hazardous materials,

consistency in laws and regulations governing the transportation of

hazardous materials is necessary and desirable,

(5) In order to achieve greater uniformity and to promote the

public health, welfare, and safety at all levels, Federal standards

for regulating the transportation of hazardous materials in

intrastate, interstate, and foreign commerce are necessary and

desirable.

Pub. L.101-615 section 2, 104 Stat. 3244. A Federal Court of Appeals

has found that uniformity was the ``linchpin'' in the design of the

HMTA, including the 1990 amendments which expanded the preemption

provisions. Colorado Pub. Util. Comm'n v. Harmon, 951 F.2d 1571, 1575

(10th Cir. 1991). (In 1994, the HMTA was revised, codified

[[Page 30034]]

and enacted ``without substantive change,'' at 49 U.S.C. Chapter 51.

Pub. L. 103-272, 108 Stat. 745.)

Under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d)(1), any directly affected person may apply

to the Secretary of Transportation for a determination whether a State,

political subdivision or Indian tribe requirement is preempted. The

Secretary of Transportation has delegated authority to make

determinations of preemption that concern highway routing to FHWA and

those concerning all other hazardous materials transportation issues to

RSPA. 49 CFR 1.48(u)(2), 1.53(b).

Section 5125(d)(1) requires that notice of an application for a

preemption determination must be published in the Federal Register.

Following the receipt and consideration of written comments, RSPA will

publish its determination in the Federal Register. See 49 CFR

107.209(d). A short period of time is allowed for filing of petitions

for reconsideration. 49 CFR 107.211. Any party to the proceeding may

seek judicial review in a Federal district court. 49 U.S.C. 5125(f).

Preemption determinations do not address issues of preemption

arising under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution or under statutes

other than the Federal hazardous materials transportation law unless it

is necessary to do so in order to determine whether a requirement is

authorized by another Federal law. A State, local or Indian tribe

requirement is not authorized by another Federal law merely because it

is not preempted by another Federal statue. Colorado Pub. Util. Comm'n

v. Harmon, above, 951 F2d at 1581 n.10. In making preemption

determinations under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d), RSPA is guided by the

principles and policy set forth in Executive Order No. 12612, entitled

``Federalism'' (52 FR 41685, Oct. 30, 1987). Section 4(a) of that

Executive Order authorizes preemption of State laws only when a statute

contains an express preemption provision, there is other firm and

palpable evidence of Congressional intent to preempt, or the exercise

of State authority directly conflicts with the exercise of Federal

authority. Section 5125 contains express preemption provisions, which

RSPA has implemented through its regulations.

III. Public Comment

Comments should be limited to whether Federal hazardous material

transportation law preempts the provision of New York state's marking

requirements in Section 230.4(a)(3) and recordkeeping and retention

requirements in Section 230.6, respectively. Comments should:

(1) Set forth in detail the manner in which these marking and

recordkeeping and retention requirements are applied and enforced; and

(2) Specifically address the preemption criteria described in Part

II above (``obstacle'' and ``covered subjects'').

Persons intending to comment should review the standards and

procedures governing RSPA's consideration of applications for

preemption determinations, set forth at 49 CFR 107.201-107.211.

Issued in Washington, DC, on May 22, 1998.

Alan I. Roberts,

Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety, Research and

Special Programs Administration.

Appendix A

Before the Research & Special Programs Administration, United States

Department of Transportation

In the matter of: An Application For A Preemption Determination In

the Matter of Certain Regulations Codified and Enforced By the State

of New York

Petition filed by: National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc., 2200 Mill

Road, Alexandria, VA 22314, (703) 838-1960; Fax (703) 684-5753,

Clifford J. Harvison, President

February 1, 1998.

Before the Administrator: National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc.

(NTTC) is a trade association representing over 200 corporate

members specializing in the highway transportation of hazardous

materials, hazardous substances and hazardous wastes, in cargo tank

motor vehicles, throughout the continental United States. Several

NTTC members conduct high volume operations within the State of New

York. Certain regulations (codified and enforced by that state) are

the subject of this petition.

The Regulations In Question--New York State's Department of

Environmental Conservation (DEC) is charged with enforcement of 6

NYCRR, Part 230 entitled ``Gasoline Dispensing Sites and Transport

Vehicles (a copy of relevant portions is attached). Therein, Section

230.6 (Gasoline transport vehicles--recordkeeping and reporting)

proscribes the following:

``(a) The owner of any gasoline transport vehicle subject to

this Part must maintain records of pressure-vacuum testing and

repairs. The records must include the identity of the gasoline

transport vehicle, the results of the testing, the date that the

testing and repairs, as needed, were done, the nature of needed

repairs and the date of retests where appropriate.

``(b) A copy of the most recent pressure-vacuum test results, in

a form acceptable to the commissioner, must be kept with the

gasoline transport vehicle.

``(c) Records acceptable to the commissioner must be retained

for two years after the testing occurred, and must be made available

to the commissioner or his representative on request at any

reasonable time.''

Furthermore, that same body of state regulations contains the

following provision at 230.4 (a) and (a) (3):

``(a) No owner or operator of a gasoline transport vehicle

subject to this Part will allow said vehicle to be filled or emptied

unless the gasoline transport vehicle:

``(3) displays a marking, near the U.S. Department of

Transportation certificate plate, in letters and numerals at least

two inches high, which reads: NYS DEC and the date on which the

gasoline transport vehicle was last tested.''

NTTC has been informed (by various members) that they have

received citations, issued by (DEC) enforcement personnel for

violations of these regulations; thus, it is evident that they are

being actively enforced.

NTTC's Position--NTTC holds that Section 230.4 (a)(3) is

preempted because it is not ``substantively the same'' as current

Federal requirements dealing with the ``marking'' of a container or

package which is represented, marked, certified or sold as qualified

for use in the transportation of a hazardous material. This latter

state requirement is (in the vernacular of the Administrator) a

``covered subject''.

Additionally, this Association holds that Section 230.6 is

preempted by applicable provisions of the Hazardous Materials

Transportation Uniform Safety Act (HMTUSA) (as amended) in that the

provisions violate the so-called ``obstacle test'' (a traditional

criterion used by the Administrator in evaluating non-Federal laws

and regulations in applications for preemption determination).

Moreover, as enforced, the state regulation creates unnecessary

delay, and--if replicated by other jurisdictions--would serve to

create a multiplicity of non-uniform restrictions that would

(potentially) compromise safety.

In the alternative, the State of New York may petition the

Administrator to amend Federal regulations (should the state feel

that the amendments would enhance safety); or, the State may

acknowledge Federal preemption and apply for a ``Waiver of

Preemption'' under procedures established by the Administrator.

The Relevant Element of the Hazardous Materials Regulations

(HMR)--Pursuant to HMTUSA's mandate, the Secretary of Transportation

has delegated to the Administrator of the Department's Research and

Special Programs Administration (RSPA) the authority to issue

regulations specific to the transportation of hazardous materials.

The Administrator has fulfilled that mandate by promulgation of the

HMR, Parts 171-180.

Specifically, Part 180 of the HMR (``Continuing Qualification

And Maintenance of Packagings'') sets forth a comprehensive series

of regulations dealing with the inspection, testing, maintenance and

repair of cargo tank motor vehicles which are represented (by the

owner/operator) as being constructed and operated in compliance with

the HMR.

Argument--In terms of the requested preemption of Section 230.6

of New York's

[[Page 30035]]

Code, we wish to note at the outset that we have no quarrel with the

provisions of subsection ``(a)'' of that Section.

In contrast, however, NTTC notes that 49 CFR 180.417 contains

direct requirements for ``Reporting and Record Retention

Requirements''. Significantly, there is no Federal requirement for

copies of reports and/or records to be carried in the cargo tank

motor vehicle. Instead, the Administrator relies on certain (and

specified) markings on the cargo tank as indicia of compliance.

Moreover, 49 CFR 180.417(a)(2) allows carriers to retain relevant

documents at either their ``principal place of business'', or (upon

application to the Federal Highway Administration) ``at a regional

or terminal office''.

Conversely, the state's regulations require documentation to be

retained ``in the vehicle.'' NTTC holds that Section 230.6(b) is

preempted by the HMR. As the Administrator well knows, cargo tanks

regularly move from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. For instance,

nationwide carriers may move vehicles from southern states into the

New England area to move gasoline when transportation demands for MC

306/DOT406 equipment accelerate because of the winter ``fuel oil

season''. Unnecessary delay is created when carriers are compelled

to retrieve documents from storage, reproduce those documents, and

exercise the management controls necessary to put copies in some

vehicles but not in others. The situation is compounded when one

realizes the potential for other jurisdictions to play havoc with

the current system. For instance, should the Administrator not

preempt, what would prevent a state or locality from requiring all

service and maintenance records (including the vehicle

manufacturer's original certification) to be retained in the

vehicle?

In Docket HM-183 (the administrative proceeding which created

Part 180), the Administrator decided that the proper indicia for

compliance with Part 180 is vehicle marking (as codified at

180.415). As has often been noted in both (the former)

``inconsistency petitions'' and in ``preemption determinations'',

the Administrator's regulations are ``presumed safe''. New York

State is not free to unilaterally amend RSPA's requirements.

With regard to the state's requirement at 230.6(c), the same

arguments and fact patterns apply. At 49 CFR 180.417(c)(2), the

specified retention time is length of (cargo tank) ownership plus

one year. New York requires ``. . . two years after the testing

occurred.'' It, too, must be preempted.

Our problem with New York's requirement at 230.4(a)(3) is more

direct and concise. Simply stated, this regulation is a ``hazardous

materials specific'' marking requirement. It applies only to DOT

Specification tanks (authorized for the transportation of gasoline).

HMTUSA specifies that ``marking'' (of a package or container) is a

``covered subject''. The Administrator's relevant requirements at 49

CFR 180.415 ``occupy the field''. New York's regulation must be

stricken.

Precedent On These Issues Is Abundant--NTTC believes that the

Administrator's decisions in both ``Inconsistency Rulings'' (IR) and

``Preemption Determinations'' (PD) buttress our claims with respect

to the New York State regulations under question.

For instance, in both IR#19 and #IR 28, the Administrator ruled

that, ``. . . the HMTA and HMR provide sufficient information and

documentation requirements for the safe transportation of hazardous

materials; state and local requirements in excess of them constitute

obstacles to implementation of the HMTA and HMR and thus are

inconsistent with them.''

Similarly, in those two rulings (plus a host of others), it was

ruled that, ``Requirements for information or documentation in

excess of Federal requirements create potential delay, constitute an

obstacle to execution of the Federal hazmat law and the HMR, and

thus are preempted.''

In at least 14 prior proceedings of this type (IR's and PD's),

RSPA has struck down state and local requirements found to be ``* *

* likely to cause'' and/or ``* * * the mere threat'' of unnecessary

delays in hazardous materials transportation.

As the Administrator ruled in PD-4 (R), ``Required markings of

packagings (cargo tanks and portable tanks) to certify current

registration and inspection are preempted since they are not

substantively the same as the markings required by the HMR.''

(emphasis added)

Even the United States Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit

weighed in most directly. In reversing a District Court decision in

the matter of Colorado Pub. Utilities Commission v. Harmon, the

Court went to the heart of NTTC's complaint specifying that a state

may not require a carrier to retain inspection reports in a vehicle;

and, that such an additional documentation requirement could ``* * *

create confusion and increase hazards.''

Given the fact that the State of New York is aggressively

enforcing the regulations cited above, we ask expedited

consideration of NTTC's application for a preemption determination.

I hereby certify that I have sent a copy of this petition to:

Mr. John P. Cahill, Commissioner, Department of Environmental

Conservation, State of New York, 50 Wolf Road, Albany, NY 12233.

Respectfully submitted:

Clifford J. Harvison,

President.

Attachments

(A) Part 230 of New York Codes, Rules and Regulations.

[FR Doc. 98-14562 Filed 6-1-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.