Proposed Exemptions; The Everett Clinic Profit Sharing Plan

Federal RegisterJun 4, 1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF LABOR

Pension and Welfare Benefits Administration

[Application No. D-10171, et al.]

Proposed Exemptions; The Everett Clinic Profit Sharing Plan

AGENCY: Pension and Welfare Benefits Administration, Labor.

ACTION: Notice of proposed exemptions.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This document contains notices of pendency before the

Department of Labor (the Department) of proposed exemptions from

certain of the prohibited transaction restriction of the Employee

Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (the Act) and/or the Internal

Revenue Code of 1986 (the Code).

Written Comments and Hearing Requests

All interested persons are invited to submit written comments or

request for a hearing on the pending exemptions, unless otherwise

stated in the Notice of Proposed Exemption, within 45 days from the

date of publication of this Federal Register Notice. Comments and

request for a hearing should state: (1) the name, address, and

telephone number of the person making the comment or request, and (2)

the nature of the person's interest in the exemption and the manner in

which the person would be adversely affected by the exemption. A

request for a hearing must also state the issues to be addressed and

include a general description of the evidence to be presented at the

hearing. A request for a hearing must also state the issues to be

addressed and include a general description of the evidence to be

presented at the hearing.

ADDRESSES: All written comments and request for a hearing (at least

three copies) should be sent to the Pension and Welfare Benefits

Administration, Office of Exemption Determinations, Room N-5649, U.S.

Department of Labor, 200 Constitution Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C.

20210. Attention: Application No. stated in each Notice of Proposed

Exemption. The applications for exemption and the comments received

will be available for public inspection in the Public Documents Room of

Pension and Welfare Benefits Administration, U.S. Department of Labor,

Room N-5507, 200 Constitution Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20210.

Notice to Interested Persons

Notice of the proposed exemptions will be provided to all

interested persons in the manner agreed upon by the applicant and the

Department within 15 days of the date of publication in the Federal

Register. Such notice shall include a copy of the notice of proposed

exemption as published in the Federal Register and shall inform

interested persons of their right to comment and to request a hearing

(where appropriate).

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The proposed exemptions were requested in

applications filed pursuant to section

[[Page 28238]]

408(a) of the Act and/or section 4975(c)(2) of the Code, and in

accordance with procedures set forth in 29 CFR Part 2570, Subpart B (55

FR 32836, 32847, August 10, 1990). Effective December 31, 1978, section

102 of Reorganization Plan No. 4 of 1978 (43 FR 47713, October 17,

1978) transferred the authority of the Secretary of the Treasury to

issue exemptions of the type requested to the Secretary of Labor.

Therefore, these notices of proposed exemption are issued solely by the

Department.

The applications contain representations with regard to the

proposed exemptions which are summarized below. Interested persons are

referred to the applications on file with the Department for a complete

statement of the facts and representations.

The Everett Clinic Profit Sharing Plan and 401(k) Employee Savings Plan

and Trust (the Plan) Located in Everett, Washington

[Application No. D-10171]

Proposed Exemption

The Department is considering granting an exemption under the

authority of section 408(a) of the Act and section 4975(c)(2) of the

Code and in accordance with the procedures set forth in 29 CFR Part

2570, Subpart B (55 FR 32836, 32847, August 10, 1990). If the exemption

is granted, the restrictions of sections 406(a), 406 (b)(1) and (b)(2)

of the Act and the sanctions resulting from the application of section

4975 of the Code, by reason of section 4975(c)(1) (A) through (E) of

the Code, shall not apply to the following proposed transactions

between the Plan and the Everett Clinic (the Employer), a party in

interest with respect to the Plan: (1) The exchange of cash and real

property (Parcel B) owned by the Plan for other real property (Parcel

C) owned by the Employer; (2) the grant by the Employer to the Plan of

a perpetual easement to run with the land on the Plan's Parcel B to be

exchanged and on the Employer's property (Parcel E); (3) the

modification and extension of an existing lease (the New Lease) of

improved real property by the Plan to the Employer, so as to include

Parcel C and, effective January 1, 1997, a parking lot owned by the

Employer (Parcel D) to be contributed gratuitously 1 to the Plan;

and (4) the potential future purchase of the leased premises by the

Employer pursuant to the terms of an option agreement contained in the

New Lease.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ The Department notes the Employer's representation that its

contribution of Parcel D to the Plan will not be a prohibited

transaction under the Department's regulation at 29 CFR 2509.94-3

because the contribution will not be made pursuant to any legal

obligation of the Employer to contribute. The Plan is a profit-

sharing plan which provides for a fully discretionary annual

contribution by the Employer. It is represented that Parcel D will

be contributed to the Plan on December 31, 1996 for the 1996 Plan

Year and that no contribution has been declared for the 1996 Plan

Year; therefore, the Employer has no existing obligation to

contribute any amounts to the Plan. However, the Department

expresses no opinion herein as to whether the Employer's

contribution of Parcel D to the Plan is fully discretionary.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

This proposed exemption is subject to the following conditions:

(1) the Plan is represented in all the transactions by a qualified,

independent fiduciary;

(2) the terms and conditions of the transactions are at least as

favorable to the Plan as those the Plan could obtain in comparable

arm's length transactions with unrelated parties;

(3) under the purchase agreement (the Purchase Agreement) with

respect to the exchange of Parcel B for Parcel C, the Plan pays to the

Employer an amount no more than the difference between the fair market

values of Parcel B and Parcel C as of the date of the exchange, as

established by a qualified, independent appraiser, with the Plan

receiving full market value for Parcel B (notwithstanding its being

transferred subject to an easement);

(4) the rent paid to the Plan under the New Lease is and continues

to be no less than the fair market rental value of the leased premises,

as established by a qualified, independent appraiser;

(5) the rent is adjusted every three years, based upon an updated

independent appraisal, but never falls below the fair market rental

amount initially established;

(6) the New Lease is a triple net lease under which the Employer as

the tenant is obligated for all operating expenses, including

maintenance, repairs, taxes, insurance, and utilities;

(7) the independent fiduciary expressly approves any improvements

over $100,000 to the leased premises and any renewal of the New Lease

beyond the initial term;

(8) the New Lease contains a two-way option agreement enabling the

Plan to sell the leased premises to the Employer (or the Employer to

purchase the leased premises from the Plan), in the event the

independent fiduciary determines that such a sale is in the best

interests of the Plan, for cash in an amount which is the greater of:

(a) the original acquisition cost of the premises to the Plan plus

expenses, or (b) the fair market value of the premises as of the date

of the sale, as established by a qualified, independent appraiser

selected by the independent fiduciary;

(9) at all times, the fair market value of the leased premises

represents no more than 25% of the total assets of the Plan;

(10) the independent fiduciary determines that all of the

transactions are appropriate for and in the best interests of the Plan

and its participants and beneficiaries at the time of the transactions;

(11) at all times, the independent fiduciary monitors and enforces

compliance with the terms and conditions of the Purchase Agreement, the

New Lease, and the exemption; and

(12) the Plan incurs no commissions, costs, fees, nor other

expenses relating to any of the transactions.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This exemption, if granted, will be effective as of

June 1, 1996.

Summary of Facts and Representations

1. The Plan is a defined contribution, 401(k)/profit sharing plan

sponsored by the Employer. The Employer, a Washington corporation, is a

multi-specialty group medical practice with a main campus at 3901 Hoyt

Avenue, Everett, Washington and five satellite facilities in Snohomish

County. As of December 31, 1994, the Plan had 627 participants and

beneficiaries and total assets of $55,469,695. The trustees of the Plan

are Robert E. Andre, M.D., James R. Pinkham, M.D., John P. Nolan, M.D.,

Patricia J. Slater, Andrea B. Rodewald, Ann Wanner, M.D., Raymond S.

Wilson, M.D., Rochelle Crollard, and Frederick T. Goset.

2. Parcel A, which is owned by the Plan, consists of an area of

74,846 square feet and includes the old clinic building (Old Clinic

Building). Parcel A is being leased to the Employer (the Current Lease)

pursuant to an individual administrative exemption granted by the

Department, Prohibited Transaction Exemption 81- 46 (PTE 81-46, 46 FR

113, June 12, 1981). The Plan and the Employer initiated a leasing

arrangement in 1962, prior to passage of the Act. In 1974, the parties

entered into a revised lease agreement, which was superseded by the

Current Lease. The 15-year term of the Current Lease will expire on

June 30, 1996. The rights of the Plan with respect to the Current Lease

are represented for all purposes by the First Interstate Bank of

Washington N.A. (First Interstate), successor to the Olympic Bank of

Everett, Washington (the Olympic Bank). First Interstate will also be

acting as an independent fiduciary for the Plan with respect to all the

proposed

[[Page 28239]]

transactions which are the subject of the instant exemption request.

3. Parcel B, which is owned by the Plan, consists of a rectangular-

shaped parking lot with an area of 28,660 square feet and is located

directly across the street from the Old Clinic Building. Parcel B

adjoins property owned by the Employer and is being leased to the

Employer, along with Parcel A, under the Current Lease. Parcel B is

paved, marked, and curbed for automobile parking, and has no building

improvements.

Parcel C, which is owned by the Employer, consists of an area of

16,818 square feet and includes a fully improved medical clinic

facility (the Addition). Parcel C adjoins the Old Clinic Building and

is otherwise surrounded by property owned by the Plan (primarily space

used for parking). In its unimproved state, Parcel C originally

belonged to the Plan. It is represented that Parcel C was sold to a

partnership Colby Building Associates, on June 14, 1984, in accordance

with the provisions of section 414(c)(3) of the Act,2 for purposes

of constructing the Addition. That partnership was later merged with

the Employer and no longer exists.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\2\ The Department expresses no opinion herein as to whether

the sale of Parcel C complied with the requirements of section

414(c)(3) of the Act.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Parcel D, which is owned by the Employer, consists of a parking lot

with an area of 4,361 square feet and is adjacent to Parcel A, which,

as described above, is owned by the Plan.

4. Parcels A, B, and C were appraised by James D. McCallum, M.A.I.,

and Grant S. Gladow of McCallum & Associates, both independent real

estate appraisers certified in the State of Washington. Relying

primarily on the income approach to valuation, Messrs. McCallum and

Gladow determined that as of July 1, 1996, Parcel A will have a

prospective fair market value of $4,900,000 and Parcel C, $3,900,000.

Relying on the cost approach to valuation, Messrs. McCallum and Gladow

determined that as of that same date, Parcel B will have a prospective

fair market value of $390,000.3 The appraisal states that the

total value of $9,190,000 for all three parcels represents a simple

summation of the values of each of the individual parcels. While the

available market data does not provide direct evidence that the

assemblage value of the parcels (under single ownership) is greater

than the sum of its component parts, in the opinion of the appraisers,

consolidation of ownership in one entity will enhance the marketability

of all the parcels.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ The appraisal states that the figure of $390,000 represents

a ``fee simple value'' for Parcel B (i.e., a valuation that does not

take into account the anticipated transfer of Parcel B subject to an

easement).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Messrs. McCallum and Gladow further determined that as of July 1,

1996, Parcel A will have a prospective fair market rental value of

$533,688 per annum ($44,474 per month) and Parcel C, $413,616 per annum

($34,468 per month). The appraisal states that the zoning status of

Parcels A, B, and C is R-4, allowing for a variety of uses, including

multi-family development, commercial activities, and professional

office/medical facilities. The highest and best use of the subject

parcels, if vacant, is as medical offices. The highest and best use of

the subject parcels, as improved, is their continued use as medical

facilities.

Parcel D was appraised by Richard J. DeFrancesco of Macaulay &

Associates, also an independent real estate appraiser certified in the

State of Washington. Relying primarily on the sales comparison approach

to valuation, Mr. DeFrancesco determined that the fair market value of

Parcel D as of July 21, 1995 was $110,000.

5. An administrative exemption is requested from the Department for

the following proposed transactions. The Plan trustees desire that the

Plan acquire Parcel C from the Employer in order to consolidate

ownership of adjoining Parcels A and C, thus enhancing the

marketability of property the Plan already owns. The Employer desires

to acquire Parcel B from the Plan for purposes of constructing a three-

story parking garage on Parcel B and on other contiguous property owned

by the Employer, namely Parcel E. The parking garage, which will be

available free of charge to customers of the Employer, will provide

parking as required under municipal building codes to support the new

surgery center to be built by the Employer on Parcel E, as well as the

existing clinic facilities on Parcels A and C. Under the proposed

Purchase Agreement, the Plan will convey title to Parcel B to the

Employer, and the Employer will convey title to Parcel C to the Plan.

The Plan will pay to the Employer additional cash consideration

representing the difference between the fair market values of Parcel B

and Parcel C ($3,510,000 as of July 1, 1996), based upon an updated

independent appraisal as of the date of the exchange. The Employer will

grant to the Plan, as part of the exchange, a perpetual, non-exclusive

pedestrian and vehicle parking easement 4 to run with the land on

Parcels B and E in favor of Parcels A and C to guarantee adequate

parking for the Plan-owned property following the exchange. The Plan

will receive full market value for Parcel B, notwithstanding its being

transferred subject to an easement. Finally, an exemption is requested

for the New Lease, which will modify the Current Lease to reflect the

transactions described above, as well as the gratuitous contribution by

the Employer to the Plan, effective December 31, 1996, of Parcel D (to

be included among the premises being leased back to the Employer).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\4\ The Department notes the Employer's representation that the

term ``non-exclusive'' refers to an arrangement whereby the Employer

and the Plan are intended to have joint use, as opposed to the

Plan's having exclusive use, of the easement (i.e., the Employer

will reserve the right of access to the new parking garage for all

purposes not inconsistent nor in interference with the rights

granted to the Plan).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

An actuarial consulting firm Trautmann, Maher & Associates, located

in Mill Creek, Washington, prepared an asset projection report of the

Plan's assets. The report, dated September 25, 1995, states that the

fair market value of all employer real property after the Plan's

divestment of Parcel B and its acquisition of Parcel C will comprise

12.58% of the Plan's total assets, as of December 31, 1996.5 This

projected percentage of all employer real property was calculated to be

the highest level of Plan assets that will be reached for the duration

of the New Lease.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\5\ Due to the fact that the Employer's decision to contribute

Parcel D (valued at $110,000) to the Plan was made subsequent to

preparation of the plan assets projection report by Trautmann, Maher

& Associates, such report does not take into account the Plan's

acquisition of Parcel D.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

6. First Interstate, as noted above, will act as an independent

fiduciary to represent the Plan's interests with respect to all the

proposed transactions. First Interstate and its predecessor the Olympic

Bank, have served as non- discretionary custodian of a portion of the

Plan's assets since approximately December 1980. In addition, the

Olympic Bank was appointed the Plan's independent fiduciary at the time

of the filing of the exemption application with respect to the Current

Lease, whose term began in 1981. First Interstate, whose fees are paid

by the Employer, represents that it is independent of the Employer and

that the Bank has less than one percent of its deposits and less than

one percent of its outstanding loans attributable to deposits and loans

of the Employer. First Interstate represents that it has extensive

experience as a fiduciary under the Act, that it is knowledgeable as to

the subject transactions, and that it acknowledges and accepts its

duties and

[[Page 28240]]

responsibilities in acting as a fiduciary with respect to the Plan.

7. Regardless of whether the exchange of Parcel B and Parcel C

closes by July 1, 1996, the New Lease, which is to extend and modify

the Current Lease, will begin as of that date. The New Lease provides

for an initial term of 10 years, which may be extended at the option of

the lessee in five-year increments, upon the express approval of the

independent fiduciary. The Employer will pay an initial rent to the

Plan at the annual rate of $533,688 ($44,474 per month), which is the

fair market rental value of Parcel A. When Parcel C is added (upon

closing of the exchange), the rent will increase by an amount equal to

the fair market rental value of Parcel C as of the date of the exchange

(appraised at $413,616 per year as of July 1, 1996) to an annual rate

of approximately $947,304 (approximately $78,942 per month). When

Parcel D is added, the rent will increase by an amount to be determined

by the independent fiduciary by reference to a qualified, independent

appraisal of the fair market rental value of Parcel D as of January 1,

1997. The total rent for the leased premises is to be adjusted every

three years, based upon an updated independent appraisal, and is not to

fall below the fair market rental amounts initially established. The

New Lease will be a triple-net lease under which the Employer as the

tenant is obligated for all operating expenses, including maintenance,

repairs, taxes, insurance, and utilities. The Employer will indemnify

and hold the Plan harmless for any loss or damages to the leased

premises.

The New Lease permits the Employer to remodel and make structural

changes or additions to the leased premises at the Employer's expense,

so long as such improvements comply with all applicable government

regulations. Any expense over $100,000 must be expressly approved by

the independent fiduciary. The threshold of $100,000 is intended to

provide the Employer with discretion to make routine renovations, such

as the installation of new carpeting, without having to consult the

independent fiduciary. Any improvements or renovations of the property

will belong to the Plan upon termination of the New Lease.

The New Lease also contains a two-way option agreement enabling the

Plan to sell the leased premises to the Employer (or the Employer to

purchase the leased premises from the Plan), in the event the

independent fiduciary determines that such a sale is in the best

interests of the Plan, for an amount which is the greater of: (a) the

original acquisition cost of the premises to the Plan plus expenses, or

(b) the fair market value of the premises as of the date of the sale,

as established by a qualified, independent appraiser selected by the

independent fiduciary. Any such sale would be a one-time transaction

for cash, and the Plan would incur no expenses relating to the sale.

8. The independent fiduciary represents that it has negotiated the

terms and conditions of the Purchase Agreement and of the New Lease and

has determined that such terms and conditions are at least as favorable

to the Plan as those the Plan could obtain in comparable arm's length

transactions with unrelated parties. The properties involved have been

independently appraised, as well as having been subjected to an

environmental audit. The independent fiduciary recognized that because

of Parcel B's importance to the Employer's plans to construct a parking

garage and a surgery center, the Plan was entitled to a premium in the

exchange of Parcel B for Parcel C. Accordingly, the Plan will receive

from the Employer the benefit of a perpetual parking easement to run

with the land on Parcels B and E, in addition to the full market value

of Parcel B. Finally, the independent fiduciary has conducted an

investigation of the relevant rental market in order to develop

appropriate terms for the New Lease.

9. The independent fiduciary represents that it believes the

proposed transactions are in the best interests of the Plan and its

participants and beneficiaries. The Plan's acquisition of Parcels C and

D will combine adjoining Parcels A, C, and D under single ownership,

providing the Plan with ownership of almost an entire block (the block

between Hoyt and Colby Avenues), and thus will enhance the value and

marketability of property that the Plan already owns. Parcel B will be

transferred to the Employer at its full market value, despite being

subject to a perpetual parking easement in favor of Plan-owned

Property. The New Lease will generate income to the Plan in the form of

rent and thus provide the Plan with a return on its investment in

addition to any appreciation of the value of the leased property. The

Plan is bearing none of the expenses with respect to any of the

proposed transactions.

The independent fiduciary has also determined that the proposed

transactions are appropriate for the Plan in light of the Plan's

overall investment portfolio for the following reasons. The projected

percentage of all employer real property (Parcels A, C, and D) will not

exceed approximately 13% of Plan assets for the duration of the New

Lease. The Plan's acquisition of Parcel C will not create a liquidity

problem, will provide increased assurance that the Plan will be able to

sell the adjoining property the Plan now owns, and will return income

to the Plan. The Plan's divestment of Parcel B will reduce the

concentration of Plan assets in real estate and the amount that the

Plan must pay for Parcel C. The Current Lease should be extended

because of the difficulties involved in finding another tenant or a

ready purchaser for the leased property at its appraised fair market

value. The income from the Current Lease has provided the Plan with a

stable and favorable rate of investment return (over 9% per annum for

the period covering the 1980's and the first half of the 1990's,

ranking in the top 5% of the Independent Consultants Cooperative

database). The stable and predictable returns provided by the Current

Lease have enabled the Plan trustees to invest the remainder of the

Plan's assets in more volatile investments offering the potential for

higher returns. The independent fiduciary has also examined the

financial viability of the Employer (including the potential impact of

any substantial malpractice claims), determined that the Employer's

past performance under the Current Lease has been in accordance with

its contractual obligations, and concluded that the Employer will

continue to be a good tenant.

The independent fiduciary will recommend to the Plan trustees

execution of the Purchase Agreement and the New Lease only if they

remain appropriate for and in the best interests of the Plan and its

participants and beneficiaries at the time of the transactions.

Further, the independent fiduciary will, at all times, monitor and

enforce the Employer's compliance with the terms and conditions of the

Purchase Agreement, the Proposed Lease, and the exemption.

10. In summary, the applicant represents that the proposed

transactions satisfy the statutory criteria for an exemption under

section 408(a) of the Act for the following reasons: (1) The Plan will

be represented in all the transactions by a qualified, independent

fiduciary; (2) the terms and conditions of the transactions will be at

least as favorable to the Plan as those the Plan could obtain in

comparable arm's length transactions with unrelated parties; (3) the

Plan will pay to the Employer cash in an amount no more than the

difference between the fair market

[[Page 28241]]

values of Parcel B and Parcel C as of the date of the exchange, as

established by a qualified, independent appraiser; (4) the Plan will

receive in the exchange full market value for Parcel B, while retaining

a perpetual parking easement granting the Plan access to the new

parking garage to be constructed; (5) the Plan will have single

ownership of both portions of the clinic facilities, as well as Parcel

D, which will enhance the value and marketability of the Plan-owned

property; (6) the rent paid to the Plan under the New Lease will be no

less than the fair market rental value of the leased premises, as

established by a qualified, independent appraiser; (7) the rent will be

adjusted every three years, based upon an updated independent

appraisal, but will never fall below the fair market rental amount

initially established; (8) the New Lease will be a triple net lease

under which the Employer as the tenant is obligated for all operating

expenses, including maintenance, repairs, taxes, insurance, and

utilities; (9) the independent fiduciary will expressly approve any

improvements over $100,000 to the leased premises and any renewal of

the New Lease beyond the initial term; (10) the New Lease will contain

a two-way option agreement enabling the Plan to sell the leased

premises to the Employer (or the Employer to purchase the leased

premises from the Plan), in the event the independent fiduciary

determines that such a sale is in the best interests of the Plan, for

cash in an amount which is the greater of: (a) the original acquisition

cost of the premises to the Plan plus expenses, or (b) the fair market

value of the premises as of the date of the sale, as established by a

qualified, independent appraiser selected by the independent fiduciary;

(11) at all times, the fair market value of the leased premises will

represent no more than 25% of the total assets of the Plan; (12) the

independent fiduciary will determine that all of the transactions are

appropriate for and in the best interests of the Plan and its

participants and beneficiaries at the time of the transactions; (13) at

all times, the independent fiduciary will monitor and enforce

compliance with the terms and conditions of the Purchase Agreement, the

New Lease, and the exemption; and (14) the Plan will incur no

commissions, costs, fees, nor other expenses relating to any of the

transactions.

Notice to Interested Persons

Notice of the proposed exemption shall be given to all interested

persons by first-class mail and by posting the required information at

the Employer's offices within 10 days of the date of publication of the

notice of pendency in the Federal Register. Such notice shall include a

copy of the notice of proposed exemption as published in the Federal

Register and shall inform interested persons of their right to comment

and/or to request a hearing with respect to the proposed exemption.

Comments and requests for a hearing are due within 40 days of the date

of publication of this notice in the Federal Register.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Ms. Karin Weng of the Department,

telephone (202) 219-8881. (This is not a toll-free number.)

The SUP Welfare Plan (the Plan) Located in San Francisco, California

[Application No. L-10221]

Proposed Exemption

The Department is considering granting an exemption under the

authority of section 408(a) of the Act and in accordance with the

procedures set forth in 29 CFR Part 2570, Subpart B (55 FR 32836,

32847, August 10, 1990). If the exemption is granted, the restrictions

of sections 406(a), 406(b)(1) and (b)(2) of the Act shall not apply to

the proposed sale by the Plan of the remaining term of a one-hundred

year pre-paid leasehold interest (the Interest) to the Sailors' Union

of the Pacific Building Corporation (SUPBC), a party in interest with

respect to the Plan, provided the following conditions are satisfied:

a) the sale is a one-time transaction for cash; b) the Plan pays no

commissions or other expenses in connection with the sale; c) the Plan

receives the greater of $438,000 or the fair market value of the

Interest as of the date of the sale; and d) the fair market value of

the Interest has been determined by a qualified, independent appraiser.

Summary of Facts and Representations

1. The Plan was created in 1952 to provide welfare benefits to

eligible unlicensed seamen who work in the West Coast maritime

industry. The Plan is sponsored by the Sailors' Union of the Pacific

(the Union). The Plan has approximately 2,500 participants and

beneficiaries, and as of July 31, 1994, the fair market value of the

net assets of the Plan was $10,269,079.

2. During its early years, the Plan acquired facilities in Los

Angeles, San Francisco, Portland and Seattle to provide temporary

shelter for participants who were sometimes impoverished and homeless

between periods of shipboard employment. In 1954, the SUPBC, an

affiliate of the Union, constructed a building (the Building) at 2505

First Avenue, Seattle, Washington, for use as the Union's headquarters

in Seattle.

3. In exchange for $251,200, SUPBC conveyed to the Plan a pre-paid

one hundred year lease of the third floor of the Building. The lease

term began on June 1, 1954. Since 1954, the Plan has used the space to

provide housing benefits to Plan participants.

4. The applicants represent that the huge decline in the American

flag merchant marine has seriously eroded the funding available to the

Plan. The Plan's trustees desire to eliminate the housing program and

to concentrate Plan resources for the purpose of providing traditional

medical benefits. An opportunity currently exists to dispose of the

Interest because the Union and SUPBC have decided that they no longer

need to retain their interests in the property. Accordingly, the

applicants have requested the exemption proposed herein to permit the

Plan to sell the Interest to SUPBC.

5. The Plan will receive cash in the amount of the appraised fair

market value of the Interest. Mr. Allen N. Safer, MAI, of Property

Counselors, an independent appraiser in Seattle, Washington, appraised

the Interest as having a fair market value of $375,000 on July 1, 1994.

In 1995, Mr. Safer updated his appraisal of the Interest and determined

that the Interest had a fair market value of $405,000 as of December

14, 1995. However, Mr. Safer represents that he did not take into

account any premium that the Plan might receive based on its position

of being able to block the SUPBC's sale of the Building to a third

party. Mr. James B. Welle, a Senior Broker for the real estate firm of

Cushman & Wakefield of Washington, located in Bellevue, Washington, has

determined that a premium of $33,000 to the Plan is appropriate under

the circumstances. Accordingly, the applicants represent that the Plan

will receive the greater of $438,000 or the fair market value of the

Interest as of the date of the sale. The Plan will pay no commissions

or other expenses in connection with the sale.

6. In summary, the applicants represent that the proposed

transaction satisfies the criteria of section 408(a) of the Act

because: (a) the sale is a one-time transaction for cash; (b) the Plan

will pay no commissions or other expenses in connection with the sale;

and (c) the Plan will receive the greater of $438,000 or the fair

market value of the Interest as of the date of sale as determined by a

qualified, independent appraiser.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Gary H. Lefkowitz of the Department,

[[Page 28242]]

telephone (202) 219-8881. (This is not a toll-free number.)

Cablevision Industries Corporation Profit Sharing Plan (the Plan)

Located in New York, New York

[Application No. D-10233]

Proposed Exemption

The Department is considering granting an exemption under the

authority of section 408(a) of the Act and section 4975(c)(2) of the

Code and in accordance with the procedures set forth in 29 C.F.R. Part

2570, Subpart B (55 F.R. 32836, 32847, August 10, 1990). If the

exemption is granted the restrictions of sections 406(a), 406 (b)(1)

and (b)(2) of the Act and the sanctions resulting from the application

of section 4975 of the Code, by reason of section 4975(c)(1) (A)

through (E) of the Code, shall not apply to the proposed purchase from

the Plan by Cablevision Industries Corporation (the Employer), the

sponsor of the Plan, of the Plan's entire remaining interest (the

Surviving Claim) in guaranteed investment contract number GCNG8690011A

(the GIC) issued by the Executive Life Insurance Company (Executive

Life); provided that the following conditions are satisfied:

(A) All terms and conditions of the transaction are at least as

favorable to the Plan as those which the Plan could obtain in an arm's-

length transaction with an unrelated party;

(B) The Plan receives a cash purchase price which is no less than

the greater of (1) the fair market value of the Surviving Claim as of

the sale date, or (2) the Plan's principal investment attributable to

the Surviving Claim plus interest through the purchase date at the

Contract Rate (as defined below); and

(C) In the event the Employer subsequently receives payments with

respect to the Surviving Claim from any source in excess of the

purchase price paid to Plan, such excess will be paid to the Plan.

EFFECTIVE DATE: This exemption, if granted, will be effective as of

June 17, 1996.

Summary of Facts and Representations

1. The Employer, an indirect subsidiary of Time Warner, Inc., is a

New York corporation engaged in the distribution of cable television

services, with its principal place of business in New York, New York.

The Plan is a defined contribution profit sharing plan with 1,598

participants and total assets of approximately $16,810,297 as of

February 13, 1996. The Plan's assets are held by its trustee, Fleet

Trust Company in New York, New York (the Trustee), subject to the

direction of the Plan's investment committee (the Committee). The

Committee, comprised of officers of Time Warner Inc. (TWI), the parent

corporation of the Employer, has complete authority to manage and

control Plan assets and to determine the investment policy of the Plan.

2. Assets of the Plan are invested by the Trustee pursuant to the

directions of the Committee. Among the assets in the Plan is an

interest in a single-deposit guaranteed investment contract (the GIC)

issued to the Trustee on August 8, 1986 by Executive Life Insurance

Company of California (Executive Life). The Trustee purchased the GIC

on behalf of approximately 81 employee benefit plans which were clients

of the Trustee, including the Plan. At the time the GIC was purchased,

the Trustee served as investment manager of the Plan. The Plan made an

initial principal deposit of $49,800, representing a 1.66 percent

interest in the GIC (the GIC Interest). Under the terms of the GIC,

which is designated as Executive Life Contract Number GCNG8690011A, the

principal earns interest at the rate of 8.86 percent per annum (the

Contract Rate). The GIC terms permit the Plan to make withdrawals (the

Withdrawals) solely for the purchase of individual annuity contracts

for retiring Plan participants. Upon the GIC's stated maturity date of

August 8, 1991 (the Maturity Date), Executive Life was obligated to

make a lump-sum payment (the Maturity Payment) in the amount of the

total principal plus interest at the Contract Rate less Withdrawals.

3. On April 23, 1991 (the Conservatorship Date), Executive Life was

placed into conservatorship and rehabilitation by order of the Supreme

Court of New York (the Court), and a rehabilitator (the Rehabilitator)

was appointed by the Court. Payments and withdrawals with respect to

all Executive Life guaranteed investment contracts, including the GIC,

ceased at that time.6

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\6\ The Department notes that the decisions to acquire and hold

the GIC Interest are governed by the fiduciary responsibility

requirements of Part 4, Subtitle B, Title I of the Act. In this

proposed exemption, the Department is not proposing relief for any

violations of Part 4 which may have arisen as a result of the

acquisition and holding of the GIC Interest.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

As of the Conservatorship Date, the accumulated book value 7

of the GIC Interest was $74,325. As of the Maturity Date the amount of

the Maturity Payment which was due the Plan under the GIC as determined

by the Contract Rates was $76,132. On December 16, 1992, the Court

approved a plan of rehabilitation (the Rehab Plan) of Executive Life

which provided for the Rehabilitator to set new rates of interest (the

Rehab Rates) with respect to the GIC. In accordance with the Rehab

Plan, the Rehabilitator established the following Rehab Rates for the

principal amounts deposited under the GIC:

\7\ The accumulated book value of the GIC Interest is the total

principal deposited plus interest at the Contract Rate less

Withdrawals.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

From 8/8/86 to 8/8/91: 8.86 percent

From 8/8/91 to 8/7/92: 6.00 percent

From 8/7/92 to 2/28/93: 3.50 percent

From 2/28/93 to 2/15/94: 3.25 percent

From 2/15/94 to Final Payment: 4.00 percent

Pursuant to the Rehab Plan and a consequent agreement of January 4,

1994 (the Rehab Agreement) between the Trustee and the Rehabilitator,

the value of the GIC Interest, determined by the Rehab Rates, was

disbursed in a 93.7 percent immediate payout with a surviving claim

(the Surviving Claim) for the remaining 6.3 percent. The Surviving

Claim continues to earn a Rehab Rate of four percent annual interest

until payment to the Trustee with respect to the GIC Interest is

completed. Although the Plan received $79,862.91 on February 15, 1994

as the 93.7 percent payout with respect to the GIC Interest exclusive

of the Surviving Claim, the Employer represents that under the Rehab

Plan and the Rehab Agreement the Plan will not be made whole with

respect to its investment in the Surviving Claim in accordance with the

original terms of the GIC. The value of the Plan's interest in the

Surviving Claim, as determined by the Rehab Rates, was $5,871.67 as of

April 30, 1996.

4. Meanwhile, in January 1996 the Employer was acquired by a

subsidiary of TWI, and became a member of its controlled group of

entities involved in the cable television industry (the Merger). As a

result of the Merger, the Employer has determined to merge the Plan

with the Time Warner Entertainment Company, L.P. Additional Account

Plan (the New Plan), of which the Fidelity Management Trust Company

(Fidelity) is the trustee and investment manager. However, the Employer

represents that Fidelity will be unable to administer the GIC Interest

as part of the merged trust assets in the New Plan without considerable

additional cost.

The Employer desires to facilitate completion of the merger of the

Plan with the New Plan by providing for total and immediate liquidation

of the GIC Interest, and to prevent any loss on amounts due the Plan

under the terms of the GIC. To accomplish these

[[Page 28243]]

objectives, the Employer and the Committee determined that the most

expeditious means would be the Employer's cash purchase of the Plan's

remaining interest in the GIC. The Employer requests an exemption for

this transaction under the terms and conditions described herein.

5. The Employer proposes that the Plan transfer to the Employer the

Plan's entire remaining interest in the GIC in exchange for a cash

purchase price in the amount of the Plan's GIC Interest principal

investment attributable to the Surviving Claim plus interest at the

Contract Rate effective August 8, 1986 through the date of the

purchase. The Plan will incur no expenses with respect to the proposed

transaction. Subsequent to the purchase, the Employer, as owner of the

GIC Interest, will receive the Rehab Payments with respect to the

Surviving Claim, which includes interest at four percent. In the event

the Employer receives funds from any source with respect to the

Surviving Claim in excess of the purchase price paid to the Plan by the

Employer, such excess will be paid to the Plan.

6. The Employer is requesting that the exemption, if granted, be

effective as of June 17, 1996. The Employer explains that its

reorganizational activities commencing with its acquisition by TWI

subsidiaries in January 1996 have led to a greater number of Plan

participant terminations than usual. Whereas the Plan has permitted

distributions only annually, the New Plan enables distributions on a

monthly basis. Because distributions to many former participants of the

Plan are pending, the Employer desires to enable distributions to be

processed in the June 1996 processing cycle of the New Plan. This will

require the completed liquidation of the GIC Interest by June 17, 1996.

Accordingly, the Employer intends to consummate the proposed purchase

transaction on that date under the terms and conditions described

above.

7. In summary, the applicant represents that the proposed

transactions satisfy the criteria of section 408(a) of the Act for the

following reasons: (1) The transaction will provide the Plan with an

immediate return on its investment in the Surviving Claim at a rate of

interest, the Contract Rate, which is higher than the Rehab Rates; (2)

The proposed transfer of the GIC Interest to the Employer for a cash

purchase price will be a one- time transaction in which the Plan

receives no less than the greater of the fair market value of the GIC

Interest or the Plan's principal investment attributable to the

Surviving Claim plus interest through the purchase date at the Contract

Rate; (3) The Plan will incur no expenses with respect to the proposed

transaction; and (4) In the event the Employer receives payments with

respect to the GIC Interest in excess of the purchase price paid the

Plan, such excess will be paid to the Plan.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Ronald Willett of the Department,

telephone (202) 219-8881. (This is not a toll-free number.)

General Information

The attention of interested persons is directed to the following:

(1) The fact that a transaction is the subject of an exemption

under section 408(a) of the Act and/or section 4975(c)(2) of the Code

does not relieve a fiduciary or other party in interest of disqualified

person from certain other provisions of the Act and/or the Code,

including any prohibited transaction provisions to which the exemption

does not apply and the general fiduciary responsibility provisions of

section 404 of the Act, which among other things require a fiduciary to

discharge his duties respecting the plan solely in the interest of the

participants and beneficiaries of the plan and in a prudent fashion in

accordance with section 404(a)(1)(b) of the act; nor does it affect the

requirement of section 401(a) of the Code that the plan must operate

for the exclusive benefit of the employees of the employer maintaining

the plan and their beneficiaries;

(2) Before an exemption may be granted under section 408(a) of the

Act and/or section 4975(c)(2) of the Code, the Department must find

that the exemption is administratively feasible, in the interests of

the plan and of its participants and beneficiaries and protective of

the rights of participants and beneficiaries of the plan;

(3) The proposed exemptions, if granted, will be supplemental to,

and not in derogation of, any other provisions of the Act and/or the

Code, including statutory or administrative exemptions and transitional

rules. Furthermore, the fact that a transaction is subject to an

administrative or statutory exemption is not dispositive of whether the

transaction is in fact a prohibited transaction; and

(4) The proposed exemptions, if granted, will be subject to the

express condition that the material facts and representations contained

in each application are true and complete, and that each application

accurately describes all material terms of the transaction which is the

subject of the exemption.

Signed at Washington, DC, this 30th day of May, 1996.

Ivan Strasfeld,

Director of Exemption Determinations, Pension and Welfare Benefits

Administration, U.S. Department of Labor.

[FR Doc. 96-13916 Filed 6-3-96; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4510-29-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.