Alternate Standards for Open-Head Fiber Drum Packaging

Federal RegisterJan 25, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

[[Page 4879]]

DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Research and Special Programs Administration

49 CFR Parts 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 179, and 180

[Docket No. HM-221; Notice No. 95-2]

RIN 2137-AC62

Alternate Standards for Open-Head Fiber Drum Packaging

AGENCY: Research and Special Programs Administration (RSPA), DOT.

ACTION: Supplemental advance notice of proposed rulemaking; reopening

of public comment period and announcement of public hearing.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: RSPA is inviting additional proposals and comments concerning

alternate standards for open-head fiber drum packagings, for the

domestic transportation of liquid hazardous materials. Among the

matters on which further comments may be submitted are the alternate

standards proposed by the International Fibre Drum Institute; a

proposed exception for certain shipments of hazardous wastes; and the

factors which RSPA should consider in this rulemaking proceeding.

DATES: Written comments: Comments must be received on or before March

13, 1995.

Public hearing: A public hearing will be held on February 17, 1995,

beginning at 9:30 a.m.

ADDRESSES: Comments: Address comments to Dockets Unit, Research and

Special Programs Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation,

Washington, DC 20590-0001. Comments should identify the Docket (HM-221)

and be submitted, if possible, in five copies. Persons wishing to

receive confirmation of receipt of their comments should include a

self-addressed stamped postcard showing the docket number. The Dockets

Unit is located in Room 8419 of the Nassif Building, 400 Seventh

Street, SW., Washington, DC 20590-0001. Telephone: 202-366-5046. Public

dockets may be reviewed between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 5:30 p.m.,

Monday through Friday except Federal holidays.

Public hearing: The February 17, 1995 public hearing will be held

at the Federal Aviation Administration's Auditorium, 3rd floor, 800

Independence Avenue, SW., Washington, DC. Any person planning to

present an oral statement at the public hearing should notify John

Potter or Diane LaValle, by telephone or in writing by February 15,

1995. Each request must include the identity of the speaker and

organization represented, if any; a daytime telephone number; and

anticipated length of presentation, not to exceed 10 minutes. Speakers

are requested to provide a written copy of their prepared text to the

presiding officer prior to making their oral statement. The hearing may

conclude before 5 p.m. if all persons wishing to speak have been heard.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: John Potter or Diane LaValle, Office

of Hazardous Materials Standards, Research and Special Programs

Administration, U.S. Department of Transportation, 400 Seventh Street,

SW., Washington, DC 20590-0001; telephone 202-366-4488.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

I. Background

On and after October 1, 1996, fiber drums used for the

transportation of liquid hazardous materials must meet the performance-

oriented standards set forth in Subpart M of 49 CFR Part 178. See 49

CFR 171.14(a)(1)(iii). These consist of the tests and standard

prescribed in the following sections of 49 CFR:

Sec. 178.603--drop test

Sec. 178.604--leakproofness test

Sec. 178.605--hydrostatic test

Sec. 178.606--stacking test

Sec. 178.608--vibration standard

These performance-oriented standards were adopted in RSPA's

rulemaking proceeding No. HM-181. 55 FR 52042 (Dec. 21, 1990); 56 FR

66124 (Dec. 20, 1991); 57 FR 45442, 45446 (Oct. 1, 1992); 57 FR 46624

(Oct. 9, 1992).

On October 7, 1994, RSPA published in the Federal Register an

advance notice of proposed rulemaking (ANPRM), Docket No. HM-221;

Notice No. 94-9 (59 FR 51157), soliciting comments and proposals for

alternate standards for open-head fiber drum packaging. The ANPRM was

issued to fulfill the requirement in Section 122(a) of the Hazardous

Materials Transportation Authorization Act of 1994 (Pub. L. 103-311)

(the ``Act'') that DOT initiate a rulemaking proceeding

To determine whether the requirements of section 5103(b) of

title 49, United States Code (relating to regulations for safe

transportation) as they pertain to open head fiber drum packaging

can be met for the domestic transportation of liquid hazardous

materials (with respect to those classifications of hazardous

materials transported by such drums pursuant to regulations in

effect on September 30, 1991) with standards other than the

performance-oriented packaging standards adopted under docket number

HM-181 contained in part 178 of title 49, Code of Federal

Regulations.

If, as a result of this rulemaking proceeding, DOT determines

That a packaging standard other than the performance-oriented

packaging standards referred to in [Section 122(a)] will provide an

equal or greater level of safety for the domestic transportation of

liquid hazardous materials than would be provided if such

performance-oriented standards were in effect, [DOT] shall issue

regulations which implement such other standards and which take

effect before October 1, 1996.

Section 122(b). The Act also requires that the rulemaking

proceeding be completed before October 1, 1995 (Section 122(c)), but

that this rulemaking and any regulations issued ``shall not apply to

packaging for those hazardous materials regulated by the Department of

Transportation as poisonous by inhalation * * *'' Section 122(d)(1).

In the ANPRM, RSPA requested ``[d]etailed comments and proposals .

. . that will assist RSPA in developing an appropriate regulatory

proposal consistent with the requirement quoted above.'' 59 FR 51158.

RSPA invited proposals, ``preferably in the form of a draft standard,

that would assist RSPA in accomplishing the intended effect of this

law.'' Id. RSPA also invited comments on whether alternate standards

for open head fiber drums should be limited to domestic transportation

of liquid hazardous materials. The comment period on the ANPRM closed

December 12, 1994.

In response to the ANPRM, RSPA received comments from 17 parties.

In addition, RSPA's Administrator and other DOT officials have held two

meetings concerning this rulemaking with: (1) Counsel for the

International Fibre Drum Institute (IFDI) and officials of Sonoco

Products Company (a member of IFDI), on September 30, 1994, and (2)

representatives of the Association of Container Reconditioners, the 3M

Corporation, USX Corporation, and the Steel Shipping Container

Institute (SSCI), on December 16, 1994. Notes of these two meetings

have been placed in the public docket file of this rulemaking

proceeding.

Only IFDI has proposed alternate standards for open-head fiber drum

packaging for the transportation of liquid hazardous materials. Several

other commenters expressed opposition to alternate standards, including

SSCI which asserted that alternate standards would move the United

States away from an international system of hazardous materials

regulations, forcing some shippers to stock different packagings for

domestic and [[Page 4880]] international shipments, and compromise

transportation safety by authorizing lower quality packagings. Another

commenter stated that alternate packagings should be approved only

under the provisions of 49 CFR 178.601(h), which authorizes RSPA's

Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety to approve

packagings which are ``shown to be equally effective, and testing

methods used must be equivalent.''

Another party, Monsanto Company, expressed general support for the

performance-oriented packaging standards adopted in HM-181, but urged

RSPA to provide a limited exception to allow the use of non-standard

fiber drums for the shipment of liquid hazardous wastes in packing

groups II and III to incineration facilities. Monsanto's proposal would

apply to the situation when the entire package (with its contents) was

to be incinerated, and would allow the one-time use of drums similar in

design to former DOT specifications 21C and 21P, under conditions

similar to those set forth in 49 CFR 173.12(c) (authorizing the reuse

of standard packagings for shipments of hazardous waste, by highway

only, when the packaging is packed at least 24 hours in advance of

transportation, inspected for leaks, and loaded by the shipper and

unloaded by the consignee--or handled only by private or contract

carrier). Monsanto would also limit to 90 days the total time the non-

standard fiber drum could contain the liquid hazardous waste.

Other commenters stated that any alternate standards adopted should

apply to all open-head drums (of whatever construction materials);

Russell-Stanley Corp. specifically requested that RSPA expand this

rulemaking to include steel and plastic drums ``of equal performance,''

if RSPA issued alternate standards for fiber drums.

In its comments, IFDI stated that open-head fiber drums presently

being manufactured meet the stacking test set forth in 49 CFR 178.606

and the vibration standard set forth in 49 CFR 178.608. As alternatives

to the other three HM-181 performance standards (drop, leakproofness,

and hydrostatic pressure tests), IFDI has proposed, and it discussed in

its written comments, a set of six standards entitled as follows:

IFDI Standard 101, Rev. 1--Compatibility Test

IFDI Standard 110, Rev. 1--Joint Integrity Test

IFDI Standard 120, Rev. 1--Leakage Spray Test

IFDI Standard 130, Rev. 1--Weatherproofing Test

IFDI Standard 140, Rev. 1--Fibre Drum Structure

IFDI Standard 150, Rev. 1--Impact Test

These six proposed standards appear to be identical to standards

proposed by IFDI's predecessor organization, the Fibre Drum Technical

Council (FDTC), in a June 8, 1992 application for an exemption. RSPA's

Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety denied FDTC's

application for an exemption because he found that FDTC's proposed

impact test was not equivalent to the 3.9 and 2.6 foot drop tests

required for Packing Group II and III packagings, respectively, and

that FDTC's other proposed tests did not address the pressure

requirements of the leakproofness and hydrostatic pressure tests

required for packagings intended for liquid hazardous materials.

RSPA's Acting Administrator affirmed the denial of FDTC's

application for an exemption and found that the standards proposed by

FDTC would not achieve a level of safety ``at least equal to that

specified in the regulation from which the exemption is sought.'' 49

CFR 107.103(b)(9)(1). (Attachment A to IFDI's written comments contains

copies of FDTC's application for an exemption to allow the continued

use, after October 1, 1996, of open-head fiber drums that do not meet

the HM-181 performance-oriented packaging standards; RSPA's denials of

that application; RSPA's evaluation form and issue papers; and FDTC's

appeal of RSPA's denial of the application for an exemption.)

In a separate letter, which IFDI also included in its written

comments (Attachment B), IFDI has asserted that the ANPRM was deficient

for failing to specify factors that, according to IFDI,

Congress directed DOT to consider. These factors are set forth

in the legislative history and include: (1) DOT's Hazardous Incident

Reporting System as it pertains to fibre drums; (2) the fibre drum

industry's own safety record; (3) the 30 years of shipping

experience associated with use of these drums; and (4) existing

industry standards that have led to the industry's ``excellent

shipping record.''

II. Request for Additional Comment

Based on the comments to the ANPRM, RSPA is issuing this

supplemental ANPRM and scheduling a public hearing, to allow interested

parties to submit additional proposals and comments with regard to

alternate standards for open-head fiber drum packaging. Additional

comments are requested on the issue of whether the alternate standards

proposed by IFDI ``will provide an equal or greater level of safety for

the domestic transportation of liquid hazardous materials than would be

provided if [the HM-181] performance-oriented packaging standards were

in effect,'' as required by Section 122(b) of the Act, particularly in

light of RSPA's prior determination (on FDTC's exemption application)

that similar standards did not provide an equal or greater level of

safety than the HM-181 performance standards. Comments are also

requested on the factors ``set forth in the legislative history'' of

Section 122, as outlined above. Further comments are also invited on

whether alternate standards, if adopted, should apply to packagings

other than fiber drums, as well as with regard to Monsanto's proposal

for an exception to allow non-standard fiber drums to be used for

shipping hazardous wastes to incineration facilities.

Interested parties are encouraged to consult the ANPRM and submit

any comments relevant to the direction in Section 122 of the Act,

including, but not limited to, those matters specified in the preceding

paragraph.

To facilitate the submission of further comments, RSPA is mailing

to each party that has submitted comments on the ANPRM a copy of IFDI's

December 12, 1994 written comments and the text of the six alternative

standards proposed by IFDI. Any interested person may obtain a copy of

these materials or a copy of RSPA's Action on Appeal affirming the

denial of FDTC's application for an exemption, at no cost, from RSPA's

Docket's Unit (see the address and telephone number set forth in

Addresses above).

III. Regulatory Analyses and Notices

A. Executive Order 12866 and DOT Regulatory Policies and Procedures

This supplemental advance notice of proposed rulemaking is not

considered a significant regulatory action under section 3(f) of

Executive Order 12866 and was not reviewed by the Office of Management

and Budget. This supplemental advance notice of proposed rulemaking is

not considered significant under the regulatory policies and procedures

of the Department of Transportation (44 FR 11034; February 26, 1979).

B. Executive Order 12612

RSPA will evaluate any proposed rule in accordance with the

principles and criteria contained in Executive Order 12612

(``Federalism'').

C. Regulatory Flexibility Act

RSPA will evaluate any proposed rule to determine whether it would

have a [[Page 4881]] significant economic impact on a substantial

number of small entities.

D. Paperwork Reduction Act

There are no new information collection requirements in this

advance notice of proposed rulemaking.

E. Regulations Identifier Number (RIN)

A regulation identifier number (RIN) is assigned to each regulatory

action listed in the Unified Agenda of Federal Regulations. The

Regulatory Information Service Center publishes the Unified Agenda in

April and October of each year. The RIN number contained in the heading

of this document can be used to cross-reference this action with the

Unified Agenda.

Issued at Washington, DC, on January 19, 1995, under authority

delegated in 49 CFR Part 106.

Alan I. Roberts,

Associate Administrator for Hazardous Materials Safety.

[FR Doc. 95-1804 Filed 1-24-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4910-60-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.