Federal Energy Management and Planning Programs; Methodology and Procedures for Life Cycle Cost Analyses

Federal RegisterJun 25, 1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY

Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy

10 CFR Part 436

[Docket No. EE-RM-95-501]

Federal Energy Management and Planning Programs; Methodology and

Procedures for Life Cycle Cost Analyses

AGENCY: Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, DOE.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The Department of Energy (DOE) is publishing a final rule to

implement its Federal Energy Management Program to include application

of the life cycle costing methodology when evaluating and comparing the

cost effectiveness of water conservation measures in Federal buildings.

The amendments are directed principally toward updating the life cycle

cost methodology and procedures in subpart A in light of changes in law

requiring the use of life cycle costing methodology when installing

water conservation measures.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This regulation is effective July 25, 1996.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Theodore C. Collins, Federal Energy

Management Program, Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy,

Mail Station EE-92, U.S. Department of Energy, 1000 Independence

Avenue, SW., Washington, DC 20585, (202) 586-8017.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Introduction

On August 25, 1995, DOE published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking

to amend some of the provisions in 10 CFR part 436 which are applicable

to programs for the management of energy consumption by Federal

agencies (60 FR 44286). The amendments are directed principally toward

updating the life cycle cost methodology and procedures in subpart A in

light of changes in law requiring the use of life cycle costing

methodology when installing water conservation measures.

Section 152 of the Energy Policy Act of 1992 (Pub.L. 102-486)

amended the legislatively mandated policies with regard to federal

energy management originally set forth in section 542 of the National

Energy Conservation Policy Act (Act or NECPA). 42 U.S.C. 8252. This

amendment to section 542 expands the purpose of the Federal Energy

Management Program to include the conservation and the efficient use of

water, in addition to non-renewable energy, by the Federal government.

Section 543 of the Act (42 U.S.C. 8253(a)) ``Energy Management

Goals'' was also amended by section 152 of the Energy Policy Act by

adding an energy management requirement for Federal agencies that ``Not

later than January 1, 2005, each agency shall, to the maximum extent

practicable, install in Federal buildings owned by the United States

all energy and water conservation measures with payback periods of less

than 10 years, as determined by using the methods and procedures

developed pursuant to section 544.'' To implement this statutory

provision, it is necessary to amend the life cycle cost regulations as

set forth in part 436 of the Code of Federal Regulations, pursuant to

section 544 of the Act, so that the life cycle cost methodology and

procedures can be applied to the installation of water conservation

measures which are implemented by Federal agencies to meet the

requirements of the Act.

In response to the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, DOE received no

written comments and there were no commenters at a public hearing held

on October 12, 1995 in Washington, DC. In view of the above, no changes

have been

[[Page 32648]]

made to the rule proposed on August 25, 1995.

II. Background of the Life Cycle Cost Methodology

On January 23, 1980, DOE published a final Life Cycle Cost rule

(LCC) (45 FR 5620) which established the methodology and procedures for

calculating and comparing the life cycle cost of proposed investments

to upgrade the economic efficiency of Federal buildings through energy

conservation or substitution of renewable energy sources. The LCC rule

was published pursuant to section 381(a)(2) of the Energy Policy and

Conservation Act, as amended, 42 U.S.C 6361(a)(2), section 10 of

Executive Order 11912, and Title V, part 3, of the National Energy

Conservation Policy Act (NECPA).

On November 30, 1990, DOE published final amendments to 10 CFR part

436 (55 FR 48217) to update the guidelines applicable to Federal agency

in-house energy management programs. That rulemaking was directed

principally toward updating the life cycle cost methodology and

procedures in subpart A of 10 CFR part 436 in light of provisions in

the Federal Energy Management Improvement Act of 1988 granting DOE more

discretion in setting discount and energy cost escalation rates (Pub.

L. 100-615).

The principle uses of the LCC rule are determining the cost

effectiveness of proposed investments and assigning priorities among

proposed cost-effective investments. The methodology and procedures of

the LCC rule are amplified in a manual published for DOE by the

National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) HB135, revised as

necessary to reflect amendments. It is referred to as the ``Life Cycle

Costing Manual for the Federal Energy Management Program.'' The

methodology required by the LCC rule involves a systematic analysis of

all significant costs associated with proposed investments, the

principal purpose of which is to increase energy efficiency on a life-

cycle cost effectiveness basis. This analysis relates investment costs

to future costs associated with a proposed investment. The LCC rule

provides for standardized assumptions for establishing and comparing

relevant cost. See 10 CFR 436.14.

The Energy Policy Act of 1992 (Pub. L. 102-486) amended NECPA by

adding water and the use of renewable energy sources to the purpose of

NECPA (42 U.S.C. 8252) and requiring the use of the life cycle cost

methodology when installing in Federal buildings energy and water

conservation measures with payback periods of less than 10 years (42

U.S.C. 8253(b)). The amendments published today relating to water

conservation measures are pursuant to this authority.

III. General Discussion of Amendments

These amendments for the most part insert the term ``water'' in the

various provisions of the rule to reflect the fact that the

conservation and efficient use of water are now included within the

purpose and scope of the Federal Energy Management Program. The

methodology and procedures for applying life cycle cost analyses to

water conservation measures have been determined to be generally

consistent with the treatment of energy. In those instances where the

nature of water conservation measures require different treatment, a

separate provision is added. Overall, only minor changes to the rule

have been made to comply with the mandates imposed by the Energy Policy

Act of 1992.

The basic requirements of the life cycle cost methodology and

procedures are not changed by the amendments. Their coverage is

expanded so that they apply to water conservation measures which are

the primary subject of the amendments. To accommodate the differences

found when examining factors which may be unique only to water or

energy, the Department of Energy is adding new and revised definitions

in Sec. 436.11 to allow for the computation of factors unique to water

conservation measures for the purpose of performing the life cycle

costing calculations. It is the intent of the amendatory language to

make clear that the application of the life cycle cost methodology and

procedures to water conservation measures are treated parallel, where

practicable, to energy conservation measures when determining life

cycle cost effectiveness. For example, the new definition of ``building

water system'' parallels that of ``building energy system.'' The

difference is the type of system which is the subject of the analysis.

In many instances, the Department of Energy has amended the rule with

addition of the terms ``and water'' or ``or water,'' as determined

appropriate, to meet the requirement of the Act to apply life cycle

cost methodology and procedures to water conservation measures.

There are a few minor changes which serve to clarify and facilitate

agency implementation. Section 436.13 presumes that investment in a

retrofit to an existing Federal building is not life cycle cost-

effective if it is occupied under a lease which includes the cost of

utilities in the rent and does not provide a pass-through of energy or

water savings to the government. Language was added to be explicit that

this presumption applies only to Federal investment and should not

necessarily be used to determine the cost effectiveness of building

owners' investments in their Federally-leased buildings. Such

investments are, in fact, cost-effective and are encouraged. The

assumption in section 436.14 that ``water prices will not escalate'' is

based upon the fact that there are no escalation rates established for

water at the national level. However, agencies are permitted to use

escalation rates when they are available from suppliers. Section 436.23

was modified to allow agencies to include future price changes when

they estimate simple payback time in order to be consistent with

national consensus standards developed by the American Society of

Testing and Materials.

IV. Review Under Executive Order 12866

This rule was reviewed under the provisions of this Executive Order

governing Regulatory Planning and Review. DOE has determined that this

rule does not constitute a ``significant regulatory action'' and is

therefore not subject to the provisions of section 6 of the Executive

Order requiring review by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).

V. Review Under the Regulatory Flexibility Act

This rule was reviewed under the Regulatory Flexibility Act of

1980, Public Law 96-354 (5 U.S.C. 601-612). DOE has determined that

this rule will not have a significant economic impact on a substantial

number of small entities, therefore, no regulatory flexibility analysis

has been performed.

VI. Review Under the Paperwork Reduction Act

The Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980 (44 U.S.C. 3501-3520) requires

that Federal agencies obtain approval from the OMB before collecting

information from 10 or more persons. There are no information

collection requirements in these amendments.

VII. Review Under the National Environmental Policy Act

DOE has determined that promulgation of this rule falls within the

interpreting/amending rulemaking class, Category A5 of appendix A to

subpart D, ``Categorical Exclusions Applicable to General Agency

Actions,'' of the DOE National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)

regulations. 10 CFR part 1021. It is therefore categorically

[[Page 32649]]

excluded from preparation of either an Environmental Assessment or an

Environmental Impact Statement under NEPA (42 U.S.C. 4321, et. seq).

VIII. Review Under Executive Order 12612

Executive Order 12612, 52 FR 41685 (October 30, 1987), requires

that regulations, rules, legislation, and any other policy actions be

reviewed for any substantial direct effects on States, on the

relationship between the National government and the States, or in the

distribution of power and responsibilities among various levels of

government. If there are sufficient substantial direct effects, then

the Executive Order requires preparation of a federalism assessment to

be used in all decisions involved in promulgating and implementing a

policy action. The rule revises certain policy and procedural

requirements applicable only to Federal energy management programs.

Therefore, the Department of Energy has determined that the rule will

not have a substantial direct effect on the institutional interests or

traditional functions of States.

IX. Review Under Executive Order 12988

With respect to the review of existing regulations and the

promulgation of new regulations, section 3 (a) of Executive Order

12988, ``Civil Justice Reform,'' 61 FR 4729 (February 7, 1996), imposes

on Executive agencies the general duty to adhere to the following

requirements: (1) Eliminate drafting errors and ambiguity; (2) write

regulations to minimize litigation; and (3) provide a clear legal

standard for affected conduct rather than a general standard and

promote simplificaiton and burden reduction. With regard to the review

required by section 3(a), section 3(b) of Executive Order 12988

specifically requires that Executive agencies make every reasonable

effort to ensure that the regulation: (1) Clearly specifies the

preemptive effect, if any; (2) clearly specifies any effect on existing

Federal law or regulation; (3) provides a clear legal standard for

affected conduct while promoting simplification and burden reduction;

(4) specifies the retroactive effect, if any; (5) adequately defines

key terms; and (6) addresses other important issues affecting clarity

and general draftsmanship under any guidelines issued by the Attorney

General. Section 3(c) of Executive Order 12988 requires agencies to

review regulations in light of applicable standards in section 3(a) and

section 3(b) to determine whether they are met or it is unreasonable to

meet one or more of them. DOE has completed the required review and

determined that, to the extent permitted by law, the final regulations

meet the relevant standards of Executive Order 12988.

List of Subjects in 10 CFR Part 436

Energy Conservation, Federal buildings and facilities.

Issued in Washington, DC, on June 4, 1996.

Christine A. Ervin,

Assistant Secretary, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.

For the reasons set out in the preamble, 10 CFR part 436 is amended

as follows:

PART 436--FEDERAL ENERGY MANAGEMENT AND PLANNING PROGRAMS

1. The authority citation for part 436 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 42 U.S.C. 6361; 42 U.S.C. 8251-8263; and 42 U.S.C.

8287-8287c.

2. Section 436.1 is revised as follows:

Sec. 436.1 Scope.

This part sets forth the rules for Federal energy management and

planning programs to reduce Federal energy consumption and to promote

life cycle cost effective investments in building energy systems,

building water systems and energy and water conservation measures for

Federal buildings.

3. Section 436.2 is amended by revising paragraph (b) to read as

follows:

Sec. 436.2 General objectives.

* * * * *

(b) To promote the methodology and procedures for conducting life

cycle cost analyses of proposed investments in building energy systems,

building water systems and energy and water conservation measures;

* * * * *

4. Section 436.10 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 436.10 Purpose.

This subpart establishes a methodology and procedures for

estimating and comparing the life cycle costs of Federal buildings, for

determining the life cycle cost effectiveness of energy conservation

measures and water conservation measures, and for rank ordering life

cycle cost effective measures in order to design a new Federal building

or to retrofit an existing Federal building. It also establishes the

method by which efficiency shall be considered when entering into or

renewing leases of Federal building space.

5. Section 436.11 is amended by:

(a) Revising the definitions of component price, Federal building,

life cycle cost, replacement cost, retrofit, and salvage value, and (b)

adding definitions for building water system, non-water operation and

maintenance costs, and water conservation measures in alphabetical

order to read as follows:

Sec. 436.11 Definitions.

* * * * *

Building water system means a water conservation measure or any

portion of the structure of a building or any mechanical, electrical,

or other functional system supporting the building, the nature or

selection of which for a new building influences significantly the cost

of water consumed.

Component price means any variable sub-element of the total charge

for a fuel or energy or water, including but not limited to such

charges as ``demand charges,'' ``off-peak charges'' and ``seasonal

charges.''

* * * * *

Federal building means an energy or water conservation measure or

any building, structure, or facility, or part thereof, including the

associated energy and water consuming support systems, which is

constructed, renovated, leased, or purchased in whole or in part for

use by the Federal government. This term also means a collection of

such buildings, structures, or facilities and the energy and water

consuming support systems for such collection.

* * * * *

Life cycle cost means the total cost of owning, operating and

maintaining a building over its useful life (including its fuel and

water, energy, labor, and replacement components), determined on the

basis of a systematic evaluation and comparison of alternative building

systems, except that in the case of leased buildings, the life cycle

cost shall be calculated over the effective remaining term of the

lease.

* * * * *

Non-water operation and maintenance costs mean material and labor

cost for routine upkeep, repair and operation exclusive of water cost.

* * * * *

Replacement costs mean future cost to replace a building energy

system or building water system, an energy or water conservation

measure, or any component thereof.

Retrofit means installation of a building energy system or building

water system alternative in an existing Federal building.

[[Page 32650]]

Salvage value means the value of any building energy system or

building water system removed or replaced during the study period, or

recovered through resale or remaining at the end of the study period.

* * * * *

Water conservation measures mean measures that are applied to an

existing Federal building that improve the efficiency of water use,

reduce the amount of water for sewage disposal and are life cycle cost

effective and that involve water conservation, improvements in

operation and maintenance efficiencies, or retrofit activities.

6. Section 436.13 is amended by revising paragraph (a), the

introductory text of paragraph (b) and paragraph (b)(2) to read as

follows:

Sec. 436.13 Presuming cost-effectiveness results.

(a) If the investment and other costs for an energy or water

conservation measure considered for retrofit to an existing Federal

building or a building energy system or building water system

considered for incorporation into a new building design are

insignificant, a Federal agency may presume that such a system is life

cycle cost-effective without further analysis.

(b) A Federal agency may presume that an investment in an energy or

water conservation measure retrofit to an existing Federal building is

not life cycle cost-effective for Federal investment if the Federal

building is--

* * * * *

(2) Occupied under a lease which includes the cost of utilities in

the rent and does not provide a pass-through of energy or water savings

to the government; or

* * * * *

8. Section 436.14, is amended by revising paragraphs (b)(1), (c),

introductory text to paragraph (d)(2), (e) and (g) as follows:

Sec. 436.14 Methodological assumptions.

* * * * *

(b) * * *

(1) If the Federal agency is using component prices under

Sec. 436.14(c), that agency may use corresponding component escalation

rates provided by the energy or water supplier.

* * * * *

(c) Each Federal agency shall assume that the price of energy or

water in the base year is the actual price charged for energy or water

delivered to the Federal building and may use actual component prices

as provided by the energy or water supplier.

(d) * * *

(2) For determining the life cycle costs or net savings of mutually

exclusive alternatives for a given building energy system or building

water system (e.g., alternative designs for a particular system or size

of a new or retrofit building energy system or building water system),

a uniform study period for all alternatives shall be assumed which is

equal to--

* * * * *

(e) Each Federal agency shall assume that the expected life of any

building energy system or building water system is the period of

service without major renewal or overhaul, as estimated by a qualified

engineer or architect, as appropriate, or any other reliable source

except that the period of service of a building energy or water system

shall not be deemed to exceed the expected life of the owned building,

or the effective remaining term of the leased building (taking into

account renewal options likely to be exercised).

* * * * *

(g) Each Federal agency may assume that energy or water costs and

non-fuel or non-water operation and maintenance costs begin to accrue

at the beginning of the base year or when actually projected to occur.

* * * * *

8. Section 436.16 is amended by revising the section heading,

redesignating paragraphs (b) and (c) as paragraphs (c) and (d), and by

adding a new paragraph (b) as follows:

Sec. 436.16 Establishing non-fuel and non-water cost categories.

* * * * *

(b) The relevant non-water cost categories are--

(1) Investment costs;

(2) Non-water operation and maintenance cost;

(3) Replacement cost; and

(4) Salvage value.

* * * * *

9. Section 436.17 is amended by revising the section heading and by

adding paragraphs (c) and (d) to read as follows:

Sec. 436.17 Establishing energy or water cost data.

* * * * *

(c) Each Federal agency shall establish water costs in the base

year by multiplying the total units of water used in the base year by

the price per unit of water in the base year as determined in

accordance with Sec. 436.14(c).

(d) When water costs begin to accrue in the base year, the present

value of water costs over the study period is the product of water

costs in the base year as established under Sec. 436.17(a), or as

calculated by computer software provided or approved by DOE and used

with the official discount rate and assumptions under Sec. 436.14. When

water costs begin to accrue at a later time, subtract the present value

of water costs over the delay, calculated using the uniform present

worth factor for the period of delay, from the present value of water

costs over the study period or, if using computer software, indicate a

delayed beneficial occupancy date.

10. Section 436.18 is amended by revising the introductory text to

paragraph (c), paragraph (d), the first sentence of paragraph (e) and

paragraph (f) to read as follows:

Sec. 436.18 Measuring cost-effectiveness.

* * * * *

(c) Replacement of a building energy or water system with an energy

or water conservation measure by retrofit to an existing Federal

building or by substitution in the design for a new Federal building

shall be deemed cost-effective if--

* * * * *

(d) As a rough measure, each Federal agency may determine estimated

simple payback time under Sec. 436.23, which indicates whether a

retrofit is likely to be cost effective under one of the four

calculation methods referenced in Sec. 436.18(c). An energy or water

conservation measure alternative is likely to be cost-effective if

estimated payback time is significantly less than the useful life of

that system, and of the Federal building in which it is to be

installed.

(e) Mutually exclusive alternatives for a given building energy or

water system, considered in determining such matters as the optimal

size of a solar energy system, the optimal thickness of insulation, or

the best choice of double-glazing or triple-glazing for windows, shall

be compared and evaluated on the basis of life cycle costs or net

savings over equivalent study periods. * * *

(f) When available appropriations will not permit all cost-

effective energy or water conservation measures to be undertaken, they

shall be ranked in descending order of their savings-to-investment

ratios, or their adjusted internal rate of return, to establish

priority. If available appropriations cannot be fully exhausted for a

fiscal year by taking all budgeted energy or water conservation

measures according to their rank, the set of energy or water

conservation measures that will maximize net savings for available

appropriations should be selected.

* * * * *

[[Page 32651]]

11. Section 436.19 is amended by revising paragraph (d) to read as

follows:

Sec. 436.19 Life cycle costs.

* * * * *

(d) Energy and/or water costs.

12. Section 436.21 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 436.21 Savings-to-investment ratio.

The savings-to-investment ratio is the ratio of the present value

savings to the present value costs of an energy or water conservation

measure. The numerator of the ratio is the present value of net savings

in energy or water and non-fuel or non-water operation and maintenance

costs attributable to the proposed energy or water conservation

measure. The denominator of the ratio is the present value of the net

increase in investment and replacement costs less salvage value

attributable to the proposed energy or water conservation measure.

13. Section 436.22 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 436.22 Adjusted internal rate of return.

The adjusted internal rate of return is the overall rate of return

on an energy or water conservation measure. It is calculated by

subtracting 1 from the nth root of the ratio of the terminal value of

savings to the present value of costs, where n is the number of years

in the study period. The numerator of the ratio is calculated by using

the discount rate to compound forward to the end of the study period

the yearly net savings in energy or water and non-fuel or non-water

operation and maintenance costs attributable to the proposed energy or

water conservation measure. The denominator of the ratio is the present

value of the net increase in investment and replacement costs less

salvage value attributable to the proposed energy or water conservation

measure.

14. Section 436.23 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 436.23 Estimated simple payback time.

The estimated simple payback time is the number of years required

for the cumulative value of energy or water cost savings less future

non-fuel or non-water costs to equal the investment costs of the

building energy or water system, without consideration of discount

rates.

15. Section 436.24 is amended by revising the last sentence in the

section as follows:

Sec. 436.24 Uncertainty analyses.

* * * If additional analysis casts substantial doubt on the life

cycle cost analysis results, a Federal agency should consider obtaining

more reliable data or eliminating the building energy or water system

alternative.

[FR Doc. 96-16120 Filed 6-24-96;8:45am]

BILLING CODE 6450-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.