Notice of Preliminary Determination of Sales at Less Than Fair Value and Postponement of Final Determination: Furfuryl Alcohol From the People's Republic of China

Federal RegisterDec 16, 1994

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

International Trade Administration

[A-570-835]

Notice of Preliminary Determination of Sales at Less Than Fair

Value and Postponement of Final Determination: Furfuryl Alcohol From

the People's Republic of China

AGENCY: Import Administration, International Trade Administration,

Department of Commerce.

EFFECTIVE DATE: December 16, 1994.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: John Brinkmann or Donna Berg, Office

of Antidumping Investigations, Import Administration, International

Trade Administration, U.S. Department of Commerce, 14th Street and

Constitution Avenue, NW, Washington, D.C. 20230; telephone (202) 482-

5288 or 482-0114, respectively.

Preliminary Determination

We preliminarily determine that imports of furfuryl alcohol from

the People's Republic of China (PRC) are being, or are likely to be,

sold in the United States at less than fair value, as provided in

section 733 of the Tariff Act of 1930 (the Act), as amended. The

estimated margins of sales at less than fair value are shown in the

``Suspension of Liquidation'' section of this notice.

Case History

Since the initiation of this investigation on June 20, 1994, (59 FR

32953, June 27, 1994), the following events have occurred.

On July 19, 1994, officials of the Department of Commerce (the

Department) visited the petitioner's facilities to observe the furfuryl

alcohol production process for purposes of developing the

questionnaire.

On June 21, 1994, we sent a survey to the PRC's Ministry of Foreign

Trade and Economic Cooperation (MOFTEC) and certain companies in the

PRC requesting information on production and sales of furfuryl alcohol

exported to the United States. The names of the companies were found in

the petition and in data supplied by the Port Import Export Reporting

Service (PIERS). We requested MOFTEC's assistance in forwarding the

survey to all exporters and producers of furfuryl alcohol and in

submitting complete responses on their behalf. On June 23, 1994, MOFTEC

sent us a list of exporters of furfuryl alcohol. On July 1 and 8, 1994,

we sent letters to the China Chamber of Commerce of Metals, Minerals &

Chemical Importers & Exporters (CCCMMC) for assistance in identifying

the producers and any other exporters of furfuryl alcohol. CCCMMC

provided a list of producers on July 12, 1994.

On July 15, 1994, the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC)

notified the Department of its preliminary determination that there is

a reasonable indication that an industry in the United States is

materially injured by reason of imports of furfuryl alcohol from the

PRC that are alleged to be sold at less than fair value.

The Department forwarded to MOFTEC and those PRC producers and

exporters identified in the course of this proceeding full

questionnaires on August 5, 1994. Additionally, during the month of

August 1994, the Department held a questionnaire presentation with

company officials in China.

On September 2, 1994, responses to section A of our questionnaire

were received from the following two exporters of furfuryl alcohol:

Qingdao Chemicals & Medicines Import & Export Corporation (Qingdao I&E)

and Sinochem Shandong Import & Export Group Corporation Ltd. (Sinochem

Shandong I&E). The following three manufacturers also submitted Section

A responses on September 2, 1994: Linzi Organic Chemicals Co., Ltd.

(Linzi), Shandong Zhucheng Chemical Co., Ltd. (Zhucheng), and Zibo

Gaintact Chemical Co., Ltd. (Zibo).

On September 20, 1994, we received relevant responses to the

remaining sections of our questionnaire from Qingdao I&E, Sinochem

Shandong I&E, Linzi, Zhucheng, and Zibo.

The petitioner submitted comments concerning the respondents'

questionnaire responses on September 16 and October 16, 1994.

At the request of the petitioner, on October 18, 1994, the

Department postponed its preliminary determination until no later than

December 9, 1994 (59 FR 53634, October 25, 1994).

On October 7, 1994, the respondents' counsel submitted comments

concerning surrogate country selection. The petitioner submitted its

comments on October 7 and 14, 1994.

On November 3, 1994, the Department issued supplemental

questionnaires to all producers and exporters in the investigation. The

respondents submitted responses to these questionnaires on November 21,

22, 23 and December 8, 1994.

Postponement of Final Determination

Pursuant to section 735(a)(2)(A) of the Act, on December 9, 1994,

the respondents requested that, in the event of an affirmative

preliminary determination in this investigation, the Department

postpone its final determination until 135 days after the date of

publication of an affirmative preliminary determination in the Federal

Register. Pursuant to 19 CFR 353.20(b), because our preliminary

determination is affirmative, and no compelling reasons for denial

exist, we are doing so.

Scope of the Investigation

The product covered by this investigation is furfuryl alcohol

(C4H3OCH2OH). Furfuryl alcohol is a primary alcohol, and

is colorless or a pale yellow in appearance. It is used in the

manufacture of resins and as a wetting agent and solvent for coating

resins, nitrocellulose, cellulose acetate, and other soluble dyes.

The product subject to this investigation is classifiable under

subheading 2932.13.0000 of the U.S. Harmonized Tariff Schedule (HTSUS).

Although the HTSUS subheading is provided for convenience and Customs

purposes, our written description of the scope of this investigation is

dispositive.

Period of Investigation

The period of investigation (POI) is December 1, 1993, through May

31, 1994.

Nonmarket Economy Country Status

The Department has treated the PRC as a nonmarket economy country

(NME) in all past antidumping investigations (see, e.g., Notice of

Final Determination of Sales at Less than Fair Value: Saccharin from

the PRC (59 FR 58818, November 15, 1994). No information has been

provided in this proceeding that would lead us to overturn our former

determinations. Therefore, in accordance with section 771(18)(c) of the

Act, we have treated the PRC as an NME for purposes of this

investigation.

Separate Rates

Qingdao I&E and Sinochem Shandong I&E each has requested that it be

assigned a separate, company-specific dumping margin. Their respective

business licenses each indicate that they are owned ``by all the

people.'' As stated in the Final Determination of Sales at Less than

Fair Value: Silicon Carbide from the People's Republic of China (59 FR

22585, 22586, May 2, 1994) (Silicon Carbide), ``ownership of a company

by all the people does not require the application of a single rate.''

Accordingly, these two respondents are eligible for consideration for

separate rates.

To establish whether a firm is sufficiently independent to be

entitled to a separate rate, the Department analyzes each exporting

entity under a test arising out of the Final Determination of Sales at

Less Than Fair Value: Sparklers from the People's Republic of China (56

FR 20588, May 6, 1991) (Sparklers) and amplified in Silicon Carbide.

Under the separate rates criteria, the Department assigns separate

rates only where the respondents can demonstrate the absence of both de

jure and de facto governmental control over export activities.

1. Absence of De Jure Control

The respondents in this investigation have submitted a number of

documents to demonstrate absence of de jure control. These are the

``Law of the People's Republic of China on Industrial Enterprises Owned

by the Whole People,'' adopted on April 13, 1988 (1988 Law) and

``Regulations for Transformation of Operational Mechanism of State-

Owned Industrial Enterprises,'' approved on August 23, 1992 (1992

Regulations), both of which indicate that the responsibility for

managing enterprises ``owned by all of the people'' is with the

enterprises themselves and not with the government. They have also

submitted the ``Temporary Provisions for Administration of Export

Commodities,'' approved on December 21, 1992 (Export Provisions).

The 1988 Law and 1992 Regulations shifted control from the

government to the enterprises themselves. The 1988 Law provides that

enterprises owned ``by the whole people'' shall make their own

management decisions, be responsible for their own profits and losses,

choose their own suppliers, and purchase their own goods and materials.

The 1988 Law also has other provisions which support a finding that

enterprises have management independence from the government. The 1992

Regulations provide that these same enterprises can, for example, set

their own prices (Article IX); make their own production decisions

(Article XI); use their own retained foreign exchange (Article XII);

allocate profits (Article II); sell their own products without

government interference (Article X); make their own investment

decisions (Article XIII); dispose of their own assets (Article XV); and

hire and fire their employees without government approval (Article

XVII).

The Export Provisions list those products subject to direct

government control. While furfuryl alcohol is included on the list of

commodities that are subject to export quotas, the quotas are confined

to exports to the countries of the European Community and Japan and are

not applicable to PRC exports to the United States. There is no

indication that the export prices to the United States of furfuryl

alcohol are subject to governmental control.

The existence of these enactments indicates that Qingdao I&E and

Sinochem Shandong I&E are not de jure subject to governmental control.

However, there is some evidence that the provisions of the above-cited

laws and regulations have not been implemented uniformly among

different sectors and/or jurisdictions in the PRC (see ``PRC Government

Findings on Enterprise Autonomy,'' in Foreign Broadcast Information

Service-China-93-133 (July 14, 1993)). Therefore, the Department has

determined that an analysis of de facto control is critical to

determining whether the respondents are, in fact, subject to

governmental control.

2. Absence of De Facto Control

The Department typically considers four factors in evaluating

whether each respondent is subject to de facto governmental control of

its export functions: (1) whether the export prices are set by or

subject to the approval of a governmental authority; (2) whether the

respondent has authority to negotiate and sign contracts and other

agreements; (3) whether the respondent has autonomy from the government

in making decisions regarding the selection of management; and (4)

whether the respondent retains the proceeds of its export sales and

makes independent decisions regarding disposition of profits or

financing of losses (see Silicon Carbide).

Qingdao I&E and Sinochem Shandong I&E each has asserted that (1) it

establishes its own export prices; (2) it negotiates contracts without

guidance from any governmental entities or organizations; (3) its

management operates with a high degree of autonomy and there is no

information on the record that suggests central government control over

selection of management; and (4) it retains the proceeds of its export

sales, and has the authority to sell its assets and to obtain loans. In

addition, questionnaire responses indicating that company-specific

pricing during the POI does not suggest any coordination among

exporters (i.e., the prices for comparable products differ among

companies). This information supports a preliminary finding that there

is a de facto absence of governmental control of export functions.

Consequently, Qingdao I&E and Sinochem Shandong I&E have

preliminarily met the criteria for the application of separate rates.

We will examine this issue in detail at verification and determine

whether the questionnaire responses are supported by verifiable

documentation.

Surrogate Country

Where the Department is investigating imports from an NME, section

773(c)(1) of the Act directs us to base foreign market value (FMV) on

the NME producers' factors of production, valued in a market economy

that is at a level of economic development comparable to that of the

NME under investigation and that is a significant producer of

comparable merchandise. We have done so in this case.

Section 773(c)(4) of the Act requires the Department to value the

NME producers' factors of production, to the extent possible, in one or

more market economies that (1) are at a level of economic development

comparable to that of the NME country, and (2) are significant

producers of comparable merchandise. The Department has determined that

Indonesia is the most suitable surrogate for purposes of this

investigation. Based on available statistical information, Indonesia is

at a level of economic development comparable to that of the PRC.

Further, Indonesian government statistics and other data indicate that

the country is a significant producer of the product under

investigation. Based on available information, Indonesia is the only

surrogate country, of those identified by our Office of Policy, that

meets both of these criteria. For those factors that we have been

unable to value using information from Indonesia, we have used India as

the surrogate. India is economically comparable to the PRC and is a

significant producer of furfuryl, which is comparable to furfuryl

alcohol within the meaning of section 773(c)(1). Furfuryl is the

feedstock, and the major input, in the production of furfuryl alcohol.

When a furfuryl producer sees a demand for furfuryl alcohol, the

facilities necessary to produce the furfuryl alcohol are usually added

on site. (See, memorandum to the file from Donna Lea Berg to John

Brinkmann, Surrogate Producers of Furfuryl Alcohol, dated November 22,

1994, and memorandum from David Mueller, Director, Office of Policy to

Gary Taverman, Director, Office of Antidumping Investigations, dated

August 2, 1994, Furfuryl Alcohol from the People's Republic of China,

Non-Market Economy Status and Surrogate Country Selection.)

Fair Value Comparisons

To determine whether sales of furfuryl alcohol from the PRC by

Qingdao I&E and Sinochem Shandong I&E were made at less than fair

value, we compared the United States price (USP) to FMV, as specified

in the ``United States Price'' and ``Foreign Market Value'' sections of

the notice.

United States Price

We based USP on purchase price, in accordance with section 772(b)

of the Act, because the subject merchandise was sold directly by the

Chinese exporters to unrelated parties in the United States prior to

importation into the United States.

For the two responding exporters, we calculated purchase price

based on packed, CIF U.S.-port or FOB Chinese-port prices to unrelated

purchasers in the United States. As necessary, we made deductions for

foreign inland freight, containerization, port storage, foreign

brokerage and handling expenses, and marine insurance, valued in India.

Where applicable, we made deductions for ocean freight based on rates

of a market-economy shipper. (For a complete analysis of USP

deductions, see the calculation memorandum for this proceeding on file

in Room B-099 of the Main Commerce Department building.)

Foreign Market Value

In accordance with section 773(c) of the Act, we calculated FMV

based on factors of production reported by the factories in the PRC

which produced the subject merchandise for the two responding

exporters. To calculate FMV, the reported factor quantities were

multiplied by the appropriate surrogate values from Indonesia for those

inputs purchased domestically from PRC suppliers. Where inputs were

imported from market economy countries and paid for in a market economy

currency, we used the actual costs incurred by the producers to value

those factors (see, e.g., Final Determination of Sales at Less Than

Fair Value: Oscillating Ceiling Fans From the People's Republic of

China, 56 FR 55271, October 25, 1991).

The respondents have argued that the PRC prices for the major input

in the production of furfuryl alcohol (i.e., furfuryl) are market

determined. Thus, the respondents assert that the Department should

rely on the domestic prices of furfuryl in the PRC. We disagree with

this argument and have not used the prices for these inputs in

calculating FMV. Our practice is to afford respondents the opportunity

to show that the subject merchandise is produced within a market-

oriented industry. Showing that a respondent purchases one input at a

market-determined price is relevant to but, alone, not sufficient for

granting market-oriented treatment (see e.g., Final Determination of

Sales at Less Than Fair Value: Sulfanilic Acid from the PRC, 57 FR

29705, July 6, 1992).

In determining which surrogate value to use for each factor of

production that was not sourced from a market-economy country, we

selected, where possible, from publicly available, published

information that is: (1) an average non-export value; (2)

representative of a range of prices within the POI if submitted by an

interested party, or most contemporaneous with the POI; (3) product-

specific; and (4) tax-exclusive.

With the exception of corn cobs and furfuryl, we used Indonesian

import prices taken from the Indonesian Foreign Trade Statistical

Bulletin--Imports, November 1993. For furfuryl and corn cobs, we relied

on a December 5, 1994, U.S. State Department cable from the U.S.

Embassy in Indonesia. We were unable to find public information on corn

cobs. In the case of furfuryl, the publicly available data that we

found was inconsistent (see attachment three of the concurrence

memorandum to this proceeding).

We used Indonesian transportation rates taken from a September 18,

1991, U.S. State Department cable from the U.S. Embassy in Indonesia to

value inland freight between the source of the production factor and

the furfuryl alcohol factories. In those cases where the respondent

failed to provide any information on transportation distances and

modes, we applied, as the best information available, the furthest

distance and the more expensive mode of transport available from the

surrogate information we had selected.

To value electricity, we used public information from Electric

Utilities Data Book for the Asian and Pacific Region, (January 1993)

published by the Asian Development Bank. For other energy inputs, we

relied on values for Indonesia published in Energy Detente, and

Indonesian Foreign Trade Statistical Bulletin--Imports, November 1993.

To value labor amounts, we used labor rates published by the Bureau

of International Labor Affairs, U.S. Department of Labor, in Foreign

Labor Trends--Indonesia, 1994.

We adjusted the factor values, when necessary, to the POI using

wholesale price and consumer price indices published by the

International Monetary Fund.

To value factory overhead, we calculated percentages specific to

the furfuryl alcohol industry based on a December 2, 1994, U.S. State

Department cable from the U.S. Embassy in Jakarta.

For general expense percentages, we used the statutory minimum of

10 percent of materials, labor, and overhead costs calculated for each

factory. For profit we used the statutory minimum of eight percent of

materials, labor, factory overhead, and general expenses. We did not

have Indonesian values for either general expenses or profit.

We added packing based on Indonesian values obtained from a

December 2, 1994 U.S. State Department cable from the U.S. Embassy in

Jakarta.

All Other Rate

MOFTEC and CCCMMC have identified two PRC exporters of furfuryl

alcohol to the United States during the POI. Both have responded in

this investigation. Accordingly, we have based the All Other Rate on

the weighted average of the margins calculated in this proceeding.

Verification

As provided in section 776(b) of the Act, we will verify

information used in making our final determination.

Suspension of Liquidation

In accordance with section 733(d)(1) of the Act, we are directing

the Customs Service to suspend liquidation of all entries of furfuryl

alcohol from the PRC, as defined in the ``Scope of the Investigation''

section of this notice, that are entered, or withdrawn from warehouse,

for consumption on or after the date of publication of this notice in

the Federal Register. The Customs Service shall require a cash deposit

or posting of a bond equal to the estimated dumping margins, as shown

below. This suspension of liquidation will remain in effect until

further notice. The weighted-average dumping margins are as follows:

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Margin

Manufacture/producer/exporter percent

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Qingdao I&E................................................ 109.34

Sinochem Shandong I&E...................................... 85.88

All Others................................................. 91.82

------------------------------------------------------------------------

ITC Notification

In accordance with section 733(f) of the Act, we have notified the

ITC of our determination. If our final determination is affirmative,

the ITC will determine before the later of 120 days after the date of

the preliminary determination or 45 days after our final determination

whether imports of the subject merchandise are materially injuring, or

threaten material injury to, the U.S. industry.

Public Comment

Interested parties who wish to request a hearing must submit a

written request to the Assistant Secretary for Import Administration,

U.S. Department of Commerce, Room B-099, within ten days of the

publication of this notice.

Requests should contain: (1) the party's name, address, and

telephone number; (2) the number of participants; and (3) a list of the

issues to be discussed.

In accordance with 19 CFR 353.38, case briefs or other written

comments in at least ten copies must be submitted to the Assistant

Secretary no later than March 27, 1995, and rebuttal briefs no later

than March 30, 1995. A hearing, if requested, will be held on Monday,

April 3, 1995, at 2:00 pm at the U.S. Department of Commerce in Room

1414. Parties should confirm by telephone the time, date, and place of

the hearing 48 hours prior to the scheduled time. In accordance with 19

CFR 353.38(b), oral presentations will be limited to issues raised in

the briefs.

We will make our final determination not later than 135 days after

the signing of this preliminary determination.

This determination is published pursuant to section 733(f) of the

Act and 19 CFR 353.15(a)(4).

Dated: December 9, 1994.

Susan G. Esserman,

Assistant Secretary for Import Administration.

[FR Doc. 94-30982 Filed 12-15-94; 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3510-DS-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.