Summary of Precedent Opinions of the General Counsel

Federal RegisterDec 1, 1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS

Summary of Precedent Opinions of the General Counsel

AGENCY: Department of Veterans Affairs.

ACTION: Notice.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) is publishing a

summary of legal interpretations issued by the Department's General

Counsel involving veterans' benefits under laws administered by VA.

These interpretations are considered precedential by VA and will be

followed by VA officials and employees in future claim matters. The

summary is published to provide the public, and, in particular,

veterans' benefit claimants and their representatives, with notice of

VA's interpretations regarding the legal matter at issue.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Jane L. Lehman, Chief, Law Library, Department of Veterans Affairs, 810

Vermont Avenue, NW., Washington, DC 20420, (202) 273-6558.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: VA regulations at 38 CFR 2.6(e)(9) and

14.507 authorize the Department's General Counsel to issue written

legal opinions having precedential effect in adjudications and appeals

involving veterans' benefits under laws administered by VA. The General

Counsel's interpretations on legal matters, contained in such opinions,

are conclusive as to all VA officials and employees not only in the

matter at issue but also in future adjudications and appeals, in the

absence of a change in controlling statute or regulation or a

superseding written legal opinion of the General Counsel.

VA publishes summaries of such opinions in order to provide the

public with notice of those interpretations of the General Counsel that

must be followed in future benefit matters and to assist veterans'

benefit claimants and their representatives in the prosecution of

benefit claims. The full text of such opinions, with personal

identifiers deleted, may be obtained by contacting the VA official

named above.

[[Page 63604]]

VAOPGCPREC 22-97

Question Presented

May the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) withhold monthly

benefits from beneficiaries in situations where the payee refuses to

participate in the Electronic Funds Transfer Program?

Held

The Secretary has authority under the DCIA to withhold monthly VA

benefits to a recipient of Federal payments subject to the EFT program

if the recipient has not complied with the statutory EFT requirements

and is not entitled to a waiver of their application.

Effective Date: June 20, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 23-97

Question Presented

Where a claimant has arthritis and instability of the knee, does 38

CFR 4.71a authorize multiple ratings under diagnostic codes 5003 and

5257?

Held

A claimant who has arthritis and instability of the knee may be

rated separately under diagnostic codes 5003 and 5257.

Effective Date: July 1, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 24-97

Question Presented

Is a veteran who is receiving compensation pursuant to 38 U.S.C.

1151 due to blindness in both eyes which resulted from the veteran's

hospitalization, medical, or surgical treatment by VA, and not incurred

or aggravated in the line of duty in the active military, naval, or air

service, eligible for a special housing adaptation grant under chapter

21 of title 38, United States Code?

Held

A veteran with a disability that resulted from VA hospitalization

or medical or surgical treatment who has been determined eligible for

compensation ``as if'' such injury were service connected pursuant to

38 U.S.C. 1151 is not eligible for a special housing adaptation grant

as a result of the disability caused by VA medical care.

Effective Date: July 3, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 25-97

Question Presented

Should military retired pay that is paid directly to a veteran's

ex-spouse by a military finance center pursuant to a divorce decree or

garnishment order be considered income of the veteran for purposes of

determining his or her entitlement to Department of Veterans Affairs

(VA) need-based benefits?

Held

Whether military retired pay paid directly to a veteran's ex-spouse

by a military finance center pursuant to a divorce must be included in

the veteran's annual income for purposes of determining eligibility for

need-based veterans' benefits is dependent upon the property rights of

the parties in the military retired pay, as determined in the pertinent

divorce decree and any related property settlement, interpreted in

light of applicable state law. Where, in a divorce proceeding, military

retired pay is treated as marital property and divided between the

parties to the proceeding, only that portion of the retired pay which

is determined to be the property of the veteran is countable as income

of the veteran for purposes of determining entitlement for need-based

veterans' benefits. Where no such division of property has occurred,

the full amount of such retired pay is attributable to the veteran,

regardless of whether all or a portion of the retired pay is paid

directly to the veteran's ex-spouse pursuant to a voluntary or

involuntary allotment or a garnishment order.

Effective Date: July 16, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 26-97

Question Presented

Was the addition of a diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder

(PTSD) to the rating schedule, effective April 11, 1980, ``a

liberalizing law, or a liberalizing [Department of Veterans Affairs

(VA)] issue'' of 38 CFR 3.114(a)?

Held

The addition of PTSD as a diagnostic entity in the schedule for

rating mental disorders was a ``liberalizing VA issue'' for purposes of

38 CFR 3.114(a). However, an effective date prior to the date of claim

cannot be assigned under section 3.114(a) unless the claimant met all

eligibility criteria for the liberalized benefit on April 11, 1980, the

effective date of the regulatory amendment adding the diagnostic code

for PTSD, and such eligibility existed continuously from that date to

the date of claim or administrative determination of entitlement.

Effective Date: July 16, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 27-97

Question Presented

Whether service on a naval vessel in the waters off the shore of

Vietnam constitutes service in the Republic of Vietnam for purposes of

38 U.S.C. 101(29)(A), which defines the Vietnam era as the period

beginning on February 28, 1961, and ending on May 7, 1975, in the case

of a veteran who served in the Republic of Vietnam during that period.

Held

Service on a deep-water naval vessel in waters off the shore of the

Republic of Vietnam does not constitute service in the Republic of

Vietnam for purposes of 38 U.S.C. 101(29)(A), as added by section 505

of the Veterans' Benefits Improvements Act of 1996, which provides that

the term ``Vietnam era'' means the period beginning on February 28,

1961, and ending on May 7, 1975, in the case of a veteran who served in

the Republic of Vietnam during that period.

Effective Date: July 23, 1997

VAOPGCPREC 28-97

Question Presented

Whether a person insured under Service Disabled Veterans'

Insurance, who does not receive a waiver of premiums pursuant to 38

U.S.C. 1912 because the insured died prior to the continuance of total

disability for six consecutive months, is nonetheless eligible for

supplemental Service Disabled Veterans' pursuant to 38 U.S.C. 1922A.

Held

A person insured under Service Disabled Veterans' Insurance, who

does not qualify for a waiver of premiums pursuant to 38 U.S.C. 1912

because the insured died prior to the continuance of total disability

for six months, is not eligible for supplemental Service Disabled

Veterans Insurance pursuant to 38 U.S.C. 1922A.

VAOPGCPREC 29-97

Question Presented

Does 38 C.F.R. 3.105(e) apply to cases subject to the special

settlement review under the provisions of the October 15, 1993,

Stipulation and Order in Fernando Giusti Bravo, et al v. U.S.

Department of Veterans Affairs, et al., where there is no reduction of

a service-connected disability rating which results in reduction or

discontinuance of compensation payments currently being made?

Held

38 C.F.R. 3.105(e) applies to cases subject to the special

settlement review under the provisions of the October 15, 1993,

Stipulation and Order in Fernando Giusti Bravo, et al. v. U.S.

[[Page 63605]]

Department of Veterans Affairs, et al. only where there is a reduction

of service-connected disability rating which results in reduction or

discontinuance of compensation payments currently being made. Thus, the

provisions of section 3.105(e) which require VA to provide a proposed

rating action and a 60-day pretermination notice are inapplicable where

there is no reduction of a service-connected disability rating which

results in reduction or discontinuance of compensation payments

currently being made.

Effective Date: August 7, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 30-97

Question Presented

What level of special monthly compensation (SMC) should be awarded

to a claimant with nonservice-connected paraplegia who is entitled to

compensation under 38 U.S.C. 1151 for disarticulation of the hips?

Held

Regardless of preexisting paraplegia, SMC is payable at the rate

prescribed in 38 U.S.C. 1114(n) to a claimant who is entitled to

compensation for bilateral disarticulation of the hips under 38 U.S.C.

1151.

Effective Date: August 29, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 31-97

Question Presented

If the Board of Veterans' Appeals concludes upon reconsideration

that the Department of Veterans Affairs Regional Office erred in

determining the effective date of a reduction in compensation pursuant

to 38 U.S.C. 5112(6) and 38 CFR 3.105(e), does that error render the

decision reducing the rating void ab initio, requiring reinstatement of

the prior rating?

Held

The reduction of a disability rating, if otherwise supportable, is

not rendered void ab initio by virtue of error in the assignment of the

effective date for it.

Effective Date: August 29, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 32-97

Question Presented

When a claimant has service-connected, partial hearing loss in only

one ear, should the hearing in the other ear be considered normal for

purposes of rating the service-connected hearing loss?

Held

If a claimant has service-connected hearing loss in one ear and

nonservice-connected hearing loss in the other ear, the hearing in the

ear having nonservice-connected loss should be considered normal for

purposes of computing the service-connected disability rating, unless

the claimant is totally deaf in both ears.

Effective Date: August 29, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 33-97

Question Presented

Are assets which are placed in an irrevocable special needs trust

includable in the claimant's net worth for purposes of determining

eligibility for improved pension?

Held

Assets transferred by a legally competent claimant, or by the

fiduciary of a leagally incompetent one, to an irrevocable ``living

trust'' or an estate-planning vehicle of the same nature designed to

preserve estate assets by restricting trust expenditures to the

claimant's ``special needs,'' while maximizing the use of governmental

resources in the care and maintenance of the claimant, should be

considered in calculating the claimant's net worth for improved-pension

purposes.

Effective Date: August 29, 1997.

VAOPGCPREC 34-97

Question Presented

Does 38 U.S.C. 3104(b) or any other statute or regulation, e.g.,

Department of Labor Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and associated

regulations, either require or preclude VA from assisting appellant in

purchasing a computer and related materials for recreational

activities?

Held

1. No statute or regulation, including section 702 of the

Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and its associated regulations, either

specifically directs VA to authorize or precludes VA from authorizing

services and assistance of a recreational nature as a component of an

eligible veteran's program of independent living services and

assistance under 38 U.S.C. 3120.

2. VA has the authority, and responsibility, to provide all

services and assistance deemed necessary on the facts of the particular

case to enable an eligible veteran participating in such a program to

live and function independently in his or her family and community

without, or with a reduced level of, the services of others. This

includes the authority to approve, when appropriate, services and

assistance that are in whole or part recreational in character when the

services are found to be needed to enable or enhance the veteran's

ability to engage in family and community activities integral to the

veteran's achieving his or her independent living program goals.

Effective Date: November 5, 1997.

By the Direction of the Secretary:

Robert E. Coy,

Acting General Counsel.

[FR Doc. 97-31329 Filed 11-28-97; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 8320-01-P-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.