Performance Management

Federal RegisterAug 23, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUMMARY: The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) is issuing final

regulations to deregulate performance management and incentive awards,

including provisions allowing agencies to use as few as two levels for

critical element appraisals for and summary performance assessments of

non-SES employees, and to make conforming changes to related

regulations. These changes provide agencies additional flexibility as

called for by the National Performance Review.

EFFECTIVE DATE: September 22, 1995.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Barbara Colchao, (202) 606-2720.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: OPM published for comment in the Federal

Register on January 27, 1995, at 60 FR 5542-5557, proposed revisions to

the regulations on performance management systems. A total of 52

comments and/or suggestions were received: 37 from agencies, 6 from

unions, 6 from individuals, and 3 from management associations. The

comments generally supported the proposed changes. On some topics,

commenters suggested additional changes. In other instances, commenters

either suggested that no change be made to the current regulations or

suggested some modification to the proposed changes. Comments and

suggestions, along with the rationale for and explanation of revisions

to the final regulations, are discussed below.

I. Background

Following several years of study and recommendations for ways to

improve the Federal Government's performance management system for non-

Senior Executive Service (SES) employees, OPM reviewed the regulatory

structure for appraisal and awards for opportunities to implement the

various recommendations. OPM concluded that the regulations

implementing the basic statutory requirements could be made much more

flexible and constructive for managing and recognizing group as well as

individual performance. Consequently, OPM proposed a variety of changes

to the regulations covering performance appraisal (part 430) and

incentive awards (part 451), as well as related regulations that

referenced appraisal results (e.g., granting within-grade and quality

step increases).

OPM's intent in deregulating performance management was to give

agencies a great deal of flexibility for both appraisal and awards so

that the working organizations of the Federal Government could operate

in a decentralized environment where the performance management

procedures for planning, monitoring, evaluating, and rewarding

individual, team, and organizational performance were tailored to fit

local work technologies and cultures. A chief means of achieving this

flexibility was to remove a great deal of regulatory language. As a

result of comments received, OPM is restoring language in several

instances that had been deleted in the proposed regulations (e.g.,

restoring a reference to ``employee'' in the definition of critical

element). Whenever reasonable, the restoration is establishing a

permissive authority, rather than a Governmentwide requirement. OPM's

original strategy was to adopt a ``permissive silence'' approach to

many issues. That is, by leaving the regulations silent, agencies would

not be constrained from designing and implementing a variety of

procedures and mechanisms. However, the comments clearly indicated that

in some cases, agencies believe a direct reference to certain

permissible techniques, such as permitting the assigning of a summary

level as part of a performance rating, is needed to permit their use.

Consequently, OPM is reinserting some broad language in certain cases.

Even with these additions, however, OPM believes that our goal of

creating a deregulated Governmentwide policy framework in which

performance management can be revitalized and reinvented is being

achieved, without sacrificing agency accountability and adequate

employee protections. OPM encourages agencies to seize these

flexibilities and work to make performance appraisal and awards an

integral part of their general efforts to address the serious

challenges Government is facing to create and sustain high performance

organizations.

II. Statutory Limitations

OPM's proposals for regulatory changes to performance management

implemented specific National Performance Review recommendations which

were achievable within the limits of existing statute and which we

believe substantially reform performance management in the Federal

Government. However, there were several requests made by commenters to

take actions that are outside OPM's authority. For example, a few

commenters suggested that the regulations be further modified to

require mandatory collective bargaining of aspects of performance

appraisal and awards such as performance standards. Several other

commenters made suggestions that also would require changes to statute;

for example--

integrate sections from different chapters of title 5,

United States Code;

eliminate the requirement that OPM approve performance

appraisal systems;

require that agencies take a chapter 43 action against

employees whose performance is less than fully successful, but better

than unacceptable as defined in statute;

lift the prohibition on granting honorary, nonmonetary

awards to political officers during a Presidential election period;

modify regulations to permit that within-grade increases

that are delayed do not have to be granted retroactively; and

eliminate the connection between performance appraisal and

retention standing in a reduction in force.

OPM does not have the authority under existing statute to take these

actions. Therefore, they are not being adopted.

III. Employee Involvement and Labor Relations Issues

As OPM stated when publishing the proposed regulations, agencies

are strongly urged to develop their performance management systems and

programs in partnership with their employees and union representatives

in accordance with law. Many studies have shown that the success of a

performance management system in achieving its goals is dependent upon

acceptance by the management and employees who use it. There is no

better way to garner support for a system than by giving all

stakeholders a role in developing it. Further, the National Performance

Review stated in its accompanying report, Reinventing Human Resource

Management, that under the ideal performance management system

``Employees and their representatives will be involved in design and

implementation of performance management programs and in development of

performance expectations.'' Consequently, OPM advises agencies that

these regulatory changes in performance management should be

implemented through full partnership with employees and their union

representatives.

Several comments pointed out that the elimination of a

Governmentwide

[[Page 43937]]

regulation could affect the negotiability of a particular aspect of an

appraisal or award program. OPM is aware of this potential implication

of removing such regulations. In balancing among the interests of

establishing flexibility for effective program design, decentralizing

programs to facilitate their being properly tailored to local work

settings and cultures, achieving meaningful employee involvement to

increase program acceptance, and maintaining an appropriate framework

of Governmentwide regulation to ensure that statutory requirements are

met, OPM is deciding more often than not to remove regulatory

constraints.

A number of comments focused on OPM's objective of providing for

involving employees in the design and implementation of performance

management programs and the implications of the proposed regulations

for how that involvement could and should be achieved. The principle

that successful performance management approaches are best served by

the involvement of the employees that will be affected by them is well

established. In the Federal Government, under the Federal Service

Labor-Management Relations Statute (chapter 71 of title 5, United

States Code), for employees in bargaining units where a labor

organization has been given exclusive recognition, employee involvement

must be through that exclusive representative for subject matters that

are within the statutory duty to bargain. As well as striving to

develop performance management systems and programs in partnership,

agencies must be mindful of the requirements of chapter 71 as they

implement these final regulations.

Several comments raised questions about the means and methods of

involving employees who are not in recognized bargaining units. One

commenter suggested that OPM mandate that agencies use representatives

of professional and management associations to involve employees who

make up their memberships. OPM has no authority to set such a

requirement. OPM strongly encourages agencies to involve all employees,

including managers and supervisors, in the design and implementation of

performance management programs. Where appropriate, this should include

the involvement of representatives of professional and managerial

associations, OPM, however, does not have the authority to require such

involvement.

Also, agency officials are reminded that 18 U.S.C. 201-216 place

restrictions on a wide range of activities by Federal employees,

including representational activities on behalf of organizations that

are not labor organizations. OPM therefore advises agency officials to

consult with their designated agency ethics official for guidance

regarding any conflicts of interest that may arise. Accordingly, OPM is

revising text to clarify that agencies are free to choose appropriate

forms of employee involvement in accordance with law. (See

Sec. 430.204(c), Sec. 430.205(d), and Sec. 451.103(b).)

Several comments raised related labor relations issues concerning

employees who serve as representatives of labor organizations in their

agencies under chapter 71 of title 5, United States Code. For example,

one commenter suggested adding a requirement that union officials be

granted presumptive ratings at the ``Fully Successful'' (or equivalent)

level. Under performance appraisal provisions in part 430, the

performance to be planned, monitored, and rated covers the work,

duties, and responsibilities that accomplish the agency mission and for

which the employee is accountable to the employing organization. When

an employee is serving as the representative of a labor organization,

he or she is performing duties for that labor organization. To

intermingle performance of the representational duties into the

appraisal program would be inappropriate because appraisal of the

employee's performance must be based solely upon the employee's

performance of agency duties. For employees who spend 100 percent of

their time as labor representatives, and for employees who spend a

significant amount of time as determined by the agency, this means that

they cannot, and should not, be given performance appraisal ratings of

record. In the interest of preserving the distinction between the

agency-assigned duties of an official position and union duties and

responsibilities, OPM is not adopting this suggestion. The regulations

at part 430 continue to preclude a ``presumptive'' or ``assumed''

rating of record and such employees are considered ``unratable.'' The

only place in regulations where an ``assumed'' rating is used is in the

regulations at Sec. 351.504 for granting addition service credit based

on performance in a reduction in force.

Other commenters asked whether the waiver of an acceptable level of

competence (ALOC) determination at Sec. 531.409(d) is discretionary or

mandatory. OPM is clarifying that waiving the ALOC determination for

labor representatives is not discretionary for representatives who are

unratable based upon the fact that ALOC must be based on a performance

determination.

An additional comment stated that the provision addressing the ALOC

waiver for union officials should also refer to representational

duties. OPM is adopting the suggestion to clarify the representational

duties are performed under the authority of chapter 71 of title 5,

United States Code. (See Sec. 531.409(d)(1)(v).)

One commenter suggested that where the proposed regulations at

Sec. 451.104(h) clarified that employees do not have appeal rights with

respect to awards, language be added concerning the right to grieve an

award. In considering this suggestion, OPM has concluded that it is not

necessary to promulgate a Governmentwide regulation in this subpart

that reminds employees about matters where they do and do not have

appeal or grievance rights. Consequently, OPM is eliminating all

reference to appealing awards by deleting Sec. 451.104(h). Because

appeal rights to the Merit Systems Protection Board must be granted

specifically by law or regulation, deletion of this regulatory language

does not have the effect of creating such an appeal right. (See

Sec. 541.104 (paragraph (h) as proposed, removed).)

IV. OPM Role Examined

Several comments raised questions that concern OPM's role in

administering the Federal Government's performance management system

under the provisions of chapters 43 and 45 of title 5, United States

Code. One commenter asked whether these regulatory changes would affect

the administrative exclusions that OPM had already granted some

agencies for some excepted service employees under its authority at 5

U.S.C. 4301(2)(G). OPM has concluded that all existing administrative

exclusions the Director of OPM has already granted will remain in

effect and that agencies need not reapply for those exclusions.

One commenter suggested that OPM seek a reinterpretation of the

statutory requirement that OPM review and approve agency appraisal

systems in advance of program implementation. OPM believes that case

law and established practice are sufficiently clear in this regard and

that appraisal system approval must still be required in advance of

program implementation.

One commenter expressed concern about the distinctions OPM is

making between appraisal system and appraisal program. The commenter

suggested that OPM would not be carrying out our

[[Page 43938]]

review and approval responsibilities properly if only a framework of

parameters that an agency's programs must comply with were to be

reviewed. OPM believes that the system descriptions that agencies will

submit to OPM will provide sufficient information about the policies

under which appraisals will be conducted to permit an adequate

determination of whether the agency meets the requirements of

subchapter I of chapter 43 of title 5, United States Code, which is

OPM's responsibility under the law. As a consequence, the final

regulations at Secs. 430.203-205 continue to distinguish agency

appraisal systems from appraisal programs and require at Secs. 430.209-

210 the submission and review of agency systems. (See Sec. 430.203

(appraisal program, appraisal system) and Secs. 430.205 (a) and (c).)

Other commenters asked about what documents agencies would be

required to submit for OPM review. OPM will be distributing specific

guidance and instructions, providing models, holding informational

meetings, and supplying technical assistance to the agencies to

facilitate the submission and approval of their systems and to support

the design and implementation of revised appraisal and award programs.

One commenter suggested that the definition of ``Performance

Management Plan'' be removed as paragraph Sec. 430.102(c) and grouped

with other definitions in Sec. 430.203. OPM is taking this suggestion

one step further by removing the provision and all references to

``Performance Management Plan'' in part 430, subparts A and B, which

cover non-SES employees. Also, OPM is making conforming changes in

subpart C by removing references to subpart A as a source of the

continued SES requirement for a Performance Management Plan. From a

Governmentwide regulatory perspective, reference to a document (e.g., a

Performance Management Plan) that serves as the repository for an

agency's non-SES performance management systems is no longer necessary

because the regulations are clear in requiring agencies only to submit

appraisal systems for OPM review and approval. However, agencies are

free to continue to use a Performance Management Plan for internal

purposes. The requirements for submitting appraisal systems for SES

employees and for non-SES employees are spelled out separately in their

respective subparts. (See Sec. 430.102 (paragraph (c) as proposed,

removed), Sec. 430.209(d), Sec. 430.303 (Performance Management Plan),

and Sec. 430.310.)

On OPM's evaluation responsibilities, one commenter suggested the

wording ``must evaluate'' and another suggested the wording ``will

evaluate'' to replace the wording ``may evaluate'' systems and programs

at Sec. 430.210(b) and Sec. 451.107(d). Another commenter suggested

that OPM include in the regulations at Sec. 430.209(d) the criteria

against which programs would be evaluated. OPM is fully committed to

executing our evaluation role in a meaningful way. Moreover, OPM

believes that agencies will be in the best position to establish

criteria for evaluating their programs against the specific objectives

that program design features were intended to achieve. Consequently,

the suggested changes are not being adopted.

V. More Flexibility Requested

Some commenters did not feel that OPM had gone far enough in our

proposals and urged OPM to consider providing further flexibilities. By

far, the most commonly raised concern addressed the fact that OPM had

not proposed any changes to the regulations at Sec. 351.504 governing

how additional service credit is granted during a reduction in force

(RIF) on the basis of performance appraisal ratings of record. Most

commenters noted that OPM's proposal to provide flexibility about the

number of summary levels used in an appraisal program was a highly

desirable system improvement. However, 27 of the 52 commenters

suggested that OPM revisit the issue of crediting performance in a RIF.

A few commenters urged that the connection between appraisal and

retention be completely eliminated. Others suggested particular

approaches for dealing with situations where employees in the same

competitive area in a RIF were given ratings of record under programs

that use different patterns of summary levels. To respond to the

concerns expressed, OPM will review the RIF regulations in part 351 and

consider whether any changes to the RIF retention provisions would be

beneficial and appropriate. As part of this review, OPM will confer

with stakeholders to assure that a full range of interests is

considered.

In four other instances, changes were suggested that would have

lifted regulatory requirements beyond what OPM had proposed. One

commenter requested that the required progress review in the regulation

at Sec. 430.207(b) about monitoring performance during the appraised

period be eliminated on grounds that agencies ``should not be required

to conduct a formalized review.'' OPM had maintained the requirement

for a progress review as a reasonable implementation of the specific

statutory requirement that employees be evaluated during (and not just

at the end of) their appraisal period. Given the more flexible

definition of progress review, which could now be much simpler than a

formally conducted or written review, OPM is preserving the

requirement.

Another commenter suggested that after one appraisal period,

journey-level employees should not be required under Sec. 430.206(b)(2)

to receive performance plans at the start of each subsequent period.

Instead, a performance plan would be provided upon reaching the journey

level and ``carry over'' after that. OPM understands that situations

may continue where performance plans are constructed in such a way that

they need not change from period to period. However, OPM believes that

the statutory requirement for employees to be evaluated during each

appraisal period on their standards is reasonably implemented by the

current requirement. Also, eliminating the current requirement would

strongly suggest that such plans are by their nature unchanging, at

least at the journey level. One of OPM's goals in deregulating

performance management is to reemphasize the value and importance of

effective planning and goal setting. Consequently, OPM is not adopting

the suggestion.

Two commenters sought greater flexibility with respect to assigning

summary levels. One thought that the regulations at Sec. 430.208(d)(1)

should allow an appraisal program to use more than five summary levels.

Other personnel systems and actions, including granting quality step

increases, granting within-grade increases, and granting additional

service credit in a reduction in force, are regulated to operate with

reference to the five numerically-designated summary levels. The

proposed regulations offered the flexibility for an appraisal program

to assess performance at more than five levels, so long as the program

included some method of translating such assessments to one of the

patterns of summary levels that programs are permitted to use to

designate their official ratings of record that the other personnel

systems use. Given that flexibility, OPM is not adopting the suggestion

to permit more than five summary levels.

The other commenter suggested that the proposed deregulation at

Sec. 430.208(e) to eliminate the Governmentwide requirement that all

assigned summary levels be reviewed by a reviewing official should be

extended

[[Page 43939]]

to Level 1 (``Unacceptable'') ratings of record. OPM has proposed

maintaining the requirement for reviewing Level 1 ratings as an

appropriate employee protection in cases where the assigned rating of

record could affect an employee's retention in the Federal service. OPM

believes such a measure of protection is still justified and is not

adopting the suggestion.

VI. Restoring or Adding Restrictions and Requirements

A considerable number of comments requested that Governmentwide

restrictions or requirements be restored or that new ones be

established. OPM considered each of these suggestions carefully,

attempting to implement the National Performance Review recommendation

to eliminate unnecessary regulation consistent with our responsibility

to regulate the Governmentwide implementation of chapters 43 and 45 of

title 5, United States Code, as required by law.

A. Team and Organizational Performance

A number of commenters wanted OPM to restore language that we had

proposed be removed from the regulations. For example, in the provision

dealing with performance plans, OPM had proposed to eliminate the

language referring to supervisor. Several commenters suggested that OPM

restore the language that referred to supervisors. Current regulation

at Sec. 430.204(c)(4) states that ``Final authority for establishing

such plans rests with the supervising officials.'' By proposing the

removal of this type of language, OPM had hoped to broaden the coverage

of the regulations to the management of team and organizational

performance in other than traditional hierarchical organizations, as

well as individual performance, without detracting from the management

rights preserved by law.

The deletion of the reference to supervisors was not intended to,

and cannot have the effect of, subtracting from management's inherent

rights because those rights are preserved elsewhere in the law. For

example, 5 U.S.C. 7106(a)(2) (A) and (B) protect management's right to

direct employees and to assign work. Therefore, reference to the

supervisor did not confer upon management any rights that did not

already exist. Consequently, OPM is not adopting the suggestion to

restore the reference to the supervisor establishing a performance

plan.

The requirement for higher-level review of awards had been proposed

for removal to accommodate restructured organizational environments.

Several commenters suggested that the requirement be restored because

its removal could have the effect of making award programs negotiable.

OPM is not adopting this suggestion because of our focus on eliminating

unnecessary layers of review to create flatter, more effective

organizations. Such delayering could be used to establish more

effective recognition systems.

Four commenters suggested OPM restore an exclusive reference to the

performance of ``an employee.'' One of these suggestions applied to the

definition of performance rating and another to the provision for

ongoing appraisal at Sec. 430.207(b). OPM is not adopting either change

because each would limit performance to the individual, excluding the

use of team or organizational performance from the appraisal process. A

third commenter wanted to restore classification-centered references to

duties and responsibilities in the definition of critical element. The

third proposed change could result in limiting critical elements by

tying them to position descriptions that are frequently outdated rather

than allowing them to reflect the employee responsibilities needed by

the organization. Accordingly, OPM is not adopting this suggestion. The

fourth commenter, however, suggested restoring reference to ``an

employee's'' overall performance in the definition of critical element

as that which is found unacceptable if performance on one or more

critical elements is unacceptable. OPM is adopting this suggestion

because it emphasizes the necessary connection in the law between

critical elements and the individual employee for retention purposes.

(See Sec. 430.203 (critical element) and Sec. 432.103(b).)

B. Meaning and Use of Terms

1. Critical Elements and Other Performance Factors. OPM received a

number of comments about the meaning and use of terms such as ``other

performance factors'' and ``non-critical elements'' and the

relationships among those and ``critical elements,'' especially with

respect to their use in performance plans and their impact on summary

ratings of record. Two commenters requested OPM to restore the

definition of ``non-critical element.''

In response to these comments, OPM is amending definitions and

provisions to establish three distinct kinds of performance elements:

critical, non-critical, and additional. The concept of ``other

performance factors'' that the proposed regulations had included has

been replaced and refined by using ``non-critical elements'' and

``additional performance elements.''

The meaning and use of a ``critical element'' cannot change; as set

forth in 5 U.S.C. 4301(3), failure to meet established performance

standards on one or more critical elements means unacceptable

performance. Because an appraisal system must be able to identify

unacceptable performance, an appraisal program must use at least one

critical element, and any critical element must have an established

performance standard and be appraisable as ``Unacceptable.'' Critical

elements must be used in deriving a summary level, and they form the

only basis for taking a performance-based action under 5 CFR part 432

or 752.

The definition of non-critical element is being adjusted to reflect

a new, broader meaning. (This change renders moot another commenter's

suggestion to remove all references to noncritical elements.) As in

current regulation, establishing a non-critical element is optional. If

used, it must be included in the employee's performance plan. It cannot

be used as a basis for taking a performance-based action under 5 CFR

part 432 or 752. However, a non-critical element would be used in

deriving a summary level. As in the proposed regulations and because it

must be factored into the summary level, it must be appraisable at a

minimum of two levels with a performance standard established for at

least one level, which need not be the ``Fully Successful'' level. This

change is being made in recognition of 5 U.S.C. 4302(b)(3), which

requires that employees be evaluated against their performance

standards.

OPM is changing the definition and use of non-critical elements to

permit them to focus on levels of performance other than individual and

on a standard other than that required for retention. Critical elements

are designed to be focused on individual performance and an established

performance standard for retention because of the definition of

unacceptable performance at 5 U.S.C. 4301(3). Agencies may continue to

use non-critical elements as they are used now under current

regulation, provided they are used to derive a summary level.

Under these regulations, an optional ``additional performance

element'' gives agencies additional flexibility for communicating

performance expectations important to the organization. This kind of

performance element differs from the other two in that it may not be

used in deriving a summary level. However, it may be used for other

purposes, such as making award determinations. Therefore, as was

[[Page 43940]]

proposed for ``other performance factors'' in general in the proposed

regulations, an additional performance element need not include a

performance standard, be appraised at any particular level, or

necessarily be included in the employee performance plan. Also, by

making clear that performance on an additional performance element may

not be used in assigning a summary level, this change addresses one

commenter's concerns that summary level derivations could be affected

by performance expectations (``other performance factors'') not

expressed at the beginning of the appraisal period in the performance

plan.

Accordingly, OPM is adding definitions of additional performance

element and non-critical element; revising procedures at

Sec. 430.206(b) required to establish performance plans to clarify

options and requirements; and making conforming changes in other

definitions and provisions. (See Sec. 430.203) (additional performance

element, non-critical element, performance plan, performance rating,

progress review), Sec. 430.204(b)(3)(iii), Secs. 430.206 (b)(4) through

(b)(7), Sec. 430.207(b), and Sec. 430.208(b).)

2. Summary Rating. Two commenters suggested that the definition of

``summary rating'' be retained. Another commenter suggested that either

the definition be retained or all references to summary rating be

removed. In current regulation at Sec. 430.203, the definition of

summary rating requires a label describing an employee's overall level

of performance. In practice, the term ``summary rating'' frequently

means the label only, without reference to the appraisal process or

documentation that generated it. OPM proposed to replace summary rating

with performance rating, which requires only the appraisal of critical

and non-critical elements in an employee's performance plan. To help

minimize confusion in this area, OPM is removing references to summary

rating. OPM also is replacing references to ``summary rating level''

with ``summary level.'' A summary level must be assigned with a

performance rating is prepared as part of a rating of record. At other

times, assigning a summary level is optional. (See Sec. 430.203

(performance plan, rating of record); Sec. 430.204(b)(3)(iv);

Secs. 430.208 (b), (c), and (d); and Sec. 531.504(b).)

3. Other Terms. In several instances, commenters requested that

definitions of terms such as ``team,'' ``informal recognition item,''

and the performance and summary levels themselves be provided in the

regulations. Commenters also requested that--

the regulations include precise requirements for

performance standards;

``as soon as practicable'' be defined;

the proposed provision at Sec. 531.409(d)(1)(v) for

waiving the acceptable level of competence (ALOC) determination for

labor representatives be permitted only for employees who are

performing representational duties a full 100 percent of their time;

and

``performance-based'' be added to modify ``actions based

on unacceptable performance'' that must be provided for under

Sec. 430.207(d)(2), which would have restricted the actions an agency

could take to deal with a poor performer.

OPM is committed to emphasizing flexibility for the performance

appraisal and award programs that will be established under these

regulations. Accordingly, OPM is not adopting these suggestions.

C. Appraisal Program Procedures

A number of commenters suggested restoring or adding procedural

requirements within an appraisal program, such as--

requiring paper copies of performance plans and ratings of

record;

requiring a minimum appraisal period of at least 90 days;

requiring close-out ratings;

specifying how to treat employees on detail;

coordinating the assignment of summary levels between

programs to assure equitable distribution of rewards; and

establishing specific requirements and criteria for

granting quality step increases under appraisal programs that do not

use a Level 5 summary.

OPM believes that agencies should have the flexibility and authority to

design their own means of addressing these procedures so that they fit

their work technologies or cultures well. Consequently, OPM is not

adopting these suggestions.

Five commenters urged OPM to reconsider removing the requirement to

assist employees whose performance is better than ``Unacceptable,'' but

not ``Fully Successful'' (or equivalent). OPM had removed the

requirement on the basis that it went further than the statute required

and that agencies would have the full discretion to provide such

assistance without a Governmentwide regulation. However, OPM agrees

that a commitment to improving performance includes assisting a

marginal performer. Accordingly, OPM is adding language to emphasize

that agencies should offer assistance to employees whose performance is

less than ``Fully Successful'' (or equivalent). (See Sec. 430.207(c).)

Some commenters suggested that the proposed provision to permit the

delay of an acceptable level of competence (ALOC) determination for

employees completing an opportunity to improve or under notice of a

performance-based action to be taken under 5 CFR part 432 or 752 is

unfair to employees whose performance is less than ``Fully Successful''

but better than ``Unacceptable.'' These marginal performers would not

have access to such a delay and, upon improvement to the ``Fully

Successful'' level, to a retroactive within-grade increase. Thus, those

whom management deemed to be performing at an unacceptable level would

be endowed with greater rights than those whose performance is somewhat

better, thereby creating an inequity in the application of the law.

OPM agrees. The proposed regulation does not further our policy

objectives. All employees whose performance is deemed less than ``Fully

Successful'' should be treated equally for ALOC determinations. No

group of less than ``Fully Successful'' performers should be granted

advantage over any others. Accordingly, these final regulations do not

include the provision at Sec. 531.409(c) as described above for

delaying the ALOC determination. (See Sec. 531.409 (amendments to

paragraphs (c)(2) through (c)(3) as proposed, withdrawn).)

Four commenters addressed the provision requiring agencies to

communicate to employees about relevant parts of applicable performance

management systems and programs. All stressed, to varying degrees, the

importance of training and the concern that OPM's omitting specific

mention of it would send inappropriate signals about its importance, if

not necessity, in implementing effective systems and programs. One

commenter specifically recommended that OPM re-insert the training

requirement. OPM is not adopting this suggestion because we had

proposed to remove the training requirement to allow agencies the

flexibility to use resources in addition to formal training funds to

communicate system and program operations to supervisors and employees.

OPM recognizes, however, that while formal training is rarely

sufficient, it often is necessary to ensure adequate communication.

Accordingly, OPM is adding a specific reference to formal training as

an example of communicating to employees and supervisors about the

relevant parts of applicable appraisal systems and programs and award

programs. (See Sec. 430.209(c) and Sec. 451.106(c).)

[[Page 43941]]

D. Forced Distributions of Ratings

Several commenters questioned OPM's proposal at Sec. 430.208(c) to

permit agency appraisal programs to use ``forced distributions'' of

summary levels for ratings of record and urged that OPM restore the

existing prohibition on their use. These commenters believed that

forced distributions were incompatible with effective performance

management. OPM is persuaded by the arguments that criticized the use

of forced distributions and is adopting the suggestions that the

regulations continue to prohibit forced distributions, as the current

regulations do at Sec. 430.206(d). Therefore, the proposed language at

Sec. 430.208(c) is being changed from being a permissive authority.

Under these final regulations, no limitations on ratings at any level

used by an appraisal program are permitted. The regulations still

require that a summary level be derived solely from comparing

performance to the pre-established standards required for critical and

non-critical elements and not be based at all on additional performance

elements. Definitions of additional performance element and non-

critical element are added or restored as outlined above to clarify

this issue. OPM is permitting more flexibility to use non-critical

elements to derive a summary level and in making performance

distinctions above a Level 3 summary (``Fully Successful'' or

equivalent), while heeding the commenters' calls for not permitting

quotas for summary levels. However, OPM is also adding language to

clarify that using methods where relative comparisons are made among

individuals or groups, such as rank ordering or categorizing employees,

may be used for purposes outside appraisal and assigning a summary

level, such as making decisions about distributing rewards. (See

Sec. 430.208(c).)

VII. Performance and Awards Data

Nine commenters requested additional information and OPM guidance

regarding how to report award and performance data to the Central

Personnel Data File (CPDF) and clarification of the transfer of rating

requirements when employees change agencies or leave Federal service.

The inclusion of these reporting requirements in the performance

management and award regulations is intended to reinforce their

mandatory nature. However, official OPM policy on how agencies are to

comply with these reporting requirements is contained in three OPM

Operating Manuals. Policy and instructions on how to submit data to the

CPDF are contained in FEDERAL WORKFORCE REPORTING SYSTEMS. Policy and

instructions on how to process personnel actions, including appropriate

nature-of-action codes (NOAC's) for awards, within-grade increases, and

quality step increases, are in THE GUIDE TO PROCESSING PERSONNEL

ACTIONS. Finally, policy and instructions on the transfer of

performance records are addressed in the regulations at 5 CFR part 293

and, along with records documentation requirements for the Official

Personnel Folder (OPF), in THE GUIDE TO PERSONNEL RECORDKEEPING.

The new regulations in part 451 remove the specific requirement to

prepare an SF-50 for a time-off award. This is consistent with OPM's

intent to review the data collection and reporting and documentation

requirements for appraisal and awards in the coming months with the

objective of simplifying requirements to the extent possible, given

OPM's responsibilities for maintaining Governmentwide data in these

areas. In the meantime, agencies are reminded that they should follow

the reporting and documentation requirements specified in the relevant

OPM Operating Manuals, which at this point still require SF-50's for

all cash and time-off awards. Accordingly, the regulations are amended

to clarify that transfer, documentation, and reporting of records must

be done in compliance with these OPM Operating Manuals. Further,

language is added to indicate where they can be obtained. (See

Secs. 430.209(b) and (e); Secs. 451.106(e), (f), and (g); and

Sec. 531.507(b).)

VIII. Miscellaneous, Technical, and Editorial Changes

OPM is incorporating two structural changes in these final

regulations. OPM is replacing text describing the summary levels

available for program use with a table of permissible patterns of

summary levels and explanatory text. In addition to providing a clearer

presentation of what combinations of summary levels may be used, this

table establishes a convenient pattern label (A through H) for possible

reference in future data reporting instructions in the OPM Operating

Manual, FEDERAL WORKFORCE REPORTING SYSTEMS. A conforming change

requires agencies to specify in their systems which patterns, not

levels, programs are permitted to adopt. (See Sec. 430.204(b)(3)(iv)

and Secs. 430.208(d)(1) and (2).)

OPM is revising the definitions of appraisal period and rating of

record to accommodate their establishment under programs in accordance

with an agency system. (See Sec. 430.203 (appraisal period, rating of

record).)

One commenter found it confusing that the definition of performance

rating makes no mention of deriving a summary level. OPM had intended

that silence on the derivation of a summary level would be taken to

imply consent. To make our intent clearer, however, OPM is revising the

definition of performance rating to specify explicitly that assigning a

summary level is permitted. A summary level is required only for a

rating of record. (See Sec. 430.203 (performance rating).)

The definition of performance rating is being revised to include

the new flexibility to use additional performance elements. (See

Sec. 430.203 (Performance standard).)

The provision requiring an appraisal program to establish a minimum

period is being revised so that the minimum period applies to

performance ratings only, rather than a more general performance

determination. This change accommodates a commenter's suggestion to

ensure that agencies retain the flexibility to make a determination

about performance at any time, as permitted, for example, in an

unacceptable performance determination. (See Sec. 430.207(a).)

The provision prohibiting the assignment of a Level 1

(``Unacceptable'') summary if all critical elements are rated ``Fully

Successful'' (or equivalent) or better is being corrected to align with

statute, which links unacceptable performance overall with an

``Unacceptable'' (not just ``less than `Fully Successful' '') appraisal

on one or more critical elements. (See Sec. 430.208(b)(1).)

One commenter asserted that OPM must, but does not, allow itself to

disapprove an appraisal system at Sec. 430.210. OPM does not

contemplate such disapproval because an agency must have an approved

appraisal system under which it can manage performance, take

performance-based actions under 5 CFR part 432 or 752, and make other

personnel decisions. In this respect, an appraisal system is unlike an

award, which OPM may disapprove in some cases. This does not mean that

OPM cannot withhold approval of a proposed appraisal system until it is

made to conform to regulatory requirements; it only means that

ultimately an appraisal system must be approved. Of course, OPM would

work with the agency to ensure that such approval could be given.

Accordingly, OPM is not adopting the suggestion.

The provisions cross-referencing current regulation at Sec. 534.403

are being revised to clarify that Senior Executive

[[Page 43942]]

Service (SES) performance awards are authorized by 5 U.S.C. 5384, not

subchapter I of chapter 45, United States Code. Awards to SES members

for goals, objectives, and accomplishments attained through sustained

superior performance of regular job duties and responsibilities are

properly made under 5 U.S.C. 5384. (See Secs. 451.101(d) and

451.104(a)(3).)

One commenter suggested that the reference to ``productivity

gainshares'' be removed from the definition of award proposed at

Sec. 451.102. OPM is adopting this suggestion and is including

``productivity gain'' among the contributions that can form the basis

for granting an award. (See Sec. 451.102 (award) and

Sec. 451.104(a)(1).)

One commenter asked whether time-off and honorary awards should be

excluded from tax withholding. OPM does not have the authority to

determine the applicability of tax withholding or any other tax rules.

The provision specifying that awards are subject to tax withholding has

always been intended to serve as a reminder to agencies of their

obligations to the Internal Revenue Service and other tax collecting

authorities. Accordingly, it is being broadened to reflect the fact

that non-cash awards may be considered supplemental wages and subject

to applicable tax rules (See Sec. 451.104(c).)

One commenter suggested that the awards regulations be amended to

permit giving awards to private citizens and former Federal employees.

OPM addressed a similar comment in the final regulations on incentive

awards, pay, and leave published on June 27, 1995, at 60 FR 33097-

33098. In the supplementary information published with those

regulations, OPM explained that awards authorized by chapter 45 of

title 5, United States Code, may be granted only to Federal employees

or former Federal employees for contributions made while in the Federal

service. To accord with current regulation (as amended June 27, 1995)

and statutory intent, OPM is extending the provision permitting

agencies to grant awards to the legal heirs or estates of deceased

employees to include former employees, but not private citizens. (See

Sec. 451.104(e).)

To protect the integrity of quality step increases (QSI's), OPM is

adding a provision that requires an employee covered by an appraisal

program not using a Level 5 (``Outstanding, or equivalent) summary to

receive the highest rating of record that the program does use as well

as to meet whatever eligibility criteria the agency establishes before

the employee can receive a QSI. QSI's are intended to recognize or

provide incentives for sustained, extraordinary performance. Granting

one to an employee who has not demonstrated both by receiving the

highest rating of record that can be achieved would be inconsistent

with that intent. (See Sec. 531.504(b).)

OPM is amending Sec. 531.507 to eliminate the requirement that

agencies establish plans for granting quality step increases. Executive

Order 11721 (Providing for Federal Pay Administration, May 23, 1973),

as amended, which required that OPM establish such an agency

responsibility, has been revoked. Accordingly, OPM may now deregulate

further in this area and will no longer require these plans. Of course,

agencies may continue to establish such plans. Additional references to

Executive Order 11721 are also being removed. (See Sec. 531.404(a),

Sec. 531.501, and Sec. 531.507 (paragraph (a) as proposed, removed).)

OPM is not revising, as was proposed, the authority citation for

part 531 and two of the provisions establishing principal authorities

for regulating within-grade increases. The authority citation and the

provision at Sec. 531.401(c) need not be revised because of final

regulations on incentive awards, pay, and leave published on June 27,

1995, at 60 FR 33097-33098. Those regulations corrected references in

the authority citation and revised Sec. 531.401(c) to replace

references to 5 U.S.C. 5335 and E.O. 11721 (revoked) with a general

reference to 5 U.S.C. 5338. The provision at Sec. 531.401(d) need not

be revised because the title of Public Law 103-89 is already identified

properly. Accordingly, the authority citation as proposed is being

revised to match current regulation (as amended June 27, 1995), and its

instruction line revised to indicate no change. Also, the entire

instruction to revise paragraphs (c) and (d) in Sec. 531.401 is being

removed. (See part 531 (authority citation) and Sec. 531.401

(amendments to paragraphs (c) and (d) as proposed, withdrawn).)

The undesignated provision at the end of Sec. 531.409(d) is being

designated, which requires redesignation of the rest of

Sec. 531.409(d). (See Secs. 531.409 (d)(1) through (d)(2).)

Finally, OPM received several comments suggesting minor editorial

changes to improve understanding and readability of regulatory text.

OPM is adopting many of them and making conforming changes. Also, minor

editorial changes are being made to correct typographical errors or to

clarify text: (See Sec. 430.102(b)(4); Sec. 430.201(b);

Sec. 430.202(c); Secs. 430.204 (b) and (b)(3) through (b)(5);

Sec. 430.205(b); Sec. 430.206(b)(6); Sec. 430.207(d); Sec. 430.208(b);

part 451 (authority citation); Secs. 451.101 (a) and (c); Sec. 451.102

(award program); Sec. 451.104(b); Secs. 451.105 (a) and (b),

Secs. 451.106 (b) and (h); Secs. 451.107 (a) and (b); Sec. 451.201(b);

Sec. 531.402(a); Sec. 531.403 (acceptable level of competence,

equivalent increase) Sec. 531.409(d)(2); and Secs. 531.507 (a) and

(b).)

IX. Requests for Guidance

Fourteen commenters requested that OPM provide additional guidance

on a variety of topics, including:

how to proceed from a centralized to a decentralized

approach to systems and programs;

model appraisal and award programs and information about

agency experience;

examples of what the phrase ``or otherwise recorded''

might cover and how agencies can appropriately move to a paperless

format;

examples of Governmentwide regulations with compliance

implications for designing an award program; and

examples of criteria and procedures that could be used to

identify ``sustained performance of high quality'' when determining

eligibility for quality step increases under appraisal programs that do

not use a Level 5 summary.

OPM will issue additional guidance in various formats on all of these

issues. In particular, agency personnel directors will receive specific

guidance for submitting agency system descriptions. OPM will also

provide program designers with examples of the wide variety of programs

that can be designed under a single, flexible agency appraisal system.

E.O. 12866, Regulatory Review

This rule has been reviewed by the Office of Management and Budget

in accordance with E.O. 12866.

Regulatory Flexibility Act

I certify that these regulations will not have a significant

economic impact on a substantial number of small entities because they

apply only to Federal agencies and employees.

List of Subjects

5 CFR Parts 430 and 451

Decorations, medals, awards, Government employees.

5 CFR Part 432

Administrative practice and procedure, Government employees.

[[Page 43943]]

5 CFR Part 531

Government employees, Law enforcement officers, Wages.

U.S. Office of Personnel Management.

James B. King,

Director.

Accordingly, OPM is amending parts 430, 432, 451 and 531 of title

5, Code of Federal Regulations, as follows:

PART 430--PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT

1. The authority citation for part 430 is revised to read as

follows:

Authority: 5 U.S.C. chapter 43.

2. Subpart A, is revised to read as follows:

Subpart A--Performance Management

Sec.

430.101 Authority.

430.102 Performance management.

Subpart A--Performance Management

Sec. 430.101 Authority.

Chapter 43 of title 5, United States Code, provides for the

performance appraisal of Federal employees. This subpart supplements

and implements this portion of the law.

Sec. 430.102 Performance management.

(a) Performance management is the systematic process by which an

agency involves its employees, as individuals and members of a group,

in improving organizational effectiveness in the accomplishment of

agency mission and goals.

(b) Performance management integrates the processes in agency uses

to--

(1) Communicate and clarify organizational goals to employees;

(2) Identify individual and, where applicable, team accountability

for accomplishing organizational goals;

(3) Identify and address developmental needs for individuals and,

where applicable, teams;

(4) Assess and improve individual, team, and organizational

performance;

(5) Use appropriate measures of performance as the basis for

recognizing and rewarding accomplishments; and

(6) Use the results of performance appraisal as a basis for

appropriate personnel actions.

3. Subpart B, consisting of Secs. 430.201 through 430.210, is

revised to read as follows:

Subpart B--Performance Appraisal for General Schedule, Prevailing

Rate, and Certain Other Employees

Sec.

430.201 General.

430.202 Coverage.

430.203 Definitions.

430.204 Agency performance appraisal system(s).

430.205 Agency performance appraisal program(s).

430.206 Planning performance.

430.207 Monitoring performance.

430.208 Rating performance.

430.209 Agency responsibilities.

430.210 OPM responsibilities.

Subpart B--Performance Appraisal for General Schedule, Prevailing

Rate, and Certain Other Employees

Sec. 430.201 General.

(a) Statutory authority. Chapter 43 of title 5, United States Code,

provides for the establishment of agency performance appraisal systems

and requires the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) to prescribe

regulations governing such systems. The regulations in this subpart in

combination with statute set forth the requirements for agency

performance appraisal system(s) and program(s) for employees covered by

subchapter I of chapter 43.

(b) Savings provision. The performance appraisal system portion of

an agency's Performance Management Plan approved by OPM as of August

23, 1995 shall constitute an approved performance appraisal system

under the regulations in this subpart until such time changes to the

system are approved. No provision of the regulations in this subpart

shall be applied in such a way as to affect any administrative

proceeding related to any action taken under regulations in this

chapter pending on August 23, 1995.

Sec. 430.202 Coverage.

(a) Employees and agencies covered by statute. (1) Section 4301(1)

of title 5, United States Code, defines agencies covered by this

subpart.

(2) Section 4301(2) of title 5, United States Code, defines

employees covered by statute by this subpart. Besides General Schedule

(GS/GM) and prevailing rate employees, coverage includes, but is not

limited to, senior-level and scientific and professional employees paid

under 5 U.S.C. 5376.

(b) Statutory exclusions. This subpart does not apply to agencies

or employees excluded by 5 U.S.C. 4301(1) and (2), the United States

Postal Service, or the Postal Rate Commission.

(c) Administrative exclusions. OPM may exclude any position or

group of positions in the excepted service under the authority of 5

U.S.C. 4301(2)(G). The regulations in this subpart exclude excepted

service positions for which employment is not reasonably expected to

exceed the minimum period established under Sec. 430.207(a) in a

consecutive 12-month period.

(d) Agency requests for exclusions. Heads of agencies or their

designees may request the Director of OPM to exclude positions in the

excepted service. The request must be in writing, explaining why the

exclusion would be in the interest of good administration.

Sec. 430.203 Definitions.

In this subpart, terms are defined as follows:

Additional performance element means a dimension or aspect of

individual, team, or organizational performance that is not a critical

or non-critical element. Such elements are not used in assigning a

summary level but, like critical and non-critical elements, are useful

for purposes such as communicating performance expectations and serving

as the basis for granting awards. Such elements may include, but are

not limited to, objectives, goals, program plans, work plans, and other

means of expressing expected performance.

Appraisal means the process under which performance is reviewed and

evaluated.

Appraisal period means the established period of time for which

performance will be reviewed and a rating of record will be prepared.

Appraisal program means the specific procedures and requirements

established under the policies and parameters of an agency appraisal

system.

Appraisal system means a framework of policies and parameters

established by an agency as defined at 5 U.S.C. 4301(1) for the

administration of performance appraisal programs under subchapter I of

chapter 43 of title 5, United States Code, and this subpart.

Critical element means a work assignment or responsibility of such

importance that unacceptable performance on the element would result in

a determination that an employee's overall performance is unacceptable.

Non-critical element means a dimension or aspect of individual,

team, or organizational performance, exclusive of a critical element,

that is used in assigning a summary level. Such elements may include,

but are not limited to, objectives, goals, program plans, work plans,

and other means of expressing expected performance.

Performance means accomplishment of work assignments or

responsibilities.

Performance appraisal system: See Appraisal system.

Performance plan means all of the written, or otherwise recorded,

[[Page 43944]]

performance elements that set forth expected performance. A plan must

include all critical and non-critical elements and their performance

standards.

Performance rating means the written, or otherwise recorded,

appraisal of performance compared to the performance standard(s) for

each critical and non-critical element on which there has been an

opportunity to perform for the minimum period. A performance rating may

include the assignment of a summary level (as specified in

Sec. 430.208(d)).

Performance standard means the management-approved expression of

the performance threshold(s), requirement(s), or expectation(s) that

must be met to be appraised at a particular level of performance. A

performance standard may include, but is not limited to, quality,

quantity, timeliness, and manner of performance.

Progress review means communicating with the employee about

performance compared to the performance standards of critical and non-

critical elements.

Rating of record means the performance rating prepared at the end

of an appraisal period for performance over the entire period and the

assignment of a summary level (as specified in Sec. 430.208(d)). This

constitutes the official rating of record referenced in this chapter.

Sec. 430.204 Agency performance appraisal system(s).

(a) Each agency as defined at section 4301(1) of title 5, United

States Code, shall develop one or more performance appraisal systems

for employees covered by this subpart.

(b) An agency appraisal system shall establish agencywide policies

and parameters for the application and operation of performance

appraisal within the agency for the employees covered by the system. At

a minimum, a agency system shall--

(1) Provide for--

(i) Establishing employee performance plans, including, but not

limited to, critical elements and performance standards;

(ii) Communicating performance plans to employees at the beginning

of an appraisal period;

(iii) Evaluating each employee during the appraisal period on the

employee's elements and standards;

(iv) Recognizing and rewarding employees whose performance so

warrants;

(v) Assisting employees in improving unacceptable performance; and

(vi) Reassigning, reducing in grade, or removing employees who

continue to have unacceptable performance, but only after an

opportunity to demonstrate acceptable performance.

(2) Identify employees covered by the system;

(3) Specify the flexibilities an agency program established under

the system has for setting--

(i) The length of the appraisal period (as specified in

Sec. 430.206(a));

(ii) The length of the minimum period (as specified in

Sec. 430.207(a));

(iii) The number(s) of performance levels at which critical and

non-critical elements may be appraised (as specified in

Sec. 430.206(b)(7) (i)(A) and (ii)(A)); and

(iv) The pattern of summary levels that may be assigned in a rating

of record (as specified in Sec. 420.208(d));

(4) Include, where applicable, criteria and procedures for

establishing separate appraisal programs under an appraisal system; and

(5) Require that an appraisal program shall conform to statute, the

regulations of this chapter, and the requirements established by the

appraisal system.

(c) Agencies are encouraged to involve employees in developing and

implementing their system(s). When agencies involve employees, the

method of involvement shall be in accordance with the law.

Sec. 430.205 Agency performance appraisal program(s).

(a) Each agency shall establish at least one appraisal program of

specific procedures and requirements to be implemented in accordance

with the applicable agency appraisal system. At a minimum, each

appraisal program shall specify the employees covered by the program

and include the procedures and requirements for planning performance

(as specified in Sec. 430.206), monitoring performance (as specified in

Sec. 430.207), and rating performance (as specified in Sec. 430.208).

(b) An agency program shall establish criteria and procedures to

address employee performance for employees who are on detail, who are

transferred, and for other special circumstances as established by the

agency.

(c) An agency may permit the development of separate appraisal

programs under an appraisal system.

(d) Agencies are encouraged to involve employees in developing and

implementing their program(s). When agencies involve employees, the

method of involvement shall be in accordance with law.

Sec. 430.206 Planning performance.

(a) Appraisal period. (1) An appraisal program shall designate an

official appraisal period for which a performance plan shall be

prepared, during which performance shall be monitored, and for which a

rating of record shall be prepared.

(2) The appraisal period shall generally be designated so that

employees shall be provided a rating of record on an annual basis. An

appraisal program may provide that longer appraisal periods may be

designated when work assignments and responsibilities so warrant or

performance management objectives can be achieved more effectively.

(b) Performance plan. (1) Agencies shall encourage employee

participation in establishing performance plans.

(2) Performance plans shall be provided to employees at the

beginning of each appraisal period (normally within 30 days).

(3) An appraisal program shall require that each employee be

covered by an appropriate written, or otherwise recorded, performance

plan based on work assignments and responsibilities.

(4) Each performance plan shall include all elements which are used

in deriving and assigning a summary level, including--

(i) At least one critical element that addresses individual

performance; and

(ii) Any non-critical element(s).

(5) Each performance plan may include one or more additional

performance elements, which--

(i) Are not used in deriving and assigning a summary level, and

(ii) Are used to support performance management processes as

described at Sec. 430.102(b).

(6) An appraisal program shall establish how many and which

performance levels may be used to appraise critical and non-critical

elements.

(7) Elements and standards shall be established as follows--

(i) For a critical element--

(A) At least two levels for appraisal shall be used with one level

being ``Fully Successful'' or its equivalent and another level being

``Unacceptable,'' and

(B) A performance standard shall be established at the ``Fully

Successful'' level and may be established at other levels.

(ii) For non-critical elements, when established,--

(A) At least two levels for appraisal shall be used, and

(B) A performance standard(s) shall be established at whatever

level(s) is appropriate.

(iii) The absence of an established performance standard at a level

specified in the program shall not preclude a determination that

performance is at that level.

[[Page 43945]]

Sec. 430.207 Monitoring performance.

(a) Minimum period. An appraisal program shall establish a minimum

period of performance that must be completed before a performance

rating may be prepared.

(b) Ongoing appraisal. An appraisal program shall include methods

for appraising each critical and non-critical element during the

appraisal period. Performance on each critical and non-critical element

shall be appraised against its performance standard(s). Ongoing

appraisal methods shall include, but not be limited to, conducting one

or more progress reviews during each appraisal period.

(c) Marginal performance. Appraisal programs should provide

assistance whenever performance is determined to be below ``Fully

Successful'' or equivalent but above ``Unacceptable.''

(d) Unacceptable performance. An appraisal program shall provide

for--

(1) Assisting employees in improving unacceptable performance at

any time during the appraisal period that performance is determined to

be unacceptable in one or more critical elements; and

(2) Taking action based on unacceptable performance.

Sec. 430.208 Rating performance.

(a) As soon as practicable after the end of the appraisal period, a

written, or otherwise recorded, rating of record shall be given to each

employee.

(b) Rating of record procedures for each appraisal program shall

include a method for deriving and assigning a summary level as

specified in paragraph (d) of this section based on appraisal of

performance on critical elements and, as applicable, non-critical

elements.

(1) A Level 1 summary (``Unacceptable'') shall be assigned if and

only if performance on one or more critical elements is appraised as

``Unacceptable.''

(2) Consideration of non-critical elements shall not result in

assigning a Level 1 summary (`` Unacceptable'').

(c) The method for deriving and assigning a summary level may not

limit or require the use of particular summary levels (i.e., establish

a forced distribution of summary levels). However, methods used to make

distinctions among employees or groups of employees such as comparing,

categorizing, and ranking employees or groups on the basis of their

performance may be used for purposes other than assigning a summary

level including, but not limited to, award determinations and promotion

decisions.

(d) Summary levels. (1) An appraisal program shall use one of the

following patterns of summary levels:

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Summary level

Pattern -------------------------------------------------

1 2 3 4 5

------------------------------------------------------------------------

A..................... X ........ X ........ ........

B..................... X ........ X ........ X

C..................... X ........ X X ........

D..................... X X X ........ ........

E..................... X ........ X X X

F..................... X X X ........ X

G..................... X X X X ........

H..................... X X X X X

------------------------------------------------------------------------

(2) Summary levels shall comply with the following requirements:

(i) Level 1 through Level 5 are ordered categories, with Level 1 as

the lowest and Level 5 as the highest;

(ii) Level 1 is ``Unacceptable'';

(iii) Level 3 is ``Fully Successful'' or equivalent; and

(iv) Level 5 is ``Outstanding'' or equivalent.

(3) The term ``Outstanding'' shall be used only to describe a Level

5 summary.

(4) Summary levels (Level 1 through Level 5) shall be used to

provide consistency in describing ratings of record and in referencing

other related regulations (including, but not limited to, Sec. 351.504

of this chapter).

(e) A rating of record of ``Unacceptable'' (Level 1) shall be

reviewed and approved by a higher level management official.

(f) The rating of record or performance rating for a disabled

veteran shall not be lowered because the veteran has been absent from

work to seek medical treatment as provided in Executive Order 5396.

(g) When a rating of record cannot be prepared at the time

specified, the appraisal period shall be extended. Once the conditions

necessary to complete a rating of record have been met, a rating of

record shall be prepared as soon as practicable.

(h) A performance rating may be prepared at such other times as an

appraisal program may specify for special circumstances including, but

not limited to, transfers and performance on details.

Sec. 430.209 Agency responsibilities.

An agency shall--

(a) Submit to OPM for approval a description of its appraisal

system(s) as specified in Sec. 430.204(b) of this subpart, and any

subsequent changes that modify any element of the agency's system(s)

that is subject to a regulatory requirement in this part;

(b) Transfer the employee's most recent ratings of record, and any

subsequent performance ratings, when an employee transfers to another

agency or is assigned to another organization within the agency in

compliance with part 293 of this chapter and instructions in the OPM

Operating Manual, THE GUIDE TO PERSONNEL RECORDKEEPING, for sale by the

U.S. Government Printing Office, Superintendent of Documents;

(c) Communicate with supervisors and employees (e.g., through

formal training) about relevant parts of its performance appraisal

system(s) and program(s);

(d) Evaluate the performance appraisal system(s) and performance

appraisal program(s) in operation in the agency;

(e) Report ratings of record data to the Central Personnel Data

File in compliance with instructions in the OPM Operating Manual,

FEDERAL WORKFORCE REPORTING SYSTEMS, for sale by the U.S. Government

Printing Office, Superintendent of Documents;

(f) Maintain and submit such records as OPM may require; and

(g) Take any action required by OPM to ensure conformance with

applicable law, regulation, and OPM policy.

Sec. 430.210 OPM responsibilities.

(a) OPM shall review and approve an agency's performance appraisal

system(s).

(b) OPM may evaluate the operation and application of an agency's

[[Page 43946]]

performance appraisal system(s) and program(s).

(c) If OPM determines that an appraisal system or program does not

meet the requirements of applicable law, regulation, or OPM policy, it

shall direct the agency to implement an appropriate system or program

or to take other corrective action.

4. In Sec. 430.303, the last sentence of the definition of

Performance Management Plan is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 430.303 Definitions.

* * * * *

Performance Management Plan * * * The Performance Management Plan,

which includes the SES performance appraisal plan, must be submitted to

OPM for review and approval as required in Sec. 430.310 of this

subpart.

* * * * *

5. Section 430.310 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 430.310 SES Performance appraisal systems.

Agencies must submit proposed SES performance appraisal plans to

OPM for approval as part of Performance Management Plans in accordance

with provisions of this subpart.

6. Subpart D [Reserved], and Subpart E, consisting of Secs. 430.501

through 430.506, are removed.

PART 432--PERFORMANCE BASED REDUCTION IN GRADE AND REMOVAL ACTIONS

7. The authority citation for part 432 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 5 U.S.C. 4303, 4305.

8. In Sec. 432.103, paragraph (b) is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 432.103 Definitions.

* * * * *

(b) Critical element means a work assignment or responsibility of

such importance that unacceptable performance on the element would

result in a determination that an employee's overall performance is

unacceptable.

* * * * *

PART 451--AWARDS

9. The title of part 451 is revised to read as follows:

PART 451--AWARDS

10. The authority citation for part 451 is revised to read as

follows:

Authority: 5 U.S.C. 4302, 4501-4509; E.O. 11438, 12828.

11. Subpart A, consisting of Secs. 451.101 through 451.107, is

revised to read as follows:

Subpart A--Agency Awards

Sec.

451.101 Authority and coverage.

451.102 Definitions.

451.103 Agency award program(s).

451.104 Awards.

451.105 Award restrictions.

451.106 Agency responsibilities.

451.107 OPM responsibilities.

Subpart A--Agency Awards

Sec. 451.101 Authority and coverage.

(a) Chapter 45 of title 5, United States Code authorizes agencies

to pay a cash award to, grant time-off to, and incur necessary expense

for the honorary recognition of, an employee (individually or as a

member of a group) and requires the Office of Personnel Management to

prescribe regulations governing such authority. Chapter 43 of title 5,

United States Code, provides for recognizing and rewarding employees

whose performance so warrants. The regulations in this subpart, in

combination with chapters 43 and 45 of title 5, United States Code, and

any other applicable law, establish the requirements for agency award

programs.

(b) Section 4 of E.O. 11438 (Prescribing Procedures Governing

Interdepartmental Cash Awards to the Members of the Armed Forces,

December 3, 1968) requires the Office of Personnel Management to

prescribe procedures for covering the cost of a cash award recommended

by more than one agency for a member of the armed forces for the

adoption or use of a suggestion, invention, or scientific achievement.

Section 1 of E.O. 12828 (Delegation of Certain Personnel Management

Authorities, January 5, 1993) delegates to the Office of Personnel

Management the authority of the President to permit performance-based

cash awards under 5 U.S.C. 4505a to be paid to categories of employees

who would not be eligible otherwise.

(c) This subpart applies to employees as defined by section 2105

and agencies as defined by section 4501 title 5, United States Code,

except as provided in Secs. 451.105 and 451.201(b).

(d) For the regulatory requirements for granting performance awards

to Senior Executive Service (SES) employees under 5 U.S.C. 5384, refer

to Sec. 534.403 of this chapter.

Sec. 451.102 Definitions.

Award means something bestowed or an action taken to recognize and

reward individual or team achievement that contributes to meeting

organizational goals or improving the efficiency, effectiveness, and

economy of the Government or is otherwise in the public interest. Such

awards include, but are not limited to, employee incentives which are

based on predetermined criteria such as productivity standards,

performance goals, measurement systems, award formulas, or payout

schedules.

Award program means the specific procedures and requirements

established by an agency or a component of an agency for granting

awards under subchapter I of chapter 43 and subchapter I of chapter 45

of title 5, United States Code, and this subpart.

Sec. 451.103 Agency award program(s).

(a) Agencies shall develop one or more award programs for employees

covered by this subpart.

(b) Agencies are encouraged to involve employees in developing such

programs. When agencies involve employees, the method of involvement

shall be in accordance with law.

(c) An agency award program shall provide for--

(1) Obligating funds consistent with applicable agency financial

management controls and delegations of authority; and

(2) Documenting justification for awards that are not based on a

rating of record (as defined in Sec. 430.20 of this chapter).

Sec. 451.104 Awards.

(a) An agency may grant a cash, honorary, or informal recognition

award, or grant time-off without charge to leave or loss of pay

consistent with chapter 45 of title 5, United States Code, and this

part to an employee, as an individual or member of a group, on the

basis of--

(1) A suggestion, invention, superior accomplishment, productivity

gain, or other personal effort that contributes to the efficiency,

economy, or other improvement of Government operations or achieves a

significant reduction in paperwork;

(2) A special act or service in the public interest in connection

with or related to official employment; or

(3) Performance as reflected in the employee's most recent rating

of record (as defined in Sec. 430.203 of this chapter), except that

performance awards may be paid to SES employees only under Sec. 534.403

of this chapter and not on the basis of this subpart.

(b) A cash award under this subpart is a lump sum payment and is

not basic pay for any purpose.

(c) An award is subject to applicable tax rules, such as

withholding.

[[Page 43947]]

(d) When an award is approved for--

(1) An employee of another agency, the benefiting agency shall make

arrangements to transfer funds to the employing agency to cover the

award. If the administrative costs of transferring funds would exceed

the amount of the award, the employing agency shall absorb the award

costs and pay the award; and

(2) A member of the armed forces for a suggestion, invention, or

scientific achievement, arrangements shall be made to transfer funds to

the agency having jurisdiction over the member in accordance with E.O.

11438, ``Prescribing Procedures Governing Interdepartmental Cash Awards

to the Members of the Armed Forces''.

(e) An award may be granted to a separated employee or the legal

heir(s) or estate of a deceased employee.

(f) A time-off award granted under this subpart shall not be

converted to a cash payment under any circumstances.

(g) When granting an award on the basis of a rating of record that

is paid as a percentage of basic pay under 5 U.S.C. 4505a(a)(2)(A), the

rate of basic pay used shall be determined without taking into account

any locality-based comparability payment under 5 U.S.C. 5304 or an

interim geographic adjustment or special law enforcement adjustment

under section 302 or 404 of the Federal Employees Pay Comparability Act

of 1990, respectively.

Sec. 451.105 Award restrictions.

(a) In accordance with 5 U.S.C. 4508, agencies shall not grant

awards under this subpart during a Presidential election period to

employees who are--

(1) In a Senior Executive Service position and not a career

appointee as defined under 5 U.S.C. 3132(a)(4); or

(2) In an excepted service position of a confidential or policy-

determining character (schedule C).

(b) In accordance with 5 U.S.C. 4509, agencies shall not grant cash

awards under this subpart to employees appointed by the President with

Senate confirmation who serve in--

(1) An Executive Schedule position, or

(2) A position for which pay is set in statute by reference to a

section or level of the Executive Schedule.

Sec. 451.106 Agency responsibilities.

(a) In establishing and operating its award program(s), an agency

shall assure that a program does not conflict with or violate any other

law or Governmentwide regulation.

(b) When a recommended award would grant more than $10,000 to an

individual employee, the agency shall submit the recommendation to OPM

for approval.

(c) Agencies shall provide for communicating with employees and

supervisors (e.g., through formal training) about the relevant parts of

their award program(s).

(d) Agencies shall evaluate their award program(s).

(e) Agencies shall document all cash and time off awards in

compliance with instructions in the OPM Operating Manual, THE GUIDE TO

PROCESSING PERSONNEL ACTIONS, for sale by the U.S. Government Printing

Office, Superintendent of Documents.

(f) Agencies shall file award documents in the Official Personnel

Folder in compliance with instructions in the OPM Operating Manual, THE

GUIDE TO PERSONNEL RECORDKEEPING, for sale by the U.S. Government

Printing Office, Superintendent of Documents.

(g) Agencies shall report award data to the Central Personnel Data

File in Compliance with instructions in the OPM Operating Manual,

FEDERAL WORKFORCE REPORTING SYSTEMS, for sale by the U.S. Government

Printing Office, Superintendent of Documents.

(h) Agencies shall maintain and submit to OPM such records as OPM

may require.

(i) Agencies shall give due weight to an award granted under this

part in qualifying and selecting an employee for promotion as provided

in 5 U.S.C. 3362.

(j) Agencies shall take any corrective action required by OPM to

ensure conformance with applicable law, regulation, and OPM policy.

Sec. 451.107 OPM responsibilities.

(a) OPM shall review and approve or disapprove each agency

recommendation for an award that would grant more than $10,000 to an

individual employee.

(b) When a recommended award would grant more than $25,000 to an

individual employee, OPM shall review the recommendation and submit it

(if approved) to the President for final approval.

(c) OPM shall review and approve or disapprove a request from the

head of an Executive agency to extend the provisions of 5 U.S.C. 4505a

to any category of employees within that agency that would not be

covered otherwise.

(d) OPM may evaluate the operation and application of an agency's

award program(s).

12. In Sec. 451.201, the second introductory paragraph (a) is

removed, paragraph (b), (c), and (d) are redesignated as paragraphs

(c), (d), and (e) respectively, and a new paragraph (b) is added to

read as follows:

Sec. 451.201 Authority and coverage.

* * * * *

(b) Awards granted under paragraph (a) of this section are subject

to the restrictions as specified in Sec. 451.105.

* * * * *

13. Subpart C, consisting of Secs. 451.301 through 451.307, is

removed.

PART 531--PAY UNDER THE GENERAL SCHEDULE

14. The authority citation for part 531 continues to read as

follows:

Authority: 5 U.S.C. 5115, 5307, and 5338; sec. 4 of Pub. L. 103-

89, 107 Stat. 981; and E.O. 12748, 56 FR 4521, 3 CFR, 1991 Comp., p.

316;

Subpart A also issued under 5 U.S.C. 5304, 5305, and 5553;

section 302 of the Federal Employees Pay Comparability Act of 1990

(FEPCA), Pub. L. 101-509, 104 Stat. 1462; and E.O. 12786, 56 FR

67453, 3 CFR, 1991 Comp., p. 376;

Subpart B also issued under 5 U.S.C. 5303(g), 5333, 5334(a), and

7701(b)(2);

Subpart C also issued under 5 U.S.C. 5304, 5305, and 5553;

sections 302 and 404 of FEPCA, Pub. L. 101-509, 104 Stat. 1462 and

1466; and section 3(7) of Pub. L. 102-378, 106 Stat. 1356;

Subpart D also issued under 5 U.S.C. 5335(g) and 7701(b)(2);

Subpart E also issued under 5 U.S.C. 5336;

Subpart F also issued under 5 U.S.C. 5304, 5305(g)(1), and 5553;

and E.O. 12883, 58 FR 63281, 3 CFR, 1993 Comp., p. 682.

15. In Sec. 531.402, paragraph (a) is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.402 Employee coverage.

(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b) of this section, this

subpart applies to employees who occupy permanent positions classified

and paid under the General Schedule and who are paid less than the

maximum rate of their grades.

* * * * *

16. In Sec. 531.403, the definitions of acceptable level of

competence, critical element, and equivalent increase are revised to

read as follows:

Sec. 531.403 Definitions.

* * * * *

Acceptable level of competence means performance by an employee

that warrants advancement of the employee's rate of basic pay to the

next higher step of the grade or the next higher rate within the grade

(as defined in this section) of his or her position, subject to the

requirements of Sec. 531.404 of this subpart, as determined by the head

of the agency.

* * * * *

[[Page 43948]]

Critical element has the meaning given that term in Sec. 430.203 of

this chapter.

* * * * *

Equivalent increase means an increase or increases in an employee's

rate of basic pay equal to or greater than the difference between the

employee's rate of basic pay and the rate of pay for the next higher

step of that grade or the next higher rate within the grade (as defined

in this section).

* * * * *

17. In Sec. 531.404, the introductory text, and the introductory

text of paragraph (a) are revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.404 Earning within-grade increase.

An employee paid at less than the maximum rate of the grade of his

or her position shall earn advancement in pay to the next higher step

of the grade or the next higher rate within the grade (as defined in

Sec. 531.403) upon meeting the following three requirements established

by law:

(a) The employee's performance must be at an acceptable level of

competence, as defined in this subpart. To be determined at an

acceptable level of competence, the employee's most recent rating of

record (as defined in Sec. 430.203 of this chapter) shall be at least

Level 3 (``Fully Successful'' or equivalent).

* * * * *

18. Section 531.408 is removed and reserved.

Sec. 531.408 [Reserved].

19. In Sec. 531.409, paragraphs (b) and (d) are revised to read as

follows:

Sec. 531.409 Acceptable level of competence determinations.

* * * * *

(b) Basis for determination. When applicable, an acceptable level

of competence determination shall be based on a current rating of

record made under part 430, subpart B, of this chapter. For those

agencies not covered by chapter 43 of title 5, United States Code, and

for employees in positions excluded from 5 U.S.C. 4301, an acceptable

level of competence determination shall be based on performance

appraisal requirements established by the agency. If an employee has

been reduced in grade because of unacceptable performance and has

served in one position at the lower grade for at least the minimum

period established by the agency, a rating of record at the lower grade

shall be used as the basis for an acceptable level of competence

determination.

* * * * *

(d) Waiver of requirement for determination. (1) An acceptable

level of competence determination shall be waived and a within-grade

increase granted when an employee has not served in any position for

the minimum period under an applicable agency performance appraisal

program during the final 52 calendar weeks of the waiting period for

one or more of the following reasons:

(i) Because of absences that are creditable service in the

computation of a waiting period or periods under Sec. 531.406 of this

subpart;

(ii) Because of paid leave;

(iii) Because the employee received service credit under the back

pay provisions of subpart H of part 550 of this chapter;

(iv) Because of details to another agency or employer for which no

rating has been prepared;

(v) Because the employee has had insufficient time to demonstrate

an acceptable level of competence due to authorized activities of

official interest to the agency not subject to appraisal under part 430

of this chapter (including, but not limited to, labor-management

partnership activities under section 2 of Executive Order 12871 and

serving as a representative of a labor organization under chapter 71 of

title 5, United States Code); or

(vi) Because of long-term training.

(2) When an acceptable level of competence determination has been

waived and a within-grade increase granted under paragraph (d)(1) of

this section, there shall be a presumption that the employee would have

performed at an acceptable level of competence had the employee

performed the duties of his or her position of record for the minimum

period under the applicable agency performance appraisal program.

* * * * *

20. Section 531.501 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.501 Applicability.

This subpart contains regulations of the Office of Personnel

Management to carry out section 5336 of title 5, United States Code,

which authorizes the head of an agency, or another official to whom

such authority is delegated, to grant quality step increases.

21. Section 531.503 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.503 Purpose of quality step increases.

The purpose of quality step increases is to provide appropriate

incentives and recognition for excellence in performance by granting

faster than normal step increases.

22. Section 531.504 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.504 Level of performance required for quality step increase.

A quality step increase shall not be required but may be granted

only to--

(a) An employee who receives a rating of record at Level 5

(``Outstanding'' or equivalent), as defined in part 430, subpart B, of

this chapter; or

(b) An employee who, when covered by a performance appraisal

program that does not use a Level 5 summary--

(1) Receives a rating of record at the highest summary level used

by the program; and

(2) Demonstrates sustained performance of high quality

significantly above that expected at the ``Fully Successful'' level in

the type of position concerned, as determined under performance-related

criteria established by the agency.

23. Section 531.506 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.506 Effective date of a quality step increase.

The quality step increase should be made effective as soon as

practicable after it is approved.

24. Section 531.507 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.507 Agency responsibilities.

(a) Agencies shall maintain and submit to OPM such records as OPM

may require.

(b) Agencies shall report quality step increases to the Central

Personnel Data File in compliance with instructions in the OPM

Operating Manual, FEDERAL WORKFORCE REPORTING SYSTEMS, for sale by the

U.S. Government Printing Office, Superintendent of Documents.

25. Section 531.508 is revised to read as follows:

Sec. 531.508 Evaluation of quality step increase authority.

The Office of Personnel Management may evaluate an agency's use of

the authority to grant quality step increases. The agency shall take

any corrective action required by the Office.

[FR Doc. 95-20745 Filed 8-22-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 6325-01-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.