Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Stability and Control of Medium and Heavy Vehicles During Braking; and Stopping Distance Requirements

Federal RegisterDec 13, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

49 CFR Part 571

[Docket No. 92-29; Notice 7; Docket No. 93-06; Notice 4; Docket No. 93-

07; Notice 4]

RIN 2127-AF96; 2127-AF97; 2127-AF98; 2127-AF99

Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Stability and Control of

Medium and Heavy Vehicles During Braking; and Stopping Distance

Requirements

AGENCY: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), DOT.

ACTION: Final rule, petitions for reconsideration.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This document responds to petitions for reconsideration of a

final rule that amended Standard No. 105, Hydraulic Brake Systems, and

Standard No. 121, Air Brake Systems, to require medium and heavy

vehicles be equipped with an antilock brake system (ABS). This document

also responds to petitions for reconsideration of final rules that

established 60 mph stopping distance requirements for hydraulic-braked

heavy vehicles and reinstated such requirements for air-braked heavy

vehicles.

DATES: Effective Dates: The amendments to Sec. 571.101 are effective

January 12, 1996, the amendments to Sec. 571.105 are effective March 1,

1999, and amendments to Sec. 571.121 are effective March 1, 1997.

Compliance dates: Compliance with the amendments to 49 CFR 571.101

and 49 CFR 571.105 with respect to hydraulic-braked vehicles will be

required on and after March 1, 1999. Compliance with 49 CFR 571.101 and

49 CFR 571.121 with respect to air-braked tractors will be required on

and after March 1, 1997 and compliance with 49 CFR 571.101 and 49 CFR

571.121 with respect to air-braked trailers and single unit trucks and

buses will be required on and after March 1, 1998.

Petitions for Reconsideration: Any petitions for reconsideration of

this rule must be received by NHTSA no later than January 12, 1996.

ADDRESSES: Petitions for reconsideration of this rule should refer to

the above referenced docket numbers and should be submitted to:

Administrator, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 400

Seventh Street, S.W., Washington, D.C. 20590.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

For non-legal issues: Mr. George Soodoo, Office of Crash Avoidance,

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 400 Seventh Street SW.,

Washington, D.C. 20590 (202) 366-5892.

For legal issues: Mr. Marvin L. Shaw, NCC-20, Rulemaking Division,

Office of Chief Counsel, National Highway Traffic Safety

Administration, 400 Seventh Street SW., Washington, D.C. 20590 (202)

366-2992.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

II. Petitions for Reconsideration

III. Definitions Related to Antilock Brake Systems

A. Definition of Antilock Brake Systems

B. Directly Controlled Wheel

C. Independent Wheel Control

IV. Overall Brake Test Sequence

A. Performance Test Sequence

B. Brake Adjustment During Test Sequence

C. Final Brake Inspection in Test Sequence

V. Braking-In-A-Curve Test

A. General Considerations

B. Type of Brake Application

C. Number of Test Stops for Certification

D. Initial Brake Temperature

VI. Stopping Distance Performance

A. Stopping Distance Requirements

B. Test Surface Specification

C. Wheel Lockup Restrictions

D. Burnish Procedure

E. Definition of Nonsteerable Axle

VII. ABS Malfunction Indicator Lamps

A. In-cab Malfunction Lamp for Trailer ABS

B. Trailer-mounted ABS Malfunction Indicator

C. Activation Protocol for Malfunction Indicators

D. Signal Storage

E. ABS Failed System Requirements

VIII. Power Source

A. Separate Powering for Trailer ABS

B. ABS Malfunction Signal Circuit and Ground

C. Tractor Trailer ABS Interface Connector

IX. Applicability of Amendments and Leadtime

A. Hydraulic-Braked Vehicles

B. Class 3 Vehicles

C. Four-Wheel Drive Vehicles

D. Trailers and Dollies

X. Miscellaneous

A. National Uniformity

B. Publish Complete Regulatory Texts and Compliance Test

Procedures

C. Costs

D. Corrections to Standard No. 101 and Standard No. 105

I. Background

On March 10, 1995, NHTSA published three final rules that amended

the agency's brake standards for medium and heavy vehicles.\1\ (60 FR

13216). One of those final rules requires heavy vehicles to be equipped

with an antilock brake system (ABS) to improve the directional

stability and control of these vehicles during braking.\2\ The other

two final rules announced NHTSA's decision to reinstate stopping

distance requirements for air-braked heavy vehicles and to establish

such requirements for hydraulic-braked heavy vehicles. (60 FR 13286,

13297)

\1\ Hereinafter referred to as ``heavy vehicles.''

\2\ Hereinafter referred to as ``the ABS final rule.''

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

As specified in the ABS final rule, in addition to the ABS

requirement, truck tractors are required to comply with a 30-mph

braking-in-a-curve test using a full brake application on a low

coefficient of friction surface representing a wet surface. All powered

heavy vehicles are also required to be equipped with an in-cab lamp to

indicate ABS malfunctions. Truck tractors and other towing vehicles are

required to be equipped with two separate in-cab lamps: one indicating

malfunctions in the towing vehicle ABS and the other indicating

malfunctions in the ABS on one or more towed trailers and/or dollies.

Trailers (including dollies) produced during an initial eight-year

period are also required to be equipped with an external malfunction

[[Page 63966]]

indicator that was to be visible to the driver through the rearview

mirror of the towing vehicle.

NHTSA issued the ABS final rule pursuant to the Motor Carrier Act

of 1991, a part of the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act

(ISTEA) of 1991. Section 4012 of ISTEA directed the Secretary of

Transportation to initiate rulemaking concerning methods for improving

braking performance of new commercial motor vehicles,\3\ including

truck tractors, trailers, and their dollies. Congress specifically

directed that such a rulemaking examine antilock systems, means of

improving brake compatibility, and methods of ensuring effectiveness of

brake timing. The Act required that the rulemaking be consistent with

the Motor Carrier Safety Act of 1984 (49 U.S.C. Sec. 31147) and be

carried out pursuant to, and in accordance with, the National Traffic

and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966 (Safety Act) (49 U.S.C. Sec. 30101

et seq.).

\3\ Vehicles with a gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR) of 26,001

pounds or greater.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

II. Petitions for Reconsideration

NHTSA received petitions for reconsideration from the American

Trucking Associations (ATA), the American Automobile Manufacturers

Association (AAMA), the Truck Trailer Manufacturers Association (TTMA),

the Heavy Duty Brake Manufacturers Council (HDBMC), the United Parcel

Service (UPS), vehicle manufacturers, including Chrysler, Navistar, AM

General, and brake or component manufacturers including Midland-Grau,

Jenflo, AlliedSignal, Rockwell WABCO, Rockwell International, Kelsey-

Hayes, and Ferodo America.

The petitioners generally agreed with NHTSA's decision to require

all heavy vehicles to be equipped with ABS and to comply with the

stopping distance requirements and to require truck tractors to comply

with the braking-in-a-curve requirements. Nevertheless, they requested

modifications of various aspects of those requirements. The issues

raised by the petitioners include the definition of antilock brake

systems and the wheels to which the ABS requirement applies, the ABS

requirement's applicability to hydraulic-braked vehicles, the

implementation schedule, certain aspects of the performance tests,

certain aspects of the malfunction indicator requirements, and the

requirements addressing trailer ABS powering. The agency responds to

each of the issues raised by the petitioners throughout the remainder

of the document.

III. Definitions Related to Antilock Brake Systems

A. Definition of Antilock Brake Systems

In the ABS final rule, NHTSA decided to require that each heavy

vehicle be equipped with an antilock brake system that satisfies the

following definition:

``Antilock braking system'' means a portion of a service brake

system that automatically controls the degree of rotational wheel

slip during braking by:

(1) Sensing the rate of angular rotation of the wheels;

(2) Transmitting signals regarding the rate of wheel angular

rotation to one or more devices which interpret those signals and

generate responsive controlling output signals; and

(3) Transmitting those controlling signals to one or more

devices which adjust brake actuating forces in response to those

signals.

To meet this definition, an antilock braking system must be closed-

loop.\4\ With respect to the definition for ABS, the input is the act

of sensing the rate of angular rotation of the wheels, which is

typically done by a device known as a wheel speed sensor. The output is

the act of transmitting responsive controlling output signals to a

device or devices known as modulator valves that adjust brake actuating

forces in response to those signals.

\4\ A closed loop control system is one which examines the

output of the system and adjusts the input to the system in response

to that output. This inclusion of the output (or some function of

the output) as part of the input to such a system is referred to as

feedback.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Jenflo petitioned the agency to amend the definition of an antilock

braking system so that the definition did not refer to components such

as wheel speed sensors, control units, and modulators. Jenflo believes

that it is possible to control rotational wheel slip and impending

wheel lockup without monitoring these conditions, while still providing

controlled stops. In its petition for reconsideration, Jenflo submitted

56 pages of test data, but did not explain the relevance of the data to

the vehicle's ABS performance.

NHTSA has decided to deny Jenflo's petition to amend the definition

of ABS so as to permit open-loop systems. In previous notices, the

agency discussed in extensive detail the reasons for requiring a

``closed-loop'' antilock system and for combining an equipment

requirement with a dynamic test requirement for truck tractors. (60 FR

13224-13228) NHTSA's definition permits any ABS, provided that it is a

closed-loop system that ensures feedback between what is actually

happening at the tire-road surface interface and what the device is

doing to respond to changes in wheel slip. As many brake and vehicle

manufacturers commented on the September 1993 NPRM, a device that

satisfies these criteria is necessary to prevent wheel lockup under a

wide variety of real world conditions, thereby significantly improving

safety. In contrast, a definition that permitted open-loop systems

would allow systems that would not necessarily prevent wheel lockup.

NHTSA also stated that the desired safety benefits of ABS could

currently be achieved only by means of both a specific equipment

requirement for ABS and a dynamic performance test requirement

applicable to truck tractors only. In its petition for reconsideration,

Jenflo did not provide any information to support reliance solely on a

dynamic performance requirement, or to support its statement that it is

possible to control rotational wheel slip without monitoring wheel slip

conditions. The agency therefore has decided to deny Jenflo's petition

to amend the definition for antilock brake system.

B. Directly Controlled Wheel

In the ABS final rule, the agency defined ``directly controlled

wheel'' to mean a wheel at which the degree of rotational wheel slip is

sensed and corresponding signals are transmitted to one or more

modulators that adjust the brake actuating forces at that wheel. (60 FR

13228-13230) The definition further stated that each modulator may also

adjust the brake actuating forces at other wheels in response to the

same signal or signals. NHTSA explained that, by ``directly controlled

wheel,'' it meant that the signal provided at the wheel or on the axle

of the wheel would directly modulate the braking forces of that wheel

or axle.

AAMA, Chrysler, and Kelsey Hayes petitioned the agency to revise

the definition of ``directly controlled wheel'' to allow the use of a

single in-differential 5 or in-axle wheel speed sensor to control

the rear wheel slip. Chrysler indicated that all of its pickup trucks

in the 10,000-12,000 pound gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR) class now

successfully use this type of sensor.

\5\ A differential is comprised of a set of gears which

establish a constant equilibrium of torques between the left-side

and right-side driven wheels, and which allow the outer wheels of a

vehicle to rotate at a higher speed than the inner wheels during

cornering.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

After reviewing the petitions for reconsideration regarding in-axle

sensors, NHTSA has decided to revise the definition of ``directly

controlled wheel'' to allow wheel speeds to be sensed at any point on

the axle shaft of

[[Page 63967]]

the wheel. This includes any point between the wheel hub and the point

where the axle shaft mates with the differential output shaft. The

agency believes that this modification to the definition will permit

the manufacture of proven antilock systems, without any detriment to

safety. This amendment is reflected in the revised definition for

``directly controlled wheel'' by adding the phrase ``either at that

wheel or on the axle shaft for that wheel'' and allows two in-

differential sensors to transmit corresponding signals to one or more

modulators that adjust the brake actuating forces at the wheels on that

axle.

NHTSA emphasizes that single in-differential sensors will only be

allowed on light vehicles with GVWRs between 10,000 and 12,000 pounds.

This limitation is reflected in S5.5.1 of Standard No. 105, which

permits only vehicles with such GVWRs to provide direct wheel control

by means of a single sensor in the drive line. The agency is concerned

that sensing of rotational wheel slip at the ring gear or at other

points on the driveline 6 forward of the drive axle, does not

provide sufficiently precise measurements of wheel slip for effective

ABS control on vehicles over 12,000 pounds. The braking distribution

between the front and rear axles of heavy vehicles is different than on

light vehicles, primarily because of the greater load-carrying capacity

of heavy vehicles, which necessitates more braking at the rear wheels.

As a result, greater braking efficiency is typically required at the

rear wheels of heavy vehicles than on lighter vehicles. Based on the

above considerations, the agency has decided to allow the use of a

single in-axle or in-differential sensor, and include in-transmission

sensors, for ABS control of rear wheel slip on vehicles with a GVWR

between 10,000 and 12,000 pounds.

6 The driveline constitutes those parts of the vehicle

that transfer power from the transmission to the drive wheels,

including the drive shaft, differential, and axle shafts of the

driven wheel.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rockwell WABCO requested that the agency change the definition of a

``directly controlled wheel'' to ensure that the modulator for

controlling the wheels of the front axle is not used to control the

wheels of the rear axle, and vice versa.

NHTSA has reviewed the definition of a ``directly controlled

wheel'' and has concluded that it does not clearly state that, on

single unit vehicles and full trailers, the same modulator should not

be used to control both the front and rear axles. It is possible that

the definition may be misinterpreted to allow a four sensor/one

modulator (4S/1M) system on single unit vehicles and full trailers. As

discussed in the final rule, it was the agency's intent to require at

least one modulator for controlling the front axle(s) and at least one

modulator for controlling the rear axle(s) of those vehicles. (60 FR

13230) In revising the definition, the agency has added the phrase

``that are on the same axle or in the same axle set,'' to make it clear

that the modulator that controls a directly controlled wheel, can also

control a wheel on the same axle or wheel(s) on other axles in the same

tandem 7.

7 An arrangement of two or more axles placed in proximity

one behind the other.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Based on the above considerations, NHTSA has decided to amend the

definition of directly controlled wheel as follows:

``Directly Controlled Wheel'' means a wheel for which the degree

of rotational wheel slip is sensed, either at that wheel or on the

axle shaft for that wheel, and corresponding signals are transmitted

to one or more modulators that adjust the brake actuating forces at

that wheel. Each modulator may also adjust the brake actuating

forces at other wheels that are on the same axle or in the same axle

set in response to the same signal(s).

(Italicized phrases are additions to the definition).

C. Independent Wheel Control

In the ABS final rule, NHTSA defined ``independently controlled

wheel'' to mean a directly controlled wheel for which there is a

modulator that adjusts the brake actuating forces at that wheel, but

not at any other wheel on the same axle.

Jenflo petitioned the agency to delete the requirement for

independent wheel control on truck tractors and issue what it called

``performance only'' requirements. That company stated that requiring

independent wheel control is unreasonably design- restrictive and is

not a performance requirement.

In the ABS final rule, NHTSA set forth the reasons for requiring

independent control of at least one axle for truck tractors and the

reasons for having more stringent requirements for truck tractors than

for other types of vehicles. (60 FR 13230). The agency considers these

reasons to be a sufficient basis for requiring independent control.

Nevertheless, Jenflo has not addressed these reasons in the petition.

AAMA requested confirmation that the ABS rule requires a truck

tractor to have an ABS with at least four sensors and three modulators

(which are also known as channels of control)(4S/3M), a single unit

vehicle to have an ABS with at least four sensors and two modulators

(4S/2M), and a semitrailer to have an ABS with at least two sensors and

one modulator (2S/1M). NHTSA confirms the AAMA's interpretation. In

addition, the agency notes that a full trailer will be required to have

an ABS with at least four sensors and two modulators (4S/2M), and a

hydraulic-braked single unit vehicle with a GVWR between 10,000 lbs.

and 12,000 lbs. will be required to have at least three sensors and two

modulators (3S/2M).

IV. Overall Brake Test Sequence

A. Performance Test Sequence

In Table I of the stopping distance final rule for braked vehicles,

NHTSA specified the sequence in which the brake tests are to be

conducted for compliance testing, as follows:

(1) Burnish.

(2) Stops with vehicle at gross vehicle weight rating:

(a) Straight line stop at 60 mph on a peak friction coefficient

surface of 0.9, for a truck tractor with a loaded unbraked control

trailer, or for a single-unit vehicle (straight line stop).

(b) Braking-in-a-curve stop at 30 mph on a peak friction

coefficient surface of 0.5, for a truck tractor with a loaded unbraked

control trailer.

(c) Emergency brake stops at 60 mph on a peak friction coefficient

surface of 0.9, for a single-unit vehicle. Truck tractors are not

required to be tested in the loaded condition.

(3) Parking brake test with vehicle loaded to GVWR.

(4) Stops with vehicle at unloaded weight plus up to 500 lbs.

(a) Straight line stop at 60 mph on a peak friction coefficient

surface of 0.9, for a truck tractor or for a single-unit vehicle.

(b) Braking-in-a-curve stop at 30 mph service brake stops on a peak

friction coefficient surface of 0.5, for a truck tractor.

(c) Emergency brake stops at 60 mph on a peak friction coefficient

surface of 0.9, for a truck tractor or for a single-unit vehicle.

5. Parking brake test with vehicle at unloaded weight plus up to

500 lbs.

6. Final inspection of service brake system for condition of

adjustment. (60 FR 13297)

AAMA, HDBMC, Midland-Grau, and Navistar requested that the agency

revise the performance test sequence in Standard No. 121 by placing

both braking-in-a-curve tests for truck tractors immediately after the

burnish. These petitioners stated that such a change would result in

certain

[[Page 63968]]

advantages, including (1) allowing test track wetting to be

accomplished more efficiently; (2) minimizing ABS performance

variability since the tires would not be previously subject to the high

speed stopping distance tests on a high coefficient of friction

surface; and (3) minimizing vehicle transfers for those manufacturers

that use a different test site for their low coefficient of friction

tests.

After reviewing the petitions, NHTSA has decided to amend the

performance test sequence by placing both braking-in-a-curve tests

immediately after the burnish. The agency believes that conducting the

braking-in-a-curve tests at the beginning of the test sequence

simplifies the procedure and reduces the testing burden without

compromising safety. The agency has specified the GVWR loading

condition first because it coincides with the GVWR/LLVW sequence of the

other stopping performance tests. This decision is also supported by

the fact that performance variability due to tire wear and flat-

spotting will be minimized if the GVWR test runs are conducted first,

since wheel lock is more likely to occur in the lightly-loaded

condition.

B. Brake Adjustment During Test Sequence

AAMA, HDBMC, Midland-Grau, and Rockwell International petitioned

NHTSA to permit manual brake adjustments to be made after each part of

the test sequence in Standard No. 121. The petitioners are concerned

about the potential for over-adjustment and the impact on the

subsequent tests in the sequence, during testing with automatic brake

adjusters. Standard No. 121 currently requires that air-braked vehicles

be equipped with automatic brake adjusters. The standard allows three

manual adjustments, at the manufacturer's recommended intervals, during

the burnish sequence, but does not allow subsequent adjustments during

the testing itself.

NHTSA agrees with the petitioners that there is a potential for

over-adjustment by automatic brake adjusters during a series of full

treadle brake applications, as is required for the braking-in-a-curve

tests. The agency also believes that it is important to specify

precisely where in the test sequence the manual adjustments are

allowed, since this enhances uniformity of the test procedures. The

agency nevertheless believes that adjusting the brakes as frequently as

after each test sequence is inappropriate, because it would be less

representative of real world braking conditions.

Based on the above considerations, NHTSA has decided to amend the

test sequence in Standard No. 121 by allowing some adjustment during

testing. It is allowing two manual brake adjustments for truck tractors

- the first at the end of the braking-in-a-curve tests and the second

at the end of the GVWR parking brake test. It is also allowing one

manual brake adjustment for single unit trucks and buses, at the end of

the GVWR parking brake test. The agency believes that allowing a

limited number of additional adjustments during testing accommodates

the petitioners' concerns, while preserving a well- defined test

procedure that properly accounts for the newly adopted test procedures.

NHTSA believes that there is no need to allow additional brake

adjustments in the test procedure for Standard No. 105 for hydraulic-

braked heavy vehicles, since the brake test procedure currently

specifies four burnishes (one burnish and three reburnishes) and a

brake adjustment after each burnish. Moreover, hydraulic-braked

vehicles are not subject to the braking-in-a-curve test.

C. Final Brake Inspection in Test Sequence

HDBMC and Rockwell International petitioned NHTSA to delete the

final brake inspection requirement that is specified at the end of the

stopping sequence in Table I of Standard No. 121. They claimed that

there are no stated requirements necessary to satisfy the results of

this inspection, and that the condition of the adjusters has little

significance to the brake adjusters condition after real world

service.

NHTSA disagrees with the petitioners' claims that the final brake

inspection provision is unnecessary. The agency notes that Standard No.

121 was amended to include the final brake inspection as part of the

amendments for the rulemaking on automatic brake adjusters. This issue

has never been included in any of the notices for the heavy vehicle ABS

rulemaking. As a result, the agency cannot delete the requirement

without giving the public an opportunity to comment on the issue.

Moreover, the agency disagrees with the petitioners that there are no

stated requirements by which a manufacturer can ensure that its vehicle

complies with this inspection. Paragraph S5.9, Final Inspection,

specifies that the inspection is conducted to determine the condition

of adjustment and for the brake indicator display, in accordance with

S5.1.8 and S5.2.2 (i.e., brake adjustment within the limits recommended

by the vehicle manufacturer). Based on these considerations, the agency

has decided to deny the petitioners' request to delete the provision

regarding the final brake inspection.

V. Braking-In-A-Curve Test

A. General Considerations

Navistar requested that the agency eliminate the braking-in-a-curve

test for ABS-equipped truck tractors. That company stated that such a

test is redundant to the provision requiring ABS because the test would

not cause any changes to the ABS equipment mandated by the ABS

equipment requirement.

NHTSA disagrees with Navistar's claim that the braking-in-a-curve

performance test is redundant. As explained in the ABS final rule, the

braking-in-a-curve test provides an important check of ABS performance.

Merely having the ABS definition does not ensure that an antilock

system will provide an acceptable level of performance. The test serves

to evaluate the basic performance of an antilock system. The agency

notes that the industry, through the Motor Vehicle Safety Research

Advisory Committee (MVSRAC), has previously endorsed and recommended to

the agency essentially the same dynamic performance test that is

contained in the ABS final rule. The agency further notes that Navistar

provided no support for its claim that the braking-in-a-curve

performance requirement for truck tractors is redundant. Based on the

above considerations, the agency has decided to deny Navistar's request

to delete the braking-in-a-curve test for truck tractors equipped with

antilock systems.

ATA requested that the agency apply the braking-in-a-curve

performance requirements to single unit vehicles and trailers. ATA also

requested that the agency consider making the requirements less design-

restrictive by permitting, for an interim period, the option of meeting

either the equipment requirement or the performance requirement.

While NHTSA agrees with ATA's goal of having a performance test for

all heavy duty vehicles and not just for tractors, the agency believes

that it is premature to do so at this time.

Thus, NHTSA has decided to deny ATA's requests to apply the

braking-in-a-curve test to single unit vehicles and trailers at this

time. In the ABS final rule, the agency discussed in detail the reasons

for including a performance test for truck tractors. (60 FR 13230-

13232) One of those reasons was that extensive truck tractor testing

conducted by the

[[Page 63969]]

agency and the industry indicated that the braking-in-a-curve test on a

low mu surface is an objective, repeatable, and practicable procedure

for evaluating a heavy vehicle's antilock braking system. However, for

other heavy vehicles, the agency decided not to apply the braking-in-a-

curve test at that time due to the need to conduct additional testing

to ensure that these vehicles could be safely tested to the braking-in-

a-curve maneuver. NHTSA is currently planning vehicle research to

develop such a procedure for other vehicles and, should the research be

successful, will consider adding performance tests for these vehicles

to the standard.

As explained in the final rule, NHTSA regards the braking-in-a-

curve requirement as a complement to the ABS equipment requirement, and

not as an alternative to it. (60 FR 13231) The braking-in-a-curve test

alone can neither evaluate the overall effectiveness of ABS nor ensure

the use of a closed-loop system. Such an evaluation would require an

array of performance tests such as split mu tests, surface transition

tests, and stopping distance performance tests. However, as indicated

above, the braking-in-a-curve test is an objective, repeatable, and

practicable procedure for evaluating the performance of a vehicle's

ABS, and will be used by the agency to complement the ABS equipment

requirement. Based on these considerations, the agency has decided to

deny ATA's request to allow vehicle manufacturers the option of

complying either with the equipment requirement or with the braking-in-

a-curve requirement.

B. Type of Brake Application

In the ABS final rule, NHTSA decided to specify that a driver

conducting the braking-in-a-curve test must make a full treadle

application, i.e., apply the brake at a rate sufficient to reach a

pressure of 100 psi within 0.2 seconds, in at least one of the treadle

valve's output circuits. The agency believed that these values properly

represent full brake applications in terms of both the rate of

application and level of output pressure. (60 FR 13234) This brake

application is intended to evaluate worst case braking applications in

an aggressive or ``hard'' stop.

AAMA, Allied Signal, HDBMC, and Midland-Grau petitioned NHTSA to

change the definition of full-treadle brake application to allow

treadle pressure of 60 psi in 0.2 seconds, or maximum treadle travel in

0.2 seconds. The petitioners claim that some pneumatic systems do not

achieve 100 psi in 0.2 seconds, but that all systems can achieve 60 psi

in that time. In support of its claim, Midland-Grau submitted data from

testing performed on different antilock systems installed on various

vehicles. The test data show that with the vehicles in the loaded

condition, the full-treadle brake application pressures at the treadle

valve were not consistently able to achieve 100 psi in 0.2 seconds.

However, they were all able to achieve at least 85 psi within 0.2

seconds.

Based on NHTSA's analysis of the test data submitted by Midland-

Grau, the agency has decided to amend the definition for ``full treadle

brake application'' to mean a brake application in which the treadle

pressure reaches 85 psi within 0.2 seconds * * * '' The agency agrees

with the petitioners that not all pneumatic systems would have been

able to achieve a treadle valve output pressure of 100 psi within 0.2

seconds and that such a high threshold is not necessary to represent an

aggressive stop. Midland-Grau's data further indicate that the ABS

would activate at brake chamber pressures below 60 psi on most heavy

vehicles in the loaded condition on a test surface with a peak friction

coefficient (PFC) 0.5. However, there are some systems that would need

at least 60 psi at the brake chamber within 0.2 seconds to ensure

sufficient air pressure availability for effective ABS control.

NHTSA has also decided to modify the definition for ``full-treadle

brake application'' to include a reference to maximum treadle travel

within 0.2 seconds. By ``maximum treadle travel,'' the agency means the

distance that the treadle moves, from its position when no force is

applied to its position when the treadle reaches a full stop. Allowing

such an alternative is consistent with the agency's intent to require a

brake application that simulates emergency braking. Moreover, this

alternative may facilitate the introduction of certain future

technologies such as electronic braking for which the pressure/time

relationship at the treadle valve is not applicable.

Jenflo stated in its petition that NHTSA did not specify a duration

for the full-treadle brake application. NHTSA agrees that such a

duration should be specified to avoid misinterpretation of the brake

application requirement. Accordingly, the agency has decided to amend

S5.3.6.1 of Standard 121 to read as follows: ``using a full-treadle

brake application for the duration of the stop, stop the vehicle * *

*.'' (emphasis added)

C. Number of Test Stops for Certification

In the ABS final rule, NHTSA decided that requiring compliance with

the braking-in-a-curve requirements during three consecutive stops is

appropriate. The agency noted that specifying three consecutive full

treadle test stops is consistent with both NHTSA's own testing at its

Vehicle Research and Test Center (VRTC) and its testing in conjunction

with the motor vehicle industry through the MVSRAC ABS Task Force. The

agency further noted that because the ABS automatically modulates the

brakes, using full treadle brake applications to test an ABS- equipped

vehicle in the braking-in-a-curve maneuver requires less driver skill

than using a driver-best-effort modulated brake application in the

stopping distance performance tests. The agency further noted that the

braking-in-a-curve test is easier to perform than the stopping distance

test because it is not coupled with a stopping distance requirement.

Therefore, NHTSA decided not to adopt the AAMA recommendation in the

NPRM that manufacturers should be given the option of complying in only

three of ten stops. Adopting that recommendation would have made the

braking-in-a-curve requirement unreasonably lenient.

AlliedSignal, Rockwell WABCO, HDBMC, AAMA, and Navistar petitioned

the agency to allow truck tractors to be regarded as complying with the

braking-in-a-curve test if they make three successful test runs out of

six attempts. The petitioners claimed that additional test runs should

be permitted given that some variability may be caused by the driver's

performance of braking and steering while conducting these stops. They

further stated that all of the stopping distance tests of Standard No.

105, Standard No. 121, and Standard No. 135 recognize the significance

of driver-best-effort variability by prescribing that just one of six

attempts need to be successful to satisfy the requirement.

NHTSA believes that treating three successful runs out of six

attempts as demonstrating compliance would not provide a sufficiently

stringent test for antilock brake systems, whose technology has

demonstrated remarkably consistent performance during vehicle testing

conducted by the agency and by the motor vehicle industry. As the

agency stated in the final rule, it is unlikely that driver influences

will result in significant variability, since the driver does not have

to modulate the brake pedal to

[[Page 63970]]

reduce wheel lockup and achieve the best stopping distance performance.

(60 FR 13234) Nevertheless, since there may be some minor variability

in the test driver's performance, the agency has decided to provide

that compliance with the braking-in-a-curve test is demonstrated if a

vehicle has three successful test runs out of four attempts. NHTSA

believes that this number of test runs, which allows one failed test

run, is appropriate for an antilock system tested to a braking-in-a-

curve maneuver.

D. Initial Brake Temperature

In the March 1995 final rules, NHTSA concluded that an initial

brake temperature range of between 150 deg.F and 200 deg.F is more

appropriate than the proposed temperature range of 250 deg.F to 300

deg.F. The agency determined that testing using the 150 deg.F to 200

deg.F temperature range is more repeatable and results in less

variation between test runs, compared to testing conducted at an

initial brake temperature of 250 deg.F to 300 deg.F, particularly for

the emergency brake stops.

Ferodo petitioned the agency to change the initial brake

temperature to between 100 deg.F and 200 deg.F, claiming that this is

a more practicable range.

NHTSA continues to believe that the initial brake temperature range

of between 150 deg.F-200 deg.F is appropriate. It appears that Ferodo

is not aware that broadening the initial brake temperature range makes

the requirements more stringent, since the vehicle would have to comply

with the requirements at any point within the specified range. The

consensus of the comments received to the ABS and stopping distance

NPRMs was that the agency should maintain the 150 deg.F-200 deg.F

temperature range. In addition, the agency's vehicle research reached a

similar conclusion. (60 FR 13235) Based on the above considerations,

the agency has decided to deny Ferodo's petition to broaden the initial

brake temperature to the range of 100 deg.F to 200 deg.F.

VI. Stopping Distance Performance

A. Stopping Distance Requirements for School Buses

AAMA and HDBMC petitioned the agency to allow manufacturers the

option of certifying hydraulic-braked school buses to either the

existing standard or the new standard with ABS, between now and March

1, 1999. They stated that, by being given such an option, manufacturers

would have the incentive to offer ABS on hydraulic-braked school buses

prior to 1999, and the vehicles would have to meet the more stringent

second effectiveness test. HDBMC also petitioned the agency to

immediately delete the first effectiveness test for school buses with a

GVWR greater than 10,000 pounds.

NHTSA agrees with the petitioners' request to allow the option of

meeting the new requirements, including the ABS requirements, prior to

March 1, 1999. This amendment will facilitate the introduction of ABS

equipped school buses. Nevertheless, the agency does not agree with

HDBMC's request to immediately delete the first effectiveness test,

since deleting this requirement prior to a vehicle being equipped with

ABS might decrease the braking performance of school buses. NHTSA has

modified S5.1.1(c) of Standard No. 105 to allow school bus

manufacturers the option of certifying that their vehicles comply with

the new requirements, beginning 30 days after this final rule is

published.

B. Test Surface Specification

In the stopping distance final rule, NHTSA concluded that a PFC of

0.9 represents a typical dry surface and will not be a significant

source of variability in the stopping distance tests. (60 FR 13289,

13290) The agency's conclusion was based on the industry-government

cooperative testing to evaluate the effect of fluctuations of PFC on

vehicle stopping performance.8 Testing indicates that the expected

minor variability of a high coefficient of friction surface appears to

have a negligible impact on vehicle stopping distance performance. This

testing led the agency to conclude that any variability in the stopping

performance on a high coefficient of friction surface is more likely

due to variation in the vehicle's performance than test surface

variability. The agency further stated that a test surface

specification of PFC 1.0 would result in practicability problems for

the agency, since it would have problems finding such a surface and

conducting compliance testing on such a surface.

8 Public Files Docket PF88-01, MVSRAC ABS Task Force,

Round Robin No. 1.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

Navistar petitioned NHTSA to specify a PFC of 1.0 instead of 0.9

for the high coefficient of friction surface on which the stopping

distance performance tests are to be conducted. The petitioner claimed

that the specification of PFC 0.9 will cause industry to incur costs

for expensive equipment, maintenance, delays in testing and

redeployment of scarce resources without any demonstrable safety

improvement.

NHTSA has decided to continue to specify a PFC of 0.9 for high

coefficient of friction surfaces, for the reasons set forth in the

final rule. The agency notes that Navistar provided no additional

information calling into question the agency's earlier conclusion that

a test surface specification of PFC 1.0 would result in practicability

problems for the agency. The agency therefore has decided to deny

Navistar's petition.

AAMA petitioned the agency to allow the PFC of the curved test

surface for the braking-in-a-curve test to be measured by the American

Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) trailer on a straight section

of the curved test surface. Since the ASTM Method E1337-90 procedure

specifies a straight line measurement, the agency agrees that measuring

PFC on a curved road might introduce variability in the measurement as

a result of lateral forces present at the tire. NHTSA therefore has

decided to amend Standard No. 121 to allow the PFC of the 500-foot

radius curved test surface to be measured by the ASTM skid trailer on a

straight section of the test surface.

ATA requested that the agency amend S5.3.6.1 to specify that the

ASTM Method E1337-90 be run either on a wet surface without further

water delivery or on a dry surface with water delivery.

NHTSA believes that such an amendment about the test surface is not

necessary. The agency's skid trailer measurements taken at VRTC show a

negligible difference (i.e., less than 0.05) for PFC measurements for a

surface that is ``double wetted'' as compared with an already wet

surface. This is the same data variability that VRTC obtains from the

skid trailer measurements of a wetted surface when one type of wetting

is used. Therefore, if a wet test surface is wetted again just prior to

skid trailer testing, the level of stringency of the test would be

essentially the same as that for a ``single wetting'' condition.

C. Wheel Lockup Restrictions

AlliedSignal, AAMA, HDBMC, and Midland-Grau petitioned NHTSA to

clarify the wording in S5.3.1 and S5.7.1 of Standard No. 121 to

explicitly state that ``unlimited wheel lockup is allowed during

partial failure stops,'' as is stated in S6.10.2(e) of Standard No.

105.

NHTSA has decided that it is appropriate to modify the regulatory

language in S5.7.1 of Standard No. 121 to explicitly allow unlimited

wheel lockup during emergency brake stops. The agency emphasizes that

this amendment serves merely to make it clear that unlimited wheel

lockup is allowed during emergency brake system performance tests.

While the agency intends to allow unlimited wheel lockup during

emergency brake stops, it does not intend to allow such unlimited wheel

lockup for service brake stops in

[[Page 63971]]

S5.3.1 of Standard No. 121. NHTSA notes that this is only a

clarification and does not change the requirements that were adopted in

the March 1995 final rules.

D. Burnish Procedure

On May 15, 1995, NHTSA issued a notice that terminated rulemaking

to amend Standard No. 105 and Standard No. 121 with respect to the

burnish procedures for medium and heavy vehicles. (60 FR 25880) The

agency determined that it would be unnecessary to extend the period

during which a manufacturer may choose between two burnish procedures.

The agency reasoned that its decision was appropriate because

manufacturers have been certifying compliance to the brake standards,

based on the ``new'' more representative burnish procedure, since

September 1994.

In response to the March 1995 final rules, Navistar petitioned the

agency to allow, indefinitely, the option of using either the old or

the new burnish procedure.

As explained in the May 1995 termination notice, the new burnish

procedure is currently in effect. Therefore, the issue of allowing the

option of using the old procedure is moot.

E. Definition of Nonsteerable Axle

In the stopping distance final rule, NHTSA stated that wheel lockup

is permitted at certain wheels, including ``any wheel on a nonsteerable

axle other than the two rearmost nonliftable, nonsteerable axles * * *,

for any duration * * *.'' (see paragraph S5.3.1(a))

AAMA requested the agency to make it clear that a nonsteerable axle

is an axle that does not steer by means of a driver-controlled

mechanism, and that a self-steering axle would be considered a

nonsteerable axle.

NHTSA considers a self-steering axle to be a nonsteerable axle in

this context, since such an axle is not under the control of the

driver. The pertinent criterion is that an axle is only considered

``steerable'' for purposes of this requirement, if the steerability of

the wheels on that axle is controlled by the steering wheel of the

vehicle. Since a self-steering axle is not under the control of the

driver's steering wheel, it is not considered to be steerable.

VII. ABS Malfunction Indicator Lamps

A. In-Cab Malfunction Lamp for Trailer ABS

In the final rule, NHTSA decided to require lamps in the cab of

truck tractors to indicate any malfunction with the ABS of any towed

vehicles. (60 FR 13244, 13245) The agency also required trailers to

supply trailer ABS malfunction signals to the tractor. This requirement

is essentially the same as the one proposed prior to the March 1995

final rule.

ATA petitioned the agency to delete the provision requiring in-cab

indication of trailer ABS malfunctions. That organization claimed both

in its comments to the NPRM and in its petition for reconsideration

that such a lamp is unnecessary. It also argued that such a requirement

needlessly complicates the electrical system of the tractor and the

electrical connector arrangement between tractors and trailers.

NHTSA disagrees with ATA that the in-cab trailer malfunction lamp

is unnecessary. Studies have shown that an in-cab malfunction lamp is a

more effective means of making the driver aware of an ABS malfunction,

compared with an external malfunction lamp on the trailer.9 The

agency also disagrees with ATA's statement that having two malfunction

indicators unreasonably complicates the electrical systems in

combination vehicles. In their comments on the NPRM, several brake and

vehicle manufacturers stated that it was appropriate to have two

indicators. For instance, Midland-Grau strongly opposed having a single

malfunction indicator, claiming that having a single lamp would make it

difficult to identify which vehicle had a malfunction without using

separate diagnostic equipment. Since this issue has been addressed in

detail in previous notices, and since ATA has not submitted any

additional data to substantiate its claim, the agency has decided to

deny ATA's request to delete the in-cab malfunction lamp for the

trailer ABS.

\9\ ``An In-Service Evaluation of the Performance, Reliability,

Maintainability, and Durability of Antilock Braking Systems for

Semitrailers,'' U.S. Department of Transportation/ NHTSA Report No.

DOT HS 808 059, October 1993.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

B. Trailer-Mounted ABS Malfunction Indicator

In the final rule, NHTSA decided to require an external ABS

malfunction lamp on trailers and dollies for the eight-year period

during which some non-ABS-equipped tractors will be towing ABS-equipped

trailers. (60 FR 13244, 13245) The requirement specified that the

external lamp ``be visible within the driver's forward field of view

through rearview mirrors.''

ATA and UPS petitioned the agency to delete the requirements for an

external trailer-mounted malfunction lamp. They claimed that the

external malfunction lamp will lead to less safety because drivers will

be looking in their mirrors during braking to see whether the ABS lamp

is functioning, instead of looking at traffic conditions ahead of their

vehicle.

NHTSA continues to believe that it is appropriate to require an

external malfunction lamp on trailers and dollies for the eight-year

period during which some non-ABS-equipped tractors will be towing ABS-

equipped trailers. The external malfunction lamp will indicate trailer

ABS malfunctions to the driver of a non-ABS tractor and will also

assist Federal and State inspectors in determining the operational

status of a trailer's antilock system. NHTSA disagrees with ATA's claim

that the external malfunction lamp would create a less safe condition

for drivers. The agency anticipates that most drivers will look through

their mirrors to check the lamp infrequently, and only when the vehicle

is stationary or the road ahead is clear. The agency therefore denies

the petitions from ATA and UPS to delete the trailer-mounted ABS

malfunction lamp.

Midland-Grau and TTMA petitioned the agency to delete the

requirement in S5.2.3.3 that the external indicator on a trailer be

visible from the driver's seating position ``through the rearview

mirrors.'' Midland-Grau stated that since the truck tractor

manufacturers cannot control where the external lamp would be located,

requiring that the lamp be visible from the cab of the truck tractor is

unreasonable. TTMA stated that since trailer manufacturers have no

responsibility for the mirrors, requiring the ABS malfunction lamp on

dollies and trailers to be visible ``through the rearview mirrors'' is

not appropriate. They also stated that there is no good, practical

location for such a lamp on a dolly.

Even though NHTSA believes that the external trailer malfunction

lamp is appropriate, the agency agrees with Midland-Grau and TTMA that

it is inappropriate to specify a location requirement for the external

malfunction lamp that is based on what can be seen in a truck tractor's

rearview mirror. Compliance with such a requirement would depend on

factors that are not fully controlled by the trailer manufacturer.

Rearview visibility of the ABS external malfunction lamp could vary

based on truck tractor design and its aerodynamic fairings, the field

of view provided by the rearview mirrors, and on the location of the

lamp. Accordingly, the agency has decided to delete the requirement in

S5.2.3.3 for rearview mirror visibility of the lamp on trailers and

dollies.

[[Page 63972]]

TTMA requested that if the agency retains the requirement for an

external malfunction lamp on the trailer, then the location of the

lamp, its color, and its intensity should be specified in Standard No.

108, Lamps, reflective devices, and associated equipment.

NHTSA emphasizes that it is important for the driver to see the

trailer mounted malfunction lamp from his or her driving position.

Therefore, the agency is issuing, simultaneously with this final rule,

an NPRM that proposes a lamp location on the trailer and the dolly, but

without stating any visibility requirements with reference to the

tractor. The agency agrees with TTMA that it is appropriate to propose

the location, color, and intensity of the trailer and dolly ABS

external malfunction lamp. Specifically, the agency is proposing a

location for the external ABS malfunction indicator on trailers, which

is similar to the location proposed by the agency when it was

considering requiring a low pressure warning lamp on trailers (55 FR

4453, February 8, 1995).

ATA and UPS petitioned the agency to only require that the ABS

check lamp be visible for visual inspection during a walk-around of a

vehicle.

NHTSA believes that only requiring a lamp for visual inspection

during a vehicle walk-around is insufficient because current designs

would require more than one person to conduct the inspection, if the

trailer is powered through the stop lamp circuit. One person would have

to apply the brake pedal to provide ABS power to the trailer, and

another would need to be outside the vehicle to view the ABS lamp, if

it is located somewhere on the trailer's chassis.

C. Activation Protocol for Malfunction Indicators

In the final rule, NHTSA decided to require the malfunction

indicator lamp to activate when a problem exists and not activate when

the system is functioning properly. (60 FR 13246) Under this

requirement, the indicator lamp is required to provide a continuous

indication until a function check of the ABS is completed. Under that

format, the ABS malfunction lamp extinguishes after a function check,

and before the vehicle is driven. The agency explained that this ABS

malfunction lamp format, together with the requirement that the system

stores malfunctions until the next key-on, is necessary to enable

Federal and State inspectors to determine the operational status of an

ABS without moving the vehicle. In support of its decision, the agency

noted that this activation pattern is consistent with the one for light

vehicle ABS and the one adopted by the Economic Commission for Europe

(ECE).

Navistar petitioned NHTSA to allow the vehicle to be in motion at

low vehicle speed during an ABS system check so that the sensor check

could be included before the lamp extinguishes. Navistar stated that

the benefits of a sensor check outweigh the convenience for use by

Federal or State inspectors.

As explained in the final rule, NHTSA believes that the requirement

that the system store malfunctions until the next key-on is necessary

to enable Federal and State inspectors to determine the operational

status of an ABS without moving the vehicle. On March 10, 1995, the

Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) published a notice of intent to

initiate rulemaking addressing requirements for motor carriers to

maintain the ABS on those vehicles that are subject to NHTSA's final

rule. These requirements could include inspecting the vehicle to

determine whether ABS is operational. Navistar's request to allow the

vehicle to be in motion before the lamp extinguishes would impede

FHWA's inspection process to determine the operational status of ABS.

The agency therefore has decided to deny Navistar's petition to amend

the malfunction lamp protocol to allow the lamp to stay lit until the

vehicle is driven.

AlliedSignal and TTMA requested that the check of lamp function on

the external trailer ABS malfunction lamp would only activate when

power is supplied to the ABS and the vehicle is stationary. They stated

that such a requirement would prevent the ABS lamp from cycling on and

off whenever power is supplied or with every brake application in cases

where the trailer ABS is being powered through the stop lamp circuit.

NHTSA agrees with the petitioners that such a requirement reduces

potential distractions to the driver or to drivers of other vehicles

caused by the lamp cycling on and off with every brake application. The

agency notes that this modification retains the requirement's primary

purpose, which is to indicate an ABS malfunction to the driver or to

Federal and State inspection personnel. The agency has therefore

decided to amend paragraph S5.2.3.3 to specify that the check of lamp

function will activate the trailer ABS malfunction lamp, whenever power

is supplied to the ABS and there is an absence of wheel speed (i.e.,

that the vehicle is stationary).

TTMA stated that the final rule does not address the operation of

the ABS malfunction lamp in the event of a total loss of electrical

power. That organization requested that the agency explicitly state

that neither the external trailer lamp nor the in-cab lamp is required

to be activated if there is a total loss of electrical power to the

trailer.

A total loss of power causes the control unit to be incapable of

sending a malfunction signal to the indicator lamp, since the control

unit for an electronic ABS requires electrical power for operation.

NHTSA notes that no vehicle system is capable of indicating a warning

or malfunction in the event of a total loss of electrical power. The

agency therefore believes that there is no need to specify regulatory

language about the operation of the ABS malfunction lamp in the event

of a total loss of electrical power.

D. Signal Storage

In the final rule, NHTSA decided to require that the ABS indicator

lamp system be capable of storing information regarding any malfunction

that existed when the ignition was last turned to the ``off'' position

or in the case of towed vehicles, when power was last received by the

ABS. (60 FR 13246, 13247) The agency explained that the malfunction

storage requirement is necessary to ensure that relief drivers and

Federal and State inspectors are advised about any malfunctions in a

vehicle's ABS without having to move the vehicle.

Rockwell WABCO, Midland-Grau, AAMA, TTMA, and ATA requested that

the agency define a pre-existing malfunction as a malfunction that

existed when the ignition switch was last turned to the ``off''

position. These petitioners argued that such a definition is necessary

to clarify that malfunctions that no longer exist are to be cleared and

do not need to be indicated.

After reviewing the petitions, NHTSA had decided to amend S5.3.3(b)

of Standard No. 105, and S5.1.6.2 (a) and (b) and S5.2.3.2 of Standard

No. 121 to clarify that a pre-existing malfunction is a malfunction

that existed when the ignition switch was last turned to the ``off''

position. The agency never intended to require the indication of

malfunctions that have been corrected but still remain in the long-term

memory of the electronic control unit.

E. ABS Failed System Requirements

In the final rule, NHTSA decided to revise Standard No. 121 to

prohibit any change in brake timing in the event of ABS malfunctions

that affect the generation or transmission of response or control

signals. The agency explained that this modification will ensure that

the brake system reverts to normal

[[Page 63973]]

braking without antilock control, in the event of such a malfunction in

the antilock system.

AlliedSignal, HDBMC, and Midland-Grau petitioned the agency to

amend S5.5.1 to require each vehicle to meet the emergency brake

stopping requirements but not the service brake, actuation and release

timing requirements. The petitioners are concerned about the potential

for noncompliance that is not within the control of known antilock

brake systems.

NHTSA believes that it is important that a heavy vehicle's brake

system revert to normal braking without antilock control, in the event

of an ABS malfunction that affects the generation or transmission of

response or control signals in any part of the antilock system. The

agency believes that it would be inappropriate to allow brake

performance to degrade to the level of the emergency braking

performance requirements when a typical ABS malfunction exists. The

service brakes of a vehicle with a malfunctioning ABS should provide a

level of braking performance that is not substantially different from

the service brake performance with the ABS operational. This is

necessary so that the resulting braking performance will not surprise a

driver when the ABS malfunctions. Based on the above considerations,

the agency has decided to deny the petitions to amend the performance

requirements for a vehicle with a failed antilock system.

VIII. Power Source

A. Separate Powering for Trailer ABS

In the final rule, NHTSA decided to require full time powering for

the trailer ABSs as well as requiring that the towing vehicle have a

corresponding separate circuit. (60 FR 13248-13250) The agency

explained that this requirement provides the strongest possible source

of electrical power from the tractor to ensure the functioning of the

ECU, the modulators, and a continuous malfunction indication whenever a

malfunction exists.

AAMA, Midland-Grau, and TTMA requested the agency to make it clear

that the phrase, ``separate electrical circuits, specifically provided

to power the antilock system,'' is not intended to require that a

circuit be exclusively utilized by the towed vehicle ABS. AAMA and

Midland-Grau want the agency to allow other uses for this circuit, such

as interior van trailer lights and multiplexing applications. ATA

asserted that the requirement for a separate circuit is redundant and

costly. ATA subsequently requested the agency in a September 6, 1995

letter to interpret the requirement for a separate electrical circuit.

NHTSA has decided to deny the request to permit other uses for the

separate ABS circuit. As emphasized in the final rule, based on the

best data available to the agency, NHTSA determined that it is

necessary for the ABS on towed vehicles to receive full-time power

through a circuit that is exclusively used by the towed vehicle ABS, so

as to reduce the possibility of the ABS being inoperative due to lack

of power. Throughout the rulemaking, the agency has intended that a

towed vehicle antilock system be powered through a separate electrical

circuit that is specifically provided to power the antilock system.

NHTSA based that decision on the results of its field evaluation of

the durability, reliability, and maintainability of trailer ABS systems

(as reported in DOT Report No. HS 808 059). That report noted that each

of the three electrical powering methods that employed a separate

circuit (e.g., the Cole-Hersee 13-pin connector, the separate 6-pin

connector, and the separate ISO connector) was superior to the stoplamp

powering approach. Each of these separate powering approaches used

completely dedicated electrical circuits, which included separate,

fully dedicated positive and ground wires, to power the trailer ABS

ECUs. Based on the existing data, the agency therefore believes that

both positive and ground wires separate from those now provided for

other uses are necessary to adequately power trailer ABS systems. The

agency has no technical basis for concluding that circuits that share

the existing ground provided by the currently-used SAE J560 connector

would provide power as well as a fully separate circuit, and therefore

has no basis to conclude that such a powering scheme would be adequate.

NHTSA is aware of extensive industry efforts in various Society of

Automotive Engineers' (SAE) technical committees to establish

performance standards for electrical systems used to power tractor and

trailer ABS systems which include objective performance test

procedures, measurement criteria, and, in some cases, target

performance levels. If those efforts result in the development of

consensus standards that would ensure high quality tractor and trailer

electrical systems that could be demonstrated to adequately supply

electrical power to trailer ABS systems, the agency would consider

alternative means of satisfying the safety need for adequate trailer

ABS powering, other than the one which currently available data

indicate is necessary.

NHTSA has been asked whether the rule allows the use of the SAE

J560 connector. The agency reiterates the point it made in the final

rule, i.e, that it is leaving to industry the decision as to which

design approach is used to implement the performance requirement that

trailer ABS be supplied power through a separate circuit and that a

means of signaling trailer ABS malfunctions to the tractor also be

provided. SAE J560 standard both specifies the physical connector and

standardizes the uses for each of the seven pins. Thus, the connector,

if it is configured as specified in the J560 standard could not be

used, because there is, at most, one pin available for new uses, and up

to three new ones could be required. However, if the industry chooses

to reconfigure the presently-used SAE J560 connector hardware in such a

manner as to meet the requirements for a separate trailer ABS powering

circuit (both positive and ground) and malfunction signaling, then that

solution would be permitted. The agency notes that such a solution

would require multiplexing of some circuits, in order to free up enough

pins for ABS power.

NHTSA agrees with TTMA's concern that ``if the auxiliary circuit is

used to provide full-time power to ABS, then there would be potential

for inadvertently powering the auxiliary devices, due to human error,

if a manual switch is left on * * *'' Such an inadvertent powering of

an auxiliary device that uses the same power circuit as the ABS could

result in a low voltage condition at the electronic control unit of the

ABS, thus making the ABS inoperative. Also, the suggestion that the

trailer ABS powering circuit could be shared with other electrical

devices and still be adequate if power to those devices were

automatically switched off (except when the vehicle is stationary),

lacks an objective basis to gauge whether such an automatic means would

be fail-safe. If the automatic means failed, the trailer ABS systems

could have insufficient power. The agency therefore considers this

approach to providing separate power to trailer ABSs to be inadequate.

B. ABS Malfunction Signal Circuit and Ground

In the final rule, NHTSA specified detailed requirements about the

capabilities of the electrical circuits. Among other things, paragraph

S5.2.3.2 requires each non-towing trailer to have the means for

connection of the antilock

[[Page 63974]]

malfunction signal circuit and ground, at the front of the trailer.

AAMA and Midland-Grau petitioned the agency to delete the word

``circuit'' in the phrase ``malfunction signal circuit and ground'' in

S5.2.3.2, claiming that it could be interpreted as requiring a separate

circuit with dedicated power and ground wires.

After reviewing the petitions, NHTSA has decided to amend paragraph

S5.2.3.2 to delete the words ``and ground'' from the phrase

``malfunction signal circuit and ground.'' The agency notes that it did

not intend to require a dedicated circuit for the ABS malfunction

signal circuit on trailers. The agency agrees with the petitioners that

since a ``circuit'' is defined as an electrical path having both a

power source and a ground, the present language could be confusing, and

that the language should be changed to avoid being misinterpreted.

TTMA requested that the agency amend S5.1.6.2(a) and S5.2.3.2,

which require that the vehicle be equipped with an ``electrical circuit

that is capable of signaling a malfunction.'' The petitioner stated

that the ABS, not the electrical circuit, should be required to signal

a malfunction.

NHTSA agrees that TTMA's requested language is more precise than

the wording in the final rule's regulatory text, and amends the

regulatory language accordingly.

AAMA, Midland-Grau, and TTMA petitioned the agency to amend

S5.1.6.2(c), which currently requires that a truck or truck tractor

designed to tow another vehicle have an electrical circuit that is

capable of ``transmitting'' information about a malfunction. The

petitioners requested that the word ``transmitting'' be changed to

``receiving.''

NHTSA believes that it would be inappropriate to substitute the

word ``receiving'' for ``transmitting'' since this electrical circuit

both transmits and receives information. When towing a trailer, a

tractor transmits the malfunction information that it receives from the

trailer's ABS to the ABS malfunction indicator lamp in the cab of the

tractor or the truck. Even though the agency has decided not to change

the word ``transmitting'' in S5.1.6.2 to ``receiving,'' it has decided

to clarify the provision's wording.

In addition to the changes specifically addressed by the petitions,

NHTSA has decided to reword all three ABS malfunction circuit and

indicator provisions (S5.1.6.2, S5.2.3.2, and S5.2.3.3) to clarify them

and make them more consistent in form and wording to each other and to

the other parts of the standard.

In particular:

(a) The new 10 S5.1.6.2(a) is written as a general

requirement.

\10\ ``New'' refers to changes made in today's document; ``old''

refers to the regulatory text adopted in the March 10, 1995 final

rule.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

(b) The old S5.1.6.2(a) and S5.1.6.2(b) has been combined into one

paragraph.

(c) The old S5.1.6.2(c) has been renumbered S5.1.6.2(b) and has

been reworded to delete references to trailer failures in a tractor

requirement.

(d) The new S5.2.3.2 no longer references a ``key switch'' or an

in-cab ABS malfunction lamp, because those items are not present on

trailers.

(e) The new S5.2.3.3 now includes requirements for memory and check

of lamp functions.

C. Tractor Trailer ABS Interface Connector

AAMA petitioned the agency to specify the electrical connector, SAE

J2272, Tractor Trailer Interface Connector, stating that ``the industry

will not be able to converge to a single solution in the absence of

regulatory direction.'' AAMA claimed that without regulatory direction,

the end users could prevent an industry approach from being

implemented, which would result in a proliferation, rather than needed

deproliferation, in connector strategies. In its petition for

reconsideration, TTMA supported the J2272 connector. However, in a

later submission to the docket, that organization withdrew its support

of that connector. TTMA now supports a separate connector, but does not

favor any one in particular. ATA supports the current seven-pin

connector.

NHTSA is aware that the industry is considering several options for

powering trailer antilock systems and that it is having a difficult

time reaching a consensus. The agency agrees that the SAE J2272

connector is one potentially permissible approach that should be given

full consideration by the industry. However, the agency is also aware

that the 7-pin configuration of the SAE J2272 connector might not allow

the industry to have a one-connector solution in the long term, even if

some of its pins are multiplexed. It is NHTSA's belief that the

industry understands and can best respond to the future electrical

powering needs for trailers, such as antilock braking systems,

electronic braking systems, and satellite tracking and communications

network. The agency believes that obtaining compatibility provides

sufficient incentive for the industry to reach a consensus to

standardize on a connector to comply with the full-time power and in-

cab malfunction lamp requirements without the need for an electrical

connector equipment requirement mandated by NHTSA. AMA, ATA, TTMA, and

brake component manufacturers have been meeting under the auspices of

SAE in an effort to reach consensus on the connector issue. These

meetings indicate that all parties have placed forward and backward

compatibility as an important issue for the industry to resolve and

reach consensus. Based on these considerations, the agency has decided

to deny the petition from AAMA to specify the SAE J2272 Tractor Trailer

Interface Connector (or any other specific connector) as required

equipment for tractors and trailers.

IX. Applicability of Amendments and Leadtime

A. Hydraulic-Braked Vehicles

In the final rule, NHTSA stated that a March 1999 compliance date

for installing antilock brake systems on hydraulic-braked single-unit

trucks and buses provides sufficient time for vehicle manufacturers and

ABS manufacturers to complete the development and testing of these

systems. (60 FR 13250-13251) It noted that some Japanese and European

manufacturers are currently marketing ABS for medium and heavy

hydraulic-braked vehicles and that brake manufacturers expressed

confidence that such antilock systems will be available in the United

States.

In its petition, ATA expressed concern that NHTSA was requiring

hydraulic-braked heavy vehicles to be equipped with antilock brake

systems, even though that organization claimed that such systems are

not currently commercially available for heavy vehicles sold in the

United States. ATA further stated that ``different concepts are

necessary for hydraulic ABS on medium and heavy vehicles because of

dissimilarities'' between the braking systems of hydraulic-braked light

vehicles and hydraulic-braked medium/heavy vehicles. Given these

concerns, ATA and UPS petitioned the agency to postpone the compliance

date for hydraulic-braked vehicles, claiming that no antilock systems

are available for these vehicles and such systems, when they are

available, would need time to be tested. The petitioners urged the

agency to postpone the compliance date for these vehicles until 2 years

after the technology is readily available. Further, UPS reiterated its

request for a three-year phase-in scheme of 20 percent/50

[[Page 63975]]

percent/100 percent for the entire ABS applicability requirement.

NHTSA continues to believe that it is appropriate to require that

medium and heavy hydraulic-braked vehicles be equipped with ABS,

starting in March 1999. Two leading manufacturers of medium and heavy

hydraulic vehicles, Freightliner and Navistar, have announced that they

will offer the AlliedSignal hydraulic antilock brake system on their

hydraulic-braked vehicles in 1996. Freightliner will offer ABS as an

option on its Class 5-8 hydraulic Business Class models, while Navistar

will offer hydraulic ABS as standard equipment on all its medium truck

chassis, including the 4000 Series.11 Moreover, in its comments to

the April 1994 SNPRM, Freightliner stated that the March 1, 1999 ABS

compliance date for hydraulic-braked heavy vehicles is realistic and

appropriate, but urged the agency to continue to monitor manufacturers'

progress and be willing to act on short notice, if necessary, to

provide additional lead time.

11 ``Medium-Duty ABS,'' Pickup and Delivery September

1995

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

NHTSA disagrees with ATA's claim that there are significant

differences between ABS on hydraulic-braked light vehicles compared

with medium and heavy vehicles. AlliedSignal, a manufacturer of both

air-braked and hydraulic-braked ABS, stated in its comments to the

September 1993 NPRM that the hydraulic- braked ABS technology that will

be used on heavy vehicles is the same as the technology now used on

passenger cars and other light vehicles, and that the application of

hydraulic-braked ABS on heavy vehicles ``should not present significant

technical risk.'' That company also explicitly stated that ``components

are identical or nearly identical to that used in the passenger car and

light truck applications.'' It added that ``the wheel speed sensors are

the same technology as used in light vehicle applications, and in fact

are the same as that planned for air-braked vehicles. The electronic

control unit utilizes the same components as light vehicles * * * and

is planned to be the same as that supplied by our AlliedSignal Truck

Brake System Company for air braked vehicle applications.''

AlliedSignal concluded their comments to the NPRM by stating that as a

supplier of ABS for hydraulic-braked vehicles, the requirements can be

reliably achieved with proven technology within the suggested time

frame.

Such similarities are also present when comparing ABS on air braked

vehicles and hydraulic-braked vehicles. In the September 1995 Pickup &

Delivery article, a representative of AlliedSignal stated that--

There's quite a few similarities in complexity [between

hydraulic and air braked ABS]. For example, the means of sensing

wheel speed is basically identical. There's a wheel speed sensor

that's used to check the speed of each wheel. You also have an ECU

which monitors those wheel speeds and identifies if they are

remaining constant or there are differentials from one side to

another or front to rear.

ATA also disagreed with NHTSA statements, claiming that ABS will

not be required on European trucks until after NHTSA's requirement

takes effect.

NHTSA believes that ATA's claim is based on a misinterpretation of

the European type approval system as compared with the United States'

self-certification system. The agency is aware that there are new

European requirements pending for hydraulic-braked medium and heavy

vehicles equipped with ABS, with the first compliance date of January

1999. In Europe, newly produced vehicles with old type-approvals can

use their old brake system design for a period of time after the

compliance dates when ABS will be required on new type-approved

vehicles. Therefore, these vehicles can continue to be built and sold

without ABS, even after the European compliance dates, which begin in

January 1999. When a manufacturer redesigns a vehicle, however, the new

design has to be typed-approved, and therefore would be required to

comply with the new ABS requirements. Hence, ATA is technically correct

that some hydraulic-braked heavy vehicles built for the European market

will be allowed to be built without ABS even after the compliance date

for the United States requirements. However, other European market

vehicles with hydraulic brakes will have to have ABS before their

United States counterparts. Due to the differences between the type

approval and self-certification processes, there is no way to

completely synchronize the introduction of ABS on hydraulic- braked

heavy vehicles in the United States and in Europe, and there is no

reason to delay introduction in the United States until after all

European vehicles are required to have it.

Based on the above comments from manufacturers and the positive

experience in other countries with ABS-equipped hydraulic-braked

vehicles, NHTSA has determined that requiring hydraulic-braked vehicles

to be equipped with ABS is practicable and appropriate. The agency

continues to believe that four years is sufficient leadtime for vehicle

manufacturers to develop and test these antilock systems, given that

ABS technology has already been introduced on light vehicles equipped

with hydraulic braking systems. Therefore, the agency has decided to

deny ATA's petition to extend the compliance date for equipping

hydraulic-braked vehicles with ABS.

AM General petitioned the agency to change the compliance date for

equipping hydraulic-braked vehicles with ABS from March 1, 1999, to

September 1, 1999. It claimed that the company would face complications

in making such a major mid-year change.

NHTSA notes that vehicles produced on or after the specified

compliance dates must comply with the new requirements. This also means

that a vehicle manufacturer can comply with the new brake requirements

before the compliance date of the new requirements. Hence, if AM

General finds it difficult to comply with the March 1, 1999 compliance

date because of the mid-year timing of the date, then it has the option

of complying with the new requirements prior to that date, such as on

September 1, 1998.

AM General petitioned the agency to specify a timetable for

monitoring and reviewing the technical status and viability of

commercially available hydraulic antilock systems.

NHTSA currently has no plans for specifying a formal timetable for

monitoring and reviewing the technical status of hydraulic-braked ABS

for heavy vehicles. Nevertheless, the agency plans to monitor this

development closely and could modify the implementation schedule if

development of antilock systems for hydraulic-braked vehicles faced

unexpected development problems. As stated above, vehicle and brake

manufacturers indicate that they will have hydraulic antilock systems

commercially available in 1996. The agency has provided a leadtime of

four years to ensure that manufacturers will have sufficient time to

develop and test antilock systems for hydraulic-braked heavy vehicles.

The agency believes that the fleets and users, the ABS manufacturers,

and the vehicle manufacturers can work together to lay out a timetable

for the industry so that antilock systems for these heavy vehicles are

ready for commercial use by March 1, 1999.

B. Class 3 Vehicles

AM General petitioned that the ABS requirements not apply to

vehicles with GVWRs between 10,001 and 14,000 pounds (Class 3 trucks).

It argued that

[[Page 63976]]

since many of these vehicles are derived from light vehicles, and given

its belief that the effectiveness of ABS on light vehicles is open to

debate, the industry should be given the opportunity to review and

consider comments on equipping Class 3 vehicles with ABS.

NHTSA has previously stated that excluding vehicles of certain

weight classes between 10,000 and 26,000 pounds GVWR would create an

uneven application of the ABS requirements and could result in an

inconsistent regulatory framework that would not provide safety

benefits to all vehicles. The results of the accident data analysis

that examined the effectiveness of ABS on light vehicles showed that

there was a net positive safety benefit from equipping vans, sport

utilities, and light trucks with ABS. Since many Class 3 vehicles are

derived from these light trucks, the agency anticipates that Class 3

vehicles will also experience safety benefits from being equipped with

ABS. The agency therefore disagrees with AM General's conclusion and

has decided to deny its petition requesting that Class 3 vehicles be

excluded from applicability to the ABS requirements because of the lack

of demonstrated effectiveness of ABS on passenger cars.

C. Four-Wheel Drive Vehicles

AM General also requested that the ABS requirement not apply to

four-wheel drive vehicles. The company stated that it has had

difficulty getting an ABS supplier to develop a system for its Hummer

vehicle because of the vehicle's full-time 4WD, torque-biasing

differentials on both axles, and low volume production. AM General

believes that the issue of four-wheel drive ABS has been overlooked and

needs to be addressed openly.

NHTSA believes that it is appropriate to apply the ABS requirements

to four-wheel drive vehicles, since such vehicles can and do lose

control during braking. Moreover, the agency is aware of ABS

applications on current vehicles equipped with full-time four-wheel

drive or with all-wheel drive, and believes that the ABS technology, to

accomplish an ABS installation on AM General's Hummer vehicle, is

readily available. Therefore, the agency has decided to deny AM

General's petition requesting that four-wheel drive vehicles be

excluded from being equipped with ABS.

D. Trailers and Dollies

UPS petitioned the agency to implement ABS on air-braked vehicles

by using a three-year phase-in scheme of 20 percent/50 percent/100

percent for trailers and dollies. That company requested that in 1998,

20 percent of trailers and dollies be required to have ABS; in 1999, 50

percent be required to have ABS; and in 2000, 100 percent be required

to have ABS. UPS claims that it faces critical problems regarding

reliability and cost to meet the current effective dates.

NHTSA believes that such a protracted delay in the implementation

of ABS on trailers and dollies is unnecessary, given the current state

of development of ABS for these vehicles and given that 2S/1M and

tandem control configurations on semi-trailers and dollies are being

allowed. The agency further notes that no ABS or trailer manufacturer

expressed concerns about the agency's timetable or ABS reliability.

Moreover, in the final rule, the agency discussed in detail the issues

that ATA and UPS raised about reliability of ABS on heavy vehicles.

NHTSA concluded that ABSs are reliable and that maintenance costs

associated with ABS are neither excessive nor unreasonable compared to

other maintenance costs. The agency further stated that these costs

will not be significantly reduced if the implementation dates of this

rule are further delayed.

X. Miscellaneous

A. National Uniformity

ATA petitioned the agency to clarify that States may not impose

compliance dates that differ from NHTSA's rules. That organization

specifically requested NHTSA to ``confirm * * * that any attempt under

State law to impose a retroactive ABS mandate would frustrate the

significant Federal statutory purpose and, therefore, is not

permitted.''

NHTSA notes that the statute (formerly known as the ``National

Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act of 1966'') clearly addresses the

issue of preemption at 49 USC 30103(b). That provision states that when

a Federal motor vehicle safety standard is in effect, a State generally

may only prescribe an identical standard.

B. Publish Complete Regulatory Texts and Compliance Test Procedures

AAMA, HDBMC, and Midland-Grau requested that the agency immediately

publish complete and updated versions of Standard No. 105 and Standard

No. 121.

NHTSA agrees that there should be complete and updated versions of

Standard No. 105 and Standard No. 121, showing all the amendments made

by the ABS and Stopping Distance rulemakings. Such changes are

generally reflected in the Code of Federal Regulations published

annually by the National Archives and Records Administration. The

agency believes that the publication of updated versions of Standard

No. 105 and Standard No. 121 would be helpful to the regulated

industry. Since the agency's first priority is to issue the substantive

rules, it has issued today's notice first. The agency anticipates

publishing the updated Standards in 1996.

AAMA, AlliedSignal, HDBMC, and Midland-Grau petitioned the agency

to provide the compliance test procedures for Standard 121, TP-121,

within 60 days after April 10, 1995.

NHTSA notes that these compliance test procedures are currently

under development by the agency and will be made available in the near

future.

C. Costs

ATA claimed that NHTSA's cost estimate for ABS ``are low by roughly

a factor of two.'' That organization stated that fleets are getting

bids on ABS equipment and actual quotes are running at almost $2,000

per tractor and $1,400 per trailer.

NHTSA disagrees with ATA that the agency's cost estimates for ABS

are low by ``a factor of two.'' The agency conducted an in-depth study

of heavy vehicle ABS cost, and the findings are reported in a final

report, ``Incremental Cost, Weight, and Leadtime Impacts of Requiring

Heavy Truck Tractor/Trailer ABS,'' published in June 1994. This study

is based on an annual production volume of 100,000 ABS units. Hence, it

is to be expected that the current prices that ATA is quoting would be

higher than those provided in the agency's study, considering that

current annual production of ABS units is under 10,000 units.

D. Corrections to Standard No. 101 and Standard No. 105

NHTSA has revised Table 2 of Standard No. 101, Controls and

Displays, to correct several of the identifying symbols in Column 4,

which were inadvertently changed in the regulatory text of the final

rule. The attached Table 2 has been revised to include the original

identifying symbols in Column 4.

NHTSA has also corrected Table II of Standard No. 105 to reflect

correct positioning of footnote references.

XI. Rulemaking Analyses and Notices

A. Executive Order 12866 and DOT Regulatory Policies and Procedures

This notice was reviewed under Executive Order 12866. NHTSA has

[[Page 63977]]

considered the impacts of this rulemaking action and determined that it

is ``significant'' within the meaning of the Department of

Transportation's regulatory policies and procedures. In connection with

the March 1995 final rules, the agency prepared a Final Economic

Assessment (FEA) describing the economic and other effects of this

rulemaking action. Summary discussions of those effects were provided

in the ABS final rule. The amendments in this final rule do not make

those effects any more stringent, and in some respects make it easier

for a manufacturer to comply with them. For persons wishing to examine

the full analysis, a copy is in the docket.

B. Regulatory Flexibility Act

NHTSA has also considered the effects of both this final rule or

the original final rule under the Regulatory Flexibility Act. I hereby

certify that it will not have a significant economic impact on a

substantial number of small entities. Accordingly, the agency has not

prepared a final regulatory flexibility analysis.

The primary cost effect of the requirements in this final rule or

in the original final rules will be on manufacturers of heavy vehicles

which are generally large businesses. However, final stage

manufacturers are generally small businesses. A detailed discussion

about the anticipated economic impact on these businesses is provided

in the FEA.

C. National Environmental Policy Act

NHTSA has analyzed this rulemaking action for the purposes of the

National Environmental Policy Act. The agency has determined that

implementation of this action will not have any significant impact on

the quality of the human environment.

D. Executive Order 12612 (Federalism)

NHTSA has analyzed this action under the principles and criteria in

Executive Order 12612. The agency has determined that this notice does

not have sufficient Federalism implications to warrant the preparation

of a Federalism Assessment. No State laws will be affected.

E. Civil Justice Reform

This final rule does not have any retroactive effect. Under 49

U.S.C. 30103, whenever a Federal motor vehicle safety standard is in

effect, a State may not adopt or maintain a safety standard applicable

to the same aspect of performance which is not identical to the Federal

standard, except to the extent that the State requirement imposes a

higher level of performance and applies only to vehicles procured for

the State's use. 49 U.S.C. 30161 sets forth a procedure for judicial

review of final rules establishing, amending or revoking Federal motor

vehicle safety standards. That section does not require submission of a

petition for reconsideration or other administrative proceedings before

parties may file suit in court.

List of Subjects in 49 CFR Part 571

Imports, Motor vehicle safety, Motor vehicles, Rubber and rubber

products, Tires.

In consideration of the foregoing, the agency is amending Standard

No. 101, Controls and Displays, Standard No. 105, Hydraulic Brake

Systems and Standard No. 121, Air Brake Systems, in Title 49 of the

Code of Federal Regulations at Part 571 as follows:

PART 571--[AMENDED]

1. The authority citation for Part 571 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 49 U.S.C. 322, 30111, 30115, 30117, and 30166,

delegation of authority at 49 CFR 1.50.

2. In Sec. 571.101, Table 2 is revised to appear as follows:

Sec. 571.101 Standard No. 101; Controls and Displays.

* * * * *

BILLING CODE 4910-59-P

[[Page 63978]]

[GRAPHIC][TIFF OMITTED]TR13DE95.001

BILLING CODE 4910-59-C

[[Page 63979]]

2. Section 571.105 is amended by revising the definition of

``Directly controlled wheel'' in S4; by revising S5.1.1(c), S5.3.3(b);

S5.5.1, S7, and S7.5 to read as follows:

Sec. 571.105 Standard No. 105, Hydraulic Brake Systems

* * * * *

S4.* * *

Directly Controlled Wheel means a wheel for which the degree of

rotational wheel slip is sensed, either at that wheel or on the axle

shaft for that wheel and corresponding signals are transmitted to one

or more modulators that adjust the brake actuating forces at that

wheel. Each modulator may also adjust the brake actuating forces at

other wheels that are on the same axle or in the same axle set in

response to the same signal or signals.

* * * * *

S5.1.1* * *

(c) The service brakes shall be capable of stopping each vehicle

with a GVWR greater than 10,000 pounds in two effectiveness tests

within the distances and from the speeds specified in S5.1.1.2 and

S5.1.1.3. Each school bus with a GVWR greater than 10,000 pounds

manufactured after January 12, 1996 and before March 1, 1999 and which

is equipped with an antilock brake system may comply with paragraph

S5.1.1.2 and S5.5.1 rather than the first effectiveness test, as

specified in S5.1.1.1. Each school bus with a GVWR greater than 10,000

pounds manufactured on or after March 1, 1999 shall be capable of

meeting the requirements of S5.1.1 through S5.1.5, under the conditions

prescribed in S6, when tested according to the procedures and in the

sequence set forth in S7.

* * * * *

S5.3.3* * *

(b) For vehicles with a GVWR greater than 10,000 pounds, each

message about the existence of a malfunction, as described in

S5.3.1(c), shall be stored in the antilock brake system after the

ignition switch is turned to the ``off'' position and the indicator

lamp shall be automatically reactivated when the ignition switch is

again turned to the ``on'' position. The indicator lamp shall also be

activated as a check of lamp function whenever the ignition is turned

to the ``on'' (run) position. The indicator lamp shall be deactivated

at the end of the check of lamp function unless there is a malfunction

or a message about a malfunction that existed when the key switch was

last turned to the ``off'' position.

* * * * *

S5.5.1 Each vehicle with a GVWR greater than 10,000 pounds, except

for any vehicle that has a speed attainable in 2 miles of not more than

33 mph, shall be equipped with an antilock brake system that directly

controls the wheels of at least one front axle and the wheels of at

least one rear axle of the vehicle. On each vehicle with a GVWR greater

than 10,000 pounds but not greater than 12,000 pounds, the antilock

brake system may also directly control the wheels of the drive axle by

means of a single sensor in the drive line. Wheels on other axles of

the vehicle may be indirectly controlled by the antilock brake system.

* * * * *

S7. Test procedures and sequence. Each vehicle shall be capable of

meeting all the applicable requirements of S5 when tested according to

the procedures and in the sequence set forth below, without replacing

any brake system part or making any adjustments to the brake system

other than as permitted in the burnish and reburnish procedures and in

S7.9 and S7.10. (For vehicles only having to meet the requirements of

S5.1.1, S5.1.2 and S5.1.3 in section S5.1, the applicable test

procedures and sequence are S7.1, S7.2, S7.4, S7.5, S7.8, S7.9, S7.10

and S7.18. However, at the option of the manufacturer, the following

test procedures and sequence may be conducted: S7.1, S7.2, S7.3, S7.4,

S7.5, S7.6, S7.7 S7.8, S7.9, S7.10 and S7.18. The choice of this option

shall not be construed as adding to the requirements specified in

S5.1.2 and S5.1.3.) Automatic adjusters must remain activated at all

times. A vehicle shall be deemed to comply with the stopping distance

requirements of S5.1 if at least one of the stops at each speed and

load specified in each of S7.3, S7.5, S7.8, S7.9, S7.10, S7.15 and

S7.17 (check stops) is made within a stopping distance that does not

exceed the corresponding distance specified in Table II. When the

transmission selector control is required to be in neutral for a

deceleration, a stop or snub shall be obtained by the following

procedures:

(a) Exceed the test speed by 4 to 8 mph;

(b) close the throttle and coast in gear to approximately 2 mph

above the test speed;

(c) shift to neutral; and

(d) when the test speed is reached, apply the service brakes.

* * * * *

S7.5 Service brake system-second effectiveness test. Repeat S7.3,

except for vehicles with a GVWR greater than 10,000 lbs. Then, for

vehicles with a GVWR of 10,000 pounds or less, make four stops from 80

mph if the speed attainable in 2 miles is not less 84 mph.

* * * * *

3. Section 571.121 is amended by revising the definitions of

``Directly Controlled Wheel'' and ``Full-treadle brake application'' in

S4; by adding the definition for ``Maximum treadle travel'' in S4; and

by revising S5.1.6.2, S5.2.3.2, S5.2.3.3, S5.3.1, S5.3.6, S5.3.6.1, and

S5.7.1 to read as follows:

Sec. 571.121 Standard No. 121; Air Brake Systems.

* * * * *

S4.* * *

Directly Controlled Wheel means a wheel for which the degree of

rotational wheel slip is sensed, either at that wheel or on the axle

shaft for that wheel and corresponding signals are transmitted to one

or more modulators that adjust the brake actuating forces at that

wheel. Each modulator may also adjust the brake actuating forces at

other wheels that are on the same axle or in the same axle set in

response to the same signal or signals.

* * * * *

Full-treadle brake application means a brake application in which

the treadle valve pressure in any of the valve's output circuits

reaches 85 psi within 0.2 seconds after the application is initiated,

or in which maximum treadle travel is achieved within 0.2 seconds after

the application is initiated.

* * * * *

Maximum treadle travel means the distance that the treadle moves

from its position when no force is applied to its position when the

treadle reaches a full stop.

* * * * *

S5.1.6.2 Antilock Malfunction Signal.

(a) Each truck tractor manufactured on or after March 1, 1997 and

each single unit vehicle manufactured on or after March 1, 1998 shall

be equipped with an indicator lamp, mounted in front of and in clear

view of the driver, which is activated whenever there is a malfunction

that affects the generation or transmission of response or control

signals in the vehicle's antilock brake system. The indicator lamp

shall remain activated as long as such a malfunction exists, whenever

the ignition (start) switch is in the ``on'' (run) position, whether or

not the engine is running. Each message about the existence of such a

malfunction shall be stored in the antilock brake system after the

ignition switch is turned to the ``off'' position and automatically

reactivated when the ignition switch is again turned to the ``on''

position. The indicator lamp shall also be activated as a check of lamp

function whenever the ignition is turned to the ``on'' or ``run''

position.

[[Page 63980]]

The indicator lamp shall be deactivated at the end of the check of lamp

function unless there is a malfunction or a message about a malfunction

that existed when the key switch was last turned to the ``off''

position.

(b) Each truck tractor manufactured on or after March 1, 1997, and

each single unit vehicle manufactured on or after March 1, 1998 that is

equipped to tow another air-braked vehicle, shall be equipped with an

electrical circuit that is capable of transmitting a malfunction signal

from the antilock brake system(s) on one or more towed vehicle(s)

(e.g., trailer(s) and dolly(ies)) to the trailer ABS malfunction lamp

in the cab of the towing vehicle, and shall have the means for

connection of this electrical circuit to the towed vehicle. Each such

truck tractor and single unit vehicle shall also be equipped with an

indicator lamp, separate from the lamp required in S5.1.6.2(a), mounted

in front of and in clear view of the driver, which is activated

whenever the malfunction signal circuit described above receives a

signal indicating an ABS malfunction on one or more towed vehicle(s).

The indicator lamp shall remain activated as long as an ABS malfunction

signal from one or more towed vehicle(s) is present, whenever the

ignition (start) switch is in the ``on'' (run) position, whether or not

the engine is running. The indicator lamp shall also be activated as a

check of lamp function whenever the ignition is turned to the ``on'' or

``run'' position. The indicator lamp shall be deactivated at the end of

the check of lamp function unless a trailer ABS malfunction signal is

present.

(c) [Reserved]

* * * * *

S5.2.3.2 Antilock Malfunction Signal. Each trailer (including a

trailer converter dolly) manufactured on or after March 1, 1998 that is

equipped with an antilock brake system shall be equipped with an

electrical circuit that is capable of signalling a malfunction in the

trailer's antilock brake system, and shall have the means for

connection of this antilock brake system malfunction signal circuit to

the towing vehicle. The electrical circuit need not be separate or

dedicated exclusively to this malfunction signaling function. The

signal shall be present whenever there is a malfunction that affects

the generation or transmission of response or control signals in the

trailer's antilock brake system. The signal shall remain present as

long as the malfunction exists, whenever power is supplied to the

antilock brake system. Each message about the existence of such a

malfunction shall be stored in the antilock brake system whenever power

is no longer supplied to the system, and the malfunction signal shall

be automatically reactivated whenever power is again supplied to the

trailer's antilock brake system. In addition, each trailer manufactured

on or after March 1, 1998, that is designed to tow another air-brake

equipped trailer shall be capable of transmitting a malfunction signal

from the antilock brake system(s) of additional trailers in a

combination by means of its ABS malfunction signal circuit, and shall

have the means for connection of its ABS malfunction signal circuit to

the towed vehicle.

S5.2.3.3 Antilock Malfunction Indicator. In addition to the

requirements of S5.2.3.2, each trailer (including a trailer converter

dolly) manufactured on or after March 1, 1998 and before March 1, 2006,

shall be equipped with an external indicator lamp that is activated

whenever there is a malfunction that affects the generation or

transmission of response or control signals in the trailer's antilock

brake system. The indicator lamp shall remain activated as long as such

a malfunction exists, whenever power is supplied to the antilock brake

system. Each message about the existence of such a malfunction shall be

stored in the antilock brake system whenever power is no longer

supplied to the system, and the malfunction signal shall be

automatically reactivated when power is again supplied to the trailer's

antilock brake system. The indicator lamp shall also be activated as a

check of lamp function whenever power is supplied to the antilock brake

system and the vehicle is stationary. The indicator lamp shall be

deactivated at the end of the check of lamp function unless there is a

malfunction or a message about a malfunction that existed when power

was last supplied to the antilock brake system.

* * * * *

S5.3.1 Stopping distance--trucks and buses. When stopped six times

for each combination of vehicle type, weight, and speed specified in

S5.3.1.1, in the sequence specified in Table I, each truck tractor

manufactured on or after March 1, 1997 and each single unit vehicle

manufactured on or after March 1, 1998 shall stop at least once in not

more than the distance specified in Table II, measured from the point

at which movement of the service brake control begins, without any part

of the vehicle leaving the roadway, and with wheel lockup permitted

only as follows:

(a) At vehicle speeds above 20 mph, any wheel on a nonsteerable

axle other than the two rearmost nonliftable, nonsteerable axles may

lock up, for any duration. The wheels on the two rearmost nonliftable,

nonsteerable axles may lock up according to (b).

(b) At vehicle speeds above 20 mph, one wheel on any axle or two

wheels on any tandem may lock up for any duration.

(c) At vehicle speeds above 20 mph, any wheel not permitted to lock

in (a) or (b) may lock up repeatedly, with each lockup occurring for a

duration of one second or less.

(d) At vehicle speeds of 20 mph or less, any wheel may lock up for

any duration.

Table I.--Stopping Sequence

1. Burnish.

2. Stops on a peak friction coefficient surface of 0.5: (a) With

the vehicle at gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR), stop the vehicle

from 30 mph using the service brake, for a truck tractor with a loaded

unbraked control trailer. (b) With the vehicle at unloaded weight plus

up to 500 lbs., stop the vehicle from 30 mph using the service brake,

for a truck tractor.

3. Manual adjustment of the service brakes allowed for truck

tractors, within the limits recommended by the vehicle manufacturer.

4. Other stops with vehicle at GVWR:

(a) 60 mph service brake stops on a peak friction coefficient

surface of 0.9, for a truck tractor with a loaded unbraked control

trailer, or for a single-unit vehicle.

(b) 60 mph emergency brake stops on a peak friction coefficient of

0.9, for a single-unit vehicle. Truck tractors are not required to be

tested in the loaded condition.

5. Parking brake test with the vehicle loaded to GVWR.

6. Manual adjustment of the service brakes allowed for truck

tractors and single-unit vehicles, within the limits recommended by the

vehicle manufacturer.

7. Other stops with the vehicle at unloaded weight plus up to 500

lbs.

(a) 60 mph service brake stops on a peak friction coefficient

surface of 0.9, for a truck tractor or for a single-unit vehicle.

(b) 60 mph emergency brake stops on a peak friction coefficient of

0.9, for a truck tractor or for a single-unit vehicle.

8. Parking brake test with the vehicle at unloaded weight plus up

to 500 lbs.

9. Final inspection of service brake system for condition of

adjustment.

S5.3.6 Stability and Control During Braking-Truck Tractors. When

stopped four consecutive times for each combination of weight, speed,

and road conditions specified in S5.3.6.1 and

[[Page 63981]]

S5.3.6.2, each truck tractor manufactured on or after March 1, 1997

shall stop at least three times within the 12-foot lane, without any

part of the vehicle leaving the roadway.

S5.3.6.1 Using a full-treadle brake application for the duration

of the stop, stop the vehicle from 30 mph or 75 percent of the maximum

drive-through speed, whichever is less, on a 500- foot radius curved

roadway with a wet level surface having a peak friction coefficient of

0.5 when measured on a straight or curved section of the curved roadway

using an American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) E1136

standard reference tire, in accordance with ASTM Method E1337-90, at a

speed of 40 mph, with water delivery.

* * * * *

S5.7.1 Emergency brake system performance. When stopped six times

for each combination of weight and speed specified in S5.3.1.1, except

for a loaded truck tractor with an unbraked control trailer, on a road

surface having a PFC of 0.9, with a single failure in the service brake

system of a part designed to contain compressed air or brake fluid

(except failure of a common valve, manifold, brake fluid housing, or

brake chamber housing), the vehicle shall stop at least once in not

more than the distance specified in Column 5 of Table II, measured from

the point at which movement of the service brake control begins, except

that a truck-tractor tested at its unloaded vehicle weight plus up to

500 pounds shall stop at least once in not more than the distance

specified in Column 6 of Table II. The stop shall be made without any

part of the vehicle leaving the roadway, and with unlimited wheel

lockup permitted at any speed.

* * * * *

Issued on: December 8, 1995.

Ricardo Martinez,

Administrator.

[FR Doc. 95-30375 Filed 12-11-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-59-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.