United States v. Raytheon Company and Texas Instruments Inc.; Proposed Final Judgment and Competitive Impact Statement

Federal RegisterJul 23, 1997

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE

Antitrust Division

United States v. Raytheon Company and Texas Instruments Inc.;

Proposed Final Judgment and Competitive Impact Statement

Notice is hereby given pursuant to the Antitrust Procedures and

Penalties Act, 15 U.S.C. 16(b)-(h), that a proposed Final Judgment,

Stipulation and Order, Hold Separate and Partition Plan Stipulation and

Order and Competitive Impact Statement have been filed with the United

States District Court in the District of Columbia, Civil No.

1:97CV01515.

On July 2, 1997, the United States filed a Complaint alleging that

the proposed acquisition by Raytheon Company of the Defense Systems and

Electronics Unit of Texas Instruments Inc. (``DS&E'') would violate

Section 7 of the Clayton Act, 15 U.S.C. Sec. 18. The complaint further

alleges that the acquisition by Raytheon of DS&E would lead to a

monopoly in X-band high power amplifier monolithic microwave integrated

circuits (``MMICs''). The proposed Final Judgment, filed the same time

as the Complaint, requires Raytheon to divest the MMICs business of

DS&E.

Public comment is invited within the statutory 60-day comment

period. Such comments and responses thereto will be published in the

Federal Register and filed with the Court. Comments should be directed

to J. Robert Kramer, Chief, Litigation II Section, Antitrust Division,

United States Department of Justice, 1401 H Street, N.W., Suite 3000,

Washington, D.C. 20530 (telephone: 202/307-0924).

Copies of the Complaint, Stipulation and Order, Hold Separate and

Partition Plan Stipulation and Order, Proposed Final Judgment, and

Competitive Impact Statement are available for inspection in Room 215

of the U.S. Department of Justice, Antitrust Division, 325 7th Street,

N.W., Washington, D.C. 20530, (202) 514-2841. Copies of these

[[Page 39541]]

materials may be obtained upon request and payment of a copying fee.

Constance K. Robinson,

Director of Operations, Antitrust Division.

Stipulation and Order

It is stipulated by and between the undersigned parties, by their

respective attorneys, as follows:

(1) The Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this

action and over each of the parties hereto, and venue of this action is

proper in the United States District Court for the District of

Columbia.

(2) The parties stipulate that a Final Judgment in the form hereto

attached may be filed and entered by the Court, upon the motion of any

party or upon the Court's own motion, at any time after compliance with

the requirements of the Antitrust Procedures and Penalties Act (15

U.S.C. Sec. 16), and without further notice to any party or other

proceedings, provided that plaintiff has not withdrawn its consent,

which it may do at any time before the entry of the proposed Final

Judgment by serving notice thereof on defendants and by filing that

notice with the Court.

(3) Defendant shall abide by and comply with the provisions of the

proposed Final Judgment pending entry of the Final Judgment by the

Court, or until expiration of time for all appeals of any Court ruling

declining entry of the proposed Final Judgment, and shall, from the

date of the signing of this Stipulation by the parties, comply with all

the terms and provisions of the proposed Final Judgment as though the

same were in full force and effect as an Order of the Court.

(4) This Stipulation shall apply with equal force and effect to any

amended proposed Final Judgment agreed upon in writing by the parties

and submitted to the Court.

(5) In the event plaintiff withdraws its consent, as provided in

paragraph 2 above, or in the event the proposed Final Judgment is not

entered pursuant to this Stipulation, the time has expired for all

appeals of any Court ruling declining entry of the proposed Final

Judgment, and the Court has not otherwise ordered continued compliance

with the terms and provisions of the proposed Final Judgment, then the

parties are released from all further obligations under this

Stipulation, and the making of this Stipulation shall be without

prejudice to any party in this or any other proceeding.

(6) Defendants represent that the divestiture ordered in the

proposed Final Judgment can and will be made, and that defendants will

later raise no claim of hardship or difficulty as grounds for asking

the Court to modify any of the divestiture provisions contained

therein.

Dated: July 2, 1997.

For Plaintiff United States of America:

Willie L. Hudgins, Esquire, (D.C. Bar #37127, U.S. Department of

Justice, Antitrust Division, Litigation II, Suite 3000, Washington,

D.C. 20005, (202) 307-0924.

For Defendant Raytheon Company:

Robert D. Paul, Esquire, (D.C. Bar #416314), Michael S. Shuster,

Esquire, White & Case, 601 13th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20005-

3807, (202) 626-3614.

For Defendant Texas Instruments Inc.:

Kathleen L. Ferrell, Esquire, (D.C. Bar #367971), Paul Bartel,

Esquire, Davis, Polk & Wardwell, 450 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY

10017, (212) 450-4760.

It is so ordered by the Court, this ______ day of July, 1997.

______, United States District Judge.

Parties Entitled to Notice of Entry of Order

United States of America:

Department of Justice Antitrust Division, J. Robert Kramer II, Esq.,

Willie L. Hudgins, Esq., Suite 3000, 1401 H Street, N.W.,

Washington, D.C. 20530.

Counsel for Raytheon Company:

Robert D. Paul, Esq., Michael S. Shuster, Esq., White & Case, 601

13th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20005-3807.

Counsel for Texas Instruments Incorporated:

Paul W. Bartel, Esq., Thomas P. Ogden, Esq., Kathleen L.

Ferrell, Davis, Polk & Wardwell, 450 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY

10017.

Hold Separate and Partition Plan Stipulation and Order

It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the undersigned,

subject to approval and entry by the Court, that:

I. Definitions

As used in this Hold Separate and Partition Plan Stipulation and

Order:

A. ``DoD'' means the Department of Defense.

B. ``DOJ'' means the Antitrust Division of the Department of

Justice.

C. ``GaAs'' means gallium arsenide.

D. ``MMIC'' means a Monolithic Microwave Integrated Circuit.

E. ``MMIC Business'' means the GaAs foundry and MMIC business of

the R/F Microwave Business Unit of TI purchased by Raytheon, including

the GaAs Operations Group, Microwave GaAs Products Business Unit, the

MMIC component of the Microwave Integrated Circuits Center of

Excellence, the MMIC research and development component of the System

Components Laboratory, and associated contracting, quality assurance

and control personnel located in the North Building and East Building

of TI's Expressway site, all employees listed in attachment A, and all

assets, including:

1. all tangible assets purchased by Raytheon used in the operation

of the MMIC Business including but not limited to: all real property

(owned or leased), including interests in the North Building and East

Building, used in the operation of that MMIC Business, including

research and development activities; all manufacturing, personal

property, inventory, office furniture, fixed assets and fixtures,

materials, supplies, on-site warehouses or storage facilities, and

other tangible property or improvements used in the operation of the

MMIC Business; all licenses, permits and authorizations issued by any

governmental organization relating to that MMIC Business; all

contracts, teaming arrangements, agreements, leases, commitments and

understandings pertaining to the MMIC Business and its operations;

supply agreements; all customer lists and credit records; and other

records maintained by TI in connection with the MMIC Business;

2. all intangible assets purchased by Raytheon relating to the MMIC

Business, including but not limited to all patents, licenses and

sublicenses, intellectual property, maskwork rights, technical

information, know-how, trade secrets, drawings, blueprints, designs,

design protocols, cell libraries, specifications for materials,

specifications for parts and devices, safety procedures for the

handling of materials and substances, quality assurance and control

procedures, design tools and simulation capability, and all manuals and

technical information TI provides to its own employees, customers,

suppliers, agents or licensees; and

3. all research data concerning historic and current research and

development efforts relating to the MMIC Business, including designs of

experiments, and the results of unsuccessful designs and experiments.

F. ``Raytheon'' means Raytheon Company, a Delaware corporation with

its headquarters and principal place of business in Lexington,

Massaschusetts, and its successors, assigns, subsidiaries, divisions,

groups, affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures, directors

officers, managers, agents, and employees.

G. ``TI'' means defendant Texas Instruments, Inc., a Delaware

corporation with its headquarters and principal place of business in

Dallas, Texas, and its successors, assigns subsidiaries, divisions,

groups, affiliates, partnerships and joint

[[Page 39542]]

ventures, and directors, officers, managers, agents and employees.

II. Objectives

The Final Judgment filed in this case is meant to ensure Raytheon's

prompt divestiture of the MMIC Business for the purposes of creating a

viable competitor in development, production and sale of MMICs used in

advance military radars and to remedy the effects that the United

States alleges would otherwise result from Raytheon's proposed

acquisition of the MMIC Business of TI. This Hold Separate and

Partition Plan Stipulation and Order ensures the timely and complete

transfer of the MMIC Business and maintains the MMIC Business as an

independent, viable competitor until divestiture is complete.

III. Hold Separate Provisions

A. Raytheon and MMIC Business shall expressly undertake to compete

in the MMIC market in the exercise of their best judgments and without

regard to the merger agreement, as if they were in all respects

separate and independent business entities.

B. Raytheon shall preserve, maintain, and operate the MMIC Business

purchased by Raytheon from TI as an independent competitor with

management, research, development, production, sales and operations

held entirely separate, distinct and apart from those of Raytheon.

Raytheon shall not coordinate its production, marketing or sale of

gallium arsenide products with that of the MMIC Business, except to the

limited extent provided in III(D) below. Within fifteen (15) days of

the entering of this Order, Raytheon will inform the DOJ and DoD of the

steps taken to comply with this provision.

C. Raytheon shall take all steps necessary to ensure that the MMIC

Business will be maintained and operated as an independent, ongoing,

economically viable and active competitor in the development,

production and sale of gallium arsenide products, including MMICs, that

the management of the MMIC Business will not be influenced by Raytheon,

and that the books, records, competitively sensitive sales, marketing

and pricing information, and decision-making associated with the MMIC

Business, including the performance and decision-making functions

regarding internal research and development, sales and pricing, will be

kept separate and apart from the business of Raytheon. Raytheon's

influence over the MMIC Business shall be limited to that necessary to

carry out Raytheon's obligations under this Order and the Final

Judgment. Nothing in the provision, however, shall prevent Raytheon

from obtaining information customarily provided in due diligence to

allow Raytheon to determine what technology, intellectual property, and

know-how it may desire to license from the purchaser of the MMIC

Business and to determine whether to contract with the purchaser of the

MMIC Business to produce product for Raytheon.

D. Raytheon shall provide and maintain sufficient working capital

to maintain the MMIC Business as a viable, ongoing business, consistent

with current business plans.

E. Raytheon shall provide and maintain sufficient lines and sources

of credit to maintain the MMIC Business as a viable, ongoing business.

F. Raytheon shall maintain on behalf of the business of the MMIC

Business in accordance with sound accounting practices, separate, true

and complete financial ledgers, books and records reporting the profit

and loss and liabilities of the business on a monthly and quarterly

basis.

G. Raytheon shall use all reasonable efforts to maintain and

increase sales of the MMIC Business, and shall maintain at 1996 or

previously approved levels for 1997, whichever are higher, internal

research and development funding, sales, marketing, and support for

MMIC and module products produced by the MMIC Business.

H. Raytheon shall not sell, lease, assign, transfer or otherwise

dispose of, or pledge as collateral for loans, assets that may be

required to be divested pursuant to the Final Judgment.

I. Raytheon shall preserve the assets that may be required to be

divested pursuant to the Final Judgment in a state of repair equal to

their state of repair as of the date of this Order, ordinary wear and

tear excepted.

J. Nothing in this Order shall prohibit Raytheon from contracting

with the MMIC Business, pursuant to arm's length negotiations, to have

the MMIC Business produce product for Raytheon from any excess capacity

at the foundry of the MMIC Business.

K. Except in the ordinary course of business or as is otherwise

consistent with this Order, defendants shall not transfer or terminate,

or alter, to the detriment of any employee, any current employment or

salary agreements for any MMIC Business employee who, on the date of

entry of this Order, works for the MMIC Business. Defendants shall not

solicit to hire any individual who, on the date of entry of this Order,

was an employee of the MMIC Business. Defendants shall not hire any

individual who, on the date of entry of this Order, was an employee of

the MMIC Business, unless such individual has a written offer of

employment from a third party for a like position.

L. Until such time as this Order is terminated, the MMIC Business

shall be managed by Thomas Cordner. Mr. Cordner shall have complete

managerial responsibility for the MMIC Business, subject to the

provisions of this Order and the Final Judgment. In the event that Mr.

Cordner is unable to perform his duties, Raytheon shall appoint from

the current management of the MMIC Business, subject to the DOJ's

approval, a replacement within ten (10) working days. Should Raytheon

fail to appoint a replacement acceptable to the DOJ within ten (10)

working days, the DOJ, after consultation with DoD, shall appoint a

replacement.

M. Raytheon shall take no action that would interfere with the

ability of any trustee appointed pursuant to the Final Judgment to

complete the divestiture pursuant to the Final Judgment to a suitable

purchaser.

N. This Order shall remain in effect until the divestiture required

by the Final Judgment is complete, or until further Order of the Court.

IV. Partition Plan

A. Defendants are hereby ordered and directed to present a plan to

partition the facilities of the MMIC Business from the facilities of

Raytheon and TI to the DoD and DOJ, within twenty-eight (28) days of

the entry of this Order. In the event the parties are unable to agree

on a partition plan within twenty-eight (28) days of the entry of this

Order, DOJ, in consultation with DoD, may appoint an expert to devise

such a partition plan. The expert shall have the right, in its sole

discretion, to allocate space and equipment between Raytheon, TI and

the MMIC Business. Defendants shall not object to the partitioning plan

devised by the expert on any grounds other than the expert's

malfeasance. The expert shall serve at the cost and expense of

Raytheon. Raytheon shall take no action to interfere with or impede the

expert's partition plan.

B. Raytheon shall ensure to the satisfaction of DoD that the

operations of the MMIC Business, including its support of DoD programs,

not be disrupted.

Dated: July 2, 1997.

For Plaintiff United States of America:

Willie L. Hudgins, Esquire, (D.C. Bar # 37127), U.S. Department

of Justice, Antitrust Division, Litigation II, Suite 3000,

Washington, D.C. 20005, (202) 307-0924.

For Defendant Raytheon Company:

Robert D. Paul, Esquire, (D.C. Bar # 416314), Michael S.

Shuster, Esquire, White

[[Page 39543]]

& Case, 601 13th St., N.W., Washington, D.C. 20005-3807, (202) 626-

3614.

For Defendant Texas Instruments Inc.:

Kathleen L. Ferrell, Esquire, (D.C. Bar # 367971), Paul Bartel,

Esquire, Davis, Polk & Wardwell, 450 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY

10017, (212) 450-4760.

It is so ordered by the Court, this ______ day of July, 1997.

__________, United States District Judge.

Parties Entitled to Notice of Entry of Order

United States of America:

Department of Justice Antitrust Division, J. Robert Kramer II, Esq.,

Willie L. Hudgins, Esq., Suite 3000, 1401 H Street, N.W.,

Washington, DC 20530.

Counsel for Raytheon Company:

Robert D. Paul. Esq., Michael S. Shuster, Esq., White & Case, 601

13th St., N.W., Washington, DC 20005-3807.

Counsel for Texas Instruments Incorporated:

Paul W. Bartel, Esq., Thomas P. Ogden, Esq., Kathleen L. Ferrell,

Davis, Polk & Wardell, 450 Lexington Ave., New York, NY 10017.

Final Judgment

Whereas, plaintiff, the United States of America, and defendants

Raytheon Company (``Raytheon'') and Texas Instruments, Inc. (``TI''),

by their respective attorneys, having consented to the entry of this

Final Judgment without trial or adjudication of any issue of fact or

law herein, and without this Final Judgment constituting any evidence

against or an admission by any party with respect to any issue of law

or fact herein;

And whereas, defendants have agreed to be bound by the provisions

of this Final Judgment pending its approval by the Court;

And whereas, the essence of this Final Judgment is the prompt and

certain divestiture of the gallium arsenide foundry and MMIC business

of TI to assure that competition is not substantially lessened;

And whereas, plaintiff requires defendants to make certain

divestitures for the purpose of establishing a viable competitor in the

development, production and sale of X-band high power amplifier MMICs;

And whereas, defendants have represented to the plaintiff that the

divestitures ordered herein can and will be made and that defendants

will later raise no claims of hardship or difficulty as grounds for

asking the Court to modify any of the divestiture provisions contained

below;

Now, therefore, before the taking of any testimony, and without

trial or adjudication of any issue of fact or law herein, and upon

consent of the parties hereto, it is hereby ordered, adjudged, and

decreed as follows:

I. Jurisdiction

This Court has jurisdiction over each of the parties hereto and

over the subject matter of this action. The Complaint states a claim

upon which relief may be granted against defendants as hereinafter

defined, under Section 7 of the Clayton Act, as amended (15 U.S.C

Sec. 18).

II. Definitions

As used in this Final Judgment:

A. ``DoD'' means the Department of Defense.

B. ``DOI'' means the Antitrust Division of the Department of

Justice.

C. ``GaAs'' means gallium arsenide.

D. ``MMIC'' means a Monolithic Microwave Integrated Circuit.

E. ``MMIC Business'' means the GaAs foundry and MMIC business of

the R/F Microwave Business Unit of TI purchased by Raytheon, including

the GaAs Operations Group, Microwave GaAs Products Business Unit, the

MMIC component of the Microwave Integrated Circuits Center of

Excellence, the MMIC research and development component of the System

Components Laboratory and associated contracting, quality assurance and

control personnel located in the North Building and East Building of

TI's Expressway site, all employees listed in attachment A, and all

assets, including:

1. all tangible assets purchased by Raytheon used in the operation

of the MMIC Business including but not limited to: all real property

(owned or leased), including interests in the North Building and East

building, used in the operation of that MMIC Business, including

research and development activities, as identified pursuant to the

Court's Hold Separate and Partition Plan Stipulation and Order; all

manufacturing, personal property, inventory, office furniture, fixed

assets and fixtures, materials, supplies, on-site warehouses or storage

facilities, and other tangible property or improvements used in the

operation of the MMIC Business; all licenses, permits and

authorizations issued by any governmental organization relating to that

MMIC Business; all contracts, teaming arrangements, agreements, leases,

commitments and understandings pertaining to the MMIC Business and its

operations; supply agreements; all customer lists and credit records;

and other records maintained by TI in connection with the MMIC

Business;

2. all intangible assets purchased by Raytheon relating to the MMIC

Business, including but not limited to all patents, licenses and

sublicenses, intellectual property, maskwork rights, technical

information, know-how, trade secrets, drawings, blueprints, designs,

design protocols, cell libraries, specifications for materials,

specifications for parts and devices, safety procedures for the

handling of materials and substances, quality assurance and control

procedures, design tools and simulation capability, and all manuals and

technical information TI provides to its own employees, customers,

suppliers, agents or licensee; and

3. all research data concerning historic and current research and

development efforts relating to the MMIC Business, including designs of

experiments, and the results of unsuccessful designs and experiments.

F. ``Module Business'' means the transmit and receive module

business of the R/F Microwave Business Unit of TI purchased by

Raytheon, including the R/F Microwave Manufacturing Group, Microwave

Module & Subsystems Center for Excellence Microwave Packaging Center

for Excellence, Microwave Laboratories and Support Systems Center for

Excellence, Technology Programs Customer Product Team, module component

of the Microwave Integrated Circuits Center for Excellence, and

associated contracting, quality assurance and control personnel located

in the North Building of TI's Expressway site, and all assets,

including:

1. all tangible assets purchased by Raytheon used in the operation

of the Module Business including but not limited to: all real property

(owned or leased), including interests in the North Building, used in

the operation of that Module Business, including research and

development activities; all manufacturing, personal property,

inventory, office furniture, fixed assets and fixtures, materials,

supplies, on-site warehouses or storage facilities, and other tangible

property or improvements used in the operation of the Module Business;

all licenses, permits and authorizations issued by any governmental

organization relating to that Module Business; all contracts, teaming

arrangements, agreements, leases, commitments and understandings

pertaining to the Module Business and its operations; supply

agreements; all customer lists and credit records; and other records

maintained by TI in connection with the Module Business;

2. all intangible assets purchased by Raytheon relating to the

Module Business, excluding information relating to TI's MMIC Business,

and otherwise including but not limited to all patents,

[[Page 39544]]

licenses and sublicenses, intellectual property, technical information,

know-how, trade secrets, drawings, blueprints, designs, design

protocols, specifications for materials, specifications for parts and

devices, safety procedures for the handling of material and substances,

quality assurance and control procedures, design tools and simulation

capability, and all manuals and technical information TI provides to

its own employees, customers, suppliers agents or licensee; and

3. all research data concerning historic and current research and

development efforts relating to the Module Business, including design

of experiments, and the results of unsuccessful designs and

experiments.

G. ``Raytheon'' means Raytheon Company, a Delaware corporation with

its headquarters and principal place of business in Lexington,

Massachusetts, and its successors, assigns, subsidiaries, divisions,

groups, affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures, and directors,

officers, managers, agents, and employees.

H. ``TI'' means defendant Texas Instruments, Inc., a Delaware

corporation with its headquarters and principal place of business in

Dallas, Texas, and its successors, assigns, subsidiaries, divisions,

groups, affiliates, partnerships and joint ventures, and directors,

officers, managers, agents and employees.

III. Applicability

A. The provisions of this Final Judgment apply to Raytheon, its

successors and assigns, their subsidiaries, directors, officers,

managers, agents, and employees, and all other persons in active

concert or participation with any of them who shall have received

actual notice of this Final Judgment by personal service or otherwise.

B. Raytheon shall require, as a condition of the sale or other

disposition of all or substantially all of its assets or of a lesser

business unit that includes Raytheon's business of developing and

producing MMICs, that the transferee agree to be bound by the

provisions of this Final Judgment.

IV. Divestiture

A. Raytheon is hereby ordered and directed in accordance with the

terms of this Final Judgment, within one hundred and eighty (180)

calendar days after the filing of the Complaint in this matter, or five

(5) days after notice of the entry of this Final Judgment by the Court,

whichever is later, to divest the MMIC Business to an acquirer

acceptable to DOJ and DoD in their sole discretion.

B. Raytheon shall use its best efforts to accomplish the

divestiture as expeditiously and timely as possible. DOJ in its sole

determination, in consultation with DoD, may extend the time period for

any divestiture an additional period of time not to exceed thirty (30)

calendar days.

C. In accomplishing the divestiture ordered by this Final Judgment,

Raytheon promptly shall make known, by usual and customary means, the

availability of the MMIC Business described in this Final Judgment.

Raytheon shall inform any person making an inquiry regarding a possible

purchase that the sale is being made pursuant to this Final Judgment

and provide such person with a copy of this Final Judgment. Raytheon

shall also offer to furnish to all bona fide prospective purchasers,

subject to customary confidentially assurances, all information

regarding the MMIC Business customarily provided in a due diligence

process except such information subject to attorney-client privilege or

attorney work product privilege Raytheon shall make available such

information to the DOJ at the same time that such information is made

available to any other person.

D. Raytheon shall permit prospective purchasers of the MMIC

Business to have reasonable access to personnel and to make such

inspection of the physical facilities of the MMIC Business and any and

all Financial, Operational, or other documents and information

customarily provided as part of a due diligence process.

E. Raytheon shall not take any action that will impede in any way

the operation of the MMIC Business.

F. Unless both DOJ and DoD otherwise consent in writing, the

divestiture pursuant to Section IV, or by trustee appointed pursuant to

Section V of this Final Judgment, shall include the entire MMIC

Business, operated in place pursuant to the Hold Separate and Partition

Plan Stipulation and Order, and be accomplished by selling or otherwise

conveying the MMIC Business to a purchaser in such a way as to satisfy

DOJ and DoD, in their sole discretion, that the MMIC Business can and

will be used by the purchaser as part of a viable, ongoing business or

businesses engaged in the development, production and sale of MMICs.

The divestiture, whether pursuant to Section IV or Section V of this

Final Judgment, shall be made to a purchaser for whom it is

demonstrated to DOJs and DoD sole satisfaction: (1) Has the capability

and intent of competing effectively in the development, production and

sale of MMICs for advanced DoD radar systems; (2) has the managerial,

operational, and financial capability to complete effectively in the

development, production and sale of MMICs for advanced DoD radar

systems; (3) is eligible to receive applicable DoD security clearances;

and (4) that none of the terms of any agreement between the purchaser

and Raytheon give Raytheon the ability unreasonably to raise the

purchasers costs, to lower the purchasers' efficiency, or otherwise to

interfere in the ability of the purchaser to complete effectively.

Subject to these provisions, nothing in this Final Judgment shall

prohibit TI from seeking to re-acquire the MMIC Business from Raytheon.

G. Nothing in this Final Judgment shall prevent Raytheon and the

purchaser of the MMIC Business from entering into a contract under

which the purchaser would produce product for Raytheon using any

capacity of the MMIC Business not required to support DoD programs. In

addition, nothing in this Final Judgment shall prevent Raytheon from

licensing technology or know-how from the purchaser.

H. For a period two years from the filing of the Complaint in this

matter, defendants shall not solicit to hire any individual who, on the

date of the filing of the Complaint in this matter, with an employee of

the MMIC Business, For a period of two years from the filing of the

Complaint in this matter, defendants shall not hire any individual who,

on the date of the filing of the Complaint in this matter, was an

employee of the MMIC business unless such individual has a written

offer of employment from a third party for alike position.

I. Raytheon shall comply with all agreements with DoD regarding the

protection of information related to classified programs.

J. Raytheon shall not charge to DoD any costs directly or

indirectly incurred in complying with this Final Judgment.

V. Appointment of Trustee

A. In the event that Raytheon has not divested the MMIC Business

within the time specified in Section IV of this Final Judgment, the

Court shall appoint, on application of the United States, a trustee

selected by DOJ, in consultation with DoD, to effect the-divestiture of

the MMIC Business.

B. After the appointment of a trustee becomes effective, only the

trustee shall have the right to sell the MMIC Business described in

Section II(E) of this Final Judgment. The trustee shall have the power

and authority to accomplish the divesture at the best price then

[[Page 39545]]

obtainable upon a reasonable effort by the trustee, subject to the

provision of sections IV and VIII of this Final Judgment, and shall

have such other powers as the Court shall deem appropriate. The trustee

shall have the right, in its sole discretion, to include in the package

of assets to be divested the Module Business; in such event all of the

obligations and of Raytheon under Section IV of this Final Judgment

shall apply to the Module Business as well. Subject to Section V(C) of

this Final Judgment, the trustee shall have the power and authority to

hire at the cost and expense of Raytheon any investment bankers,

attorneys, or other agents reasonably necessary in the judgment of the

truest to assist in the divestiture, and such professionals and agents

shall be accountable solely to the trustee. The trustee shall have the

power and authority to accomplish the divestiture at the earliest

possible time to a purchaser acceptable to the DOJ and DoD, and shall

have such other powers as this Court shall deem appropriate. Raytheon

shall not object to a sale by the trustee on any grounds other than the

trustee's malfeasance. Any such objections by Raytheon must be conveyed

in writing to DOJ and the trustee within ten (10) calendar days after

the trustee has provided the notice required under Section VI of this

Final Judgment.

C. The trustee shall serve at the cost and expense of Raytheon, on

such terms and conditions as the Court may prescribe, and shall account

for all monies derived from the sale of the assets sold by the trustee

and all costs and expenses so incurred. After approval by the Court of

the trustee's accounting, including fees for its services and those of

any professionals and agents retained by the trustee, all remaining

money shall be paid to Raytheon and the trust shall then be terminated.

The compensation of such trustee and of any professionals and agents

retained by the trustee shall be reasonable in light of the value of

the divested business and based on a fee arrangement providing the

trustee with an incentive based on the price and terms of the

divestiture and the speed with which it is accomplished.

D. Raytheon shall use its best efforts to assist the trustee in

accomplishing the required divestiture, including best efforts to

affect all necessary regulatory approvals. The trustee and any

consultants, accountants, attorneys, and other persons retained by the

trustee shall have full and complete access to the personnel, books,

records, and facilities of the business to be divested, and Raytheon

shall develop financial or other information relevant to the business

to be divested customarily provided in a due diligence process as the

trustee may reasonably request, subject to customary confidentiality

assurances. Raytheon shall permit bona fide prospective acquirers of

the assets to have reasonable access to personnel and to make such

inspection of physical facilities and any and all financial,

operational or other documents and other information as may be relevant

to the divestiture required by this Final Judgment.

E. After its appointment, the trustee shall file monthly reports

with the parties and the Court setting forth the trustee's efforts to

accomplish the divestiture ordered under this Final Judgment; provided,

however, that to the extent such reports contain information that the

trustee deems confidential, such reports shall not be filed in the

public docket of the court. Such reports shall include the name,

address and telephone number of each person who, during the preceding

month, made an offer to acquire, expressed an interest in acquiring,

entered into negotiations to acquire, or was contacted or made an

inquiry about acquiring, any interest in the business to be divested,

and shall describe in detail each contact with any such person during

that period. The trustee shall maintain full records of all efforts

made to divest the business to be divested.

F. If the trustee has not accomplished such divestiture within six

(6) months after its appointment, the trustee thereupon shall file

promptly with the Court a report setting forth (1) The trustee's

efforts to accomplish the required divestiture, (2) the reasons, in the

trustee's judgment, why the required divestiture has not been

accomplished, and (3) the trustee's recommendations; provided, however,

that to the extent such reports contain information that the trustee

deems confidential, such reports shall not be filed in the public

docket of the Court. The trustee shall at the same time furnish such

report to the parties, who shall each have the right to be heard and to

make additional recommendations consistent with the purpose of the

trust. The Court shall enter thereafter such orders as it shall deem

appropriate in order to carry out the purpose of the trust which may,

if necessary, include extending the trust and the term of the trustee's

appointment by a period requested by DOJ.

VI. Notification

Within two (2) business days following execution of a definitive

agreement, contingent upon compliance with the terms of this Final

Judgment, to effect, in whole or in part, any proposed divestiture

pursuant to Sections IV or V of this Final Judgment, Raytheon or the

trustee, whichever is then responsible for effecting the divestiture,

shall notify DOJ and DoD of the proposed divestiture. If the trustee is

responsible, it shall similarly notify Raytheon. The notice shall set

forth the details of the proposed transaction and list the name,

address, and telephone number of each person previously identified who

offered to, or expressed an interest in or a desire to, acquire any

ownership interest in the business to be divested that is the subject

of the binding contract, together with full details of same. Within

fifteen (15) calendar days of receipt by DOJ and DoD of such notice,

DOJ, in consultation with DoD, may request from Raytheon, the proposed

purchaser, or any other third party additional information concerning

the proposed divestiture and the proposed purchaser. Raytheon and the

trustee shall furnish any additional information requested from them

within fifteen (15) calendar days of the receipt of the request, unless

the parties shall otherwise agree. Within thirty (30) calendar days

after receipt of the notice or within twenty (20) calendar days after

the DOJ has been provided the additional information requested from

Raytheon, the proposed purchaser, and any third party, whichever is

later, DOJ and DoD shall each provide written notice to Raytheon and

the trustee, if there is one, stating whether or not it objects to the

proposed divestiture. If DOJ and DoD provide written notice to Raytheon

and the trustee that they do not object, then the divestiture may be

consummated, subject only to Raytheon's limited right to object to the

sale under Section V(B) of this Final Judgment. Absent written notice

that DOJ and DoD do not object to the proposed purchaser or upon

objection by DOJ or DoD, a divestiture proposed under Section IV or

Section V may be consummated. Upon objection by Raytheon under the

provision in Section V(B), a divestiture proposed under Section V shall

not be consummated unless approved by the Court.

VII. Affidavits

A. Within twenty (20) calendar days of the filing of the Complaint

in this matter and every thirty (30) calendar days thereafter until the

divestiture has been completed whether pursuant to Section IV or

Section V of this Final Judgment, Raytheon shall deliver to DOJ and DoD

an affidavit as to the fact and manner of compliance with Sections IV

or V of this Final Judgment. Each such

[[Page 39546]]

affidavit shall include, inter alia, the name, address, and telephone

number of each person who, at any time after the period covered by the

last such report, made an offer to acquire, expressed an interest in

acquiring, entered into negotiations to acquire, or was contacted or

made an inquiry about acquiring, any interest in the business to be

divested, and shall describe in detail each contact with any such

person during that period. Each such affidavit shall also include a

description of the efforts that Raytheon has taken to solicit a buyer

for the relevant assets and to provide required information to

prospective purchasers including the limitations, if any, on such

information. Assuming the information set forth in the affidavit is

true and complete, any objection by DOJ to information provided by

Raytheon, including limitations on information, shall be made within

fourteen (14) days of receipt of such affidavit.

B. Within twenty (20) calendar days of the filing of the Complaint

in this matter, Raytheon shall deliver to DOJ and DoD an affidavit

which describes in detail all actions Raytheon has taken and all steps

Raytheon has implemented on an on-going basis to preserve the MMIC

Business pursuant to Section VIII of this Final Judgment and the Hold

Separate and Partition Order entered by the Court. The affidavit also

shall describe, but not be limited to, Raytheon's efforts to maintain

and operate the MMIC Business as an active competitor, maintain the

management, staffing, research and development activities, sales,

marketing and pricing of the MMIC Business, and maintain the MMIC

Business in operable condition at current capacity configurations.

Raytheon shall deliver to DOJ and DoD an affidavit describing any

changes to the efforts and actions outlined in Raytheon's earlier

affidavit(s) filed pursuant to this Section within fifteen (15)

calendar days after the change is implemented.

C. Until one year after such divestiture has been completed,

Raytheon shall preserve all records of all efforts made to preserve the

business to be divested and effect the divestiture.

VIII. Hold Separate Order

Until the divestitures required by the Final Judgment have been

accomplished, Raytheon shall take all steps necessary to comply with

the Hold Separate and Partition Plan Stipulation and Order entered by

this Court and to preserve the assets of the Module Business.

Defendants shall take no action that would jeopardize the divestiture

ordered by this Court.

IX. Financing

Raytheon is ordered and directed not to finance all or any part of

any purchase by an acquirer made pursuant to Sections IV or V of this

Final Judgment without prior written consent of DOJ.

X. Compliance Inspection

For purposes of determining or securing compliance with the Final

Judgment and subject to any legally recognized privilege, from time to

time:

A. Duly authorized representatives of the United States Department

of Justice, upon written request of the Attorney General or of the

Assistant Attorney General in charge of the Antitrust Division, and on

reasonable notice to Raytheon made to its principal offices, shall be

permitted:

1. Access during office hours of Raytheon to inspect and copy all

books, ledgers, accounts, correspondence, memoranda, and other records

and documents in the possession or under the control of Raytheon, who

may have counsel present, relating to the matters contained in this

Final Judgment and the Hold Separate Stipulation and Order; and

2. Subject to the reasonable convenience of Raytheon and without

restraint or interference from it, to interview, either informally or

on the record, its officers, employees, and agents, who may have

counsel present, regarding any such matters.

B. Upon the written request of the Attorney General or of the

Assistant Attorney General in charge of the Antitrust Division, made to

Raytheon's principal offices, Raytheon shall submit such written

reports, under oath if requested, with respect to any matter contained

in the Final Judgment and the Hold Separate and Partition Order.

C. No information or documents obtained by the means provided in

Sections VII or X of this Final Judgment shall be divulged by a

representative of the plaintiff to any person other than a duly

authorized representative of the Executive Branch of the United States,

except in the course of legal proceedings to which the United States is

a party (including grand jury proceedings), or for the purpose of

securing compliance with this Final Judgment, or as otherwise required

by law.

D. If at the time information or documents are furnished by

Raytheon to DOJ or DoD, Raytheon represents and identifies in writing

the material in any such information or documents to which a claim of

protection may be asserted under Rule 26(c)(7) of the Federal Rules of

Civil Procedure, and Raytheon marks each pertinent page of such

material, ``Subject to claim of protection under Rule 26(c)(7) of the

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure,'' then ten (10) calendar days notice

shall be given by DOJ or DoD to Raytheon prior to divulging such

material in any legal proceeding (other than a grand jury proceeding)

to which Raytheon is not a party.

XI. Retention of Jurisdiction

Jurisdiction is retained by this Court for the purpose of enabling

any of the parties to this Final Judgment to apply to this Court at any

time for such further order and directions as may be necessary or

appropriate for the construction or carrying out this Final Judgment,

for the modification of any of the provisions hereof, for the

enforcement of compliance herewith, and for the punishment of any

violations hereof.

XII. Termination

Unless this Court grants an extension, this Final Judgment will

expire upon the tenth anniversary of the date of its entry.

XIII. Public Interest

Entry of this Final Judgment is in the public interest.

Dated__________, 1997.

__________, United States District Judge.

Competitive Impact Statement

The United States, pursuant to Section 2(b) of the Antitrust

Procedures and Penalties Act (``APPA''), 15 U.S.C. Sec. 16(b)-(h),

files this Competitive Impact Statement relating to the proposed Final

Judgment submitted for entry in this civil antitrust proceeding.

I. Nature and Purpose of the Proceeding

On July 2, 1997, the United States filed a civil antitrust

Complaint alleging that the proposed acquisition by Raytheon Company

(``Raytheon'') of the Defense Systems and Electronics Unit (``DS&E'')

of Texas Instruments (``TI'') would violate Section 7 of the Clayton

Act, 15 U.S.C. Sec. 18. The Complaint alleges that Raytheon and TI are

the only two firms that are now in a position to develop and produce an

essential input required in state-of-the-art military radar systems

that will cost the Department of Defense about $10 billion. These

inputs are X-band high power amplifier monolithic microwave integrated

circuits (``MMICs''). Raytheon is also a leading producer of radar

systems. TI, on the other hand, is an independent supplier of MMICs,

often supplying them to Raytheon's radar system competitors.

[[Page 39547]]

As described in the Complaint, since X-band high power amplifier

MMICs are purchased by domestic radar producers for inclusion in weapon

systems sold to the Department of Defense, and there are no foreign

producers to which domestic radar producers could reasonably turn to

purchase these MMICs, the relevant geographic market is the United

States.

The prayer for relief in the Complaint seeks: (1) a judgment that

the proposed acquisition would violate Section 7 of the Clayton Act;

and (2) a permanent injunction preventing Raytheon from acquiring DS&E.

When the Complaint was filed, the United States also filed a

proposed settlement that would permit Raytheon to complete its

acquisition of DS&E, but require a divestiture and other terms that

will preserve competition in the relevant market. This settlement

consists of a Stipulation and Order, Hold Separate and Partition Plan

Stipulation and Order, and a proposed Final Judgment.

The proposed Final Judgment orders Raytheon to divest, within one

hundred and eighty (180) calendar days after the filings of the

Complaint in this matter, or five (5) days after notice of the entry of

the Final Judgment by the Court, whichever is later, the MMIC Business

(as defined in the Final Judgment) of DS&E to an acquirer acceptable to

the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice (``DOJ'') and the

Department of Defense (``DoD''). TI's MMIC Business includes its

commercial and defense MMICs, a gallium arsenide foundry, and all

tangible and intangible assets used by TI in the operation of its MMIC

Business. Raytheon is also required to divest the Module Business (as

defined in the Final Judgment) of DS&E if a trustee deems the sale of

this business is necessary to perfect a sale of the MMIC Business.

Until such divestiture is completed, the terms of the Hold Separate

and Partition Plan Stipulation and Order entered into by the parties

apply to ensure that the MMIC Business of DS&E shall be maintained as

an independent competitor from Raytheon.

The plaintiff and defendants have stipulated that the proposed

Final Judgment may be entered after compliance with the APPA. Entry of

the proposed Final Judgment would terminate the action, except that the

Court would retain jurisdiction to construe, modify, or enforce the

provisions of the proposed Final Judgment and to punish violations

thereof.

II. Description of the Events Giving Rise to the Alleged Violation

A. The Defendants and the Proposed Transaction

Raytheon is a Delaware corporation headquartered in Lexington,

Massachusetts. Raytheon produces aircraft, guided missiles, space

vehicles, and defense electronics equipment. It develops and produces

high power amplifier MMICs for military radars as its Advanced Device

Center in Andover, Massachusetts. In 1996, Raytheon reported total

sales of about $12 billion. Raytheon is also a leading designer and

producer of radar systems.

TI is a Delaware corporation headquartered in Dallas, Texas. In

1996, TI reported total sales of about $13 billion. Its DS&E unit

produces guided missiles, electro-optical systems, and defense

electronics equipment. DS&E develops and produces high power amplifier

MMICs for military radars through its R/F Microwave Business Unit at a

facility in Dallas, Texas. In 1996, DS&E reported total sales of about

$1.3 billion.

On January 4, 1997, Raytheon entered into an agreement with TI to

purchase DS&E. This transaction, which would, in part, take place in

the highly concentrated high power amplifier MMIC market, precipitated

the government's suit.

B. MMIC Market

High power amplifier MMICs are solid state semiconductor components

(commonly referred to as ``chips'') made of gallium arsenide and used

in active electronically scanned array (``AESA'') radars MMICs are

designed to operate within specified frequency ranges or bands of the

microwave spectrum. Military AESA radars demand the highest performance

MMICs typically those operating in that part of the spectrum called the

X-band, because this band offers the best combination of all-weather

capability and ability to detect low-level targets. Because of the

importance of the X-band high power amplifier MMIC to the performance

of an AESA radar, the performance of these MMICs is important selection

criterion among competing radar systems.

Raytheon has produced more high power amplifier MMICs and modules

than any other firm, and TI is the recognized leader in developing high

power amplifier MMICs. The two companies are the only firms capable of

developing and producing the high power amplifier MMICs required for

military radar bids scheduled for the next two to three years. In the

next two to three years, radar programs worth over $10 billion will be

competed. The radars for these programs will all require X-band high

power amplifier MMICs. TI and Raytheon are the only firms that have

established production processes and proven manufacturing capability

for these high power amplifier MMICs.

Raytheon's acquisition of TI's DS&E, including the MMICs Business,

would have eliminated competition in the development, production, and

sale of X-band high power amplifier MMICs for military radars being

developed over the next two to three years. The proposed acquisition

would have resulted in a single supplier with the incentive and ability

to raise prices and little or no incentive to minimize cost.

The acquisition also likely would have resulted in a lessening of

competition in the market for military radars. Raytheon is not only a

supplier of high power amplifier MMICs but is also a major supplier of

the radar systems of which these devices are critical components. Prior

to announcement of the acquisition. TI had teamed with other radar

systems suppliers to develop MMICs that met the required specifications

for DoD weapon systems. If it acquired the MMIC Business, Raytheon

would have controlled access to all currently viable high power

amplifier MMICs. Without access to the latest high power amplifier

MMICs, a radar manufacturer would be at a serious disadvantage for

upcoming military radar competitions.

Successful entry into the production and sale of high power

amplifier MMICs is difficult, time consuming, and costly. Entry

requires advanced technology, skilled engineers, and costly customized

equipment. A new gallium arsenide foundry costs $50-100 million and

takes at least two years to construct. A potential entrant would have

to engage in difficult, expensive, and time consuming research to

develop designs and production processes that can economically and

reliably produce high power amplifier MMICs. These designs and

production processes must be perfected in order to bid successfully for

a military radar program.

Because the high power amplifier MMIC is a crucial input of the

radar system, there are no reasonable substitutes to which customers

could switch in the event of a small, but significant and non-

transitory price increase.

C. Harm to Competition As A Consequence of the Acquisition

Raytheon's acquisition of DS&E's MMIC Business would eliminate

[[Page 39548]]

competition in the research, development, and production of high power

amplifier MMICs necessary to military weapons systems in the United

States.

If Raytheon acquired the MMIC Business of DS&E, the current two

producers of high power amplifier MMICs in the United States would be

reduced to one. Entry by a new company would not be timely, likely or

sufficient to prevent harm to competition.

The Complaint alleges that the transaction would have the following

effects, among others: competition generally in the innovation,

development, production, and sale of high power amplifier MMICs for

military radars in the United States would be lessened substantially;

actual and future competition between Raytheon and TI in the

development, production and sale of high power amplifier MMICs for

military radars in the United States will be eliminated; prices for

high power amplifier MMICs for military radars in the United States

would likely increase; and competition generally in development,

production and sale of military radars in the United States would be

lessened substantially.

III. Explanation of the Proposed Final Judgment

The provisions of the proposed Final Judgment are designed to

eliminate the anticompetitive effects of the acquisition of DS&E's MMIC

Business by Raytheon.

The proposed Final Judgment provides that Raytheon must divest,

within one hundred and eighty (180) calendar days after the filing of

the Complaint in this matter, or five (5) days after notice of the

entry of the Final Judgment by the Court, whichever is later, the MMIC

Business of DS&E to an acquirer acceptable to the DOJ and DoD. If

defendants fail to divest the MMIC Business, a trustee (selected by DOJ

in consultation with DoD) will be appointed. The trustee will be

authorized to sell, in his or her sole discretion, the MMIC Business.

In addition, the trustee shall have the right, in his or her sole

discretion, to include in the package of assets to be divested the

Module Business, if sale of the Module Business is necessary to perfect

a sale of the MMIC Business.

The Final Judgment provides that Raytheon will pay all costs and

expenses of the trustee. After his or her appointment becomes

effective, the trustee will file monthly reports with the parties and

the Court, setting forth the trustee's efforts to accomplish

divestiture. At the end of six months, if the divestiture has not been

accomplished, the trustee and the parties will make recommendations to

the Court, which shall enter such orders as appropriate in order to

carry out the purpose of the trust, including extending the trust or

the term of the trustee's appointment.

Divestiture of the MMIC Business preserves competition because it

will restore the high power amplifier MMIC market to a structure that

existed prior to the acquisition and will preserve the existence of an

independent competitor. Divestiture will keep at least two producers of

high power amplifier MMICs in the market competing for upcoming AESA

radar programs, which will preserve and encourage ongoing competition

in product innovation and development, production, and sales.

Divestiture will also prevent radar system manufacturers from being

foreclosed from a critical input and thus will preserve competition in

upcoming military radar programs.

IV. Remedies Available to Potential Private Litigants

Section 4 of the Clayton Act (15 U.S.C. 15) provides that any

person who has been injured as a result of conduct prohibited by the

antitrust laws may bring suit in federal court to recover three times

the damages the person has suffered, as well as costs and reasonable

attorneys' fees. Entry of the proposed Final Judgment will neither

impair nor assist the bringing of any private antitrust damage action.

Under the provisions of Section 5(a) of the Clayton Act (15 U.S.C.

16(a)), the proposed Final Judgment has no prima facie effect in any

subsequent private lawsuit that may be brought against defendants.

V. Procedures Available for Modification of the Proposed Final Judgment

The United States and defendants have stipulated that the proposed

Final Judgment may be entered by the Court after compliance with the

provisions of the APPA, provided that the United States has not

withdrawn its consent. The APPA conditions entry upon the Court's

determination that the proposed Final Judgment is in the public

interest.

The APPA provides a period of at least 60 days preceding the

effective date of the proposed Final Judgment within which any person

may submit to the United States written comments regarding the proposed

Final Judgment. Any person who wishes to comment should do so within

sixty (60) days of the date of publication of this Competitive Impact

Statement in the Federal Register. The United States will evaluate and

respond to the comments. All comments will be given due consideration

by the Department of Justice, which remains free to withdraw its

consent to the proposed Judgment at any time prior to entry. The

comments and the response of the United States will be filed with the

Court and published in the Federal Register. Written comments should be

submitted to: J. Robert Kramer II, Chief, Litigation II Section,

Antitrust Division, United States Department of Justice, 1401 H Street,

NW., Suite 3000, Washington, DC 20530.

The proposed Final Judgment provides that the Court retains

jurisdiction over this action, and the parties may apply to the Court

for any order necessary or appropriate for the modification,

interpretation, or enforcement of the Final Judgment.

VI. Alternatives to the Proposed Final Judgment

The United States considered, as an alternative to the proposed

Final Judgment, a full trial on the merits against defendants Raytheon

and TI. The United States could have brought suit and sought

preliminary and permanent injunctions against Raytheon's acquisition.

The United States also considered a settlement involving the licensing

of MMIC technology to one or more firms. The United States determined,

however, that such a proposal would not fully protect competition for

important radar projects over the next several years.

United States is satisfied that the divestiture of the described

assets and the other terms specified in the proposed Final Judgment

will encourage viable competition in the research, development, and

production of high power amplifier MMICs. The United States is

satisfied that the proposed relief will prevent the acquisition from

having anticompetitive effects in this market. The divestiture of the

MMIC Business and the other proposed terms will restore the high power

amplifier MMIC market to a structure that existed prior to the

acquisition and will preserve the existence of an independent

competitor.

VII. Standard of Review Under the APPA for Proposed Final Judgment

The APPA requires that proposed consent judgment in antitrust cases

brought by the United States be subject to a sixty-day comment period,

after which the court shall determine whether entry of the proposed

Final Judgment ``is the public interest.'' In making that

determination, the court may consider--

[[Page 39549]]

(1) the competitive impact of such judgment, including termination

of alleged violations, provisions for enforcement and modification,

duration or relief sought, anticipated effects of alternative remedies

actually considered, and any other considerations bearing upon the

adequacy of such judgment;

(2) the impact of entry of such judgment upon the public generally

and individuals alleging specific injury from the violations set forth

in the complaint including consideration of the public benefit, if any,

to be derived from a determination of the issues at trail.

15 U.S.C. Sec. 16(e) (emphasis added). As the Court of Appeals for the

District of Columbia Circuit recently held, the APPA permits a court to

consider, among other things, the relationship between the remedy

secured and the specific allegations set forth in the government's

complaint, whether the decree is sufficiently clear, whether

enforcement mechanisms are sufficient, and whether the decree may

positively harm third parties. See United States v. Microsoft, 56 F.3d

1448 (D.C. Cir. 1995).

In conduction this injury, ``the Court is nowhere compelled to go

to trial or to engage in extended proceedings which might have the

effect of vitiating the benefits of prompt and less costly settlement

through the consent decree process.'' \1\ Rather, absent a showing of

corrupt failure of the government to discharge its duty, the Court, in

making its public interest finding, should . . . carefully consider the

explanations of the government in the competitive impact statement and

its responses to comments in order to determine whether those

explanations are reasonable under the circumstances.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ 119 Cong. Rec. 24598 (1973). See also United States v.

Gillete Co., 406 F. Supp. 713, 715 (D. Mass. 1975). A ``public

interest'' determination can be made properly on the basis of the

Competitive Impact Statement and Response to Comments filed pursuant

to the APPA. Although the APPA authorizes the use of additional

procedures, 15 U.S.C. Sec. 16(f), those procedures are

discretionary. A court need not invoke any of them unless it

believes that the comments have raised significant issues and that

further proceedings would aid the court in resolving those issues.

See H.R. 93-1463, 93rd Cong. 2d Sess. 8-9, reprinted in (1974) U.S.

Code Cong. & Ad. News 6535, 6538.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

United States v. Mid-America Dairymen, Inc., 1977-1 Trace Cas

para.61.508, at 71.980 (W.D. Mo. 1977).

Accordingly, with respect to the adequacy of the relief secured by

the decree, a court may not ``engage in an unrestricted evaluation of

what relief would best serve the public.'' United States v. BNS, Inc.,

858 F.2d 456, 462 (9th Cir. 1988), quoting United States v. Bechtel

Corp., 648 F.2d 660,666 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 454 U.S. 1083 (1981);

see also, Microsoft, 56 F.3d 1448 (D.C. Cir. 1995). Precedent requires

that

[t]he balancing of competing social and political interests affected

by a proposed antitrust consent decree must be left, in the first

instance, to the discretion of the Attorney General. The court's

role in protecting the public interest is one of insuring that the

government has not breached its duty to the pubic in consenting to

the decree. The court is required to determine not whether a

particular decree is the one that will best serve society, but

whether the settlement is `within the reaches of the public

interest,' More elaborate requirements might undermine the

effectiveness of antitrust enforcement by consent decree.\2\

\2\ United States v. Bechtel, 648 F.2d at 666 (internal

citations omitted) (emphasis added); see United States v. BNS, Inc.,

858 F.2d at 463; United States v. National Broadcasting Co., 449 F.

Supp. 1127, 1143 (C.D. Cal. 1978); United States v. Gillette Co.,

406 F. Supp. at 716. See also United States v. American Cyanamid

Co., 719 F.2d 558, 565 (2d Cir. 1983).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The proposed Final Judgment, therefore, should not be reviewed

under a standard of whether it is certain to eliminate every

anticompetitive effect of a particular practice or whether it mandates

certainly of free competition in the future. Court approval of a final

judgment requires a standard more flexible and less strict than the

standard required for a finding of liability. ``[A] proposed decree

must be approved even if it falls short of the remedy the court would

impose on its own, as long as it falls within the range of

acceptability or is `within the reaches of public interest.' (citations

omitted).\3\

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ United States v. American Tel. and Tel Co., 552 F. Supp.

131, 150 (D.D.C. 1982), aff'd sub nom. Maryland v. United States,

460 U.S. 1001 (1983), quoting United States v. Gillette Co., supra,

406 F. Supp. at 716; United States v. Alcan Aluminum, Ltd., 605 F.

Supp. 619, 622 (W.D. Ky 1985).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

VIII. Determinative Documents

There are no determinative materials or documents within the

meaning of the APPA that were considered by the United States in

formulating the proposed Final Judgment.

For Plaintiff United States of America:

J. Robert Kramer II, Chief, Litigation II Section, PA Bar #

23963; William L. Hudgins, Assistant Chief, Litigation II Section,

DC Bar # 37127; and

Janet Adams Nash, Kevin C. Quin, Stacy Nelson, Laura M. Scott, Nancy

Olson, Tara M. Higgins, Charles R. Schwidde, Robert W. Wilder,

Melanie Sabo,

Trail Attorneys, U.S. Department of Justice, Antitrust Division,

1401 H St., N.W., Suite 3000, Washington, D.C. 20530, 202-307-0924,

202-307-6283 (Facsimile).

Dated: July 2, 1997.

[FR Doc. 97-19315 Filed 7-22-97; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4410-11-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.