Medicare and Medicaid; Resident Assessment in Long Term Care Facilities
Federal RegisterDec 23, 1997
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
SUMMARY: This final rule establishes a resident assessment instrument
for use by long term care facilities participating in the Medicare and
Medicaid programs when conducting a periodic assessment of a resident's
functional capacity. The resident assessment instrument (RAI) consists
of a minimum data set (MDS) of elements, common definitions, and coding
categories needed to perform a comprehensive assessment of a long term
care facility resident. A State may choose to use the Federally
established resident assessment instrument or an alternate instrument
that is designed by the State and approved by us. These regulations
establish guidelines for use of the data set and designation of the
assessment instrument.
The provisions contained in these regulations implement statutory
requirements. The resident assessment instrument is intended to produce
a comprehensive, accurate, standardized, reproducible assessment of
each long term care facility resident's functional capacity.
EFFECTIVE DATE: Except for Secs. 483.20(f) and 483.315(h), these
regulations are effective March 23, 1998. Sections 483.20(f) Facility
computerization requirements and 483.315(h) State computerization
requirements are effective June 22, 1998.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Cindy Hake, (410) 786-3404.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
On December 28, 1992, we published in the Federal Register, at 57
FR 61614, a proposed rule with an opportunity for public comment,
``Resident Assessment in Long Term Care Facilities,'' which established
a resident assessment instrument that all long term care facilities
participating in the Medicare and Medicaid programs must use when
conducting an assessment of a resident's functional capacity. We
proposed that a State may choose to use the Federally established
resident assessment instrument or an alternate instrument that is
designed by the State and approved by us. We proposed that a facility
must enter information from the resident assessment into a computer, in
accordance with HCFA-specified formats. At least monthly, the facility
must transmit electronically the information contained in each resident
assessment to the State.
The resident assessment instrument would consist of a minimum data
set (MDS) of screening and assessment elements, including common
definitions and coding categories for use by a facility in performing a
comprehensive assessment of a long term care facility resident. In
addition to containing identifying information such as name, birthdate,
and occupation, the MDS consists of standardized items that assess, for
example, a resident's communication patterns, cognitive patterns,
physical functioning and structural problems, health conditions, and
medications. The proposed rule established guidelines for use of the
data set, and designated one or more assessment instruments that a
State may require a facility to use.
We proposed to add a new Sec. 483.315, which would require a State
to specify for use in long term care facilities within the State either
the HCFA-designated resident assessment instrument or an alternate
instrument. The State would request and receive approval from us before
implementing or modifying an alternate instrument. The uniform MDS was
included in Sec. 483.315(b). We also provided as attachments to the
regulations the utilization guidelines for the resident assessment
instrument, MDS common definitions, and resident assessment protocols
(RAPs).
II. Analysis of and Responses to Public Comments
We received 146 timely letters in response to our December 28,
1992, proposed regulation. Most were from provider organizations and
nursing home staff. We also heard from consumer organizations,
professional organizations, nursing home residents and their families,
and State and Federal agencies.
Prior to addressing comments on specific regulatory sections, we
will provide a summary of public comments on major topics, and discuss
some of the general issues raised by these regulations (in the order in
which those issues appeared in the preamble to the proposed rule).
Summary of Public Comments
Summary of Public Comments on MDS
During the public comment period, respondents suggested over 70
different additions to the MDS. Many commenters suggested modifying
items to increase clarity. For example, the item ``wheeled self'' was
divided into two items, ``wheeled self on unit'' and ``wheeled self off
unit'' to further differentiate a resident's capabilities. Commenters
also suggested the addition of items that provided information needed
by clinical staff caring for residents. Data suggest that nursing home
residents experience pain on a regular basis, but the MDS items
associated with pain did not differentiate the intensity and location
of pain (chest, joint, other). We expanded MDS items associated with
pain to assist clinicians in determining the nature and scope of pain
for care planning purposes.
There was a concern expressed by commenters that the MDS, as
originally designed, could not be used for determining nursing home
payment or monitoring quality of care, either at the resident and or
the facility level. To address this concern, we added items to the MDS
that are needed to support a case-mix classification system for long
term care facility payment known as, Resource Utilization Groups III,
which is a mechanism for determining the level of resources necessary
to care for an individual based upon his clinical characteristics as
measured by the MDS. This classification system was developed under the
auspices of the HCFA-funded Multistate Nursing Home Case-mix and
Quality demonstration, whose purpose is to develop, implement and
evaluate a case-mix payment system for SNF services under Medicare. The
original four States participating in the demonstration began using the
MDS+ (an alternate RAI that consists of the original MDS, plus
additional assessment items specified by the State for use in all
Medicare and Medicaid-certified nursing homes in the State), based on
the Resource Utilization Groups III classification system in their
Medicaid programs in 1994, as have several other States subsequently.
Section 4432 of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 (Public Law 105-
33), amends section 1888 of the Social Security Act (the Act), by
adding a new subsection (e). The Balanced Budget Act and the
Prospective Payment System (PPS) will require national implementation
in Fiscal Year 1998 of a casemix payment system for Medicare that is
based on MDS data. The Secretary determines the manner and
[[Page 67175]]
time frames within which resident assessment data are collected at the
State and national levels to develop and implement casemix payment
rates. The resident assessment data submitted to the State is a
resource upon which the Secretary can draw for development and
implementation of the PPS system.
We added other items to the original MDS to ensure that key
indicators of quality of care, (known as quality measures) could be
derived from the MDS and monitored longitudinally at the resident and
facility level. The addition of items needed to support payment and
quality monitoring programs will also strengthen the clinical relevancy
of the MDS by providing important information to facility staff about
the resident's potential for achieving the highest level of
functioning. One example of such items are nursing care interventions
related to rehabilitation and restorative care for the resident, such
as range of motion, training and skill practice in walking,
transferring, eating, dressing/grooming, and communication.
Commenters were particularly concerned with the ability of the MDS
to assist in assessing the quality of life for nursing home residents.
Revisions we made within the section on mood and behavior, in
particular, have the potential for providing important information
regarding the resident's risk for depression, as well as the presence
of depression. Nursing home residents have a high risk of developing
depression, with clinical experts estimating that at least 60 percent
of current nursing home residents have some level of depression.
However, analysis of MDS records for a large group of residents showed
that the mood and behavior items were checked for only 16 percent of
the residents. We found that nursing homes that have clinical staff
with expertise in this area identify more residents with mood and
behavior problems. Concerned that residents with, or at risk of,
depression may not be identified, we have modified the mood and
behavior items to help facility staff identify objective behaviors
frequently associated with depression. We also added a scale to measure
the frequency with which these symptoms occur. An item indicating the
use of a behavior management program was modified to allow the assessor
to identify specific strategies that were being used with the resident
to deal with mood and behavior symptoms.
Finally, commenters expressed concern that the MDS was not
appropriate to use with some groups of nursing home residents, such as
the non-elderly or short term stay populations. To better understand
the changing nursing home population, we have added an item in Section
P that identifies different populations often served by nursing homes
(for example, pediatric resident, hospice care resident). To address
commenters' concerns, we also added items focusing more on short-term
nursing and therapy needs, and issues important to terminal residents,
such as pain. We also expanded the item on discharge planning to assess
the resident's potential for discharge, including the resident's desire
to return to the community and the presence of a support person who is
positive towards discharge. This item will also be useful in developing
a RAP on discharge planning that was suggested by a number of
commenters.
Summary of Public Comments on Triggers
Commenters believed that the trigger legend was too complex and
needed to be simplified or eliminated. It is substantially revised, and
we have reduced the number of triggers for particular RAPs. We have
also eliminated the categories of automatic and potential triggers as
this had not been well understood and sometimes led to unnecessary work
by nursing home staff.
Summary of Public Comments on the RAP Summary Form
We revised the RAP Summary Form and accompanying instructions to
reduce confusion regarding their use that was noted by commenters.
Specifically, the revised form provides a column for indicating if the
RAP was triggered. It provides more specific instruction and direction
on the type of information that we would expect a facility to document
for each triggered RAP, including rationale to support decision-making
regarding whether to proceed with a care plan for a triggered RAP.
Additionally, because we consider the RAPs part of the utilization
guidelines for the MDS, we designated the RAP Summary form as Section V
of the MDS. This will provide nursing home staff and surveyors with
more complete information on resident care problems and outcomes. This
will also permit surveyors to monitor the completion of the RAPs.
Summary of Public Comments on RAPs
Most of the commenters valued the RAPs as part of the RAI for
improving the quality of care. A number of commenters indicated the
need for the addition of new RAPs. Specifically, we received comments
suggesting the creation of RAPs on discharge planning, pain, terminal
care/imminent death, resident rights, bowel incontinence/constipation,
abnormal lab values, and foot care. A new RAP on discharge planning is
already developed and we expect to develop other RAPs during 1997.
There was also concern that many of the current RAPs do not address
the needs of short-stay residents. Work is currently in progress and we
expect to publish revised RAP Guidelines that address the needs of this
population in 1997.
Comments on MDS and RAPS
Comment: Most commenters asserted that the original MDS did not
provide enough information in some areas. These commenters noted that
the areas of nursing diagnosis and medical needs, and certain
information needed for care planning, were lacking. Some commenters
stated that professional nurses are knowledgeable regarding areas that
are not addressed on the MDS and automatically incorporate them into
the assessment and care plan. Another commenter pointed out that the
MDS+ includes additional information that is helpful in care planning.
Response: As discussed elsewhere, we have added a number of items
that nursing home staff have identified as useful in assessing a
resident's functional capability and medical problems. We have also
clarified items that had been confusing for facility staff in the past.
Some of the items added to the MDS were previously on the MDS+. We
believe that the MDS captures information on most of the areas of
concern in assessing nursing home residents. While we agree that there
are additional items that would provide necessary information for
nursing home staffs' use in care planning, it is not possible for us to
design an instrument that covers every potential item that a nursing
home needs to know to provide care to residents. The RAI is not
intended to replace or substitute for a resident's full clinical
record. The facility should document in those clinical records
pertinent information whether or not required by the RAI. A facility is
responsible for providing care that is necessary to assist a resident
in attaining or maintaining his or her highest practicable well-being,
regardless of whether the care areas are captured on the MDS. A
facility may document additional information regarding the resident's
status wherever it chooses in the resident's clinical records.
Comment: One commenter urged that we move cautiously in adding any
other
[[Page 67176]]
data elements to the MDS, explaining that some States with a non-MDS
based case-mix system are having difficulty merging the MDS and their
reimbursement system. Other commenters disagreed regarding the need to
add items to the MDS at this time. They thought that we should maintain
the status quo until the industry and surveyors have more fully
understood and integrated the current instrument into their way of
doing business. Commenters mentioned that the MDS is a screening tool
that already contains most of the relevant items. One commenter stated
that the original MDS underwent extensive scrutiny and testing during
its development and should be kept as is for at least 10 years in order
to maintain consistency for providers, computer companies, research,
and case-mix reimbursement.
Response: We disagree regarding the need to maintain the MDS for
the next several years in the form it was originally issued in 1990
(not as revised in 1995 in version 2.0). Many of the changes in version
2.0 of the MDS were made to address areas that had been particularly
troublesome or poorly understood by clinicians responsible for
completing the RAI. Moreover, changes in the MDS have not been frequent
enough to cause significant disruption for facilities. Nearly all
States began to require use of the original RAI in late 1990 or early
1991, and most did not require facilities to use the new RAI until
January 1996 (with some States deferring that requirement to 1997).
This means that the original RAI was in place for nearly 5 years before
facilities were expected to change to the new instrument. Additionally,
it is less burdensome and confusing to incorporate necessary
improvements in the RAI at this time than it will be after
implementation of requirements in this regulation for facility
computerization of MDS information. Overall, the advantages of
implementing version 2.0 of the RAI in 1996 far outweigh maintenance of
the original assessment system.
If clinically warranted and supported by affected parties, we
anticipate reviewing the MDS every 3 to 5 years to determine whether it
needs to be revised, and sponsoring the development of a new version of
the RAI approximately every 5 years. For all RAI refinement activities,
we will seek the input of interested and affected parties.
Comment: Several other commenters expressed the belief that we
should conduct more RAI training on a national level and institute a
facility support effort, rather than making major changes to the
instrument.
Response: We support the need for more RAI training at all levels
and have numerous activities underway to strengthen the knowledge of
facility staff and surveyors about comprehensive assessment and its
linkage to resident care planning and quality of care. The need for
additional RAI training has been consistently supported by the States,
provider, consumer and professional associations with which we have
worked to develop version 2.0 of the RAI. In 1995, we published a new
edition of the Resident Assessment Instrument User's Manual for version
2.0 of the RAI that contains new information on the use of the RAPs and
linking the RAI to care plans. We have developed ``train the trainer''
materials for use in both provider and surveyor training, and have
begun a multi-year effort to develop educational materials for both
providers and surveyors at both basic and advanced levels. We train all
long term care facility surveyors on the RAI as part of our basic
health surveyor course and have offered specialty courses on advanced
resident assessment issues for surveyors as well as other State staff
on a routine basis. We also offered a full-day program on resident
assessment for all long term care facility surveyors during each of the
HCFA regional conferences held during 1994. We are committed to working
in partnership with providers and States to identify training needs and
develop methods to facilitate the dissemination of consistent
information and improve providers' use of the RAI in order to improve
care outcomes for nursing home residents.
We believe that the industry also shares a responsibility to
promote understanding of the RAI within facilities. Provider and
professional organizations should offer sessions on resident assessment
during their annual meetings or as special continuing education
programs held throughout the course of the year. Our staff have
participated in a number of national meetings and will continue to do
so, as warranted. However, we believe that providers can best learn how
to integrate RAI requirements into their daily practice from other
providers who have implemented successful programs. We encourage the
use of ``peer teaching'' programs in a variety of forms.
Beneficiary organizations have also played an important role in
getting information on the RAI out to their members. The organizations
have educated residents, families and ombudsmen regarding the role of
resident assessment in quality care and how to use the RAI in care
planning and conflict resolution. They also provided invaluable input
in modifying the RAI.
As part of a contract with us, the Research Triangle Institute
evaluated the extent to which facilities had implemented the RAI as
well as the accuracy of the assessments being conducted. The Research
Triangle Institute compared available assessment information for 23
specific assessment items in facilities both before and after the
implementation of the RAI. Their sample consisted of over 260
facilities in 10 States. The Research Triangle Institute's results
showed that:
The percent of residents with no assessment information
available for particular health status issues decreased on average by
81 percent;
The percent of residents with accurate information
documented on assessment items increased on average by 24 percent;
The percent of residents with available information on all
23 items increased by 53 percent.
The Research Triangle Institute's study asserts that facilities are
using the RAI, and that the RAI has resulted in the presence of more
accurate information on which a facility can base its individualized
care plans.
Comment: Commenters addressed the usefulness of the RAPs. Of those
who responded to this request for comment, some said that the RAPs are
useful and provide a structured framework for making sense of the MDS
data through analysis, interpretation, and synthesis, believing that
the RAPs tie the assessment process together. A consumer advocacy
organization believed that the RAPs assist facility staff in learning
causes of problems and identifying potential risks of decline that
require further staff attention. A few said that the RAPs have improved
the quality of care in nursing homes, or could with the appropriate
training and administrative support.
Response: The RAPs are structured decision frameworks which contain
guidelines for additional assessment of relevant resident attributes,
risk factors, clinical history and other factors. They assist with
clinical decision-making and help nursing home staff gather and analyze
necessary information to develop an appropriate and individualized care
plan.
The Guidelines section of each RAP assists staff to determine
whether a problem exists and to identify relevant causal factors that
affect the resident's condition. The RAPs also offer suggestions
regarding how a facility can eliminate or minimize factors
[[Page 67177]]
contributing to the resident's problem, or how a facility can maximize
a resident's strengths to achieve the highest practicable well-being.
In this way, the RAPs help facility staff to develop an individualized
care plan that meets the needs of the resident.
According to the report of the Research Triangle Institute's study,
directors of nursing indicated the RAP triggers and guidelines were
used routinely in over 90 percent of the facilities participating in
the survey. Three-quarters of the directors of nursing stated that they
believed that use of the RAP triggers had increased their facility's
ability to identify residents' clinical problems, and two-thirds
believed that using the RAPs had increased their facility's ability to
identify residents' potential for rehabilitation improvement.
Among the 180 directors of nursing who thought the RAP triggers had
increased identification of clinical problems, 45 percent were able to
identify, without prompting, specific RAPs for which this increase was
most pronounced. They most frequently cited cognitive loss/dementia (21
percent), ADL/functional rehabilitation potential (17 percent),
delirium (16 percent), and communication (15 percent). Seventy-two
percent of the directors of nursing interviewed stated that they did
not believe it had been at all difficult for staff to provide necessary
care in response to the newly identified clinical problems.
Comment: Some commenters believed that the RAPs are too
prescriptive, and that we are ``legislating a cookbook approach.''
Response: RAPs function as resident-care related assessment tools
rather than as clinical standards. RAPs do not contain prescriptive
mandates to perform particular diagnostic tests or specialized
assessments. Rather, RAPs lead facility staff through a process that
enables them to gain a better understanding of the resident's status in
a particular area.
For each resident, facility staff are required to make decisions
regarding whether each RAP that triggered for that resident identifies
a problem that requires care planning and intervention. Staff are
required to proceed with a care plan only if clinically appropriate. As
part of the RAP review process, facilities are required to document key
information regarding a particular area or condition that includes
objective findings and subjective complaints of the resident.
Irrespective of RAI requirements, this type of information should be
routinely assessed and documented by a facility as a part of good
clinical practice. We do not require that a facility provide
documentation that addresses each issue or question raised in a
particular RAP guideline. We disagree that the RAPs represent a
cookbook approach. The RAPs are tested assessment protocols that lead
facility staff through a focused, logically progressive, clinical
evaluation of the resident, relative to the particular area addressed
by the RAP. The RAPs are not intended to prescribe courses of action
for a facility. Rather, they provide a structured, problem-oriented
framework for organizing MDS information and additional clinically
relevant information that identifies medical problems. Upon completion
of the RAPs, the facility staff will have:
Identified clinical issues unique to the resident that may
adversely affect his or her highest practicable level of well-being;
Identified factors that place the resident's highest
practicable functioning at risk;
Considered whether the identified potential problems could
be prevented or reversed, or risk factors minimized, and evaluated the
extent to which the resident is able to attain a higher level of well-
being and functional independence; and
Evaluated ongoing care practices for the individual
resident.
Comment: One commenter asked that we not mandate standards for care
planning until there is better understanding of how the assessment
process works. The commenter stated that a great deal of work needs to
be done in setting up appropriate standards for care planning.
Response: Neither the RAPs, nor any other component of the RAI
contains required standards of care or standards regarding the specific
interventions and time frames for evaluation that must be present in
care plans. As noted in the responses above, the RAPs are a structured
framework that lead the facility through more in-depth assessment; they
do not mandate a course of action for care planning. A facility has a
great deal of flexibility in developing a care plan to meet a
resident's individual needs.
Comment: Some who commented thought that the RAPs are too complex
and difficult to use. One expressed the belief that the RAPs are not
the only correct criteria for providing good care. Another pointed out
that it has been a difficult learning process for facilities to
understand that the MDS provides only raw data about a resident.
Commenters recommended that some of the RAP items be included in the
MDS as core assessment items.
Response: We agree that there has been a steep learning curve in
terms of facilities' understanding of the RAPs and their ability to
integrate them into day-to-day clinical process. Anecdotally, and more
recently supported in the Research Triangle Institute study, facilities
report that understanding and use of the RAPs has lagged well behind
that of the MDS. Recognizing that the system required a major learning
process, we have tried to address the RAPs in newer versions of our
train-the-trainer courses offered annually for State RAI coordinators.
Initially, our courses and materials focused on use of the MDS, then
use of the RAPs, then integration of the RAI in care planning. Many
States are still in the process of conducting training sessions for
providers on use of the RAPs and care planning.
We also have made revisions to the RAP Summary form and our
instructions regarding use of the RAPs in order to make them easier to
understand and use. We will continue to refine our training products as
well as evaluate facility staffs' ability to use the RAPs. If problems
are identified, we are open to exploring ways to revise the RAP format
or content in order to make the comprehensive assessment process more
meaningful and productive for both facility staff and residents. We
have incorporated some additional RAP triggers into the MDS and
integrated assessment procedures contained in the RAP Guidelines
throughout the instructions contained in the October 1995 edition of
the RAI User's Manual.
Comment: A few commenters suggested that we make the RAPs available
to facilities on request. Commenters asserted that often there is not a
copy at the nurse's station.
Response: We agree that it is important for the RAPs to be
available for staff use. In 1990, we sent information to each nursing
home administrator regarding the RAI, and this information included a
copy of the RAPs. Additionally, in 1990, we provided each State with a
camera-ready copy of the original version of the RAI, and in 1995, we
provided each State with a camera-ready copy of the new RAI, version
2.0. States were then responsible for providing facilities with a copy
of the revised RAI including the RAPs.
We do not believe it is our responsibility to ensure that each
nursing home currently has a copy of the RAPs. Facilities could request
a copy from States, provider organizations or from other sources.
However, we are exploring strategies to improve consistent distribution
of RAI
[[Page 67178]]
information to nursing homes and ensure that clinical staff have access
to the RAI User's Manual. We believe that for the RAPs to be used as
intended, a copy of the RAPs should be available at each nursing
station. States are responsible for communicating with facilities
regarding the State-specified instrument and should, therefore, ensure
that the facilities have the most current RAPs.
Comment: Some commenters wanted more flexibility in using the RAPs.
They thought the RAPs should be adaptable, and, as professionals,
facility staff should be able to pick and choose appropriate
interventions from those suggested in the RAPs. Commenters also
suggested that we make the RAPs optional. One commenter believed that
the final product and process forces health care professionals into a
format that stifles flexibility and interferes with the assessment and
care planning process. Another suggestion was to allow a facility to
use the RAPs as a flexible assistive device in care planning.
Response: We agree that facility staff are capable professionals
and, as such, should be able to use the RAPs as is appropriate for each
individual resident. This has always been our intent regarding their
use. A facility may supplement the RAP assessment.
We believe that negative feelings regarding the utility of the RAPs
are associated with lack of understanding of their use. As
aforementioned, our training in the past did not focus on the RAPs. It
has been our experience that facility staff who have been properly
trained on the RAPs and integrated them into their clinical practice
are convinced of their utility and positive effects on resident
outcomes.
We do not believe that use of the RAPs should be optional, as they
reflect necessary components of a comprehensive assessment. The RAPs
represent a standard methodology for assessing and analyzing certain
aspects of resident status. As part of the utilization guidelines for
the RAI, the RAPs ensure consistent identification of medical problems
and description of functional capabilities. They supplement the MDS to
provide a standardized comprehensive assessment as is required by the
Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1987 (OBRA '87).
Comment: A few commenters suggested that we collaborate with the
Department's Agency for Health Care Policy and Research and the
industry to make the RAPs more germane to current industry practice,
knowledge, and standards. One commenter wanted us to provide actual
assessment tools and decision trees. A State provider association
recommended that the RAI contain fewer RAPs, and furthermore, that we
encourage facilities to develop their own triggers consistent with
their care planning system.
Response: We collaborated extensively with the industry in
developing the original 18 RAPs. The Department's Agency for Health
Care Policy and Research was not yet in existence when we developed the
original RAPs. In revising the RAPs, we will seek the input of
interested and affected parties. Regarding the comment to develop
assessment tools and decision trees, it would be difficult for us to
develop decision trees that cover all possible scenarios. We do not
wish to require such a methodology for completing the RAPs, as it would
limit the flexibility of facilities. Most providers have tended to
request that we develop more RAPs, rather than fewer. We have an
ongoing process for developing new RAPs by clinical experts and
validating the RAPs through testing. Also, we will review the content
of the current RAPs to ensure that they contain information pertinent
to the changing nursing home population. We do not anticipate issuing
changes to the RAPs more frequently than once a year. States may, with
our approval, revise their instruments as frequently as they deem
necessary.
Triggers are risk factors or strengths that are indicative of a
need for additional assessment. They do not automatically flag all
problems worthy of care planning. The original triggers were developed
using an expert consensus process and have been empirically validated.
As such, it is inappropriate to suggest that a facility identify its
own triggers based on their care planning systems. A facility may
choose to add additional triggers, but must use at least the triggers
identified in the State RAI. Facility staff may choose to assess
residents using the RAPs even if the RAPs are not triggered.
Comment: Commenters suggested that we emphasize that the RAP
process is not limited to the completion of the RAP Summary form. It
includes the need to understand why the resident's condition triggered
the RAP. The commenter also recommended that the RAI Training Manual
contain a set of examples concerning how to use the information in the
RAPs as part of the assessment process.
Response: We agree that the RAP process is not merely filling out
the RAP Summary form, but is an important link between gathering
assessment information and developing the appropriate care plan. In
April 1992, we issued guidance to our regional offices and the States
regarding the RAP process and other policy issues. We also shared this
information with provider and consumer organizations. We have revised
the RAI User's Manual to include this guidance and more specific
instructions and examples, including RAP documentation and linkages to
care planning. In October 1995, we distributed to States and
associations ``train the trainer'' materials that included special
course content for RAI surveyors and trainers. This included
instructions on using the RAPs.
Comment: A commenter urged that we structure the RAPs so that they
identify resident problems, complicating conditions and risk factors.
The individual stated that some RAPs are currently in this structure
and that this would make the RAPs easier to use.
Response: We believe that all RAPs presently contain this
information. However, we are open to reviewing the RAPs to ensure that
their format is consistent as a part of our ongoing RAP review and
refinement process that we began in 1995.
Comments on the Development of a Computerized National Data Base of
Assessment Information
Comment: Generally, commenters that supported the proposed
requirement to computerize the MDS included State governments and
national and State provider organizations. One State expressed the
belief that computerization should be optional; they thought that
States should determine when and whether participation is feasible
given the States' prevailing conditions.
Response: We intend to implement a Federal process for assuring and
improving quality in this country's nursing homes which relies on
resident-level MDS assessment data reported by nursing homes
participating in Medicaid and Medicare. Furthermore, our intention is
to improve the Federal long term care survey process by using
information derived from MDS data to identify potential quality
problems within nursing facilities. The goals of this approach are
twofold: to improve care received by beneficiaries by enhancing the
timeliness and effectiveness of facility monitoring; and to better
utilize survey agency resources by targeting potential problem
facilities and by focusing onsite survey activities on specific problem
areas within a facility.
We view the collection of MDS data and its use within a
standardized survey process, as defined under our State
[[Page 67179]]
Operations Manual as being consistent with our current practices. Under
the present survey process, the facility must submit specific
information to the State survey agency, including data on resident
census, facility staffing and ownership status. These facility-specific
data, along with other information gathered by the survey team (for
example, facility deficiency information) are currently maintained both
at State agencies and within a national data base maintained by HCFA.
In addition, survey teams review residents' clinical records and other
resident-specific information. The submission and use of MDS data
within the context of facility regulation is entirely consistent with
existing practices and our obligation to collect the information
necessary to ensure the quality of care provided to residents of
Medicare and Medicaid certified long term care facilities.
Automated data collection is essential to meaningful analysis of
the quantity of data collected. The MDS data system would allow us to
expand our existing system for gathering data related to quality, and
provide us with objective and detailed measures of the health status
and care outcomes for residents of a facility. Coupled with facility
characteristic and deficiency history data, we expect the MDS system
will be more reliable and effective in supporting early identification
of potential care problems and directing the survey process towards
these identified problem areas.
In their roles as our agents for conducting regulatory survey and
quality assurance activities, States will be required to process and
analyze MDS data reported by facilities to meet the objectives stated
above. MDS information collected by States will also be used to
construct a national repository of MDS assessments. The national data
base will be used to serve numerous functions: to study and refine the
quality measures used to direct survey activities of State agencies
(for example, to enhance the ability of these indicators to support
survey targeting); to understand the characteristics of the nation's
nursing home residents and the services they receive; to measure the
impact of regulation and assist in the formulation of national health
care policy; and to provide researchers with information needed to
evaluate the outcomes of various types of care and to improve standards
of clinical practice.
Our authority to require computerization of MDS information is
based on our general authority to set health and safety standards for
providers under sections 1819(f)(1) and 1919(f)(1) of the Act. We will
use the computerized data to establish standards, evaluate a facility's
compliance with these standards, and review the standards'
effectiveness and their continued appropriateness. For example,
analysis of MDS assessments within a national repository might indicate
an increase in the number of residents suffering from depression. We
may then develop standards to assist facility staff in detecting and
treating the disease. Such a standard could then be evaluated and its
effectiveness assessed by a process of continually re-analyzing the MDS
data base for changes in the prevalence of this characteristic over
time.
Computerization of RAI data is also consistent with our authority
under sections 1819(h)(3) and 1919(h)(3) of the Act to perform, review
and validate facility surveys. As is discussed above, we intend to
revise the survey process to utilize computerized assessment data. The
new process will be an information-based approach, oriented around
quality measures derived from computerized MDS data, as well as other
sources of information. Furthermore, sections 1819(g)(2)(A)(I) and
1919(g)(2)(A)(I) of the Act mandate that we subject facilities to a
``standard'' survey. The availability of computerized assessment data
will improve our ability to make the survey process more standard and
consistently implemented within the across the States.
Currently, part of the standard survey includes an assessment of
the status of a sample of residents over time to determine whether the
facility has assisted the residents to attain or maintain their highest
practicable level of well-being. Computerized assessment data will be
instrumental in that it will allow a complete monitoring of
characteristics of ``all'' residents, including changes in their
functional status over time. Furthermore, under the current survey
process, we can only determine changes in resident status and a
facility's relative success in maintaining resident well-being cross-
sectionally during an annual onsite survey. MDS computerization, on the
other hand, provides the ability to monitor resident functional status
and other characteristics through a longitudinal process of continuous
measurement.
These uses of computerized RAI data also provide justification for
requiring computerization under our overall program supervision
responsibilities and general rulemaking authority under section 1102 of
the Act, to the extent that the information will be used for general
monitoring of care and beneficiary needs. This computerized information
will ensure that program standards set forth in sections 1819(b) and
1919(b) of the Act are met, that the program is being properly
administered, and that beneficiaries are being served, as contemplated
generally by the Act. We address elsewhere the further uses of the data
for monitoring the Medicaid and Medicare programs.
In addition to the authority cited above, to the extent that the
RAI data are collected solely for Medicaid purposes, section 1906(a)(6)
of the Act requires State agencies to make reports as required by the
Secretary. As discussed above, the RAI data are essential for the
Secretary's evaluation and monitoring responsibilities under the Act.
We disagree with suggestions to offer States a choice to
participate in the proposed national MDS data base for a number of
reasons. First, the processes being regulated by Federal authority via
State agencies (healthcare delivery and associated standards of care)
do not have varying criteria from one State to the next. In other
words, standards of medical care and health service delivery do not
vary across States; health standards in New York are the same as those
in Alaska. This commonality has reasonably led to the formulation of
one national set of regulations to evaluate provider performance with
respect to these common health standards. It is our belief that this
standard regulatory approach is in the best interest of the nation's
healthcare consumers with respect to both ensuring consistent delivery
of services across States and with respect to the healthcare industry's
reasonable expectation to operate under a single set of rules and
requirements. Thus, as this standard approach to facility regulation
evolves over time, with its specific objectives for continuous
improvement and refinement, it is appropriate for us to require our
agents (in other words, States) to adopt the standard processes and
mechanisms required to consistently implement these new approaches.
Specifically, allowing States to choose not to adopt a standard
system for MDS information will adversely affect our ability to meet
the objectives for these data. The following goals cannot be met
without consistent implementation of the MDS system and process
standards across all States:
The ability to construct a modern regulatory model
provides a reliable and objective means of measuring facility
performance. MDS information gathered and maintained by a standard
system in each State provides an information structure capable of
providing this
[[Page 67180]]
alternate approach to measuring quality and creates the foundation for
an information-based regulatory model. The ability to successfully
implement such an approach is directly tied to process standardization
across States.
If States are allowed to choose not to operate this
standard system, then we would not be capable of developing and
implementing a facility targeting system or, information-based survey
process consistently across States; thus, at best, an environment would
exist in which facilities in one State would be subject to different
quality monitoring and survey approaches than facilities in a
neighboring State.
Our ability to build a centralized national repository to
support our various objectives with respect to quality monitoring,
policy, program and regulatory development and evaluation, and to
facilitate healthcare research, is dependent on our ability to receive
reliable and timely MDS information from each State. Without a
standardized MDS collection system in each State, the development of
this MDS repository will be severely limited if not entirely impossible
due to the prohibitive costs associated with interacting with varying
system implementations in each State. Furthermore, without full
participation of each State in this program, the general
representativeness and usefulness of the information in the data base
will likely be skewed or biased, depending on which States choose to
participate. This would affect the validity of the information and
could seriously limit its application for health resource planning and
research of value to State and Federal governments, providers and
consumers.
Finally, States will play a critical role in informing
consumers in that States will make aggregate MDS information available.
This information will allow potential residents or their family members
to select a facility that may best suit their needs. Without a standard
approach and system for developing these public information resources,
consumers and advocacy groups will not have reliable, consistent and
comparable information healthcare providers across States.
Comment: In commenting on what specific uses States would have for
the computerized data, commenters discussed using the data in the
nursing home survey process. One State believed that the data would
assist State survey agencies to focus the survey process and set norms.
A consumer advocacy organization pointed out that, based on the
strengths and weaknesses of a facility, a State could individualize the
composition of the survey team sent to evaluate the facility's
regulatory compliance. In other words, the number and type of surveyors
sent onsite would be based on the types of potential care problems
identified at the facility. For example, if a facility had a high
prevalence of antipsychotic drug use, the survey team would include a
pharmacist. This approach has the dual benefits of maximizing limited
survey agency resources by better targeting them against the most
likely problem areas, and for minimizing the general invasiveness of
the survey process within the facility by focusing the process on key
problem areas.
The MDS data set provides objective and consistent measures of a
number of facility care and outcome parameters. By comparing individual
providers to ``gold standards'' and other peer group-based norms on
each of these parameters, States can identify high and low facility
performance outliers on measures associated with the quality of care
and the quality of life for residents of these facilities. Commenters
also suggested that the data could be used to replace some resident-
level information currently collected during the survey process on a
form called the Resident Census and Conditions of Residents (HCFA-672),
as well as other reporting forms for State and Federal needs, which
would reduce facility burden. The MDS assessment contains detailed
resident characteristics that can be used to eliminate all other forms
and resident-level data collected by facilities to meet State and
Federal requirements. One commenter, however, believed that the
information should not be collected by the survey agency and used for
investigations or enforcement.
Response: As described in prior responses, MDS data will assist
State survey agencies in a plethora of ways to achieve greater
efficiencies in monitoring quality of care and ensuring the highest
levels of quality of care and quality of life for residents of nursing
facilities. These examples include:
Problem identification: the capability to reliably target
areas for investigation of potential resident care problems prior to
and in support of the onsite survey process;
Survey targeting and scheduling: the ability to determine
survey frequency and scope based on specific indicators of potential
care problems;
Tailoring survey team composition to specific problem
potentials in facilities to most efficiently use limited staff and
resources. It is important to note that States currently are not
prohibited from considering nursing home characteristics when
determining survey team composition, provided that the team includes a
registered nurse. The State Operations Manual notes in section 2801
that to the extent practical, the team's composition should reflect the
type of facility surveyed; and
Conducting cost/benefit analysis of care approaches, based
on resident outcome data adjusted for case-mix classification
categories. This is consistent with the Department's medical treatment
effectiveness initiative.
Many software programs currently used by nursing homes to enter MDS
information already have the capacity to generate timely resident
census information such as that found on the HCFA form 672. Several
States are also developing systems to facilitate this activity for
providers. The availability of the MDS standard system will provide
significantly more detail on resident characteristics than general
census information, and will make use of definitions that have been
clinically developed and refined to maximize both reliability and
validity. As such, the MDS will create a whole new model for
understanding and communicating about resident characteristics. This
new model will far outperform the limited view of residents that can be
derived from information from current sources, such as the Form 672.
We further believe that automated resident status information has
much more potential to further decrease the amount of paper work
associated with the survey process. We have recently completed an
evaluation of the survey process and intend to make ongoing refinements
to incorporate new technologies and increase the efficiency of the
survey process.
Comment: One commenter stated that using computerized data to
target surveys would resemble a ``big brother'' environment and not one
conducive to accurate assessments for fear of investigations based upon
minimal data.
Response: We disagree that using assessment data to target the
survey process would resemble a ``big brother'' environment or that
fear of investigations would affect the accuracy of assessments.
Facilities already submit significant resident-level information to
support both survey agency functions and for claims processing under
Medicaid and Medicare. These data have been collected for years without
the adverse effects suggested by a ``big brother'' analogy; instead, to
the extent that facility information has been made public (for example,
release of survey and complaint results and findings), this release has
served to provide valuable information to those interested in promoting
the quality of life in nursing
[[Page 67181]]
facilities. There is no reason to believe that collection and analysis
of MDS information will not similarly be used in the interests of the
general public with respect to their right to know the quality of
healthcare services delivered by Medicaid and Medicare providers.
The MDS simply provides a better, more powerful mechanism than is
currently available to observe and report resident condition or to
monitor facility quality and safeguard the rights of residents of these
facilities. The MDS is a tool for measuring healthcare facility
performance, which also creates a foundation for improving the
effectiveness of regulatory agencies as well as their operational
efficiency.
Having a standard MDS repository available within State and Federal
agencies provides a rich information resource to serve many objectives:
it will provide access to reliable information and standard measures of
resident characteristics for the many groups interested in improving
care and quality of life in nursing homes, including consumer advocates
and researchers; and, the MDS will support many other programs within
States including providing the basis for Medicaid payments as is
currently in effect in a number of States.
Clearly, the availability of MDS information within standardized
Federal systems maintained by States directly benefits the general
public as consumers of healthcare services and generally enhances the
public knowledge of the quality of these services.
Furthermore, we expect that the MDS repository will enable HCFA or
its State agent, or both, to provide facilities with analytic reports
based on aggregated resident characteristics. This is consistent with a
quality improvement model, as it allows facilities to compare
themselves to other homes that are similar in terms of size and
resident demographics. This directly promotes facilities as they seek
to develop their own in-house quality assurance programs. Ultimately,
facilities may use the data in ways that would analyze allocation of
resources, and demonstrate efficiencies in caring for certain types of
residents, and in turn, negotiate with managed care organizations for
admission of certain types of residents.
We recognize that information contained within the MDS assessment
is sensitive and must be safeguarded, and that protecting the privacy
of residents is essential. In establishing a system of records for
storage of MDS data, both HCFA and the States (as HCFA's contractors in
performing survey functions) must comply with the Privacy Act, which
applies to Federal systems of records containing individually-
identifiable information. While we can make public aggregate summaries
of the data, there are strict Federal guidelines for the release of
individually-identifiable information by Federal agencies to any
individual or organization. We can only release individually-
identifiable information if a disclosure provision exists in the
Privacy Act System of Records that is published in the Federal
Register. We review requests on an individual basis, according to the
provisions of the Privacy Act. Refer to the more detailed discussion
later in this preamble concerning protection of privacy.
In summary, it is clear that the availability of structured
analyses derived from MDS information will empower those working with a
variety of approaches to improve the lives of residents of nursing
homes. Whereas the big brother term suggests a scenario in which the
interests of the individual are sacrificed to promote the interests of
the State, this is clearly not the case with respect to the objectives
for MDS information. Instead, MDS information will be used to directly
support the interests of individual nursing home residents by
substantially enhancing our understanding of healthcare delivery in
nursing homes and by creating a standard framework for monitoring the
quality of this care.
Comment: A few commenters noted that computerized assessment data
would support a case-mix reimbursement system, and that it would be
helpful to be able to compare facilities with similar case-mix levels.
Response: Our Office of Research and Demonstrations began the
Nursing Home Case-mix and Quality Demonstration in 1989. One goal of
the demonstration is to design, implement and evaluate a nursing home
payment and quality monitoring system for Medicare skilled nursing
facilities based on resident-level information contained in an expanded
set of MDS data. States participating in the demonstration are also
using MDS data to calculate reimbursement under Medicaid. Computerized
information from the demonstration's data base will provide information
on outcomes and processes of care, stratified by case-mix and other
characteristics in the six participating States. This will also provide
a mechanism by which to evaluate the effect of reimbursement on quality
issues.
Several other Medicaid agencies in States not participating in the
demonstration have chosen to independently implement an MDS-based case-
mix system for setting payment rates for facilities and for determining
coverage. Numerous other States are currently studying moving toward a
case-mix payment system based on the MDS. Furthermore, States have
identified a plethora of other functions to be supported by information
contained on the MDS assessment form, these functions include:
utilization review, service placement, and improvement in the States'
ability to monitor and evaluate the cost-effectiveness and quality of
care and services provided under the Medicaid program.
At least two States have already incorporated, or plan to
incorporate, MDS information into their Medicaid management information
system. West Virginia notes that to do so will allow the State to fine-
tune its long term care rate setting and payment methodology. West
Virginia integrated its stand-alone long term care payment process into
the Medicaid management information system. The system captures monthly
data to calculate the resident-specific case-mix index. An electronic
billing system was implemented through the Medicaid management
information system, which calculates the base rate reimbursement for
all Medicaid beneficiaries, as well as the additional payment due based
on the case-mix acuity determined from an expanded set of MDS data. The
MDS reporting system not only enables the Medicaid agency to conduct
utilization review, but also allows the survey agency to use the
reports for quality of care issues.
Another State has a legislative mandate to integrate to the fullest
extent possible, its MDS system, preadmission screening and annual
resident review system, and treatment authorization request system. The
State points out that, because it uses a composite per diem rate, the
State agency has little ability to comprehensively review and adjust
approval or reimbursement systems in order to improve the quality of
care, increase efficiency, or control costs in long term care. We
believe that integration of the MDS and the Medicaid management
information system will support the objectives of its Medicaid program,
including provision of the highest practical level of care and
management of available funds in a fiscally prudent manner to maximize
purchasing power. The State maintains that its system will provide
information to facilities, State and Federal agencies, and to the
public that will improve the quality and cost effectiveness of care
delivered in the State.
Comment: Another use of computerized resident data that
[[Page 67182]]
commenters addressed was to support policy analysis and monitoring of
trends. One State noted that the data could be used to inform and
improve general Medicare and Medicaid policies. Another State gave the
example of using the data as a tracking system for prevalence of
pressure sores, restraints, and drug therapy. A commenter stated that
data could be used by the appropriate quality monitoring personnel in
the State to increase the probability of detecting and analyzing State-
wide health care problems. Another State commenter suggested using the
data at the resident-specific level to determine an individual's needs
for assistance with activities of daily living and other required
services. The commenter also discussed analyzing aggregate information
for residents by facility.
Response: We agree that these data will benefit both the policy and
operational components of States and the Federal Government as well as
provide valuable information to the consumers of long term care
services.
Potential benefits in policy development and evaluation expected
from this information include the following:
Foremost is the added operational efficiency derived from
the MDS' ability to support a multitude of applications and
programmatic objectives. As a single form designed to capture a
comprehensive view of residents and related facility care practices,
when submitted within the context of a standardized data management
system, it greatly reduces the operational costs of data gathering as
compared to current program requirements involving multiple forms and
submissions from the facility. For example, many States receive three
different categories of resident information from facilities, each
requiring separate forms and submission rules: placement determination
forms (for example, preadmission screening and resident review),
payment-oriented clinical information to support case-mix adjustment
(for example, Minnesota's or West Virginia's case-mix assessments), and
survey-oriented forms describing resident characteristics. With the
breadth of data collected on the MDS, the requirements in each of these
examples can easily be met via a single submission of MDS data; thus,
the operational overhead and associated costs for both facility and
State are reduced.
At the national level, policy decision-making,
development, and evaluation are supported through the creation of a
standard means to analyze State differences in the quality of services
and resident care outcomes in the nation's 17,000 certified long term
care facilities.
By deriving both payment and quality functions from a
single instrument, a framework is developed to closely monitor the
relationship between payment and corresponding service delivery, and to
provide an objective basis upon which incentives to promote and reward
outstanding care patterns and outcomes can be built.
With respect to support for survey agency operations, creation of a
standardized MDS repository in State agencies provides the framework
for the development of an information-driven survey process by which
the frequency and scope of facility review are based on objective
measures of a facility's performance in comparison to established
standards. This information-based survey concept and its benefits are
discussed in prior sections of this regulation.
Comment: We also received other suggestions and examples of ways
that States are currently using computerized MDS data. A few States
indicated that they are using or could use the data for resident review
requirements under the preadmission screening and resident review
program (PASRR). Other ideas included:
Relating to research support, MDS information will support
both basic clinical research activities as well as practical
applications such as identifying issues for ``best practice''
conferences.
Using the resident data to identify strengths of each
facility, staffing patterns, common diagnoses, and resident
characteristics (suggested by a professional organization).
Using the data for health planning related to long term
care services, certificate of need decision-support, projecting nursing
home bed need, and determining characteristics and care needs of
current residents.
Identifying industry and surveyor training needs with
respect to changing demographics and industry structural delivery
mechanisms (for example, as service delivery blends across multiple
traditional care settings).
One State commenter expressed the belief that the paperwork burden
in that State would be reduced by having MDS data available for a
variety of purposes.
Response: We agree that potential benefits exist for all of the
above listed uses of automated assessment information. A standardized
system for MDS data collection and analysis that we will be providing
to States will facilitate States' and facilities' ability to make use
of these data by creating an infrastructure for managing, analyzing and
distributing information to meet these varying program objectives.
Comment: A commenter did not think that a facility could determine
staffing patterns from the MDS data set, which would negate its ability
to be used in determining differential rates of payment.
Response: The commenter is partially correct, in that the RAI does
not explicitly collect information on staffing. However, staffing
standards, staffing mix, and minimum staffing requirements are already
well understood with respect to the intensity of care required for a
given resident and his or her clinical characteristics. There are, in
fact, several commercially available systems that currently use MDS
data and derived resident characteristics information to assist
facility administrators in setting appropriate staffing levels
according to the mix of resident care requirements in their facility.
Furthermore, with respect to State payment and rate setting, States
that currently use an MDS-based case-mix payment approach have adopted
the resource utilization group methodology for the payment
determination. This methodology is based on resource groupings that are
created through time studies of facility staff as they carry out their
daily care tasks. These time study data are then linked to
corresponding resident characteristics data to determine levels of care
resource utilization (staff time, supplies, etc.) for given sets of
care needs.
Thus, in this approach, staff requirements are implicit in the
determination of each distinct care grouping, each of which is then
associated with a specific reimbursement rate. Residents with complex
care characteristics fall into a higher reimbursement group which
directly reflects the additional staff resources required to care for
that resident. In more sophisticated States, these models have been
extended to allow for staffing pay rate differences across various
regions within the State (for example, urban vs. rural staff pay
differentials).
The current MDS 2.0 assessment form includes calculations for
several of the most common variations of the resource utilization
group's scoring in the standard specification for MDS data. Therefore,
States that do not currently use case-mix-based reimbursement will
still have an implicit and proven method of measuring the relative care
and staffing requirements of residents
[[Page 67183]]
according to widely accepted norms for such comparisons.
Again, the ability to support this functionality is created by the
deployment of the standardized system for managing State MDS data
repositories, upon which such resource utilization groups-oriented
analyses will be derived.
Comment: We requested public comment on whether to collect a sample
or 100 percent of MDS data. Of those who commented, most believed it
would be preferable to collect 100 percent of facility data. One State
thought that collecting only a sample of data would not produce the
necessary level of detail required for a multipurpose data base system.
The commenter further stated that operational activities generally
focus on specific individuals, which would usually require information
on all residents from all facilities. Another noted that 100 percent
would be advantageous for rate setting and quality assurance,
recognizing that the intended use of the data influences the collection
requirements. The commenter said that an aggregate of 100 percent of
facility data would serve well for the Federal level data set. A third
State believed that having facilities submit data for all residents
would make the State survey agency's sampling procedure in the long
term care survey process more effective, as well as result in a
comprehensive national data base. One State thought that sampled data
would be disadvantageous in that it would provide incomplete or
inaccurate representation and would be influenced by factors such as
population density.
Those opposing collection of 100 percent of the data listed the
associated cost, the size of the data base, and the man hours involved
in collecting and maintaining the data. Proponents of collecting a
sample of facility data noted that current survey protocols determine
compliance with State and Federal requirements based on a sample, and
that MDS data set required for submission should be no different. A
national provider organization said that collecting 100 percent of the
data would not meet the underlying intent of the law pertaining to the
implementation of comprehensive assessments, the resultant care plans,
and improved quality of care. A national provider organization believed
that if 100 percent of the data is collected at the facility level, the
State should send us a stratified sample on a quarterly basis, while if
a sample is gathered at the facility level, the State should send us
the entire sample on a quarterly basis.
Response: There are many drawbacks associated with sampling. An
incomplete representation or smaller number of records would make
estimates of trends more difficult. Problems with resampling would
prevent the development of longitudinal measures. Such problems
include:
The retention of any bias in the initial sample that would
increase over time and would affect the reliability of the data.
The unequal burden on facilities in the sample to correct
errors, respond to inquiries and provide data.
The need to develop complex instructions that would direct
facilities how to replenish the sample when subjects drop out. We would
require other instructions to handle changes of ownership in
facilities, facilities that leave the Medicare and Medicaid programs,
and facilities that go out of business.
In short, it would be difficult and expensive to construct and
maintain a statistically significant sample of residents for whom we
would require a facility to transmit its MDS records to the State.
Furthermore, since the facility must obtain the information
required by the MDS on each resident for clinical care planning, and
given that most facilities today have already automated this process,
the added requirement of submission of data adds comparatively little
overhead and associated costs to this process. Certainly, there is some
fixed cost associated with developing and supporting transmission of a
single resident's record to the State, but the marginal cost of
transmitting all residents' records is negligible. Therefore, there is
no cost saving to the facility to transmit MDS assessments for a sample
versus the entire population of residents.
We agree with the comments that support requiring facilities to
transmit 100 percent of all required MDS assessments. We are requiring
that a facility submit all initial, annual, and quarterly reviews, as
well as partial assessments completed upon discharge, transfer, death,
or reentry to the facility, for all residents, and that a State submit
those assessments to us.
Generally, selection of a statistically representative sample of
MDS assessments adds another complicated, costly and unnecessary layer
to producing useful, valid data that can be used to inform States,
nursing homes, and us about the quality of care and the status of
residents in nursing homes.
One hundred percent of the data is necessary for the following
reasons:
It is necessary for longitudinal tracking of residents
across time and facility admissions. This will allow us to track
special subpopulations of residents such as those with pressure sores
or Alzheimer's disease. It will allow the detection of certain trends,
such as characteristics of new admissions to nursing facilities, and it
will allow the detection of rare but significant events, such as
hospitalizations for pneumonia, fractures or other conditions.
The universe of data is also necessary to link to facility
level data bases, such as ASPEN deficiency data in State agencies and
the Online Survey, Certification and Reporting System, and to link to
Medicare and Medicaid claims files at the national or State level to
determine patterns of utilization and resource use pre- and post-
admission to nursing homes, and to determine resource utilization in
nursing homes.
It allows for targeting individual and aggregate resident
outcomes for use in an information-driven survey process that would be
impossible without a universal data base.
The universe of MDS assessments makes possible the analysis of data
at any level (for example, resident, unit within a facility, facility,
State, regional, national, or for specific resident populations). An
incomplete representation or smaller number of MDS assessments, as well
as issues associated with resampling that were mentioned above, would
limit trend analyses.
Working with the universal population of resident assessments will
eliminate the technical difficulty and expense of selecting and
maintaining a representative sample such as will be necessary to
support longitudinal analyses. Creating and implementing a complex
sampling process would be burdensome to facilities and States, and the
burden could fall unequally on selected States or selected facilities.
If facilities were required to perform sampling, there would be
additional cost to upgrade their software and training for this
capability. Additionally, some sampling methodologies would require
complicated survey analyses to adjust sampling design. This would also
be expensive.
In conclusion, the marginal additional cost of obtaining the full
universe of assessments will, in fact, be exceeded by the cost and
difficulty of maintaining a representative sample of assessments large
enough to provide the necessary information for all the uses proposed
for the data base.
[[Page 67184]]
Comment: A State suggested submitting 100 percent of data to the
State, which would then submit only a sample to us. The State contended
that it needed the most complete data set possible. The State also
noted that its data base would be manageable and would not warrant
sampling.
Response: We disagree with the concept of sending a sample of data
to us. Our regional offices have many of the same needs as State survey
agencies for 100 percent of resident-level data for certified long term
care facilities within their States as one method to target and conduct
Federal monitoring surveys in nursing homes. Furthermore, we need 100
percent of the data to develop and refine quality measures, which will
be an integral part of the data-driven survey process.
All the factors enumerated in the above comment regarding the
negative aspects of sampled submissions between facilities and States
apply equally to the submission between States and the national data
base: there is no advantage in terms of cost saving by using a sampling
approach as it is no more costly or complex to transmit assessments for
the full population. In fact, managing sampled data sets is actually
more costly; and, the ability to meet the objectives for these data at
the national level in terms of support for policy decision-making,
development and evaluation, as well as for support for research
initiatives, requires access to a complete population-based repository
of assessments.
Comment: Commenters discussed whether a national data base would
provide useful information to States for making comparisons for
management, performance, measurement, and research purposes. Of those
who addressed this, all agreed that such information would be valuable.
One State said that it would be helpful for them to be able to compare
their State with others regarding length of stay for residents with
certain diagnoses and for utilization rates of special treatments and
procedures.
Response: As discussed previously, we agree that there are many
useful purposes for information from this proposed national MDS data
base. One example of this submitted by a commenter is that the data
base could provide information for interstate comparisons of resident
lengths of stay according to diagnoses or outcomes.
Fundamentally, the MDS data, represented within the context of a
standardized information system, provides the foundation for organizing
complex clinical and facility information in ways that can be easily
generalized to support numerous current and future objectives at the
facility, State, and Federal levels. It provides a common framework for
communicating about resident clinical characteristics, care outcomes,
and quality, as well as facilities' service delivery and quality. Many
of these specific objectives have been identified throughout this
regulation.
Finally, the RAI has been translated into at least seven languages
and is being used in several European and Asian countries for care
planning to improve clinical care and for research purposes. The
international development of comparable data sets would facilitate
performance of cross-national research studies to examine the effects
of differences in care patterns on long term care resident outcomes.
These studies may provide a great deal of information on the geriatric
long term care population across all countries.
Comment: Of those who addressed how data should flow, the majority
of commenters, including a national provider organization, stated that
data should flow through the States to us. Some expressed the belief
that States should also maintain their own data base. One commenter
recommended that data be transmitted to us by the States on an annual
basis. A few commenters believed that the States should send summary
information to us. One commenter said that initially, facilities will
need a great deal of technical assistance, and it would be easiest for
that to come from the States. A national provider organization wanted
States mandated to devise methods for disseminating computerization
information to facilities and for providing technical assistance. One
State noted, however, that States should not be required to collect and
store information, if there are no expectations about how the data will
be used.
Response: We agree that States should have the responsibility to
provide some level of general and technical assistance to facilities as
relates to our and States' requirements for encoding and transmission
of MDS data. We understand that States have varying levels of
experience with the use of computerized information systems and data
bases. However, several States have already established an MDS data
base for case-mix, quality assurance or survey and certification
purposes, or both, and have provided necessary training and assistance
to facilities which enabled them to successfully implement automated
systems.
We have established technical and user groups as part of the
systems design process. These groups consist of States, provider and
consumer representatives and experts in systems design. Their expertise
and knowledge will be used to facilitate provider and State automation.
We will also work with States to ensure that personnel have the
necessary technical expertise and training to fulfill State automation
responsibilities. Also, system specifications and other relevant
materials are already available via an internet web-site, initially
established to support MDS software vendors, and otherwise available
from HCFA.
The pilot testing of the MDS standard system and associated
procedures is another step currently undertaken by us to ensure that
all aspects of this standard MDS system are fully understood with
respect to technical operational requirements, State and facility user
support needs, and general issues associated with deployment and system
acceptance. Information from this test phase will directly support our
ability to assist States in successfully installing and operating this
system and ensure that facilities can easily accomplish their
assessment submission requirements.
We fully appreciate the magnitude of support and effort that will
be necessary to ensure that appropriate training is developed and
disseminated to all who will be involved in implementing this data
base, and are in the process of developing additional procedures and
communication strategies to address this need.
Finally, a central requirement for the MDS standard system design
is to ensure that maximum attention is given to understanding and
assessing current technologies employed by facilities and States so
that the MDS system will best integrate and accommodate these existing
systems. We intend that this will both facilitate system acceptance
across all user levels, and minimize support and other implementation
costs. Also, we will emphasize technologies that lend themselves to
ease of use and user-friendliness in the selection process for each
level of the standard systems, but especially as this relates to
systems used by facilities to submit MDS assessments to their State
agency. Also, one of the implicit benefits of the decision to develop a
standard system for MDS data management is that this provides the
greatest ability to centralize support efforts, and also reduces costs
for multi-state facility chains and software vendors by reducing the
variation of systems with which they will interface, in that they need
only support access to a single standard system across States.
[[Page 67185]]
Comment: A few commenters thought that the data should be sent
directly to us without being sent to the State first. One said that it
would be costly and duplicative if States maintained their own data
base. One State agreed that State data bases would be duplicative and
suggested that States have access to a HCFA data base through the
Online Survey, Certification and Reporting System. The State commenter
noted that this could be difficult for States that have adopted an
alternate Resident Assessment Instrument, since it would be necessary
to remove extraneous data collected by the alternate instrument. A
State put forth the idea of creating a single national entity for the
centralized collection of MDS data. The commenter suggested that States
could then arrange for periodic digital communications with the entity,
believing that this method would be more efficient than each State
having to develop the capacity to receive facility data.
Response: We support having each facility initially submit 100
percent of the MDS data to the State. This would enable States to
maintain a data base for use in Medicare and Medicaid activities that
are primarily State responsibilities: quality assurance, longitudinal
tracking of care outcomes for survey, certification and licensing, and
in some States, case-mix reimbursement classification systems. Several
States are already using computerized MDS information for this purpose,
having decided that the derived benefits outweigh the costs of
establishing and maintaining such a system. Our experience has been
that States realize even more programmatic uses for the data once it is
available to them.
While we could develop a central mechanism for collecting
information from providers, there are significant disadvantages
associated with this approach: (1) It would impose an additional layer
between facilities and States with associated impact on timeliness and
accuracy of information; (2) With so many of the objectives for MDS
data being at the State level, direct submission of information to us
creates an unnatural information flow which will have an impact on the
ability of States to meet these objectives, especially as many of the
objectives, such as the information-based survey process, are so
dependent on timely access to MDS assessment information; (3) With the
many State-specific uses for MDS information, such as case-mix payment,
many of which require specialized elements recorded in the State-unique
S Section of the MDS, we could not possibly centralize support for
these functions or even accommodate all these variations in a central
repository; thus, direct submission to us would defeat the goal of
supporting unique State objectives; and, (4) States are in a much more
appropriate position to support their individual facilities with
respect to the MDS assessment, submission and data validation
processes.
The information provided by a State-maintained MDS data base is not
duplicative of a national data base. States vary with regard to their
demographics, licensing policies, quality assurance and reimbursement
systems. States are a logical level for maintenance of MDS information
since each State performs and must manage its own survey and regulation
processes. Information provided by MDS assessments cannot be obtained
from our Online Survey, Certification and Reporting System. The Online
Survey, Certification and Reporting System itself is not designed to
provide the quantity and specificity of the information in the proposed
MDS data base. Furthermore, a central MDS repository is necessary to
support objectives such as policy and regulation development, but would
not be as readily available for State functions as State-specific data.
Since specific functions (for example, information-based survey
process) are performed from this data base at the State level, it would
be inefficient to require States to support these functions via access
to a central repository.
We disagree that it will be significantly more expensive for States
with alternate instruments to collect MDS data. The design of every
aspect of the standard MDS system, from the record transmission format
to the State data base repository, is intended to support the
customizations required by individual States. Thus, although there will
be some additional costs during the initial system implementation in
States requiring custom formats, the system design makes these costs
insignificant. At this time, there is no State variant of the MDS that
cannot be accommodated within the context of the standard system
architecture.
With respect to transmissions between the State and national
repositories, we are requiring that a facility transmit only the core
MDS items on the HCFA-designated RAI, the State will only maintain the
State-specific elements at the State level.
Comment: A State noted that it currently collects computerized data
from only Medicaid-certified nursing facilities because the State can
reimburse them. The State asked if computer requirements apply to
Medicare-certified facilities, and whether Medicare facilities would
submit directly to us.
Response: The requirement to place the MDS in machine readable
format applies to all Medicare and Medicaid certified nursing homes.
There are no plans to have Medicare-only facilities submit MDS
information directly to us. In the impact statement, we address how
certified facilities will be reimbursed for information systems
equipment and supplies, as well as data encoding and transmission. Long
term care facilities certified to participate in Medicare are required
under section 1819(b)(3) of the Act to use the State-specified RAI. The
State's authority to collect computerized data from Medicare facilities
springs from its role as an agent for us in performing Medicare surveys
under section 1864 of the Act.
Comment: Commenters discussed auditing procedures that would ensure
the accuracy of the data entered into the national data base. Some,
including State commenters, believed that the accuracy of the data
should be verified through the survey and certification process. A
State commenter believed that it would take surveyors approximately 5
minutes to compare a resident's actual records with a computer
printout. One commenter pointed out that if the accuracy is checked
during the survey, a facility will take the assessment seriously and
the assessment would not be viewed as ``paperwork.'' Another supported
using surveyors to audit the match between a resident, his or her MDS
and a computer editing software system.
Response: We agree that auditing the accuracy of MDS data on an on-
going basis is very important in validating the ability of the data to
support key operational and policy decisions. Indeed, the establishment
of mechanisms to ensure acceptable reliability levels is critical to
our ability to move forward with using MDS data for quality assessment
and improvement activities, as well as other programmatic purposes.
Currently, the survey process includes evaluation of the accuracy of
assessments, as required by sections 1819(g)(2)(A)(II) and 1919
(g)(2)(A)(II) of the Act. Surveyors compare information from the most
recently completed RAI with the current status of a sample of residents
found onsite at the time of survey. We may modify and enhance the
methods for accomplishing this task to reflect access to more
longitudinal resident status information.
Several States, particularly those with case-mix reimbursement
systems, have a separate auditing system in which nurse reviewers
conduct an onsite assessment
[[Page 67186]]
using the MDS and compare it to that completed by the facility in order
to verify the accuracy of the facility's assessment. We have recently
completed a study of such methods and will be considering how to most
efficiently assure the quality of MDS data. The methods under
consideration could involve onsite review by surveyors or others, as
designated by us, or offsite data analysis and evaluation, or both. We
are also considering whether auditing would be carried out in
conjunction with the survey process, as well as the timing and
frequency of audits.
Comment: Commenters discussed methods for data verification. A few
commenters stated that we should not require auditing and we should
accept data as submitted. One State noted that any auditing process
will result in cost increases. Another commenter pointed out that the
data should be error free before the facility submits it. A commenter
suggested that we not require auditing unless the MDS data is used for
reimbursement purposes. A few commenters, including a national provider
organization, disagreed with the idea of double entering data as a
means of ensuring data integrity. They stated that it would be too
costly, resulting in an unnecessary expenditure of time, cost, and
effort.
Response: We strongly disagree with the comments that verifying
accuracy of the data is not necessary. Foremost, it is imperative that
the data be accurate and reliable for it to be used in any policy
making, planning or resource utilization capacity. Accurate resident
status information is necessary not only for reimbursement systems but
for the health planning at the State and Federal level. Secondly,
accurate assessments are necessary for quality care at the facility
level, given that care planning should be based on the resident's
assessment.
While data verification may be costly in the short run, we believe
that it is cost efficient in the long run, in that accurate data will
help prevent unnecessary expenditures or poor policy or reimbursement
decisions that might result from erroneous information.
Several States that have computerized MDS data bases have
encountered significant inaccuracies in the data originally received
from facilities. This problem was rectified by establishing a process
for ongoing validation of the accuracy of the data through on-line
electronic systems feedback to facilities, or other systems for
frequent cross checks and communication.
On-line data editing systems can facilitate timely detection and
correction of inaccuracies. Virtually all the States that have
computerized MDS data bases have developed built-in edit checks for
obvious inaccuracies which would disallow entry of conflicting or
invalid data, for example, for a resident coded simultaneously as
comatose yet, inconsistently, enjoying playing cards.
We agree that double entering data to ensure validity would be
expensive and we are not requiring it. We emphasize, however, the
important role that validation plays in the establishment of a data
base. To this end, we published standardized range and relational edits
in May 1995 that MDS data will have to pass in order to be accepted at
the State level.
Comment: Some commenters placed responsibility for the accuracy of
the data on the facility. According to a commenter, having the edit
checking process occur at the facility is critical, otherwise the State
system would quickly become overburdened with rejecting records back to
the facility for correction. One recommendation was for a facility to
have a system for visually checking MDS information prior to submitting
the data. Commenters noted that computer software can validate that the
MDS is complete and that responses are within an acceptable range, and
can also generate a condensed MDS with the responses, and staff can
compare this to the MDS to verify accuracy. A State commenter proposed
that we require a facility to maintain an accuracy rate of 95 percent
for its data to be accepted by the State. Commenters suggested that a
facility only transmit updates and changes to the data base once the
original assessment is on file. Another proposal was for us to require
a facility to incorporate surveillance and correction procedures as
part of its quality assurance program.
Response: We concur that a facility has a responsibility to submit
assessment data that is accurate, and there are many ways to accomplish
this. A facility is required by section 1919(b)(3) of the Act to
conduct a comprehensive, accurate, standardized and reproducible
assessment of each resident's functional capacity. We are adding to
Sec. 483.20(g) the facility's responsibility to accurately assess
residents, as well as Sec. 483.20(f)(3), which notes the facility's
responsibility to transmit accurate data to the State. We believe,
however, that the State also has a role in verifying the accuracy of
the data and systematically monitoring and evaluating the quality and
accuracy of the assessment data which will be submitted from
facilities.
States will monitor completeness and accuracy of MDS data
submissions from the facility. A facility will be in compliance unless
an unacceptable percentage of the records completed by the facility
during a target period are either not submitted to the State or not
accepted by the State because of data errors. We will determine
compliance based on a review of missing records for the target period,
allowing sufficient time after the close of the specified period for
relevant records to be submitted from the facility to the State.
Our initial plan is to have States accept required records
submitted by the facility, except when specific data errors occur.
Currently, plans are for States to reject records only if:
A submission file has a missing or misplaced header record
or trailer record;
Any record in the file does not have the correct record
length with the last data character being the ``end of record''
delimiter required by the standard data specifications;
The submission file contains an invalid facility ID code
(Fac__Id in the data specifications) in the header record or data
record; or
The total number of records in the submission file does
not correspond to the record count given in the trailer record.
We will evaluate this process and make necessary changes based on
experience.
A facility is in compliance unless there is an unacceptable error
rate for the set of records completed by the facility during a
specified period. Determination of compliance is based on a review of
records accepted by the State, allowing sufficient time after the close
of the specified period for relevant records to be submitted from the
facility to the State. The error rate in question is the total number
of fields in error, due to either range or consistency errors as
identified in the MDS 2.0 data specifications in effect, divided by the
total number of required fields across all records for the specified
period. The fields that we require for each type of record (for
example, admission assessment, quarterly assessment, discharge tracking
form, etc.) are detailed in the MDS 2.0 data specifications.
Further, States have a role in training facility personnel in
methods of preventing and correcting data errors. The suggestion by a
commenter that we require a facility to incorporate surveillance and
correction procedures as part of its quality assurance program may be a
viable option.
[[Page 67187]]
Comment: Other commenters believed that States should bear primary
responsibility for the accuracy of the RAI data. One State suggested
that the States should provide facilities with report formats that
cross check interrelated data. Another commenter proposed that a State
keep verification requirements for transmitting data separate from
verification of clinical consistency of the data. A commenter pointed
out that it was unclear whether we intended that States notify a
facility of errant data before transmitting the data to us. One
suggestion was for the State to check data for completeness, accuracy
and compliance with processing instructions. Another was that the State
specify a standardized format for transmitting data that would require
compliance with edits. A few commenters thought that the States should
be responsible for the quality of the data transmitted to us.
Response: The responsibility for data accuracy must reside with the
facility, the source of the data, and a facility should ensure that MDS
data pass all standard accuracy edits before transmission to the State.
The State does have a responsibility to monitor accuracy of data
submitted by a facility and aid the facility in achieving accuracy. The
State will perform standard accuracy edits on data files as they are
received and report any errors found to the facility. A State will also
be able to monitor the error rate for a facility over time and produce
an error summary report to share with the facility. The State will also
have the ability to monitor the error rates for any MDS software
vendor. When systematic problems are found for a vendor, the State will
have the opportunity to work with that vendor to correct the problems.
We may also develop procedures for onsite data accuracy visits to the
facility when error rates are high. We will determine the frequency of
such visits during our formal systems design process. MDS data
submitted to the State will be transmitted to us at least monthly. We
will again edit the data for accuracy. Accuracy edits will be performed
at the facility, State, and HCFA levels.
Comment: We received a number of other suggestions to ensure the
accuracy of data. One was to allow the registered nurse assessment
coordinator to validate the data. A few suggested a computer system
that has a basic set of edit checks, like high-low checks, completeness
checks, clinical inconsistencies, and incorrect data checks. A consumer
advocacy organization pointed out that some States currently have
special nurse auditors who validate the match between a resident and
his or her MDS. A State suggested that the reliability of MDS data be
verified by periodic, random, onsite review of individual records
performed by either State program agency staff or by a contracting
organization. Another noted that if validity becomes an issue, we could
consider a regulatory mechanism for appointing independent assessors.
Response: We agree that the computer systems should have basic edit
checks, which ought to be in place both at the facility level and at
the State level. The standard data specifications we have developed
include valid ranges and required formatting for MDS items and
consistency between MDS items. Detailed information concerning these
data specifications is available on our MDS World Wide Web site (at
http://www.hcfa.gov/Medicare/hsqb/mds20/) and is otherwise available
from us and the State survey agency. We anticipate that facilities will
be able to select commercially available software packages that use
these data specifications. We note that the current regulation grants
States the authority to take over the assessment process if a facility
knowingly and willfully certifies false assessment statements. Section
483.20(c)(4) allows the State to require that assessments be conducted
and certified by individuals who are independent of the facility and
who are approved by the State. New York, for example, contracts with
their peer review organization to conduct onsite audits of the Patient
Review Instrument, used to calculate Medicaid reimbursement. Nurses
sample a certain number of resident records. If the records do not pass
standards based on resource utilization group, the facility loses its
``delegated status'' to conduct assessments and must hire an
independent assessor for 1 year.
Comment: Many of the comments we received regarding privacy and
confidentiality issues demonstrated concern regarding privacy issues
and indicated that residents' identities need to be protected. Some of
the commenters believed that MDS information should be available or
reported in the aggregate format. A few commenters wanted identifying
data available at the State level but not in any public data sets
created. One commenter questioned why we should have access to
assessment information of private pay residents. A national provider
organization stated that the need for information in planning and
quality assurance should not be met at the expense of the resident's
and facility's right to confidentiality. Commenters suggested that we
develop ways to block resident identifiers or develop an alternate
system of identification like numerical coding.
Response: We agree that protecting the privacy of the resident is
essential. In establishing this system of records, both we and the
State (as HCFA's contractor in performing survey functions) must comply
with the Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552a), which applies to Federal systems
of records containing individually identifiable information. While
aggregate summaries of the data can be made public, there are strict
Federal guidelines for the release of individually identifiable
information by Federal agencies to any individual or organization. A
release of personal identifiable information can only be made in
limited circumstances described in the Privacy Act. Disclosure may be
made under the Privacy Act for ``routine uses,'' which are compatible
with the purpose for which the information was collected. These routine
uses are described in the Privacy Act System of Records, which is
published in the Federal Register. Requirements associated with routine
uses are also set forth in the System of Records. In most cases, a
``data use agreement'' is required with the recipient being bound, in
turn, by the Privacy Act. Some States have additional laws
strengthening the protection of privacy of the resident.
We would have difficulty assuring the quality of care in facilities
if we only had access to periodic aggregate data. While allowing
evaluation of prevalence rates (percent of residents who have a
particular condition at a given point in time) over time, such data
would largely preclude any quality of care indicators based on
incidence rates (percent of residents who acquire a given condition in
a facility between two points in time). For example, periodic aggregate
data might show the prevalence of decubitus ulcers in the resident
population, but we could not review it to determine the incidence of
such ulcers while residents are in the care of the facility. A high
prevalence of ulcers may indicate that the facility accepts residents
with existing ulcers from the hospital, but a high incidence may
indicate substandard care. If access were limited to aggregate data, it
would also be impossible to evaluate other important outcome measures
potentially indicative of quality of care.
Our quality assurance activities in Medicare and Medicaid certified
facilities are not limited to selected residents (for example, Medicare
or Medicaid residents, or both). Our long term care survey process
directs State
[[Page 67188]]
survey agencies to review the care provided to all residents of
certified facilities, regardless of payor source. For example, quality
assurance survey teams review a random sample of residents without
respect to payor. We would often have difficulties evaluating the
quality of care in Medicare and Medicaid certified facilities if access
to data is limited to residents who are Medicare or Medicaid funded.
This is especially true in a facility in which Medicare or Medicaid
residents, or both, are a minority. This requirement is, therefore, in
keeping with the quality protections that are afforded to all residents
in certified long term care facilities. We will not give out
identifying information unless there is a demonstrated need for it; the
routine use permits disclosure only if we determine that the research
cannot be reasonably accomplished unless the record is provided in
individually identifiable form.
Comment: One commenter was unclear why confidentiality is an issue,
since we already have systems in place to guard confidentiality, and
these systems could carry over into the MDS system. A professional
organization recommended developing a software program that could block
identifying information except when needed by designated persons.
Some commenters addressed the question of who should have access to
the data base. Several suggestions were submitted, including:
The State survey and certification agency;
The reimbursement agency (without resident identifiers);
The ombudsman (one commenter suggested without resident
identifiers while another said consistent with current access rights
for resident records);
The submitting facility (with no access to other
facilities); and
Aggregate data should be available to the public.
Commenters proposed that a State have access to facility data in its
own State with resident identifiers and to other States and the
national data without identifiers.
Response: As aforementioned, under the Privacy Act, when personal
information in the possession of the Federal Government on an
individual is accessed by name, Social Security number or any other
identifying symbol, we must publish a system of records notice. This
notifies the public that we are collecting the information and will be
accessing it in an individually identifiable way.
The notice lists routine uses for the information, including a list
of entities to which we may release information upon request, the uses
for which we may release information, and conditions under which we may
release individually identifiable information. The Privacy Act requires
that the routine uses be consistent with the purpose for which the
information is collected. The Privacy Act does not mandate us to
release the information. The system of records notice will support
research as a routine use, but will require safeguards to ensure the
maximum protection of individually identified information. It requires
that persons or entities requesting the information sign an agreement
to not re-release the data. The system of records notice also permits
release to government agencies for purposes of monitoring nursing home
care. We already have a routine use disclosure provision in place for
handling data requests by those conducting health services or other
appropriate research for most of our systems. We evaluate each request
on an individual basis, including whether it is appropriate to release
any data with identifying information.
Comment: A few commenters recommended that we not release resident-
specific information unless the resident has directly consented. One
State suggested that we and States issue ``designator'' numbers that
would allow resident-specific information to be released. A commenter
suggested that we build fines and penalties into the system for breach
of confidentiality.
Response: As aforementioned, we will follow all provisions of the
Privacy Act, as well as the Freedom of Information Act in managing the
information from this proposed data base. Our Freedom of Information
Act officer decides whether to release the records if a request is made
at the Federal level. Under the Freedom of Information Act,
individually identified RAI data generally would be exempt from
disclosure as medical (and similar) files, the disclosure of which
would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of privacy (5 USC
522(b)(6)). Under the Privacy Act, individually identified records may
not be disclosed, except for good cause, including routine uses
consistent with the purposes for which the information was collected (5
USC 522a(b)). (Aggregate data, not individually identifiable, could be
released under either law.)
For records collected under the authority of our RAI requirements,
States are bound by the Privacy act as our agent. In addition, most
States have their own rules governing protection of privacy for records
maintained at the State level. We expect each State to take the
appropriate steps to ensure that resident-identifiable information is
protected.
We are adding language to Sec. 483.20(f)(5) that prohibits a State
from releasing resident-identifiable information to the public, and
provides that a facility may release resident-identifiable information
to an agent only in accordance with a contract under which the agent
agrees not to use or disclose the information except to the extent the
facility itself is permitted to do so. We note that the Health
Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (Public Law 104-
191) provides stiff penalties for persons who wrongfully disclose
individually identifiable health information. Such penalties can
include fines or imprisonment, or both.
RAI data would be part of a resident's clinical record, and as
such, would be protected from improper disclosure by facilities under
current law. Facilities are required by sections 1819(c)(1)(A)(iv) and
1919(c)(1)(A)(iv) of the Act and Sec. 483.75 (l)(3) and (l)(4), to keep
confidential all information contained in the resident's record and to
maintain safeguards against the unauthorized use of a resident's
clinical record information, regardless of the form or storage method
of the records. We recognize that there are circumstances that may
necessitate the release of information from the resident's clinical
record. However, these instances are limited by regulation to
circumstances required by (1) transfer to another health care
institution, (2) law, (3) third party payment contract, or (4) the
resident (Sec. 483.75(l)(4)).
The transmission is limited to (1) using a private dial-up network
based on a direct telephone connection from the facility or (2) mailing
a diskette from the facility. In the case of either telephone
communications or the mail, the information transmitted is secure, with
interception of information being prohibited by Federal and State law,
and strong penalties apply. We and the States both receive large
volumes of unencrypted voice phone calls, unencrypted data
telecommunications (for example, claims data), and unencrypted
mailings, all including resident-specific information.
Section 1902(a)(7) of the Act requires Medicaid agencies to provide
safeguards that restrict the use or disclosure of information
concerning applicants and recipients to purposes directly connected
with the administration of the plan. Moreover, under the agreement
between the Secretary and the State survey agency pertaining to
[[Page 67189]]
section 1864 of the Act, the State is required to adopt policies and
procedures to ensure that information contained in its records from the
Secretary or from any provider will be disclosed only as provided in
the Act or regulations.
States may allow other agencies within the State to have access to
MDS data to the extent that it is related to the operation of the
Medicaid programs. All agencies must adhere to the confidentiality
requirements of the Medicare and Medicaid programs relative to this
information. We are also providing in Sec. 483.315(j) that a State may
not release resident-identifiable information to the public. Further,
the State may not release resident-identifiable RAI data to a
contractor without a written agreement under which the contractor
agrees to restrict access to the data.
We believe that adherence to Sec. 483.10(b)(1), Notice of rights
and services, adequately addresses the commenter's suggestion that
residents be notified. We believe that using designator numbers as a
vehicle to permit release of resident-specific information is not
feasible. Because such a system would require that all providers use
the same number for the same resident, (in other words, to enable
tracking of residents across different providers), implementation would
be extremely burdensome.
Comment: Commenters addressed other issues pertaining to privacy
and confidentiality. We received a recommendation to contact specific
individuals who could assist in developing the security of a data base.
Another recommendation was to carefully control computer access (in
other words who can get to the data via computer at the facility and at
the State).
Response: Both at the facility and the State, access to the MDS
records for residents, whether those records are hard copy or
electronic, must be secured and controlled in compliance with our
requirements for safeguarding the confidentiality of clinical records.
The facility must take precautions to ensure that only authorized staff
have access to confidential information. Electronic MDS data should
reside on stand-alone computers in secured physical locations, or
access to those data should incorporate standard user ID and password
techniques.
Comment: A few commenters thought that only the facility in which a
resident resides should be able to make changes in the data entered.
One commenter proposed that the data system require the facility to
``close-out'' a resident's information upon discharge or transfer,
which would prevent the facility from changing that information. It
would also prevent ``a receiving facility'' from entering new data on a
transferred resident until the information base is closed by the
transferring facility.
Response: We are in agreement that no other facility may make
changes in the MDS data. A facility may only change MDS hard copy and
electronic data as allowed by our policy. This policy requires that
after the facility performs the assessment, it is ``sealed,'' and
electronic records are ``locked.'' HCFA policy also require facilities
to complete tracking forms indicating resident discharge from and
reentry to the facility. The facility must complete and submit these
forms and corresponding electronic records to the State within
specified time frames. It would not be appropriate to require one
facility to ``wait for'' a discharge record from another facility
before entering and submitting data for Medicaid payment. This could
result in payment delays for the one facility when another facility is
delinquent on submitting MDS records.
MDS data bases at the State will be used for a variety of purposes,
including quality monitoring, Medicaid and Medicare payment, and policy
analysis. It would prove quite cumbersome and, at times unworkable, for
all data changes to always be made by the facility of residence and
then updated in the State data bases after resubmission from the
facility.
Comment: Commenters discussed the schedule for submission of data
by facilities, for example on an annual or quarterly basis. A national
advocacy organization supported continuous data flow, pointing out that
States need up-to-date information due to the survey cycle and their
need to be able to respond to complaints when they are received. One
commenter said that most facilities in their State routinely transmit
on a weekly basis. Other commenters questioned how current would be the
data that are to be maintained. The few who responded agreed that the
data do need to be up-to-date and agreed with others who said that
transmission should coincide with the RAI requirements. Others
addressed the need for a transaction log to document transmission.
Some commenters noted that reimbursement agencies may require data
on a more frequent basis for the purpose of rate setting. It was also
mentioned that requiring transmission on a more frequent basis would be
an administrative burden. A few commenters wanted the quarterly reviews
to be transmitted also. A national provider group suggested quarterly
submission, staggered in order to facilitate managing the large volume
of data. For example, at the end of each month, \1/12\ of the
facilities would submit data for the preceding 3 months.
One commenter recommended that States transmit data to us on an
annual basis. There was some support for collecting data on a quarterly
basis. A few commenters believed that the States should send us summary
information. A few States suggested submitting data on the same
schedule as the MDS is completed--that is, upon admission, within 14
days of a significant change, and annually. Others agreed that annual
submission would be adequate. A few proposed that data be transmitted
twice a year. One commenter believed that all States should submit data
on the same date.
Response: In order for MDS information to be timely enough for use
in ongoing quality assurance programs, a facility must submit MDS data
at least monthly to States. This would entail submitting all full MDS
assessments (initial, annual and significant change), and any partial
assessments (quarterly, discharge, and reentry) completed since the
facility last transmitted data to the States.
States will also submit data to us at least monthly. The regional
offices also need timely information in order to perform Federal
monitoring surveys. To a certain extent, the role of the regional
office mirrors that of State survey agencies. Hence, the regional
offices need timely, complete information. Furthermore, this is
necessary to enable us to timely evaluate State trends or regional
problems. For example, linking resident status information with SNF
cost report data could identify potential Medicare utilization problems
in relation to certain outcomes or resident status changes.
Analysis regarding the timeliness of MDS data and frequency of
transmission requirements has shown that the MDS data base must contain
quarterly review information if it is to be used for quality monitoring
purposes by State survey agencies. Much of the work being done to
develop quality measures relies on quarterly assessment data for each
resident. Leading researchers and survey experts agree that the
quarterly review data are needed for the timely and reliable
identification of resident outcomes for this purpose. There is under
development, discussion and testing, a case-mix demonstration payment
system using MDS data in calculating appropriate payment rates.
Comment: Commenters made suggestions regarding what edits should
[[Page 67190]]
be allowed without requiring the facility to produce a new electronic
record or hard copy. One State wanted any change in MDS information to
result in a new hard copy. Another State proposed that we allow a
typographical error to be corrected at any time. A consumer advocacy
organization proposed that if a facility makes changes to a
computerized copy, it should be held to the same standard as written
records. Another commenter believed that MDS software should create an
audit trail of changes made to an assessment that would include the
name of the person making the change, the date, the old value, and the
new value. The commenter suggested that we permit a facility to keep
the most current copy in a hard copy format. A State commenter believed
that the computer program should have the ability to update the
assessment information without changing the original version. Another
State did not want to make changes if the data had been transmitted
after the 21st day after admission. Another State proposed using those
things that meet the criteria for significant change with regard to
edits.
Response: According to current policy, a facility may correct
typographical or factual errors within required time frames. To make
revisions on paper records, a facility enters the correct response,
draws a line through the previous response without obliterating it, and
initials and dates the corrected entry. Computer-based systems must
have a way to indicate and differentiate between the original and
corrected entries on the printout of the corrected form, and to ensure
that the correct information is transmitted to the State. Again, we
note that the assessment must be accurate. A significant correction of
prior assessment is completed at the facility's prerogative, because
the previous assessment was inaccurate or completed incorrectly.
Version 2.0 of the MDS contains an item response that, when checked,
indicates that the assessment is a significant correction of a prior
comprehensive assessment. A number of providers have called to our
attention that the wording of this item precludes its use when the
prior assessment that is being corrected was a Quarterly Review
Assessment. We will add code to the MDS version 2.0 that will provide a
mechanism for this.
A significant correction of prior assessment differs from a
significant change in status assessment, in which there has been an
actual change in resident's health status. If there has been a
significant change in health status, the facility cannot merely correct
the affected items on the MDS. The facility must complete a full new
assessment. Any subsequent changes should be noted elsewhere in the
resident's record (for example, in the progress notes). As stated
previously, however, the procedures and policy governing issues of data
storage, retrieval, validation and maintenance in facilities will also
be addressed more fully in a forthcoming HCFA publication, such as a
State Operations Manual.
Comment: Some commenters requested that the requirements we issue
allow electronic signatures. This would avoid duplication by not
requiring that the facility keep on file a hard copy with signatures.
Response: In the development of the system, we will consider
requirements for electronic signatures.
Comment: Commenters addressed how and to what extent we should
standardize electronic formats and how to revise the format to be
consistent with technological changes. One State did not think that a
standardized electronic format is necessary, and proposed that we
request summary reports, findings and group data instead of
individualized data, which would obviate the need for a standard
format. Several others expressed the belief that we should specify a
format. A national provider organization pointed out that a
standardized format would facilitate collecting, merging, and analyzing
national data. Another commenter noted that it would also decrease
software development costs. A State provider organization pointed out
that nothing would be more frustrating and costly than software that is
not well thought out and requires several revisions. The commenter
suggested that we already have experience in formatting because of the
case-mix demonstration project.
A State expressed the belief that it would be easier to maintain a
single format than have to deal with different software languages and
media types. The commenter further said that we or the States should be
responsible for making formatting changes and sharing them with those
affected. Another recommendation was to use Online Survey,
Certification and Reporting System and create a subsystem for MDS data.
By accessing an ``enhancement log,'' the system would be under constant
review and revision.
Response: We concur that many of these suggestions have merit. In
the spring of 1995, we developed and issued a standard record layout
and data dictionary. These were made available to facilities and
software vendors as well as the States. When these regulations go into
effect, the assessment records that facilities transmit to States must
conform to the standard layout. Hence, software vendors have been
strongly encouraged to use the layout and data dictionary when
developing software products for MDS version 2.0. We believe that this
will ensure uniformity in format but still allow facility flexibility
and choice in terms of the software products they use to encode MDS
records.
Comment: A national provider group proposed that we require States
to develop and make available a software package that would transmit
data in the appropriate format. A few commenters expressed the belief
that as long as they meet Federal standards, States and facilities
should be able to develop additional standards.
Response: We have developed, and are in the process of testing, a
national system for MDS data transmission that will be made available
to all States that includes commercially available standard
transmission software. We are mandating that the facility transmit MDS
data to the State according to minimum data validity specifications and
using standard communication and transmission protocols. The State may
choose to impose additional data validity specifications, exceeding our
mandated minimum specifications.
Comment: We received a few suggestions regarding specific
organizations with whom we could consult in developing a standardized
format. One suggestion was to form a technical advisory board that
would consist of Federal and State personnel, providers, hardware and
software vendors, and resident advocacy groups. Another was to contact
a specific standards committee to obtain their input on developing a
format.
Response: We sought technical assistance from those parties as part
of a technical advisory group that we organized as part of the systems
design process. We met with several of the groups mentioned above early
in the design process to get input on a number of systems development
issues. We will continue to seek input throughout the development. We
are committed to working closely with interested and affected parties
in the design process.
Comment: Commenters suggested that the standardized format should
be in either ASCII or EBCDIC, and should include data item description,
data item beginning and ending column, data item length, and whether
the data is right or left justified. One State noted that some States
have already begun to computerize and that the format should be
receptive to those programs,
[[Page 67191]]
particularly for States utilizing our RAI. A State commenter believed
that a data dictionary should be provided for each data submission,
which would provide a vehicle for documenting problems with the data
submission.
Response: As previously stated, we have been working closely with
States that are computerized. Several States were instrumental in
developing the data dictionary and record layout. With their expertise,
we constructed a standard layout that still allows flexibility for
States which have added MDS items. Facilities and States must conform
to the standard record layout, which is currently constructed in ASCII.
Comment: Several commenters wondered how facility noncompliance
with the requirement to transmit the MDS data would be enforced.
Response: As stated earlier in this preamble, facility
noncompliance with the reporting requirement established by this final
rule will be subject to the full range of enforcement remedies set
forth in part 488, subpart F, ``Enforcement of compliance for long-term
care facilities with deficiencies.'' We will treat a facility's failure
to comply with MDS reporting requirements as noncompliance under the
definition in Sec. 488.301. At a minimum, we will require a plan of
correction, and will impose the mandatory denial of payment for new
admissions sanction if the facility has not achieved substantial
compliance within 3 months from the date of the finding of
noncompliance. In such a case, if the facility is still not in
compliance with requirements within 6 months from the date of the
finding, we will terminate its provider agreement. Also, we may impose
one or more other remedies, as determined by us or the State, in
accordance with part 488, subpart F.
Facility failure to meet acceptable standards of performance,
including failure to transmit the MDS data, or failure to otherwise
improve upon its past poor performance, or failure to transmit or to
maintain compliance relative to this reporting requirement could be
considered by us to be indicative of the facility's inability or
unwillingness to perform the resident assessment itself. We believe
that this is a reasonable conclusion because if the requirement to
conduct a resident assessment has been satisfied and completed, then
the administrative reporting requirement would simply and logically
follow. Noncompliance that is repeated or which recurs intermittently
becomes part of the facility's noncompliance history which is a factor
when we or the State selects the appropriate enforcement response. We
will sanction, accordingly, a facility that demonstrates little or no
commitment to continual, rather than cyclical, compliance. A State will
be easily able to ascertain whether a facility is transmitting the
required information timely and in the manner that we prescribe, those
facilities that fail to meet the standard may be subject to the full
range of available remedies, including denial of payment for new
admissions and civil money penalties. We do not expect perfection
relative to compliance with this reporting requirement; we will
incorporate limited tolerance into the compliance assessment process,
whereby good faith efforts made by facilities will be considered. An
additional level of tolerance will exist during early phases of
implementation of the requirement.
Comment: A number of commenters addressed a wide variety of issues
relating to the computerization of MDS information. A State commenter
stressed that we should emphasize the benefits to facility staff and
residents. A consumer advocacy group expressed the belief that we
should address how computerization will affect utilization of the RAPs
and the individualization of the care planning process.
Response: As mentioned in the previous discussion of data uses, we
believe that the automation of this information will be extremely
helpful to facilities. We note that computerization of resident
assessment information does not relieve facilities of their
responsibility to develop, by an interdisciplinary team, a
comprehensive, individualized care plan. While software packages exist
that will automatically print a plan of care based on responses to MDS
items that trigger a RAP, an individual must still exercise
professional clinical judgment in customizing the care plan to suit
each resident's individual needs.
Comment: Commenters proposed that we develop regulations and manual
instructions relating to transmitting data. A State wanted a
telecommunications program to be mandated. Another State expressed the
belief that we should penalize facilities which do not comply with
submission requirements.
Response: Once we develop key specifications for data transmission,
we will issue clarifying policy and give instructions to States and
providers in a State Operations Manual transmittal. We will require
that a facility comply with the policy and regulations covering this
data base in order to participate in the Medicare and Medicaid
programs. As mentioned above, we are requiring that a facility
electronically transmit its data via telecommunications infrastructure
to the State. Penalties for not complying with submission requirements
are addressed with the comments on proposed Sec. 483.20(b)(6),
Automated data processing requirement.
Comment: Some commenters discussed software vendors who have
developed RAI packages. Commenters suggested that we develop a program
to test vendor software for minimal acceptability.
Response: We are developing several aids to promote the accuracy of
RAI software packages developed by commercial vendors. These efforts
include the following documents and data files, being published on our
World Wide Web site (at http://www.hcfa.gov/Medicare/hsqb/mds20/) and
otherwise available from us.
Detailed specifications for data validity (valid ranges
and consistency requirements for MDS items).
Detailed logic and a test data base for RAP determination.
Detailed specifications for the file structure, record
layout, and field formatting for MDS files submitted by facilities.
Detailed logic, a test data base, and a test program for
Resource Utilization Group calculation.
We are also developing a standard State-level MDS processing system
to be distributed to each State. One feature of this system allows RAI
software developers to transmit test files of MDS data to the State and
receive a detailed log of all data validity errors encountered in the
test file.
We will continue to promote processes for assuring the accuracy of
software packages developed by vendors even though the approaches to
this effort will change over time.
Comment: In the preamble to the proposed rule, we encouraged
comment on developing a mechanism for advising us on the need and
method to update the MDS and RAPs. Commenters agreed that we do need a
method to update the RAI. Several suggested that we establish a
clinical advisory panel or commission similar to the project team,
clinical panel and advisory committee that developed the RAI. Other
ideas included an annual update schedule, including any changes in the
MDS as an addendum; sending periodic questionnaires to providers, State
agencies and organizations; and a yearly comment period.
Response: We have always recognized that the RAI will need to
reflect advances in clinical practice and assessment technology. We
will be making periodic revisions to the RAI. In 1994, we awarded a
contract to the
[[Page 67192]]
Hebrew Rehabilitation Center for Aged, under which we will revise the
RAI over a few years. The contractor will convene representatives of
States, provider organizations, professional associations, and consumer
organizations. These groups will advise us regarding the need to add or
refine items or definitions, and regarding areas that are less well
understood, and require clarification. As in the past, the revision
process will be one in which we seek input from the many interested and
affected groups.
Comment: We solicited comment on how to coordinate the assessment
process with other assessment protocols such as home health assessments
and the uniform needs assessment instrument (comments on coordinating
with PASRR are discussed with the comments on proposed
Sec. 483.20(b)(5), Coordination). Some who commented merely agreed that
it is necessary to coordinate assessments. Others gave suggestions, for
example, that we issue a stronger directive that a facility provide a
copy of the MDS as part of their post-discharge care, use the RAI in
all long-term care settings, and coordinate with the home and community
based waiver MDS of OBRA '90.
Response: We recognize the need to coordinate an individual's
health care across various health care settings and the importance of
assessments in this process. Currently, we have no statutory authority
to require this coordination except in the case of coordination of the
RAI with preadmission screening programs for individuals who are
mentally ill and mentally retarded. However, there is great interest in
the development of clinical data sets like the MDS for several provider
types, including end-stage renal disease facilities and home health
agencies. Work is well underway to develop screening tools in some of
these areas.
Sec. 483.20(b)(1) Resident Assessment Instrument
Comment: Commenters addressed the proposed requirement that the
assessment process must include direct observation and communication
with the resident, as well as communication with licensed and
nonlicensed direct care staff on all shifts. Most supported the
requirement. A few commenters were concerned with enforcement of the
requirement. Some wanted us to require that the facility communicate
with the resident only when clinically feasible, since the resident may
not have the cognitive skills to verbally communicate.
Response: The resident is a primary source of information when
completing the assessment and may be the only source of information for
many items. In the RAI User's Manual and in the State Operations
Manual, Transmittal No. 272, we have instructed facility staff to talk
with and observe the resident. It is still possible to interact with a
resident, even if he or she is unable to communicate verbally. Staff
can closely observe the resident and respond to many MDS items based on
observation. We acknowledge that evaluating facility compliance may be
difficult but we believe that this requirement is too important to
delete. However, we do not want to require a specific process for
documenting collection of data across shifts. This would burden
facilities and limit their flexibility to implement a process that is
most appropriate for each facility's specific situation and practices.
Comment: A few commenters believed that only the direct care staff
responsible for providing care to the resident on all shifts should be
included in the assessment process. Others wanted us to require that
the facility talk to other people, such as a resident's family members/
guardians, the attending physician, and other licensed personnel.
Response: We did not limit the assessment process to only those
staff members responsible for actually providing hands-on care because
we believe that facility staff who are not the primary care-givers
often have valuable, first-hand information about a resident. For
example, housekeeping staff who routinely talk with residents may be
aware that a resident prefers extra pillows on her bed because it
alleviates her back pain. In the State Operations Manual Transmittal
No. 272 and in the RAI User's Manual we suggest that information
sources for the assessment should include, but are not limited to,
discussion with the resident's attending physician, appropriate
licensed health professionals and family members. Family members are a
valuable source of information regarding the resident, particularly for
cognitively impaired residents, for whom family is often the only
source of information regarding the resident. For example; a resident's
spouse may be the only person who knows what the resident was like
prior to admission to the nursing home, and is able to provide
background information that is necessary for staff to complete the
Customary Routine section of the MDS.
We require that a physician be a part of the interdisciplinary team
that prepares the care plan. We acknowledge that a doctor's schedule
may not allow consistent participation in the assessment process. While
we encourage facilities to discuss the resident's status with the
attending physician to gain and validate information, we are not
requiring it. The statute is silent regarding the participation of
individuals other than health professionals.
Comment: Some commenters wanted us to clarify that communication
with all shifts can be both verbal and written. For example,
information could be exchanged at pre-shift meetings, through progress
notes or other documentation in the clinical record, or by other means.
Response: We agree that information can be exchanged in a number of
ways, and discuss possible mechanisms in the RAI User's Manual. At this
time we do not wish to mandate a communication process; rather, each
facility should determine how to best exchange information about the
resident.
While we did not receive comments regarding the facility assessing
the resident using the RAI specified by the State, we are adding to
Sec. 483.315(c) that the State must obtain our approval of a State-
specified instrument. This is more consistent with sections 1819(e)(5)
and 1919(e)(5) of the Act. Furthermore, we are specifying those domains
or areas that the facility must assess. We listed these domains in the
assessment requirement previously, and inadvertently omitted them at
former paragraph (b)(2); a State suggested that removing the domains
weakened the requirement. Additionally, surveyors use the regulatory
tags for particular domains to cite deficiencies when a facility has
problems only in certain assessment areas. The State is responsible for
obtaining approval from us for its instrument and to specify its
approved instrument to facilities. Facilities must therefore rely upon
the State's assertion that the instrument is approved by the Secretary.
Proposed Sec. 483.20(b)(2) When Required
Comment: Several commenters addressed our proposed requirement that
a facility complete the comprehensive assessment within 14 days after a
resident's admission. Some commenters agreed with the 14-day time
period, and wanted us to emphasize that the RAI and quarterly review
are a minimum, stressing that all the resident's needs must be
identified and care planned as necessary. A commenter requested
clarification regarding completion ``within 14 days after admission,''
stating that it could be interpreted differently. For example, the
facility could construe the requirement
[[Page 67193]]
to mean ``14 days after admission'' or ``the fourteenth day of
admission.''
Response: Completion of the RAI specified by the State does not
necessarily fulfill a facility's obligation to perform a comprehensive
assessment. As previously stated, Sec. 483.25 requires that a facility
ensure that each resident attains or maintains his or her highest
practicable well-being. A facility is responsible for assessing areas
that are relevant for individual residents, regardless of whether they
are included in the RAI. For example, in completing the MDS, the
assessor simply indicates whether or not a factor is present. If the
MDS indicates the presence of a potential resident problem, need, or
strength, the assessor should then investigate the resident's condition
in more detail. The RAPs may assist in this investigation.
Other problems that are relevant for an individual resident may not
be addressed by the RAI at all. For example, the MDS includes a listing
of those diagnoses that affect the resident's functioning or needs in
the past 7 days. While the MDS may indicate the presence of medical
problems such as unstable diabetes or orthostatic hypotension, there
should be evidence of additional assessment of these factors if
relevant to the development of a care plan for an individual resident.
Another example of resident concerns not addressed by the MDS is sexual
patterns. Some facilities have responded by creating additional
assessment tools which they complete for all residents in addition to
the State RAI. This is not a Federal requirement. Additional assessment
is necessary only for factors that are relevant for an individual
resident. Facility staff have stated that many of the items added to
version 2.0 of the MDS may eliminate the need for supplementation of
items in facility specific assessments and will hopefully contribute to
a more comprehensive assessment for each resident.
A facility is also responsible for assessing and intervening in
response to acute or emergent problems such as respiratory distress or
fever. While this may seem obvious, surveyors have reported numerous
instances in which this has not occurred.
A facility must complete the initial assessment no later than 14
days after a resident's admission. For example, if a resident is
admitted on July 1, the assessment must be completed by July 15.
Although Federal requirements dictate the completion of RAI assessments
according to certain time frames, standards of good clinical practice
dictate that the assessment process is more fluid, and should be on-
going.
Comment: A few commenters recommended that we require the
assessment within the month that the annual is due and not a narrowly
defined ``every 365 days.''
Response: The statute requires that a facility conduct an
assessment no less often than once every 12 months. The facility should
use the completion date of the last assessment (in other words, the
date the registered nurse coordinator has certified the completion of
the assessment on the RAP Summary form in section V) to calculate when
the annual assessment is due. Current policy is that the next
assessment is due within 365 days. As we are not aware of any problems
regarding this policy, it will remain unchanged.
Comment: Commenters proposed alternatives to the requirement that a
facility complete an initial assessment within 14 days of a resident's
admission. A commenter suggested that a facility complete the MDS
within 14 days of admission, and the RAPs and care plan within 7 days
of completing the MDS (instead of completing the MDS and the RAP
process in 14 days). This would allow adequate time to complete and
document the in-depth assessment. Others believed that 21 days to
complete the assessment and 30 days to complete the care plan is
necessary.
Response: As mentioned above, the statute currently specifies the
time frame for the initial assessment, which does not allow us any
latitude. We have defined the RAI to include the MDS, triggers and
utilization guidelines, including the RAPs. Since the RAPs are part of
the comprehensive assessment, they too must be completed within 14 days
after admission or detection of a significant change. Current care
planning requirements allow 7 days after completion of the RAI for
completion of the plan of care.
Comment: A consumer advocacy group suggested that we require an
assessment similar to the quarterly review upon the resident's return
from a hospitalization, since some change in the resident's condition
had necessitated the hospital visit. Another commenter recommended that
we require an assessment when the use of restraints for an individual
increased over a prescribed threshold.
Response: We agree that it may be beneficial for the facility to
complete another assessment upon return from hospitalization or upon an
increase in restraint usage. An increase in restraint use is an example
of a situation in which a significant change reassessment is probably
necessary. If it becomes necessary to restrain a resident or increase
restraint usage, it is likely that the resident's condition has
deteriorated and there are behaviors of new onset or increased
frequency. In this case, the facility must revise the care plan. If a
resident's condition has significantly changed prior to or after
hospitalization, the facility must complete a comprehensive,
significant change assessment on the resident's return to the facility.
Some facilities have instituted a policy requiring a comprehensive RAI
assessment each time a resident is readmitted after hospitalization. We
prefer, however, to leave our requirement so that it is based on what
is clinically warranted (in other words, whether the resident's
condition meets the definition of a significant change).
Comment: Several commenters, including some State and national
provider organizations, were concerned with the impact that the 14-day
requirement would have on facilities whose residents are typically
short-stay, such as residents in hospital-based SNFs. A few wanted us
to exempt facilities which have an average length of stay less than 30
days from having to complete the assessment. Others wanted all
facilities to have 30 days in which to complete the assessment. Some
commenters suggested that we develop an alternate instrument that
pertains to the specific care needs of short-stay residents. For
example, they maintained that the MDS does not contain enough detail on
the rehabilitative aspects of care, nor does it capture important
information about a post-acute resident's health conditions. Others
proposed that we allow a facility to complete only those MDS items that
are appropriate for short-stay residents and skip the rest. A few
commenters wanted us to convene a clinical advisory panel that would
assist in identifying the clinical characteristics of short-stay
populations and determining which MDS elements are critical for them.
Response: From the comments received, it is evident that there are
a variety of strategies that people believe would be useful in dealing
with the assessment of short-stay residents. We cannot, under the law,
extend the time frame for completion of the RAI. Nor can we currently
exempt any facility certified under the long term care facility
requirements, even though it may provide care exclusively or primarily
for individuals needing a short period of rehabilitation prior to
return to the community. While we are aware that this has long been a
concern voiced by some providers, various
[[Page 67194]]
clinical experts have long believed that the majority of the RAI
gathers useful information for short-stay individuals as well as long-
term residents. In 1992 and 1993, we consulted with several panels of
expert clinicians and health professional, provider, and consumer
groups to identify MDS items that were not pertinent for short-stay
individuals. Of the few items that the panels proposed as not being
relevant for short-stay individuals, there was no consensus on
eliminating items, with all groups in agreement that all individuals in
certified facilities would benefit from the RAI assessment process.
We agree that the original MDS did not contain enough relevant
information pertinent to short-stay populations. We have added some
items to version 2.0 related to special therapies and care needs
(previously included in the MDS+, an alternate RAI used by some States)
that are very relevant for short-stay populations. A national
association representing hospital-based skilled nursing facilities
reported finding these MDS+ items useful in identifying nursing and
therapy needs for short term stay residents and for determining
Medicare coverage and subsequent reimbursement.
We have also added an item to collect information on pain that will
assist facilities in providing more focused care for short-stay
residents. Furthermore, we will clarify and add material to several of
the RAPs specific to short-stay populations as part of our contract
with the Hebrew Rehabilitation Center for Aged to refine the RAI, in an
effort to facilitate a more effective and efficient assessment for
these residents.
Moreover, as this concern has continued to be voiced by providers
and as the number of individuals undergoing a short-term, generally
rehabilitative stay in certified skilled nursing facilities has
continued to increase, we have begun to revisit this issue. We are
currently consulting with providers, consumer groups and professional
associations for the purpose of informing them about our work on
developing a module of assessment items that would be completed as an
alternative to many of the core MDS items. In this way, probably
through the use of the ``skip pattern'' logic in the MDS, facilities
providing care for ``short term stay'' individuals could perform a
standardized, reproducible assessment that is more relevant to the
resident population, while still adhering to the statutory requirement
to perform a comprehensive assessment based on the MDS.
Comment: Several commenters expressed the belief that the MDS is
not appropriate or does not collect enough information for special care
populations, like pediatrics, individuals with AIDS, individuals with
head injuries, individuals who are terminal and are receiving hospice
care, and properly placed residents who have mental illness or mental
retardation. The concerns were similar to those who addressed short
stay residents. A State provider organization asserted that the MDS is
designed for a homogeneous, chronic long term care resident and
suggested that we develop a variety of assessment parameters. Another
State organization stated that 70 percent of the MDS+ elements do not
apply to children. The commenter went on to say that about one-fifth of
those that do apply are demographic in nature. Commenters noted that
facility staff need to know what kinds of behavior usually heralded the
onset of a psychiatric crisis for a resident with mental illness, and
that the MDS does not sufficiently capture behavioral disorders, mood
disturbances, activity potential, and cognitive functioning for
individuals with mental illness or mental retardation. To address these
concerns, commenters recommended that we:
Waive special care populations from the RAI requirement;
Develop additional RAPs to address specific needs;
Develop additional MDS elements in modules for ``special
care'' residents;
Have skip patterns; or
Develop a new instrument.
Response: We acknowledge that the MDS may not be completely
responsive to the needs of special populations in nursing homes today.
We expect to use MDS data to gain a better sense of the clinical
characteristics and care needs of the diverse population of long term
care facilities, and to refine the RAI as it appears warranted over
time. In the meantime, some of the items that were added to the MDS are
more responsive to the needs of these residents. For example, items
that assess the presence, type, intensity, and treatment of pain were
added to version 2.0; this is particularly important for residents in a
hospice program. We have expanded significantly the MDS items
associated with mood and behavior, and also included the use of
programs for treatment of mood and behavior problems. Again, we note
that the statute does not allow us to exempt certain populations.
Comment: A State commenter requested that we exempt terminal/
hospice residents from RAI requirements since the philosophy of hospice
care is vastly different from the rehabilitative approach of the
typical nursing facility. Another State commenter noted that SNF/NF
residents who are residents of a certified hospice will have two
assessments and two care plans because of two sets of requirements; it
is possible that the care plans may be conflicting.
Response: When a resident of a Medicare participating SNF/NF elects
the Medicare hospice benefit, the hospice and the SNF/NF must
coordinate, establish, and agree upon a plan of care for both providers
which reflects the hospice philosophy and is based on an assessment of
the individual's needs and unique living situation in the SNF/NF. This
coordinated plan of care must identify the care and services that the
SNF/NF and hospice will provide in order to be responsive to the unique
needs of the individual and his or her expressed desire for hospice
care. The plan of care must include directives for managing pain and
other distressing symptoms and be revised and updated by the SNF/NF and
hospice, as necessary, to reflect the individual's current status.
Our policy is that when a resident of a SNF/NF elects to receive
Medicare coverage of services under the hospice benefit, both the
Medicare hospice conditions of participation and the SNF/NF
requirements apply. This means that the facility must assess a resident
using RAI. Some confusion arose among the SNF/NF providers concerning
the completion of RAPs that were not clinically appropriate. We have
issued a clarification memorandum reminding providers that the RAPs are
guidelines for assessment. They are not meant as prescriptive courses
of actions. Rather, they are intended as frameworks for assessment that
are clinically indicated depending on the needs of each individual
resident. For example, some of the RAP guidelines may include content
suggestive of an aggressive work-up to determine causal factors that
may not be appropriate for individuals who are terminally ill (for
example, an aggressive work-up to determine the cause of weight loss
would generally not be appropriate or expected for a resident receiving
hospice care.) Many of the RAPs, however, such as ``Activities'' or
maintenance of the resident's ``Activities of Daily Living'' should
lead to more aggressive assessment if they are useful in helping
facility staff increase the resident's comfort level and ability to
attain or maintain his or her highest practicable well-being and create
an atmosphere in which the resident will be able to die with dignity.
[[Page 67195]]
It is important to remember that RAP documentation and the plan of care
may also reflect a resident's right to refuse treatment or services.
In summary, we developed the RAPs to assist facilities in planning
appropriate and individualized care for residents. As we revise the RAP
guidelines over the next few years, we intend to incorporate material
specifically related to terminal care to better address the needs of
the hospice residents residing in SNF and NFs.
Comment: Some commenters wanted changes in the proposed definition
of ``readmission.'' One asked for clarification of what a ``temporary''
absence meant, asserting that a 5-month absence could be temporary for
someone who has lived in the facility for 10 years. A State provider
organization thought that ``temporary absence'' should not be defined
only as a hospitalization, but should allow for other absences like
doctor's visits.
Response: We do not consider it to be a temporary absence when a
resident leaves a facility for a doctor's visit; we do not require that
a facility conduct a new assessment merely because of such a visit.
Readmission is defined as a resident returning to a facility from the
hospital or therapeutic leave. We consider an absence to be temporary
when the facility fully expects the resident to return. For example, if
a resident leaves the facility for a few days during a holiday season,
the nursing home would not need to complete a new assessment (unless
there has been a significant change). If the resident is absent for an
extended period of time, however, it may be difficult for the facility
to determine if a significant change has occurred, and the facility may
wish to conduct an assessment. Furthermore, if the resident is absent
for a year or more, the facility must conduct its annual reassessment
upon the resident's return. However, we are not attaching a time frame
to temporary absence. This holds regardless of where the resident went
and how long he or she was absent from the facility. This policy
recognizes that there is variation in bed hold and discharge policies
in the States.
Comment: A few commenters expressed concern with the proposed
provision in Sec. 483.20(b)(2)(i) that would allow a facility to amend
assessment information up to 21 days after admission in some
situations. One commenter thought the entire MDS was amendable. A
national provider organization recommended that we permit a facility to
correct ``technical'' items on the MDS beyond the 21st day because
these items would not alter the triggers or RAP process.
Response: In the past, we had not allowed a facility to correct
non-factual errors once the assessment was completed. Rather, thes
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.