Preliminary Determination of Sales at Less Than Fair Value and Postponement of Final Determination: Pure Magnesium From Ukraine

Federal RegisterNov 7, 1994

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE

International Trade Administration

[A-823-806]

Preliminary Determination of Sales at Less Than Fair Value and

Postponement of Final Determination: Pure Magnesium From Ukraine

AGENCY: Import Administration, International trade Administration,

Department of Commerce.

EFFECTIVE DATE: November 7, 1994.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Ellen Grebasch or Erik Warga, Office of Antidumping Investigations,

Import Administration, International Trade Administration, U.S.

Department of Commerce, 14th Street and Constitution Avenue NW.,

Washington, DC 20230; telephone: (202) 482-3773 or (202) 482-0922,

respectively.

PRELIMINARY DETERMINATION: We preliminarily determine that imports of

pure magnesium from Ukraine are being, or are likely to be, sold in the

Untied States at less than fair value (``LTFV''), as provided in

section 733 of the Tariff Act of 1930, as amended (``the Act''). The

estimated margins are shown in the ``Suspension of Liquidation''

section of this notice.

Case History

Since the initiation of this investigation on April 20, 1994, (59

FR 21748, April 26, 1994), the following events have occurred.

On May 16, 1994, the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC)

notified the Department of Commerce (the Department) of its preliminary

determination that there is a reasonable indication that an industry in

the United States is materially injured, or threatened with material

injury, by reason of imports of pure magnesium from Ulkraine. The ITC

also determined in the companion investigation of alloy magnesium from

Ukraine that there is not a likelihood that a U.S. domestic industry is

materially injured, or threatened with material injury, by reason of

imports of alloy magnesium from Ukraine, thereby terminating that

investigation.

On June 13, 1994, we sent the antidumping questionnaire to the

Ukrainian Embassy and the two Ukrainian manufacturers of pure

magnesium, Concern Chlorvinyl and Zaporozhye Titanium and Magnesium

Plant. (The antidumping questionnaire was divided into three sections:

section A requesting general information on each company; section C

requesting information on, and a listing of, U.S. sales made during the

period of investigation (``POI''); and, section D requesting

information on the production process, including specific amounts of

each input used in manufacturing pure magnesium.) We requested the

Embassy's assistance in forwarding the questionnaire to all exporters

and producers of pure magnesium from Ukraine and submitting complete

questionnaire responses on their behalf.

On August 8, 1994, the Department postponed its preliminary

determination until October 27, 1994 (59 FR 42200, August 17, 1994).

On August 10, 1994, the Department provided interested parties with

the opportunity to submit published, publicly-available information for

consideration in valuing factor inputs. Petitioners submitted

information on September 7, 1994; respondents submitted information on

September 22, 1994.

Respondent Selection

In addition to sending the Ukrainian Embassy the questionnaire, the

Department independently attempted to identify other possible exporters

of Ukrainian pure magnesium to the United States during the POI based

on information obtained from petitioners, and through examination of

PIERS data and other sources of information. Our efforts consisted of

issuing an August 8, 1994, survey requesting information on exports to

the United States of the subject merchandise; issuing the antidumping

questionnaires (limited to Sections A and C) to trading companies

operating in various European countries (on August 19, September 7, and

September 13, 1994); and a September 15, 1994, follow-up letter to

unresponsive questionnaire recipients.

We sent either the survey, the questionnaire, or both documents to

56 companies, with the following results.

Two companies, Gerald Metals and MG Metals, provided

responses to Sections A and C of the questionnaire.

Twenty-five other companies, meanwhile, indicated that

they did not export the subject merchandise to the United States during

the POI. The companies that did not export were Intreid; Kemokomplex;

Nobel Trading; Raba Company; Alamet; Compagnie de Mines et Metals;

Expromptorg; Fred Lonner & Co., Inc.; Metal Exchange Corporation;

Minmeta S.A., Minmetals Canada, Inc.; Scandinavian Steel AB; Stena

Metall Atervinning AB; Sinex AG; Maks Trade Kft.; Sassoon Metals and

Chemicals; Seleb; Weko Food Trading; IMEX Consulting Sprl; W&O

Bergmann; Steinweg Handelsveem; A. Hartrodt; C. Steinweg Handelsveem

B.V.; J. Oosterom & Zoom; and Siegfried Kahn AG.

Seven companies indicated that they were related to

companies who had provided information as to whether or not they had

made U.S. sales.

Eighteen companies provided either no response or an

inadequate response. The Department received no response from the

following 16 contacted companies: Derek Raphael & Co. Ltd.; Marco

Trading; Wogen Group Ltd.; Alex; Mages; and 11 other companies whose

names cannot be disclosed in this notice because their identities has

been deemed business proprietary information. We have designated these

11 companies as companies ``A'' through ``K'' in the ``Suspension of

Liquidation'' section of this notice, below. We will, however, identify

them to the Customs Service for enforcement of this determination.

Additionally, F&S and Alusuisse-Lonza indicated that they made POI

sales to the United States, but provided inadequate responses to our

requests for information.

Finally, surveys or questionnaires sent to four companies

were returned as undeliverable.

From July to October 1994, the Department received responses to

sections A and D from Concern Chlorvinyl, which indicated that it had

made no sales of the subject merchandise directly to the United States

during the POI. Zaporozhye responded to section A but did not reply to

subsequent deficiency letters.

During September and October 1994, the Department also requested

clarifications of the information submitted by Concern Chlorvinyl,

Gerald Metals, MG Metals, and Alusuisse-Lonza. Alusuisse-Lonza did not

respond to the supplemental request. Because of the deadlines

established for responses to these supplemental requests, certain

information submitted by Gerald Metals and MG Metals was not considered

for this preliminary determination.

Postponement of Final Determination

Pursuant to section 735(a)(2)(A) of the Act, on October 24, 1994,

Gerald Metals, a reseller accounting for a significant proportion of

the merchandise in this proceeding, requested that, in the event of an

affirmative preliminary determination in this investigation, the

Department postpone the final determination to 135 days after the date

of publication of the affirmative preliminary determination in the

Federal Register. Concern Chlorvinyl, a producer accounting for a

significant proportion of merchandise in this proceeding, made a

similar request on October 26, 1994. Therefore, we are postponing the

final determination until the 135th day after the publication of this

notice in the Federal Register.

Scope of Investigation

The product covered by this investigation is pure primary

magnesium, regardless of chemistry, form or size, unless expressly

excluded from the scope of this investigation. Primary magnesium is a

metal or alloy containing by weight primarily the element magnesium and

produced by decomposing raw materials into magnesium metal.

Pure primary magnesium encompasses all products that contain at

least 99.95% primary magnesium, by weight (generally referred to as

``ultra-pure'' magnesium), as well as products containing less than

99.95% but not less than 99.8% primary magnesium, by weight (generally

referred to as ``pure'' magnesium). Products that have the

aforementioned primary magnesium content, but that do not conform to

ASTM specifications or other industry or customer-specific

specifications, are included in the scope of this investigation.

Pure primary magnesium is cast and sold in various physical forms

and sizes, including ingots, slabs, rounds, billets and other shapes.

Excluded from the scope of this investigation are primary magnesium

anodes, granular primary magnesium (including turnings and powder), and

secondary magnesium.

Granular magnesium, turnings, and powder are currently classifiable

under Harmonized Tariff Schedule of the United States (HTSUS)

subheading 8104.30.00. Magnesium granules and turnings (also referred

to as chips) are produced by grinding and/or crushing primary magnesium

and thus have the same chemistry as primary magnesium. Although not

susceptible to precise measurement because of their irregular shapes,

turnings or chips are typically produced in coarse shapes and have

maximum length of less than 1 inch. Although sometimes produced in

larger sizes, granules are more regularly shaped than turnings or

chips, and have a typical size of 2 mm in diameter or smaller.

Powders are also produced from grinding and/or crushing primary

magnesium and have the same chemistry as primary magnesium, but are

even smaller than granules or turnings. Powders are defined by the

Section Notes to Section XV, the section of the HTSUS in which

subheading 8104.30.00 appears, as products of which 90 percent or more

by weight will pass through a sieve having a mesh aperture of 1 mm.

(See HTSUS, Section XV, Base Metals and Articles of Base Metals, Note

6(b).) Accordingly, the exclusion of magnesium turnings, granules and

powder from the scope includes products having a maximum physical

dimension (i.e., length or diameter) of 1 inch or less.

The products subject to this investigation are currently

classifiable under subheadings 8104.11.00 and 8104.20.00 of the HTSUS.

Although the HTSUS subheadings are provided for convenience and customs

purposes, our written description of the scope is dispositive.

Nonmarket Economy Status

Ukraine has been treated as a nonmarket economy (``NME'') country

in all past antidumping proceedings (see, e.g., Final Determination of

Sales at Less Than Fair Value: Uranium from Ukraine (58 FR 36640, July

8, 1993)). No information has been provided in this proceeding that

would lead us to overturn this designation. Therefore, in accordance

with section 771(18)(c) of the Act, we have treated Ukraine as an NME

for purposes of this investigation.

Period of Investigation

The POI is October 1, 1993, through March 31, 1994.

Fair Value Comparisons

A. Participating Respondents

To determine whether sales by Gerald Metals and MG Metals of pure

magnesium from Ukraine to the United States were made at less than fair

value, we compared the United States price (``USP'') to the foreign

market value (``FMV''), as specified in the ``United States Price'' and

``Foreign Market Value'' sections of this notice.

B. Non-Participating Respondents

All companies to which a questionnaire was issued are considered

mandatory respondents in this proceeding. We consider those mandatory

respondents that did not respond to the questionnaire to be

uncooperative respondents and have based the less-than-fair-value

margin for those companies on the best information available (``BIA'').

We consider the following companies to be uncooperative respondents:

Alusuisse-Lonza; Derek Raphael & Co. Ltd.; Marco Trading; Wogen Group

Ltd.; Alex; Mages; F&S; and the 11 companies whose names cannot be

disclosed because their identities are deemed business proprietary

information. Accordingly, we have based these companies' LTFV margin on

an uncooperative BIA rate.

In determining what to use as BIA, the Department follows a two-

tiered methodology, whereby the Department normally assigns lower

margins to those respondents that cooperated in an investigation and

margins based on more adverse assumptions for those respondents which

did not cooperate in an investigation. As outlined in the Final

Determination of Sales at Less Than Fair Value; Certain Hot-Rolled

Carbon Steel Flat Products, Certain Cold-Rolled Carbon Steel Flat

Products, and Certain Cut-to-Length Carbon Steel Plate From Belgium, 58

FR 37083 (July 9, 1993), when a company refuses to provide the

information requested in the form required, or otherwise significantly

impedes the Department's investigation, it is appropriate for the

Department to assign to that company the higher of (a) the highest

margin alleged in the petition, or (b) the highest calculated rate of

any respondent in the investigation. Here, since these companies failed

to respond to our questionnaire, we are deeming them uncooperative and

are assigning them a BIA margin of 53.99 percent. This margin

represents the highest margin in the petition, as recalculated by the

Department at the time of the initiation to account for errors in

arithmetic and/or methodology.

C. All Other Companies

We are basing the LTFV margins for all other companies, including

those companies which reported that they did not sell the subject

merchandise to the United States during the POI, on a simple average of

the rates calculated for the mandatory respondents, including rates

based on BIA but excluding zero and de minimis margins, if any.

United States Price

We based USP on purchase price sales, in accordance with section

772(b) of the Act, because the subject merchandise was sold directly by

the exporters to unrelated parties in the United States prior to

importation into the United States and because exporter's sales price

methodology was not indicated by other circumstances.

For those exporters that responded to the Department's

questionnaire, we calculated purchase price based on packed, CIF or FOB

foreign-port prices to unrelated purchasers in the United States. In

addition, for CIF prices, we made the following deductions (where

appropriate): for MG Metals, we deducted foreign brokerage, ocean

freight, marine insurance, U.S. duty, U.S. inland freight, U.S. inland

insurance and U.S. brokerage and repacking cost; for Gerald Metals, we

deducted foreign brokerage, ocean freight, U.S. Duty, U.S. inland

freight, U.S. insurance and U.S. brokerage.

From each exporter's U.S. price, we calculated and then deducted

foreign inland freight between the factory and the reported

intermediate destination. We based our calculation on the per-ton

foreign inland freight amount reported in the petition as best

information available because the exporters failed to report

information on this area in their questionnaire responses.

Foreign Market Value

A. Surrogate Country Selection

In accordance with section 773(c)(4) of the Act, we must, to the

extent possible, value the factors of production in one or more market

economy countries that (1) are at a level of economic development

comparable to that of the non-market economy country, and (2) are

significant producers of comparable merchandise. There are no countries

economically comparable to Ukraine that are significant producers of

magnesium. Accordingly, we considered as potential surrogates countries

that are economically comparable that produce comparable merchandise.

In these investigations, we have determined that aluminum should be

considered comparable merchandise. Although the material inputs used to

produce magnesium and aluminum are different, according to both U.S.

Bureau of Mines and Department of Commerce experts, aluminum is

comparable to magnesium in that both (1) are light metals in terms of

molecular weight; (2) are electricity-intensive products; (3) are

produced using an electrolytic process, and (4) share some common end

uses (e.g., dye casting).

We have determined that Indonesia and Egypt are both economically

comparable to Ukraine (see October 21, 1994, Memorandum from the Office

of Policy to the File.) In addition, both countries are significant

producers of aluminum. Because we were able to obtain more information

from Indonesia than from Egypt, we have used Indonesia as our primary

surrogate. However, we have resorted to Egypt for certain surrogate

values where values in Indonesia were either unavailable or out of

date. We have obtained and relied upon published, publicly available

information, wherever possible.

B. Factors of Production

In accordance with section 773(c)(1), we used factors of production

as the fair value benchmark for the U.S. price of sales of Concern

Chlorvinyl-produced merchandise by Gerald Metals and MG Metals. In the

case of U.S. sales of Zaporozhye-produced merchandise for which we did

not receive factors of production data, a BIA margin was assigned using

the higher of (a) the highest adjusted alleged margin cited in our

initiation notice or (b) the highest margin calculated for a sale of

Concern Chlorvinyl-produced merchandise. The factors used to produce

pure magnesium include materials, labor, and energy. To calculate FMV,

the reported quantities were multiplied by the appropriate surrogate

values for the different inputs. (For a complete analysis of surrogate

values, see our calculation memorandum.) We then added amounts for

factor overhead, general expenses and profit, the cost of containers

and coverings, and other expenses incident to placing the merchandise

in condition packed and ready for shipment to the United States.

To value the raw materials, we used publicly available information

from Indonesia in the UN Trade Commodity Statistics (``UN Trade

Statistics'') for January through December 1993 and the 1992 Indonesia

Foreign Trade Statistics. No adjustment for inflation was necessary

since the 1993 UN Trade Statistics for Indonesia reported data for a

portion of the POI. For values taken from Indonesian Foreign Trade

Statistics, we made appropriate adjustments to account for inflation.

For one energy input, we used data from the 1992 UN Trade Statistics

for Egypt since the unit value from the 1993 UN Trade Statistics for

Indonesia was based on an extremely small quantity and appeared to be

aberrational. The 1992 Egyptian value for this input was inflated to

the POI. For one raw material, we used information from the petition as

best available information because we were unable to find a value in

either Indonesia or Egypt.

To adjust material input values to account for source-to-factory

freight, we used Indonesia freight rates from a 1991 cable from the

U.S. Embassy in Jakarta. (See Final Determination of Sales at Less Than

Fair Value: Certain Carbon Steel Butt-Weld Pipe Fittings from the

People's Republic of China (57 FR 21058, May 18, 1992).

To value labor amounts for production and packing, we used labor

data for Egypt, as reported in the International Labor Office's 1993

Yearbook of Labor Statistics because the labor value available for

Egypt was more up-to-date (1987) than was the labor value available for

Indonesia (1986). We adjusted labor wage rates to account for inflation

using world price indices for Egypt as reported in the International

Monetary Funds' International Financial Statistics (IFS).

To value heavy oil and diesel fuel, we used 1993 data for Indonesia

from the Energy Information Administration's International Energy

Annual. Although we are unable to adjust these values for taxes

included in the published prices, they are the only data found for

heavy oil and diesel fuel in Indonesia.

To value electricity, we used information for Indonesia from the

Asian Development Bank's 1993 Electric Utilities Data Book for Asian

and Pacific Region.

Because we were unable to find surrogate values for factory

overhead from either Indonesia or Egypt, we used factory overhead rates

from the petition.

We used the statutory minima of ten percent for selling, general

and administrative expenses and eight percent for profit because no

surrogate country information reflected percentages for those amounts

that were above the statutory minima.

To value packing materials, we used data from the 1993 UN Trade

Statistics for Indonesia. Because information for certain packing

materials was incompletely reported, we were unable to calculate a unit

factor value for these materials. Therefore, we included data from the

petition to account for the cost of these packing materials.

Verification

As provided in section 776(b) of the Act, we will verify all

information determined to be acceptable for use in making our final

determination.

Suspension of Liquidation

In accordance with section 733(d)(1) of the Act, we are directing

the Customs Service to suspend liquidation of all imports of the

subject merchandise that are entered, or withdrawn from warehouse, from

consumption on or after the date of publication of this notice in the

Federal Register. The Customs Service shall require a cash deposit or

posting of a bond equal to the estimated amount by which the FMV

exceeds the USP as shown below. We will also inform Customs of the

identities of those companies, identified below by a code letter, whose

names we are unable to disclose. These suspension of liquidation

instructions will remain in effect until further notice.

The weighted-average dumping margins are as follows:

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Weighted-

average

Manufacturer/producer/exporter margin

percentage

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gerald Metals............................................... 52.21

MG Metals................................................... 36.05

Alusuisse Lonza............................................. 53.99

Derek Raphael & Co., Ltd.................................... 53.99

Marco Trading............................................... 53.99

Wogen Group Ltd............................................. 53.99

Alex........................................................ 53.99

Mages....................................................... 53.99

F&S......................................................... 53.99

Company A................................................... 53.99

Company B................................................... 53.99

Company C................................................... 53.99

Company D................................................... 53.99

Company E................................................... 53.99

Company F................................................... 53.99

Company G................................................... 53.99

Company H................................................... 53.99

Company I................................................... 53.99

Company J................................................... 53.99

Company K................................................... 53.99

All Others.................................................. 53.00

------------------------------------------------------------------------

ITC Notification

In accordance with section 733(f) of the Act, we have notified the

ITC of our determination. If our final determination is affirmative,

the ITC will determine before the later of 120 days after the date of

this preliminary determination or 45 days after our final determination

whether these imports are materially injuring, or threaten material

injury to, the U.S. industry.

Public Comment

In accordance with 19 CFR 353.38, case briefs or other written

comments in at least ten copies must be submitted to the Assistant

Secretary for Import Administration no later than February 10, 1995,

and rebuttal briefs, no later than February 17, 1995. In accordance

with 19 CFR 353.38(b), we will hold a public hearing, if requested, to

afford interested parties an opportunity to comment on arguments raised

in case or rebuttal briefs. Tentatively, the hearing will be held on

February 21, 1995, at 10:00 a.m. at the U.S. Department of Commerce,

Room 3708, 14th Street and Constitution Avenue, NW., Washington, DC

20230. Parties should confirm by telephone the time, date, and place of

the hearing 48 hours before the scheduled time.

Interested parties who wish to request a hearing, or to participate

if one is requested, must submit a written request to the Assistant

Secretary for Import Administration, U.S. Department of Commerce, Room

B-099, within ten days of the publication of this notice. Requests

should contain: (1) The party's name, address, and telephone number;

(2) the number of participants; and (3) a list of the issues to be

discussed. In accordance with 19 CFR 353.38(b), oral presentations will

be limited to issues raised in the briefs. If this investigation

proceeds normally, we will make our final determination by the 135th

day after the date of publication of the affirmative preliminary

determination in the Federal Register.

This determination is published pursuant to section 733(f) of the

Act and 19 CFR 353.15(a)(4).

Dated: October 27, 1994.

Susan G. Esserman,

Assistant Secretary for Import Administration.

[FR Doc. 94-27435 Filed 11-4-94, 8:45 am]

BILLING CODE 3510-PS-P

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.