CSX Corporation and CSX Transportation, Inc.Control and MergerConrail Inc. and Consolidated Rail Corporation

Federal RegisterNov 15, 1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Surface Transportation Board

[STB Finance Docket No. 33220]

CSX Corporation and CSX Transportation, Inc.--Control and

Merger--Conrail Inc. and Consolidated Rail Corporation

AGENCY: Surface Transportation Board.

ACTION: Decision No. 3; notice of proposed procedural schedule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Board invites comments from interested persons on a

proposed procedural schedule.

DATES: Written comments on the proposed schedule must be filed with the

Board no later than December 6, 1996. Applicants' reply is due by

December 16, 1996.

ADDRESSES: An original and 25 copies of all documents must refer to STB

Finance Docket No. 33220 and must be sent to the Office of the

Secretary, Case Control Branch, ATTN: STB Finance Docket No. 33220,

Surface Transportation Board, 1201 Constitution Avenue, NW.,

Washington, DC 20423.\1\ In addition, one copy of all documents in this

proceeding must be sent to each of the applicants' representatives: (1)

Dennis G. Lyons, Esq., Arnold & Porter, 555 12th Street, NW.,

Washington, DC 20004-1202; and (2) Paul A. Cunningham, Esq., Harkins

Cunningham, Suite 600, 1300 Nineteenth Street, NW., Washington, DC

20036.

\1\ In addition to submitting an original and 25 copies of all

documents filed with the Board, the parties are encouraged to submit

all pleadings and attachments as computer data contained on a 3.5-

inch floppy diskette which is formatted for WordPerfect 5.1 (or

formatted so that it can be converted into WordPerfect 5.1) and is

clearly labeled with the identification acronym and number of the

pleading contained on the diskette [49 CFR 1180.4(2)]. The computer

data contained on the computer diskettes submitted will be subject

to the protective order entered in Decision No. 1, served on October

25, 1996, in this proceeding, and is for the exclusive use of Board

employees reviewing substantive matters in this proceeding. The

flexibility provided by such computer file data will facilitate

expedited review by the Board and its staff.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Julia M. Farr, (202) 927-5352. [TDD for the hearing impaired: (202)

927-5721.]

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: In Decision No. 2, served and published in

the Federal Register on November 15, 1996, the Board issued a notice to

the public that, pursuant to 49 CFR 1180.4(b), CSX Corporation (CSXC),

CSX Transportation, Inc. (CSXT), Conrail Inc. (CRI), and Consolidated

Rail Corporation (CRC) \2\ had filed on October 18, 1996, a notice of

their intent to file an application seeking authority under 49 U.S.C.

11323-25 for: (1) the acquisition of control of CRI by Green

Acquisition Corp. (Acquisition), a wholly owned subsidiary of CSXC; (2)

the merger of CRI into Acquisition; and (3) the resulting common

control of CSXT and CRI and CSXC. The Board found this to be a major

transaction as defined in 49 CFR part 1180. Applicants intend to file

their application on or before March 1, 1997.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\2\ CSXC and CSXT are referred to collectively as CSX. CRI and

CRC are referred to collectively as Conrail. CSX and Conrail are

referred to collectively as ``applicants.''

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Applicants also filed on October 18, 1996, a petition to establish

a procedural schedule (CSX/CR-3). Applicants' proposed procedural

schedule is as follows:

Applicants' Proposed Procedural Schedule

F Primary application and related applications filed.

F+30 Board notice of acceptance of primary application and related

applications published in the Federal Register.

F+45 Notification of intent to participate in proceeding due.

F+60 Description of anticipated inconsistent and responsive

applications due; petitions for waiver or clarification due with

respect to such applications.

F+120 Inconsistent and responsive applications due. All comments,

protests, requests for conditions, and any other opposition evidence

and argument due. Comments by U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) and U.S.

Department of Transportation (DOT) due.

F+135 Notice of acceptance (if required) of inconsistent and

responsive applications published in the Federal Register.

F+150 Response to inconsistent and responsive applications due.

Response to comments, protests, requested conditions, and other

opposition due. Rebuttal in support of primary application and related

applications due.

F+165 Rebuttal in support of inconsistent and responsive applications

due.

F+185 Briefs due, all parties (not to exceed 50 pages).

F+215 Oral argument (at Board's discretion).

F+217 Voting conference.

F+255 Date of service of final decision.

Under applicants' proposal, immediately upon each evidentiary

filing, the filing party shall place all documents relevant to the

filing (other than documents that are privileged or otherwise protected

from discovery) in a depository open to all parties, and shall make its

witnesses available for discovery depositions. Access to documents

subject to the protective order shall be appropriately restricted.

Parties seeking discovery depositions may proceed by agreement.

Relevant excerpts of transcripts will be received in lieu of cross-

examination, unless cross-examination is needed to resolve material

issues of disputed fact. Discovery on responsive and inconsistent

applications will begin immediately upon their filing. The

Administrative Law Judge assigned to this proceeding will have the

authority initially to resolve any discovery disputes.\3\

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ As we stated in Decision No. 2, the process of assigning an

ALJ to this proceeding is underway, and we will leave all discovery

matters, including the adoption of any guidelines governing

discovery initially, to the discretion of the ALJ. A decision naming

that judge will be issued as soon as possible.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The proposed schedule is substantially similar to that adopted in

Union Pacific Corporation, Union Pacific Railroad Company and Missouri

Pacific Railroad Company--Control and Merger--Southern Pacific Rail

Corporation, Southern Pacific Transportation Company, St. Louis

Southwestern Railway Company, SPCSL Corp., and The Denver and Rio

Grande Western Railway Company (UP/SP), Finance Docket No. 32760 (see

Decision No. 6, ICC served Oct. 19, 1995; and Decision No. 9, ICC

served Dec. 27, 1995).

Applicants' proposal is the first major consolidation transaction

presented to the Board under the ICC Termination Act of 1995, Pub. L.

104-88, 109 Stat. 803 (ICCTA), enacted December 29, 1995, and effective

January 1, 1996. The Board is seeking comments from the public on

applicants' proposed procedural schedule, as modified by us below to

adhere more closely to the provisions of ICCTA. In ICCTA,

[[Page 58612]]

Congress provided pursuant to 49 U.S.C. 11325(b) [emphasis added]:

(b) If the application involves the merger or control of two or

more Class I railroads, as defined by the Board, the following

conditions apply:

(1) Written comments about an application may be filed with the

Board within 45 days after notice of the application is published F

+ 75 days under subsection (a) \4\ of this section. Copies of such

comments shall be served on the Attorney General and the Secretary

of Transportation, who may decide to intervene as a party to the

proceeding. That decision must be made by the 15th day after the

date of receipt of the written comments, and if the decision is to

intervene, preliminary comments about the application must be sent

to the Board by the end of the 15th day after the date of receipt of

the written comments F + 90 days.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\4\ Under 49 U.S.C. 11325(a), ``[t]he Board shall publish notice

of the application under section 11324 in the Federal Register by

the 30th day after the application is filed with the Board * * *.''

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

(2) The Board shall require that applications inconsistent with

an application, notice of which was published under subsection (a)

of this section, and applications for inclusion in the transaction,

be filed with it by the 90th day after publication of notice F + 120

days under that subsection.

(3) The Board must conclude evidentiary proceedings by the end

of 1 year after the date of publication of notice under subsection

(a) of this section. The Board must issue a final decision by the

90th day after the date on which it concludes the evidentiary

proceedings.

Specifically, we propose to modify applicants' proposed schedule to

require parties intending to file comments, protests, requests for

conditions, and any other opposition evidence and argument to file

their submissions 75 days from the date the application is filed [F +

75] as provided for under 49 U.S.C. 11325(b)(1), with comments from the

U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) and the U.S. Department of

Transportation (DOT) due 90 days from the date the application is filed

[F + 90 days] as provided for under 49 U.S.C. 11325(b)(1). If these due

dates were to be established for comments in this proceeding, responses

to comments, protests, requested conditions, and other opposition, and

also rebuttal in support of the primary application and related

applications would be due 30 days after the due date (i.e., on F + 105

for responses to commenters and parties other than DOJ and DOT; and on

day F + 120 for responses to DOJ and DOT). We propose to keep

inconsistent and responsive applications due 120 days from the date the

application is filed [F + 120 days] as provided for under 49 U.S.C.

11325(b)(2). Because there has not been a major merger in the East

since the early 1980s, given our merger experience, we believe it would

be prudent for us to factor in some additional time to accommodate

possible unique issues that may arise. We propose extending applicants'

proposed procedural schedule by 45 days allocated as follows: (1)

Adding 5 days to applicants' proposed period of time for parties to

prepare their briefs, so that briefs would be due on F + 190 days; (2)

adding 15 days to applicants' proposed period of time for parties to

prepare for oral argument, so that oral argument would occur on F + 235

days; (3) adding 3 days to applicants' proposed 2-day interval between

the oral argument and the voting conference, so that a voting

conference would occur on F + 240 days; and (4) adding 22 days to

applicants' proposed period of time after the voting conference for the

service of the Board's final decision on F + 300 days. In addition, we

propose requiring applicants to file an environmental report, including

all supporting documents, no later than 30 days prior to the filing of

the primary application.\5\

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\5\ While applicants need not file their actual operating plan

due at the time of the filing of their application, the supporting

documents must be completely consistent with their operating plan

and contain sufficient information to allow immediate initiation of

the environmental review process.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Proposed Procedural Schedule as Modified by the Board

F-30 Environmental report, including all supporting documents due.

F Primary application and related applications filed.

F+30 Board notice of acceptance of primary application and related

applications published in the Federal Register.

F+45 Notification of intent to participate in proceeding due.

F+60 Description of anticipated inconsistent and responsive

applications due; petitions for waiver or clarification due with

respect to such applications.

F+75 All comments, protests, requests for conditions, and any other

opposition evidence and argument due.

F+90 Comments by U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) and U.S. Department

of Transportation (DOT) due.

F+105 Responses to comments, protests, requested conditions, and other

opposition due. Rebuttal in support of primary application and related

applications due in response to filings on day F+75.

F+120 Inconsistent and responsive applications due. Rebuttal in

support of primary application and related applications due in response

to filings of DOJ and DOT on day F+90.

F+135 Notice of acceptance (if required) of inconsistent and

responsive applications published in the Federal Register.

F+150 Response to inconsistent and responsive applications due.

F+165 Rebuttal in support of inconsistent and responsive applications

due.

F+190 Briefs due, all parties (not to exceed 50 pages).

F+235 Oral argument (close of record).

F+240 Voting conference.

F+300 Date of service of final decision.

Applicants are proposing that any applications for authority for,

or for exemption of, merger-related abandonments, and any supporting

verified statements, be filed with the primary application, and be

treated as related applications, with any opposition evidence,

comments, rebuttal and briefing on those applications to be submitted

in accordance with the same schedule as the primary application. We

agree that we should process any merger-related abandonment

applications in accordance with the overall merger procedural schedule,

rather than applying the procedures found at 49 U.S.C. 10903, which is

similar to the process we used in the UP/SP proceeding. See UP/SP

(Decision No. 9) (ICC served Dec. 27, 1995), slip op. at 9-10.

Therefore, we will grant applicants' request for waiver under 49 CFR

1152.24(e)(5) to permit modifications of the procedures and timetables

prescribed in 49 CFR 1152.25(d) (6) and (7) to be consistent with the

procedural schedule subsequently adopted in this proposed merger

proceeding.\6\

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\6\ Applicants indicate that they intend to file shortly a

petition for waiver or clarification of Railroad Consolidation

Procedures, and related relief. As in UP/SP, applicants should also

seek an exemption under 49 U.S.C. 10502 from any statutory

procedural requirements at 49 U.S.C. 10903 necessary to allow the

Board to process the merger-related abandonment applications under

the procedural schedule ultimately adopted. See UP/SP (Decision No.

3) (ICC served Sept. 5, 1995), slip op at 7-10.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

We invite all interested persons to submit written comments on the

procedural schedule we are proposing here. Comments must be filed by

December 6, 1996. Applicants may reply by December 16, 1996.

This action will not significantly affect either the quality of the

human environment or the conservation of energy resources.

Decided: November 13, 1996.

[[Page 58613]]

By the Board, Chairman Morgan, Vice Chairman Simmons, and

Commissioner Owen.

Vernon A. Williams,

Secretary.

[FR Doc. 96-29438 Filed 11-14-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4915-00-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.