Protection of Stratospheric Ozone: Supplemental Rule To Amend Phaseout of Ozone-Depleting Substances To Include Potential Production Allowances for Methyl Bromide

Federal RegisterDec 20, 1994

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

40 CFR Part 82

[FRL-5125-1]

RIN 2060-AD91

Protection of Stratospheric Ozone: Supplemental Rule To Amend

Phaseout of Ozone-Depleting Substances To Include Potential Production

Allowances for Methyl Bromide

AGENCY: Environmental Protection Agency.

ACTION: Final rule.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

SUMMARY: With this action, EPA allocates potential production

allowances to producers who have baseline allowances for the production

of methyl bromide. These potential production allowances are intended

solely for the production of methyl bromide for export to Article 5

countries, as defined under Article 5 of the Montreal Protocol on

Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer. In drafting the accelerated

phaseout rule, which was published in the Federal Register on December

10, 1993, the Agency inadvertently omitted methyl bromide from the list

of chemicals for which potential production allowances were granted.

Today's action correctly allocates potential production allowances for

all control periods beginning January 1, 1994, and ending before

January 1, 2001, equal to 10 percent of a company's baseline production

allowances. The Agency may propose potential production allowances for

methyl bromide for control periods after January 1, 2001, at a later

date. Today's action makes the above-mentioned correction while

maintaining the goals of the accelerated phaseout to protect human

health and the environment.

EFFECTIVE DATE: December 20, 1994. Potential production allowances for

methyl bromide are granted for the 1994 control period (which began

January 1, 1994) and for control periods until January 1, 2001.

ADDRESSES: Materials relevant to this amendment to the accelerated

phaseout of ozone-depleting substances are contained in Air Docket No.

A-92-13 at U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, 401 M St., SW,

Washington, DC 20460. The public docket is located in room M-1500,

Waterside Mall (Ground Floor). Material may be inspected from 8 a.m. to

5:30 p.m. Monday through Friday. A reasonable fee may be charged by EPA

for copying docket materials. Information on this amendment can also be

obtained from the Stratospheric Protection Information Hotline at 1-

800-296-1996.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: The Stratospheric Protection

Information Hotline at 1-800-296-1996 or Tom Land, Stratospheric

Protection Division, Office of Atmospheric Programs, Office of Air and

Radiation (6205J), 401 M Street SW., Washington, DC 20460, (202)-233-

9185.

I. Background

When Parties to the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete

the Ozone Layer (the Protocol) first met in 1987, they agreed in

Article 2H to allow additional production of controlled substances

beyond the levels being set for the developed countries for developing

countries. The United States, as well as other Parties to the Protocol,

recognized the need to continue to supply controlled substances to

developing countries during the period of scheduled reductions and for

a limited time after the phaseout of production of controlled

substances. Under Article 5 of the Protocol, developing countries are

defined as Parties to the Protocol consuming less than 0.3 kilograms

per capita of class I, Group I and II controlled substances. These

Article 5 countries have limited resources to adopt alternative

technologies to replace the phased out controlled substances. To ensure

that such countries do not purchase the technologies to produce

controlled substances and otherwise bypass controls on controlled

substances, the Parties to the Protocol agreed to provide a set-aside

level of production for Article 5 countries. Article 5 countries must

ensure that these imported controlled substances are used to meet basic

domestic needs.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) implements a program

domestically that limits and monitors production and consumption of

controlled substances, including methyl bromide. Production for Article

5 countries in the United States is monitored by allocating potential

production allowances to those companies that have baseline production

allowances. Since 1989, EPA has allocated potential production

allowances equal to 10 percent of baseline production allowances for

specific controlled substances. EPA grants authorization to producers

to convert potential production allowances to production allowances

once they have exported to an Article 5 country. The July 30, 1992,

Federal Register document (57 FR 3375), as well as the December 10,

1993, Federal Register document (58 FR 65018), explains these controls,

as well as the recordkeeping and reporting required for such

transactions. The specific provisions governing production for, and

export to, Article 5 countries are in Secs. 82.9 and 82.11. Appendix D

of subpart A of 40 CFR part 82 contains a listing of Article 5

countries.1

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

\1\EPA is drafting a final rule that amends the accelerated

phaseout rule to adjust the dates relating to exports for Article 5

countries. That final rule will also reflect today's amendments

granting methyl bromide potential production allowances.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

II. Summary of Proposal

In the October 14, 1994 proposal to grant potential production

allowances for methyl bromide, EPA discussed the inadvertent omission

of the allocation of these allowances in the final rule published

December 10, 1993 (58 FR 65018). In drafting the December 10, 1993

final rule, EPA focused on the level of control of methyl bromide and

its phaseout, but inadvertently failed to allocate additional

production allowances of methyl bromide for exports to Article 5

countries. Due to this oversight, EPA proposed on October 14 to

allocate potential production allowances to methyl bromide producers

equal to 10 percent of their baseline production allowances beginning

in the current control period (which began January 1, 1994). Because

section 82.11 indicates that authorizations to convert potential

production allowances to production allowances are valid during the

control period in which the controlled substance departed the United

States, companies may use these potential production allowances for

methyl bromide only for the control period in which the shipment

departed the United States. The 10 percent level of additional

production for Article 5 countries would continue until the effective

date of the phaseout of production of methyl bromide, January 1, 2001.

Section 602(d) of the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 establishes the

phaseout date for methyl bromide by stating that production may not

extend beyond ``a date more than seven years after January 1 of the

year after the year in which the substance is added to the list of

class I substances.'' Methyl bromide was added to the list of class I

substances in 1993. With this proposal, EPA is reserving action in

allocating potential production allowances for control periods starting

January 1, 2001, and beyond.

III. Comments on the Proposal

a. General Comments

EPA received three comments on the proposed allocation of potential

production allowances for methyl bromide. Two of these comments support

the allocation of potential production allowances for methyl bromide

for export to Article 5 countries.

The two supporting comments agree with EPA's proposal stating that:

``(1) The Agency has the legal authority to adopt this amendment; (2)

there is a serious need for this amendment; and (3) this amendment will

have no adverse environmental consequences.'' The legal authority to

grant potential production allowances for methyl bromide was discussed

in the proposal published October 14, 1994 (59 FR 52126). One of the

two supporting comments acknowledged that, ``there is no contrary

authority (within the Montreal Protocol or the Clean Air Act Amendments

of 1990) to these provisions; therefore, EPA has the legal authority to

promulgate this amendment to 40 CFR Part 82.''

The two comments state, and EPA agrees, that the need for this

amendment to allocate potential production allowances for methyl

bromide stems from a need to maintain competitiveness in world markets

for U.S. methyl bromide producers. Without the additional production

allowances, U.S. companies are placed at a competitive disadvantage

relative to other producers of methyl bromide in developed countries

for the methyl bromide markets in Article 5 countries. The demand

within Article 5 countries for methyl bromide is smaller than the

potential global supply as currently allowed under the Montreal

Protocol (100 percent of 1991 levels plus the 10 percent to meet basic

domestic needs in Article 5 countries). Therefore, methyl bromide will

be produced and exported to Article 5 countries, regardless of whether

it is supplied by U.S. companies or another Party. EPA believes that it

is important for U.S. producers of methyl bromide to continue to

maintain their position in these markets as international contacts will

enable U.S. companies to lead the global transition to alternative

pesticides other than methyl bromide.

The two comments state, and EPA agrees, that the allocation of

potential production allowances to U.S. companies for the export of

methyl bromide to Article 5 countries will not have a detrimental

environmental impact. The allocation of potential production allowances

for methyl bromide to U.S. companies will not change global emissions;

nor will global emissions increase if such additional allowances are

granted. Because the demand for methyl bromide from Article 5 countries

is limited, the percent of methyl bromide that will be emitted during

the use and application of methyl bromide will be the same, regardless

of the supplier.

The provisions in the Protocol for additional production to meet

the basic domestic needs of Article 5 countries were included by the

Parties for sound environmental policy reasons. The additional

production provided in the U.S. by potential production allowances is

designed to meet the basic domestic needs of Article 5 countries. The

Parties felt it would be preferable to meet the basic domestic needs of

Article 5 countries through production and exports from existing

facilities than through construction of new production facilities in

Article 5 countries. If Article 5 countries were to build new

production facilities, the level of production would not be subject to

the same controls as those in developed countries and more methyl

bromide would potentially be produced over a longer time period because

Article 5 countries have a 10-year grace period beyond the phaseout

date for the various ozone-depleting substances.

The third comment EPA received on the October 14, 1994, proposal

was from an environmental group that also expressed support for the

Montreal Protocol and the potential production allowances for Article 5

countries. However, the commenter expressed concern about EPA's

argument justifying the quantity of allowances allocated. EPA does not

believe this is a valid concern as the quantity of allowances

authorized to be allocated (the 10 percent additional production for

export to Article 5 countries) is not set unilaterally by EPA, but is

derived from provisions of the Protocol.

The commenter also expressed concern with EPA's argument that if

U.S. companies do not produce methyl bromide for Article 5 countries,

another Party will. The commenter indicated that if this view is

adopted by other Parties, it would encourage increased use and

dependence on methyl bromide by Article 5 countries. EPA disagrees with

these comments. As stated above, the potential global supply of methyl

bromide far exceeds current demand in Article 5 countries. Therefore,

there is no environmental benefit in denying U.S. companies the 10

percent additional production which is granted under the Protocol.

Protecting stratospheric ozone can only be achieved through a

cooperative global effort and EPA does not wish to put U.S. companies

at a disadvantage in competing in the global methyl bromide market

unless there is an environmental benefit. In this case, EPA does not

believe an environmental benefit would accrue from a lesser allocation

of potential production allowances for methyl bromide. Furthermore,

denying the potential production allowances intended by the Parties to

the Protocol to be allocated to all producers of class I substances at

the 10 percent rate would be disadvantage producers without evidence of

significant environmental detriment.

The third comment also urged EPA to revisit the issue and ``to

craft a more stringent regulation regarding the production of methyl

bromide for export to Article 5 countries.'' EPA believes that the 10

percent allocation of potential production allowances for the export of

methyl bromide to Article 5 countries in today's notice does not

preclude future consideration of more stringent regulations for methyl

bromide. In fact, EPA is continuing to analyze methyl bromide's role in

stratospheric ozone depletion and the potential environmental and

health benefits that could potentially be obtained through further

regulatory controls.

b. Use of Allocation and Conversions During the Control Period

In the proposal of October 14, 1994, EPA stated that the allocation

of potential production allowances for Article 5 countries may be

retroactive to the beginning of the control period starting January 1,

1994. In this final action, EPA allocates potential production

allowances for the control period starting January 1, 1994, to those

companies with baseline production allowances for methyl bromide.

EPA received a comment that further clarification is needed that

conversions of potential production allowances into production

allowances should also be made retroactive for the 1994 control period.

As noted earlier, authorizations to convert potential production

allowances to production allowances are valid during the control period

in which the controlled substance was exported. Thus, EPA agrees with

this comment and will process requests to convert potential production

allowances to production allowances for exports that occurred in the

1994 control period.

EPA will process authorizations to convert potential production

allowances into production allowances for exports that occur within the

1994 control period (before midnight of December 31, 1994) as long as

the paperwork is received by EPA before the final day of the first

quarter of 1995. The current regulations refer to control periods and

do not prohibit companies from seeking authorizations to convert for

quantities of methyl bromide exported, as long as the export occurs in

the same control period in which the production allowances are used.

The export, conversion and use of the production allowances must all

occur within the same control period. Therefore, a company that

receives production allowances through a conversion during the first

quarter of the year following the export will not be able to use these

allowances for production, but may use them to ensure compliance for

the control period in which the export occurred.

c. Production Levels

With this amendment, EPA allocates to companies that produced

methyl bromide in 1991 production up to 10 percent of their baseline

allowances for Article 5 countries for the control periods starting

January 1, 1994, and ending before January 1, 2001. EPA is setting the

level at 10 percent to be consistent with Article 2H of the Montreal

Protocol, and to be consistent with the approach used for all Class I

controlled substances except for Group VII, the hydrobromofluorocarbons

(no additional production for Article 5 countries is granted under the

Protocol for these chemicals.)

d. Use of 1994 Potential Production Allowances

EPA received a comment that requests a change in the procedures for

the use of 1994 production allowances and/or consumption allowances for

methyl bromide exports to Article 5 countries. The commenter makes two

proposals to rectify the granting of potential production allowances

late in the 1994 control period. The commenter requests that companies

be able to use production allowances converted from 1994 potential

production allowances for six months into 1995. As a less desirable

alternative, the commenter suggests that, ``production using the

converted potential production allowances could occur in the 1994

control period without the requirement that consumption allowances be

available at the time of production.''

EPA disagrees with the suggestions for rectifying the late granting

of potential production allowances in 1994 because the Protocol

establishes strict limits on production for Parties to the Protocol for

each control period. Therefore, EPA may not alter the definition of a

control period, nor exceed the limits on production for a control

period. EPA's regulations lay out a system for allocating production

and consumption allowances in accordance with the Protocol to limit

production and importation within control periods. Both production

allowances and consumption allowances are needed simultaneously, to be

able to produce within a control period. To extend the use of

allowances from one control period into the following control period

would be a violation of the United States commitments under the

Montreal Protocol to limit production. EPA will also not allow

production without consumption allowances. This would set an

unacceptable precedent that is contrary to existing regulatory

requirements and the Protocol. EPA suggests that the companies continue

to apply for consumption allowances for exports to Article 5 countries

and use these to produce in conjunction with existing production

allowances and those requested for conversion from potential production

allowances.

A commenter added that the time taken to grant the conversion of

potential production allowances to production allowances ``requires at

least 3 weeks after the documentation is submitted to EPA.'' EPA

believes that the average time taken to process a request to convert is

five days and almost never exceeds ten working days.

e. Allocation After the Phaseout

In the October 14, 1994 proposal, EPA reserved the right to

allocate potential production allowances after the phaseout date for

methyl bromide, starting January 1, 2001, and beyond. One comment was

received suggesting EPA state an intention to allocate potential

production allowance, at some level, after the U.S. phaseout date. EPA

intends to analyze the role of methyl bromide in the depletion of

stratospheric ozone as more scientific information is gathered over the

next few years. EPA also intends to monitor global and U.S. production

of methyl bromide and its use. At this time, EPA cannot predict the

future actions relative to the post-phaseout period for methyl bromide.

Based on the monitoring and analysis activities, EPA will continue to

consider proposing an allocation of potential production allowances

after the U.S. phaseout date for methyl bromide.

IV. Summary of Supporting Analysis

A. Executive Order 12866

Under Executive Order 12866 (58 FR 51735, October 4, 1993), the

Agency must determine whether this regulatory action is ``significant''

and therefore subject to OMB review and the requirements of the

Executive Order. The Order defines ``significant'' regulatory action as

one that is likely to lead to a rule that may:

(1) have an annual effect on the economy of $100 million or more,

or adversely and materially affect a sector of the economy,

productivity, competition, jobs, the environment, public health or

safety, or State, local, or tribal governments or communities;

(2) create a serious inconsistency or otherwise interfere with an

action taken or planned by another agency;

(3) materially alter the budgetary impact of entitlement, grants,

user fees, or loan programs or the rights and obligations of recipients

thereof; or

(4) raise novel legal or policy issues arising out of legal

mandates, the President's priorities, or the principles set forth in

the Executive Order.

It has been determined by OMB and EPA that this amendment to the

final rule is not a ``significant regulatory action'' under the terms

of Executive Order 12866 and is therefore not subject to OMB review.

B. Regulatory Flexibility Act

The Regulatory Flexibility Act, 5 U.S.C. 601-602, requires that

Federal agencies examine the impacts of their regulations on small

entities. Under 5 U.S.C. 604(a), whenever an agency is required to

publish a general notice of proposed rulemaking, it must prepare and

make available for public comment an initial regulatory flexibility

analysis (RFA). Such an analysis is not required if the head of an

agency certifies that a rule will not have a significant economic

impact on a substantial number of small entities, pursuant to 5 U.S.C.

605(b).

EPA believes that any impact that this amendment will have on the

regulated community will serve only to provide relief from otherwise

applicable regulations, and will therefore limit the negative economic

impact associated with the regulations previously promulgated under

Section 604 and 606. An examination of the impacts on small entities

was discussed in the final rule (58 FR 65018 and 58 FR 69235). That

final rule assessed the impact the rule may have on small entities. A

separate regulatory impact analysis accompanied the final rule and is

contained in Docket A-92-01. I certify that this amendment to the

accelerated phaseout rule will not have any additional negative

economic impacts on any small entities.

C. Paperwork Reduction Act

Any information collection requirements in a rule must be submitted

for approval to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) under the

Paperwork Reduction Act, 44 U.S.C. 3501 et seq. Because no additional

informational collection requirements are required by this amendment,

EPA has determined that the Paperwork Reduction Act does not apply to

this rulemaking and no new Information Collection Request document has

been prepared.

List of Subjects in 40 CFR Part 82

Environmental protection, Administrative practice and procedure,

Air pollution control, Chemicals, Chlorofluorocarbons, Exports,

Reporting and recordkeeping requirements, Stratospheric ozone layer.

Dated: December 13, 1994.

Carol Browner,

Administrator.

40 CFR Part 82 is amended as follows:

PART 82--PROTECTION OF STRATOSPHERIC OZONE

1. The authority citation for part 82 continues to read as follows:

Authority: 42 U.S.C. 7414, 7601, 7671-7671q.

Subpart A--Production and Consumption Controls

2. Section 82.9 is amended by revising paragraphs (a) introductory

text, (a)(1) and (a)(2) to read as follows:

Sec. 82.9 Availability of production allowances in addition to

baseline production allowances.

(a) Every person apportioned baseline production allowances for

class I controlled substances under Sec. 82.5 (a) through (f) is also

granted potential production allowances equal to:

(1) 10 percent of his apportionment under Sec. 82.5 for each

control period ending before January 1, 2000 (January 1, 2001 for

methyl bromide); and

(2) 15 percent of his apportionment under Sec. 82.5 for each

control period beginning after December 31, 1999, and ending before

January 1, 2011 (January 1, 2013 in the case of methyl chloroform;

except for methyl bromide which is reserved).

* * * * *

[FR Doc. 94-31232 Filed 12-19-94; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 6560-50-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.