Title IHelping Disadvantaged Children Meet High Standards

Federal RegisterJul 3, 1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

SUMMARY: As specifically required by statute, the U.S. Secretary of

Education (Secretary) issues a single set of final regulations

implementing the programs under Title I of the Elementary and Secondary

Education Act of 1965, as amended by the Improving America's Schools

Act of 1994. In order to provide maximum flexibility to grantees

implementing the programs under Title I, these regulations address only

those few provisions for which the Secretary believes rulemaking is

absolutely necessary. These regulations replace the regulations

currently found at 34 CFR Parts 200, 201, 203, 205 and 212.

EFFECTIVE DATE: These regulations take effect on August 2, 1995.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For subparts A and E, Wendy Jo New,

Telephone: (202) 260-0982; for subpart B, Patricia McKee, Telephone:

(202) 260-0991; for subpart D, Paul Brown, Telephone: (202) 260-0976:

Compensatory Education Programs, Office of Elementary and Secondary

Education, U.S. Department of Education, 600 Independence Avenue, SW,

Portals Building, room 4400, Washington, DC 20202-6132.

For subparts C and E, James English, Office of Migrant Education,

Office of Elementary and Secondary Education, U.S. Department of

Education, 600 Independence Avenue, SW, Portals Building, room 4100,

Washington, DC 20202-6135. Telephone: (202) 260-1394.

Individuals who use a telecommunications device for the deaf (TDD)

may call the Federal Information Relay Services (FIRS) at 1-800-877-

8339 between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m., Eastern time, Monday through Friday.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The 1994 reauthorization of the Elementary

and Secondary Education Act of 1965 (ESEA) revised Federal elementary

and secondary education programs extensively to help ensure that all

children acquire the knowledge and skills they will need to succeed in

the 21st century. Under the reauthorized ESEA, Federal education

programs for the first time are designed to work together with, rather

than separately from, one another. In addition, rather than operating

apart from the broader education that children receive, the ESEA

reinforces State and community reform efforts geared to challenging

State standards, particularly those initiated or supported by the Goals

2000: Educate America Act. In fact, all of the major ESEA programs are

redesigned to support comprehensive State and local reforms of teaching

and learning and ensure that all children--whatever their background

and whatever school they attend--can reap the benefit of those reforms.

As the largest by far of all ESEA programs, Title I is the

centerpiece of the ESEA's efforts to help the neediest schools and

students reach the same challenging standards expected of all children.

Effective July 1, 1995, the four Title I programs--the basic program in

local educational agencies (LEAs) (Part A), the Even Start Family

Literacy program (Part B), the Migrant Education program (Part C), and

the Neglected, Delinquent, and At-Risk Youth program (Part D)--are

designed to work together in support of this common purpose. Moreover,

the programs embrace the same fundamental new strategies to help ensure

that the intended beneficiaries are not left behind in State and local

efforts to promote higher standards. These strategies include: a

schoolwide focus on improving teaching and learning, strong program

coordination by LEAs, flexibility at the local level combined with

clear accountability for results, more focused targeting of resources

on the neediest schools, and stronger partnerships between schools and

communities to support higher achievement for all children.

On May 1, 1995, the Secretary published a notice of proposed

rulemaking (NPRM) for Title I in the Federal Register (60 FR 21400-

21419). The preamble to the NPRM included a discussion of the

provisions enacted by Congress that were addressed in the NPRM. The

preamble also included a summary of the results of the negotiated

rulemaking process the Secretary implemented under section 1601(b) of

Title I. In developing the proposed regulations, the Secretary

considered the comments of persons who responded to the October 28,

1994 Federal Register notice requesting advice and recommendations on

regulatory issues under Title I (59 FR 54372-74) and also the comments

of participants in the negotiated rulemaking process.

Changes From the NPRM and Analysis of Comments and Changes

In response to the Secretary's invitation to comment in the NPRM,

370 letters were received from State and LEA officials, teachers,

organizations, Members of Congress, citizens, and students. An analysis

of the comments and the Secretary's responses to those comments is

published as an appendix to these final regulations.

In these final regulations, the Secretary has considered these

comments, balancing the concerns of State and local school officials,

parents, and others with the statutory purposes of the program and the

needs of the children to be served. The following sections provide a

brief summary of the final regulations that differ from the regulations

proposed in the NPRM.

State Responsibilities for Assessment (Secs. 200.1, 200.4)

The Secretary has revised Secs. 200.1 and 200.4 to clarify that a

State's set of high-quality yearly assessments must measure performance

in at least mathematics and reading/language arts, but need not be

focused solely on reading/language arts or mathematics. Rather, as

indicated in Sec. 200.4(a)(1), a State may meet this requirement by

developing or adopting assessments in other academic subjects as long

as those assessments sufficiently measure performance in mathematics

and reading/language arts. For example, an assessment in an academic

subject such as social studies may sufficiently measure performance in

reading/language arts. Particularly at the secondary level, the

Secretary believes it may be especially appropriate to measure

performance in reading/language arts through assessments in content

areas. In addition, the Secretary emphasizes the importance of all

children attaining high levels of performance in all core academic

subjects. Limiting the focus of Title I accountability in no way is

intended to alter the overall responsibility of States, local school

districts, and schools for success of all students in the core academic

subjects determined by the State. If a State has standards and

assessments for all students in subjects beyond mathematics and

reading/language arts, the regulations do not preclude a State from

including, for accountability purposes, additional subject areas, and

the Secretary encourages them to do so.

[[Page 34801]]

Schoolwide Program Requirements (Sec. 200.8)

Section 200.8(c)(3)(ii)(B)(1)(A) of the proposed regulations would

have required a school that combines in its schoolwide program funds

received under Part C of Title I, in consultation with parents of

migratory children or organizations representing those parents, to

first address the identified needs of migratory children that result

from the effects of their migratory lifestyle or are needed to permit

migratory children to participate effectively in school. The Secretary

has revised this section to clarify that both parents and organizations

representing those parents may participate in consultation together to

clarify that the two parties are not mutually exclusive.

Responsibilities for Providing Services to Children in Private Schools

(Sec. 200.10)

Recognizing that some LEAs identify a public school as eligible for

Title I on the basis of student enrollment rather than because it

serves an eligible attendance area, the Secretary has amended

Sec. 200.10(b) to clarify that if an LEA identifies a public school as

eligible on the basis of enrollment, the LEA must, in consultation with

private school officials, determine an equitable way to identify

eligible private school children.

Payments to LEAs for Capital Expenses (Sec. 200.16)

Section 200.16(a)(2)(i)(D) makes clear that the salaries of

noninstructional technicians who monitor computer-assisted instruction

in private schools are administrative costs to be taken off the top of

an LEA's allocation. As such, the LEA may fund those technicians from

its capital expense funds.

Reservation of Funds by an LEA (Sec. 200.27)

The Secretary has amended Sec. 200.27 to clarify that capital

expenses incurred to implement alternative delivery systems necessary

to serve private school students in compliance with Aguilar v. Felton

that are not reimbursed under section 1002(e) of Title I are

administrative costs that must be taken off the top of an LEA's Part A

allocation.

Allocation of Funds to School Attendance Areas and Schools

(Sec. 200.28)

The Secretary has made several changes in Sec. 200.28. First, the

Secretary has added flexibility in paragraph (a)(3) to permit an LEA

that ranks its school attendance areas or schools below 75 percent

poverty by grade span groupings to determine the percentage of children

from low-income families in the LEA as a whole for each grade span

grouping.

Second, the Secretary has addressed a significant problem

concerning the availability of adequate poverty data on children who

reside in participating public school attendance areas but who attend

private schools. Paragraph (a)(2)(i) provides that, if the same data

are not available for private school children as are available for

public school children, an LEA may use comparable data collected

through alternative means such as a survey or from existing sources

such as Aid to Families with Dependent Children or tuition scholarship

programs. Under paragraph (a)(2)(ii), if complete actual poverty data

are not available on private school children, an LEA may extrapolate

from actual data on a representative sample of private school children

the number of poor private school children. If adequate data are not

available under paragraph (a)(2)(i) or (ii), the LEA, for the 1995-96

school year only, shall derive the number of private school children

from low-income families by applying the poverty percentage of each

participating public school attendance area to the number of private

school children who reside in that area.

For example, if a participating public school area has 50 percent

poverty and 100 children who reside in that area attend private

schools, 50 private school children would be deemed to be poor and thus

would generate Part A funds. For school years after 1995-96, however,

actual poverty data (or a reasonable estimate based on an adequate

sample) will be required. Finally, the Secretary has made clear in

paragraph (b)(1) that an LEA must calculate 125 percent of the per-

pupil amount of funds the LEA receives for a given fiscal year before

the LEA reserves any funds under Sec. 200.27.

Migrant Education Program (MEP) Definitions (Sec. 200.40)

The proposed regulations contained definitions of ``migratory

agricultural worker'' and ``migratory fisher'' to require a move to

obtain temporary or seasonal agricultural or fishing work ``as a

principal means of livelihood.'' This term was proposed to focus MEP

services on children who are truly migratory, i.e., children in

families with an actual, significant dependency on migratory

agricultural or fishing work. In doing so, the new requirement was

intended to correct a situation in which persons who move across school

district lines to perform temporary or seasonal agricultural or fishing

activities for only a short time are considered ``migratory'' under the

MEP, even when they do not have a significant economic dependence on

the agricultural or fishing activities. Because many commenters

appeared to have misunderstood the scope and intent of the ``principal

means of livelihood'' language, and the degree of burden that its use

would place on State and local program staff and parents of migratory

children, the regulations have been revised to more clearly define the

term, ``principal means of livelihood,'' for purposes of the MEP and

clarify the term's applicability to moves within 15,000 square mile

districts.

Use of Program Funds for Unique Program Function Costs

(Sec. 200.41)

The proposed regulations permit an SEA to use MEP funds to carry

out other administrative activities, beyond those allowable under

Sec. 200.61, that are unique to the MEP ``or that are the same or

similar to those performed by LEAs in the State under subpart A.'' In

response to comment, the regulations have been revised to clarify that

administrative activities ``that are the same or similar to those

performed by LEAs in the State under subpart A'' are included under

those administrative activities that are unique to the MEP.

Executive Order 12866

These final regulations have been reviewed in accordance with

Executive Order 12866. Under the terms of the order, the Secretary has

assessed the potential costs and benefits of this regulatory action.

The benefits associated with these final regulations are clear.

Because the Secretary has chosen to regulate on very few statutory

provisions, SEAs and LEAs have considerable flexibility in implementing

the provisions of Title I to meet their particular needs and

circumstances. Moreover, the potential costs associated with these

final regulations are minimal; they result from specific statutory

requirements or have been determined by the Secretary to be necessary

for administering the Title I programs effectively and efficiently.

Intergovernmental Review

Grants to SEAs for the MEP and grants to SEAs and LEAs for the

Migrant Education Coordination Program are subject to the requirements

of Executive Order 12372 and the regulations in 34 CFR Part 79. The

objective of the Executive Order is to foster an intergovernmental

partnership and a strengthened federalism by relying on processes

developed by State and local

[[Page 34802]]

governments for coordination and review of proposed Federal financial

assistance.

In accordance with this order, this document is intended to provide

early notification of the Secretary's specific plans and actions for

these programs.

List of Subjects in 34 CFR Part 200

Administrative practice and procedure, Adult education, Children,

Coordination, Education, Education of disadvantaged children, Education

of individuals with disabilities, Elementary and secondary education,

Eligibility, Family, Family-centered education, Grant programs--

education, Indians--education, Institutions of higher education,

Interstate coordination, Intrastate coordination, Juvenile delinquency,

Local educational agencies, Migratory children, Migratory workers,

Neglected, Nonprofit private agencies, Private schools, Public

agencies, Reporting and recordkeeping requirements, State-administered

programs, State educational agencies, Subgrants.

34 CFR Part 201

Education of disadvantaged, Elementary and secondary education,

Grant programs--education, Migrant labor, Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements.

34 CFR Part 203

Education of disadvantaged, Elementary and secondary education,

Grant programs--education, Juvenile delinquency, Reporting and

recordkeeping requirements.

34 CFR Part 205

Education of disadvantaged, Elementary and secondary education,

Grant programs--education, Migrant labor.

34 CFR Part 212

Adult education, Education of disadvantaged, Elementary and

secondary education, Grant programs--education, Indians--education,

Infants and children, Migrant labor, Reporting and recordkeeping

requirements.

Dated: June 28, 1995.

Richard W. Riley,

Secretary of Education.

(Catalog of Federal Domestic Assistance Numbers: 84.010, Improving

Programs Operated by Local Educational Agencies; 84.011, Migrant

Education Basic State Formula Grant Program; 84.013, Prevention and

Intervention Programs for Children and Youth Who Are Neglected,

Delinquent, or At-Risk of Dropping Out; 84.144, Migrant Education

Coordination Program; 84.213, Even Start Family Literacy Program)

The Secretary amends Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations by

removing Parts 201, 203, 205, and 212 and revising Part 200 as follows:

PART 201 [Removed]

1. Part 201 is removed.

PART 203 [Removed]

2. Part 203 is removed.

PART 205 [Removed]

3. Part 205 is removed.

PART 212 [Removed]

4. Part 212 is removed.

5. Part 200 is revised to read as follows:

PART 200--TITLE I--HELPING DISADVANTAGED CHILDREN MEET HIGH

STANDARDS

Subpart A--Improving Basic Programs Operated by Local Educational

Agencies

Standards, Assessment, and Accountability

Sec.

200.1 Contents of a State plan.

200.2 State responsibilities for developing challenging standards.

200.3 Requirements for adequate progress.

200.4 State responsibilities for assessment.

200.5 Requirements for school improvement.

200.6 Requirements for LEA improvement.

200.7 [Reserved]

Schoolwide Programs

200.8 Schoolwide program requirements.

200.9 [Reserved]

Participation of Eligible Children in Private Schools

200.10 Responsibilities for providing services to children in

private schools.

200.11 Factors for determining equitable participation of children

in private schools.

200.12 Requirements to ensure that funds do not benefit a private

school.

200.13 Requirements concerning property, equipment, and supplies

for the benefit of private school children.

200.14 [Reserved]

Capital Expenses

200.15 Payments to SEAs for capital expenses.

200.16 Payments to LEAs for capital expenses.

200.17 Use of LEA payments for capital expenses.

200.18-200.19 [Reserved]

Procedures for the Within-State Allocation of LEA Program Funds

200.20 Allocation of funds to LEAs.

200.21 Determination of the number of children eligible to be

counted.

200.22 Allocation of basic grants.

200.23 Allocation of concentration grants.

200.24 Allocation of targeted grants.

200.25 Applicable hold-harmless provisions.

200.26 [Reserved]

Procedures for the Within-District Allocation of LEA Program Funds

200.27 Reservation of funds by an LEA.

200.28 Allocation of funds to school attendance areas and schools.

200.29 [Reserved]

Subpart B--Even Start Family Literacy Programs

200.30 Migrant Education Even Start program definition.

200.31-200.39 [Reserved]

Subpart C--Migrant Education Program

200.40 Program definitions.

200.41 Use of program funds for unique program function costs.

200.42 Responsibilities of SEAs and operating agencies for

assessing the effectiveness of the MEP.

200.43 Responsibilities of SEAs and operating agencies for

improving services to migratory children.

200.44 Use of MEP funds in schoolwide projects.

200.45 Responsibilities for participation of children in private

schools.

200.46-200.49 [Reserved]

Subpart D--Prevention and Intervention Programs for Children and Youth

Who Are Neglected, Delinquent, or At-Risk of Dropping Out

200.50 Program definitions.

200.51 SEA counts of eligible children.

200.52-200.59 [Reserved]

Subpart E--General Provisions

200.60 Reservation of funds for State administration and school

improvement.

200.61 Use of funds reserved for State administration.

200.62 [Reserved]

200.63 Supplement, not supplant.

200.64 Maintenance of effort.

200.65 Definitions.

200.66-200.69 [Reserved]

Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6301-6514, unless otherwise noted.

Subpart A--Improving Basic Programs Operated by Local Educational

Agencies

Standards, Assessment, and Accountability

Sec. 200.1 Contents of a State plan.

(a)(1) A State that desires to receive a grant under this subpart

shall submit to the Secretary a plan that meets the requirements of

this section.

(2) A State plan must be--

(i) Developed with broad-based consultation throughout the planning

process with local educational agencies (LEAs), teachers, pupil

services personnel, other staff, parents, and administrators, including

principals;

(ii) Developed with substantial involvement of the Committee of

[[Page 34803]]

Practitioners established under section 1603(b) of the Elementary and

Secondary Education Act of 1965, as amended (Act), and continue to

involve the Committee in monitoring the plan's implementation; and

(iii) Coordinated with other plans developed under the Act, the

Goals 2000: Educate America Act, and other acts, as appropriate,

consistent with section 14307 of the Act.

(3) In lieu of a State plan under this section, a State may include

programs under this part in a consolidated State plan submitted in

accordance with section 14302 of the Act.

(b) A State plan must address the following:

(1) Challenging standards. The State plan must include--

(i) Evidence that demonstrates that--

(A) The State has developed or adopted challenging content and

student performance standards for all students in accordance with

Sec. 200.2; and

(B) The State's procedure for setting the student performance

levels applies recognized professional and technical knowledge for

establishing the student performance levels; or

(ii) The State's strategy and schedule for developing or adopting

by the beginning of the 1997-1998 school year--

(A) Challenging content and student performance standards for all

students in accordance with Sec. 200.2(b); or

(B) Content and student performance standards for elementary and

secondary school children served under this subpart in accordance with

Sec. 200.2(c), if the State will not have developed or adopted content

and student performance standards for all students by the 1997-1998

school year or does not intend to develop such standards.

(iii) For subjects in which students will be served under this

subpart but for which a State has no standards, the State plan must

describe the State's strategy for ensuring that those students are

taught the same knowledge and skills and held to the same expectations

as are all children.

(2) Assessments. The State plan must--

(i) Demonstrate that the State has developed or adopted a set of

high-quality yearly student assessments, including assessments that

measure performance in at least mathematics and reading/language arts,

in accordance with Sec. 200.4, that will be used as the primary means

of determining the yearly performance of each school and LEA served

under this subpart in enabling all children participating under this

subpart to meet the State's student performance standards; or

(ii) If a State has not developed or adopted assessments that

measure performance in at least mathematics and reading/language arts

in accordance with Sec. 200.4--

(A) Describe the State's quality benchmarks, timetables, and

reporting schedule for completing the development and field-testing of

those assessments by the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year; and

(B) Describe the transitional set of yearly statewide assessments

the State will use to assess students' performance in mastering complex

skills and challenging subject matter; and

(iii)(A) Identify the languages other than English that are spoken

by the student population participating under this subpart; and

(B) Indicate the languages for which yearly student assessments

that meet the requirements of this section are not available and are

needed and develop a timetable for progress toward the development of

these assessments.

(3) Adequate yearly progress. The State plan must--

(i) Demonstrate, based on the assessments described under

Sec. 200.4, what constitutes adequate yearly progress toward enabling

all children to meet the State performance standards of--

(A) Any school served under this subpart; and

(B) Any LEA that receives funds under this subpart; or

(ii) For any year in which a State uses transitional assessments

under Sec. 200.4(e), describe how the State will identify schools under

Sec. 200.5 and LEAs under Sec. 200.6 in accordance with Sec. 200.3.

(4) Capacity building. Each State plan shall describe--

(i) How the State educational agency (SEA) will help each LEA and

school affected by the State plan to develop the capacity to comply

with each of the requirements of sections 1112(c)(1)(D), 1114(b), and

1115(c) of the Act that is applicable to the LEA and school; and

(ii) Other factors the State deems appropriate, which may include

opportunity-to-learn standards or strategies developed under the Goals

2000: Educate America Act, to provide students an opportunity to

achieve the knowledge and skills described in the challenging content

standards developed or adopted by the State.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6311)

Sec. 200.2 State responsibilities for developing challenging

standards.

(a) Standards in general. (1) A State shall develop or adopt

challenging content and student performance standards that will be used

by the State, its LEAs, and its schools to carry out this subpart.

(2) Standards under this subpart must include--

(i) Challenging content standards in academic subjects that--

(A) Specify what children are expected to know and be able to do;

(B) Contain coherent and rigorous content; and

(C) Encourage the teaching of advanced skills; and

(ii) Challenging student performance standards that--

(A) Are aligned with the State's content standards;

(B) Describe two levels of high performance--proficient and

advanced--that determine how well children are mastering the material

in the State's content standards; and

(C) Describe a third level of performance--partially proficient--to

provide complete information to measure the progress of lower-

performing children toward achieving to the proficient and advanced

levels of performance.

(b) Standards for all children. A State that has developed or

adopted content standards and student performance standards for all

students under Title III of the Goals 2000: Educate America Act or

under another process, or will develop or adopt such standards by the

beginning of the 1997-1998 school year, shall use those standards,

modified, if necessary, to conform with the requirements in paragraph

(a) of this section and Sec. 200.3, to carry out this subpart.

(c) Standards for children served under this subpart. (1) If a

State will not have developed or adopted content and student

performance standards for all students by the beginning of the 1997-

1998 school year, or does not intend to develop those standards, the

State shall develop content and student performance standards for

elementary and secondary school children served under this subpart in

subject areas as determined by the State, but including at least

mathematics and reading/language arts. These standards must--

(i) Include the same knowledge, skills, and levels of performance

expected of all children;

(ii) Meet the requirements in paragraph (a) of this section and

Sec. 200.3; and

(iii) Be developed by the beginning of the 1997-1998 school year.

[[Page 34804]]

(2) If a State has not developed content and student performance

standards in mathematics and reading/language arts for elementary and

secondary school children served under this subpart by the beginning of

the 1997-1998 school year, the State shall then adopt a set of

standards in those subjects such as the standards contained in other

State plans the Secretary has approved.

(3) If and when a State develops or adopts standards for all

children, the State shall use those standards to carry out this

subpart.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6311(b))

Sec. 200.3 Requirements for adequate progress.

(a) Except as provided in paragraph (c) of this section, each State

shall determine, based on the State assessment system described in

Sec. 200.1, what constitutes adequate yearly progress of--

(1) Any school served under this subpart toward enabling children

to meet the State's student performance standards; and

(2) Any LEA that receives funds under this subpart toward enabling

children in schools served under this subpart to meet the State's

student performance standards.

(b) Adequate yearly progress must be defined in a manner that--

(1) Results in continuous and substantial yearly improvement of

each school and LEA sufficient to achieve the goal of all children

served under this subpart, particularly economically disadvantaged and

limited-English proficient children, meeting the State's proficient and

advanced levels of performance;

(2) Is sufficiently rigorous to achieve that goal within an

appropriate timeframe; and

(3) Links progress primarily to performance on the State's

assessment system under Sec. 200.4, while permitting progress to be

established in part through the use of other measures, such as dropout,

retention, and attendance rates.

(c) For any year in which a State uses transitional assessments

under Sec. 200.4(e), the State shall devise a procedure for identifying

schools under Sec. 200.5 and LEAs under Sec. 200.6 that relies on

accurate information about the continuous and substantial yearly

academic progress of each school and LEA.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6311(b)(2), (7)(B))

Sec. 200.4 State responsibilities for assessment.

(a) (1) Each State shall develop or adopt a set of high-quality

yearly student assessments, including assessments that measure

performance in at least mathematics and reading/language arts, that

will be used as the primary means of determining the yearly performance

of each school and LEA served under this subpart in enabling all

children participating under this subpart to meet the State's student

performance standards.

(2) A State may satisfy this requirement if the State has developed

or adopted a set of high-quality yearly student assessments in other

academic subjects that measure performance in mathematics and reading/

language arts.

(b) Assessments under this section must meet the following

requirements:

(1) Be the same assessments used to measure the performance of all

children, if the State measures the performance of all children.

(2)(i) Be aligned with the State's challenging content and student

performance standards; and

(ii) Provide coherent information about student attainment of the

State's content and student performance standards.

(3)(i)(A) Be used for purposes for which the assessments are valid

and reliable; and

(B) Be consistent with relevant, nationally recognized professional

and technical standards for those assessments.

(ii) Assessment measures that do not meet these requirements may be

included as one of the multiple measures if the State includes in its

State plan sufficient information regarding the State's efforts to

validate the measures and to report the results of those validation

studies.

(4) Measure the proficiency of students in the academic subjects in

which a State has adopted challenging content and student performance

standards.

(5) Be administered at some time during--

(i) Grades 3 through 5;

(ii) Grades 6 through 9; and

(iii) Grades 10 through 12.

(6) Involve multiple approaches within an assessment system with

up-to-date measures of student performance, including measures that

assess complex thinking skills and understanding of challenging

content.

(7) Provide for--

(i) Participation in the assessment of all students in the grades

being assessed;

(ii) Reasonable adaptations and accommodations for students with

diverse learning needs necessary to measure the achievement of those

students relative to the State's standards; and

(iii) (A) Inclusion of limited-English proficient students who

shall be assessed, to the extent practicable, in the language and form

most likely to yield accurate and reliable information on what those

students know and can do to determine the students' mastery of skills

in subjects other than English.

(B) To meet this requirement, the State--

(1) Shall make every effort to use or develop linguistically

accessible assessment measures; and

(2) May request assistance from the Secretary if those measures are

needed.

(8) Include, for determining the progress of the LEA only, students

who have attended schools in the LEA for a full academic year, but who

have not attended a single school in the LEA for a full academic year.

(9) Provide individual student interpretive and descriptive reports

that include--

(i) Individual scores; or

(ii) Other information on the attainment of student performance

standards.

(10) Enable results to be disaggregated within each State, LEA, and

school by--

(i) Gender;

(ii) Each major racial and ethnic group;

(iii) English proficiency status;

(iv) Migrant status;

(v) Students with disabilities as compared to students without

disabilities; and

(vi) Economically disadvantaged students as compared to students

who are not economically disadvantaged.

(c) (1) If a State has developed or adopted assessments for all

students that measure performance in mathematics and reading/language

arts under Title III of the Goals 2000: Educate America Act or under

another process, the State shall use those assessments, modified, if

necessary, to conform with the requirements in paragraph (b) of this

section and Sec. 200.3, to carry out this subpart.

(2) Paragraph (c)(1) of this section does not relieve the State

from including students served under this subpart in assessments in any

other subjects the State has developed or adopted for all children.

(d) (1) Except as provided in paragraph (d) (2) and (3) of this

section, if a State has not developed or adopted assessments that

measure performance in at least mathematics and reading/language arts

that meet the requirements in paragraph (b) of this section, the State

shall--

[[Page 34805]]

(i) By the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, develop those

assessments and field-test them for one year; and

(ii) Develop a timetable and benchmarks, including reports of

validity studies, for completing the development and field testing of

those assessments.

(2) The State may request a one-year extension from the Secretary

to test its new assessments if the State submits a strategy to correct

problems identified in the field testing of its assessments.

(3) If a State has not developed assessments that measure

performance in at least mathematics and reading/language arts that meet

the requirements in paragraph (b) of this section by the beginning of

the 2000-2001 school year and is denied an extension, the State shall

adopt a set of assessments in those subjects such as assessments

contained in the plans of other States the Secretary has approved.

(e) (1) While a State is developing assessments under paragraph (d)

of this section, the State may propose to use a transitional set of

yearly statewide assessments that will--(i) Assess the performance of

complex skills and challenging subject matter in at least mathematics

and reading/language arts, which may be satisfied through assessments

in academic subjects other than mathematics and reading/language arts

if those assessments measure performance in mathematics and reading/

language arts;

(ii) Be administered at some time during--

(A) Grades 3 through 5;

(B) Grades 6 through 9; and

(C) Grades 10 through 12; and

(iii) Include all children in the grades being assessed.

(2) Transitional assessments do not need to meet the other

requirements of this section.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6311(b))

Sec. 200.5 Requirements for school improvement.

(a) Local review. (1)(i) Each LEA receiving funds under this

subpart shall review annually the progress of each school served under

this subpart to determine whether the school is meeting or making

adequate progress toward enabling its students to meet the State's

student performance standards described in the State plan.

(ii) An LEA may review a targeted assistance school on the progress

of only those students that have been or are served under this subpart.

(2) In conducting its review, an LEA shall--

(i) (A) Use the State assessments or transitional assessments

described in the State plan; and

(B) Use any additional measures or indicators described in the

LEA's plan; or

(ii) If the State assessments are not conducted in a Title I

school, use other appropriate measures or indicators to review the

school's progress; and

(iii) (A) Disaggregate the results of the review according to the

categories specified in Sec. 200.4(b)(10);

(B) Seek to produce, in schoolwide program schools, statistically

sound results for each category through the use of oversampling or

other means; and

(C) Report disaggregated data to the public only when those data

are statistically sound.

(3) The LEA shall--

(i) Publicize and disseminate to teachers and other staff, parents,

students, the community, and administrators, including principals, the

results of the annual review of all schools served under this subpart

in individual school performance profiles; and

(ii) Provide the results of the annual review to schools served

under this subpart so that the schools can continually refine their

program of instruction to help all children participating under this

subpart meet the State's student performance standards.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6317(a))

(Approved by the Office of Management and Budget under control

number 1810-0581)

Sec. 200.6 Requirements for LEA improvement.

(a) State review. (1)(i) Each SEA shall review annually the

progress of each LEA served under this subpart to determine whether the

schools receiving assistance under this subpart are making adequate

progress toward enabling their students to meet the State's student

performance standards described in the State plan.

(ii) An SEA may review the progress of the schools served by an LEA

only for those students that have been or are being served under this

subpart.

(2) In conducting its review, an SEA shall--

(i) Disaggregate the results of the review according to the

categories specified in Sec. 200.4(b)(10);

(ii) Consider other indicators, if applicable, in accordance with

section 1112(b)(1) of the Act; and

(ii) Report disaggregated data to the public only when those data

are statistically sound.

(3) The SEA shall publicize and disseminate to LEAs, teachers, and

other staff, parents, students, the community, and administrators,

including principals, the results of the State review.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6317(d))

(Approved by the Office of Management and Budget under control

number 1810-0581)

Sec. 200.7 [Reserved]

Schoolwide Programs

Sec. 200.8 Schoolwide program requirements.

(a) General. (1) An eligible school, in consultation with its LEA,

may use funds or services under this subpart, in combination with other

Federal, State, and local funds it receives, to upgrade the entire

educational program in the school to support systemic reform in

accordance with the provisions of this section.

(2)(i) Except as provided in paragraph (a)(2)(ii) of this section,

a school may not start a new schoolwide program until the SEA provides

written information to each LEA that the SEA has established a

statewide system of support and improvement.

(ii) If a school desires to start a schoolwide program prior to the

establishment of a statewide system of support and improvement, the

school shall demonstrate to the LEA that the school has received high-

quality technical assistance and support from other providers of

assistance.

(b) Eligibility for a schoolwide program. A school may operate a

schoolwide program if--

(1) The LEA determines that the school serves a participating

attendance area or is a participating school under section 1113 of the

Act; and

(2)(i) For the initial year of the schoolwide program, the school

meets either of the following criteria:

(A) For the 1995-1996 school year--

(1) The school serves a school attendance area in which not less

than 60 percent of the children are from low-income families; or

(2) Not less than 60 percent of the children enrolled in the school

are from low-income families.

(B) For the 1996-1997 school year and subsequent years, the

percentages of children from low-income families in paragraph

(b)(2)(i)(A) may not be less than 50 percent.

(ii) The LEA may choose to determine the percentage of children

from low-income families under paragraph (b)(2)(i) based on a measure

of poverty that is different from the poverty measure or measures used

by the LEA to identify and rank school attendance areas for eligibility

and participation under this subpart.

[[Page 34806]]

(c) Availability of other Federal funds. (1) In addition to funds

under this subpart, a school may use in its schoolwide program Federal

funds under any program administered by the Secretary, except programs

under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), that is

included on the most recent notice published by the Secretary in the

Federal Register.

(2) For the purposes of this section, the authority to combine

funds from other Federal programs also applies to services provided to

a school with those funds.

(3) (i) Except as provided in paragraph (c)(3)(ii) of this section,

a school that combines funds from any other Federal program

administered by the Secretary in a schoolwide program--

(A) Is not required to meet the statutory or regulatory

requirements of that program applicable at the school level; but

(B) Shall meet the intent and purposes of that program to ensure

that the needs of the intended beneficiaries of that program are

addressed.

(ii)(A) An LEA or a school that chooses to use funds from other

programs shall not be relieved of statutory and regulatory requirements

applicable to those programs relating to--

(1) Health and safety;

(2) Civil rights;

(3) Gender equity;

(4) Participation and involvement of parents and students; (5)

Private school children, teachers, and other educational personnel;

(6) Maintenance of effort;

(7) Comparability of services;

(8) Use of Federal funds to supplement, not supplant non-Federal

funds in accordance with paragraph (f)(1) (iii) and (2) of this

section; and

(9) Distribution of funds to SEAs and LEAs.

(B) A school operating a schoolwide program shall comply with the

following requirements if it combines funds from these programs in its

schoolwide program:

(1) Migrant education. A school that combines in its schoolwide

program funds received under Part C of Title I of the Act shall--

(i) In consultation with parents of migratory children or

organizations representing those parents, or both, first address the

identified needs of migratory children that result from the effects of

their migratory lifestyle or are needed to permit migratory children to

participate effectively in school; and

(ii) Document that services to address those needs have been

provided.

(2) Indian education. A school may combine funds received under

subpart 1 of Part A of Title IX of the Act in its schoolwide program if

the parent committee established by the LEA under section 9114(c)(4) of

the Act approves the inclusion of those funds.

(iii) This paragraph does not relieve--

(A) An LEA from complying with all requirements that do not affect

the operation of a schoolwide program; or

(B) A non-schoolwide program school from complying with all

applicable requirements.

(d) Components of a schoolwide program. A schoolwide program must

include the following components:

(1) A comprehensive needs assessment involving the parties listed

in paragraph (e)(2)(ii) of this section of the entire school that is

based on--

(i) Information on the performance of children in relation to the

State content standards and the State student performance standards

under section 1111(b)(1) of the Act; or

(ii) Until the State develops or adopts standards under section

1111(b)(1) of the Act, an analysis of available data on the achievement

of students in the school.

(2) Schoolwide reform strategies that--

(i) Provide opportunities, based on best knowledge and practice,

for all children in the school to meet the State's proficient and

advanced levels of student performance;

(ii) Are based on effective means of improving the achievement of

children, such as utilizing research-based teaching strategies;

(iii) Use effective instructional strategies that--

(A) Increase the amount and quality of learning time, such as

providing an extended school year and before- and after-school and

summer programs;

(B) Provide an enriched and accelerated curriculum; and

(C) Meet the educational needs of historically underserved

populations;

(iv) (A) Address the needs of all children in the school,

particularly the needs of children who are members of the target

population of any program that is included in the schoolwide program

under paragraph (c) of this section; and

(B) Address how the school will determine if those needs have been

met; and

(v) Are consistent with, and designed to implement, the State and

local improvement plans, if any, approved under Title III of the Goals

2000: Educate America Act.

(3) Instruction by highly qualified professional staff.

(4)(i) Professional development, in accordance with section 1119 of

the Act, for teachers and aides and, where appropriate, principals,

pupil services personnel, other school staff, and parents to enable all

children in the school to meet the State's student performance

standards.

(ii) The school shall devote sufficient resources to effectively

carry out its responsibilities for professional development, either

alone or in consortia with other schools.

(5) Strategies to increase parental involvement, such as family

literacy services.

(6) Strategies in an elementary school for assisting preschool

children in the transition from early childhood programs, such as Head

Start, Even Start, or a State-run preschool program, to the schoolwide

program.

(7) Strategies to involve teachers in the decisions regarding the

use of additional local, high-quality student assessments, if any,

under section 1112(b)(1) of the Act to provide information on, and to

improve, the performance of individual students and the overall

instructional program.

(8) (i) Activities to ensure that students who experience

difficulty mastering any of the standards required by section 1111(b)

of the Act during the school year will be provided effective, timely

additional assistance, which must include--

(A) Strategies to ensure that students' difficulties are identified

on a timely basis and to provide sufficient information on which to

base effective assistance;

(B) To the extent the school determines feasible using funds under

this subpart, periodic training for teachers in how to identify those

difficulties and to provide assistance to individual students; and

(C) For any student who has not met those standards, parent-teacher

conferences to discuss--

(1) What the school will do to help the student meet the standards;

(2) What the parents can do to help the student improve the

student's performance; and

(3) Additional assistance that may be available to the student at

the school or elsewhere in the community.

(ii) This provision does not--

(A) Require the school or LEA to develop an individualized

education program (IEP) for each student identified under paragraph

(d)(8) of this section; or

(B) Relieve the school or LEA from the requirement under the IDEA

to develop IEPs for students with disabilities.

(e) Schoolwide program plan. (1) An eligible school that desires to

operate a schoolwide program shall develop, in

[[Page 34807]]

consultation with the LEA and its school support team or other

technical assistance provider, a comprehensive plan for reforming the

total instructional program in the school that--

(i) Incorporates the components under paragraph (d) of this

section;

(ii) Describes how the school will use resources under this subpart

and from other sources to implement those components;

(iii) Includes a list of State and local programs and other Federal

programs under paragraph (c) of this section that will be included in

the schoolwide program; and

(iv) (A) If the State has developed or adopted a State assessment

system under section 1111(b)(3) of the Act--

(1) Describes how the school will provide individual student

assessment results, including an interpretation of those results, to

the parents of each child who participates in that assessment; and

(2) Provides for the disaggregation of data on the assessment

results of students and the reporting of those data in accordance with

Sec. 200.5(a); or

(B) If the State has not developed or adopted a State assessment

system under section 1111(b)(3) of the Act, describes the data on the

achievement of students in the school and effective instructional and

school improvement practices on which the plan is based.

(2) The schoolwide program plan must be--

(i) Developed during a one-year period unless--

(A) The LEA, after considering the recommendation of its technical

assistance providers, determines that less time is needed to develop

and implement the schoolwide program; or

(B) The school is operating a schoolwide program under section 1015

of Chapter 1 of Title I of the Act during the 1994-1995 school year, in

which case the school may continue its schoolwide program but shall

amend its current plan or develop a new plan in accordance with this

section during the first year it receives funds under this part;

(ii) Developed with the involvement of the community to be served

and individuals who will carry out the plan, including--

(A) Teachers;

(B) Principals;

(C) Other school staff;

(D) Pupil services personnel, if appropriate;

(E) Parents of students in the school; and

(F) If the plan relates to a secondary school, students from the

school;

(iii) Available to the LEA, parents, and the public;

(iv) Translated, to the extent feasible, into any language that a

significant percentage of the parents of participating children in the

school speak as their primary language; and

(v) If appropriate, developed in coordination with other programs,

including those under the School-to-Work Opportunities Act of 1994, the

Carl D. Perkins Vocational and Applied Technology Education Act, and

the National and Community Service Act of 1990.

(3) The schoolwide program plan remains in effect for the duration

of the school's participation under this section.

(4) A school operating a schoolwide program shall review and revise

its plan, as necessary, to reflect changes in its schoolwide program or

changes to reflect State standards established after the plan was

developed.

(f) Effect of operating a schoolwide program. (1) No school

operating a schoolwide program shall be required to--

(i) Identify particular children under this subpart and under any

other Federal program included under paragraph (c) of this section as

eligible to participate in the schoolwide program;

(ii) Document that funds available under this subpart and any other

Federal program included under paragraph (c) of this section are used

to benefit only the intended beneficiaries of the respective programs;

or

(iii) Demonstrate that the particular services paid for with funds

under this subpart and under any other Federal program included under

paragraph (c) of this section supplement the services regularly

provided in that school.

(2) A school operating a schoolwide program shall use funds

available under this subpart and under any other Federal program

included under paragraph (c) of this section only to supplement the

total amount of funds that would, in the absence of those funds, be

made available from non-Federal sources for that school, including

funds needed to provide services that are required by law for children

with disabilities and children with limited-English proficiency.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6314, 6396(b))

Sec. 200.9 [Reserved]

Participation of Eligible Children in Private Schools

Sec. 200.10 Responsibilities for providing services to children in

private schools.

(a) An LEA shall, after timely and meaningful consultation with

appropriate private school officials, provide special educational

services or other benefits under this subpart, on an equitable basis,

to eligible children who are enrolled in private elementary and

secondary schools in accordance with the requirements in Secs. 200.11

through 200.17 and section 1120 of the Act.

(b) (1) Eligible private school children are children who--

(i) Reside in a participating school attendance area of the LEA;

and

(ii) Meet the criteria in section 1115(b) of the Act.

(2) If an LEA identifies a public school as eligible on the basis

of enrollment, rather than because it serves an eligible school

attendance area, the LEA shall, in consultation with private school

officials, determine an equitable way to identify eligible private

school children.

(3) Among the eligible private school children, the LEA shall

select children to participate in a manner that is consistent with the

provisions in Sec. 200.11.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6315(b); 6321(a))

Sec. 200.11 Factors for determining equitable participation of

children in private schools.

(a) Equal expenditures. (1) Expenditures of funds made available

under this subpart for services for eligible private school children in

the aggregate must be equal to the amount of funds generated by private

school children from low-income families under Sec. 200.28.

(2) An LEA shall meet this requirement as follows:

(i) Before determining equal expenditures under paragraph (a)(1) of

this section, the LEA shall reserve, from the LEA's whole allocation,

funds needed to carry out Sec. 200.27.

(ii) The LEA shall reserve the amounts of funds generated by

private school children under Sec. 200.28 and, in consultation with

appropriate private school officials, may--

(A) Combine those amounts to create a pool of funds from which the

LEA provides equitable services to eligible private school children, in

the aggregate, in greatest need of those services; or

(B) Provide equitable services to eligible children in each private

school with the funds generated by children from low-income families

under Sec. 200.28 who attend that private school.

(b) Services on an equitable basis. (1) The services that an LEA

provides to eligible private school children must be equitable in

comparison to the services and other benefits provided to public school

children participating under this subpart.

(2) Services are equitable if the LEA--

[[Page 34808]]

(i) Addresses and assesses the specific needs and educational

progress of eligible private school children on a comparable basis as

public school children;

(ii) Meets the equal expenditure requirements under paragraph (a)

of this section; and

(iii) Provides private school children with an opportunity to

participate that--(A) Is equitable to the opportunity provided to

public school children; and

(B) Provides reasonable promise of those children achieving the

high levels called for by the State's student performance standards.

(3) The LEA shall make the final decisions with respect to the

services to be provided to eligible private school children.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6321(a))

Sec. 200.12 Requirements to ensure that funds do not benefit a private

school.

(a) An LEA shall use funds under this subpart to provide services

that supplement, and in no case supplant, the level of services that

would, in the absence of Title I services, be available to

participating children in private schools.

(b) An LEA shall use funds under this subpart to meet the special

educational needs of participating private school children, but not

for--

(1) The needs of the private school; or

(2) The general needs of children in the private school.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6321(a), 6322(b))

Sec. 200.13 Requirements concerning property, equipment, and supplies

for the benefit of private school children.

(a) A public agency must keep title to and exercise continuing

administrative control of all property, equipment, and supplies that

the public agency acquires with funds under this subpart for the

benefit of eligible private school children.

(b) The public agency may place equipment and supplies in a private

school for the period of time needed for the program.

(c) The public agency shall ensure that the equipment and supplies

placed in a private school--

(1) Are used only for Title I purposes; and

(2) Can be removed from the private school without remodeling the

private school facility.

(d) The public agency shall remove equipment and supplies from a

private school if--

(1) The equipment and supplies are no longer needed for Title I

purposes; or

(2) Removal is necessary to avoid unauthorized use of the equipment

or supplies for other than Title I purposes.

(e) No funds under this subpart may be used for repairs, minor

remodeling, or construction of private school facilities.

(f) For the purpose of this section, the term public agency

includes the LEA.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6321(c))

Sec. 200.14 [Reserved]

Capital Expenses

Sec. 200.15 Payments to SEAs for capital expenses.

(a) From the amount appropriated for capital expenses under section

1002(e) of the Act, the Secretary pays a State an amount that bears the

same ratio to the amount appropriated as the number of private school

children in the State who received services under this subpart in the

most recent year for which data satisfactory to the Secretary are

available bears to the total number of private school children served

in that same year in all the States.

(b) The Secretary reallocates funds not used by a State for

purposes of Sec. 200.16 among other States on the basis of their

respective needs.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6321(e)(1))

Sec. 200.16 Payments to LEAs for capital expenses.

(a)(1)(i) An LEA may apply to the SEA for a payment to cover

capital expenses that the LEA, in providing equitable services to

eligible private school children--

(A) Is currently incurring; or

(B) Would incur because of an expected increase in the number of

private school children to be served.

(ii) An LEA may apply for a payment to cover capital expenses it

incurred in prior years for which it has not been reimbursed if the LEA

demonstrates that its current needs for capital expenses have been met.

(2) Capital expenses means only expenditures for noninstructional

goods and services that are incurred as a result of implementation of

alternative delivery systems to comply with the requirements of Aguilar

v. Felton. These expenditures--

(i) Include--

(A) The purchase, lease, and renovation of real and personal

property (including mobile educational units, and leasing of neutral

sites or space);

(B) Insurance and maintenance costs;

(C) Transportation; and

(D) Other comparable goods and services, including noninstructional

computer technicians; and

(ii) Do not include the purchase of instructional equipment such as

computers.

(b) An SEA shall distribute funds it receives under Sec. 200.15 to

LEAs that apply on the basis of need.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6321(e))

Sec. 200.17 Use of LEA payments for capital expenses.

(a) Unless an LEA is authorized by the SEA to reimburse itself for

capital expenses incurred in prior years, the LEA shall use payments

received under Sec. 200.16 to cover capital expenses the LEA is

incurring or will incur to maintain or increase the number of private

school children being served.

(b) The LEA may not take the payments received under Sec. 200.16

into account in meeting the requirements in Sec. 200.11(a).

(c) The LEA shall account separately for payments received under

Sec. 200.16.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6321(e)(3))

Sec. 200.18-200.19 [Reserved]

Procedures for the Within-State Allocation of LEA Program Funds

Sec. 200.20 Allocation of funds to LEAs.

(a) Subcounty allocations. (1) Except as provided in paragraph (b)

of this section, Sec. 200.23(c)(1) and (3)(ii), and Sec. 200.25, an SEA

shall allocate the county amounts determined by the Secretary for basic

grants, concentration grants, and targeted grants to each eligible LEA

within the county on the basis of the number of children counted in

Sec. 200.21.

(2) If an LEA overlaps a county boundary, the SEA shall make, on a

proportionate basis, a separate allocation to the LEA from the county

aggregate amount for each county in which the LEA is located, provided

the LEA is eligible for a grant.

(b) Statewide allocations. (1) In any State in which a large number

of LEAs overlap county boundaries, an SEA may apply to the Secretary

for authority to make allocations under basic grants or targeted grants

directly to LEAs without regard to counties.

(2) In its application, the SEA shall--

(i) Identify the data in Sec. 200.21(b) the SEA will use for LEA

allocations; and

(ii) Provide assurances that--

(A) Allocations will be based on the data approved by the Secretary

under this paragraph; and

(B) A procedure has been established through which an LEA

dissatisfied with the determination by the SEA may appeal directly to

the Secretary for a final determination.

(c) LEAs containing two or more counties in their entirety. If an

LEA contains two or more counties in their entirety, the SEA shall

allocate funds

[[Page 34809]]

under paragraphs (a) and (b) of this section to each county as if such

county were a separate LEA.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6333-6335)

Sec. 200.21 Determination of the number of children eligible to be

counted.

(a) General. An SEA shall count the number of children aged 5-17,

inclusive, from low-income families and the number of children residing

in local institutions for neglected children.

(b) Children from low-income families. (1) An SEA shall count the

number of children from low-income families in the school districts of

the LEAs using the best available data. The SEA shall use the same

measure of low-income throughout the State.

(2) An SEA may use one of the following options to obtain its count

of children from low-income families:

(i) The factors under section 1124(c)(1) of the Act (excluding

children in local institutions for neglected or delinquent children),

which include--

(A) Census data on children in families below the poverty level;

(B) Data on children in families above poverty receiving payments

under the program of Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC);

and

(C) Data on foster children.

(ii) Alternative data that an SEA determines best reflect the

distribution of children from low-income families and that are adjusted

to be equivalent in proportion to the total number of children counted

under section 1124(c) of the Act (excluding children in local

institutions for neglected or delinquent children).

(iii) Data that more accurately reflect the distribution of

poverty.

(c) Children in local institutions for neglected children.

The SEA shall count the number of children ages 5 to 17, inclusive,

in the LEA who resided in a local institution for neglected children--

and were not counted under subpart 1 of Part D of Title I (programs for

neglected or delinquent children operated by State agencies)--for at

least 30 consecutive days, at least one day of which was in the month

of October of the preceding fiscal year.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6333(c))

Sec. 200.22 Allocation of basic grants.

(a) Eligibility. An LEA is eligible for a basic grant if--(1) In

school year 1995-96, there are at least 10 children counted under

Sec. 200.21 in the LEA; and

(2) Beginning in school year 1996-97--

(i) There are at least 10 children counted under Sec. 200.21 in the

LEA; and

(ii) The number of those children is greater than two percent of

the LEA's total population aged 5 to 17 years, inclusive.

(b) Amount of the LEA grant. An SEA shall allocate basic grant

funds to eligible LEAs as provided in Sec. 200.20, except that the SEA

shall apply the hold-harmless provisions described in Sec. 200.25.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6333)

Sec. 200.23 Allocation of concentration grants.

(a) Eligibility. An LEA is eligible for a concentration grant if--

(1) The LEA is eligible for a basic grant under paragraph

Sec. 200.22(a); and

(2) The number of children counted under Sec. 200.21 in the LEA

exceeds--

(i) 6,500; or

(ii) 15 percent of the LEA's total population ages 5 to 17,

inclusive.

(b) Amount of the grant. (1) Except as provided in paragraph (c) of

this section, an SEA shall allocate a county's concentration grant

funds only to LEAs that--

(i) Lie, in whole or in part, within the county; and

(ii) Meet the eligibility criteria in paragraph (a) of this

section.

(2) An SEA shall allocate concentration grant funds to eligible

LEAs as provided in Sec. 200.20(a), except that the SEA shall apply the

hold-harmless provision described in Sec. 200.25(a).

(c) Exceptions. (1) Eligible LEAs in ineligible counties.

(i) An SEA may reserve not more than two percent of the amount of

concentration grant funds it receives to make direct allocations to

eligible LEAs that are located in counties that do not receive a

concentration grant allocation.

(ii) If an SEA plans to reserve concentration grant funds under

paragraph (c)(1)(i) of this section, the SEA, before allocating any

concentration grant funds under paragraph (b) of this section, shall--

(A) Determine which LEAs located in ineligible counties are

eligible to receive concentration grant funds;

(B) Determine the appropriate amount to be reserved;

(C) Proportionately reduce the amount available for concentration

grants for eligible counties or LEAs to provide the reserved amount,

except that for school year 1996-97 an SEA may not reduce an LEA's

allocation below the hold-harmless amount determined under

Sec. 200.25(a);

(D) Rank order the LEAs eligible for concentration grant funds that

are located in ineligible counties according to the number or

percentage of children counted under Sec. 200.21;

(E) Select in rank order, those LEAs that the SEA plans to provide

concentration grant funds; and

(F) Distribute the reserved funds among the selected LEAs based on

the number of children counted under Sec. 200.21.

(2) Eligible counties with no eligible LEAs. In a county in which

no LEA meets the eligibility criteria in paragraph (a) of this section,

an SEA shall--

(i) Identify those LEAs in which either the number or percentage of

children counted under Sec. 200.21 exceeds the average number or

percentage of those children in the county; and

(ii) Allocate concentration grant funds for the county among the

LEAs identified in paragraph (c)(2)(i) of this section based on the

number of children counted under Sec. 200.21 in each LEA compared to

the number of those children in all those LEAs.

(3) States receiving minimum allocations. In a State that receives

a minimum concentration grant under section 1124A(d) of the Act, the

SEA shall--

(i) Allocate concentration grant funds among LEAs in the State

under paragraphs (a), (b), and (c)(1) and (2) of this section; or

(ii) Without regard to the counties in which the LEAs are located-

(A) Identify those LEAs in which either the number or percentage of

children counted under Sec. 200.21 exceeds the average number or

percentage of those children in the State; and

(B) Allocate concentration grant funds among the LEAs identified in

paragraph (c)(3)(ii)(A) of this section based on the number of children

counted under Sec. 200.21 in each LEA.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6334)

Sec. 200.24 Allocation of targeted grants.

(a) Eligibility. An LEA is eligible for a targeted grant if--

(1) There are at least 10 children counted under Sec. 200.21 in the

LEA; and

(2) The number of those children is at least five percent of the

LEA's total population ages 5 to 17 years, inclusive.

(b) Weighted child count. In determining an LEA's grant, the SEA

shall compute a weighted child count in accordance with section 1125(c)

of the Act by taking the larger of--

(1) Percent-weighted child count. The number of children counted

under Sec. 200.21 multiplied by the weights shown in the following

table, with the weights applied in a step-wise manner so that only

those children above each weighting threshold receive the higher

weight:

[[Page 34810]]

------------------------------------------------------------------------

LEA percentage of children counted under Sec. 200.21 as a

percent of total children ages 5 through 17 Weights

------------------------------------------------------------------------

0 to 14.265%................................................. 1.00

More than 14.265% up to 21.553%.............................. 1.75

More than 21.553% up to 29.223%.............................. 2.50

More than 29.223% up to 36.538%.............................. 3.25

More than 36.538%............................................ 4.00

------------------------------------------------------------------------

or;

(2) Number-weighted child count. The number of children counted

under Sec. 200.21 multiplied by the weights shown in the following

table, with the weights applied in a step-wise manner so that only

those children above each weighting threshold receive the higher

weight:

------------------------------------------------------------------------

LEA number of children counted under Sec. 200.21 Weights

------------------------------------------------------------------------

1 to 575..................................................... 1.0

576 to 1,870................................................. 1.5

1,871 to 6,910............................................... 2.0

6,911 to 42,000.............................................. 2.5

42,001 or more............................................... 3.0

------------------------------------------------------------------------

(c) Amount of LEA grant. An SEA shall allocate targeted grant funds

to eligible LEAs as provided in Sec. 200.20 based on the weighted child

count determined in paragraph (b) of this section, except that the SEA

shall apply the hold-harmless provisions described in Sec. 200.25.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6335)

Sec. 200.25 Applicable hold-harmless provisions.

(a) General. (1) An SEA may not reduce the allocation of an

eligible LEA below the hold-harmless amounts established under section

1122(c) of the Act.

(2) The hold-harmless protection limits the maximum reduction in an

LEA's allocation when compared to the LEA's allocation for the

preceding year.

(3) The hold-harmless shall be applied separately for basic grants,

concentration grants, and targeted grants, and shall be applied for

each grant formula only in those years authorized under section 1122(c)

of the Act, as shown in the table contained in paragraph (a)(4) of this

section.

(4) Under section 1122(c) of the Act, the hold-harmless percentage

varies based on the year and, for school years 1997-98 and beyond,

based on the LEA's number of children counted under Sec. 200.21 as a

percentage of the total number of children ages 5-17, inclusive, in the

LEA, as shown in the following table:

------------------------------------------------------------------------

LEA's Sec.

200.21 children Hold-

School year as a percentage harmless Applicable grant

of children ages percentage formulas

5-17, inclusive

------------------------------------------------------------------------

1995-96.......... Not applicable... 85 Basic Grants.

1996-97.......... Not applicable... 100 Basic Grants and

Concentration Grants.

1997-98 and 30% or more...... 95 Basic Grants and

beyond. Targeted Grants.

15% or more and 90

less than 30%.

Less than 15%.... 85

------------------------------------------------------------------------

(5) For school year 1995-96, the SEA shall compute each LEA's hold-

harmless amount without regard to the amount the LEA received for

delinquent children counted under section 1005 of Chapter 1 of Title I

of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965 as in effect on

September 30, 1994.

(b) Adjustment for insufficient funds. (1) School year 1995-96. If

the Secretary's allocation for a county is not sufficient to give an

LEA 85 percent of the amount it received for school year 1994-95,

without regard to the amount the LEA received for delinquent children,

the SEA may use funds received under Part D, subpart 2 (local agency

programs) of the Act to bring such LEA up to its hold-harmless amount.

(2) School years 1997-98 and beyond. If the Secretary's allocation

for a county is not sufficient to meet the LEA hold-harmless

requirements of paragraph (a) of this section, the SEA shall reallocate

funds proportionately from all other LEAs in the State that are

receiving funds in excess of the hold-harmless amounts specified in

paragraph (a) of this section.

(c) Eligibility for hold-harmless protection. An LEA must be

eligible for basic grant, concentration grant, and targeted grant funds

in order for the respective provisions in paragraphs (a) and (b) of

this section to apply.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6332(c))

Sec. 200.26 [Reserved]

Procedures for the Within-District Allocation of LEA Program Funds

Sec. 200.27 Reservation of funds by an LEA.

Before allocating funds in accordance with Sec. 200.28, an LEA

shall reserve funds as are reasonable and necessary to--

(a) Provide services comparable to those provided to children in

participating school attendance areas and schools to serve--

(1) Children in local institutions for neglected children; and

(2) Where appropriate--

(i) Eligible homeless children who do not attend participating

schools, including providing educationally related support services to

children in shelters;

(ii) Children in local institutions for delinquent children; and

(iii) Neglected and delinquent children in community-day school

programs;

(b) Meet the requirements for parental involvement in section

1118(a)(3) of the Act;

(c) Administer programs for public and private school children

under this part, including special capital expenses not paid for from

funds provided under Sec. 200.16 that are incurred as a result of

implementing alternative delivery systems to comply with the

requirements of Aguilar v. Felton; and

(d) Conduct other authorized activities such as professional

development, school improvement, and coordinated services.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6313(c)(3), 6317(c), 6319(a)(3), 6320)

Sec. 200.28 Allocation of funds to school attendance areas and

schools.

(a)(1) An LEA shall allocate funds under this subpart to school

attendance areas or schools, identified as eligible and selected to

participate under section 1113(a) or (b) of the Act, in rank order

[[Page 34811]]

on the basis of the total number of children from low-income families

in each area or school.

(2)(i) In calculating the total number of children from low-income

families, the LEA shall include children from low-income families who

attend private schools, using--

(A) The same poverty data, if available, as the LEA uses to count

public school children; or

(B) If the same data are not available, comparable data--

(1) Collected through alternative means such as a survey; or

(2) From existing sources such as AFDC or tuition scholarship

programs.

(ii) If complete actual poverty data are not available on private

school children, an LEA may extrapolate from actual data on a

representative sample of private school children the number of children

from low-income families who attend private schools.

(iii) For the 1995-96 school year only, if adequate data on the

number of private school children from low-income families are not

available under paragraph (a)(2) (i) or (ii) of this section, the LEA

shall derive the number of private school children from low-income

families by applying the poverty percentage of each participating

public school attendance area to the number of private school children

who reside in that area.

(3) If an LEA ranks its school attendance areas or schools below 75

percent poverty by grade span groupings, the LEA may determine the

percentage of children from low-income families in the LEA as a whole

for each grade span grouping.

(b)(1) Except as provided in paragraphs (b)(2) and (d) of this

section, an LEA shall allocate to each participating school attendance

area or school an amount for each low-income child that is at least 125

percent of the per-pupil amount of funds the LEA received for that year

under subpart 2 of Part A of Title I. The LEA shall calculate this per-

pupil amount before the LEA reserves any funds under Sec. 200.27, using

the poverty measure selected by the LEA under section 1113(a)(5) of the

Act.

(2) If an LEA is serving only school attendance areas or schools in

which the percentage of children from low-income families is 35 percent

or more, the LEA is not required to allocate a per-pupil amount of at

least 125 percent.

(c) An LEA is not required to allocate the same per-pupil amount to

each participating school attendance area or school provided the LEA

allocates higher per-pupil amounts to areas or schools with higher

concentrations of poverty than to areas or schools with lower

concentrations of poverty.

(d) An LEA may reduce the amount of funds allocated under this

section to a school attendance area or school if the area or school is

spending supplemental State or local funds for programs that meet the

requirements in Sec. 200.62(c).

(e) If an LEA contains two or more counties in their entirety, the

LEA shall distribute to schools within each county a share of the LEA's

total grant that is no less than the county's share of the child count

used to calculate the LEA's grant.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6313(c), 6333(c)(2))

Sec. 200.29 [Reserved]

Subpart B--Even Start Family Literacy Program

Sec. 200.30 Migrant Education Even Start Program Definition.

Eligible participants under the Migrant Education Even Start

Program (MEES) are those who meet the definitions of a migratory child,

a migratory agricultural worker or a migratory fisher in Sec. 200.40.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6362, 6511)

Secs. 200.31--200.39 [Reserved]

Subpart C--Migrant Education Program

Sec. 200.40 Program definitions.

The following definitions apply to programs and projects operated

under this subpart:

(a) Agricultural activity means--

(1) Any activity directly related to the production or processing

of crops, dairy products, poultry or livestock for initial commercial

sale or personal subsistence;

(2) Any activity directly related to the cultivation or harvesting

of trees; or

(3) Any activity directly related to fish farms.

(b) Fishing activity means any activity directly related to the

catching or processing of fish or shellfish for initial commercial sale

or personal subsistence.

(c) Migratory agricultural worker means a person who, in the

preceding 36 months, has moved from one school district to another, or

from one administrative area to another within a State that is

comprised of a single school district, in order to obtain temporary or

seasonal employment in agricultural activities (including dairy work)

as a principal means of livelihood.

(d) Migratory child means a child who is, or whose parent, spouse,

or guardian is, a migratory agricultural worker, including a migratory

dairy worker, or a migratory fisher, and who, in the preceding 36

months, in order to obtain, or accompany such parent, spouse, guardian

in order to obtain, temporary or seasonal employment in agricultural or

fishing work--

(1) Has moved from one school district to another;

(2) In a State that is comprised of a single school district, has

moved from one administrative area to another within such district; or

(3) Resides in a school district of more than 15,000 square miles,

and migrates a distance of 20 miles or more to a temporary residence to

engage in a fishing activity.

(e) Migratory fisher means a person who, in the preceding 36

months, has moved from one school district to another, or from one

administrative area to another within a State that is comprised of a

single school district, in order to obtain temporary or seasonal

employment in fishing activities as a principal means of livelihood.

This definition also includes a person who, in the preceding 36 months,

resided in a school district of more than 15,000 square miles, and

moved a distance of 20 miles or more to a temporary residence to engage

in a fishing activity as a principal means of livelihood.

(f) Principal means of livelihood means that temporary or seasonal

agricultural or fishing activity plays an important part in providing a

living for the worker and his or her family.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6391-6399, 6511)

Sec. 200.41 Use of program funds for unique program function costs.

An SEA may use the funds available from its State Migrant Education

Program to carry out other administrative activities, beyond those

allowable under Sec. 200.61, that are unique to the MEP, including

those that are the same or similar to those performed by LEAs in the

State under subpart A. These activities include but are not limited

to--

(a) Statewide identification and recruitment of eligible migratory

children;

(b) Interstate and intrastate coordination of the State MEP and its

local projects with other relevant programs and local projects in the

State and in other States;

(c) Procedures for providing for educational continuity for

migratory children through the timely transfer of educational and

health records, beyond that required generally by State and local

agencies.

[[Page 34812]]

(d) Collecting and using information for accurate distribution of

subgrant funds; and

(e) Development and implementation of a statewide plan for needs

assessment and service delivery.

(f) Supervision of instructional and support staff.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6392, 6511)

Sec. 200.42 Responsibilities of SEAs and operating agencies for

assessing the effectiveness of the MEP.

(a) Each SEA and operating agency receiving funds under the MEP has

the responsibility to determine the effectiveness of its program and

projects in providing migratory students with the opportunity to meet

the same challenging State content and performance standards, required

under Sec. 200.2, that the State has established for all children.

(b) To determine the effectiveness of its program and projects,

each SEA and operating agency receiving MEP funds shall, wherever

feasible, use the same high-quality yearly student assessments or

transitional assessments that the State establishes for use in meeting

the requirements of Sec. 200.4.

(c) In a project where it is not feasible to use the same student

assessments that are being used to meet the requirements of Sec. 200.4

(e.g., in a summer-only project, or in a project where no migratory

students are enrolled at the time the State-established assessment

takes place), the SEA must ensure that the relevant operating agency

carries out some other reasonable process or processes for examining

the effectiveness of the project.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6394)

Sec. 200.43 Responsibilities of SEAs and operating agencies for

improving services to migratory children.

While the specific school improvement requirements of section 1116

of the statute do not apply to the MEP, SEAs and local operating

agencies receiving MEP funds shall use the results of the assessments

carried out under Sec. 200.42 to improve the services provided to

migratory children.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6394)

Sec. 200.44 Use of MEP funds in schoolwide projects.

Funds available under Part C of Title I of the Act may be used in a

schoolwide program subject to the requirements of

Sec. 200.8(c)(3)(ii)(B)(1).

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6396)

Sec. 200.45 Responsibilities for participation of children in private

schools.

An SEA and its operating agencies shall conduct programs and

projects under this subpart in a manner consistent with the basic

requirements of section 1120 of the Act.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6394)

Secs. 200.46-200.49 [Reserved]

Subpart D--Prevention and Intervention Programs for Children and

Youth Who Are Neglected, Delinquent, or At-Risk of Dropping Out

Sec. 200.50 Program definitions.

(a) The following definitions apply to the programs authorized in

Part D, subparts 1 and 2 of Title I of the Act:

Children and Youth means the same as ``children'' as that term is

defined in Sec. 200.65(a).

(b) The following definitions apply to the programs authorized in

Part D, subpart 1 of Title I of the Act:

Institution for delinquent children and youth means, as determined

by the SEA, a public or private residential facility that is operated

primarily for the care of children and youth who--

(1) Have been adjudicated to be delinquent or in need of

supervision; and

(2) Have had an average length of stay in the institution of at

least 30 days.

Institution for neglected children and youth means, as determined

by the SEA, a public or private residential facility, other than a

foster home, that is operated primarily for the care of children and

youth who--

(1) Have been committed to the institution or voluntarily placed in

the institution under applicable State law due to abandonment, neglect,

or death of their parents or guardians; and

(2) Have had an average length of stay in the institution of at

least 30 days.

Regular program of instruction means an educational program (not

beyond grade 12) in an institution or a community day program for

neglected or delinquent children that consists of classroom instruction

in basic school subjects such as reading, mathematics, and vocationally

oriented subjects, and that is supported by non-Federal funds. Neither

the manufacture of goods within the institution nor activities related

to institutional maintenance are considered classroom instruction.

(c) The following definitions apply to the local agency program

authorized in Part D, subpart 2 of Title I of the Act:

Immigrant children and youth and Limited English Proficiency have

the same meanings as those terms are defined in section 7501 of the

Act, except that the terms ``individual'' and ``children and youth''

used in those definitions mean ``children and youth'' as defined in

this section.

Locally operated correctional facility means a facility in which

persons are confined as a result of a conviction for a criminal

offense, including persons under 21 years of age. The term also

includes a local public or private institution and community day

program or school not operated by the State that serves delinquent

children and youth.

Migrant youth means the same as ``migratory child'' as that term is

defined in Sec. 200.40(d).

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6432, 6472)

Sec. 200.51 SEA counts of eligible children.

To receive an allocation under Part D, subpart 1 of Title I of the

Act, an SEA must provide the Secretary with a count of children and

youth under the age of 21 enrolled in a regular program of instruction

operated or supported by State agencies in institutions or community

day programs for neglected or delinquent children and youth and adult

correctional institutions as specified in paragraphs (a) and (b) of

this section:

(a) Enrollment. (1) To be counted, a child or youth must be

enrolled in a regular program of instruction for at least--

(i) 20 hours per week if in an institution or community day program

for neglected or delinquent children; or

(ii) 15 hours per week if in an adult correctional institution.

(2) The State agency shall specify the date on which the enrollment

of neglected or delinquent children is determined under paragraph

(a)(1) of this section, except that the date specified shall be--

(i) Consistent for all institutions or community day programs

operated by the State agency; and

(ii) Represent a school day in the calendar year preceding the year

in which funds become available.

(b) Adjustment of enrollment. The SEA shall adjust the enrollment

for each institution or community day program served by a State agency

by--

(1) Multiplying the number determined in paragraph (a) of this

section by the number of days per year the regular program of

instruction operates; and

(2) Dividing the result of paragraph (b)(1) of this section by 180.

(c) Date of submission. The SEA must annually submit the data in

paragraph (b) of this section no later than January 31.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6432)

[[Page 34813]]

Secs. 200.52-200.59 [Reserved]

Subpart E--General Provisions

Sec. 200.60 Reservation of funds for State administration and school

improvement.

(a) State administration. An SEA may reserve for State

administration activities authorized in section 1603 of the Act no more

than--

(1) One percent from each of the amounts allocated to the State or

Outlying Area under section 1002(a), (c), and (d) of the Act; or

(2)(i) $400,000 ($50,000 for the Outlying Areas), whichever is

greater.

(ii) An SEA reserving $400,000 under paragraph (a)(2)(i) of this

section shall reserve proportionate amounts from each of the amounts

allocated to the State or Outlying Area under section 1002(a), (c), and

(d) of the Act.

(b) School improvement. (1) To carry out school improvement

activities authorized under sections 1116 and 1117 of the Act, an SEA

may reserve no more than .5 percent from each of the amounts allocated

to the State or Outlying Area under section 1002(a), (c), and (d) of

the Act.

(2)(i) An SEA shall have available from funds received under

section 1002(f) of the Act or reserved under paragraph (b)(1) of this

section no less than $200,000 ($25,000 for the Outlying Areas) to carry

out school improvement activities.

(ii)(A) If funds made available for school improvement under

section 1002(f) of the Act do not equal $200,000 ($25,000 for Outlying

Areas), the SEA shall reserve funds in accordance with paragraph (b)(1)

of this section.

(B) If the amount reserved under paragraph (b)(1) when added to

funds received under section 1002(f), does not equal $200,000 ($25,000

for the Outlying Areas), the SEA shall reserve additional funds under

section 1002(a), (c), and (d) as are necessary to make $200,000

($25,000 for the Outlying Areas) available to the SEA.

(c) Reservation from section 1002(a) funds. In reserving funds for

State administration and school improvement under section 1002(a) of

the Act, an SEA shall--

(1) Reserve proportionate amounts from each of the State's basic

grant, concentration grant, and targeted grant allocations; and

(2) Ensure that from the funds remaining for basic grants,

concentration grants, and targeted grants after reserving funds for

State administration and school improvement, no eligible LEA receives

less than the hold-harmless amounts determined under Sec. 200.25,

except when the amounts remaining are insufficient to pay all LEAs the

hold-harmless amounts provided in Sec. 200.25, the SEA shall ratably

reduce each LEA's hold harmless allocation to the amount available.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6303, 6513(c))

Sec. 200.61 Use of funds reserved for State administration.

An SEA may use any of the funds that it has reserved under

Sec. 200.60(a) to perform general administrative activities necessary

to carry out, at the State level, any of the programs authorized under

Title I of the Act.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6513(c))

Sec. 200.62 [Reserved]

Sec. 200.63 Supplement, not supplant.

(a) Except as provided in paragraph (c) of this section, a grantee

or subgrantee under subparts A, C, or D of this part may use funds

available under these subparts only to supplement the amount of funds

that would be made available, in the absence of funds made available

under subparts A, C, and D from non-Federal sources for the education

of pupils participating in programs assisted under subparts A, C, and D

and in no case may funds available under these subparts be used to

supplant those non-Federal funds.

(b) To meet the requirement in paragraph (a) of this section, a

grantee or subgrantee under subparts A, C, or D is not required to

provide services under subparts A, C, or D through the use of a

particular instructional method or in a particular instructional

setting.

(c)(1) For purposes of determining compliance with paragraph (a) of

this section, a grantee or subgrantee under subparts A or C may exclude

supplemental State and local funds spent in any eligible school

attendance area or eligible school for programs that meet the

requirements of section 1114 or section 1115 of the Act.

(2) A supplemental State or local program will be considered to

meet the requirements of section 1114 if the program--

(i) Is implemented in a school that meets the schoolwide poverty

threshold for eligibility in Sec. 200.8(b);

(ii) Is designed to upgrade the entire educational program in the

school to support students in their achievement toward meeting the

State's challenging student performance standards;

(iii) Is designed to meet the educational needs of all children in

the school, particularly the needs of children who are failing, or most

at risk of failing, to meet the State's challenging student performance

standards; and

(iv) Uses the State's system of assessment to review the

effectiveness of the program.

(3) A supplemental State or local program will be considered to

meet the requirements of section 1115 if the program--

(i) Serves only children who are failing, or most at risk of

failing, to meet the State's challenging student performance standards;

(ii) Provides supplementary services designed to meet the special

educational needs of the children who are participating to support

their achievement toward meeting the State's student performance

standards that all children are expected to meet; and

(iii) Uses the State's system of assessment to review the

effectiveness of the program.

(4) These conditions also apply to supplemental State and local

funds expended under sections 1113(b)(1)(C) and 1113(c)(2)(B) of the

Act.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6322(b))

Sec. 200.64 Maintenance of effort.

(a) General. An LEA receiving funds under subparts A or C may

receive its full allocation of funds under subparts A and C if it finds

that either the combined fiscal effort per student or the aggregate

expenditures of State and local funds with respect to the provision of

free public education in the LEA for the preceding fiscal year was not

less than 90 percent of combined fiscal effort per student or the

aggregate expenditures for the second preceding fiscal year.

(b) Meaning of ``preceding fiscal year''. For purposes of

determining maintenance of effort, the ``preceding fiscal year'' is the

Federal fiscal year or the 12-month fiscal period most commonly used in

a State for official reporting purposes prior to the beginning of the

Federal fiscal year in which funds are available.

Example: For funds first made available on July 1, 1995, if a

State is using the Federal fiscal year, the ``preceding fiscal

year'' is Federal fiscal year 1994 (which began on October 1, 1993)

and the ``second preceding fiscal year'' is Federal fiscal year 1993

(which began on October 1, 1992). If a State is using a fiscal year

that begins on July 1, 1995, the ``preceding fiscal year'' is the

12-month period ending on June 30, 1994, and the ``second preceding

fiscal year, is the period ending on June 30, 1993.

(c) Expenditures. (1) To be considered. In determining an LEA's

compliance with the maintenance of effort requirement, the SEA shall

consider the LEA's expenditures from State and local funds for free

public education. These include expenditures

[[Page 34814]]

for administration, instruction, attendance and health services, pupil

transportation services, operation and maintenance of plant, fixed

charges, and net expenditures to cover deficits for food services and

student body activities.

(2) Not to be considered. The SEA shall not consider the following

expenditures in determining an LEA's compliance with the maintenance of

effort requirement:

(i) Any expenditures for community services, capital outlay, and

debt service; and

(ii) Any expenditures made from funds provided by the Federal

Government for which the LEA is required to account to the Federal

Government directly or through the SEA.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6322(a))

Sec. 200.65 Definitions.

The following definitions apply to programs and projects operated

under this part:

(a) Children means--

(1) Persons up through age 21 who are entitled to a free public

education through grade 12; and

(2) Preschool children.

(b) Fiscal year means the Federal fiscal year--a period beginning

on October 1 and ending on the following September 30--or another 12-

month period normally used by the SEA for record-keeping.

(c) Preschool children means children who are--

(1) Below the age and grade level at which the agency provides free

public education; and

(2) Of an age at which they can benefit from an organized

instructional program provided in a school or educational setting.

(Authority: 20 U.S.C. 6315, 6511)

Secs. 200.66-200.69 [Reserved]

Appendix--Analysis of Comments and Changes

(Note: This appendix will not be codified in the Code of Federal

Regulations)

TITLE I--HELPING DISADVANTAGED CHILDREN MEET HIGH STANDARDS

Subpart A--Improving Basic Programs Operated by Local Educational

Agencies

Standards, Assessment, and Accountability

Section 200.1 Contents of a State Plan

Comment: One commenter suggested that the regulations include the

assurances or a reference to the assurances required by section 1111(c)

of Title I to be included in a State plan.

Discussion: The assurances in section 1111(c) relate to the

additional responsibilities of States to support teaching and learning.

The Department mailed to all States guidance for the development of a

Title I State plan and for consolidated applications that include Title

I. There is no need also to reference the assurances in the

regulations.

Changes: None.

Comment: A number of commenters commented on the requirement in

Sec. 200.1(b)(2)(iii) of the regulations to identify the languages

other than English for which yearly student assessments are needed but

not available, and then develop assessments for all those languages

according to a timetable established in the State plan. Several

commenters contended that this requirement is unreasonable because it

would be very expensive and time consuming. Moreover, in some cases,

the assessment would apply only to a few students and might not meet

the same standards of validity and reliability established for other

assessments. Several commenters suggested that the development of these

assessments in languages other than English be required only ``to the

extent practicable,'' tied to a minimum percentage of students that

speak a certain language in a State, or only be required when

instruction is actually given in that language. One commenter suggested

that the requirement to develop a timetable for progress towards the

development of these assessments is unreasonable because of the large

number of languages spoken in a State. Another commenter suggested that

a survey rather than a binding regulation be used to identify languages

other than English that are spoken by Title I participating students.

On the other hand, several commenters supported this requirement.

One commenter emphasized that States have a special obligation with

regard to assessing limited-English proficient (LEP) students and must

make every effort to develop assessments in languages that will yield

accurate information. Another commenter suggested that more specific

reporting requirements be included for identifying spoken languages and

developing assessments. One commenter suggested that the regulations

provide guidelines for inclusion of LEP students in State assessments

and another commenter suggested that the regulations address access to

assistance from the Department's Office of Bilingual Education and

Minority Languages Affairs.

Discussion: Section 1111(b)(3)(F)(iii) of Title I requires that

each State's assessments provide for the inclusion of LEP students who

shall be assessed, to the extent practicable, in the language and form

most likely to yield accurate and reliable information on what such

students know and can do to determine such students' mastery of skills

in subjects other than English. Also, section 1111(b)(5) of Title I

requires that each State plan identify the languages other than English

that are present in the participating student population and indicate

the languages for which yearly student assessments are not available

and are needed.

Section 200.1(b)(2)(iii)(B) of the regulations requires each State

plan to include a timetable for progress towards the development of

these assessments to ensure that States match their needs for LEP

assessments to a workable timetable that, over time, would improve

participation of LEP students in high-quality, yearly assessments. The

Secretary recognizes that there are many problems that must be

addressed in the process, including issues involving time, expense, and

usefulness of such assessments. To help address these issues, the

Department's Office of Bilingual Education and Minority Languages

Affairs and Office of Elementary and Secondary Education are developing

nonregulatory guidance on options that States might consider in

determining their own policy regarding the development of assessments

in other languages and criteria for inclusion of LEP students.

Changes: None.

Comment: Two commenters suggested that Title I State plans include

evidence that States used recognized professional and technical

knowledge to develop challenging content standards and performance

standards that may serve as benchmarks for student performance and as a

means of issuing rewards and sanctions for schools and districts.

Another commenter recommended that performance standards in Title I

schools be comparable to those established for schools that serve

middle- and upper-income families.

Discussion: Section 1111(b)(1)(D)(i) of Title I and

Sec. 200.2(a)(2)(i) of the regulations require States to demonstrate in

their plan that they have established, or will establish, challenging

content standards in academic subjects that specify what all children

are expected to know and be able to do, contain coherent and rigorous

content, and encourage the teaching of advanced skills to all

[[Page 34815]]

children. In addition, section 1111(b)(1)(D)(ii) of Title I and

Sec. 200.2(a)(2)(ii) of the regulations require States to establish

challenging student performance standards that are aligned with the

State's content standards and that include two levels of high

performance and a third level of partial proficiency against which the

progress of students and schools can be measured. Also,

Sec. 200.1(b)(1)(i)(B) of the regulations requires that a State plan

include evidence that the State's procedure for setting student

performance levels applies recognized professional and technical

knowledge. Finally, provisions in sections 1116 and 1117 of Title I

focus on recognized professional and technical knowledge as a basis for

State systems for rewarding school districts and holding them

accountable for progress. The Secretary believes these provisions

adequately address the concerns of the commenters.

Changes: None.

Comment: Several commenters suggested that Sec. 200.1(b)(2)(ii)(B)

of the regulations, which requires the State plan to describe the

transitional set of yearly statewide assessments the State will use to

assess students' performance in mastering complex skills and

challenging subject matter, be replaced with the statutory language in

section 1111(b)(7) of Title I that, in the commenters' opinion, makes

transitional assessments an option for States instead of a requirement.

Two commenters expressed concerns that, because the regulatory

provision only requires States to describe transitional assessments, it

sends the message that States need not go through the approval process.

Discussion: Section 1111(b)(7) of Title I states that, if a State

does not have final assessments that fully meet the statutory

requirements, ``the State may propose to use a transitional set of

yearly statewide assessments that will assess the performance of

complex skills and challenging subject matter.'' The Secretary does not

believe that use of the word ``may'' in this context means that

transitional assessments are optional. Rather, the Secretary believes

that the word ``may'' permits the use of transitional assessments while

final assessments are being developed, rather than requiring final

assessments immediately. Moreover, because transitional assessments are

part of the State plan, they are subject to peer review and approval

under section 1111(d) of Title I.

Changes: None.

Section 200.2 State Responsibilities for Developing Challenging

Standards

Comment: One commenter suggested that the regulations and guidance

need to clarify that a State may adopt or approve locally developed

standards and assessments under the Goals 2000 process or another State

process for use in the Title I program. Another commenter recommended

that the Department clarify whether State standards and assessments

must be uniform throughout the State for Title I accountability

purposes. This commenter suggested that past experience with LEAs

establishing high school graduation standards resulted in high-level

proficiencies for affluent communities and low-level proficiencies for

poor communities.

Discussion: Section 1111(b)(1)(B) of Title I and Secs. 200.2(b) and

200.4(c) of the regulations make clear that, if a State has State

content standards or State student performance standards and an aligned

set of assessments for all students developed under Title III of the

Goals 2000: Educate America Act or another process, the State must use

those standards and assessments, modified, if necessary, to conform

with the requirements of section 1111 of Title I, to carry out Part A.

Guidance for Goals 2000 requires that participating States develop or

adopt challenging content and performance standards. It does not

require that there be a single set of content or performance standards

that are applied uniformly to every LEA within the State. A State may

choose to develop or adopt model standards or criteria against which

locally developed standards would be measured and approved.

Changes: None.

Section 200.3 Requirements for Adequate Progress

Comment: One commenter suggested that the phrase ``except as

provided in paragraph (c) of this section'' should be deleted from

Sec. 200.3(a) of the regulations, suggesting that it appears to require

States to develop two different definitions of adequate yearly

progress. The commenter argued that, while Congress intended for States

to use different measures in transitional and final assessment periods

to determine adequate yearly progress, Congress also intended that

States develop one standard for determining adequate yearly progress

regardless of the assessment period.

Discussion: The Secretary believes that Sec. 200.3 (a) and (c) of

the regulations accurately reflect the statute and is necessary to give

each State the flexibility to develop and refine, over the next five

years, its own approach for establishing high-quality assessments that

will effectively assess learning. The definition of adequate yearly

progress must be flexible to accommodate changes in State approaches to

assessment. It does not make sense to require one standard for

determining adequate progress when assessments used to measure that

progress may be different during the transition period. The Secretary,

however, does not expect States to establish lower expectations during

the transitional period.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that references to adequate yearly

progress in different regulatory sections are repetitive and could be

confusing.

Discussion: State and local accountability for helping Title I

children meet high standards is a central theme in the Title I statute.

Adequate yearly progress plays a pivotal role in measuring

accountability and it is part of several different statutory sections.

The regulations clarify these statutory provisions, first with regard

to the State plan and then in subsequent sections devoted to

implementation. The Secretary believes that adequate yearly progress

needs emphasis in the regulations to help maintain an overall focus on

enabling children in Title I programs to meet the same high standards

expected of all children.

Changes: None.

Comment: Two commenters argued that repetition of the statute

regarding adequate yearly progress without additional explanation

provides insufficient guidance to grantees.

Discussion: Section 200.3(b)(2) of the regulations provides that a

State's determination of adequate yearly progress must be sufficiently

rigorous to achieve the goal of helping all children served under Part

A, particularly economically disadvantaged and LEP children, meet the

State's proficient and advanced levels of performance within an

appropriate timeframe. Each State has the flexibility to develop its

own definition within its framework for standards and assessments.

Standards and assessments will differ from State to State, along with

definitions of adequate progress for each State's schools and LEAs.

Some models and examples will be provided through policy guidance.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that adequate yearly progress be

based on empirical data on or knowledge about growth in academic

performance of schools and LEAs in the State in order to prevent States

from arbitrarily using a benchmark.

[[Page 34816]]

Discussion: Section 200.3(b)(3) of the regulations requires that

adequate yearly progress be defined in a manner that links progress

primarily to performance on the State's assessment system under

Sec. 200.4, while permitting progress to be established in part through

the use of other measures, such as dropout, retention, and attendance

rates. The Secretary expects that a State, in developing its definition

of adequate progress, would draw on knowledge and empirical data about

the degree of progress that should be expected of effective schools.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that the regulations require SEAs

and LEAs to make every effort to notify private schools about the SEA's

definition of adequate yearly progress.

Discussion: The definition of adequate yearly progress that an SEA

establishes will be the standard against which schools and LEAs will be

measured as to whether they are enabling children to meet the State's

challenging student performance standards. While private schools are

not recipients of Title I funds, the Department will issue policy

guidance that will, for the purpose of private school student Title I

participants, address whether private school students served by Title

I, but not private schools, are making adequate yearly progress toward

meeting the standards.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter expressed concern regarding the statement in

the preamble of the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM) that the new

Title I will shift from ``an evaluation of how individual students are

performing to an evaluation of how well schools and LEAs are helping

students meet the challenging standards'' since States will be

assessing changes in the performance of different cohorts of students.

The commenter argued that changes in test scores are likely to reflect

differences in the groups of students instead of changes in school or

LEA performance, particularly in poor urban districts with high rates

of student mobility.

Discussion: The impact of the Title I program cannot be divorced

from that of the regular program. This is particularly true as an

increasing number of Title I schools develop schoolwide programs.

Although the assessment systems operated by States and LEAs generally

test only some grades, the Secretary believes that they will provide

more revealing data than the current Chapter 1 testing system on the

success of Title I schools and children served by Title I because they

will be tied to high standards and will show how Title I schools are

doing compared to other schools in the district and State. In addition,

Chapter assessments, which used gains of individual students, rather

than a specified level of expected achievement, often resulted in

minimal expectations of gains being set for Chapter 1 children. While

the children improved, they were still performing far below a level

needed for successful completion of school and employment. Classroom

teachers will continue--as they do now--to assess individual children

to determine their performance and improvement on an ongoing basis.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter requested that the regulations allow a State

to define adequate progress in terms of progress made over either a

one- or two-year period for the purpose of meeting the requirements of

Title I accountability.

Discussion: States have the discretion to define adequate yearly

progress over a one- or two-year period as long as the definition is

sufficiently rigorous to achieve the goal that all children served

under Part A, particularly economically disadvantaged and LEP children,

meet the State's proficient and advanced levels of performance within

an appropriate timeframe.

Changes: None.

Section 200.4 State Responsibilities for Assessment

Comment: One commenter suggested that the regulations inform SEAs

and LEAs of their responsibilities regarding the assessment of

participating private school children and specify that the expenses of

conducting the assessment are allowable costs under Title I.

Discussion: The assessment requirements in the statute apply to

private school students as well as public school students who

participate in Title I. The Department will clarify in guidance that

Title I funds may be used to assess private school children if they

would not otherwise be participating in the State assessment. However,

if private school children, in general, are included in the State

assessment, Title I funds may not be used to pay for the assessment of

those private school children participating in Title I.

Changes: None.

Comment: Many comments were received regarding the issue on which

the Secretary specifically invited comments in the NPRM: whether

accountability under Title I should be based on all subject areas for

which a State has developed or adopted standards and assessments for

all children or whether assessments in mathematics and reading/language

arts are sufficient for Title I accountability purposes as permitted in

Sec. 200.4(c)(1) of the regulations. Many commenters agreed with the

regulations that accountability in math and reading/language arts was

sufficient for Title I purposes. A number of other commenters, however,

recommended that Title I schools be held accountable for all areas in

which the State has developed standards and assessments in order to

break the mold of Title I as a remedial reading and math program with

lower expectations for the children served. A handful of commenters

recommended a different resolution--that science be assessed in

addition to reading and math to reflect the importance of that subject

or that Title I accountability be based on those subject areas in which

Title I services are provided.

Discussion: This issue continues to be one of the most difficult to

resolve because each of the two major options has important advantages

but also significant drawbacks. A major goal of the reauthorization is

to redirect Title I from a low-level reading and math add-on program to

a significant resource for high-poverty Title I schools to use to

promote comprehensive schoolwide improvement in teaching and learning

geared to the same challenging standards expected of all children.

There is significant and legitimate concern that permitting Title I

accountability to be limited to reading and math will stymie the shift

toward comprehensive schoolwide reform, reinforce lower expectations

for Title I schools, and send a message that other subjects are not

important for children in high-poverty schools to learn. There is also

the concern that this provision will lead States, LEAs, and schools to

abrogate their responsibility for the performance of students served by

Part A in all other subject areas besides reading and math. Extending

Title I accountability to include all subjects in which a State has

standards and assessments, including applying Title I assessment

requirements to each of those subjects, however, also raises

significant concerns about federal overreaching and the imposition of

unwarranted and excessive burden. In addition, it risks creating

additional disincentives to developing new State standards and limits

the ability of States and LEAs to take advantage of innovations in

performance assessments since, in the short run, many of those

assessments will not be able to satisfy the Title I assessment

requirements--at least in a timely and cost-efficient way.

Needing to give effect to the statutory language that a State must

have

[[Page 34817]]

developed or adopted a set of assessments in at least mathematics and

reading/language arts while not imposing additional requirements at the

Federal level, the Secretary has retained the requirement that a State

must use assessments that measure performance in math and reading/

language arts to determine accountability under Part A. Nevertheless,

the Secretary is concerned that Title I not continue to be viewed as

solely a remedial program in math and reading. In addition, he wishes

to afford appropriate flexibility to States as they begin to implement

Goals 2000 plans. Therefore, the Secretary has revised Sec. 200.4 to

clarify that a State's assessments need not be focused solely on math

and reading/language arts. Rather, a State may meet Title I's

assessment requirements by developing or adopting assessments in other

academic subjects as long as those assessments sufficiently measure

performance in math and reading/language arts. For example, an

assessment in an academic subject such as social studies may

sufficiently measure performance in reading/language arts. Particularly

at the secondary level, the Secretary believes it may be especially

appropriate to measure performance in reading/language arts through

assessments in content areas.

The Secretary emphasizes the importance of all children attaining

high levels of performance in all core academic subjects. Limiting the

focus of Title I accountability to math and reading/language arts in no

way is intended to alter the overall responsibility of States, LEAs,

and schools for the success of all students in the core academic

subjects determined by the State. If a State has standards and

assessments for all students in subjects beyond math and reading/

language arts, the regulations do not preclude a State from including,

for accountability purposes, additional subject areas, and the

Secretary encourages them to do so.

Changes: Section 200.4(a)(1) of the regulations has been revised to

clarify that a State may satisfy the requirement to develop or adopt a

set of high-quality yearly assessments, including assessments that

measure performance in at least mathematics and reading/language arts

if the State has developed or adopted a set of high-quality yearly

student assessments in other academic subjects that measure the

performance in mathematics and reading/language arts. Likewise,

Sec. 200.4(e)(1)(i) has been revised to clarify that a State's

transitional set of yearly statewide assessments may be assessments in

academic subjects other than mathematics and reading/language arts that

measure performance in mathematics and reading/language arts.

References to these clarifications are reflected in Sec. 200.1

regarding State plan requirements and throughout Sec. 200.4 in

provisions related to the development or adoption of State assessments.

Comment: A number of commenters proposed that some or all of the

criteria applicable to the final assessments under Title I be applied

to the transitional assessments. The commenters were concerned that,

without additional transitional requirements, States would be relieved

of accountability during the entire reauthorization period. A number of

commenters recommended that the regulations require all, or at least

one, transitional assessment to be valid and reliable and consistent

with existing professional and technical standards. A number of

commenters also proposed that disaggregated data be required during the

transition period, particularly for LEP children and poor children and

for schoolwide programs. Other transitional assessment criteria that

commenters recommended include; that all students, including LEP,

minority, and poor students, be included in transitional assessments;

that transitional assessments be aligned with State standards once

these standards are developed; that LEP criteria for assessments be

provided; that there be individual student and interpretive reports;

and that parents receive the achievement information they need to be

involved in the education of their children. In addition, three

commenters supported applying all of the requirements of the final

assessments to the interim assessments, although one would be willing

to exempt specific technical requirements that need to be field tested,

while the two others would only grant narrow exceptions after careful

examination.

Discussion: Section 1111(a)(3)(7) of Title I allows States

developing final assessments to use a transitional set of yearly

statewide assessments that assesses the performance of complex skills

and challenging subject matter. The Act itself contains no other

criteria for these assessments and Sec. 200.4(e) of the regulations

only clarifies that these assessments must be at least in mathematics

and reading/language arts and be administered during the grade spans

required of the final assessments. Neither the statute nor the

legislative history supports the application of other requirements on

transitional assessments. In fact, the Secretary believes that

requiring transitional assessments to meet a host of requirements,

particularly those relating to validity, reliability, and

disaggregation, may end up frustrating Title I's longer-term goal of

promoting high-quality innovative assessments aligned with challenging

standards. Developing new, high-quality assessments that conform with

these requirements will require time--time that the transition period

is precisely designed to provide. If the same criteria are applied to

transitional assessments as to the final assessments, this purpose

would be nullified and States, in effect, may have to develop two

systems.

Title I and the regulations, however, clearly intend that all

children within the grades tested during the transition period

participate in the assessment. Moreover, section 1111(b)(7)(B) of Title

I and Sec. 200.3(c) make clear that LEAs and schools must be identified

for improvement during the transitional period based on accurate

information about the academic progress of each such local education

agency and school.

Changes: Section 200.4(e)(1)(iii) has been added to clarify that

transitional assessments must include all students in the grades

assessed.

Comment: One commenter recommended that the reliability and

validity of assessments used to evaluate Title I programs be

established and described for each specific purpose or use of the

scores. Another commenter emphasized the importance of conducting and

reporting on validation studies to ensure that accountability decisions

are not based on flawed results, and another suggested that the

Department make clear that following a particular validation process is

not required.

Discussion: Section 200.4(b)(3)(i) of the regulations requires that

each State's assessments be used for purposes for which they are valid

and reliable and to be consistent with relevant, nationally recognized

professional and technical standards for those assessments. The

Secretary believes that this provision adequately addresses the

commenters' concerns yet does not require a particular validation

process.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter expressed concern that the individual,

group, total school, and district reports required by the regulations

will be subject to error from several sources, including measurement

and sampling error: many schools will have too few students in some of

the groups for which disaggregated reporting is required to provide

reliable estimates of group performance (let alone reliable estimates

of change). The requirements also overlook that some State assessment

[[Page 34818]]

programs are designed to provide school-level rather than student-level

estimates of performance. At a minimum, the commenter recommends:

adding language in Sec. 200.4(b)(9) requiring that individual student

reports include estimates of measurement error for the scores and any

limitations of the results to permit accurate interpretation; adding

language in Sec. 200.4(b)(10) that reports of disaggregated data should

be modified when the results would be unreliable or invalid due to

inadequate numbers of students in the categories; or permitting a

school to report annual results in a three-year rolling average to

reflect that estimates from individual years contain too much error to

be interpreted in isolation.

Discussion: Section 200.5(a)(2)(iii)(C) of the regulations

clarifies that disaggregated data should be reported to the public only

when those data would be statistically sound. It is appropriate for a

State to have considerable flexibility in determining the content of

its assessment reports so long as those reports conform with the

requirements of the law.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter described some of the difficulties involved

in disaggregating data by economically disadvantaged children: the

definition is subject to various interpretations; schools currently do

not collect these data in disaggregated form; collection of such data

would be very difficult; and current USDA guidelines limit the use of

individual student eligibility free and reduced price lunch data to

USDA purposes only. Another commenter, reinforcing this position,

suggested that the regulations provide as much flexibility as possible

regarding disaggregation of data by poverty status.

Discussion: The Secretary recognizes that there are difficulties

involved in complying with this requirement. However, the need to

determine how well Title I is assisting poor children to meet

challenging standards is acute.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested deleting the phrase ``in the

grades being assessed'' from Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(i) of the regulations on

the grounds that it may cause unnecessary problems for students who are

placed in ``ungraded'' classes, or who have disabilities and are not in

the age-appropriate grade. According to the commenter, this phrase is

not necessary to clarify that students in all grades need not be

assessed and might create perverse incentives for schools wanting to

exclude students from assessments. Another commenter suggested that

Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(i) of the regulations be modified to read

``participation in the assessment of all students, including students

served under this subpart, in the grades being assessed.''

Discussion: Inclusion of the phrase ``in the grades being

assessed'' in Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(i) of the regulations is necessary to

clarify that assessments used for Title I purposes do not have to

assess all students in a school or all students served by Title I, but

only those students in the specific grades being assessed. Within the

grades being assessed, however, students being served under Title I

must be included in the assessment.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter stated that the requirement in Sec. 200.4(b)

of the regulations that the ``same assessments be used to measure the

performance of all children'' should be relaxed to permit appropriate

modifications for children with diverse learning needs. The commenter

recommended regulatory language stating that ``reasonable adaptations

may require modifications in item format, item content, test structure,

administrative procedures and time limits that result in a different

test form and/or procedure.'' The commenter would also require those

modifications to be described and the validity and reliability of those

assessments estimated and reported. Another commenter suggested that

the regulations state that all students, including those who are

limited English proficient, have a disability, or otherwise might not

always be included in State and local assessment systems, be included

under Title I assessment requirements, with appropriate modifications.

Discussion: Section 1111(b)(3)(A) of Title I and Sec. 200.4(b)(1)

of the regulations make clear that assessments used for Title I

purposes must be the same assessments used to measure the performance

of all children, if the State measures the performance of all children.

These provisions remedy the situation under Chapter 1, in which a

separate testing system was often used to assess only Chapter 1

participants. Section 200.4(b)(7)(i) of the regulations makes clear

that State assessments must provide for the participation of all

students in the grades being assessed. Section 200.4(b)(7)(ii) further

clarifies that all students includes students with diverse learning

needs. However, it also makes clear that reasonable adaptations and

accommodations must be made for students with diverse learning needs so

that the State's assessment measures the achievement of those students

relative to the State's content and performance standards. Moreover,

under Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(iii), children with limited English proficiency

must be assessed, to the extent practicable, in the language and form

most likely to yield accurate and reliable information on what those

students know and can do to determine the students' mastery of skills

in subjects other than English. The Secretary believes these provisions

effectively address the commenters' concerns.

Changes: None.

Comment: Several commenters focused specifically on

Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(iii) concerning the assessment of limited English

proficient children. One commenter recommended modifying this section

to make clear that the State must make every effort to use or develop

linguistically accessible assessment measures and develop appropriate

modifications to test formats and administration procedures for LEP

students assessed in English. Another commenter recommended deleting

``to the extent practicable'' from Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(iii)(A) to ensure

the assessment of all students without regard to primary language.

Discussion: The Secretary believes that Sec. 200.4(b)(7) of the

regulations, which replicates, by and large, the language in section

1111(b)(3)(F) of Title I is clear in its requirements that all students

participate in the assessments, that reasonable adaptations and

accommodations be provided where necessary, and that children with

limited English proficiency be assessed, to the extent practicable, in

the language and form most likely to yield accurate and reliable

information on what those students know and can do to determine the

students' mastery of skills in subjects other than English.

Changes: None.

Comment: Several commenters expressed concerns about the addition

of the phrase ``to meet this requirement'' in Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(iii)(B)

of the regulations. To some, it suggests that States can meet the

requirement that they include LEP students in their assessment by

making every effort to use linguistically accessible assessment

measures even though these are two distinct and important provisions.

To another commenter, the provision gives the impression that

assessment of LEP students is required only when assessments are

available in the students' native languages. Recommendations included

either deleting the phrase, or substituting the words ``in meeting''

for ``to meet'' in Sec. 200.4(b)(7)(iii)(B).

Discussion: The Secretary agrees with the commenter that, as

proposed, the provision did not make clear the

[[Page 34819]]

requirement for including LEP students in the State assessments. In

meeting this requirement, States must make every effort to develop

linguistically accessible assessments. However, even without such

assessments, LEP students must be included in the State's assessments.

Changes: Section 200.4(b)(7)(iii)(B) has been modified by deleting

the phrase ``to meet this requirement'' and inserting ``in meeting this

requirement.''

Comment: One commenter suggested that clarification is needed in

Sec. 200.4(b)(8) of the regulations regarding determining of those

children from mobile families who have attended schools in the LEA for

``a full academic year.'' Specifically, in districts operating year-

round programs, the commenter suggested that students who have attended

school in the district for the amount of time required of any

particular student must be included in determining the progress of the

LEA.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that students from mobile families

must be included in determining an LEA's progress if they have attended

school in that LEA for the period of time necessary to meet the State's

annual requirement for compulsory education.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter recommended that the regulations expressly

state that group-administered, norm-referenced tests below grade 4 are

inappropriate. The same commenter recommended that LEAs, not SEAs,

select the particular approaches to assess children's school

performance during the first 3-4 years of elementary school.

Discussion: Under Title I, States are provided with the

responsibility of developing assessments aligned with State-developed

standards. LEAs may also implement any additional assessments. The

Secretary, therefore, believes it is inappropriate to prescribe the

type of assessments that SEAs and LEAs should use.

Changes: None.

Section 200.5 Requirements for school improvement

Comment: One commenter requested that Secs. 200.5 and 200.6 of the

regulations be expanded to cover the numerous interrelated and complex

provisions of Title I on which no regulations for program improvement

have been included.

Discussion: The Secretary is committed to issuing regulations only

where absolutely necessary and, when regulating, to promoting flexible

approaches to meeting the requirements of the law. As a result, the

Secretary has not expanded the provisions on school improvement through

regulations. The Secretary intends, however, to issue nonregulatory

guidance on these provisions, including examples to illustrate possible

approaches to school improvement.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that, when an LEA reviews a

targeted assistance school to determine if the school has made adequate

progress, the State should have the flexibility to decide whether to

include only students served by Title I or all students who participate

in the assessment.

Discussion: Section 1116(c)(1)(B)(ii) of Title I states that an LEA

shall identify for school improvement any school served under this part

that has not made adequate progress as defined in the State's plan for

two consecutive school years, except that, in the case of a targeted

assistance school, such school may be reviewed on the progress of only

those students that have been or are served under this part.

Additionally, section 1116(d)(3)(A)(i) of Title I provides a State some

flexibility in reviewing the progress of an LEA. In a State's review of

an LEA, schools served by the LEA that are operating targeted

assistance programs may be reviewed on the basis of the progress of

only those students served under Part A.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that language be added to

Sec. 200.5(a)(2) to include parental involvement in the annual review

of the progress of each school for school improvement since parental

involvement is a key theme in Title I of the Act.

Discussion: The Secretary strongly supports parental involvement

efforts and participation by parents in their children's learning

process and believes that such participation is crucial to the

children's success in school. However, the progress of a school is

measured on the basis of student achievement, not the process to elicit

that achievement. Section 1118 of Title I contains comprehensive

parental involvement requirements, including a requirement for the

yearly review of the effectiveness of the parental involvement policy

in increasing the participation of parents.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter supported the Secretary's position in

Sec. 200.5(a)(2)(iii)(c) that in conducting its annual review, an LEA

must report disaggregated data to the public only when those data are

statistically sound. This commenter explained that reporting data that

are not statistically sound will mislead policymakers and the public

regarding how well schools are performing.

Discussion: The Secretary supports reporting data to teachers and

other staff, parents, students, and the community annually so that this

information may be used to determine the effectiveness of the program

and for school improvement purposes. However, informed decisions can be

made only if the data are accurate and statistically sound.

Changes: None.

Schoolwide Programs

Section 200.8 Schoolwide Program Requirements

Comment: Some commenters recommended that Sec. 200.8(a)(1) of the

regulations be changed to indicate that the decision to operate a

schoolwide program is an LEA decision or an LEA decision after

consultation with school-level staff as opposed to a school decision

after consultation with the LEA. According to one of the commenters,

this change would respect the role of the LEA and, at the same time,

reinforce the concept that schoolwide programs should be undertaken in

a building on a voluntary basis.

Discussion: Both section 1114 of Title I on schoolwide programs and

section 1115 of Title I on targeted assistance schools emphasize

greater decisionmaking authority at the school level so that schools,

in consultation with their LEA, determine how to use their Title I

funds in ways that best meet the needs of their students. Section 1114

contains many provisions addressing a school's responsibility for

conducting a schoolwide program should the school choose to operate

one. By emphasizing that an eligible school makes the decision to

operate a schoolwide program, in consultation with its LEA,

Sec. 200.8(a)(1) recognizes that schoolwide programs will be successful

only when the school community is fully behind that decision and that

accountability at the school level must be coupled with decisionmaking

authority.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter requested that the following language be

added to Sec. 200.8(a)(2)(ii): ``If a district selects a provider of

School Support from another entity outside of the statewide system, it

must be subject to the State Validation System before the SWP plan is

approved by the local board.''

Discussion: A State may choose to include, as part of its State

support system addressed in section 1117 of Title I, provisions

allowing its LEAs to select technical assistance providers

[[Page 34820]]

other than those provided by the State. Because the responsibility is

placed upon a State to design its system of support, this is an

individual State decision.

Changes: None.

Comment: Numerous comments were received on Sec. 200.8(c) of the

regulations combining other Federal education program funds to support

schoolwide programs and exempting those funds from their specific

program requirements. Two commenters viewed the proposed regulations as

going beyond what Congress authorized and did not believe that the

ability to combine funds exempts schools from other Federal education

laws and regulations. Several commenters asked that the authority to

combine funds not extend to Title VII bilingual programs. They also

stated that Sec. 200.8(c)(ii)(B), which requires only that the intent

and purposes of Federal education programs whose funds are combined be

met, is too vague and will allow LEAs to evade the intent of Congress.

Some commenters suggested deleting Sec. 200.8(c)(3)(i)(A) because they

believe that provision misconstrues the statute by exempting

``programs'' as opposed to the statutory term ``provisions.'' Other

commenters suggested deleting all references to ``and any other Federal

program included under (c) in this section.'' One commenter expressed

concern that protection of services children receive will be

eliminated, especially if parents are not specifically informed about

funding and program design.

Discussion: One of the most promising changes in the recent

reauthorization of Title I is the expansion of schoolwide programs to

include other Federal programs. A schoolwide program permits a school

to use funds under Part A of Title I to upgrade the entire educational

program of the school and to raise academic achievement for all

children in the school, in contrast to categorical programs in which

Federal funds may generally be used only for supplementary educational

services for specific target populations.

The Secretary strongly believes that schoolwide programs hold the

greatest promise for raising the achievement of all children in high-

poverty schools. He also believes the success of schoolwide programs

depends on the ability of the schools to combine other Federal

education program funds along with Part A funds and State and local

funds to support their overall instructional programs. This authority

affords a schoolwide program school significant flexibility to serve

more effectively all children in the school and their families through

comprehensive reforms of the entire instructional program, rather than

by providing separate services to specific target populations.

The Secretary emphasizes that a school with a schoolwide program

must address the needs of all children in the school, particularly the

needs of children who are members of the target population of any other

Federal education program that is included in the schoolwide program

and that accountability is based on how well children in the target

populations perform with respect to State standards. The Secretary has

not included additional provisions in the regulations because he does

not want to impede a schoolwide program school from serving all

children through comprehensive reforms of its entire instructional

program.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter stated that Sec. 200.8(c)(3)(ii)(A)(8) and

(f)(1)(iii) and (2) of the regulations concerning application of the

supplement, not supplant requirement in schoolwide program schools are

contradictory and confusing.

Discussion: Consistent with section 1114(a)(4)(B) of Title I,

Sec. 200.8(c)(3)(ii)(A)(8) of the regulations does not relieve an LEA

or school operating a schoolwide program from applicable supplement,

not supplant requirements. On the other hand, consistent with section

1114(a)(3), Sec. 200.8(f)(1)(iii) and (2) exempts a schoolwide program

school from providing supplemental services to eligible children,

although it requires the school to demonstrate that Part A funds and

any other Federal education funds that are combined for use in a

schoolwide program supplement the total amount of funds that would, in

the absence of such funds, be made available to the school from non-

Federal sources. Thus, the regulations do not contradict one another.

Rather, paragraph (f) clarifies paragraph (c): schoolwide program

schools must comply with the modified supplement, not supplant

requirements in section 1114(a)(3) of Title I and Sec. 200.8

(f)(1)(iii) and (2) of the regulations.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that Sec. 200.8(e)(1)(iv)(A)(2) of

the regulations conform to the statutory requirement for the collection

of disaggregated achievement and assessment results, which the

commenter argues is required during the transitional assessment period.

Discussion: Section 1111(b)(3)(I) of Title I requires that final

assessment systems enable assessment results to be disaggregated.

Section 1111(b)(7), which authorizes transitional assessments, does not

include the requirement for disaggregation. Therefore, disaggregating

assessment data for schoolwide programs during the transitional

assessment period is not required by the statute. Moreover, the

Secretary believes that requiring disaggregation during the transition

period would frustrate Title I's long-term goal of promoting high-

quality, innovative assessments aligned with challenging standards. If

there are data that can be disaggregated in a schoolwide program, an

LEA may certainly disaggregate that data during the transitional

assessment period. Furthermore, the Secretary encourages LEAs and

schools to use information available from other sources such as

teacher-made assessments to determine the progress of intended

beneficiaries in the programs included in the schoolwide program.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter requested that language be added to

Sec. 200.8(d)(8)(C) of the regulations permitting Title I funds to be

used to conduct parent-teacher conferences in parents' native language

in order to help LEP parents be more involved.

Discussion: The use of Title I funds to conduct parent-teacher

conferences, including in a parent's native language, is an allowable

and appropriate use of Title I funds. Given that many funding sources

may be combined to conduct schoolwide programs, any of the funding

sources, including Title I, could provide such language-related

services. The Department is planning to issue guidance on schoolwide

programs that covers additional issues, including this one.

Furthermore, the Department is consulting with many groups with

knowledge on and experience with issues concerning the specific needs

of children and their parents with limited-English proficiency and will

produce specific guidance on activities related to working with LEP

children and their families.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter requested that Sec. 200.8(c)(3)(ii)(B)(1) of

the regulations concerning a special rule for migratory children in

schoolwide programs be expanded to include students from homeless,

highly mobile, and isolated families.

Discussion: Part C of Title I includes a specific provision with

respect to migratory children in schoolwide programs, which is

reflected in the regulations. There is no authority to

[[Page 34821]]

expand that provision to cover other target populations.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter requested that Sec. 200.8(c)(3)(ii)(B)(1)(i)

of the regulations be revised to refer to parents of migratory children

``and/or'' organizations representing those parents.

Discussion: The Secretary agrees that an LEA may consult with both

parents of migratory children and organizations representing those

parents. These parties are not mutually exclusive.

Changes: The Secretary has revised Sec. 200.8(c)(3)(ii)(B)(1)(i) to

include ``or both.''

Comment: One commenter recommended that Sec. 200.8(d)(8)(ii)(A) and

(B) of the regulations be deleted, arguing that the language on

Individualized Education Programs (IEP) is an unnecessary clarification

that unfairly targets an effective strategy that helps children with

special needs improve their academic achievement.

Discussion: This provision is included to prevent misinterpretation

of the statutory provision that requires a schoolwide program to

discuss with parents what the school will do to help students meet the

standards and identify additional assistance that may be available.

Section 200.8(d)(8)(ii)(A) of the regulations makes clear the statute

does not require that IEPs, like those required under the Individuals

with Disabilities Education Act, be developed for children not served

in special education. This clarification does not, however, prohibit

IEPs from being developed should a schoolwide program school elect to

do so.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that the Secretary focus on

curriculum and instruction in its guidance to States, school districts,

and schools regarding the development of schoolwide plans. The

commenter also suggested that schools be required to explain how and

why they designed their instructional program and to describe any

evidence that their approach has been researched and evaluated in peer-

reviewed publications. In addition, the commenter suggested that the

Secretary ask schools to explain how their schoolwide programs will

help students master the knowledge and skills outlined in the State

content standards. Further, the commenter suggested that the Secretary

urge schools to include a timetable in their schoolwide plans showing

what changes will take place immediately and what other changes will

follow.

Discussion: Section 1114(b)(1) of Title I contains the components

required of a schoolwide program, including, among other things,

schoolwide reform strategies that provide opportunities for all

children to meet the State's proficient and advanced levels of student

performance, that are based on effective means of improving the

achievement of children, and that use effective instructional

strategies. Further, section 1114(b)(2) provides that a school

operating a schoolwide program must develop a comprehensive plan for

reforming the school that incorporates the components required in

section 1114(b)(1). Therefore, the statute already sufficiently ensures

that the schoolwide program plan include information on those areas

critical to the improvement of teaching and learning.

Changes: None.

Participation of Eligible Children in Private Schools

Section 200.10 Responsibilities for Providing Services to Children in

Private Schools

Comment: Two commenters suggested that Sec. 200.10(a) of the

regulations be augmented to clarify that timely and meaningful

consultation must occur before decisions are made that affect the

opportunities of participating private school children and that a

unilateral offer of services would not suffice.

Discussion: Section 1120(a) of Title I requires an LEA to provide

equitable services to eligible private school children after timely

meaningful consultation with private school officials. Section 1120(b)

further elaborates on what constitutes timely and meaningful

consultation. Paragraph (b)(2) requires consultation to occur ``before

the [LEA] makes any decision that affects the opportunities of eligible

private school children to participate'' in Part A programs. These

statutory provisions clearly preclude an LEA from making a unilateral

offer of services or consulting after services are already being

provided, and no further regulations are needed.

Changes: None.

Comment: Several commenters argued that the definition of eligible

students in section 1115 of Title I does not require eligible Title I

children attending private schools to reside in a participating

attendance area as stated in Sec. 200.10(b)(1) of the regulations. They

argued that the poverty of a private school is reflective of a larger

area such as an entire LEA and, therefore, the attendance areas of the

public school system are not relevant.

Discussion: Section 1113(a) of Title I defines a public school

attendance area as the geographic area in which children who are

normally served by the school reside. To be eligible for Title I

services, a school attendance area must have a higher percentage of

poverty than the LEA as a whole. The degree of poverty in a private

school is irrelevant because private schools do not participate in

Title I. Rather, private school children are eligible because they

reside in a public school attendance area that is participating in

Title I; thus, they would have been eligible for services had they

attended the public school. In essence, Title I puts private school

children in the same place they would have been in had they attended a

public school.

Changes: None.

Section 200.11 Factors for Determining Equitable Participation of

Children in Private Schools

Comment: Several commenters commented on Sec. 200.11(a)(2)(ii) (A)-

(B) of the regulations, which provides two options to an LEA for

determining which eligible private school children to serve. One

commenter suggested that a combination of the options should be allowed

as a third option. Another commenter recommended that paragraph (A),

which permits the pooling of funds generated by poor private school

children in all participating areas, be deleted because it provides

greater flexibility in serving private school children than exists for

serving public school children. Other commenters recommended that

paragraph (B) be deleted, arguing that it is administratively

burdensome and appears to directly benefit private schools.

Discussion: The regulations provide two options for utilizing the

funds allocated on the basis of the number of low-income children who

reside in participating Title I attendance area. In consultation with

private school officials, an LEA may select one option or combine the

options to best serve eligible private school children. Thus, an LEA

does not need to select the option in paragraph (B) if the LEA believes

it is administratively burdensome. The Secretary does not believe the

option for pooling funds in paragraph (A) favors private school

children. Rather, it adds needed flexibility, particularly because the

number of poor children who reside in participating public school

attendance areas and attend a particular private school may be so small

that the funds those children generate are not commensurate with the

educational needs of eligible children in that school.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that Sec. 200.11(b)(2)(iii) of the

regulations

[[Page 34822]]

be modified to require that private school children be provided with an

opportunity to participate in Title I in a manner that addresses the

particular needs of the private school children.

Discussion: Section 1120 of Title I clearly provides private school

children an opportunity to participate in Title I in a way that

addresses their particular educational needs. It requires that

equitable services be provided and requires an LEA to consult with

private school officials about how private school children's needs will

be identified and what services will be provided. Moreover, because

there is no longer a districtwide needs assessment, the needs of

private school children can be determined independently from the needs

of public school children.

Changes: None.

Section 200.13 Requirements Concerning Property, Equipment, and

Supplies for the Benefit of Private School Children

Comment: Several commenters recommended that Sec. 200.13(d) of the

regulations be revised to afford LEAs discretion in deciding whether to

remove equipment and materials no longer needed to provide services to

private school children if there is the possibility that the program

would be resumed in a subsequent year. The commenters explained that

new zoning ordinances in many districts make it very expensive, once

portable units, for example, are removed, to resituate the units.

Discussion: The Secretary recognizes that, under the new law,

services to eligible private school children may differ from those

provided under Chapter 1. The Secretary has attempted in Sec. 200.28 of

the regulations to provide maximum flexibility to ease the transition

to the new law. Consistent with that flexibility, however, if equipment

is no longer needed to provide equitable services to private school

children, it must be removed as required in Sec. 200.13(d).

Changes: None.

Capital Expenses

Section 200.16 Payments to LEAs for Capital Expenses

Comment: Two commenters recommended amending

Sec. 200.16(a)(1)(i)(B) of the regulations to also allow capital

expenses to pay for costs that would be incurred to improve the quality

of services provided to private school students.

Discussion: Capital expenses funds may pay the costs of

noninstructional goods and services needed to improve the quality of

equitable services provided to private school children. The Secretary

did not amend the regulations because these costs would be covered

under Sec. 200.16(a)(1)(i)(A)--that is, capital expenses an LEA ``is

currently incurring'' to provide equitable services.

Changes: None.

Comment: One commenter suggested that Sec. 200.16(a)(1)(ii) of the

regulations be revised to allow an LEA to apply for a payment to cover

capital expenses it incurred in prior years for which it has not been

reimbursed ``only'' if the LEA demonstrates that its current needs for

capital expenses have been met.

Discussion: The Secretary believes that the regulatory language in

Sec. 200.16(a)(1)(ii) clearly does not permit payments for previously

incurred capital expenses if the LEA cannot demonstrate that its

current needs for capital expenses have been met.

Changes: None.

Section 200.17 Use of LEA Payments for Capital Expenses

Comment: One commenter supported the use of capital expenses for

reimbursement of costs in prior years but suggested that such

reimbursement not be contingent upon approval by the SEA.

Discussion: Section 200.16(a)(1)(ii) of the regulations makes clear

that an LEA may apply to the SEA for capital expense funds to cover

expenses it incurred in prior years only if the LEA has demonstrated

that its current needs for capital expenses have been met. Section

200.17 reflects this provision.

Changes: None.

Procedures for the Within-State Allocation of LEA Program Funds

Section 200.20 Allocation of Funds to LEAs

Comment: One commenter asked why Sections 1124(a)(2) and 1125(d) of

Title I and Sec. 2

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Title IHelping Disadvantaged Children Meet High Standards · 60 FR 34800 | Frix