Application by National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc., for a Preemption Determination as to Hazardous Materials Requirements Imposed by the City of El Paso, Texas

Federal RegisterJan 19, 1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

[Docket No. PDA-14(R)]

Application by National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc., for a

Preemption Determination as to Hazardous Materials Requirements Imposed

by the City of El Paso, Texas

AGENCY: Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA), DOT.

ACTION: Public notice and invitation to comment.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc. (NTTC) has applied for

an administrative determination as to whether the Federal hazardous

material transportation law preempts certain provisions of Chapter 9.56

of the City of El Paso, Texas Municipal Code requiring motor carriers

or operators that transport hazardous materials to obtain a permit

based on inspections which are conducted only during limited time

periods, from November 1 through December 31 of each year.

DATES: Comments received on or before March 4, 1996, and rebuttal

comments received on or before April 18, 1996, will be considered

before an administrative ruling is issued by RSPA's Associate

Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety. Rebuttal comments may

discuss only those issues raised in comments received during the

initial comment period and may not discuss new issues.

ADDRESSES: The application and any comments received may be reviewed in

the Dockets Unit, Research and Special Programs Administration, Room

8421, 400 Seventh Street, SW, Washington, DC 20590-0001 (Tel. No. [202]

366-4453). Comments and rebuttal comments on the application may be

submitted to the Dockets Unit at the above address, and should include

the Docket Number (PDA-14(R)). Three copies of each should be

submitted. In addition, a copy of each comment and each rebuttal

comment must be sent to: (1) Mr. Clifford J. Harvison, President,

National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc., 2200 Mill Road, Alexandria, VA

22314; and (2) Mr. David Caylor, City Attorney, City of El Paso, #2

Civic Center Plaza, Ninth Floor, El Paso, TX 79901. A certification

that a copy has been sent to each person must also be included with

each comment. (The following format is suggested: ``I hereby certify

that copies of this comment have been sent to Messrs. Harvison and

Caylor at the addresses specified in the Federal Register.'')

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Karin V. Christian, Attorney, Office

of the Chief Counsel, Research and Special Programs Administration,

U.S. Department of Transportation, 400 Seventh Street SW, Washington,

DC 20590-0001 (Tel. No. [202] 366-4400).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. NTTC'S Application for a Preemption Determination

On December 10, 1995, NTTC applied for a determination that the

Federal hazardous material transportation law preempts certain

provisions of Chapter 9.56 of the City of El Paso, Texas Municipal Code

requiring motor carriers or operators transporting hazardous materials

to obtain permits based on inspections conducted only during limited

periods of time, from November 1 through December 31 of each year.

Section 9.56.080 of the City of El Paso Municipal Code states:

(a) It is unlawful for any motor carrier or operator to transport

hazardous materials from a point of origin within the city or to a

point of destination within the city without a permit issued by the

Fire Marshal, or his designee.

(b) The annual inspection period shall be from November 1 through

December 31 of each year.

(c) A permit fee of Fifty Dollars ($50.00) per vehicle shall be

paid upon inspection of the vehicle. Vehicles failing inspection shall

be assessed an additional Twenty-Five Dollars ($25.00) fee for

reinspection.

(d) No permit issued under this Chapter shall be transferable from

one person to another nor from one vehicle to another. The permit shall

be visibly posted in each vehicle.

The text of NTTC's application is set forth in Appendix A. The

attachments to the application, consisting of a copy of the ordinance

adopting a new Chapter 9.56 of the El Paso Municipal Code and an El

Paso Fire Department letter confirming active enforcement of the

ordinance, may be examined at RSPA's Dockets Unit. Copies of the

attachments will be provided at no cost, upon request to RSPA's Dockets

Unit (see the address and telephone number set forth in the Addresses

section above.)

II. Preemption Under the Federal Hazardous Material Transportation Law

The Hazardous Materials Transportation Act (HMTA) was enacted in

1975 to give the Department of Transportation greater authority ``to

protect the Nation adequately against the risks to life and property

which are inherent in the transportation of hazardous materials in

commerce.'' Pub. L. 93-633 Sec. 102, 88 Stat. 2156, amended by Pub. L.

103-272 and codified as revised in 49 U.S.C. 5101. A key aspect of HMTA

is that it replaced a patchwork of State and local laws. On July 5,

1994, the HMTA was among the many Federal laws relating to

transportation that were revised, codified and enacted ``without

substantive change'' by Public Law 103-272, 108 Stat. 745. The Federal

hazardous material transportation law is now found in 49 U.S.C. Chapter

51.

A statutory provision for Federal preemption was central to the

HMTA. In 1974, the Senate Commerce Committee ``endorse[d] the principle

of preemption in order to preclude a multiplicity of State and local

regulations and the potential for varying as well as conflicting

regulations in the area of hazardous materials transportation.'' S.

Rep. No. 1102, 93rd Cong. 2nd Sess. 37 (1974). More recently, the U.S.

Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit found that uniformity was the

``linchpin'' in the design of the HMTA, including the 1990 amendments

which expanded the preemption provisions. Colorado Public Utilities

Comm. v. Harmon, 951 F.2d 1571, 1575 (10th Cir. 1991).

Following the 1990 amendments and the subsequent 1994 codification

of the Federal law governing the transportation of hazardous material,

in the absence of a waiver of preemption by the Department of

Transportation (DOT) under 49 U.S.C. 5125(e), ``a requirement of a

State, political subdivision of a State, or Indian tribe'' is

explicitly preempted (unless it is authorized by another Federal law)

if--

(1) complying with a requirement of the State, political

subdivision or tribe and a requirement of this chapter or a

regulation issued under this chapter is not possible; or

(2) the requirement of the State, political subdivision, or

Indian tribe, as applied or enforced, is an obstacle to

accomplishing and carrying out this chapter or a regulation

prescribed under this chapter.

49 U.S.C. 5125(a). These two paragraphs set forth the ``dual

compliance'' and ``obstacle'' criteria which RSPA consistently has

applied since 1978.

In the 1990 amendments to the HMTA, Congress also confirmed that

there is no room for deviations from

[[Page 1433]]

Federal requirements in certain key matters involving the

transportation of hazardous material. Under the present codified

statute, a non-Federal requirement ``about any of the following

subjects, that is not substantively the same as a provision of this

chapter or a regulation prescribed under this chapter,'' is preempted

unless it is authorized by another Federal law or DOT grants a waiver

of preemption. Section 5125(b)(1) lists these five ``covered subjects''

as:

(A) the designation, description, and classification of

hazardous material.

(B) the packing, repacking, handling, labeling, marking, and

placarding of hazardous material.

(C) the preparation, execution, and use of shipping documents

related to hazardous material and requirements related to the

number, contents, and placement of those documents.

(D) the written notification, recording, and reporting of the

unintentional release in transportation of hazardous material.

(E) the design, manufacturing, fabricating, marking,

maintenance, reconditioning, repairing, or testing of a packaging or

a container represented, marked, certified, or sold as qualified for

use in transporting hazardous material.

RSPA has defined ``substantively the same'' to mean ``conforms in every

significant respect to the Federal requirement. Editorial and other

similar de minimis changes are permitted.'' 49 CFR 107.202(d).

Under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d)(1), any person directly affected by a

requirement may apply to the Secretary of Transportation for a

determination whether a State, political subdivision, or Indian tribe

requirement is preempted by the Federal hazardous material

transportation law. Notice of an application for a preemption

determination must be published in the Federal Register, and the

applicant is precluded from seeking judicial relief on the ``same or

substantially the same issue'' of preemption for 180 days after the

application, or until the Secretary takes final action on the

application, whichever occurs first. Following the receipt and

consideration of written comments, RSPA publishes its determination in

the Federal Register. See 49 C.F.R. 107.209(d). A party to a preemption

determination proceeding may seek judicial review of the determination

in U.S. district court within 60 days after the determination becomes

final. 49 U.S.C. 5125((f).

The Secretary of Transportation has delegated to RSPA the authority

to make determinations of preemption, except for those concerning

highway routing, which have been delegated to the Federal Highway

Administration. 49 CFR 1.53(b). RSPA's regulations concerning

preemption determinations are set forth at 49 CFR 107.201-107.211.

Under these regulations, RSPA's Associate Administrator for Hazardous

Materials Safety issues preemption determinations. Any person aggrieved

by RSPA's decision on an application for a preemption determination may

file a petition for reconsideration within 20 days of service of that

decision. 49 CFR 107.211(a).

The decision by RSPA's Associate Administrator for Hazardous

Materials Safety becomes RSPA's final decision 20 days after service if

no petition for reconsideration is filed within that time; the filing

of a petition for reconsideration is not a prerequisite to seeking

judicial review under 49 U.S.C. 5125(f). If a petition for

reconsideration is filed, the action by RSPA's Associate Administrator

for Hazardous Materials Safety on the petition for reconsideration is

RSPA's final agency action. 49 CFR 107.211(d).

Preemption determinations do not address issues of preemption

arising under the Commerce Clause of the Constitution or under statutes

other than the Federal hazardous material transportation law unless it

is necessary to do so in order to determine whether a requirement is

authorized by another Federal law.

In making preemption determinations under 49 U.S.C. 5125(d), RSPA

is guided by the principles and policy set forth in Executive Order No.

12,612, entitled ``Federalism'' (52 FR 41685 [Oct. 30, 1987]). Section

4(a) of that Executive Order authorizes preemption of State laws only

when a statute contains 10 an express preemption provision, there is

other firm and palpable evidence of Congressional intent to preempt, or

the exercise of State authority directly conflicts with the exercise of

Federal authority. Section 5125 contains express provisions, which RSPA

has implemented through its regulations.

III. Public Comment

All comments should be limited to the issue of whether the cited

provisions of Chapter 9.56 of the City of El Paso Municipal Code are

preempted by the Federal hazardous material transportation law.

Comments should specifically address the preemption criteria

(``substantively the same,'' ``dual compliance,'' and ``obstacle''

tests described in Part II above) and whether the City of El Paso

Municipal Code requirements are ``otherwise authorized by Federal

law.''

Persons intending to comment should review the standards and

procedures governing RSPA's consideration of applications for

preemption determinations, set forth at 49 CFR 107.201-107.211.

Issued in Washington, DC on January 11, 1996.

Alan I. Roberts,

Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety.

Appendix A--A Petition Seeking a ``Preemption Determination'' With

Regard to Specified Laws and Ordinances of the City of El Paso, Texas.

Filed by: National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc.

Before The Administrator:

National Tank Truck Carriers, Inc. (NTTC) is a trade association

representing over 200 motor carriers specializing in the transportation

of hazardous materials, hazardous substances and hazardous wastes in

cargo tank motor vehicles. Typically, this association's membership

operates vehicles over irregular routes throughout the continental

United States.

Virtually all of the members of NTTC are involved in the ``common

carrier'' transportation of commodities regulated as ``hazardous

materials'' by the Administrator. Given the nature of ``common

carriage'', individual members of this [association], having neither a

domicile nor a terminal in El Paso, Texas, are (nonetheless) called

upon to perform transportation services into, out of and through that

City. Thus, the interests of this Association (and its individual

members) are impacted.

Most recently, this association has become aware that the City of

El Paso, Texas intends an active enforcement program relative to

provisions of Chapter 9.56 of that city's ``Municipal Code'' (herein

referred to, alternatively, as ``the Ordinance''). A copy of Chapter

9.56 (as forwarded to NTTC by the City Clerk's office of the City) is

appended to this petition. Also attached is a copy of a letter from the

City's Fire Department underscoring the intention of the City to

conduct vehicle inspections, during a limited period of time.

Presumably, the vehicular inspections are a prerequisite to obtaining a

permit mandated by the Ordinance. We enclose this letter only to

underscore the fact that active enforcement is contemplated by the

City. The issue is not moot.

NTTC's Position

NTTC believes that substantial provisions of the City of El Paso's

Chapter 9.56, as enforced, are preempted by the Hazardous Materials

Transportation Uniform Safety Act (as amended) (``the Act''), and we

ask that

[[Page 1434]]

following public notice and opportunity for comment the Administrator

issue a formal determination of preemption. Specifically, NTTC believes

that the El Paso regulation, as currently applied and enforced, would

cause a motor carrier to violate 49 CFR 177.853(a).

A Brief Description of the Issue

On December 29, 1993, officials of the City of El Paso codified

revisions of Chapter 9.56 of the city's Municipal Code. Certain

provisions of the new Ordinance encompass ``findings'', various

definitions, ``minimum safety requirements'', a routing scheme

(including allowable circumstances for deviation), ``permits and

fees'', ``violations and penalties'', etc. It would appear that the

Ordinance is enforceable against any commercial vehicle laden with

hazardous materials, regardless of configuration (e.g. cargo tank vs.

van trailer, etc.). Moreover, via the Ordinance the city adopts certain

portions of the Administrator's Hazardous Materials Regulations (HMR)

as its own.

According to NTTC's interpretation of Chapter 9.56, virtually any

transporter having cause to pick-up and/or deliver regulated quantities

of any hazardous material (as defined within the HMR), at any time in a

given year at any place in the City, would be required to present any

and all vehicles used in such transportation at designated points

within the city, between November 1 and December 31, each year, for

inspection. We assume that the inspection would evaluate compliance

with relevant Federal regulations. Presuming satisfactory completion of

the inspection, the vehicle owner would pay a fee (for the inspection)

and be issued a ``permit''. That permit would be valid for one year and

must be ``visibly posted'' in the vehicle. Permits may not be

transferred from vehicle to vehicle.

The permit is subject to revocation, suspension, modification or

denial, and an appeal process is in place. The provisions of the 14

Ordinance are enforceable by designated city employees and the

penalties for non-compliance are substantial.

Safety and Operational Considerations

From the standpoint of its impact on the tank truck industry,

Chapter 9.56 is little more than a series of enforceable requirements

rolled into one. Herein, NTTC will concentrate on two areas of concern;

namely, the ``permit'' and the ``inspection''.

Historically, the Administrator has charged petitioners (in these

disputes) to evaluate state and local restrictions in terms of the

``dual compliance test'' and/or the ``obstacle test''.

Standing alone, neither the inspection program nor the permit

scheme invite review. Certainly, NTTC would not question the efficacy

of safety inspections conducted by trained personnel and aimed at

measuring compliance with Federal safety regulations. Similarly (and

beginning with IR#2), the Administrator has held that a permit, per se,

is not necessarily preempted.

In the case of the El Paso law, however, the inspection and the

permit are linked, inexorably. One cannot obtain a permit without an

inspection and one cannot have a vehicle inspected unless he/she

presents that vehicle before city officials at specific points and

within a very narrow time frame.

Argument

NTTC believes that the Administrator need not go beyond his

findings and ruling in the matter of PD-4(R); Docket No. PDA-6(R)

``California Requirements Applicable to Cargo Tanks Transporting

Flammable and Combustible Liquids; Decision on Petition for

Reconsideration'' to justify a ruling that the El Paso Ordinance is

(similarly) preempted.

Perhaps unknowingly, the City of El Paso has taken the preempted

provisions of the California Vehicle Code and added a new and sharply

limiting twist. California required an in-bound vehicle to remain in

that state (whether loaded or empty) until a safety inspection had been

performed. In the alternative, a carrier could ``pre-notify''

California officials of a shipment bound for its jurisdiction and

``schedule'' an inspection. El Paso, on the other hand, would not only

replicate California's preempted ``waiting'' period, it would compound

the felony by limiting inspection times to a time frame within November

1 and December 31.

As we noted in the California docket, ``the call and demand nature

of common carriage means that management may be unaware that a given

vehicle, dispatched from a given terminal at a given time, is destined

for California.'' Obviously, the same holds true for El Paso.

Even if the City amends its current procedures for performing

inspections and issuing permits such must only be done within

constraints clearly outlined by the Administrator, to wit: (a

jurisdiction) may not require an inspection as a condition of

travelling on (that jurisdiction's) roads when the inspection cannot be

conducted without delay because an inspector must come to the place of

inspection from another location. (PD-4(R); Docket No. PDA-6(R);

Decision on Petition for Reconsideration. Issued February 7, 1995).

We grant the fact that, in the case of El Paso's ordinance some

circumstances differ from those explored in the California decision,

but the burden is the same, to wit: the carrier is compelled to present

its vehicle (whether laden or empty) for inspection at a specific place

and within a narrow time frame. The net impact of the city's law

replicates the opportunities (and actualities) for delay preempted in

California.

Paraphrasing the Administrator's rationale in preempting the

California regulations, we suggest that, ``. . . (El Paso) is free, and

is encouraged, to conduct inspections of cargo tanks and portable tanks

at POEs, other roadside inspection locations, and terminals. However,

it may not require an inspection as a condition of travelling on (El

Paso's) roads when the inspection cannot be conducted without

(unnecessary) delay. . . .''

Additionally, and as noted by NTTC in other proceedings, should

other state or local jurisdictions enact requirements replicating El

Paso's the result would be chaotic. We foresee wandering parades of

trucks, of all shapes and sizes, crossing the nation's landscape

seeking safety inspections in the off-hand chance that sometime in the

next 365 days they might required to pick up and/or deliver a load to

one or more of the inspecting jurisdictions. We see the windshields of

those trucks so plastered with ``permits'' that the driver's field of

vision is through a ``paper tunnel''.

Frankly, we doubt that the City has any realistic idea of the

tumult that would result from comprehensive enforcement of Chapter

9.56.

Summary

Chapter 9.56 of the El Paso Municipal Code imposes an inspection

and permit scheme which, in substance and enforcement, replicates that

of the State of California which was preempted by the Administrator. As

such, it deserves (indeed, mandates) a similar fate.

(Note: A copy of this petition has been sent via first class

mail to the Office of the City Clerk and the Office of the Mayor of

El Paso, Texas).

Respectfully submitted:

Clifford J. Harvison,

President.

[FR Doc. 96-547 Filed 1-18-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.