Swamp Timber Sales and Associated Activities; Kootenai National Forest, Lincoln County, Montana

Federal RegisterDec 1, 1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

Forest Service

Swamp Timber Sales and Associated Activities; Kootenai National

Forest, Lincoln County, Montana

AGENCY: Forest Service, USDA.

ACTION: Notice of Intent to prepare an environmental impact statement.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The USDA, Forest Service, will prepare an Environmental Impact

Statement (EIS) to disclose the environmental effects of timber harvest

(including salvage of beetle-killed lodgepole pine and windthrown

trees), prescribed fire, watershed rehabilitation, year-round road

restrictions, road obliteration, construction of temporary roads and

reconstruction of specified roads in the Swamp Analysis Area on the

Fortine Ranger District of the Kootenai National Forest. The Swamp

Analysis Area is located approximately 30 air miles northeast of Libby,

Montana, near the communities of Trego, Fortine and Eureka, Montana.

The proposed actions to harvest and reforest timber stands, improve

stream

[[Page 63511]]

and watershed conditions, reconstruct, rehabilitate or obliterate

roads, restrict road access and underburn forest fuels and debris are

being considered together because they represent either connected or

cumulative actions as defined by the Council on Environmental Quality

(40 CFR 1508.25). The purposes of the project are: (1) To manage for a

diversity of plant communities and age classes to meet the specific

habitat requirements for a variety of plant and animal species; (2) to

provide timber to support local, regional, and national needs; and (3)

to manage for stable stream channels, viable and productive habitats

for aquatic species, and water quality that meets or exceeds State of

Montana water quality goals.

The EIS will tier to the Kootenai National Forest Land and Resource

Management Plan and Final EIS of September, 1987, which provides

overall guidance for forest management of the area. All activities

associated with the proposal will be designed to maintain high quality

wildlife, fisheries, and watershed objectives.

DATES: Written comments and suggestions should be postmarked or

received by December 31, 1997.

ADDRESSES: The Responsible Official is Edward C. Monnig, District

Ranger, Fortine Ranger District, P.O. Box 116, Fortine, Montana, 59918.

Written comments and suggestions concerning the scope of the analysis

may be sent to him at that address.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Michael Liu, Project Leader, Fortine Ranger District. Phone: (406) 882-

4451.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Swamp Decision Area contains

approximately 40,680 acres of land within the Kootenai National Forest

in Lincoln County, Montana. All of the proposed projects would occur on

National Forest lands in the Swamp, Beaver and Edna Creek drainages

near Trego, Montana.

The legal location of the Swamp Decision Area is as follows: All or

portions of Sections 1-3 and 11-12 of Township 32 North, Range 28 West;

Sections 2-11 and 14-16 of Township 32 North, Range 27 West; Section 36

of Township 33 North, Range 28 West; Sections 1-4, 8-17, and 19-36 of

Township 33 North, Range 27 West; Sections 1-11, 14-22, and 29-32 of

Township 33 North, Range 26 West; Sections 24-26 and 34-36 of Township

34 North, Range 27 West; and Sections 17-36 of Township 34 North, Range

26 West; Principal Montana Meridian, Lincoln County, Montana.

All proposed activities are outside the boundaries of any roadless

area or any areas considered for inclusion to the National Wilderness

System as recommended by the Kootenai National Forest Plan or by any

past or present legislative wilderness proposals.

The Forest Service proposes to harvest approximately 36,600 hundred

cubic feet (CCF), the equivalent of 15 million board feet (MMBF), of

timber through application of a variety of harvest methods on

approximately 4780 acres of forest land within the Swamp Decision Area.

Use of existing and temporary roads would be needed to access timber

harvest areas. An estimated 47 miles of existing roads would be

reconstructed to access timber harvest areas or improve watershed

conditions. An additional 13 miles of road would be rehabilitated to

improve watershed conditions. All temporary roads would be obliterated

following completion of sale activities. An additional 16 miles of road

no longer in use, would be obliterated by various methods, such as

removal of culverts, recontouring, ripping and seeding, and installing

barriers. The method of obliteration would be based on site specific

conditions. An estimated 24 miles of existing road would be restricted

year-round to improve watershed conditions, minimize future road

maintenance costs, and to regulate overall open road density to improve

big game security. The proposal also includes prescribed burning on

approximately 500 acres to enhance wildlife habitat, and promote

vegetative diversity. Prescribed burning would also be used to reduce

fuels and prepare sites for natural or artificial reforestation on

regeneration harvest units after completion of harvest operation.

More specifically management activities in this proposal include:

Regeneration Harvest

These activities emphasize development of a new stand of trees

through harvest of existing live or dead trees. The following types of

regeneration harvest are proposed: (1) Salvage of merchantable dead

lodgepole pine and other species would be removed in one entry, leaving

6-10 live trees/acre. Approximately 126 acres would be harvested

resulting in approximately 2,440 CCF (1 MMBF) of timber; (2) Seedtree/

shelterwood harvest of all merchantable trees except for 6-10 trees/

acre in seed tree or 20-40 trees/acre in shelterwood prescriptions.

Some shelterwood trees could be removed in a second entry when the

stand has been certified as regenerated. A total of approximately 299

acres would be harvested resulting in approximately 7296 CCF (3 MMBF)

of timber; (3) Using a group shelterwood prescription some units would

be harvested in 3-5 acre openings. Three entries would take place over

a 20 year period, removing one-third of the stand with each entry.

Leave trees would be left in the openings. Approximately 574 acres

would be harvested and yield approximately 4636 CCF (1.9 MMBF) of

timber; (4) Special shelterwood harvests would remove all merchantable

trees except for 20-25 large diameter (>18''DBH) larch and Douglas fir

trees/acre. The remaining shelterwood trees would be left in the unit

to provide stand structure. Approximately 259 acres would be harvested

yielding approximately 4,880 CCF (2 MMBF) of timber.

Intermediate Harvest

These activities emphasize active management of existing trees by

thinning the stand. The following types of intermediate harvest

prescriptions are planned: (1) Blowdown salvage and lodgepole pine

salvage would remove merchantable dead trees while protecting desirable

live trees in the stand. Approximately 1550 acres would be harvested

yielding approximately 7857 CCF (3.2 MMBF) of timber; (2) Commercial

thinning of merchantable and less dominant trees in the stand would

occur to meet desired stand stocking levels. The largest and healthiest

trees would be left in the stands. Approximately 1964 acres would be

harvested resulting in approximately 9590 CCF (3.9 MMBF) of timber; (3)

Harvest of post and pole sized lodgepole pine from approximately 170

acres is proposed. Larger healthy lodgepole pine and other species

would be left on roughly a 12 by 12 spacing. No volume has been

estimated at this time.

Underburning

Underburning is proposed on approximately 500 acres to reduce fuel

loads, and improve stands for wildlife. The prescription would involve

burning stands during spring and early summer for good smoke dispersion

and safe burning conditions.

Watershed Rehabilitation

A number of watershed rehabilitation projects are proposed in the

Swamp Decision Area. These include: two stream channel enhancement

projects, two riparian enhancement projects and three projects to

control cattle access to streams.

[[Page 63512]]

Road Reconstruction and Rehabilitation

Approximately 47 miles of existing road would be reconstructed to

access harvest areas or improve watershed conditions. Approximately 13

miles would be rehabilitated to improve watershed conditions and 16

miles would be obliterated because they are no longer in use.

Obliteration would be accomplished through removal of culverts,

recontouring, or ripping and seeding the road bed.

Year-round Road Restrictions

Approximately 24 miles of road would be temporarily restricted

year-round. These restrictions would help to improve watershed

conditions to minimize future road maintenance costs and to improve big

game security by reducing overall open road densities.

The Kootenai National Forest Land and Resource Management Plan

provides overall management objectives in individual delineated

management areas (MA's). The proposed projects encompass seven

predominant MA's; 11, 12, 13, 15, 16, 21 and 24. Briefly described, MA

11 (4% of the area) is managed to maintain or enhance the winter range

habitat effectiveness for big-game species and produce a programmed

yield of timber. MA 12 (17% of the area) is designated to maintain or

enhance big game summer range and produce a programmed yield of timber.

MA 13 (9% of the area) is designated to provide special habitat

necessary for old growth dependent wildlife. MA 15 (43% of the area)

focuses upon timber production using various silvicultural practices

while providing for other resource values such as soil, air, water,

wildlife, recreation, and forage for domestic livestock. MA 16 (2% of

the area) is managed to produce timber while providing for a pleasing

view. MA 21 (1% of the area) is the designated as a special interest

area and serves to provide protection or special management of unique,

unusual, or important attributes (flora, fauna, geologic, etc.). MA 24

(4% of the area) is usually not productive ground and is managed to

provide site protection and for any inherent wildlife resources. Timber

harvest is proposed in MA's 11, 12, 15, 16 and 24.

This proposal includes openings greater than 40 acres to replicate

historic disturbance patterns. If these large openings are included in

the preferred alternative in the Draft EIS, a 60-day public review will

be provided during the comment period on the Draft EIS. Approval of the

Regional Forester for exceeding the 40-acre limitation for regeneration

harvest would be required prior to the signing of the Record of

Decision.

The Forest Service will consider a range of alternatives. One of

these will be the ``no action'' alternative in which none of the

proposed activities would be implemented. Additional alternatives will

examine varying levels and locations for the proposed activities to

achieve the proposal's purposes, as well as to respond to the issues

and other resource values.

Preliminary Issues

The following preliminary issues have been identified for this

proposal:

--Road Management: Specific roads would need to be restricted or

obliterated to meet road densities for wildlife security and improve

watershed conditions. Some individuals feel that these activities

unfairly restrict public use and waste taxpayer dollars. Others feel

restrictions are a benefit to wildlife and watershed conditions and

should be implemented.

--Timber Supply: A continued supply of timber is a concern of both

internal and external publics. The methods used to provide that supply

as well as amount of timber harvested are components of this issue

--Water Quality: Road construction and reconstruction, cattle use, as

well as timber harvest and prescribed burning are concerns of the

public in relation to the issue of water quality.

Public Involvement and Scoping

On March 13, 1997 an advertisement was placed in the Daily Inter

Lake, Kalispell, Montana, requesting public comment and information

concerning the Swamp Analysis Area. In addition, on March 14, 1997 a

letter was mailed to the approximately 216 individuals comprising the

mailing list for the Swamp Analysis Area. Taking into account the

comments received and information gathered during preliminary analysis,

it was decided to prepare an EIS for the Swamp Timber Sales and

Associated Activities. Comments received prior to this notice will be

included in the documentation for the EIS.

This environmental analysis and decision making process will enable

additional interested and affected people to participate and contribute

to the final decision. The public is encouraged to take part in the

process and is encouraged to visit with Forest Service officials at any

time during the analysis and prior to the decision. The Forest Service

will be seeking information, comments, and assistance from Federal,

State, local agencies and other individuals or organizations who may be

interested in or affected by the proposed action. This input will be

used in preparation of the Draft and Final EIS. Comments received on

this proposal will be made part of the public record and may be

included in the Draft and Final EIS. Names and addresses of commentors

are subject to inquiries under the Freedom of Information Act and would

be disclosed upon request. Comments on this proposal must be postmarked

or received by December 31, 1997.

Estimated Dates for Filing

The Draft EIS is expected to be filed with the Environmental

Protection Agency (EPA) and available for public review by June, 1998.

At that time, EPA will publish a Notice of Availability of the Draft

EIS in the Federal Register. The comment period on the Draft EIS will

be a minimum of 45 days from the date the EPA publishes the Notice of

Availability in the Federal Register.

The Final EIS is scheduled to be completed by August, 1998. In the

Final EIS, the Forest Service is required to respond to comments and

responses received during the comment period that pertain to the

environmental consequences discussed in the Draft EIS and applicable

laws, regulations, and policies considered in making a decision

regarding the proposal.

Reviewers Obligations

The Forest Service believes, at this early stage, it is important

to give reviewers notice of several court rulings related to public

participation in the environmental review process. First, reviewers of

Draft EIS's must structure their participation in the environmental

review of the proposal so that it is meaningful and alerts an agency to

the reviewer's position and contentions. Vermont Yankee Nuclear Power

Corp. v. NRDC, 435 U.S.C. 519, 553 (1978). Also, environmental

objections that could be raised at the Draft EIS stage may be waived or

dismissed by the courts. City of Angoon v. Hodel, 803 F.2d 1016, 1022

(9th Cir. 1986) and Wisconsin Heritages, Inc. v. Harris, 490 F. Supp.

1334, 1338 (E.D. Wis. 1980). Because of these court rulings, it is very

important that those interested in this proposed action participate by

the close of the Draft EIS 45 day comment period so that substantive

comments and objections are made available to the Forest Service at a

time when it can meaningfully consider and respond to them in the Final

EIS.

To assist the Forest Service in identifying and considering issues

and

[[Page 63513]]

concerns on the proposed action, comments on the Draft EIS should be as

specific as possible. It is also helpful if comments refer to specific

pages or chapters of the draft statement. Comments may also address the

adequacy of the Draft EIS or the merits of the alternatives discussed.

Reviewers may wish to refer to the Council on Environmental Quality

regulations for implementing the procedural provisions of the National

Environmental Policy Act at 40 CFR 1503.3 in addressing these points.

Responsible Official

Edward C. Monnig, District Ranger, Fortine Ranger District,

Kootenai National Forest, P.O. Box 116, Fortine, Montana, 59918, is the

Responsible Official. As the Responsible Official, I will decide which,

if any, of the proposed projects will be implemented. I will document

the decision and reasons for the decision in the Record of Decision.

That decision will be subject to Forest Service Appeal Regulations.

Dated: November 21, 1997.

Edward C. Monnig,

District Ranger, Fortine Ranger District.

[FR Doc. 97-31330 Filed 11-28-97; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3410-11-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.