Requests for Applications for the Pipeline Risk Management Demonstration Program

Federal RegisterMar 27, 1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

[Docket No. PS-142; Notice 5]

Requests for Applications for the Pipeline Risk Management

Demonstration Program

AGENCY: Office of Pipeline Safety, DOT.

ACTION: Notice of request for letters of intent.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Research and Special Programs Administration's (RSPA)

Office of Pipeline Safety (OPS) invites eligible pipeline operators to

submit Letters of Intent expressing interest in participating in its

Pipeline Risk Management Demonstration Program. This notice begins the

solicitation process by specifying a deadline and address for Letters

of Intent, by directing interested operators to supplementary guidance

documents, and by providing updated guidance for operators interested

in participating.

DATES: Letters of Intent will be accepted no later than July 25, 1997.

ADDRESSES: Letters of Intent should be sent to Richard B. Felder,

Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety, Research and Special

Programs Administration, Department of Transportation, Room 2335, 400

7th St., SW, Washington, DC, 20590.

SUPPLEMENTAL DOCUMENTS:

(1) Program Framework for Risk Management Demonstrations (61 FR

58605): Describes the processes by which OPS will receive, review,

approve, monitor, modify, and terminate company risk management

demonstration projects, and provides a description of the information a

company should include in its Letter of Intent. The guidance in the

Program Framework is current except where noted in Section II of this

notice. The significant information in the Program Framework is

contained in Appendix A of this document or available on the Internet

at OPS address http://ops.dot.gov.

(2) Interim Risk Management Program Standard: Describes the

essential elements and characteristics of a company's risk management

program. A Letter of Intent should include evidence that the company

will address all considerations raised in the Program Standard. It is

available by contacting Eben Wyman at (202)366-0918 or on Internet at

OPS address http://ops.dot.gov.

(3) Guidance on Performance Measures: Provides the basis for

participating companies and OPS to assess, through the demonstration

projects, whether risk management is an effective alternative to the

current regulatory environment; and to determine whether superior

public safety and environmental protection is being achieved. OPS

considers the performance measures proposed in the consultation process

to be critical to approving a demonstration project. Companies may

include proposed performance measures, if available, in their Letters

of Intent. The March 1997 guidance is available by contacting Eben

Wyman at (202)366-0918 or on Internet at http://opspm.volpe60.dot.gov.

(4) Risk Management Communications Plan: Outlines the processes to

enable all stakeholders (including OPS, companies, States, and local

officials) to exchange information about the goals, objectives, and

status of the Demonstration Program and individual projects. The

Communications Plan describes the information OPS intends to share with

stakeholders via local prospectuses once candidate companies are

selected for consultations. Companies may consult the Plan to ensure

their Letters of Intent contain sufficient information for the

prospectuses, and for guidance on local level communications the

company should conduct. OPS will continue to develop communications

with the public during the Demonstration Program. The Plan is available

by contacting Eben Wyman at (202)366-0918 or on Internet at OPS address

http://ops.dot.gov.

(5) Risk Management Training Curricula: Describes the content of

the risk management training that will be provided to industry and

regulator participants in the Demonstration Program. Companies who

submit Letters of Intent and who OPS identifies as candidates for

selection will be invited to participate in the training. The company

may request an orientation with the OPS personnel who will be assigned

to evaluate and monitor its demonstration project. An outline of the

curricula is available by contacting Eben Wyman at (202)366-0918 or on

Internet at OPS address http://ops.dot.gov.

(6) Proceedings from January 28, 1997 Public Meeting held at the

Hilton Riverside Hotel, New Orleans, LA: Record of OPS response to

public comment on elements of the Demonstration Program. Available by

contacting Eben Wyman at (202)366-0918, or on Internet at OPS address

http://ops.dot.gov. A summary of OPS comments at the public meeting is

contained in Appendix B of this notice.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Eben M. Wyman, (202) 366-0918, or by

E-mail ([email protected]), regarding the subject matter of this

document. Persons wishing to review previously submitted comments may

contact the RSPA Dockets Clerk, (202) 366-5046, U.S. Department of

Transportation, room 8421, 400 Seventh Street, SW, Washington, DC

20590. Inquiries should identify the docket number (PS-142). The

Dockets Facility is open from 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Monday through

Friday, except on Federal holidays when the facility is closed.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Overview

The Program Framework for Risk Management Demonstrations (Program

Framework)(61 FR 58605), published on November 15, 1996, describes the

Pipeline Risk Management Demonstration Program and its objectives and

statutory basis, and provides guidance for pipeline operators who may

wish to participate. The Demonstration Program will enable

participating pipeline operators to substitute compliance with the

provisions of an OPS-approved demonstration project for compliance with

existing pipeline safety standards. The objective of the Demonstration

Program is to test whether allowing operators the flexibility to

allocate safety resources through risk management is an effective way

to improve public safety, environmental protection, and reliability of

service. It will also provide data on how to administer risk management

as a permanent feature of the Federal pipeline safety program, should

risk management prove to be a viable regulatory alternative.

[[Page 14720]]

Guidance for participation by companies, regulators, and the public

in the Demonstration Program is contained in the documents referenced

at the front of this notice. OPS expects documents (1) through (5) will

be refined and improved as more is learned during the course of the

Program. OPS will report at least annually on the Program's progress,

via Federal Register notices, nationally broadcast two-way video

teleconferences, mailed updates on the individual project prospectuses,

and other means. By March 31, 2000, OPS will submit a Report to

Congress on the Demonstration Program status. A final report will be

issued in four years evaluating how effectively safety, environmental

protection, and reliability of service have been improved by

participating operators, the feasibility of risk management in general,

and recommending whether and in what form risk management should be

incorporated into the Federal pipeline safety program on a permanent

basis.

II. Modifications and Clarifications to Program Framework

The following modifications and clarifications to the Program

Framework for Risk Management Demonstrations are in response to public

comment to the docket, meetings with individual operators, national

public, environmental and other interested organizations, and continued

interaction with industry and the States through ``joint risk

management quality teams'' (JRAQT).

1. Window for submission of Letters of Intent

Companies considering participating in a demonstration project must

submit a Letter of Intent to OPS no later than July 25, 1997. This

provides operators a 120-day window, rather than the previously

published 60-day window.

2. Phased Selection of Demonstration Projects

OPS will likely select a few candidates for consultations before

the 120-day window for submission of Letters of Intent has closed. This

phased approach would allow OPS to better manage workload. OPS would

base these selections on evidence in the Letter of Intent that the

proposed demonstration project has a high likelihood of being approved

per the criteria described in the Program Framework.

3. Screening Criteria

As part of the screening criteria, previously described in the

Program Framework, OPS will favor companies with a demonstrated

commitment to risk management and a demonstrated ability to communicate

with OPS by, for example, being forthcoming with relevant data. OPS

will favor proposed projects that:

Are comprehensive, indicating a more systematic and

thorough assessment of risk and risk control options so that superior

protection can be achieved;

Provide a good opportunity to evaluate risk management as

a regulatory alternative; and

Contain distinguishing features, such as support from or a

pre-established relationship with local or stakeholders.

4. Informational Meetings with OPS

OPS is continuing its informational meetings at company sites to

discuss demonstration project concepts, to explore the potential for

more comprehensive project proposals, and to provide companies a better

understanding of Program objectives, opportunities, and the

administrative process and approach to application evaluation. In

addition to assisting companies with questions about risk management,

these meetings could position OPS to better plan the evaluation phase

of the Demonstration Program.

5. Local Distribution Companies (LDC) are Not Eligible to Participate

in the Current Demonstration Program

As stated in the Program Framework, eligibility for the current

Demonstration Program is limited to interstate natural gas transmission

and hazardous liquid pipeline companies. However, on February 26, 1997,

the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC)

Committee on Gas passed a Resolution supporting an LDC Risk Assessment

Quality Action Team to conduct a feasibility study of risk management

as a regulatory alternative.

6. Role of States in the Demonstration Program

In keeping with the statutory provision (49 US USC 60126(d)) that

allows the Department to provide for State consultation in the

Demonstration Program, OPS will contact State pipeline safety agencies

that may be affected by a proposed demonstration project to discuss the

extent of the State's involvement in the project. This could entail the

State providing input on geographic, socioeconomic, and other local

factors that the Project Review Team (PRT) should consider during its

consultation with an operator. It could also entail the State pipeline

safety agency acting as a conduit for other State agencies wishing to

provide input to the PRT. The State could serve, along with OPS and the

company, as a point-of-contact for members of the public providing

comments and raising questions. Should the State pipeline safety agency

choose not to participate in the Demonstration Program, OPS will find

alternative means of ensuring that the PRT considers input from other

State agencies and the public.

7. Meaning of ``Clear & Established Safety Record'' in Presidential

Directive

A Presidential directive to the Secretary of Transportation directs

the Secretary to limit risk management demonstration projects to those

pipeline operators that have clear and established records of

compliance with respect to safety and environmental protection. OPS

will review its records to determine if candidate companies have

historically met requirements of applicable State pipeline safety

regulations. Operators should have addressed all safety and

environmental protection actions prescribed by existing regulations and

orders, including consent orders and commitments for corrective action

made to OPS. OPS will consult with other agencies about their knowledge

of the company's safety and environmental compliance record. A company

may include in its Letter of Intent a statement identifying the

relationship of any ongoing prescribed actions to the proposed

demonstration project.

8. Role of Other Agencies

At the annual National Response Team (NRT) Regional Response Team

(RRT) Co-chairs' meeting in February, 1997, OPS invited the 15 State

NRT agencies to participate in the Demonstration Program. Once OPS

announces the candidate demonstration sites, OPS will contact NRT

officials whose regions may be affected by a proposed demonstration

project to identify an appropriate role for the officials'

participation in the Demonstration Program. This could entail the NRT

official identifying any issues and concerns he or she may have with a

candidate demonstration project, including the company's safety and

environmental compliance record. OPS will keep these officials abreast

of the Demonstration Program and individual projects in their regions

via periodic program briefings, project prospectuses, and updates. At

the State level, State pipeline safety agencies participating in the

Demonstration Program may act as

[[Page 14721]]

points-of-contact for other State agencies (including State

environmental agencies).

10. Clarification of Term ``Stakeholder''

OPS uses the term stakeholder in reference to parties at the

National, State, and local levels that have interest in the Pipeline

Risk Management Demonstration Program.

11. Error in Citing Part 192 as Source of Reporting Requirements for

Gas Operators

OPS could issue orders exempting participating operators from any

but the reporting requirements in 49 CFR Parts 191 or 195, but expects

that the projects approved in 1997 will require exemptions from only

one or a portion of the regulations. The Program Framework erroneously

cited Part 192 as the source for reporting requirements for gas

operators.

12. Clarify Role of Local Public Officials

The Program Framework was unclear about why OPS asks that

participating companies establish a dialogue with local officials in

proximity to their demonstration projects. The expected benefits of

local public involvement include:

Providing information about specific local conditions that

may not be known at the Federal or State level;

Ensuring that government agencies have considered all

relevant factors in making decisions to approve projects; and

Providing local feedback as to whether the Program is

accomplishing the goals for which it was designed.

To broaden opportunities for public involvement, other planned

outreach opportunities include an Internet homepage with each project's

status and national two-way video teleconferences available via

Internet.

OPS is seeking a diverse set of demonstration projects, and

encourages all interested interstate natural gas transmission and

hazardous liquid pipeline operators to submit Letters of Intent for

consideration.

Issued in Washington, DC on March 24, 1997.

Richard B. Felder,

Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety.

Appendix A--Excerpt from the Program Framework for Risk Management

Demonstrations (61 FR 58606)

SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION:

I. Overview

Section 5 of the Accountable Pipeline Safety and Partnership Act of

1996 (Pub.L.No.104-304, Oct. 12, 1996) requires OPS to establish the

Pipeline Risk Management Demonstration Program and sets forth

requirements for carrying out risk management projects. In a memorandum

issued when the statute was enacted, the President directed the

Secretary of Transportation to use his discretion to administer the

Demonstration Program with certain safeguards in place. The safeguards

identified in the President's memorandum to the Secretary include

making provisions for:

Accepting projects that can achieve superior public safety

and environmental protection.

Enabling full and meaningful participation by affected

communities and constituencies in risk management project approval.

Using orders ensuring that the requirements of risk

management projects are subject to full enforcement authority.

Limiting the number of demonstration projects to ten (10).

Limiting participation to operators with clear and

established records of compliance with respect to safety and

environmental protection.

The statutory requirements, the President's memorandum to the

Secretary, comments on previous framework concepts (published in 60 FR

49040, September 21, 1995, and 60 FR 65725, December 20, 1995), and

other stakeholder input were used to develop the present framework,

which provides guidance to operators who may decide to participate in

the demonstration projects that are expected to begin in 1997.

Risk management can provide pipeline owners and operators greater

flexibility in their choice of safety-related activities than is

possible within OPS's present universally applicable regulatory

program. Risk management enables a company to customize its safety

program to address its pipeline's particular risks. Furthermore, risk

management is a dynamic process, with built-in features for evaluating

and improving safety activities as experience is gained.

The demonstration projects will test whether allowing operators the

flexibility to allocate safety resources through risk management is an

effective way to improve safety, environmental protection, and

reliability. They will also provide data on how to administer risk

management as a permanent feature of the Federal pipeline safety

program, should risk management prove to be a viable regulatory

alternative. The new standards, technologies, and communication

processes developed by operators and OPS for the risk management

demonstration projects will be adapted to support the range of risk-

based regulatory, compliance, and research and development activities

OPS presently has under development.

OPS expects that risk management methods and the formalized process

of interactions and negotiation between regulators and company

personnel will result in superior public safety and environmental

protection than could otherwise be attained through existing regulatory

requirements. Risk management is, by OPS definition, a more systematic

and thorough assessment of risk and risk control options, with the

intended result of superior decision making. As a result of improved

assessment, OPS believes there is a potential to identify more risk

than may have been found using existing practices.

OPS plans to select companies for demonstration projects with a

demonstrated commitment (1) to work in partnership to evaluate merits

of risk management processes and technologies and (2) to develop risk

management as an integral part of company day-to-day business

practices, at least related to the demonstration project. The selection

criteria favors projects showing potential for more comprehensive risk

management applications. All participants will be focused on improving

safety and environmental results, prioritizing resources more

effectively, and enhancing the ability of government and industry to

effect positive outcomes. OPS will have clear profiles of its

assessment of pipeline integrity before and after the demonstration

program. At the program conclusion, OPS fully expects to have a better

understanding of individual pipeline risks and to be in a better

position to evaluate risk control options.

Finally, OPS expects risk management to be able to provide better

accountability for safety and environmental protection, and a better

basis to communicate with the public. To assure that safety and

environmental protection improve, OPS will measure local, project-

specific data such as current physical data, new test data, comparison

with similar segments, outcomes from risk control actions, precursor or

``anticipative'' event measures, level of risk awareness, history of

service interruptions and incident data. OPS also expects to measure

improvements in communications, understanding, and resulting increased

ability of government and industry to effect desired safety and

environmental project outcomes. OPS and operators

[[Page 14722]]

participating in the Demonstration Program will report to the public

periodically during the four year period.

OPS will be accepting into the Demonstration Program those

projects, as proposed or ultimately negotiated, that are expected to

achieve superior public safety and environmental protection than is

currently being achieved through regulatory compliance. Because of the

nature of the risk management process, OPS believes that operators

choosing to participate will be able to propose projects demonstrating

such protection.

Each demonstration project is expected to have a four-year

duration. Participation in risk management demonstrations will be

voluntary and subject to OPS approval based on criteria set forth later

in this notice. Eligibility for the demonstration projects beginning in

1997 is limited to interstate natural gas transmission and hazardous

liquid pipeline companies. RSPA may later broaden eligibility to

include distribution and other intrastate operators.

II. Activities Presently Underway and Next Steps

The December 20, 1995, Federal Register notice gave the background

for OPS's consideration of company-specific risk management projects as

an alternative to the existing regulations. The notice described many

of the safety, environmental, legislative, technical, public

perception, and economic factors driving government, corporate, and

public interest in risk management.

Since December 1995, OPS has been working with ``joint risk

management quality teams'' (JRAQT) composed of representatives of State

pipeline regulatory agencies, the oil and gas industries, and local

public safety and environmental representatives to develop the five

primary components of the Pipeline Risk Management Demonstration

Program. These components include the Interim Risk Management Program

Standard, the guidance for assessing risk management as a regulatory

alternative using general industry data, the training protocols for

instructing government and corporate participants about their new roles

under risk management, a plan for productive communication between all

participants and the public, and the regulatory framework presented in

this notice. The standard and the regulatory framework are now ready

for public comment. The guidance for assessing risk management as a

regulatory alternative will be ready for public comment in November.

The Interim Risk Management Program Standard will serve as a common

ground upon which the pipeline industry can develop and refine

effective risk management demonstration projects that regulators can

approve and monitor. It defines certain elements that all programs

should contain, but allows flexibility to each company to customize its

project to fit its particular needs and corporate practices, and allows

projects to evolve as experience is gained. The standard will also

provide companies guidance for selecting performance measures to ensure

that safety and environmental protection are safeguarded in

demonstration projects. Directions for obtaining and commenting on the

standard are at the front of this notice.

The regulatory framework component presented in this notice guides

pipeline companies in how they can gain OPS approval of their risk

management projects and describes how OPS would monitor the plans. The

framework presented here will guide the demonstration projects that

begin in 1997. The experience gained from the demonstration projects

will help OPS to later develop a permanent procedure for approving risk

management projects, if risk management proves to be a viable

regulatory alternative. Directions for public comment on the regulatory

framework are also at the front of this notice.

To help ensure that the Demonstration Program components provide

the flexibility to fairly and consistently evaluate and support actual

risk management projects, OPS has been conducting a series of meetings

with individual operators since August 1996. The topics of discussion

include risk management projects the operator has in place or under

consideration and criteria OPS might use to evaluate them. During the

meetings, operators also learn about and comment on the Demonstration

Program components under development.

OPS has held two public meetings on risk management demonstration

projects and will hold a third on Tuesday, January 28, 1997, in New

Orleans, Louisiana. At that meeting, OPS and the JRAQT will present the

Interim Risk Management Program Standard that operators will use during

the demonstration projects. OPS will also present prototype risk

management projects to illustrate the documentation needed and the

types of issues to be addressed during project review, approval and

monitoring. After the meeting, OPS will publish a Federal Register

notice to begin the project approval process described in Section IV of

this notice. Between now and the January meeting, OPS will continue to

refine the Demonstration Program components based on public comment on

this notice, meetings with individual operators, national public,

environmental and other interested organizations, and continued

interaction with industry and the States through the JRAQT teams.

III. Risk Management Demonstration Project Objectives and Policies

The objectives of the Pipeline Risk Management Demonstration

Program, which stem from the statutory requirements and the

Presidential directive, are to accomplish the following:

To show that more effective allocation of resources can

result in improved safety and environmental protection over what is

presently achieved through regulatory compliance.

To address risks not addressed by regulations by

capitalizing on features inherent to the risk management process, such

as improved quality and integration of safety data and, as a result,

more comprehensive assessment of threats.

To systematically test risk management as a regulatory

alternative through objective evaluation under a broad range of

conditions.

To establish a common framework for productive

communication with public safety officials and the public, and for

getting meaningful public input into the risk management process.

To develop and apply new risk assessment models, processes

and technologies.

OPS believes that the following elements need to be structured into

the Demonstration Program:

(1) Operators participating in the Pipeline Risk Management

Demonstration Program will need to provide sufficient data and

background information to enable OPS to determine whether risk

management is an effective regulatory alternative that provides

superior safety and environmental protection.

Implicit in a company's participation in the Demonstration Program

should be the commitment to work in partnership with OPS to determine

whether and how risk management might become a permanent feature of the

Federal pipeline safety program. OPS will ask for evidence that risk

management, as it relates to the proposed demonstration project, is or

will be developed and implemented as an integral part of the day-to-day

business practices of the company. OPS will also periodically ask

[[Page 14723]]

companies for suggested refinements to the primary program components.

In keeping with the Interim Risk Management Program Standard, the

operator must identify project-specific performance measures that

demonstrate the effectiveness of the risk-control decisions being made.

During the project approval process, OPS will determine whether these

local project-specific performance measures appear appropriate and

adequate. Throughout a demonstration project, the operator will

evaluate local and broader program measures and ensure that the

performance measures are appropriate and adequate. The operator would

periodically report on these project-specific performance measurements

to OPS.

OPS is developing guidance for additional more general measures

operators would report during the four-year demonstration period to

enable OPS to determine the effectiveness of risk management as a

regulatory alternative. These measures will help OPS answer the

following questions:

Does risk management result in a greater safety,

environmental protection, and service reliability than would otherwise

be achieved through compliance with the safety regulations?

Are resources being better prioritized and more

effectively applied under risk management?

Has agency and industry involvement in the discussion of

risks and risk control options, and the agency and industry's ability

to impact desired outcomes, increased under risk management?

(2) Operators will be allowed to reallocate resources geographically,

as long as safety is adequately safeguarded at each location along a

demonstration site

OPS will allow operators the flexibility in a risk management

demonstration project to reallocate safety resources across several

pipeline segments. An operator may substitute one or more activities

for others, or do away with redundant activities altogether, as long as

the basic safety and environmental protection along the pipeline is

safeguarded at each point. However, it is still expected that the

overall demonstration project performance will result in superior

safety and environmental protection.

(3) OPS will consider approving demonstration projects of various

scopes and complexities

The scope of a risk management demonstration project may be an

entire pipeline system and all safety activities, or may be focused on

parts of a system and specific activities.

Since operators have different levels of experience with, and

confidence in, risk management, OPS expects some proposals to begin

with approaches that are limited in scope. Therefore, an operator may

propose a phased entry into a demonstration project, broadening the

scope of the project as experience is gained. During the project

approval process, OPS will favor projects showing a potential for

expansion and more comprehensive application of risk management. OPS

expects to work with companies to develop a profile which compares the

demonstration site to the rest of the pipeline.

OPS recognizes that significant benefits can accrue from even the

less sophisticated applications of risk management. Because no single

risk management approach will be universally appropriate for every

situation, OPS is looking for those that match the level of risk

management with the complexity of the risks being managed. However, any

operator who participates in the Demonstration Program must have in

place the program elements defined in the Interim Risk Management

Program Standard. The program elements provide the structure for the

limited scope proposal.

When an operator proposes risk control alternatives to implement

during a demonstration project, the operator should demonstrate a

knowledge and understanding of the range of risks along the

demonstration site and show that it has considered significant failure

modes. An operator may draw on corporate experience, skills, and

available documentation to support the proposed alternatives.

(4) OPS considers an operator's compliance with the provisions of an

OPS-approved risk management project to be an equivalent and acceptable

alternative to compliance with the regulations

OPS considers the provisions of an approved risk management project

to be a regulatory commitment. The terms and conditions of the project

will be incorporated into an order that is subject to enforcement

authority. By this order, an operator conducting risk management

activities in an approved project will be exempt from regulations

corresponding to the stated scope of the project, but will be required

to comply with the provisions of the project. An operator not complying

with the provisions of its OPS-approved project will be subject to the

same civil penalties administered under existing regulations.

OPS has the authority to exempt, by order, an owner or operator

participating in a risk management demonstration project from all or a

portion of the regulatory requirements, and from any new regulations,

applying to the covered pipeline facility. OPS could issue orders

exempting participating operators from any but the reporting

requirements in 49 CFR Parts 192 or 195, but expects that the projects

approved in 1997 will require exemptions from only one or a portion of

the regulations.

When the project concludes at the end of four years, or if it is

terminated earlier, consideration will be given to installations or

facility modifications made during the demonstration project that

conflict with existing or future regulatory actions. Actions taken by

the operator in good faith in an approved risk management project could

be ``grandfathered'' and exempt from future regulatory compliance,

provided safety and environmental protection are not compromised.

(5) The operator is responsible for active communication with State and

local officials regarding risk management. OPS will ensure that such

communication is part of the operator's demonstration project plan and

that the communication is carried out.

OPS sees potential for risk management to provide better

accountability to the public for safety and environmental programs. OPS

is beginning to explore appropriate strategies for productive

communication with public safety officials and the public, and for

getting meaningful public input into the risk management process.

Similarly, OPS realizes the importance of training and other

information exchange in supporting the institutional change that would

occur under risk management.

Companies must establish appropriate dialogue with State and local

public safety and environment officials. At a minimum, these public

officials should be aware that a risk management demonstration project

is underway on the pipeline, that OPS is monitoring the project, and

who functions as a point-of-contact. Such a dialogue would enable local

officials to reassure the public that an appropriate regulatory

presence is in place and how the overall safety and environmental

protection are enhanced by risk management. OPS will discuss external

communications with the operator during a consultation prior to formal

application.

[[Page 14724]]

IV. Process for Selecting Projects

OPS is providing the following as guidance for operators to seek

approval of their risk management demonstration projects. OPS plans to

formally solicit operators to voluntarily participate in the risk

management demonstration projects via a Federal Register Notice in

first quarter 1997. That notice will give target dates for the various

steps described below.

(1) Letter of Intent

Operators would notify OPS of interest in participating in a

demonstration project, and OPS would screen operators to ensure that

only companies whose demonstration project concepts have a reasonable

likelihood of being approved expend the resources to develop formal

applications. OPS will screen Letters of Intent to identify no more

than ten projects as candidates for selection in the Demonstration

Program. Ten is the maximum number OPS can reasonably expect to

evaluate and, if selected, to monitor. OPS would accept Letters of

Intent during a 60-day window in early 1997. A Letter of Intent is an

expression of a company's interest, but does not obligate a company to

participate in a demonstration.

OPS would require that a demonstration project cover any part or

all of a pipeline system that is covered by either 49 CFR Part 192 or

195, is under State oversight or oversight by a participating

interstate agent, and is currently in operation or under conversion to

service. Operators should commit to a project duration of at least four

years, and provide evidence that they will address all considerations

raised in the Interim Risk Management Program Standard. This includes

providing a description of the means by which the company would

communicate with local officials regarding its demonstration project.

OPS would like to choose operators who provide evidence of

consistent corporate commitment to risk management. This could be

demonstrated by a corporate officer, who controls the resource

allocation for the demonstration project and competing operations,

signing the Letter of Intent.

The Letter of Intent would include a general discussion of risk

management principles as part of a company's operating philosophy. To

provide OPS adequate data to choose a diverse set of demonstration

projects, the Letter would provide a brief system profile of the

pipeline, including product(s) transported, pipeline age and operating

history, types of population distributions and geographic conditions in

proximity of the pipeline, and any other features the operator thinks

are notable. The Letter would also describe the scope of the project as

defined per the Interim Risk Management Program Standard and any new

technologies and processes to be developed or deployed during the

demonstration phase.

In making its choice, OPS would consider those operators who have

clear records of safety and environmental compliance, based on OPS

records and consultation with other interested agencies. OPS will also

limit selection to projects which would achieve superior safety and

environmental protection. Operators should have completed any OPS-

initiated corrective actions.

OPS will publish for public comment a Federal Register notice

describing proposals of selected companies and the demonstration sites

under consideration. OPS will also follow through with national public,

environmental and other interested organizations about the sites under

consideration so that local officials can be notified and informed.

(2) Consultation

OPS would invite each operator submitting a promising Letter of

Intent to a consultation within 60 days of receipt of the Letter of

Intent. The purpose of the consultation would be to familiarize OPS and

affected States with specific aspects of an operator's risk management

project concept, to provide guidance to the operator on what

refinements (if any) are needed for OPS to approve the concept as a

demonstration project, to enable regulators to plan the expected level

of monitoring based on the company's own audit process, and to enable

regulators and the operator to agree on the roles and responsibilities

of each throughout the project duration. OPS intends that the

consultation begin a negotiation process that results in a

demonstration project that OPS could approve.

OPS will provide notification that encourages local officials and

the public with questions about demonstration projects to raise them

with State pipeline safety officials who can raise them in the

consultation process.

OPS would constitute a Project Review Team (PRT) to consult with

the operator, keep abreast of any subsequent discussions, and provide

technical input on whether a demonstration project could be approved.

OPS would customize the make-up of each PRT to the company and project.

The PRT members'' roles would be defined in OPS-developed protocols,

designed to ensure rigorous yet fair and consistent treatment of all

operators throughout plan negotiation, approval, and monitoring. The

mix of States and OPS regional personnel on the PRTs, as well as any

outside technical expertise consulted, would vary from project to

project depending on the demonstration's technical focus and geographic

location.

Some of the same OPS headquarters staff would be on all PRTs to

ensure consistent application of policy throughout the project and to

follow all issues raised during the consultations to their resolution.

The consultation would focus on the design, operations, and

maintenance practices that would replace practices required by 49 CFR

Part 192 or 195, and that would achieve superior overall safety and

environmental protection. The operator would provide the rationale for

these risk control alternatives by generally describing the specific

risk management models, processes, and sources of data supporting their

selection.

Other consultation discussion topics would include the program

goals, the project scope defined per the Interim Risk Management

Program Standard, the project-specific performance measures, the

operator's auditing plan, a plan for OPS audits, proprietary issues,

provisions for public communication, and the outline for a work plan

including benchmarks, risk assessment processes, new technologies

applied, points-of-disclosure, and mechanisms for monitoring and

refinement.

(3) Formal Application and Approval

An operator would submit an application formally indicating its

intent to enter into a risk management demonstration project.

Consistent with the program standard's intent for an efficient

information flow among appropriate stakeholders, a summary of this

formal application would be published in the Federal Register, and the

application itself would be made available for review and comment in

the docket. OPS will again communicate with national public,

environmental and other interested organizations about the sites in

which we intend to approve demonstration projects so that local

officials can be notified and informed.

The formal application, including a detailed work plan, would

document operator/PRT resolution of issues raised during the

consultation and any subsequent discussions. It would also provide

assurance of a corporate commitment to implement the project in

accordance with the operator's risk management application. Other

issues may be included at the operator's

[[Page 14725]]

discretion, such as how to return to compliance with the regulations

should a demonstration be terminated.

OPS would review the application and comments, and decide whether

to approve the project. If OPS decides to approve the project, OPS

would issue the operator a written order. The order, in addition to

exempting an operator from the applicability of specified pipeline

safety regulatory requirements for the period of the demonstration,

would set forth the terms and conditions for the operator's

participation in the demonstration project. The order would be

enforceable.

(4) Implementation

A risk management project would start as soon as OPS approves the

formal application and work plan, issues the order, and notifies the

public through the Federal Register that the order is in effect.

Regulators and operators would monitor risk management demonstration

projects for compliance with the order. OPS would provide each

participating operator with a plan describing the regulators' expected

level of effort in monitoring the demonstration, including the type of

audits, their frequency, the participants, the audit scope, and the

operator's means of addressing those aspects of the demonstration site

remaining in compliance with the regulations, but this plan would not

limit OPS's statutory authority to inspect a pipeline facility during

the period of the demonstration. Planned OPS audits would coincide with

the operator's data taking at key decision points, such as when the

operator evaluates the effectiveness of safety activities or considers

modifying safety activities.

An operator would notify OPS of any intent to make substantive

modifications to the risk management project once a demonstration is

underway. The PRT may reconvene to renegotiate project approval or to

resolve other significant issues. Provisions will be made for public

review and comment on renegotiated projects.

OPS could, through appropriate administrative action, address any

unsafe conditions that arise during the demonstration period to ensure

that such conditions are quickly addressed. OPS would also administer

civil penalties within the provisions of the existing regulations for

operators not complying with the order.

(5) Termination

OPS intends that, where a risk management demonstration project is

determined to have been successful, the operator could, in lieu of

switching to compliance with the regulations, continue to exercise risk

management on that part of the system that was covered by the

demonstration. However, this determination could not be made until the

end of the demonstration period. Upon conclusion of the project, or if

it is terminated earlier, consideration would be given to installations

or facility modifications made during the demonstration project that

conflict with future regulatory actions.

OPS may consider terminating a demonstration project if:

(i) The operator requests termination due to changed circumstances;

(ii) The operator does not comply with the terms and conditions of

the approved risk management project;

(iii) Safety has been compromised; or

(iv) OPS and the operator fail to agree on a substantive

modification to a risk management project.

V. Summary of Means of Achieving Meaningful Public and Community

Involvement

OPS is providing numerous opportunities for public participation in

the design and implementation of the Pipeline Risk Management

Demonstration Program. One of OPS's objectives for the demonstrations

is to establish a common framework for productive communication with

public safety officials and the public, and for getting meaningful

public input into the risk management process. OPS believes meaningful

public input is essential if the demonstrations are to be successful.

The public was invited to comment on early regulatory framework

concepts via Federal Register notices published in 60 FR 49040,

September 21, 1995, and 60 FR 65725, December 20, 1995. OPS is

soliciting public comment on the latest framework concepts via this

notice. In addition to the notices, OPS has held two public meetings in

preparation for the demonstrations and has scheduled a third for

January 28, 1997, in New Orleans, LA. The previous public meetings were

held on November 7, 1995, in McLean, Virginia, and on April 14-15,

1996, in Houston, TX. At the third meeting, OPS plans to present the

final framework and supporting documents, and to demonstrate the review

and approval process using prototype risk management projects.

This notice directs interested members of the public to the docket,

to the American Petroleum Institute (API), or to a website to obtain

and comment on the latest draft of the Interim Risk Management Program

Standard. The standard describes the elements that OPS, its State

partners, and industry agree must be common to all demonstration

projects. One requirement is an external communications element, in

which regulator and other stakeholder interests and concerns are

understood, and program goals and results are communicated to and

discussed with the public, as well as Federal, State, and local

regulators, and other stakeholders as appropriate. The docket

associated with this notice will have available for review any comments

received on the standard and on the regulatory framework.

This notice also describes the numerous opportunities OPS is

offering the public for comment during the demonstration review and

approval process. Before formal applications are due, OPS will publish

for public comment a Federal Register notice describing the

demonstration projects under consideration and each company's concept

for communicating with local safety officials should OPS approve its

demonstration project. The public will be noticed again once the formal

application is received and approval is imminent. At this time, a

summary of the formal application will be published in the Federal

Register, and the application itself will be made available for review

and comment through the docket. At each opportunity for notice in the

Federal Register, OPS will communicate with national public,

environmental and other interested organizations about the sites under

consideration so that local officials can be notified and informed

about planned program activities.

Affected States will be a part of the Project Review Team (PRT)

recommending whether or not OPS should approve a demonstration project.

OPS will provide notification that encourages local officials and the

public with questions about demonstration projects to raise them with

State pipeline safety officials who can raise them with the PRT.

OPS and industry's communications effort focusing on public and

environmental officials and other interested organization

representatives is intended to provide these officials with adequate

information to reassure the public that an appropriate regulatory

presence is in place during the demonstrations, and to describe how

safety and environmental protection will be enhanced by risk

management. OPS would appreciate comments on whether these mechanisms

are adequate to ensure public and community involvement, and if not,

what OPS and operators choosing to participate in the

[[Page 14726]]

demonstration projects can do to achieve such involvement.

VI. Report to Congress

By March 31, 2000, OPS will submit a Report to Congress on the

results of the demonstration projects, evaluating how effectively

safety, environmental protection, and reliability have been improved by

participating operators, the feasibility of risk management in general,

and recommending whether and in what form risk management should be

incorporated into the Federal pipeline safety program on a permanent

basis.

Appendix B--The Pipeline Risk Management Demonstration Program Public

Meeting, January 28, 1997, New Orleans, Louisiana

Note: The complete transcript of this Public Meeting is

available on the Internet at: http://ops.dot.gov

1. Background and Objectives

Moving into Implementation

Over the last few years, the Office of Pipeline Safety (OPS) has

been investigating the use of risk management as a regulatory

alternative that would produce superior performance in more cost-

effective ways. Over this time, OPS has worked in partnership with the

pipeline industry and State regulators through a series of Risk

Assessment Quality Teams (RAQTs) and has discussed progress and

concerns at a series of meetings and conferences, including a Pipeline

Safety Summit in 1994, and Risk Management Conferences in 1995 and

1996.

The initial RAQTs, which investigated the feasibility of using risk

management within the pipeline industry, concluded that risk management

had the potential to provide significant benefits by improving safety,

environmental protection, reliability, and cost-effective operation.

However, these Teams noted a variety of technical and regulatory issues

that still needed to be resolved, and recommended that a demonstration

program be planned and implemented to test the viability of risk

management as a regulatory alternative.

The first Risk Management Conference, held in McLean, Virginia, in

November 1995, identified the most important of these issues. A major

conclusion from this first Risk Management Conference was that a set of

``building blocks'' needed to be developed to provide an adequate

foundation upon which a viable and responsible Risk Management

Demonstration Program could be constructed. After this conference,

partnerships representing OPS, States, localities, industry and the

public were formed to design and construct the following building

blocks:

The Risk Management Program Framework that defines how OPS

receives, reviews, approves, and monitors operators risk management

demonstration projects;

The Risk Management Program Standard that defines the

essential elements and characteristics of an operator's risk management

program;

Guidance on Performance Measures that supports the ability

of operators and OPS to monitor performance, ensure that superior

performance is being achieved, and evaluate the results of the Risk

Management Demonstration Program;

A Communications Plan that describes how information about

the demonstration projects will be provided to local safety officials

and other interested parties, and how information from these parties

will be input to the demonstration process;

A Training Plan that defines how OPS, States, and industry

will be trained in the risk management building blocks.

Work commenced on these building blocks in early 1996. A second

Risk Management Conference was held in Houston, Texas in April, 1996 to

review progress and to hear input, concerns, and suggestions about the

building blocks.

A draft version of the Program Framework was developed by OPS and

published in the Federal Register on November 15, 1996, followed by a

60-day public comment period.

A draft Program Standard was developed by the Program Standard

Quality Team and referenced in the Federal Register notice. Comments

were received, and incorporated into an Interim Program Standard in

early January, 1997.

A draft Performance Measures Guidance was produced by the

Performance Measures Working Group, and distributed for comment in

December, 1996.

A draft Communications Plan was produced by OPS and the JRAQT

Coordination Team and distributed for comment in early January, 1997.

A draft Training Plan was produced by OPS and distributed for

comment in early January, 1997.

The Accountable Pipeline Safety and Partnership Act of 1996 was

passed by Congress and signed into law by President Clinton on October

12, 1996. This Act required the Secretary of Transportation to

``establish risk management demonstration projects--A) to demonstrate,

through the voluntary participation by owners and operators of gas

pipeline facilities and hazardous liquid pipeline facilities, the

application of risk management, and B) to evaluate the safety and cost-

effectiveness of the program.'' President Clinton provided additional

direction to the Secretary through a Memorandum that directed the

Secretary to implement administrative safeguards for carrying out the

law that will enhance accountability and protection of public safety

and the environment.

Meeting Purpose

This Public Meeting was designed to allow OPS to: 1) Present to the

public the basic risk management demonstration program building blocks,

2) Describe and illustrate, with simple examples, how the review and

approval process is envisioned to work, and 3) Obtain input from all

interested parties concerning the building blocks or any other aspect

of the Risk Management Demonstration Program.

Each of the draft building block documents, the Act of 1996, the

President's Directive, and other relevant documents were provided as

handout to each person attending the meeting and distributed to all

State pipeline safety agencies.

[OPS received input from this Meeting, revised the draft building

blocks as necessary, and published a final Program Framework in the

Federal Register in March 1997, inviting companies to submit Letters of

Intent for risk management demonstration projects.]

2. Conference Synopsis

This section provides a brief summary of each of the major sessions

on the Meeting agenda.

Welcome and Introduction

Richard Felder--Associate Administrator for Pipeline Safety

Mr. Felder opened the conference by welcoming everyone. He noted

that OPS and its State and industry partners started out over two years

ago with the realization that there may be a better way of approaching

pipeline safety regulation, an approach that is not event-driven and

that does not result in specification-based regulation. OPS is looking

for a better approach that will give superior safety through

customization, flexibility, collaboration, and innovation.

Mr. Felder read a letter from Mr. Bruce Ellsworth, a Public Service

Commissioner in New Hampshire and

[[Page 14727]]

Chairman of the National Association of Regulatory Utility

Commissioners, to illustrate changes in perception from the first risk

management meetings until now. Mr. Ellsworth noted that he was

originally skeptical about replacing the existing safety regulations

with risk management. He believes that the Natural Gas Pipeline Safety

Act of 1968 has led to an outstanding safety record, and was reluctant

to fix something that was not broken. However, as a result of his

participation on the Joint Risk Assessment Policy Steering Team, he has

seen that there may be an opportunity to make the system work better,

cheaper, and more effectively. Mr Ellsworth's letter stated that he

believed OPS has been right in exploring the viability of risk

management as a regulatory alternative, and communicated his support

for the pilot demonstration program.

Mr. Felder then delineated the basic building blocks of the

Demonstration Program and emphasized the new awareness and resolve on

the part of OPS to address the issues of public involvement.

RSPA Perspectives

Kelley Coyner, Research and Special Programs Administration

Ms. Coyner's discussion focused on the two twins of ``opportunity''

and ``responsibility'' that risk management presents. Risk management

provides a tremendous opportunity, but only if we take the

responsibility to do it right very seriously. She said that the

pipeline risk management initiative was consistent and supportive of

President Clinton's vision of a government that is humble enough not to

solve all of our problems, but strong enough to give us the tools to

solve our problems ourselves.

Ms. Coyner described the opportunities that risk management

provides to comprehensively analyze risks, prioritize resources, and

track performance; to be smarter and more accountable. She spoke of the

responsibilities of continuing the partnerships that got us to this

point, to continuously improve as we move forward, and to set clear and

ambitious performance goals.

A major theme of Ms. Coyner's talk was the need for communication

and public involvement. Improving public involvement has been a program

goal from the beginning. She asked members of the audience to take

seriously the challenge to make sure that OPS and its partners are off

to a good start and going in the right direction by providing their

comments in this public meeting.

Risk Management Building Blocks Panel

Program Framework

Stacey Gerard, Office of Pipeline Safety

Program Standard

Denise Hamsher, Lakehead Pipe Line

Performance Measures Guidance

Ivan Huntoon, Office of Pipeline Safety, Don Stursma, Iowa Commerce

Department

Communications Plan

Stacey Gerard, Office of Pipeline Safety

Training Outline

Richard Sanders, Transportation Safety Institute

Program Framework

Ms. Gerard discussed the Program Framework, which describes the

processes by which OPS will receive, review, approve, audit, and

communicate information about operator risk management demonstration

projects. She described the contents of the draft Program Framework

(published in the Federal Register) and the comments received on this

draft. Ms. Gerard also discussed the Accountable Pipeline Safety and

Partnership Act of 1996 and the President's Directive that accompanied

the law. She noted that the President's Directive requires that risk

management demonstration projects produce superior safety and

environmental protection, and directed OPS to place more emphasis on

meaningful public and community involvement.

Ms. Gerard outlined the basic steps in the regulatory process,

including:

The Letter of Intent (LOI), in which the company

communicates its intention to develop and propose a risk management

demonstration project;

The Screening Process, in which OPS screens the LOI to

select a set of potential projects that have the best chance of

supporting the Demonstration Program goals;

Pre-consultations, in which OPS staff meets with the

selected operators to discuss their proposed project, clarify

information in the LOI, and prepare the Project Review Team (PRT) for

an efficient consultation with the operator;

The Consultation Process, in which an PRT meets with the

company, and through a series of discussions, information exchange, and

interactions come to agreement on the scope and characteristics of an

acceptable risk management demonstration project, leading to the

submittal of an application by the operator;

The Review and Approval Process, in which OPS reviews the

operator's application, approves it if appropriate, and reflects the

commitments and terms and conditions of the program in a DOT Order;

The Audit Plan, developed by OPS, which will coincide with

the company's Work Plan milestones and decision points, and which

describes the specific processes and areas of OPS audits of the risk

management demonstration project;

The Implementation Phase, in which OPS and the operator

monitor progress, and modify or terminate the project as necessary.

She noted that, based on comments to the FR Notice, the window of

time for submitting LOIs will be extended to 90 or 120 days. She

strongly encouraged capable companies to submit LOIs.

Ms. Gerard discussed the issue of the ``clear and established''

safety record required by the President in his Directive of all

demonstration program participants. She noted that OPS wanted companies

with a clear record of compliance to start the project, and OPS will

work with companies to be sure there is a clear record.

Ms. Gerard also discussed the issue of ``superior performance''.

The President's Directive states that: ``The Secretary [of

Transportation] shall require each project to achieve superior levels

of public safety and environmental protection when compared with

regulatory requirements that otherwise would apply.'' Ms. Gerard noted

that, consistent with other aspects of the President's Directive,

superior performance would be achieved through a combination of:

(a) Improved analytical and decision-making processes. Risk

management programs consistent with the Program Standard would be

expected to include a comprehensive examination of risks, improved

allocation of resources, enhanced communications within the company,

better interactions with the regulators, meaningful public involvement,

and other features that would lead to superior performance.

(b) Selection of an integrated set of risk control activities that

is expected to reduce risks to the public, workers, and the

environment.

(c) Full accountability. Operators will be expected to identify

project-specific performance measures and submit project work plans

that explicitly define operator commitments. These commitments are

reflected in Orders that delineate the terms and conditions under which

the operator's risk management program is authorized, and which are

subject to the full

[[Page 14728]]

enforcement authority of the United States.

She clarified the role of the States, stating that OPS is inviting

the States to participate in the PRT process, but not mandating

participation of the States.

Program Standard

Ms. Hamsher, Co-Chair of the Joint Risk Assessment Program Standard

Team, described the basic objectives of the Program Standard, how it

was developed, and its basic elements. She stated that the Program

Standard describes the basic elements and characteristics of an

operator's risk management program. The Program Standard describes the

basic program and process elements, and the functional requirements of

a risk management program, but does not specify exactly how these

elements or functions should be performed, allowing operators to

customize their specific programs and technical tools to their

situation and needs. It is not an instruction manual, a substitute for

training, or a tool box. The Program Standard can provide the starting

point for the OPS review of proposed demonstration projects, but it is

not intended as a checklist for review and approval of demonstration

projects.

Ms. Hamsher discussed some of the risk management guiding

principles that were developed by the JRAQT. One of the key guiding

principles is that risk management is a management decision support

process. It is not just a set of technical models, but a comprehensive

program that is integrated with the overall operation of the company to

produce better decisions leading to superior performance. Risk

management supports responsible, prudent, and experienced managers, it

does not replace them. She also noted a guiding principle that risk can

be controlled and often reduced, but it cannot be totally eliminated.

We all need to reinforce, and communicate this realization so that

expectations for zero risk are not established. Another guiding

principle that went into the development of the Standard was that risk

management produces integrated information about safety and

environmental protection. Risk management increases information and

information flow, between the company, its regulators, and the public.

She noted that the JRAQT recognized that the technical models,

tools, and processes associated with a risk management program

necessarily include some subjective judgements, uncertain assumptions,

and limited data. Accordingly, the Program Standard includes a

Performance Monitoring element that includes the definition and

monitoring of performance measures that are directly tied to validating

the specific assumptions and input data of the operator's risk

assessment model and process.

Ms. Hamsher concluded by discussing the future of the Program

Standard. Progress on the demonstration projects will be monitored, and

the Program Standard will be refined and improved over the next four

years. However, because of the way the Program Standard was developed,

laying out the basic elements without prescribing details, it is not

expected that major modifications will be necessary over the

demonstration period. It is expected that this Program Standard will

eventually be transformed into an industry consensus standard.

Performance Measures Guidance

Mr. Huntoon, Regional Director for the OPS Central Region, and Don

Stursma, from the Iowa Commerce Department, discussed the work of the

Performance Measures Workgroup and the issues the group addressed in

producing the draft Guidance on Performance Measures. The Performance

Measures Workgroup was formed after a number of issues related to

performance measures were identified by the JRAQT Program Standard

Team.

The Workgroup concluded that there were two key areas where

performance measures were important:

(1) In monitoring the specific results produced by individual

company demonstration projects to ensure that the underlying

assumptions and input data of the risk assessment and risk control

models are valid, and that the approved projects are indeed resulting

in superior performance as predicted.

(2) In assessing the overall success of the Risk Management

Demonstration Program, providing input to the required OPS report to

Congress, and other progress reports.

Key issues that the Workgroup addressed were the availability of

data to support meaningful performance monitoring and the cost and

sensitivity of data reporting.

The report produced by the Workgroup is intended to provide

guidance for operators who are planning to participate in the risk

management demonstration program. The guidance should assist operators

in developing a performance monitoring process as described in the

Program Standard, and provide OPS the information it needs to assess

the overall effectiveness of risk management as a regulatory

alternative.

The project-specific performance measures will be included as part

of the operator's demonstration project application, and will depend

upon the expected outcomes of the demonstration project, and the

selected risk control activities. Mr. Huntoon delineated some of the

criteria developed by the Workgroup for these project-specific

performance measures.

In order to assess the overall benefit of risk management as a

regulatory alternative, the Workgroup felt that program-wide

performance measures were needed to allow individual companies and OPS

to address the following questions:

(1) Safety and Reliability. Does risk management result in greater

safety, environmental protection, and service reliability than would

otherwise be achieved through compliance with the safety regulations?

(2) Resource Effectiveness. Are resources being better prioritized

and more effectively applied under risk management?

(3) Communication and Partnership. Have agency and industry

involvement in the discussion of risks and risk control options, and

the agency's and industry's ability to impact desired outcomes

increased under risk management?

Mr. Stursma discussed each of these major areas in turn, describing

the issues that the Workgroup discussed in the process of producing the

Guidance on Performance Measures. He also gave a variety of practical,

everyday examples of the different types of performance measures to

illustrate the concepts.

He noted that the information gained from these program-wide

performance measures will be used by OPS to prepare a report to

Congress on the results of the Risk Management Demonstration Program.

The report will address each individual project and provide an overall

recommendation on the application of risk management as a regulatory

alternative. It was recommended that a successor group to the

Performance Measures Workgroup be formed, which would prepare annual,

interim progress reports. It is expected that OPS, the successor group

to the Performance Measures Workgroup, and operators participating in

the demonstration program will jointly prepare the interim annual

progress reports.

Communication Plan

Ms. Gerard described the evolution of the Communications Plan and

its basic elements. She reiterated the importance of meaningful public

involvement to the

[[Page 14729]]

success of the risk management program, and summarized the numerous

mechanisms planned for communication and involvement. In response to

concerns expressed by some that the public would only be informed too

late in the game to have any meaningful impact, Ms. Gerard pointed out

that OPS will, right at the beginning of the review and approval

process, summarize the Letters of Intent from companies selected to

provide risk management project applications. In addition to

publication in the Federal Register, project summaries will be

distributed to local safety officials, and feedback loops will be

established to obtain input from interested parties, at the very

beginning of the consultation process. Information that comes in will

feed into the pre-consultation and consultation process.

Each project summary, referred to as a prospectus, will describe to

local officials the objectives of each project, the safety alternatives

being discussed, and the company's approach to communications with the

public. The prospectus will define at least three points of contact for

anyone wishing to provide information or comment. One point of contact

will be from OPS Headquarters, one will be at the State level (if the

State agrees), and one from the operating company. As new or additional

information is developed during the consultation process, the

prospectus will be updated to keep people posted on events throughout

the process.

At the time of the formal application from the company, the

company's application will be made available in the docket, and a

summary will be published in the Federal Register. When the application

is approved and an Order is issued, OPS will issue another Federal

Register Notice.

Ms. Gerard stated that the aggressive OPS communications effort

under risk management is a much larger commitment that they have ever

made before because they understand how important meaningful public

involvement is to the success of the program.

Training Outline

Mr. Sanders, from the Transportation Safety Institute, summarized

the training program that OPS is developing to support the risk

management demonstration program. OPS is committed to joint government/

industry training to ensure that all parties have a mutual

understanding of the program, and speak the same language (or can at

least accurately interpret each other's language) to facilitate the

consultation process, and ensure high quality, comprehensive risk

management programs result that produce superior performance.

Mr. Sanders outlined the currently envisioned training program,

which is designed to support the Project Review Team, OPS, and the

company during the project review and approval process. The program

includes:

An Overview of the Risk Management Demonstration Program.

The Demonstration Process and Building Blocks.

The Risk Management Program and Process Elements.

OPS Auditing of an Approved Risk Management Demonstration

Project.

Prototypical Examples to Illustrate the Demonstration

Process.

The training program will be developed in a modular format, so that

orientations and training courses can be customized to the specific

audience, its level of experience, and its specific training needs. The

first two blocks of the training listed above, and selected portions of

the other blocks, can be provided as an orientation or ``headstart''

program to those that have not been actively involved in the program

development phase, or who wish to establish a common starting point.

The Risk Management Program and Process Elements portion of the

training is based on the Program Standard building block produced by

the JRAQT, and will provide overview descriptions of various types of

risk assessment and prioritization models and processes.

Mr. Sanders asked for review of the training material, and input

about training needs, including the usefulness of video, computer-based

training, or Internet interactive training.

Prototypes

Moderator: Mike Neuhard, Fairfax County Fire Department

Panelists: Bruce Hansen, Office of Pipeline Safety, Andy Drake,

PanEnergy Corporation, Beth Callsen, Office of Pipeline Safety, Gary

Zimmerman, Shell Pipeline

Two examples of possible regulatory alternatives, one from the

natural gas industry and one from the hazardous liquid industry were

discussed to illustrate the demonstration process described in the

Program Framework and discussed in the Building Blocks Panel. The

examples were simplified versions of what would be expected in a real

demonstration project, designed to illustrate the interactive process

between OPS and the company, and were not presented as practical

examples of comprehensive risk management programs or to illustrate the

critical public involvement aspects of the process.

The topics addressed by each of the prototypes included:

The information expected in the Letter of Intent.

The characteristics of the proposed demonstration project

that OPS would look for in screening Letters of Intent.

The topics that would be discussed at pre-consultation

sessions between OPS staff and the operator.

The discussions between the PRT and the company concerning

the risk-based justification for the proposed safety alternatives.

The performance measures necessary to validate assumptions

of the risk models and to confirm that superior performance was being

produced.

Audience Questions and Comments

Questions and comments from the audience were received by speakers

and panelists at a few different points in the meeting. Some of the

major areas of questions and comments are summarized below. A full,

verbatim set of all questions, comments, and OPS responses is available

in the meeting transcript.

The liability of companies under risk management

demonstration projects for compliance with the existing Federal or

State regulations.

Mr. Felder stated that a company that implements an OPS-approved

demonstration project is committed to abiding under the terms of their

approved application, as reflected in the associated OPS Order.

Participation in a demonstration project is not an exemption from the

minimum Federal pipeline safety standards as a whole. The underlying

regulations that would otherwise apply would not apply to the segment

of the pipeline within the demonstration project; the approved project

and corresponding Order would apply. There should be no problem from

the public's perspective if the company is in compliance with the

provisions of its demonstration project as opposed to being in

compliance with the underlying regulations; compliance with provisions

of the project is equivalent to compliance with the pipeline safety

regulations. The up-front review and approval process assures at the

outset that the demonstration project will result in a superior level

of safety compared to what you would have under the minimum State

standards.

The quality of the data to support risk management.

Mr. Felder noted that some of the audience comments reflected the

[[Page 14730]]

situation at OPS in years past, but did not reflect the many efforts

over the past few years that OPS has taken in increasing partnership

with industry, States, and the public to identify new regulatory

pathways, to get the type of information needed to regulate

effectively. He also noted that considerable work has gone into

ensuring that the risk management process will significantly improve

the amount and quality of data that will be available to OPS. The past

is not a good indicator of where OPS is going in the future as far as

risk information and data is concerned.

The level and type of communication with the public, and

OPS's role in this process.

Mr. Felder and Ms. Gerard reiterated the importance placed on

communication by OPS, and the need to engage in an unprecedented

outreach effort from OPS, but also noted the joint responsibility for

communication among OPS, industry, local safety officials, and the

public. Government cannot, and should not, do everything. Mr. Felder

said that it was important to understand that the people who run the

companies are also citizens of the country. They have a great stake in

the outcome of the work they do, and a great stake in the communities

that they affect. That is why OPS is enlisting their resources as part

of the public outreach process. He further noted that OPS is working

with national organizations because they have people and resources in

every community in America, and this can leverage OPS efforts in

getting down to the local community level. He stated that we need a

communication partnership among Federal regulators, the States,

national organizations, local officials, and the public.

Mr. Felder also pointed out that the situation with a risk

management demonstration project is not analogous to the siting of new

pipeline, where a company may be introducing a new risk into a

community that did not exist before. Risk management demonstration

projects will only be allowed by OPS where the company can demonstrate

that superior performance can be achieved. The communications and due-

process needs and mechanisms are accordingly different than that

associated with a new right-of-way or zoning change hearing where new

and additional risks are being introduced.

Ms. Hamsher pointed out that, in addition to the OPS Communication

Plan, the Program Standard contained explicit requirements for the

company to develop a two-way communications effort, ensuring that

public information will be input to the risk assessment and risk

control processes.

Public access to the Letters of Intent.

Mr. Felder stated that the Letters of Intent, as well as the formal

company application will be available in the docket for public

examination.

The interactive nature of the screening process.

Mr. Felder and Ms. Gerard stated that the screening process may

require information meetings and interactions with the companies to

clarify points in the Letters of Intent or to gather additional

information needed by OPS. However, any interactions, consultations, or

discussions with the company or States does not change the ultimate

responsibility for public safety, which sits in the hands of the OPS

regulators.

The relationship between the OPS program and other

regulators such as EPA.

Mr. Felder noted that OPS has had close collaboration with Mineral

Management Service and works closely with the Coast Guard, a part of

DOT. OPS is interested in putting together a larger network of agencies

to share experiences about risk management and other alternative

approaches to regulation. OPS has already performed a study that looked

at over a dozen other State agency programs in risk management,

defining and incorporating lessons learned from these programs into the

pipeline risk management program. OPS has began meeting with EPA and

will continue to consult with the EPA on issues of mutual interest.

[Subsequent to the public meeting, OPS briefed the 15 State

National Response Team (NRT) agencies and invited them to participate

in the Demonstration Program. As part of the screening and selection

process, OPS will contact NRT officials whose regions may be affected

by a proposed demonstration project to identify an appropriate role for

the officials' participation in the Demonstration Program. This could

entail the NRT official identifying any issues and concerns he or she

may have with a candidate demonstration project, including the

company's safety and environmental compliance record. OPS will keep

these officials abreast of the Demonstration Program and individual

projects in their regions via annual program briefings, project

prospectuses, and updates.]

Limitations on the number of demonstration projects.

Mr. Felder stated that OPS is restricted by Presidential directive

to ten demonstration projects, involving interstate pipelines. No

demonstration projects are planned for the local distribution companies

at this time. In addition, OPS will be undertaking a variety of other

initiatives related to regulatory reform and risk-based regulation

beyond the demonstration projects themselves. OPS is committed to

ensuring a high quality demonstration program that protects and

improves safety and the environment, understands the significant

resources required to support this program, and will not take on any

more projects than it can responsibly and prudently handle.

Summary and Closing

John Riordan, Interstate Natural Gas Association of America (INGAA)

Pipeline Safety Task Force, Joe Martinelli, API General Committee on

Pipelines, Rich Felder, Office of Pipeline Safety

Mr. Riordan, from MidCon and the spokesman for INGAA, discussed how

the Board of INGAA, which is represented by the Chief Executive

Officers of the major pipelines in the United States, Mexico, and

Canada became interested in risk management as a means to improve

safety. He noted that society and the marketplace are demanding

increased accountability from industry and the people that regulate the

industry, and INGAA believes that the risk management demonstration

program is very important in this regard. He emphasized the importance

of communications, and the need to continuously improve in a changing

world.

Mr. Martinelli, past President of Chevron Pipeline and Chairman of

the General Committee on Pipeline for API, recounted the history of how

industry, OPS, and other interested parties got to this point on risk

management. He applauded the tremendous amount of work done by a large

number of people in government and industry and the public. He noted

that a key recognition four years ago was ``one size fits all''

regulation was not in the best interests of anybody, and a fundamental

change was needed. Mr. Martinelli discussed the difficulty of change,

whether in a person, a company, or an entire industry, and challenged

all parties to not be fearful of change. He warned people not to get

caught up in the ``30-year'' syndrome or the ``not invented here''

syndrome that resists change. He also talked about the recognition that

government and industry had to be more collaborative than adversarial.

Mr. Martinelli also noted that we were not

[[Page 14731]]

at the end of a journey with the development of the risk management

building blocks, but just at the beginning of the journey, and the

journey will be a long and hard one that requires significant continued

effort from all parties. A key message was: ``Get comfortable with

change'' and he provided a rule of thumb called the Rule of Three

Positives. ``When somebody suggests a change to you, don't say: `No,

that won't work. That's not the way I do it.' When somebody suggests

something new, stop and think and make three positive comments about

the new idea before you make one negative comment.'' He challenged the

companies to be innovative, creative, and provide OPS with so many

quality demonstration proposals that their selection process will be

difficult.

Mr. Felder closed the conference by expressing appreciation to all

those that attended and to all of his staff that made the public

meeting possible. He and Stacey Gerard then handed out DOT certificates

of appreciation to individuals outside the government, in industry, the

public, and contractors, that have worked with the various Risk

Assessment Quality Teams.

[FR Doc. 97-7827 Filed 3-26-97; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.