Proposed Class Exemption for Plan Asset Transactions Determined by In-House Asset Managers

Federal RegisterMar 24, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF LABOR

Pension and Welfare Benefits Administration

[Application No. D-09602]

Proposed Class Exemption for Plan Asset Transactions Determined

by In-House Asset Managers

AGENCY: Pension and Welfare Benefits Administration, Labor.

ACTION: Notice of proposed class exemption.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This document contains a notice of pendency before the

Department of Labor (the Department) of a proposed class exemption from

certain prohibited transaction restrictions of the Employee Retirement

Income Security Act (ERISA or the Act) and from certain taxes imposed

by the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (the Code). If granted, the

proposed exemption would exempt various transactions involving employee

benefit plans whose assets are managed by in-house managers (INHAMS),

provided that the conditions of the proposal are met. The proposed

exemption, if granted, would affect participants and beneficiaries of

employee benefit plans, the sponsoring employers of such plans, INHAMS,

and other persons engaging in the described transactions.

DATES: Written comments and requests for a hearing must be received by

the Department on or before May 8, 1995.

ADDRESSES: All written comments and requests for a public hearing

(preferably 3 copies) should be sent to: Pension and Welfare Benefits

Administration, Office of Exemption Determinations, Room N-5649, 200

Constitution Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20210, Attention: CIEBA Class

Exemption Proposal. The application for exemption (Application Number

D-9602), as well as all comments received from interested persons, will

be available for public inspection in the Public Documents Room,

Pension and Welfare Benefits Administration, U.S. Department of Labor,

Room N-5638, 200 Constitution Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20210.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Virginia J. Miller, Office of

Exemption Determinations, Pension and Welfare Benefits Administration,

U.S. Department of Labor, Washington, DC 20210 (202) 219-8971 (not a

toll-free number); or Paul D. Mannina, Plan Benefits Security Division,

Office of the Solicitor, U.S. Department of Labor, Washington, DC 20210

(202) 219-9141 (not a toll free number.)

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: This document contains a notice of pendency

before the Department of a proposed class exemption from certain of the

restrictions of sections 406 and 407(a) of ERISA and from certain taxes

imposed by section 4975(a) and (b) of the Code, by reason of section

4975(c)(1) of the Code. The proposed exemption was requested in an

application dated December 16, 1993, submitted by the Committee on

Investment of Employee Benefits Assets (CIEBA)1 pursuant to

section 408(a) of ERISA and section 4975(c)(2) of the Code, and in

accordance with the procedures set forth in 29 CFR section 2570 subpart

B (55 FR 32836, August 10, 1990).2

\1\CIEBA is a committee of the Financial Executives Institute,

an organization whose membership is made up of senior financial

executives in corporations engaged in, among other things, banking,

manufacturing, and insurance.

\2\Section 102 of Reorganization Plan No. 4 of 1978 (43 FR

47713, October 17, 1978), effective December 31, 1978 (44 FR 1065,

January 3, 1979), generally transferred the authority of the

Secretary of the Treasury to issue exemptions under section

4975(c)(2) of the Code to the Secretary of Labor. In the discussion

of the exemption, references to sections 406 and 408 of the Act

should be read to refer as well to the corresponding provisions of

section 4975 of the Code.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

I. Background

On March 13, 1984, the Department granted Prohibited Transaction

Exemption 84-14 (PTE 84-14) (49 FR 9494), a class exemption which

permits various parties who are related to employee benefit plans to

engage in transactions involving plan assets if, among other

conditions, the assets are managed by a ``qualified professional asset

manager'' (QPAM), which is independent of the parties in interest and

which meets specified financial standards. Additional exemptive relief

is provided for employers to furnish limited amounts of goods and

services in the ordinary course of business. Limited relief is also

provided for leases of office or commercial space between managed funds

and QPAMs or contributing employers.

The QPAM exemption was proposed by the Department on its own motion

in an effort to give institutional managers greater flexibility to

engage in a variety of beneficial transactions which would otherwise

have been prohibited by ERISA, without sacrificing the interests of

plan participants and beneficiaries. In its proposal for the QPAM

exemption, the Department noted its belief that, as a general matter,

transactions entered into on behalf of plans with parties in interest

are most likely to conform to ERISA's general fiduciary standards where

the decision to enter into the transaction is made by an independent

fiduciary. Thus, the relief contained in the QPAM exemption was

predicated upon the existence of a professional asset manager who is

solely responsible for the discretionary management of plan assets that

are transferred to its control.

The QPAM exemption did not provide relief for transactions

involving the assets of plans managed by in-house asset managers.

Nonetheless, in granting the QPAM exemption, the Department noted that

the grant of the QPAM exemption did not foreclose future consideration

of additional exemptive relief for transactions involving plan assets

that are not managed by ``QPAMs'' or for transactions which do not meet

all of the conditions of PTE 84-14. The Department further stated that

it would consider pursuing additional exemptive relief for transactions

involving assets of plans managed by in-house managers if the requisite

findings under section 408(a) could be made.

CIEBA, in its application, has requested exemptive relief for in-

house managers similar to that available to outside managers under the

QPAM exemption. CIEBA represents that in-house managers encounter

technical problems under the prohibited transaction rules of ERISA in

the course of considering arm's-length transactions that would be in

the interests of their plans. The applicant believes that the narrowly

focused relief requested, combined with the conditions and restrictions

built into the exemption, [[Page 15598]] should resolve the most common

problems faced by CIEBA members while being protective of the interests

of plan participants and beneficiaries.

II. Discussion of the Application

A. Summary of Facts and Representations

The application contains facts and representations with regard to

the requested exemption which are summarized below. Interested persons

are referred to the application on file with the Department for the

complete representations of the applicant.

The applicant represents that many transactions that have little if

any potential for abuse of the plan constitute technical prohibited

transactions as a result of the breadth of the rules under section

406(a) and the definition of party in interest. The applicant states

that the problem results largely from the inclusion of all persons

providing services to a plan in the definition of a party in interest,

under section 3(14)(B) of ERISA, as well as persons owning a 10% or

more interest in such service providers, under section 3(14)(H) or (I).

For example, a broker-dealer who has an ongoing relationship with a

plan through its securities brokerage business may be prohibited from

selling debt securities issued by itself or its parent organization to

the plan, or otherwise from selling property to the plan (other than

securities, which meet the requirements of PTE 75-1).3 Similarly,

CIEBA represents that a bank which provides trustee or custodial

services to a plan may not be able to engage in any sale or credit

transactions with that plan.

\3\40 FR 50845 (October 31, 1975)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

CIEBA states that INHAMs have become an established part of many

large companies which manage some or all of their plan assets in-house.

According to the applicant, many of the large corporations that make up

its membership maintain one or more employee benefit plans holding in

the aggregate assets in excess of $250 million. These large

corporations have determined that they can reduce costs and maintain

high quality management by developing an in-house asset management

capability rather than relying exclusively on outside managers or

consultants. It is represented that, in addition to providing reduced

costs for comparable or better quality management, in-house managers

are attractive to employers because they devote their time solely to

the plan's asset management activities, while outside managers have

other clients and responsibilities. The applicant also asserts that the

named plan fiduciaries benefit from having access to in-house expertise

and advice to assist them in carrying out their fiduciary

responsibilities.

The applicant represents that the in-house management of plan

assets can take several forms. The in-house manager may be a direct or

indirect subsidiary of an employer with respect to a plan.

Alternatively, the management of the assets may be performed by a

division or group within the employer's corporate structure that

reports to the employer's treasurer or senior financial officer. In

some instances, the in-house manager is established as a separate

membership non-profit corporation, with the majority of the members

being officers or directors of the employer. According to the

applicant, the in-house manager has direct management responsibility

over at least part of the assets, and usually also advises a higher-

level investment committee of the employer or other named fiduciary of

the plan with respect to asset allocation and the selection and

monitoring of outside managers.

The applicant states that the in-house manager's operations are

monitored by a plan fiduciary, which may be a senior management

employee, a committee made up of, or appointed by, the plan sponsor's

board of directors, or a person otherwise appointed by the board or the

named fiduciary of the plan. The fiduciary monitors the in-house

manager's performance and sets investment guidelines and objectives for

the sponsor's plans. The investment guidelines promulgated by the

fiduciary generally describe the overall investment strategy and

objectives for the plan, any criteria for investment in certain asset

classes, and what level of approvals, if any, are required for

particular investments.

CIEBA represents that, unless the Department provides broad

exemptive relief for in-house asset managers, plans will be

disadvantaged because of the restrictions on the types of transactions

an in-house manager can engage in on behalf of a plan. The applicant

explains that, with very large plans, there may be thousands of parties

in interest, so that many transactions may be prohibited. The task of

determining whether a particular transaction is prohibited can present

a considerable burden for plan fiduciaries. According to the applicant,

if the in-house manager wishes to enter into a transaction which he or

she believes would be beneficial to the plan but which also involves a

party in interest, that manager must either (1) seek an individual

prohibited transaction exemption; (2) retain a QPAM for the

transaction; or (3) forgo the transaction. The applicant argues that

seeking an individual exemption involves time and legal expenses. In

addition, the applicant notes that the use of a QPAM entails additional

expenses for the plan despite the fact that the in-house manager has

already done most of the work required for the transaction, including

performing the necessary due diligence as to, for example, the

creditworthiness of the other parties to the transaction.4

Finally, the applicant argues that forgoing the transaction may cause

the plan to miss out on a beneficial investment opportunity. Thus,

CIEBA argues that an INHAM class exemption is necessary because the

existing limitations on a plan's investment choices can raise a plan's

investment costs in the short run by limiting the parties with whom it

may deal, and adversely affect investment performance in the long run.

Accordingly, CIEBA requests relief for three general categories of

transactions which are more fully described below.

\4\The Department is expressing no opinion as to whether the

above-described transaction would come within the scope of relief

provided by PTE 84-14.

B. Description of the Requested Exemption

1. The INHAM Concept

Under the requested exemption, an INHAM would be defined as either

(1) a direct or indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of an employer with

respect to a plan, or a direct or indirect wholly- owned subsidiary of

a parent organization of the employer, or (2) a membership nonprofit

corporation, a majority of whose members are officers or directors of

the employer or a parent organization. In addition, the INHAM would

have to be registered as an investment adviser under the Investment

Advisers Act of 1940. Under the applicant's proposed definition, the

employer with which the INHAM is affiliated must be a plan sponsor (or

group of related plan sponsors) whose plan or plans hold in the

aggregate assets of at least $250 million of which at least $50 million

of such assets must be under the direct management and responsibility

of the INHAM.

2. Transactions With Service Providers

The applicant requests broad relief for transactions between a plan

managed by an INHAM and a person who is a party in interest with

respect to the plan solely by reason of providing services to the plan

or solely by reason of a [[Page 15599]] relationship to such service

provider. The applicant notes that the broad relief requested is

similar to the general exemption in PTE 84-14, but is more restrictive

in that it is only available for transactions with service providers.

Among the conditions suggested by the applicant is a requirement that

the party in interest not be the INHAM or a person related to the

INHAM. A party in interest and an INHAM would be considered related

under the requested exemption if either entity owns a 5% or more

interest, directly or indirectly, in the other entity.

In addition, the terms of the transaction would have to be

negotiated by the INHAM on behalf of the plan, and the INHAM would have

to make the decision to enter into the transaction. Notwithstanding the

foregoing, the applicant requests that the proposed exemption permit

the plan sponsor to retain approval or veto power over large

transactions since these types of transactions are customarily subject

to increased scrutiny by the plan sponsor. The applicant explains that

the higher levels of review are generally conducted by an investment

committee or other named fiduciary. The applicant further represents

that the requirement that the INHAM negotiate and decide upon the

transaction is not affected by any such higher levels of review.

The applicant also proposes that the exemption not provide relief

for transactions described in three class exemptions previously granted

by the Department: PTE 81-6 (46 FR 7527, 1/23/81) (relating to

securities lending arrangements); PTE 83-1 (48 FR 895, 1/7/83)

(relating to acquisitions by plans of interests in mortgage pools); or

PTE 88-59 (53 FR 24811, 6/30/88) (relating to certain mortgage

financing arrangements).5 Lastly, CIEBA has suggested, as an

additional condition, the requirement that the INHAM undergo an annual

fiduciary audit to determine whether the written procedures adopted by

the INHAM are adequate to assure compliance with the terms and

conditions of the exemption. The applicant represents that, by

requiring a party independent of the employer to be involved in

overseeing compliance with the exemption, the fiduciary audit would

serve as a meaningful additional independent safeguard while not unduly

interfering with the INHAM's investment decisions.

\5\In this regard, see section I(b) of PTE 84-14, which contains

the identical requirement.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The applicant asserts that plans would be adequately protected

under the proposal because the INHAMs would be independent of and

unrelated to the service providers with whom they are dealing. In

addition, the proposed definition of INHAM is designed to assure that

the INHAM is in the business of investment management and, thus, in a

position to develop experience and sophistication in dealing with

investment issues. The registration of the INHAM as an investment

adviser assures that the INHAM is subject to regulation under the

Investment Advisers Act of 1940 and oversight by the Securities and

Exchange Commission. The applicant represents that the standards

proposed for the INHAM limit relief to only those employers whose

managers have sufficient resources to assure knowledge and

sophistication in financial and business matters.

3. Specific Exemptions for Employers

CIEBA represents that, where a plan is sponsored by a company that

is a producer of goods such as appliances or equipment, the plan may

not be able to purchase the appliances or equipment for its own use,

even at cost, because the purchase could be a prohibited transaction.

Similarly, the plan sponsor may provide services in the ordinary course

of its business to consumers, such as utility services or maintenance

and support services for goods or equipment sold. The applicant notes

that, while section 408(b)(2) provides a statutory exemption for the

provision of services to a plan by a party in interest, including an

employer, that statutory exemption appears to limit the sponsor's

compensation for the provision of services to its ``direct

costs''.6 CIEBA argues that, for many types of services, it may be

difficult as a practical matter to determine what the ``direct costs''

of these services would be, or the particular division or subsidiary of

the sponsor may not be willing to provide the services at direct cost

because it would not be economical to do so. In addition, with services

such as utilities, the company providing the service may not

necessarily know whether the transaction involves a plan asset.

629 CFR Sec. 2550.408b-2(a) of the Department's

regulations provides that section 408(b)(2) does not contain an

exemption for an act described in section 406(b) even if such act

occurs in connection with a provision of services which is exempt

under section 408(b)(2). However, regulation section 29 CFR

2550.408(b)-2(e)(3) provides that if a fiduciary furnishes services

to a plan without the receipt of compensation or other consideration

(other than reimbursement of direct expenses properly and actually

incurred in the performance of such services within the meaning of

Sec. 2550.408c-2(b)(3)), the provision of such services does not, in

and of itself, constitute an act described in section 406(b) of the

Act.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Thus, CIEBA requests an exemption which would permit the sale,

leasing or servicing of goods, or the furnishing of services, to a plan

by an employer or its affiliate. All covered transactions would be

subject to a number of conditions, including the requirement that the

transactions must take place in the ordinary course of a business

engaged in by the employer or its affiliate with the general public on

terms no less favorable than those available to the general public. As

a further limitation, transactions engaged in under this exemption

could not exceed 1% of the employer's or affiliate's annual gross

receipts received from all sources for its prior taxable year.

CIEBA also requests relief for the leasing of office or commercial

space to employers. The applicant represents that the statutory

exemption under section 408(e) of ERISA, for the acquisition and

leasing of ``qualifying employer real property'', may not exempt the

lease of a single parcel of property to an employer or affiliate by a

plan.7 This lack of exemptive relief has resulted in inadvertent

prohibited transactions where a plan not holding any other employer

real property unexpectedly acquires property in which an employer or an

affiliate is a tenant, such as upon foreclosure. The applicant explains

that the foreclosure may be necessary to avoid the complete loss of the

plan's investment, and the plan fiduciaries are unlikely to be aware of

the identities of the tenants until after the foreclosure occurs. CIEBA

states that the Congressional concerns underlying the requirement that

a substantial number of parcels be dispersed geographically are not

present where only a small portion of a single parcel is leased by a

plan to its employer.

7The definition of ``qualifying employer real property''

under ERISA section 407(d)(4) requires, in part, that a substantial

number of leased parcels be geographically dispersed.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Under the requested exemption for the leasing of office or

commercial space to an employer or affiliate, all the conditions

otherwise applicable under ERISA section 408(e) would have to be met,

including the requirements that the lease be for adequate

consideration, that no commission be charged, and that the investment

comply with the 10% limitation contained in section 407(a) with respect

to the lease or acquisition of qualifying employer real property by

plans other than eligible individual account plans.8 As a further

limitation, [[Page 15600]] the amount of space covered by the lease

could not exceed 15% of the rentable space of the property.

8CIEBA also suggests that this exemption be subject to the

requirement that the real property leased to the employer be

suitable or adaptable, without excessive cost, for more than one

use. In this regard, see section 407(d)(4), which contains a similar

requirement.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

The applicant also requests relief for the leasing of residential

space owned by a plan to an employee of an employer any of whose

employees are covered by such plan, or to an employee of a 50% or more

parent or subsidiary of the employer, provided that the amount of space

covered by the lease does not exceed 10 percent of the rentable space

of the residential property and the employee does not have or exercise

any authority with respect to the lease transaction. The applicant

represents that this type of relief is necessary because the property

manager who manages the property for the plan is unlikely to be aware

of any relationship between the tenants and the plan sponsor and the

employees are unlikely to be aware that the property is owned by the

plan.

The applicant further notes that a plan could inadvertently engage

in prohibited transactions with employees of the employer through

investments in portfolios of consumer receivables. For example, a plan

may purchase an interest in a pool of credit card receivables or

mortgages, where the receivables or mortgages may include obligations

of officers, directors or employees who are parties in interest under

ERISA section 3(14)(H). The applicant represents that the plan

fiduciary is unlikely to be aware of the identities of the individual

obligors who have some interest in the pool, and even if the fiduciary

is aware of the identities, it is unlikely to be aware of the

relationship, if any, that these obligors have to the investing plan.

In addition, the applicant explains that obligations of parties in

interest may be added to the portfolio subsequent to the plan's

investment, an event over which the plan would not have any control.

Accordingly, the applicant requests a limited exemption for the

acquisition, holding or disposition by the plan of an interest in a

consumer receivables portfolio, where a borrower whose obligation is

part of the portfolio is a party in interest solely by reason of being

an employee, officer, director, or 10% or more shareholder, partner or

joint venturer with respect to either the employer, an employee

organization whose members are covered by the plan, or a 50% or more

parent or subsidiary of the employer.

4. Places of Public Accommodation

The applicant represents that, if a plan owns a hotel that is part

of the property managed by an INHAM, a prohibited transaction may occur

if a party in interest stays at that hotel. This would be the case even

though the hotel is likely to be operated by persons who are unaware of

the party in interest relationship. CIEBA notes that there is little

likelihood of abuse in these types of transactions since the persons

managing the hotels and motels are generally management companies that

would not be aware of the party in interest relationship. In addition,

the applicant notes that the Department has granted similar relief in

several class and individual exemptions.9

9See PTE 84-14, 49 FR 9494 (March 13, 1984) and PTE 91-38, 56

FR 31966 (July 12, 1991).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Accordingly, CIEBA requests relief for the furnishing of services,

facilities and incidental goods to a party in interest by a place of

public accommodation, such as a hotel or motel owned by a plan managed

by an INHAM if the services, facilities and incidental goods are

furnished on a comparable basis to the general public.

III. The Proposed Exemption

The proposed exemption consists of four separate parts. Part I sets

forth the general exemption and enumerates certain conditions

applicable to the transactions described therein. Parts II and III of

the proposal set forth specific exemptions. Part IV contains

definitions for certain terms used in the proposed exemption.

A. The INHAM Concept

As proposed, the class exemption would be available for various

party in interest transactions that involve those assets of a plan that

are managed by an INHAM. The Department has determined to adopt the

definition of INHAM proposed by the applicant. Accordingly, an INHAM is

defined as either (1) a wholly-owned subsidiary of an employer with

respect to a plan, or a wholly- owned subsidiary of a parent

organization of the employer, or (2) a membership nonprofit

corporation, a majority of whose members are officers or directors of

the employer or parent organization. The definition also requires the

INHAM to be registered as an investment adviser under the Investment

Advisers Act of 1940. Finally, the employer with which the INHAM is

affiliated must be a plan sponsor (or group of related plan sponsors)

whose plan or plans hold in the aggregate assets of at least $250

million, $50 million of which is under the direct management and

control of the INHAM. The Department believes that these standards will

help to ensure that the INHAM is an entity that has developed an

appropriate level of expertise in financial and business matters.

B. General Exemption

The general exemption, set forth in Part I, would allow that

portion of a plan which is managed by an INHAM to engage in all

transactions described in section 406(a)(1)(A) through (D) with

virtually all party in interest service providers except the INHAM or a

person related to the INHAM.10 As proposed, this exemption does

not extend to transactions which would give rise to violations of

section 406(b) of ERISA.

10The applicant notes that, with the constantly changing

nature of the financial markets, managers seek to invest in new

areas to (a) increase investment return, (b) diversify investment

portfolios, and (c) better manage investment risk. In this regard,

the Department wishes to note that ERISA's general standards of

fiduciary conduct would apply to new areas of investment permitted

by this proposed exemption, and that satisfaction of the conditions

of this proposal should not be viewed as an endorsement of any

particular investment by the Department. Section 404 of ERISA

requires, among other things, that a fiduciary discharge his duties

with respect to a plan solely in the interest of the plan's

participants and beneficiaries and in a prudent fashion.

Accordingly, the manager or other plan fiduciary must act prudently

with respect to the decision to enter into an investment

transaction, as well as to the negotiation of the specific terms

under which the plan will engage in such transaction. The Department

further emphasizes that it expects a manager or other plan fiduciary

to fully understand the benefits and risks associated with engaging

in a specific transaction, following disclosure to such fiduciary of

all relevant information. In addition, such manager or plan

fiduciary must be capable of periodically monitoring the investment,

including any changes in the value of the investment and the

creditworthiness of the issuer or other party to the transaction.

Thus, in considering whether to enter into a transaction, a

fiduciary should take into account its ability to provide adequate

oversight of the particular investment.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Generally, the relief for service providers proposed herein is

based upon that requested by the applicant. However, the Department has

modified CIEBA's request in several respects, as more fully described

below.

In general, section I(a) of the proposal requires that the INHAM

function as the decision maker for the plan in all covered

transactions. Specifically, section I(a) requires that the terms of the

transaction be negotiated by, or under the authority and general

direction of, the INHAM and that the INHAM make the decision to enter

into the transaction. Under the proposal, however, the exemption would

not be unavailable merely because the plan sponsor retains the right to

veto or approve transactions involving amounts [[Page 15601]] in excess

of $5 million, which have been negotiated on behalf of the plan by the

INHAM. In this regard, the Department notes that section I(a) of the

proposal would allow the retention of a veto or approval power by the

plan sponsor under circumstances where the INHAM negotiated an

investment transaction which obligates the plan to make a number of

payments which, in the aggregate, exceed $5 million. Thus, for example,

section I(a) would be deemed met, despite the retention of a veto or

approval power by the sponsoring employer, if a plan is required, as

part of an investment in a real estate limited partnership negotiated

by the INHAM, to make three capital contributions to such partnership

totalling $6 million over a pre-determined period. In this regard, the

Department cautions that Part I would not be available for any

transaction that is negotiated by an employer which sponsors a plan,

and is then subsequently presented to an INHAM for approval.

Under section I(b) of the proposal, no relief is provided for those

transactions described in Prohibited Transaction Exemptions 81-6, 83-1

and 88-59.

Section I(c) of the proposed exemption excludes from relief any

transaction which is part of an agreement, arrangement or understanding

designed to benefit a party in interest. Section I(d) requires that the

terms of each transaction must be at least as favorable to the plan as

the terms generally available in arm's length transactions between

unrelated parties. Moreover, under section I(e), an INHAM could not

enter into transactions with a party in interest who has discretionary

authority or control with respect to the assets involved in the

transaction or otherwise renders investment advice with respect to such

assets. In addition, section I(f) provides that the general exemption

would not be available if the INHAM and the party in interest dealing

with the plan are related parties. Section IV(d) generally provides

that a party in interest and an INHAM would be ``related'' if either

entity owns a five percent or more interest, directly or indirectly, in

the other entity.

PTE 84-14 was developed and granted based on the premise that broad

relief from the prohibitions of section 406(a) of ERISA could be

afforded to a broad range of transactions if the investment of plan

assets and the negotiations leading thereto are the sole responsibility

of an independent manager. In addressing this lack of independence of

the INHAM under the requested exemption, CIEBA has suggested that any

exemption proposed by the Department be conditioned upon a requirement

that an independent auditor conduct an annual fiduciary audit to

determine whether the written procedures adopted by the INHAM are

designed to assure compliance with the conditions of the exemption. The

Department has adopted CIEBA's suggestion under section I(g) of the

proposal. The term ``fiduciary audit'' is defined in section IV(f) of

the proposal as including: (1) a determination by the auditor as to

whether or not the plan has developed adequate internal policies and

procedures to assure compliance with the terms of the exemption; (2) a

test of a representative sample of the plan's transactions to determine

operational compliance with such policies and procedures; and (3) a

determination as to whether or not the INHAM meets the definition of

INHAM set forth in the exemption.

The following examples illustrate the types of transactions which

would be covered by Part I of the proposed exemption:

(1) Corporation C designates INHAM X to manage a portion of Plan

P's assets. Assume that X meets the criteria for an INHAM that are

proposed. X uses Plan P assets to purchase a building from Y, a wholly-

owned subsidiary of a broker-dealer that provides services to the Plan.

Absent this proposed exemption, the purchase of the building from Y, a

party in interest described in ERISA section 3(14)(G), would violate

the restrictions contained in section 406(a)(1)(A), and the transaction

could not proceed until exempted by the Department. The general

exemption set forth in Part I would allow such transaction if the

conditions contained therein are met.

(2) INHAM X invests part of a pension fund's assets to acquire a

parcel of unimproved real property from the president of the employer

sponsoring the Plan. Part I does not provide an exemption for the

purchase of the property since relief is limited under that Part to

transactions with service providers and their affiliates. In addition,

no relief would be provided under the proposal for the act of self-

dealing described in section 406(b)(1) arising in connection with X's

use of the fund's assets in a transaction which benefits a person in

whom X has an interest which may affect the exercise of its best

judgement as a fiduciary.

(3) Corporation C is the named fiduciary of Plan P. C chooses INHAM

X to manage the portion of P's assets allocated for real estate

investments. X, using its discretionary authority, locates and

negotiates the purchase for $6 million of a commercial building in New

York that is being offered for sale by Corporation Z. Z provides

accounting services to Plan P. Pursuant to its arrangement with C, X is

required to seek the approval of C for all real estate transactions

involving amounts in excess of $5 million. On the basis of X's

recommendation, C approves the transaction. Despite the retention of

approval power by C, Part I of the proposal would be available for the

purchase of the building provided there is no arrangement with C that

requires X to buy the building from Z and the conditions of Part I are

otherwise met.

(4) Corporation C allocates part of the assets of its Plan P to a

master trust managed by INHAM X. X uses master trust assets to purchase

an office building which is subsequently leased to M. M provides

administrative services to Plan P. During the term of the lease, M

becomes a wholly-owned subsidiary of Corporation C. Although M is no

longer a party in interest with respect to Plan P solely by reason of

providing services to such Plan, Part I will continue to be available

for the entire lease term since, at the time the transaction was

entered into (as defined in section in IV(e)), M was not affiliated

with the plan sponsor and its relationship to Plan P was solely that of

a service provider.

(5) INHAM X retains Broker-Dealer B to provide brokerage services

to Plan P. In a separate transaction, X uses Plan P assets to purchase

corporate bonds directly from B. The bonds were originally issued by

Corporation Z, an investment manager for a portion of the Plan's assets

that are not controlled by INHAM X. Since the Department expects that,

as part of its fiduciary responsibilities, the INHAM would have

analyzed the terms of the bonds prior to purchase, the relief provided

by Part I could extend to both the acquisition of the bonds and the

underlying extension of credit. Thus, Part I could cover a subsidiary

transaction with a party in interest if such transaction is itself

subject to relief under the proposal and the applicable conditions are

otherwise met.

C. Specific Exemptions for Employers

Part II of the proposed exemption provides limited relief under

both sections 406(a) and (b) of ERISA for certain transactions

involving employers and their affiliates who cannot qualify for the

general exemption provided by Part I.

In this regard, the Department has not proposed the broad relief

requested by the applicant for transactions with employers and their

affiliates. The Department does not believe that it has sufficient

information at this time to [[Page 15602]] make the broad findings

necessary under section 408(a) of ERISA to propose exemptive relief

with respect to transactions that may inure to the direct or indirect

benefit of an employer. Nonetheless, the Department believes that it is

appropriate to propose more limited relief under circumstances where

the potential for the exercise of undue influence that would benefit an

employer is more remote. However, the Department wishes to take the

opportunity to note that its determination not to propose the broad

relief requested does not foreclose future consideration of additional

exemptive relief for transactions involving plan assets that are

managed by INHAMS.

Part II is divided into two subparts. Section II(a) provides

limited relief for the leasing of office or commercial space by a plan

to an employer if the plan acquired the property subject to an

outstanding lease with an employer or affiliate as a result of

foreclosure on a mortgage or deed of trust. As a limitation, the

exemption is effective until the expiration of the lease term and any

renewal that does not require the consent of the plan. Section II(a) of

the proposed exemption further requires that the decision to foreclose

on the mortgage or deed of trust be made by the INHAM as part of the

exercise of its discretionary authority, and that the unit of space

under the lease does not exceed 15 percent of the rentable space of the

office building or commercial center. The availability of relief is

further conditioned upon the requirement that the transaction satisfy

the conditions of sections I(c) and I(g) of the proposed exemption.

The application of section II(a) is illustrated by the following

example:

(6) INHAM X is responsible for managing Plan P's assets and uses a

portion of the assets to provide financing for Developer D's

acquisition of an office building. Plan P's loan to D is secured by a

first mortgage on the office building. Subsequently, D defaults on the

loan and Plan P forecloses on its mortgage on the property. Upon

assuming ownership of the office building, X discovers that a tenant in

the building is Corporation Z, a wholly-owned subsidiary of the plan

sponsor. Although the relief afforded by Part I of the proposed

exemption would not be available to Corporation Z because it is

``related'' to the INHAM, Part II(a) of the proposal is available for

the entire lease term if the conditions of Part II(a) are otherwise

met.

Section II(b) would permit a plan to lease residential space to an

employee of an employer any of whose employees are covered by such

plan, or to any employee of a 50% or more parent or subsidiary of the

employer. However, no relief is available under this exemption for

officers, directors, and 10 percent or more shareholders of the

employer or an affiliate of such employer, or for any employees who

have or exercise any discretionary authority with respect to the assets

involved in the lease transaction. As a further limitation, the

proposal requires that the unit of space leased to an employee does not

exceed 5% of the rentable space of the residential property and that

the total amount of space leased to all employees of the employer, or

affiliates not exceed 10% of the rentable space of the residential

property. The Department believes that requiring a significant number

of unrelated lessees will help to ensure that the terms of the lease(s)

are no more favorable to the employee(s) than the terms available to

other unrelated lessees of the residential property owned by the plan.

The availability of relief under this section is further

conditioned on the requirement that the transactions satisfy the

provisions of sections I(b), I(c), I(d) and I(g) of the proposed

exemption.

The application of section II(b) is illustrated by the following

example:

(7) Inham X is responsible for managing Plan P's assets and invests

a portion of the assets in a new garden apartment complex comprised of

25 one bedroom apartments. Three employees of Corporation C, Plan P's

sponsor, each rent 1 of the apartments from Plan P. Assume that none of

the employees is an officer, director, or 10% or more shareholder of

Corporation C or an affiliate, or has discretionary authority or

renders investment advice with respect to the assets involved in the

lease transactions. The proposed exemption under section II(b) would

not be available for these lease transactions because, although each

lease represents less than 5% of the rentable space of the residential

property, the aggregate amount of space leased to employees of

Corporation C exceeds 10% of the rentable space of the property.

D. Places of Public Accommodation

The Department is proposing an exemption, set forth in Part III,

that would provide relief from sections 406(a)(1)(A) through (D) and

406(b)(1) and (b)(2) of ERISA for the furnishing of services,

facilities and any goods incidental thereto by a place of accommodation

owned by a plan managed by an INHAM to a party in interest with respect

to the plan, if the services, facilities or incidental goods are

furnished on a comparable basis to the general public.

General Information

The attention of interested persons is directed to the following:

(1) The fact that a transaction is the subject of an exemption

under section 408(a) of the Act and section 4975(c)(2) of the Code does

not relieve a fiduciary or other party in interest or disqualified

person from certain other provisions of the Act and the Code, including

any prohibited transaction provisions to which the exemption does not

apply and the general fiduciary responsibility provisions of section

404 of the Act which require, among other things, that a fiduciary

discharge his duties respecting the plan solely in the interests of the

participants and beneficiaries of the plan and in a prudent fashion in

accordance with section 404(a)(1)(B) of the Act; nor does it affect the

requirement of section 401(a) of the Code that the plan must operate

for the exclusive benefit of the employees of the employer maintaining

the plan and their beneficiaries;

(2) Before an exemption may be granted under section 408(a) of the

Act and section 4975(c)(2) of the Code, the Department must find that

the exemption is administratively feasible, in the interests of the

plan and of its participants and beneficiaries and protective of the

rights of the participants and beneficiaries;

(3) If granted, the proposed class exemption will be applicable to

a particular transaction only if the transaction satisfies the

conditions specified in the class exemption; and

(4) The proposed exemption, if granted, will be supplemental to,

and not in derogation of, any other provisions of the Code and Act,

including statutory or administrative exemptions and transitional

rules. Furthermore, the fact that a transaction is subject to an

administrative or statutory exemption is not dispositive of whether the

transaction is in fact a prohibited transaction.

Written Comments and Hearing Requests

All interested persons are invited to submit written comments or

requests for a hearing on the proposed exemption to the address and

within the time period set forth above. All comments will be made a

part of the record. Comments and requests for a hearing should state

the reasons for the writer's interest in the proposed exemption.

Comments received will be available for public inspection with the

application for [[Page 15603]] exemption at the address set forth

above.

Proposed Exemption

The Department has under consideration the grant of the following

class exemption under the authority of section 408(a) of the Act and

section 4975(c)(2) of the Code, and in accordance with the procedures

set forth in 29 CFR part 2570, subpart B (55 FR 32836, 32847, August

10, 1990).

Part I--Basic Exemption

Effective [date of publication of final class exemption], the

restrictions of section 406(a)(1) (A) through (D) of the Act and the

taxes imposed by Code section 4975 (a) and (b) of the Code, by reason

of 4975(c)(1) (A) through (D), shall not apply to a transaction between

a party in interest with respect to a plan and such plan, provided that

an in-house asset manager (INHAM) (as defined in section IV(a)) has

discretionary authority or control with respect to the plan assets

involved in the transaction and the following conditions are satisfied:

(a) The terms of the transaction are negotiated on behalf of the

plan by, or under the authority and general direction of, the INHAM,

and either the INHAM, or (so long as the INHAM retains full fiduciary

responsibility with respect to the transaction) a property manager

acting in accordance with written guidelines established and

administered by the INHAM, makes the decision on behalf of the plan to

enter into the transaction. Notwithstanding the foregoing, a

transaction involving an amount in excess of $5,000,000, which has been

negotiated on behalf of the plan by the INHAM will not fail to meet the

requirements of this section I(a) solely because the plan sponsor or

its designee retains the right to veto or approve such transaction;

(b) The transaction is not described in--

(1) Prohibited Transaction Exemption 81-6 (46 FR 7527; January 23,

1981) (relating to securities lending arrangements),

(2) Prohibited Transaction Exemption 83-1 (48 FR 895; January 7,

1983) (relating to acquisitions by plans of interests in mortgage

pools), or

(3) Prohibited Transaction Exemption 88-59 (53 FR 24811; June 30,

1988) (relating to certain mortgage financing arrangements);

(c) The transaction is not part of an agreement, arrangement or

understanding designed to benefit a party in interest;

(d) At the time the transaction is entered into, and at the time of

any subsequent renewal or modification thereof that requires the

consent of the INHAM, the terms of the transaction are at least as

favorable to the plan as the terms generally available in arm's length

transactions between unrelated parties;

(e) The party in interest dealing with the plan: (1) is a party in

interest with respect to the plan (including a fiduciary) solely by

reason of providing services to the plan, or solely by reason of a

relationship to a service provider described in section 3(14)(F), (G),

(H), or (I) of ERISA; and (2) does not have discretionary authority or

control with respect to the investment of the plan assets involved in

the transaction and does not render investment advice (within the

meaning of 29 CFR 2510.3-21(c)) with respect to those assets;

(f) The party in interest dealing with the plan is neither the

INHAM nor a person related to the INHAM (within the meaning of section

IV(d)); and

(g) An independent auditor, who has appropriate technical training

and proficiency with ERISA's fiduciary responsibility provisions and so

represents in writing, conducts a fiduciary audit (as defined in

section IV(f)) on an annual basis to determine whether the written

procedures adopted by the INHAM are designed to operate in a manner

which assures compliance with the conditions of the exemption.

Following completion of the fiduciary audit, the auditor shall issue a

written report to the plan presenting its specific findings regarding

the design of such procedures and the level of compliance with the

procedures.

Part II--Specific Exemptions

Effective [date of publication of final class exemption], the

restrictions of sections 406(a), 406(b)(1), 406(b)(2) and 407(a) of the

Act and the taxes imposed by section 4975 (a) and (b) of the Code, by

reason of Code section 4975(c)(1) (A) through (E), shall not apply to:

(a) The leasing of office or commercial space owned by a plan

managed by an INHAM to an employer any of whose employees are covered

by the plan or an affiliate of such an employer (as defined in section

407(d)(7) of the Act), if--

(1) The plan acquires the office or commercial space subject to an

existing lease with an employer, or its affiliate as a result of

foreclosure on a mortgage or deed of trust;

(2) The INHAM makes the decision on behalf of the plan to foreclose

on the mortgage or deed of trust as part of the exercise of its

discretionary authority;

(3) The exemption provided for transactions engaged in with a plan

pursuant to section II(a) is effective until the later of the

expiration of the lease term or any renewal thereof which does not

require the consent of the plan lessor;

(4) The amount of space covered by the lease does not exceed

fifteen (15) percent of the rentable space of the office building or

the commercial center; and

(5) The requirements of sections I(c) and I(g) are satisfied with

respect to the transaction.

(b) The leasing of residential space by a plan to a party in

interest if--

(1) The party in interest leasing space from the plan is an

employee of an employer any of whose employees are covered by the plan

or an employee of an affiliate of such employer (as defined in section

407(d)(7) of the Act);

(2) The employee who is leasing space does not have any

discretionary authority or control with respect to the investment of

the assets involved in the lease transaction and does not render

investment advice (within the meaning of 29 CFR 2510.3- 21(c)) with

respect to those assets;

(3) The employee who is leasing space is not an officer, director,

or a 10% or more shareholder of the employer or an affiliate of such

employer;

(4) At the time the transaction is entered into, and at the time of

any subsequent renewal or modification thereof that requires the

consent of the INHAM, the terms of the transaction are not less

favorable to the plan than the terms afforded by the plan to other,

unrelated lessees in comparable arm's length transactions;

(5) The amount of space covered by the lease does not exceed five

percent (5%) of the rentable space of the apartment building or multi-

unit residential subdivision [townhouses or garden apartments], and the

aggregate amount of space leased to all employees of the employer or an

affiliate of such employer does not exceed ten percent (10%) of such

rentable space; and

(6) The requirements of sections I(a), I(c), I(d) and I(g) are

satisfied with respect to the transaction.

Part III--Places of Public Accommodation

Effective [date of publication of final class exemption], the

restrictions of section 406(a)(1)(A) through (D) and 406(b)(1) and (2)

of ERISA and the taxes imposed by Code section 4975(a) and (b), by

reason of Code section 4975(c)(1)(A) through (E), shall not apply to

the furnishing of services and facilities (and goods incidental

thereto) by a place of public accommodation owned by a plan and managed

by an INHAM to a party in interest with respect to the plan, if the

services and [[Page 15604]] facilities (and incidental goods) are

furnished on a comparable basis to the general public.

Part IV--Definitions

For the purposes of this exemption:

(a) The term ``in-house asset manager'' or ``INHAM'' means an

organization which is--

(1) either (A) a direct or indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of an

employer, or a direct or indirect wholly-owned subsidiary of a parent

organization of such an employer, or (B) a membership nonprofit

corporation a majority of whose members are officers or directors of

such an employer or parent organization; and

(2) an investment adviser registered under the Investment Advisers

Act of 1940 that, as of the last day of its most recent fiscal year,

has under its management and control total assets attributable to plans

maintained by affiliates of the INHAM (as defined in section IV(b)) in

excess of $50 million;

Provided that plans maintained by such affiliates of the INHAM

have, as of the last day of each plan's reporting year, aggregate

assets of at least $250 million.

(b) For purposes of section IV(a), an ``affiliate'' of an INHAM

means a member of either (1) a controlled group of corporations (as

defined in section 414(b) of the Code) of which the INHAM is a member,

or (2) a group of trades or businesses under common control (as defined

in section 414(c) of the Code) of which the INHAM is a member; provided

that ``50 percent'' shall be substituted for ``80 percent'' wherever

``80 percent'' appears in section 414(b) or 414(c) or the rules

thereunder.

(c) The term ``party in interest'' means a person described in Act

section 3(14) and includes a ``disqualified person'' as defined in Code

section 4975(e)(2).

(d) An INHAM is ``related'' to a party in interest for purposes of

section I(f) of this exemption if the party in interest (or a person

controlling, or controlled by, the party in interest) owns a five

percent or more interest in the INHAM or if the INHAM (or a person

controlling, or controlled by, the INHAM) owns a five percent or more

interest in the party in interest. For purposes of this definition:

(1) The term ``interest'' means with respect to ownership of an

entity--

A) The combined voting power of all classes of stock entitled to

vote or the total value of the shares of all classes of stock of the

entity if the entity is a corporation.

(B) The capital interest or the profits interest of the entity if

the entity is a partnership, or

(C) The beneficial interest of the entity if the entity is a trust

or unincorporated enterprise; and

(2) A person is considered to own an interest held in any capacity

if the person has or shares the authority--

(A) To exercise any voting rights or to direct some other person to

exercise the voting rights relating to such interest, or

(B) To dispose or to direct the disposition of such interest.

(e) For purposes of this exemption, the time as of which any

transaction occurs is the date upon which the transaction is entered

into. In addition, in the case of a transaction that is continuing, the

transaction shall be deemed to occur until it is terminated. If any

transaction is entered into on or after [date of publication of final

class exemption], or any renewal that requires the consent of the INHAM

occurs on or after [date of publication of final class exemption], and

the requirements of this exemption are satisfied at the time the

transaction is entered into or renewed, respectively, the requirements

will continue to be satisfied thereafter with respect to the

transaction. Nothing in this paragraph shall be construed as exempting

a transaction entered into by a plan which becomes a transaction

described in section 406 of the Act or section 4975 of the Code while

the transaction is continuing, unless the conditions of the exemption

were met either at the time the transaction was entered into or at the

time the transaction would have become prohibited but for this

exemption.

(f) Fiduciary Audit. A ``fiduciary audit'' of a plan must include,

among other things, the following:

(1) A determination as to whether the plan has developed adequate

policies and procedures designed to assure compliance with the proposed

exemption;

(2) A test of a representative sample of the plan's transactions to

determine operational compliance with the written policies and

procedures;

(3) A determination as to whether the INHAM has satisfied the

definition of an INHAM under the proposal; and

(4) A written report describing the steps performed by the auditor

during the course of its review and the auditor's findings and

recommendations.

Signed at Washington, DC, this 20th day of March, 1995.

Alan D. Lebowitz,

Deputy Assistant Secretary for Program Operations, Pension and Welfare

Benefits Administration, Department of Labor.

[FR Doc. 95-7364 Filed 3-23-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4510-29-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.