Medicare Program; Changes to the Hospital Inpatient Prospective Payment Systems and Fiscal Year 1998 Rates

Federal RegisterMay 12, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUMMARY: This final rule responds to public comments received on those

portions of a final rule with comment period published in the Federal

Register on August 29, 1997, that revised the Medicare hospital

inpatient prospective payment systems for operating costs and capital-

related costs to implement necessary changes resulting from the

Balanced Budget Act (BBA) of 1997, Public Law 105-33. This rule also

addresses public comments on other BBA changes relating to cost limits

for hospitals and hospital units excluded from the prospective payment

systems as well as direct graduate medical education payments that were

included in the August 29, 1997 document. Generally, these BBA changes

were applicable to hospital discharges occurring on or after October 1,

1997.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This final rule is effective on June 11, 1998.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Nancy Edwards, (410) 786-4531, Operating Prospective Payment and Wage

Index Issues

Tzvi Hefter, (410) 786-4487, Capital Prospective Payment, Excluded

Hospitals Critical Access Hospitals, and Graduate Medical Education

Issues

Copies: To order copies of the Federal Register containing this

document, send your request to: New Orders, Superintendent of

Documents, P.O. Box 371954, Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7954. Specify the date

of the issue requested and enclose a check or money order payable to

the Superintendent of Documents, or enclose your Visa or Master Card

number and expiration date. Credit card orders can also be placed by

calling the order desk at (202) 512-1800 or by faxing to (202) 512-

2250. The cost for each copy is $8.00. As an alternative, you can view

and photocopy the Federal Register document at most libraries

designated as Federal Depository Libraries and at many other public and

academic libraries throughout the country that receive the Federal

Register.

This Federal Register document is also available from the Federal

Register online database through GPO Access, a service of the U.S.

Government Printing Office. Free public access is available on a Wide

Area Information Server (WAIS) through the Internet and via

asynchronous dial-in. Internet users can access the database by using

the World Wide Web; the Superintendent of Documents home page address

is http://www.access.gpo.gov/su__docs/, by using local WAIS client

software, or by telnet to swais.access.gpo.gov, then login as guest (no

password required). Dial-in users should use communications software

and modem to call (202) 512-1661; type swais, then login as guest (no

password required).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

A. Summary

Under section 1886(d) of the Social Security Act (the Act), payment

for the operating costs of acute care hospital inpatient stays under

Medicare Part A (Hospital Insurance) is based on prospectively-set

rates. Under this system, which was established effective with hospital

cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1983, Medicare

payment for hospital inpatient operating costs is made at a

predetermined, specific rate for each hospital discharge. All

discharges are classified according to a list of diagnosis-related

groups (DRGs). The regulations governing the hospital inpatient

prospective payment system are located in 42 CFR Part 412.

As required by section 1886(g) of the Act, effective with cost

reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1991, we also use a

prospective payment methodology for hospital inpatient capital-related

costs. Under the capital-related cost methodology, a predetermined

payment amount per discharge is made for Medicare inpatient capital-

related costs.

The prospectively set rates and methodologies are updated annually

as required by law or as new legislation is enacted.

B. Summary of the Provisions of the August 29, 1997 Final Rule with

Comment Period Resulting from the Balanced Budget Act of 1997

On August 29, 1997, we published a final rule with comment period

in the Federal Register (62 FR 45966) setting forth statutorily

required changes to the Medicare hospital inpatient prospective payment

systems for both operating costs and capital-related costs, which were

effective for discharges occurring on or after October 1, 1997. This

final rule with comment period followed a proposed rule published in

the Federal Register on June 2, 1997 (62 FR 29902) that set forth

proposed updates and changes. Following issuance of the June 2, 1997

proposed rule, the Balanced Budget Act (BBA) of 1997, Public Law 105-

33, was enacted on August 5, 1997. This new law made major changes to

the hospital prospective payment systems, effective October 1, 1997.

Therefore, a major part of the August 29, 1997 final rule with comment

period incorporated changes made by the BBA. Because the BBA was

enacted after we had issued the June 2 proposed rule and because most

of the BBA changes were effective October 1, 1997, we issued the August

29, 1997 document as a final rule with comment period.

The BBA made major changes that affected Medicare payments for

inpatient hospital services under the prospective payment systems, and

the cost limits applicable to excluded hospitals and hospital units as

well as payment for the direct costs of graduate medical education. The

provisions of the BBA that we implemented in the August 29, 1997 final

rule with comment period related to the following:

The hospital operating payment update factor. (Sections

4401(a) and (b))

The hospital capital rate reduction. (Section 4402)

Reductions in payments to disproportionate share

hospitals. (Section 4403)

Elimination of payment of indirect medical education (IME)

and disproportionate share adjustment on outlier payments. (Section

4405)

Base payment rate to Puerto Rico hospitals. (Section 4406)

Special reclassification of Stanly County, North Carolina

for purposes of the prospective payment system. (Section 4408)

New guidelines for geographic reclassification of certain

hospitals for Federal fiscal year 1998 and subsequent fiscal years.

(Sections 4409 and 4410(c))

Floor on area wage index. (Sections 4410(a) and (b))

Revision of the IME formula, limitations on full-time

equivalent residents, and payment to teaching hospitals for IME costs

associated with Medicare managed care discharges. (Sections 4621(a),

4621(b), and 4622)

Classification of rural referral centers (RRC) for FY 1998

and

[[Page 26319]]

subsequent fiscal years. (Section 4202(b))

Special treatment of Medicare-dependent, small rural

hospitals (MDHs). (Section 4204)

Reinstatement of the add-on payment for blood clotting

factor for inpatient beneficiaries with hemophilia. (Section 4452)

Counting residents for direct graduate medical education.

(Section 4623)

Payments to managed care plans for graduate medical

education. (Section 4624)

Payment to nonhospital providers for the direct costs of

medical education incurred in the operation of an approved medical

residency training program. (Section 4625)

Payment for combined medical residency training programs.

(Section 4627)

Payment update for excluded hospitals and hospital units.

(Section 4411)

Reductions in capital payment amounts for certain excluded

hospitals and hospital units. (Section 4412)

Rebasing target amounts for excluded hospitals. (Section

4413)

Cap on target amounts for excluded hospitals and hospital

units (psychiatric hospitals and units, rehabilitation hospitals and

units, and long-term care hospitals) for FYs 1998 through 2002.

(Section 4414)

Bonus and relief payments to excluded hospitals and

hospital units. (Section 4415)

Change in payment and target amount for new providers.

(Sections 4416 and 4419)

Treatment of certain long-term care hospitals. (Sections

4417(a) and 4417(b))

Exclusion of certain cancer hospitals from the prospective

payment system. (Section 4418)

Establishment of a new ``Medicare Rural Hospital

Flexibility Program'' to replace the existing Essential Access

Community Hospital/Rural Primary Care Hospital (EACH/RPCH) program that

operates in seven States. (Section 4201)

Beginning with the FY 1999 update, a change in the

publication dates for the DRG prospective payment rate methodology and

the recommended hospital prospective payment updates as a proposed rule

by April 1 and as a final rule by August 1 of each year. (Section

4644(a)(1) and (b)(1))

As a conforming change, the deadline for applications for

geographic reclassification for years beginning with FY 2000 was moved

from October 1 to September 1. Because the FY 1999 applications were

due on October 1, 1997, we shortened the deadlines for decisionmaking

by the Medicare Geographic Classification Review Board (MGCRB), so that

a final decision for all applications is made by June 15, 1998.

(Section 4644(c))

II. Summary of the BBA Provisions and Discussion of Public Comments

A. General

We received a total of 180 pieces of correspondence containing

public comments on the BBA changes addressed in the August 29, 1997

final rule with comment period. Below we discuss the BBA provisions,

the changes we made to implement these provisions, the public comments

received on each provision, and our response to the public comments.

B. Hospital Operating Payment Update Factor

1. General Provision

The BBA made several revisions to the applicable percentage change

(the update factor) to the Federal rates for prospective payment

hospitals. Section 4401(a)(1) of the BBA amended section

1886(b)(3)(B)(i) of the Act to revise the update factors for the

Federal rates for inpatient operating costs for FYs 1998 through 2002.

The update factor for FY 1998 was set at 0 percent for hospitals in all

areas. For FY 1999, the update for hospitals in all areas is the market

basket rate of increase minus 1.9 percentage points. For FY 2000, the

update for all areas is the market basket rate of increase minus 1.8

percentage points. For FY 2001 and FY 2002, the update for all areas is

the market basket rate of increase minus 1.1 percentage points. For FY

2003 and subsequent years, the update for all areas is the market

basket rate of increase.

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we made necessary

changes to Sec. 412.63 of our regulations.

Comment: One commenter asserted that while the 0 percent update of

the prospective payment rates for FY 1998 is consistent with the

requirements of section 4401(a)(2) of the BBA, it is inappropriate

given circumstances in the real world.

Response: As the commenter noted, HCFA is required by statute to

implement the 0 percent update to the prospective payment rates for FY

1998. We believe that the 0 percent update is appropriate for the

reasons discussed in both our update recommendation in the June 2

proposed rule (62 FR 30035) and our responses to comments on that

recommendation in the August 29 final rule with comment period (62 FR

46139).

2. Special Update for Certain Nonteaching, Nondisproportionate Share

Hospitals that do not Qualify as MDHs

Section 4401(b) of the BBA provided a temporary special payment for

FYs 1998 and 1999 for certain hospitals that do not receive any

additional payment through the IME or DSH adjustment and do not meet

the criteria to be classified as an MDH. As set forth in section

4401(b)(2), in order to qualify for the special payment, a hospital

must be located in a State in which the aggregate operating prospective

payment for hospitals that meet the special payment criteria (that is,

non-IME, non-DSH, non-MDH hospitals) is less than the aggregate

allowable operating costs of inpatient hospital services (referred to

hereafter as a negative operating prospective payment margin) for those

hospitals for their cost reporting periods that began during FY 1995.

In addition, a hospital must have a negative operating prospective

payment margin during the cost reporting period at issue (beginning in

FY 1998 or 1999).

Under the provisions of section 4401(b)(1), for these hospitals,

the percentage increase otherwise applicable to the standardized amount

for FY 1998 was increased by 0.5 percentage points and, for FY 1999,

the applicable percentage increase will be increased by 0.3 percentage

points. Based on current statutory provisions, this means that these

hospitals will receive an update of 0.5 percent for FY 1998 (the update

for all other hospitals is 0) and, for FY 1999, an update of the market

basket increase minus 1.6 percentage points (1.9 for all other

hospitals). Under section 4401(b)(1), in applying these updates, the

increase provided in FY 1998 will not apply in computing the update for

FY 1999 and neither update will affect the updates provided for

discharges in fiscal years after FY 1999.

In accordance with section 4401(b)(2) of the BBA, in determining

whether a hospital qualifies for the special payment for a given cost

reporting period, we looked first at statewide aggregate data for non-

IME, non-DSH, non-MDH hospitals for cost reporting periods beginning

during FY 1995, and second at hospital-specific characteristics for the

cost reporting period at issue to determine whether the hospital has a

negative operating prospective payment margin for that period, and

whether the hospital received IME or DSH payments or qualified as an

MDH for that period. Using the latest cost reporting data, we

identified 17 States that met the criteria

[[Page 26320]]

set forth in section 4401(b)(2): Alaska, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii,

Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Louisiana, Maine, Missouri, New Hampshire, New

Jersey, Ohio, Puerto Rica, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Wisconsin. The

fiscal intermediaries will make interim payment to hospitals in these

17 designated States, beginning with discharges occurring on or after

October 1, 1997, based on the higher standardized amount during the

fiscal year. However, as noted above, the final decision as to a

hospital's qualification for the additional payment is determined based

on whether the hospital has a negative operating prospective payment

margin during its FY 1998 or FY 1999 cost reporting period. Therefore,

the final determination will be made at cost report settlement.

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we added a new

Sec. 412.107 to the regulations and revised Sec. 412.90 to implement

this provision.

Comment: Two hospital associations commented that any hospital

identified by its fiscal intermediary as likely to qualify for an

update of 0.5 percentage points under the temporary special payment

provision of section 4401(b) of the BBA should be given the option of

declining the higher interim payments. The commenters were concerned

that some hospitals that receive the additional money on an interim

basis might have difficulty paying back the funds should the

intermediary determine at cost report settlement that the hospital does

not qualify for the update.

Response: If a hospital that has been identified as eligible for

the higher interim payment believes that ultimately it may not qualify

for the higher update and wishes to decline the higher interim

payments, it should notify its intermediary.

C. Hospital Capital Rate Reduction

Section 4402 of the BBA amended section 1886(g)(1)(A) of the Act to

require that, for discharges occurring on or after October 1, 1997, the

Secretary must apply the budget neutrality adjustment factor used to

determine the Federal capital payment rate in effect on September 30,

1995 (as described in Sec. 412.352) to the unadjusted standard Federal

capital payment rate (as described in Sec. 412.308(c)) effective

September 30, 1997, and the unadjusted hospital-specific rate (as

described in Sec. 412.328(e)(1)) effective September 30, 1997. For

discharges occurring on or after October 1, 1997, and before September

30, 2002, the Secretary must reduce the same rates an additional 2.1

percent.

The budget neutrality adjustment factor effective September 30,

1995 was 0.8432 (59 FR 45416), which is equivalent to a 15.68 percent

((1.0-0.8432) * 100) reduction in the unadjusted standard Federal

capital payment rate and the unadjusted hospital-specific rate in

effect on September 30, 1997. The additional 2.1 percent reduction to

the rates reduces the rates in effect on September 30, 1997 by a total

of 17.78 percent. The unadjusted standard Federal rate must be

distinguished from the annual Federal rate actually used in making

payment under the capital PPS system. The unadjusted standard Federal

rate is the underlying or base rate used to determine the Federal rate

for each Federal fiscal year by applying the formula described in

Sec. 412.308(c). The annual Federal rate is the result of that

determination process in Sec. 412.308(c). In accordance with the broad

authority conferred in section 1886(g) of the Act, to implement a

capital prospective payment system, we extended the reduction to the

capital rates to the Puerto Rico capital rates and incorporated it in

Sec. 412.374(a).

Under the statute, the additional 2.1 percent reduction applies to

discharges occurring ``before September 30, 2002''. This provision

would have required us to calculate special rates that would be in

effect for only one day. Because we believed that the Congress intended

to apply the reduction to discharges occurring through September 30,

2002, we indicated in the August 29 final rule with comment period that

we plan to seek a technical correction to change the date that the 2.1

percent reduction expires from September 29, 2002, to September 30,

2002. Since we assumed this technical error would be corrected, we used

the September 30, 2002 expiration date in our regulations.

When we restore the 2.1 percent reduction to the Federal rate after

September 30, 2002, we plan to restore the rate to the level that it

would have been without the reduction. We determined the adjustment

factor for FY 1998 by deducting both cuts (0.1568 and 0.021) from 1

(1-0.1568-0.021 =0.8222). We then applied 0.8222 to the unadjusted

standard Federal rate. The adjustment factor to restore the 2.1 percent

cut would be the adjustment without the 2.1 percent cut (0.8432)

divided by the adjustment with the 2.1 percent cut (0.8222). (0.8432/

0.8222=1.02554). To restore the 2.1 percent reduction, we will apply

1.02554 to the unadjusted standard Federal capital payment rate in

setting rates for discharges after September 30, 2002.

Section 412.328(e) of the regulations provides that the hospital-

specific rate for each fiscal year is determined by adjusting the

previous fiscal year's hospital specific rate by the hospital specific

rate update factor and the exceptions payment adjustment factor. After

these two adjustments are applied, a net adjustment to the rate is

determined. The previous year's hospital specific rate is analogous to

the standard Federal rate, which is updated each year to become the

annual Federal rate.

When the 2.1 percent reduction is restored, most hospitals will

have completed the transition to a fully prospective payment system for

capital related costs. However, new hospitals might be eligible for

hold harmless payments beyond the transition, so we may need to

continue to compute a hospital specific rate. If we need to restore the

2.1 percent reduction to the hospital specific rates, we will do so in

a manner similar to that described above with respect to the unadjusted

standard Federal capital payment rate.

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised two

sections of the capital prospective payment system regulations to

implement these statutory requirements. Specifically, we revised

Secs. 412.308(c) and 412.328(e) to provide for the required 15.68 and

2.1 percent reduction to the rates. The 2.1 percent reduction will be

restored after September 30, 2002.

Comment: One commenter noted that as a result of the high capital

rate paid in FY 1997, many hold-harmless hospitals switched from being

paid based on a blend of their old and new capital to being paid based

on 100 percent of the Federal rate, because the Federal rate was higher

than their old and new capital payment would have been. The commenter

also stated that when Congress reduced the capital rate as part of the

provisions of the BBA, many hospitals' payments would have been higher

had they been allowed to return to their previous old capital and new

capital payment methodology. The commenter suggested deleting the

requirement at Sec. 412.344(b) that once a hospital is paid based on

100 percent of the Federal rate, it cannot return to payments based on

a blend of its old and new capital costs. The commenter also noted that

when the Federal capital rate was reduced under the provisions of OBRA

1993, fiscal intermediaries were given specific authority to

redetermine each hospital's payment methodology.

[[Page 26321]]

Response: In section 13501(a)(3) of the Omnibus Budget

Reconciliation Act of 1993 (Public Law 103-66), Congress reduced the

Federal capital rate and not the hospital-specific rate. Hospital

payment methodology redeterminations were expressly provided for in

that section of the statute. However, in 1997, when Congress reduced

both the hospital-specific rate and the Federal capital rate as part of

the BBA, hospital payment methodology redeterminations were not

provided for by the legislation and we do not believe that it would be

appropriate to provide for redeterminations by regulation. In addition,

we do not believe it would be appropriate to allow hospitals to return

to payment based on their ratio of old and new capital once they have

been paid based on 100 percent of the Federal rate. We are in the

seventh year of the 10 year transition to a fully prospective capital

payment system. By October 1, 2002, all hospitals will be paid based on

100 percent of the Federal rate. It would not be appropriate to allow

hospitals to return to cost-based payment this point in the transition.

D. Disproportionate Share Hospital (DSH) Payments

Section 4403(a) of the BBA reduced the payment for hospitals that

treat a disproportionately large number of low-income patients. The

payment a hospital would otherwise receive under the disproportionate

share formula is reduced by 1 percent for FY 1998, 2 percent for FY

1999, 3 percent for FY 2000, 4 percent for FY 2001, 5 percent for FY

2002, and 0 percent for FY 2003 and each subsequent fiscal year. In the

August 29 final rule with comment period, we added a new paragraph (e)

to Sec. 412.106 to implement this provision.

Comment: One commenter asked that we clarify the applicability of

the provisions of section 4403(a) of the BBA, which relate to

disproportionate share operating payments, to the prospective payment

system for capital related costs. Specifically, the commenter requested

that we verify that the phased-in 5 percent reduction of operating DSH

payments does not apply to capital DSH payments. The commenter also

asked us to codify our decision as to the applicability of this

provision in the appropriate section of the capital regulations

governing DSH.

Response: The commenter is correct. Section 4403 amended section

1886(d)(5)(F) of the Act to reduce the amount otherwise payable for

operating DSH. The capital DSH adjustment set forth at Sec. 412.320

references the operating DSH definition of low income patients at

Sec. 412.106(b) and uses the definition of the disproportionate patient

percentage at Sec. 412.106(c)(2), but section 4403 does not affect

capital DSH payments. In response to the commenter's request that we

codify in the regulations the applicability of the BBA operating

provisions to capital payments, we do not believe that it is necessary

to do so. The capital regulations that are affected will be

automatically included by their reference to the appropriate section of

the operating regulations. The capital regulations that are not

affected (regarding the reduction to DSH payments need not be revised.

E. Outlier Payments

Section 4405 of the BBA amended sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(i)(I) and

(d)(5)(F)(ii)(I) of the Act to provide that, in determining the payment

for hospitals that receive indirect medical education or

disproportionate share payments, the IME and DSH adjustment factors are

applied only to the base DRG payment, not the sum of the base DRG

payment and any cost outlier payments, effective with discharges

occurring on or after October 1, 1997. The same section of the BBA also

amended section 1886(d)(5)(A)(ii) of the Act to require that the fixed

loss cost outlier threshold is based on the sum of DRG payments and IME

and DSH payments for purposes of comparing costs to payments.

Therefore, in the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised

our regulations at Sec. 412.84(g) to remove the provision that costs be

reduced by the IME and DSH adjustment factors for purposes of comparing

costs to payments to determine if costs exceed the fixed loss cost

outlier threshold, as well as to delete Sec. 412.80(c). Conforming

changes were made to Sec. 412.105(a) (IME adjustment) and

Sec. 412.106(a)(2) (DSH adjustment). We also made a corresponding

change to the capital cost outlier methodology. We received two

comments on this provision, both of which concurred with HCFA's

interpretation of section 4405 of the BBA.

F. Payment Rate for Puerto Rico Hospitals

1. Operating Payment Rate

Section 4406 of the BBA amended section 1886(d)(9)(A) of the Act to

revise the Puerto Rico and national shares of the Puerto Rico payment

rate. Beginning with discharges occurring on or after October 1, 1997,

the Puerto Rico payment rate will be a blend of 50 percent of the

Puerto Rico standardized amount and 50 percent of a national

standardized amount (compared to a blend of 75 and 25 percent,

respectively, prior to enactment of the BBA). In the August 29 final

rule with comment period, we revised Sec. 412.204 of the regulations to

conform with this amendment.

2. Capital Payment Rate

Under the broad authority of section 1886(g) of the Act, in the

August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised the calculation of

capital payments to Puerto Rico to parallel the change that was made in

the calculation of operating payments to Puerto Rico. Effective October

1, 1997, we will base capital payments to hospitals in Puerto Rico on a

blend of 50 percent of the national rate and 50 percent of the Puerto

Rico-specific rate. This change will increase payments to Puerto Rico

hospitals since the national rate is higher than the Puerto Rico rate.

We did not receive any public comments on either of these

provisions.

G. Special County Designation

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, the Secretary

exercised the authority granted to her by section 4408 of the BBA to

include Stanly County in the Charlotte-Gastonia-Rock Hill, North

Carolina-South Carolina MSA for purposes of the prospective payment

system. This change was reflected in the final wage index included in

that document.

We did not receive any public comments on this provision.

H. Changes to the Medicare Geographic Classification Review Board

(MGCRB) Guidelines and Timeframes

Various provisions of the BBA addressed the guidelines the MGCRB

uses to reclassify hospitals to other geographic areas as well as the

timetable under which hospitals must submit applications for

reclassification and when the MGCRB and the Secretary must make

decisions on those applications.

1. Revised Application and MGCRB Timeframes

Prior to the enactment of the BBA, a hospital had to submit an

application to the MGCRB for geographic reclassification for a fiscal

year by the first day of the preceding fiscal year (that is, October 1,

1997 for reclassification effective in FY 1999). The MGCRB had 180 days

to make a decision on that application (no later than March 31 of the

fiscal year), the hospital has 15 days to request a review of that

decision by the Administrator of HCFA (by April 15), and the

[[Page 26322]]

Administrator had up to 90 days to issue a final decision (July 15).

The July 15 deadline allowed the final geographic reclassification

decisions to be incorporated in the wage index and payment rates that

were published in the final rule (on or about September 1).

Sections 4644(a)(1) and (b)(1) of the BBA amended section

1886(d)(6) and (e) of the Act to provide that the prospective payment

system final rule setting the payment rates for years beginning with FY

1999 must be published by August 1. Because this change in publication

date would conflict with the timetable for geographic reclassification

decisions, section 4644(c) of the BBA amended section

1886(d)(10)(C)(ii) of the Act to require a hospital, beginning with

applications filed for reclassification for FY 2000, to submit its

application for reclassification no later than the first day of the

month preceding the beginning of the Federal fiscal year (that is, by

September 1). Under this timetable, the amount of time the MGCRB and

the Administrator have to make decisions will not change from the

existing schedule.

In addition, because applications filed for reclassification

effective in FY 1999 were not due until October 1, 1997, section

4644(c)(2) required us to shorten the deadlines under section

1886(d)(10)(C) of the Act so that all final decisions on MGCRB

applications will be completed by June 15, 1998.

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised

Secs. 412.256 and 412.274 to implement the change in the application

deadline.

2. Alternative Wage Index Reclassification Guidelines for Individual

Hospitals

Effective for FY 1998 reclassification, sections 4409 and 4410 of

the BBA required the Secretary to establish alternative wage index

guidelines for geographic reclassification for certain

disproportionately large hospitals. In the case of a hospital that is

owned by a municipality and that was reclassified as an urban hospital

for FY 1996, in calculating the hospital's average hourly wage for the

purposes of geographic reclassification for FY 1998 only, section

4410(c) of the BBA required the exclusion of general service wages and

hours of personnel associated with a skilled nursing facility that is

owned by the hospital of the same municipality and that is physically

separated from the hospital to the extent that such wages and hours of

such personnel are not shared with the hospital and are separately

documented. Because the application and decisionmaking processes for FY

1998 reclassification were already completed, we had to provide special

guidelines for hospitals to apply for reclassification under these

provisions for FY 1998.

A hospital seeking reclassification for FY 1998 under either

section 4409 or 4410(c) had to submit its application to the MGCRB (7

copies) by September 15, 1997. If the MGCRB rendered a favorable

decision on a hospital's application, the hospital was reclassified for

purposes of the wage index for FY 1998 as if that decision had been

made under the usual guidelines and timetable.

We also extended the existing appeal rights for decisions on

requests for reclassification to decisions made under sections 4409 and

4410. Therefore, for such appeals, in the August 29 final rule with

comment period, we incorporated the existing appeals and review process

(including the timetables for a hospital to request review and for the

Administrator to complete review) even though that process was not

finalized until after the beginning of the fiscal year. We revised the

regulations at Sec. 412.230(e) to implement section 4409. However,

because the provision of section 4410(c) applied for only one year, we

did not revise the codified regulations text to reflect that provision.

3. Reclassification for Rural Referral Centers and the Disproportionate

Share Adjustment

Currently, under section 1886(d)(10)(D) of the Act, rural referral

centers (RRCs) are allowed to apply to the MGCRB to be reclassified for

purposes of the wage index adjustment. To be reclassified, RRCs must

meet the following criteria:

The hospital's average hourly wage must be at least 108

percent of the Statewide rural hourly wage.

The hospital's average hourly wage must be at least 84

percent of the average hourly wage of the target urban area to which

the RRC is applying.

Section 4202 of the BBA prohibits the MGCRB from rejecting a

hospital's request for reclassification on the basis of any comparison

between the hospital's own average hourly wage and the average hourly

wage of hospitals in the area in which the hospital is located if the

hospital was ever classified as an RRC. However, RRCs will continue to

be required to have an average hourly wage that is at least 84 percent

of the average hourly wage of the target urban area to which the RRC is

applying. In addition, while RRCs do not have to meet the proximity

requirements for reclassification, they continue to be required to seek

reclassification to the nearest urban area. In the August 29 final rule

with comment period, we revised Sec. 412.230(a)(3) to implement this

provision.

Section 4203 of the BBA provided that, for a limited time, a rural

hospital may apply and qualify for reclassification to another area for

purposes of disproportionate share adjustment payments whether or not

the standardized amount is the same for both areas. For 30 months after

the date of enactment of the BBA, the MGCRB will consider the

application under section 1886(d)(10)(C)(i) of the Act from a hospital

requesting a change in the hospital's geographic classification for

purposes of determining, for a fiscal year, eligibility for and

additional payment amounts under section 1886(d)(5)(F) of the Act. The

MGCRB will apply the guidelines for standardized amount

reclassification (Sec. 412.230(d)) until the Secretary establishes

separate guidelines. Therefore, hospitals seeking such reclassification

for FY 1999 must have submitted a reclassification application to the

MGCRB by October 1, 1997. Decisions based on these applications will be

effective for FY 1999 (beginning on October 1, 1998). Section 4203 of

the BBA is effective for the 30-month period beginning on the date of

enactment. Accordingly, hospitals may seek reclassification for

purposes of DSH for FY 1999, FY 2000, and FY 2001. In the August 29

final rule with comment period, we revised Sec. 412.230(a)(5)(ii) of

the regulations to implement this provision.

Comment: One commenter questioned the effective date of sections

4202 and 4203 of the BBA, which exempt RRCs from the 108 percent

criterion in applying for wage index reclassification and allow a

hospital to reclassify to another area for purposes of the

disproportionate share adjustment even if the standardized amount of

both areas is the same, respectively. The commenter asserted that the

conference report accompanying the statute clearly states that the

effective date of these provisions is ``enactment'' of the BBA, that

is, August 5, 1997. Therefore, the commenter believes that hospitals

should have been allowed to apply to the MGCRB and reclassify under

these provisions for FY 1998 reclassifications, which were effective

beginning October 1, 1997. The August 29 final rule with comment period

limited the effect of these provisions to reclassifications beginning

in FY 1999.

Response: We agree that the provisions of sections 4202 and 4203 of

the BBA are effective August 5, 1997. However, the statutory language

contains no

[[Page 26323]]

directive to apply these provisions to hospital reclassifications

effective for FY 1998 (compare sections 4409 and 4410(c) of the BBA,

both of which specifically stated that their provisions were effective

for FY 1998 reclassifications). Section 4202 amends section

1886(d)(10)(D) of the Act to provide that the MGCRB ``may not reject

the application'' of a hospital on the basis of a comparison specified

in the statute. Accordingly, if the MGCRB considers an application on

or after August 5, 1997, it will not reject the application on the

basis specified in the statute. Section 4202 does not require the MGCRB

to re-evaluate applications that the MGCRB rejected before August 5,

1997.

Similarly, section 4203 provides that, for the 30-month period

beginning on August 5, 1997, the MGCRB ``shall consider'' a hospital's

application for reclassification for purposes of DSH payments.

Accordingly, if a hospital submits an application to be reclassified

for purposes of DSH on or after August 5, 1997, the MGCRB will consider

the application. Generally, the deadline for FY 1998 reclassifications

was October 1, 1996. Section 4203, unlike other provisions of the BBA,

does not require the MGCRB to grant reclassifications for FY 1998

notwithstanding this deadline.

Thus, hospitals may apply for reclassification under the provisions

of sections 4202 and 4203 after August 5, 1997. The first such

applications would be those for FY 1999 reclassification beginning on

October 1, 1998, which were due by October 1, 1997. We note that,

although the provisions of section 4202 are permanent, section 4203 is

effective for 30 months and applies only to those reclassifications

effective for FY 1999, 2000, and 2001.

I. Floor on Area Wage Index

As provided by section 4410(a) of the BBA, for discharges on or

after October 1, 1997, the area wage index applicable to any hospital

that is not located in a rural area may not be less than the area wage

index applicable to hospitals located in rural areas in the State in

which the hospital is located. For FY 1998, this change affected 128

hospitals in 32 MSAs. Furthermore, this wage index floor is to be

implemented in such a manner as to assure that aggregate prospective

payment system payments are not greater or less than those which would

have been made in the year if this section did not apply.

We did not receive any public comments on this provision.

J. Indirect Medical Education (IME) Adjustment

1. Operating IME Adjustment

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised our

regulations to incorporate the provisions of section 4621 of the BBA,

which amended section 1886(d)(5)(B) of the Act in several ways. First,

it gradually reduces the current level of the IME adjustment

(approximately a 7.7 percent increase for every 10 percent increase in

the resident-to-bed ratio) over the next several years according to the

following schedule: 7.0 percent for discharges during FY 1998; 6.5

percent during FY 1999; 6.0 percent during FY 2000; and 5.5 percent

during FY 2001 and thereafter.

Second, section 4621 established certain limits both on the full-

time equivalent (FTE) number of residents counted by each hospital and

on the resident-to-bed ratio. Effective for discharges on or after

October 1, 1997, section 4621(b)(1) added a new section

1886(d)(5)(B)(v) to the Act to require that a hospital's total number

of resident FTEs in the fields of allopathic and osteopathic medicine

may not exceed the total number of such resident FTEs counted by the

hospital during its most recent cost reporting period ending on or

before December 31, 1996. Furthermore, section 1886(d)(5)(B)(vi)(I)

provides that the ratio of residents-to-beds may not exceed the ratio

calculated during the prior cost reporting period (after accounting for

the cap on the number of resident FTEs).

Third, for cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1,

1997, and subject to the new limit on counting residents described

above (as well as the expansion of allowable settings to off-site

services, as described below), section 1886(d)(5)(B)(vi)(II) provides

that ``the total number of full-time equivalent residents for payment

purposes shall equal the average of the actual full-time equivalent

resident count for the cost reporting period and the preceding two cost

reporting periods.'' For the first cost reporting period beginning on

or after October 1, 1997, this provision ``shall be applied using the

average for such period and the preceding cost reporting period.'' For

purposes of this provision, section 1886(d)(5)(B)(vii) requires the

Secretary to make appropriate modifications in the event of a cost

reporting period other than 12 months.

With respect to medical residency training programs established on

or after January 1, 1995, section 1886(d)(5)(B)(viii) provides that the

Secretary must develop rules to apply these limits to such new

programs, giving special consideration to ``facilities that meet the

needs of underserved areas,'' and to facilitate the application of

aggregate limits in the case of affiliated groups (as defined by the

Secretary). Finally, ``(t)he Secretary may require any entity that

operates a medical residency training program . . . to submit to the

Secretary such additional information as the Secretary considers

necessary to carry out such (limits).'' We revised the regulations at

Sec. 413.86(g)(6) to comply with these directions for both the indirect

and direct GME FTE counts.

Finally, section 4621(b)(2) amended section 1886(d)(5)(B)(iv) of

the Act to allow all the time spent by a resident in patient care

activities under an approved medical residency training program at an

entity in a nonhospital setting to be counted towards the determination

of full-time equivalency if the hospital incurs all, or substantially

all, of the costs for the training program in the setting. Therefore,

in the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised

Sec. 412.105(g)(1)(ii)(C), which allowed hospitals to include the time

residents spent in patient care activities in nonhospital settings, for

purposes of IME. The eligibility criteria for this provision is similar

to a provision regarding direct graduate medical education payments at

section 1886(h)(4)(E) of the Act, and implemented at

Sec. 413.86(f)(iii). For IME purposes, we intend to rely upon the same

criteria as are applied for the direct GME to identify eligible

situations under this new provision.

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised

Sec. 412.105 to reflect these changes, and issued instructions to

fiscal intermediaries to implement these changes prior to October 1,

1997. In response to our discussion of the changes enacted by the BBA,

we received numerous comments seeking clarification on many of these

issues.

Comment: Several commenters noted a discrepancy in the preamble of

the August 29 document concerning the effective date of the cap on

allopathic and osteopathic FTEs: In the preamble summary of the BBA

changes at 62 FR 45968, the effective date of the provision is stated

as ``cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1997.'' In

the full discussion of the provision in the preamble at 62 FR 46003,

the provision is made effective for ``discharges on or after October 1,

1997.''

Response: The effective date for applying the cap on allopathic and

osteopathic FTEs, as set forth in section

[[Page 26324]]

1886(d)(5)(B)(v) of the Act, is for ``discharges on or after October 1,

1997.'' This effective date citation in the preamble summary at 62 FR

45968 was a typographic error.

Comment: Commenters noted that the requirements set forth in

section 1886(h)(4)(H) of the Act concerning special rules for applying

the FTE limits for direct graduate medical education for new programs

and affiliated groups also apply to IME payments. The commenters

requested that they be added to the regulations at Sec. 412.105.

Response: The commenters are correct. Under section

1886(d)(5)(B)(viii) of the Act, as added by section 4621(b)(1) of the

BBA, rules similar to the rules set forth at section 1886(h)(4)(H) of

the Act apply for purposes of implementing: the cap on resident FTEs;

the cap on the resident-to-bed ratio; and the 3-year rolling average

resident count. We are revising Sec. 412.105(f)(1)(vi) and (vii)

accordingly.

The count of residents in accordance with the rules for special

circumstances (new programs and affiliated groups) under section

1886(d)(5)(B)(viii) of the Act is described in sections II.N.3 and 4 of

this final rule. We note that this section of the Act applies only to

the limits set forth in sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and (vi) of the Act.

Comment: Several commenters objected to our interpretation of the

language of section 1886(d)(5)(B)(vi) of the Act, which describes the

cap on the resident-to-bed ratio. In the August 29 final rule with

comment period, we stated that this is a cap on the total resident FTE

count including dental and podiatry residents. The commenters believe

the Congress intended that dental and podiatry residents should be

exempt from this cap in addition to their exemption from the cap

established for resident FTEs. In support of their interpretation, the

commenters noted the reference to the FTE cap in establishing the cap

on the ratio (section 1886(d)(5)(B)(vi) of the Act). One commenter

stated that including dental and podiatry residents in the FTE

calculation before applying the ratio cap leads to a nonsensical result

since the Congress established a cap on allopathic and osteopathic

residents but explicitly did not include dental and podiatry residents

under this cap.

Another commenter supported applying the cap to total FTEs,

including dentists and podiatrists. This commenter noted that the ratio

could increase after a one-year lag to reflect additional dental or

podiatry residents.

Response: Section 1886(d)(5)(B)(vi) of the Act, as amended by the

BBA, establishes a cap on the value of ``r,'' which is defined in

section 1886(d)(5)(B)(ii) of the Act as ``the ratio of the hospital's

full-time equivalent interns and residents to beds.'' The IME formula

defined in this section of the Act explicitly includes the value `r' in

the IME calculation. Therefore, `r' has a very precise and significant

value.

Section 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) of the Act (as amended) states that ``the

total number of full-time equivalent interns and residents in the

fields of allopathic and osteopathic medicine'' may not exceed the

number of such residents in either a hospital or nonhospital setting

with respect to the hospital's most recent cost reporting period ending

on or before December 31, 1996. This section sets a cap on a subset

(allopathic and osteopathic medical residents) of the total number of

residents. The numerator of the ratio is the total number of residents

including the effect of the cap; the Congress did not provide that `r'

would be computed using only a subset of residents. In fact, one could

argue that under such an interpretation, there would be no explicit

methodology in the Act for including dental and podiatry residents in

the IME calculation. The reference in section 1886(d)(5)(B)(vi)(I) of

the Act to ``the limit under clause (v)'' means that the numerator

includes the effect of the cap on allopathic and osteopathic residents,

not that the numerator is limited to those residents. Thus, the

statutory language requires that we apply the cap on the ratio after

including all residents, dental and podiatry as well as allopathic and

osteopathic, in the calculation of the numerator.

Comment: Other commenters believe that it is inappropriate not to

allow exceptions to the ratio cap when hospitals are voluntarily

closing inpatient beds. In addition, commenters requested that the cap

be adjusted to include the residents' time spent in nonprovider

settings.

Response: Section 4621 of the BBA addresses the application of the

cap, specific situations where special rules are appropriate, and the

allowance of residents' time spent in nonprovider settings. In

addition, we note that the ratio could increase after a one-year delay

for legitimate changes in either the numerator or the denominator. That

is, the ratio is capped based on its value during the prior cost

reporting period. An increase in the ratio thereby establishes a higher

cap for the following cost reporting period.

Comment: One commenter requested clarification of the term ``the

prior cost reporting period'' as used in the preamble of the final rule

with comment period when describing the application of the cap on the

ratio of residents-to-beds (62 FR 46003).

Response: The phrase ``prior cost reporting period'' refers to the

immediately preceding period. A hospital's cost reporting period

beginning July 1, 1998 would have its ratio capped at the value of its

ratio for its cost reporting period ending June 30, 1998. In

determining a hospital's resident-to-bed ratio for a cost reporting

period that begins before October 1, 1997 (the effective date of the

cap on allopathic and osteopathic FTEs) and ends after that date, the

ratio for that period will reflect a prorated resident FTE count. That

is, the numerator is determined through averaging the uncapped and

capped FTE amounts based on the number of months in the cost reporting

period before and after October 1, 1997. This FTE count will also be

used to determine the rolling average amount for subsequent years.

Comment: Commenters requested an explanation of how the ratio cap

would be determined under the special rules implemented pursuant to

section 1886(d)(5)(B)(viii) of the Act (that is, the new program and

affiliated group provisions).

Response: The ratio is first determined by calculating the resident

FTE count taking into account all of the relevant limitations and

applicable rolling averages, and the denominator in the ratio is the

hospital's available bed count during the current cost reporting

period. If this results in a ratio in excess of the previous cost

reporting period's ratio, the hospital's IME adjustment is based on the

ratio from the previous cost reporting period.

Special rules apply for the special circumstances at section

1886(d)(5)(B)(viii) of the Act. In the event that the application of

section 1886(d)(5)(B)(viii) results in a higher resident-to-bed ratio

for a hospital compared to its most recently completed cost reporting

period, the special rule will be applicable only for the portion of the

higher ratio due to the increase in residents. In such instances, the

ratio during the prior cost reporting period is similarly applicable,

but it is adjusted for the additional residents allowed by the special

circumstances rule. In practice, this is accomplished by adding the

additional residents to the resident FTE count used in the prior cost

reporting period's resident-to-bed ratio. It should be noted that this

adjustment is the result of a special rule for applying the cap on `r'

for new programs and affiliated groups as set forth in section

1886(d)(5)(B)(viii) of the Act. Therefore, no adjustment to the ratio

is made for an increase in dental

[[Page 26325]]

or podiatry residents during the cost reporting period in which an

increase occurs.

In the case of recognized affiliation arrangements, each hospital

will be paid on the basis of its individual resident-to-bed ratio.

Under such an arrangement, the ratio is the number of residents counted

by the hospital in accordance with the special FTE counting rules for

these arrangements, over the hospital's bed count during the current

cost reporting period. As described above, the ratio may increase

during a particular cost reporting period due to an increase in the

number of residents allowed under the special affiliation arrangement.

Any such exemption from the ratio cap will be limited to the increase

in residents and will not reflect changes in hospital bed size.

Comment: Commenters were concerned about the language establishing

the resident FTE cap (section 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) of the Act) that the

number of allopathic and osteopathic residents may not exceed ``the

number of such full-time equivalent interns and residents in the

hospital'' during the most recent cost reporting period ending on or

before December 31, 1996. The commenters believed that this

disadvantages the programs that have already been training residents in

nonprovider settings. Commenters suggested that we support the effort

to delete the phrase ``in the hospital'' from this section.

Response: As is indicated by the comments, residents in nonhospital

settings during the most recent cost reporting period ending on or

before December 31, 1996, are excluded by the Act from the

determination of the allopathic and osteopathic cap. Furthermore,

although we recognize that many of these arrangements that were in

existence during 1996 reflected the demand for more primary care

physicians, we would note that the purpose of allowing hospitals to

count this time in the future is to create an incentive for even more

primary care training. In that regard, hospitals that had previously

established residency training in nonhospital settings did so in

response to the existing incentives at that time.

Comment: Several commenters suggested that the reduction in the IME

adjustment factor (from approximately a 7.7 percent increase for every

10 percent increase in the ratio of residents to beds to 7.0 percent

for discharges during FY 1998, and gradually reducing further for 3

years beyond that) places a disproportionate share of the cost-cutting

burden on teaching hospitals, especially academic medical centers.

Response: The reduction to the IME adjustment factor is set forth

in the statute. However, given the gradual reduction in the factor and

the recent very high Medicare operating margins for teaching hospitals

(especially major teaching hospitals), we disagree that the reductions

to the IME adjustment unfairly burden these hospitals. We note that

HCFA and the Prospective Payment Assessment Commission (ProPAC) have

both supported a reduction in the IME adjustment for several years

based on our analysis of the indirect effect of graduate medical

education programs on total hospital costs.

2. Capital IME Adjustment

Comment: One commenter asked us to clarify whether the following

conclusions are correct in applying the IME provisions of the BBA to

the capital prospective payment system:

(1) The cap on the number of residents training in the fields of

allopathic and osteopathic medicine for purposes of computing the

operating IME adjustment does pertain to the capital IME adjustment;

(2) The rolling average resident count for purposes of computing

the operating IME adjustment does pertain to the capital IME

adjustment; and

(3) The cap on the ratio of interns and residents to beds for

purposes of computing the operating IME adjustment does not pertain to

the ratio of interns and residents to the average daily census for

purposes of computing the capital IME adjustment.

As with the DSH provisions, the commenter also asked us to codify

our policy on the applicability of these operating provisions in the

appropriate sections of the capital regulations governing the IME

adjustment.

Response: Cap on Number of Residents in Allopathic and Osteopathic

Medicine--The regulations at Sec. 412.322 describe the capital IME

adjustment. Section 412.322(a)(1) provides that the hospital's number

of full-time equivalent (FTE) residents is determined in accordance

with Sec. 412.105(f) of the operating regulation. Since the BBA

provisions affected Sec. 412.105(f)(iv) by capping the number of

allopathic and osteopathic interns and residents at the number of

interns and residents reported on a hospital's cost report for the

period ending December 31, 1996, the capital IME intern and resident

count for allopathic and osteopathic residents is also capped

automatically.

Rolling Average Resident Count--The BBA provision implementing a

rolling average resident count (section 4623) is also included in

Sec. 412.105(f) of the operating IME regulations. Since the capital IME

regulations reference the operating IME regulation at Sec. 412.105(f),

the capital IME FTE count is affected by the rolling average resident

count as well.

Cap on Ratio of Interns to Beds--The cap on the number of interns

and residents to beds (section 4621) does not have an impact on the

capital IME payments because we use the ratio of hospital FTEs to

average daily census to determine the capital IME adjustment factor.

In response to the commenter's request that we codify in the

regulations the applicability of these BBA operating IME provisions to

capital payments, we do not believe that it is necessary to do so. The

capital regulations that are affected (regarding the cap on the number

of residents in allopathic and osteopathic medicine, and the rolling

average resident count) will be automatically included by their

reference to the appropriate section of the operating regulations. The

capital regulations that are not affected (regarding the cap on the

ratio of interns to beds) need not be revised.

It has come to our attention that there has also been some question

raised about the applicability of sections 4001 and 4622 of the BBA--

Payment to Hospitals of Indirect Medical Education Costs for

Medicare+Choice Enrollees to capital IME payments. Section 4001 of the

BBA instructs the Secretary to exclude from the Medicare+Choice

capitation rate payment adjustments for the indirect costs of medical

education under section 1886(d)(5)(B) of the Act. Section 4622 of the

BBA provides for payments to teaching hospitals for discharges

associated with Medicare managed care beneficiaries for portions of

cost reporting periods beginning on or after January 1, 1998.

Section 4001 of the BBA refers only to the indirect costs of

medical education as defined in section 1886(d)(5)(B) of the Act. This

section refers to operating IME payments and not capital IME payments,

which were established by regulation. Thus, section 4001 affects only

operating IME payments.

K. Rural Referral Centers

Based on section 1886(d)(5)(C)(i) of the Act and the Conference

Committee Report accompanying Public Law 98-21 (the original

legislation implementing the prospective payment system), we

established qualifying criteria for referral center status to identify

those rural hospitals that, because of bed size,

[[Page 26326]]

a large number of complicated cases, a high number of discharges, or a

large number of referrals from other hospitals or from physicians

outside the hospital's service area, were likely to have operating

costs more similar to urban hospitals than to the average smaller

community hospitals. The regulations implementing the referral center

provision are codified at Sec. 412.96.

In 1984, after a year's experience with the referral center

criteria, we determined that once approved for the referral center

adjustment, a hospital would retain its status for a 3-year period. At

the end of the 3-year period, we would review the hospital's

performance to determine whether it should be requalified for an

additional 3-year period. The requirement for triennial review was

added to the regulations in 1984 (Sec. 412.96(f)) to be effective for

cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1987 (the end

of the first 3 years of the referral center adjustment). However, since

then, three statutory moratoria on the performance of the triennial

reviews were enacted by Congress. When the third of these moratoria

expired at the end of cost reporting periods that began during FY 1994,

we implemented the triennial review requirements and some hospitals

lost their referral center status. (See the September 1, 1993 final

rule (58 FR 46310) for a detailed explanation of the moratoria and the

implementation of the triennial reviews.)

Hospitals could lose rural referral center status in other ways.

With the creation of the MGCRB and a hospital's ability, beginning in

FY 1992, to request that it be reclassified from one geographic

location to another, we stated that if a referral center was

reclassified to an urban area for purposes of the standardized amount,

it would, in most instances, be voluntarily terminating its referral

center status. (See the June 4, 1991 final rule with comment period (56

FR 25482).) This was true because, in most instances, a hospital's

ability to qualify as a ``rural referral center'' was contingent upon

(among other criteria) its status as a rural hospital.

In addition, rural referral centers located in areas that were

redesignated as urban by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) lost

their referral center status. These hospitals had qualified for

referral center status under criteria applicable only to hospitals

located in rural areas. OMB's designation of the areas to urban status

meant that such hospitals were urban for all purposes and thus could no

longer qualify as rural referral centers.

Section 4202(b)(1) of the BBA states that, ``Any hospital

classified as a rural referral center by the Secretary . . . for fiscal

year 1991 shall be classified as such a rural referral center for

fiscal year 1998 and each subsequent fiscal year.'' Thus, many of the

hospitals that lost their referral center status for the reasons listed

above must be reinstated. For the purpose of implementing this

provision, we consider that a hospital that was classified as a

referral center for any day during FY 1991 (October 1, 1990 through

September 30, 1991) meets the reinstatement criterion.

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we reinstated

rural referral center status for all hospitals that lost the status due

to triennial review or MGCRB reclassification regardless of whether it

was classified as an RRC during FY 1991. We did not reinstate rural

referral center status to hospitals in areas redesignated as urban by

OMB because they are no longer rural hospitals. We also did not

reinstate the status of the six hospitals that voluntarily requested

termination of their RRC status. However, we would allow any of these

six hospitals to requalify if they so desire.

In addition, we terminated the requirement for triennial reviews of

referral center status. Thus, Secs. 412.96(f) and (g) (1) and (2) were

deleted in the August 29 final rule with comment period. If we later

discover some hospital or class of hospitals that we believe should not

be allowed to retain referral center status because they fail to meet

some basic requirement we believe is essential to receiving this

special designation, we will consider reinstating some type of annual

or periodic qualifying criteria.

Finally, we eliminated our policy that terminated RRC status for

any hospital that is reclassified as urban by the MGCRB.

Comment: One commenter expressed agreement with our decision to

reinstate hospitals that lost their RRC status as a result of failure

to meet triennial review requirements or due to MGCRB reclassification

to an urban area for purposes of the standardized amount. The commenter

further commended HCFA for terminating triennial reviews and

eliminating the policy that a hospital loses its RRC status if it is

reclassified as urban by the MGCRB. However, the commenter disagreed

with our decision to not restore the RRC status of hospitals that are

in areas redesignated as urban by OMB. The commenter believes that this

policy unfairly disadvantages those hospitals when applying for

reclassification for the wage index. That is, they will be unable to

reclassify under the special provisions of section 1886(d)(10)(D)(iii)

of the Act as amended by section 4202(a) of the BBA if they meet all

requirements except the 108 percent rule.

Response: The language of section 4202(b)(1) states that any

hospital classified as a rural referral center for FY 1991, `` * * *

shall be classified as such a rural referral center for fiscal year

1998 and each subsequent year.'' (Emphasis added.) Hospitals located in

areas redesignated as urban by OMB are no longer physically located in

a rural area. Designation by OMB of an area to urban status means that

any hospital located in that area becomes urban for all purposes and

thus could no longer qualify as rural referral centers. In reinstating

referral center status, section 4202(b) of the BBA did not revise the

qualifying criteria for these hospitals. Thus, we believe that our

decision to not reinstate hospitals located in urban areas as rural

referral centers is appropriate.

We note, however, that these hospitals are not precluded from

taking advantage of the provisions of section 1886(d)(10)(D)(iii) of

the Act, which state that the MGCRB is prohibited from rejecting a

hospital's application for reclassification on the basis of any

comparison between its hourly wage and the average hourly wage of the

hospitals in the area in which the hospital is located if the hospital

``has ever been classified by the Secretary as a rural referral

center.'' (Emphasis added.) This means that the hospital need not

currently be classified as an RRC in order to take advantage of this

provision.

L. Medicare-Dependent Small, Rural Hospitals

Section 4204 of the BBA amended section 1886(d)(5)(G) of the Act to

reinstate the classification of Medicare-dependent, small rural

hospitals (MDHs) for cost reporting periods beginning on or after

October 1, 1997 and before October 1, 2001. This category of hospitals

was originally created by section 6003(f) of the Omnibus Budget

Reconciliation Act of 1989 (Public Law 101-239), enacted on December

19, 1989, which added a new section 1886(d)(5)(G) of the Act. The

statute provides that the special payment for MDHs was to be available

for cost reporting periods beginning on or after April 1, 1990 and

ending on or before March 31, 1993. Hospitals classified as MDHs were

paid using the same methodology applicable to sole community hospitals.

[[Page 26327]]

Section 13501(e)(1) of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of

1993 (Public Law 103-66), enacted on August 10, 1993, extended the MDH

provision through discharges occurring before October 1, 1994. Under

this revised provision, after the hospital's first three 12-month cost

reporting periods beginning on or after April 1, 1990, the additional

payment to an MDH whose applicable hospital-specific rate exceeded the

Federal rate was limited to 50 percent of the amount by which that

hospital-specific rate exceeded the Federal rate.

In reinstating the MDH special payment for discharges occurring on

or after October 1, 1997 and before October 1, 2001, section 4204 of

the BBA did not revise either the qualifying criteria for these

hospitals nor the most recent payment methodology. Therefore, the

criteria a hospital must meet in order to be classified as an MDH are

the same as before. Since classification as an MDH is not optional, we

reinstated all qualifying hospitals as of October 1, 1997.

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised

Secs. 412.90 and 412.108 to reflect the reinstatement of the MDH

special payment.

Section 4204(a)(3) of the BBA permits those hospitals that qualify

as an MDH and that applied and were approved for reclassification to a

large urban area for purposes of receiving the large urban rates

through the MGCRB to decline that reclassification for FY 1998.

Normally, hospitals approved for reclassification have only 45 days

from the date of the proposed rule to withdraw their request for

reclassification. However, the statute provides that, in this

situation, hospitals may withdraw their request for FY 1998

reclassification to a large urban area for purposes of the standardized

amount. Any hospital that does not requalify for MDH reinstatement for

FY 1998 because of a reclassification to an urban area by the MGCRB for

FY 1998 will be notified and given the opportunity to decline that

reclassification.

Comment: Three commenters support the reinstatement of the special

payment for MDHs. However, the commenters recommended that HCFA

establish a process for identifying those hospitals that did not

qualify previously but now meet the criteria for classification as an

MDH.

Response: Since section 4204 of the BBA did not revise the criteria

for classification as an MDH, it is unlikely that there will be new

hospitals that qualify except for those hospitals that met all of the

original criteria except bed size.

We have instructed our fiscal intermediaries to review their

records to determine if there are any hospitals that did not meet the

criteria in 1994 and that do now; for example, a hospital that had more

than 100 beds in 1994 and now has 100 or fewer beds. In addition, as

discussed in the August 29, 1997 final rule (62 FR 46000), at the time

of a hospital's year-end cost report settlement, the fiscal

intermediary will determine if the hospital met the criteria to qualify

as an MDH.

Although the fiscal intermediaries are making every effort to

identify and notify all affected hospitals, any hospital that believes

it meets the criteria for MDH status but has not received notification

should contact its fiscal intermediary.

M. Reinstatement of the Add-On Payment for Blood Clotting Factor for

Hemophilia Inpatients

Section 4452 of the BBA amended section 6011(d) of Public Law 101-

239 to reinstate the add-on payment for the costs of administering

blood clotting factor to Medicare beneficiaries who have hemophilia

(which was previously in effect from June 19, 1990 through September

30, 1994) and who are hospital inpatients for discharges occurring on

or after October 1, 1997. The payment is based on a predetermined price

per unit of clotting factor multiplied by the number of units provided.

In our August 29, 1997 final rule with comment period, we stated

that we would calculate the add-on payment for FY 1998 using the same

methodology we have used in the past (62 FR 46002). Thus, we

established a price per unit of clotting factor based on the current

price listing available from the 1997 Drug Topics Red Book, the

publication of pharmaceutical average wholesale prices (AWP). We set

separate add-on amounts for the following clotting factors, as

described by HCFA's Common Procedure Coding System (HCPCS). The add-on

payment amount for each HCPCS code is based on the median AWP of the

several products available in that category of factor, discounted by 15

percent.

Based on this methodology, we established the following prices per

unit of factor for discharges occurring on or after October 1, 1997:

J7190 Factor VIII (antihemophilic factor-human)................. $0.76

J7192 Factor VIII (antihemophilic factor-recombinant)........... 1.00

J7194 Factor IX (complex)....................................... 0.32

J7196 Other hemophilia clotting factors (e.g., anti-inhibitors). 1.10

In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we solicited

comments on the appropriateness of the add-on payment amount and

suggestions for the best methodology to calculate this amount.

Comment: We received five comments on this issue. The commenters

indicated that the payment add-ons for blood clotting factors were

appropriate with the exception of the payment amount under HCPCS code

J7194, Factor IX (complex). The commenters asserted that ``purified''

Factor IX products (that is, products that contained Factor IX only)

constituted a distinctly different and much more costly group of

products than Factor IX (complex); thus, it was inappropriate to group

all ``Factor IX'' products together under one HCPCS code. They

recommended that HCFA either allow the purified Factor IX products to

be billed under HCPCS code J7196 (Other hemophilia clotting factors) or

establish a separate HCPCS code (or codes) for the purified Factor IX

products.

Response: We agree that there is a need for further distinctions

among the Factor IX products. Therefore, as suggested by the

commenters, we are establishing the following two new HCPCS billing

codes for purified Factor IX products:

Q0160 Factor IX (antihemophilic factor, purified,

nonrecombinant)................................................ $0.93

Q0161 Factor IX (antihemophilic factor, purified, recombinant).. 1.00

(Note that ``Q-codes'' are national temporary HCPCS codes that HCFA

establishes unilaterally. We will request approval for permanent

HCPCS codes at the next session of the national HCPCS panel.)

We will issue instructions to Medicare hospitals and fiscal

intermediaries stating that payment should be made under these codes

for all applicable discharges occurring on or after the effective date

of this rule (that is, June 11, 1998). As discussed in the August 29

document, payment will be made for blood clotting factor only if there

is an ICD-9-CM diagnosis code for hemophilia included on the bill.

N. Counting Residents for Direct Graduate Medical Education

1. Limit on the Count of Residents

Section 4623 of the BBA added section 1886(h)(4)(F) of the Act to

establish a limit on the number of allopathic and osteopathic residents

that a hospital can include in its full time equivalent (FTE) count for

direct GME payment. Residents in dentistry and podiatry are exempt from

the cap. For cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1,

1997, a hospital's

[[Page 26328]]

unweighted direct medical education FTE count may not exceed the

hospital's unweighted FTE count for its most recent cost reporting

period ending on or before December 31, 1996.

Section 1886(h)(4)(H)(iii) of the Act gives the Secretary authority

to collect whatever data are necessary to implement this provision.

Hospitals have been required to report resident-specific information to

their fiscal intermediaries under longstanding requirements of

Sec. 413.86, and we believe it is possible to implement section

1886(h)(4)(F) without mandating significant additional reporting. We

expect to amend the Medicare cost report in light of all of the

provisions of the BBA addressing indirect and direct GME payments. We

believe that the data, for the most recent cost reporting periods

ending on or before December 31, 1996, necessary to implement the

indirect and direct GME provisions is already available to fiscal

intermediaries through the intern and resident information system.

We believe the hospital's unweighted FTE limit for its most recent

cost reporting period ending on or before December 31, 1996 should be

based on a 12 month cost reporting period. If the hospital's most

recent cost reporting period ending on or before December 31, 1996 is a

short period report, the fiscal intermediaries shall make adjustments

so that the hospital's unweighted FTE limit corresponds to the

equivalent of a 12-month cost reporting period. In the August 29 final

rule with comment period, we revised Sec. 413.86(g)(4) accordingly.

Comment: We received comments that many hospitals received approval

from the Accreditation Council on Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) to

expand existing medical residency training programs prior to enactment

of the BBA. The additional residents associated with these program

expansions may not have been included in the hospital's most recent

cost reporting period ending on or before December 31, 1996. Some

commenters felt that it was not the intent of the Congress to ``unduly

burden residency programs and hospitals by putting into effect

regulations which retroactively punish programs attempting to expand.''

These commenters stated that even if it was Congressional intent to

halt program expansion, programs serving rural and rural underserved

areas should be exempt. Some commenters urged that the cap be adjusted

to allow for situations where documented expansion plans were approved

by national credentialing bodies or state regulatory agencies prior to

August 5, 1997, or where hospitals made commitments to residents for

the 1997/1998 academic year. Other commenters stated that HCFA should

allow all residents training before August 5, 1997, to be included in

hospital FTE caps. One commenter suggested that HCFA consider the

number of approved slots rather than the actual number of residents on

December 31, 1996, for purposes of calculating the FTE cap. This

commenter did not believe that Congress intended to punish well-

established programs that happened to have an open slot on a particular

date, nor to force programs with significant activity in the training

of rural physicians to reduce their number of residency slots. Some

commenters recognized that the statute requires the Secretary to

establish hospital specific FTE caps from the hospitals' most recent

cost reporting period ending on or before December 31, 1996, even in

situations where hospitals made commitments to training additional

residents after their cost reporting period ending during 1996 and

before the enactment of the BBA. The commenters urged HCFA to recommend

a statutory change to the 1996 cost report year provision to ameliorate

the retrospective nature of this provision.

Response: Under sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and 1886(h)(4)(F), as

amended by the BBA, the number of a hospital's residents in allopathic

medicine and osteopathic medicine may not exceed the number of such

residents for the hospital's most recent cost reporting period ending

on or before December 31, 1996. The limit applies to discharges

occurring on or after October 1, 1997, for indirect medical education

and to cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1997,

for direct GME. Thus, for an individual hospital, the amount of

Medicare payment for direct and indirect GME is limited by the number

of residents in a base year specified by the statute.

Many of the comments we received indicated that hospitals made

commitments to expand existing residency programs between their most

recent cost reporting periods ending on or before December 31, 1996,

and their first cost reporting period in which the caps apply. As a

result, the hospital may have more residents in its current cost

reporting period than its FTE cap. If we adjusted the caps for these

hospitals we would effectively give them a base year contrary to the

one specified by the statute.

Similarly, establishing FTE caps based on the number of residents

training on August 5, 1997 or in the 1997-1998 program year would be

inconsistent with the statutory base year. In response to the comment

that we establish FTE caps based on approved slots rather than the

actual number of residents in training, the statute specifically

establishes that the cap equals the number of allopathic and

osteopathic FTE residents (before the application of the initial

residency period weighting factors) in the hospital's most recent cost

reporting period ending on or before December 31, 1996. The Conference

Report for the BBA states that ``the conference agreement provides for

a `cap' or limit on the number of residents that may be reimbursed by

the Secretary, on a national and a facility level.''

Section 1886(h)(5)(H) states that the Secretary shall give special

consideration to facilities that meet the needs of underserved areas

but only in the context of prescribing rules for medical residency

training programs created on or after January 1, 1995. Thus, we

disagree with these commenters that hospitals that meet the needs of

rural underserved areas should be exempt from the FTE caps.

Comment: We received several comments on the need for flexibility

in the FTE caps. These comments stated that an institution-specific cap

does not allow training to move from one hospital to another even if

those sites become undesirable. One commenter suggested that a

hospital's FTE resident count should be allowed to increase if the

residents are moved from another teaching hospital because that

hospital no longer provides a desirable training site. Another

commenter stated that program sponsors are responsible for ensuring

that residency program sites meet accreditation requirements, and that

a program sponsor is required to move residency slots if an affiliated

hospital cannot or does not want to continue to support residency

program changes. These commenters noted that if the sponsor of a

residency program moves residents from one hospital to another, the

receiving hospital will not be paid for those residents above its cap

even though there is no net growth in the number of residents. These

commenters requested that the regulations be modified to allow a

hospital's FTE cap to increase if the residents are moved from one

teaching hospital to another by the program sponsor if there is no net

growth in residency slots. One comment proposed setting the cap at the

number of residents included in an institution's sponsored programs as

an alternative to the unweighted cap based on the time a resident works

at a facility. Rotating residents would be counted outside the

[[Page 26329]]

cap since the increase in FTEs at one institution due to rotations is

balanced by a decrease in the FTEs at the originating institution. One

commenter stated that since hospitals now ``own'' residency slots,

program sponsors are put at a disadvantage in negotiating with

affiliated hospitals for reimbursement of resident salaries and faculty

supervision costs, and an affiliated hospital may choose to ``sell its

residency slots to the highest bidder.''

Response: The statute does not prohibit program sponsors from

restructuring a residency training program or resident rotation

schedules. Sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and 1886(h)(4)(F) only provide for

hospital-specific FTE caps for purposes of determining Medicare payment

for indirect and direct GME. We believe the concerns of these

commenters may be addressed by our rules for affiliated groups, which

permit hospitals to elect to apply the caps on an aggregate basis. As

discussed later, if two or more hospitals are members of the same

affiliated group, they can, by mutual agreement, adjust each respective

hospital's FTE cap under an aggregate FTE cap. Absent this mutual

agreement, we do not believe it is appropriate for the Secretary to

establish rules that allow adjustments to hospital-specific FTE caps

based on unilateral decisions by the residency training program

director.

With regard to the comment that the hospital's FTE caps should be

based on the hospital's sponsored programs, sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v)

and 1886(h)(4)(F) specifically limit the hospital's FTEs for

determining Medicare payment to the number included in the hospital's

most recent cost reporting period ending on or before December 31,

1996. We would further note that medical residency training programs

may also be sponsored by medical schools. If we were to adopt this

commenter's suggestion that the FTE cap be equal to the number of

residents in a hospital's sponsored programs, residents in programs

sponsored by medical schools would not be included in any hospital's

FTE cap.

We recognize the concern of the commenter who stated that the FTE

caps may result in changes in financial relationships between program

sponsors and affiliated training sites to the disadvantage of program

sponsors. If, indeed, program sponsors are at a disadvantage in

negotiating financial arrangements, it is a result of the BBA statutory

requirement that Medicare payment for direct and indirect GME be

limited by hospital specific FTE caps and not a result of any

regulations promulgated by the Secretary.

Comment: One commenter stated that because of osteopathic

medicine's commitment to primary care and work in underserved

communities, HCFA should create an exemption to the residency cap for

osteopathic residency programs. Other commenters stated concerns about

the adequacy of postgraduate medical education training positions for

osteopathic medicine residents. One commenter stated that the

osteopathic medical profession is currently 3,000-3,500 positions in

deficit, based on the postdoctoral needs of all students who are

currently and will register in colleges of osteopathic medicine over

the next 3 years. The commenter argues that, since the allopathic

positions total approximately 143 percent of U.S. allopathic medical

graduates, a similar restriction on U.S. osteopathic positions does not

seem warranted. This commenter stated that a mechanism should be

permitted to allow the osteopathic profession the flexibility to

enhance osteopathic training positions by approximately 3,000-4,000

positions. Another commenter noted that osteopathic physicians serve

disproportionately in rural areas and appear to fulfill physician

workforce objectives, which represents an additional justification for

maintaining osteopathic residency slots. One commenter noted that it is

important that a GME FTE cap not adversely affect training osteopathic

surgical subspecialty physicians. According to this commenter,

osteopathic medical graduates do not have access to allopathic surgical

subspecialty programs.

Response: Section 1886(h)(4)(F) provides for a cap on the total

number of FTE residents in a hospital's ``approved medical residency

training programs in the fields of allopathic and osteopathic

medicine.'' The statutory limit on the number of residents paid for by

Medicare specifically encompasses residents in osteopathic medicine.

Comment: Several commenters asked about application of the cap for

hospitals that merged after December 31, 1996 but before the BBA, where

only one hospital maintains its provider number and participation

agreement. Another commenter stated that the law and regulations do not

address application of the resident cap for hospital mergers and

acquisitions. These commenters do not believe that it was the intent of

the BBA to eliminate funding for residents when hospitals merge.

Another commenter stated that applying the limits based on cost reports

ending on or before December 31, 1996, does not allow for the long-term

plans of providers attempting to reduce medical education costs and

consolidate programs. The commenters recommended that HCFA interpret

the BBA provisions to allow hospitals that merged after the base year

to include the count of both hospitals. Some commenters suggested that

another approach would be to redefine an affiliated group to include

hospitals that merged after the December 31, 1996, cost reporting

period. Another commenter stated that where there is a merger involving

two hospitals, the merged cap should reflect a 12-month cost reporting

period. This commenter suggested we amend the regulations specifically

to ensure that the FTE cap is based on the equivalent of a 12-month

cost report in the context of a merger.

Response: We agree with the commenters that when there is a merger,

the cap for the hospital should reflect the base year FTE counts for

the hospitals that merged. This is consistent with the principle of

limiting payments based on the base year specified in the statute.

Also, in implementing the COBRA 1985 provision establishing a hospital-

specific per resident amount in the situation of a merger, we have

calculated the revised per resident amount for the merged hospital

using an FTE weighted average of each of the respective hospital's per

resident amount which is part of the merger. We believe that it would

be appropriate to address the FTE caps using the same principle. For

purposes of this final rule, where two or more or more hospitals merge

after each hospital's cost reporting period ending during FY 1996, the

merged hospital's FTE cap will be an aggregation of the FTE cap for

each hospital participating in the merger. We are modifying

Sec. 413.86(g)(6) to reflect this change.

With regard to the comment that we modify the regulations to ensure

that the FTE caps are applied on the basis of a 12-month cost reporting

period specifically in the context of mergers and acquisitions, the

existing regulations state that the fiscal intermediary may make

appropriate modifications to apply the FTE cap based on the equivalent

of a 12-month cost reporting period. We do not believe that additional

regulatory revisions are warranted.

Comment: Several commenters argued that we should adjust the caps

when a hospital began training additional residents after its cost

reporting period ending during 1996 because another hospital closed or

discontinued its

[[Page 26330]]

teaching programs during the July 1996-June 1997 residency year. One

commenter stated that there should be a mechanism for allowing FTE

positions from merged or closed osteopathic residency programs to be

used by other programs. One commenter suggested that we allow an

adjustment to the FTE cap if the hospital met the following criteria:

(1) During the July 1996-June 1997 residency year the hospital assumed

additional medical residents from a hospital that was closing or

discontinuing its training programs; (2) The hospital added the

residents with the intent of allowing them to complete their education

program; and (3) The hospital that closed does not seek reimbursement

for the residents. If a hospital meets these three criteria, this

commenter stated that it should have an unweighted FTE count which

equals its unweighted FTE count for its most recent cost reporting

period ending on or before December 31, 1996, adjusted for the

additional residents added from residency programs at the closed

hospital.

Response: Similar to the situation of a merger, we agree that, when

a hospital takes on residents because another hospital closes or

discontinues its program, a temporary adjustment to the cap is

appropriate and consistent with the base year system. In these

situations, residents may have partially completed a medical residency

training program and would be unable to complete their training without

a residency position at another hospital. We believe that it is

appropriate to allow temporary adjustments to the FTE caps for a

hospital that provides residency positions to medical residents who

have partially completed a residency training program at a hospital

which closed.

For purposes of this final rule, we will allow for temporary

adjustments to a hospital's FTE cap to reflect residents affected by a

hospital closure. That is, we will allow an adjustment to a hospital's

FTE cap if the hospital meets the following criteria: (1) During the

July 1996-June 1997 residency year the hospital assumed additional

medical residents from a hospital that was closing; (2) The hospital

added the residents with the intent of allowing them to complete their

education program; and (3) The hospital that closed does not seek

reimbursement for the residents. As stated above, this adjustment will

be temporary to allow Medicare payment for those residents from the

closed hospital. After this period, the hospital's cap will be based

solely on the statutory base year. Hospitals seeking an adjustment for

this situation must document to their intermediary that an adjustment

is warranted for this purpose and the length of time that the

adjustment is needed.

Comment: One commenter stated that an appeals process must be

established for providers to present cases when they believe their

particular medical education programs have been unfairly penalized.

Response: Since the direct and indirect medical education FTE

counts are used in determining hospital payments on the basis of a cost

reporting period and the hospital has appeal rights on the settlement

of the cost report under 42 CFR Part 405, we do not believe that a new

appeals process needs to be established.

2. Counting Residents Based on a 3-Year Average

Section 1886(h)(4)(G)(iii) of the Act, as added by section 4623 of

the BBA, provides that for the hospital's first cost reporting period

beginning on or after October 1, 1997, the hospital's weighted FTE

count for payment purposes equals the average of the weighted FTE count

for that cost reporting period and the preceding cost reporting period.

For cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1998,

section 1886(h)(4)(G) of the Act requires that hospitals' direct

medical education weighted FTE count for payment purposes equal the

average of the actual weighted FTE count for the payment year cost

reporting period and the preceding 2 cost reporting periods. This

provision provides incentives for hospitals to reduce the number of

residents in training by phasing in the associated reduction in payment

over a 3-year period. In the August 29 final rule with comment period,

we revised Sec. 413.86(g)(5) accordingly.

For cost reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1997,

we indicated in the August 29 final rule with comment period how we

would determine direct GME payments.

To address situations in which a hospital increases the number of

FTE residents over the cap, notwithstanding the limit established under

section 1886(h)(4)(F), in the August 29 final rule with comment period

we established the following policy for determining the hospital's

weighted direct GME FTE count for cost reporting periods beginning on

or after October 1, 1997.

Determine the ratio of the hospital's weighted FTE count

for residents in allopathic and osteopathic medicine to the hospital's

unweighted number of FTE residents without application of the cap for

the cost reporting period at issue.

Multiply the ratio determined above by the hospital's FTE

cap. Add the weighted count of residents in dentistry and podiatry to

determine the weighted FTEs for the cost reporting period. This

methodology should be used for purposes of determining payment for cost

reporting periods beginning on or after October 1, 1997. The hospital's

unweighted count of interns and residents for a cost reporting period

beginning before October 1, 1997 will not be subject to the FTE limit.

If a hospital's unweighted count of residents in specialties other

than dentistry and podiatry does not exceed the limit, the weighted FTE

count equals the actual weighted FTE count for the cost reporting

period. The weighted FTE count in either instance will be used to

determine a hospital's payment under the 3-year rolling average payment

rules. We believe this proportional reduction in the hospital's

unweighted FTE count is an equitable mechanism for implementing the

statutory provision.

Section 1886(h)(4)(G)(ii) of the Act provides that the Secretary

makes appropriate modifications to ensure that the average FTE resident

counts are based on the equivalent of full 12 month cost reporting

periods. In the August 29 final rule with comment period, we revised

Sec. 413.86(g)(5) to allow the fiscal intermediaries to make the

appropriate adjustments to ensure that 3-year and 2-year average FTE

counts are based on the equivalent of 12-month periods.

Comment: Some commenters stated that application of the 3-year

rolling average rule penalizes hospitals that participate in an

affiliated group and increase residents under an aggregate FTE cap. We

received comments stating that the 3-year rolling average may penalize

hospitals that legitimately qualify for an increase in their FTE count

because they established a medical residency training program on or

after January 1, 1995. The commenters argue that, in these cases,

hospitals should be able to choose to have IME or direct GME payments

based on the current year count of FTE residents or the 3-year rolling

average. One commenter stated that the rolling average methodology

arbitrarily penalizes areas of the country undergoing substantial

growth.

Response: Section 1886(h)(4)(H)(i) states that ``the Secretary

shall, consistent with the principles of subparagraphs (F) and (G),

prescribe rules for the application'' of the FTE caps and the 3-year

rolling average in the case of medical residency programs established

after January 1, 1995. We agree with these commenters that FTE

[[Page 26331]]

residents participating in new medical residency training programs

should be included in the direct and indirect GME FTE counts after

application of the 3-year averaging methodology. Accordingly, we are

revising Sec. 413.86(g)(5) to determine a hospital's 3-year average FTE

count prior to adding residents participating in new medical residency

training programs consistent with section 1886(h)(4)(H)(i). However,

section 1886(h)(4)(H)(ii) states that ``the Secretary may prescribe

rules which allow institutions which are members of the same affiliated

group (as defined by the Secretary) to elect to apply the limitation of

subparagraph (F) on an aggregate basis.'' Since the statute provides

that the Secretary's rules regarding affiliated groups should only

apply to the FTE cap, we believe the 3-year rolling average should be

applied for affiliated groups. That is, we will apply the 3-year

rolling average for hospitals that are part of an affiliated group,

subject to application of the aggregate cap.

Comment: We received some comments asking HCFA to clarify that

dental and podiatric residents are not included in the rolling average

resident count. Several other commenters suggested that we modify the

regulations so that dental and podiatric residents are not included in

the 3-year averaging of FTE counts. The commenters asserted that the

intent of the provision was that the count of dental and podiatric

positions be made separately.

Response: Although the FTE caps established under sections

1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and (h)(4)(F) are limited to residents in allopathic

and osteopathic medicine, there is no similar limitation in section

1886(d)(5)(B)(vi) and (h)(4)(G) when determining indirect and direct

GME payments based on a 3-year average. These provisions state that the

Secretary shall determine payment based on an ``average of the actual

full-time equivalent resident count for the cost reporting period and

the preceding two cost reporting periods.'' There is no statutory

distinction between dental, podiatric and other residents in

determining payment based on the 3-year averaging rules.

Comment: One commenter stated that capping FTEs for individual cost

reporting periods in calculating the 3-year average is not the

intention of the statute. This commenter stated that capping the FTEs

in the individual years depreciates the FTE count for that year,

misrepresenting the total number of FTEs during that year. This

commenter recommended that in calculating the 3-year rolling average,

the gross number of FTEs should be used in the calculation.

Response: Section 1886(h)(4)(G), as added by the BBA, provides that

the computation of the rolling average is ``subject to the limit

described in subparagraph (F)''. The 3-year rolling average must

reflect application of the FTE cap.

3. Special Rules for Applying the Direct GME FTE Limit and Rolling

Average

Under section 1886(h)(4)(H)(i) of the Act, as added by the BBA, the

Secretary is required, consistent with the principles of establishing a

limitation on the number of residents paid for by Medicare and the 3-

year rolling average, to establish rules with respect to the counting

of residents in medical residency training programs established on or

after January 1, 1995. Such rules must give special consideration to

facilities that meet the needs of underserved rural areas. Language in

the Conference Report for the BBA indicates concern that there be

proper flexibility to respond to changing needs given the sizeable

number of hospitals that elect to initiate new (or terminate existing)

training programs.

Pursuant to the statute, in the August 29 final rule with comment

period, we established the following rules for applying the FTE limit

and determining the FTE count for hospitals that established new

medical residency training programs on or after January 1, 1995. For

purposes of this provision, a ``program'' would be considered newly

established if it is accredited for the first time, including

provisional accreditation, on or after January 1, 1995, by the

appropriate accrediting body. The Secretary has broad authority to

prescribe rules for counting residents in new programs, but the

Conference Report for the BBA indicates concern that the aggregate

number of FTE residents should not increase over current levels.

Accordingly, we indicated that we would continue to monitor growth in

the aggregate number of residency positions and may consider changes to

the policies described below if there continues to be growth in the

number of residency positions.

Comment: One commenter believed that the Congress intended to

create exceptions for circumstances where commitments to begin new

training programs had been made prior to enactment of the cap,

including situations where programs had begun prior to enactment but

were not filled in 1996 and situations where a new facility opens after

enactment, and had no residents in the base year.

Response: The regulations published on August 29, 1997 provide for

adjustments to hospital FTE caps for hospitals that previously did not

participate in GME training and hospitals that established new medical

residency training programs on or after January 1, 1995 and on or

before the August 5, 1997 enactment of the BBA.

Comment: Some commenters questioned the definition of ``new medical

residency training program'' established for purposes of section

1886(h)(4)(H) of the Act. The regulation defines a new program as one

that receives initial accreditation on or after July 1, 1995. Several

commenters stated that the definition of new program should recognize

programs that have not yet received accreditation but are approved GME

programs eligible for payment. The commenter suggested that the current

definition of ``new medical residency training program'' would not

recognize programs leading to an American Board of Medical Specialties

certification since they are not accredited by an accreditation body,

even though such programs qualify as approved GME programs and are

eligible for payment. Some commenters suggested that the new program

definition be based on the date the residents begin training rather

than the date of an accreditation letter. These commenters noted that

the majority of programs starting July 1, 1995, received their

accreditation letters prior to January 1, 1995, and would not qualify

as new programs. Other commenters believed that a new medical residency

program should be determined based on the date a program received

approval from the accrediting body. One commenter stated that programs

which receive ``provisional accreditation'' should be included in the

regulatory definition of a new program. One commenter stated that the

new program definition should include programs for which hospitals

submitted a formal application before August 5, 1997. The commenter

noted that it takes from 8-12 months before accreditation action is

taken. Another comment requested clarification that the documentation

required under this section (42 CFR 413.86(g)(6)(iv)) related solely to

justifying the existence of a new program.

Response: We inadvertently used the date ``July 1, 1995'' when we

added Sec. 413.86(g)(7) in the final rule with comment published August

29, 1997. We are correcting the date to January 1, 1995 in this final

rule.

As the comments reflect, establishing a newly accredited medical

residency training program can be a costly and

[[Page 26332]]

time consuming process. We recognize that hospitals that either

received accreditation for a new medical residency training program or

began training residents in the new program may have expended

substantial resources during the accreditation process. We also

recognize that hospitals usually do not begin training residents

immediately upon receiving an accreditation letter. For these reasons,

we believe it is appropriate to consider a medical residency training

program to be newly established if the program received initial

accreditation or began training residents on or after January 1, 1995.

We are modifying the regulation accordingly.

A hospital seeking to qualify as a new program must provide

documentation to the intermediary indicating the date a program

received accreditation and/or the date the residents begin training for

the hospital to receive an adjustment to its FTE cap. We are not

allowing programs to be considered newly established based on the date

the sponsor began seeking accreditation since the date of an

accreditation application is not indicative of a substantial commitment

of resources that warrant an adjustment to FTE caps.

Comment: Some commenters requested that the example in the August

29 final rule with comment period at 62 FR 46006, on programs that

received direct GME before January 1, 1995, clearly state that

dentistry and podiatry positions are not subject to the cap and that

hospitals may add new programs in dentistry and podiatry without being

subject to the Secretary's rules for establishment of new programs. The

commenter would also like the statement on page 46006 that HCFA ``will

continue to monitor growth in the aggregate number of residency

positions and may consider changes to the policies described below if

there continues to be growth in the number of residency positions'

modified to indicate that it applies only to allopathic and osteopathic

residency positions.

Response: The regulations and preamble published on August 29,

1997, clearly stated that hospitals may include dental and podiatric

residents in their FTE counts for purposes of direct and indirect

medical education payment without limit, regardless of whether it is an

expansion of an existing program or the establishment of a new program.

We do not believe modification of the regulation is necessary.

Comment: Several commenters requested clarification about

adjustments to the FTE cap for new osteopathic rotating internships.

Another commenter suggested that the osteopathic rotating internship

should be exempt from the cap as are residents in dentistry and

podiatry. One commenter noted that the rules call for counting the

number of first year residents in the third year of the residency

program. The commenter proposed that a consistent rule for internships

would adjust the FTE cap for a new internship program based on the

number of internship positions filled in the third year. One commenter

expressed concern that our rules should recognize that specialty

training in osteopathic medical specialties occurs subsequent to the

osteopathic rotating internship in the second postgraduate year and

that we should separately make adjustments to the FTE caps for new

osteopathic internships and new osteopathic specialty training

programs.

Response: The osteopathic rotating internship is the first

postgraduate year of training for osteopathic medical graduates and

precedes all subsequent specialty training. Since osteopathic rotation

internship programs are individually accredited, we are applying the

same rules for new osteopathic rotating internships that we apply for

all other new medical residency training programs. That is, if a

hospital qualifies for an adjustment to its FTE cap for a new

osteopathic rotating internship, the adjustment will be equal to the

product of the minimum accredited length for the osteopathic rotating

internship (that is, one year) and the number of FTEs participating in

the internship in its third year of existence. Since osteopathic

rotating internships are one year in length, the minimum accredited

length is equal to one year.

We will allow adjustments to FTE caps for new osteopathic specialty

programs based on the product of the minimum length for the accredited

program and the highest number of residents in any program year

subsequent to the osteopathic rotating internship (that is, program

year 2, program year 3 or program year 4) in the third year of the

program's existence. We are applying the same rule for new allopathic

training programs (that is, the adjustment for the new medical

residency program is based on the highest number of residents in any

program year in the third year of the program's existence). The

adjustment to the hospital's FTE cap may not exceed the number of

accredited resident slots for the new medical residency training

program. In response to the comment that the osteopathic rotating

internship be exempt from FTE caps, as stated earlier, the FTE caps

under sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and (h)(4)(F) specifically encompass

residents participating in allopathic and osteopathic training

programs.

a. Hospitals with no residents prior to January 1, 1995. Section

1886(h)(4)(H) of the Act allows the Secretary to prescribe special

rules for the application of the FTE caps and 3-year averaging for

medical residency training programs established on or after January 1,

1995. In the August 29, 1997 final rule with comment period (62 FR

46005), we provided a special rule for application of the FTE resident

cap for hospitals which did not participate in GME training prior to

January 1, 1995. Under this special rule, we allowed hospitals to

establish their FTE cap based on the product of the number of first

year residents participating in accredited GME training programs in the

third year that the hospital received payment for GME and the minimum

accredited length for the type of program.

Comment: Some commenters stated that hospitals that did not receive

GME payments prior to January 1, 1995, and subsequently become teaching

hospitals by affiliating with an existing training program, should be

eligible for GME payments if they incur substantially all of the costs

of the resident training and the overall number of residents does not

increase. In this situation, the location of settings in which

residents receive training changes but there is no net increase in the

number of residents. One commenter stated that the limit on resident

growth in new hospitals to those from ``newly accredited programs''

severely limits flexibility of moving residents and requires a

duplicative administrative burden to start new programs when sharing

residents would work just as well. Another commenter asked whether new

hospitals may include residents transferred from other hospitals if all

parties concur. To ensure that this does not increase the number of

resident slots, hospitals transferring residents would have their caps

correspondingly reduced. Several commenters asked how the cap would

apply to hospitals that decide to become teaching institutions and will

have residency programs that will be a mix of new programs and programs

currently running in another hospital.

Response: Under Sec. 413.86(g)(4), hospitals that are part of the

same affiliated group may elect to apply the FTE cap under section

1886(h)(4)(F) on an aggregate basis. If a hospital that did not receive

direct or indirect GME payment prior to January 1, 1995, qualifies to

be part of the same affiliated group with another hospital that

[[Page 26333]]

participates in residency training, these hospitals can, by mutual

agreement, provide for adjustments to each respective hospital's FTE

cap under an aggregate cap for the affiliated hospitals.

With regard to application of the cap for hospitals that become

teaching institutions on or after January 1, 1995, and on or before

August 5, 1997, our policy is that a hospital can receive an adjustment

to its FTE cap for a new medical residency training program and can

affiliate with hospitals that have existing medical residency training

programs. Hospitals in urban areas that participate in medical

residency training programs for the first time, after the August 5,

1997 enactment date of the BBA may receive an adjustment only for new

medical residency training programs; they cannot affiliate with

hospitals that have existing medical residency training programs. We

are establishing this policy because of our concern that hospitals with

existing medical residency training programs may affiliate with

hospitals that establish new medical residency programs solely for the

purpose of moving the new residency program to its own hospital and

receiving an upward adjustment to its FTE cap under an affiliation

agreement.

We will allow hospitals in rural areas that qualify for an

adjustment to its FTE cap for new medical residency training programs

to affiliate with hospitals in urban areas. However, we will only allow

a rural hospital that qualifies for an adjustment to its FTE cap for a

new medical residency training program to be a member of the same

affiliated group with an urban hospital if the rural hospital provides

training for the FTE equivalent of at least one third of the residents

participating in the joint programs of the affiliated hospitals. We are

allowing these affiliations between rural and urban hospitals to

recognize that rural hospitals may not have sufficient patient care

utilization to be able to establish a training program within the rural

area to meet accreditation standards. However, we remain concerned that

there needs to be a sizeable component of training in the rural area

for the policy to provide appropriate consideration for hospitals

meeting the needs of underserved rural areas. We believe that providing

for at least one third of the training in rural area will allow

programs which focus on, but are not exclusively limited to training in

those areas.

Comment: One commenter argued that there is an inconsistency

between the rules for teaching hospitals that had residents prior to

January 1, 1995, and nonteaching hospitals that became teaching

hospitals between January 1, 1995, and August 5, 1997. Hospitals in the

former category may have their limits adjusted upward for all new

programs established prior to August 5, 1997, while hospitals in the

latter category are allowed an adjustment only for residents in the

first program created even though additional programs may have been

created prior to August 5, 1997. This commenter recommended that all

hospitals be entitled to cap adjustment for programs created before

August 5, 1997.

Response: We agree and will establish the FTE cap for a hospital

which did not participate in residency training prior to January 1,

1995, based on the product of the minimum length for the type of

program and highest number of residents in any program year for all

residency programs created in the 3rd year after residents first begin

training (Sec. 413.86(g)(60)(i) and (ii)). This policy addresses

adjustments for all new medical residency programs established prior to

August 5, 1997.

Comment: One commenter suggested (1) allowing a new hospital 5

years to build its residency programs, and not differentiating between

new and established programs, (2) using the 3-year methodology outlined

in the rule but not differentiating between new and established

programs, or (3) allowing the cap to move with the residents when

programs are transferred from one hospital to another. Another

commenter suggested that permitting hospitals to transfer residency

programs to other hospitals by mutual agreement is necessary to provide

cooperating hospitals, or hospitals within networks, the necessary

flexibility to determine requirements for a quality training program

and how they will meet them.

Response: One of these commenters is suggesting three alternatives

for establishing the FTE cap for a new hospital that establishes a

medical residency training program. Under the first two options, the

commenter is suggesting that we should not distinguish between whether

the hospital's resident count is adjusted for new medical residency

training programs or previously established programs where some or all

of the residents are transferred to the new hospital. As stated

earlier, hospitals that did not participate in a medical residency

training program prior to August 5, 1997, and establish a new medical

residency training program for the first time after the enactment date

of BBA will have their FTE caps established in the third year in which

they participate in residency training.

We are not allowing hospitals that first participate in medical

residency training programs to affiliate with hospitals that already

have an established FTE cap because of our concern that hospitals with

existing medical residency training programs would affiliate with

hospitals that do not currently train residents solely for purposes of

establishing a higher FTE cap, which is inconsistent with sections

1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and (h)(4)(F) of the Act. As a result of this concern,

we are reluctant to adopt the first two approaches suggested by this

commenter for adjusting the FTE cap for a hospital which participates

in medical residency training for the first time after August 5, 1997.

This commenter has also suggested allowing the FTE cap to move between

hospitals when programs are transferred. Hospitals that qualify to be

members of the same affiliated group can mutually agree to adjustments

in their respective FTE caps.

Comment: One commenter stated that the requirement that all new

programs begin at the same time in new hospitals is contradictory to

the Accreditation Council on Graduate Medical Education requirement

that certain new programs be started in hospitals that already have

other programs. Under HCFA's regulations, a new hospital must start all

new programs at once in order to receive an adjustment to the FTE cap

based on the number of residents participating in all of the hospital's

accredited programs in the third year that the hospital participates in

training. The commenter suggested that HCFA provide an adequate time

period for new hospitals to build complementary residency programs that

do not conflict with Accreditation Council on Graduate Medical

Education requirements. One commenter stated that basing the resident

cap for new residency programs on the first program(s) will inhibit

growth of other primary care programs or the introduction of new

primary care programs. One commenter stated that nothing in the statute

suggests that recognition of new programs should be limited to the

first program. This commenter stated that if an internal medicine

program is accredited in April 1996 with its first residents in July

and a specialty program is developed in 1997 with residents beginning

in 1998, the cap should be adjusted to account for the additional

residents in the second program. One commenter recommended that the cap

for new programs be adjusted based on all programs established in the

hospital's first year rather than the first programs simultaneously

established. One

[[Page 26334]]

commenter suggested that the cap adjustment for new programs in

hospitals should be available without a cut-off date. Another commenter

recommended allowing hospitals a period of time, no less than 5 years,

to establish their GME training programs. One commenter stated that the

resident count should be determined in the third year of the program

based on the number of residents in either the first, second, or third

residency year, whichever is the highest. In addition, the regulations

should allow the limits to be adjusted upward for each of the first two

years of the program to permit payments for residents present during

that period.

Response: We agree that hospitals that establish new medical

residency programs will need time to establish complementary residency

programs. Additionally, we are concerned that hospitals may be

disadvantaged by basing the adjustment on the number of first year

residents in the third year of the program's existence. Therefore, we

are revising Sec. 413.86(g)(6)(i) to state that the hospital's cap

adjustment is based on the product of the minimum accredited length for

the specialty program and the highest number of residents training in

any program year during the 3rd year of the program's existence. For

purposes of determining the FTE cap for hospitals which first

participate in GME training on or after January 1, 1995, we will

establish the hospital's FTE cap 3 years after the first medical

residency program is established. The hospital's cap will reflect an

adjustment based on the product of the minimum accredited length for

the program and the highest number of residents in any program year for

each new medical residency program in existence at the time the cap is

established. The hospital's FTE cap may not exceed the number of

accredited resident slots available to the hospital.

b. Hospitals with residents rrior to January 1, 1995 not located in

rural areas. In the August 29, 1997 final rule with comment period, we

also provided a special rule for the application of the FTE cap for

hospitals that participated in GME training before January 1, 1995 and

established medical residency training programs on or after January 1,

1995. Under this special rule, we allowed hospitals with new medical

residency training programs established on or after January 1, 1995 and

on or before August 5, 1997 to adjust their FTE caps. The hospital's

FTE caps are adjusted for the incremental increase in residents

participating in the new medical residency training program which are

not reflected in the hospital's cost reporting period ending during

calendar year 1996.

Comment: We received comments stating that an adjustment should be

made to the FTE cap for programs established prior to January 1, 1995,

that had not reached their third year or minimum accredited length for

the type of program during the cost reporting period ending on or

before December 31, 1996.

Response: Section 1886(h)(4)(H) states that the Secretary shall

prescribe rules for application of the FTE cap and 3-year rolling

average ``in the case of medical residency training programs

established on or after January 1, 1995.'' Our policy of limiting

adjustments to FTE caps for medical residency training programs

established on or after January 1, 1995 is consistent with this

statutory requirement.

Comment: We received comments stating that HCFA should allow

adjustments to the FTE cap for new residency programs established on or

after August 5, 1997 in hospitals with existing residency programs.

Many commenters believed that the August 5, 1997 date was unfair to

primary care programs since several new family practice programs were

accredited in September 1997 and there are a number of additional

programs that will be established in the next 1 to 2 years. According

to these commenters, if a public policy goal is to increase the number

of primary care physicians, HCFA should allow for adjustments for

programs created before September, 1999. One comment stated that urban

hospitals will be deterred from opening new, desirable residency

programs such as ambulatory care training programs if they cannot

receive an adjustment for programs established after August 5, 1997. If

HCFA does not allow hospitals in urban areas to create additional

programs after August 5, 1997, this commenter suggested that HCFA allow

adjustments for primary care programs where the majority of training is

in ambulatory care. One commenter requested that the Secretary consider

the needs of elderly beneficiaries in rural areas and allow adjustments

to a hospital's FTE cap for new medical residency training in geriatric

medicine. Another commenter stated that the Secretary should be

required to give special consideration to facilities that establish

residency training programs on or after January 1, 1995 ``which meet

the needs of geriatric populations, including mental health needs of

the aged.''

Response: As we have stated earlier, sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and

1886(h)(4)(F) limit the number of allopathic and osteopathic residents

that a hospital may include in its FTE count for purposes of indirect

and direct GME payments. The Conference Report further states that ``a

facility limit on the number of residents was provided, rather than any

direction on payments according to specialty of physicians in training,

to specifically avoid the involvement by the Secretary in decision

making about workforce matters. The Conferees emphatically believe that

such decisions should remain within each facility, which is best able

to respond to clinical needs and opportunities.''

Since sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and 1886(h)(4)(F) provide for an

FTE cap for medical residents in all allopathic and osteopathic

specialties and the Conference Report states that the Secretary should

not be involved in workforce matters, we disagree with these commenters

that we should allow for adjustments to FTE caps for programs that

train primary care residents, programs that focus on ambulatory

training or geriatric training programs. We believe the statute

anticipates that each facility, within its FTE cap, will make decisions

about training programs based on the needs of its own institution.

c. Rural underserved areas. Consistent with section 1886(h)(4)(H),

we provided a special rule for the application of the FTE cap to give

special consideration to hospitals that meet the needs of underserved

rural areas. Under this special rule, we provide adjustments to FTE

caps for hospitals located in rural areas that established medical

residency training programs on or after January 1, 1995. The caps can

be adjusted for all programs created on or after January 1, 1995

including programs created after the enactment of BBA. The adjustment

to an individual hospital's FTE cap is based on the product of the

number of first year residents participating in the newly established

program in the program's third year of existence and the minimum

accredited length for the program.

Comment: Many commenters recommended that an exception to the FTE

caps should be permitted to encourage existing programs to expand to

meet the needs of rural, underserved areas. Several commenters also

suggested providing an exception to the cap that would allow a

geographic area with substantial population growth to expand existing

medical residency training programs to hospitals which previously have

not participated in residency training. Some commenters suggested that

the needs of rural (and other underserved) areas are frequently met by

facilities that do not exist within

[[Page 26335]]

those areas, but whose graduates subsequently practice there. This

commenter requested that HCFA redesignate certain urban MSAs as rural

for residency training purposes. One commenter suggested that the

designation of programs in underserved areas receiving special

consideration might better be phrased as ``programs whose graduates

serve underserved areas,'' in order to be consistent with the purpose

of this language. Many commenters stated that Congress' intent that

special consideration be given to facilities that meet the needs of

underserved rural areas was meant to include entire States that have

low ``per population'' ratios of both physicians and residents. This

commenter suggested that this special rule could be limited to the five

States with lowest physician to population ratios.

One commenter stated that without an exception, the FTE cap could

have a ``chilling'' effect on urban hospitals sending residents to

rural settings. This commenter stated that there have been several

recent expansions in family practice residency programs that include a

rural training track, with residents located in outlying hospitals, or

with satellite programs designed specifically to train residents to

work in areas with underserved populations. The commenter suggested

that urban hospitals should be eligible for exceptions to the cap if

they place residents in rural, underserved areas. One commenter

recommended that the FTE cap should be adjusted for urban programs that

provide 25 percent of their training in rural areas that are designated

as medically underserved areas and/or health professional shortage

areas.

Another commenter stated that, given the value of rural training to

the needs of underserved populations, HCFA should develop additional

exception language for rural training tracks or programs that seek to

train residents in working with underserved populations. The commenter

recommended that HCFA consider, in designating rural and rural

underserved areas, the population served by the program and where the

graduates practice upon completion of the program rather than the

location of the training of the residents. We received comments

indicating that hospitals will be unlikely to benefit from the special

rules for hospitals located in rural areas. The commenters believed

that it is unlikely that a rural hospital will establish a residency

program because the smallest program which may be accredited is for 12

residents. Another commenter stated that the majority of physicians

will settle within 100 miles of their residency training location and

suggested that programs which serve underserved rural areas should be

defined as:

(a) Any residency program with more than 10 health professional

shortage areas within 100 miles of the program;

(b) Residencies that have identified themselves prior to August 5,

1997 as having the mission of training rural physicians, and have

placed more than 10 percent of residents in the preceding 2 years in

rural underserved areas and more than 40 percent in rural areas; or

(c) Residencies within States where greater than 70 percent of the

land mass is rural; and

(d) Programs meeting the above qualifications and those located

within health professional shortage areas would be disqualified by

being in a community of greater than 100,000.

Response: We believe that the Congress enacted sections

1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and 1886(h)(4)(F) because of a concern about the

growing supply of physicians in combination with reports that the

United States may be training too many physicians for practice in the

21st century. The Conference Report accompanying the BBA states that

the ``conference agreement provides for a `cap' or limit on the number

of residents that may be reimbursed by the Secretary, on a national and

a facility level.'' At the same time, the Conference Report

acknowledged that the FTE caps could create problems in several

circumstances. Accordingly, the statute provides for special rules for

medical residency programs created on or after January 1, 1995, and

directs the Secretary to ``give special consideration to facilities

that meet the needs of rural underserved areas.''

Given the hospital specific FTE caps mandated by the statute and

the Conference Report language that the number of FTE residents paid

for by Medicare should not exceed current levels, we believe our policy

with regard to medical residency training programs created on or after

January 1, 1995, establishes an appropriate balance between the

competing goals of limiting the number of residents in training

nationally and making appropriate payments for necessary training.

Although we acknowledge that GME programs that provide a component of

training in rural areas also include significant training in hospitals

located in urban areas, we are concerned about the impact of providing

adjustments to the FTE limit for hospitals located in non-rural areas

until we have more experience with the current special rules. As we

stated above, we will make adjustments to the caps for rural hospitals

that establish new medical residency training programs and will allow

those hospitals to affiliate with hospitals in nonrural areas. Taken

together, these policies allow rural hospitals, in combination with

urban hospitals, to establish training programs which can receive

Medicare payment for direct and indirect GME. Finally, based on a

review of the 1997/1998 Graduate Medical Education Directory, we would

note that, in limited circumstances, family practice programs of fewer

than 12 residents that focus on rural training may be accredited.

Comment: One commenter suggested that many osteopathic training

programs are located in underserved, urban areas called Empowerment

Zones and that these programs should receive a waiver from the FTE

caps. Another commenter recommends that exceptions be permitted for

urban hospitals serving underserved populations.

Response: As stated above, sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and

1886(h)(4)(F) cap the number of osteopathic and allopathic physicians a

hospital may include in its FTE count. Section 1886(h)(4)(H)(i)

requires the Secretary to prescribe special rules for application of

the cap and the 3-year rolling average for medical residency training

programs created on or after January 1, 1995, and states that the

Secretary should give special consideration to hospitals that meet the

needs of rural underserved areas in drafting these rules. The statute

includes osteopathic medical residency training programs in the FTE

caps and the Secretary is directed by the statute to give special

preference only to rural underserved areas. Consistent with the

statute, we are providing for adjustment to FTE caps for new medical

residency training programs created on or after January 1, 1995 and are

not providing for the types of adjustments suggested by these

commenters.

Comment: Several commenters noted that medicine is constantly

evolving, leading to new specialty training programs. According to the

commenters, new specialties do not necessarily replace old specialties

so absent explicit recognition of new specialties, the cap on resident

training will hamper the ability of teaching institutions to implement

new training programs without downsizing or eliminating existing

programs. The commenters urged HCFA, in consultation with the medical

profession, to look at constructive ways to address this issue.

Response: As we have stated earlier, sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and

(h)(4)(F) provide for limits on the number of

[[Page 26336]]

residents used in determining Medicare payment for indirect and direct

GME. It does not preclude hospitals from establishing new medical

training programs. Nevertheless, we do acknowledge that Medicare's

payments for GME may be important in decisionmaking about training and

the FTE caps mandated by the BBA may have an effect on the future

developments in GME training. These issues would be appropriate

consideration for Congress as well as the Medicare Payment Advisory

Commission and the National Bipartisan Commission on the Future of

Medicare. Section 4629 of the BBA requires the Medicare Payment

Advisory Commission to report on the ``extent Medicare payment policies

and other Federal policies regarding teaching hospitals and graduate

medical education should be changed.'' Section 4021 of the BBA creates

a National Bipartisan Commission on the Future of Medicare which is

required to ``make recommendations regarding the financing of graduate

medical education.''

Comment: One commenter stated that there are no instructions on how

to apply for an exception to the FTE cap.

Response: Hospitals seeking to receive payments under the rules for

a new medical residency training program should consult with and

provide supporting documentation to their fiscal intermediary.

4. Aggregate Direct GME FTE Limit for Affiliated Institutions

Section 1886(h)(4)(H)(ii) of the Act permits but does not require

the Secretary to prescribe rules that allow institutions that are

members of the same affiliated group (as defined by the Secretary) to

elect to apply the FTE resident limit on an aggregate basis. This

provision would permit hospitals flexibility in structuring rotations

within a combined cap when they share residents.

a. Definition of affiliated group. Pursuant to the broad authority

conferred by the statute, in the August 29, 1997 final rule with

comment period, we established criteria to define ``affiliated group''.

We defined ``affiliated group'' as

Hospitals in the same geographic wage area that rotate

residents to other hospitals of the group during the course of the

approved program; or

Hospitals that are not located in the same geographic wage

area and are jointly listed as ``major participating institutions'' as

that term is used in the Graduate Medical Education Directory for one

or more programs.

Comment: Some commenters requested that we clarify whether the term

geographic wage area included reclassification for purposes of the wage

index or the national standardized amounts or both. These commenters

have questioned whether ``geographic wage area'' means a metropolitan

statistical area (MSA) before the effect of reclassification and some

commenters were unsure whether the term geographic wage area included

the effect of reclassification for the standardized amount or the wage

index or both.

Response: For purposes of defining an affiliated group, we are

using the terms ``urban area'' and ``rural area'' before the effect of

geographic reclassification under part 412. To avoid further confusion,

we are revising Sec. 413.86(b) to use the terms ``urban area'' and

``rural area'' (as those terms are defined in Sec. 412.62(f)) for the

purpose of defining an affiliated group. Section 412.62(f) states that

an urban area means a metropolitan statistical area or New England

County Metropolitan Area as defined by the Executive Office of

Management and Budget. A rural area means any area outside of an urban

area.

Comment: Some commenters recommended allowing hospitals to be part

of an affiliated group if they are located in the same State or located

in contiguous geographic wage areas.

Response: We agree with this recommendation and are revising the

criteria specified in Sec. 413.86(b) as follows. Specifically, we are

revising this section to provide that hospitals in the same urban area

or a contiguous urban area may be part of the same affiliated group if

the hospitals participate jointly in training residents in at least one

training program. If a hospital is located in a rural area, it may

affiliate with any hospital in which it jointly participates in

training residents in the same rural area or a contiguous area.

Comment: Many commenters disagreed with the limitation of

affiliated group to geographic areas. Some commenters stated that

hospital systems today are geographically diverse, the wage area

distinction is dysfunctional, and the requirement that hospitals be

located in the same geographic wage area or jointly listed as major

participating institutions in the Graduate Medical Education Directory

is too limited. These commenters requested that the wage area and joint

listing requirements be eliminated.

Response: The criteria we established to determine whether two or

more hospitals qualify to be an affiliated group were designed to

identify hospitals that have relationships for training residents and

to allow those hospitals to continue to have the flexibility to rotate

residents under an aggregate FTE cap. By focusing on hospitals that

rotate residents within a geographic area and on whether they are

recognized for jointly participating in residency training by the

accrediting body, we are identifying hospitals that are affiliated for

purposes of GME training. We believe that our approach for identifying

hospitals that require flexibility under an aggregate FTE cap is

reasonable and consistent with section 1886(h)(5)(H) of the Act, which

provides the Secretary with authority to define hospitals that are

members of the same affiliated group. We believe that the geographic

boundary provided by an urban or rural area is an appropriate basis

upon which to identify hospitals that share residents for purposes of

GME training. We agree, however, that focusing solely on hospitals

located within an MSA is limiting and are making the qualifying

criteria for being members of the same affiliated group less

restrictive. Under this final rule, we are allowing hospitals to be

members of the same affiliated group which jointly participate in

residency training and are located in the same or a contiguous MSA or

the same rural area and a contiguous area.

Comment: One commenter stated that the rules regarding ``major

participating institution'' are disadvantageous to residency programs

in small towns and relatively small geographic wage areas because the

definition of ``major participating institution'' requires that the

hospital provide rotations of at least one-sixth of the program length

or 6 months. Since rural hospitals are more likely to sponsor shorter

rotations, hospitals in rural areas would be much less able to meet the

criteria to become part of an affiliated group. The commenter believes

this does not meet with Congressional intent to provide special

consideration for rural areas.

Response: As discussed above, we are modifying the definition of

affiliated group to permit affiliations between hospitals located in

rural areas and hospitals located in an area contiguous to the rural

area.

Comment: Some commenters recommended allowing entities under common

ownership or part of the same ``system'' to be an affiliated group for

purposes of aggregating their caps. Another commenter recommended

creating an additional ``affiliated group'' definition that would allow

aggregation of FTE residents for hospitals under common ownership and

operation with one or more medical schools (the program sponsors)

provided such

[[Page 26337]]

hospitals are within the geographic border of a single state. Another

commenter suggested that hospitals that certify they operate as a

single health care system should be considered an affiliated group,

regardless of the hospitals' geographic locations. These systems

functionally operate coordinated and centrally controlled GME programs

and often rotate their residents among their various facilities

depending on training needs and other considerations.

Response: We agree with the commenters who suggested that hospitals

that are under common ownership should be permitted to be part of the

same affiliated group regardless of geographic boundaries and are

modifying Sec. 413.86(b) accordingly.

Comment: One commenter stated that Medicare's related party

principle should be a basis for defining affiliated group because that

would allow hospitals to better manage training of residents.

Response: We do not agree that Medicare's related party principle

should govern which hospitals qualify to be part of the same affiliated

group. The criteria for being part of an affiliated group are intended

to identify a relationship among hospitals for sharing residents. The

related party principle is used under principles of Medicare cost

reimbursement to determine the costs of a related party which may be

claimed on a hospital's cost report. Under the related party principle,

hospitals may claim costs of a related party which may not be a

hospital. For instance, a hospital may include the costs of a related

medical school on its cost report. Since the related party principle is

used in determining which costs of a related party a hospital is

entitled to claim and is not indicative of joint participation in a

training program, we do not believe the related party principle is

appropriate criteria for determining whether hospitals may be part of

the same affiliated group.

Comment: One commenter stated that the ``affiliation'' policy

should allow for situations where not all affiliated institutions

choose to elect to apply for an aggregate cap.

Response: Hospitals that could qualify to be part of an affiliated

group do not have to affiliate. As we describe in more detail below,

for purposes of applying an aggregate cap hospitals must affiliate by

explicit agreement. If a hospital does not affiliate, that hospital

will remain subject to a cap based on its FTE count in its most recent

cost reporting period ending on or before December 31, 1996. The

aggregate cap will only be applied for hospitals that elect to be part

of an affiliated group.

Comment: Other commenters suggested that unrelated hospitals that

jointly sponsor programs should be allowed to be part of the same

affiliated group.

Response: Under our regulations, common sponsorship will qualify

two or more hospitals to be part of the same affiliated group. We are

revising Sec. 413.86(b) to clarify that hospitals that are jointly

listed for one or more medical residency training programs in the

Graduate Medical Education Directory as a sponsor, primary clinical

site or major participating institution may qualify to be an affiliated

group for purposes of an aggregate FTE cap.

Comment: Many commenters stated that program sponsors should be

able to make decisions about where training should occur and the

hospital FTE caps should be adjusted accordingly. Several commenters

stated that hospitals in an affiliated group should be allowed to

arrange residencies in the manner that best fits their community. One

commenter stated that we should permit adjustments to caps to reflect

rotations resulting from restructuring training programs brought about

by changes in provider affiliations, giving preference to the

sponsoring teaching hospital to subsume residency positions that were

previously in affiliated institutions.

Response: Although we agree that program sponsors are likely the

best qualified to determine how and where training should occur, we do

not believe that it would be appropriate to allow hospital specific

adjustments to FTE caps based on unilateral decisions by program

sponsors or the hospital which sponsors the training program. In

situations where the sponsor of the program is a medical school and not

a hospital, we do not believe it would be appropriate to make

adjustments to hospital FTE caps based on the decision of an entity

that has no relationship to the Medicare program. Furthermore, since

medical schools do not provide cost reports or counts of FTE residents

to Medicare, we do not believe there would be an appropriate mechanism

for making adjustments to hospital FTE caps under the aggregate caps if

decisions regarding affiliations and adjustments are not being made by

hospitals. We would also note that hospitals may be involved in many

medical residency training programs involving different program

directors. Making adjustments to hospital caps based on the decisions

of multiple people within the hospital would not be administratively

feasible. Further, since hospitals may not sponsor all of the programs

they participate in, we do not believe that it is appropriate to make

downward adjustments in a hospital's FTE cap based on a unilateral

decision of another hospital.

Comment: Several commenters noted that the Graduate Medical

Education Directory does not include osteopathic training programs and

requested a reference to an official listing of American Osteopathic

Association approved training programs.

Response: We agree with the commenters who suggested that the

regulation needs a comparable reference for osteopathic medical

residency training programs to the Graduate Medical Education

Directory, which only lists allopathic training programs. Medical

residency programs accredited by the American Osteopathic Association

are listed in a publication called Opportunities, Directory of

Osteopathic Postdoctoral Programs. For purposes of this final rule, if

two hospitals are not located in the same MSA or a contiguous MSA, they

may qualify to be part of the same affiliated group if the hospitals

are jointly listed for one or more programs in Opportunities as the

sponsor or under the heading ``affiliations and outside rotations''

(413.86(b)).

Comment: One commenter stated that the American Osteopathic

Association is requiring all accredited osteopathic GME programs to be

part of an osteopathic postdoctoral training institution (OPTI) by July

1, 1999. There are several hospitals that are currently participating

in an approved OPTI. The commenter was concerned that the OPTI is a

consortium of providers and these consortia would not qualify as an

affiliated group. The commenter recommended that HCFA recognize a

formally organized osteopathic GME consortia without geographic limit.

Further, the commenter stated that any affiliation should be recognized

for aggregation purposes even if the hospitals are not in the same

geographic wage area.

Response: We have reviewed materials regarding the OPTI concept

from the American Osteopathic Association and note that an OPTI may

include an ``associate institution'' that provides 6 months or more of

training per year and an ``affiliate institution'' where less than 6

months of rotations per year are occurring. Since the OPTI concept is

not yet fully implemented, we believe it would be premature to begin

recognizing institutions which are part of an OPTI under the definition

of affiliated groups for purposes of an aggregate FTE cap. However, we

will continue to evaluate whether hospitals

[[Page 26338]]

participating in an OPTI could be part of an affiliated group, and we

will specifically focus on the duration of rotations among hospitals

within the OPTI in making this decision.

Comment: Several commenters stated that accreditation requirements

mandated an increase in their hospital's FTE resident count due to the

transfer of residents from a Veterans Affairs Medical Center or a

Department of Defense facility. These commenters stated that an

exception to the FTE cap should be allowed when a hospital's resident

count increased in situations where the aggregate count of residents

among the affiliated hospitals, including Veterans' Affairs Medical

Centers, remains unchanged. Other commenters recommended that HCFA give

program sponsors the ability to transfer residents from Veterans

Affairs' hospitals to non-Veterans' Affairs hospitals.

Response: Sections 1886(d)(5)(B)(v) and (h)(4)(F) of the Act

provide for FTE caps on the basis of a hospital's most recent cost

reporting period ending on or before December 31, 1996. Section

1886(h)(4)(H) of the Act allows hospitals that are part of the same

affiliated group to apply the FTE cap on an aggregate basis. Veterans'

Affairs and Department of Defense hospitals do not have cost reporting

periods for Medicare payment purposes and do not provide data on FTE

resident counts to Medicare. We believe that hospitals that do not

participate in Medicare should not be part of an affiliated group since

the statute caps the number of residents based on the number of

residents reported by the hospital in its Medicare cost reporting

periods. In addition, hospitals that do not participate in Medicare do

not submit cost reports to a fiscal intermediary; therefore, we would

be unable to apply an aggregate FTE cap to an affiliated group that

included these hospitals.

In summary, we are defining an affiliated group as follows:

Hospitals in the same urban area or in contiguous urban

areas which rotate residents to other hospitals of the group during the

course of the program year;

Hospitals located in the same rural area or in contiguous

rural and urban areas that rotate residents to other hospitals of the

group during the course of the program year; or

Hospitals that are--

--Jointly listed as the sponsor, primary clinical site or major

participating institution as those terms are used in the Graduate

Medical Education Directory for one or more programs; or

--Jointly listed as the program sponsor or under affiliations and

outside rotations in Opportunities, the directory of osteopathic

graduate medical education programs; or

Hospitals which are under common ownership.

b. Application of the FTE caps to an affiliated group. In the

August 29, 1997 final rule, we addressed application of the FTE cap for

hospitals which are members of the same affiliated group. Hospitals

which qualify to be part of the same affiliated group may elect to have

the individual FTE caps applied on an aggregate basis. This means that

we would apply a cap to the group as a whole, and the cap for the group

would equal the sum of the individual FTE caps for all hospitals that

are part of the affiliated group. Indirect and direct graduate medical

education payment would be based on hospital specific FTE counts under

an aggregate FTE cap. In the August 29, 1997 final rule with comment

period, we stated that the aggregate FTE cap for an affiliated group

would be applied on an institution-wide basis. We recognize that

hospitals may participate in many different speciality programs and may

share residents for one specialty program with one hospital but share

residents for a different program with another hospital, but we did not

believe it would be administratively feasible to apply the FTE cap on a

program by program basis. That is, the aggregate cap under the August

29, 1997 final rule with comment period would be the combined

individual caps of each hospital that elects to be part of an

affiliated group

Comment: One commenter stated that hospitals may have rotation

relationships with a number of different hospitals. According to these

commenters, aggregation of resident counts among all hospitals is not

practical or feasible. Many commenters suggested that we should permit

hospitals to aggregate resident numbers at the program level if the

hospitals provide supporting documentation that the aggregate count of

residents within the program remains unchanged. One commenter who

supported affiliations at the program level stated that HCFA should

require hospitals to report FTEs by program sponsor and include a

separate count of each program on the Medicare cost report. Hospitals

would have multiple FTE caps and would be responsible for reconciling

each individual program cap with the intermediary. Several commenters

stated that HCFA should allow affiliated hospitals to transfer programs

and that each hospital's cap be adjusted based on a joint letter from

the affected providers.

Response: As we stated in the August 29, 1997 final rule with

comment period, we recognize that many hospitals may share residents

for particular specialty programs. We stated that hospital affiliations

must be on an institution-wide basis because of our concern about the

administrative feasibility of allowing affiliations on a program-by-

program basis. Although we continue to have concerns that program

specific affiliations may generate enormous complexity in monitoring

FTE resident counts for fiscal intermediaries and may impose

significant documentation burdens on hospitals, we agree with the

commenters that it would be appropriate for Medicare to accommodate

agreements between individual hospitals for specific programs. A

hospital could have an agreement with one hospital for a particular

program and another hospital for a different program. An agreement

between two hospitals does not mean only those hospitals are an

affiliated group, if those hospitals also have agreements with other

hospitals. Rather, the affiliated group includes the original two

hospitals that have an agreement and every hospital that has an

agreement with any of those hospitals. We will continue to apply the

FTE cap on an aggregate basis for institutions that are part of an

affiliated group. That is, we will combine the individual caps for each

institution that has an agreement to be an affiliated group to verify

that the sum total of the resident counts for all institutions does not

exceed the aggregate cap. We will make payment to individual hospitals

based on hospital specific FTE counts.

Each agreement must specify the adjustment to each hospital's FTE

counts from the cost reporting period ending during calendar year 1996

for purposes of applying the aggregate FTE cap for the period of the

agreement. The agreements must specify the adjustment to the IME and

direct GME FTE counts separately since hospitals are subject to two

different FTE counts for each respective cap. Since medical residency

training programs generally follow a July 1 to June 30 residency

training year, each agreement should specify adjustments to FTE counts

on a 12-month basis from July 1 to June 30 of each year. The agreements

must be for a minimum of one program year but may be for more than one

year. A hospital will be permitted to engage in multiple agreements

with different hospitals as illustrated below. For example, hospital A

can have an agreement with hospital B for an

[[Page 26339]]

internal medicine program and another agreement with hospital C for

emergency medicine. Although hospitals B and C do not have an agreement

for any program, the affiliated group is A, B, and C, we will apply the

cap on an aggregate basis for A, B, and C; that is the FTE resident

counts at hospitals A, B, and C can not exceed the sum of the combined

caps for the three hospitals.

If the combined FTE counts for hospitals A, B, and C does not

exceed the aggregate cap, we will pay each hospital based on its

hospital specific FTE count. If the combined FTE counts for hospitals

A, B, and C exceed the aggregate cap, we need individual caps for each

hospital in order to limit payment to the number of FTEs included under

the aggregate FTE cap. In this situation, each hospital will be paid

based on its actual FTE up to its individual FTE cap as adjusted per

agreements. We will allow each respective institution's individual cap

to reflect the adjustment per their individual agreements. However, we

are requiring that agreements regarding application of the aggregate

cap planned for the year be completed by the beginning of each

residency training year (that is, July 1). The hospitals in the

affiliated group may adjust the initial FTE counts by June 30 of each

residency training year if actual FTE counts for the program year are

different than projected in the original agreement.

If a hospital cost report does not correspond with a July 1 to June

30 residency training year, we will prorate the changes specified in

the agreement to each hospital's FTE cap on the basis of a cost

reporting period. In the example illustrated below, there is an

agreement between hospitals A and B to allow hospital A an additional

10 residents that were previously included in hospital B's FTE count.

Hospital B also has an agreement with hospital C to allow hospital B an

additional five residents previously counted by hospital C. We are also

assuming that these agreements are for two years. The aggregate FTE cap

for hospitals A, B, and C will be the combined FTE cap for the these

hospitals. For instance, if hospital A, B, and C each have an FTE cap

of 100 residents, the aggregate cap will be 300 residents. The cap will

be applied as follows per the planned changes assuming hospital A has a

July 1 to June 30 cost reporting period and hospital B has a October 1

to September 30 cost reporting period and hospital C has a calendar

year cost report:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Planned change

Planned change in FTE for cost

Hospital Cost reporting period count (for 07/01-06/30) reporting

period

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hospital A.............................. 07/01/98-6/30/99.......... +10 per agreement with B.. +10.00

Hospital B.............................. 10/01/97-09/30/98......... -10 per agreement with A.. -2.50

10/01/98-9/30/99.......... .......................... -10.00

Hospital B..............................

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.