Interstate Shipment of State-inspected Meat and Poultry Products

Federal RegisterMay 7, 1996

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE

Food Safety and Inspection Service

[Docket No. 96-012N]

Interstate Shipment of State-inspected Meat and Poultry Products

AGENCY: Food Safety and Inspection Service, USDA.

ACTION: Notice; request for public comments.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: The 1996 Farm Bill requires the Secretary of Agriculture to

submit to Congress, by July 3, 1996, recommendations concerning the

steps necessary to achieve interstate shipment of State-inspected meat

and poultry products. Under the Federal Meat Inspection Act (FMIA) and

the Poultry Products Inspection Act (PPIA), products inspected under

State programs ``at least equal to'' the Federal inspection program may

be distributed only within State boundaries. FSIS is requesting comment

from the public on which issues need to be addressed in responding to

the Congressional directive to make recommendations concerning the

interstate shipment of State-inspected products. Possible issues

include, but are not limited to: the safety, wholesomeness, and

labeling of State-inspected products; recall responsibilities; the

administration of State programs; the funding of Federal oversight of

State inspection programs; the funding of Federal assistance to State

inspection programs; jurisdictional complications; eligibility of such

products for export; and economic effects. The Agency plans to use

these comments in formulating its recommendations to Congress

concerning State-inspected meat and poultry products.

DATES: Comments must be received on or before June 6, 1996.

ADDRESSES: Please send an original and two copies of written comments

to Policy, Evaluation and Planning Staff, Attn: FSIS Docket Clerk,

DOCKET No. 96-012N, Room 4352 South Building, Food Safety and

Inspection Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC

20250.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mr. Patrick Clerkin, Office of the

Administrator, Food Safety and Inspection Service, U.S. Department of

Agriculture, Washington, DC 20250; Code (202) 205-0700.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

1996 Farm Bill Provision

Section 918(b) of the Federal Agriculture Improvement and Reform

Act of 1996 (PL 104-127; known as the 1996 Farm Bill), which was signed

into law April 4, 1996, requires that, not later than 90 days after

enactment of the Farm Bill, or by July 3, 1996, the Secretary of

Agriculture submit a report to Congress concerning the steps necessary

to achieve interstate shipment of meat and poultry products inspected

under State programs that are ``at least equal to'' the Federal

inspection programs. Under the current Federal meat and poultry

inspection laws, such products may be distributed solely within the

States in which they are prepared.

Background

Under the Federal Meat Inspection Act (FMIA; 21 U.S.C. 601 et seq.)

and the Poultry Products Inspection Act (PPIA; 21 U.S.C. 451 et seq.),

FSIS is responsible for ensuring that meat, meat food, and poultry

products distributed in interstate and foreign commerce are safe,

wholesome, not adulterated, and properly marked, labeled, and packaged.

FSIS currently conducts antemortem and postmortem inspection of

livestock and poultry at slaughtering establishments, inspects further-

processed meat and poultry products, inspects the sanitary conditions

of facilities where meat and poultry products are produced, and

certifies U.S. products for export to foreign countries. FSIS

investigates violations of the inspection laws and violative products

are controlled through detentions, civil seizures and voluntary

recalls.

FSIS inspection is supported by laboratory services in the fields

of chemistry, microbiology, serology, and pathology. An important

laboratory-supported function is the National Residue Program, which is

designed to help prevent the distribution in commerce of products

containing illegal concentrations of drugs, pesticides, and other

chemicals. FSIS also carries out microbiological surveys to determine

pathogen levels in raw meat and poultry and special microbiological

studies and surveillance of raw and processed products. An example of

this is the testing of raw ground beef for the presence of E. coli

O157:H7.

FSIS operates a compliance program aimed at ensuring that meat and

poultry products in commerce are not adulterated or misbranded. Through

this program, the Agency exercises regulatory authority over businesses

that transport, store, or distribute meat and poultry products in

interstate commerce after those products leave federally inspected

establishments. The Agency also registers meat or poultry brokers,

renderers, manufacturers, or wholesalers, or others dealing in meat or

poultry products that are not intended for human consumption.

FSIS also maintains a comprehensive import inspection system. That

system involves two major activities, the first being oversight to

ensure that exporting countries have in place appropriate controls over

their meat and poultry inspection systems. Such countries (1) must

undergo a rigorous review process before they can become eligible to

export meat and poultry to the United States and (2) must receive

periodic reviews by FSIS to maintain such eligibility. Only plants

operating under FSIS approved national inspection programs may qualify

to export meat and poultry products into the United States. Meat and

poultry products inspected under regional or provincial (i.e., state)

inspection programs in foreign countries are not eligible for export to

the United States.

The second part of our import control program is reinspection at

the port of entry, on a sample basis, of meat and poultry products as

they enter the United States. Reinspection is a check to make sure that

the foreign country's inspection system is working. Seventy-four import

inspection personnel carry out import reinspection at approximately 160

official import establishments.

The program for determining the eligibility of a foreign country to

export to the United States is based on a systems approach. FSIS

focuses on a country's overall inspection system as a means of ensuring

consumer protection. For instance, the Agency examines whether the

country has the legal authority to impose requirements equivalent to

those of the United States in areas such as sanitation and antemortem

and postmortem inspection. We examine the organizational structure and

staffing of its inspection program. We also conduct on-site reviews of

the country's inspection operations to evaluate the effectiveness of

all aspects of the country's program.

Once a country becomes eligible, FSIS conducts on-site reviews of

its inspection system--usually one or more times a year. The frequency

of the reviews is determined by a country's performance history,

including previous plant reviews as well as product reinspection at

United States ports-of-entry. If a country does not continue to operate

an inspection system that

[[Page 20510]]

complies with all FSIS requirements, it is removed from the list of

countries eligible to export to the United States.

FSIS port-of-entry inspection is a further check on the

effectiveness of the foreign country's inspection system. It should be

emphasized that reinspection is carried out on products that have

already passed the foreign country's inspection and been certified as

meeting all U.S. requirements by the exporting country.

USDA import inspectors, using an automated system, examine each lot

of product for general condition, proper labeling, and proper

certification that the products comply with all U.S. regulatory

requirements. In addition, based on a plant's history of compliance

with inspection requirements, the nature of the product, and the size

of the shipment, the automated system generates an inspection plan for

each shipment that may identify additional inspection tasks. The system

applies a statistical sampling plan to each lot of product presented

for reinspection. Selected reinspection tasks could include detailed

product examination; net weight verification; container condition

review; product label examination; species testing; and laboratory

analyses for food chemistry, residues, and microbial contamination. In

addition, import inspectors can take additional samples whenever they

suspect a problem. Daily reinspection results from all ports-of-entry

are entered and stored in the system, continuously updating the

compliance histories for every foreign establishment exporting to the

United States.

The FMIA (at 7 U.S.C. 661) and the PPIA (at 7 U.S.C. 454) authorize

the Secretary of Agriculture to cooperate with the States in their

development and administration of meat and poultry inspection programs

that impose requirements for mandatory antemortem and postmortem

inspection and establishment sanitation, and requirements governing the

preparation of further-processed products, that are ``at least equal

to'' the corresponding Federal requirements. Products produced for

human food and inspected under ``equal-to'' State programs are limited

by Federal law to intrastate distribution. The Acts further authorize

the Secretary to cooperate with the States in administering compliance

programs under authorities that are ``at least equal to'' those

provided by Title II of the FMIA (21 U.S.C. 641-645) or Section 11 of

the PPIA (21 U.S.C. 460).

FSIS has signed State-Federal cooperative agreements with States

that have chosen to operate their own inspection programs; with

separate agreements on compliance-related matters. Under these

agreements, FSIS provides advice and technical assistance to the States

and funds up to 50 percent of the cost of operating the State programs.

Technical assistance activities include providing routine training of

State inspection personnel at the FSIS training center, providing

special training when new inspection systems are introduced, and

helping State laboratories with problems requiring specialized

expertise. Federal and State compliance personnel are trained together

at the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center.

If, for any reason, a State fails to develop or maintain and

enforce effective inspection requirements that are ``at least equal

to'' those of the Federal program, USDA is required to designate the

State for Federal inspection. In designated States, all establishments

wishing to engage in commercial activities requiring inspection must

apply to, and be approved by, FSIS for Federal inspection. Designation

may also be applied to individual establishments, the meat portion of a

State program, the poultry portion, or the entire program.

The FMIA and PPIA provisions for ``equal-to'' State inspection

programs were introduced by the 1967 Wholesome Meat Act (WMA) and the

1968 Wholesome Poultry Products Act (WPPA), which provided numerous

amendments to the Meat Inspection Act of 1906 and the Poultry Products

Inspection Act of 1957. The amendments relating to State programs were

prompted mainly by concern over the potential for distribution to the

consumer of unwholesome or adulterated meat and poultry products

because of the absence of mandatory inspection for products produced

and sold within States and localities. The original inspection laws had

provided for mandatory Federal inspection of products in interstate

commerce but not of products distributed solely within a State. At the

time the WMA and WPPA were passed, up to 25 percent of meat food

products and 13 percent of poultry products were produced without

Federal inspection coverage and, if inspected at all, were subject to

widely varying State and local standards.

The WMA and WPPA extended inspection coverage to thousands of

establishments that had not been previously subject to Federal

standards or ``equal-to'' State standards. Many of the establishments

affected were smaller facilities, some located in remote areas, which

produced small quantities of meat, meat food, or poultry products. In

presenting the WMA to the Senate, the Senate Committee on Agriculture

and Forestry (Senate Report No. 799, Nov. 21, 1967) expressed the view

that some of the Federal standards for plant construction were

unrealistic for some small facilities, and encouraged USDA to consider

basing the eligibility of an establishment for inspection on a combined

evaluation of the operating procedures used by the establishment and

the building construction and physical facilities rather than upon a

separate evaluation of these factors. If the operating procedures were

patterned so as to ensure the sanitary handling of products within the

establishment and result in wholesome food, the establishment could be

declared eligible for Federal inspection. However, the Senate report

emphasized that State requirements concerning wholesomeness, additives,

labeling, and other regulations were not to be compromised and had to

be at least equal to Federal standards. The WPPA accommodated small

establishments by authorizing USDA to exempt from inspection

establishments handling 20,000 or fewer birds per year to be

distributed solely within a State and by providing other exemptions.

Growth and Development of the State-Federal Cooperative Inspection

Program

Following the enactment of the WMA and the WPPA, many States opted

for designation rather than fund the necessary improvements to meet the

``equal-to'' provisions of the Acts. From 1971 to 1981, 23 States and

four Territories were designated, primarily because of an inability to

fund the programs. Four States chose to designate the poultry

inspection branches of their programs, but retained the meat inspection

branches. USDA monitored and reviewed the remaining 27 meat or meat and

poultry inspection programs, and issued annual certifications that the

programs were meeting the ``equal-to'' requirements, as provided in the

Acts. At present, 26 States have active programs, 24 covering both meat

and poultry inspection and 2 covering meat only.

During the 1970's and 1980's, the Federal approach to oversight of

State programs changed. Initially, FSIS provided training and guidance

to assist the States in applying the national standards. Once the

various State programs were able to demonstrate their ability to

administer and maintain ``equal-to'' programs without Federal guidance,

FSIS changed its oversight approach to one of monitoring and

verification.

[[Page 20511]]

In exercising its oversight function, FSIS conducts a system review

of each State's program. A system review involves a combined evaluation

of the State's requirements, operations, and enforcement of its meat

and poultry inspection laws. Each State maintaining an inspection

program must keep on file with USDA an up-to-date State Performance

Plan (SPP) 1. The SPP, which is required by an FSIS directive and

not by regulation, documents the existence of State laws, regulations,

funding, workforce, laboratories, and other resources necessary for the

State to operate an ``equal-to'' program. The SPP also describes

operations and enforcement and how the State's program works in the

particular environment of the State to ensure the integrity of meat and

poultry products intended for intrastate sale, transportation, and use.

The head of each State program must certify annually, in writing, that

the program meets ``equal-to'' requirements.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\ Members of the public who are interested in reviewing a

State's SPP may contact Dr. Robert Fetzner, Director, Federal-State

Relations Staff, at (202) 720-6313, to arrange an appointment.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Teams of subject matter experts from FSIS conduct comprehensive

reviews of each State program every three-to-five years to verify

adherence to SPP's. These reviews include random sampling of in-plant

records and conditions. On a continuing basis, FSIS field officials

work directly with State officials providing advice and assistance.

When information from Federal officials in the field or from other

sources leads FSIS to suspect deficiencies in State programs, FSIS

conducts special reviews.

FSIS also exercises oversight of State compliance programs covering

intrastate commerce in meat and poultry products intended for human

food or other purposes to ensure that these programs are ``at least

equal to'' the Federal compliance program. FSIS verifies that the laws

and regulations covering compliance-related matters provide the State

with authorities ``at least equal to'' those provided FSIS under the

FMIA and PPIA. FSIS also ensures that State agencies have resources

adequate to carry out effective compliance programs, including

qualified personnel and adequate funding. State compliance programs

must be effective in controlling products that are suspected of being

adulterated or misbranded; in enforcing recordkeeping requirements and

providing for necessary access to establishment facilities, records,

and inventory; and in ensuring proper registration of meat or poultry

brokers, renderers, manufacturers, wholesalers, or others dealing in

meat or poultry products not intended for human consumption.

In addition, FSIS reviews State procedures for reporting violations

of State meat and poultry inspection laws, initiating civil or criminal

proceedings, documenting breakdowns in the State inspection system, and

ensuring that the requirements for products not to be used for human

food are observed.

External Reviews of FSIS Oversight of State Programs

The efficacy of FSIS reviews of State ``equal-to'' status has been

questioned periodically by external reviewers. In 1983, the General

Accounting Office (GAO) audited USDA's State oversight procedures to

determine whether FSIS certification of State ``equal-to'' status

conformed to the authorizing legislation. At the time, FSIS was basing

its certification on a quarterly review and rating of individual State-

inspected establishments. GAO reported that USDA's procedures were

reasonable, but that the certification process lacked uniformity across

regions.2 GAO also noted that FSIS's internal reviews did not

include regular assessments of State program oversight.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\2\ A copy of the GAO report is on file in the FSIS Docket Room,

Room 4352 South Agriculture Building, Washington DC 20250.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

In response to the GAO Report, FSIS adopted a systems approach to

reviewing and evaluating State inspection programs. This change

resulted in the SPP requirement and the comprehensive reviews described

above. FSIS chose this approach because it provided for long-range

improvement, allowed States to assume more responsibility for program

controls, broadened the scope of Federal oversight, and reduced Federal

costs.

In January 1994, the Department's Office of Inspector General (OIG)

reported, among other findings, that the Agency's comprehensive reviews

did not address State program weaknesses in a number of areas,

including establishment sanitation, inspection scheduling, and

procedures for obtaining and handling laboratory samples.3 OIG

also questioned the consistency of FSIS reviews from region to region

and the adequacy of follow-ups to verify that State corrective action

plans resulting from FSIS comprehensive reviews were carried out. FSIS

has taken some steps to address the deficiencies noted in the OIG

report and continues to work on improvements.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\3\ A copy of the OIG report is on file in the FSIS Docket Room,

Room 4352 South Agriculture Building, Washington, DC 20250.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Interstate Shipment Issue

As stated above, the FMIA and PPIA, as amended by the WMA and the

WPPA, permit State-inspected products to be shipped only in intrastate

commerce. The Acts would have to be amended before State-inspected

products could be distributed in interstate commerce.

In 1968, when Congress was deliberating on the WPPA, the issue of

interstate shipment of State poultry products was debated at length.

Congress rejected the proposal at that time. One reason was that

allowing interstate shipment of State inspected poultry but not of red

meat would create an unacceptable disparity between the red meat and

poultry inspection programs. Congress left open the possibility of

future consideration of the interstate shipment issue after State meat

and poultry inspection programs had been firmly established. Congress

has considered amending the Acts to allow the interstate shipment of

State-inspected products on a number of occasions since that time.

Issues to be Addressed

FSIS is requesting comments to be used in preparing its report to

Congress on the interstate shipment issue as required by the 1996 Farm

Bill. FSIS is, regrettably, setting a short time limit for submitting

comments on this issue. However, the Farm Bill has set a 90-day

timeframe within which the Agency must submit its recommendations to

Congress.

In the view of FSIS, reporting on ``the steps necessary to achieve

interstate shipment'' of State-inspected meat and poultry products,

means, in part, addressing any issues arising from the States'

Performance Plans. Concerning these issues, commenters should identify

the factors that might weigh for or against permitting State-inspected

products into interstate commerce and what steps would be necessary to

address those factors. Commenters should specify whether such factors

are generic to all establishment types or specific to slaughter

establishments or to processing establishments. Some specific aspects

of the current SPP's that may warrant focus include:

Food safety

Laboratory services and sampling

Facility and equipment requirements

Labeling

Recall procedures

[[Page 20512]]

Food Safety Issues: Current Inspection System

What additional steps, if any, should be taken to provide

full assurance to the Nation's consumers that State-inspected products

produced under the current system of inspection meet the same standards

of food safety and wholesomeness as Federal or foreign-inspected

products?

What modifications to the SPP's would be necessary to

provide for the monitoring of each State's product in interstate

commerce and for feedback to the State program?

Laboratory Services

What improvements, if any, need to be made in State

laboratory standards, sampling programs, or performance?

Establishment facility and equipment requirements

What issues relating to establishments' facilities,

equipment, and sanitation need to be considered, and how?

Marking and Labeling; Product Identification

How should State-inspected product be identified in

commerce? Should special marking or labeling requirements be imposed?

What effect would permitting interstate shipment of State-

inspected product have on the consumer's ability to determine whether a

product or its ingredients had been inspected and would consumer

confidence in the safety and quality of meat and poultry products be in

any way affected?

Recall Procedures

Which agency or agencies should exercise jurisdiction in

cases involving the recall of a State-inspected product that may have

been distributed to several other States?

Could confusion over jurisdiction arise that could impede

timely action to prevent the consumption of unsafe, adulterated

products?

In addition to the issues arising from the SPP's, FSIS welcomes

comments on other issues that could have a bearing on interstate

shipment of State-inspected products. These issues include State

implementation of HACCP-based inspection, interstate relations

(including the refusal of one State to accept the products of another

State), acceptance of product inspected under equivalent systems, the

export of State-inspected product, economic effects, and the

availability of resources for Federal assistance and oversight.

Administration of State Programs; HACCP

Commenters are invited to consider what additional challenges might

arise with the adoption and implementation of ``Pathogen Reduction;

HACCP'' regulations proposed by the Agency.

Should interstate shipment of State-inspected products be

authorized prior to the States' implementation of the HACCP and

pathogen reduction regulations?

Should interstate shipment of State-inspected products be

authorized prior to FSIS's evaluation of States' operations under these

adopted regulations?

Is implementation of HACCP by the States a factor that

should even be considered?

Interstate Relations

What potential exists for States with conflicting

standards to bring actions in Federal courts against firms located in

other States or against the States in which such firms are located?

If interstate shipment of State-inspected meat and

poultry products is allowed, should there be some provision for all

consumers in the States and Territories to participate in the

rulemaking proceedings in any one of the States concerning such

products?

Should a State be able to refuse acceptance of another

State's products? If so, under what conditions? What avenues of

recourse are available to the State whose products are refused? What

should be the FSIS role in such matters?

Acceptance of Product Inspected Under Equivalent Systems

Meat and poultry products prepared under foreign inspection systems

that are equivalent to the Federal inspection system are allowed in

interstate commerce. Foreign products that are shipped to the United

States have been inspected and passed by a national inspection program

that meets standards equivalent to those of this country's Federal

program. These programs are subject to regular systems reviews by FSIS

officials and, in addition, products imported to this country are

subject to FSIS reinspection at points of entry before they are shipped

in interstate commerce. Reinspection is a performance-based system;

foreign establishments with better compliance histories have their

products reinspected less frequently.

Should the FSIS reinspection system for imported products

be considered to provide the same level of assurance to the public that

foreign-inspected products receive?

If State-inspected products are allowed in interstate

commerce without reinspection, should any other measures be considered?

What resources would be necessary to carry out this

inspection and from what source or sources should they be obtained?

Export of State-inspected Product

Should State-inspected product be considered eligible for

export? Why or why not? Under what conditions should export of State-

inspected product be permitted?

How would technical problems and trade issues be

addressed? By whom would these problems and issues be addressed?

How would costs be addressed?

How would permitting the interstate shipment of State-

inspected product affect the acceptability to foreign countries and

importers of U.S.-export products generally?

What agency or agencies would be responsible for

certifying exports?

Economic Effects

The number of meat and poultry establishments under State

inspection has been declining steadily in recent years. For example, in

1986, 3,707 meat or poultry establishments were operating under State

inspection in 27 States, but by 1994 there were 2,904 such

establishments in the same number of States.

Permitting interstate sale and distribution of State-inspected

products could eliminate the incentives for holding a Federal grant of

inspection rather than a State grant. This change could affect the

economies of the Federal and State programs if it resulted in

significant shifts of establishments between the Federal and State

systems.

Should the ability of an establishment to choose between

Federal and State inspection be restricted in any way? Why?

Would States be induced to compete with one another by

marketing their inspection programs so as to influence company

decisions on where to locate new or relocate existing meat and poultry

establishments? If so, what would be the consequences for the States,

for workers, for consumers?

What would be the implications or consequences of

allowing sales of State-inspected product to Federal establishments for

further processing? Would this affect decisions by domestic or foreign

buyers?

What effect should permitting the interstate shipment of

State-inspected product have on establishments where Federal inspection

is performed by State

[[Page 20513]]

employees under Federal-State cooperative agreements, pursuant to the

Talmadge-Aiken Act (7 U.S.C. 450)?

Availability of Resources for Federal Oversight of and Assistance to

State Programs

A perennial question to be addressed is the availability of

resources for appropriate Federal oversight of State programs to ensure

that they are ``at least equal to'' the Federal program. The resource

question is sometimes highlighted when the Agency's oversight of State

programs undergoes external evaluation by GAO or OIG, as discussed

above. Nevertheless, the ability of the Agency to meet the need for

oversight of State programs will continue to be challenged by a

scarcity of resources. This challenge is likely to be far greater than

it is at present if State-inspected products are permitted to be

shipped in interstate commerce, for the volume and geographical

distribution of State-inspected products could be greater than they are

now, and the handling of the products more complicated.

What is the best way to ensure the continued provision of

resources necessary for Federal oversight of State programs?

What would be the effect on State resources of allowing

interstate shipment of State-inspected product, especially if large

numbers of establishments switch from Federal to State inspection?

In addition, how should the financing of State programs

be accomplished? Should USDA continue to pay up to half the cost of

operating a State program?

If a wider market were opened to State-inspected

products, would sales volumes rise and would State economies be better

able to support a larger share of program operations?

The foregoing list of issues is not intended to be inclusive; FSIS

recognizes that commenters may suggest other issues and provide

comments regarding them. FSIS welcomes comments on other issues related

to interstate shipment of meat and poultry from State-inspected

establishments.

Done, at Washington, D.C., on: May 3, 1996.

Michael R. Taylor,

Acting Under Secretary for Food Safety.

[FR Doc. 96-11456 Filed 5-3-96; 1:40 pm]

BILLING CODE 3510-12-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.