Centers for Independent Living

Federal RegisterAug 1, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUMMARY: The Secretary amends the regulations governing the Centers for

Independent Living (CIL) program. These regulations are needed to

establish indicators of minimum compliance with the evaluation

standards for centers for independent living enacted in the

Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (Act), as amended by the Rehabilitation Act

Amendments of 1992 (1992 Amendments) and the Rehabilitation Act

Amendments of 1993 (1993 Amendments).

EFFECTIVE DATE: These regulations take effect August 31, 1995.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: John Nelson, U.S. Department of

Education, 600 Independence Avenue, SW., Room 3326, Mary E. Switzer

Building, Washington, DC 20202-2741. Telephone or TDD: (202) 205-9362.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The CIL program supports the planning for

and establishing, conducting, administrating, assisting, and evaluating

of centers. These regulations add a new subpart G to 34 CFR part 366,

which contains the regulations governing the CIL program. Section

725(b) of the Act establishes evaluation standards for centers. Section

706(b) of the Act requires the Secretary to publish indicators of what

constitutes minimum compliance with the evaluation standards. Subpart G

incorporates these evaluation standards and compliance indicators into

the program regulations.

The CIL program is an important part of the National Education

Goals. This program supports the National Education Goal that, by the

year 2000, every adult American will be literate and will possess the

knowledge and skills necessary to compete in a global economy and

exercise the rights and responsibilities of citizenship.

The Rehabilitation Act Amendments of 1986, Pub. L. 99-506, required

that the Secretary publish indicators of what constitutes minimum

compliance with the evaluation standards under section 711(e) of the

Act, as it existed prior to the 1992 Amendments, Pub. L. 102-569. The

Secretary published proposed compliance indicators in the Federal

Register in an advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM) on July

10, 1992. The Secretary received over 100 written comments during the

comment period on the ANPRM, as well as 35 oral comments during a

public meeting held on August 27, 1992. Following the publication of

the ANPRM, the Secretary also solicited and received input from experts

in the field concerning alternative approaches to the indicators.

The major elements of six of the evaluation standards proposed by

the U.S. Department of Education (Department) in the ANPRM were

codified as part of the Act by the 1992 Amendments, which was enacted

shortly after publication of the ANPRM. In addition, the 1992

Amendments requires that the Secretary publish indicators of what

constitutes minimum compliance with the evaluation standards under

section 725(b) of the Act.

On October 27, 1993, the Secretary published a notice of proposed

rulemaking (NPRM) in the Federal Register (58 FR 57942) proposing to

amend existing regulations for the CIL program by establishing

indicators of minimum compliance with the new evaluation standards. On

December 21, 1993 (58 FR 67383), the Secretary extended the comment

period on the NPRM to coincide with the comment period on the proposed

regulations implementing other changes to Title VII of the Act. The

major issues related to the CIL program were discussed in the preamble

to the NPRM.

In general, the commenters agreed with the direction that the

Department had taken. However, a significant number of the commenters

were opposed to the bifurcated approach of demonstrating compliance

with the evaluation standards through (1) Baseline requirements that

had to be met by all centers and (2) a selection of various activities

that centers could choose from to earn a minimum number of bonus

points. Some commenters believed that this approach placed small

centers at a disadvantage. Another commenter stated that this approach

appeared to establish two sets of minimum standards without

establishing one absolute minimum standard. The Secretary agrees that

the indicators should be simplified by eliminating the requirement that

centers engage in various activities within each of the indicators to

earn a minimum number of bonus points to comply with the evaluation

standards. Therefore, in response to these and other public comments,

the final regulations delete the bonus point approach, including all of

the bonus point activities. In addition, the final regulations include

other changes to the NPRM made in response to public comment.

The Secretary also is moving to 34 CFR part 366 two of the

definitions that were proposed to be added to 34 CFR part 364 in the

NPRM.

Analysis of Comments and Changes

In response to the Secretary's invitation in the NPRM, 99 parties

submitted comments on the proposed regulations. An analysis of the

comments and of the changes in the regulations since publication of the

NPRM follows. General comments are discussed first, followed by

comments on specific sections of the regulations. Because the bonus

point activities have been eliminated as part of the elimination of the

bonus point approach, comments on each of these bonus point activities

are not discussed. In addition, technical and other minor changes--and

suggested changes the Secretary is not legally authorized to make under

the applicable statutory authority--are not addressed.

General Comments

Comments: One commenter expressed concern that the proposed

regulations did not include or mention assistive technology services

and devices. This commenter recommended that centers demonstrate how

these services and devices are provided.

Discussion: Although a center may provide assistive services and

devices to a particular individual, assistive services and devices are

not listed in the Act as a specific IL service that a center is

required to provide. Therefore, the Secretary does not believe centers

should be required to demonstrate that they have provided these

services to achieve minimum compliance with the evaluation standards

for the CIL program.

Changes: None.

Comments: Several commenters recommended that the regulations place

more emphasis on advocacy activities and less on service delivery. In

addition, some commenters recommended that the regulations place more

emphasis on outcomes and less on process.

Discussion: The Secretary believes that the final regulations

properly reflect the emphasis on advocacy activities, service delivery,

and outcomes found in the Act.

Changes: None.

Comments: None.

Discussion: Since publication of the NPRM, the Secretary has

amended 34 CFR 75.118(a) and deleted the requirement for applications

for non-competing continuation awards. In the place of an application,

an applicant for

[[Page 39217]]

a continuation award needs to submit only a simple performance report.

Changes: The Secretary has deleted all references to an application for

a continuation award and substituted ``annual performance report'' in

its place in these final regulations.

Definitions (Sec. 366.5)

Comments: None.

Discussion: Since publication of the NPRM, the Secretary has

reviewed the final regulations for IL services programs (34 CFR part

366) that were published in the Federal Register on August 15, 1994 (59

FR 41880) and determined that a definitions section was inadvertently

left out of part 366. This omission was the result of the separate

publication of this subpart G, which included proposed definitions

applicable only to part 366 but did not add a definitions section to

part 366. Therefore, the Secretary is correcting this omission at this

time.

Changes: The Secretary is adding a new ``Sec. 366.5 What

definitions apply to this program?'' to 34 CFR part 366 of the final

regulations for IL services programs. In addition, the Secretary is

redesignating current ``Sec. 366.5 How are program funds allotted?'' as

Sec. 366.6.

Comments: None.

Discussion: Since publication of the NPRM, the Secretary has

published final regulations for the IL services programs. See 59 FR

41880-41912. The Secretary included definitions for the following terms

in those final regulations: ``Individual with a significant

disability,'' ``Minority group,'' ``Significant disability,'' and

``Unserved and underserved groups or populations.'' Therefore, the

Secretary does not believe it is necessary to repeat those definitions

in these final regulations. In addition, the Secretary has determined

that the proposed definitions of ``consumer,'' ``consumer service

record,'' ``cross-disability peer counseling,'' ``information and

referral services,'' ``independent living skills training,'' and ``peer

counseling'' are unnecessary. The Secretary does not believe it is

necessary or useful to establish definitions for these terms through

regulations. The Secretary expects that States and centers will

interpret these terms in a manner that will provide for the efficient

and proper administration of this program. However, comments on

requirements related to the terms ``decisionmaking position'' and

``staff position'' indicate that definitions of these terms will assist

centers in determining how to comply with these requirements.

Changes: The Secretary has deleted the definitions of ``consumer,''

``consumer service record,'' ``cross-disability peer counseling,''

``information and referral services,'' ``independent living skills

training,'' ``individual with a significant disability,'' ``minority

group,'' ``peer counseling,'' ``significant disability,'' and

``unserved or underserved'' from the final regulations.

Comments: Several commenters suggested that the definition of

``decisionmaking position'' be clarified.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that this definition should be

clarified by removing the reference to first-line and second-line

supervisors. The Secretary believes that any supervisor should be

included in the definition of ``decisionmaking position.'' The

Secretary also believes that this definition provides flexibility for

centers to determine who exercises decisionmaking authority within a

center.

Changes: The Secretary has revised the definition of a

``decisionmaking position'' to clarify that any position within a

center that carries the authority to establish policy for the center is

included within this definition.

Comments: A few commenters recommended that the proposed definition

of ``staff position'' be revised to conform with the definition of this

term established by the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL). However, none

of the commenters stated the DOL definition or identified where this

definition can be found. One commenter suggested that decisionmakers be

included in the definition of ``staff position'' because decisionmakers

are also ``staff.''

Discussion: Neither the Secretary nor DOL staff consulted by ED

staff is aware of a DOL definition of ``staff position'' or

``decisionmaking position.'' Although a definition exists for the term

``employee'' in regulations implementing the Fair Labor Standards Act,

the Secretary does not believe DOL's definition of ``employee'' is

either helpful or necessary for purposes of this indicator.

Nevertheless, nothing in the definition of ``staff position'' in the

final regulations is inconsistent with DOL's definition of

``employee.'' The Secretary does not agree that decisionmakers should

be included as ``staff'' for purposes of this indicator because this

would create an unnecessary overlap between the meaning of the terms

``staff position'' and ``decisionmaking position.''

Changes: None.

Comments: Several commenters recommended additional definitions for

the following terms: ``increasing and improving community options,''

``increasing and improving community capacity,'' ``self-help and self-

advocacy,'' and ``systems advocacy.''

Discussion: The Secretary does not believe it is necessary or

useful to establish definitions for these terms through regulations.

The Secretary expects that States and centers will interpret these

terms in a manner that will provide for the efficient and proper

administration of this program.

Changes: None.

Multi-State Centers (Sec. 366.62)

Comments: Several commenters recommended that centers serving more

than one State or region and receiving funds from multiple sources be

reviewed for compliance with the evaluation standards as a single

center.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees with the commenters. The

regulations are silent on this issue and neither require nor permit the

Department to conduct separate reviews of a center for each grant that

the center receives from the Department. The Secretary believes section

706(c)(1) of the Act provides sufficient guidance on the Secretary's

responsibility to conduct on-site compliance reviews of centers and

does not believe it is necessary to regulate further on this issue.

Changes: None.

Staff Positions (Sec. 366.63(a)(1))

Comments: A few commenters agreed with the exclusion of personal

care assistants, readers, and interpreters from the determination of a

center's compliance with the requirement that more than 50 percent of a

center's decisionmaking and staff positions be filled by individuals

with disabilities. These commenters recommended adding van drivers to

the list of those persons to be excluded from this determination. A

couple of commenters disagreed with the exclusion of personal care

assistants, readers, and interpreters from this determination.

Discussion: The Secretary believes that a center should have the

option of excluding drivers, as well as interpreters, personal

assistants, and readers, from the determination of a center's

compliance with this provision.

Changes: The Secretary has added drivers to Sec. 366.63(a)(1)(ii)

of the final regulations and given a center the option of excluding

drivers, interpreters, personal assistants, and readers from the

determination of the center's compliance with this requirement.

Comments: Several commenters did not understand or disagreed with

the proposed use of total number of hours worked by paid employees to

determine a center's compliance with the requirement that more than 50

percent

[[Page 39218]]

of a center's decisionmaking and staff positions must be filled by

individuals with disabilities. One commenter stated that this approach

would be burdensome and would require unnecessary reporting and

recordkeeping. A couple of commenters suggested that only ``positions''

be considered to determine compliance with this requirement and that

the positions must be based on 40 full-time equivalent (FTE) hours per

week. Another commenter questioned whether the total number of hours

worked will be determined using expected or actual number of hours

worked.

Discussion: The Secretary does not agree that this requirement is

burdensome or will require unnecessary reporting and recordkeeping.

Centers already are required to maintain records of the number of hours

their paid employees work each week. Using the number of hours worked

to determine compliance with the greater than 50 percent staffing

requirement would not require additional recordkeeping. In addition,

the Secretary believes that overtime hours should be excluded from this

determination because extra hours worked by individual employees could

produce a distorted representation of a center's work force. Also,

centers with equal numbers of staff who are individuals with

significant disabilities and who are not individuals with significant

disabilities might simply assign overtime to their staff who are

individuals with significant disabilities to comply with the greater

than 50 percent staffing requirement. Excluding overtime will simplify

the calculation that a center needs to make to comply with this

requirement.

Finally, the Secretary believes that only those hours for which an

employee is compensated should be considered to determine compliance

with the greater than 50 percent staffing requirement because of the

difficulty in determining the number of extra hours an employee may

have worked for which the employee was not compensated.

Changes: The Secretary has revised Sec. 366.63(a)(1)(iii) to

exclude overtime from the determination of a center's compliance with

this requirement. In addition, the Secretary has revised this provision

to include only those hours for which an employee is actually paid in

determining a center's compliance with this requirement.

Comments: Several commenters disagreed with the proposed use of the

three-month period preceding the application date to determine a

center's compliance with the requirement that more than 50 percent of a

center's decisionmaking and staff positions must be filled by

individuals with disabilities. Several commenters recommended that the

relevant period be the six-month period preceding the application date

because data collected during the six-month period preceding the end of

the project year would be more reliable. A couple of commenters

suggested that the relevant period be the 12-month period preceding the

application date.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees with the commenters that the

three-month period is too short and that the six-month period preceding

the end of the reporting period is the least burdensome timeframe for a

center to gather information concerning its paid employees. The

Secretary also agrees that data collected during the six-month period

preceding the end of the project year will be more reliable than the

three-month period proposed in the NPRM.

In addition, the NPRM was published before the Department

eliminated the need for grantees to submit applications for non-

competing continuation awards. Grantees are now required only to submit

an annual performance report that demonstrates their compliance with

statutory and regulatory requirements and the terms of the grant award.

The final regulations reflect this change by eliminating any reference

to continuation applications and referring instead to annual

performance reports.

Changes: The Secretary has changed the period of consideration in

Sec. 366.63(a)(1)(iii) of the final regulations from the three-month

period preceding the date the center submits its continuation

application to the last six months of the period covered by the

center's most recent annual performance report.

Comments: A couple of commenters recommended that individuals who

are on family or maternity leave be counted during the three-month

period preceding the application date to determine a center's

compliance with the 50 percent requirement.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that an individual who is on

unpaid family or maternity leave during any or all of the six-month

period should be included in this determination. Compliance with the 50

percent requirement should not be affected just because an employee of

a center is on unpaid family or maternity leave during this six-month

period. In making its determination, a center will use the number of

weekly hours worked by an employee prior to going on unpaid family or

maternity leave.

Changes: The Secretary has added language to Sec. 366.63(a)(1)(iii)

to permit a center to include employees on unpaid family or maternity

leave for determining its compliance with the 50 percent requirement. A

center must include in this determination its employees who are on

unpaid family or maternity leave during the six-month period.

Self-Help and Self-Advocacy

Comments: None.

Discussion: Pursuant to the NPRM, a center would have been required

to provide evidence that it established written policies for promoting

self-help and self-advocacy among individuals with significant

disabilities. Since publication of the NPRM, the Secretary has reviewed

this section and determined that whether or not a center has written

policies is unimportant if the center actually promotes self-help and

self-advocacy among individuals with significant disabilities.

Changes: The Secretary has deleted the requirement for written

policies from the final regulations.

Development of Peer Relationships and Peer Role Models

(Sec. 366.63(3)(iii))

Comments: One commenter stated that the use of individuals with

significant disabilities as instructors is more effective than written

policies and procedures.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that written policies are

unimportant if the center actually promotes the development of peer

relationships and peer role models among individuals with significant

disabilities. However, the Secretary also believes that the development

of peer relationships and peer role models among individuals with

significant disabilities can be accomplished in a variety of ways and

does not believe it is necessary to require a center to use individuals

with significant disabilities as instructors to meet this requirement.

Changes: The Secretary has deleted the requirement for written

policies from the final regulations.

Equal Access (Sec. 366.63(a)(4)) and Provision of Services on a Cross-

Disability Basis (Sec. 366.63(b)(1))

Comments: Some commenters recommended that the proposed regulations

be clarified to permit centers to provide services or programs that are

targeted or limited to persons with a single type of disability (e.g.,

individuals who are blind or deaf).

Discussion: The 1992 Amendments require that centers receiving

funds under Title VII of the Act provide IL services to individuals

with significant disabilities without regard to the type or

[[Page 39219]]

types of specific significant disabilities of the individuals or groups

of individuals. Under the final regulations, a center must provide the

IL core services to individuals with significant disabilities in a

manner that is neither targeted nor limited to a particular type of

significant disability. In addition, a center may not limit the

provision of any other IL service that could be provided to individuals

with a variety of significant disabilities to individuals with a

particular type of significant disability. For example: A center may

not limit the provision of personal assistance services to individuals

who are blind. However, a center may limit the provision of Braille

instruction to individuals who are blind. The availability of an IL

service (other than the IL core services) may be limited to individuals

with a particular type of significant disability only if that IL

service is unique to the significant disability of the individuals to

be served.

Whether a center may target individuals with a particular type of

significant disability for a particular type of IL service is a

different question. If a center has identified individuals with a

particular type of significant disability as an ``unserved or

underserved group or population'' pursuant to the definition in 34 CFR

364.4(b), the center may target this unserved or underserved group or

population for any IL service, including the IL core services. However,

the center may not limit the IL services it provides to only this group

or population of individuals with a particular type of significant

disability.

Changes: The Secretary has added language to Sec. 366.63(b)(1) of

the final regulations that allows a center to restrict the availability

of an IL service (other than the IL core services) to individuals with

a particular type of significant disability if the IL service (other

than the IL core services) is unique to that significant disability of

the individuals to be served.

Comments: One commenter recommended that the proposed regulations

include an assurance that centers conduct affirmative action programs

to hire members of minority groups. This commenter believes that

Federal laws generally require recipients of Federal funds to conduct

affirmative action programs to hire members of minority groups, even

though the commenter did not identify any specific statute.

Discussion: Although section 725(c)(5) of the Act requires that an

applicant for funds under Part C of Chapter 1 of Title VII of the Act

take affirmative action to employ and advance in employment qualified

individuals with significant disabilities, nothing in Title VII

requires centers receiving funds under Part C of Chapter 1 of Title VII

of the Act to take affirmative action to employ and advance in

employment qualified minorities.

Changes: None.

Comments: One commenter recommended that a center's written

policies and materials be available in alternative formats as a means

of providing equal access to individuals with disabilities.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that a center should make

available, as appropriate, all of its written policies and materials in

alternative formats for effective communication. In addition, the

Secretary believes that, as appropriate, a center should make its IL

services available in alternative formats. For example, if a center

provides a list of available housing units that are accessible to

individuals with significant disabilities as part of its information

and referral services, then the center should make this list available,

as appropriate, either orally, in Braille, or on tape, if the written

form of the list prevents effective communication with an individual

requesting the list.

Changes: The Secretary has added a new Sec. 366.63(a)(5) to the

final regulations that requires a center to make available, as

appropriate, all of its written policies and materials in alternative

formats for effective communication. In addition, this new provision

requires a center to make available, as appropriate, its IL services in

alternative formats.

Cross-Disability (Sec. 366.63(b))

Comments: One commenter recommended that a center be able to comply

with the cross-disability requirement by demonstrating a fairly even

distribution of services across a simple majority of the Federal

disability reporting categories.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that a center that demonstrates a

fairly even distribution of services across a simple majority of the

Federal disability reporting categories is presumed to be in compliance

with the cross-disability requirement, if no evidence exists that the

center has denied eligibility for an IL service to any individual with

a significant disability based on the type of the individual's

disability. Because other evidence may exist that a center is not in

compliance with this requirement, the Secretary does not believe it is

appropriate to create an irrebuttable presumption of compliance.

Changes: None.

Comments: One commenter recommended that the proposed regulations

be clarified to ensure that all of the core services are available to

an individual regardless of the individual's disability. Another

commenter recommended that the proposed regulations be revised to

prevent a center from relying on an individual's secondary disability

to comply with the cross-disability requirement. Another commenter

recommended that centers maintain a tracking system to ensure that all

individuals in need of IL services are served by the center.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that the language in the proposed

regulations should be clarified to ensure that all of the core services

are available to an individual regardless of the individual's

disability and to prevent a center from relying on an individual's

disability (whether ``secondary'' or otherwise) to comply with the

cross-disability requirement. By forbidding a center from targeting or

limiting the IL core services based on an individual's type of

significant disability, the classification of an individual's

significant disability as ``primary'' or ``secondary'' will be

irrelevant for purposes of providing the IL core services and for

complying with the cross-disability requirement.

In addition, the Secretary believes that the reporting requirements

and recordkeeping requirements are adequate to prevent discrimination

on the basis of type of disability and to ensure that centers provide

the IL core services to individuals with a broad range of disabilities.

Therefore, the Secretary does not agree that these regulations should

require centers to maintain a tracking system as suggested by the

commenter.

Changes: The Secretary has added language to Sec. 366.63(b)(3) of

the final regulations to clarify that a center may not target or limit

the IL core services to any individual or group of individuals with

significant disabilities based on the type of significant disability of

the individual or group of individuals.

IL Goals (Sec. 366.63(c))

Comments: One commenter recommended that centers be required to

achieve a 25 percent success rate on the IL goals identified by

consumers. Another commenter stated that the attempt to achieve an IL

goal is as important as achieving it.

Discussion: The Secretary does not believe it is appropriate to

establish a percentage that centers must attain for the achievement of

IL goals developed

[[Page 39220]]

by consumers. The populations served by different centers may vary so

widely that a reasonable percentage for one center may be unrealistic

for another center.

Changes: None.

Comments: A few commenters stated that requiring a center to

measure or track the achievement of IL goals by consumers is

inappropriate or may be nearly impossible.

Discussion: Any measurement of the achievement of IL goals would

require uniformity to be meaningful. However, IL goals and how they are

achieved is not uniform. Therefore, the Secretary agrees that requiring

a center to measure the achievement of IL goals by a consumer is

inappropriate. However, the Secretary believes that maintaining records

of the IL goals that consumers believe they have achieved is

appropriate and feasible, both for the consumer and the center.

Changes: The Secretary has deleted the requirement that a center

measure the achievement of IL goals by consumers but has specified that

consumer service records meet the requirements of 34 CFR 364.53.

Section 364.53 includes the requirements that a consumer service record

include (1) the IL goals or objectives established and achieved by the

consumer; and (2) either an IL plan or a waiver signed by the consumer

that an IL plan is unnecessary.

Comments: None.

Discussion: Pursuant to the NPRM, a center was required to

facilitate the development and achievement of IL goals selected by

individuals with significant disabilities who request assistance from

the center. Since publication of the NPRM, the Secretary has reviewed

this section and determined that compliance with this standard can best

be accomplished by requiring a center to assess consumer satisfaction

with the center's services and policies in facilitating consumers'

achievement of IL goals. In addition, the Secretary believes compliance

will be further insured by requiring a center to provide this

information to its governing board and the appropriate SILC. Finally,

the Secretary believes that notifying consumers of their right to

develop or waive the development of an IL plan (ILP) also is important

to insure compliance with this standard.

Changes: The Secretary has added a requirement to the final

regulations that a center (1) assess consumer satisfaction with the

center's services and policies in facilitating consumers' achievement

of IL goals and provide this information to its governing board and the

appropriate SILC; and (2) notify all consumers of their right to

develop or waive the development of an ILP.

Comments: A few commenters recommended that any reporting

requirements be limited in scope and suggested that a consumer service

record not be required for ``casual services.'' A couple of commenters

suggested that an ``intake sheet'' be sufficient as a case service

record. Another commenter recommended that a case service record

include only the consumer's application form and any notes by the

center staff member who works with the consumer.

Discussion: The information that must be included in a consumer

service record is described in 34 CFR 364.53. The Secretary believes

that this information is necessary for the proper and efficient

administration of this program. An ``intake sheet'' or an application

form and notes made by the center's staff member who works with the

consumer are sufficient if they include the information required by 34

CFR 364.53.

Changes: The Secretary has added language to the definition of

consumer service record in the final regulations to clarify that a

consumer service record must meet the requirements of 34 CFR 364.53.

Community Options and Community Capacity (Sec. 366.63(d))

Comments: One commenter stated that this indicator is meaningless

without further explanation and definitions of the required activities.

Another commenter recommended that these regulations require more

specific measures of compliance. Another commenter recommended that the

term ``community advocacy,'' which is used in this provision, be

defined. Another commenter stated that clarification is needed on what

constitutes a center's service area.

Discussion: The Secretary does not believe it is necessary to

define further the activities that a center must carry out to comply

with this indicator. The Secretary believes that each center should

have flexibility in defining these activities within the context of its

own operating environment and service area. The Secretary also expects

that each center will define its own service area and describe the area

it expects to serve in its application for funding under this program.

Finally, the Secretary believes that the term ``community advocacy'' is

encompassed by the term ``systems (or systemic) advocacy,'' which is

defined in 34 CFR 364.4(b) of the IL regulations. The IL regulations

were published on August 15, 1994 (59 FR 41880).

Changes: None.

Comments: A few commenters recommended that centers not be

responsible for removing community barriers or for serving as a

catalyst for change in the community. One of these commenters

recommended that centers not be evaluated on how well the community

responds to the needs of individuals with disabilities.

Discussion: Nothing in the proposed regulations required a center

to remove community barriers or to serve as a catalyst for change in

the community. Furthermore, nothing in the proposed regulations

provided that centers would be evaluated on how well the community

responds to the needs of individuals with disabilities. However, to the

extent that a center engages in systems advocacy, the Secretary fully

expects that a center will engage in activities that are designed to

accomplish these goals.

Changes: None.

Comments: One commenter recommended that a center's compliance with

the community options and community capacity indicator not be based

solely on the center's activities within its service area.

Discussion: Although a center may engage in advocacy or other

activities that may have an impact outside of its service area, the

Secretary believes that a center's performance under its Title VII

grant must be assessed in terms of the beneficiaries the grant was

intended to serve, i.e., the individuals within the center's service

area.

Changes: None.

Comments: One commenter recommended that centers be required to

provide annual community accessibility updates to help centers develop

strategies for prioritizing the removal of identified community

barriers and to document the results of activities that have been

completed to remove those barriers.

Discussion: The Secretary does not believe that centers should be

required to develop strategies for prioritizing the removal of

identified community barriers. The Secretary believes it is sufficient

for a center to comply with the requirements already established for

this indicator.

Changes: None.

Comments: One commenter recommended that outreach materials be

provided in accessible formats.

Discussion: The Secretary believes that new Sec. 366.63(a)(5) will

ensure that a center will provide outreach materials in accessible

formats.

Changes: None.

[[Page 39221]]

IL Services (Sec. 366.63(e))

Comments: One commenter stated that cross-disability counseling is

not a valid service because the commenter believes that ``peer'' means

a person with a similar disability.

Discussion: The Secretary disagrees that ``peer counseling'' is

limited to counseling by an individual with a disability that is

similar to the disability of the consumer. The Secretary believes that

an individual with a significant disability may engage in peer

counseling for another individual with a significant disability,

regardless of the types of significant disabilities of the two

individuals.

Changes: None.

Resource Development (Sec. 366.63(f))

Comments: One commenter recommended that a center be rewarded only

for specific activities that result in increased funding and that

automatic State appropriations not be included in determining the

success of a center's fundraising activities.

Discussion: The Secretary encourages States to participate in the

funding of centers. Therefore, the Secretary believes it is appropriate

to include State funds in determining the success of a center's

fundraising activities.

Changes: None.

Executive Order 12866

These final regulations have been reviewed in accordance with

Executive Order 12866. Under the terms of the order the Secretary has

assessed the potential costs and benefits of this regulatory action.

The potential costs associated with the final regulations are those

resulting from statutory requirements and those determined by the

Secretary to be necessary for administering this program effectively

and efficiently.

In assessing the potential costs and benefits--both quantitative

and qualitative--of these regulations, the Secretary has determined

that the benefits of the regulations justify the costs.

The Secretary has also determined that this regulatory action does

not unduly interfere with State, local, and tribal governments in the

exercise of their governmental functions.

Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980

Sections 366.62 and 366.63 contain information collection

requirements. As required by the Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980, the

Department of Education submitted a copy of these sections to the

Office of Management and Budget (OMB) for its review. (44 U.S.C.

3504(h)).

States and centers are eligible to apply for grants under these

regulations. The Department needs and uses the information to make

grants. Annual public reporting burden for this collection of

information is estimated to average 40 hours per response for 200

respondents, including the time for gathering and maintaining the data

needed and for completing and reviewing the collection of information.

Intergovernmental Review

These programs are subject to the requirements of Executive Order

12372 and the regulations in 34 CFR part 79. The objective of the

Executive order is to foster an intergovernmental partnership and a

strengthened federalism by relying on processes developed by State and

local governments for coordination and review of proposed Federal

financial assistance.

In accordance with the order, this document is intended to provide

early notification of the Department's specific plans and actions for

this program.

Assessment of Educational Impact

In the notice of proposed rulemaking, the Secretary requested

comments on whether the proposed regulations would require transmission

of information that is being gathered by or is available from any other

agency or authority of the United States.

Based on the response to the proposed regulations and on its own

review, the Department has determined that the regulations in this

document do not require transmission of information that is being

gathered by or is available from any other agency or authority of the

United States.

List of Subjects in 34 CFR Part 366

Education, Grant programs--social programs, Vocational

rehabilitation, Recordkeeping and reporting requirements.

(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Number 84.132--Centers for

Independent Living)

Dated: July 26, 1995.

Richard W. Riley,

Secretary of Education.

The Secretary amends Part 366 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal

Regulations as follows:

PART 366--CENTERS FOR INDEPENDENT LIVING

1. The authority citation for part 366 is revised to read as

follows:

Authority: 29 U.S.C. 796d-1(b) and 796f-796f-6, unless otherwise

noted.

Sec. 366.6 [Redesignated from Sec. 366.5]

2. Section 366.5 is redesignated as Sec. 366.6.

3. A new Sec. 366.5 is added to read as follows:

Sec. 366.5 What definitions apply to this program?

Decisionmaking position means the executive director, any

supervisory position, and any other policymaking position within the

center.

Staff position means a paid non-contract position within the center

that is not included within the definition of a ``decisionmaking

position.''

(Authority: 29 U.S.C. 796a(a))

4. Part 366 is amended by adding a new Subpart G consisting of

Secs. 366.60 through 366.63 to read as follows:

Subpart G--Evaluation Standards and Compliance Indicators

Sec.

366.60 What are project evaluation standards?

366.61 What are the compliance indicators?

366.62 What are the requirements for continuation funding?

366.63 What evidence must a center present to demonstrate that it

is in minimum compliance with the evaluation standards?

Subpart G--Evaluation Standards and Compliance Indicators

Sec. 366.60 What are the project evaluation standards?

To be eligible to receive funds under this part, an applicant must

agree to comply with the following evaluation standards:

(a) Evaluation standard 1--Philosophy. The center shall promote and

practice the IL philosophy of--

(1) Consumer control of the center regarding decisionmaking,

service delivery, management, and establishment of the policy and

direction of the center;

(2) Self-help and self-advocacy;

(3) Development of peer relationships and peer role models;

(4) Equal access of individuals with significant disabilities to

all of the center's services, programs, activities, resources, and

facilities, whether publicly or privately funded, without regard to the

type of significant disability of the individual; and

(5) Promoting equal access of individuals with significant

disabilities to all services, programs, activities, resources, and

facilities in society, whether public or private, and regardless of

funding source, on the same basis that access is provided to other

individuals with disabilities and to individuals without disabilities.

[[Page 39222]]

(b) Evaluation standard 2--Provision of services. (1) The center

shall provide IL services to individuals with a range of significant

disabilities.

(2) The center shall provide IL services on a cross-disability

basis (i.e., for individuals with all different types of significant

disabilities, including individuals with significant disabilities who

are members of populations that are unserved or underserved by programs

under Title VII of this Act).

(3) The center shall determine eligibility for IL services. The

center may not base eligibility on the presence of any one specific

significant disability.

(c) Evaluation standard 3--Independent living goals. The center

shall facilitate the development and achievement of IL goals selected

by individuals with significant disabilities who seek assistance in the

development and achievement of IL goals from the center.

(d) Evaluation standard 4--Community options. The center shall

conduct activities to increase the availability and improve the quality

of community options for IL to facilitate the development and

achievement of IL goals by individuals with significant disabilities.

(e) Evaluation standard 5--Independent living core services. The

center shall provide IL core services and, as appropriate, a

combination of any other IL services specified in section 7(30)(B) of

the Act.

(f) Evaluation standard 6--Activities to increase community

capacity. The center shall conduct activities to increase the capacity

of communities within the service area of the center to meet the needs

of individuals with significant disabilities.

(g) Evaluation standard 7--Resource development activities. The

center shall conduct resource development activities to obtain funding

from sources other than Chapter 1 of Title VII of the Act.

(Authority: 29 U.S.C. 796f-4)

Sec. 366.61 What are the compliance indicators?

(a) The compliance indicators establish the activities that a

center shall carry out to demonstrate minimum compliance with the

evaluation standards in Sec. 366.60.

(b) If a center fails to satisfy any one of the indicators, the

center is out of compliance with the evaluation standards.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 796d-1(b))

Sec. 366.62 What are the requirements for continuation funding?

(a) To be eligible to receive a continuation award for the third or

any subsequent year of a grant, a center shall--

(1) Have complied fully during the previous project year with all

of the terms and conditions of its grant;

(2) Provide adequate evidence in its most recent annual performance

report that the center is in minimum compliance with the evaluation

standards in Sec. 366.60 (Cross-reference: See Secs. 366.50 (h) and (i)

and 34 CFR 75.118(a)); and

(3) Meet the requirements in this Part 366.

(b) If a recipient receives funding for more than one center, each

individual center that receives a continuation award shall meet the

requirements of paragraph (a) of this section.

(Approved by the Office of Management and Budget under control

number 1820-0606.)

(Authority: 29 U.S.C. 711(c), 796d-1(b), 796e, and 796f-4)

Sec. 366.63 What evidence must a center present to demonstrate that it

is in minimum compliance with the evaluation standards?

(a) Compliance indicator 1--Philosophy.

(1) Consumer control.

(i) The center shall provide evidence in its most recent annual

performance report that--

(A) Individuals with significant disabilities constitute more than

50 percent of the center's governing board; and

(B) Individuals with disabilities constitute more than 50 percent

of the center's--

(1) Employees in decisionmaking positions; and

(2) Employees in staff positions.

(ii) A center may exclude personal assistants, readers, drivers,

and interpreters employed by the center from the requirement in

paragraph (a)(1)(B) of this section.

(iii) The determination that over 50 percent of a center's

employees in decisionmaking and staff positions are individuals with

disabilities must be based on the total number of hours (excluding any

overtime) for which employees are actually paid during the last six-

month period covered by the center's most recent annual performance

report. However, a center must include in this determination its

employees who are on unpaid family or maternity leave during this six-

month period.

(2) Self-help and self-advocacy. The center shall provide evidence

in its most recent annual performance report that it promotes self-help

and self-advocacy among individuals with significant disabilities

(e.g., by conducting activities to train individuals with significant

disabilities in self-advocacy).

(3) Development of peer relationships and peer role models. The

center shall provide evidence in its most recent annual performance

report that it promotes the development of peer relationships and peer

role models among individuals with significant disabilities (e.g., by

using individuals with significant disabilities who have achieved IL

goals [whether the goals were achieved independently or through

assistance and services provided by a center] as instructors [volunteer

or paid] in its training programs or as peer counselors).

(4) Equal access. The center shall provide evidence in its most

recent annual performance report that it--

(i) Ensures equal access of individuals with significant

disabilities, including communication and physical access, to the

center's services, programs, activities, resources, and facilities,

whether publicly or privately funded. Equal access, for purposes of

this paragraph, means that the same access is provided to any

individual with a significant disability regardless of the individual's

type of significant disability.

(ii) Advocates for and conducts activities that promote the equal

access to all services, programs, activities, resources, and facilities

in society, whether public or private, and regardless of funding

source, for individuals with significant disabilities. Equal access,

for purposes of this paragraph, means that the same access provided to

individuals without disabilities is provided in the center's service

area to individuals with significant disabilities.

(5) Alternative formats. To ensure that a center complies with

Sec. 366.63(a)(4) and for effective communication, a center shall make

available in alternative formats, as appropriate, all of its written

policies and materials and IL services.

(b) Compliance indicator 2--Provision of services on a cross-

disability basis. The center shall provide evidence in its most recent

annual performance report that it--

(1) Provides IL services to eligible individuals or groups of

individuals without restrictions based on the particular type or types

of significant disability of an individual or group of individuals,

unless the restricted IL service (other than the IL core services) is

unique to the significant disability of the individuals to be served;

(2) Provides IL services to individuals with a diversity of

significant disabilities and individuals who are members of populations

that are

[[Page 39223]]

unserved or underserved by programs under Title VII of the Act; and

(3) Provides IL core services to individuals with significant

disabilities in a manner that is neither targeted nor limited to a

particular type of significant disability.

(c) Compliance indicator 3--Independent living goals. (1) The

center shall provide evidence in its most recent annual performance

report that it--

(i) Maintains a consumer service record that meets the requirements

of 34 CFR 364.53 for each consumer;

(ii) Facilitates the development and achievement of IL goals

selected by individuals with significant disabilities who request

assistance from the center;

(iii) Provides opportunities for consumers to express satisfaction

with the center's services and policies in facilitating their

achievement of IL goals and provides any results to its governing board

and the appropriate SILC; and

(iv) Notifies all consumers of their right to develop or waive the

development of an IL plan (ILP).

(2) The center shall provide evidence in its most recent annual

performance report that the center maintains records on--

(i) The IL goals that consumers receiving services at the center

believe they have achieved;

(ii) The number of ILPs developed by consumers receiving services

at the center; and

(iii) The number of waivers signed by consumers receiving services

at the center stating that an ILP is unnecessary.

(d) Compliance indicator 4--Community options and community

capacity. The center shall provide evidence in its most recent annual

performance report that, during the project year covered by the

center's most recent annual performance report, the center promoted the

increased availability and improved quality of community-based programs

that serve individuals with significant disabilities and promoted the

removal of any existing architectural, attitudinal, communication,

environmental, or other type of barrier that prevents the full

integration of these individuals into society. This evidence must

demonstrate that the center performed at least one activity in each of

the following categories:

(1) Community advocacy.

(2) Technical assistance to the community on making services,

programs, activities, resources, and facilities in society accessible

to individuals with significant disabilities.

(3) Public information and education.

(4) Aggressive outreach to members of populations of individuals

with significant disabilities that are unserved or underserved by

programs under Title VII of the Act in the center's service area.

(5) Collaboration with service providers, other agencies, and

organizations that could assist in improving the options available for

individuals with significant disabilities to avail themselves of the

services, programs, activities, resources, and facilities in the

center's service area.

(e) Compliance indicator 5--IL core services and other IL services.

The center shall provide evidence in its most recent annual performance

report that it provides--

(1) Information and referral services to all individuals who

request this type of assistance or services from the center in formats

accessible to the individual requesting these services; and

(2) As appropriate in response to requests from individuals with

significant disabilities who are eligible for IL services from the

center, the following services:

(i) IL skills training.

(ii) Peer counseling (including cross-disability peer counseling).

(iii) Individual and systems advocacy.

(iv) A combination, as appropriate, of any two or more of the IL

services defined in section 7(30)(B) of the Act.

(f) Compliance indicator 6--Resource development activities. The

center shall provide evidence in its most recent annual performance

report that it has conducted resource development activities within the

period covered by the performance report to obtain funding from sources

other than Chapter 1 of Title VII of the Act.

(Approved by the Office of Management and Budget under control

number 1820-0606.)

(Authority: 29 U.S.C. 711(c), 796d-1(b), and 796f-4)

[FR Doc. 95-18774 Filed 7-31-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4000-01-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.