Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Occupant Crash Protection

Federal RegisterNov 9, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

49 CFR Part 571

[Docket No. 74-14; Notice 97]

RIN 2127--AG14

Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Occupant Crash Protection

AGENCY: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), DOT.

ACTION: Request for comments.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: Air bags are now standard equipment in millions of passenger

cars, light trucks, sport utility vehicles, and vans and widely

regarded to be a noteworthy safety advance, especially in higher speed

crashes. However, air bags--even air bags with a lap/shoulder belt

being used--are not a cure-all for every type of injury in crashes. The

agency is aware of situations in which current air bag designs have

undesired side effects. These include situations in which an air bag

appears to have contributed to serious injuries and even death to

vehicle occupants.

This document is intended to inform the public about NHTSA's

actions to minimize these adverse side effects and to invite the public

to share information and views with the agency.

DATES: Comments must be received by December 26, 1995.

ADDRESSES: Comments should refer to the docket and notice number of

this notice and be submitted to: Docket Section, Room 5109, National

Highway Traffic Safety Administration, 400 Seventh Street, SW,

Washington, DC 20590. (Docket Room hours are 9:30 a.m.-4 p.m., Monday

through Friday.)

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Stephen R. Kratzke, Office of Vehicle

Safety Standards, NPS-10, National Highway Traffic Safety

Administration, 400 Seventh Street, SW, Washington, DC 20590. Mr.

Kratzke can be reached by telephone at (202) 366-5203 or by fax at

(202) 366-4329.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Air bags are being offered on more and

more light vehicles (i.e., cars, pickup trucks, vans, and sport

utility vehicles). A decade ago, very few vehicles offered air bags

and those that did were almost exclusively expensive luxury cars.

In response to public demand, nearly every 1996 model year

passenger car will be equipped with dual air bags as standard

equipment. Installation of air bags is being accomplished in

advance of federal statutory requirements that dual air bags be

provided in all 1998 and later model year cars, and all 1999 and

later model year light trucks and vans.

Air bags have an impressive overall performance record. Since 1987,

they are estimated to have saved 911 lives. NHTSA estimates that in

1994 alone, air bags saved 374 lives. The agency fully expects these

numbers to continue to increase.

The agency emphasizes that the presence of an air bag does not mean

that it is less important for occupants to use their safety belts. Air

bags are supplemental restraints. The primary means of occupant

restraint, the safety belt, works in all types of crashes and is

particularly effective in preventing ejection, where the air bag has

limited benefits. NHTSA estimates that in 1994, safety belts saved

almost 9,200 lives and prevented more than 211,000 moderate

[[Page 56555]]

to critical injuries. The combination of wearing safety belts and

having an air bag installed at a seating position provides vehicle

occupants with maximum safety protection in all types of crashes.

Applying appropriate scientific techniques, NHTSA has been

carefully monitoring the real world performance of air bags, including

any side effects, for more than a decade. The agency published an

Evaluation Plan for front-seat occupant protection in January 1990 (55

FR 1586; January 17, 1990), which calls for periodic interim analyses

of effectiveness (a final evaluation of effectiveness will not be

possible until after air bags have been standard equipment for some

time on high production volume cars). An Interim Evaluation Report,

including analyses of fatality and injury reductions, was published in

June 1992. The agency also submitted a Report to Congress on this

subject in November 1992. The agency's analyses indicated that air bags

are producing benefits for vehicle occupants. NHTSA plans to update its

interim analyses of effectiveness early in 1996.

NHTSA's National Center for Statistics and Analysis (NCSA) provides

comprehensive, high quality data on highway crashes. These data are

used to relate human, vehicle, environmental, and roadway

characteristics to crash frequency and the severity of injuries

sustained in those crashes. NCSA has developed several programs for

providing these data. The Fatal Accident Reporting System (FARS)

provides basic information on all highway crashes in the U.S. in which

one or more people die of their injuries within 30 days of a crash. The

National Accident Sampling System (NASS) provides information from

investigations of a statistical sample of police reported crashes at

all levels of injury severity. As part of NASS, detailed investigations

of 5,000 highway crashes are conducted annually to provide information

on crash dynamics, injury mechanisms, and consequences of those

mechanisms, and to support occupant protection research and rulemaking.

To supplement the NASS system, the Special Crash Investigation Program

conducts from 50 to 75 in-depth investigations per year, concentrating

on crashes involving air bag deployments. Paper copies of individual

investigations and electronic data files are available to the public.

For more information contact NCSA at (202) 366-5394.

In addition, NHTSA's Office of Research and Development has a

number of on-going projects examining specific air bag issues. A

discussion of these projects can be found in the technical paper

discussed later in this notice.

There are certain situations in which air bags can have adverse

side effects. As more and more vehicles are equipped with them, these

side effects have become better known to researchers. The agency wants

to act expeditiously to ensure that these adverse side effects of air

bags are minimized or eliminated.

This notice summarizes what NHTSA knows about side effects of air

bags and how it plans to minimize them in the future. NHTSA is also

asking manufacturers, insurers, members of the medical community, and

any other interested members of the public to share information about

air bag designs or experience.

In a frontal crash, the occupant moves forward toward the

windshield and instrument panel prior to air bag deployment. The air

bag inflator must produce enough energy to inflate the air bag fully in

about 25 milliseconds to ``cushion'' the occupant before the occupant

strikes the vehicle interior. The energy necessary to inflate the air

bag in such a short time interval can cause injury or even fatality to

an occupant who is not properly restrained, especially to children,

given their small stature and light weight.

The table below shows, in no particular order, the types of

situations in which the agency has some information suggesting there

may be a risk of serious injury to vehicle occupants from the air bag.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Seating position of Probable cause of

Group affected primary risk problem

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Unrestrained Small Statured Driver Position..... Proximity to Air Bag

and/or Older People. at Time of

Deployment.

Infants in Rear-Facing Child Passenger Position.. Proximity to Air Bag

Restraints. at Time of

Deployment.

Children Unrestrained in Passenger Position.. Proximity to Air Bag

Front Seat. at Time of

Deployment.

Out-of-Position Occupants... Driver and Passenger Proximity to Air Bag

Position. at Time of

Deployment

Persons with Disabilities... Driver Position..... Proximity to Air Bag

at Time of

Deployment;

Adaptive Equipment

between Air Bag and

Driver; Safety

Features in Vehicle

Must be Modified to

Accommodate

Adaptive Equipment.

Persons Experiencing Driver and Passenger Unknown; Under

Extremity Injuries. Position. Study.

------------------------------------------------------------------------

It appears from this table that the primary task is to reduce the

risk to occupants who are very near the air bag at the time of

deployment. Such actions, however, won't necessarily help persons with

disabilities.

NHTSA has already taken steps to address the problem of infants in

rear-facing child seats by warning parents of air bag/infant restraint

interaction problems through consumer advisories and warnings on infant

restraints, on sun visors, and in owner's manuals. NHTSA's position is

that rear-facing child seats should be used only in the rear seat of a

vehicle with a passenger-side air bag.\1\ In addition, on May 23, 1995,

NHTSA published a final rule amending Standard No. 208, Occupant Crash

Protection, to allow manufacturers the option of installing a manual

device that motorists could use to deactivate the front passenger-side

air bag in vehicles in which infant restraints can only fit in the

front seat.

\1\ A complete description of various steps NHTSA has taken to

address this problem can be found in a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking

published on October 7, 1994 (59 FR 51158).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

For air bag vehicles already on the road or being produced in this

model year, the agency's primary efforts will be directed at better

educating the public about the characteristics of air bags and the

steps which the public can take to minimize the likelihood of

experiencing adverse side effects from air bags. On October 27, 1995,

the agency issued a consumer advisory focusing on preventing children

from being injured. The consumer advisory recommends three specific

steps: (1) always restrain children properly, (2) put them in the back

seat whenever possible, and (3)

[[Page 56556]]

when they must ride in the front seat, move the seat back as far as

possible--away from the air bag. NHTSA will continue to work with state

safety officials, national safety and medical organizations, vehicle

manufacturers, insurers, and interested citizens to educate the public

in this area.

In addition, anyone with knowledge of an unusual injury or fatality

resulting from a low speed or other crash involving an air bag-equipped

vehicle is urged to report this information to NHTSA's Auto Safety

Hotline at (800) 424-9393 or (202) 366-0123.

For vehicles manufactured far enough in the future to incorporate

significant design changes, NHTSA believes that there will be

technological enhancements available that could minimize the unintended

side effects of air bags. Vehicle manufacturers and air bag suppliers

are now working on highly advanced air bags, often called ``smart

bags.'' These smart bags include advanced technologies for occupant

sensing, phased deployment of air bags, and so forth. These

technologies will be able to perform a number of functions, including

preventing air bag deployment when they sense that an occupant is too

close to the point of deployment, inflating the air bag at different

speeds according to the severity of the crash, and preventing the bag

from deploying in the absence of an occupant at that seating position.

Based on discussions with suppliers and vehicle manufacturers, NHTSA

anticipates these types of smart bags will eventually be widely

incorporated into production. The agency will step up its monitoring of

manufacturer efforts to use smart bags, especially the technologies

being explored, the practicability and reliability of smart bag

systems, and the timetables for availability of smart bag systems.

While NHTSA anticipates that these smart bag systems will

substantially minimize adverse side effects of air bags in the not too

distant future, this still leaves the question of what can be done in

addition to public education for the near future. Manufacturers may be

able to make adjustments to existing air bag systems. Further, NHTSA

may be able to make temporary adjustments to its regulations if it is

shown to be necessary to enable manufacturers to minimize any adverse

side effects during this period.

For example, Ford has requested that NHTSA amend its crash testing

procedures in Standard No. 208. The standard currently requires test

dummies to be protected in a 30 mile per hour (mph) crash both when

wearing safety belts and when not wearing the belts (i.e., protected by

the air bag alone). Ford asked that the test speed for the unbelted

dummies be lowered to 25 mph, while the test speed for the belted

dummies be raised to 35 mph. According to Ford, this change would allow

manufacturers to better ``tune'' the interaction between the air bag

and the safety belt so as to optimize the protection afforded to

occupants who use their belts. Ford stated that the current testing

procedure forces manufacturers to base occupant protection designs

solely on the air bag, rather than the interaction between the air bag

and the belt. Ford believes that such a change can reduce air bag-

induced injuries.

In response to this request, NHTSA prepared a detailed preliminary

technical assessment of the issues presented in Ford's request. This

technical assessment sets forth the agency's knowledge with respect to

injuries from air bags. To help move public discussion forward in this

area, NHTSA has placed copies of its technical assessment of the Ford

request in the public docket for this rulemaking. Interested members of

the public are invited to comment on the Ford proposal and to review

this assessment to gain a better understanding both of what is known

and of what is not known by NHTSA about injuries from deploying air

bags, as well as the agency's plans for further research and data

analyses in this area. Copies of the technical assessment can be

obtained from the Docket Section at the address given above or by

telephone at (202) 366-4949.

The agency hopes that this request for comments will help the

agency obtain the information needed to make reasoned decisions about

whether some regulatory changes are needed for the interim period,

whether some simple technological fixes are available to minimize side

effects until smart bags become a reality, or whether other activities,

such as consumer information, offer the best chance of effectively

minimizing these side effects.

Persons with disabilities may have problems with air bags in

addition to those that result primarily from their proximity to the air

bag at the time of deployment. While many drivers with disabilities may

have a problem because of having to sit very near the steering wheel,

they may also face unique problems because of the special adaptive

equipment needed to allow them to drive. This adaptive equipment may

reduce the protection afforded by air bags by interfering with their

deployment. In September 1994, the agency issued a consumer advisory

cautioning drivers with disabilities not to use steering control

devices mounted on a bar installed across the steering wheel hub (a

``spanner bar'').

Light trucks that meet certain criteria, defined as ``vehicles

manufactured for operation by persons with disabilities,'' are not

required to provide automatic protection until September 1, 1997.

Automatic protection may be either an air bag or an automatic belt. As

a practical matter, NHTSA believes that light truck manufacturers will

install air bags as the only type of automatic protection in their 1998

model year vehicles because of the Federal law that requires air bags

in all their vehicles as of September 1, 1998 (the 1999 model year).

NHTSA does not now have sufficient data to allow the agency to decide

if air bags will pose any unique problems for drivers with disabilities

because of the interaction with the special adaptive equipment needed

to allow people with disabilities to drive. However, the agency will

conduct testing during fiscal year 1996 to examine this subject in

detail. This testing will allow NHTSA to take any necessary regulatory

and/or consumer information actions before the current exclusion for

drivers with disabilities expires in September 1997.

Questions for the Public

To aid the agency in obtaining useful comments, NHTSA is including

an appendix to this notice which consists of a number of specific

questions and requests for data. For easy reference, the questions are

numbered consecutively. NHTSA encourages commenters to provide specific

responses for each question for which they may have information or

views. In addition, in order to facilitate tabulating the comments by

issue, the agency encourages commenters to respond to the questions in

sequence, and to identify the number of each question to which they are

responding.

NHTSA requests that commenters provide as specific a rationale as

possible, including an analysis of safety consequences, for any

positions that are taken. Commenters with a technical background are

encouraged to provide scientific analysis of these matters. The

automobile manufacturers and air bag component and system suppliers are

requested to define major milestones for future plans and give

estimated completion dates. The agency appreciates that much of this

information may be confidential business information and will treat it

in accordance with statutory requirements.

[[Page 56557]]

The list of questions does not purport to be an all inclusive list

of items or information which the public may have available and believe

is valuable in assessing the issues. Commenters are encouraged to

provide any other data that they believe are relevant.

Public Meeting

NHTSA anticipates holding one or more public meetings on this

subject after the written comments have been received.

Rulemaking Analyses and Notices

Executive Order 12866 and DOT Regulatory Policies and Procedures

This document seeks public input on possible regulatory and

nonregulatory responses to an emerging issue. It does not contain any

regulatory changes that have so far been identified as sufficiently

likely to warrant calculation of possible benefits and costs. The task

of calculating costs is further complicated by the fact that while some

of the regulatory changes would mandate changes to existing air bag

designs, those changes would not involve the addition or deletion of

easily identifiable design elements or features. NHTSA has not analyzed

the impact of this notice under E.O. 12866 and the Department of

Transportation's regulatory policies and procedures. If at some time in

the future the agency proposes some regulatory action, it will make the

determinations in connection with that future action.

Executive Order 12612 (Federalism)

NHTSA has analyzed this notice in accordance with the principles

and criteria contained in E.O. 12612, and has determined that it does

not have significant federalism implications to warrant the preparation

of a Federalism Assessment.

Submission of Comments

Interested persons are invited to submit comments. It is requested

but not required that 10 copies be submitted.

All comments must not exceed 15 pages in length. (49 CAR 553.21).

Necessary attachments may be appended to these submissions without

regard to the 15-page limit. This limitation is intended to encourage

commenters to detail their primary arguments in a concise fashion.

If a commenter wishes to submit certain information under a claim

of confidentiality, three copies of the complete submission, including

purportedly confidential business information, should be submitted to

the Chief Counsel, NHTSA, at the street address given above, and seven

copies from which the purportedly confidential information has been

deleted should be submitted to the Docket Section. A request for

confidentiality should be accompanied by a cover letter setting forth

the information specified in the agency's confidential business

information regulation. 49 CAR part 512.

All comments received before the close of business on the comment

closing date indicated above will be considered, and will be available

for examination in the docket at the above address both before and

after that date. To the extent possible, comments filed after the

closing date will also be considered. Comments will be available for

inspection in the docket. The NHTSA will continue to file relevant

information as it becomes available in the docket after the closing

date, and it is recommended that interested persons continue to examine

the docket for new material.

Those persons desiring to be notified upon receipt of their

comments in the rules docket should enclose a self-addressed, stamped

postcard in the envelope with their comments. Upon receiving the

comments, the docket supervisor will return the postcard by mail.

List of Subjects in 49 CFR Part 571

Imports, Motor vehicle safety, Motor vehicles.

(Authority: 49 U.S.C. 322, 30111, 30115, 30117, and 30166;

delegation of authority at 49 CFR 1.50)

Issued on November 6, 1995.

Barry Felrice,

Associate Administrator for Safety Performance Standards.

Appendix--List of Questions

Field Experience With Air Bags

As discussed above, NHTSA relies on data from FARS and NASS,

including the Special Crash Investigation Program, to monitor air

bag performance in crashes. However, the public, particularly

insurers, vehicle manufacturers, and the medical community may have

information that would supplement the NHTSA data regarding air bag

performance in crashes.

1. Please provide any available air bag performance information

in the following areas, separately for each calendar year from 1987

to the present 2:

2 September 1, 1986 was the start of the phase-in of

automatic protection for all new passenger cars. Automatic

protection means a vehicle must offer either air bags or automatic

belts. Accordingly, 1987 was the first year for which any

substantial number of vehicles with air bags were on the road.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

a. The total number of air bag deployments in crashes during the

calendar year;

b. The air bag deployments in crashes for each make/model of

vehicle;

c. The total number of air bag deployments in crashes in which

the crash severity was 15 mph or less or in which little damage

occurred to the vehicle; and

d. Any cases of deployment in which the air bag may have

contributed to serious injuries or fatalities for occupants - if

such cases are identified, please provide details about the position

in which the occupant was seated (driver or passenger position), the

injured person's gender, age, height, and weight, whether the

occupant was belted, unbelted, or in a child restraint, and the

source for this information (e.g., police report, insurance claim,

hospital report, etc.).

e. Any cases of deployment in which the air bag may have saved

lives, prevented injuries or reduced injury severity, etc.

NHTSA requests that when insurance companies provide data about

field experience, it would be very helpful if they would include the

number of vehicles they insured in each calendar year (insured

vehicle years).

2. What information is available concerning the reduction or

increase in different types of injuries and injury severities that

may be associated with the introduction of air bags? The medical

community is especially requested to respond to this question.

Crash Sensing

NHTSA's data indicate that situations in which air bags appear

to have contributed to serious or fatal injuries have occurred at

crash severities below 15 mph, some even below 10 mph, with minimal

damage to the vehicle. The agency is asking the public to provide

information that would help NHTSA assess the range of deployment

thresholds currently chosen by vehicle manufacturers for their

different vehicles, why those differences exist, and the

manufacturers' efforts to adjust and redefine the algorithms used to

determine whether the air bag should deploy. Specifically, the

agency would like to learn:

3. What algorithms and calibrations do manufacturers use to

determine when the air bag should deploy in each of their vehicles?

4. What are the reasons why that threshold for air bag

deployment was chosen (e.g., corresponds to the speed at which an

unbelted occupant would experience facial fractures from steering

wheel, speed at which unbelted occupant would be likely to

experience serious chest injuries, etc.)?

5. NHTSA believes that manufacturers generally specify different

deployment thresholds for different vehicles. Is this belief correct

and, if so, what are the reasons why different deployment thresholds

are specified (e.g., more interior room in vehicle, different

intended use of vehicle, different target purchasers, etc.)?

6. How do the deployment thresholds specified for different

vehicles correlate to the speed the thresholds represent in a

frontal crash test into a fixed rigid barrier?

Air Bag Inflators

Ford indicated in its request to the agency that it could reduce

the air bag inflator onset

[[Page 56558]]

rate simply by decreasing the amount of propellant contained in the

inflator. Ford said that such a change could be made quickly and

would, in Ford's opinion, reduce the incidence of air bag-induced

injuries, particularly to upper extremities, and allow more optimal

tuning of current safety belt systems.

7. Please provide as detailed information as possible about

current air bag inflators, including inflator tank pressure curves,

the effect of reduced propellant on those pressure curves and the

overall performance of the inflator, and inflators that use dual or

multiple staged inflation. The agency is particularly interested in

learning why manufacturers have chosen the particular

characteristics for the inflators used in their vehicles (e.g.,

cost, simplicity, etc.) and the leadtime that would be needed to

change inflator characteristics in production vehicles.

Air Bag Design

NHTSA knows that there are many variables in air bag design that

may affect the performance of air bag systems in the field. The

agency would like to learn if there are data that indicate any of

these variables significantly affect the performance of air bag

systems. The variables NHTSA has identified thus far include:

--Air Bag Volume

--Air Bag Fold Patterns

--Air Bag Tethering

--Air Bag Venting

--Air Bag Mass/Material

--Shape and Size of Air Bag Module Opening

--Module location and deployment path

To help answer questions about these variables, NHTSA would like

to learn:

8. What are the parameters for each of the above variables on

the air bags used in current vehicles?

9. To the extent that a manufacturer uses different parameters

on different vehicles, what are the reasons for the difference?

10. What other variables not identified above affect air bag

performance, and what is the basis for that belief?

11. What is the estimated leadtime needed to change each of

these variables in production vehicles, and what are the reasons for

why such leadtime is needed?

Proximity Considerations

Most of the fatalities involving air bags have occurred to

children and small statured adults who were unbelted or otherwise

improperly restrained, possibly out of position, and very close to

the air bag at deployment. To assist the agency in identifying

possible approaches to mitigate the problem in these circumstances,

the public is asked to provide any data or information that may be

available on the following subjects:

12. Is there a quantified minimum safe distance from the

inflator nozzle/air bag at the time of deployment for air bags

generally or for any particular air bag designs? If so, please

provide that information and the data in support of that distance.

For the following questions, NHTSA is especially interested in

all the data and information that support the response given. In

addition, the agency would like the public to identify the trade-

offs that would be involved in taking any of these actions.

13. Do ``top mounted'' air bags substantially reduce the adverse

side effects at the passenger position?

14. Can the adverse side effects be substantially reduced by

recessing the inflator/air bag either in the steering wheel assembly

or in the dash?

15. Would displacement of the inflator away from the occupant at

deployment substantially reduce the adverse side effects?

16. Would pedal adjusters (which move the pedals closer to the

driver and allow the driver's arms instead of leg length to

determine how close the driver must sit) reduce adverse side effects

of air bags by allowing drivers to sit further back?

17. Would telescoping and/or tilt steering wheel assemblies

substantially reduce the adverse side effects of air bags?

18. Can advanced sensors, which would either sound a warning or

not deploy when an occupant was too close to an air bag,

substantially reduce the adverse side effects of air bags?

19. Would safety belt pre-tensioners reduce the risk of air bag

deployment injuries?

20. What laboratory test procedures and devices do manufacturers

use and find appropriate to assess inflation hazards to occupants in

close proximity to the driver or passenger air bag?

Near Term Considerations

The agency would like to know if there are near term (six months

to one year) changes which could significantly reduce the

probabilities of the serious injuries and fatalities attributed to

air bag deployment. The agency is aware that some possible near term

changes to air bags could involve safety tradeoffs; i.e., reducing

certain types of injuries while allowing increases in others,

offering higher protection at higher speeds at the expense of lower

speed crashes, or protecting certain types of occupants (e.g.,

belted or those of small stature) at the expense of others (e.g.,

unbelted or large occupants). The agency would like to obtain

information on possible near term changes and any safety tradeoffs

associated with such changes. NHTSA is particularly interested in

the effects of any potential changes on particular groups, such as

young adults and children, and occupants of the growing light truck

and van market, where belt use has traditionally been lower.

21. What would be the safety consequences of permitting manual

air bag cut-off switches? Are there policy or other considerations

that warrant treating the driver's and passenger's positions

differently? How difficult would it be to retrofit such devices for

vehicles on the road?

22. It seems that a change in deployment threshold could be made

relatively quickly simply by modifying the calibration of the

sensors or the algorithm used for deployment. What is the estimated

leadtime needed to change the deployment threshold used in current

air bag designs, and why is that amount of leadtime needed to make

such a change?

23. What would be the safety consequences of a reduction or

modification of the inflation rate?

24. How quickly can the manufacturers develop module locations

that are recessed in the steering wheel or the instrument panel?

Future Plans

The agency is aware that much effort is underway to develop

various levels of ``smart'' air bag systems. These smart air bag

systems may range from dual threshold sensors that deploy the bag at

different crash severities by recognizing whether the occupant is

restrained or unrestrained (such systems are already in some luxury

vehicles) to systems that include items such as:

Variable inflation rates

Occupant seat sensors

Proximity detection/sensing

Dual or multi-stage inflators/sensors

Dual or variable venting, etc.

25. Please provide detailed information concerning the

technologies and strategies being considered in each of the above

areas, as well as any other advanced air bag concepts, and the

potential and expected dates of implementation.

Obstacles to Near and Long Term Plans

26. The agency requests information and explanations of any

obstacles that may hinder advancements in reaching near or long term

solutions to these problems. These could include or require changes

in present regulations or the development of new regulations. Please

provide recommendations for any agency actions that could be

beneficial, the rationale for that action, and its safety

consequences (quantified, if possible).

27. As discussed above, Ford has requested that the agency

reduce FMVSS 208's unbelted test speed from 30 mph to 25 mph.

According to Ford, this would make it easier for it to reduce the

air bag inflation speed, thereby reducing low speed air bag

injuries.

a. If NHTSA were to make a short-term change in FMVSS 208 to

facilitate quick reductions in air bag inflation speeds (i.e., a

change that would apply until manufacturers can implement smart air

bags or other design changes to address low speed air bag injuries),

how would manufacturers respond? What would be the specific safety

consequences of such a change, including possible adverse

consequences for unbelted occupants and for occupants in much higher

speed crashes?

b. A reduction in FMVSS 208's unbelted test speed might not be

the only way to facilitate quick reductions in air bag inflation

speeds. For example, NHTSA could possibly retain the 30 mph unbelted

test but temporarily increase the chest loading maximum of 60 g's

for that test. FMVSS No. 208 currently specifies the same chest

loading maximum for both the belted and unbelted tests. The agency

notes that a preliminary review of recent biomechanical data

generated for NHTSA suggests that the human tolerance to

acceleration for serious chest injury may be higher for air bags

than for belts, because the air bag delivers a more broadly

distributed, uniform loading to the chest than does a safety belt.

Would

[[Page 56559]]

manufacturers respond to this type of change differently than for the

change suggested by Ford? What would be the specific safety

consequences of such a change, including possible adverse

consequences?

Air Bag Issues Related to Persons With Disabilities

28. What has been the experience in modifying air bag-equipped

vehicles to be driven by persons with disabilities? What type of

problems have been encountered? Have the drivers been pleased with

the results?

29. Has any person with a disability that you know of been

involved in a crash in which the air bag deployed at his or her

seating position?

30. Were any of these persons apparently saved from serious

injury by the air bag? If so, please describe the situation.

31. Has any person with a disability been injured by the

deployment of an air bag in a vehicle (mpv, car or truck)? If so,

please provide as much information as possible on the event.

32. Is it very common that children with disabilities (whether

small enough to use a child seat or not) must for health reasons sit

in the front seat to be near the driver, when the driver is the only

adult in the vehicle. Of these, how many can not use conventional

seat belts, or child seats, due to their disabilities?

33. How many persons in the U.S. use steering control devices

mounted on steering wheels containing air bags? What is your source

of data, or how would you estimate this number?

34. What types of conditions in persons with disabilities would

make them more susceptible to injury from an air bag (driver or

passenger) than any other person in the same seating position? Would

these people also be more susceptible to seat belt-induced injury?

[FR Doc. 95-27781 Filed 11-6-95; 11:29 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-59-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.