Accreditation, Innovation, and Modernization: The Secretary's Recognition of Accrediting Agencies: Institutional Eligibility Under the Higher Education Act of 1965, as Amended, Student Assistance General Provisions
Federal RegisterAug 20, 2026
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
34 CFR Parts 600, 602, and 668
[Docket ID ED-2025-OPE-1042]
RIN 1840-AD82
Accreditation, Innovation, and Modernization: The Secretary's Recognition of Accrediting Agencies: Institutional Eligibility Under the Higher Education Act of 1965, as Amended, Student Assistance General Provisions
AGENCY:
Office of Postsecondary Education, Department of Education.
ACTION:
Notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM).
SUMMARY:
The Department proposes to revise the existing accrediting agency recognition regulations at 34 CFR part 602 to implement the directives set forth in Executive Order 14279, Reforming Accreditation to Strengthen Higher Education, and other Administration priorities, align the regulations more closely with statute, and reduce regulatory burden.
DATES:
We must receive your comments on or before September 21, 2026.
ADDRESSES:
Submit your comments through the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
regulations.gov.
The Department will not accept comments submitted by fax or by email or comments submitted after the comment period closes. To ensure that the Department does not receive duplicate copies, please submit your comment only once. Additionally, please include the Docket ID at the top of your comments. Pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act at 5 U.S.C. 553(b)(4), a plain language summary of the rule is available at
regulations.gov
.
Information on using
Regulations.gov
, including instructions for submitting comments, is available on the site under “FAQ.” If you require an accommodation or cannot otherwise submit your comments via
Regulations.gov
, please contact
regulationshelpdesk@gsa.gov
or by phone at 1-866-498-2945. If you are deaf, hard of hearing, or have a speech disability and wish to access telecommunications relay services, please dial 7-1-1.
Privacy Note:
The Department's policy is to make all comments received from members of the public available for public viewing in their entirety on the Federal eRulemaking website at
www.regulations.gov.
Therefore, commenters should include in their comments only information that they wish to make publicly available. Additionally, commenters should not include in their comments any personally identifiable information (PII) about other individuals. For example, if your comment describes an experience of someone other than yourself, please do not identify that individual or include any personal information that identifies that individual. The Department reserves the right to redact a portion of a comment or the entire comment at any time if PII about other individuals is included.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Aaron Washington, Office of Postsecondary Education, 400 Maryland Ave. SW, Washington, DC 20202. Telephone: 202-987-0911. Email:
aaron.washington@ed.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Executive Summary
The Secretary of Education recognizes accrediting agencies currently under existing regulations at 34 CFR part 602. Accrediting agencies serve as key gatekeepers in determining which institutions may participate in the Federal student aid programs, which currently provide more than $100 billion in Pell Grants and Federal student loans annually. Unfortunately, while the existing regulations are intended to ensure that the accrediting agencies recognized by the Secretary are “reliable authorities regarding the quality of education or training offered by the institutions or programs they accredit,” many are failing to do so and recognize institutions and programs that fail some of the most important indicia of quality and returns on investment, hurting students and taxpayers. Amidst this decline in student outcomes, some accrediting agencies have neglected their positions of public trust, improperly shifting their focus away from student achievement to compelling institutions to adopt illegal and discriminatory ideology and practices, and intruding on State and local authority over public institutions. All of this has been done under the guise of establishing and applying accreditation standards on institutions and programs.
As a result, Americans' trust and confidence in the U.S. higher education system has declined significantly over the last decade. Americans deserve and demand better. To that end, and to ensure that accrediting agencies are taking their responsibilities as quality indicators seriously, the Department is therefore proposing a comprehensive modernization of the regulations for recognition of accrediting agencies, one that focuses on student achievement and providing a high-quality education.
The proposed regulations would break down barriers that have long held back institutions from adopting innovative and cost-effective educational models. The proposed regulations would eliminate requirements not required by statute, including the “two-year rule” for initial recognition of new agencies, prescriptive site visit mandates, unnecessary documentation requirements, and rigid and overly long processing timelines. These commonsense reforms would also remove existing regulatory barriers impeding institutions' ability to change or work with multiple accrediting agencies, while agencies would have more flexibility to apply certain standards that meet the needs of their accredited institutions and programs. The Department also proposes a new review framework for better oversight of recognized accrediting agencies that serve as the primary gatekeepers for the Federal student aid programs, and whose potential failures pose the greatest risk to taxpayers.
Additionally, in order to reduce administrative costs that are negatively impacting college affordability, the Department is proposing to require recognized accrediting agencies to apply their standards in ways that minimize institutional administrative burden, avoid duplicative reporting, and support the implementation of lower-cost educational models. These changes would also shift institutions' and programs' focus towards cost-effective practices for staffing, facilities, student services, and program design.
The proposed regulations promote greater integrity in decision making by recognized accrediting agencies and eliminate previous regulatory exceptions for resource-sharing and other areas of potential conflicts of interest. The proposed regulations would also take the final step to eliminating geographic-scope distinctions and make other anticompetitive behavior a negative factor in consideration of agency recognition.
The Department proposes to reinforce the existing legal, constitutional, civil rights, and consumer protection obligations already required of recognized accrediting agencies and the institutions and programs that they accredit. Accrediting agencies recognized by the Secretary would be required to confirm that institutions and programs they accredit comply with all Federal and State laws and would prevent recognized accrediting agencies from applying standards that direct accredited institutions and programs to
violate those laws. New student outcome and program-level performance expectations would focus accrediting agencies on important objective measures of student and institution performance such as completion, licensure pass rates, and economic returns.
Further, the proposed regulations also address persistent issues with transfer of credit policies, ensuring that students are not required to undertake duplicative coursework when not necessary. While institutions and programs would have the latitude to deny a transfer of credit based on the credit failing to meet the institutions' standards, schools would have to provide written reasoning for the denial. These regulations also propose to require more transparency before a student enrolls, so he or she can have a full understanding of the scope, and cost, of the education.
Taken together, these proposed regulations aim to improve educational quality, protect students and taxpayers, and promote a higher education accreditation system that supports innovation, accountability, and legal compliance.
II. Summary of the Major Provisions of This Regulatory Action
The proposed regulations would:
Part 600—Institutional Eligibility Under the Higher Education Act of 1965, as Amended
Subpart A—General
• Amend § 600.11 to make it less burdensome for institutions that are changing accrediting agencies or wish to utilize more than one accrediting agency.
• Amend § 602.2 to require the Department provide public notice on its accreditation website if the Secretary denies continued recognition to a previously recognized agency, or if the Secretary limits, suspends, or terminates the agency's recognition before the end of its recognition period.
• Amend § 602.3 to define and use the term “institution” in these regulations instead of “institution of higher education” which is defined in the HEA, and elsewhere in the Department's regulations, and refers to a narrower subset of institutions, and to add a definition for “related, associated, or affiliated trade association.”
Subpart B—The Criteria for Recognition
• Amend § 602.10 to clarify the Secretary's recognition extends only to those accrediting agencies whose institutions or programs actively participate in a Federal program.
• Amend § 602.11 to require accrediting agencies to clearly describe the scope of their accrediting activities and remove geographic restrictions that restrict institutions and programs from choosing an accrediting agency.
• Amend § 602.12 to remove references to geographic areas and geographic constraints and require review of contractions of scope. Additionally, amends the regulations to clarify the policies and capacity an accrediting agency must have to seek initial recognition, and eliminates the “two-year rule” for initial recognition due to lack of statutory requirement.
• Unreserve and amend § 602.13 to specify that an accrediting agency's recognition by the Department does not provide any immunity from antitrust laws.
• Amend § 602.14 to strengthen the fiscal and administrative criteria an accrediting agency must meet to prove it is fully separate and independent from any related, associated, or affiliated trade or membership organization.
• Amend § 602.15 to require accrediting agencies to administer their standards, policies, and procedures in a manner that minimizes unnecessary compliance costs and administrative burdens on accredited institutions, as well as requires agencies to maintain appropriate conflict of interest controls and policies.
• Amend § 602.16 to codify that an agency may establish additional lawful accreditation standards that are consistent with ensuring institutional or programmatic quality and integrity as it deems appropriate.
• Amend § 602.17 to clarify expectations for reviewing student achievement and faculty related policies, including academic freedom and intellectual diversity. There are also new requirements for cost-benefit analysis, institutional flexibility and mission, program length review, and safeguards against misrepresentation.
• Amend § 602.18 to require accrediting agency decisions to be neutral with respect to viewpoint and ideology, except for those with a religious mission.
• Amend § 602.20 to provide guidance to accrediting agencies on how to structure their arbitration procedures and remove overly prescriptive requirements.
• Amend § 602.21 to remove overly prescriptive requirements.
• Amend § 602.22 to refine the list of changes requiring accreditor approval, add prison education programs as a defined substantive change, and remove outdated and overly prescriptive requirements.
• Amend § 602.23 to require accrediting agencies to ensure institutions comply with all applicable Federal and State laws and remove overly prescriptive requirements.
• Amend § 602.24 to strengthen accrediting agencies' oversight of institutional changes, expand requirements for teach-out planning, including transcript access, and increase transparency and support for students when institutions face disruptions. These regulations would also establish clearer, fairer rules by defining consistent criteria, prohibiting discriminatory denials, requiring acceptance of comparable credits, and providing students with an appeals process.
• Amend § 602.25 to remove overly prescriptive requirements.
• Amend § 602.26 to update and modernize the required content of agency notices and better align these requirements with contemporary methods of disclosure and allow temporary continuation of eligibility for title IV, HEA funds after erroneous decisions on the part of the accrediting agency.
• Amend § 602.27 to require the Department's website to be updated on a regular, timely basis to display the current accreditation status of all institutions and programs.
• Amend § 602.28 to broaden the circumstances under which an accrediting agency must re-evaluate an institution or program following negative actions by other authorities.
• Amend § 602.30 to modernize how accrediting agencies submit applications and reports to the Department.
Subpart C—The Recognition Process
• Amend § 602.32 and split it into two sections: § 602.31 and § 602.32.
• Amend § 602.31 to modernize and streamline the procedures accrediting agencies must follow when submitting applications for initial or renewed recognition.
• Amend § 602.32 to modernize and clarify the processes used to review an accrediting agency's expansions or contractions of scope, compliance reports, and increases in headcount enrollment.
• Amend § 602.33 to modernize and streamline the procedures for review of agencies during the period of recognition, including the review of monitoring reports.
• Amend § 602.34 to require the National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity (NACIQI) to review applications for
contractions of scope, and for accrediting agencies to post public notice of upcoming NACIQI reviews.
• Amend §§ 602.35, 602.36, and 602.37 to update cross references.
Part 668—Student Assistance General Provisions
Subpart D—Institutional and Financial Assistance Information for Students
• Amend § 668.43 to require transfer of credit disclosures and direct written notice to students.
Cost and Benefits
As further detailed in the Regulatory Impact Analysis (RIA), the proposed regulations include numerous provisions that may impact students, institutions of higher education, accrediting agencies, and the Federal government. The proposed regulations include provisions related to transfer-of-credit policies, which may benefit students by making it easier for students to transfer credits to continue their postsecondary enrollment at a new institution. Students will benefit from these proposed changes because they will likely spend less time and money retaking courses that failed to transfer, whereas institutions may experience costs from these provisions due to the lower levels of tuition revenue they may receive from transfer students. The proposed regulation also encourages accrediting agencies to include new criteria that evaluates program and institutional outcomes. This may impose new costs on accreditors, who may need to develop such criteria, and on institutions, who may need to implement changes to meet such criteria. Furthermore, the proposed regulations will remove several barriers for new accrediting agencies to emerge and obtain Department recognition, which may ultimately benefit accrediting agencies through the reduction in administrative burden to gain initial recognition and maintain recognition. Additionally, the proposed rule would also require accrediting agencies to adopt several new policies and procedures that aim to increase college affordability and innovation, while also putting downward pressure on credential inflation. Students may benefit from these provisions if the changes result in more affordable and flexible educational opportunities.
As noted in the RIA, the Department does not estimate a significant net budget impact on the title IV, HEA federal student aid programs from the proposed regulations. In prior regulations
1
the Department estimated the accreditation reform would result in volume increases from easier recognition of new accreditors or agencies with an expanded scope to new credential levels, and the option for alternative standards to allow for faster introduction of innovative programs. In 2019, we did not estimate a significant change in repayment performance as institutions with less favorable program outcomes could find more lenient accrediting agencies or institutions with strong programs could take advantage of the flexibility allowed by the substantive change policy revisions to expand their program offerings. At the time we noted the uncertainty of the extent to which increasing accreditation options and encouraging program innovation would shift loan and grant volume among more options for students versus generating new volume and that uncertainty remains. Additionally, greater acceptance of transfer credits may increase volumes by encouraging some students to complete degrees but also may reduce volumes by credits being recognized by the institutions receiving transfers. In retrospect, we know the number of institutions that changed accreditors was fairly low and it is difficult to attribute particular changes in volume to accreditation reforms given other economic, demographic, and programmatic developments during the same period. The Department seeks feedback on the reasonability of the estimate that the proposed regulations will not have a significant net budget impact and sources of data or analysis for further consideration of this question as we prepare the final regulations.
1
84 CFR 58834.
III. Directed Questions
§ 602.15—Administrative and Fiscal Responsibilities
Under § 602.15(e), the Department proposes to require an accrediting agency have clear and effective controls to: (1) prevent conflicts of interest, (2) ensure that members of the standards-setting body are prevented from voting as members of the decision-making body, (3) determine its dues without review from a related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization, (4) disallow shared resources, (5) ensure that the accrediting agency does not share or solicit feedback from an associated or affiliated trade association or professional association, (6) disclose on its website any relationship with related, associated, or affiliated trade associations or professional organizations and, (7) not act to restrict access to employment in a profession, occupation or vocation.
The Department seeks feedback about the extent to which the “conflict of interest” requirements impact accrediting agencies in relation to 401K, health insurance, and other areas. We understand that there may be some agencies who utilize the same resources in these certain areas, and that there may be some consideration to the amount of time and resources it would take to unwind the sharing of resources in such instances. We welcome comments from agencies that have current relationships exist between themselves and the related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional association that would be affected by the amendments to the regulations proposed here. Specifically, the Department requests information that considers the length of time it would take to unwind these benefits from a related, associated, or affiliated association.
Regulatory Impact Analysis—Data Constraints
The Department recognizes that there is limited data available to estimate the proposed regulation's potential impact on accrediting agencies, institutions of higher education, and students. Due to the scarcity of existing information, the Department invites public feedback on possible methods and data sources that could strengthen the analysis presented in the RIA. Additionally, the Department welcomes input regarding prior research on accreditation reform, especially insights on how findings from such research might further inform and support the analysis included in the RIA. The Department is particularly interested in research findings on the way that accreditation reform is associated with accreditor innovation, competition, and quality, along with any associations that reform has on student behavior and outcomes. Additionally, the Department is also interested in receiving comments regarding possible impacts not identified by the Department, along with supporting data and analysis.
IV. Invitation To Comment
We invite you to submit comments regarding these proposed regulations. For your comments to have maximum effect in developing the final regulations, we urge you to clearly identify the specific section or sections of the proposed regulations that each of your comments address and to arrange your comments in the same order as the proposed regulations. The Department
will not accept comments submitted after the comment period closes.
The following tips are meant to help you prepare your comments:
• Be concise but support your claims.
• Explain your views as clearly as possible and avoid using profanity.
• Refer to specific sections and subsections of the proposed regulations throughout your comments, particularly in any headings that are used to organize your submission.
• Explain why you agree or disagree with the proposed regulatory text and support these reasons with data-driven evidence, including the depth and breadth of your personal or professional experiences.
• Where you disagree with the proposed regulatory text, suggest alternatives, including regulatory language, and your rationale for the alternative suggestion.
• Submit your public comment only.
• Do not include personally identifiable information (PII) such as Social Security numbers or loan account numbers for yourself or for others in your submission.
• Do not include any information that directly identifies or could identify other individuals or that permits readers to identify other individuals.
Mass Writing Campaigns:
In instances where individual submissions appear to be duplicates or near duplicates of comments prepared as part of a writing campaign, the Department will post one representative sample comment along with the total comment count for that campaign to
Regulations.gov.
The Department will consider these comments along with all other comments received.
In instances where individual submissions are bundled together (submitted as a single document or packaged together), the Department will post all of the substantive comments included in the submissions along with the total comment count for that document or package to
Regulations.gov.
A well-supported comment is often more informative to the agency than multiple form letters.
Public Comments:
The Department invites you to submit comments on all aspects of the proposed regulatory language specified in this NPRM, and in the Regulatory Impact Analysis and Paperwork Reduction Act sections.
The Department may, at its discretion, decide not to post or to withdraw certain comments and other materials that contain promotion of commercial services or products, and spam.
We may not address comments outside of the scope of these proposed regulations in the final rule. Comments that are outside of the scope of these proposed regulations are comments that do not discuss the content or impact of the proposed regulations or the Department's evidence or reasons for the proposed regulations.
Comments that are submitted after the comment period closes will not be posted to
Regulations.gov
or addressed in the final rule.
We invite you to assist us in complying with the requirements of Executive Orders 12866 and 13563 and their overall requirement of reducing regulatory burden that might result from these proposed regulations. Please let us know of any further ways we could reduce potential costs or increase potential benefits while preserving the effective and efficient administration of the Department's programs and activities. During and after the comment period, you may inspect public comments about these proposed regulations by accessing
Regulations.gov.
Assistance to Individuals with Disabilities in Reviewing the Rulemaking Record:
On request, we will provide appropriate accommodation or auxiliary aid to an individual with a disability who needs assistance to review the comments or other documents in the public rulemaking record for these proposed regulations. If you want to schedule an appointment for this type of accommodation or auxiliary aid, please contact the Information Technology Accessibility Program Help Desk at
ITAPSupport@ed.gov
to help facilitate this request.
Clarity of the Regulations
Executive Order 12866 and the Presidential memorandum “Plain Language in Government Writing” require each agency to write regulations that are easy to understand. The Secretary invites comments on how to make the regulation easier to understand, including answers to questions such as the following:
• Are the requirements in the proposed regulations clearly stated?
• Do the proposed regulations contain technical terms or other wording that interferes with their clarity?
• Does the format of the proposed regulations (grouping and order of sections, use of headings, paragraphing) aid or reduce its clarity?
• Would the proposed regulations be easier to understand if we divided them into more (but shorter) sections? (A “section” is preceded by the symbol “§ ” and a numbered heading; for example, § 668.2 General definitions.)
• Could the description of the proposed regulations in the
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
section of this preamble be more helpful in making the proposed regulations easier to understand? If so, how?
• What else could we do to make the proposed regulation easier to understand?
To send any comments that concern how the Department could make these proposed regulations easier to understand, see the instructions in the
ADDRESSES
section.
V. Background
Section 496 of the Higher Education Act (HEA), as amended, requires the Secretary of Education (Secretary) to establish criteria for determining whether an accrediting agency is a reliable authority, for purposes of participation in programs authorized under the HEA and other Federal programs, on the quality of education or training offered by the institutions and programs that they accredit. Such criteria are required to include appropriate measures of student achievement.
Consistent with the statute, the Secretary has established regulations for recognition of accrediting agencies at 34 CFR part 602 and has revised these regulations periodically.
Executive Order (E.O.) 14279, titled “Reforming Accreditation to Strengthen Higher Education,” issued on April 23, 2025, by President Trump, directs the Secretary to take several actions related to the recognition of accrediting agencies or associations by the Department. Some of these actions require changes to existing regulations.
The goal of these regulatory changes is to realign the Secretary's criteria for recognition of accrediting agencies to promote high-quality, high value, and affordable education for students that—
• Promotes such academic programs and activities at higher education institutions that are focused on student outcomes and are free from unlawful discrimination and other violations of Federal law;
• Reduces barriers that limit competition, innovation, and new education models that advance credential and degree completion;
• Holds institutions accountable for discrimination and other unlawful acts; and
• Advances academic freedom, intellectual inquiry, and student learning by ensuring that accreditation requires that institutions support and prioritize intellectual diversity among faculty.
Specifically, the Executive Order directs the Secretary to—
• Resume recognition of new accrediting agencies to foster competition and expand institutional options; and
• Mandate that accrediting agencies require member institutions to use data on program-level student outcomes to improve such outcomes, without reference to race, ethnicity, or sex.
The Department undertook this rulemaking in part to address the goals contained within the Executive Order, but also to propose substantive changes that would reform the static and outdated higher education accountability system. These regulations are intended to increase competition among accrediting agencies by reducing barriers to entry, facilitating institutional mobility among recognized agencies, and reducing regulatory requirements that may unnecessarily discourage the formation of innovative accrediting organizations. Increased competition is expected to improve institutional responsiveness, reduce accreditation costs over time, and encourage greater innovation in the market for quality assurance validation.
The Department believes that increasing competition among recognized accrediting agencies is likely to improve the quality, responsiveness, and effectiveness of accreditation. Accreditation has historically seen very little competition because it evolved from voluntary membership peer review groups to set uniform academic standards within those groups. Institutional accreditors (including former “regional” accreditors) rarely engage in head-to-head competition, institutions face difficulty in changing accrediting agencies due to high switching costs and potential risks in maintaining eligibility for Federal student aid for their students, and there are regulatory barriers to the recognition of new agencies. During negotiated rulemaking, the Department explained that competition among accreditors is expected to generally improve quality and expand choices for institutions.
Competition creates incentives for agencies to innovate, respond to workforce changes, expand choices for institutions among agencies engaged in various types of innovative activities and to develop new measures for assessing student success by institutions.
As explained by a Department economist during negotiated rulemaking, there is a high concentration of institutions that are accredited by a handful of institutional accrediting agencies. The Department recognizes that empirical evidence measuring the causal effect of institutions changing accreditors is limited. Because institutions rarely switch accreditors, and those that do may differ systematically from those that do not, it is difficult to isolate the independent effect of changing accreditors on institutional outcomes. Moreover, previous regulatory barriers have resulted in too few accreditor switches to permit rigorous statistical analysis. The absence of such evidence, however, does not undermine the broader economic evidence concerning the benefits of competition in quality assurance markets.
Economic research has consistently found that competition encourages innovation and improved performance. Joseph Schumpeter argued that competition produces “creative destruction” that drives innovation by creating new markets that render older ones obsolete, while more recent empirical work has found that introducing competition into concentrated markets substantially increases innovation. The Department believes these findings are relevant because higher education accreditation has historically exhibited many characteristics of an uncompetitive market.
Competition is also expected to improve the informational value of accreditation. During negotiated rulemaking, the Department explained that institutions seek credible signals of educational quality, and that in a competitive accreditation market, agencies would compete to provide those signals. Rather than offering only a binary “approved/not approved” determination, competing accreditors may distinguish themselves by offering scaled ratings for institutional quality. On April 14, 2026, during opening remarks for negotiated rulemaking, the Department stated:
“Competition will include competition for relevance and universities will signal their quality level through accreditation . . . Current accreditors give universities and colleges pass-fail grades which provide very little useful information.”
2
2
Opening Remarks—David Barker—Assistant Secretary for the Office of Postsecondary Education—
https://www.ed.gov/media/document/2026-negotiated-rulemaking-aim-transcripts-day-2-am-113991.pdf.
This reasoning is consistent with the economic literature on certification intermediaries. In “Information Revelation and Certification Intermediaries”, Alessandro Lizzeri
3
demonstrates that monopolistic certifiers have incentives to reveal only limited information, whereas competition among certifiers results in more informative quality signals. Similarly, in “The Effect of Information on Product Quality: Evidence from Restaurant Hygiene Grade Cards” Giner Zhe Jin and Phillip Leslie
4
found that more detailed quality information improves quality outcomes.
3
“Information Revelation and Certification Intermediaries.” The RAND Journal of Economics 30, no. 2 (1999): 214-31.
https://doi.org/10.2307/2556078.
4
Ginger Zhe Jin, Phillip Leslie, “The Effect of Information on Product Quality: Evidence from Restaurant Hygiene Grade Cards.” The Quarterly Journal of Economics 118, no. 2, (2003): 409-451.
https://doi.org/10.1162/003355303321675428.
The Department also believes that competition can strengthen, rather than weaken, Federal oversight. During negotiated rulemaking, the Department explained that where only one recognized accreditor effectively serves a sector, withdrawal of recognition may significantly disrupt institutions and students making it more difficult to impose such a penalty. By contrast, when multiple recognized accreditors are available, institutions have viable alternatives, reducing barriers to enforcement. As the Department stated during negotiated rulemaking:
“With regional and programmatic monopolies, withdrawal of recognition can throw industries into chaos . . . . If alternatives are available, if competition exists, any hesitation to derecognize agencies disappears.” The Department believes competition will increase accountability both for institutions and for accrediting agencies themselves.
Finally, the Department believes that competition will encourage innovation in accreditation. Accrediting agencies that face meaningful competition will have stronger incentives to develop new approaches to quality assurance, reduce unnecessary costs, respond to institutional diversity, and improve services to institutions and students. As explained in the Department's written responses during negotiated rulemaking, barriers to switching generally reduce competition and increase market power through a lock-in effect. Eliminating or reducing those barriers promotes innovation and responsiveness.
For these reasons, the Department finds that reducing unnecessary barriers to competition among qualified accrediting agencies is likely to improve accreditation over time while preserving the Department's responsibility to establish minimum standards for Federal recognition. The Department does not believe competition will cause a “race to the bottom.” Rather, quite the opposite will likely occur. Recognized accrediting agencies must continue to satisfy all statutory and regulatory
recognition requirements, while competing to provide higher quality, more informative, and more innovative quality assurance services. As stated during negotiated rulemaking, “We shouldn't fear healthy competition. It is the basis of a free market economy, and we need more of it in the coddled, protected business of higher education.”
VI. Authority for This Regulatory Action
The authority for this rulemaking is Section 496 of the HEA. Section 496(a) of the HEA provides criteria that an accrediting agency must meet for the Secretary to recognize it as a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered. The same section states that the Secretary shall, after notice and opportunity for a hearing, establish criteria for such determinations.
Section 496(o) of the HEA directs the Secretary to establish, through regulation, procedures governing the recognition of accrediting agencies and the appeal of recognition decisions. At the same time, Congress provided that the Secretary shall not promulgate regulations with respect to the standards of an accrediting agency described in Section 496(a)(5). The Department interprets these provisions together to mean that the Secretary may establish recognition criteria governing whether an accrediting agency functions as a reliable authority under Section 496, while leaving to accrediting agencies the responsibility for developing and applying their own substantive accreditation standards. Accordingly, these proposed regulations establish the criteria the Secretary will use in determining whether an accrediting agency qualifies for Federal recognition. Except where expressly required by statute, the proposed regulations do not prescribe the substantive content of institutional accreditation standards, but instead establish minimum expectations regarding the processes, consistency, transparency, and lawful administration of those standards.
The Department has also reviewed existing regulations in light of section 496(o). Where current regulations prescribe requirements that extend beyond recognition procedures and instead direct the content or administration of accrediting standards without a clear statutory basis, the Department proposes to remove or simplify those requirements to better align the regulations with congressional direction.
VII. Public Participation
Section 492 of the HEA, 20 U.S.C. 1098a, requires the Secretary to obtain public involvement in the development of proposed regulations affecting programs authorized by the title IV, HEA programs. Prior to developing this NPRM, the Department obtained advice and recommendations from individuals and representatives of groups involved in the title IV, HEA programs. This outreach included a 30-day public comment period, one day of public hearings, and five days of in-person negotiated rulemaking on these proposed regulations at the Department's headquarters in Washington, DC. Further details regarding these efforts are provided below.
On April 4, 2025, the Department published in the
Federal Register
(90 FR 14741) a notice of our intent to hold public hearings and to establish negotiated rulemaking committees to consider regulatory changes to the title IV, HEA programs, with one committee addressing topics that would streamline current federal student financial assistance program regulations while maintaining or improving program integrity and institutional quality. The engagement included a 30-day written public comment period, two public hearings on April 29 and May 1, 2025, and nine days of negotiated rulemaking specific to this NPRM.
Public Comments and Hearings
We received written comments in response to the
Federal Register
notice. Additionally, we held two public hearings on April 29 and May 1, 2025.
You may view the written comments submitted in response to the April 4, 2025 “Intent to Establish Negotiated Rulemaking Committees; Correction” correction notice (90 FR 14741), by visiting the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
Regulations.gov
, within docket ID ED-2025-OPE-0016. Instructions for finding comments are also available on the site under “FAQ.”
Transcripts of the public hearings can be accessed at
https://www.ed.gov/laws-and-policy/higher-education-laws-and-policy/higher-education-policy/negotiated-rulemaking-for-higher-education-2025-2026.
Negotiated Rulemaking
After obtaining extensive advice and recommendations from the public, the Secretary, as required by Section 492 of the HEA, 20 U.S.C. 1098a, prepared draft regulations and submitted them to a negotiated rulemaking process.
On January 27, 2026, we published a notice in the
Federal Register
(91 FR 3403).
5
That notice set forth a schedule for committee meetings and requested nominations for individual negotiators to serve on the Accreditation, Innovation, and Modernization (AIM) Committee.
5
Intent To Establish Negotiated Rulemaking Committee (91 FR 3403)—
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/01/27/2026-01620/intent-to-establish-negotiated-rulemaking-committee.
We chose members of the negotiated rulemaking committee from individuals nominated by groups involved in the title IV, HEA programs. We selected individuals with demonstrated expertise or experience with the proposed topics. The negotiated rulemaking committee included the following members, representing their respective constituencies:
•
Students, student loan borrowers, or groups representing them:
Magnus Noble, University of Illinois Springfield, and Ryan Hofer (alternate), Independent Advocate for Student Borrowers.
•
Veterans and U.S. military service members, or groups representing them:
Julie Howell, Paralyzed Veterans of America, and Colonel Stuart B. Helgeson (alternate), Valley Forge Military College.
•
Organizations representing workforce development needs, professional associations or employers:
Dr. Siri Terjesen, Florida Atlantic University.
•
Legal assistance organizations, consumer advocates, and civil rights organizations that represent students or borrowers:
Rabbi A.D. Motzen, Agudath Israel of America.
•
Public Institutions of Higher Education, including community colleges, Historically Black Colleges and Universities, and Tribally Controlled Colleges and Universities:
Monty Sullivan, Louisiana Community and Technical College System (Ret.), and Luciano DeCastro (alternate), University of Iowa.
•
Private Nonprofit Institutions of Higher Education, including institutions with a religious mission, Historically Black Colleges and Universities, and Tribally Controlled Colleges and Universities:
David Eubanks, Furman University, William L. Hathaway (alternate), Regent University.
•
Proprietary Institutions of Higher Education, as defined in 34 CFR 600.5:
Jeffrey Bodimer, Post University, and David Cohen (alternate), Five Towns College.
•
State officials, including Governors, State higher education executive officers, State authorizing agencies and State attorneys general:
Raymond Rodrigues, State University System of
Florida, and Michael Duffey (alternate), Ohio Department of Higher Education.
•
Institutional accrediting agencies recognized by the Secretary under 34 CFR part 602:
Michale S. McComis, Accrediting Commission of Career Schools and Colleges, and Heather F. Perfetti (alternate), Middle States Commission on Higher Education.
•
Programmatic accrediting agencies recognized by the Secretary under 34 CFR part 602:
Rebecca A. Busacca, National Accreditation Commission, and Brian Kessler (alternate), Meritus School of Osteopathic Medicine.
•
Organizations representing taxpayers and the public interest Primary:
Michael Shires, America First Policy Institute, and Jim Blew (alternate), Defense of Freedom Institute.
•
Nascent accreditation organizations not currently recognized by the Secretary under 34 CFR part 602, and third-party organizations that measure outcome-based quality assurance standards for postsecondary education that are aligned with established industry standards:
Mark Becker, Commission for Public Higher Education Alternate, and Jade Foster (alternate), National Council for AI Workforce Program Accreditation.
•
National Advisory Committee on Institutional Quality and Integrity:
Jennifer Blum, Blum Higher Education Advising, PLLC.
After obtaining extensive advice and recommendations from the public, the Secretary, as required by Section 492 of the HEA, 20 U.S.C. 1098a, prepared draft regulations and submitted them to a negotiated rulemaking process. The Committee for these proposed regulations convened April 13-17, 2026, and May 18-21, 2026. The Committee reviewed and discussed draft regulations prepared by the Department, as well as alternative regulatory language and suggestions proposed by Committee members. Additionally, during each negotiated rulemaking meeting, some non-Federal negotiators shared feedback that they had received from stakeholders in their respective constituencies. This approach facilitated the inclusion of a wide array of ideas and perspectives, which contributed to the development of the consensus language.
Under the organizational protocols for negotiated rulemaking agreed to by all members of the Committee, if the Committee reaches consensus on the proposed regulations, the Department agrees to publish, without substantive alteration, a defined group of regulations on which the Committee reached consensus—unless the Secretary reopens the process or provides a written explanation to the participants stating why she has decided to depart from the agreement reached during negotiations. In this instance, consensus is considered to be the absence of dissent by any member of the negotiated rulemaking Committee (abstaining members are not considered to be dissenting from the proposal). The Committee reached consensus on the entirety of the draft regulations on May 21, 2026. As a result, this NPRM reflects the consensus language with minor technical and non-substantive corrections which are noted in subsequent sections of this NPRM.
VII. Significant Proposed Regulations
The Department discusses substantive issues under the sections of the proposed regulations to which they pertain. Generally, we do not address proposed regulatory provisions that are technical or otherwise minor in effect. The Department may to release subregulatory guidance as a compliment to the regulations because E.O. 14279 requires that the Department “update the Accreditation Handbook to ensure that the accreditor recognition and reauthorization process is transparent, efficient, and not unduly burdensome.” The Department may provide subregulatory guidance in the Accreditation Handbook on areas like student engagement, site visits, complaint processes, faculty structure and evaluation. We also intend to clarify terminology such as peer review and evaluation teams in the Accreditation Handbook as well.
§ 600.11 Special Rules Regarding Institutional Accreditation or Preaccreditation
Statute:
Section 496(h) of the HEA states that the Secretary shall not recognize the accreditation of any otherwise eligible institution of higher education if the institution of higher education is in the process of changing its accrediting agency or association, unless the eligible institution submits to the Secretary all materials relating to the prior accreditation, including materials demonstrating reasonable cause for changing the accrediting agency or association.
Section 496(i) of the HEA states the Secretary shall not recognize the accreditation of any otherwise eligible institution of higher education if the institution of higher education is accredited, as an institution, by more than one accrediting agency or association, unless the institution submits to each such agency and association and to the Secretary the reasons for accreditation by more than one such agency or association and demonstrates to the Secretary reasonable cause for its accreditation by more than one agency or association. If the institution is accredited, as an institution, by more than one accrediting agency or association, the institution shall designate which agency's accreditation shall be utilized in determining the institution's eligibility for programs under the HEA.
Current Regulations:
Current regulations under § 600.11(a) state that the Secretary does not recognize the accreditation or preaccreditation of an otherwise eligible institution if that institution is in the process of changing its accrediting agency, unless the institution provides materials described in regulation to the Secretary and receives approval, or if the institution was not provided its due process.
Current regulations under § 600.11(b) provide exceptions to the Secretary recognizing the accreditation or preaccreditation of an otherwise eligible institution if that institution is accredited or preaccredited as an institution by more than one accrediting agency.
Proposed Regulations:
We proposed to amend paragraph § 600.11(a) to read that for purposes of §§ 600.4(a)(5)(i), 600.5(a)(6), and 600.6(a)(5)(i), the Secretary does not recognize the accreditation or preaccreditation of an otherwise eligible institution if that institution is in the process of changing its accrediting agency, unless the institution provides the following to the Secretary: (1) all materials related to its prior accreditation or preaccreditation and (2) materials demonstrating reasonable cause for changing its accrediting agency. The Secretary will determine such cause to be reasonable unless the Secretary determines that the institution is seeking the change in order to—(A) evade or circumvent a requirement of Federal law or regulation; (B) avoid or delay enforcement or oversight by the Department or an accrediting agency; (C) obtain eligibility for title IV, HEA programs through misrepresentation or other unlawful means; or (D) otherwise undermine the integrity of the title IV, HEA programs.
We propose to require an institution to publicly disclose the change of accrediting agency within 10 business days on its website and make reasonable efforts to notify all current students and recent graduates for whom they have active contact information.
Under § 600.11(b), we propose that an institution may obtain accreditation or preaccreditation from more than one
accrediting agency recognized by the Secretary if the institution provides the following to the Secretary:
materials related to its prior accreditation or preaccreditation and a written explanation showing reasonable cause for having multiple accreditors. Under the proposed regulations, the Secretary would determine such cause to be reasonable unless the Secretary determines that the institution is seeking to be accredited by more than one accrediting agency in order to: evade or circumvent a requirement of Federal law or regulation; avoid or delay enforcement or oversight by the Department or an accrediting agency; obtain eligibility for title IV, HEA programs through misrepresentation or other unlawful means; or otherwise undermine the integrity of the title IV, HEA programs. Additionally, the Secretary would not determine the cause of having multiple accrediting agencies to be unreasonable due to a withdrawal, revocation, other termination of accreditation, probation or equivalent, show cause order, or suspension order.
Reasons:
We propose the changes under § 600.11(a) to ease restrictions on institutions wishing to change accrediting agencies and the changes under § 600.11(b) to ease restrictions on institutions wishing to hold accreditation from multiple agencies.
The proposed changes also incorporate the policies and practices in the Dear Colleague Letter (DCL) that the Department issued on May 1, 2025, titled “Changes to the Approval Process for Changing Accrediting Agencies”. This guidance noted that the Department's lone interest in the matter of institutions changing accrediting agencies relates to “ensuring the institution is not switching accrediting agencies as a means of avoiding adherence to the Department's laws and regulations.” The proposed regulations affirm institutions' ability to freely develop unique partnerships with accrediting agencies or to hold multiple recognitions from accrediting agencies, which the statute neither prohibits nor disincentivizes.
These changes promote flexibility and innovation while maintaining necessary and robust guardrails that prevent fraud, waste, and abuse of taxpayer funds. Taxpayer funds would be protected through the stipulations that an institution subject to an adverse action cannot switch its recognition to simply avoid consequences, thereby ensuring Federal financial aid dollars do not flow to institutions with malintent. These changes also encourage competition; by removing regulations not directly based in the statute that prohibited an institution from freely changing accrediting agencies based solely on geographic or other factors, institutions will now have the freedom to seek out accreditors that better fit their needs. By eliminating regulations that restrict movement among agencies, accrediting bodies will be incentivized to adapt and innovate in order to recognize additional institutions or retain their current institutions. The changes also assist in accomplishing the streamlining of the process to switch accrediting agencies so that institutions may find an agency that better aligns with their mission and values, a goal of E.O. 14279.
§ 602.2 How do I know which agencies the Secretary recognizes?
Statute:
Section 101(c) of the HEA states that the Secretary shall publish a list of nationally recognized accrediting agencies or associations that the Secretary determines to be reliable authority as to the quality of the education or training offered.
Current Regulations:
Current regulations require that the Secretary periodically publish a list of recognized agencies in the
Federal Register
, together with each agency's scope of recognition. The public may obtain a copy of the list from the Department at any time, and the list is also available on the Department's website.
The regulations also require that if the Secretary denies continued recognition to a previously recognized agency, or if the Secretary limits, suspends, or terminates the agency's recognition before the end of its recognition period, the Secretary must publish a notice of that action in the
Federal Register
. The Secretary also must make the reasons for the action available to the public, on request.
Proposed Regulations:
The proposed regulations change a reference from “web site” to “website.” The regulations would also change the publication type from a “notice” to an “announcement” on the Department's website. The proposed regulations would also specify that the Secretary publishes an announcement of each action limiting, terminating, or suspending an agency's recognition on the Department's website, along with the reasons for the action and the date it was taken, in addition to publishing such information in the
Federal Register
.
Reasons:
The changes are proposed to update and simplify regulations while implementing the Department's current practices in regulation. The updated reference to “website” is a solely a technical change to conform to standard grammatical practices. Transitioning to the use of the word “announcement” rather than “notice” allows the Department to more quickly notify the public about certain accreditation actions taken and in a different medium. The Department will relay this information in a
Federal Register
notice, as is standard practice for most agency publications; however, modifying the regulations to allow for publication on the Department's website allows information to be disseminated to the public more quickly, as a posting to the
Federal Register
can often take multiple days to process. Additionally, we propose adding the requirement that the Secretary publish the date when the action was taken to provide specific, transparent information about how long the agency has been subject to said action.
§ 602.3 What definitions apply to this part?
Statute:
Section 496 of the HEA provides criteria that an accrediting agency must meet for the Secretary to recognize it as a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered.
Current Regulations:
The regulations under § 602.3 define frequently used terms throughout § 602 and cross references to definitions in 34 CFR part 600, including the definition of “institution of higher education.” The regulations also prescribe definitions of terms, including but not limited to,
accreditation, accrediting agency or agency, institutional accrediting agency, program,
and
representative of the public.
Proposed Regulations:
The proposed regulations remove the cross reference to the definition of an institution of higher education under 34 CFR part 600. The proposed regulations add a definition of “institution,” which would mean an educational institution that meets the requirements of paragraph (1) of the definition of
eligible institution
found in 34 CFR 600.2. The Department would eliminate all references to “institution of higher education” throughout § 602 and replace them with “institution.”
The proposed regulations amend the definition of an “accrediting agency or agency” to remove the stipulation that accrediting activities must be conducted through peer review. The proposed definition of an accrediting agency or agency is a legal entity, or that part of a legal entity, that conducts accrediting activities through voluntary, non-Federal review, that may include peer review, and makes decisions concerning
the accreditation or preaccreditation status of institutions, programs, or both.
The Department proposes to add a definition of “related, associated, or affiliated trade association” to mean an organization that is generally a membership organization, that is organized to promote a line of commerce, business, industry, or profession, does not engage in a regular business of a kind ordinarily carried on for profit, and no part of the net earnings of which inures to the benefit of any member, and is related to a particular accrediting agency in that the agency accredits institutions or programs that prepare students to enter the workforce of the same or substantially the same line of commerce, business, industry, or profession that organization promotes.
Finally, the Department proposes to reverse the order of affiliated with and associated in the definition of “representative of the public”. We propose that part (2) of the definition means a person who is not a member of any trade association or membership organization related to, associated with, or affiliated with the agency.
Reasons:
The addition of the definition of “institution” is technical and non-substantive. There is not a singular definition of institution of higher education in 34 CFR part 600. There is, however, a singular definition of an “eligible institution” which includes public, nonprofit, proprietary and vocational institutions of higher education. Therefore, to clarify the definition and reduce the instances in which the Department would need to repeat “institutions of higher education” throughout § 602, we added the definition of “institution” to § 602.3 to cross reference the definition of “eligible institution” in 34 CFR part 600.
The Department proposes to remove the requirement for peer review from the definition of an “accrediting agency or agency” based on a recommendation from several negotiators. During negotiated rulemaking, non-Federal negotiators argued that accrediting agencies may wish to include professionals and experts on site visit teams who do not directly fit within the strictest meanings implied by the word “peer” or “peer reviewers.” The negotiators requested, in order to ensure flexibility for agencies and facilitate quality site reviews, for the Department to eliminate the reference to peer reviews. The Department ultimately agreed with these negotiators in an effort to enhance flexibility for accrediting bodies; however, we note that the exclusion of the word “peer” does not preclude an agency from using peer review where it sees fit. The Department proposes to make use of peer review optional, not mandatory. We concur with the negotiators in their arguments that subject matter expertise does exist outside of the peer review process; other individuals or groups may have similar, if not more, subject matter expertise that allows them to be an effective evaluator of the quality of an institution or program. This flexibility would permit innovation in accreditation to allow agencies to create a unique review process for institutions and programs. This change would also reduce the regulatory burden of having to comply with outdated regulations not required under statute.
The Department proposes to add a definition of “related, associated, or affiliated trade association,” as the phrase appears both in statute and in our current and proposed regulations. In previous iterations of regulations under 34 Part 602, this term has not been defined, therefore, the Department believes that there is a need for a standardized definition so that all accrediting agencies can comply with the regulatory requirements in good faith. We find it critical to define this phrase in order to successfully apply the ‘separate and independent’ requirements contained in Section 496(b) of the HEA in the same manner across all agencies, and so that agencies have clarity on the organizations that the Department expects it to maintain clear firewalls with. For example, the HEA requires that an accrediting agency be separate and independent from a related, associated, or affiliated trade association to ensure there is no undue influence over the decision-making body that makes accreditation or preaccreditation decisions of institutions or programs, the accrediting agency's dues, or the accrediting agency's own budget. This separation is critical to ensuring the independence of accrediting bodies, ensuring that the priorities of such organizations focus primarily on students and educational outcomes, rather than the interests of a relevant trade association. For more discussion on proposed regulations to address reducing conflicts of interest please see the discussion under § 602.15. This provision also more clearly defines the affiliates that an agency may not engage in antitrust activities with, as further described in the “Reasons” section of § 602.13.
Finally, the Department amends the definition of “representative of the public” by reversing the order of “affiliated with” and “associated with” to match the order of the definition of “Related, associated, or affiliated trade association”. This is a non-substantive technical change that aligns the language of regulations across Part 602.
§ 602.10 Link to Federal Programs
Statute:
Section 496(m) of the HEA states that the Secretary may only recognize accrediting agencies or associations which accredit institutions of higher education for the purpose of enabling such institutions to establish eligibility to participate in the programs under this Act or which accredit institutions of higher education or higher education programs for the purpose of enabling them to establish eligibility to participate in other programs administered by the Department of Education or other Federal agencies.
Current Regulations:
The current regulations state that an accrediting agency must demonstrate that its accreditation is a required element in enabling at least one institution of higher education to establish eligibility to participate in HEA programs, or that its accreditation is a required element in enabling at least one institution of higher education or program to establish eligibility to participate in non-HEA Federal programs. This concept is referred to as the “Federal link,” meaning the Department can only recognize accreditors if they have a nexus through the HEA or another federal government program.
Proposed Regulations:
The Department proposes to amend the regulations under § 602.10(a) to state that if an accrediting agency is seeking renewal of recognition, it must demonstrate that its accreditation is a required element in enabling at least one institution to establish eligibility to participate in the title IV, HEA programs. The proposed regulations state that if an agency accredits one or more institutions that participate in the title IV, HEA programs, the agency satisfies the Federal link requirement, even if the institution currently designates another institutional accrediting agency as its Federal link.
Under § 602.10(b), if the accrediting agency is seeking renewal of recognition and the agency accredits institutions, programs, or both, it must demonstrate that its accreditation is a required element to enable an entity to participate in a non-HEA Federal program, as stated in a Federal statute, regulation, grant or funding announcement, or other official Federal agency notice establishing eligibility requirements for participation. The proposed regulations also establish that the agency must provide documentation
that an institution or program is currently relying on the agency's accreditation as a condition of eligibility to participate in such programs.
Finally, we propose under § 602.10(c), if the accrediting agency is seeking initial recognition, it must demonstrate that an institution or program it accredits is likely to rely on the agency's accreditation to establish or continue eligibility to participate in an HEA or non-HEA Federal program upon recognition of the agency within two years. In the event the agency does not have an institution or program that is relying upon the agency's accreditation to establish or continue eligibility to participate in an HEA or non-HEA Federal program when the agency is recognized by the Department, it must report to the Secretary when the first institution or program it accredits begins relying upon its accreditation for such purposes. If, after two years after initial recognition, there are no institutions or programs that rely on the agency's accreditation to establish or continue eligibility to participate in an HEA or non-HEA Federal program upon recognition of the agency, then the agency ceases to be recognized by the Department.
Reasons:
Under § 602.10(a) we propose several minor technical, non-substantive edits. For example, we have updated “institutions of higher education” to “institutions” to conform with the updated definition in § 600.6. We also propose to add “title IV” before “HEA programs” to specify the section of the HEA that affects these regulations. Because the current regulations cover Federal link requirements for accrediting agencies that are seeking recognition and renewal of recognition, we propose to break out § 602.10(a) to only cover accrediting agencies seeking renewal of recognition.
Proposed regulations under § 602.10(b) would cover Federal link requirements for accrediting agencies that are seeking renewal of recognition. Combined, the proposed regulations under § 602.10(a) and (b) clarify that accrediting agencies will only be recognized if the agency's recognition is a material condition of eligibility for an institution or program to participate in a certain Federal programs. These edits strengthen the Federal link requirements for accrediting agencies that do not accredit institutions participating in the title IV, HEA programs and limit the Department's recognition reviews to accrediting agencies whose accredited institutions or programs actually utilize Federal funding programs. By increasing the strength of the Federal link requirement, the Department proposes to ensure that government resources are expended solely on accrediting agencies that utilize Federal funding. This preserves Department Accreditation Group staff resources, who must review the agencies for recognition, as well as resources utilized to host meetings of the NACIQI, who must further review the agencies up for initial or renewal of recognition. Department recognition should extend, upon proper evaluation, only to those agencies that benefit from its use. An agency without any ties to the Federal government through title IV, HEA programs, or non-HEA federal programs, should consider the use of government resources when evaluating whether to continue to seek Department recognition when it is not necessary for its purposes.
The proposed changes to § 602.10(c) provide the expectation that institutions or programs accredited by accrediting agencies that are granted initial recognition would be expected to utilize a Federal funding program for an agency to maintain recognition. A single demonstration of use would not be sufficient to continue to claim a Federal link.
§ 602.11 Extent of Accrediting Activities
Statute:
Section 496(a)(1) authorizes the Secretary to recognize nationally recognized accrediting agencies that can seek to operate as an agency or association within a State, region, or nationally, as appropriate. Every recognized accrediting agency is a “nationally recognized accrediting agency,” because the HEA requires it to be nationally recognized in order to perform title IV gatekeeping functions under Section 101 and Section 496(m) of the HEA.
Current Regulations:
The current regulations require an accrediting agency to demonstrate that it conducts accrediting activities within a State, a region or group of States, or the United States.
Proposed Regulations:
Under § 602.11(a), the Department proposes to remove the reference to a State, if the agency is a part of a State government, and replace the language with a requirement that the agency must identify the extent of its accrediting activities and demonstrate that it has the capacity, policies, and procedures necessary to conduct accrediting activities within the identified extent.
Under § 602.11(b), we propose that an agency may seek recognition to operate in a group of States, or in all States, but the Secretary does not assign, prefer, or limit geographic scope, except as necessary to ensure that the agency has the capacity to carry out its intended accrediting activities. Any geographical limitations are imposed at the sole discretion of the agency itself. We also propose that the Secretary may not assign institutions or programs to accrediting agencies, restrict institutions or programs from seeking accreditation from any agency recognized by the Secretary, directly or indirectly discourage institutions or programs from seeking accreditation from another recognized agency through policy, guidance, communications, other actions, or otherwise favor one recognized accrediting agency over another.
Finally, we propose that the Secretary may not delay, condition, or otherwise adversely affect an institution's participation in title IV, HEA programs solely because the institution seeks accreditation from, or changes accreditation to, another agency recognized by the Secretary.
Reasons:
These regulations codify guidance in the “Clarification of the Appropriate Use of Terms `National' and `Regional' by Recognized Accrediting Agencies” (91 FR 7199) and discourage the identification of accrediting agencies as having a regional scope.
The guidance in 91 FR 7199 clarifies the appropriate use of the terms “regional” and “national” by an accrediting agency recognized by the Department when describing an accrediting agency's area of operation or recognition scope. The guidance was intended to further clarify the changes to the regulations in 34 Part 602 made by the Department's final rule published on November 1, 2019 (84 FR 58834).
Though these regulations ended the Department's recognition of accrediting agencies as “regional,” some accrediting agencies and institutions of higher education continue to rely on such term in their representative texts and to the public. As noted in the Department's 2019 final rule, and in the guidance at 91 FR 7199, the Department does not recognize accrediting agencies as “regional.”
The Department proposes in this final rule to adopt the principles in the guidance to clarify further the intent of the 2019 Final Rule, the Department seeks to ensure that the use of `regional' nomenclature is eliminated to avoid sending false signals to students or the public that the institution lost its accreditation from a “regional accreditor” or that it now has a lesser accreditation status. These changes are intended to eliminate any preconceived notion that one accrediting agency or
association may be fundamentally `better' than another, simply due to longstanding opinions, length of existence of the agency, or the institutions that the agency accredits. There is significant variety in institutions each formerly regional accrediting agency recognizes, and the elimination of the geographic border in 2019 allowed institutions to find an agency that better aligned with their mission or values. By proposing to fully eradicate the terminology here, the Department continues to break down barriers to competition and choice.
These proposed regulations make it clear that an agency may limit where it chooses to accredit, whether that be via State or group of States by geographic extent, but it is not a requirement for recognition by the Department, nor can an agency so term itself “regional” because of a self-imposed limitation on scope of recognition. Further, the Department proposes that it cannot intervene in or retaliate against an institution or program for its own decision to seek accreditation from any nationally recognized accrediting agency. This ultimately would ensure choice and flexibility in choosing an accrediting body is present for institutions, and allows consistency in perception of the quality of an accrediting agency.
Note that the title in the consensus language for this section was “§ 602.11 Geographic area Extent of accrediting activities.” The Department made a technical, non-substantive edit to amend the title to be “§ 602.11 Extent of accrediting activities.”
§ 602.12 Accrediting Experience
Statute:
Section 496(a)(1) of the HEA requires that an accrediting agency demonstrate the ability and the experience to operate as an accrediting agency or association within the State, region, or nationally, as appropriate.
Current Regulations:
Current regulations under § 602.12(a) require that an accrediting agency seeking initial recognition demonstrate that it has granted accreditation or preaccreditation prior to applying to the Department for recognition. Additionally, current regulations require that the agency has conducted accrediting activities for at least two years prior to seeking recognition, unless the agency is affiliated with or a division of another recognized agency.
Under § 602.12(b), a recognized accrediting agency seeking an expansion of scope must follow specific steps outlined in the regulations and demonstrate that it has policies in place that meet all criteria for recognition. An agency that cannot demonstrate experience making an accreditation or a preaccreditation decision under an expanded scope may be limited in the number of institutions or programs to which it may grant accreditation under the expanded scope. The accrediting agency may also be required to submit a monitoring report regarding decisions made under the expanded scope.
Proposed Regulations:
We propose to amend § 602.12(a) to require that an agency seeking initial recognition demonstrate that it has sufficient accreditation experience prior to submitting an application for recognition. An agency would be eligible to submit an application for recognition when it can show the following: (1) the agency is legally established to operate in the relevant jurisdiction; (2) the agency has adopted accreditation standards consistent with § 602.16; (3) the agency has adopted operating procedures consistent with § 602.23; and (4) the agency has established a process to accept applications for accreditation consistent with 34 CFR 602.17 and has at least one institution or program which has submitted an application for accreditation.
We propose to redesignate § 602.12(b) to § 602.12(d). The new paragraph § 602.12(b) would require that an agency seeking initial recognition must undergo the Secretary's recognition process, defined in § 602.31, and an evaluation of the agency's compliance with the Secretary's recognition criteria, defined in 34 CFR part 602, for the purpose of determining if the agency is a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training provided by the institutions or programs it accredits before its application for recognition may be considered by the Advisory Committee.
We propose to add new § 602.12(c), which would require that an accrediting agency must have granted accreditation to one or more institutions if it is requesting recognition as an institutional accrediting agency, and to one or more programs if it is requesting recognition as a programmatic accrediting agency before the agency may be granted recognition.
Under the redesignated § 602.12(d)(1), we propose to amend the current requirements to add that a “contraction” of scope must also follow specific requirements. The amendments would require an accrediting agency seeking an expansion
or
contraction of its scope of recognition to follow the requirements in § 602.32, as well as demonstrate that it has accreditation or preaccreditation policies in place that meet all the criteria for recognition covering the range of the specific degrees, certificates, institutions, and programs it seeks in its proposed scope. A change to an agency's geographic area of accrediting activities does not constitute an expansion or contraction of the agency's scope of recognition, but the agency must notify the Department of, and publicly disclose on the agency's website, any such change. Paragraph (d)(2) of this section would remain the same as current (b)(2).
Finally, the Department proposes to add a new § 602.12(e), noting that experience qualifying under this section is not limited to the accreditation of institutions within a particular geographic area and may include experience obtained in a national, State or group of States, or programmatic basis.
Reasons:
Changes proposed to § 602.12 would reduce overall regulatory burden for accrediting agencies seeking initial recognition. The proposal represents an alignment with the Department's goal to reduce barriers to entry while also seeking to serve the interest of taxpayers and students by (1) ensuring minimum eligibility criteria are met and (2) that accrediting agencies with little experience in accrediting institutions or programs or enforcing standards be required to demonstrate success in this regard, aligning with the Department's goal of a risk-based approach for initial recognition. The Department interprets the statutory requirement for a “comprehensive review and evaluation” to require that the Secretary consider whether an agency continues to satisfy all applicable recognition criteria. This is a holistic approach to ensure that any altered or changed elements do not contradict or conflict with any remaining elements and that the totality of the agency continues to benefit and not harm recognition.
The statute does not prescribe the form of an agency's submission or require the Department to review criterion in support of unchanged policies and documentation during every review cycle. However, every renewal remains comprehensive because every recognition criterion is part of a holistic review. The Department is merely tailoring the documentation requested from agencies whose prior reviews and ongoing oversight indicate relatively lower risk.
We propose to add clearly defined guardrails that ensure that accrediting agencies seeking recognition are legally established in the relevant jurisdiction, and that the agency has accreditation standards and operating procedures consistent with the law and regulations.
This ensures that agencies that seek recognition from the Department have already established legitimate operations before initial petition, and that Department staff in the Accreditation Group have sufficient evidence to begin review of compliance with the Secretary's recognition criteria.
We propose to add § 602.12(b) to ensure that each agency submits a comprehensive petition to the Department for evaluation demonstrating that the accrediting agency meets the basic eligibility requirements and demonstrates implementation of the required accrediting standards, operating policies and procedures.
We propose to amend § 602.12(c) to remove language related to the requirement that an accrediting agency specify the geographic area for which the accrediting agency seeks recognition. By removing references to geographic area, the Department seeks to discourage identification of accrediting agencies based on geography and reduces unnecessary barriers to the recognition of accrediting agencies and an agency's subsequent recognition of an institution or program.
We also propose to remove the requirement that an accrediting agency grant or deny accreditation or preaccreditation for at least two years prior to seeking recognition by the Department. This two-year requirement is not statutory and represents undue and unnecessary burden for accrediting agencies seeking recognition. Timelines for review can be lengthy, given the cycle of review by the NACIQI, and may cause accrediting agencies seeking initial recognition to linger in review stage longer than necessary. Eliminating this two-year requirement removes a significant competitive barrier to entry that the Department expects will induce more accreditation agencies to pursue recognition and ultimately increase competition in the accreditation market.
By allowing agencies to petition for recognition as soon as it has received an application from at least one institution or program, it ensures that Department staff have evidence of standards and practices to review. And, by ensuring that recognition by the Department cannot be granted until the agency has approved a program or institution, it allows Department staff, NACIQI, and the Senior Department official to review implementation of such standards and practices to ensure the agency is functioning as a quality indicator. Both these stipulations provide enhanced guardrails to ensure Federal student aid is only flowing to qualified programs or institutions but also provides the agency with increased flexibility in timeline for review and decreases overall time to recognition. These changes also implement the Department's interpretation and guidance published contained in 91 FR 7199.
Further, the Department proposes to redesignate current regulations under § 602.12(b) to § 602.12(d). In redesignating, we have also added a condition that accrediting agencies must apply to the Department when seeking a contraction in scope. For example, an accrediting agency would need to apply to the Department by fulfilling requirements under proposed § 602.32 if that agency sought to contract its scope from accrediting entry-level programs in a profession at the master's degree level to only programs at to the doctoral degree level. The proposed addition will provide an avenue for the Department and the senior Department official to take action related to the current language at § 602.32(e): “The Department may view as a negative factor when considering an application for initial, or expansion of scope of, recognition as proposed by an agency, among other factors, any evidence that the agency was part of a concerted effort to unnecessarily restrict the qualifications necessary for a student to sit for a licensure or certification examination or otherwise be eligible for entry into a profession.”
Finally, we propose adding 602.12(e) to reduce unnecessary barriers to the recognition of accrediting agencies, as directed by E.O. 14279, by acknowledging that accreditation experience can occur outside of a particular geographic area and may include in a national, State, or programmatic basis.
§ 602.13 Effect of Recognition
Statute:
Section 496(a) of the HEA states that the Secretary may recognize an accrediting agency or association to be a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered for the purposes of title IV, HEA programs or for other Federal purposes, if, among other things, the agency or association is one of the four types enumerated in HEA Section 496(a)(1). With the exception of a State agency approved by the Secretary for the purpose of accrediting institutions of higher education, all three of these categories require that the agency or association be comprised of a “voluntary membership.”
See
HEA Section 496(a)(2).
Additionally, HEA Section 496(n)(3) states that, when reviewing and evaluating the performance of all accrediting agencies or associations seeking recognition by the Secretary, the “Secretary shall consider all available relevant information concerning the compliance of the accrediting agency or association with the criteria provided for in this section, including any complaints or legal actions against such agency or association.”
Current Regulations:
None. This section is currently reserved.
Proposed Regulations:
Under § 602.13(a), the Department proposes to affirm that recognition does not confer immunity or any relief from Federal or State antitrust laws. Accrediting agencies, institutions, and programs remain subject to those laws, notwithstanding recognition or eligibility determinations made by the Department.
Under § 602.13(b), the Department proposes to amend the regulations to state that recognition does not authorize collective action among accrediting agencies, institutions, or programs that would otherwise be subject to oversight under Federal or State law.
Finally, we propose to amend § 602.13(c) such that recognition does not create a property interest or entitlement to continued recognition.
Reasons:
The HEA does not provide that recognition of an accrediting agency or association by the Secretary confers any form of immunity from Federal or state antitrust laws.
The U.S. Department of Justice recently made clear in a statement of interest filed in a private lawsuit on December 15, 2025 that the antitrust laws apply to recognized accreditation agencies.
6
In that case, a party suggested that the Department of Education's recognition displaces the antitrust laws.
7
The Department of Justice explained that “[a]rguments supposing “[r]epeals of the antitrust laws by implication from a regulatory statute are strongly disfavored.”
Norfolk & W. Ry. Co.
v.
Am. Train Dispatchers Ass'n,
499 U.S. 117, 129 (1991) (quoting
United States
v.
Phila. Nat. Bank,
374 U.S. 321, 350 (1963)). And that, the party had failed to make a “convincing showing of clear repugnancy between the antitrust laws and the [Department of Education's] regulatory system” necessary to establish a repeal by implication.”
8
6
Statement of Interest of the United States at 17,
Lincoln Mem'l Univ.
v.
Am. Veterinary Med. Assoc.
No. 25-cv-00282 (E.D. Tenn. Dec. 15, 2025), available at
http://www.justice.gov/atr/media/1420886/dl?inline
7
Id.
8
Id.
The Department believes that adding clarification to its regulations regarding
this point is important, for multiple reasons.
First, the Department interprets the phrase “voluntary membership,” as used in HEA Section 496(a)(2), in accordance with the plain meaning of the word “voluntary”—
i.e.,
a membership composed of persons or institutions or programs who have joined on their “own free will without valuable consideration or legal obligation” or otherwise “unconstrained by interference.”
See
Merriam-Webster,
Voluntary,
Merriam-Webster.com
(last updated June 20, 2026). One form of interference which would preclude an agency or association's membership from being truly voluntary is that agency or association engaging in anti-competitive behavior prohibited by Federal or State antitrust laws, as such actions undermine the efficiency and fairness of the accreditation marketplace and limit the choices of market participants.
Second, the Department notes that E.O. 14279 directed the Department to “resume recognizing new accreditors to increase competition and accountability in promoting high-quality, high-value academic programs focused on student outcomes.” The Department believes that, to carry out this directive successfully, it is necessary to remind existing accrediting agencies of the legal obligations to comply with Federal or State antitrust laws (despite this not being a new requirement) and to ensure that agencies do not attempt to construe the Secretary's recognition to permit behavior that is illegal under the antitrust laws.
In a similar vein, neither the HEA, nor current Department regulations, authorize collective action among accrediting agencies, institutions, or programs that would otherwise be subject to oversight under Federal or State law, however, the Department believes that it is important to clarify this point for accrediting agencies. While the Department seeks to encourage collaboration amongst accrediting agencies, institutions, and other stakeholders, agreements to take collective action can limit competition and run afoul of antitrust regulation. Therefore, the Department proposes to include this language in regulation to minimize any potential for an accrediting agency to improperly construe the Secretary's recognition to allow for activities which may violate Federal or State antitrust laws.
Finally, the Department proposes to add language stating that recognition of an accrediting agency by the Secretary does not create a property interest or entitlement to continued recognition for clarity. “To have a property interest in a benefit,” a person or entity must “have a legitimate claim of entitlement to it.”
Bd. of Regents of State Colls.
v.
Roth,
408 U.S. 565, 577 (1972). Legitimate claims of entitlement arise from sources of positive law, such as statutes or regulations, that create reasonable expectations of specific benefits.
Id.
Thus, because neither Section 496 of the HEA, nor the Department's regulations, require the Secretary to grant recognition to an agency or association or to continue such recognition after it is initially granted, no such legitimate claim of entitlement or property interest in such recognition can possibly exist. Adding this language to the Department's regulations will simply serve to provide additional clarity and will provide the Department with protection in the event an accrediting agency who is denied recognition pursues legal action against the Department.
We further clarify that the Department is not the enforcer of antitrust law, but accrediting agencies are expected to comply with federal law, including avoiding anti-competitive practices, and that any findings by the Department of antitrust violations by agencies would be based on competent legal authority.
§ 602.14 Purpose and Organization
Statute:
Section 496(a)(2) of the HEA lists the categories of accrediting agencies that the Department will recognize, including but not limited to, a State agency listed by the Secretary as nationally recognized on or before October 1, 1991; an agency with voluntary membership of institutions that utilize the agency's accreditation to access title IV, HEA programs; an agency that has voluntary membership of institutions or programs that utilize the agency's accreditation to access other Department or Federal programs; or an agency that has a voluntary membership of individuals in a profession or programs within institutions to access title IV, HEA programs. Section 496(a)(3) requires an accrediting agency to operate “separate and independent” of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization unless that agency is categorized as having a voluntary membership of institutions or programs that utilize the agency's accreditation to access other Department or Federal programs. Section 496(b) of the HEA defines the term “separate and independent”.
Current Regulations:
The current regulations under § 602.14(a) generally mirror statutory requirements that prescribe which agencies the Department can recognize. Similarly, § 602.14(b) prescribes the definition of “separate and independent,” which generally follows the statutory framework.
Regulations under § 602.14(c) allow for the joint use of personnel, services, equipment, or facilities by an agency and a related, associated or affiliated trade association or membership organization and clarifies these shared resources do not violate separate and independent requirements when certain firewalls are in place. Paragraph § 602.14(d) provides the parameters by which the Secretary may waive the “separate and independent” requirements. Finally, current regulations under § 602.14(e) state that an agency seeking a waiver of the “separate and independent” requirements must apply for the waiver each time the agency seeks recognition or continued recognition.
Proposed Regulations:
The Department proposes to remove the phrase “ . . . or obtain a waiver of those requirements under paragraph (d) of the section” from § 602.14(a)(4)(ii). The Department does not interpret this change to eliminate any waiver authority that Congress expressly provided in § 496(a)(3)(C). Rather, the Department concludes that no separate regulatory waiver process is necessary because the Secretary retains whatever waiver authority the statute itself provides.
We also propose to amend paragraphs (b)(1)-(5) and add new (b)(6). We propose amending § 602.14(b) to define “separate and independent” as (1) the members of the agency's decision-making body, who decide the accreditation or preaccreditation status of institutions or programs, establish the agency's accreditation policies, or both, are not elected or selected by the board or chief executive officer of any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization and are not staff of the related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization; (2) at least one member of an the agency's decision-making body is a representative of the public, and at least one-seventh of the body consists of representatives of the public; (3) the agency has established and implemented mandatory conflict of interest controls for each member of the decision making body in accordance with § 602.15(e); (4) the agency's dues are paid and held separately from any dues paid to any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization; (5) the agency develops and determines its own budget, without review by or in
consultation with any other entity or organization, including any related, associated or affiliated trade association or professional organization; and (6) the authorized representative of the agency submits a signed statement certifying that it has met the requirements to be “separate and independent” within each petition for recognition submitted to the Department, and includes in that statement information regarding any complaints received during the current recognition period that are material.
Finally, we proposed to remove and rescind § 602.14(c) and (d).
Reasons:
The proposed changes to § 602.14 strengthen the fiscal and administrative requirements that an agency must meet in order for an agency to demonstrate that it is “separate and independent” from any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or membership organization. We propose to strike “or obtains a waiver of those requirements under paragraph (d) of this section” from § 602.14(a)(4)(ii) to no longer allow for waivers from compliance with the separate and independent criteria. The Department also clarifies that removal of the waiver may only affect those agencies eligible for a waiver under the current regulations. The Department does not interpret this change to eliminate any waiver authority that Congress expressly provided in § 496(a)(3)(C). Rather, the Department concludes that no separate regulatory waiver process is necessary because the Secretary retains whatever waiver authority the statute itself provides. Section 496(a)(3)(C) of the HEA; statute also clarifies that the granting of a waiver has been subject to the Secretary's discretion. We believe that an accrediting agency's decision-making body must not be influenced by any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization, and the waiver outlined under § 602.14 (d) did not adequately restrict such influence in the accreditation or preaccreditation of institutions or programs. The ability for an agency to seek a waiver has the potential to compromise some of the controls in place to prevent certain negative consequences, such as credential inflation, restrictions on entry into occupational fields, restrictions on the capacity of educational institutions, and slower adoption of innovations.
There was extensive discussion by the AIM Committee surrounding § 602.14(c) and proposed changes. Negotiators were concerned that accrediting agencies that share joint use or personnel services, equipment, or facilities with a related, associated, or affiliated trade association would be penalized, even if there was no interaction between the two bodies. A few negotiators commented that some localities have limited office space that could necessitate that need to occupy the same facility; others pointed to the size of some facilities and the ability to separate via multiple floors or office spaces. One negotiator asked what the process would be for accrediting agencies that currently occupy the same facility as the related, associated, or affiliated trade association under a multiyear lease. The Department reiterated its position that, at minimum, accrediting agencies must avoid conflicts of interest by having separate personnel services, equipment, or facilities with a related, associated or affiliated trade association. Though we can appreciate the fact that there may be some hurdles accrediting agencies may face when shifting offices, that does not alleviate concerns that such proximity could exacerbate relationships that are already too close. Further, the Department clarified that we do not share the same concerns that an agency may not be able to find a separate space to conduct activities. The earliest these regulations would become effective is July 1, 2027, which we believe is sufficient time for an agency to find separate space and plan to comply with any changes in regulations. Additionally, we have provided for additional time for an agency that currently has a lease within the same facility at the related, associated or affiliated trade association. Under § 602.15(e)(4), the Department proposes to provide agencies with an additional year to comply with any regulations that affect shared spaces; therefore, the earliest date that agencies would be expected to comply with the regulation would be July 1, 2028.
§ 602.15 Administrative and Fiscal Responsibilities
Statute:
Section 496(c) of the HEA provides that no accrediting agency or association may be recognized by the Secretary as a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered by an institution seeking to participate in title IV, HEA programs unless the agency or association maintains specific operating procedures enumerated therein. HEA section 496(c)(1) requires an accrediting agency that wishes to be recognized by the Secretary to ensure accreditation team members are well-trained and knowledgeable with respect to their responsibilities.
With respect to those accrediting agencies serving as institutional agencies, as well as for programmatic accrediting agencies (whether or not the programmatic agency serves as a title IV gatekeeper), Section 496(a)(2) of the HEA requires that agency's membership be “voluntary.”
Section 496(a)(4)(A) requires that to be recognized by the Secretary, an accrediting agency or association must demonstrate that it consistently applies and enforces standards that respect the stated mission of the institution of higher education, including religious missions, and that ensure that the education offered by the institution of higher education is of sufficient quality to achieve the stated objective for which the courses or the programs are offered.
Current Regulations:
Current regulations under § 602.15 require that an accrediting agency has administrative and fiscal capability to carry out accreditation activities in light of its scope of recognition. An agency must demonstrate that it has (1) adequate staff and financial resources, (2) competent and knowledgeable individuals, qualified by education or experience to conduct on-site evaluations, apply or establish policies, and make accreditation or preaccreditation decisions, (3) academic and administrative personnel on its evaluation, policy, and decision-making bodies, if an institutional agency, (4) educators, practitioners, and employers on its evaluation, policy and decision-making bodies, if a programmatic agency, (5) representatives of the public on all decision-making bodies, and (6) clear and effective controls to prevent or resolve conflicts of interest by the agency's board members, commissioners, evaluation team members, consultants, administrative staff, and other agency representatives.
Proposed Regulations:
We propose to amend the regulations at § 602.15 to add that the agency must have conflict of interest controls that apply to its own activities to carry out its accreditation activities in light of its requested scope of recognition. We propose to amend § 602.15(a) to state that the agency meets this requirement if it demonstrates that it has (1) adequate administrative staff and financial resources to carry out its accrediting responsibilities, (2) competent and knowledgeable individuals, qualified by education or experience in their own right as appropriate for their roles, (3) training provided to all agency representatives and staff that includes topics related to best practices in various educational delivery methods, models, and modalities; innovative or lower-cost educational delivery models that may provide high quality education to students; and avoiding unnecessary costs to institutions in the accreditation process, and (4) representatives of the
public on all decision-making bodies. We propose to move and amend the requirements currently at § 602.15(a)(6) to § 602.15(e).
In addition to amending existing requirements under § 602.15, we propose to add four additional requirements for an agency to demonstrate administrative and fiscal responsibilities.
We propose at § 602.15(c) that that the agency must conduct its accreditation activities in a manner that seeks to avoid unnecessary financial, compliance, and administrative burdens, including by avoiding duplicative reporting, excessive documentation requirements, and unwarranted prescriptive processes.
We propose at § 602.15(d) that the agency will cooperate with other agencies and the Department in the development of common templates and forms for institutions or programs to submit when seeking to change accrediting agencies.
We propose at § 602.15(e) that the agency has clear and effective controls, including guidelines, to (1) prevent or resolve conflicts of interest, or the appearance of conflicts of interest, by the agency's officers and directors, employees (including temporary, part-time, and full-time employees), evaluation team members, consultants and contractors, volunteers, and other agency representatives, (2) ensure that members of the standards-setting body, which may include members of the decision-making body, do not vote as members of the decision-making body on the setting of standards or policies that affect any institution or program that of which such a member is an officer, director, or employee, (3) determine its dues without review by any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization, (4) disallow shared resources, such as personnel, services, equipment, facilities, or information technology, nor have office space in the same building as any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization. The requirement for separate office space will take effect one year after the effective date of the final regulations, (5) ensure that any officers, directors, employees, or volunteers of the agency do not share or solicit feedback regarding the agency's policies, standards, or decisions with respect to any institution or program from any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional association, (6) prominently disclose on its website all relationships with related, associated, or affiliated trade associations or professional organizations, and (7) not act to restrict access to employment in a profession, occupation, or vocation unless the agency provides notice of clear and convincing evidence to the Secretary that the restriction is necessary to protect the public interest; the expected public benefits outweigh the costs to the public from reduced access to the profession, occupation, or vocation; and no less restrictive alternative would adequately protect the public interest. We propose that restricting access to employment includes taking steps to increase credentialing standards; increasing the cost or level of required education or training; or decreasing the availability of education or training in a manner that may benefit any related, associated, or affiliated trade association or professional organization.
Finally, we propose at § 602.15(f) that the agency's accreditation standards, policies and enforcement practices must not restrict public institutions from fulfilling their obligations under the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States. These standards similarly also must not restrict any private institutions that, through their institutional policies, guarantee the same or similar protections for students or faculty, unless the institution has a religious mission.
Reasons:
The Department proposes to amend 34 CFR 602.15 to provide accrediting agencies with the flexibility necessary to adopt policies and procedures that encourage innovation and minimize unnecessary expenses for institutions, while simultaneously requiring agencies to operate in an open, transparent manner. The Department also seeks to add language to 34 CFR 602.15 for the purposes of clarifying that accrediting agencies should be composed of a “voluntary” membership and to require accrediting agencies to adopt policies designed to restrict anticompetitive behavior that could preclude institutions or programs from choosing, or switching to, the agency which best aligns with the institution's or program's educational mission.
First, to provide additional flexibility to accrediting agencies, the Department proposes to eliminate the current requirement in 34 CFR 602.15(a)(3) that institutional agencies include academic and administrative personnel on their evaluation, policy, and decision-making bodies. Likewise, the Department proposes to remove the current requirement in 34 CFR 602.15(a)(4) for programmatic accrediting agencies to include educators, practitioners, and/or employers on their evaluation, policy, and decision-making bodies. Instead, the Department proposes to reduce the burden by simplifying these requirements by expecting that all accrediting agencies possess competent and knowledgeable individuals, qualified by education or experience, and trained by the agency on their responsibilities, as appropriate for their roles. The Department believes that this change will allow accrediting agencies the discretion to adopt the structures necessary to best perform their function and respond to the needs of their membership.
Additionally, the Department proposes to require accrediting agencies to adopt procedures necessary to manage conflicts of interest and prevent collusion between agencies, the institutions or programs which they accredit, related, associated, or affiliated trade associations, or professional organizations which could lead to accrediting agencies engaging in anticompetitive behavior that would compromise the “voluntary” membership of the agency and taint the agency's ability to apply and enforce its standards in a consistent manner. While the current regulations require accrediting agencies to adopt controls to manage conflicts of interest, the Department believes that it necessary to increase the specificity of these requirements, in recognition of the influence that agencies, both institutional and programmatic, wield over the institutions and programs that they accredit. To this end, the Department proposes requiring accrediting agencies to prominently disclose their relationships with related, associated, or affiliated trade associations and adopt controls to ensure that such organizations do not influence an agency's independent evaluation of the institutions and programs they accredit.
In this same vein, the Department proposes adding language barring accrediting agencies from acting to restrict employment in a given profession, occupation, or vocation. The purpose of this change is to ensure that agencies do not attempt to establish a monopoly over the accreditation of certain types of programs or institutions, particularly those that may lead to credential inflation, resulting in increased costs to students and lengthier time to credential. However, the Department recognizes that certain restrictions on access to employment in specific professions, occupations, or vocations may be necessary to protect the public interest, such as ensuring sufficient level of quality and safety in job performance. To this end, the Department proposes adding provisions
that allow accrediting agencies to act to create such restrictions, so long as the agency provides clear and convincing evidence that such restrictions are necessary to the public interest.
Finally, the Department proposes to add language that explicitly bars accrediting agencies from adopting or enforcing policies that would prevent public institutions from fulfilling their obligations under the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States or private institutions from adopting policies which guarantee similar protections to students and faculty. The Department believes that this requirement is necessary to ensure that all institutions or programs are treated in a consistent manner by accrediting agencies and that agencies do not take actions that would unnecessarily restrict free inquiry and academic discourse at institutions or programs.
§ 602.16 Accreditation and Preaccreditation Standards
Statute:
Section 496(a)(5) states that accrediting agencies must establish standards of accreditation to assess the institution's or program's success with respect to student achievement, curricula, faculty, facilities, fiscal and administrative capacity, student support services, recruiting and admissions practices, program length and credentials, student complaints, and compliance with program responsibilities under title IV of the HEA.
Current Regulations:
The current regulations require that an accrediting agency's standards set forth clear expectations for the institutions or programs it accredits under the same criteria as listed under the
Statute
heading of this section. The accrediting agency's preaccreditation standards, if offered, must relate to its accreditation standards and not span more than five years before a final action is made.
Specifically, § 602.16(a)(1) and (a)(1)(i) require that the agency's accreditation standards must set forth expectations for the institutions or programs it accredits in the following areas, including success with respect to student achievement in relation to the institution's mission, which may include different standards for different institutions or programs, as established by the institution, including, as appropriate, consideration of State licensing examinations, course completion, and job placement rates.
Proposed Regulations:
We propose to amend § 602.16(a)(1) and (a)(1)(i) to require that the agency's accreditation standards must establish requirements for the institutions or programs it accredits in the following areas: (i) Success with respect to student achievement at the institutional and program level in relation to the institution's mission, which may include different standards for different institutions or programs, as established by the institution, including, as appropriate, consideration of State licensing examinations, course completion, and job placement rates, as described in § 602.17(a)(1). We also propose under § 602.16(f) that an agency that has established and applies the standards in paragraph (a) of this section may establish any additional lawful accreditation standards that are consistent with ensuring institutional or programmatic quality and integrity, as it deems appropriate.
Reasons:
The proposed edits under § 602.16 eliminate subjectivity and increase the clarity of the regulations by changing “set forth clear expectations” to the proposed “establish requirements” under § 602.16(a)(1), which does not change the effect of the regulation, and adding “at the institutional and program level” under § 602.16 (a)(1)(i). Also, under § 602.16(a)(1)(i), we propose to add a cross reference to § 602.17(a)(1) to provide accrediting agencies with clarity on the application of standards.
Finally, we added clarifying language to § 602.16(f) to require that any additional standard that an accrediting agency adopts beyond those required by Section 496 of the HEA does not violate any other Federal law and is consistent with ensuring institutional or programmatic quality and integrity. In amending these standards, we also address one of the goals of E.O. 14279, which is to ensure that accrediting agencies do not force institutions or programs to violate State laws, unless those conflict with Federal law or the Constitution. For example, this requirement would prohibit an agency from holding a standard that would require its recognized institutions or programs to only hire faculty 30 years old or younger. Such a standard would violate the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967, therefore placing the institution in violation of Federal law due to the agency's policies. A policy such as this would neither be lawful, nor would it contribute to the evaluation or assurance of quality or integrity at an institution or program.
§ 602.17 Application of Standards in Reaching Accreditation Decisions
Statute:
Section 496(a)(6)(A) states that no accrediting agency or association may be determined by the Secretary to be a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered or for other Federal purposes, unless the agency or association meets criteria established by the Secretary. The Secretary shall, after notice and opportunity for a hearing, establish criteria for such determinations. Such criteria shall include an appropriate measure or measures of student achievement. Such criteria shall require that such an agency or association establish and apply review procedures throughout the accrediting process, including evaluation and withdrawal proceedings, which comply with due process procedures.
Current Regulations:
Current regulations require that the agency have effective mechanisms for evaluating an institution's or program's compliance with the agency's standards before reaching a decision to accredit or preaccredit the institution or program. The agency meets this requirement if the agency demonstrates that it evaluates whether the institution or program maintains clearly specified educational objectives that are consistent with its mission and appropriate in light of the degrees or certificates awarded; is successful in achieving its stated objectives at both the institutional and program levels; and maintains requirements that at least conform to commonly accepted academic standards, or the equivalent, including pilot programs in § 602.18(b). The regulations also state that an agency's standards must require an institution or program to engage in a self-study process that assesses the institution's or program's education quality and success in meeting its mission and objectives; to highlight opportunities for improvement; and include a plan for making those improvements. The regulations also require an accrediting agency to conduct at least one on-site review of the institution or program during which it obtains sufficient information to determine if the institution or program complies with the agency's standards. The current regulations also require an agency to allow the institution or program the opportunity to respond in writing to the report of the on-site review.
Current regulations also require an agency to conduct its own analysis of the self-study and supporting documentation furnished by the institution or program, the report of the on-site review, the institution's or program's response to the report, and any other information substantiated by the agency from other sources to determine whether the institution or program complies with the agency's
standards. They also require an agency to provide the institution or program with a detailed written report that assesses the institution's or program's compliance with the agency's standards, including areas needing improvement, and the institution's or program's performance with respect to student achievement.
Finally, the regulations require an agency's standards to ensure institutions have processes in place through which the institution establishes that a student who registers in any course offered via distance education or correspondence is the same student who academically engages in the course or program. Regulations also require it to be stated, clearly and in writing, that institutions must use processes that protect student privacy and notify students of any projected additional student charges associated with the verification of student identity at the time of registration or enrollment.
Proposed Regulations:
We propose to amend § 602.17(a) to tie process of an agency applying and reviewing the standards to the standards as set forth under § 602.16. The remainder of § 602.17(a) would require that the accrediting agency evaluates whether an institution or program maintains clearly specified educational objectives, which may include credit for prior learning, that are consistent with its mission and appropriate in light of the degrees or certificates awarded that are developed, regularly reviewed, and updated using reliable data. We propose that, as appropriate to the accrediting agency's own standards, it reviews an institution's student success with respect to student achievement at both the institutional and program levels, including minimum expectations, by assessing State licensing or certification examination results, where applicable to the program of study; program retention, completion, or graduation rates, including as appropriate the extent to which grades meaningfully reflect student learning and support progression through the program of study, post-completion or graduation outcomes, including employment and continued education; scores on relevant standardized assessments taken for admission to a higher-level degree, during and after the time of enrollment at an institution, as available; and educational and economic returns aligned to the program's credential level, length, and occupational context relative to the total cost of attendance. Such returns shall be assessed using the earnings data calculated under 34 CFR 668 Subpart Q, enhanced Unemployment Insurance wage records, or other reliable earnings data available to the agency.
We propose that when applying its standards on faculty, the accrediting agency evaluate whether an institution maintains a sufficient number of appropriately qualified faculty and other subject matter instructors who are regularly evaluated on the performance of their instructional, research, or service responsibilities and applies written faculty performance evaluation policies that include defined performance criteria and are conducted on a periodic basis. The accrediting agency would be required to maintain academic freedom protections that are clearly articulated and applied consistently to faculty regardless of appointment classification, race or other immutable characteristics, viewpoint, or ideology, unless the institution has a religious mission. If an institution has a religious mission, the agency would evaluate whether the institution maintains academic freedom protections that are consistent with the institution's religious mission and applied consistently to faculty, regardless of appointment classification, race or other immutable characteristics, and with sufficient flexibility in instructional staffing policies and procedures to respond to persistent, material changes in student demand, program viability, or financial conditions. In addition, in the case of public institutions, the agency would be required to consistently apply polices that protect the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States. The agency should similarly evaluate any private institution that, through its institutional policies, guarantees the same or similar protections for students or faculty. The agency would also be required to maintain policies regarding the integrity of scholarly activity, research, and practices designed to prevent, detect, and address fabrication, material misrepresentation or falsification, plagiarism, and other forms of research misconduct. This would need to include mechanisms for timely investigation, corrective actions, and, as appropriate, public disclosure. Agencies would need to evaluate whether institutions have a policy, or policies, to protect civil rights and, as applicable, First Amendment rights, and whether such policy or policies include academic freedom protections that are clearly articulated and applied consistently to faculty regardless of appointment classification, race or other immutable characteristics, viewpoint, or ideology, unless the institution has a religious mission. We propose to require that such policies must also include academic freedom and freedom of inquiry protections for faculty in teaching, scholarship, and research within the subject matter of a course and research within their academic discipline, including conditions under which a range of academic perspectives may be expressed and examined without adverse action based on lawful viewpoints unrelated to professional or academic competence, unless the institution has a religious mission. In the case of a private institution, agencies would be required to assess policies that, if established, guarantee the same or similar protections.
We propose to require a recognized accrediting agency to establish a policy that is designed to support, promote, and appropriately prioritize intellectual diversity and the free exchange of ideas amongst faculty, to include elements that address intellectual inquiry and student learning, and measures student and faculty perceptions on the range of viewpoints and perspectives offered by the institution or program, unless the institution or program has a religious mission. If an institution or program has a religious mission, the policy would need to include elements that address intellectual inquiry and student learning that are consistent with the institution's religious mission.
We propose that when applying its standards related to facilities, equipment, and supplies and student support services, agencies conduct a cost/benefit analysis, which means a review by the agency of the institution's budget, resource utilization and allocation, and if existing, its business/strategic plan, continuous improvement strategic plan, and review of whether the institution considers whether the expected benefits of the institution's activities justify the associated financial, administrative and opportunity costs, and the impact of capital expenditures on future operating expenses. Agencies would also be required to conduct a review of an institution's practices and capabilities regarding the administration of student aid programs, and of the sufficiency and proper maintenance of the institution's facilities to ensure that such facilities comply with applicable safety standards, laws, and regulations.
We propose, when applying its standards on program length and the objectives of degrees or credential offered, an accrediting agency seeks to ensure that program length is appropriate to the objectives of the program and credential awarded at the institution. In applying its standard, the agency must not categorically prohibit or unreasonably restrict the
accreditation of a short-term program that is designed to prepare students for employment in recognized occupations eligible for Federal student aid under applicable law or a certificate or degree program offered for a shorter period of time than is traditionally required to obtain that credential, so long as the program results in comparable academic, professional, and employment outcomes for students who would complete such programs.
We changed the initial wording slightly (without changing the meaning) in subparagraphs (a)(2)(ii) and (v) from the consensus language to grammatically align them with the stem and the rest of the sentence structure.
We propose to add new § 602.17(b), which would establish requirements for how an agency must apply and determine an institution's or program's compliance with its standards. We propose to remove the current requirement for self-study and replace it with the requirement for a comprehensive review process, that may include self-study. We propose to make conforming changes throughout § 602.17, renumbering current paragraphs (b)-(f) to 602.17(b)(1)-(5). We propose to move current 602.17(g) to 602.17(c), in which a clarifying, non-substantive technical edit is made. Our proposal also strikes the current paragraph at 602.17(h).
We propose to add § 602.17(d) to require that, when applying its standards, an agency seeks to reduce unnecessary barriers which restrict the ability of institutions or programs from adopting instructional, programmatic, or delivery practices that improve student access, accelerate credential or degree completion, or support innovative models of postsecondary education, including program length.
We propose to add § 602.17(e) to require that the agency adopts, implements, and enforces written policies and procedures that seek to ensure the accuracy, completeness, and integrity of all representations made by the agency tot The Secretary, the public, including current and prospective students, State, Tribal, and other governmental authorities, and institutions or programs it accredits or preaccredits.
Under proposed § 602.17(f), we would require that the agency has policies to ensure it does not knowingly make false, misleading, or materially incomplete statements regarding the accreditation or preaccreditation status of any institution or program; the scope, conditions, or implications of accreditation or preaccreditation, or compliance of an institution or program with applicable Federal or State law.
We propose to require that the accrediting agency maintain procedures for the prompt correction of materially inaccurate public statements or disclosures, maintains procedures for investigating credible allegations that the agency or its representatives made materially inaccurate or misleading representations, and takes appropriate corrective or disciplinary action when it determines that materially inaccurate or misleading representations have occurred.
We propose under § 602.17(g) that the agency may not have standards that encourage, direct, or otherwise require institutions or programs to violate Federal or State law, including by having policies that provide any preferences on the basis of race.
Finally, under § 602.17(h) we propose to state that nothing in this section would be construed to require any action that would conflict with applicable Federal or State law.
Reasons:
In amending § 602.17(a), we propose to codify in regulation that the stipulations for review and evaluation under this section is how accrediting agencies must evaluate and monitor its established standards in accordance with § 602.16 at its recognized institutions and programs. When applying these standards, the Department anticipates that accrediting agencies will use data to ensure continuous improvement in their programs and consistent evaluation against previous benchmarks. We proposed changes under § 602.17(a)(1) to ensure that standards related to student achievement may include credit for prior learning. This ensures that a priority of E.O. 14279 is addressed, which requested that the Department reduce barriers to agencies implementing innovative practices to advance credential completion and establishing new educational models. Requiring accrediting agencies to evaluate prior credit ensures that educational programs and coursework becomes stackable, and that students retain high-quality prior credit to shorten time to completion, as well as keep credit earned from outside learning while enrolled at a program. Additionally, the proposed requirements to regularly review degree or certificate offerings using reliable data continues to emphasize several of the Administration's goals, which is to ensure that there are objective measures of quality utilized alongside of subjective measures. Using reliable data ensures that programs are evaluated against the same metrics and can be comparatively weighted to ensure accountability in higher education. These data may also speak to the quality of outcomes upon graduation, including employment rates, placement rates, or average wages. Note that the Department may provide more clarity on how an agency may assess “relevant standardized assessments” taken for admission to a higher-level degree in the future sub-regulatory guidance.
We propose changes to § 602.17(a)(2), and the addition of § 602.17(a)(1)(ii), to set expectations that accrediting agencies must adhere to when evaluating institutions and programs for standards related to student achievement. The proposed addition of § 602.17(a)(2) would set expectations to which accrediting agencies must adhere when evaluating institutions and programs for standards related to faculty. This addition includes § 602.17(a)(2)(iii)-(viii) to implement the requirements in E.O. 14279 which “requires that institutions support and appropriately prioritize intellectual diversity amongst faculty in order to advance academic freedom, intellectual inquiry, and student learning” and to ensure that “accreditors are not using their role under Federal law to encourage or force institution to violate State laws, unless such State laws violate the Constitution or Federal law.” The Department's goal in instituting these regulations is to support academic freedom and intellectual diversity on college campuses as a critical component of educational quality. Diversity of thought and perspectives help inform students' decision-making, research, and practices.
The Department believes promoting intellectual diversity at postsecondary institutions will also help to increase critical thinking amongst students. As students graduate and enter the workforce, their jobs, family, and many other life circumstances will require strong critical thinking skills. Individuals will be able to make more thoughtful, well-developed decisions having been exposed to a diversity of thought during college. Intellectual diversity will also expose students to a wide variety of perspectives which will encourage them to express their own views and strengthen their understanding of their rights to constitutionally protected speech. We also believe that healthy debate is necessary, and intellectual diversity will encourage students to engage in meaningful conversations with professors and other students. Students can find common ground on various subjects or simply agree to disagree but still come away with a full
understanding of other thoughts and viewpoints.
The intent is not to prescribe specific institutional policies or override institutional autonomy, but rather to ensure that sufficient consideration is given to ensuring intellectual diversity is present on campus. The proposed regulations would also require accrediting agencies to ensure that accredited public institutions' policies, practices, and procedures comport with the First Amendment, as interpreted by Federal courts, including with respect to viewpoint nondiscrimination, religious nondiscrimination, and speech protections. Such references, throughout the regulations, are not intended to make accrediting agencies the arbiters of constitutional law, but to ensure institutions have and apply policies consistent with legal requirements. Further, accrediting agencies are not expected to investigate or enforce civil rights law but to ensure institutions have policies and respond appropriately to findings by competent authorities. The accrediting agency's role is to ensure institutions have and apply appropriate policies, not to adjudicate legal disputes or act as enforcement agencies. The HEA does not define the term “academic freedom”. During negotiated rulemaking, the Department proposed a definition of academic freedom. While we believe that the proposal was clear and represented a fair interpretation of the phrase, a few negotiators dissented to the inclusion of a definition of academic freedom in the regulations. The Department subsequently removed the definition from the proposal; instead, we propose to require that agencies adopt and implement standards for evaluating if an institution has a policy for academic freedom. For reference, the Department's non-binding proposed language for adoption is represented below. We are not requiring agencies or institutions to apply this definition; however, if an agency or institution does apply this definition, we believe that would meet the requirements of the E.O. and our proposed regulations.
Academic Freedom:
(1) Means the freedom of faculty to:
(i) conduct research, publish their findings, and teach without undue interference and engage in discussion of any matter germane to the subject of the course being taught; and
(ii) speak and write in their personal capacity, provided that such activities are lawful and comply with applicable institutional rules and policies, and that faculty do not represent their views as those of the institution.
(2) Does not include the freedom to introduce, or solicit discussion of, material that is not germane to the subject of the course being taught.
(3) Nothing in this definition shall be construed to prohibit institutions or accrediting agencies from adopting and enforcing policies reasonably designed to promote intellectual diversity, the exposure of students to a range of scholarly viewpoints, or the balanced presentation of competing perspectives, so long as such policies do not infringe the core protections of academic freedom described in this section.
The proposed § 602.17(a)(2)(vi) requires that, in evaluating whether an institution is in compliance with an agency's standards, the agency must evaluate whether an institution maintains policies related to research misconduct. Research misconduct includes, but is not limited to, plagiarism, material misrepresentation of research findings, including through undisclosed selective reporting or other practices that distort the accuracy or reliability of results. We believe that accrediting agencies must ensure institutions have policies in place to prevent faculty members from engaging in improper authorship attribution, citation manipulation, or coordinated practices intended to inflate or misrepresent scholarly impact. We encourage the use of artificial intelligence to enhance productivity, streamline processes, and make teaching more efficient. However, we also believe agencies and institutions must ensure that artificial intelligence is not used by faculty to supplant teaching and instruction. We do not believe that artificial intelligence should degrade methods in the conduct and presentation of research. The proposed regulations help to maintain integrity of research and among the institution's faculty by encouraging responsible uses of beneficial technology. Students benefit from the research activities of institutions of higher education in many ways. Many students have opportunities to work directly with faculty on research projects and gain valuable experience and exposure to cutting-edge technology and ideas. Faculty involved in research are better able to teach students about current ideas in their disciplines. Research that is not conducted with integrity, however, will not convey these benefits to students, and can even tarnish the reputations of students involved in unethical research and teach the wrong lessons. Additionally, the proposal will benefit taxpayers by ensuring that the education system they help fund is built upon integrity and responsible practice.
We propose to add § 602.17(a)(3)(i) and (ii), which would require accrediting agencies to conduct a cost/benefit analysis to review and ensure institutions have sufficient flexibility in instructional staffing policies and policies regarding integrity of scholarly activity. The addition of this language is intended to provide relief for students and taxpayers who have suffered increased debt burdens through costly standards of accreditation, whether that be decreasing the number of students allowed in a classroom at once, requiring increased student to teacher ratios where not necessarily required, or decreasing the number of courses a professor is required to teach, thereby adding additional hiring costs. These regulations would allow greater institutional flexibility to control costs and to make cost efficiency a factor that accrediting agencies consider when evaluating whether to implement certain standards, and in evaluating whether changes made by a recognized program or institution are justifiably necessary to the quality of the program at the cost proposed. The intent is not to require burdensome analyses for every expenditure, but to encourage prudent, evidence-based decision-making.
The Department also proposes to add § 602.17(a)(4), which provides that agencies must evaluate whether the length of a program is appropriate to the goals of such program and the credential sought. In proposing this regulation, the Department seeks to ensure that program length is not artificially extended in order to seek additional revenue from a student. For example, when evaluating programs in accordance with the proposed regulation, the Department would expect that accrediting bodies would weigh the length of the program against peer programs. A bachelor's degree that requires five years of education may be a program that an agency would feel to be inappropriate in length, given the nation-wide standard of four-year bachelor's degrees. Conversely, an agency must also ensure that the program length is sufficient to provide the appropriate education, which may be more subjective and varied at the graduate level. This provision would require the agency to conduct careful evaluation to ensure that Federal student aid dollars, and taxpayer resources, are not being used inappropriately to increase an institution's bottom line. In adding this provision to regulations, we aim to continue to decrease barriers that limit
innovation and practices that advance credential completion.
Proposed changes to § 602.17(b) would eliminate the requirement that an institution or program engage only in a “self-study” and allow agencies to implement innovative and comprehensive approaches to evaluating the quality of an institution or program. We believe that only allowing institutions to conduct a self-study is limiting, and new approaches for reflection and evaluation should be encouraged to spur competition and advancement in accreditation. During self-study the institution or program seeking recognition prepares an in-depth self-evaluation study that measures its performance against the standards established by the accrediting agency. We believe innovation is key to advancing evaluation of academic quality. Relying on a one-size fits all approach discourages progress and new methodologies from emerging that may be better than a self-study. Accrediting agencies can continue to require a self-study; however, other options may be better for institutions. Institutions may prefer an independent audit or a review from business leaders in the community or region that the institution is located among forms of evaluation.
The proposed addition of § 602.17(d) is a direct application of the requirement in E.O. 14279 that prohibits accrediting agencies from engaging in practices that result in credential inflation that burdens students with additional unnecessary costs. One of the most common letters that the Department receives from the public is regarding the high cost of attendance at postsecondary institutions. Many prospective students have written to the Department requesting more be done regarding overall costs to credential completion. By prohibiting agencies from establishing unnecessary barriers to actions that may improve access, accelerate credential completion, or support innovative models around program length, the Department is taking the necessary steps to encourage agencies and institutions to think about and enact policies that reduce a student's need to borrow more. The proposed addition of § 602.17(e) seeks to mandate that the accrediting agency has a policy that ensures that accredited institutions only present factual information to stakeholders. The proposal ensures transparency and consistency, while also protecting taxpayers and students by adding requirements regarding misrepresentation and fraud. We proposed to add § 602.17(f) to require integrity and transparency in the public communications and policy of accrediting agencies. Accurate statements from accrediting agencies about accredited and preaccreditation institutions serve to protect and safeguard students, taxpayers and postsecondary institutions.
The proposed addition of § 602.17(g) reinforces the Department's objective, and a goal of E.O. 14279, of ensuring that higher education programs are free from unlawful discrimination or other violations of Federal law. As noted above, this does not intend to make the agency the arbiter of any violation of Federal law, but rather ensures that the agency evaluates any glaring violations of such law. The proposed language under § 602.17(g) related to discrimination or preferences is limited to those practices that are unlawful under Federal or State law, and not intended to prohibit lawful single-sex or mission-based practices.
Finally, the proposed addition of § 602.17(h) confirms that these regulations do not require an accrediting agency to violate applicable Federal or State law to demonstrate compliance.
The changes proposed in § 602.17 are intended to provide flexibility when taking into account institutional mission, program type, and other contexts.
§ 602.18 Ensuring Consistency in Decision-Making
Statute:
Section 496(a)(4)(A) states that the Secretary shall establish criteria to require that such agency or association consistently applies and enforces standards that respect the stated mission of the institution of higher education, including religious missions, and that ensure that the courses or programs of instruction, training, or study offered by the institution of higher education, including distance education or correspondence courses or programs, are of sufficient quality to achieve, for the duration of the accreditation period, the stated objective for which the courses or the programs are offered.
Current Regulations:
The current regulations under § 602.18(a) require accrediting agencies to consistently apply and enforce standards that respect the stated mission of the institution and ensure that its instruction is of sufficient quality to achieve its stated objective for the accreditation or preaccreditation period.
The current regulations under § 602.18(b) require an accrediting agency to have written specification of the requirements for accreditation and preaccreditation, have effective controls against inconsistent application of standards, base decisions on published standards, have a reasonable basis for determining that information is reliable, and provide the institution or program with a detailed written report that identifies deficiencies and publish policies for retroactive accreditation.
The current regulations at § 602.18(c) state that nothing prohibits an agency, when special circumstances exist, to include innovative program delivery approaches or, when an undue hardship on students occurs, from applying equivalent written standards, policies, and procedures that provide alternative means of satisfying one or more of the requirements set forth in 34 CFR 602.16, 602.17, 602.19, 602.20, 602.22, and 602.24, as compared with written standards, policies, and procedures the agency ordinarily applies as along as certain conditions are met.
The regulations under § 602.18(d) state that nothing prohibits an agency from permitting the institution or program to be out of compliance with one or more of its standards, policies, and procedures adopted in satisfaction of §§ 602.16, 602.17, 602.19, 602.20, 602.22, and 602.24 for a period of time, as determined by the agency annually, not to exceed three years unless the agency determines there is good cause to extend the period of time and meets several other regulatory requirements.
Proposed Regulations:
We propose to add new paragraph § 602.18(b)(4) that states that the agency meets the requirement in paragraph (a) of this section if the agency “has adopted and followed procedures to ensure that agency decisions are neutral with respect to viewpoint and ideology that are unrelated to its accrediting policies or standards, except that nothing in this paragraph requires an accrediting agency with a religious mission to be neutral with respect to viewpoints,” followed by conforming changes to renumber current paragraphs 602.18(b)(4)-602.18(b)(6) to 602.18(b)(5)-602.18(b)(7).
We propose to amend paragraph § 602.18(c) to codify that nothing prohibits an agency from reducing barriers that limit institutions and programs from adopting practices that advance credential and degree completion, and that promote new models of education by applying equivalent written standards, policies, and procedures that provide alternative means of satisfying one or more of the requirements set forth in §§ 602.16, 602.17, 602.19, 602.20, 602.22, and 602.24, as compared with written standards, policies, and procedures the agency ordinarily applies as long as conditions under the current regulations
are met. Finally, we propose rescinding § 602.18(d).
Reasons:
We propose the addition of paragraph § 602.18(b)(4) to ensure that accrediting agencies remain neutral towards viewpoint diversity and prioritize diversity of thought on campuses. Within this, we also recognize that there are several accrediting agencies or associations with religious missions. As such, we stipulate here that this does not apply to institutions accredited by these agencies, in the name of respecting the mission of such an agency. We propose edits to paragraph (c) to clarify that the Department encourages new education models to accelerate innovation and improve accountability by establishing new flexible and streamlined quality assurance pathways for higher education institutions that provide high-quality, high-value academic programs.
We rescinded § 602.18(d) because we propose to move to the language to § 602.20 with modifications, as described below.
§ 602.20 Enforcement of Standards
Statute:
Section 496(a)(4)(A) states that an accrediting agency consistently applies and enforces standards that respect the stated mission of the institution of higher education. Section 496(a)(6) states that an accrediting agency or association shall establish and apply review procedures throughout the accrediting process, including evaluation and withdrawal proceedings, which comply with due process procedures. Finally, Section 496(e) states that the Secretary may not recognize the accreditation of any institution of higher education unless the institution of higher education agrees to submit any dispute involving the final denial, withdrawal, or termination of accreditation to initial arbitration prior to any other legal action.
Current Regulations:
Under current § 602.20(a)(4), if the agency's review of an institution or program under any standard indicates that the institution or program is not in compliance with that standard, the agency must have a written policy to evaluate and approve or disapprove monitoring or compliance reports it requires, provide ongoing monitoring, if warranted, and evaluate an institution's or program's progress in resolving the finding of noncompliance. The regulations prescribe the procedures an accrediting agency must implement if it finds an institution or program out of compliance. Additionally, § 602.20(e) requires that all adverse actions are subject to arbitration requirements.
Proposed Regulations:
Under § 602.20(a)(4), we propose to remove the requirement that an accrediting agency be required to approve or disapprove monitoring or compliance reports and provide ongoing monitoring, if warranted, for an institution or program that is non-compliant with any one of the agency's standards. The proposed paragraph would require that an accrediting agency have a written policy to evaluate an institution's or program's progress in resolving the finding of noncompliance. Under § 602.20(e), we propose to add language to the existing paragraph to require that any agency arbitration standard or policy must be nonbinding, except that both parties may agree to binding arbitration after a dispute arises on a case-by-case basis. If an agency has an arbitration policy or standard, it must apply to all final adverse actions, however, an agency may require the institution or program to first exhaust the agency's appeal process; ensure that the arbitration process is fair and impartial; and provide for a transparent and reasonable period of time for resolution of disputes.
We propose adding new § 602.20(h). Under the proposed regulations, an agency must have a policy for restoring accreditation (including retroactive restoration) in circumstances that the agency determines are appropriate, including if required by an applicable judicial decision.
As noted above in our description of the reasons for proposed amendments to § 602.18, we propose moving current § 602.18(d) to a new § 602.20(i) and to make one amendment to remove current 602.18(d)(1)(v).
Reasons:
We proposed the edits to § 602.20(a)(4) to simplify regulations. We believe the current language is confusing to accrediting agencies since we use the terms “monitoring or compliance reports,” which are defined at § 602.3 as applicable to an agency, not an institution or program. We believe removing the language does not substantively change the requirement; accrediting agencies will still need to have a written policy to evaluate an institution's or program's progress in resolving a finding on noncompliance.
We propose the additions under § 602.20(e) to more closely align with the statutory text. Section 496(e) of the HEA states that “The Secretary may not recognize the accreditation of any institution of higher education unless the institution of higher education agrees to submit any dispute involving the final denial, withdrawal, or termination of accreditation to initial arbitration prior to any other legal action.” The best reading of this section is that the Department cannot recognize that an institution is accredited unless the institution and agency have agreed to an initial arbitration when the institution is first accredited and asks for that accreditation to be recognized by the Department. This arbitration agreement cannot be binding, because the statute specifies that it must be “initial” and provides that the institution may still instigate “any other legal action” after arbitration. A binding arbitration agreement would prevent the institution from pursuing “any” other legal action. However, nothing in the statute prevents an institution and agency from entering into a binding arbitration agreement later, once a dispute has arisen. Indeed, nothing in the statute gives the Department the authority to impose requirements on arbitration agreements other than that which is entered into when the institution is first accredited. The Department also released guidance in November 2023,
9
that clarified that arbitration must be initial and non-binding. If an accrediting agency and institution choose to enter into binding arbitration after a dispute arises, then that is permissible because both parties come to an agreement as opposed to an agency requiring the arbitration as a requirement to seek or maintain accreditation.
9
Dear Colleague Letter GEN-23-14 Regulations Governing the Recognition of Accrediting Agencies, Institutional Eligibility, and Arbitration—
https://fsapartners.ed.gov/knowledge-center/library/dear-colleague-letters/2023-11-03/regulations-governing-recognition-accrediting-agencies-institutional-eligibility-and-arbitration-updated-dec-5-2023
.
We propose to add language under § 602.20(h) to require an accrediting agency to have a policy to restore accreditation in circumstances it deems appropriate, including if required by an applicable judicial decision. Current regulations already allow for such a policy, but this proposal now requires an accrediting agency to have such a policy. We believe the proposed language is necessary because retroactive accreditation may be appropriate based on unseen circumstances that might arise.
With the exception of § 602.18(d)(1)(v), we propose moving language from § 602.18(d) to § 602.20(i).
§ 602.21 Review of Standards
Statute:
Section 496(a)(5) states that accrediting agencies must establish standards of accreditation to assess the institution's success with respect to student achievement in relation to the institution's mission, which may include different standards for different institutions or programs; curricula;
faculty; facilities, equipment, supplies; fiscal and administrative capacity; student support services; recruiting and admissions practices, academic calendars, catalogs, publications, grading and advertising; program length and credentials; student complaints; and record of compliance.
Current Regulations:
§ 602.21(a) requires an accrediting agency to maintain a comprehensive systematic program of review that involves all relevant constituencies, and that demonstrates that its standards are adequate to evaluate the quality of the education or training provided by the institutions and programs it accredits and is relevant to the educational or training needs of students. § 602.21(b) requires that an accrediting agency review follow specific procedures outlined in that paragraph. § 602.21(c) requires that changes to an accrediting agency's standards be initiated with 12 months and that such action must be completed within a reasonable period of time. Finally, § 602.21(d) prescribes the process an accrediting agency must complete prior to finalizing any changes to its standards.
Proposed Regulations:
We propose to amend § 602.21(a) to require an accrediting agency to maintain a comprehensive systematic program of review that occurs at regular intervals, involves all relevant constituencies (including students), and that demonstrates that its standards are adequate to evaluate the quality of the education or training provided by the institutions and programs it accredits and is relevant to the educational or training needs of students. We propose to rescind paragraphs (b), (c), and (d) of this section.
Reasons:
We propose to amend 602.21 to add a condition that the review of standards occur at regular intervals. This will ensure that accrediting agencies continually and consistently review standards dynamically. As technology advances and approaches to education inevitably shift, accrediting agencies should be at least reviewing standards regularly to ensure that students are receiving the most relevant and high-quality education as possible. Without regular review of standards, an accrediting agency and institutions that it accredits could become obsolete and ineffective in producing positive outcomes. An ineffective and outdated accrediting agency is not a good use of taxpayer dollars via the institutions or programs it accredits and may leave students without a good return on investment and with insurmountable student loan debt that they may struggle to repay debt. The inclusion of students in the reviews by the accrediting agency was a suggestion by a negotiator during rulemaking. The negotiator believed that students should serve a mandatory role in reviewing standards by which accrediting agencies will evaluate institutions. Several negotiators noted that students are often already included in reviews of institutions and programs, therefore this addition may be inconsequential.
The Department proposes rescinding paragraphs (b),(c), and (d) to remove prescriptive regulations that are not based on statute. Removing these paragraphs eliminates burdensome and complex regulations that are not only difficult for accrediting agencies to implement but also difficult for the Department to enforce. The regulations continue to retain the statutory requirement for accrediting agencies to regularly review their standards which, in totality, affords them the flexibility to innovate but also maintain the guardrails of a regular review process. Note that because only one paragraph remains in the section, we would not keep the remaining paragraph labeled as (a), instead there will not be paragraph indicators in the section.
§ 602.22 Substantive Changes and Other Reporting Requirements
Statute:
Section 496(c)(1) states that no accrediting agency or association may be recognized by the Secretary as a reliable authority as to the quality of education or training offered by an institution seeking to participate in the programs authori
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.