Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Determination of Endangered Status for Nine Plants From the Grasslands or Mesic Areas of the Central Coast of California

Federal RegisterOct 22, 1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR

Fish and Wildlife Service

50 CFR Part 17

RIN 1018-AD36

Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Determination of

Endangered Status for Nine Plants From the Grasslands or Mesic Areas of

the Central Coast of California

AGENCY: Fish and Wildlife Service, Interior.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) determines

endangered status pursuant to the Endangered Species Act of 1973, as

amended (Act) for nine plants: Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis

(Sonoma alopecurus), Astragalus clarianus (Clara Hunt's milk-vetch),

Carex albida (white sedge), Clarkia imbricata (Vine Hill clarkia),

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense (Pitkin Marsh lily), Plagiobothrys

strictus (Calistoga allocarya), Poa napensis (Napa bluegrass), Sidalcea

oregana ssp. valida (Kenwood Marsh checker-mallow), and Trifolium

amoenum (showy Indian clover). These nine species grow in a variety of

habitats including valley grasslands, meadows, freshwater marshes,

seeps, and blue oak woodlands in Marin, Napa, and Sonoma Counties on

the central coast of California. Habitat loss and degradation,

competition from invasive plant species, elimination through plant

community succession, trampling and herbivory by livestock and

wildlife, collection for horticultural use, and hydrological

alterations to wetland areas threaten the continued existence of these

plants. This rule implements Federal protection and recovery provisions

afforded by the Act for these nine species.

DATES: Effective November 21, 1997.

ADDRESSES: The complete file for this rule is available for public

inspection, by appointment, during normal business hours at the

Sacramento Field Office, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 3310 El Camino

Avenue, Suite 130, Sacramento, California 95821-6340.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Diane Elam or David Wright, Sacramento

Field Office (see ADDRESSES section) (telephone 916/979-2120; facsimile

916/979-2128).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

Populations of the nine plant species in this rule are found in

Sonoma, Marin, and Napa Counties, California. Astragalus clarianus

(Clara Hunt's milk-vetch), Plagiobothrys strictus (Calistoga

allocarya), and Poa napensis (Napa bluegrass) are found up to 70

kilometers (km) (32 miles (mi)) inland in a variety of habitats near

the City of Calistoga in the Napa Valley, California. Alopecurus

aequalis var. sonomensis (Sonoma alopecurus), Carex albida (white

sedge), Clarkia imbricata (Vine Hill clarkia), Lilium pardalinum ssp.

pitkinense (Pitkin Marsh lily), Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida (Kenwood

Marsh checker-mallow), and Trifolium amoenum

[[Page 54792]]

(showy Indian clover) are found in mesic areas mostly within 33 km (15

mi) of the central coast of California. Urbanization, road

construction, airport construction, development of hot springs into

commercial resorts, agricultural land conversion, hydrological

alteration of wetlands, waste disposal, competition with invasive plant

species, collection for horticultural use, or livestock grazing have

eliminated or adversely impacted much of the habitat and have

extirpated numerous populations of these plant species. Historically,

these species have not been known to occur outside of Alameda, Marin,

Mendocino, Napa, Santa Clara, Solano, and Sonoma Counties.

Willis Jepson (1925a) first described Astragalus clarianus in 1909

from specimens collected by Clara Hunt in the Conn Valley near St.

Helena, Napa County, California. Axel Rydberg (1929) and Jepson (1936)

later treated this taxon as Hamosa clariana and Astragalus rattani var.

clarianus, respectively. Rupert Barneby (1950) reestablished Astragalus

clarianus as a full species, a treatment retained by Spellenberg

(1993). Astragalus clarianus is a low-growing annual herb in the pea

family (Fabaceae). It is a slender, sparsely leafed plant, sparingly

covered with sharp, stiff, appressed hairs. The simple single or few

basally branching, stems ascend 7 to 20 centimeters (cm) (3 to 8 inches

(in)) in height. The leaves are alternate, 1.5 to 6.0 cm (0.5 to 2.5

in) long, with 5 to 9 uncrowded leaflets 2 to 10 millimeters (mm) (0.1

to 0.4 in) long. The leaflets are oblong to obovate, narrow at the

base, and notched at the tip. Small flowers appear from March through

April. The petals are bicolored, with the wings whitish and the banner

and keel purple in the upper third. The keel is longer and wider than

the wings. The horizontal to declining seed pods are narrow, linear,

slightly curved, pointed at both ends, and are borne on a 1.5 to 2.5 mm

(0.06 to 0.10 in) long slender stalk. Astragalus rattanii var.

jepsonianus resembles A. clarianus, but grows 10 to 36 cm (4 to 14 in)

tall, has larger flowers, and has seed pods that are not elevated on a

stalk.

Astragalus clarianus is found on thin, rocky clay soils derived

from volcanic or serpentine substrates (Joe Callizo, California Native

Plant Society (CNPS), in litt. 1996; Jake Ruygt, CNPS, Napa Valley

Chapter, pers. comm. 1996, public hearing transcript) in grasslands and

openings in whiteleaf manzanita (Arctostaphylos manzanita)-blue oak

(Quercus douglasii) woodlands (Liston 1990) over an elevation range of

75 to 225 meters (m) (240 to 840 feet (ft)). Six historical occurrences

were known from Napa and Sonoma counties. Two of these occurrences were

extirpated by urbanization and viticulture (California Natural

Diversity Data Base (CNDDB) 1996). Of the remaining four occurrences,

three are found in northwestern Napa County and one occurs in adjacent

Sonoma County. These four disjunct occurrences are restricted to about

28 hectares (ha) (70 acres (ac)) (CNDDB 1996). The trend for Clara

Hunt's milk-vetch is one of decline as a result of habitat destruction

and modification (California Department of Fish and Game (CDFG) 1991).

Extant populations of A. clarianus are variously threatened by

urbanization, recreational activities, airport maintenance, elimination

due to plant community succession, competition from invasive weeds, a

proposed water storage project, and random events. Populations occur on

private, State, and municipal land.

Edward Greene (1892) and Jepson (Abrams ex Jepson 1951) treated

Plagiobothrys strictus as Allocarya stricta and Allocarya californica

var. stricta, respectively, before Ivan Johnston (1923) assigned the

name, Plagiobothrys strictus, to specimens collected on alkaline flats

near sulphur springs at Calistoga, Napa County, California. This

treatment was retained by Messick (1993). Plagiobothrys strictus is a

small, erect, annual herb belonging to the borage family

(Boraginaceae). It grows 1 to 4 decimeters (dm) (4 to 15 in) in height.

The nearly hairless plant has either a single stem or branches from

near the base. The linear lower leaves are 4 to 9 cm (1.5 to 4 in)

long. Small, usually paired, white flowers appear in March to April in

a slender, unbranched inflorescence. The fruit is an egg-shaped nutlet

about 1.5 mm (0.6 in) long, keeled on the back, with wart-like

projections without any prickles. Plagiobothrys greenei, P.

lithocaryus, P. mollis var. vestitus, P. stipitatus, and P. tener have

ranges that overlap with that of Plagiobothrys strictus and occur in

similar habitats, but they do not resemble P. strictus and have not

been found at the known P. strictus sites (J. Callizo, in litt. 1996).

Plagiobothrys strictus is found in pools and swales adjacent to and

fed by hot springs and small geysers in grasslands within an elevation

range of 90 to 160 m (300 to 500 ft). Three historical populations

occurred within a 3 km (2 mi) radius of Calistoga, Napa County,

California. One population was extirpated by urbanization and

agricultural land conversion. Of the two remaining populations of P.

strictus, one occurs near a geyser and some undeveloped thermal hot

springs while the other occurs at the airport in the city of Calistoga.

The combined area of the two remaining populations is less than 80

square meters (m2) (900 square feet (ft2)) (CNPS

1990). The overall trend for Calistoga allocarya (Plagiobothrys

strictus) is one of decline (CDFG 1991). The species is threatened by

recreational activities, airport maintenance, urbanization, and random

events. Both populations are on private land and neither is protected.

Alan Beetle first described Poa napensis in 1946 from specimens

that he collected in a meadow moistened by seepage from hot springs, 3

km (2 mi) north of Calistoga at Myrtledale Hot Springs, Napa County,

California. This treatment was retained by Soreng (1993). Poa napensis

is an erect, tufted perennial bunchgrass in the grass family (Poaceae)

that grows to 1 dm (4 in) in height. Leaves are folded, stiffly erect,

1 mm (0.04 in) wide, with the basal leaves 20 cm (8 in) long and upper

stem leaves to 15 cm (6 in) in length. A few stiff, erect flowering

stems appear in May and grow 7 dm (27 in) in height. Flower clusters

occur as a pale green to purple, condensed, oblong-oval panicle 10 to

15 cm (4 to 6 in) long and 2 to 5 cm (0.8 to 2.0 in) wide. Poa napensis

most closely resembles P. unilateralis (ocean bluff bluegrass), but

differs in leaf and panicle form and habitat.

Poa napensis is found in grasslands and moist, alkaline meadows fed

by hot springs. The elevation range of this plant is 100 to 120 m (340

to 400 ft) within a radius of 6 km (4 mi) of Calistoga. Historically,

the range of this plant has been diminished by the development of

recreational hot springs and the growth of the town of Calistoga. Only

two populations of the species are known to exist, one near Myrtledale

Hot Springs which is restricted to a 100 m2 (1,100

ft2) area, and a second smaller population of 100 plants

nearby (CDFG 1979). Both populations of P. napensis depend on moisture

from adjacent hot springs or surface runoff. Any action that would

alter the hydrology or flow from these hot springs would be detrimental

to these populations (CDFG 1979). The trend for Napa bluegrass is one

of decline (CDFG 1991). Poa napensis is threatened by recreational

activities, airport maintenance, urbanization, and random events (CNPS

1987, 1990; J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993; J. Ruygt, pers. comm. 1996). Both

extant populations are located on private land and are not protected.

Peter Rubtzoff (1961) described Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis

based on a specimen collected in 1955

[[Page 54793]]

in Guerneville Marsh, Sonoma County, California. Specimens assignable

to this taxon were collected as early as 1880 in Sonoma and Marin

counties, but had been identified as Alopecurus aequalis Sobol., a

circumboreal foxtail grass found as far south as adjacent Mendocino

County. These specimens, however, deviated considerably from typical A.

aequalis and were identified by Rubtzoff as A. aequalis var.

sonomensis. Although William Crins (1993) only referred to this variety

in passing in a discussion of the species, its varietal status

adequately reflects its morphological and ecological attributes and it

is considered to be a distinct variety (William Crins, Ontario Ministry

of Natural Resources, in litt. 1993).

Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis is a tufted perennial in the

grass family (Poaceae) that reaches 30 to 75 cm (12 to 30 in) in

height. The stems are mostly erect and either straight or weakly bent

near the base. The leaf blades are up to 7.5 mm (0.3 in) wide. The

panicle is 2.5 to 9.0 cm (1.0 to 3.5 in) long and 4 to 8 mm (0.1 to 0.3

in) wide. The spikelets are usually tinged violet-gray near the tip.

The awn (bristlelike part) is straight, and exceeds the lemma body by

1.0 to 2.5 mm (0.04 to 0.1 in). This variety is distinguished from A.

aequalis var. aequalis by its more robust, upright appearance,

generally wider panicle, violet-gray tinged spikelets, and longer awn

(Rubtzoff 1961; William Crins, Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources,

in litt. 1993).

When the proposed rule was written, Alopecurus aequalis var.

sonomensis was known from five natural populations. Three of the sites,

in Sonoma County, were privately owned, and two sites were on Federal

land within Point Reyes National Seashore (PRNS) in Marin County (CNDDB

1993; Virginia Norris, CNPS, Marin Chapter, in litt. 1993). Three more

natural sites in Marin County have since been identified. Two are on

Federal land within PRNS, and the third is a private inholding within

the PRNS (CNDDB 1996; V. Norris, in litt. 1995; Robert Soost, CNPS,

Marin Chapter, in litt. 1996). One of the newly discovered populations

was initially thought to be the result of seeds washed down from a

reintroduced population, but it is now considered a natural population

(V. Norris, in litt. 1995). All populations occur in moist soils in

permanent freshwater marshes between 6 and 210 m (20 and 680 ft) in

elevation.

Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis was known historically from 16

populations. The historical range of the taxon was approximately 48 km

(30 mi), extending north from Point Reyes Peninsula to Guerneville and

east to Cunningham. Although fewer sites are now present, the range of

the species has changed little. The numbers of populations of this

species are declining due to competition from invasive plant species,

trampling and grazing by cattle, and low reproductive success. Three

attempts to reintroduce the species in the PRNS have failed (CNDDB

1996; V. Norris, in litt. 1995). The proposed rule, published August 2,

1995 (60 FR 39314), stated that one attempt was destroyed by a flash

flood in 1993. It is now thought that the affected population was a

natural population and not a reintroduction. This population

reestablished and contained 15 plants in 1994 and 13 in 1995 (V.

Norris, in litt. 1995).

The number of individuals in populations of Alopecurus aequalis

var. sonomensis may fluctuate markedly between years. The largest

population recorded in recent years was about 600 plants in 1995; this

population dropped to about 100 plants in 1996 (V. Norris, in litt.

1995; R. Soost, in litt. 1996). A population in Sonoma County reported

to have 150 individuals in 1987 had dropped to only 4 plants by 1994

(V. Norris, in litt. 1995). Most often, populations of A. aequalis ssp.

sonomensis have about 100 or fewer individuals (CNDDB 1996).

Liberty Bailey (1889) described Carex albida based on a specimen

collected by John Bigelow in 1854 on Santa Rosa Creek, Sonoma County,

California. Specimens of the plant collected by John T. Howell and John

W. Stacey in 1937 were described as C. sonomensis (Stacey 1937), but

Howell (1957) later stated that the type specimen of C. albida had been

misinterpreted by Stacey and others and that C. sonomensis is a synonym

of C. albida. Howell's interpretation continues to be accepted

(Mastrogiuseppe 1993).

Carex albida is a loosely tufted perennial herb in the sedge family

(Cyperaceae). The stems are triangular, 4 to 6 dm (1.3 to 2.0 ft) tall,

erect, and longer than the leaves. The leaves are flat and 3 to 5 cm (1

to 2 in) wide with closed sheaths. The inflorescence consists of 4 to 7

ovoid or obovoid to oblong spikelets 8 to 18 mm (0.3 to 0.7 in) long.

The achenes (fruits) are three-sided when mature. The sacs (perigynia)

surrounding the achenes are light green to yellow-green when mature and

3.0 to 4.5 mm (0.1 to 0.2 in) long. Several traits distinguish C.

albida from other closely related sedges. Carex albida has

inflorescences with staminate flowers above the pistillate flowers,

especially on the terminal inflorescence, lateral spikelets, and leaves

that are shorter than the stems and 3 to 5 mm (0.1 to 0.2 in) wide.

Some individuals of Carex lemmonii resemble C. albida, but differ in

perigynia and fruit size, or in other respects.

Carex albida was thought to be extinct but is now known from a

single population discovered in 1987. Carex albida was known

historically from four other locations including the type locality on

Santa Rosa Creek and three additional populations in two marshes, all

in Sonoma County. The marsh containing C. albida at the Santa Rosa

Creek site was destroyed in the 1960's by channelization and other

alterations to Santa Rosa Creek (Betty Guggolz, CNPS, Milo Baker

Chapter, in litt. 1993). A second marsh has been used for cannery waste

disposal since 1971, causing the probable loss of the population (CNDDB

1996). At the third marsh, one of the two historical populations has

not been seen since 1951. Access to the other population has been

denied by the landowner, and the presence of the plant has not been

confirmed since 1976. This marsh has become drier in recent years

because the addition of wells and other construction has altered the

marsh hydrology, and it likely no longer supports the species (B.

Guggolz, in litt. 1993).

The only extant population of C. albida is found in a sphagnum bog,

between 45 and 60 m (150 and 200 ft) in elevation. The population

contains about 1,000 plants and occurs on private property in Sonoma

County (CDFG 1993a, CNDDB 1996). Carex albida is threatened by

potential alteration of hydrology from changes in land use or potential

disturbance from a proposed wastewater treatment project, competition

from invasive species, potential disturbance from repair or alteration

of a nearby state highway, and random events.

F. Harlan Lewis and Margaret Lewis (1953) described Clarkia

imbricata from specimens they collected on July 10, 1951, along Vine

Hill Road, Sonoma County. This treatment continues to be accepted

(Lewis 1993). Clarkia imbricata is an erect, annual herb in the

evening-primrose family (Onagraceae). The stems grow to 6 dm (2.5 ft)

tall, unbranched or with numerous short branches in the upper parts.

This plant is densely leafy, with entire, lanceolate leaves 2.0 to 2.5

cm (0.8 to 1.0 in) long and 4 to 7 mm (0.2 to 0.3 in) broad that are

ascending and overlapping. The showy inflorescences appear from June

through July. The flowers are grouped closely together and each flower

has a conspicuous funnel-shaped tube at its base. Each flower has four

fan-shaped, lavender petals 2.0 to 2.5 cm (0.8 to 1.0

[[Page 54794]]

in) long with a V-shaped purple spot extending from the middle to the

upper margin of the petal. Clarkia purpurea ssp. viminea is the only

other Clarkia taxon with which C. imbricata can be confused. Clarkia

purpurea ssp. viminea has a much shorter, funnel-shaped tube and does

not have the relatively broad, ascending, overlapping leaves of C.

imbricata.

Clarkia imbricata has never been known to be common. Unsuccessful

searches for this plant at its type locality have been made since 1974

(B. Guggolz, in litt. 1993). This taxon is only known from two

populations, one natural and one planted in a preserve, found in sandy

grasslands in Sonoma County. The natural population was the source for

cuttings that were transplanted into the 0.6 ha (1.5 ac) preserve in

1974. The two populations are 1.2 km (0.75 mi) apart, have an elevation

range of 60 to 75 m (200 to 250 ft), and occur on private land. The

natural population contains 2,000 to 5,000 plants and occurs on an

open, flat grassland surrounded by a variety of introduced trees and

shrubs. The planted population, located in a preserve owned and managed

by the CNPS, has fluctuated between 200 and 300 plants. Plants have

recently expanded onto an adjacent parcel of private land to the east,

where 70 to 100 plants were found in 1993. The planted population is

threatened by damage associated with trespassers collecting other rare

plants found in the preserve, while the natural population is at risk

due to proposed land use conversion (B. Guggolz, in litt. 1993). Both

populations are also susceptible to adverse impacts from random events.

Lawrence Beane and Albert M. Vollmer first collected Lilium

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense on July 20, 1954, in Sonoma County,

California. Beane (1955) described the plant as Lilium pitkinense. Mark

Skinner (1993) subsequently treated the plant as a subspecies of L.

pardalinum.

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense is an herbaceous, rhizomatous

(underground stem) perennial in the lily family (Liliaceae). The

slender, erect stems reach 1 to 2 m (3 to 6 ft) in height. Leaves are

yellow-green, up to 14 cm (5.5 in) long, and 1 to 2 cm (0.4 to 0.8 in)

wide. The leaves are generally scattered along the stem, but in some

plants occur in 2 or 3 whorls of 3 to 6 leaves near the middle of the

stem. The inflorescence is a terminal raceme. The flowers are large,

showy, and nodding. The petals, which are reflexed from the middle, are

red at the outer edge changing to yellow at the center with small, deep

maroon dots mostly within the yellow zone. Anthers (pollen-bearing part

of the stamen) are purple-brown. The fruit is an elliptical capsule

containing many rounded seeds (CDFG 1993b). The species flowers from

June to July. Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense is distinguished from

L. pardalinum ssp. pardalinum by generally shorter petals and anthers.

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense grows only in permanently

saturated, sandy soils in freshwater marshes and wet meadows that are

35 to 60 m (115 to 200 ft) in elevation. Only three populations of L.

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense at two sites were recorded historically. All

three populations are on private land within a distance of 13 km (8 mi)

in Sonoma County. Access to one of the sites has been denied by the

landowner since 1975 (CNPS 1988a). As a result, the status of this

population has not been confirmed, but it is presumed to be extant. Two

populations occur at a second site. The size of these populations has

declined due to loss of habitat from urbanization and competition with

blackberries (Rubus spp.) (CDFG 1993b). About 300 individual plants

remain on these two sites (B. Guggolz, pers. comm. 1996). Collection of

plants, seeds, and bulbs for horticultural use, competition from

invasive plant species, potential disturbance from a proposed

subdivision, trampling and herbivory by livestock and wildlife and

random events threaten this species (Lynn Lozier, The Nature

Conservancy (TNC), in litt. 1990; CDFG 1993b; B. Guggolz, pers. comm.

1993, 1996).

Edward L. Greene (1897) first described Sidalcea oregana ssp.

valida in June, 1894, based on material he collected from Knight's

Valley, Sonoma County, California. Since then, this taxon has been

known as S. maxima (Baker), S. oregana var. spicata (Jepson), S. eximia

(Baker) and S. spicata ssp. valida (Wiggins) (CNPS 1988b). C. L.

Hitchcock (1957) studied the genus Sidalcea and recognized four

subspecies, including S. oregana ssp. valida, a treatment accepted by

Steven Hill (1993).

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida is a perennial herb in the mallow

family (Malvaceae). The plants are 1 to 2 m (3 to 6 ft) tall. The

leaves are rounded. Lower leaves have 5 to 7 shallow lobes; upper

leaves are generally smaller and divided into 3 to 5 entire, lanceolate

segments. The compound inflorescence consists of densely flowered,

spike-like racemes 2 to 5 cm (0.8 to 2.0 in) long. Petals are 1.0 to

1.5 cm (0.4 to 0.6 in) long, notched at the apex, and deep pink-mauve.

The flowers appear from late June to September. Sidalcea oregana ssp.

valida differs from S. oregana ssp. eximia in having a hairless calyx.

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida has never been recorded as abundant

and only two occurrences are known. These occurrences are about 29 km

(18 mi) apart in Sonoma County, California. Both are on private land.

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida inhabits freshwater marshes approximately

150 m (490 ft) in elevation. One population covers less than 0.1 ha

(0.25 ac), and was reported to have fewer than 100 plants in 1979 (CDFG

1987) and approximately 60 plants in 1993 (Nick Wilcox, State Water

Resources Control Board, pers. comm. 1993). The other population

contained approximately 70 individuals in 1993 (Ann Howald, CDFG, pers.

comm. 1993). Both populations are adversely affected by trampling and

reduced seed set resulting from cattle grazing (CNPS 1988b). The

potential alteration of the hydrology of one site due to urbanization

and water withdrawal poses a threat to the species (A. Howald, pers.

comm. 1993). The plants may also suffer from competition by common tule

(Scirpus acutus) and yellow star-thistle (Centaurea solstitialis), and

from periodic maintenance of a local aqueduct located in the marsh (A.

Howald, pers. comm. 1993). This species is also susceptible to adverse

impacts from random events.

Edward L. Greene (1891) described Trifolium amoenum from specimens

that he collected near Vanden, Solano County, California, in 1890. This

treatment was retained by Duane Isely (1993). Historically, this

species has been found in a variety of habitats including low, wet

swales, grasslands, and grassy hillsides up to 310 m (1,020 ft) in

elevation. This annual plant, which is a member of the pea family

(Fabaceae), is hairy, erect, and grows to 1 to 6 dm (4 to 27 in) in

height. The leaves are pinnately compound, widely obovate, and 2 to 3

cm (0.8 to 1.2 in) long. The flowers, which are purple with white tips,

are 12 to 16 mm (0.5 to 0.6 in) long and occur in dense, round or ovoid

heads, 2 to 3 cm (0.8 to 1.2 in) long. Flowers appear from April to

June. Trifolium amoenum is similar in appearance to T. macraei, but is

generally larger and the flowers lack subtending bracts.

The historical range of Trifolium amoenum was from the western edge

of the Sacramento Valley in Solano County, west and north to Marin and

Sonoma counties, where many sites were presumed extirpated by urban and

agricultural development (CNPS 1977). Until 1993, Trifolium amoenum was

considered extinct. However, one

[[Page 54795]]

locality was discovered in 1993 and a second in 1996. In 1993, Peter

Connors, Bodega Marine Laboratory, discovered a single Trifolium

amoenum plant in Sonoma County. The land on which this plant was found

is private (CNDDB 1996), and at the time of writing of the proposed

rule the land was for sale (Peter Connors, Bodega Marine Laboratory,

pers. comm. 1994). No plants were found at the site in 1994 or 1995,

and the site has now been developed (P. Connors, pers. comm. 1996). The

only known extant population of T. amoenum is that found in 1996. This

population consists of about 200 plants growing on two residential lots

in Marin County. One lot has a house on it, and a house is being built

on the other; both landowners are currently cooperating in the

conservation of the species on their property (P. Connors, pers. comm.

1996).

In 1994, Dr. Connors grew 18 plants in cultivation from seed

produced by the single plant found in 1993 (Connors 1994). These plants

were grown to produce seed for later reintroduction efforts (P.

Connors, pers. comm. 1994); the seed is expected to be viable for

decades (P. Connors, pers. comm. 1996). Should additional T. amoenum be

found, these populations would likely be threatened by urbanization,

competition with invasive plants, land conversion to agriculture,

livestock grazing, and random events.

Previous Federal Action

Federal government actions on these nine species began as a result

of section 12 of the Act which directed the Secretary of the

Smithsonian Institution to prepare a report on those plants considered

to be endangered, threatened, or extinct in the United States. This

report, designated as House Document No. 94-51, was presented to

Congress on January 9, 1975, and included Astragalus clarianus, Carex

albida, Clarkia imbricata, Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense (as L.

pitkinense), Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, and Trifolium

amoenum as endangered and Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida as threatened.

The Service published a notice in the July 1, 1975, Federal Register

(40 FR 27823) of its acceptance of the report of the Smithsonian

Institution as a petition within the context of section 4(c)(2)

(petition provisions are now found in section 4(b)(3) of the Act) and

of its intent to review the status of the plant taxa named therein. The

above eight taxa were included in the July 1, 1975, notice. On June 16,

1976, the Service published a proposal in the Federal Register (41 FR

24523) to determine approximately 1,700 vascular plant species to be

endangered species pursuant to section 4 of the Act. The list of 1,700

plant taxa was assembled on the basis of comments and data received by

the Smithsonian Institution and the Service in response to House

Document No. 94-51 and the July 1, 1975, Federal Register publication.

Astragalus clarianus, Carex albida, Clarkia imbricata, Lilium

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, Poa napensis, and Trifolium amoenum were

included in the June 16, 1976, Federal Register document.

General comments received in relation to the 1976 proposal were

summarized in an April 26, 1978, Federal Register publication (43 FR

17909). The Endangered Species Act Amendments of 1978 required that all

proposals over 2 years old be withdrawn. A 1-year grace period was

given to those proposals already more than 2 years old. In the December

10, 1979, Federal Register (44 FR 70796), the Service published a

notice of withdrawal of the June 16, 1976, proposal, along with four

other proposals that had expired.

The Service published a Notice of Review for plants in the Federal

Register on December 15, 1980 (45 FR 82480). This notice included

Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis, Astragalus clarianus, Carex

albida, Clarkia imbricata, Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense,

Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida, and

Trifolium amoenum as a Candidate species. On November 28, 1983, the

Service published a supplement to the Notice of Review (48 FR 53640).

This supplement changed Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis, Astragalus

clarianus, Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, Sidalcea oregana ssp.

valida, and Trifolium amoenum to category 2. At that time, category 2

taxa were those being considered for possible addition to the Federal

List of Endangered and Threatened Wildlife. Designation of category 2

species was discontinued in the February 28, 1996, Federal Register

notice (61 FR 7596).

The plant notice was revised again on September 27, 1985 (50 FR

39526). The candidate status of eight of the plant species remained

unchanged in this notice. Trifolium amoenum was indicated as being

possibly extinct. Another revision of the plant notice was published on

February 21, 1990 (55 FR 6184). In this revision, Astragalus clarianus,

Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, and Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida

were designated as Candidates. The Service made no changes to the

status of any of the nine species in the plant notice published on

September 30, 1993 (58 FR 51144). The Service approved Candidate status

for Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis on August 26, 1993. However,

the status change was inadvertently not published in the plant notice

published on September 30, 1993. After the publication of that notice,

the Service received information that Trifolium amoenum had been

rediscovered (Connors 1994).

In the August 2, 1995, Federal Register, the Service published a

proposed rule to list the nine plant species as endangered, and invited

public comment (60 FR 39314). Processing of the proposed rule was

delayed by a congressional moratorium on activities associated with

final listings from April 10, 1995, through April 26, 1996. After the

moratorium was lifted, the Service reopened the comment period and

scheduled a public hearing on September 11, 1996 (61 FR 47856).

Section 4(b)(3)(B) of the Act requires the Secretary to make

findings on pending petitions within 12 months of their receipt.

Section 2(b)(1) of the 1982 amendments further requires that all

petitions pending on October 13, 1982, be treated as having been newly

submitted on that date. This was the case for Astragalus clarianus,

Carex albida, Clarkia imbricata, Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense,

Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida, and

Trifolium amoenum because the 1975 Smithsonian report had been accepted

as a petition. The Service found that the petitioned listing of those

eight species was warranted but precluded by other higher priority

listing actions. This finding was reviewed annually in October from

1983 through 1994. Publication of the proposed rule on August 2, 1995

(60 FR 39314), constituted the final finding for the petitioned action

for these species.

The processing of this final listing rule conforms with the

Service's final listing priority guidance made final on December 5,

1996 (61 FR 64475). The guidance clarifies the order in which the

Service will process rulemakings following two related events, the

lifting, on April 26, 1996, of the moratorium on final listings imposed

on April 10, 1995 (Pub. L. 104-6) and the restoration of significant

funding for listing through passage of the omnibus budget

reconciliation law on April 26, 1996, following severe funding

constraints imposed by a number of continuing resolutions between

November 1995 and April 1996. The guidance calls for giving highest

priority to handling

[[Page 54796]]

emergency situations (Tier 1) and second highest priority (Tier 2) to

resolving the status of proposed listings. A lower priority is assigned

to resolving the conservation status of candidate species and

processing administrative findings on petitions to add species to the

lists or reclassify species from threatened to endangered status (Tier

3). The lowest priority actions are in Tier 4, a category which

includes processing critical habitat determinations, delistings, or

other types of reclassifications. Processing of this final rule is Tier

2 action.

Summary of Comments and Recommendations

In the August 2, 1995, proposed rule and associated notifications,

all interested parties were requested to submit factual reports or

information that would contribute to the development of a final

determination on the proposed listing. A 65-day comment period closed

on October 9, 1995. Appropriate Federal and State agencies, county and

city governments, scientists, and interested parties were contacted and

requested to comment. The Service published notices in the Marin

Independent Journal, Mill Valley Pacific Sun, Santa Rosa Press

Democrat, Ross Valley Reporter, San Francisco Chronicle and San

Francisco Examiner on August 9, 1995, in the Napa Register on August

10, 1995, and in the Napa County Record and Petaluma Argus-Courier on

August 11, 1995, inviting general public comment. In response to the

publication of the proposed rule, the Sonoma County Farm Bureau, Santa

Rosa, California, requested a public hearing in one of 2 letters each

dated August 28, 1995.

Following the lifting of the listing moratorium, the comment period

was reopened on September 11, 1996, for 35 days, closing on October 15,

1996. Upon the reopening of the comment period, the Service again

contacted interested parties, and published notices--in the Petaluma

Argus-Courier on September 17, 1996, in the Marin Scope and Mill Valley

Pacific Sun on September 18, 1996, and in the Marin Independent

Journal, Napa Register, and Santa Rosa Press Democrat on September 19,

1996--inviting general public comment and announcing the scheduling of

a public hearing. A public hearing was held at the Best Western Novato

Oaks Inn in Novato, California, on October 3, 1996. The hearing was

attended by approximately 20 people, of whom nine presented oral or

written testimony.

In accordance with Service peer review policy published on July 1,

1994, (59 FR 34270), the Service sent copies of the proposed rule to

one ecologist who works for a university, two plant ecologists who work

for State agencies, eight university professors who are species

experts, and six other species experts. The Service received one

response, from a species expert. The comments received in this response

did not contain any new information substantive to the listing

determination. The remaining reviewers did not respond to the Service.

In total, 24 individuals, groups, or agencies submitted comments,

including the California Department of Parks and Recreation, the

California Native Plant Society (CNPS), the Marin and the Sonoma County

Farm Bureaus, the California Cattlemen's Association, and the

Washington Legal Foundation. Several individuals commented more than

once. Nine commenters supported the proposed action, eight opposed it

or expressed reservations, and seven did not state a position. Several

commenters provided corrections or updated information regarding one or

more of the species proposed for listing. The Service has incorporated

into the final rule any verifiable new information that is substantive

to the listing decision.

Written comments and oral statements presented at the public

hearing and received during the comment periods are addressed in the

following summary. Comments of a similar nature are grouped together

into general issues. These issues and the Service's responses are

presented below.

Issue 1: Several commenters expressed concern that listing the

plants would adversely affect the economies of Marin, Sonoma, and Napa

counties, or requested the Service to consider possible economic

impacts.

Service Response: Under section 4(b)(1)(A), a listing determination

must be based solely on the best scientific and commercial data

available. The legislative history of this provision clearly states the

intent of Congress to ``ensure'' that listing decisions are ``based

solely on biological criteria and to prevent non-biological

considerations from affecting such decisions,'' H. R. Rep. No. 97-835,

97th Cong. 2d Sess. 19 (1982). As further stated in the legislative

history, ``Applying economic criteria * * * to any phase of the species

listing process is applying economics to the determinations made under

section 4 of the Act and is specifically rejected by the inclusion of

the word `solely' in this legislation,'' H.R. Rep. No. 97-835, 97th

Cong. 2d Sess. 19 (1982). Because the Service is precluded from

considering economic impacts in a final decision on a proposed listing,

the Service has not examined such impacts.

Issue 2: One commenter stated that the Service must complete a

Taking Implications Assessment, as directed by Presidential Executive

Order 12630, before issuing a final rule.

Service Response: The Attorney General has issued guidelines to the

Department of the Interior (Department) on implementing Executive Order

12630: Governmental Actions and Interference with Constitutionally

Protected Property Rights. Under these guidelines, a special rule

applies when an agency within the Department is required by law to act

without exercising its usual discretion, that is, to act solely upon

specified criteria that leave the agency no choice. In the present

context, the Service's action might be subject to legal challenge if it

considered or acted upon economic information in reaching a listing

decision.

In such cases, the Attorney General's guidelines state that Taking

Implications Assessments (TIAs) shall be prepared after, rather than

before, the agency makes the decision in which its discretion is

restricted. The purpose of the TIAs in these special circumstances is

to inform policy makers of areas where unavoidable taking exposures

exist. Such TIAs must not be considered in the making of administrative

decisions that must, by law, be made without regard to their economic

impact. In enacting the Act, Congress required that listings be based

solely on scientific and commercial data showing whether or not the

species are in danger of extinction. Thus, by law and by U.S. Attorney

General guidelines, the Service is forbidden to conduct TIAs prior to

listing.

Issue 3: Several commenters expressed concern that farmers and

ranchers would be restricted in their everyday operations by listing of

the nine plant species. One worried that farmers and ranchers would be

subject to criminal prosecution for the accidental taking of these

plants. Another suggested that compensation should be provided for land

taken out of range production.

Service Response: The Act does not restrict the taking of listed

plants due to otherwise lawful private activities on private land.

Listing the nine plants as endangered will not regulate farming or

ranching operations, including cattle grazing, on private land. Other

activities that do not violate the taking prohibitions of section

9(a)(2) of the Act are discussed further under ``Conservation

Measures.''

[[Page 54797]]

Issue 4: Several commenters, including representatives of the

California Cattlemen's Association, Sonoma-Marin Cattlemen's

Association, and the Marin County Farm Bureau, stated that grazing is

likely to be beneficial to the nine plant species, both as a land use

alternative to urbanization and other land uses, and in reducing

competition from other plant species, notably nonnative grasses. One

commenter stated that there is no verifiable evidence of a relationship

between grazing and these plants. Another said that because there is

public debate about the effects of grazing on land and vegetation,

little scientific basis exists for claims that grazing is a threat. One

commenter asserted that the Service has a strong bias against all

grazing.

Service Response: Some degree of grazing by cattle and other

animals is likely to be beneficial to some or all of the nine plant

species addressed in this rule. Evidence that heavy grazing is a threat

to some of the species, however, is discussed under Factor C. The

Service is not opposed to grazing, and maintains that best grazing

management practices are compatible with many natural resource

objectives.

Issue 5: Two commenters believed that listing would allow the

Service or the California Department of Fish and Game to intrude upon

private property to search for the listed plants.

Service Response: Listing will have no such effect. The Act does

not give any person or government agency the right to trespass.

Issue 6: Several commenters requested an extension of the comment

period beyond the second deadline of October 15, 1996. One member of

the Marin County Farm Bureau stated that their organization had not had

adequate time to notify their membership of the public hearing

regarding the proposed rule. Other commenters requested additional

hearings at more convenient places and times.

Service Response: The Service believes that the comment period

provided was adequate. The beginning of this section reviews the

Service's efforts to notify the public of the proposed rule regarding

these nine plants. In addition to publication in the Federal Register

and public notices appearing in several local and regional newspapers,

the Service mailed separate notifications of the public hearing to

species experts, other individuals, and Federal, State, and county

entities, including the Marin County Farm Bureau, on September 17,

1996. The location and time of the public hearing was selected to be

convenient to most citizens living around populations of the proposed

plant species.

Issue 7: One commenter, noting certain errors in the proposed rule

and in a Service press release on the proposed listing, requested an

additional public hearing after corrections had been made.

Service Response: One purpose of the public comment period is to

seek feedback on the accuracy of the information in the proposed rule;

correction of errors in the rule does not mandate the re-opening of

public comment. The inaccurate information in the Service's press

release dealt only with consequences of any listing, not with

information or procedures relevant to this listing determination.

Issue 8: One commenter questioned whether all appropriate public

land has been surveyed for the nine plant species, and whether the

species can truly be listed as threatened by extinction without such

surveys. She requested that the listing decision be postponed and the

comment period be extended until such surveys have been conducted.

Another commenter asserted that the Service lacks data supporting the

likelihood of the purported threats to the species, and that the

Service has discussed threats that do not exist. As examples, the

commenter stated that the water level of Lake Hennessey has not been

raised such that it completely inundates a population of Astragalus

clarianus and that Carex albida is not grazed, yet the Service

considers these threats.

Service Response: The Act requires the Service to reach its

decision based on the best scientific and commercial information

available. The Service believes that botanical study of the appropriate

habitats on public and private lands in Marin, Napa, Sonoma, and nearby

counties has been adequate to show that the nine plants are indeed

extremely rare. The threats to the species discussed under Summary of

Factors Affecting the Species are also based on the best information

available, and are well documented or reasonably foreseeable. With

respect to the assertion that the Service has identified threats that

do not exist, threats, by general definition, are descriptions of

events that have not yet taken place but that are likely to occur in

the foreseeable future.

Issue 9: One commenter argued it would be safer to engage in

conservation actions without listing the nine plants, since listing

could provoke malicious damage.

Service Response: Factor D presents information about the

inadequacy of existing protections for the nine plant species.

Additional protections that they will receive as a result of listing

are discussed under Available Conservation Measures. The Service

believes that listing these nine species as endangered under the Act

will significantly reduce the threats to their continued existence.

Although real, the Service considers the risk of malicious damage to

most of these plants to be relatively small, especially for the species

that are inconspicuous. The degree of risk, however, will increase

significantly if precise maps of the locations of these species were

published. This aspect is discussed further in the Critical Habitat

section.

Issue 10: One commenter asserted that the Service has not given

proper consideration to data provided by ranchers and other landowners,

and that the Service gives much more weight to the information provided

by California Native Plant Society volunteers. He further stated that

references to grazing impacts in reports to the Natural Diversity

Database maintained by the California Department of Fish and Game are

inaccurate and biased and that the volunteers who submit these reports

lack experience in range management or livestock behavior.

Service Response: The Service considers all information received

from all sources. No group's or individual's information receives

``more weight'' than others. Information received from all sources was

carefully evaluated in accordance with Service policy on information

standards under the Act, published on July 1, 1994 (59 FR 34271).

Criteria for what information may be considered are discussed in the

Summary of Factors Affecting the Species, and in the response to Issue

1. The Service has checked all substantive information for accuracy,

and believes that the information included in this rule is reliable and

credible and represents the best scientific and commercial information

available.

Issue 11: One commenter, representing the California Cattlemen's

Association, commented that it is very unlikely that grazing is a

threat to Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, in part because livestock

prefer dry areas to the bogs and marshes in which this plant grows.

Service Response: Although cattle prefer dryer areas, they will

enter and graze such wet areas, especially if forage in the surrounding

dry areas is less attractive. Evidence of cattle and other herbivores

grazing on Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, is discussed under Factor

C.

[[Page 54798]]

Issue 12: One commenter suggested that the nine plants may be

naturally rare, and may nevertheless be thriving.

Service Response: Decisions on listing plants and animals are based

on the threats facing the species. A species may be determined to be

endangered or threatened due to one or more of the five factors

described in section 4(a)(1) of the Act. Evidence that the nine plants

are in danger of extinction in all or significant portions of their

ranges is discussed under Summary of Factors Affecting the Species.

Issue 13: One commenter noted that the proposed rule claimed that

habitat for Trifolium amoenum has been lost due to livestock grazing

and called for the Service to recognize that livestock grazing does not

permanently alter the landscape.

Service Response: The final rule has been changed to clarify that

proper grazing generally does not cause permanent habitat loss.

Issue 14: Two commenters suggested that the observation in the

proposed rule that a fenced population of Lilium pardalinum ssp.

pitkinense continued to suffer from herbivory demonstrating that

something other than domestic livestock is causing the damage.

Service Response: The Service maintains that domestic livestock as

well as other vertebrate and invertebrate herbivores are capable of

damaging these plants (see Factor C and response to Issue 11).

Issue 15: One commenter said that Alopecurus aequalis var.

sonomensis and Trifolium amoenum might prove to have agricultural

value, since both are palatable to cattle. Alopecurus aequalis var.

sonomensis appears tolerant of some grazing, and T. amoenum might renew

soil fertility and provide valuable forage if it could be grown in

sufficient quantity. The commenter speculated that these species could

be seeded to improve pastures.

Service Response: The Service will evaluate these points as it

plans and implements the recovery of these species.

Issue 16: One commenter argued that passive preservation of

individual species is ecologically unsound and will not ultimately

protect biodiversity.

Service Response: The Service notes that habitat protection helps

conserve other species with similar habitat needs contributing to the

biodiversity of the ecosystem. Some species require active management

and the Service will address this in the recovery plan.

Issue 17: One commenter asserted that policies calling for the

removal of nonnative species are based on outdated science, that

nonnative plants have increased the biodiversity of California's annual

grasslands and that these alien species do not threaten the ecological

community of grasslands.

Service Response: The Service has extensive information and has

received a large number of comments from farmers, ranchers, and

scientists, indicating that competition from invasive plants, mostly of

nonnative origin, has played a major role in the decline of several of

the nine plant species and is a continuing and serious threat to most

of them. This information is summarized under Factor E.

Issue 18: One commenter stated that, under the National

Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the Service must prepare an

Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for this rule.

Service Response: For the reasons set out in the NEPA section of

this document, the Service has determined that the rules issued under

section 4(a) of the Act do not require the preparation of an EIS.

Courts in Pacific Legal Foundation v. Andrus, 657 F.2d 829 (6th Circuit

1981), held that an EIS is not required for listing under the Act. The

Sixth Circuit decision noted that preparing an EIS on listing actions

does not further the goals of NEPA or the Act.

Issue 19: One commenter urged the Service, in the event of listing,

to designate critical habitat for the nine plant species with a

consideration of economic impacts of such designation required by law.

Service Response: The Service has determined that the designation

of critical habitat for these nine plant species is not prudent. Please

refer to the ``Critical Habitat'' section of this rule for a detailed

discussion of the critical habitat determination.

Summary of Factors Affecting the Species

After a thorough review and consideration of all information

available, the Service has determined that Alopecurus aequalis Sobol.

var. sonomensis Rubtzoff (Sonoma alopecurus), Astragalus clarianus

Jepson (Clara Hunt's milk-vetch), Carex albida Bailey (white sedge),

Clarkia imbricata Lewis and Lewis (Vine Hill clarkia), Lilium

pardalinum Kellogg. ssp. pitkinense (Beane and Vollmer) M. Skinner

(Pitkin Marsh lily), Plagiobothrys strictus (Greene) I.M. Johnston

(Calistoga allocarya), Poa napensis Beetle (Napa bluegrass), Sidalcea

oregana (Nutt.) Gray ssp. valida (Greene) C.L. Hitchcock (Kenwood Marsh

checker-mallow), and Trifolium amoenum Greene (showy Indian clover)

should be classified as endangered species. The Service followed

procedures found at section 4(a)(1) of the Act and regulations

implementing the listing provisions of the Act (50 CFR part 424) in

reaching this determination. A species may be determined to be

endangered or threatened due to one or more of the five factors

described in section 4(a)(1). These factors and their application to

the nine species are as follows:

A. The present or threatened destruction, modification, or

curtailment of their habitat or range. Habitat destruction and

modification due to urbanization, land use changes, or alterations in

hydrology pose the most serious threats to the survival of these nine

plant species.

Astragalus clarianus is known currently from three populations in

Napa County and one population in Sonoma County (CNPS 1989, CNDDB

1996). The four populations face a variety of threats to their

continued existence. One population in Napa County was reduced in size

when the creation of Lake Hennessey in the 1950's inundated much of the

site (L. Lozier, pers. comm. 1993). The City of Napa owns the lake and

uses Lake Hennessey as a water source. Recently, the City of Napa

conducted a feasibility study on the raising in elevation of the dam as

part of a project to increase water storage for the city. This would

have raised the lake level and submerged the remnant population of A.

clarianus (J. Ruygt, CNPS, in litt. 1993). This increased water-storage

project at Lake Hennessey is currently considered too costly (Don

Ridenhour, Public Works Dept., City of Napa, pers. comm. 1993).

However, any future water storage project that would involve increasing

the height of the dam and raising the level of Lake Hennessey would

constitute a threat to the population of A. clarianus that lies along

the lakeshore. In December 1990, this remnant population was nearly

destroyed when dredge spoils from the lake were placed on top of it (A.

Howald, pers. comm. 1993). The City of Napa, in cooperation with CDFG,

removed most of the dredge spoils and fenced the 1 ha (2 ac) area,

placing a gate in the fence for fishing access to the lake. Ground

disturbance caused by dredge spoil removal resulted in proliferation of

invasive weeds that further threaten the site, as discussed below under

Factor E. The population has not recovered well (J. Ruygt, pers. comm.

1996). Eight plants of A. clarianus were counted at this site in 1991,

325 plants in 1992, 156 plants in 1993 (CDFG 1989; J. Ruygt, in litt.

1993), 9 plants in 1994 (CNDDB 1996), and 15 plants in 1996 (J. Ruygt,

pers. comm.

[[Page 54799]]

1996, public hearing transcript). The area remains a favorite fishing

access to the lake and receives significant use by the public (CDFG

1989). The City of Napa has repaired damage to the fence several times

(A. Howald, pers. comm. 1993).

Another population of Astragalus clarianus occurs in Bothe Napa

Valley State Park. Plant numbers have been reported as 8 plants in

1988, 220 plants in 1992, 101 plants in 1993, and 39 plants in 1996 on

a 1 ha (2 ac) monitoring site (J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993, pers. comm.

1996, public hearing transcript). The larger portion of the population

of A. clarianus outside of the monitoring zone occurs sparsely on a 6

ha (15 ac) area. This area has been partially protected by placing

brush piles next to a foot trail to divert people away from the

population (William Grummer, Bothe Napa Valley State Park, California

Dept. of Parks and Recreation, pers. comm. 1993). The general plan for

the park indicates a campground to be placed over the larger portion of

A. clarianus, but the Service does not consider the proposed action in

this plan as an imminent threat because of lack of funding and possible

revisions to the park plan (W. Grummer, pers. comm. 1993). At present,

no specific plans to develop a campground have been made (W. Grummer,

pers. comm. 1996). Although the campground development may be relocated

away from the population of A. clarianus, the Service considers that

increased recreational use from an additional campground in this park

constitutes a potential threat.

The third population of Astragalus clarianus occurs near the City

of Santa Rosa in eastern Sonoma County. This population was estimated

at 2,100 plants in 1996 scattered over 6 ha (15 ac) and appears stable

at the present time (Saxon Holt, CNPS, Milo Baker Chapter, pers. comm.

1996). It is on private land under a voluntary protection agreement

with TNC. Upslope and adjacent to this population is the 454 ha (1,350

ac) approved Saddle Mountain subdivision (J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993, S.

Holt, pers. comm. 1996). Soil erosion from proposed road and pad

construction for house lots potentially threatens this population of A.

clarianus (J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993). Construction of this development

has not yet begun (S. Holt, pers. comm. 1996).

The fourth population of Astragalus clarianus consisted of 2,238

plants in 1993 scattered over less than 2 ha (5 ac) of private land (J.

Ruygt, in litt. 1993). Feral pigs uprooted a substantial number of

plants during 1994; the number of plants at this site has declined in

1995 and 1996, although this decline may be attributable to factors

other than damage by pigs (J. Ruygt, pers. comm. 1996, public hearing

transcript).

One historical occurrence and over 70 percent of the original

habitat of Plagiobothrys strictus have been extirpated by urbanization

and conversion of land to vineyards (CNPS 1990). The two remaining

populations of P. strictus are threatened by urbanization (CNDDB 1996,

CNPS 1990). One of these populations occurs at the Calistoga Airport,

where about 5,000 plants were counted in an area of about 180 m\2\

(2,000 ft\2\) in 1994 (J. Ruygt, pers. comm. 1996, public hearing

transcript). The number of individuals in this population fluctuates

considerably, perhaps due to variations in spring rainfall between

years (CDFG 1988). Future development at this site could threaten this

population (J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993), as could airport maintenance

activities (J. Ruygt, pers. comm. 1996). The other population of P.

strictus is scattered over a 4 ha (10 ac) area bisected by an asphalt

road on private land near Myrtledale Hot Springs in the City of

Calistoga. The number of individuals in this population was estimated

to be in the hundreds (J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993). In recent years, the

landowner has denied access to the site. The landowner has proposed to

build a hospital on this site, but has been unsuccessful due to current

zoning status (CDFG 1988; J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993; J. Ruygt, pers.

comm. 1996).

Historically, the habitat of the two remaining populations of Poa

napensis has been reduced by the development of health spas and resorts

in the City of Calistoga and other construction activities at the

Calistoga Airport (CNPS 1989). The remnant population of P. napensis at

the Calistoga Airport was thought to be extirpated as a result of

construction activities in 1981 because no plants were found that year.

By 1987, however, 500 plants were counted at the airport location (CDFG

1989; J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993). In 1994 and 1996, about 150 plants were

counted at the airport site (J. Ruygt, pers. comm. 1996). The only

other population is near Myrtledale Hot Springs in the City of

Calistoga, where several thousand plants were reported in a 100 m\2\

(1,100 ft\2\) area in the early 1980's. The landowner has denied access

to the property in recent years. Because Poa napensis and Plagiobothrys

strictus occur at both the Calistoga Airport site and the other site

near Myrtledale Hot Springs, the threats from urbanization, including

construction of a hospital, are the same for both species (CNPS 1987,

1990; J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993; J. Ruygt, pers. comm. 1996).

The single known population of Carex albida is located

approximately 46 m (150 ft) from a State highway in a sphagnum bog. Any

direct impact or change in the hydrology of the area resulting from

highway widening or maintenance, or a change in land use would

adversely affect the population. Draining the wetland would not only

directly impact the species but would encourage the spread of

blackberries (Rubus spp.), which have become dominant in other parts of

the marsh that have been drained (CDFG 1993a; CNDDB 1996; B. Guggolz,

in litt. 1993).

When the proposed rule was written, a wastewater treatment project

was proposed to be built 300 m (328 yards) from the Carex albida

population. Potential impacts from this project, as originally

proposed, included adverse effects from the application of recycled

wastewater and the temporary or permanent removal of wetlands, riparian

vegetation, and special status plants and their habitats (Environmental

Science Associates 1993). The treatment plant has now been constructed,

but the use of recycled wastewater has not been implemented (B.

Guggolz, pers. comm. 1996). If implemented, from 1,200 to 4,900 cubic m

(1 to 4 ac-ft) of wastewater per year would be applied on approximately

14 to 27 ha (35 to 60 ac) of land. Although the population of C. albida

would not be directly impacted, the application of this volume of

wastewater could result in the alteration of remaining habitat within

the historical range of C. albida through modification of surface

hydrology (Environmental Science Associates 1993). The historical

ranges of Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense and Alopecurus aequalis

var. sonomensis also occur within the project boundaries.

The type locality of Clarkia imbricata along the roadside at Pitkin

Ranch was extirpated prior to 1974, as a probable result of changes in

land use or roadside maintenance (B. Guggolz, in litt. 1993). Another

population of C. imbricata in Sonoma County was extirpated as a result

of tree farming and weed control activities (B. Guggolz, in litt.

1993). The sole remaining natural population of C. imbricata is

threatened by changing land use, such as conversion to agriculture, and

inadvertent mowing of its habitat (B. Guggolz, in litt. 1993; B.

Guggolz, pers. comm. 1996).

One site with two populations of Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense

was largely destroyed by urbanization in 1961; however, approximately

300 plants remain at this site (CDFG 1993b;

[[Page 54800]]

B. Guggolz, pers. comm. 1996). Although a subdivision is planned for

the area surrounding a portion of this site, the landowner agreed to

protect a portion of the habitat of L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense

(Allan Buckmann, CDFG, in litt. 1993; B. Guggolz, pers. comm. 1996).

This agreement, if implemented, would place all sensitive natural

resource areas in a conservation easement for long-term management,

with CDFG as easement holder (A. Buckmann, in litt. 1993). Neither this

easement, however, nor another easement that would protect the other

population of L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense at this site, has been

executed and recorded (B. Guggolz, pers. comm. 1996). At the second

site, wetland fills in the marsh have lowered the water table and

resulted in drier soil conditions, which have negatively affected L.

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense. This change in habitat quality is

considered a significant threat to the population (CDFG 1993b), since

only about 10 plants remain at this site (CNDDB 1996; B. Guggolz, pers.

comm. 1996).

One of the two remaining sites of Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida is

threatened by permitted and unauthorized water diversions from a stream

that flows into the marsh where two subpopulations of the species

occur. In the past, these diversions have removed all water from the

stream channel, eliminating a source of surface water to the marsh (A.

Howald, pers. comm. 1993). Plant census data from 1991 indicate that

the eastern and western subpopulations in the marsh declined by

approximately 40 and 30 percent, respectively, compared to 1989 and

1990 data. These figures suggest that this population may have been

experiencing a delayed response to a drought period that began in the

late 1980's. The adverse effects of future droughts may be exacerbated

by increased surface water diversions and result in a further decline,

or extinction of the species (John Turner, CDFG, in litt. 1993).

Trifolium amoenum was known from about 20 historical occurrences in

7 counties (Skinner and Pavlik 1994; CNDDB 1996). Loss of this habitat

resulted primarily from urbanization and land conversion to agriculture

(CNPS, 1977; Corelli and Chandik 1995). Two occurrences of T. amoenum

have been recently discovered. The occurrence found in 1993 in Sonoma

County consisted of a single plant located on private property that has

subsequently been developed. The second, a population of about 200

plants, is found on two residential lots in Marin County (P. Connors,

pers. comm 1996). If this property is further developed or altered, it

may no longer contain suitable habitat for T. amoenum. Widespread

urbanization has occurred, and continues to occur, throughout the

historic range of the species. The populations of Sonoma and Marin

counties are expected to grow by 11.1 and 10.4 percent, respectively,

by the year 2000 (California Department of Finance 1993, 1996).

B. Overutilization for commercial, recreational, scientific, or

educational purposes. One of the remaining populations of Lilium

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense has been nearly extirpated by uncontrolled

collection of plants, seeds, and bulbs for horticultural use. This

species was abundant historically at this site, but the removal of

plants and bulbs for horticultural use reduced this population to two

plants by 1993 (CDFG 1993b). This population of L. pardalinum ssp.

pitkinense has since expanded slightly to approximately 10 plants (B.

Guggolz, pers. comm. 1996). Similar activities at the remaining site,

which contains only 300 individuals in two populations, would likely

result in the extinction of the species (B. Guggolz, pers. comm. 1993,

1996). Of the two remaining populations of Clarkia imbricata, one

population is found in a preserve owned by the CNPS. Although CNPS has

attempted to discourage unauthorized collection by fencing the preserve

and by not publicizing the exact location of the site, trespassers have

damaged the fence, trampled the vegetation, and collected seed of C.

imbricata on several occasions (B. Guggolz, in litt. 1993).

No evidence of over-collection of Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida by

botanists and/or horticulturists for scientific and commercial purposes

is known at this time, although the species is considered to have

horticultural potential (Hill 1993). Both populations are small enough,

however, that even limited collecting pressure would have adverse

impacts. Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida is an attractive plant, and may

be sought for collection once the rarity of this species becomes known

and if current site locations become known. Wild collected seed of the

species, S. oregana (no variety given), are available through a seed

exchange program offered by an international gardening society (North

American Rock Garden Society (NARGS) 1996).

Any occurrences of Trifolium amoenum that may be discovered in the

future also may attract collectors of plants or seed because the

species was previously considered to be extinct. Overutilization is

currently not known to be a factor for the remaining five species, but

unrestricted collecting for scientific or horticultural purposes or

excessive visits by individuals interested in seeing rare plants could

result from increased publicity as a result of this proposal.

C. Disease or predation. Little is known about any diseases that

may affect the nine plant species considered here. None of the species

is currently known to be threatened by disease.

Seven of the 8 known sites of Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis

are currently grazed or have been grazed in recent years by cattle

(CNDDB 1996; V. Norris, in litt. 1995; R. Soost, in litt. 1996). All

three populations in Sonoma County are currently threatened by cattle

grazing (CNDDB 1996), as is a portion of one population outside of a

fenced area on the PRNS where three small patches disappeared from a

gathering place for cattle over a one week period of observation (V.

Norris, in litt. 1995). The portion of the population inside of the

fenced area decreased from 603 flowering culms (stems) in 1995 to 195

flowering culms in 1996, possibly due to annual fluctuation or

competition from other vegetation (R. Soost, in litt. 1996). Another

population on the PRNS was fenced from cattle in 1987. The number of

individuals of A. aequalis var. sonomensis was 0 in 1990, 14 in 1991,

and 0 in 1993, possibly due to competition from a dense growth of other

marsh plants (V. Norris, in litt. 1993). Since then, experiments have

been conducted with partial opening and closing of the entry gate, but

few cattle found their way in and no plants have been seen at this site

since 1991 (V. Norris, in litt. 1995; R. Soost, , in litt. 1996). These

results suggest that some grazing may be necessary to maintain

populations of A. aequalis var. sonomensis in the face of competition

from other plants, but that excessive grazing by cattle can adversely

impact the species.

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida is adversely affected at both of its

locations by reduced seed set resulting from cattle grazing (CNPS

1988b). Populations of Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense have been

enclosed with various types of wire fencing in an attempt to prevent

grazing or browsing by cattle, horses, and deer, but most of the fences

have failed to prevent grazing completely. The plants continue to

suffer from herbivory by cattle, deer, and perhaps gophers and other

herbivores, resulting in loss of flowers and seeds (L. Lozier, in litt.

1990).

Trifolium amoenum may have disappeared from some of its former

[[Page 54801]]

locations due to grazing (Connors 1994). This species is a large clover

that blooms when many grassland plants have already turned brown,

likely making it more attractive to grazing herbivores. Most recent

sightings of the plant were located outside of fences along roadsides,

suggesting that the species survived for a period where it was

protected from grazing (Connors 1994). Threats due to herbivory on the

one natural population of this species, which occurs on portions of two

residential lots, are unknown, but livestock grazing is unlikely.

Grazing may, however, pose a threat to any undiscovered sites for the

species.

D. The inadequacy of existing regulatory mechanisms. The California

Fish and Game Commission has listed Carex albida, Clarkia imbricata,

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, Poa napensis, and Sidalcea oregana

ssp. valida as endangered species under the California Endangered

Species Act (Division 3, Chapter 1.5 section 2050 et seq. of the

California Fish and Game Code and Title 14 California Code of

Regulations 670.2). The California Fish and Game Commission has also

listed Astragalus clarianus and Plagiobothrys strictus as threatened

species. Listing by the State of California requires individuals to

obtain authorization from CDFG to possess or ``take'' a listed species.

Although the ``take'' of State-listed plants is prohibited (California

Native Plant Protection Act, Division 2, Chapter 10, section 1908 and

California Endangered Species Act, Division 3, Chapter 1.5, section

2080), State law exempts the taking of such plants via habitat

modification or land use changes by the owner. After CDFG notifies a

landowner that a State-listed plant grows on his or her property, the

California Native Plant Protection Act only requires that the landowner

notify the agency ``at least 10 days in advance of changing the land

use to allow salvage of such a plant'' (Division 2, Chapter 10, section

1913 of the California Fish and Game Code).

The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a full

disclosure of the potential environmental impacts of proposed projects.

The public agency with primary authority or jurisdiction over the

project is designated as the lead agency and is responsible for

conducting a review of the project and consulting with the other

agencies concerned with the resources affected by the project. Section

15065 of the CEQA Guidelines requires a finding of significance if a

project has the potential to ``reduce the number or restrict the range

of a rare or endangered plant or animal.'' Species that are eligible

for State listing as rare, threatened, or endangered, but are not so

listed, are given the same protection as those species that are

officially listed with the State or Federal governments. Once

significant effects are identified, the lead agency has the option to

require mitigation for effects through changes in the project or to

decide that overriding considerations make mitigation infeasible. In

the latter case, projects may be approved that cause significant

environmental damage, such as destruction of endangered species.

Protection of listed species through CEQA is, therefore, dependent upon

the discretion of the agency involved. In addition, CEQA guidelines

recently have been revised in ways which, if made final, may weaken

protections for threatened, endangered, and other sensitive species.

Hot spring areas and perennial freshwater emergent marshes are

generally small and scattered, and treated as isolated wetlands or

waters of the United States for regulatory purposes by the U.S. Army

Corps of Engineers (Corps) under section 404 of the Clean Water Act.

However, the Clean Water Act, alone, does not provide adequate

protection for Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis, Carex albida,

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, Poa napensis, Plagiobothrys

strictus, Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida, and Trifolium amoenum. For

example, Nationwide Permit (NWP) No. 26 (33 CFR part 330 Appendix B

(26)) was established by the Corps to facilitate issuance of permits

for discharge of fill into wetlands. Under current regulations, NWPs

may be issued for fills up to 1.2 ha (3.0 ac); fills greater than 1.2

ha require an individual permit. For project proposals falling under

NWP 26, the Corps seldom withholds authorization unless a listed

threatened or endangered species' continued existence would be

jeopardized by the proposed action, regardless of the significance of

other wetland resources. Moreover, for fills less than 0.13 ha (\1/3\

ac) only an after-the-fact report is required by the Corps. This report

must be submitted within 30 days of completion of the work and include

only the name, address, and telephone number of the permittee; location

and description of the work; and the type and acreage of the loss. All

of the populations of the seven species in this rule that occur in

wetlands are significantly smaller than 0.13 ha (\1/3\ ac). Although

General Condition 11 of the NWP states that ``no activity is authorized

under any NWP which is likely to jeopardize the continued existence of

a threatened or endangered species or which is likely to destroy or

modify the critical habitat of such species,'' the after-the-fact

nature of the reporting requirement is inadequate to ensure the

protection of populations that occur in areas smaller than the 0.13 ha

(\1/3\ ac) threshold. Four of the seven plant species in this rule that

occur in wetlands are known from only two populations, and two of the

seven species are known only from a single population. Thus, for six of

the seven species, the post facto reporting requirement may be

inadequate to prevent their extinction.

Additionally and equally important, the upland watersheds that

contribute significantly to the hydrology of marshes are not provided

any direct protection under section 404. Disturbance to, or loss of,

seep or marsh habitat and alteration of hydrology have damaged

populations and habitat, as discussed previously under Factor A.

Reductions in water volume or inundation of the sites have the

potential to adversely affect the seven plant taxa listed above. Thus,

as a consequence of the small size of these marsh, meadow, and hot

spring areas and lack of protection of associated uplands, these types

of habitats receive insufficient protection under section 404 of the

Clean Water Act.

The Sonoma County Department of Planning has designated several

marshes where some of these plants occur as ``critical habitat''

(Sonoma County 1989). The streams within these marshes are designated

as ``riparian corridors.'' It is not likely that these designations

will adequately protect the species involved. County policies for

``critical habitat'' include 15 m (50 ft) setbacks of construction from

wetland boundaries and preparation of biotic resource assessments for

development of mitigation measures, if the planning director determines

that a ``critical habitat'' area will be impacted (Sonoma County 1989).

A setback may be waived, however, if the setback is determined to make

the parcel unsuitable for construction. The single population of Carex

albida and the larger population of Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense

occur within 15 m (50 ft) of streams in Sonoma County (CNDDB 1996). The

Sonoma County policy for ``riparian corridors'' allows the removal of

riparian vegetation as part of a pest management program administered

by the County Agricultural Commissioner, as well as construction of

roads and summer dams (Sonoma County 1989). In addition, agricultural

projects that may involve removal of native vegetation, including the

species in this

[[Page 54802]]

rule and their habitats, are considered in Sonoma County to be

``ministerial'' (Ken Ellison, Sonoma County Department of Planning,

pers. comm. 1993). Ministerial projects are those projects that the

public agency must approve after the applicant shows compliance with

certain legal requirements. They may be approved or carried out without

undertaking CEQA review.

Only a few measures have been taken to protect some of the species

in this rule. In 1989, the landowners of the two confirmed populations

of Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense entered into voluntary protection

agreements with TNC (CDFG 1993b). Since that time, TNC and the

California Conservation Corps have jointly built and maintained cattle

exclosures in an attempt to protect the plants at both sites. Some

plants, however, continue to suffer herbivory from livestock and

wildlife, resulting in loss of flowers and seeds (L. Lozier, in litt.

1990). A memorandum of understanding is currently in effect between

CDFG and the Berry Botanic Garden, Portland, Oregon, for research on

germination and recovery of this species (CDFG 1993b). TNC also

obtained a voluntary agreement with private landowners in 1990 to

protect one population of Astragalus clarianus.

CDFG has proposed to purchase approximately 37 ha (90 ac) of the

marsh where Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida occurs to create an ecological

preserve (A. Howald, pers. comm. 1993). Acquisition of the preserve,

however, is dependent on the cooperation of the current landowners. The

owner of one parcel with about half of the population has declined to

sell her property to the State (N. Wilcox, pers. comm. 1994). Purchase

of the land as a preserve would ensure appropriate grazing practices on

the site and would allow direct management of the plant population with

possible opportunities to expand the population (A. Howald, pers. comm.

1993). The preserve would include only a small portion of the

watershed, however, limiting the protection that the preserve would

afford to the hydrology of the marsh (N. Wilcox, pers. comm. 1994).

TNC also has entered into a verbal conservation agreement with a

landowner for the protection of the one natural population of Clarkia

imbricata. However, this population of C. imbricata was inadvertently

mowed before seed set in 1989 and 1991, reducing the seed production

and number of plants in the years following mowing (B. Guggolz, in

litt. 1993).

Seed from cultivated Trifolium amoenum plants is currently being

collected for future reintroduction efforts (P. Connors, pers. comm.

1994, 1996). In addition, half of the seed that was recovered from the

single plant in 1993 was deposited for long-term storage at the U.S.

Department of Agriculture National Seed Storage Laboratory in Fort

Collins, Colorado (Connors 1994).

Although the PRNS is part of the National Park system, 17 cattle

and dairy ranches are contained within its boundaries. Grazing and

ranching, which have occurred on the peninsula for more than a century,

have been determined to be ``consistent with the purpose for which the

Seashore was authorized'' (Clark and Fellers 1987). Clark and Fellers

(1986) state that grazing has been a serious threat to Alopecurus

aequalis var. sonomensis occurrences located on the Seashore, but more

recent reports indicate concerns about both too much and too little

grazing (CNDDB 1996; V. Norris, in litt. 1995; R. Soost, in litt.

1996).

E. Other natural or manmade factors affecting their continued

existence. Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis suffers from competition

from invasive emergent wetland species, including rushes (Juncus spp.)

and nutsedges (Cyperus spp.) at one location. These wetland plants have

nearly extirpated A. aequalis var. sonomensis from that site (V.

Norris, in litt. 1993; CNDDB 1996). Additionally, A. aequalis var.

sonomensis is not readily propagated. Three attempts to reintroduce the

species from seed to suitable habitat within its range have failed, as

has an attempt to start a population in the East Bay Botanic Garden in

Tilden Park. Naturally occurring floods also may be an ongoing threat.

One population was damaged by a flash flood in 1993 (V. Norris, in

litt. 1995; R. Soost, in litt. 1996).

The population of Astragalus clarianus located along the north

shore of Lake Hennessey has an infestation of the invasive and

dominating alien weed, yellow star-thistle (Centaurea solstitialis) (A.

Howald, pers. comm. 1993; J. Ruygt, hearing transcript). This

infestation was a direct result of ground disturbance associated with

the removal of dredge spoils that were placed on top of this population

as discussed under Factor A (A. Howald, pers. comm. 1993). Competition

from this alien annual weed is also considered a threat to the

population of A. clarianus at the Bothe Napa Valley State Park (J.

Ruygt, in litt. 1993). A proposed application to build two small

agricultural water storage reservoirs along a creek in Napa County

would avoid direct impacts to another population of A. clarianus, but

ground disturbance would most likely introduce this same alien invasive

weed (A. Howald, pers. comm. 1993).

Plant succession may be excluding or reducing the population of

Astragalus clarianus at one site (J. Ruygt, in litt. 1993) where A.

clarianus grows sparingly in the gaps between manzanita plants. As

established plants continue to grow, and new manzanita seedlings become

established, less space is available for A. clarianus. Fire suppression

has reduced fire frequency in the manzanita community. Periodic fire

reduces manzanita cover and creates space for other plants, including

A. clarianus. This species, therefore, is vulnerable to habitat loss

from plant succession. Another population of A. clarianus is threatened

by competition from French broom (Genista monospessulana), an invasive

alien shrub, and the rooting behavior of wild pigs (CNDDB 1996; J.

Ruygt, pers. comm. 1996).

The potential for loss of the only population of Sidalcea oregana

ssp. valida from naturally occurring events, because of the small

population size, is exacerbated by drought and water diversions. In

addition, this population is being encroached upon by invasive weeds,

including yellow star-thistle and blackberry (A. Howald, pers. comm.

1993). One of the subpopulations was damaged by an off-road vehicle

during maintenance of a local aqueduct, which passes through the marsh.

The maintenance activity occurred late in the season when the soil was

relatively dry, resulting in minimal damage to the plants. If such

maintenance activities occur during a time when the soil is saturated,

they pose a threat to the plants (A. Howald, pers. comm. 1993).

Because Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense is unlikely to be self-

pollinating, single plants or widely separated plants in sparse

populations may not set viable seed (Mark Skinner, CNPS, pers. comm.

1994). The remaining plants at one site are monitored closely by CNPS

volunteers and, at the time the proposed rule was written, had not been

observed to have set seed for several years (M. Skinner, pers. comm.

1994). Much of the habitat for L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense has been

invaded by blackberry vines that compete for space, light, and

nutrients (CDFG 1993b).

Grass mowing, vehicle traffic, and parking have impacted and

continue to threaten one population of Poa napensis at the Calistoga

airport (CNPS 1990; Robert Soreng, Cornell Univ., in litt. 1993). Grass

mowing is done at regular intervals through the spring and summer to

reduce fire and aircraft safety hazards. Mowing for fire control during

[[Page 54803]]

the reproductive cycle of Clarkia imbricata has reduced the size of one

of its populations by a third (B. Guggolz, in litt. 1996). Airport

users include a spray plane service, recreational gliders, and

associated tow planes. Service vehicles for the planes and the private

vehicles of the customers impact this population of P. napensis,

especially during the spring and summer when airport use increases.

The extirpation of historical populations of Trifolium amoenum may

have partially been a result of competition with weedy, alien plant

species. A recent germination study of other Trifolium species from

historical T. amoenum habitat in Sonoma County suggested that some

annual Trifolium species germinate in late November, well after many

introduced species, including redstem storkbill (Erodium cicutarium),

ripgut brome (Bromus diandrus), and California burclover (Medicago

polymorpha) (Connors 1994). By germinating and growing earlier, it is

likely that alien species have reduced the numbers of T. amoenum plants

by occupying available space (Connors 1994).

The small population size of most of these nine plant species

increases the susceptibility to extirpation from random events.

Population sizes of 100 or fewer are known for one or more populations

of Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis, Astragalus clarianus, Lilium

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, and

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida. The single extant population of Trifolium

amoenum contains about 200 individuals. These species may also be

subject to increased genetic drift and inbreeding as a consequence of

their small population sizes (Menges 1991, Ellstrand and Elam 1993).

Increased homozygosity resulting from genetic drift and inbreeding may

lead to a loss of fitness (ability of individuals to survive and

reproduce) in small populations. In addition, reduced genetic variation

in small populations may make any species less able to successfully

adapt to future environmental changes (Ellstrand and Elam 1993). Thus,

seven of the nine species are threatened by potential loss of fitness

and/or genetic variability associated with small population sizes.

Each of the species addressed in this rule is known from few

populations. Carex albida and Trifolium amoenum each have only one

population. Clarkia imbricata, Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense,

Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, and Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida

each have only two confirmed populations. Astragalus clarianus is known

from four populations. Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis has eight

populations. The combination of few populations, small range, and

restricted habitat makes the nine species highly susceptible to

extinction or extirpation from a significant portion of their ranges

due to random events, such as flood, drought, disease, or other

occurrences (Shaffer 1981, Primack 1993). Such events are not usually a

concern until the number of populations or geographic distribution

become severely limited, as is the case with all of the species

discussed here. Once the number of populations, or the plant population

size, is reduced due to habitat destruction or fragmentation, the

remnant populations, or portions of populations, have a higher

probability of extinction from random events.

The Service has carefully assessed the best scientific and

commercial information available regarding the past, present, and

future threats faced by these species in determining to make this rule

final. Based on this evaluation, the preferred action is to list

Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis (Sonoma alopecurus), Astragalus

clarianus (Clara Hunt's milkvetch), Carex albida (white sedge), Clarkia

imbricata (Vine Hill clarkia), Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense

(Pitkin Marsh lily), Plagiobothrys strictus (Calistoga allocarya), Poa

napensis (Napa bluegrass), Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida (Kenwood marsh

checker-mallow), and Trifolium amoenum (showy Indian clover) as

endangered. Competition with invasive plant species or excessive cattle

grazing threatens five of the eight remaining populations of Alopecurus

aequalis var. sonomensis. Efforts to reintroduce this species to sites

within its range have failed. If combined, all four populations of

Astragalus clarianus would occupy only a 0.5 ha (1 ac) area, and are

threatened variously by a potential water storage project, an approved

subdivision, competition from invasive plant species, recreational

activities, airport maintenance, and elimination through plant

community succession. The single Carex albida population, totaling

approximately 1,000 plants, is located 46 m (150 ft) from the State

highway and is threatened by potential changes in the site's hydrology

resulting from wetland drainage or fill, competition from invasive

plant species, changes in land management by the owner, highway

widening or maintenance, and potential disturbance from a proposed

wastewater treatment. The two remaining populations of Clarkia

imbricata are threatened by changing land use, mowing for fire control,

and unauthorized collection. The three remaining populations of Lilium

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, totaling approximately 300 plants, suffer

from uncontrolled collection of plants, seeds, and bulbs for

horticultural use, and from herbivory by livestock and wildlife. One

site is potentially threatened by a proposed wastewater treatment

project; the other site is potentially threatened by a proposed

subdivision. Competition from invasive plants such as blackberry also

adversely impacts this species. If combined, the remaining populations

of Plagiobothrys strictus and Poa napensis would occupy an area of less

than 0.5 ha (1 ac) each. These populations are surrounded by hot

springs resorts or housing. Plagiobothrys strictus and Poa napensis

both occur at the same two sites where they are threatened by airport

activities, including traffic and vehicle parking on the plants, grass

mowing, and land use changes, including the construction of a hospital

at one site. Both populations of the two species are also threatened by

potential alteration of hot springs hydrology. The only population of

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida is threatened by trampling and reduced

seed set resulting from cattle grazing, aqueduct maintenance,

competition from invasive plant species, and the potential alteration

of hydrology from urbanization. Trifolium amoenum has been extirpated

from all 24 historical occurrences in seven counties; the species

currently is known from one natural population. This species is

threatened by competition with invasive plant species, loss of habitat

from urbanization and other land use changes. All nine species, because

of their few, small populations and very narrow ranges are also highly

susceptible to genetic complications and at increased risk of local

extirpation or extinction from random events.

These nine species are imminently threatened by extinction

throughout all or a significant portion of their range by the factors

summarized above, and the final action, therefore, is to list them as

endangered.

Critical Habitat

Critical habitat is defined in section 3 of the Act as: (i) the

specific areas within the geographical area occupied by a species, at

the time it is listed in accordance with the Act, on which are found

those physical or biological features (I) essential to the conservation

of the species and (II) that may require special management

consideration or protection and; (ii) specific areas outside the

geographical area occupied

[[Page 54804]]

by a species at the time it is listed, upon a determination that such

areas are essential for the conservation of the species.

``Conservation'' means the use of all methods and procedures needed to

bring the species to the point at which listing under the Act is no

longer necessary.

Section 4(a)(3) of the Act, as amended, and implementing

regulations (50 CFR 424.12) require that, to the maximum extent prudent

and determinable, the Secretary designate critical habitat at the time

the species is determined to be endangered or threatened. Critical

habitat is not determinable when one or both of the following

situations exist--(1) Information sufficient to perform required

analyses of the impacts of the designation is lacking, or (2) the

biological needs of the species are not sufficiently well known to

permit identification of an area as critical habitat (50 CFR

424.12(a)(2)). Service regulations (50 CFR 424.12(a)(1)) state that

designation of critical habitat is not prudent when one or both of the

following situations exist--(1) The species is threatened by taking or

other human activity, and identification of critical habitat can be

expected to increase the degree of threat to the species, or (2) such

designation of critical habitat would not be beneficial to the species.

The Service finds that designation of critical habitat is not

prudent for any of these nine plant taxa. Designation of critical

habitat is not prudent for Astragalus clarianus, Clarkia imbricata,

Lilium pardalinum, Carex albida, Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis,

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida, Trifolium amoenum, and Alopecurus

aequalis var. sonomensis because of lack of benefit. Moreover,

designation of critical habitat for Clarkia imbricata, Lilium

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, Carex albida, Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida,

and some populations of Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis is not

prudent because doing so would increase the degree of threat to these

species, or another species in this rule with which it occurs. The

basis for these conclusions, including the factors considered in

weighing the benefits against the risks of designation, are provided by

species below.

Astragalus clarianus

None of the four known occurrences of Astragalus clarianus, which

total about 28 ha (70 ac), are on Federal land (CNDDB 1996). This

species does not occur in wetlands and no Federal actions are likely to

occur in its habitat. Critical habitat designation outside of the areas

where A. clarianus occurs also would serve no purpose because all other

historical sites have been destroyed by urban development and

viticulture (CNDDB 1996) and have no practical value for the survival

and recovery of the species. Designation of critical habitat for A.

clarianus, therefore, is not prudent because it provides no additional

benefit to the species beyond that conferred by listing.

Clarkia Imbricata and Lilium Pardalinum ssp. Pitkinense

Clarkia imbricata and Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense are

attractive to plant collectors and incidents of overutilization and

illegal collection of both species have occurred in the past. Both taxa

are known only from private land. One of the two remaining populations

of C. imbricata occurs on a CNPS preserve where, despite attempts to

not publicize the preserve location and to discourage unauthorized

collection, trespassers have damaged the fencing, trampled vegetation,

and collected seeds of C. imbricata on several occasions (B. Guggolz,

in litt. 1993). Critical habitat designation outside of the areas where

C. imbricata occurs would serve no purpose because no other sites are

known to be essential to the conservation of this species. At one of

the two remaining sites for L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, the species

was once abundant, but it has now been nearly extirpated by the

uncontrolled collection of plants, seeds, and bulbs for horticultural

use (CDFG 1993b). No historical sites for this taxon other than the two

where it now occurs have ever been reported.

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense is a wetland species and

alteration of its habitat may be regulated by the Army Corps of

Engineers under section 404 of the Clean Water Act. The Service

believes that activities regulated under section 404 that could impact

the habitat of L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense are unlikely to occur in

the foreseeable future, and that this species is primarily threatened

by overcollection, unregulated hydrological alterations, competition

from alien plants, and trampling and herbivory by livestock and

wildlife. Moreover, the inadequacies of the section 404 permitting

process for protecting very small plant populations, discussed in

detail under factor D of the ``Summary of the Factors'' section, apply

to this species. In addition to these inadequacies, due to the small

size of the only two populations of this species and the lack of

historical habitat elsewhere, any adverse modification of its habitat

would also likely jeopardize its continued existence. This would also

hold true as the species recovers and its numbers increase. Any

benefits that might result from the designation of critical habitat for

L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense would be outweighed by the likely

increased threat of uncontrolled collection to this species.

Designation of critical habitat for Clarkia imbricata and Lilium

pardalinum ssp. pitkinense, therefore, is not prudent because doing so

would increase the degree of threat to these species. Although there

may be a Federal nexus for L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense through the

Clean Water Act, the designation of critical habitat for this species

would provide little or no benefit to the protection of this species

beyond that provided by listing. The publication of maps and precise

locations of populations that is required for designation of critical

habitat would contribute to the further decline of this species by

facilitating trespassing, uncontrolled collecting, and hindering

recovery efforts. Any benefit from designation of critical habitat for

these species, therefore, would be outweighed by the increased degree

of risk to these species due to the publication of precise maps of

their populations.

Carex Albida

The only known population of Carex albida occupies less than 300

m\2\ of private land in Sonoma County (CDFG 1993a). Critical habitat

designation outside of the areas where C. imbricata occurs would serve

no purpose. The other four historical localities for the species, due

to hydrological alteration and the long-term effects of effluent

discharge from a cannery (CDFG 1993a), serve no practical value for the

survival and recovery of the species. The Service believes that

activities regulated under section 404 that could impact the habitat of

C. albida are unlikely to occur in the foreseeable future, and that

this species is primarily threatened by unregulated hydrological

alterations and competition from native and alien plant species favored

by drier conditions. Moreover, the inadequacies of the section 404

permitting process for protecting very small plant populations,

discussed in detail under factor D of the ``Summary of the Factors''

section above, apply to this species. Even if a proposed fill was

larger than the regulatory threshold and a pre-construction permit was

required, any activity that would destroy or adversely modify the

habitat of the sole remaining population of this species would also

likely jeopardize its continued existence. This would also hold true as

[[Page 54805]]

the species recovers and its numbers increase. Because the site occurs

within 45 m (150 ft) of a State highway, a potential Federal nexus also

exists through activities of the Federal Highway Administration. In

such a situation, however, any action that would adversely modify the

habitat of the only known population of the species would also likely

jeopardize the continued existence of the species. This would also hold

true as the species recovers and its numbers increase. Designation of

critical habitat for C. albida, therefore, is not prudent because it

provides no additional benefit to the species beyond that conferred by

listing. In addition, C. albida occurs at the same site as Lilium

pardalinum ssp. parkinense (see previous paragraph) and the designation

of critical habitat and publication of detailed maps of this site would

contribute to the further decline of the latter species by facilitating

trespassing, uncontrolled collecting, and hindering recovery efforts

for the latter species. The plants at this site are particularly

vunerable since they are close to a State highway and more easily

accessible to collectors.

Alopecurus Aequalis var. Sonomensis

Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis is the only species in this

rule that occurs on Federal land. Four of the eight known populations

occur on Federal land within the PRNS (CNDDB 1996). The plant appears

to have very strict habitat requirements and suitable habitats occur in

only a few places within the PRNS (V. Norris, in litt. 1995). Several

attempts at establishing new populations in seemingly suitable habitat

on the PRNS have been unsuccessful. The locations of these four

populations are known to the managers of the PRNS and each population

is closely monitored by CNPS members, acting in an official capacity as

National Park Service (NPS) volunteers (V. Norris, in litt. 1995; R.

Soost, in litt. 1996). This monitoring includes annual surveys for new

populations of the species. The NPS has also fenced a portion of one

population. The species within the exclosure declined despite this

effort. Because the presence of this plant, and its specific locations,

are well known to the managers of the PRNS, no modification of its

habitat is likely to occur without consultation under section 7 of the

Act. Any action which would destroy or adversely modify the habitat of

the few remaining populations of this species would also likely

jeopardize its continued existence. This would also hold true as the

species recovers and its numbers increase. Designation of critical

habitat for any of the four populations of Alopecurus aequalis var.

sonomensis on Federal land with the PRNS, therefore is not prudent

because it provides no additional benefit to the species beyond that

conferred by listing.

The other four populations occur on private land and may have a

Federal nexus through the Clean Water Act. However, the inadequacies of

the section 404 permitting process for protecting very small plant

populations, discussed in detail under Factor D of the ``Summary of the

Factors'' section, apply to this species. In addition to these

inadequacies, due to the small size of the only known populations of

this species any adverse modification of its habitat would also likely

jeopardize its continued existence. This would also hold true as the

species recovers and its numbers increase.

Moreover, two of the four populations of Alopecurus aequalis var.

sonomensis on private land are found in proximity to L. pardalinum ssp.

pitkinense (see previous discussion of this species). Although A.

aequalis var. sonomensis is not collected for horticultural use,

mapping specific localities of A. aequalis var. sonomensis could lead

to increased collection of L. pardalinum ssp. pitkinense. The

horticultural value of the latter species makes it highly attractive

and one of its two populations has been nearly extirpated by the

uncontrolled collection of plants, seeds, and bulbs for horticultural

use (CDFG 1993b). Designation of critical habitat for these two

populations of Alopecurus sonomensis, therefore, would increase the

degree of threat to Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense by facilitating

trespassing and uncontrolled collecting, and hindering recovery

efforts.

Designation of critical habitat for any of the four populations of

Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis on Federal land with the PRNS,

therefore, is not prudent because it provides no additional benefit to

the species beyond that conferred by listing. Critical habitat

designation for known populations on private land would also confer no

benefit beyond that provided by listing. Because of the few small

occurrences of this species, any adverse modification of its habitat

would likely jeopardize its continued existence. The publication of

maps and precise locations of the two private populations at which A.

aequalis var. sonomensis occurs with Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense

would also contribute to the further decline of the latter species by

facilitating trespassing and uncontrolled collecting, and hindering

recovery efforts.

Plagiobothrys strictus

Plagiobothrys strictus is known only from two populations on

private land. The total area of these populations is less than 80

m2 (900 ft2). The only other historical locality

has been rendered unsuitable by urbanization and agricultural land

conversion (CNPS 1990) and has no practical value for the survival and

recovery of the species. Thus, the establishment of critical habitat in

this unoccupied area would serve no purpose. As with Carex albida, the

habitat for P. strictus will likely be regulated under section 404 of

the Federal Clean Water Act, but the total area of the population is

significantly smaller than the minimum regulatory threshold of 0.13 ha

(\1/3\ ac) for pre-construction notification. Even if a pre-

construction permit was required, any activity that would destroy or

adversely modify the habitat of the sole remaining population of this

species would also likely jeopardize its continued existence. This

would also hold true as the species recovers and its numbers increase.

The designation of critical habitat for Plagiobothrys strictus,

therefore, is not prudent because it provides no additional benefit to

the species beyond that conferred by listing.

Poa Napensis

Both extant populations of Poa napensis occur on private land,

where they occupy slightly more than 100 m2 (1,100

ft2). Urban growth and recreational development of hot

springs in the Calistoga area has rendered all other historical

localities unsuitable for this species (CDFG 1979). Thus, the

establishment of critical habitat in these unoccupied areas would serve

no purpose since these areas have no practical value for the survival

and recovery of the species. At least some of the suitable wetland

habitat for P. napensis may be regulated under section 404 of the Clean

Water Act. As with Carex albida and Plagiobothrys strictus, the total

population area is significantly smaller than the 0.13 ha (\1/3\ ac)

minimum regulatory threshold for pre-construction notification. As is

also the case with these species, even if a pre-construction permit was

required, any activity that would destroy or adversely modify the

habitat of the Poa napensis would also likely jeopardize its continued

existence. This would also hold true as the species recovers and its

numbers increase. Designation of critical habitat for P. napensis,

therefore, is not prudent because doing so provides no additional

benefit to the species beyond that conferred by listing.

[[Page 54806]]

Sidalcea Oregana ssp. Valida

Both populations of Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida occur only on

private land. There is no evidence that the species was ever present at

any other localities (CNPS 1988b, CDFG 1987). It grows in a habitat

which is likely to be regulated under the Clean Water Act but, as with

the other wetland species discussed above, the small populations occupy

less than the 0.13 ha (1/3 ac) minimum regulatory threshold for pre-

construction notification. Moreover, due to the small size of the only

two extant populations, any activity that would destroy or adversely

modify the habitat of either of the two remaining populations of this

species would also likely jeopardize its continued existence. This

would also hold true as the species recovers and its numbers increase.

The species is also of recognized horticultural value (Hill 1993), and

wild-collected seeds of this species (no variety given) are available

through a seed exchange program offered by a international gardening

society (NARGS 1996). Both populations are small enough that even

limited collecting pressure would have adverse impacts. Designation of

critical habitat for S. oregana ssp. valida, therefore, is not prudent

because it provides no additional benefit to the species beyond that

conferred by listing and because doing so would increase the degree of

threat to this species. The publication of maps and precise locations

of the populations that is required for designation of critical

habitat, therefore, would contribute to the further decline of this

species by facilitating trespassing and uncontrolled collecting, and

hindering recovery efforts.

Trifolium Amoenum

Only a single population of Trifolium amoenum is known to be

extant. Although the species was widespread north and east of San

Francisco Bay historically, it had last been seen in 1969 and presumed

extinct until its rediscovery in 1992 after years of searching (Connors

1994). Because it is a large, attractive plant, it is highly likely

that it has been extirpated from its historical localities (Connors

1994). The sole population is on private land with little probability

of any Federal activity. No other suitable habitat on Federal land, or

where any Federal action is likely to occur, is known to exist. The

species has probably been eliminated at its other historical localities

by competition with alien species of annual plants and because of the

prevalance of alien species throughout the historical range of T.

amoenum, (Connors 1994). Although historically the plant was known from

``wet swales,'' the current site is not a regulated wetland. Even if a

Federal nexus were identified, any activity that would destroy or

adversely modify the habitat of the sole remaining population of this

species would also likely jeopardize its continued existence. This

would also hold true as the species recovers and its numbers increase.

Designation of critical habitat for Trifolium amoenum at this site,

therefore, is not prudent because it provides no additional benefit to

the species beyond that conferred by listing. Although collection is

not currently thought to be a threat to the species, the plant is large

with showy flowers and its populations are small enough that even

limited collecting pressure would have adverse impacts. Designation of

critical habitat for T. amoenum anywhere within its historical range,

therefore, is not prudent because doing so would increase the degree of

threat to this species. The publication of maps and precise locations

of involved plant populations that is required for designation of

critical habitat would contribute to the further decline of this

species by facilitating trespassing and uncontrolled collecting, and

hindering recovery efforts.

Available Conservation Measures

Conservation measures provided to species listed as endangered or

threatened under the Act include recognition, recovery actions,

requirements for Federal protection, and prohibitions against certain

practices. Recognition through listing results in public awareness and

conservation actions by Federal, State, and local agencies, private

organizations, and individuals. The Act provides for possible land

acquisition and cooperation with the State, and requires that recovery

plans be developed for all listed species. The protection required of

Federal agencies and the prohibitions against certain activities

involving listed plants are discussed, in part, below.

Section 7(a) of the Act, as amended, requires Federal agencies to

evaluate their actions with respect to any species that is proposed or

listed as endangered or threatened and with respect to its critical

habitat, if any. Regulations implementing this interagency cooperation

provision of the Act are codified at 50 CFR part 402.

Section 7(a)(4) of the Act requires Federal agencies to confer with

the Service on any action that is likely to jeopardize the continued

existence of a species proposed for listing or result in destruction or

adverse modification of proposed critical habitat. If a species is

listed subsequently, section 7(a)(2) requires Federal agencies to

ensure that activities they authorize, fund, or carry out are not

likely to jeopardize the continued existence of the species or destroy

or adversely modify its critical habitat. If a Federal action may

affect a listed species or its critical habitat, the responsible

Federal agency must enter into formal consultation with the Service.

To the extent that six of the nine taxa proposed herein are

currently known to inhabit marshes, wet meadows, perennial streams, or

thermal hot springs, the Service anticipates that the Corps will enter

into section 7 consultations regarding these species if it regulates

fill of these wetlands under section 404 of the Clean Water Act.

Because of the small area covered by these populations, however,

actions which could impact their habitats may not be subject to pre-

construction notification. The inadequacies of current regulations for

NWP 26 processing under the Clean Water Act are discussed in detail

under factor D in the ``Summary of Factors'' section above. The

National Park Service may participate in section 7 consultation because

of potential grazing effects on Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis at

the PRNS, and concerning park management plans that directly or

indirectly affect this species.

Listing Alopecurus aequalis var. sonomensis, Astragalus clarianus,

Carex albida, Clarkia imbricata, Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense,

Plagiobothrys strictus, Poa napensis, Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida, and

Trifolium amoenum would provide for development of a recovery plan (or

plans) for them. Such plan(s) would bring together both State and

Federal efforts for conservation of the plants. The plan(s) would

establish a framework for agencies to coordinate activities and

cooperate with each other in conservation efforts, set recovery

priorities, and estimate costs of various tasks necessary to accomplish

them. The plan(s) also would describe site-specific management actions

necessary to achieve conservation and survival of the nine plant

species. Additionally, pursuant to section 6 of the Act, the Service

would be more likely to grant funds to affected states for management

actions promoting the protection and recovery of these species.

The Act and its implementing regulations set forth a series of

general prohibitions and exceptions that apply to all endangered

plants. All prohibitions of section 9(a)(2) of the Act,

[[Page 54807]]

implemented by 50 CFR 17.61, apply. These prohibitions, in part, make

it illegal for any person subject to the jurisdiction of the United

States to import or export any of the plants, transport them in

interstate or foreign commerce in the course of a commercial activity,

sell or offer them for sale in interstate or foreign commerce, or

remove and reduce any of the plants to possession from areas under

Federal jurisdiction. In addition, the Act prohibits the malicious

damage or destruction of endangered plants on areas under Federal

jurisdiction, as well as the removal, cutting, digging up, or damaging

or destroying of such plant species in knowing violation of any State

law or regulation, including State criminal trespass law. Certain

exceptions to the prohibitions apply to agents of the Service and State

conservation agencies.

The Act and 50 CFR 17.62 and 17.63 also provide for the issuance of

permits to carry out otherwise prohibited activities involving

endangered plant species under certain circumstances. Such permits are

available for scientific purposes and to enhance the propagation or

survival of the species. The Service anticipates that few permits would

ever be sought or issued for most of the species because they are

typically not sought for cultivation and are uncommon in the wild.

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense and Clarkia imbricata, however, are

collected for horticultural use.

It is the policy of the Service, published in the Federal Register

on July 1, 1994 (59 FR 34272), to identify to the maximum extent

practicable at the time a species is listed those activities that would

or would not constitute a violation of section 9 of the Act. The intent

of this policy is to increase public awareness of the effect of the

listing of the nine plant species on proposed and ongoing activities

within the species' range. Collection, damage or destruction of these

species on Federal lands is prohibited, although in appropriate cases a

Federal permit may be issued to allow collection for scientific or

recovery purposes. Such activities on non-Federal (private) lands would

constitute a violation of section 9 when conducted in knowing violation

of California State law or regulations or in violation of State

criminal trespass law. See Factor D. for a discussion of California's

law protecting plants.

As noted above, Federal listing of plant species protects plants

occurring on Federal lands and when Federal activities may affect the

species. Thus, activities on private lands such as landscape

maintenance, clearing vegetation for firebreaks, and livestock grazing,

are not prohibited or regulated unless they are conducted in knowing

violation of State law or are federally funded or authorized. Questions

regarding whether specific activities would constitute a violation of

section 9 should be directed to the Field Supervisor of the Service's

Sacramento Field Office (see ADDRESSES section). Requests for copies of

the regulations regarding listed plants and inquiries about

prohibitions and permits may be addressed to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife

Service, Ecological Services, Endangered Species Permits, 911 NE 11th

Ave., Portland, Oregon 97232-4181 (phone 503/231-2063, facsimile 503/

231-6243).

National Environmental Policy Act

The Fish and Wildlife Service has determined that Environmental

Assessments and Environmental Impact Statements, as defined under the

authority of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, need not be

prepared in connection with regulations adopted pursuant to section

4(a) of the Act. A notice outlining the Service's reasons for this

determination was published in the Federal Register on October 25, 1983

(48 FR 49244).

Required Determinations

The Service has examined this regulation under the Paperwork

Reduction Act of 1995 and found it to contain no information collection

requirements.

References Cited

A complete list of all references cited herein is available upon

request from the Field Supervisor, Sacramento Field Office (see

ADDRESSES section).

Author

The primary authors of this final rule are Diane Elam and David

Wright, Sacramento Field Office (see ADDRESSES section).

List of Subjects in 50 CFR Part 17

Endangered and threatened species, Exports, Imports, Reporting and

recordkeeping requirements, Transportation.

Regulation Promulgation

Accordingly, part 17, subchapter B of chapter I, title 50 of the

Code of Federal Regulations, the Service amends as follows:

PART 17--[AMENDED]

1. The authority citation for part 17 continues to read as follows:

Authority: 16 U.S.C. 1361-1407; 16 U.S.C. 1531-1544; 16 U.S.C.

4201-4245; Pub. L. 99-625, 100 Stat. 3500; unless otherwise noted.

2. Amend Section 17.12(h) by adding the following, in alphabetical

order under FLOWERING PLANTS, to the List of Endangered and Threatened

Plants to read as follows:

Sec. 17.12 Endangered and threatened plants.

* * * * *

(h) * * *

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Species

-------------------------------------------------------- Historic Range Family Status When listed Critical Special

Scientific name Common Name habitat rules

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Flowering Plants

* * * * * * *

Alopecurus aequalis var. Sonoma alopecurus... U.S.A. (CA)........ Poaceae............ E 625 NA NA

sonomensis.

* * * * * * *

Astragalus clarianus............. Clara Hunt's milk- U.S.A. (CA)........ Fabaceae........... E 625 NA NA

vetch.

* * * * * * *

Carex albida..................... white sedge......... U.S.A. (CA)........ Cyperaceae......... E 625 NA NA

* * * * * * *

Clarkia imbricata................ Vine Hill clarkia... U.S.A. (CA)........ Onagraceae......... E 625 NA NA

[[Page 54808]]

* * * * * * *

Lilium pardalinum ssp. pitkinense Pitkin Marsh lily... U.S.A. (CA)........ Liliaceae.......... E 625 NA NA

* * * * * * *

Plagiobothrys strictus........... Calistoga allocarya. U.S.A. (CA)........ Boraginaceae....... E 625 NA NA

* * * * * * *

Poa napensis..................... Napa bluegrass...... U.S.A. (CA)........ Poaceae............ E 625 NA NA

* * * * * * *

Sidalcea oregana ssp. valida..... Kenwood Marsh U.S.A. (CA)........ Malvaceae.......... E 625 NA NA

checker-mallow.

* * * * * * *

Trifolium amoenum................ showy Indian clover. U.S.A. (CA)........ Fabaceae........... E 625 NA NA

* * * * * * *

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Dated: September 29, 1997.

Jamie Rappaport Clark,

Director, Fish and Wildlife Service.

[FR Doc. 97-27924 Filed 10-21-97; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4310-55-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.