Student Assistance General Provisions

Federal RegisterSep 21, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUMMARY: The Secretary proposes to amend the Student Assistance General

Provisions (General Provisions) regulations. The General Provisions

regulations govern elements common to all the Federal Student Financial

Aid programs authorized by Title IV of the Higher Education Act of

1965, as amended (HEA) (hereafter Title IV Programs). These amendments

would modify the Secretary's Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL)

Program default reduction initiative and implement default prevention

measures in the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan (Direct Loan)

Program. These regulations would streamline the Secretary's ability to

take limitation, suspension, and termination (L,S, and T) action

against an institution and would prevent an institution from evading

the consequences of a high FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct

Loan Program cohort rate, or weighted average cohort rate.

DATES: Comments must be received on or before October 31, 1995.

ADDRESSES: All comments concerning these proposed regulations should be

addressed to Mr. Douglas Laine, Program Specialist, Direct Loan Policy

Group, Policy Development Division, U.S. Department of Education, P.O.

Box 23272, Washington, DC 20026-3272. Comments may also be sent through

the internet to [email protected].

To ensure that public comments have maximum effect in developing

the final regulations, the Department urges that each comment clearly

identify the specific section or sections of the regulations that the

comment addresses and that comments be in the same order as the

regulations.

Comments that concern information collection requirements must be

sent to the Office of Management and Budget at the address listed in

the Paperwork Reduction Act section of this preamble. A copy of those

comments may also be sent to the Department representative named in the

preceding paragraph.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mr. Douglas Laine, Program Specialist,

Direct Loan Policy Group, Policy Development Division, U.S. Department

of Education, 600 Independence Avenue, SW, room 3045, Regional Office

Building 3, Washington, DC 20202-5400, telephone: (202) 708-9406.

Individuals who use a telecommunications device for the deaf (TDD) may

call the Federal Information Relay Service (FIRS) at 1-800-877-8339

between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m., Eastern time, Monday through Friday.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Background

The Secretary is proposing to revise 34 CFR part 668 to enhance the

Secretary's FFEL Program default reduction initiative and provide

additional default prevention measures in the Direct Loan Program. The

Secretary first published regulations to begin the FFEL Program default

reduction initiative on June 5, 1989. This gave the Department the

authority to take action to limit, suspend or terminate an

institution's participation in the Title IV programs based on a high

FFEL Program cohort default rate. The June 5, 1989 regulations provided

that the Department may take L, S, and T action against an institution

if it has an FFEL Program cohort default rate that exceeds 40 percent.

On July 19, 1991, the Secretary further expanded the default

reduction initiative to reflect new legislation that made an

institution ineligible to participate in the FFEL Program if that

institution had a high FFEL Program cohort default rate for three

consecutive years, unless the institution could demonstrate to the

Secretary that exceptional mitigating circumstances would make the loss

of eligibility inequitable. Currently, under that legislation, an

institution is subject to the loss of eligibility if it has an FFEL

Program cohort default rate that equals or exceeds 25 percent for three

consecutive fiscal years. Under the exceptional mitigating

circumstances criteria in the Department's regulations, an institution

may appeal this loss of eligibility if it can demonstrate to the

satisfaction of the Secretary that it has a completion and placement

rate of at least 66.6 percent, and either less than 15 percent of its

students borrow under the FFEL Program or at least 66.6 percent of its

students come from economically disadvantaged backgrounds.

The Direct Loan Program was authorized by the Omnibus Budget

Reconciliation Act of 1993 (Pub. L. 103-66) with the first loans made

in July 1994. When the Direct Loan Program was authorized, the statute

mandating the calculation of FFEL Program cohort default rates was not

revised to include Direct Loan Program loans. Moreover, the statute

authorizing the Direct Loan Program does not specifically require the

Secretary to calculate a similar rate for institutions that participate

in the Direct Loan Program or contain a specific provision under which

an institution would lose its eligibility to participate in the Direct

Loan Program based on a default rate. The Secretary has determined,

however, that it is appropriate to establish a measurement similar to

the FFEL cohort default rate in the Direct Loan Program. Therefore, the

Secretary is proposing in regulations to define a measurement similar

to the FFEL Program cohort default rate under the Direct Loan Program,

a ``cohort rate'' for Direct Loans, and to establish similar

institutional eligibility requirements based on the repayment of Direct

Loans by the institution's former students. The Secretary is proposing

this change because FFEL Program cohort default rates have been a

useful measure of institutional performance and have provided the

Secretary an effective means to reduce defaults by removing high

default institutions from participation in the FFEL Program. The

potential loss of eligibility to participate in the FFEL Program based

on high FFEL Program cohort default rates provides a powerful incentive

for institutions to keep their FFEL Program cohort default rates low.

This has resulted in increased protection for students and taxpayers,

and has improved the integrity of the FFEL Program.

As in the FFEL Program, the Secretary proposes that exceptional

mitigating circumstances be taken into consideration in determining

whether an institution may continue to participate in the Direct Loan

Program on the basis of its cohort rate. Further, the Secretary is

proposing to modify the regulations for the FFEL Program to simplify

the cohort default rate appeal process and to establish fair and

reasonable measures for exceptional mitigating circumstances, while

reducing the substantial burden on institutions and the Department that

exists under the current regulations. Exceptional mitigating

circumstances under the Direct Loan and FFEL Programs would be the

same.

Finally, to make the L, S, and T process more effective, the

Secretary is proposing to streamline the current L, S, and T procedures

and to limit the grounds on which the institution may appeal when the

L, S, or T action is warranted by high default rates. The current L, S,

and T procedures are exceedingly lengthy and have not effectively

protected students and Federal taxpayers from institutions

[[Page 49179]]

whose high FFEL Program cohort default rates are evidence of abuse of

the Title IV programs. Additionally, the Secretary is proposing to

prescribe timeframes that would reduce the amount of time an L, S, and

T action would take to complete. Finally, the Secretary is proposing to

remove the ``Appendix D defense'' which contains measures for an

institution to follow to help the institution to reduce its cohort

default rate. The Secretary believes that the measures included in the

Appendix D defense, while effective for helping an institution reduce

its default rate, do not support the continuation of a high FFEL

Program cohort default rate institution's participation in the Title IV

programs. The Secretary is proposing that the only means by which an

institution may successfully appeal an L, S, and T action against its

participation in the Title IV programs is to demonstrate to the hearing

officer that its FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program

cohort rate, or if applicable, weighted average cohort rate, is

inaccurate, and that a correct recalculation of the rate would result

in the institution having a rate that is beneath the thresholds that

make the institution subject to L, S, and T action.

Proposed Regulatory Changes

Due to the complex nature of these proposed regulations, a chart is

provided in each major section of the preamble that provides an

overview of the proposed changes.

Section 668.17 Default Reduction and Prevention Measures

L, S, and T Authority. The proposed regulations would provide the

Secretary with the authority to take L, S, and T action against an

institution if it has an FFEL Program cohort default rate, a Direct

Loan Program cohort rate, or, if applicable, a weighted average cohort

rate that is greater than 40 percent for a fiscal year. The Secretary

is proposing this 40 percent threshold to make his authority to take L,

S, and T action against an institution participating in the Direct Loan

Program comparable with such authority under the FFEL Program.

The proposed regulations would also provide the Secretary with the

authority to take L, S, and T action against an institution's

participation in the FFEL Program if it has any combination of an FFEL

Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or, if

applicable, a weighted average cohort rate that equals or exceeds 25

percent for three consecutive fiscal years. Having a combination of

these rates for three consecutive fiscal years is analogous to having

FFEL Program cohort default rates that exceed the thresholds for three

consecutive years. The Secretary is proposing this measure to prevent

an institution that would not be eligible to participate in the Direct

Loan Program based on consecutively high Direct Loan Program cohort

rates or weighted average cohort rates from participating in the FFEL

Program. The Secretary believes that this action is consistent with the

statutory requirement that institutions with consecutively high default

rates lose their eligibility to participate in the FFEL Program.

Action Taken Against Schools by Type of Rate

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Type of rate Direct loan program schools FFEL program schools

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

40+ percent FFEL Program cohort default rate, L, S, and T for Title IV..... L, S, and T for Title IV.

Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or weighted

average cohort rate for one year.

25 percent or greater Direct Loan Program cohort Loss of eligibility for L, S, and T for FFEL Program.

rate for three consecutive years. Direct Loan Program.

25 percent or greater weighted average cohort rate Loss of eligibility for L, S, and T for FFEL Program.

for three consecutive years. Direct Loan Program.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Direct Loan Program cohort rate and weighted average cohort rate.

The Secretary proposes to calculate a Direct Loan Program cohort rate

or weighted average cohort rate to use as a measure to determine if an

institution should remain eligible to participate in the Direct Loan

Program. The Secretary is proposing to use different formulas to

calculate these rates for different sectors of institutions.

For a public institution, private nonprofit institution, or degree-

granting proprietary institution, the Secretary proposes to calculate a

Direct Loan Program cohort rate or weighted average cohort rate based

on the number of an institution's current and former students who enter

repayment on a Direct Loan in a fiscal year and who, by the end of the

following fiscal year, are in default on those loans. This is the same

formula the Secretary is required by section 435(a) of the HEA to use

to calculate cohort default rates under the FFEL Program.

For non-degree-granting proprietary institutions, the Secretary is

proposing to calculate Direct Loan Program cohort rates or weighted

average cohort rates based on the percentage of students who enter

repayment in a fiscal year and who, by the end of the following fiscal

year, are either in default or are in repayment under the income

contingent repayment (ICR) plan, and have scheduled monthly payments

that are less than $15 per month, and that payment is less than the

interest that is accruing on the loan (i.e., in negative amortization).

If there are both FFEL Program and Direct Loan Program loans

entering repayment in the institution's cohort, the Secretary will

calculate a weighted average cohort rate for the institution. As in the

FFEL Program, the Secretary will base the Direct Loan Program cohort

rate or weighted average cohort rate on borrowers, not loans. For

example, if a student enters repayment on both FFEL Program and Direct

Loan Program loans so as to be in the same cohort, the student will be

counted only once in the calculation used to calculate the rate.

However, an institution will continue to have an FFEL Program cohort

default rate as long as it has former students entering repayment on

FFEL Program loans. Such an institution will continue to be subject to

loss of eligibility to participate in the FFEL Program or be subject to

L, S, and T action based on its FFEL Program cohort default rate.

A ``weighted average'' cohort rate is calculated by taking the

percentage of students who entered repayment on FFEL Program and Direct

Loan Program loans in a fiscal year received for attendance at the

institution (or on the portion of a loan made under the Federal Direct

Consolidation Loan or Federal Consolidation Loan Programs that is used

to repay those loans), who are in default before the end of the fiscal

year immediately following the year in which they entered repayment,

and, for non-degree-granting institutions, are in repayment under the

income contingent

[[Page 49180]]

repayment plan at the end of that following fiscal year and have

scheduled payments that are less than $15 per month and that payment

results in negative amortization.

Borrowers Included in Types of Rates

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Type of institution Type of rate Defaulted borrowers ICR component

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Public, private-nonprofit, and FFEL Program Cohort Default Rate. Yes................. No.

degree-granting proprietary

institutions.

Direct Loan Program Cohort Rate.. Yes................. No.

Weighted Average Cohort Rate..... Yes................. No.

Non-Degree-Granting Proprietary FFEL Program Cohort Default Rate. Yes................. No.

Institutions.

Direct Loan Program Cohort Rate.. Yes................. Yes.

Weighted Average Cohort Rate..... Yes................. Yes.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If an institution has less than 30 former students entering

repayment in a fiscal year on Direct Loan and FFEL Program loans

received at that institution, the Secretary will calculate the

institution's Direct Loan Program cohort rate or weighted average

cohort rate for that fiscal year based on the institution's former

students who enter repayment on their Direct Loans or FFEL Program

loans over the three most recent fiscal years.

A loan will be considered in default for purposes of a Direct Loan

Program cohort rate or weighted average cohort rate for all

institutions if a borrower or endorser has failed to make an

installment payment when due provided that this failure has persisted

for 270 days. The Secretary has chosen 270 days because this closely

approximates the date a default claim is paid under the FFEL Program.

The date a default claim is paid by a guaranty agency is used as the

date the loan defaults for FFEL Program cohort default rates. A loan

will not be considered in default if, after going into default, the

borrower has made 12 consecutive on-time monthly payments under 34 CFR

685.211(e) on the loan before the end of the fiscal year following the

fiscal year the loan entered repayment.

The Secretary has chosen to include a minimum payment component in

defining the Direct Loan Program cohort rate and weighted average

cohort rate for non-degree-granting proprietary institutions for

several reasons. The Secretary believes that this is an appropriate

performance-based measure to assess a borrower's ability to repay a

student loan and the institution's quality of training. The Secretary

is concerned that without such a measure an institution could have a

low Direct Loan Program cohort rate or weighted average cohort rate

when its former students are only making minimal payments on their

loans. The Secretary believes that this measure is needed to prevent an

institution from effectively avoiding the effects of its failure to

provide appropriate training by encouraging its students to repay their

loans under the ICR plan. Under the ICR plan, a borrower with a low

income may have scheduled monthly payments that are very low or zero.

The $15 payment rate was chosen because it is the approximate amount a

borrower would have to pay if his or her income is at the poverty level

as determined by the Department of Health and Human Services. The

Secretary believes that if a sufficient proportion of borrower incomes

is so low that the scheduled monthly payments for those borrowers under

the ICR program are less than $15 per month and those payment amounts

result in negative amortization, this is generally evidence that the

institution has not provided those borrowers with the education or

training needed to obtain gainful employment that can provide the

borrowers with sufficient incomes to repay the student loans incurred

to attend the institution. The Secretary believes that such loans would

likely go into default if the ICR plan were not available. The negative

amortization factor was included with the $15 dollar payment in order

to exclude from the default calculation borrowers with incomes much

higher than the poverty level who have small debts. The Secretary is

proposing to use the minimum payment rate for non-degree-granting

proprietary institutions because these institutions are in business to

provide students with education or training needed to secure

employment. A borrower's repayment schedule under the ICR plan will

directly reflect the value of the education or training provided by the

institution in the marketplace. Further, the former student borrowers

of non-degree-granting proprietary institutions are at the highest risk

of default among all the sectors of institutions and the Secretary

believes that for this reason, the use of the ICR plan by former

students of these institutions be closely monitored.

The Secretary invites public comment regarding the use of the

minimum payment under the ICR plan that may be used for the Direct Loan

Program cohort rate for certain sectors of institutions. In addition,

the Secretary is interested in knowing if the public believes the

Secretary should implement measures to prevent an institution from

evading the proposed rules under which a Direct Loan Program cohort

rate and weighted average cohort rate are calculated for non-degree-

granting proprietary institutions if such an institution switched to a

non-profit status. The Secretary is also interested in receiving public

comment regarding other possible measures that may be used to determine

if an institution should be able to continue to participate in the

Direct Loan Program or FFEL Program. The Secretary is especially

interested in public comment on the following possible alternative

measures to determine if an institution should continue to participate

in the Direct Loan Program: (1) A percentage of Direct Loan borrowers

paying under the ICR plan whose scheduled payments are less than the

amount of interest that accrues monthly on their loans, i.e., in

negative amortization, and (2) a percentage of the institution's former

students who are making payments under the ICR plan whose income is

less than a certain amount, such as $15,000 (because income is a major

factor in calculating monthly payments under the ICR plan).

The Secretary is also interested in public comment regarding a

measure for borrowers for whom payment has been deferred for an

extended period of time under the economic hardship or

[[Page 49181]]

unemployment deferment or forbearance. The Secretary is considering

using such a measurement to trigger L, S, and T action against an

institution participating in the FFEL and Direct Loan programs if a

high percentage of its former students have forborne repayment on their

loans or have deferred repayment on their loans for an extended period

of time because of unemployment or economic hardship. Similar to the

Secretary's concern that institutions may attempt to evade the

consequences of a high Direct Loan Program cohort rate or weighted

average cohort rate by encouraging students to use the ICR plan, the

Secretary is concerned that institutions are evading the consequences

of a high FFEL Program cohort default rate by encouraging and assisting

a high percentage of their former students to obtain deferments or

forbearance solely for the purpose of keeping their loans out of

default until the period the Department uses to calculate FFEL Program

cohort default rate has elapsed. Because a deferment or forbearance

generally lasts for one year, an institution generally needs to assist

a former student to obtain only one deferment or forbearance to ensure

that the former student does not default during the period the

Department uses to calculate the FFEL Program cohort default rate.

Finally, the Secretary specifically requests comment regarding how a

borrower who has a scheduled ICR payment of less than $15 and who would

qualify for the economic hardship deferment should be treated in the

Direct Loan Program cohort rate or weighted average cohort rate

calculation.

Loss of eligibility to continue to participate in the Direct Loan

Program. An institution with any combination of an FFEL Program cohort

default rate, a Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or a weighted average

cohort rate calculated by the Secretary that is equal to or greater

than 25 percent for three consecutive fiscal years would cease to be

eligible to participate in the Direct Loan Program beginning 30 days

from the date it receives notification of the loss of eligibility

unless it can demonstrate to the satisfaction of the Secretary that

exceptional mitigating circumstances would make the loss of eligibility

inequitable. The Secretary will place such an institution on

reimbursement until the 30th day following the institution's receipt of

the notification of the loss of eligibility or, if the institution

appeals, until the appeal is decided. Once the institution's appeal is

decided, the Secretary will take the institution off reimbursement only

if the appeal is successful. If the appeal is denied, the institution

will not be eligible to participate in the Direct Loan Program for the

remainder of the current fiscal year plus the following two fiscal

years.

Eligibility Status of Institutions With High Rates

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Type of rate Direct loan program FFEL program

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

25 percent or greater FFEL Program cohort default Loss of eligibility for Loss of eligibility for the

rate for three consecutive years. Direct Loan Program. FFEL Program.

25 percent or greater Direct Loan Program cohort Loss of eligibility for L,S, and T for FFEL Program

rate for three consecutive years. Direct Loan Program. only.

25 percent or greater weighted average cohort rate Loss of eligibility for L,S, and T for FFEL Program

for three consecutive years. Direct Loan Program. only.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Secretary has chosen to eliminate institutions from the Direct

Loan Program based on high cohort rates for several reasons. First, the

Secretary believes it is imperative that institutions that would have

high FFEL Program cohort default rates not be able to evade the

consequences of that rate by participating in the Direct Loan Program,

which currently has no default rate definition. Second, the Secretary

is firmly committed to protecting students and Federal taxpayers from

unscrupulous institutions that participate heavily in the loan programs

but do not provide quality educational services to their students. The

sanctions the Secretary is authorized to impose under the HEA and

regulations on institutions that participate in the FFEL Program have

proven to be a successful way to protect students, the Federal

taxpayer, and the integrity of the loan programs. Therefore, the

Secretary is proposing these regulations to provide him with the

authority to take similar actions against institutions that have a high

percentage of students that do not repay their Direct Loan Program

loans.

The Secretary does not have the authority to amend or add to the

definition of the FFEL Program cohort default rate because that

definition is specifically mandated in statute. The Secretary is,

therefore, prohibited from adding to the FFEL Program cohort default

rate a component that measures a minimum payment amount. The Secretary

also does not have the authority to immediately terminate an

institution's eligibility to participate in the FFEL Program if it has

a Direct Loan Program cohort rate or weighted average cohort rate that

equals or exceeds 25 percent for three consecutive years. This means

that an institution could have an FFEL Program cohort default rate of

25 percent or more for two years and a Direct Loan Program cohort rate

of 25 percent for one year and remain eligible for the FFEL Program

after it has lost its eligibility to participate in the Direct Loan

Program. In this case, the Secretary will take L, S, and T action

against the institution's participation in the FFEL Program.

Under these proposed rules, if an institution's former students

enter repayment under both the FFEL Program and the Direct Loan Program

in a fiscal year, the Secretary would calculate a weighted average

cohort rate to determine if an institution would lose its eligibility

to participate in the Direct Loan Program. The Secretary will continue

to use only FFEL Program loans to calculate an FFEL Program cohort

default rate for that institution which will trigger a statutory loss

of eligibility to participate in the FFEL Program. True equity between

the Direct Loan and FFEL programs on this issue would require a

statutory change that gives the Secretary authority to establish, in

regulations, institutional eligibility requirements for the FFEL

Program similar to the statutory authority for the Direct Loan Program,

thus allowing him to move quickly to terminate any institution's

participation in the FFEL Program when that institution's FFEL Program

cohort default rate, Direct Loan cohort rate, or weighted average

cohort rate warrants an action. The loss of eligibility provision in

section 435 (a) of the HEA does not authorize the Secretary to make an

institution ineligible to participate in the FFEL Program if it has

Direct Loan Program cohort rates or weighted average cohort rates that

exceed 25 percent for three consecutive years. However, under these

regulations, the

[[Page 49182]]

Secretary will consider excessive Direct Loan Program cohort rates or

weighted average cohort rates as a basis to take L, S, and T action

against an institution's participation in the FFEL Program.

In addition to establishing this strict eligibility requirement

under the Direct Loan Program, the Secretary will provide Direct Loan

institutions with certain tools to help manage and reduce their Direct

Loan Program cohort default rates. While the Secretary believes that

the repayment plans available under the Direct Loan Program, coupled

with the frequent borrower contact maintained by the Department's loan

servicing efforts, will result in fewer defaults than in the FFEL

Program, the Secretary is committed to developing, and making available

to institutions, tools that will enable them to work effectively with

borrowers to prevent defaults. These tools will include reports on

delinquent borrowers, access to borrower information on the toll-free

servicing telephone number, and free loan counseling materials for use

during both entrance and exit interviews with borrowers. The Secretary

invites public comment on the types and frequency of assistance that

institutions need to help prevent Direct Loan defaults.

Exceptional Mitigating Circumstances. The Secretary proposes to

modify the exceptional mitigating circumstances and the appeal process

under which an institution may appeal the statutory loss of its

eligibility to participate in the FFEL Program and the proposed loss of

its eligibility to participate in the Direct Loan Program. Exceptional

mitigating circumstances would be the same for both the Direct Loan and

FFEL Programs. The Secretary believes that the current standards for

exceptional mitigating circumstances are burdensome on an institution

and administratively difficult for the Department to administer. For

these reasons, the Secretary is proposing to change the exceptional

mitigating circumstances and require that any appeal based on an

exceptional mitigating circumstance be verified by an independent

auditor prior to its submission to the Secretary. Under the proposed

rules, any of the following criteria may be used as exceptional

mitigating circumstances:

Exceptional Mitigating Circumstances

1. Participation Rate Index equal to or less than 0.0375 (Rate

times percentage of students participating in the FFEL or Direct Loan

programs)

2. 70 percent or greater completion rate and 70 percent or more

students come from economically disadvantaged backgrounds, for public

or private-nonprofit institutions.

3. 50 percent or greater placement rate and 70 percent or more

students come from economically disadvantaged backgrounds, for

proprietary institutions.

Participation rate index: The participation rate index is

a new criterion based on an institution's FFEL Program cohort default

rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or weighted average cohort rate

and the percent of an institution's students who were enrolled on at

least a half-time basis that borrow under the FFEL or Direct Loan

programs. This rate would be calculated by multiplying the

institution's FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program

cohort rate, or, if applicable, its weighted average cohort rate by the

percent of the institution's students who were enrolled on at least a

half-time basis that borrowed under that loan program during a 12-month

period that ended during the six months immediately preceding the

fiscal year used to determine the cohort of borrowers for the

institution's rate. If this product is equal to or less than 0.0375,

the institution would meet an exceptional mitigating circumstance. The

Secretary has chosen 0.0375 as the participation rate index standard

because, under the current mitigating circumstances, a borrower

participation rate of 15 percent or less is acceptable as part of one

of the exceptional mitigating circumstances. A cohort default rate of

25 percent for three consecutive years was the minimum rate that would

trigger loss of eligibility. The Secretary has formulated the 0.0375

participation rate index criterion based on these percentages;

0.25 x 0.15=0.0375. Therefore the Secretary is proposing to use 0.0375

as the index.

For example, under this formula, an institution with an FFEL

Program cohort default rate of 28 percent and a student borrower

participation rate of 13 percent would be able to continue to

participate in the FFEL program because 0.28 x 0.13=0.0364, which is

less than 0.0375. The participation rate index criterion may be used by

any institution that has an FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct

Loan Program cohort rate, or, if applicable, a weighted average cohort

rate of less than 40 percent for the most recent fiscal year. In order

to appeal under this criterion, an institution would only need to

submit to the Secretary a statement certifying the number of its

students who were enrolled on at least a half-time basis during a 12-

month period that has ended during the six months immediately preceding

the fiscal year used to determine the cohort of borrowers for the

institution's borrower participation rate, and the number of those

students that borrowed under the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program,

along with identifying information for those borrowers so they may be

verified by the Secretary. In particular, the institution would need to

provide the Secretary with the name, address, and social security

number of each of those students. This will help the Department to

verify this information through the National Student Loan Data System.

Economically disadvantaged background rate and completion

or placement rate: This exceptional mitigating circumstance criterion

is derived from the current criteria which use completion rates,

placement rates and the percent of the institution's students from

economically disadvantaged backgrounds. Under this proposed rule, an

institution would meet this exceptional mitigating circumstance if it

can demonstrate that 70 percent or more of its student population, over

a 12-month period that ended during the six months immediately

preceding the fiscal year used to determine the cohort of borrowers for

the institution's FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program

cohort rate, or weighted average cohort rate, came from an economically

disadvantaged background, and either:

(1) For a public or private nonprofit institution, 70 percent of

its students who were enrolled on at least a half-time basis, and were

originally scheduled to complete their programs during a 12-month

period that has ended during the six months immediately preceding the

fiscal year used to determine the cohort of borrowers in the

institution's rate, have completed their programs; or

(2) For a proprietary institution, 50 percent of its students

originally scheduled to complete the programs during a 12-month period

that has ended during the six months immediately preceding the fiscal

year used to determine the cohort of borrowers used to calculate the

institution's rate are currently employed, or were employed for at

least 13 weeks, in an occupation related to the training they received,

or are enrolled in a higher level educational program at another

institution, or were enrolled such an institution for at least 13

weeks, for which the appealing institution's educational program

provided substantial preparation.

For purposes of the completion rate and placement rate, a student

is originally scheduled, at the time of

[[Page 49183]]

enrollment, to complete the educational program on the date when the

student will have been enrolled in the program for the amount of time

normally required to complete the program. The ``amount of time

normally required to complete the program'' is the period of time

specified in the institution's enrollment contract, catalog, or other

materials, for completion of the program by a full-time student, or the

period of time between the date of enrollment and the anticipated

graduation date appearing on the student's loan application, if any,

whichever is less.

For purposes of the completion rate, a student is considered to

have completed the program if the student received a degree,

certificate, or other recognized educational credential from the

institution, transferred to a higher level educational program at

another institution, or remained enrolled and was making satisfactory

academic progress toward completion of the educational program.

The Secretary has chosen a 50 percent placement rate based on the

completion rate and placement rate standards that are used to determine

if certain programs are eligible for purposes of the FFEL Program. See

section 481(e) of the HEA. This section mandates that such a program

have a verified completion rate of at least 70 percent and a verified

placement rate of 70 percent. The 50 percent threshold is derived from

these two percentages. If an institution has a 70 percent completion

rate and 70 percent of those students obtain employment in a relevant

occupation, the institution will have a 49 percent placement rate under

the proposed placement rate. The Secretary has chosen 50 percent

because he believes an institution should exceed this threshold to be

considered under an exceptional mitigating circumstance.

For purposes of the placement rate, a former student is considered

placed if the student is employed or had been employed for at least 13

weeks following his or her last day of attendance at the institution,

or enrolled in a higher level educational program at another

institution for which the appealing institution's educational program

provided substantial preparation.

The Secretary is proposing to remove the 15 percent or less student

loan borrower rate as well as the 66.6 percent completion rate and 66.6

placement rate as an exceptional mitigating circumstance. In place of

the loan borrower rate, the Secretary is proposing to add the

participation rate index criterion because he believes that, when an

institution has such a small percent of its students borrow under the

Direct Loan or FFEL Programs, borrower behavior may not reflect the

quality of education at the institution. An appeal under this criterion

is limited to institutions that have a Direct Loan Program cohort rate,

an FFEL Program cohort default rate, or, if applicable, a weighted

average cohort rate, that is less than 40 percent for a fiscal year.

When more than 40 percent of all students at an institution are not

repaying their loans, even if this percentage is based on a small

proportion of the student body, the Secretary considers the institution

to represent a significant financial risk for the taxpayers. Further,

the Secretary believes that future student borrowers at the institution

should be protected from the risks associated with borrowing Federal

loans to pay for attending the institution.

Under the current exceptional mitigating circumstances, an

institution can appeal if it has a completion rate of 66.6 percent or

more, a placement rate of 66.6 percent or more, and if 66.6 percent or

more of its students came from an economically disadvantaged

background. The proposed regulations would make an appeal less

burdensome to institutions because it would examine the completion,

placement, and economically disadvantaged rates of the institution's

former students over a shorter period of time. These modifications will

also make the students who are included in the completion, placement

and economically disadvantaged rates more representative of the

borrowers included in the cohort used to determine the institution's

FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or

weighted average cohort rate. Although the formula used for calculating

the completion rate and student population from economically

disadvantaged backgrounds is essentially the same, the institution

would only need to review students who attended the institution (or for

the completion rate, those students who were scheduled to complete

their programs), during the 12-month period that preceded the fiscal

year used to determine the cohort for the institution's FFEL Program

cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or weighted

average cohort rate. The current regulations require an institution to

review students over a 24-month period.

The Secretary is also proposing to modify the placement rate

criterion for appeals to make it available only to proprietary

institutions of higher education. The proposed placement rate will be

measured by using the percent of the institution's former students who

were scheduled to complete their programs, during a 12-month period

that ended during the six months immediately preceding the fiscal year

used to determine the cohort of borrowers for the institution's FFEL

Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or

weighted average cohort rate, who either received a job in an

occupation related to the training they received for at least 13 weeks

or transferred to a higher level educational program. The current

regulations base the placement rate on only those students who complete

their educational programs in a recent 24-month period chosen by the

institution. The Secretary has decided to use the students who were

scheduled to graduate during the 12-month period preceding the fiscal

year in which the cohort is determined for the institution's rate

because it will be more representative of the former students in that

cohort. The Secretary also believes that the calculation of a

completion rate in this fashion is more equitable for proprietary

institutions because students receiving training to obtain employment

in a particular field may gain such employment before they complete

their programs.

The Secretary is also proposing to revise the appeal procedures to

make them easier for the institutions as well as the Department to

manage while maintaining program integrity to ensure speedy resolution

of appeals. Under the current appeal process, to remain eligible to

participate in the FFEL Program during an appeal process, an

institution is required to notify the Secretary within seven days

following its receipt of its notification of the loss of eligibility

that it intends to appeal the loss. The institution must then submit

all the required information to support its appeal within 30 calendar

days following the notification of loss of eligibility. The Secretary

is proposing to remove from the regulations the requirement that the

institution notify the Secretary in writing within the seven days that

it intends to appeal in order to remain eligible during the appeal.

The Secretary is also proposing to remove the requirement that an

institution notify the Secretary that it has requested verification of

its FFEL Program cohort default rate data from the relevant guaranty

agencies. Under the proposed regulations, an institution would remain

eligible to participate in the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program

during the appeal if it submits a complete and accurate appeal, under

the guidelines for exceptional mitigating

[[Page 49184]]

circumstances or inaccurate data, within 30 days from the date it is

notified by the Secretary that it is no longer eligible to participate

in the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program.

Under the current regulations, if an institution requests

verification of the data used to determine its cohort default rate from

a guaranty agency, the institution remains eligible to participate in

the FFEL Program until the guaranty agency verifies the data. Under the

proposed rules, an institution would not remain eligible to participate

beyond the 30-day period if the Secretary has not received the verified

data by the 30th day following the notification of loss of eligibility.

The Secretary believes that the new procedures for issuance and review

of draft FFEL Program cohort default rates, that allow an institution

to review the draft rates for error prior to the issuance of the

official rates, will significantly improve the accuracy of the official

FFEL Program cohort default rate. The Secretary will provide Direct

Loan Program institutions with Direct Loan Program cohort rates, or if

applicable, weighted average cohort rates, a similar opportunity to

review the data used to determine those rates to ensure that they are

accurate before the rates are made official. An institution should be

able to resolve any additional discrepancies it believes exist in the

FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan cohort rate, or weighted

average cohort rate within 30 days.

Exceptional Mitigating Circumstances Appeal Process

Institution receives notice that its participation in the

FFEL or Direct Loan program will end in 30 days unless the institution

appeals.

The institution must submit a complete written appeal

within 30 days after receiving the notice of loss of eligibility. An

appeal will not be accepted after the 30th day.

The Secretary issues a final decision on the institution's

appeal within 45 days after receiving the appeal.

No oral hearing is provided.

Subpart G--Fine, Limitation, Suspension, and Termination Proceedings

The proposed rules would provide the Secretary with the authority

to take L, S, and T action against an institution that has a Direct

Loan Program cohort rate or weighted average cohort rate that is

greater than 40 percent for a fiscal year. The Secretary believes that

such an authority is needed to protect students and taxpayers from

abuse of the Direct Loan Program. The Secretary has chosen a 40 percent

Direct Loan Program cohort rate to parallel the 40 percent default rate

threshold that triggers L, S, and T action against an institution that

participates in the FFEL Program under 34 CFR 668.17(a)(1). Further,

under the proposed rules, the Secretary could initiate an L, S, or T

action against an institution's participation in the FFEL Program if it

has a combination of an FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan

Program cohort rate, or, if applicable, weighted average cohort rate

that equals or exceeds 25 percent for three consecutive years. For

example, an L, S, and T action could be taken against the institution

if it has an FFEL Program cohort default rate that equals or exceeds 25

percent for one fiscal year, and a weighted average cohort rate for

each of the two following fiscal years that equals or exceeds 25

percent. Such an institution is not subject to statutory loss of

eligibility to participate in the FFEL Program. The Secretary is

proposing this provision to prevent an institution that has lost its

eligibility to participate in the Direct Loan Program, or attempts to

evade a potential loss of eligibility to participate in the Direct Loan

Program, from participating in the FFEL Program. The Secretary believes

that such an institution presents an unreasonable risk to students and

the Federal taxpayer. Under the proposed rules, the Secretary will

cease any L, S, and T action against an institution's participation in

the FFEL Program if that institution successfully appeals its loss of

eligibility to participate in the Direct Loan Program under exceptional

mitigating circumstances.

The Secretary is also proposing to revise the procedures and

appeals for an L, S, and T action he may initiate when an institution

has an FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort

rate, or, if applicable, a weighted average cohort rate above 40

percent for a fiscal year or a combination of an FFEL Program cohort

default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate or weighted average

cohort rate that equals or exceeds 25 percent for three consecutive

fiscal years. Under these revised procedures, an institution would have

30 days to notify the designated department official that it intends to

appeal the L, S, or T; otherwise the action would become effective on

the 31st day. If the institution intends to appeal, it may request a

hearing or it may send written material to the designated department

official within 30 days after it receives notice of the Secretary's

intent to initiate L, S, or T action. If a hearing is requested, the

hearing officer must schedule a hearing within 15 days of the date the

institution notifies the designated department official that it

requests the hearing.

The designated department official or the hearing officer may only

consider the accuracy of the institution's FFEL Program cohort default

rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or, if applicable, the weighted

average cohort rate to determine if the L, S, or T action should be

upheld or dismissed. In light of the extensive process for determining

default rates, the institution will have the burden of proving that the

calculation of the rate was wrong. The Secretary believes it is

appropriate to presume that the rates are accurate unless the

institution can present clear and convincing evidence that the rate

identified in the notice of intent is not final (i.e., the default rate

appeal is pending) or does not accurately reflect the final rate

determined by the Department. The designated department official or the

hearing officer shall issue a final determination to uphold or dismiss

the L, S, or T action within 30 days after the date the written

material is received by the designated department official or the date

the hearing is concluded, whichever is later.

In addition to streamlining the L, S, and T process, the Secretary

is proposing to eliminate Appendix D as a defense from L, S, and T

action. Appendix D was created to protect institutions from the

consequences of L, S, and T action while they took action to reduce

their FFEL Program cohort default rates. The Secretary believes that

institutions have had ample time to exercise the measures provided in

this section to reduce their FFEL Program cohort default rates and keep

them low. The Secretary does not believe that the implementation of

default reduction measures by an institution justifies the continued

participation of a high default institution in the Title IV programs.

However, the Secretary encourages institutions to continue to implement

these measures to keep their default rates low.

Streamlined L, S, and T Procedures

Institution receives notice stating that the L, S, or T

action will be effective in 30 days unless the institution requests a

hearing.

Institution must request the hearing prior to the

effective date.

The hearing will be scheduled within 15-20 days after the

request is received.

[[Page 49185]]

The institution may appeal the proposed action only on the

basis of the accuracy of the rate.

The L, S, and T action is effective 30 days after the

hearing if the hearing officer decides the action is warranted.

Executive Order 12866

1. Assessment of Costs and Benefits

These proposed regulations have been reviewed in accordance with

Executive Order 12866. Under the terms of the order the Secretary has

assessed the potential costs and benefits of this proposed regulatory

action.

The potential costs associated with the proposed regulations are

those resulting from statutory requirements and those determined by the

Secretary to be necessary for administering the Title IV, HEA programs

effectively and efficiently. Burdens specifically associated with

information collection requirements, if any, are explained elsewhere in

this preamble under the heading of Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995.

In assessing the potential costs and benefits--both quantitative

and qualitative--of these proposed regulations, the Secretary has

determined that the benefits of the proposed regulations justify the

costs.

The Secretary has also determined that this regulatory action does

not unduly interfere with State, local, and tribal governments in the

exercise of their governmental functions.

To assist the Department in complying with the specific

requirements of Executive Order 12866, the Secretary invites comment on

whether there may be further opportunities to reduce any potential

costs or increase potential benefits resulting from these proposed

regulations without impeding the effective and efficient administration

of the Title IV, HEA programs.

2. Clarity of the Regulations

Executive Order 12866 requires each agency to write regulations

that are easy to understand.

The Secretary invites comments on how to make these regulations

easier to understand, including answers to questions such as the

following: (1) Are the requirements in the regulations clearly stated?

(2) Do the regulations contain technical terms or other wording that

interferes with their clarity? (3) Does the format of the regulations

(grouping and order of sections, use of headings, paragraphing, etc.)

aid or reduce their clarity? Would the regulations be easier to

understand if they were divided into more (but shorter) sections? (A

``section'' is preceded by the symbol ``Sec. '' and a numbered heading;

for example, Sec. 668.17 Default Reduction and Prevention Measures) (4)

Is the description of the proposed regulations in the ``Supplementary

Information'' section of this preamble helpful in the understanding of

the proposed regulations? How could this description be more helpful in

making the proposed regulations easier to understand? (5) What else

could the Department do to make the regulations easier to understand?

A copy of any comments that concern whether these proposed

regulations are easy to understand should also be sent to Stanley

Cohen, Regulations Quality Officer, U.S. Department of Education, 600

Independence Avenue, SW., (Room 5100 FB-10), Washington, D.C. 20202.

Regulatory Flexibility Act Certification

The Secretary certifies that these proposed regulations would not

have a significant economic impact on a substantial number of small

entities. Certain reporting, recordkeeping, and compliance requirements

are imposed on institutions by the regulations. These requirements,

however, would not have a significant impact because the regulations

would not impose excessive regulatory burdens or require unnecessary

Federal supervision.

Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995

Section 668.17 contains information collection requirements. As

required by the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1995 (44 U.S.C. 3507(d)),

the Department of Education has submitted a copy of this section to the

Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for its review.

Collection of Information: Exceptional Mitigating Circumstances

Appeals

The Student Assistance General Provisions regulations codify the

procedures and the exceptional mitigating circumstances criteria under

which an institution may appeal a loss of eligibility to participate in

the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program. The information to be

collected may include one of the following: (1) For the participation

rate index, the number of an institution's students enrolled on at

least a half-time basis who enrolled in the appealing institution

during a 12-month period and the number of those students who borrowed

under the FFEL and Direct Loan programs during that 12-month period and

the name, address and social security number of those students; (2) for

the completion rate, the number of an institution's students who were

scheduled to complete their programs in a 12-month period and the name,

address and social security number and, if applicable, the name of the

institution and program to which the student transferred, for each of

those students who actually completed; (3) for the placement rate, the

number of students who were scheduled to complete their programs during

a 12-month period and the name, address, social security number, job

title, dates during which the student was employed, and the employer's

name and address for all those students who obtained employment in an

occupation related to the education or training received. The

Department needs and uses the information to determine whether the

institution may continue to participate in the FFEL or Direct Loan

programs.

All information is to be collected and reported only once and only

if the institution has a FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan

Program cohort rate or weighted average cohort rate that equals or

exceeds 25 percent for three consecutive fiscal years. Annual public

reporting and recordkeeping burden contained in the collection of

information proposed in these regulations is estimated to be 80 hours

per response for 200 respondents (total annual reporting and

recordkeeping burden equals 16,000 hours) including the time for

reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and

maintaining the data needed, completing and reviewing collection of

information, and submitting materials.

Organizations and individuals desiring to submit comments on the

information collection requirements should direct them to the Office of

Information and Regulatory Affairs, OMB, Room 10235, New Executive

Office Building, Washington, DC 20503; Attention: Desk Officer for U.S.

Department of Education.

The Department considers comments by the public on this proposed

collection of information in--

Evaluating whether the proposed collection of information

is necessary for the proper performance of the functions of the

Department, including whether the information will have practical use;

Evaluating the accuracy of the Department's estimate of

the burden of the proposed collection of information, including the

validity of the methodology and assumptions used;

Enhancing the quality, usefulness, and clarity of the

information to be collected; and

Minimizing the burden of the collection of information on

those who are to respond, including through the

[[Page 49186]]

use of appropriate automated, electronic, mechanical, or other

technological collection techniques or other forms of information

technology, e.g., permitting electronic submission of responses.

OMB is required to make a decision concerning the collection of

information contained in these proposed regulations between 30 and 60

days after publication of this document in the Federal Register.

Therefore, a comment to OMB is best assured of having its full effect

if OMB receives it within 30 days of publication. This does not affect

the deadline for the public to comment to the Department on the

proposed regulations.

Invitation to Comment

Interested persons are invited to submit comments and

recommendations regarding these proposed regulations. All comments

submitted in response to these proposed regulations will be available

for public inspection, during and after the comment period, in room

3045, Regional Office Building 3, 7th and D Streets, SW., Washington,

DC, between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 4 p.m., Monday through Friday of

each week except federal holidays.

Assessment of Educational Impact

The Secretary particularly requests comments on whether the

proposed regulations in this document would require transmission of

information that is being gathered by or is available from any other

agency or authority of the United States.

List of Subjects in 34 CFR Part 668

Administrative practice and procedure, Colleges and universities,

Consumer protection, Education, Grant programs-education, Loan

programs-education, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements, Student

aid, Vocational education.

Dated: September 14, 1995.

Richard W. Riley,

Secretary of Education.

(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Numbers: 84.007 Supplemental

Educational Opportunity Grant Program; 84.032 Stafford Loan Program;

84.032 PLUS Program; 84.032 Supplemental Loans for Students Program;

84.033 College Work-Study Program; 84.038 Perkins Loan Program;

84.063 Pell Grant Program; 84.069 State Student Incentive Grant

Program; and 84.226 Income Contingent Loan Program)

The Secretary proposes to amend part 668 of title 34 of the Code of

Federal Regulations as follows:

PART 668--STUDENT ASSISTANCE GENERAL PROVISIONS

1. The authority citation for part 668 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 20 U.S.C. 1085, 1088, 1091, 1092, 1094, and 1148,

unless otherwise noted.

2. Section 668.17 is amended by redesignating paragraphs (f), (g),

and (h) as paragraphs (g), (h) and (i) respectively, and revising

paragraphs (a) through (f) to read as follows:

Sec. 668.17 Default reduction and prevention measures.

(a) Default rates. (1) If the FFEL Program cohort default rate,

Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or if applicable, weighted average

cohort rate for an institution exceeds 20 percent for any fiscal year,

the Secretary notifies the institution of that rate.

(2) The Secretary may initiate a proceeding under subpart G of this

part to limit, suspend, or terminate the participation of an

institution in the Title IV, HEA programs, if--

(i) For an institution whose former students enter repayment only

on FFEL Program loans in a fiscal year, the FFEL Program cohort default

rate for that institution exceeds 40 percent for that fiscal year;

(ii) For an institution whose former students enter repayment only

on Direct Loan Program loans in a fiscal year, the Direct Loan Program

cohort rate for that institution exceeds 40 percent for that fiscal

year; or

(iii) For an institution that has both FFEL Program and Direct Loan

Program loans entering repayment in the same fiscal year, the weighted

average cohort rate for that institution exceeds 40 percent for that

fiscal year.

(3) Unless an institution is subject to loss of eligibility to

participate in the FFEL Program under paragraph (b)(1) of this section,

the Secretary initiates a proceeding under subpart G of this part to

limit, suspend, or terminate an institution's participation in the FFEL

Program if the institution, for three consecutive fiscal years, has a

combination of--

(i) An FFEL Program cohort default rate that is equal to or greater

than 25 percent if only FFEL loans enter repayment in that cohort;

(ii) A Direct Loan Program cohort rate that is equal to or greater

than 25 percent if only Direct Loan Program loans enter repayment in

that cohort; or

(iii) A weighted average cohort rate that is equal to or greater

than 25 percent if both FFEL Program and Direct Loan Program loans

enter repayment in that cohort.

(4) The Secretary may require an institution that meets the

criteria under paragraph (a)(2) of this section to submit to the

Secretary, within a timeframe determined by the Secretary, any

reasonable information to help the Secretary make a preliminary

determination as to what action should be taken against the

institution.

(5) The Secretary will cease any limitation, suspension, or

termination action against an institution under paragraph (a)(3) of

this section if the institution satisfactorily demonstrates to the

Secretary that, pursuant to a timely submitted appeal under paragraph

(b)(6) of this section, the institution meets one of the exceptional

mitigating circumstances under paragraph (c)(1)(ii) of this section.

(b) End of participation. (1) Except as provided in paragraph

(b)(6) of this section, an institution's participation in the FFEL

Program ends 30 days after the date the institution receives

notification from the Secretary that its FFEL Program cohort default

rate for each of the three most recent fiscal years for which the

Secretary has determined the institution's rate, is equal to or greater

than 25 percent.

(2) Except as provided in paragraph (b)(6) of this section, an

institution's participation in the Direct Loan Program ends 30 days

after the date the institution receives notification from the Secretary

that for each of the three most recent fiscal years the institution has

any combination of--

(i) An FFEL Program cohort default rate that is equal to or greater

than 25 percent if only FFEL Program loans enter repayment in that

cohort;

(ii) A Direct Loan Program cohort rate that is equal to or greater

than 25 percent if only Direct Loan Program loans enter repayment in

that cohort; or

(iii) A weighted average cohort rate that is equal to or greater

than 25 percent if both FFEL Program and Direct Loan Program loans

enter repayment in that cohort.

(3) Except as provided in paragraph (b)(6) of this section, an

institution whose participation in the FFEL Program or Direct Loan

Program ends under paragraph (b)(1) or (2) of this section respectively

may not participate in that program on or after the 30th day after the

date it receives notification from the Secretary that its FFEL Program

cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or, if

applicable, weighted average cohort rate exceeds the thresholds

specified in paragraph (b)(1) or (2) of this section and continuing--

(i) For the remainder of the fiscal year in which the Secretary

determines that

[[Page 49187]]

the institution's participation has ended under paragraph (b)(1) or (2)

of this section; and

(ii) For the two subsequent fiscal years.

(4) An institution whose participation in the FFEL Program or

Direct Loan Program ends under paragraph (b)(1) or (2) of this section

may not participate in that program until the institution satisfies the

Secretary that the institution meets all requirements for participation

in the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program and executes a new agreement

with the Secretary for participation in that program following the

period described in paragraph (b)(3) of this section.

(5) Until July 1, 1998, the provisions of paragraph (b)(1) or (2)

of this section and the provisions of Sec. 668.16(m) do not apply to a

historically black college or university within the meaning of section

322(2) of the HEA, a tribally controlled community college within the

meaning of section 2(a)(4) of the Tribally Controlled Community College

Assistance Act of 1978, or a Navajo community college under the Navajo

Community College Act.

(6) An institution may, notwithstanding Sec. 668.26, continue to

participate in the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program, if the

Secretary receives an appeal that is complete, accurate, and timely in

accordance with paragraph (c) of this section.

(c) Appeal procedures. (1) An institution may appeal the loss of

participation in the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program under

paragraph (b)(1) or (2) of this section by submitting an appeal in

writing to the Secretary that must be received by the 30th calendar day

following the date the institution receives notification of the end of

participation. The institution may appeal on the grounds that--

(i)(A) The calculation of the institution's FFEL Program cohort

default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or, if applicable,

weighted average cohort rate, for any of the three fiscal years

relevant to the end of participation is not accurate; and

(B) A recalculation of the institution's FFEL Program cohort

default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or weighted average

cohort rate, with corrected data verified by the cognizant guaranty

agency or agencies for the FFEL Program loans, or the Secretary for

Direct Loan Program loans would produce an FFEL Program cohort default

rate, a Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or weighted average cohort

rate for any of those fiscal years that is below the threshold

percentage specified in paragraph (b) (1) or (2) of this section; or

(ii) The institution meets one of the following exceptional

mitigating circumstances:

(A) The institution has a participation rate index of 0.0375 or

less. The participation rate index is determined by multiplying the

institution's FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program

cohort rate or, if applicable, weighted average cohort rate, by the

percentage of the institution's students who were enrolled on at least

a half-time basis who received a loan made under either the FFEL

Program or Direct Loan Program, for a 12-month period that has ended

during the six months immediately preceding the fiscal year for which

the cohort of borrowers used to calculate the institution's rate is

determined.

(B) For a 12-month period that has ended during the six months

immediately preceding the fiscal year for which the cohort of borrowers

used to calculate the institution's rate is determined, 70 percent or

more of the institution's students who are enrolled on at least a half-

time basis are individuals from disadvantaged economic backgrounds, as

established by documentary evidence submitted by the institution. Such

evidence must relate to either qualification by those students for an

expected family contribution (EFC) of zero for any award year that

generally coincides with the 12-month period, or attribution to those

students of an adjusted gross income of the student and his or her

parents or spouse, if applicable, reported for any award year that

generally coincides with the 12-month period, of less than the poverty

level, as determined under criteria established by the Department of

Health and Human Services.

(1) For a public or private nonprofit institution, 70 percent or

more of the institution's students who were initially enrolled on a

full-time basis, and were scheduled to complete their programs during a

12-month period that has ended during the six months immediately

preceding the fiscal year for which the cohort of borrowers used to

calculate the institution's rate is determined, completed the

educational programs in which they were enrolled. This rate is

calculated by comparing the number of students who were classified as

full-time at their initial enrollment in the institution and were

originally scheduled, at the time of enrollment, to complete their

programs within the relevant 12 month period, with the number of these

students who received a degree, certificate, or other recognized

educational credential from the institution; transferred from the

institution to a higher level educational program at another

institution for which the prior program provided substantial

preparation; or, at the end of the 12-month period, remained enrolled

and were making satisfactory academic progress toward completion of

their educational programs; or

(2) For a proprietary institution, the institution had a placement

rate of 50 percent or more with respect to its former students who were

enrolled in a program to receive a degree, certificate, or other

recognized educational credential from the institution, and who

remained in the program beyond the point the students would have

received a 100 percent tuition refund from the institution. This rate

is based on those students who were scheduled to complete their

educational programs during the 12-month period ending prior to the

fiscal year for which the cohort for the institution's rate is

determined. This rate is calculated by determining the percentage of

all those students who, based on evidence submitted by the institution,

are, on the date the institution submits the appeal, employed, or had

been employed for at least 13 weeks following their last day of

attendance at the institution, in the occupation for which the

institution provided training, or are enrolled, or had been enrolled

for at least 13 weeks following receipt of the credential from the

institution, in a higher level educational program at another

institution for which the prior educational program provided

substantial preparation.

(2) For purposes of the completion rate and placement rate

described in paragraph (c)(1)(ii)(B) (1) and (2) of this section, a

student is originally scheduled, at the time of enrollment, to complete

the educational program on the date when the student will have been

enrolled in the program for the amount of time normally required to

complete the program. The ``amount of time normally required to

complete the program'' is the period of time specified in the

institution's enrollment contract, catalog, or other materials, for

completion of the program by a full-time student, or the period of time

between the original date of enrollment and the anticipated graduation

date appearing on the student's loan application, if any, whichever is

less.

(3) The Secretary issues a decision on the institution's appeal

within 45 days after the institution submits a complete appeal that

addresses the applicable criteria in paragraph (c)(1)(i) or (ii) of

this section to the Secretary.

(4) The Secretary's decision is based on the consideration of

written material

[[Page 49188]]

submitted by the institution. No oral hearing is provided.

(5) The Secretary withdraws the notification of loss of

participation in the FFEL Program or Direct Loan Program sent to an

institution under paragraph (b)(1) or (2) of this section, if he

determines that the institution's appeal satisfies one of the grounds

specified in paragraph (c)(1)(i) or (ii) of this section.

(6) An institution must include in its appeal a certification by

the institution's chief executive officer that all information provided

by the institution in support of its appeal is true and correct.

(7) An institution that appeals on the grounds that it meets the

exceptional mitigating circumstances criteria contained in paragraph

(c)(1)(ii) of this section must include in its appeal the following

information:

(i) A written statement from an independent auditor that the

information contained in the appeal is complete, accurate and

determined in accordance with the requirements of this section;

(ii) For purposes of the participation index under paragraph

(c)(1)(ii)(A) of this section--

(A) A statement indicating the number of students who were enrolled

on at least a half-time basis at the institution in the relevant 12-

month period; and

(B) The name, address, and social security number of each of the

institution's current and former students who received Federal

Stafford, Federal SLS, or Direct Loan Program loans during that 12-

month period.

(iii) For purposes of the institution's percentage of students

coming from disadvantaged economic backgrounds under paragraph

(c)(1)(ii)(B) of this section:

(A) The number of students who were enrolled on at least a half-

time basis at the institution in the relevant 12-month period; and

(B)(1) If EFC is used to determine if a student comes from an

economically disadvantaged background, the name, address, and social

security number, of each student with an EFC of zero, for an award year

that, in whole or part, coincides with the relevant 12-month period,

who was enrolled on at least a half-time basis at the institution in

the relevant 12-month period; or

(2) If poverty level income as determined by the Department of

Health and Human Services is used to measure an economically

disadvantaged background, the name, address, and social security number

of each student with an adjusted gross income, or attribution to that

student of an adjusted gross income of that student and his or her

parents or spouse, if applicable, reported for the most recent calendar

year that is less than the poverty level, and documentation of that

income.

(iv) For purposes of the completion rate under paragraph

(c)(1)(ii)(B)(1) of this section--

(A) The number of students who were initially enrolled on a full-

time basis at the institution and were scheduled to complete their

programs in the relevant 12-month period;

(B) For each of those former students who received a degree,

certificate, or other recognized educational credential from the

institution, the student's name, address, and social security number;

(C) For each of those former students who transferred to a higher

level educational program at another institution, the name, address,

social security number of the student, and the name and address of the

institution to which the student transferred and the name of the higher

level program; and

(D) For each of those students who remained enrolled and was making

satisfactory academic progress toward completion of the educational

program, the student's name, address, and social security number.

(v) For purposes of the placement rate under paragraph

(c)(1)(ii)(B)(2) of this section--

(A) The number of students who were scheduled to receive a degree,

certificate, or other recognized educational credential at the

institution during the relevant 12 month period who remained enrolled

beyond the point in the program in which he or she would receive a 100

percent tuition refund from the institution;

(B) For each of those former students who is employed or had been

employed for at least 13 weeks following his or her last day of

attendance at the institution, the student's name, address, and social

security number, the employer's name and address, the student's job

title, and the dates the student was so employed; and

(C) For each of those former students who enrolled in a higher

level educational program at another institution for which the

appealing institution's educational program provided substantial

preparation, the former student's name, address, and social security

number, the subsequent institution's name and address, the name of the

educational program, and the dates the former student was so enrolled.

(d) Definitions. The following definitions apply to this section

and Sec. 668.90:

(1)(i) For purposes of the FFEL Program, except as provided in

paragraph (e)(1)(ii) of this section, the term FFEL Program cohort

default rate means--

(A) For any fiscal year in which 30 or more current and former

students at the institution enter repayment on Federal Stafford loans

or Federal SLS loans (or on the portion of a loan made under the

Federal Consolidation Loan Program that is used to repay such loans)

received for attendance at the institution, the percentage of those

current and former students who enter repayment in that fiscal year on

those loans who default before the end of the following fiscal year; or

(B) For any fiscal year in which fewer than 30 of the institution's

current and former students enter repayment on Federal Stafford loans

or Federal SLS loans (or on the portion of a loan made under the

Federal Consolidation Loan Program that is used to repay such loans)

received for attendance at the institution, the percentage of those

current and former students who entered repayment on such loans in any

of the three most recent fiscal years, who default before the end of

the fiscal year immediately following the year in which they entered

repayment.

(C) In determining the number of students who default before the

end of that following fiscal year, the Secretary includes only loans

for which the Secretary or a guaranty agency has paid claims for

insurance.

(ii)(A) In the case of a student who has attended and borrowed at

more than one institution, the student (and his or her subsequent

repayment or default) is attributed to each institution for attendance

at which the student received a loan that entered repayment in the

fiscal year.

(B) A loan on which a payment is made by the institution, its

owner, agent, contractor, employee, or any other affiliated entity or

individual, in order to avoid default by the borrower, is considered as

in default for purposes of this definition.

(C) Any loan that has been rehabilitated under section 428F of the

HEA before the end of that following fiscal year is not considered as

in default for purposes of this definition.

(D) For the purposes of this definition, an SLS loan made in

accordance with section 428A of the HEA (or a loan made under the

Federal Consolidation Loan Program, a portion of which is used to repay

a Federal SLS loan) shall not be considered to enter repayment

[[Page 49189]]

until after the borrower has ceased to be enrolled in an educational

program leading to a degree, certificate, or other recognized

educational credential at the participating institution on at least a

half-time basis (as determined by the institution) and ceased to be in

a period of forbearance or deferment based on such enrollment. Each

eligible lender of a loan made under section 428A (or a loan made under

the Federal Consolidation Loan Program, a portion of which is used to

repay a Federal SLS loan) of the HEA shall provide the guaranty agency

with the information necessary to determine when the loan entered

repayment for purposes of this definition, and the guaranty agency

shall provide that information to the Secretary.

(iii)(A) An FFEL Program cohort default rate of an institution

applies to all locations of the institution as the institution exists

on the first day of the fiscal year for which the rate is calculated.

(B) An FFEL Program cohort default rate of an institution applies

to all locations of the institution from the date the institution is

notified of that rate until the institution is notified by the

Secretary that the rate no longer applies.

(iv)(A) For an institution that changes its status from that of a

location of one institution to that of a free-standing institution, the

Secretary determines the FFEL Program cohort default rate based on the

institution's status as of October 1 of the fiscal year for which an

FFEL Program cohort default rate is being calculated.

(B) For an institution that changes its status from that of a free-

standing institution to that of a location of another institution, the

Secretary determines the FFEL Program cohort default rate based on the

combined number of students who enter repayment during the applicable

fiscal year and the combined number of students who default during the

applicable fiscal years from both the former free-standing institution

and the other institution. This FFEL Program cohort default rate

applies to the new, consolidated institution and all of its current

locations.

(C) For free-standing institutions that merge to form a new,

consolidated institution, the Secretary determines the FFEL Program

cohort default rate based on the combined number of students who enter

repayment during the applicable fiscal year and the combined number of

students who default during the applicable fiscal years from all of the

institutions that are merging. This FFEL Program cohort default rate

applies to the new consolidated institution.

(D) For a location of one institution that becomes a location of

another institution, the Secretary determines the FFEL Program cohort

default rate based on the combined number of students who enter

repayment during the applicable fiscal year and the number of students

who default during the applicable fiscal years from both of the

institutions in their entirety, not limited solely to the respective

locations.

(2) Fiscal year means the period from and including October 1 of a

calendar year through and including September 30 of the following

calendar year.

(e)(1) Direct Loan Program cohort rate. For purposes of the Direct

Loan Program, the Secretary calculates Direct Loan Program cohort rates

using the following formulas:

(i) For public institutions, private nonprofit institutions, or

proprietary degree granting institutions--

(A) For any fiscal year in which 30 or more current and former

students at the institution enter repayment on a Direct Loan Program

loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the Federal Direct

Consolidation Loan Program that is used to repay those loans) received

for attendance at the institution, the percentage of those current and

former students who enter repayment in that fiscal year on those loans

who are in default before the end of the following fiscal year; or

(B) For any fiscal year in which fewer than 30 of the institution's

current and former students enter repayment on a Direct Loan Program

loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the Federal Direct

Consolidation Loan Program that is used to repay those loans) received

for attendance at the institution, the percentage of those current and

former students who entered repayment on those loans in any of the

three most recent fiscal years, who are in default before the end of

the fiscal year immediately following the year in which they entered

repayment.

(ii) For proprietary non-degree granting institutions--

(A) For any fiscal year in which 30 or more current and former

students at the institution enter repayment on a Direct Loan Program

loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the Federal Direct

Consolidation Loan Program that is used to repay those loans) received

for attendance at the institution, the percentage of those current and

former students who enter repayment in that fiscal year on those loans

who are in default before the end of the following fiscal year, or are

in repayment under the income-contingent repayment plan at the end of

that following fiscal year whose scheduled payments are less than 15

dollars per month and that payment results in negative amortization; or

(B) For any fiscal year in which fewer than 30 of the institution's

current and former students enter repayment on a Direct Loan Program

loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the Federal Direct

Consolidation Loan Program that is used to repay those loans) received

for attendance at the institution, the percentage of those current and

former students who entered repayment on those loans in the three most

recent fiscal years, who are in default before the end of the fiscal

year immediately following the year in which they entered repayment, or

are in repayment under the income contingent repayment plan at the end

of that following fiscal year and whose scheduled payments are less

than 15 dollars per month and that payment results in negative

amortization.

(2) In the case of a student who has attended and borrowed at more

than one institution, the student (and his or her subsequent repayment

or default) is attributed to each institution for attendance at which

the student received a loan that entered repayment in the fiscal year.

(3) A loan on which a payment is made by the institution, its

owner, agent, contractor, employee, or any other affiliated entity or

individual, in order to avoid default by the borrower, is considered as

in default for purposes of this definition.

(4) Any loan on which the borrower has made 12 consecutive monthly

on-time payments under 34 CFR 685.211(e) before the end of that

following fiscal year is not considered as in default for purposes of

this definition.

(5) A Direct Loan Program cohort rate of an institution applies to

all locations of the institution as the institution exists on the first

day of the fiscal year for which the rate is calculated.

(6) A Direct Loan Program cohort rate of an institution applies to

all locations of the institution from the date the institution is

notified of that rate until the institution is notified by the

Secretary that the rate no longer applies.

(7) For an institution that changes its status from that of a

location of one institution to that of a free-standing institution, the

Secretary determines the Direct Loan Program cohort rate based on the

institution's status as of October 1 of the fiscal year for which the

rate is being calculated.

(8) For an institution that changes its status from that of a free-

standing institution to that of a location of another institution, the

Secretary determines the Direct Loan Program cohort rate based on the

combined

[[Page 49190]]

number of students who enter repayment during the applicable fiscal

year from both the former free-standing institution and the other

institution. This Direct Loan Program cohort rate applies to the new,

consolidated institution and all of its current locations.

(9) For free-standing institutions that merge to form a new,

consolidated institution, the Secretary determines the Direct Loan

Program cohort rate based on the combined number of students who enter

repayment during the applicable fiscal year from all of the

institutions that are merging. This Direct Loan Program cohort rate

applies to the new consolidated institution.

(10) For a location of one institution that becomes a location of

another institution, the Secretary determines the Direct Loan Program

cohort rate based on the combined number of students who enter

repayment during the applicable fiscal year from both of the

institutions in their entirety, not limited solely to the respective

locations.

(11) Fiscal year means the period from and including October 1 of a

calendar year through and including September 30 of the following

calendar year.

(12) For purposes of an institution's Direct Loan cohort rate, a

Direct Loan Program loan is considered in default when the borrower's

or endorser's failure to make an installment payment when due has

persisted for 270 days.

(f)(1) Weighted average cohort rate. For purposes of an institution

that has former students entering repayment in a fiscal year on both

Direct Loan Program and FFEL Program, the Secretary calculates a

weighted average cohort rate using the following formulas;

(i) For public institutions, private nonprofit institutions, or

proprietary degree granting institutions--

(A) For any fiscal year in which 30 or more current and former

students at the institution enter repayment on an FFEL Program or

Direct Loan Program loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the

Federal Consolidation Loan Program or Federal Direct Consolidation Loan

Program that is used to repay those loans) received for attendance at

the institution, the percentage of those current and former students

who enter repayment in that fiscal year on those loans who are in

default before the end of the following fiscal year; and

(B) For any fiscal year in which fewer than 30 of the institution's

current and former students enter repayment on an FFEL Program or

Direct Loan Program loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the

Federal Consolidation Loan Program or Federal Direct Consolidation Loan

Program that is used to repay such loans) received for attendance at

the institution, the percentage of those current and former students

who entered repayment on such loans in the three most recent fiscal

years, who are in default before the end of the fiscal year immediately

following the year in which they entered repayment.

(ii) For proprietary non-degree granting institutions--

(A) For any fiscal year in which 30 or more current and former

students at the institution enter repayment on an FFEL Program or

Direct Loan Program loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the

Federal Consolidation Loan or Federal Direct Consolidation Loan Program

that is used to repay those loans) received for attendance at the

institution, the percentage of those current and former students who

enter repayment in that fiscal year on such loans who are in default

before the end of the following fiscal year, or are in repayment under

the income-contingent repayment plan at the end of that following

fiscal year and whose scheduled payments are less than 15 dollars per

month and that payment results in negative amortization; or

(B) For any fiscal year in which fewer than 30 of the institution's

current and former students enter repayment on an FFEL Program or

Direct Loan Program loan (or on the portion of a loan made under the

Federal Consolidation Loan Program or Federal Direct Consolidation Loan

Program that is used to repay those loans) received for attendance at

the institution, the percentage of those current and former students

who entered repayment on those loans in any of the three most recent

fiscal years, who are in default before the end of the fiscal year

immediately following the year in which they entered repayment or are

in repayment under the income contingent repayment plan at the end of

that following fiscal year whose scheduled payments are less than 15

dollars per month and that payment results in negative amortization.

(2) In the case of a student who has attended and borrowed at more

than one institution, the student (and his or her subsequent repayment

or default) is attributed to each institution for attendance at which

the student received a loan that entered repayment in the fiscal year.

(3) A loan on which a payment is made by the institution, its

owner, agent, contractor, employee, or any other affiliated entity or

individual, in order to avoid default by the borrower, is considered as

in default for purposes of this definition.

(4) Any Direct Loan Program loan on which the borrower has made 12

consecutive monthly on-time payments under 34 CFR 685.211(e) or has an

FFEL Program loan that has been rehabilitated under section 428F of the

HEA before the end of that following fiscal year is not considered as

in default for purposes of this definition.

(5) A weighted average cohort rate of an institution applies to all

locations of the institution as the institution exists on the first day

of the fiscal year for which the rate is calculated.

(6) A weighted average cohort rate of an institution applies to all

locations of the institution from the date the institution is notified

of that rate until the institution is notified by the Secretary that

the rate no longer applies.

(7) For an institution that changes its status from that of a

location of one institution to that of a free-standing institution, the

Secretary determines the weighted average cohort rate based on the

institution's status as of October 1 of the fiscal year for which the

rate is being calculated.

(8) For an institution that changes its status from that of a free-

standing institution to that of a location of another institution, the

Secretary determines the weighted average cohort rate based on the

combined number of students who enter repayment during the applicable

fiscal year from both the former free-standing institution and the

other institution. This weighted average cohort rate applies to the

new, consolidated institution and all of its current locations.

(9) For free-standing institutions that merge to form a new,

consolidated institution, the Secretary determines the weighted average

cohort rate based on the combined number of students who enter

repayment during the applicable fiscal year from all of the

institutions that are merging. This weighted average cohort rate

applies to the new consolidated institution.

(10) For a location of one institution that becomes a location of

another institution, the Secretary determines the weighted average

cohort rate based on the combined number of students who enter

repayment during the applicable fiscal year from both of the

institutions in their entirety, not limited solely to the respective

locations.

(11) Fiscal year means the period from and including October 1 of a

calendar year through and including September 30 of the following

calendar year.

(12) For purposes of an institution's weighted average cohort rate

cohort rate, a Direct Loan Program loan is considered in default when a

borrower's or endorser's failure to make an installment payment when

due has persisted for 270 days.

[[Page 49191]]

3. Section 668.85 is amended by revising paragraph (b)(1)(ii) and

revising paragraph (b)(3) to read as follows:

Sec. 668.85 Suspension proceedings.

* * * * *

(b)(1) * * *

(ii)(A) Specifies the proposed effective date of the suspension,

which is at least 20 days after the date of mailing of the notice of

intent; or

(B) In the case of a suspension action taken due to the

institution's FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program

cohort rate, or, if applicable, weighted average cohort rate, the

proposed effective date of the suspension is no more than 30 days after

the date of the mailing of the notice of intent.

* * * * *

(3) If the institution or servicer requests a hearing by the time

specified in paragraph (b)(1)(iii) of this section, the designated

department official sets the date and place. The date is at least 15

days after the designated department official receives the request. In

the case of a hearing for an institution subject to suspension action

because of its FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program

cohort rate, or, if applicable, weighted average cohort rate, the

hearing is set no later than 20 days after the date the designated

department official receives the request. The suspension does not take

place until after the requested hearing is held.

* * * * *

4. Section 668.86 is amended by revising paragraph (b)(1)(ii) and

revising paragraph (b)(3) to read as follows:

Sec. 668.86 Limitation or termination proceedings.

* * * * *

(b)(1) * * *

(ii)(A) Specifies the proposed effective date of the limitation or

termination, which is at least 20 days after the date of mailing of the

notice of intent; or

(B) In the case of a limitation or termination action based on an

institution's FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program

cohort rate, or, if applicable, weighted average cohort rate, the

proposed effective date of the termination is no more than 30 days

after the date of the mailing of the notice of intent.

* * * * *

(3) If the institution or servicer requests a hearing by the time

specified in paragraph (b)(1)(iii) of this section, the designated

department official sets the date and place. The date is at least 15

days after the designated department official receives the request. In

the case of a hearing for an institution subject to limitation or

termination action because of its FFEL Program cohort default rate,

Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or, if applicable, weighted average

cohort rate, the hearing is set no later than 20 days after the date

the designated department official receives the request. The limitation

or termination does not take place until after the requested hearing is

held.

* * * * *

5. Section 668.90 is amended by adding a new paragraph

(a)(1)(iii)(D), and revising paragraph (a)(3)(iv) to read as follows:

Sec. 668.90 Initial and final decisions.

* * * * *

(a)(1) * * *

(iii) * * *

(D) For hearings regarding the limitation, suspension, or

termination of an institution based on an institution's FFEL Program

cohort default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or, if

applicable, weighted average cohort rate, the 30th day after the

conclusion of the hearing.

* * * * *

(3) * * *

(iv) In a limitation, suspension, or termination proceeding

commenced on the grounds described in Sec. 668.17(a)(1), if the hearing

official finds that an institution's FFEL Program cohort default rate,

Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or, if applicable, weighted average

cohort rate meets the conditions specified in Sec. 668.17(a)(1) for

initiation of limitation, suspension, or termination proceedings, the

hearing official also finds that the sanction sought by the designated

department official is warranted, except that the hearing official

finds that no sanction is warranted if the institution presents clear

and convincing evidence demonstrating that its FFEL Program cohort

default rate, Direct Loan Program cohort rate, or weighted average

cohort rate is not final or does not accurately reflect the final rate

determined by the Department and that the correct rate would result in

the institution having an FFEL Program cohort default rate, Direct Loan

Program cohort rate, or weighted average cohort rate that is beneath

the thresholds that make the institution subject to limitation,

suspension, or termination action.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 1082, 1085, 1094, 1099c)

[FR Doc. 95-23470 Filed 9-20-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4000-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.