Codes and Standards: IEEE National Consensus Standard

Federal RegisterApr 23, 1998

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

10 CFR Part 50

RIN 3150-AF96

Codes and Standards: IEEE National Consensus Standard

AGENCY: Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

ACTION: Proposed rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is proposing an

amendment to its regulations that would incorporate by reference IEEE

Std. 603-1991, ``Criteria for Safety Systems for Nuclear Power

Generating Stations,'' a national consensus standard for power,

instrumentation, and control portions of safety systems in nuclear

power plants. This action is necessary to endorse the latest version of

this national consensus standard in NRC's regulations.

DATES: Comments on the proposed rule must be received on or before May

26, 1998. Comments received after this date will be considered if it is

practical to consider them, but the NRC is able to ensure consideration

only for comments received on or before this date.

ADDRESSES: Mail comments to: Secretary, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory

Commission, Washington, DC 20555-0001; Attention: Rulemakings and

Adjudications Staff. Hand deliver comments to 11555 Rockville Pike,

Rockville, Maryland, between 7:30 am and 4:15 pm on Federal workdays.

Copies of any comments received may be examined at the NRC Public

Document Room, 2120 L Street NW. (Lower Level), Washington, D.C.

You may also submit comments via the NRC's interactive rulemaking

web site through the NRC Home Page (http://www.nrc.gov). From the NRC

home page, select ``Rulemaking'' from the tool bar. The interactive

rulemaking website can then be accessed by selecting ``New Rulemaking

Website.'' This site provides the availability to upload comments as

files (any format), if your web browser supports that function. For

information about the interactive rulemaking web site, contact Ms.

Carol Gallagher at 301-415-5905 (e-mail: [email protected]).

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Satish K. Aggarwal, Senior Program

Manager, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Washington, DC 20555-0001;

telephone 301-415-6005; Fax 301-415-5074; e-mail:[email protected].

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Previous History

On October 17, 1997 (62 FR 53932), NRC published a direct final

rule in the Federal Register that amended its regulations to

incorporate by reference IEEE Std. 603-1991 for power, instrumentation,

and control portions of safety systems in nuclear power plants. The

direct final rule was withdrawn on December 23, 1997 (62 FR 66977),

because the NRC received significant adverse comments in response to

the proposed rule that was issued as a companion to the direct final

rule on October 17, 1997 (62 FR 53975). The NRC has considered the

comments it received, revised the proposed rule, and is reissuing a

second proposed rule to give the public another opportunity to comment.

This proposed rule supersedes the October 17, 1997, proposed rule.

Background

10 CFR Part 50, ``Domestic Licensing of Production and Utilization

Facilities,'' Sec. 50.55a (h) requires that the protection systems in

nuclear power plants meet the requirements stated in IEEE Std. 279,

``Criteria for Protection Systems for Nuclear Power Generating

Stations,'' in effect on the formal docket date of the application.

However, IEEE has withdrawn IEEE Std. 279-1971 and it has now been

superseded by IEEE Std. 603-1991, ``Criteria for Safety Systems for

Nuclear Power Generating Stations.''

In November 1995, the NRC staff issued a draft regulatory guide for

public comment, DG-1042, which was a proposed Revision 1 to Regulatory

Guide 1.153, ``Criteria for Safety Systems.'' This draft regulatory

guide proposed to endorse IEEE Std. 603-1991 (including the correction

sheet dated January 30, 1995). There were no adverse comments to DG-

1042, and Revision 1 to Regulatory Guide 1.153 was issued in June 1996,

endorsing IEEE Std. 603-1991. Because of the absence of adverse public

comments to Revision 1 to Regulatory Guide 1.153, the NRC believed that

there was general public consensus that IEEE Std. 603-1991 provides

acceptable criteria for safety systems in nuclear power plants. For

this reason, the NRC published the direct final rule without seeking

public comments on the amendment before issuing it. In view of the

significant public comments received, the NRC has reconsidered this

action (See the discussion under Previous History).

Discussion

This proposed rule would incorporate a national consensus standard,

IEEE Std. 603-1991, into NRC regulations to establish minimal

functional and design requirements for power, instrumentation, and

control portions of safety systems for nuclear power plants. This

action would be consistent with the provisions of the National

Technology Transfer and Advancement Act of 1995, Public Law 104-113,

which encourages Federal regulatory agencies to consider adopting

industry consensus standards as an alternative to de novo agency

development of standards affecting an industry. This action would also

be consistent with the NRC policy of evaluating the latest versions of

national consensus standards in terms of their suitability for

endorsement by regulations or regulatory guides.

Currently, 10 CFR 50.55a(h) specifies that ``protection systems''

for plants with construction permits issued after January 1, 1971, must

meet the requirements in IEEE Std. 279 in effect on the formal docket

date of the application for a construction permit.

IEEE Std. 279-1971 states that a ``protection system'' encompasses

all electric and mechanical devices and circuitry (from sensors to

actuation device input terminals) involved in generating those signals

associated with the protective function. These signals include those

that actuate reactor trip and that, in the event of a serious reactor

accident, actuate engineered safety features (ESFs), such as

containment isolation, core spray, safety injection, pressure

reduction, and air cleaning. ``Protective function'' is defined in IEEE

Std. 279-1971 as ``the sensing of one or more variables associated with

a particular generating station condition, signal processing, and

[[Page 20137]]

the initiation and completion of the protective action at values of the

variables established in the design bases.''

IEEE Std. 603-1991 uses the term ``safety systems'' rather than

``protection systems.'' A ``safety system'' is defined in IEEE Std.

603-1991 as ``a system that is relied upon to remain functional during

and following design basis events to ensure: (i) the integrity of the

reactor coolant pressure boundary, (ii) the capability to shut down the

reactor and maintain it in a safe shutdown condition, or (iii) the

capability to prevent or mitigate the consequences of accidents that

could result in potential off-site exposures comparable to the 10 CFR

Part 100 guidelines.'' A ``safety function'' is defined in IEEE Std.

603-1991 as ``one of the processes or conditions (for example,

emergency negative reactivity insertion, post-accident heat removal,

emergency core cooling, post-accident radioactivity removal, and

containment isolation) essential to maintain plant parameters within

acceptable limits established for a design basis event.''

The NRC recognizes that ``protection systems'' are a subset of

``safety systems.'' Safety system is a broad-based and all-encompassing

term, embracing the protection system in addition to other electrical

systems. Thus, the term ``protection system'' is not synonymous with

the term ``safety system.'' The proposed rule would not change the

scope of the systems covered in the final safety analysis report (FSAR)

for currently operating nuclear power plants, whether or not they

intend to make system-level replacements of protection systems.

This proposed rule would mandate the use of IEEE Std. 603-1991

(including the correction sheet dated January 30, 1995) for safety

systems for future nuclear power plants, including final design

approvals, design certifications, and combined licenses under 10 CFR

Part 52 . Current licensees may continue to meet the requirements

stated in the edition or revision of IEEE Std. 279 in effect on the

formal date of their application for a construction permit or may, at

their option, use IEEE Std. 603-1991, provided they comply with all

applicable requirements for making changes to their licensing basis.

However, system-level replacements of protection systems and addition

of new safety systems in operating nuclear power plants initiated on or

after January 1, 1999, would be required to meet the requirements in

IEEE Std. 603-1991. A ``system'' is defined as a combination of two or

more interrelated components that perform a specific safety function.

The protection systems are listed in the plant's FSAR. For example,

``neutron monitoring system'' is a protection system. The upgrade of

the average power range monitor (APRM) portion of the neutron

monitoring system to add the ability to detect and suppress potential

boiling-water reactor (BWR) instabilty may meet IEEE Std. 279 because

the modification only replaces the APRM signal processing components,

output relays, recirculation flow transmitters, and operator displays.

If this modification were to replace the neutron detectors, local power

range monitor cards, and associated power supplies, the modification

would be considered a complete replacement at a system level and must

meet IEEE Std. 603-1991. Similarly, the replacement of the source range

monitors and intermediate range monitors in a BWR with wide-range

neutron monitors must meet IEEE Std. 603-1991, because it involves the

complete replacement of the system, including sensors, preamps, signal

processors, output relays, and operator displays. Reuse of a few

existing components (e.g., selected cables, raceway, and control room

panels where the displays are mounted) as part of the system-level

replacement would still place this type of modification in the category

of a complete system-level replacement.

IEEE Std. 603-1991 references several industry codes and standards.

Unless these referenced standards are specifically incorporated by

reference elsewhere in the NRC regulations, they do not represent the

Commission's mandatory requirements. If the referenced standard has

been endorsed in a regulatory guide, the standard constitutes a method

acceptable to the NRC of meeting a regulatory requirement as described

in the regulatory guide. If a referenced standard has not been endorsed

in a regulatory guide, the licensees and applicants may consider and

use the information in the referenced standard in a manner that is

consistent with current regulatory practices.

Significant Comments on the Direct Final Rule

The NRC received 28 letters from the public by December 8, 1997,

commenting on the content of the direct final rule. Copies of comment

letters are available for public inspection and copying for a fee at

the NRC's Public Document Room. The major issues raised by the comments

and the NRC staff responses to these issues are as follows:

(1) Referenced Standards.

Issue. There are approximately 100 ``shalls'' in IEEE Std. 603-

1991, which refer to 13 other IEEE standards, 3 ANS/ANSI standards, and

1 ISA standard. This rule would require a full redesign of the plant,

if licensees are required to comply with these referenced standards.

Response. Because the NRC did not seek for any of the other

standards referenced in IEEE Std. 603-1991 to be approved for

incorporation by reference, these standards are not mandatory

requirements, even though IEEE Std. 603-1991 invokes the referenced

standards by the use of ``shall.'' However, the NRC encourages

licensees to adopt these referenced standards voluntarily because these

newer consensus standards reflect progress and the current state of

technology. If a referenced standard has been endorsed in a regulatory

guide, the standard constitutes a method acceptable to the NRC for

meeting a regulatory requirement as described in the regulatory guide.

In many cases, the regulatory guides endorse a previous version of the

IEEE standard. These guides represent the current NRC recommended

practices. Licensees may opt to use alternate approaches if they can

provide sufficient technical bases.

(2) Scope: Protection System vs. Safety System.

Issue. The terms ``protection systems'' and ``safety systems'' are

not synonymous.

Response. The NRC staff agrees that protection systems are a subset

of safety systems and thus, the terms are not synonymous. The term

protection system is defined in IEEE Std. 279-1971 (and in IEEE Std.

603-1991), and the term safety system is defined in IEEE Std. 603-1991.

The NRC staff endorses these definitions. The protection system has a

limited application; safety system is broad based and all-encompassing,

thereby embracing the protection system and other electrical systems.

This proposed rule would not change the applicable scope of the systems

for operating nuclear power plants.

(3) Applicability of Rule.

Issue. The rule does not explicitly state that it does not apply to

nuclear power plants with construction permits issued before January 1,

1971.

Response. Nuclear power plants that have not been required to meet

IEEE Std. 279-1971, because their construction permit was issued before

January 1, 1971, may continue to make modifications or changes to

components and subsystems, consistent with their licensing basis and

commitments made to the NRC, or may meet the requirements stated in

IEEE Std. 603-1991. However, the proposed rule

[[Page 20138]]

would mandate the use of IEEE Std. 603-1991 for system-level

replacements of protection systems and for the addition of new safety

systems.

(4) Changes: Components vs System Level.

Issue. The rule would result in a dual licensing basis within a

system and would introduce significant confusion, because IEEE Std.

603-1991 was written as a system standard. Replacements of components

or subsystems should not be covered by the rule.

Response. The proposed rule would not result in a dual licensing

basis within a system, because it would apply only to system-level

replacements of protection systems and the addition of new safety

systems. Modifications or changes to components and subsystems shall

meet the current requirements of IEEE Std. 279, when applicable, but

need not meet the requirements of IEEE Std. 603-1991.

Finding of No Environmental Impact: Availability of Environmental

Assessment

The NRC has determined under the National Environmental Policy Act

of 1969, as amended, and the NRC's regulations in subpart A of 10 CFR

Part 51, that because this proposed rule would not be a major Federal

action significantly affecting the quality of the human environment, an

environmental impact statement is not required. The NRC has prepared an

environmental assessment supporting this finding of no significant

environmental impact.

The NRC has sent a copy of the environmental assessment and a copy

of the Federal Register notice to every State liaison officer and

requested their comments on the environmental assessment. The

environmental assessment is available for inspection at the NRC Public

Document Room, 2120 L Street, NW., Washington, D.C. Also, the NRC has

committed itself to complying in all its actions with Presidential

Executive Order 12898, ``Federal Actions To Address Environmental

Justice in Minority Populations and Low-Income Populations'' (February

11, 1994). Therefore, the NRC also has determined that there are no

disproportionate, high, and adverse impacts on minority and low-income

populations. The NRC uses the following working definition of

environmental justice: Environmental justice means the fair treatment

and meaningful involvement of all people--regardless of race,

ethnicity, culture, income, or educational level--with respect to the

development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws,

regulations, and policies.

Paperwork Reduction Act Statement

This proposed rule does not contain a new or amended information

collection requirement subject to the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995

(44 U.S.C. 3501, et seq.). Existing requirements were approved by the

Office of Management and Budget, Approval No. 3150-0011.

Public Protection Notification

If an information collection does not display a currently valid OMB

control number, the NRC may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not

required to respond to, the information collection.

Regulatory Analysis

The NRC has prepared a regulatory analysis that shows the proposed

amendment does not impose any new requirements or costs on current

licensees who do not make changes to protection systems. However,

licensees planning or proposing system-level replacements of protection

systems will be affected because they will be required to meet the

requirements of IEEE Std. 603-1991 for system level replacements. This

impact would be minimal. Most changes to protection systems only change

a part of the system, and IEEE Std. 279-1971 will continue to apply.

The draft regulatory analysis is available for inspection in the NRC

Public Document Room, 2120 L Street NW., Washington, DC.

Regulatory Flexibility Certification

As required by the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 (5 U.S.C. 605

(b)), the NRC certifies that this rule, if adopted, would not have a

significant economic impact on small entities. This rule affects only

the operation of nuclear power plants. The companies that own these

plants do not fall within the scope of the definition of ``small

entities'' stated in the Regulatory Flexibility Act or the small

business size standards adopted by the NRC (10 CFR 2.810). Because

these companies are dominant in their service areas, this rule does not

fall within the purview of the act.

Backfit Analysis

The proposed rule would require applicants and holders of new

construction permits, new operating licenses, new final design

certifications, and combined licenses to comply with IEEE Std. 603-1991

(including the correction sheet dated January 30, 1995). System-level

replacements to protection systems in existing operating plants

initiated on or after January 1, 1999, would be required to meet the

requirements of IEEE Std. 603-1991. IEEE Std. 279 will continue to

apply to those nuclear power plants required to meet IEEE Std. 279 that

do not make system-level replacements of protection systems, but the

rule permits the licensee the option of meeting IEEE Std. 603-1991.

The backfit rule was not intended to apply to regulatory actions

that change expectations of prospective applicants and, therefore, the

backfit rule does not apply to the portion of the rule applicable to

new construction permits, new operating licenses, new final design

approvals, new design certifications, and combined licenses. This

proposed rule would not change the licensing basis (i.e., IEEE Std.

279) for plants that do not intend to make any changes to their power

and instrumentation and control systems. However, the proposed rule

would require future system-level replacements of existing power and

instrumentation and control portions of protection systems to comply

with the new standard. This would not be considered a backfit, because

the changes are voluntarily initiated by the licensee, or separately

imposed by the NRC after a separate backfit analysis. This is

consistent with past NRC practice and the discussions on backfitting in

the Value-Impact Statement prepared for Revision 1 to Regulatory Guide

1.153. A copy of the Value-Impact Statement is available for inspection

or copying for a fee in the NRC's Public Document Room at 2120 L

Street, NW., Washington, DC, under Task DG-1042.

In summary, the NRC has determined that the backfit rule, 10 CFR

50.109, does not apply to this rule because it does not impose any

backfits as defined in 10 CFR 50.109(a)(1) and, therefore, a backfit

analysis has not been prepared for this proposed rule.

List of Subjects in 10 CFR Part 50

Antitrust, Classified information, Criminal penalties, Fire

protection, Incorporation by reference, Intergovernmental relations,

Nuclear power plants and reactors, Radiation protection, Reactor siting

criteria, and Reporting and recordkeeping requirements.

For the reasons stated in the preamble and under the authority of

the Atomic Energy Act of 1954, as amended, the Energy Reorganization

Act of 1974, as amended, the Energy Reorganization Act of 1974, as

amended, and 5 U.S.C., the NRC is proposing to adopt the following

amendment to 10 CFR Part 50.

[[Page 20139]]

PART 50--DOMESTIC LICENSING OF PRODUCTION AND UTILIZATION

FACILITIES

1. The authority citation for Part 50 continues to read as follows:

Authority: Secs. 102, 103, 104, 105, 161, 182, 183, 186, 189, 68

Stat. 936, 937, 938, 948, 953, 954, 955, 956, as amended, sec. 234,

83 Stat. 1244, as amended (42 U.S.C. 2132, 2133, 2134, 2135, 2201,

2232, 2233, 2236, 2239, 2282); secs. 201, as amended, 202, 206, 88

Stat. 1242, as amended, 1244, 1246 (42 U.S.C. 5841, 5842, 5846).

Section 50.7 also issued under Pub. L. 95-601, sec. 10, 92 Stat.

2951 (42 U.S.C. 5851). Section 50.10 also issued under secs. 101,

185, 68 Stat. 955 as amended (42 U.S.C. 2131, 2235), sec. 102, Pub.

L. 91-190, 83 Stat. 853 (42 U.S.C. 4332). Sections 50.13, and 50.54

(dd), and 50.103 also issued under sec. 108, 68 Stat. 939, as

amended (42 U.S.C. 2138), Sections 50.23, 50.35, 50.55, and 50.56

also issued under sec. 185, 68 Stat. 955 (42 U.S.C. 2235), Sections

50.33a, 50.55a and Appendix Q also issued under sec. 102, Pub. L.

91-190, 83 Stat. 853 (42 U.S.C. 4332). Sections 50.34 and 50.54 also

issued under sec. 204, 88 Stat. 1245 (42 U.S.C. 5844). Sections

50.58, 50.91, and 50.92 also issued under Pub. L. 97-415, 96 Stat.

2073 (42 U.S.C. 2239). Section 50.78 also issued under sec. 122, 68

Stat. 939 (42 U.S.C. 2152). Sections 50.80-50.81 also issued under

sec. 184, 68 Stat. 954, as amended (42 U.S.C. 2234). Appendix F also

issued under sec. 187, 68 Stat. 955 (42 U.S.C. 2237).

2. In Sec. 50.55a, paragraph (h) is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 50.55a Codes and standards.

* * * * *

(h) Protection and safety systems. (1) IEEE Std. 603-1991,

including the correction sheet dated January 30, 1995, which are

referenced in paragraphs (h)(2) and (h)(3) of this section, is approved

for incorporation by reference by the Director of the Office of the

Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a) and 1 CFR Part 51.

A notice of any changes made to the material incorporated by reference

will be published in the Federal Register. Copies of IEEE Std. 603-1991

may be purchased from the Institute of Electrical and Electronics

Engineers Service Center, 445 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ 08855. The

standard is also available for inspection at the NRC Library, 11545

Rockville Pike, Rockville, MD; and at the Office of the Federal

Register, 800 North Capitol Street, NW., Suite 700, Washington, D.C.

IEEE Std. 279, which is referenced in paragraph (h)(2) of this section,

was approved for incorporation by reference by the Director of the

Office of the Federal Register in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 552(a) and 1

CFR Part 51. Copies of this standard are also available as indicated

for IEEE Std. 603-1991.

(2) Protection systems. For nuclear power plants with construction

permits issued after January 1, 1971, but before January 1, 1999,

protection systems must meet the requirements stated in either IEEE

Std. 279, ``Criteria for Protection Systems for Nuclear Power

Generating Stations,'' or in IEEE Std. 603-1991, ``Criteria for Safety

Systems for Nuclear Power Generating Stations,'' and the correction

sheet dated January 30, 1995. For nuclear power plants with

construction permits issued before January 1, 1971, protection systems

must meet the requirements stated in IEEE Std. 603-1991 or be

consistent with their licensing basis. System-level replacement of

protection systems and addition of new safety systems in existing

operating nuclear power plants initiated on or after January 1, 1999,

must meet the requirements stated in IEEE Std. 603-1991 and the

correction sheet dated January 30, 1995.

(3) Safety systems. For construction permits, operating licenses,

final design approvals, design certifications, and combined licenses

issued on or after January 1, 1999, safety systems must meet the

requirements stated in IEEE Std. 603-1991 and the correction sheet

dated January 30, 1995.

Dated at Rockville, Maryland, this 17th day of April, 1998.

For the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.

John C. Hoyle,

Secretary of the Commission.

[FR Doc. 98-10842 Filed 4-22-98; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 7590-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.