Oklahoma Regulatory Program

Federal RegisterJan 10, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR

Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement

30 CFR Part 936

Oklahoma Regulatory Program

AGENCY: Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement (OSM),

Interior.

ACTION: Final rule, approval of amendment.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: OSM is approving, with additional requirements, a proposed

amendment to the Oklahoma regulatory program (hereinafter referred to

as the ``Oklahoma program'') under the Surface Mining Control and

Reclamation Act of 1977 (SMCRA). Oklahoma proposed to amend its program

by revising its Bond Release Guidelines that include revegetation

success standards and statistically valid sampling techniques, and

guidelines for phase I, II, and III bond release. Oklahoma proposed

revisions pertaining to ground cover; requirements for permanent

impoundments, ponds, diversions, and treatment facilities; calculations

for a technical success standard for productivity; criteria regarding

the selection of test plots for demonstrating success of productivity

on prime farmland cropland; the definition of ``initial establishment

of permanent vegetative cover;'' the repair of rills and gullies as a

normal husbandry practice; a technical document reference; and the

correction of certain typographical errors. The amendment is intended

to revise the Oklahoma program to be consistent with the corresponding

Federal regulations.

EFFECTIVE DATE: January 10, 1995.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

James H. Moncrief, Telephone: (918) 581-6430.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background on the Oklahoma Program

On January 19, 1981, the Secretary of the Interior conditionally

approved the Oklahoma program. General background information on the

Oklahoma program, including the Secretary's findings, the disposition

of comments, and the conditions of approval of the Oklahoma program can

be found in the January 19, 1981, Federal Register (46 FR 4902).

Subsequent actions concerning Oklahoma's program and program amendments

can be found at 30 CFR 936.15, 936.16, and 936.30.

II. Submission of Amendment

On February 17, 1994, Oklahoma submitted a proposed amendment to

its program pursuant to SMCRA (administrative record No. OK-959.01).

Oklahoma submitted the proposed amendment with the intent of revising

the State program to be consistent with the corresponding Federal

standards. Oklahoma submitted the proposed amendment, in part, in

response to required program amendments at 30 CFR 936.16 (a) through

(i) and, in part, at its own initiative.

Oklahoma proposed to amend the Bond Release Guidelines that are

referenced in Oklahoma Administrative Code (OAC) 460:20-43-46(a)(1) and

460:20-45-46(a)(1). Specifically, Oklahoma proposed to revise the Bond

Release Guidelines at subsection I.E.3.b to require ground cover

sufficient to control erosion for approved commercial or industrial

land uses; subsection I.F.3.d to require, on areas previously disturbed

by mining, that ground cover be at least 70 percent and sufficient to

control erosion; subsection I.F.5.b to require that water discharged

from permanent impoundments, ponds, diversions, and treatment

facilities shall meet water quality effluent limitations; subsections

II.B.2.d and III.B.2.d to reference Appendix O for the method for

calculating a technical success standard for productivity on,

respectively, pastureland and grazing land; subsection V.B.2.c to

reference Appendix P for the method for calculating a technical success

standard for productivity of row crops on prime farmland cropland;

subsection V.B.2.d to add criteria regarding the selection of test

plots for demonstrating success of productivity on prime farmland

cropland; subsection V.B.2.e to reference Appendix O for the method for

calculating a technical success standard for productivity of grain or

hay crops on prime farmland cropland; subsection VI.B.2.e to reference

Appendices P and Q for the methods for calculating technical success

standards for productivity of, respectively, row crops and grain or hay

crops on nonprime farmland cropland; Appendix A to add the definition

of ``initial establishment of permanent vegetative cover;'' Appendices

J and P to correct typographical errors; and Appendix V, to add a

technical document reference. [[Page 2513]] In addition, Oklahoma

submitted a letter, dated February 1, 1994, from the U.S. Soil

Conservation Service (SCS) that was intended to provide concurrence

with Appendix R concerning the repair of rills and gullies as a normal

husbandry practice.

OSM published a notice in the March 8, 1994, Federal Register (59

FR 10770) announcing receipt of the amendment and inviting public

comment on its adequacy (administrative record No. OK-959.06). The

public hearing, scheduled for April 4,1994, was not held because no one

requested an opportunity to testify.

During its review of the amendment, OSM identified concerns with

Oklahoma's proposed revisions to the Bond Release Guidelines.

Specifically, OSM identified concerns relating to (1) sections I.E.3,

I.F.3, II.A, and III.A, the need to establish a method to determine

revegetation success standards for diversity, seasonality, permanence,

and regeneration; (2) Appendix O, the method for calculating a

technical productivity standard for success of revegetation on soils

reclaimed for use as pastureland, grazingland, and grain and hay

cropland on both prime and nonprime farmland; (3) subsection V.B.2.d,

phase II bond release requirements for the use of test plots to

demonstrate productivity on reclaimed prime farmland; and (4) Appendix

R, the repair of rills and gullies as a normal husbandry practice. In

addition, OSM identified certain editorial concerns relating to (1)

subsection I.F.5.b, phase III bond release requirements for permanent

drainage control facilities; (2) subsection V.B.2.e, the reference to

Appendix O for the method to calculate a technical productivity

standard on prime farmland for phase II bond release; and (3) Appendix

J, the example calculation for a minimum adequate sample size. OSM

notified Oklahoma of these concerns by letter dated May 20, 1994

(administrative record No. OK-959.10).

Oklahoma responded in a letter dated July 21, 1994, by submitting a

revised amendment and additional explanatory information

(administrative record No. OK-959.11).

Based upon the revisions to and additional explanatory information

for the proposed program amendment submitted by Oklahoma, OSM reopened

the public comment period in the August 9, 1994, Federal Register (59

FR 40505; administrative record No. OK-959.16). The public comment

period closed on August 24, 1994.

By letter dated September 2, 1994 (administrative record No. OK-

959.19), Oklahoma, and in response to an August 29, 1994, comment

letter from SCS (administrative record No. OK-959.18), submitted a

revised amendment. Oklahoma proposed revisions to the Bond Release

Guidelines in Appendices A, F, and O, concerning, respectively, the

definition of ``productivity,'' the method of sampling for production

on pastureland and grazingland, and the methods for calculating a

technical standard for productivity on lands reclaimed for use as

pastureland and grazingland.

Based upon these revisions to the proposed amendment submitted by

Oklahoma, OSM reopened the public comment period in the September 27,

1994, Federal Register (59 FR 49222; administrative record No. OK-

959.22). The public comment period closed on August 12, 1994.

III. Director's Findings

Set forth below, pursuant to SMCRA and the Federal regulations at

30 CFR 732.15 and 732.17, are the Director's findings for the proposed

amendment submitted by Oklahoma on February 17, 1994, as revised by it

on July 21 and September 2, 1994.

1. Nonsubstantive Revisions to the Bond Release Guidelines

Oklahoma proposed, as State initiatives, revisions to the following

previously-approved provisions of the Bond Release Guidelines that are

nonsubstantive in nature and consist of minor editorial changes

(corresponding Federal provisions are listed in parentheses):

Appendix J, Calculation of Minimum Adequate Sample Size (30 CFR

816.116(a)(2) and 817.116(a)(2)), correction of typographical errors

in example calculations, and

Appendix V, References Cited (30 CFR 816.116(a)(2) and

817.116(a)(2)), addition of a reference to Vogel, Willis G., 1987, A

Manual for Training Reclamation Inspectors in the Fundamentals of

Soils and Revegetation.

Because the proposed revisions to these previously-approved

provisions are nonsubstantive in nature, the Director finds that these

proposed revisions in Appendices J and V are no less effective than the

Federal regulations. The Director approves these proposed revisions.

2. Substantive Revisions to Oklahoma's Bond Release Guidelines

a. Subsection I.E.3.b, Phase II bond release requirements for

ground cover on all land uses. At 30 CFR 936.16(a), OSM required that

Oklahoma revise subsection I.E.3.b to clarify that, in cases of

approved commercial or industrial land uses, ground cover must be

sufficient to control erosion (finding No. 2, 58 FR 64374, 64376,

December 7, 1993).

Oklahoma proposed to revise subsection I.E.3.b in the Bond Release

Guidelines to add the requirement that, on areas with an approved

industrial or commercial postmining land use, ground cover must be

sufficient to control erosion.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(b)(4) and 817.116(b)(4)

require that the vegetative ground cover shall not be less than that

required to control erosion on areas to be developed for an industrial,

commercial, or residential land use.

The Director finds that Oklahoma's revision of subsection I.E.3.b

in the Bond Release Guidelines is no less effective than the Federal

regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(b)(4) and 817.116(b)(4). The Director

approves the proposed revision at subsection I.E.3.b and removes the

required amendment at 30 CFR 936.16(a).

b. Subsection I.F.3.d, Phase III bond release requirements for

ground cover on areas previously disturbed by mining, and sections

VII.A and VII.B, phase II and III bond release requirements for ground

cover on areas developed for commercial, industrial, or residential

use. At 30 CFR 936.16(b), OSM required that Oklahoma revise subsection

I.F.3.d to require, prior to phase III bond release on previously mined

areas (areas that were not reclaimed to the requirements of the

permanent regulatory program regulations and that were remined or

otherwise disturbed by mining), that vegetative ground cover shall not

be less than the ground cover existing before redistrubance (finding

No. 3, 58 FR 64374, 64377, December 7, 1993).

Oklahoma proposed to revise subsection I.F.3.d. in the Bond Release

Guidelines to require that the ground cover on reclaimed areas that had

been previously disturbed by mining cannot be less than the ground

cover existing prior to redisturbance. Oklahoma also proposed to revise

subsection I.F.3.d. to require that, if the ground cover prior to

redisturbance was less than 70 percent, the ground cover on the

reclaimed area must be at least 70 percent vegetation and must be

sufficient to control erosion. In effect, Oklahoma proposed that the

ground cover, on reclaimed areas that had been previously disturbed by

mining, cannot be less than 70 percent, must be equal to or greater

than the pre-existing ground cover if it was more than 70 percent, and

must be sufficient to control erosion.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(b)(5) and 817.116(b)(5)

require [[Page 2514]] on previously mined areas that the reclaimed

vegetative ground cover must (1) not be less than the ground cover

existing before redisturbance and (2) be adequate to control erosion.

With the exception of a minimum requirement that ground cover must

be at least 70 percent, Oklahoma's proposed revisions are substantively

identical to the Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(b)(5) and

817.116(b)(5). Oklahoma's proposed requirement that the ground cover on

the reclaimed area must be at least 70 percent vegetation has no

counterpart in the Federal regulations. However, this proposed

requirement is not inconsistent with the Federal regulations and, in

those cases where the ground cover of the previously disturbed area was

less than 70 percent and was sufficient to control erosion, provides

for a greater degree of revegetation of previously mined areas than do

the Federal regulations.

Therefore, the Director finds that Oklahoma's proposed revisions of

subsection I.F.3.d in the Bond Release Guidelines are no less effective

than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(b)(5) and 817.116(b)(5).

The Director approves the proposed revisions and removes the required

amendment at 30 CFR 936.16(b).

Oklahoma also required at sections VII.A and B, for phase II and

III bond release on areas developed for commercial, industrial, or

residential land use, that the ground cover must be sufficient to

control erosion. Oklahoma indicated parenthetically that the ground

cover standard would be 70 percent. Oklahoma, at OAC 460:20-43-43(a)(4)

and 460:20-45-43(a)(4), and OAC 460:20-43-46(b)(5) and 460:20-45-

46(b)(5) require respectively that (1) ground cover for all land uses

be capable of stabilizing the soil surface from erosion and (2) ground

cover be not less than that required to control erosion for areas with

an approved industrial, commercial, or residential land use. Therefore,

OSM interprets Oklahoma's parenthetical indication that there must be

70 percent ground cover on land developed for commercial, industrial,

or residential use to be a minimum standard that must be increased if

it is insufficient to control erosion.

c. Subsection I.F.5.b, Phase III bond release requirements for

permanent drainage control facilities. At 30 CFR 936.16(d), OSM

required that Oklahoma revise subsection I.F.5.b to require that water

discharged from permanent impoundments, ponds, diversions, and

treatment facilities meet applicable water quality effluent limitations

in addition to not degrading the quality of receiving water below

applicable water quality standards (finding No. 5, 58 FR 64374, 64378,

December 7, 1993).

Oklahoma proposed to revise subsection I.F.5.b in the Bond Release

Guidelines to require that water discharged from permanent

impoundments, ponds, diversions, and treatment facilities shall meet

applicable water quality effluent limitations and not degrade the

quality of receiving waters to less than the water quality standards

pursuant to applicable State and Federal laws.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.49(b)(2) and 817.49(b)(2)

require for permanent impoundments that the quality of impounded water

will meet applicable State and Federal water quality standards, and

discharges will meet applicable effluent limitations and will not

degrade the quality of receiving water below applicable State and

Federal water quality standards.

The Director finds that Oklahoma's proposed revisions of subsection

I.F.5.b in the Bond Release Guidelines are substantively identical to

and no less effective than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR

816.49(b)(2) and 817.49(b)(2). Therefore, the Director approves the

proposed revisions and removes the required amendment at 30 CFR

936.16(d).

d. Subsections II.B.2.d, III.B.2.d, and V.B.2.c, Phase III bond

release requirements for productivity on pastureland, phase III bond

release requirements for productivity on grazingland, and phase II bond

release requirements for productivity on prime farmland cropland. At 30

CFR 936.16(f), OSM required that Oklahoma revise subsections II.B.2.d,

III.B.2.d, and V.B.2.c to state that productivity standards proposed by

an applicant that are not calculated using the method described in

Appendix O must be approved by both Oklahoma and OSM (finding No. 6.b,

58 FR 64374, 64378, December 7, 1993).

Oklahoma proposed to revise subsections II.B.2.d and III.B.2.d in

the Bond Release Guidelines to require that, when a reference area is

not used, a technical success standard for productivity on pastureland

and grazingland be calculated by using the method described in Appendix

O. Oklahoma also proposed to revise subsection V.B.2.c in the Bond

Release Guidelines to require that, when a reference area is not used,

a technical success standard for productivity on prime farmland

cropland be calculated by using the method described in Appendix O.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1)

require that standards for revegetation success shall be selected by

the regulatory authority and included in an approved regulatory

program. OSM previously approved the methods for calculating technical

success standards for productivity in Appendix O in the Bond Release

Guidelines.

By referencing Appendix O in subsections II.B.2.d, III.B.2.d, and

V.B.2.c, Oklahoma has, in effect, limited technical success standards

for productivity on pastureland, grazingland, and prime farmland

cropland to only those standards calculated using the methods described

in Appendix O.

Because Oklahoma no longer allows unspecified methods that OSM

would not have an opportunity to approve, and because OSM previously

approved Appendix O, the Director finds that the proposed revisions of

subsections II.B.2.d, III.B.2.d, and V.B.2.c in the Bond Release

Guidelines are no less effective than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR

816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1). The Director approves the proposed

revisions and removes the required amendment at 30 CFR 936.36(f).

e. Subsections IV.A.1.a and b and Sections VII.A and B, Phase III

bond release requirements for diversity, seasonality, permanence, and

regeneration. At 30 CFR 936.16(c), OSM required that Oklahoma revise

the Bond Release Guidelines to identify the revegetation success

standards and sampling methods for diversity, seasonality, permanence,

and regeneration that will be applied for all land uses prior to phase

III bond release (finding No. 1.a, 58 FR 64374, 64375, December 7,

1993).

Oklahoma proposed to revise subsections IV.A.1.a and b, and

sections VII.A and B in the Bond Release Guidelines, to require, prior

to phase II and III bond release on reclaimed areas with a designated

land use of forestry, wildlife habitat, recreation, industrial,

commercial, or residential, that the bond release areas must meet

permit-specific standards for diversity, seasonality, permanence, and

regeneration.

For phase II bond release on pastureland and grazingland,

subsections II.A.1.g and III.A.1.g in the Bond Release Guidelines

require that perennial species not listed in the approved reclamation

plan (but approved by Oklahoma as desirable and compatible with the

postmining land use) cannot exceed 20 percent of total ground cover

with no more than 5 percent ground cover by any one of these species.

Subsections II.A.1.f and III.A.1.f in the Bond Release Guidelines

[[Page 2515]] require, for phase II bond release on pastureland and

grazingland, that no more than 10 percent litter and 10 percent

desirable annual or biennial forbs can be counted as acceptable ground

cover in any single sampling unit. For phase III bond release on

pastureland and grazingland, subsections II.B.1.a and III.B.1.a in the

Bond Release Guidelines refer the reader to the phase II standards.

As discussed above, Oklahoma does require, for phase II and III

bond release on pastureland and grazingland, standards which reflect

permanence, seasonality, and regeneration on pastureland and

grazingland. However, Oklahoma has not revised the Bond Release

Guidelines to address how it would evaluate the reclaimed area for

diversity of permanent species prior to phase III bond release on

pastureland and grazingland.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a) and 817.116(a) require

that the success of revegetation shall be judged on, among other

things, the requirements of 30 CFR 816.111 and 817.111. The Federal

regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1) require that all

success standards and sampling techniques must be included in an

approved regulatory program. Therefore, success standards and sampling

techniques must incorporate the various requirements at 30 CFR 816.111

and 817.111 and be approved by OSM. The Federal regulations at 30 CFR

816.111 and 817.111 require, among other things, that a permittee

establish where appropriate a vegetative cover that is diverse,

effective, and permanent (referred to as diversity and permanence). The

Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.111 and 817.111 also require a

permittee to reestablish plant species that have the same seasonal

characteristics of growth as the original vegetation and are capable of

self-regeneration and plan succession (referred to as seasonality and

regeneration).

Standards reflecting diversity, seasonality, permanence, and

regeneration on areas with designated land uses of forestry, fish and

wildlife habitat, commercial, industrial, and recreation are

appropriately addressed on a permit-specific basis, as proposed by

Oklahoma, because the standards will vary with the actual needs

specific to the area being reclaimed. For example, there may be no need

for a diversity standard for an area to reclaimed to an industrial,

commercial, or residential land use where reclamation will probably

employ a single-species ground cover established for erosion control,

but there may be a need for a significant diversity/seasonality

standard for an area to be reclaimed to as a wildlife habitat targeted

for specific wildlife species.

Therefore, with respect to areas designated for use as forestry,

wildlife habitat, recreation, industrial, commercial, or residential,

the Director finds that the proposed revisions at subsections IV.A.1.a

and b, and sections VII.A and B in the Bond Release Guidelines are no

less effective than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a),

817.116(a), 816.111, and 817.111, and approves them.

With respect to areas designated for use as pastureland and

grazingland, the Director finds that the Bond Release Guidelines are

less effective than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a),

817.116(a), 816.111, and 817.111 because Oklahoma has not addressed how

it will evaluate the reclaimed area for diversity of permanent species

prior to phase III bond release. Therefore, the Director is revising

the required amendment at 30 CFR 936.16(c) to require that Oklahoma

revise sections II.B and III.B in the Bond Release Guidelines to

address how it will evaluate diversity prior to phase III bond release

on areas designated for use as pastureland and grazingland.

f. Subsections V.B.2.d and V.B.2.e, Phase II bond release

requirements for the use of test plots to demonstrate productivity on

reclaimed prime farmland cropland. At 30 CFR 936.16(g), OSM required

that Oklahoma revise subsection V.B.2.d to either remove the allowance

for the use of test plots as a means of demonstrating productivity

success on prime farmlands, or submit a method for demonstrating that

the test plots would be representative at a 90-percent statistical

confidence level of the total reclaimed prime farmland bond release

area. OSM also required Oklahoma to consult with SCS for the proposed

method and to document this consultation (finding No. 6.c, 58 FR 64374,

64379, December 7, 1993).

Oklahoma, at OAC 460:20-43-46(c)(2) and 460:20-45-46(c)(2),

requires that the measurement period for determining revegetation

success of cropland exceed the approved standards any 2 years of the

responsibility period, except the first year. Oklahoma's Bond Release

Guidelines at subsection V.B.2.a and OAC 460:20-49-8(b)(3) require, for

phase II bond release on reclaimed prime farmland, that the measurement

period for determining the average annual crop production be a minimum

of 3 crop years. OSM interprets Oklahoma's rules and Bond Release

Guidelines to require, for phase II bond release on reclaimed prime

farmland, that a permittee demonstrate success of productivity with 3

years of crop production during the responsibility period, except the

first year.

Subsection V.B.2.d provides for the use of test plots, as an

alternative to use of the total reclaimed area, for measuring the

success of productivity on prime farmlands. Oklahoma proposed to revise

subsection V.B.2.d to require that selected test plots must be

representative of geology, soil, and slope of the reclaimed prime

farmland area, and, if the test plots are not properly managed during

the liability period, they will lose eligibility as a comparison

method.

Oklahoma also proposed to revise section V.B.2 by adding a new

subsection V.B.2.e that sets forth criteria that must be used to

establish test plots in the reclaimed bond release area. At subsections

V.B.2.e (1) through (4), Oklahoma proposed to require the following

criteria:

(1) A contiguous prime farmland or cropland area represents a

single population, test plots are selected at random throughout the

contiguous reclaimed area. Appendix C [Methods of Randomized

Selection of Sampling Locations] provides methods of selecting

randomized sampling locations.

(2) Each test plot represents one sample. Appendix Q [Minimum

Sample Size for Row Crops in Prime Farmland (or Nonprime Farmland)

Production Determination] provides the minimum sample size formulas

for measuring row crops for production standards on prime farmland.

(3) The size of the test plot should be based on the sampling

technique (i.e., hand sampling, machine harvest, etc.) that will be

used to evaluate crop production. In addition, the plots should be

large enough so that impact of any edge effect would be avoided.

(4) The methods for measuring row crop production on prime

farmlands is shown in Appendix P [Methods for Measuring Row Crops in

Prime Farmland (and Nonprime Farmland) Production].

Oklahoma did not submit evidence of consultation with SCS regarding the

use of test plots for measuring productivity on prime farmland.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(2) and 817.116(a)(2)

require that reclaimed areas be managed in the same manner as unmined

lands with the same land use in the region of the reclaimed area. The

Federal regulations at 30 CFR 823.15(b)(2) require that soil

productivity shall be measured on a representative sample or on all of

the mined and reclaimed prime farmland area using the reference crop

determined under 30 CFR 823.15(b)(6), and also require that a

statistically valid sampling technique at a 90-percent or

[[Page 2516]] greater statistical confidence level shall be used as

approved by the regulatory authority in consultation with SCS.

The Director finds that Oklahoma's proposed requirements for the

management of test plots at subsection V.B.2.d are substantively

identical to and no less effective than the requirements of 30 CFR

816.116(a)(2) and 817.116(a)(2). Because Oklahoma proposed criteria for

establishment of test plots within the reclaimed area that should

ensure that the test plots will be representative at a 90-percent

statistical confidence level of the total reclaimed prime farmland bond

release area, the Director finds that subsections V.B.2.e (1) through

(4) are no less effective than the requirements of 30 CFR 823.15(b)(2).

The Director approves the proposed revisions at subsections V.B.2.d and

V.B.2.e (1) through (4).

However, because Oklahoma did not submit evidence of consultation

with SCS as required by the Federal regulations at 30 CFR 823.15(b)(2)

for development of statistically valid sampling techniques used on

reclaimed prime farmlands, the Director is revising the required

amendment at 30 CFR 936.16(g) to require that Oklahoma must submit,

before Oklahoma allows the use of test plots as proposed at subsections

V.B.2.d and V.B.2.e in the Bond Release Guidelines, evidence of

consultation with SCS regarding the use of test plots as a

statistically valid sampling technique for demonstrating success of

productivity on prime farmlands.

g. Subsections V.B.2.f and VI.B.2.e, Phase II bond release

requirements for productivity on prime farmland cropland. At 30 CFR

936.16(e), OSM required that Oklahoma revise subsections V.B.2.e and

VI.B.2.e to reference Appendix O for the methods to calculate the

technical productivity standards for hay crops on prime and nonprime

farmland cropland, and to cite the reference for the methods for

calculating technical productivity standards that are in Appendix O

(finding No. 6.a, 58 FR 64374, 64378, December 7, 1993).

Oklahoma proposed to revise section V.B.2 by adding a new paragraph

(e) and redesignating existing paragraph (e) as (f) (see finding No.

2.f for a discussion of new subsection V.B.2.e). Oklahoma proposed to

revise subsection V.B.2.f, requirements for phase II bond release on

prime farmland cropland, by stating that the method to calculate the

technical productivity standard for grain or hay crops on prime

farmland cropland is in Appendix O. Oklahoma proposed to revise

subsection VI.B.2.e, requirements for phase III bond release on

nonprime farmland cropland, by stating that the method to calculate the

technical productivity standard for grain or hay crops on nonprime

farmland cropland is in Appendix O (see finding No. 2.h for discussion

of an additional proposed revision at subsection VI.B.2.e). In

addition, Oklahoma stated in its transmittal letter for the proposed

amendment that the reference for the methods for calculating technical

productivity standards in Appendix O is the ``Technical Guides on Use

of Reference Areas and Technical Standards for Evaluating Surface Mine

Vegetation in OSM Regions I and II,'' which is listed in the Bond

Release Guidelines in Appendix V.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1)

require that standards for success and statistically valid sampling

techniques for measuring success shall be selected by the regulatory

authority and included in an approved regulatory program.

By clearly referencing Appendix O, Oklahoma requires that a

calculated technical productivity standard be calculated by the methods

described in Appendix O, and has therefore proposed, in its regulatory

program, an alternative standard (to the standard determined by a

reference area) for measuring success of revegetation on prime and

nonprime farmlands.

The Director finds that subsections V.B.2.f and VI.B.2.e in the

Bond Release Guidelines are no less effective than the Federal

regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1). The Director

approves the proposed revisions of subsections V.B.2.f and VI.B.2.e and

removes the required amendment at 30 CFR 936.16(e).

h. Subsection VI.B.2.e, Phase II bond release requirements for

productivity on nonprime farmland cropland. Because subsection VI.B.2.e

pertains to productivity on nonprime farmland cropland, OSM required,

at 30 CFR 936.16(h), that Oklahoma revise subsection VI.B.2.e to change

``prime farmland cropland'' to ``nonprime farmland cropland'' when

referencing Appendix P for the methods to measure row crop production

(finding No. 6.d, 58 FR 64374, 64379, December 7, 1993).

Oklahoma proposed to revise subsection VI.B.2.e in the Bond Release

Guidelines to state that the methods for measuring row crop production

on nonprime farmland cropland are described in Appendix P.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1)

require that standards for success and statistically valid sampling

techniques for measuring success shall be selected by the regulatory

authority and included in an approved regulatory program.

By clarifying that the sampling methods for measuring row crop

production on nonprime farmland cropland are in Appendix P, Oklahoma

has proposed, in its regulatory program, sampling methods for measuring

success of revegetation for nonprime farmland cropland.

The Director finds that subsection VI.B.2.e in the Bond Release

Guidelines is no less effective than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR

816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1). The Director approves the revision of

subsection VI.B.2.e and removes the required amendment at 30 CFR

936.16(h).

i. Appendix A, Definition of ``productivity''. Oklahoma previously

defined, in Appendix A, the term ``productivity'' to mean

[T]he amount of harvestable standing biomass of desirable

species. Standing biomass is the aboveground living portion and the

attached litter portion of plants produced within a given growing

season. Horizontal runners of stoloniferous plants are also

included.

(Emphasis added). Oklahoma proposed, at its own initiative and in

response to an SCS comment, a revised definition of ``productivity'' to

refer to ``[t]he amount of total standing biomass of desirable

species'' (emphasis added).

There is no counterpart definition for ``productivity'' in the

Federal regulations; however, the Federal regulations at 30 CFR

816.116(a)(2) and 817.116(a)(2) require that standards for success

shall include criteria representative of unmined lands in the area

being reclaimed to evaluate the appropriate vegetation parameters of

ground cover, production, or stocking. Although not explicitly stated,

the production parameter must be representative of the total

productivity the reclaimed soils were capable of before mining.

Oklahoma, by substituting ``total standing biomass'' for ``harvestable

standing biomass,'' has proposed that the term ``productivity'' refers

to the total productivity the reclaimed soils were capable of before

mining.

The Director finds that Oklahoma's proposed definition of

``productivity'' in Appendix A in the Bond Release Guidelines is no

less effective than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(2) and

817.116(a)(2) and approves it.

j. Appendices A and R, Definition of ``initial establishment of

permanent vegetative cover'' and the ``repair of rills and gullies'' as

a normal husbandry practice. At 30 CFR 936.16(i), OSM required that

Oklahoma revise Appendix R to either remove any reference to the

proposed treatment of [[Page 2517]] rills and gullies as a normal

husbandry practice, or specify what constitutes ``initial vegetation

establishment'' and submit either the actual SCS guideline described in

Appendix R or a letter from SCS to Oklahoma stating that the practices

described in Appendix R are considered normal husbandry practices for

the repair of rills and gullies in the State of Oklahoma (finding No.

7, 58 FR 64374, 64379, December 7, 1993).

Appendix R in Oklahoma's Bond Release Guidelines includes the

``Guidelines for the Repair of Rills and Gullies.'' These guidelines

require that the repair of rills and gullies restart the revegetation

liability period unless the occurrences and treatment of such rills and

gullies constitute a normal conservation practice in the region.

Oklahoma sets forth in Appendix R these normal conservation practices,

which are the treatment practices that are considered the degree of

management customarily performed to prevent exploitation, destruction,

or neglect of the soil resource and maintain the productivity of the

land use. In Appendix R, Oklahoma requires that the treatment of rills

and gullies requiring permanent reseeding of more than 10 acres in a

contiguous block or 10 percent of a permit area initially seeded during

a single year shall be considered an augmentative practice.

Oklahoma proposed to revise Appendix R to require that any

treatment of rills and gullies after ``initial establishment of

permanent vegetative cover'' shall also be considered an augmentative

practice that would restart the liability period. In addition, Oklahoma

proposed to revise Appendix A in the Bond Release Guidelines to define

``initial establishment of permanent vegetative cover'' to mean

[T]he time period between the bond liability start date and

final approval of the Phase II bond release on the permit or

increment of the permit.

At section I.A.1 in the Bond Release Guidelines, Oklahoma requires

that the liability period for revegetation success on reclaimed lands

begins with the successful completion of initial planting of all

required permanent vegetation species on a site. Therefore, Oklahoma

proposed to allow the repair of rills and gullies without restarting

the liability period during the time period between successful

completion of initial planting and initial establishment of permanent

vegetative cover. After phase II bond release, any repair of rills and

gullies in the bond release area would be considered an augmentative

practice that would restart the liability period.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(c)(4) and 817.116(c)(4)

provide that the regulatory authority may approve selective husbandry

practices as normal husbandry practices (excluding augmented seeding,

fertilization, or irrigation), provided it obtains prior approval of

these practices from the Director of OSM in accordance with 30 CFR

732.17. These practices can be implemented as normal husbandry

practices without extending the period of responsibility for

revegetation success and bond liability, if such practices can be

expected to continue as part of the postmining land use or if

discontinuance of the practices after the liability period expires will

not reduce the probability of permanent revegetation success. Approved

husbandry practices must be normal husbandry practices within the

region for unmined lands having land uses similar to the approved

postmining land use of the disturbed area, and include such practices

as disease, pest, and vermin control, and any pruning, reseeding, and

transplanting specifically necessitated by such actions.

Because Oklahoma has defined the term ``initial establishment of

permanent vegetative cover,'' it is possible to determine when an

operator must consider the repair of rills and gullies an augmentative

practice that would restart the liability period.

Oklahoma also submitted, as part of the Bond Release Guidelines a

letter, dated February 1, 1994, from the Oklahoma State Office of SCS.

In this letter, SCS stated that

[W]e have reviewed the Oklahoma Department of Mines proposed

guidelines for the repair of rills and gullies on reclaimed mine

land in Oklahoma. We believe these guidelines are complete and

adequate for reclamation if they are followed by the operator.

In addition, in a March 14, 1994, letter to OSM (administrative

record No. OK-959-.07), SCS commented that

Appendix R represents normal practices that would be used for

gully control in the State of Oklahoma.

Therefore, because Oklahoma has adequately demonstrated that the

practices for the repair of rills and gullies in Appendix R are

supported by SCS as an acceptable land management technique for similar

situations in the State of Oklahoma, the Director finds that Oklahoma's

proposal in Appendix R for the repair of rills and gullies as a normal

husbandry practice is no less effective than the Federal regulations at

30 CFR 816.116(c)(4) and 817.116(c)(4). The Director approves the

proposed definition of ``initial establishment of permanent vegetative

cover'' in Appendix A and, as specified in Appendix R, the repair of

rills and gullies as a normal husbandry practice, and removes the

required amendment at 30 CFR 936.16(i).

k. Appendices F and O, Methods of production sampling and methods

for calculation of technical productivity standards on pastureland and

grazingland. Oklahoma presented, in Appendix O, an example of the

method for calculating a technical productivity standard using soil

yield figures expressed in animal unit months (AUM's) that are

published in SCS county soil surveys. This example calculation was

applicable to lands reclaimed for use as pastureland and grazingland.

In response to OSM's May 20, 1994, issue letter, Oklahoma proposed

to revise Appendix O to require the use of SCS county survey soil

supplements, if available, and if not available, to use SCS county soil

surveys; and to include a separate example calculation for a technical

productivity standard on grazingland based on a direct comparison for

total productivity with SCS soil productivity figures expressed in

pounds per acre (rather than AUM's).

In response to SCS comments, Oklahoma, at its own initiative,

proposed to further revise the Bond Release Guidelines. Oklahoma

revised Appendix F, concerning the method of production sampling, to

(1) recommend that pastureland or grazingland with a predominance of

warm season species be clipped during September or October and

pastureland or grazingland with a predominance of cool species be

clipped during May or June, and (2) requires that all production

samples be clipped to ground level. Oklahoma also proposed to further

revise Appendix O, concerning the methods of calculating technical

productivity standards on pastureland and grazingland, to (1) require

that the SCS soil productivity figure expressed in AUM's be multiplied

by 1560 in the calculation for a technical productivity standard on

pastureland, and (2) clarify that clipping is a direct comparison using

the calculation for a technical productivity standard on grazingland

based on soil productivity figures expressed in pounds per acre.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(1) and 817.116(a)(1)

require that standards for success and statistically valid sampling

techniques for measuring success shall be selected by the regulatory

authority and included in an approved regulatory program. The Federal

regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(2) and 817.116(a)(2) also

[[Page 2518]] require that standards for success shall include criteria

representative of unmined lands in the area being reclaimed to evaluate

the appropriate vegetation parameters of ground cover, production, or

stocking.

Oklahoma's proposed revisions of Appendices F and O will ensure

that, on land reclaimed for use as pastureland or grazingland, the

demonstration of success of restored productivity, based on technical

standards derived from SCS soil surveys, accurately represents the

productive potential of similar soils in the region.

The Director finds that Oklahoma's proposed revisions of Appendices

F and O are no less effective than the Federal regulations at 30 CFR

817.116(a) (1) and (2) and 817.116(a) (1) and (2). The Director

approves them.

IV. Summary and Disposition of Comments

1. Public Comments

OSM invited public comments on the proposed amendment, but none

were received.

2. Agency Comments

Pursuant to 732.17(h)(11)(i), OSM solicited comments on the

proposed amendment from various Federal agencies with an actual or

potential interest in the Oklahoma program (administrative record No.

OK-960).

a. SCS. On March 14, 1994, SCS responded with the following

comments (administrative record No. OK-959.07). SCS (1) recommended

that Oklahoma use the terms ``native grazingland'' and ``introduced

grazingland'' in place of the terms ``grazingland'' and

``pastureland;'' (2) recommended revision of the method described in

Appendix O to calculate a technical standard, for total production on

grazingland and pastureland; and (3) stated that the methods described

for treatment of rills and gullies in Appendix R represent normal

practices used for gully control in the State of Oklahoma.

With respect to the recommendation that Oklahoma use the terms

``introduced grazingland'' and ``native grazingland'' in place of the

terms ``pastureland'' and ``grazingland,'' the Federal regulations at

30 CFR define (1) ``pastureland'' to mean land used primarily for the

long-term production of adapted, domesticated forage plants to be

grazed by livestock or occasionally cut and cured for livestock feed,

and (2) ``grazingland'' to mean land used for grasslands and forest

lands where the indigenous vegetation is actively managed for grazing,

browsing, or occasional hay production. In addition, Oklahoma's rules

at section 701.5 include definitions of ``pastureland'' and

``grazingland'' that are identical to the Federal regulations.

Oklahoma, in Appendix O of the Bond Release Guidelines, refers to

``pastureland'' and ``grazingland'' as, respectively, improved pasture

grasses and native range grasses. Therefore, because Oklahoma's use of

the terms ``pastureland'' and ``grazingland'' in the Bond Release

Guidelines is consistent with and no less effective than the use of

these terms in Oklahoma rules and the Federal regulations, the Director

is not requiring that Oklahoma revise the amendment in response to this

comment.

With respect to the recommendation that Oklahoma revise the method

described in Appendix O to calculate a technical standard for total

production on grazingland and pastureland, OSM required in its May 20,

1994, issue letter that Oklahoma revise the method described in

Appendix O to accurately represent the total productive potential of

soils based on SCS soil county survey productivity figures expressed in

AUM's. Oklahoma responded in its July 21, 1994, revised amendment with

explanatory information and revisions to Appendix O that addressed

OSM's issue letter with respect to the calculation of a technical

standard for total production on grazingland. However, in response to

additional August 29, 1994, SCS comments concerning the calculation of

a technical standard for total production on pastureland, Oklahoma, at

its own initiative, proposed further revisions to Appendix O in its

September 2, 1994, revised amendment (see finding No. 2.K).

With respect to the comment that the methods described for

treatment of rills and gullies in Appendix R represent normal practices

used for gully control in the State of Oklahoma, the Director, as

discussed in finding No. 2.f above, is approving the guidelines for

repair of rill and gullies in Appendix R as a normal husbandry

practice.

SCS also responded on August 29, 1994, with the following comments

(administrative record No. OK-959.18). SCS again recommended, that

because both the terms ``pastureland'' and ``grazingland'' as used by

Oklahoma in Appendix O can mean grazingland, Oklahoma use either

``native grazingland'' or ``rangeland'' in place of the term

``grazingland.'' As discussed above, in response to a similar comment

made by SCS in its March 14, 1994, letter, OSM is not requiring that

Oklahoma revise the Bond Release Guidelines in response to this

comment.

SCS recommended another means of revising the method for

calculating a technical productivity figure on pastureland in Appendix

O of Oklahoma's Bond Release Guidelines. SCS recommended revising

Appendix O to instruct the permittee to convert the SCS soil survey AUM

productivity figure to an air-dried pounds of production per acre

figure. The conversion would take into consideration the 50 percent

utilization rate that is inherent in the AUM figure by doubling the

pounds of vegetation consumed by one animal (780 pounds per acre). That

is the SCS AUM productivity figure must be multiplied by 1560 to

convert it to a production figure in pounds per acre. This converted

figure would reflect the total soil production potential.

In addition, SCS recommended that Oklahoma revise Appendix F to

require that each sample be clipped to the ground and that the area be

sampled once in the spring for cool season grasses and once in the fall

for warm season grasses. SCS also commented that the native grass

figures listed in an SCS soil survey are direct production figures and

therefore, clipping on grazingland will be a direct comparison.

In response to these SCS comments, Oklahoma, at its own initiative,

in its September 2, 1994, submittal, revised, as recommended by the

SCS, (1) Appendix F, concerning the method of production sampling, and

(2) Appendix O, concerning the methods of calculating technical

productivity standards on pastureland and grazingland. As discussed in

finding No. 2.k above, the Director is approving Oklahoma's proposed

revisions of Appendices F and O.

SCS commented that because of variability in weather and soil

conditions, and interpolation of data, that the applicable productivity

levels should be set at 90 percent of the yield goal. The Federal

regulations at 30 CFR 816.116(a)(2) and 817.116(a)(2) and Oklahoma's

rules at OAC 460:20-45-46(a)(2), require for success of revegetation

that the operator demonstrate that it has achieved 90 percent of the

success standard. In other words, the operation must, in order to

demonstrate success of productivity, meet only 90 percent of the

technical success standard that is calculated by the methods described

in Appendix O of Oklahoma's Bond Release Guidelines. Therefore, because

the Federal regulations and State rules already provide for the SCS

recommendation, OSM is not requiring that Oklahoma further revise the

Bond Release Guidelines in response to this comment. [[Page 2519]]

SCS commented that Oklahoma should revise the definition of

``productivity'' in Appendix A in the Bond Release Guidelines to refer

to the ``amount of total standing biomass'' rather than ``harvestable

standing biomass.'' In response to this SCS comment, Oklahoma at its

own initiative in its September 2, 1994, submittal, revised the

definition of ``productivity'' as recommended by the SCS. As discussed

in finding No. 2.i above, the Director is approving Oklahoma's proposed

revision of the definition of ``productivity'' in Appendix A.

Finally, SCS responded on October 14, 1994, that because all

revisions previously discussed with the Oklahoma State Office had been

included in Oklahoma's September 2, 1994, revised amendment, it had no

further comments (administrative record No. OK-959.25).

b. Other Federal agencies. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

responded on February 15 and August 3, 1994, that it had no comments on

the proposed amendment (administrative record Nos. OK-959.02 and OK-

959.13).

The U.S. Bureau of Mines responded on February 16 and September 25,

1994, that it had no comments regarding the proposed amendment

(administrative record Nos. OK-959.03 and OK-959.23).

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers responded on February 25, August

10, and September 30, 1994, that the proposed revisions were

satisfactory (administrative record Nos. OK-959.04, OK-959.17, and OK-

959.24).

The U.S. Bureau of Land Management responded on October 12, 1994,

that the Bond Release Guidelines appeared to be technically correct

(administrative record No. OK-959.26).

3. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Concurrence and Comments

Pursuant to 30 CFR 732.17(h)(11)(ii), OSM is required to solicit

the written concurrence of EPA with respect to those provisions of the

proposed program amendment that relate to air or water quality

standards promulgated under the authority of the Clean Water Act (33

U.S.C. 1251 et seq.) or the Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. 7401 et seq.).

None of the revisions that Oklahoma proposed to make in its

amendment pertain to air or water quality standards. Therefore, OSM did

not request EPA's concurrence.

Pursuant to 732.17(h)(11)(i), OSM solicited comments on the

proposed amendment from EPA (administrative record No. OK-960). EPA

responded on August 24, 1994, that it had no objections to approval of

the proposed revisions (administrative record No. OK-962).

4. State Historic Preservation Officer (SHPO) and the Advisory Council

on Historic Preservation (ACHP)

Pursuant to 30 CFR 732.17(h)(4), OSM solicited comments on the

proposed amendment from the SHPO and ACHP (administrative record No.

OK-960). Neither SHPO nor ACHP responded to OSM's request.

V. Director's Decision

Based on the above findings, the Director approves, with additional

requirements, Oklahoma's proposed amendment as submitted on February

17, 1994, and as revised and supplemented with additional explanatory

information on July 21 and September 2, 1994.

With the requirement that Oklahoma further revise the Bond Release

Guidelines, the Director approves, as discussed in: finding No. 2.e,

subsections IV.A.1.a and b, and sections VII.A and B, concerning

revegetation success standards for diversity, seasonality, permanence,

and regeneration; and finding No. 2.f, subsections V.B.2.d and V.B.2.e,

concerning the use of test plots as a statistically valid sampling

technique for demonstrating success of productivity on prime farmlands.

The Director approves Oklahoma's revisions to the Bond Release

Guidelines, as discussed in: finding No. 1, Appendices J and V,

concerning nonsubstantive editorial revisions; finding No. 2.a,

subsection I.E.3.b, concerning requirements for ground cover on land

reclaimed for commercial or industrial use; finding No. 2.b, subsection

I.F.3.d, concerning requirements for ground cover on previously mined

areas; finding No. 2.c, subsection I.F.5.b, concerning the requirements

for water discharged from permanent impoundments, ponds, diversions,

and treatment facilities; finding No. 2.d, subsections II.B.2.d,

III.B.2.d, and V.B.2.c, concerning the method for calculating a

technical productivity standard on pastureland, grazingland, and prime

farmland; finding No. 2.g, subsections V.B.2.f and VI.B.2.e, concerning

the method for calculating a technical productivity standard for grain

or hay crops on prime and nonprime farmland; finding No. 2.h,

subsection VI.B.2.e, concerning the method for measuring row crop

production on nonprime farmland; finding No. 2.i, Appendix A,

concerning the definition of ``productivity;'' finding No. 2.j,

Appendices A and R, concerning the definition of ``initial

establishment of permanent vegetative cover'' and the repair of rills

and gullies as a normal husbandry practice; and finding No. 2.k,

Appendix F, concerning the method of production sampling, and Appendix

O, concerning the methods of calculating technical productivity

standards on pastureland and grazingland.

In accordance with 30 CFR 732.17(f)(1), the Director is also taking

this opportunity to clarify in the required amendment section at 30 CFR

936.16 that, within 60 days of the publication of this final rule,

Oklahoma must either submit a proposed written amendment, or a

description of an amendment to be proposed that meets the requirements

of SMCRA and 30 CFR Chapter VII and a timetable for enactment that is

consistent with Oklahoma's established administrative or legislative

procedures.

The Federal regulations at 30 CFR Part 936, codifying decisions

concerning the Oklahoma program, are being amended to implement this

decision. This final rule is being made effective immediately to

expedite the State program amendment process and to encourage States to

bring their programs into conformity with the Federal standards without

undue delay. Consistency of State and Federal standards is required by

SMCRA.

VI. Procedural Determinations

1. Executive Order 12866

This rule is exempted from review by the Office of Management and

Budget (OMB) under Executive Order 12886 (Regulatory Planning and

Review).

2. Executive Order 12778

The Department of the Interior has conducted the reviews required

by section 2 of Executive Order 12778 (Civil Justice Reform) and has

determined that this rule meets the applicable standards of subsections

(a) and (b) of that section. However, these standards are not

applicable to the actual language of State regulatory programs and

program amendments since each such program is drafted and promulgated

by a specific State, not by OSM. Under sections 503 and 505 of SMCRA

(30 U.S.C. 1253 and 12550) and the Federal regulations at 30 CFR

730.11, 732.15, and 732.17(h)(10), decisions on proposed State

regulatory programs and program amendments submitted by the States must

be based solely on a determination of whether the submittal is

consistent with SMCRA and its implementing Federal regulations and

whether the other requirements of [[Page 2520]] 30 CFR Part 730, 731,

and 732 have been met.

3. National Environmental Policy Act

No environmental impact statement is required for this rule since

section 702(d) of SMCRA (30 U.S.C. 1292(d)) provides that agency

decisions on proposed State regulatory program provisions do not

constitute major Federal actions within the meaning of section

102(2)(C) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C.

4332(c)(C)).

4. Paperwork Reduction Act

This rule does not contain information collection requirements that

require approval by OMB under the Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C.

3507 et seq).

5. Regulatory Flexibility Act

The Department of the Interior has determined that this rule will

not have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small

entities under the Regulatory Flexibility Act (5 U.S.C. 601 et seq.).

The State submittal which is the subject of this rule is based upon

counterpart Federal regulations for which an economic analysis was

prepared and certification made that such regulations would not have a

significant economic effect upon a substantial number of small

entities. Accordingly, this rule will ensure that existing requirements

previously promulgated by OSM will be implemented by the State. In

making the determination as to whether this rule would have a

significant economic impact, the Department relied upon the data and

assumptions for the counterpart Federal regulations.

List of Subjects in 30 CFR Part 936

Intergovernmental relations, Surface mining, Underground mining.

Dated: December 29, 1994.

Charles E. Sandberg,

Acting Assistant Director, Western Support Center.

For the reasons set out in the preamble, Title 30, Chapter VII,

Subchapter T of the Code of Federal Regulations is amended as set forth

below:

PART 936--OKLAHOMA

1. The authority citation for Part 936 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 30 U.S.C. 1201 et seq.

2. Section 936.15 is amended by adding paragraph (n) to read as

follows:

Sec. 936.15 Approval of regulatory program amendments.

* * * * *

(n) Revisions to the following provisions of the Bond Release

Guidelines, which include revegetation success standards and

statistically valid sampling techniques, and guidelines for phase I,

II, and III bond release, as submitted to OSM on February 17, 1994, and

as revised and supplemented with explanatory information on July 21 and

September 2, 1994, are approved effective January 10, 1995:

Subsection I.E.3.b, concerning requirements for ground cover on

land reclaimed for commercial or industrial use;

Subsection I.F.3.d, concerning requirements for ground cover on

previously mined areas;

Subsection I.F.5.b, concerning the requirements for water

discharged from permanent impoundments, ponds, diversions, and

treatment facilities;

Subsections II.B.2.d, III.B.2.d, and V.B.2.c, concerning the method

for calculating a technical productivity standard on pastureland,

grazingland, and prime farmland;

Subsections IV.A.1.a and b, and sections VII.A and B, concerning

revegetation success standards for diversity, seasonality, permanence,

and regeneration;

Subsections V.B.2.d and V.B.2.e, concerning the use of test plots

as a statistically valid sampling technique for demonstrating success

of productivity on prime farmlands;

Subsections V.B.2.f and VI.B.2.e, concerning the method for

calculating a technical productivity standard for grain or hay crops on

prime and nonprime farmland;

Subsection VI.B.2.e, concerning the method for measuring row crop

production on nonprime farmland;

Appendix A, concerning the definitions of ``initial establishment

of permanent vegetative cover'' and ``productivity;''

Appendix F, concerning the method of sampling for productivity;

Appendices J and V, concerning editorial revisions; and

Appendix R, concerning the repair of rills and gullies as a normal

husbandry practice;

Appendix O, concerning the methods for calculating technical

productivity standards on lands reclaimed for use as pastureland and

grazingland.

3. Section 936.16 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 936.16 Required regulatory program amendments.

Pursuant to 30 CFR 732.17(f)(1), Oklahoma is required to submit to

OSM by the specified date the following written, proposed program

amendment, or a description of an amendment to be proposed that meets

the requirements of SMCRA and 30 CFR Chapter VII and a timetable for

enactment that is consistent with Oklahoma's established administrative

or legislative procedures.

(a) Reserved.

(b) Reserved.

(c) By March 13, 1995, Oklahoma shall revise sections II.B and

III.B in the Bond Release Guidelines to identify the method it will use

in developing a phase III revegetation success standard for diversity

on lands reclaimed for use as pasturland and grazingland.

(d) Reserved.

(e) Reserved.

(f) Reserved.

(g) By March 13, 1995, Oklahoma must submit, before Oklahoma allows

the use of test plots as proposed at subsections V.B.2.d and V.B.2.e in

the Bond Release Guidelines, evidence of consultation with the U.S.

Soil Conservation Service regarding the use of test plots as a

statistically valid sampling technique for demonstrating success of

productivity on prime farmlands.

[FR Doc. 95-568 Filed 1-9-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4310-05-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.