Public Comments on Extension of Information Collection

Federal RegisterJun 5, 1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Maritime Administration

OMB No. 2133-0525

Public Comments on Extension of Information Collection

ACTION: Agency response and request for further comments.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: In accordance with the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (Pub.

L. 104-13, as implemented by regulations at 5 CFR part 1320), this

notice reviews comments in response to an earlier notice of the

Maritime Administration's (MARAD) intention to request the Office of

Management and Budget (OMB) for extension of approval of a currently

approved information collection. Comments to OMB are invited on this

request.

DATES: Comments should be submitted on or before July 5, 1996. Comments

should be submitted to OMB as indicated below:

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

James E. Caponiti, Associate Administrator for National Security,

Maritime Administration, MAR-630, Room 7300, 400 Seventh Street, SW.,

Washington, DC 20590. Telephone 202-366-2323 or fax 202-493-2180.

Copies of this collection can also be obtained from that office.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

Currently, Title VI of the Merchant Marine Act, 1936, as amended

(Act), 46 App. U.S.C. 1171 et seq., authorizes the Secretary of

Transportation (Secretary) to provide operating-differential subsidy

(ODS) to U.S.-flag ship operators for the operation of their vessels in

essential services in the foreign commerce of the United States.

Eligibility for the ODS program is limited to citizens of the United

States, as defined in Section 2 of the Shipping Act, 1916, as amended,

46 App. U.S.C. 802, and MARAD regulations at 46 CFR part 355. Section

801 of the Act requires extensive recordkeeping for ODS contractors and

related parties pursuant to MARAD regulations. In promulgating such

regulations, MARAD created Form MA-172, which contains requests for

specific information.

The Maritime Security Program (MSP), contained in legislation

currently pending in the Congress, H.R. 1350, the Maritime Security Act

of 1995, will replace the current ODS program and provides financial

assistance for U.S.-flag operators and vessels that meet certain

qualifications. It will require the Secretary of Transportation to

encourage the establishment of a fleet of active,

[[Page 28635]]

militarily useful, privately owned vessels to meet the national defense

and other security requirements, while also maintaining a presence in

international commercial shipping. Participation in the MSP will not be

limited to Section 2 U.S. citizens.

On March 7, 1996, MARAD published in the Federal Register a Notice

and Request for Comments to MARAD on its request for extension of OMB

approval of the information collection relating to applications to

participate in the MSP pursuant to H.R. 1350 (OMB Control No. 2133-

0525), with a 60-day public comment period (61 FR 9223).

Description of Collection

Title of Collection: Applications and Amendments for Participation

under new Section 651 of Title VI, Subtitle B, Merchant Marine Act,

1936, as amended, and amendments thereto.

Type of Request: Extension of currently approved information

collection.

OMB Control Number: 2133-0525.

Form Number: No form number is assigned to the application.

Expiration Date of Approval: May 31, 1996.

Summary of Collection of Information: The information collected

includes an initial application for participation in the program as

well as amendments of maritime security program operating agreements.

Need and Use of the Information: When enacted, H.R. 1350 will amend

Title VI of the Act and will require MARAD to accept applications for

enrollment in a Maritime Security Fleet no later than 30 days after the

date of enactment. Receipt of an application will indicate intent on

the part of the applicant to enter its vessel(s) in the MSP. MARAD will

analyze the information according to prescribed priorities and select

vessels for participation in the program. Over the life of an agreement

amendments may be necessary to include additional vessels and for

changes to existing vessels or status of the applicant.

Description of Respondents and Frequency of Collection: It is

estimated that 10 carriers would submit one-time initial applications

to participate in the program and it is estimated that five amendments

would be required over a ten year period (average 0.5 per year) of an

MSP operating agreement.

Annual Responses: 10 one-time applications, 0.5 amendments.

Annual Burden: 60 hours for one-time applications, 1 hour for

amendments.

Comments: Send all comments regarding this information collection

to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs of OMB, Attention:

Desk Officer for, Department of Transportation, Maritime

Administration.

Discussion of Comments and Summary of Requirements in the Final

Application and Rule

This section includes a discussion of the significant issues raised

by public comment and how they were addressed. One comment letter from

a research and educational organization was received on the proposed

application. The organization supported the proposed application, while

disagreeing with certain components of the financial requirements

section. On May 21, 1996, a meeting was held between the commentor and

MARAD during which some of the comments were clarified.

Summary of Comments

1. Need for Financial Data and Expected Benefit

Comment. The commentor stated that there was no practical need or

policy basis for MARAD to require the extensive financial data required

by the Form MA-172. The commentor noted that the MA-172 contained 29

financial schedules and statements in addition to the 18 single spaced

pages of financial requirements contained in MARAD's regulations at 46

CFR part 232. The commentor noted that the Notice required information

as it related to applications under the proposed statute and that the

Notice stated that MARAD will analyze the information according to

prescribed priorities to select vessels for participation in the

program. The commentor believed that new Section 651(b) of the Act,

``Vessel Eligibility,'' has a number of clear objective standards

regarding vessel eligibility for the program, none of which require the

type of information requested by MARAD in Form MA-172.

Response. MARAD is not requiring the submission of Form MA-172. In

the alternative, an applicant may submit an audited financial

statement. The proposed submission of Form MA-172 (separate approval

under OMB Control No. 2133-0005) is intended to (1) apply only to the

applicant, not to any parent company, affiliate or subsidiary; and (2)

simplify the process as most anticipated applicants have a current Form

MA-172 on file with MARAD. The financial reporting burden would

therefore be significantly reduced for a vast majority of the

applicants.

In connection with the Notice for Application to participate in the

MSP, MARAD published a Notice and Request for Comments on changes to

the Form MA-172. The commentor did not address the proposed changes

contained in that Notice in their comment. The revised Form MA-172 has

been reduced by 50 percent in an effort to lessen the burden on

respondents. In response to the 18 pages of financial requirement of

MARAD's regulations mentioned above, it was determined in the

subsequent meeting that this was a misunderstanding between the agency

and the commentor. The section on financial data submission states

``For applicants which have not completed a Form MA-172 in conjunction

with other MARAD assistance programs, complete that form as described

at 46 CFR part 232.'' MARAD's intention is to give the respondents a

format or guide to use (such as the one contained in its regulations at

46 CFR part 232), and not to actually suggest adherence to the letter

of part 232. The reference to part 232 has been removed and the section

has been reworded to read: ``Applicant must submit an audited financial

statement or have a Form MA-172 already on file with MARAD.''

With respect to the selection criteria contained in new section 652

of the Act, added by section 2 of H.R. 1350, MARAD believes it is

within its administrative purview, and in the public interest, to

consider the financial viability of a company prior to choosing it for

participation in the program.

2. Authority To Collect Data

Comment. The commentor stated that MARAD failed to identify that it

did not have the authority to collect the information as section 801 of

the Act is specifically exempted under new section 652(c) of the Act

and therefore would not apply.

Response. Section 801 of the Merchant Marine Act, 1936, as amended,

applies to contracts executed by the Secretary of Transportation under

Title VI or VII of the Act and therefore does not pertain specifically

to application for such contracts. The pending legislation does not

address information collection prior to the grant of MSP contracts. In

the absence of specific direction from the Congress, it is appropriate

for MARAD to exercise its discretion as to what information is

necessary to process MSP applications, provided that it is not

inconsistent with the express provisions of the legislation or with its

legislative history. Since the proposed legislation is silent on the

collection of information prior to the award of an MSP contract, MARAD,

acting under general rulemaking authority for the Act derived from

section 204(b) of the Act, 46 App. U.S.C. 1114, can collect appropriate

information. MARAD believes it is good

[[Page 28636]]

administrative practice to require, at a minimum, the information

requested as a condition for payment of financial assistance.

3. Subsidiaries and Affiliates

Comment. The commentor stated MARAD lacked authority to obtain

information concerning all contractors' parent companies, affiliates,

and subsidiaries together with an indication of the business transacted

by each.

Response. In the meeting held between MARAD and the commentor, the

issue was clarified and it was agreed that the request for information

should be applicable only to parent companies, affiliates, and

subsidiaries that are involved in the maritime industry for non-section

2 citizen applicants. Section 2 citizen applicants will be required to

provide information on affiliated relationships necessary to document

status as a section 2 citizen.

4. Citizenship

Comment. The commentor stated that, with respect to the extensive

disclosure required with respect to stock ownership, shareholders,

voting trusts and agreements whereby control of an applicant is in any

way held or exercised by any person not the holder of legal title to

such shares, it found the request to be too intrusive. The commentor

suggested that MARAD on an ad hoc basis continue its practice of

requiring citizenship affidavits from some applicants.

Response. MARAD conceptually agrees with the commentor's suggestion

and will require the submission of such extensive information only from

those applicants requesting to apply as citizens of the United States.

Other applicants need only prove lesser levels of citizenship.

5. Current or Anticipated Agreements

Comment. The commentor stated that the requested information

regarding current agreements with other carriers was already available

and, with respect to anticipated agreements, that request was intrusive

and unnecessary for the administration of the MSP.

Response. During the meeting between MARAD and the commentor, the

issue was clarified and it was agreed that current information on

operations and agreements was needed to assist the agency in

identifying potential sealift capacity available for use in accordance

with an Emergency Preparedness Program. As a result, the section on

agreements would read: ``Describe any current agreements and or

relationships with other carriers.'' All reference to anticipated

agreements will be deleted.

6. Certification of Citizenship

Comment. The commentor stated that the application required the

applicant to be a citizen of the United States within the meaning of

Section 2, Shipping Act, 1916, as amended, and that requirement was

wrong.

Response. The requirement to certify Section 2 citizenship as part

of the application was an error and has been corrected by adding a

provision for applicants who are not applying as Section 2 citizens

which reads: ``* * * or is eligible to document a vessel under 46

U.S.C. 121 * * *''.

Dated: May 30, 1996.

By order of the Maritime Administrator.

Joel C. Richard,

Secretary, Maritime Administration.

[FR Doc. 96-14092 Filed 6-4-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-81-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Public Comments on Extension of Information Collection · 61 FR 28634 | Frix