Application by William E. Comley, Inc. and TWC Transportation Corporation for a Preemption Determination as to Public Utilities Commission of Ohio Requirements for Cargo Tanks

Federal RegisterOct 10, 1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

[Docket No. RSPA-97-2968 (PDA-17(R))]

Application by William E. Comley, Inc. and TWC Transportation

Corporation for a Preemption Determination as to Public Utilities

Commission of Ohio Requirements for Cargo Tanks

AGENCY: Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA), DOT.

ACTION: Public notice and invitation to comment.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Interested parties are invited to submit comments on an

application by William E. Comley, Inc. and TWC Transportation

Corporation for an administrative determination whether Federal

hazardous materials transportation law preempts requirements enforced

by the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio concerning the

transportation of hypochlorite solutions in non-DOT specification cargo

tank motor vehicles.

DATES: Comments received on or before November 24, 1997, and rebuttal

comments received on or before December 9, 1997, will be considered

before an administrative ruling is issued by RSPA's Associate

Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety. Rebuttal comments may

discuss only those issues raised by comments received during the

initial comment period and may not discuss new issues.

ADDRESSES: The application and all comments received may be reviewed in

the Dockets Office, U.S. Department of Transportation, Room PL-401, 400

Seventh Street, SW, Washington, DC 20590-0001. Comments may be

submitted to the Dockets Office at the above address. Three copies of

each written comment should be submitted. Comments may also be

submitted by E-mail to ``[email protected].'' Each comment

should refer to the Docket Number set forth above.

A copy of each comment must also be sent to (1) Mr. William E.

Comley, Sr., Chairman, WECCO/TWC, 28 Kenton Lands Road, P.O. Box 18580,

Erlanger, KY 41018, and (2) Mr. William L. Wright, Assistant Attorney

General, Public Utilities Section, 180 East Broad Street, Columbus, OH

43215-3793. A certification that a copy has been sent to these persons

must also be included with the comment. (The following format is

suggested: ``I certify that copies of this comment have been sent to

Messrs. Comley and Wright at the addresses specified in the Federal

Register.'')

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Frazer C. Hilder, Office of the Chief

Counsel, Research and Special Programs Administration, U.S. Department

of Transportation, Washington, DC 20590-0001 (Tel. No. 202-366-4400).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Application for a Preemption Determination

William E. Comley, Inc. (WECCO) and TWC Transportation Corporation

(TWC) have applied for a determination that Federal hazardous material

transportation law, 49 U.S.C. 5101 et seq., preempts certain

requirements of the State of Ohio, enforced by the Public Utilities

Commission of Ohio (PUCO),

[[Page 53050]]

with respect to cargo tank motor vehicles used to transport

hypochlorite solutions. This application arises out of enforcement

proceedings brought by PUCO against WECCO and TWC for transporting

hypochlorite solutions in non-DOT specification cargo tank motor

vehicles. These companies have provided documents, including opinions

and orders of PUCO, that indicate the following:

1. WECCO's truck No. 88 was inspected by PUCO on June 3 and

September 26, 1991, and WECCO was cited both times for several

violations including transporting hypochlorite solution in an

unauthorized package.

2. At the time of PUCO's 1991 inspections, truck No. 88 did not

have any specification plate. Sometime thereafter, WECCO attached

specification plates to its three cargo tanks, including truck No. 88.

3. In its December 17, 1992 Opinion and Order relating to the 1991

citations, PUCO found that, ``in order to be an authorized package for

the transportation of sodium hypochlorite under HMR 49 CFR

173.277(a)(9), respondent's tank must be classified as an MC 310, MC

311, MC 312 or DOT 412 cargo tank.'' PUCO also found that truck No. 88

``has several design flaws which prevent it from qualifying under the

HMR as a specification MC 312 cargo tank.'' PUCO assessed a fine of

$11,470 against WECCO, which included $10,750 for violations of 49 CFR

173.277, transporting hazardous material in an unauthorized package and

willful misrepresentation of cargo tank certification. Of the total

fine, $5,000 was suspended for six months.

4. Truck No. 88, which had been transferred by WECCO to TWC, was

inspected by PUCO on June 22, 1993, and TWC was cited for eight

violations including leaking closures, transporting hypochlorite

solution in an unauthorized package, and misrepresenting that the

package met the MC 312 specification. On PUCO's hazardous materials

report form, the contents of the cargo tank is indicated as

``Hypochlorite Solution, PG III.''

5. TWC's truck No. 66 was inspected by PUCO on July 3, 1993, and

TWC was cited for seven violations including leaking closures,

transporting hypochlorite solution in an unauthorized package, and

misrepresenting that the package met the MC 312 specification. On

WECCO's shipping paper attached to PUCO's hazardous materials report

form, the hypochlorite solution is classed within ``PG III.''

6. In its October 25, 1995 Opinion and Order relating to the 1993

citations, PUCO found that ``numerous defects for both cargo tanks

(Nos. 88 and 66) * * * preclude either from meeting the specifications

of an MC 312 cargo tank.'' PUCO also stated that whether or not TWC

``need[ed] an MC 312 certified cargo tank to haul sodium hypochlorite

solution of the concentration involved in these cases * * * is not an

issue before us and respondent has not been charged with any such

violation.'' PUCO assessed a total civil forfeiture of $14,290.50

against TWC for violations which included transporting hypochlorite

solution in unauthorized packages and in tanks misrepresented as

meeting MC 312 specifications, in violation of 49 CFR 173.33(a) and 49

CFR 171.2(c), respectively.

Based on telephone conversations with WECCO and PUCO, RSPA understands

that no part of the fines or civil forfeitures assessed against WECCO

and TWC has been paid, and PUCO is currently seeking to collect these

penalties.

The State of Ohio has adopted (as State law) the requirements in

the Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMR, 49 CFR parts 171-180)

applicable to highway transportation of hazardous materials, including

hypochlorite solutions. Under the HMR, since January 1, 1991,

hypochlorite solutions containing more than 5% but less than 16%

available chlorine may be transported in ``non-DOT specification cargo

tank motor vehicles suitable for transportation of liquids'' and which

also meet the general requirements for bulk packagings set forth in 49

CFR 173.24 and 173.24b. 49 CFR 173.241(b); see also 172.101 (Hazardous

Materials Table). (At present, hypochlorite solutions up to 5%

available chlorine are not subject to the HMR. During a transition

period that continued until October 1, 1996, the HMR also authorized

the transportation of hypochlorite solutions containing up to 7%

available chlorine by weight transported in nonspecification cargo

tanks that were ``free from leaks and [with] all discharge openings * *

* securely closed during transportation.'' 49 CFR 173.510 (1990 ed.))

According to WECCO and TWC, in the course of these enforcement

proceedings, PUCO has required the use of a DOT specification cargo

tank motor vehicle, bearing a specification plate, for transportation

of hypochlorite solutions containing more than 5% but less than 16%

available chlorine. These companies also assert that PUCO has required

cargo tank motor vehicles built under the MC 312 specification, that

are unloaded at a pressure less than 15 psig, to be designed and

constructed in accordance with the ASME code and also required the

certification of MC 312 cargo tank motor vehicles in some manner other

than as specified in the HMR.

In comments addressed to this application, PUCO has stated that its

policy is to enforce the requirements in the HMR ``aggressively yet

fairly.'' It stated that the focus of its enforcement proceedings

against WECCO and TWC was the misrepresentation of these two cargo tank

motor vehicles as meeting the MC 312 specification, when PUCO

``specifically found that the cargo tanks in question did not meet MC

312 specifications.'' PUCO also stated that it allows the use of non-

specification cargo tank motor vehicles for the transportation of

hypochlorite solutions with less than 16% available chlorine, but that

WECCO and TWC have never provided any evidence on the concentration of

the sodium hypochlorite solution being transported in their trucks.

Although WECCO and TWC assert that their cargo tanks were

constructed to ASME requirements, and had wall, head, and lining

thicknesses that exceeded requirements for specification MC 312 cargo

tank motor vehicles, their application does not contain an assertion

that these trucks actually meet DOT's MC 312 specification. Rather, the

applicants state that specification plates are not required for these

vehicles to transport sodium hypochlorite with less than 16% available

chlorine, but that specification plates were applied to their trucks

only to satisfy PUCO's insistence that a specification cargo tank motor

vehicle was required for the transportation of this material. RSPA

notes that the misrepresentation of any packaging as qualified for the

transportation of a hazardous material is a serious violation of both

49 U.S.C. 5104(a) and the HMR, whether or not that packaging is

actually used for the transportation of hazardous materials. However,

because there is no evidence that PUCO has enforced design,

construction, and operational requirements for MC 312 specification

cargo tanks against these companies in any manner different from that

specified in the HMR, issues relating to PUCO's assessment of penalties

for misrepresenting cargo tank motor vehicles as meeting the MC 312

specification are not part of this proceeding.

The application submitted by WECCO and TWC is being considered

solely with respect to issues that concern whether PUCO has required

the use of a specification cargo tank motor vehicle

[[Page 53051]]

for the transportation of sodium hypochlorite with less than 16%

available chlorine, after January 1, 1991. Neither the applicants nor

PUCO has provided RSPA with copies of shipping papers or other

documents to indicate the concentration of the sodium hypochlorite in

the 1991 shipments. However, as stated above, the PUCO hazardous

materials report forms for the June and July 1993 inspections (as

provided by WECCO and TWC) indicate that the hypochlorite solutions

were classed as Packing Group III materials. Packing Group III applies

to hypochlorite solutions with more than 5% but less than 16% available

chlorine. 49 CFR 172.101.

The following materials have been placed in the public docket of

this proceeding:

Mr. Comley's April 24, 1997 application for a preemption

determination and attachments.

RSPA's May 7, 1997 letter dismissing Mr. Comley's application.

Mr. Comley's May 12, 1997 reapplication for a preemption

determination, with attachments.

RSPA's May 23, 1997 letter requesting additional information.

Mr. Comley's May 29, 1997 letter and attachments.

PUCO's July 8, 1997 letter and attachments.

Copies of these materials will be provided at no cost upon request

to RSPA's Dockets Unit, located in Room 8421, 400 Seventh Street, SW,

Washington, DC 20590-0001; telephone 202-366-4453.

II. Federal Preemption

The Hazardous Materials Transportation Act (HMTA) was enacted in

1975 to give the Department of Transportation greater authority ``to

protect the Nation adequately against the risks to life and property

which are inherent in the transportation of hazardous materials in

commerce.'' Pub. L. 93-633 Sec. 102, 88 Stat. 2156, amended by Pub. L.

103-272 and codified as revised in 49 U.S.C. 5101. The HMTA

``replace[d] a patchwork of state and federal laws and regulations * *

* with a scheme of uniform, national regulations.'' Southern Pac.

Transp. Co. v. Public Serv. Comm'n, 909 F.2d 352, 353 (9th Cir. 1980).

On July 5, 1994, the HMTA was among the many Federal laws relating to

transportation that were revised, codified and enacted ``without

substantive change'' by Pub. L. 103-272, 108 Stat. 745. The Federal

hazardous material transportation law is now found in 49 U.S.C. Chapter

51.

A statutory provision for Federal preemption was central to the

HMTA. In 1974, the Senate Commerce Committee ``endorse[d] the principle

of preemption in order to preclude a multiplicity of State and local

regulations and the potential for varying as well as conflicting

regulations in the area of hazardous materials transportation.'' S.

Rep. No. 1102, 93rd Cong. 2nd Sess. 37 (1974). More recently, a Federal

Court of Appeals found that uniformity was the ``linchpin'' in the

design of the HMTA, including the 1990 amendments which expanded the

preemption provisions. Colorado Pub. Util. Comm'n v. Harmon, 951 F.2d

1571, 1575 (10th Cir. 1991). In 1990, Congress specifically found that:

(3) many States and localities have enacted laws and regulations

which vary from Federal laws and regulations pertaining to the

transportation of hazardous materials, thereby creating the

potential for unreasonable hazards in other jurisdictions and

confounding shippers and carriers which attempt to comply with

multiple and conflicting registration, permitting, routing,

notification, and other regulatory requirements,

(4) because of the potential risks to life, property, and the

environment posed by unintentional releases of hazardous materials,

consistency in laws and regulations governing the transportation of

hazardous materials is necessary and desirable,

(5) in order to achieve greater uniformity and to promote the

public health, welfare, and safety at all levels, Federal standards

for regulating the transportation of hazardous materials in

intrastate, interstate, and foreign commerce are necessary and

desirable.

Pub. L. 101-615 Sec. 2, 104 Stat. 3244.

Following the 1990 amendments and the subsequent 1994 codification

of the Federal hazardous material transportation law, in the absence of

a waiver of preemption by DOT under 49 U.S.C. 5125(e), ``a requirement

of a State, political subdivision of a State, or Indian tribe'' is

explicitly preempted (unless it is authorized by another Federal law)

if

(1) complying with a requirement of the State, political

subdivision or tribe and a requirement of this chapter or a

regulation issued under this chapter is not possible; or

(2) the requirement of the State, political subdivision, or

Indian tribe, as applied or enforced, is an obstacle to

accomplishing and carrying out this chapter or a regulation

prescribed under this chapter.

49 U.S.C. 5125(a). These two paragraphs set forth the ``dual

compliance'' and ``obstacle'' criteria which RSPA had applied in

issuing inconsistency rulings before 1990. While advisory in nature,

these inconsistency rulings were ``an alternative to litigation for a

determination of the relationship of Federal and State or local

requirements'' and also a possible ``basis for an application * * *

[for] a waiver of preemption.'' Inconsistency Ruling (IR) No. 2, Rhode

Island Rules and Regulations Governing the Transportation of Liquefied

Natural Gas and Liquefied Propane Gas, etc. 44 FR 75566, 76657 (Dec.

20, 1979). The dual compliance and obstacle criteria are based on U.S.

Supreme Court decisions on preemption. Hines v. Davidowitz, 312 U.S. 52

(1941); Florida Lime & Avocado Growers, Inc. v. Paul, 373 U.S. 132

(1963); Ray v. Atlantic Richfield, Inc., 435 U.S. 151 (1978).

In the 1990 amendments, Congress also confirmed that there is no

room for differences from Federal requirements in certain key matters

involving the transportation of hazardous material. As now codified, a

non-Federal requirement ``about any of the following subjects, that is

not substantively the same as a provision of this chapter or a

regulation prescribed under this chapter,'' is preempted unless it is

authorized by another Federal law or DOT grants a waiver of preemption:

(A) the designation, description, and classification of

hazardous material.

(B) the packing, repacking, handling, labeling, marking, and

placarding of hazardous material.

(C) the preparation, execution, and use of shipping documents

related to hazardous material and requirements related to the

number, contents, and placement of those documents.

(D) the written notification, recording, and reporting of the

unintentional release in transportation of hazardous material.

(E) the design, manufacturing, fabricating, marking,

maintenance, reconditioning, repairing, or testing of a packaging or

a container represented, marked, certified, or sold as qualified for

use in transporting hazardous material.

49 U.S.C. 5125(b)(1). RSPA has defined ``substantively the same'' to

mean ``conforms in every significant respect to the Federal

requirement. Editorial and other similar de minimis changes are

permitted.'' 49 CFR 107.202(d).

Under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d)(1), any directly affected person may apply

to the Secretary of Transportation for a determination whether a State,

political subdivision or Indian tribe requirement is preempted. This

administrative determination replaced RSPA's process for issuing

inconsistency rulings. The Secretary of Transportation has delegated to

RSPA the authority to make determinations of preemption, except for

those concerning highway routing which have been delegated to FHWA. 49

CFR 1.53(b). Under RSPA's regulations, preemption determinations are

issued by RSPA's Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials

Safety. 49 CFR 107.209(a).

[[Page 53052]]

Section 5125(d)(1) requires that notice of an application for a

preemption determination must be published in the Federal Register. Id.

Following the receipt and consideration of written comments, RSPA

publishes its determination in the Federal Register. See 49 CFR

107.209(d). A short period of time is allowed for filing of petitions

for reconsideration. 49 C.F.R. 107.211. Any party to the proceeding may

seek judicial review in a Federal district court. 49 U.S.C. 5125(f).

RSPA's authority to issue preemption determinations does not

provide a means for review or appeal of State enforcement proceedings,

nor does RSPA consider any of the State's procedural requirements

applied in an enforcement proceedings. The filing of an application for

a preemption determination does not operate to stay a State enforcement

proceeding.

Preemption determinations do not address issues of preemption

arising under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution or under statutes

other than the Federal hazardous material transportation law unless it

is necessary to do so in order to determine whether a requirement is

authorized by another Federal law. A State, local or Indian tribe

requirement is not authorized by another Federal law merely because it

is not preempted by another Federal statute. Colorado Pub. Util. Comm'n

v. Harmon, above, 951 F.2d at 1581 n.10.

In making preemption determinations under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d), RSPA

is guided by the principles and policy set forth in Executive Order No.

12,612, entitled ``Federalism'' (52 FR 41685, Oct. 30, 1987). Section

4(a) of that Executive Order authorizes preemption of State laws only

when a statute contains an express preemption provision, there is other

firm and palpable evidence of Congressional intent to preempt, or the

exercise of State authority directly conflicts with the exercise of

Federal authority. Section 5125 contains express preemption provisions,

which RSPA has implemented through its regulations.

III. Public Comment

Comments should be limited to whether Federal hazardous material

transportation law preempts a requirement allegedly applied and

enforced by PUCO, after January 1, 1991, for the use of a DOT

specification cargo tank motor vehicle for the transportation of

hypochlorite solutions containing more than 5% and less than 16%

available chlorine. WECCO and TWC have not provided any evidence to

indicate that PUCO enforces different requirements for the design,

construction, and certification of MC 312 specification cargo tank

motor vehicles. In addition, allegations in the application relating to

PUCO's procedures for holding hearings and assessing penalties are not

subject to this proceeding.

Persons submitting comments should:

(1) Set forth in detail the manner in which PUCO applies and

enforces requirements for transportation of hypochlorite solution with

more than 5% but less than 16% available chlorine; and

(2) Specifically address whether PUCO has enforced a requirement

concerning the packing of a hazardous material that is ``not

substantively the same as'' the requirements in the HMR.

Comments may also address the ``dual compliance'' and ``obstacle''

criteria described in Part II, above.

Persons intending to comment should review the standards and

procedures governing RSPA's consideration of applications for

preemption determinations, set forth at 49 CFR 107.201-107.211.

Issued in Washington, DC, on October 3, 1997.

Alan I. Roberts,

Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety.

[FR Doc. 97-26918 Filed 10-9-97; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.