Medical Facility Construction and Modernization; Requirements for Provision of Services to Persons Unable To Pay

Federal RegisterApr 4, 1994

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES

Public Health Service

42 CFR Part 124

RIN 0905-AE06

Medical Facility Construction and Modernization; Requirements for

Provision of Services to Persons Unable To Pay

AGENCY: Public Health Service, DHHS.

ACTION: Proposed rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: This notice proposes revisions to the rules currently

governing how certain health care facilities, assisted under titles VI

and XVI of the Public Health Service Act, fulfill the assurance given

in their applications for assistance that they would provide a

reasonable volume of services to persons unable to pay. Public comment

on the current rules and operational experience with them have

indicated the need to revise the current requirements with respect to

nursing homes, many of which are unable under current requirements to

meet their obligation to provide such services. The intended effect of

this action is to permit qualified facilities to satisfy their

uncompensated services assurance.

DATES: Comments must be received on or before June 3, 1994.

ADDRESSES: Written comments may be sent to Mrs. Charlotte G. Pascoe,

Director, Division of Facilities Compliance, BHRD, HRSA, 5600 Fishers

Lane, room 11-19, Rockville, Maryland 20857.

Comments will be available for public inspection during normal

business hours at this address: PHS will take appropriate steps, where

necessary, to afford individuals with disabilities an equal opportunity

to comment.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: Mrs. Eulas Dortch, 301-443-5656.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The Secretary of Health and Human Services

proposes an amendment to the rules governing what is popularly known as

the Hill-Burton uncompensated services program. Health care facilities

covered by the program received construction assistance under two

titles of the Public Health Service Act, title VI (the ``Hill-Burton

Act,'' 42 U.S.C. 291, et seq.) and title XVI (42 U.S.C. 300q, et seq.).

Under both titles, facilities receiving such construction assistance

have been required, as a condition of receiving the construction

assistance, to provide an assurance that ``there will be available in

the facility or portion thereof to be constructed or modernized a

reasonable volume of services to persons unable to pay therefor * *

*.'' 42 U.S.C. 291c(e). See also 42 U.S.C. 300s-1(b)(1)(K)(ii). This

assurance is known as the ``uncompensated services assurance.''

Regulations governing compliance with the uncompensated services

assurance were first issued in 1947, and have been revised several

times. On May 18, 1979, comprehensive regulations governing compliance

with the assurance were issued at 44 FR 29372. Among other things, the

1979 regulations: Established a minimum level of uncompensated services

which facilities were required to provide; set an annual compliance

level of uncompensated services to be provided and required facilities

to make up any deficit in meeting the annual compliance level through

provision of more uncompensated services in later years; required

facilities to allocate their uncompensated services either under a plan

meeting certain requirements or on a first-requested, first-served

basis; required facilities to notify the public of the existence of

their uncompensated services programs through public notice and

provision of personal notice to individuals served by the facilities;

and required facilities to keep records documenting compliance and to

periodically report concerning compliance. The 1979 regulations also

for the first time established national eligibility criteria, based on

income: Individuals whose annual income was at or below the poverty

level (known as ``Category A individuals'') were automatically eligible

for uncompensated services; individuals whose annual income was at or

below two times the poverty level (known as ``Category B individuals'')

were also eligible for uncompensated services, unless the facility

decided to limit its services to Category A individuals only. The 1979

regulations also provided that amounts to which an individual was

entitled under a third-party insurance or governmental program could

not be credited towards a facility's uncompensated services quota.

On December 3, 1987, the Secretary revised the 1979 regulations at

52 FR 46022. As pertinent here, the 1987 regulations effected a

technical revision of the 1979 regulations, making explicit what had

formerly been implicit in those regulations; i.e., that coverage of an

indigent under a third-party insurance or governmental program

precludes eligibility for uncompensated services. 42 CFR 124.505(a)(1)

(1988). This policy simply reflects the long-standing Department view

of the uncompensated services program as a program of last resort,

designed to serve persons who have no source of payment, such as

Medicaid or private insurance, for medical care.

This policy has created major compliance problems for many Hill-

Burton-obligated nursing homes. HHS has determined that, of the 287

nursing homes with outstanding uncompensated services obligations under

the general compliance standards of the regulations, 243 have deficits;

the majority of these have received no uncompensated services credit.

These deficits persist despite many attempts by HHS to provide

technical assistance to nursing homes to bring them into compliance.

The fundamental problem is that, in most of these nursing homes, the

only individuals who meet the income-eligibility requirements for

receipt of uncompensated services are also covered by their State's

Medicaid program; hence, they are by definition ineligible for

uncompensated services under Sec. 124.505(a)(1). Thus, in States in

which the Medicaid eligibility limits exceed the Hill-Burton

eligibility limits and which cover most or all medical services,

nursing homes are in the unenviable position of being chronically

unable to fulfill their uncompensated services obligations.

HHS has been aware of this structural problem for some time, and

established a task force to analyze nursing home compliance issues and

develop strategies for dealing with compliance problems. The task force

found that facilities in States which have comprehensive Medicaid

coverage for nursing home services have the most difficulty finding

eligible individuals to whom they can provide uncompensated services.

Thus, the task force recommended increasing the eligibility limit for

uncompensated services to three times the poverty level to increase the

pool of individuals potentially eligible for uncompensated services.

HHS then surveyed the regional offices of the Health Care Financing

Administration, which administers the Medicaid program, to determine

whether such a change in income eligibility would permit more nursing

homes to meet their uncompensated services obligations by setting Hill-

Burton income eligibility limits above Medicaid income eligibility

limits. This survey indicated that 31 States and the District of

Columbia have medically needy programs under which Medicaid covers all

individuals who have annual incomes that are less than the cost of the

nursing home services received and less than the Medicaid resource

eligibility limits (usually, $2,000). Based on an average annual

nursing home cost of $31,000 in 1992, an increase in the Hill-Burton

income eligibility limit to three times the poverty level (to about

$20,000) will not significantly increase the opportunity for facilities

in these States to meet their uncompensated services obligations, since

patient income is irrelevant unless it exceeds nursing home costs.

However, even in these States, to the extent nursing home patients

receive services not covered by Medicaid or are ineligible for Medicaid

because they have resources exceeding the Medicaid limits, raising the

Hill-Burton income eligibility limit would increase the pool of

individuals eligible for uncompensated services. Moreover, in 16 of the

remaining 19 States, a raise in the Hill-Burton individual income

eligibility limit from the current $13,940 (double the poverty level)

to the proposed $20,910 would result in a Hill-Burton income

eligibility limit substantially above the Medicaid income eligibility

limit of $15,192 that applies in these States. An increase in the

income eligibility limit to three times the poverty level for nursing

home services would thus greatly increase the pool of Hill-Burton

eligibles in those States, and it seems likely that such a change would

accordingly increase the opportunity to fulfill the Hill-Burton

obligation for all 69 nursing homes in those States. While the

remaining three States have Medicaid income eligibility limits that are

below the current upper Hill-Burton individual income eligibility limit

of $13,940, such a change would obviously increase the pool of Hill-

Burton eligible individuals in those States as well. Thus, to the

extent the compliance problems of nursing homes in those States are a

function of a lack of eligible patients, an increase in the income

eligibility limit to three times the poverty level for nursing home

services would similarly assist them.

The rules proposed below accordingly would establish a third income

eligibility level (Category C) for nursing home services only. See,

proposed Sec. 124.505(a)(2)(iii). Category C individuals would be those

individuals whose annual incomes are greater than two times, but do not

exceed three times, the poverty level. The regulations already define

which facilities are ``nursing homes'' within the scope of the

regulation. See, Sec. 124.502(h).

HHS has considered, but rejected, even higher income eligibility

limits. The higher that income eligibility limits are raised, the

farther the program gets from targeting services to persons unable to

pay. On the other hand, given the usual cost of nursing home care, it

is apparent that individuals in need of such care are still unable to

pay for the cost of that care, even if they have annual incomes of

three times the poverty level. Thus, HHS believes that the proposed

regulation represents a reasonable approach to reducing compliance

problems for nursing homes and retaining the program's traditional

focus on persons unable to pay.

While HHS recognizes that this proposal on its face does not

resolve all nursing home compliance problems, it also does not expect

the proposed change to operate in a vacuum. Rather, HHS currently has

under consideration another compliance alternative, published in the

Federal Register on November 4, 1993, as a Notice of Proposed

Rulemaking, designed in part to help alleviate the compliance problems

of certain private, nonprofit nursing homes. The proposed compliance

alternative would exempt qualifying facilities from the procedural

requirements of the general regulations. Qualifying facilities are

those private, nonprofit facilities that either receive substantial

philanthropic support and provide free or reduced cost services, or do

not collect monies directly from persons unable to pay. The combination

of these two proposed rules should allow all of the 287 Hill-Burton

obligated nursing homes to satisfy their uncompensated services

obligations and reduce their uncompensated services deficits more

easily. In light of this, it appears prudent to minimize the change in

the underlying program until it is seen what effect the two program

alterations currently under consideration have in resolving the

compliance problems of nursing homes.

The rules proposed below also set out technical and conforming

amendments to other sections. The only one of note is proposed

Sec. 124.506(a)(1)(v). That section would provide that if a nursing

home provides services on a reduced charge basis to both Category B and

Category C individuals, it may not employ a discount method that gives

Category C individuals greater discounts than those given to Category B

individuals. This policy is simply a logical extension of a similar

policy that already exists with respect to Category A and Category B

individuals.

The Secretary solicits comments on the viability and advisability

of the above proposal. If there are suggestions for alternative

approaches to addressing the problems of nursing home compliance, the

Secretary is interested in receiving those as well.

Economic Impact

Executive Order 12866 requires that all regulations reflect

consideration of alternatives, of costs, of benefits, of incentives, of

equity, and of available information. Regulations must meet certain

standards, such as avoiding unnecessary burden. Regulations which are

``significant'' because of cost, adverse effects on the economy,

inconsistency with other agency actions, effects on the budget, or

novel legal or policy issues, require special analysis. The Regulatory

Flexibility Act requires that we analyze regulatory proposals to

determine whether they create a significant impact on a substantial

number of small entities (for purposes of the Act, all nursing home are

categorized by HHS as small entities).

The Department believes that the proposed rule change in this

regulation is beneficial. This regulation does not have an impact that

exceeds $100 million for nursing homes. While it will allow nursing

homes to qualify more individuals for uncompensated services and thus

reduce facility deficits, it will not alter existing procedural and

reporting requirements for obligated facilities. For these reasons, we

do not believe this rule necessitates an economic analysis. Therefore,

in accordance with the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980, the

Secretary certifies that this regulation will not have a significant

impact on a substantial number of small entities.

Pursuant to Executive Order 12866, the Office of Management and

Budget (OMB) has reviewed this rule. The Department requests comments

on whether there are any aspects of this proposed rule which can be

improved to make nursing home compliance more effective, more

equitable, or less costly.

Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980

This proposed rule contains no information collection or reporting

requirements which are subject to review by OMB under the Paperwork

Reduction Act of 1980. Although this rule discusses the requirement for

developing and submitting affirmative action plans, the requirement is

not new and has been previously approved under OMB control number 0915-

0077.

List of Subjects in 42 CFR Part 124

Grant programs--health; Health facilities; Loan programs--health;

Low income persons.

Dated: November 12, 1993.

Philip R. Lee,

Assistant Secretary for Health.

Approved: February 22, 1994.

Donna E. Shalala,

Secretary.

For reasons set out in the preamble, subpart F of 42 CFR part 124

is proposed to be amended as follows:

Subpart F--Reasonable Volume of Uncompensated Services to Persons

Unable To Pay

1. The authority citation for 42 CFR part 124, subpart F, continues

to read as follows:

Authority: 42 U.S.C. 216; 42 U.S.C. 300s(3).

2. The first two sentences of Sec. 124.503(b)(4) are revised to

read as follows:

Sec. 124.503 Compliance level.

* * * * *

(b) * * *

(4) Affirmative action plan for precluding future deficits. Except

where a facility reports to the Secretary in accordance with

Sec. 124.509(a)(2)(iii) that it was financially unable to provide

uncompensated services at the annual compliance level, a facility that

fails to meet its annual compliance level in any fiscal year shall, in

the following year, develop and implement a plan of action that can

reasonably be expected to enable the facility to meet its annual

compliance level. Such actions may include special notice to the

community through newspaper, radio, and television, or expansion of

service to Category B, or, with respect to nursing homes, Category C,

persons. * * *

* * * * *

3. Section 124.505 is amended by revising paragraph (a)(2)(ii) and

by adding paragraph (a)(2)(iii) to read as follows:

Sec. 124.505 Eligibility criteria.

(a) * * *

(2) * * *

(ii) Category B--A person whose annual individual or family income,

as applicable, is greater than, but not more than twice, the poverty

line issued by the Secretary pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 9902 that applies to

the individual or family. If persons in Category B are included in the

allocation plan, the facility shall provide uncompensated services to

these persons without charge, or in accordance with a schedule of

charges as specified in the allocation plan.

(iii) Category C--With respect only to persons seeking or receiving

nursing home services, a person whose annual or family income, as

applicable, is more than twice but not greater than three times the

poverty line issued by the Secretary pursuant to 42 U.S.C. 9902 that

applies to the individual or family. If persons in Category C are

included in the allocation plan, the facility shall provide

uncompensated services to these persons without charge, or in

accordance with a schedule of charges as specified in the allocation

plan; and

* * * * *

4. Section 124.506 is amended by revising paragraph (a)(1)(iii)

through (a)(1)(v) and the first sentence of paragraph (b)(2) and by

adding paragraph (a)(1)(vi) to read as follows:

Sec. 124.506 Allocation of services; plan requirement.

(a)(1) * * *

(iii) State whether Category B or, in the case of nursing homes

only, Category C persons will be provided uncompensated services, and

if so, whether the services will be available without charge or at a

reduced charge;

(iv) If services will be made available to Category B persons at a

reduced charge, specify the method for reducing charges, and provide

that the method will be applicable to all persons in Category B;

(v) With respect to nursing homes only, if services will be made

available to Category C persons at a reduced charge, specify the method

for reducing charges, provided that such method may not result in

greater reductions than those afforded to Category B persons, and

provide that this method will be applicable to all persons in Category

C; and

(vi) Provide that the facility will provide uncompensated services

to all persons eligible under the plan who request uncompensated

services.

(b)(1) * * *

(2) If no plan was previously published in accordance with

paragraph (a)(2) of this section, the facility must provide

uncompensated services without charge to all applicants in Category A

and Category B, and, with respect to nursing homes, Category C, who

request uncompensated services in the facility.

* * * * *

[FR Doc. 94-7727 Filed 4-1-94; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 4160-15-M

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.