Energy Conservation Program for Consumer Products: Determination Concerning the Potential for Energy Conservation Standards for Electric Distribution Transformers

Federal RegisterOct 22, 1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY

Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy

10 CFR Part 430

[Docket No. EE-DET-97-550]

RIN 1904-AA85

Energy Conservation Program for Consumer Products: Determination

Concerning the Potential for Energy Conservation Standards for Electric

Distribution Transformers

AGENCY: Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, Department of

Energy (DOE).

ACTION: Notice of Determination.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Department of Energy (DOE or the Department) has

[[Page 54810]]

determined, based on the best information currently available, that

energy conservation standards for electric distribution transformers

are technologically feasible, economically justified and would result

in significant energy savings. This determination initiates the process

of establishing, by notice and comment rulemaking, test procedures and

energy conservation standards for this product.

ADDRESSES: Copies of ``Guide for Determining Energy Efficiency for

Distribution Transformers'' (NEMA Standards Publication TP 1-1996),

``Determination Analysis of Energy Conservation Standards for

Distribution Transformers, ORNL-6847,'' and ``Supplement to the

Determination Analysis (ORNL-6847) and Analysis of the NEMA Efficiency

Standard for Distribution Transformers, ORNL-6925,'' are available in

the DOE Freedom of Information Reading Room, U.S. Department of Energy,

Forrestal Building, Room 1E-190, 1000 Independence Avenue, SW,

Washington, DC, 20585, (202) 586-6020, between the hours of 9 a.m. and

4 p.m., Monday through Friday, except Federal holidays.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Kathi Epping, U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Energy Efficiency

and Renewable Energy, Mail Station EE-43, Forrestal Building, 1000

Independence Avenue, SW, Washington, DC 20585-0121, (202) 586-7425,

FAX: (202) 586-4617, email: [email protected].

Edward Levy, Esq., U.S. Department of Energy, Office of General

Counsel, Mail Station GC-72, Forrestal Building, 1000 Independence

Avenue, SW, Washington, DC 20585-3410, (202) 586-9507, email:

[email protected].

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Introduction

A. Authority

B. Rulemaking Procedures

C. Background

II. Discussion of ORNL Reports

A. Purpose and Content

B. Methodology

C. Conservation Cases

1. Base Case

2. Lowest Total Owning Cost (TOC) Case

3. Median Total Owning Cost (TOC) Case

4. Average Losses Case

5. High-Efficiency Case

D. Voluntary Programs

1. NEMA-TP-1 Guide

2. National Business Awareness Campaign

III. Conclusion

A. Determination

B. Future Proceedings

I. Introduction

A. Authority

The National Energy Conservation Policy Act of 1978, Pub. L. 95-

619, amended the Energy Policy and Conservation Act (EPCA) to add a

Part C to Title III, which established an energy conservation program

for certain industrial equipment. The most recent amendments to EPCA,

in the Energy Policy Act of 1992, Pub. L. 102-486, (EPACT) included

amendments that expanded Title III of EPCA to include certain

commercial water heaters and heating and air-conditioning equipment,

incandescent and fluorescent lamps, electric motors and electric

distribution transformers.

Among these amendments is section 124(a) of EPACT, which amended

section 346 of EPCA, 42 U.S.C. 6317, to provide that the Secretary of

Energy must prescribe testing requirements and energy conservation

standards for those distribution transformers for which the Secretary

determines that standards ``would be technologically feasible and

economically justified, and would result in significant energy

savings.'' 42 U.S.C. 6317(a). Section 346 was also amended to require

the Secretary, within six months after prescribing energy conservation

standards for distribution transformers, to prescribe labeling

requirements for such transformers.

Section 346 requires the Department to make a determination that

standards for transformers are technologically feasible and

economically justified, and would save significant amounts of energy,

before the Department initiates the process for promulgating test

procedures and specific standards. The section could be read as

providing that once this initial determination is made, there is no

further consideration of technological feasibility, economic

justification, or energy savings, and that the Department must proceed

to adopt standards. Such an interpretation, however, would be

inconsistent with the approach in other provisions of EPCA, and would

be impractical. It is inconsistent, for example, with section 325(o) of

EPCA, under which economic justification is addressed after specific

standards have been proposed, based on a detailed evaluation with

respect to one or more specific standards. It is impractical because,

even if one or more design options has the potential for achieving

energy savings, a determination that such savings could in fact be

achieved cannot be made without first having developed test procedures

to measure the energy efficiency of transformer designs, and then

conducting an in-depth analysis of each design option. Such analysis

might show that no standard meets all three of the prescribed criteria:

i.e., technologically feasible, economically justified and significant

energy savings.

For these reasons, the Department construes section 346 as

requiring it to: (1) Determine based upon the best information

available whether standards for transformers would be ``technologically

feasible and economically justified, and would result in significant

energy savings,'' and (2) if energy conservation standards appear to be

warranted under these criteria, to prescribe test procedures and

conduct a rulemaking concerning such standards. During the standards

rulemaking, the Department would describe whether and at what level(s)

to promulgate standards. This decision would be based on in-depth

consideration, with public participation, of the technological

feasibility, economic justification, and energy savings of potential

standard levels. Thus, the initial determination made today that

standards are warranted under the criteria specified in section 346(a)

would in effect be reviewed during the rulemaking process, based on

more complete information than is currently available as to whether

those criteria are met.

B. Rulemaking Procedures

EPCA, which provides rulemaking procedures for the promulgation of

test procedures and standards for appliances and commercial equipment,

is ambiguous as to whether these procedures apply to rulemakings on

test procedures and standards for transformers. For the reasons

discussed below, the Department will nonetheless use these procedures

in conducting the test procedure and standards rulemakings for

transformers.

In conducting rulemakings on all subjects, the Department must, at

a minimum, adhere to the procedures required by the Administrative

Procedure Act and section 501 of the Department of Energy Organization

Act (DOE Organization Act), 42 U.S.C. 7191. Section 501 in essence

requires the following: (1) Issuance of a notice of proposed rulemaking

(NOPR), (2) an opportunity for comment, (3) an opportunity for

presentation of oral comments, if there exists ``a substantial issue of

fact or law'' or if the rule will have a ``substantial impact,'' and

(4) publication of the final rule accompanied by appropriate

explanation. Pursuant to E.O. 12662, the comment period must be at

least 75 days.

With respect to test procedures for transformers, the Department

has

[[Page 54811]]

decided to use the same rulemaking procedures it uses under Part B of

EPCA, and for other equipment covered under Part C. Thus, in addition

to the generic procedural requirements described above, the Department

will provide an opportunity for oral comment (i.e., hold a hearing) on

all proposed test procedures, regardless of the ``substantial issue''

or ``substantial impact'' criteria, as is done in other EPCA test

procedure rulemakings. See, e.g., EPCA section 323(b)(2), 42 U.S.C.

6293(b)(2). Hearings have been useful in promulgating test procedures

in the appliance program, and a hearing can help to identify issues

that should be addressed and points that should be amplified in the

written comments. In addition, permitting oral as well as written

comments will maximize the opportunity for interested parties to

express their views on the proposed rule. This should give greater

assurance of the validity and feasibility of the final test procedure

that the Department adopts.

As to energy conservation standards, for most other products

covered by EPCA, EPCA requires the Department to take supplemental

steps in promulgating standards, including the following, that are not

required by the Administrative Procedural Act or the DOE Organization

Act:

1. An advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANOPR) must be

issued, followed by a 60-day comment period;

2. The notice of proposed rulemaking (NOPR) must set forth the

maximum efficiency improvement that is technologically feasible and,

if the proposed standard does not achieve this level, an explanation

of why; and

3. A hearing must be held following issuance of the NOPR,

regardless of the ``substantial issue'' or ``substantial impact''

criteria.

EPCA sections 325(p), 336(a), and 345(a), 42 U.S.C. 6295(p), 6306(a),

and 6317(a). The Department also has a policy, in conducting

rulemakings on appliance standards, to allow 75 days for comment on the

ANOPR (rather than the 60 days required by EPCA), with at least one

public hearing or workshop during this period. Procedures for

Consideration of New or Revised Energy Conservation Standards for

Consumer Products, 61 FR 36974, (July 15, 1996) (the ``Interpretive

Rule'').

The first sentence of section 345(a) could be interpreted as

requiring the Department to employ these EPCA procedures in developing

standards on transformers. In any case, the Department has decided it

will employ the foregoing procedures set forth in EPCA and the

Interpretive Rule. It will do so in part for the same reasons it will

use EPCA procedures to promulgate transformer test procedures. These

reasons include: (1) EPCA procedures have worked well in the appliance

program, and (2) they will provide enhanced the opportunity for public

comment, thereby helping to improve the quality of the final rules. In

addition, the Department has never developed efficiency standards for a

product such as distribution transformers. Therefore, the Department

believes that the development of transformer standards will benefit

from enhanced opportunities for public participation during the

standards development process. Such participation can best be achieved

if the Department employs the full range of procedures used in its

program to set efficiency standards.

C. Background

After the passage of EPACT, the Department contracted with the Oak

Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) to conduct a study to obtain data and

assist the Department in making a determination as to whether standards

for distribution transformers are warranted. ORNL developed and

published a report, entitled ``Determination Analysis of Energy

Conservation Standards for Distribution Transformer, ORNL-6847'' which

was based on information from annual sales data, average load data, and

surveys of existing and potential transformer efficiencies that were

obtained from several organizations.

In the ORNL analysis, transformers with a primary voltage of 480 V

to 35 kV and a secondary voltage of 120 to 480 V are defined as

distribution transformers. This definition is consistent with ANSI/IEEE

C57.12.80-1978 (subsection 2.3.1.1), which defines a distribution

transformer as ``a transformer for transferring electrical energy from

a primary distribution circuit to a secondary distribution circuit or

consumer's service circuit.'' Typical utility primary distribution

voltages in the U.S. range from 5 kV to 35 kV medium-voltage classes,

and typical primary consumers' services are 480 V or higher; thus the

total primary voltage range is 480 V to 35 kV. Typical secondary

voltages in the U.S. range from 120 to 480 V. ANSI/IEEE C57.12.80-1978

indicates that distribution transformers usually have a rated capacity

in the order of 5 -500 kVA. However, ANSI/IEEE C57.12.26-1993 defines

pad-mounted distribution transformers as transformers with a rated

capacity 2500 kVA or lower, with primary voltages of 34,500 V (35 kV

class) or lower and secondary voltages of 480 V or lower. The ORNL

analysis considered rated capacities ranging from of 10 to 2500 kVA for

liquid-immersed transformers, because most manufacturers no longer

produce units smaller than 10 kVA. For dry-type transformers a rated

capacity range of 0.25 to 2500 kVA was considered; comments from

manufacturers indicate that this range covers nearly all the U.S. dry-

type transformer market, although the bulk of that market is in the

range of 10 to 2500 kVA. The ORNL analysis did not consider

transformers which are not continuously connected to a power

distribution system as a distribution transformer. For example,

transformers that are part of machinery which are switched off from

electrical power were considered by the study as a component of the

machinery's circuit and not part of the power distribution circuit.

Also, special-purpose control and signal transformers, as well as bulk

power transformers, were excluded from consideration because they are

not classified as distribution transformers.

In the Department's view, the term ``distribution transformer'' in

section 346 of EPCA means all transformers with a primary voltage of

480 V to 35 kV, a secondary voltage of 120 V to 480 V, and a capacity

of either 10 to 2500 kVA for liquid-immersed transformers or 0.25 kVA

to 2500 kVA for dry-type transformers, except for transformers

described in the foregoing three sentences. This definition encompasses

the transformers considered in the ORNL analysis.

ORNL collected data from the following organizations and sources:

The American National Standards Institute (ANSI), Department of

Commerce (DOC), Department of Energy (DOE), Edison Electric Institute

(EEI), Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE),

National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA), North American

Electric Reliability Council (NAERC), Office of Management and Budget

(OMB), various books and phone conversations with interested parties.

In addition, the ORNL report used data from a survey developed by ORNL

and circulated by NEMA to NEMA and non-NEMA manufacturers, to obtain

no-load losses, load losses and selling prices of various sizes and

types of distribution transformers. Data from these surveys and other

relevant information were used in the report to show the potential

energy savings of various conservation case studies such as: (1) Lowest

Total

[[Page 54812]]

Owning Cost (TOC)\1\ Case, (2) Median TOC Case, (3) Average Losses

Case, (4) High-Efficiency Case, and (5) Two-Year Payback Case. The last

of these, the Two-Year Payback Case, was not derived from the survey.

Rather, a manufacturer developed this case during peer review of the

report by using a combination of price and design losses, with the

objective of achieving a two-year payback based on typical transformer

operation and electricity rates. The efficiency levels used to define

the conservation cases are based on responses from surveys completed by

manufacturers.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ Total Owning Cost is a capitalized value that permits the

first cost of the transformer to be compared to the lifetime cost.

The capitalized values can be converted to the equivalent discounted

present values of the life-cycle costs by multiplying by the ratio

of the fixed charge rate over the capital recovery factor. This

information can be used to more accurately assess the tradeoffs

between transformer first costs and operating costs, and allow the

purchaser to compare the total costs of transformers with different

energy efficiency levels.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Two peer reviews of the drafts of the report were performed by

ORNL. The ORNL peer review consisted of 22 reviewers, including

representatives of distribution transformer manufacturers, metal

manufacturers, research institutions/laboratories, private as well as

municipal electric utilities, manufacturer associations, metal

associations, and energy conservation groups. After the comments from

stakeholders were incorporated into the draft, the report (ORNL-6847)

was published in July 1996. The information contained in this report

assisted the Department in making this determination on the feasibility

and significance of energy savings for distribution transformers.

In September 1996, shortly after publication of the ORNL report,

the National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) developed and

published a voluntary guide entitled ``Guide for Determining Energy

Efficiency for Distribution Transformers'' (NEMA Standards Publication

TP 1-1996, referred to ``NEMA TP-1'') to help purchasers choose more

efficient distribution transformers. The NEMA TP-1 is intended to give

manufacturers a vehicle to promote the use of high efficiency

transformers and to assist purchasers/users in the selection of energy

efficient transformers. NEMA TP-1 offers a simplified methodology to

help users of utility (liquid-immersed) and commercial/industrial (dry-

type) transformers to understand and calculate the equivalent first

cost of core and load losses. It also offers an alternative method to

users who would rather use tables of minimum efficiencies based on

transformer kVA size, voltage considerations, and type (liquid-immersed

or dry-type).

Subsequently, the Department determined that the initial estimate,

reflected in the initial ORNL report, of the market size for dry-type

transformers was too high. In addition, it was determined that the

effective annual loads for liquid-immersed transformers were also too

high. Consequently, ORNL re-analyzed the energy savings using a more

accurate disaggregated model including data for all types and sizes of

transformers. This data had not been available for the original ORNL

study. Furthermore, the manufacturer that developed the two-year

payback case advised ORNL that the actual payback will likely be

substantially longer than 2 years due to higher than anticipated

manufacturing costs. The two-year payback case was eliminated from the

analysis because of this misestimation of cost and because this case is

no longer necessary due to the addition of the TP-1 case. A description

of the new data and model, ORNL's re-analysis, and an analysis of NEMA

TP-1 are set forth in a second report, entitled ``Supplement to the

`Determination Analysis' (ORNL-6847) and Analysis of the NEMA

Efficiency Standard for Distribution Transformers, ORNL-6925''. The

purpose of this report is to assess NEMA TP-1 along with the options

considered in the determination study, using the more accurate analysis

model and transformer market and loading data developed subsequent to

the publication of the original ORNL report.

Data and comments received from stakeholders during the peer review

of the initial ORNL report have been considered in preparing this

determination and will be more fully considered during all actions

taken by the Department when proceeding with the rulemaking process to

consider conservation standards for distribution transformers. Results

of the energy savings analyses of the ORNL reports will be discussed in

detail in the following sections of this determination notice.

II. Discussion of ORNL Reports

A. Purpose and Content

ORNL assisted the Department by studying the feasibility of

achieving potential energy savings that could result from energy

conservation standards for distribution transformers. The potential

energy savings presented in the ORNL reports are preliminary estimates.

Subsequent analyses will be performed after test procedures are

established. These analyses will involve more exact, detailed

information which will be developed during the standards rulemaking

process, and will cover the effects of energy conservation standards

for distribution transformers.

B. Methodology

The study methodology consisted of four major elements: (1)

Development of a database, (2) development of conservation options, (3)

assessments of the energy conservation options, and (4) incorporation

of feedback from stakeholders. The following is a brief description of

each element:

Database development. Collecting and processing data was a

major part of the study. Data on transformer designs, losses, and sales

were provided by NEMA and individual manufacturers. The Edison Electric

Institute (EEI), the American Public Power Association (APPA), and

selected utilities provided utility user information. The database

includes the results of a survey circulated by EEI and APPA to their

member utilities. User information on dry-type transformers was

provided by the American Institute of Plant Engineers. In addition, the

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's Form 1, Energy Information

Administration data and trade journals were used. The basic information

included historical information on user purchases, and costs and losses

of new transformers for the various options considered in the study.

Information on transformer loading factors was obtained from

discussions with transformer manufacturers, utilities, and surveys of

commercial and industrial users.

Development of energy conservation options. Technically

feasible energy conservation cases for distribution transformers were

based on results of a survey circulated by NEMA, and other information

provided by non-NEMA transformer manufacturers.

Assessments. The technical analysis provided estimates of

appropriate transformer loading factors, losses, and energy savings for

the energy conservation cases.

Stakeholders input. A distribution transformer review

group consisting of manufacturers, users, material suppliers, and

public interest groups was formed to provide data, and to review the

study (see Appendix A of the initial ORNL report). Input from these

stakeholders was incorporated in the report.

Much of the data on losses associated with cost-effective

transformer designs used in this study are from a survey of

[[Page 54813]]

transformers, called the NEMA-ORNL survey, developed by ORNL and

circulated by NEMA to its members and several non-NEMA manufacturers.

Utilities usually request that manufacturers submit bids for the lowest

TOC transformer that they can design by specifying the transformer

features and their A and B factors. The NEMA-ORNL survey took this

approach. It included what were believed to be the most common features

that would be requested for each size and price for the lowest TOC

transformer they could design. The survey requested that manufacturers

reveal the transformer design that had the lowest TOC in terms of core

losses or no load losses (A factor), coil losses or load losses (B

factor), and transformer price. While both A and B factors reflect the

capitalized cost of losses, they differ in their cost per watt rates

for two reasons. First, a watt of core loss represents a continuous

loss that occurs whenever a transformer is energized, which is normally

100 percent of the time for most distribution transformers. This

continuous loss of energy increases the cost per rated watt of core

loss compared with the rated watt of coil loss, which occurs only while

power is drawn through the transformer. The second reason for the

difference in rate for A and B factors is the cost of energy associated

with the losses. Load losses are proportionally higher during peak

periods when the per unit cost of producing electricity is relatively

high.

Three combinations of A and B factors were requested in the survey.

The combinations of A/B factors requested were as follows:

1. A/B=$0/$0, which represents non-evaluated transformers. In the

$0/$0 design, only the first cost is considered, and the price of the

transformer is used as the TOC value (i.e., the value of losses is not

included in the purchase decision). This design was requested in the

survey to establish a baseline efficiency for non-evaluated

distribution transformers.

2. A/B=$3.50/$2.25, with the B factor of $2.25 per watt

representing a transformer with a relatively high average load.

3. A/B=$3.50/$0.75, with the B factor of $0.75 per watt

representing a transformer with a normal to low average load while the

A factor remains fixed at $3.50 per watt.

Twelve transformer sizes--six liquid-immersed and six dry-type--

were surveyed:

Liquid-immersed transformers

1. Single-phase 25-kVA pole-mounted

2. Single-phase 50-kVA pole-mounted

3. Single-phase 50-kVA pad-mounted

4. Three-phase 150-kVA pad-mounted

5. Three-phase 750-kVA pad-mounted

6. Three-phase 2000-kVA pad-mounted

Dry-type transformers

7. Single-phase 1-kVA

8. Single-phase 10-kVA

9. Three-phase 45-kVA

10. Three-phase 1500-kVA

11. Three-phase 2000-kVA

12. Three-phase 2500-kVA

There were 216 transformer designs submitted for the 12 different

types of transformers. Each type had at least three designs for each of

the three A and B combinations. Eight designs for each of the three A

and B combinations were submitted for the liquid-immersed 25-kVA pole,

50-kVA pole, and 50-kVA pad-mounted transformers.

Conservation cases were developed to determine if efficiency

standards are warranted for distribution transformers. These cases were

based on an economic methodology that is widely used by electric

utilities in their purchase of distribution transformers: the TOC

(total owning cost) methodology which considers the life cycle cost of

owning a transformer. It finds the economically optimal tradeoff

between the transformer's capital cost and its operating cost. The TOC

methodology is neutral with respect to the technology and materials

utilized in the transformer. It is a different approach from

conservation based standards that are developed through explicitly

considering energy efficient technologies.

For transformers, the technologies applied to alter the losses, and

hence efficiencies, are very interactive and involve multiple

variables, such as operating current density, flux density, geometric

ratios and electrical insulation. For example, reducing no-load losses

by using lower loss core materials generally requires an alteration of

flux density and core/coil dimensions, which may or may not lower load

losses. Hence, the ORNL reports used the TOC approach to allow for this

interaction of design parameters in an optimal manner.

The TOC approach allows a utility to purchase the optimum

distribution transformer for the particular set of energy costs and

operating characteristics that are anticipated over the transformer's

life. The TOC approach has led to significant increases in utility

transformer efficiencies since it became widespread in the mid-1970's.

Because the methodology is neutral with respect to transformer

technologies and materials, it leads to choosing transformers that take

advantage of any opportunities to economically improve transformer

efficiencies.

The TOC approach was used in developing the conservation cases

discussed in the ORNL reports. The first step in developing these

conservation cases was selection of parameters that define the value of

energy losses over a transformer's life. As previously explained, the

TOC methodology hinges on the development of the A and B factors which

represent the expected lifetime value per watt of a transformer's rated

full load losses using the following formula:

TOC=price+(no-load losses x A)+(load losses x B)

A second key for developing these cases was selection of the low-

TOC designs for the selected A and B values. During a typical

transformer bid process, a buyer submits its required technical

specifications and A and B values to a manufacturer. The manufacturer

considers many transformer designs that meet the buyer's technical

specifications with various load losses, no-load losses, and prices.

From this large number of designs and costs, the manufacturer submits a

selection of very low TOC designs for the buyer's consideration. The

survey of manufacturers requested information on their lowest TOC

designs for the selected A and B factors.

The losses and prices for each transformer manufacturer's lowest

TOC design were used along with the utility surveys to develop the

database. The database was used to develop the conservation cases for

the determination study: The base case, the lowest TOC case, the median

TOC case, the average losses case, and the high-efficiency case. The

base case consisted of data on non-evaluated dry-type transformers and

recent utility purchases of liquid-immersed transformers. The average

losses case was developed by averaging losses from the three lowest TOC

designs for each transformer size and type. A description of the

conservation cases and their weighted efficiencies are presented in

Table 1.

Amorphous-core transformer designs were excluded from two of the

conservation cases, the lowest TOC case and the median TOC case. This

exclusion does not imply that amorphous-core transformers are not

economical for the A and B factors used in the study. Rather the

rationale for excluding the amorphous-core transformers was to develop

moderately high-efficiency cases that do not depend on a particular

technology.

[[Page 54814]]

Table 1.--The Conservation Cases, Plus the NEMA TP-1 Case, Listed in

Order of Weighted Efficiencies

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Case

efficiency

Case Description weighted by

sales a (%)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Base.......................... Existing mix of 98.40

transformers.

NEMA TP-1..................... A voluntary efficiency 98.59

guide.

Median TOC.................... Efficiency of the 98.68

transformer with the

median TOC design

according to a survey

of manufacturers b.

Average losses................ Efficiency corresponding 98.81

to the average full-

load and no-load losses

for the three most cost-

effective transformers

according to a survey

of manufacturers b.

Lowest TOC.................... Efficiency of the most 98.88

cost-effective

transformer according

to a survey of

manufacturers b.

High-efficiency............... Efficiency corresponding 99.21

to highest efficiency

according to a survey

of manufacturers b.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

a The case efficiencies were recalculated by ORNL for this notice and

are also set forth in the supplemental ORNL report.

b Distribution transformer manufacturers were asked to submit their

lowest TOC designs corresponding to economic parameters developed to

represent the nation.

Three of the conservation cases were based on the transformer

manufacturers' minimum TOC designs. Use of different criteria to select

from among the submitted designs provides a range of cost-effective

transformer designs with different efficiencies. Estimates of the

potential energy that could be saved if distribution transformers were

more energy-efficient were developed for the conservation cases. Each

conservation case is based on maximum load and no-load losses for the

12 sizes and types that were used to represent all new transformers by

allocating each design to a range of transformer sizes. This approach

was used because NEMA reports transformer sales in categories that

include a range of transformer sizes. To estimate total annual losses

for each conservation case, the average transformer losses per

kilovolt-ampere were multiplied by the projected kilovolt-amperage of

transformer sales. The energy losses (i.e., energy consumed by the

transformer) for each conservation case were subtracted from the energy

losses for the base case to provide an estimate of annual savings. The

base case defines energy use for existing transformer purchasing

practices. Table 2 represents the possible energy savings results based

on the surveys circulated by NEMA to several NEMA and non-NEMA

transformer manufacturers.

Table 2.--Cumulative Energy Savings for Conservation Cases and NEMA TP-1

a

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Cumulative

savings,

Conservation case by transformer type 2004-2034

(quads)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

NEMA TP-1:

Liquid................................................... 0.39

Dry...................................................... 2.12

Total.................................................... 2.51

Median total owning cost (TOC):

Liquid................................................... 0.95

Dry...................................................... 2.75

Total.................................................... 3.70

Average losses:

Liquid................................................... 1.84

Dry...................................................... 3.58

Total.................................................... 5.42

Lowest TOC:

Liquid................................................... 1.26

Dry...................................................... 5.04

Total.................................................... 6.30

High-efficiency:

Liquid................................................... 5.52

Dry...................................................... 5.18

Total.................................................... 10.70

------------------------------------------------------------------------

a The energy savings were re-calculated by ORNL for this notice and are

also set forth in the supplemental ORNL report; these savings have

been revised downward from those estimated in the initial ORNL report.

The savings per kilovolt-ampere and the projections of estimated

megavolt-amperage of transformer sales have been used to estimate the

rate of savings in the first year and cumulative savings over 30 years

if a conservation standard were enacted. Table 2 assumes that both

utility and non-utility purchases of transformer capacity will grow by

1.2 percent annually, which is consistent with low-to-moderate growth

energy scenarios. Sales of liquid-immersed utility distribution

transformers depend primarily on new housing starts, while gross

private domestic investments provide a good indicator for the growth

rate of the non-utility (dry-type) transformer market. Several comments

during the peer review of the initial ORNL report indicated that higher

growth rates used in the report, such as 2.5% for the dry-type

transformer market, were not realistic for the distribution transformer

industry. The re-analysis on which Tables 1 and 2 are based essentially

accepts these comments.

C. Conservation Cases

1. Base Case

Losses for the base case were estimated from the survey of electric

utilities for evaluated liquid-immersed transformers (i.e., A and B

factors = $0), and from the survey of manufacturers for the non-

evaluated liquid-immersed and dry-type transformers (i.e., A factor =

$3.50, and B factor = $2.75 or $0.75). The percentage of evaluated

transformers was developed from information provided by transformer

manufacturers. The base case non-evaluated transformers were assumed to

have the average losses that were reported for the three lowest-priced

transformers for the $0/$0 evaluation in the NEMA-ORNL survey. It was

assumed that the evaluated transformers for the base case have the same

losses as transformers that have been recently purchased by utilities.

These losses were calculated from the average no-load and load loss

ratings reported in the EEI-ORNL survey. The weighted average

transformer efficiency for the base case was calculated at 98.40

percent.

2. Lowest Total Owning Cost (TOC) Case

The lowest TOC case measures savings resulting from the use of the

lowest TOC non-amorphous transformer design for each of the 12 types of

transformers surveyed in the NEMA-ORNL survey. The potential energy

savings for this conservation case is 6.30 quads over a period of 30

years. Liquid-immersed transformers have a potential to achieve 1.26

quads in energy savings and dry-type transformers 5.04 quads. The

weighted average transformer efficiency for this case was calculated to

be 98.88 percent. The annual energy savings of this case is equivalent

to

[[Page 54815]]

constructing a large coal-fired power plant every four years. Although

the technology required to meet this conservation case is feasible,

some retooling might be required for manufacturers of dry-type

transformers to achieve 5.05 quads of savings over a 30 year period.

The actual amount and expenses required of retooling, if any, will be

determined by performing a manufacturer impact analysis during the

standards rulemaking process.

3. Median Total Owning Cost (TOC) Case

The median TOC case measures savings from the design that

represents the median TOC of all submitted designs for each of the 12

types of transformers surveyed. The potential energy savings of this

conservation case is 3.7 quads over a 30 year period. Liquid-immersed

transformers have a potential to achieve 0.95 quads in energy savings

and dry-type 2.75 quads. The weighted average transformer efficiency

estimated for this case is 98.68 percent. The technology required to

achieve savings at this level is feasible and is currently utilized by

manufacturers of liquid and dry-type transformers. Some retooling might

be required of dry-type manufacturers to meet this particular

conservation case. Further analysis will examine this issue.

4. Average Losses Case

The average losses case measures the average losses for the designs

with the three lowest TOC's for each of the 12 types of transformers

that were evaluated. If high-efficiency amorphous-core designs

qualified as one of the three lowest TOC's, they were included in these

averages. Because this case incorporates the losses from several

designs that were averaged, it better represents the diversity in cost-

effective designs than the other cases. It is more representative of

the transformer market than the cases that are based on selecting a

single design. It should be reiterated that the transformer losses used

to represent the average losses case do not represent the losses of a

specific transformer design. Rather, this case represents an average of

the losses of the three lowest TOC's for transformers submitted for

each category in the survey.

The potential energy savings for this conservation case is 5.42

quads over a 30 year period. Liquid-immersed transformers have a

potential energy savings of 1.84 quads and dry-type transformers 3.58

quads. The weighted average efficiency level of this conservation case

is 98.81 percent. Although the technology required to meet this

conservation case is feasible, retooling might be required for

manufacturers of dry-type transformers to meet 3.58 quads of energy

savings over a 30 year period. The actual amount and expense required

of retooling, if any, will be determined by performing a manufacturer

impact analysis during the standards rulemaking process.

5. High-Efficiency Case

This case included both amorphous and non-amorphous core

transformer designs and is represented by the highest-efficiency design

that was submitted for each of the 12 transformer types surveyed,

regardless of the technology used to achieve that efficiency and

independent of any economic evaluation criteria such as TOC. The

weighted average transformer efficiency for this case is 99.21 percent.

For transformer categories where no amorphous-core designs were

submitted, the most efficient of the non-amorphous designs was

selected.

Although production of amorphous-core transformers may be less

process-intensive (i.e., manufacturing involves a smaller number of

steps) than that of oriented silicon steel transformers, it is very

labor-and materials-intensive. The lack of cost-effective access to

this technology by all manufacturers may present an economic hardship

to both the transformer manufacturers and end users.

Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), General Electric (GE),

and Allied Signal Amorphous Metals hold most of the U.S. patents for

amorphous metal and amorphous technology. The EPRI patents are

available under licensing terms and conditions to U.S. manufacturers.

An important patent on amorphous ribbon manufacturing held solely by

Allied Signal Amorphous Metals will expire this year. However, a

critical patent on magnetic field annealing used during transformer

core manufacturing is held by GE and will not expire until early in the

next century. At present, GE has licensed Allied Signal Amorphous

Metals to sublicense transformer manufacturers to use this patent.

If a standard were set at this conservation case level, the impacts

on existing liquid-immersed transformer manufacturers that do not

produce amorphous core transformers would depend on (1) the ease of

access to the technology, (2) the availability of amorphous core

material, (3) the level of necessary investments, and (4) the higher

transformer selling price. Because the quantity as well as the cost of

raw materials in this case is higher than that of oriented silicon

steel, the price of these transformers is typically 20 to 40 percent

higher than the price of silicon steel transformers. The cost of raw

material for amorphous core transformers is twice that of oriented

silicon steel. These higher costs are due to the use of ferro-boron,

most of which is imported from Japan, China, and the United Kingdom.

The cost of this material has decreased during the past two decades

from $140 per pound in 1978 to about $1.50 per pound now. By

comparison, however, the cost of materials for a non-amorphous core

transformer is considerably lower, ranging from $0.70 to $1.15 per

pound, depending on the grade of the silicon steel. Although this

conservation case is technologically feasible, the increased costs of

retooling and of purchasing amorphous core material as opposed to less

expensive silicon steel appear to be a potential burden to most

manufacturers. Further analysis during the rulemaking process will be

performed to determine the potential costs for manufacturers to meet

this energy conservation level.

This conservation case includes proprietary amorphous-core

technology. Some comments received during the peer review expressed

concern regarding the limited access to amorphous core technology. The

Department recognizes that standards which effectively limit

transformer designs to a particular technology, especially if that

particular technology is proprietary, may have adverse competitive and

consumer impacts, and that such impacts must be carefully considered in

assessing economic justification.

D. Voluntary Programs

1. NEMA TP-1 Guide

In September 1996, NEMA published voluntary guidelines, ``Guide for

Determining Energy Efficiency for Distribution Transformers'' (NEMA TP-

1), to help purchasers choose energy efficient distribution

transformers. Developed by NEMA's Transformer Committee and approved by

participating manufacturers as a means to promote the purchase of high

efficiency transformers, the guide recommends the use of the TOC

methodology to select the most desirable transformer designs and

provides a table of recommended efficiency levels for buyers that do

not wish to use the TOC methodology.

NEMA TP-1 is a significant purchase decision tool. It offers

utility transformer and commercial/industrial transformer users a

simplified method

[[Page 54816]]

for determining the equivalent first cost of transformers with

different efficiency characteristics. This information can be used by

prospective purchasers to more accurately assess the tradeoffs between

transformer first costs and operating costs. For those who choose not

to use this method for analyzing the total operating costs of

transformers, NEMA TP-1 also provides tables of minimum efficiencies

based on transformer kVA size and voltage.

NEMA TP-1's impact on energy savings will depend largely on two

variables: (1) Manufacturer participation and (2) actual buyer/user

purchase decisions. In the supplemental ORNL report, the possible

energy impacts of NEMA TP-1 program were analyzed. ORNL has advised the

Department that the upper bound of energy savings, with full

manufacturer participation and universal acceptance by transformer

purchasers of the minimum efficiency levels recommended in the NEMA TP-

1 tables, would approach 2.51 quads over a 30-year period.

The ORNL analysis concluded that the efficiency levels recommended

in the NEMA TP-1 tables would produce roughly a three year payback. The

Department believes that such efficiency levels would capture the most

cost-effective energy savings, but may not capture substantial energy

savings that appear to be economically justified and technologically

feasible.

2. National Business Awareness Campaign

The National Business Awareness Campaign was developed by NEMA to

increase awareness of the benefits of more energy efficient electrical

products, and to promote purchases of such products. This $1.5 million

campaign, which has been under development for three years, will be

directed at chief executive officers and chief financial officers of

companies that purchase or make electrical products. NEMA is seeking

support for the campaign from energy interest groups, distributors,

energy service companies, and utilities. NEMA is also seeking

partnerships with governmental agencies, such as the Environmental

Protection Agency and the Department of Energy. NEMA plans to launch

its campaign in the June/July time frame of 1997.

The Department seeks to support NEMA's campaign and intends to

monitor its effectiveness in increasing the manufacture and purchase of

more energy efficient electrical products.

III. Conclusion

A. Determination

Based on its analysis of the information now available, the

Department has determined that energy efficiency standards for

transformers appear to be technologically feasible and economically

justified, and are likely to result in significant savings.

Consequently, the Department will initiate the development of energy

efficiency test procedures and standards for electric distribution

transformers.

All energy conservation cases discussed in today's determination

notice are technologically feasible. Data from the ORNL reports clearly

show that current technologies used in the transformer market are

available to all manufacturers. These technologies include increased

use of higher grade silicon steels, copper, aluminum, and amorphous

core materials. The machinery and tools used to produce more energy

efficient transformers also appear to be generally available to

manufacturers.

The cases analyzed in the determination report show that there is a

large potential for energy savings, especially over a 30-year period:

the Lowest TOC case has the potential to save 6.30 quads over a 30-year

period; the Median TOC case could save 3.70 quads; and the High-

Efficiency case could save 10.70 quads. The Lowest and Median TOC cases

also demonstrate that increased efficiency could reduce significantly

the total operating costs incurred by users of transformers, which is a

strong indication that such efficiency levels would be economically

justified. It also appears that these efficiency levels can be achieved

without imposing substantial costs on manufacturers, thus providing

further indication that they are economically justified.

Although all of the cases analyzed are technologically feasible and

have significant energy savings, and at least two of these cases appear

to be economically justified, it is still uncertain whether further

analyses will reconfirm these findings. For example, the Department has

not assessed the potential adverse impacts of a national standard on

manufacturers or individual categories of users. During the course of

the standards rulemaking process, the Department will perform an

analysis of the impact of possible standards on manufacturers, as well

as a more disaggregated assessment of their possible impacts on users.

The Department supports and commends NEMA's initiative to develop

voluntary programs that will promote the manufacture and purchase of

energy efficient distribution transformers. Industry-wide support for

voluntary programs, such as NEMA's TP-1 guide and the National Business

Awareness Campaign, could result in significant energy savings that

might obviate the need for Federal regulatory intervention.

Based on the results of the analyses that have been completed,

however, the Department believes it would be inappropriate to conclude

now that either NEMA TP-1 or the National Business Awareness Campaign

are likely to result in savings sufficient to eliminate the potential

of technologically-feasible and economically-justified national

standards to achieve significant additional energy savings. At this

time, the Department does not share NEMA's view that the NEMA TP-1

program will result in efficiency levels that approach the maximum

technologically feasible and economically justified levels. The

supplemental ORNL report indicated that the potential energy savings of

NEMA's TP-1 program is 2.51 quads over a 30-year period, while the

potential savings from a higher efficiency level that appears to be

both technologically feasible and economically justified exceeds 6

quads over 30 years. Furthermore, based on ORNL's analysis of NEMA TP-

1, it appears that many buyers of electric distribution transformers,

especially in the commercial market (dry-type transformers), are not

likely to participate in NEMA's voluntary TP-1 program, so the actual

savings are likely to be below the 2.51 quads estimated. The Department

will reassess the impact of these voluntary programs during the

rulemaking on standards.

B. Future Proceedings

The Department will begin, therefore, the process of establishing

testing requirements for distribution transformers, which it expects

will result in the publication of a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in

1998. During this rulemaking process, the Department will consider the

draft test procedure currently being developed through a joint effort

of NEMA and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST).

The Department will schedule a public hearing and may also hold

workshops to receive comments in reference to the test procedures.

Publication of a Final Rule containing test procedures is anticipated

during 1999.

The Department will also begin a proceeding to consider

establishment of conservation standards for distribution transformers.

Throughout the

[[Page 54817]]

rulemaking process, the Department intends to adhere to the provisions

of the Interpretive Rule, where applicable. The Department will

continue its review and analysis of the likely effects of NEMA TP-1 and

National Business Awareness Campaign programs during the standards

rulemaking. There will be workshops early in the standards development

process to obtain the views of interested parties on design options,

the conduct of the engineering and life-cycle cost analyses, and the

expertise needed by the Department to perform such analyses. During the

rulemaking process, the Department also intends to reevaluate its

determination that mandatory standards are technologically feasible and

economically justified, and are likely to result in significant energy

savings. For example, the Department anticipates that NEMA will

strengthen its efforts to promote voluntary standards for distribution

transformers and will submit additional data for the Department's

review and analysis. The Department welcomes data demonstrating the

successful market penetration of NEMA TP-1 and/or the National Business

Campaign. If further analyses reveal that standards are not warranted,

DOE will revise this determination and will not proceed to promulgate

standards.

Issued in Washington, D.C., on September 5, 1997.

Joseph J. Romm,

Acting Assistant Secretary, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.

[FR Doc. 97-27948 Filed 10-21-97; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 6450-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.