Royalty Relief for Outer Continental Shelf Leases in the Gulf of Mexico

Federal RegisterFeb 23, 1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR

Minerals Management Service

30 CFR Parts 203, 256, and 260

RIN 1010-AC13

Royalty Relief for Outer Continental Shelf Leases in the Gulf of

Mexico

AGENCY: Minerals Management Service (MMS), Interior.

ACTION: Advance notice of proposed rulemaking.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Outer Continental Shelf Deep Water Royalty Relief Act

(Act) authorizes the Secretary of the Interior (Secretary) to modify

the terms of certain existing leases and to establish new terms for

leases in water depths of 200 meters or greater in parts of the Central

and Western Gulf of Mexico. This document solicits recommendations and

comments on rules that would implement the new authority under the Act.

DATES: MMS will consider all comments we receive by April 8, 1996. We

will begin reviewing comments at that time and may not fully consider

comments we receive after April 8, 1996. Please note, we expect that

the 180-day time limit the Act imposes to issue regulations will

preclude granting extensions of the 45-calendar-day comment period.

ADDRESSES: Mail or hand-carry comments to the Department of the

Interior; Minerals Management Service; Mail Stop 4700; 381 Elden

Street; Herndon, Virginia 22070-4817; Attention: Chief, Engineering and

Standards Branch.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

To obtain a copy of the Act or for other information regarding this

notice, contact Walter Cruickshank, Chief, Offshore Minerals, Analysis

Division, Minerals Management Service, at either Mail Stop 4013, 1849 C

Street, NW; Washington, DC 20240, or telephone: (202) 208-3822. You may

also access the text of the Act from the MMS homepage on the World Wide

Web at http://www.mms.gov/whatsnew.html. Because of the Act's

complexity, readers should have a copy of the Act available when

reviewing this notice.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Summary of Legislative Provisions

On November 28, 1995, the President signed the Act (Pub. L. 104-

58). The Act authorizes the Secretary to modify the royalty or net

profit share terms of certain existing leases and to offer new leases

subject to the Act's provisions for royalty suspension volumes in water

depths of 200 meters or greater in parts of the Central and Western

Gulf of Mexico. The Act directs the Secretary to promulgate

implementing regulations within 180 days of enactment. MMS and the

Secretary are making every effort to meet this deadline. Given the

complexities of the Act and the time constraints for implementation,

how should MMS best address the issues the Act raises in a timely

fashion?

The purpose of this notification is to solicit recommendations and

comments from the oil and natural gas industries, Federal agencies,

State and local governments, environmental groups, academia, and the

public on the general administrative and regulatory framework for

fulfilling the Secretary's responsibilities under the Act.

(Special Note: Oil and natural gas industry trade associations are

encouraged to act as coordinators for information responses from

member companies pertaining to this notice.)

Recommendations and detailed comments are also solicited on certain

issues or technical questions that are necessary to establish workable

rules and regulations to implement the Act.

[[Page 6959]]

This notification focuses on those new responsibilities related to

granting royalty relief for leases located in water depths of 200

meters or greater. Rules resulting from this rulemaking process may

also include provisions clarifying existing authorities and policies

for reducing royalty rates on existing leases in water depths of less

than 200 meters. In addition to this written notice, MMS will conduct a

2-day public meeting in March 1996 to solicit additional written and

oral comments pertaining to this topic. The meeting is tentatively

scheduled to be held in New Orleans, Louisiana. MMS officials from the

Gulf of Mexico Regional and Herndon, Virginia, Headquarters offices

will conduct it. Further details will be made available in the near

future in a Federal Register Notice as well as through the MMS Gulf of

Mexico Regional Information Office at 1201 Elmwood Park Boulevard, New

Orleans, Louisiana 70123-2394 telephone (504) 736-2595.

The MMS has scheduled a lease sale for April 24, 1996 for the

Central Gulf of Mexico which includes tracts that are subject to the

provisions of this Act. The MMS will publish an interim rule to

implement the legislative requirements prior to the sale. Please send

us your comments and recommendations on how we should implement the

provisions of section 304 of the Act as soon as possible so that they

may be considered as we develop the interim rule.

This advance notice of proposed rulemaking solicits comments,

recommendations, and specific remarks on issues and topics. We will

carefully evaluate all timely received responses as we develop a rule

to implement the Act. The Act contains three major provisions with

respect to new and existing leases. New leases include tracts leased as

the result of a sale held after the legislation's enactment on November

28, 1995. Existing leases are defined as all other leases.

(1) Section 302 clarifies the Secretary's pre-existing authority to

reduce royalty rates on existing leases to promote development,

increase production, and encourage production of marginal resources on

producing and non-producing leases. This provision applies only to

leases in the Gulf of Mexico, west of 87 degrees, 30 minutes West

longitude.

(2) Also, Section 302 provides that ``new production'' from

existing leases in water depths of 200 meters or greater qualifies for

royalty suspensions if the Secretary determines that the new production

would not be economic in the absence of royalty relief. The Secretary

must then determine the appropriate royalty suspension volume on a

case-by-case basis, subject to specified minimums for non-producing

leases. This provision applies only to leases in the Gulf of Mexico,

west of 87 degrees, 30 minutes West longitude.

(3) Section 303 establishes a new bidding system that allows the

Secretary to offer tracts with royalty suspensions for a period, volume

or value determined by the Secretary. All tracts offered within 5 years

of the date of enactment in water depths of 200 meters or greater in

the Gulf of Mexico, west of 87 degrees, 30 minutes West longitude, must

be offered under the new bidding system (Section 304).

Regulatory Objectives

In implementing the Act's provisions related to existing and new

oil and natural gas leases in water depths of 200 meters or greater in

certain areas of the Gulf of Mexico, MMS seeks to establish a

regulatory program that:

(1) promotes development or increased production, including

marginal resources, on producing or non-producing leases;

(2) fulfills the purposes of the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act,

as amended, including its requirement to insure the public a fair and

equitable return on the resources of the Outer Continental Shelf (OCS);

(3) establishes a set of objective criteria to render fair and

forthright decisions to individual lessees;

(4) establishes a simple and concise application process requiring

only the data and information necessary to evaluate properly the

specific circumstances addressed by the application and to ensure

compliance with payment obligations;

(5) uses procedures for the submission and review of applications

similar to those MMS used in consideration of royalty relief for all

leases regardless of water depth; and

(6) minimizes the personnel required for both lessees and MMS to

carry out the Act's activities.

Issues and Informational Needs

The specific circumstances associated with existing and future OCS

oil and natural gas exploration, development, and production activities

require the MMS to make several critical determinations in formulating

the regulations to implement royalty relief for deep-water leases. Some

of the determinations MMS must make affect all circumstances addressed

under the legislation, while others apply only to specific lease

circumstances.

Hence, for the purpose of soliciting comments and recommendations,

this notice seeks input on all relevant issues and topics, including

(I) Common Technical Issues, (II) Existing Deep-water Leases, and (III)

New Leases (i.e., leases resulting from sales conducted after November

28, 1995). The issues raised below will help MMS implement the Act but

may not become part of future regulations.

I. Common Technical Issues

(1) The Act sets minimum suspension volumes based on the water

depth of leases in a field eligible for royalty relief. What water

depth data should MMS use for royalty relief classification purposes?

The options range from prelease MMS-determined water depth boundaries

based on published Gulfwide bathymetric data to postlease tract-

specific data. Should MMS determine water depths for new and existing

leases in the same way?

a. If you recommend that MMS use published bathymetric data, what

are the best or most acceptable data sets available?

b. If you recommend that MMS use prelease data, how should MMS

handle possible inconsistencies with postlease tract-specific water

depth data that may become available on a block?

c. If you recommend that MMS use postlease data, what should be the

nature and timing of the data?

d. What water depth on a block should MMS use to determine the

royalty relief to be granted, e.g., shallowest, deepest, average, or

location of production facility?

e. How would MMS and bidders decide on the fair value of a tract if

the tract's water depth isn't specified at the time of sale? How could

MMS assure the receipt of fair market value if the royalty suspension

volume could change after the lease award?

(2) Should MMS use a standard conversion factor e.g., British

Thermal Units (BTU), in computing barrels of oil equivalent for

determining relief volumes, or should MMS make the calculations on a

case-by-case basis?

a. If you recommend one or more standard conversion factors,

specify the factor(s) and rationale for its/their use.

b. If you recommend case-by-case analyses, how should MMS base

specific decisions and how should MMS address production stream

variances over time? How should MMS determine factors for new leases or

existing leases that have never produced?

(3) Should MMS consider a fixed time period for evaluating economic

viability of proposals, or should MMS use specific case-by-case

projections of the productive life of the field? If you

[[Page 6960]]

recommend a stipulated time limit, what should that limit be and why?

(4) What specific criteria should MMS consider in determining

whether existing leases or units are economically viable?

a. Should MMS base such criteria upon case-by-case circumstances or

more generic industry standards?

b. If you recommend case-by-case analyses, what publicly available

economic analysis models might MMS employ in making such determinations

in a manner that would yield results acceptable to the diverse

companies operating leases on the OCS?

c. If you recommend industry standards, identify specific criteria

(e.g., return on investment, return on equity, etc.) and the basis for

specific levels of acceptability.

(5) For existing leases, the Act states that royalty relief

determinations can be on a lease or unit basis.

a. How should MMS treat applications for an individual lease that

comprises only a portion of a geologic structure common to several

leases or unleased tracts?

b. Should MMS require joint applications where such leases are not

unitized?

c. Should MMS change its regulations addressing unitization in

these circumstances?

d. When a lease is added to a unit that already has a royalty

suspension, how should MMS modify the approved royalty relief to

recognize the water depth, production projections, and/or other data

relating to the added lease?

(6) How should MMS treat nonlease costs (e.g., pipelines, shared

production systems, etc.) in determining economic viability?

(7) How should MMS determine gas/oil ratios for non-producing

leases for determining economic viability? Similarly, how should MMS

determine gas/oil ratios for ``new production'' from producing leases?

II. Existing Deep-Water Leases

(1) The Act requires the Secretary to define clearly the

information required for a complete application.

a. What information should MMS require for an application to be

considered complete?

b. What minimum amount and types of information do you think MMS

needs to make a determination of economic viability?

c. How should MMS establish the reasonableness of the amount and

timing of projected production, costs, and revenues?

(2) The Act states that, in determining the need for and amount of

royalty relief, the Secretary must consider the increased technological

and financial risk of deep-water development.

a. Identify specific ``technological and financial risks'' of deep-

water development that MMS should consider in determining economic

viability of leases or units addressed by the legislation.

b. Are such risks tract-specific or industry-wide?

c. How do such risks vary with water depth?

d. What means are available for quantifying such risks?

e. How should MMS account for such risks in the application and

decision process?

f. How should MMS differentiate between the ``technological and

financial risks'' of non-producing leases with approved Development

Operations Coordination Documents (DOCD) and those of leases without

approved DOCD's?

(3) Similarly, the Act requires the Secretary to consider all costs

associated with exploring, developing, and producing the lease when

determining economic viability.

a. What costs should be included and how should they be

``considered''? Please provide the rationale for your answer.

b. Should such costs be tract-specific or industry-wide?

c. What means are available for quantifying such costs?

d. At what point should such costs be considered ``sunk costs'' for

determining allowable costs in the application and decision process?

(4) For existing leases, the suspensions cease when oil or natural

gas prices exceed specified ceilings. When leases produce both oil and

natural gas or related products, and only one of the ceiling prices is

reached, should the MMS lift the suspension for the entire production

or just the product for which the price ceiling is reached? For tracts

offered in upcoming sales, should price ceilings affect suspension

volumes in the same ways as for existing leases and units?

(5) The Secretary must redetermine the need for or the volume of

relief when the lessee applies prior to the commencement of the ``new

production'' and a significant change occurs in the factors upon which

the original determination was made.

a. Identify specific factors and what should constitute

``significant'' changes that would require reconsideration of the

original determination the Secretary made.

b. Should MMS establish a limit on the number of redetermination

applications or a minimum time stipulation between redeterminations?

c. Are there any circumstances in which the Secretary should

redetermine the suspension volume without an applicant's request?

(6) The second part of the definition of new production includes

any production resulting from lease activities pursuant to a supplement

to an approved DOCD that would ``expand production significantly beyond

the level anticipated'' in a prior approved DOCD.

a. How should MMS determine the amount of ``any production . . .

that would expand production significantly beyond the level

anticipated'' in the prior DOCD?

b. Should MMS make this determination on anticipated reserves or

production levels?

c. How should MMS determine the ``start date'' for ``new

production'' from this category of existing leases?

d. How should MMS quantify the level of ``significant'' expanded

production for purposes of royalty relief determinations for this

category of leases? Assuming MMS grants royalty relief, how should MMS

allocate production between the baseline production level and the

``expanded'' production level?

e. What costs, if any, incurred prior to November 28, 1995, or

prior to the date of an application for royalty relief, should MMS

include in determining economic viability?

f. How should MMS consider production quantities and revenues for

past production?

g. For leases with approved DOCD's, how should MMS determine the

``level of anticipated production'' if not specifically stated in the

DOCD? Should MMS make this determination on anticipated reserves or

production levels (e.g., barrels of oil per day, annual production,

etc.)?

h. Should MMS require that all future DOCD's include the level of

anticipated production?

III. New Leases Issued as the Result of Lease Sales Conducted After

November 28, 1995

Provisions included in the legislation require that MMS employ a

bidding system for any lease sale within five years of November 28,

1995, which provides for suspensions of royalty payments in water

depths of 200 meters or greater for stipulated minimum volumes of

production. The suspension volumes in section 304 of the Act were based

on MMS analyses of fields at various water depths, consistent with the

way in which investment decisions

[[Page 6961]]

on deep water development projects are made.

(1) The provisions of the Act dealing with existing leases allow

the Secretary to grant suspensions on an individual lease or unit

basis. However, section 304 of the Act (Lease Sales) refers to

``tracts'' and ``leases'' (plural). How should MMS apply the royalty

suspension volumes to tracts offered for sale?

(2) Is there any basis for MMS to offer suspension volumes larger

than the minimums specified in the Act?

Dated: February 20, 1996.

Bob Armstrong,

Assistant Secretary for Land and Minerals Management.

[FR Doc. 96-4106 Filed 2-22-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4310-MR-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.