Investigator Financial Disclosure Policy

Federal RegisterJul 11, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUMMARY: The National Science Foundation (NSF) is making certain

technical changes and clarifications to its Investigator Financial

Disclosure Policy in order to make the Policy more consistent with the

provisions of the final Department of Health and Human Services (HHS)

rule on this subject.

EFFECTIVE DATE: The effective date of the Investigator Financial

Disclosure Policy and these technical changes is October 1, 1995.

Proposals submitted on or after October 1, 1995 must contain the new

certifications set forth in the Policy.

EFFECTIVE DATES: Christopher L. Ashley, Assistant General Counsel,

National Science Foundation, 4201 Wilson Boulevard, Room 1265,

Arlington, VA 22230, (703) 306-1060.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Paperwork Reduction Act Control Number 3145-0149

On June 28, 1994 NSF published in the Federal Register a final

Policy announcing revised award conditions relating to investigator

financial disclosure. Those revised conditions require grantee

institutions to maintain written and enforced policies on investigator

conflict of interest. 59 FR 33308 (June 28, 1994).

NSF has been coordinating its Investigator Financial Disclosure

Policy with the Public Health Service and the Office of the Secretary

of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). At the same time

NSF published its final policy, HHS published a notice of proposed

rulemaking also dealing with investigator conflicts. HHS received and

reviewed public comments on that proposed rule, and is issuing in this

Federal Register its final rule regarding investigator conflicts that

will be effective on October 1, 1995. In cooperation with HHS, NSF is

now making certain corresponding technical changes and clarifications

to its Investigator Financial Disclosure Policy in order to maintain

consistency with the final HHS rule. In addition, NSF and HHS will be

working together to develop common guidance, including a set of

questions and answers, to help institutions implement conflict of

interest policies that comply with both HHS and NSF requirements.

The following summarizes the changes and clarifications to NSF's

Investigator Financial Disclosure Policy:

Grant Policy Manual References: All references to GPM 310 will be

changed to GPM 510.

Disclosures by Investigators: Subparagraph b of GPM 510 will be

revised to require disclosure to the institution's representative of

significant financial interests that ``would reasonably appear to be

affected'' by the activities funded or proposed for funding by NSF.

Previously, the provision had required disclosure of interests that

``reasonably appear to be directly and significantly affected'' by such

activities. This change will result in a slightly broader disclosure by

the investigator. As explained below, the institutional

representative(s) will be responsible for reviewing the disclosures to

determine which disclosed interests could directly and significantly

affect the design, conduct or reporting of the research.

Definition of ``Significant Financial Interest''--Exclusions: For

greater clarity, the exclusion set out in subparagraph b.5 of GPM 510

will be split into two separate exclusions--one for equity interests

and one for other types of payments. Also, the dollar threshold

increased from $5,000 to $10,000. To be excluded from the definition of

``significant financial interest,'' an equity interest, when aggregated

for the Investigator and his or her spouse and dependent children, must

be under both the $10,000 and five percent ownership thresholds. For

example, an investigator who owns an equity interest which is worth

$20,000 (with reference to public prices or other reasonable measures

of fair market value), but which represents only one percent ownership

in the entity, would nevertheless be required to disclose that interest

if it would reasonably appear to be affected by the research or

educational activities funded or proposed for funding by NSF.

Conflicts of Interest: In subparagraph d of GPM 510, the definition

of a conflict of interest will be revised. As revised, a conflict of

interest exists if the reviewer(s) of disclosures determines that a

significant financial interest ``could directly and significantly

affect the design, conduct, or reporting of'' NSF-funded activities.

Thus, contrary to the previous definition, the reviewer(s) rather than

the investigator determines whether a significant financial interest

directly and significantly affects the design, conduct or reporting of

NSF-funded activities.

Timing of Conflict of Interest Review and Resolution; In order to

conform with the HHS final rule, the Certification for Authorized

Institutional Representative or Individual Applicant (in the Section

WHAT WOULD BE REQUIRED IN PROPOSALS) will be changed to require the

institutional representative to certify that any identified conflicts

of interests will be managed, reduced or eliminated ``prior to the

institution's expenditure of any funds under the award.'' The

certification previously required resolution of conflicts ``prior to

funding the award.'' This technical change will enable institutions to

refrain from reviewing and resolving identified conflicts until after

the award is funded, thereby eliminating the need to review and resolve

conflicts in proposals that do not get funded. Also, the last sentence

of the certification has been separated into two sentences to clarify

that conflicts of interest that cannot be satisfactorily managed,

reduced or eliminated must be reported to NSF. Accordingly, the

certification will now read as follows:

In addition, if the applicant institution employs more than

fifty persons, the authorized official of the applicant institution

is certifying that the institution has implemented a written and

enforced conflict of interest policy that is consistent with the

provisions of Grant Policy Manual Section 510; that to the best of

his/her knowledge, all financial disclosures required by that

conflict of interest policy have been made; and that all identified

conflicts of interest will have been satisfactorily managed, reduced

or eliminated prior to the institution's expenditure of any funds

under the award, in accordance with the institution's conflict of

interest policy. Conflicts which cannot be satisfactorily managed,

reduced or eliminated must be disclosed to NSF.

Deletion of Additional Certification for Principal Investigators

and Co-Principal Investigators: In order to conform with the HHS final

rule, NSF's policy will be revised to delete the additional

Certification for Principal Investigators and Co-Principal

Investigators that was previously to be included in Section C-1 of Part

II of the Grant Proposal Guide and on Page 2 of the NSF Form 1207,

Cover Sheet for Proposal to NSF. Although submission of the additional

certification to NSF is no longer required, NSF believes that most

institutions' policies will have principal and co-principal

investigators certify to the institution that the investigator has read

and understands the institution's policy, that all required disclosures

were made and that the investigator will comply with any conditions or

restrictions imposed by the institution to manage, reduce or eliminate

conflicts of interest.

[[Page 35821]]

Other Clarifications

1. Application of Policy to Increments of Major Awards: In addition

to new NSF proposals, the Policy will apply to certain large ongoing

projects such as centers and other activities that are currently being

funded by NSF on an incremental basis through cooperative agreements or

other agreements for which new proposals may not be submitted for

several years. NSF will require that institutions and investigators

involved in such projects, at the time of their first funding increment

which occurs after October 1, 1995, provide the certifications required

by the Policy for all cooperative agreements and for all continuing

grant increments exceeding $1,000,000. Such awardees will be advised in

advance in writing by the Grants Officer that they will be required to

have a policy in place and submit the required certifications as a

condition of future funding increments.

2. In addition to the technical changes and clarifications

announced above, NSF has made a small number of word changes to resolve

minor inconsistencies between its policy and the final HHS rule. These

changes are not intended to alter the meaning of any provision of NSF's

final policy. The changes are as follows:

a. In subparagraph b.1 of GPM 510, the word ``applicant'' will be

added before the word ``institution.'' The exclusion from the

definition of ``significant financial interest'' will now read

``salary, royalties or other remuneration from the applicant

institution.''

b. In subparagraph c of GPM 510, the word ``pendency'' will be

replaced with the word ``period''. An institutional policy must require

financial disclosures to be updated during the period the award is in

effect.

c. In subparagraph d of GPM 510, immediately before the list of

examples of conditions or restrictions to manage, reduce or limit

conflicts of interest, the words ``but are not limited to'' will be

added after ``include.''

d. In the second sentence of subparagraph d of GPM 510, the phrase

``research or educational activities funded or proposed for funding by

NSF'' will be replaced with the phrase ``NSF-funded research or

educational activities.''

e. Subparagraph g of GPM 510 will be revised to require

institutions to maintain records ``for at least three years beyond the

termination or completion of the grant to which they relate, or until

the resolution of any NSF action involving those records, whichever is

longer.''

f. The words ``actual or potential'' will be deleted in all places

where they are used to modify ``conflict of interest.''

3. Paperwork and Recordkeeping Burden: In cooperation with HHS, NSF

has revised its estimate of the paperwork burden associated with the

Policy in order to make its estimate consistent with HHS' and to

conform to certain changes in the law since NSF issued the final

Policy. NSF and HHS have used the same methodology in estimating

respective paperwork burdens for their rules.

NSF's revised estimates are as follows:

Reporting and Recordkeeping

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of Hours per

respondents response Total

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Files *.......................... 2,300 4 9,200

Reports of conflict to NSF **.... 50 80 4,000

Subsequent reports of conflict of

interest........................ 7 2 14

------------------------------------------------------------------------

* Consistent with HHS methodology, NSF is now using the number of files

expected to be necessary as a basis for estimating the Policy's

recordkeeping burden. NSF estimates that the Policy will apply to

approximately 10,000 awards annually and that 23% of all investigators

will have disclosures which will require the creation of a file. NSF

estimates that 77% of investigators will not have disclosures

requiring the creation of a file. NSF estimates that it will require

four hours for the establishment and maintenance of a file.

** HHS has estimated that it will receive 200 reports of conflicts of

interest. NSF believes that it will receive significantly fewer

reports of conflicts because NSF makes fewer awards annually than HHS

and because, on average, activities funded by NSF are less likely to

affect the financial interests of investigators.

Disclosure by Investigators

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hours per

Number of respondents response Total

------------------------------------------------------------------------

38,000........................................ 1.0 38,000

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Institutional Disclosure of Policy to Investigators ***

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hours per

Number of Institutions response Total

------------------------------------------------------------------------

2,000......................................... 20 40,000

------------------------------------------------------------------------

*** NSF did not initially include an estimate for this aspect of the

paperwork burden. However, in light of revisions to the Paperwork

Reduction Act, effective October 1, 1995, which will require this

element to be estimated, NSF is including such an estimate. NSF's

estimate is consistent with that of HHS.

Total hours for reporting, recordkeeping and disclosure: 91,214.

In accordance with the requirements of the Paperwork Reduction Act

of 1980, the National Science Foundation has submitted the information

collection requirements cited above to OMB for review and approval.

Organizations and individuals desiring to submit comments on the

information collection requirements and the estimated burden should

direct such comments to the information address cited above and to: NSF

Desk Officer, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, OMB, New

Executive Office Building, Room 10235, 725 17th Street NW., Washington,

DC 20503.

Accordingly, NSF's Investigator Financial Disclosure Policy now

reads as follows:

[[Page 35822]]

The Investigator Financial Disclosure Policy

NSF's Investigator Financial Disclosure Policy has the following

primary features:

A. A requirement that any NSF grantee employing more than fifty

persons maintain ``an appropriate written and enforced policy on

conflict of interest.''

B. Minimum requirements for what must be in an institution's

policy. These include (a) limited and targeted financial disclosure,

(b) designation of a person(s) to review the disclosures and resolve

actual or potential problems revealed, (c) enforcement mechanisms, and

(d) arrangements for informing NSF of conflicts issues that are not

resolved to the satisfaction of the institution.

Changes made to NSF issuances to establish and communicate the

Policy are described below. Copies of the NSF Grant General Conditions

and the NSF Grant Proposal Guide referenced in the Policy may be

obtained from the National Science Foundation, Forms and Publications

Unit, 4201 Wilson Blvd., Rm. P-15, Arlington, Virginia 22230, (703)

306-1130, Internet: [email protected]. Copies of the NSF Grant Policy Manual

may be obtained from the Government Printing Office.

What Would be Required in Institutional Policies

Grant General Conditions

Insert a new subparagraph b. to Article 23:

Records of investigator financial disclosures and of actions taken

to manage conflicts of interest (see Grant Policy Manual Section 510),

shall be retained until 3 years after the later of the termination or

completion of the award to which they relate, or the resolution of any

government action involving those records.

Renumber subsequent subparagraphs accordingly.

Insert a new Article 33:

For proposals submitted on or after October 1, 1995, if the grantee

employs more than fifty persons, the grantee shall maintain an

appropriate written and enforced policy on conflict of interest

consistent with the provisions of Grant Policy Manual Section 510.

Renumber subsequent articles accordingly.

Grant Policy Manual

Add a new GPM 510 ``Conflict of Interest Policies'':

a. NSF requires each grantee institution employing more than fifty

persons to maintain an appropriate written and enforced policy on

conflict of interest. Guidance for such policies has been issued by

university associations and scientific societies.\1\

\1\ See On Preventing Conflicts of Interests in Government-

Sponsored Research at Universities, a Joint Statement of the Council

of the American Association of University Professors and the

American Council on Education (1964); Managing Externally Funded

Programs at Colleges and Universities, especially ``Principle X.

Research Ethics and Conflicts'', issued by the Council on Government

Relations (1989); Guidelines for Dealing with Faculty Conflicts of

commitment and Conflicts of Interest in Research, issued by the

Association of American Medical Colleges (1990); and Framework

Document for Managing Financial Conflicts of Interest, issued by the

Association of American Universities (1993).

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

b. An institutional conflict of interest policy should require that

each investigator disclose to a responsible representative of the

institution all significant financial interests of the investigator

(including those of the investigator's spouse and dependent children)

(i) that would reasonably appear to be affected by the research or

educational activities funded or proposed for funding by NSF; or (ii)

in entities whose financial interests would reasonably appear to be

affected by such activities.

The term investigator means the principal investigator, co-

principal investigators, and any other person at the institution who is

responsible for the design, conduct, or reporting of research or

educational activities funded or proposed for funding by NSF.

The term significant financial interest means anything of monetary

value, including, but not limited to, salary or other payments for

services (e.g., consulting fees or honoraria); equity interests (e.g.,

stocks, stock options or other ownership interests); and intellectual

property rights (e.g., patents, copyrights and royalties from such

rights). The term does not include:

1. Salary, royalties or other remuneration from the applicant

institution;

2. Any ownership interests in the institution, if the institution

is an applicant under the Small Business Innovation Research Program or

Small Business Technology Transfer Program;

3. Income from seminars, lectures, or teaching engagements

sponsored by public or nonprofit entities;

4. Income from service on advisory committees or review panels for

public or nonprofit entities;

5. An equity interest that, when aggregated for the investigator

and the investigator's spouse and dependent children, meets both of the

following tests: does not exceed $10,000 in value as determined through

reference to public prices or other reasonable measures of fair market

value, and does not represent more than a 5% ownership interest in any

single entity; or

6. Salary, royalties or other payments that, when aggregated for

the investigator and the investigator's spouse and dependent children,

are not expected to exceed $10,000 during the next twelve month period.

c. An institutional policy must ensure that investigators have

provided all required financial disclosures at the time the proposal is

submitted to NSF. It must also require that those financial disclosures

are updated during the period of the award, either on an annual basis,

or as new reportable significant financial interests are obtained.

d. An institutional policy must designate one or more persons to

review financial disclosures, determine whether a conflict of interest

exists, and determine what conditions or restrictions, if any, should

be imposed by the institution to manage, reduce or eliminate such

conflict of interest. A conflict of interest exists when the

reviewer(s) reasonably determine that a significant financial interest

could directly and significantly affect the design, conduct, or

reporting of NSF-funded research or educational activities.

Examples of conditions or restrictions that might be imposed to

manage, reduce or eliminate conflicts of interest include, but are not

limited to:

1. Public disclosure of significant financial interests;

2. Monitoring of research by independent reviewers;

3. Modification of the research plan;

4. Disqualification from participation in the portion of the NSF-

funded research that would be affected by the significant financial

interests;

5. Divestiture of significant financial interests; or

6. Severance of relationships that create conflicts.

If the reviewer(s) determines that imposing conditions or

restrictions would be either ineffective or inequitable, and that the

potential negative impacts that may arise from a significant financial

interest are outweighed by interests of scientific progress, technology

transfer, or the public health and welfare, then the reviewer(s) may

allow the research to go forward without imposing such conditions or

restrictions.

e. The institutional policy must include adequate enforcement

mechanisms, and provide for sanctions where appropriate.

f. The institutional policy must include arrangements for keeping

NSF's Office of General Counsel appropriately

[[Page 35823]]

informed if the institution finds that it is unable to satisfactorily

manage a conflict of interest.

g. Institutions must maintain records of all financial disclosures

and of all actions taken to resolve conflicts of interest for at least

three years beyond the termination or completion of the grant to which

they relate, or until the resolution of any NSF action involving those

records, whichever is longer.

What Would Be Required in Proposals

Grant Proposal Guide

Section II.C.1, INSTRUCTIONS FOR PROPOSAL PREPARATION, at the end

of the Certification for Authorized Institutional Representative or

Individual Applicant, will be revised to add:

A new certification will be added that requires an institutional

representative to certify that the institution has implemented a

written and enforced policy on conflicts of interest consistent with

the provisions of Grant Policy Manual Section 510; that to the best of

his/her knowledge, all financial disclosures required by that conflict

of interest policy have been made; and that all identified conflicts of

interests will have been satisfactorily managed, reduced or eliminated

prior to the institution's expenditure of any funds under the award, in

accordance with the institution's conflict of interest policy.

Conflicts which cannot be satisfactorily managed, reduced or eliminated

must be disclosed to NSF.

Page 2 of the NSF Form 1207, Cover Sheet for Proposal to the NSF,

will be revised to add the following to the end of the section on

Certification for Authorized Institutional Representative or Individual

Applicant:

In addition, if the applicant institution employs more than fifty

persons, the authorized official of the applicant institution is

certifying that the institution has implemented a written and enforced

conflict of interest policy that is consistent with the provisions of

Grant Policy Manual Section 510; that to the best of his/her knowledge,

all financial disclosures required by that conflict of interest policy

have been made; and that all identified conflicts of interest will have

been satisfactorily managed, reduced or eliminated prior to the

institution's expenditure of any funds under the award, in accordance

with the institution's conflict of interest policy. Conflicts which

cannot be satisfactorily managed, reduced or eliminated must be

disclosed to NSF.

Dated: May 17, 1995.

Lawrence Rudolph,

General Counsel.

[FR Doc. 95-16800 Filed 7-10-95; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 7555-01-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.