Medicare Program; Strengthening Oversight of Accrediting Organizations (AOs) and Preventing AO Conflicts of Interest, and Related Provisions

Federal RegisterJun 16, 2026

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services

42 CFR Parts 488 and 489

[CMS-3367-FC]

RIN 0938-AU88

Medicare Program; Strengthening Oversight of Accrediting Organizations (AOs) and Preventing AO Conflicts of Interest, and Related Provisions

AGENCY:

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).

ACTION:

Final rule with comment period.

SUMMARY:

This final rule with comment period sets forth provisions to strengthen the oversight of Medicare national accrediting organizations by addressing conflicts of interest, establishing consistent standards, processes, and definitions, and updating the validation and performance standards systems. Additionally, this final rule with comment period revises the psychiatric hospital survey process, adds a limitation on terminated deemed providers and suppliers when reentering the program, and provides technical corrections for End-Stage Renal Disease facilities and Transplant Programs.

DATES:

Effective date:

These regulations are effective on June 16, 2027.

Comment date:

To be assured consideration, comments on sections VI., “Collection of Information” and VII., “Regulatory Impact Analysis” must be received at one of the addresses provided below, by August 17, 2026.

ADDRESSES:

In commenting, please refer to file code CMS-3367-FC.

Comments, including mass comment submissions, must be submitted in one of the following three ways (please choose only one of the ways listed):

1.

Electronically.

You may submit electronic comments on this regulation to

https://www.regulations.gov/docket/CMS-2024-0016.

Follow the “Submit a comment” instructions.

2.

By regular mail.

You may mail written comments to the following address ONLY: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Department of Health and Human Services, Attention: CMS-3367-FC, P.O. Box 8010, Baltimore, MD 21244-8010.

Please allow sufficient time for mailed comments to be received before the close of the comment period.

3.

By express or overnight mail.

You may send written comments to the following address ONLY: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Department of Health and Human Services, Attention: CMS-3367-FC, Mail Stop C4-26-05, 7500 Security Boulevard, Baltimore, MD 21244-1850.

For information on viewing public comments, see the beginning of the

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

section.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

CAPT Scott J. Cooper, USPHS, (410) 786-9465 or

AO_Applications@cms.hhs.gov.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Inspection of Public Comments:

All comments received before the close of the comment period are available for viewing by the public, including any personally identifiable or confidential business information that is included in a comment. We post all comments received before the close of the comment period on the following website as soon as possible after they have been received:

https://www.regulations.gov.

Follow the search instructions on that website to view public comments. CMS will not post on

Regulations.gov

public comments that make threats to individuals or institutions or suggest that the commenter will take actions to harm an individual. CMS continues to encourage individuals not to submit duplicative comments. We will post acceptable comments from multiple unique commenters even if the content is identical or nearly identical to other comments.

Table of Contents

I. Executive Summary

A. Purpose

B. Summary of the Major Provisions

II. Background

A. Legislative History

B. Regulatory Overview of CMS' Rules Regarding AO Programs

C. Congressional Report on the Oversight of National AOs and CMS-Approved Accreditation Programs

D. CMS Validation Survey Pilot

E. Overview of Transparency and Oversight of Accrediting Organizations

F. Prior Rulemaking—Accrediting Organizations Conflicts-of-Interest Request for Information (RFI)

G. Conflicts of Interest—The AO Owner's, Surveyor's and Other Employee's Interest in or Relationship With a Healthcare Facility That the AO Accredits

H. Public Comment on Whether it Is a Conflict of Interest for AO Board Members or Advisors To Have an Interest in, or Relationship With, a Healthcare Facility That the AO Accredits

III. Summary of the Proposed Provisions, Public Comments, and Responses to Comments on the Proposed Rule

A. General Comments in Support of the Proposed Rule

B. Comments Expressing General Opposition to the Proposed Rule

C. Add Definition of “Unannounced Survey” to § 488.1

D. Conflicts of Interest

E. Comments on the Proposed Requirement That AOs Obtain and Submit Surveyor Declarations of Any Interest in and Relationships With Healthcare Providers the AO Accredits to CMS on an Annual Basis (Proposed § 488.5(a)(22))

F. Proposed Restrictions on Fee-Based Consulting Services Provided by AOs to the Medicare-Certified Providers and Suppliers They Accredit (Proposed § 488.8(i))

G. Require AOs To Provide CMS With Information About the Fee-Based Consulting They Provide (Proposed § 488.8(i)(5))

H. Actions Against AOs Found To Be Providing AO Fee-Based Consulting Services to the Healthcare Providers or Suppliers They Accredit in Violation of the Restrictions in § 488.5(i)(1) Through § 488.5(i)(3) (Proposed § 488.8(i)(6))

I. Require Accrediting Organizations To Have Written Fee-Based Consulting Firewall Policies and Procedures (§ 488.8(j))

J. Prohibit AO Owners, Surveyors, and Other Employees From Involvement With the Survey and Accreditation Process for Healthcare Facilities With Which They Have an Interest or Relationship (§ 488.8(k))

K. Require the AOs That Accredit Medicare-Certified Providers and Suppliers To Use Medicare Conditions; and Strengthened Survey Process Comparability (Proposed § 488.4(a)(1) and (2))

L. Revise the Crosswalk Requirements at § 488.5(a)(3)

M. Strengthen the Comparability of the Survey Process Between the AOs and the States

N. Revise the AO Application Documentation Requirements Related to the Survey Processes (§ 488.5(a)(4); § 488.5(a)(4)(iii); § 488.5(a)(4)(v); § 488.5(a)(4)(vii); § 488.5(a)(4)(xi); § 488.5(a)(5); § 488.5(a)(6); § 488.5(a)(12); § 488.5(a)(13))

O. Revisions to § 488.5(a)(4)(v) (Survey Review Process)

P. Revision to § 488.5(a)(4)(vii) (Correction of Identified Non-Compliance)

Q. Revisions to § 488.5(a)(4)(xi) (AO Training and Education Programs)

R. Revisions to § 488.5(a)(5) (Composition of Survey Team)

S. Revisions to § 488.5(a)(6) (Adequate Number of Surveyors for Size of Facility)

T. Revisions to § 488.5(a)(12) (Complaint Survey Documentation Requirements)

U. Revisions to Accreditation Decision-Making Policies and Reporting § 488.5(a)(13)

V. Require AOs To Provide CMS With Survey Findings (§ 488.5(a)(4)(viii)(A))

W. Require That AO Surveyors Must Take the CMS Online Surveyor Basic Training (§ 488.5(a)(8))

X. Establish Criteria for “National in Scope” (§ 488.1)

Y. Revise the Definition of “Rate of Disparity” and To Use the Process and Outcome Disparity Rates and Performance Measures (§ 488.1)

Z. Require AOs To Submit a Publicly Reportable Plan of Correction for Unacceptable Performance Measure Scores (§§ 488.8(a)(2) and (4))

AA. Revisions to the AO Survey Validation Program (§ 488.9)

BB. Revise the Psychiatric Hospital Survey Process

CC. Limitation on Terminated Deemed Providers/Suppliers Seeking Re-Entry Into Medicare/Medicaid (§ 489.57, § 488.4(b) and § 488.5(a)(21))

DD. Finalizing Technical Correction for End-Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) Facilities and Kidney Transplant Programs (§ 488.4(a)(4))

IV. Information Regarding Timeframes and Expectation for the Submission of AO Applications

V. Severability of Provisions

VI. Collection of Information Requirements

A. Information Collection Requirements (ICRs) Related to Conflict-of-Interest Requirements

B. ICR Associated With the Requirement That AOs Provide Detailed Crosswalks Identifying Incorporation of the CMS Standards

C. ICRs Associated With the Requirement That AOs Use Survey Processes That Are Comparable to Those Used by CMS and the SAs

D. ICRs Associated With the Establishment of a Definition for “National in Scope”

E. ICR Associated With the Revision of the AO Performance Measures and To Require a Publicly Reportable Plan of Correction

F. Summary of Estimated Burden

VII. Regulatory Impact Analysis

A. Statement of Need

B. Overall Impact

C. Detailed Economic Analysis

D. Alternatives Considered

E. Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA)

F. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA)

G. Federalism

H. E.O. 14192 “Unleashing Prosperity Through Deregulation”

VIII. Waiver of Notice of Proposed Rulemaking

IX. Response to Comments

I. Executive Summary

A. Purpose

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) seeks to protect the health and safety of all patients who receive services from Medicare- and Medicaid-participating providers and suppliers, including those facilities that are accredited by CMS-approved accrediting organizations (AOs). We continue to review and revise our patient health and safety requirements and our survey process requirements to ensure that these regulations effectively drive the quality and safety of the care our beneficiaries and all patients receive from these accredited providers and suppliers.

In 2015, we published a final rule in the

Federal Register

entitled, “Medicare and Medicaid Programs: Revisions to Deeming Authority Survey, Certification, and Enforcement Procedures” (80 FR 29796), hereinafter referred to as the “2015 AO final rule” to clarify and strengthen the oversight of AOs, specifically to provide additional criteria for AOs that apply for, and are granted, recognition and approval of an accreditation program (see section “II. Background” of this final rule with comment period for additional background information). Since 2015, CMS has continued to evaluate the effectiveness of these regulatory changes and the performance of AOs. In our proposed rule, published February 15, 2024 (89 FR 11996), we proposed multiple provisions to further strengthen our oversight and enforcement capabilities of the AOs. The need for these provisions is based on multiple factors, which include: (1) direct observation and review of the AOs' accreditation programs for those AOs with CMS-approved deeming programs; (2) media reports and complaints against facilities that are deemed; (3) the CMS validation program and analysis of disparity rates between State survey agencies (SAs) and the AOs; and (4) our performance evaluations of AOs. Section IV. of the proposed rule discussed each of the proposed provisions. More specifically, the preamble provided background and analysis of why CMS proposed additional provisions and revisions to existing requirements. CMS is responsible for the oversight of the national AOs' Medicare accreditation programs, and for ensuring that providers or suppliers under CMS-approved deeming programs by the AOs meet the baseline quality and patient safety standards required by the Medicare conditions (please refer to section “II. Background” of this final rule with comment period for additional information). Based on several years of experience and data analysis, we proposed the revisions and the new requirements in the February 15, 2024, proposed rule to strengthen our oversight of AOs.

B. Summary of the Major Provisions

• We proposed at § 488.1 to add the definitions of “geographic regions”, “national in scope”, “outcome disparity rate”, “process disparity rate”, and “unannounced survey”. In addition, we proposed to revise the definition of “national accrediting organization,” and remove the definition of “rate of disparity”.

• We proposed to establish a new requirement at § 488.4(a)(1) that would require the AOs that accredit Medicare-certified providers and suppliers to include the language of the applicable Medicare Conditions of Participation (CoPs), Conditions for Coverage or Conditions for Certification (CfCs), or requirements (collectively referred to as “Medicare conditions”) set forth in the applicable CMS regulations for each provider and supplier type as their minimum accreditation requirements. However, the AOs would be free to establish additional accreditation requirements that exceed Medicare conditions, as permitted by section 1865(a)(1) of the Social Security Act (the Act).

• We proposed to add language at § 488.4(a)(2) regarding use of a comparable survey process approved by CMS, as outlined and contemplated in § 488.5.

• We proposed to add a new regulation at § 488.4(b) that would state that if Medicare terminated the participation agreement of a Medicare-certified provider or supplier, then CMS would no longer recognize the facility's AO accreditation for deemed compliance. At proposed § 488.4(b)(2), we would require a terminated provider or supplier to meet all requirements set forth at § 489.57 before their new agreement for participation in the Medicare/Medicaid program can be approved.

• We proposed to require AOs to develop a crosswalk between their accreditation standards and the Medicare conditions, at proposed § 488.5(a)(3).

• We proposed to strengthen the requirements at § 488.5(a)(4), § 488.5(a)(4)(iii), § 488.5(a)(4)(v), § 488.5(a)(4)(vii), § 488.5(a)(4)(xi), § 488.5(a)(5) and § 488.5(a)(6) related to the comparability of survey processes as mentioned above. We also proposed changes under § 488.5(a)(5)(viii)(A) related to survey reports. These strengthened requirements would be applicable to initial and renewal applications, effective 1 year after the effective date of the rule.

• We proposed at § 488.5(a)(8)(i) through § 488.5(a)(8)(iv) to require that AO surveyors complete the applicable CMS online surveyor trainings.

• We proposed to add a requirement at § 488.5(a)(10) that the AOs must provide, as part of their initial and

renewal applications, specific policies and procedures that would address how the AOs would prevent and address conflicts of interest. We proposed that AOs provide information on a number of specific policies and procedures regarding conflicts of interest.

• We proposed to revise requirements under § 488.5(a)(12) related to the AO procedures for investigating and responding to complaints against accredited facilities.

• We proposed revisions to § 488.5(a)(13) related to the AO's accreditation status decision-making process, to strengthen the comparability of the survey processes.

• We proposed to add a new requirement at § 488.5(a)(21) that would require an AO to submit a statement with its initial or renewal application certifying that, in response to a written notice from CMS notifying the AO that one of its accredited providers or suppliers has been involuntarily terminated from the Medicare/Medicaid program, the AO agrees to terminate or revoke its accreditation of the terminated provider or supplier within 5 business days from receipt of said written notice.

• We proposed at § 488.5(a)(22) to require an AO submit a declaration from each surveyor disclosing any interests or relationships the surveyor may have in or with another survey agency or in or with a healthcare facility the AO accredits (as defined in § 488.5(a)(10)).

• We proposed at § 488.8(a)(2) to expand the types of accreditation survey validation activities included in CMS' performance review.

• We proposed at § 488.8(a)(4) to require an AOs submit a plan of correction that would be subject to a public reporting requirement, when the AO's performance on survey activities identify disparity concerns, either through the outcome disparity rates or process disparity rates.

• We proposed at new § 488.8(i) to place restrictions on the fee-based consulting services provided by AOs to the healthcare providers and suppliers they accredit. At § 488.8(i)(1), we proposed that an accrediting organization or its associated fee-based consulting division or company may not provide fee-based consulting services to any healthcare provider or supplier prior to an initial accreditation survey. At § 488.5(i)(2), we proposed to prohibit AOs from providing fee-based consulting services to healthcare providers and suppliers they accredit within 12 months prior to the next scheduled re-accreditation survey of that provider or supplier. At § 488.5(i)(3), we proposed that AOs may not provide fee-based consulting services to a healthcare provider or supplier in response to a complaint received by the AO regarding that provider or supplier.

• At § 488.8(i)(4), we proposed circumstances in which the restrictions to the provision of AO fee-based consulting services would not apply.

• We proposed at § 488.8(i)(5) to require AOs to provide specific information to CMS on a bi-annual basis about the fee-based consulting services they provide.

• We proposed at § 488.8(i)(6) to take actions against AOs for the provision of prohibited fee-based consulting services.

• We proposed at § 488.8(k) that when an AO owner, surveyor, or other employee, currently or within the previous 2 years, has an interest in or relationship with a healthcare facility that the AO accredits, the AO would be required to take steps to prevent the surveyor from having any involvement with the survey of that facility; having input into the results of the survey and accreditation for that facility; having involvement with the pre- and post-survey activities for that facility; and having contact with or access to the records for the survey of that healthcare facility.

• We proposed at § 488.9(b) to revise the types of validation programs by adding a new type of validation survey to be conducted by SA or CMS surveyors.

• We proposed a new paragraph § 489.20(z) which would require a terminated provider attempting to re-enroll to follow the terms of proposed new § 489.57(b) noted below.

• We proposed to redesignate the current § 489.57(a) and (b) and add a new paragraph (b) at § 489.57, to require that Medicare-certified providers or suppliers that have been involuntarily terminated from the Medicare and/or Medicaid program must meet several requirements before CMS will approve their new Medicare agreements. Proposed § 489.57(b)(1) would place the terminated provider or supplier under the oversight of the SA for a reasonable assurance period (with the length of time to be determined by CMS) for the purpose of demonstrating compliance with the Medicare conditions. Proposed § 489.57(b)(2) would require the provider or supplier to remain under the exclusive oversight of the SA until the SA has certified and/or CMS has determined its full compliance with all Medicare conditions, and CMS has approved the new agreement for participation in the Medicare/Medicaid program. Proposed § 489.57(b)(3) would require that while a provider or supplier was terminated from the Medicare program, under the oversight of the SA, and when a new agreement for Medicare participation was pending, CMS would not accept or recognize deeming accreditation of that provider or supplier from a CMS-approved accrediting organization.

• We also proposed to remove the reference at § 488.4(a)(2) (inadvertently proposed as a revision to the proposed recodification at § 488.4(a)(4)) that currently excludes end-stage renal disease (ESRD) facilities from the opportunity for accreditation, to reflect a change included in the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 (Pub. L. 115-123). Consistent with this same provision, we also proposed to remove the reference restricting transplant programs from utilizing an accreditation option.

• We proposed to integrate the acute care hospital and psychiatric hospital survey processes for SAs to ensure that there was a systematic and integrated survey of psychiatric hospital quality and safety. We also proposed to expand the acute care hospital accreditation program for AOs to include current psychiatric hospital accreditation standards that would require AOs with existing CMS-approved hospital programs to expand their existing hospital programs to include survey activities of psychiatric services in psychiatric hospitals.

• We solicited comments on whether CMS should limit the number of times an AO could submit an incomplete initial application for a new accreditation program. We sought comment on this question because we recently received several incomplete applications which required multiple pass backs due to the applicant's failure to provide information about issues, such as their financial viability, survey processes which appeared not to be operationalized, or similar concerns.

• We note that the regulations have some minor phrasing changes related to updated style guidelines.

II. Background

A. Legislative History

To participate in the Medicare program, providers and suppliers of healthcare services must, among other things, be in substantial compliance with the applicable statutory requirements of the Social Security Act (the Act), as well as CMS' regulatory requirements related to the health and safety of patients. These health and safety requirements are generally called CoPs for most providers; Requirements for Participation for skilled nursing

facilities (SNFs) and Medicaid Nursing Facilities (NFs) (collectively, long-term care facilities); and CfCs for Ambulatory Surgical Centers (ASCs), Rural Health Clinics (RHCs), Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHCs), ESRD facilities, and some types of suppliers (collectively referred herein as Medicare conditions). A Medicare-certified provider or supplier that does not comply with the Medicare conditions risks having its Medicare provider or supplier agreement terminated. Medicaid service providers or suppliers that are required by CMS or the State to have Medicare approval would also be affected.

In accordance with section 1864 of the Act, the SAs or other appropriate local agencies, under an agreement with the Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (the Secretary), perform surveys of healthcare providers and suppliers to assess their compliance with the applicable Medicare conditions for the purpose of certification for participation in the Medicare/Medicaid program. There are several types of surveys conducted, including initial certification, recertification, and complaint surveys. The SAs and CMS also perform surveys in certain circumstances for the providers and suppliers that are accredited by an AO and deemed to meet Medicare requirements. For example, the SA performs complaint surveys for healthcare providers that are accredited by an AO, if the complaint was received by the SA directly. The SA also performs surveys of AO-accredited healthcare providers that have had their participation in the Medicare program terminated, that wish to be surveyed by the SA instead of an AO, and for the purpose of validation of the results of an AO's surveys. Rules, regulations, and guidance for the certification process performed by the SAs are discussed in the CMS State Operations Manual (SOM)

1

or communicated via Quality, Safety & Oversight (QSO) policy memorandums.

2

1

CMS Internet Only Manual, Pub. 100-07, available at

https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/internet-Only-Manuals-IOMs-Items/CMS1201984.

2

https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Provider-Enrollment-and-Certification/SurveyCertificationGenInfo/Policy-and-Memos-to-States-and-Regions.

Some provider types may only be surveyed by the SA and cannot use AOs while others cannot be surveyed by SAs pursuant to statute but can only participate in Medicare if accredited by a CMS-approved AO. We refer readers to section “III. Summary of the Proposed Provisions, Public Comments, and Responses to Comments on the Proposed Rule” of this final rule with comment period for additional information. For those providers participating via State survey, based on the SA's certification of a provider's compliance or noncompliance and recommendation, CMS determines whether the provider or supplier qualifies, or continues to qualify, for participation in the Medicare program. Additionally, section 1865(a) of the Act allows most healthcare facilities to demonstrate their compliance with the Medicare conditions through accreditation by a CMS-approved program of an AO, in lieu of being surveyed by SAs for certification. This is referred to as “deeming” accreditation. This is because CMS-approved AOs are recognized by the Secretary as having accreditation programs with accreditation standards that meet or exceed those of Medicare. Therefore, any provider or supplier that is accredited by an AO under a CMS-approved accreditation program is deemed by CMS to have also complied with the applicable Medicare conditions or requirements. The AOs perform initial, re-accreditation, follow-up, and certain complaint surveys.

In December 2020, Division CC, section 407 of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2021 (CAA, 2021) (Pub. L. 116-260), amended Part A of Title XVIII of the Act to add a new section 1822 to the Act, and amended sections 1864(a) and 1865(b) of the Act, establishing new hospice program survey and enforcement requirements. CMS issued implementing regulations for SAs and AOs in the CY 2022 Home Health Prospective Payment System Rate Update (HH PPS) final rule (86 FR 62240). The HH PPS rule finalized changes to increase and improve transparency, oversight, and enforcement for hospice programs under SA and AO oversight. Additionally, the HH PPS final rule in part requires hospice program AOs to measure and reduce inconsistency in the application of survey results among all surveyors. The HH PPS final rule: (1) requires AOs with CMS-approved hospice programs to use the same survey deficiency reports as the SAs (Form CMS-2567, “Statement of Deficiencies” or a successor form) to report survey findings; (2) requires comprehensive training and testing of SA and AO hospice program surveyors; and (3) prohibits SA and AO surveyors from surveying hospice programs for which they have worked in the last 2 years (and by which there might be a perceived or actual conflict of interest for these surveyors).

CMS is responsible for: (1) providing ongoing oversight of AO accreditation programs to ensure that a provider or supplier accredited by an AO meets the required Medicare conditions; (2) ensuring that an AO has formalized procedures to determine whether the healthcare facilities deemed under its accreditation programs meet the AO's accreditation standards (which must meet or exceed the applicable Medicare program requirements); and (3) ensuring that the AO's accreditation standards and practices for surveying providers and suppliers meet or exceed the Medicare conditions and practices for granting approval.

For some provider and supplier types, accreditation is voluntary and seeking deemed status through an accreditation organization is an option, not a requirement, for these Medicare-certified providers and suppliers. A provider or supplier has the choice to seek deeming status and accreditation from an AO with a CMS-approved program or certification through the SA survey process. A nationally recognized AO may have accreditation services which are not specifically related to Medicare-participation or Medicare conditions and an AO may offer accreditation services to a provider or supplier which Medicare does not recognize for deeming status, such as long-term care facilities. The AO may also provide accreditation with a deeming option, which is that their deemed program is recognized and approved by CMS to meet or exceed the Medicare program requirements. We refer readers to section “III.K. Require the AOs that Accredit Medicare-Certified Providers and Suppliers to Use Medicare Conditions; and Strengthened Survey Process Comparability” of this final rule with comment period for additional context.

AOs typically charge healthcare facilities a fee for the accreditation services they provide. AOs generally offer at least two accreditation options, which include non-CMS approved accreditation, and accreditation for the purpose of participating in the Medicare program. By “non-CMS approved accreditation” we mean accreditation that is offered by the AOs with an accreditation program but is not approved by Medicare, and which is not used for Medicare purposes. Such accreditation could be used for individual State accreditation purposes or additional professional accreditations that a provider or supplier seeks for business purposes, such as The Joint Commission's (TJC's) Nursing Care

Center accreditation for skilled nursing facilities, which is not recognized by CMS as an option for deemed status.

This final rule with comment period will apply only to the AOs with CMS-approved programs that accredit Medicare-certified providers and suppliers and those entities they accredit. The provisions of this final rule will not apply to the following parties: (1) healthcare providers and suppliers that are not currently accredited by AOs, such as, but not limited to, nursing homes and comprehensive outpatient rehabilitation facilities (CORFs); (2) healthcare providers and suppliers that are certified by the SAs, such as those who elect not to be deemed through an AO; (3) AOs that accredit non-certified suppliers; (4) non-certified suppliers; and (5) AOs that accredit laboratories (under the Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments of 1988 (CLIA)).

B. Regulatory Overview of CMS' Rules Regarding AO Programs

The current regulations at 42 CFR 488.4 set forth the general provisions for CMS-approved accreditation programs for Medicare-certified providers and suppliers. 42 CFR 488.5 sets out application and re-application procedures for national AOs that seek to obtain CMS approval of their accreditation programs, often called “deeming authority.”

The AO application and re-application procedures set forth at § 488.5 for Medicare-certified providers and suppliers task CMS with the responsibilities of approval and oversight of the AOs' accreditation programs while ensuring that the accredited providers and suppliers meet or exceed the Medicare conditions.

CMS conducts a thorough review of each accreditation program application submitted by an AO for CMS approval. This review establishes the “comparability” of the AOs accreditation standards with Medicare, to determine whether the AO's standards meet or exceed the Medicare conditions. The application review process also includes a review of the AO's survey processes and procedures, the AO's surveyor training, and their policies and procedures for the oversight and enforcement of provider or supplier entities they accredit. The application review team also reviews the qualifications of the AO surveyor staff. In addition, CMS reviews the AO's financial status, to determine their solvency and potential for longevity of operations.

Section 488.5(e)(1) requires that we publish a notice in the

Federal Register

when we receive a complete initial or renewal application from a national AO seeking CMS approval of its accreditation program. The

Federal Register

notice identifies the organization and the type of providers or suppliers to be covered by the accreditation program and provides a 30-day public comment period. CMS has 210 days from the receipt of a complete application to publish notice of approval or denial of the application. Upon approval, any provider or supplier subsequently accredited by the AO's approved program would be deemed by CMS to have met the applicable Medicare conditions and would be referred to as having “deemed status.”

C. Congressional Report on the Oversight of National AOs and CMS-Approved Accreditation Programs

We are required by section 1875(b) of the Act to submit an annual Report to Congress

3

on CMS' oversight of national AOs and their CMS-approved accreditation programs. This report contains information related to the AOs' activities in a fiscal year (FY) and provides a comparison of these activities to the activities of previous years. Within this report, we also measure the “disparity rate,” which is a comparison rate based on AO findings of non-compliance during an accreditation survey and the SA findings of non-compliance for the same facilities found during a look-back validation survey.

3

The most recent Report to Congress may be accessed at

https://www.cms.gov/files/document/qso-22-06-ao-clia.pdf.

For certain types of healthcare facilities, there are three levels of adverse findings on an SA survey: immediate jeopardy (IJ); condition-level deficiencies; and standard-level deficiencies. Sections 488.1 and 489.3 define immediate jeopardy as a situation in which the provider's or supplier's non-compliance with one or more of Medicare requirements, conditions of participation, conditions for coverage or certification “has caused or is likely to cause, serious injury, harm, impairment, or death to a resident or patient.” When investigating a potential immediate jeopardy situation, surveyors must find that there is non-compliance by the provider or supplier, that serious harm has occurred or is likely to occur, and that immediate action needs to be taken by the provider/supplier (see Appendix Q of the SOM for additional guidance). A condition-level deficiency means that for that particular requirement under a Medicare condition of participation or condition for coverage, also known as a CoP or a CfC respectively, the facility's noncompliance is such that it substantially limits the provider's or supplier's capacity to furnish adequate care or adversely affects the health and safety of patients (§ 488.24(b)). Surveyors may determine that a deficiency under a single standard alone may have substantially limited a facility's capacity to furnish adequate care and/or adversely affected the health and safety of the facility's patients such that it rises to the level of a condition-level deficiency. The manner and degree of the deficient practice is considered to determine whether there is substantial noncompliance (that is, a condition-level deficiency) or not. A standard-level deficiency means that the provider is out of compliance with one or more aspects of a regulatory condition or requirement that is not severe enough to rise to the level of a condition-level deficiency. A condition-level deficiency, however, is considered more serious in nature and could lead to a facility being terminated from the Medicare and Medicaid programs for non-compliance. Immediate jeopardy citations are condition-level deficiencies that pose immediate jeopardy to patient health and safety. On a validation survey, when the SA cites a condition-level deficiency for which the AO has not cited a comparable deficiency, the deficiency is considered by CMS to have been missed by the AO and is a factor in determining the AO's “disparity rate” for each facility type. The identification of one missed condition-level deficiency by the AO results in the entire survey being counted toward the disparity rate. The number of disparate surveys is divided by the total number of validation surveys performed with respect to that AO by various SAs, to determine the AO's disparity rate.

According to the most recent report, the FY 2020 Report to Congress,

4

average disparity rates for all CMS-approved AO programs for the following facility types for the most recent year in the report (FY 2019) are: Hospitals (42 percent); Psychiatric hospitals (45 percent); Critical Access Hospitals (46 percent); Home Health Agencies (HHAs, 8 percent); Hospices (19 percent) and Ambulatory Surgical Centers (34 percent). From FY 2018 to FY 2019, hospitals, HHAs and ASCs had the only decreases in disparity rates, with a decrease of 5 percentage points, 11

percentage points, and 7 percentage points, respectively. The disparity rates for psychiatric hospitals increased by seven percentage points from FY 2018 to FY 2019. The disparity rates for Critical Access Hospitals (CAHs) and hospices increased by 5 percentage points and 3 percentage points respectively from FY 2018 to FY 2019. The findings and other information are consistent with previous reports, and no other notable changes were observed in the FY 2020 Report to Congress covering the FY 2019 period of activities. We note the impact of the COVID-19 public health emergency (PHE) in relation to the decreased representative validation survey sample size and disparity rates during FY 2020, and the continued suspension of look-back validation surveys since that point.

4

https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Provider-Enrollment-and-Certification/SurveyCertificationGenInfo/Downloads/QSO-19-17-AO-CLIA.pdf.

D. CMS Validation Survey Pilot

As part of our ongoing efforts to enhance transparency and our oversight of the AOs, in 2018, CMS began a pilot for integrated validation surveys for accredited hospitals, known as the Validation Redesign Program (VRP) pilot. In a VRP pilot survey, the SA teams accompany the AO survey teams on a reaccreditation survey for an accredited facility for the purpose of evaluating the AO surveyors' competency at performing surveys and overall effectiveness during the survey process. The initial findings of the VRP pilot were discussed in the proposed rule at sections IV.J. and IV.L.3. CMS plans to continue to refine the validation process over the next several years to enhance AO oversight and verify that providers/suppliers under deemed status are in compliance with the Medicare conditions and focus surveys on key quality concerns while reducing provider/supplier burden.

A national AO seeking approval of its accreditation programs in accordance with section 1865(a) of the Act must apply for and be approved by CMS for a period not to exceed 6 years. (See §§ 488.5(a), (e)(2)(i)). An AO must submit a renewal application if it wishes to seek re-approval of its accreditation program(s) before the expiration date of its current CMS approval. Review of the AO's renewal application in a timely manner allows CMS to ensure that there would not be a lapse in accreditation for the providers and suppliers accredited by the AO. Requiring the AO to submit a renewal application periodically allows CMS to ensure that the providers or suppliers accredited by that AO meet or exceed the Medicare conditions.

E. Overview of Transparency and Oversight of Accrediting Organizations

In September 2017, an article in the Wall Street Journal

5

raised concerns regarding the performance and transparency of AO surveys and noted potential conflicts of interest between an AO's accreditation services and its consulting services. As a result of this article, CMS initiated an investigation into these allegations.

5

The Wall Street Journal, “Watchdog Awards Hospitals Seal of Approval Even After Problems Emerge” Stephanie Armour (September 8, 2017)

https://www.wsj.com/articles/watchdog-awards-hospitals-seal-of-approval-even-after-problems-emerge-1504889146.

F. Prior Rulemaking—Accrediting Organizations Conflicts-of-Interest Request for Information (RFI)

CMS is aware, from the information submitted with their applications, that some AOs with CMS-approved accreditation programs are also providing fee-based consultative services to Medicare-participating healthcare facilities. Our understanding is that typical AO fee-based consultative services include, but are not limited to, the following:

• Assistance for clinical and non-clinical leaders (including administrators) in understanding the AO standards and Medicare conditions for compliance;

• Review of facility standards and promised early intervention and action through simulation of a real survey, such as a mock survey with comprehensive written reports of findings;

• Review of a facility's processes, policies, and functions;

• Identification of, and technical assistance for, changing and sustaining areas in need of improvement; and

• Educational consultative services.

CMS acknowledges that independent fee-based consulting is a valuable resource that can help providers and suppliers improve the quality and safety of the care they provide. This does not mean that the providers or suppliers who elect not to receive fee-based consulting from an AO that offers it, or that providers or suppliers that are accredited by an AO that does not offer this service would not provide safe, quality care.

There are many third-party consultants that offer fee-based consulting across all provider and supplier types. The availability of third-party fee-based consultants give providers and suppliers access to this educational service, if their AO does not provide fee-based consulting. If a provider's/supplier's AO already offers fee-based consulting, third-party consultants can offer such providers and suppliers with an alternative, allowing providers and suppliers to compare the effectiveness and quality of consultants to address their needs within their cost limitations. The provider or supplier may also be able to negotiate a price for educational services provided by a third-party consultant, while this may not be an option with the AOs that offer fee-based consulting. It is important to note there would be no conflict of interest associated with the use of third-party fee-based consultants because these consultants do not also make compliance determinations about the provider or supplier.

Fee-based consulting services offered by AOs are not prohibited by law or regulation. However, CMS is concerned that an AO's provision of such fee-based consulting results in perceived or actual conflicts of interests because of the contractual and financial relationship that exists between the healthcare provider and the AO, which is a private entity that profits from the performance of the inherently governmental function of regulating healthcare providers through accreditation.

Because of this, on December 20, 2018, we published a Request for Information (RFI) in the

Federal Register

entitled, “Medicare Program: Accrediting Organizations Conflict of Interest and Consulting Services; Request for Information” (83 FR 65331), hereinafter referred to as “2018 AO Conflict-of-Interest RFI”, in response to increasing concern about potential conflicts of interest created by the accreditation and consultative activities of the AOs. Specifically, we solicited public comments to determine whether offering consultative services to the same entities an AO accredits may create actual or perceived conflicts of interest between an AO's accreditation program and its consultative program. We stated that this dual function may undermine, or appear to undermine, the integrity of the accreditation programs and could erode public trust in the safety of providers and suppliers that have been accredited by CMS-approved AOs. We further acknowledged that certain consulting services offered by some of the AOs, such as quality improvement work and training of facility staff, may be beneficial to some facilities and result in improvements in operations or the quality of care furnished and may be provided with the best of intentions. We stated that circumstances could arise where an AO has recommended a facility for deemed status through their accreditation

service, while the consultancy service of the AO was generating revenue assisting the same facility in passing the AO's own accreditation surveys. Some AOs have indicated that they establish firewalls between the arms of their businesses, but we stated that these firewalls may not be sufficient to ensure that no conflicts of interest result from these activities.

We further stated that, similar to quality improvement organization (QIO) and external quality review organization programs, any AO with a Medicare-approved accreditation program has assumed a position of public trust and is responsible for acting on behalf of the public, because the AO is performing a function that assists in the Federal government's enforcement programs. We also expressed our view that AOs voluntarily take on this position and responsibility when they seek accreditation approval from CMS to accredit providers and suppliers for participation in Medicare. Because of the responsibility to maintain public trust and public health, we continually ensure that all entities and programs, including AOs and their accreditation programs that require CMS approval, be held to high standards of ethical conduct so that everyone can have complete confidence in the integrity of Federal government certification. We stated that the AOs' decisions to accredit facilities must be made without regard to any additional services that a Medicare provider or supplier might obtain through the AO or its subsidiaries. We stated that this policy would ensure and maintain public trust in the Medicare certification program.

In the 2018 AO Conflict-of-Interest RFI, we solicited public comments to gather information for potential future rulemaking and to obtain insight on mechanisms to address this potential conflict of interest. We were specifically interested in ways to potentially modify § 488.5(a), which sets out the required information to be submitted with an AO's application. For example, § 488.5(a)(10) states that the application information from the AO include the organization's policies and procedures to avoid conflicts of interest, including the appearance of conflicts of interest, involving individuals who conduct surveys or participate in accreditation decisions.

We stated that potentially expanding § 488.5(a)(10) by adding provisions that would require the AOs to disclose information about any consultative services they offer to facilities could further enhance our oversight of AOs.

In addition, we solicited comments on the following issues:

• With respect to fee-based consultative services provided by AOs to the facilities they accredit—

++ How are these services provided and communicated to the facilities?

++ Are potential conflicts of interest disclosed?

• Are there other entities that could provide this training besides the AOs?

• Whether commenters perceive a conflict of interest in AOs providing fee-based consultative services to the facilities they accredit.

• Whether the ability of an AO to collect fees for consultation services from entities they accredit could degrade the public trust inherent in an AO's CMS-approved accreditation programs.

• What the appropriate consequences or impacts should be, if a conflict does exist.

• What firewalls may exist within an AO between accreditation and consultation services, or what firewalls would be prudent, to avoid potential and actual conflicts of interest.

• Examples of positive and negative effects which may arise as a result of a conflict of interest.

• What the potential impact, financially and overall would be if CMS were to finalize rulemaking which would restrict certain activities that might give rise to a real or perceived conflict of interest.

• When and/or under what circumstances it would be appropriate for AOs to provide fee-based consultative services to the facilities which they accredit.

• Whether, and if so under what specific circumstances, CMS should review a potential conflict of interest, and what factors CMS should look at to determine if a conflict of interest exists.

• A list describing under what circumstances the AOs or interested parties would believe there to be a conflict; and under which circumstances a conflict does not exist.

• The type of information which would be considered necessary, useful and/or appropriate in proving or refuting our hypothesis of a connection between the use of consultative services and preferential treatment of accredited providers and suppliers. (See 83 FR 65335.)

We received 128 public comments in response to the 2018 AO Conflict-of-Interest RFI. Approximately half of the commenters (consisting primarily of AOs and healthcare facilities that use consulting services) supported the use of AO consulting services and stated that there is no conflict of interest associated with fee-based consulting. The other half of the commenters (consisting of individuals, provider associations, medical advocacy groups and one AO) stated that the provision of fee-based consulting by the AOs creates a conflict of interest.

Several commenters stated that the benefits derived from AO fee-based consulting far outweigh any potential or actual conflict of interest that may result. Many commenters believe that AO consulting services allow the facility to seek information and guidance that helps them understand, interpret and comply with the Medicare conditions and regulatory requirements. These commenters stated that use of the AO's fee-based consulting services helped to improve the safety and quality of the care provided by the healthcare facility.

Many commenters stated that there are already implemented checks and balances between CMS and the AOs that are sufficient to ensure that no conflicts of interest occur between the AOs and their accredited facilities. These commenters stated that the AOs have robust firewall policies and procedures in place to prevent conflicts of interest related to fee-based consulting. Many commenters also stated that CMS has a specific AO fee-based consulting firewall policy in place and that this policy is adequate to prevent any conflicts of interest. However, CMS does not currently have such a policy.

6

6

In section IV.B.6. of the proposed rule, we proposed to require any AO that provides fee-based consulting services, or its associated fee-based consulting division or company, have written fee-based consulting “firewall” policies and procedures.

Several commenters stated that AOs are commissioned to ensure compliance with the Medicare conditions. These commenters stated that a big part of compliance is not only being punitive but informational/educational. One commenter suggested that AOs are in a unique position to provide this education and technical assistance because they understand the complexity of the Medicare conditions. One commenter stated that if AO fee-based consulting services were not provided, facilities could see additional deficiencies cited due to misinterpretation of requirements and multiple rounds of surveys, generating still more cost to the facility.

Several commenters stated that the financial benefit derived by the AOs from providing fee-based education is not significant. Some of these commenters also stated that the AOs gained no benefit from the success or results of accreditation whether they had assisted the provider to deliver better services or not.

One commenter stated that they are not aware of other organizations that would be capable of educating and advising healthcare providers in a similar fashion as the AOs' consulting services. Several other commenters expressed concern about having fee-based consulting services provided by an independent third-party. These commenters stated that, while there are other entities besides the AOs, such as QIOs, that could provide training, the focus would solely be on quality rather than the outcome of an accreditation.

Many commenters stated that the integrity of the accreditation process is of utmost concern for regulators, providers, and patients alike and that AOs should position themselves to be above reproach regarding overseeing patient care and quality of services that healthcare facilities provide, so as to retain the trust of patients and the public. Several commenters suggested that anything that may undermine the integrity of accreditation programs or the public trust in CMS accredited providers and suppliers be considered and addressed. One commenter stated that the ability of AOs to provide both survey services and consulting services is a conflict of interest, which results in a decreased level of trust among providers, Medicare, and the public.

Many commenters expressed concern about the financial and contractual relationship that exists between AOs and the healthcare facilities they accredit. These commenters expressed concern that the existence of a financial relationship between AOs and healthcare providers casts a veil of doubt over the entire CMS hospital accreditation process, eroding the public trust in CMS to maintain the standard of care at our nation's hospitals and to ensure that Medicare patients are receiving safe, therapeutic care. One commenter opined that the business connection between the provider and the AO creates a relationship that the AO could have an incentive to manipulate.

In addition, several commenters expressed concern about the significant financial interest the AOs have in the provision of fee-based consulting. One commenter stated that since AOs are being paid by the healthcare facilities for both accreditation services as well as consulting services, it is obviously in their financial interest to keep the healthcare facilities accredited and not to create too much dissatisfaction to incite the organization to seek another AO. Several commenters expressed concern that this financial relationship might provide the incentive for the AOs to ignore or downplay deficiencies during the survey of a consultative client to increase the apparent efficacy of its consulting services. Or, perhaps, an AO could exaggerate the deficiencies on surveys to increase the apparent value of the consulting services to providers. Because of the previously stated concerns, several commenters suggested that CMS prohibit the AOs from providing fee-based consulting to the healthcare providers and suppliers they accredit.

G. Conflicts of Interest—The AO Owner's, Surveyor's, and Other Employee's Interest in or Relationship With a Healthcare Facility That the AO Accredits

It is typical for an individual healthcare professional, such as a physician or nurse, to have concurrent employment relationships with more than one healthcare provider. Many healthcare professionals, such as physicians, physician assistants, and nurse practitioners have multi-setting practices or are employed at more than one healthcare facility. For example, a registered nurse (RN) may work on staff at a hospital but also work at other hospitals through a medical staffing agency. In addition, as employees of a healthcare facility, these healthcare professionals could possibly gain a financial interest in the healthcare facility through means such as being a contributor to the construction costs of a new wing of the facility or buying stock in the facility or its parent corporation. Management employees could be awarded stock or stock options for the facility or its parent corporation as part of their compensation and benefits package.

AOs frequently hire surveyors that are also employed at one or more outside healthcare settings because the professional associations, expertise, knowledge and skills held by these healthcare practitioners make them an asset as a surveyor. This might include, for example, an RN who is employed by a hospital and also works as a surveyor for an AO. This employment scenario does not generally violate CMS policy or regulations. Furthermore, an AO surveyor having other employment does not, in and of itself, necessarily create a conflict of interest. However, if the AO provides accreditation services to the healthcare facility that employs the AO surveyor, this could cause a conflict of interest if that surveyor is permitted to have any involvement in the survey process for that healthcare facility.

CMS has recently encountered two situations in which an AO's surveyor was also employed by the healthcare facility that was being accredited by the AO. In one of these situations, an AO surveyor was also employed in an administrative position at a rehabilitation facility that was being surveyed by the AO. This situation was not disclosed to CMS by the AO. Currently, CMS has no specific regulations that would prohibit a conflict of interest related to an AO surveyor's relationship with a healthcare facility that the AO accredits, except for home health agencies and hospice programs.

Section 488.5(a)(10) of our regulations requires that an AO provide, with its application seeking CMS approval of its accreditation program, “the organization's policies and procedures to avoid conflicts of interest, including the appearance of conflicts of interest, involving individuals who conduct surveys or participate in accreditation decisions.” However, § 488.5(a)(10) does not provide requirements for specific types of information or requirements that should be contained in the AO's conflict-of-interest policies and procedures. This regulation does not specifically prohibit or define conflicts of interest and based on the comments to the 2018 AO Conflict-of-Interest RFI, CMS proposed to revise this regulation to more specifically address situations that should be included in the AO's conflict-of-interest policy.

As noted previously, the SAs and AOs perform similar work. Section 4008 of the SOM describes examples of scenarios that would be conflicts of interest for SA surveyors who have an outside relationship with a facility that is surveyed by the SA.

7

Currently, section 4008 of the SOM applies only to SA surveyors and not AO surveyors.

7

https://www.cms.gov/Regulations-and-Guidance/Guidance/Manuals/Downloads/som107c04pdf.pdf.

Scenarios in which an AO surveyor has a relationship with a healthcare facility that their AO accredits could represent a conflict of interest. As CMS has no specific regulations that would proactively address such conflicts of interest for AOs that accredit healthcare providers other than home health agencies and hospice programs, we proposed establishing several requirements to help mitigate such conflicts of interest in section IV.B.7. of the proposed rule.

H. Public Comment on Whether it Is a Conflict of Interest for AO Board Members or Advisors To Have an Interest in, or Relationship With, a Healthcare Facility that the AO Accredits

As previously stated, it could be a conflict of interest when an AO surveyor is involved with the survey of a facility with which that surveyor has an employment, financial, business or other interest or relationship. We note that in most cases, the AO board members do have interests in or relationships with the healthcare facilities the AO accredits. In many cases, the board members of the AOs frequently hold upper management positions of a healthcare facility the AO accredits, such as chief executive officer (CEO), director, or President. In the proposed rule, we sought public comment as to whether it would be a conflict of interest for an AO board member, AO advisor, or CEO or other executive team members to also have a relationship with a healthcare organization accredited by such AO. An AO advisor would be an advisory committee member, advisor to the CEO, or an advisor to the board of directors. We refer readers to the revisions related to an AO owner's, surveyor's or other employee's interest in, or relationship with, a healthcare facility the AO accredits in section III.J. of this final rule with comment period.

We received comments in response to our request for public comments on whether it is a conflict of interest for AO board members or advisors to have an interest in or relationship with a healthcare facility that the AO accredits. The comments and responses can be found in section III.D. of this final rule with comment period.

III. Summary of the Proposed Provisions, Public Comments, and Responses to Comments on the Proposed Rule

As stated in section “I. Executive Summary” and section “II. Background” of this final rule with comment period, there are several provisions related to oversight of AOs that we believe require strengthening since we issued the 2015 AO final rule. Over the last several years, we have worked closely with the AOs to establish and implement an AO Liaison program in which we meet with each AO regularly (at least on a quarterly basis). These meetings and discussions have provided an avenue for CMS to also receive feedback on existing Medicare conditions and our interpretive guidelines and allowed us an opportunity to clarify our expectations for the AOs. Most importantly, this experience has helped us to identify areas of our AO oversight regulations in need of revision so that we might more clearly articulate the requirements for all AOs with CMS-approved accreditation programs. Therefore, we have become aware of the need to clarify, reorganize, and amend our regulations to support a more efficient and effective oversight process.

The proposed rule, titled “Medicare Program; Strengthening Oversight of Accrediting Organizations (AOs) and Preventing AO Conflict of Interest, and Related Provisions” (89 FR 11996 through 12064), was published in the

Federal Register

on February 15, 2024, with a comment period that ended on April 15, 2024. We received approximately 250 individual public comments from 58 separate commenters on our proposals, including comments from AOs; ESRD facilities; national renal groups, nephrologists, and patient organizations; patients and care partners; manufacturers; healthcare systems; and nurses.

In this final rule with comment period, we provide a summary of each proposed provision, a summary of the public comments received and our responses, the policies and requirements we are finalizing for AOs (including those for preventing AO conflicts of interest), and other related provisions we are finalizing in this rule.

A. General Comments in Support of the Proposed Rule

Comment:

Many commenters supported the provisions of the proposed rule. They stated that the rule aims to protect patients, strengthen oversight of AOs to ensure that the highest quality of care is being delivered to all patients. Commenters also stated that this rule will help to ensure that all AOs conduct their work in a consistent, rigorous, and unbiased manner. The proposals made in the rule, if finalized, will prevent conflicts of interest, streamline survey processes and ensure more consistency between AOs and CMS or SA surveyors. One commenter supported the proposed rule because they believe it is imperative that as CMS seeks to improve oversight and transparency of AOs, it avoids introducing unnecessary obstacles to the ability of providers to seek accreditation through these AOs. One commenter the proposal made in the proposed rule and further suggested that CMS be more aggressive in their effort to strengthen the requirements and process for deeming hospices eligible for Medicare certification given the ongoing challenges related to hospice fraud, waste, and abuse. Another commenter supported the proposed rule because it will help the public know which healthcare facilities to choose from and to be confident that any accredited facilities they do choose will provide high-quality care.

Response:

We thank these commenters for their support of the provisions of the proposed rule.

B. Comments Expressing General Opposition to the Proposed Rule

Comment:

Two commenters believe the proposed oversight will require additional administrative work from CMS, which one commenter believes is already concerned with existing staffing levels and which the other commenter believes is only now returning to normal workloads after the COVID

-

19 PHE.

Response:

We appreciate these commenters' concerns for the administrative burden on CMS staff to implement the provisions of this rule. We will consider the potential for additional burden to CMS staff when implementing these provisions. We anticipate a fully developed workflow for the increased AO oversight provisions prior to implementation of the rule.

Comment:

One commenter opposed the provisions in the proposed rule because they believe the extent of changes proposed are vast and far reaching; they stated that many provisions contain ambiguities and needed additional clarification.

Response:

We thank this commenter for their comment. We appreciate this commenter's concern for clarity. However, we are not able to respond to this comment because the commenter did not provide enough detail about the provisions they think were excessively far-reaching and/or unclear.

Comment:

Several commenters oppose the proposed rule because they believe that CMS does not have the statutory authority to make such proposals. One commenter stated that the Congress delegated only limited authority to CMS to grant private AOs the ability to “deem” that a provider or supplier meets or exceeds the Medicare conditions and that CMS' limited authority to regulate AOs must be tied to the statutory purpose.

Another commenter believes that the Congress has not granted CMS the authority to determine the AO's service offerings or to regulate any aspects of the AO's operations, governance structure, or business practices. In proposing that AOs only be allowed to provide certain services at certain times, the commenter believes CMS has exceeded its authority under the statute,

venturing into operational grounds with which the Congress never intended the agency to interfere.

Response:

We respectfully disagree. CMS is using the authority established by the Congress under section 1865 of the Act to establish certain requirements for AOs in this rule. The Congress gave CMS broad authority for oversight over the AOs.

Comment:

One commenter recommended that instead of implementing all of the provisions in the proposed rule, we instead select provisions for implementation that receive the least amount of negative public comments, then at a later date, update the proposed changes that may be viewed by some as more burdensome and imprecisely drafted, followed by the issuance of a RFI with an extended comment period that allows time for detailed and evidence-based responses. The commenter believes this segmented approach will allow both CMS and the AOs to focus on perfecting the selected changes without being overwhelmed and overly burdened by the number of changes implemented at one time.

Response:

We thank the commenter for their recommendations but respectfully disagree with this approach to finalizing the rule we proposed in February 2024. We note that we did publish an RFI on December 20, 2018 (83 FR 65331), seeking public input on our oversight of AOs, particularly with regard to AO conflict-of-interest issues. We carefully considered the information received on the 2018 RFI as well as the public comments received on the February 2024 proposed rule as we developed this final rule with comment period.

C. Add Definition of “Unannounced Survey” to § 488.1

We proposed to add a new definition of “unannounced survey” to § 488.1. The definition of “unannounced survey” would be consistent with the definition of “unannounced” contained in the Merriam-Webster dictionary, which is “without previous notice or arrangement and therefore unexpected”. Adding this definition of “unannounced survey” would support the existing requirements set out at § 488.5(a)(4)(i) and in our sub-regulatory guidance. This proposal clarifies and codifies existing requirements under § 488.5(a)(4)(i), which requires that surveys must be unannounced, which means that the facility must be unaware of the survey until the time that the survey team arrives, and that the provider or supplier would not receive notice of the survey until the survey team arrives at the facility. Our long standing policy behind the term “unannounced survey” is within Chapter 2, Section 2700A of the SOM, outlining the expectation that all surveys of providers and suppliers (other than clinical laboratories) must be unannounced to the provider or supplier being surveyed. This means that the provider or supplier to be surveyed would not receive notice of the survey until the survey team arrived at the facility for the survey, as is also currently the AO's process for complaint surveys. The proposed definition for “unannounced survey” would also state that unannounced surveys must be scheduled by the AO in a manner so that their timing and occurrence will not be predictable to the healthcare facility being surveyed.

One of the primary reasons surveys conducted by either the SA or the AO are required to be unannounced is to prevent the provider or supplier from making unusual preparations for the survey that would not represent the ongoing typical condition of the provider, and the true nature and quality of care provided. Examples of these activities would include unusual cleaning activities, painting, clearing obstructions from halls and entrances, denying leave to staff during that time or calling staff back to inflate staffing availability, and re-reviewing medical records outside of what is normally done. If a provider or supplier knows the exact time a surveyor will be onsite, it may temporarily adjust its typical practices such as staffing, which would provide an unrepresentative picture to surveyors of the quality of care typically provided to patients or residents. Any notice to facility leadership via organizational websites, emails, or phone calls prior to surveyors arriving onsite is considered a violation of CMS regulations.

In 2009, CMS clarified this expectation in the Survey & Certification Policy Memorandum 09-41,

8

to advise that announcing of surveys was in conflict with CMS regulations. In the effort to align AO survey processes with CMS survey processes (which are followed by the SA surveyors), as outlined in section IV.C. of the proposed rule, we determined that additional clarity regarding this prohibition was needed. Defining the term “unannounced survey” within the regulation as opposed to our SOM (sub-regulatory guidance) would provide clarity regarding our expectations, and would mirror the processes used by the SAs, who do not announce their surveys (except for clinical laboratories); as noted, any AO practice of announcing surveys could undermine the integrity of the survey process. While we recognize that some AOs may have provided up to a 60-minute advance notice of the survey team arriving onsite for initial and reaccreditation survey activities, this practice is inconsistent with the processes followed by our SAs and inconsistent with the AOs' own survey processes for complaint surveys (which are always unannounced). Therefore, in accordance with § 488.5(a)(4)(i), which requires unannounced surveys, as well as our long-standing policy in Chapter 2, Section 2700A of the SOM, we proposed to define “unannounced survey” to clarify through this definition that all surveys of providers and suppliers (other than clinical laboratories) must be unannounced and any advance notice to facilities would be prohibited. This definition would ensure clarity in the requirement that applies to AOs as well as SAs and further support our initiative to bring consistency to survey practices as outlined in section IV.C. of the proposed rule.

8

https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Provider-Enrollment-and-Certification/SurveyCertificationGenInfo/Policy-and-Memos-to-States-and-Regions-Items/CMS1223113.

Furthermore, the definition of “unannounced survey” ensures that the timing of recertification surveys is also unpredictable. AOs generally complete comprehensive re-accreditation surveys of their client providers and suppliers every 32 to 36 months. However, some providers or suppliers have informed us that they know when an AO is scheduled to survey the facility—the AO may schedule the facility for survey within the same week or month every survey cycle, or has narrowed its schedule via the use of blackout days, or informed the facility close to the time of the survey via administrative contact from the AO, such as payment collection, confirmation or change of address notification or other facility-AO specific information. All of these practices undermine the integrity of the unannounced survey process.

We received several comments, with a majority of the comments in general support of our proposed definition. The comments and our responses to the comments are set forth below.

Comment:

We received several comments supporting our proposal for unannounced surveys, restricting blackout dates and ensuring the unpredictability of surveys. One commenter stated that an unannounced survey will enable the surveying organization to more effectively assess the organization in its normal state, identify areas of risk and subsequently

improve patient care. One commenter supported our proposed definition of “unannounced survey”, highlighting that unannounced surveys would not only provide more consistency among AOs and SAs, but also may impact the proliferation of fraudulent hospices. Another commenter stated that announcing any survey allows companies time to prepare and that unannounced surveys will ensure that surveyors receive honest results. One commenter also stated that all surveys should be unannounced without the facility being aware of the survey until the arrival of the survey team. One commenter also stated that among CMS' proposals for increased comparability, the most important aspect was use of the unannounced survey to avoid rigging of the system.

Response:

We appreciate the commenters support of the proposed definition of “unannounced surveys”. We agree that adding the definition will help ensure more consistency among AOs and SAs and the integrity of survey results.

Comment:

We received one comment noting that the proposed definition of “unannounced surveys” and the preamble discussion within the proposed rule are consistent with CMS' 2023 notice letter to AOs (discussing unannounced surveys and blackout dates). The commenter stated that CMS overestimated the actions facilities could take to improve the results of an impending survey on short notice. The commenter urged CMS to consider allowing hospitals a 24-hour notice of the survey to ensure appropriate staff would be available during the survey and to maximize access to hospital leadership and other staff who could answer surveyor questions. The commenter suggested that this would allow for a more efficient survey process and that survey results would be more useful and reflective of the care provided by the facility. The commenter stated that a 24-hour window would not allow sufficient time to make outcome-changing preparations. Finally, the commenter also suggested that when AOs combine complaint investigations with the required 36-month reaccreditation survey the type of survey is frequently not identified by the surveyor. The commenter implied that this process is confusing for hospital staff and risks conflating the results and urges CMS to ensure surveyors clearly identify the purpose of the survey with outreach to hospital staff to address issues which may arise.

Response:

While we appreciate the commenter's concern, we note that we proposed to add a definition, which does not change the requirement at § 488.5(a)(4)(i) that was discussed in the 2023 letter the commenter mentioned, which is a letter from our Quality, Safety & Oversight Group Director that was sent to the AOs through our AO liaisons. Surveys are intended to assess the daily operations of the facility at any time. Facilities should always have processes in place to ensure continuity of care and operations in the event that leadership is not available or onsite. Therefore, we believe that advance notice could give leadership an opportunity to appear involved in the facility, when in normal operations, leadership could be absent or not as involved as made out to appear. Additionally, a 24-hour notice could allow for a facility to increase staffing for the day of the survey or clean areas of the facility which otherwise would have not been changed. As for the commenter's concern that when complaint investigations are incorporated into a recertification/reaccreditation survey, we note that Chapter 5 of the SOM allows both SAs and AOs to combine complaint investigations into the next survey activity if the complaint was triaged as low-priority. However, we understand the commenter's concerns for the need of a transparent process and believe that adding a regulatory definition for “unannounced survey” will further that goal.

Comment:

We received several comments raising concerns about unannounced surveys and the potential for this to disrupt operations. One commenter specifically stated that unannounced surveys disrupt the daily operations of healthcare facilities, potentially affecting patient care and staff workflows. The commenter also stated that this is a resource burden where facilities may need to allocate more resources to maintain constant readiness for survey. Another commenter stated that some individuals who support regulatory surveys may not work onsite at the facility and that certain departments such as infection prevention, quality or others may be covered by individuals working in multiple locations, especially in rural locations. Alternatively, one commenter stated that surveys should not be delayed more than 30 minutes of the reported opening time. Finally, two commenters also advised that notification on the initial day of survey is critical to ensure key members are present, negate interruptions in the facility's operations, and ensure coordination, especially for multi-site institutions. One of the two commenters specifically stated that same-day notification would protect patient and workforce safety.

Response:

While we appreciate the commenters' concerns, we note that CMS has expected that all survey activities from the SAs and AOs are to be unannounced and has reiterated this expectation in § 488.5(a)(4)(i), the SOM, and other subregulatory guidance.

9

This long-standing requirement ensures that surveyors can observe a facility's daily operation and that facilities do not make adjustments to pass the survey, as implied by the commenter. Surveyors are flexible and are required to work around the facility's schedules and its daily requirements to provide patient care. For instance, if a Registered Nurse is assisting a survey team with record reviews but needs to see patients, the expectation is that patient care takes priority over survey activities. Similarly, should a facility have staff which support the daily operations but may be off-site, surveyors will wait for their arrival and conduct other survey activities during that time, or even conduct telephone interviews should the individual not be able to travel to the facility on the survey date(s). We agree with the one commenter related to delay of survey activities upon arrival beyond 30 minutes should not be the norm; however, we believe that the facility's verification of the survey team and beginning the survey processes (including the facility gathering required documentation) should not be significantly slowed. Surveyors may delay the formal entrance conference to await leadership or staff the facility may want present, especially in situations with multiple locations.

9

https://www.cms.gov/medicare/provider-enrollment-and-certification/surveycertificationgeninfo/policy-and-memos-to-states-and-regions-items/cms1223113.

Comment:

One commenter advised that unannounced surveys and the inability to provide blackout dates would pose challenges for hospitals and accreditation specialists. Specifically, the commenter suggested that blackout dates and announced surveys offer crucial preparation time, the ability to allocate resources efficiently, conduct self-assessments and identify deficiencies proactively. The commenter also stated that lack of prior knowledge of the survey amplifies stress among the facility's staff and hampers productivity and morale in a hospital setting. The commenter also suggested that announcing survey activities in advance would allow for continuous improvement and ensure high standards of care.

Response:

We thank the commenter for expressing concerns related to unannounced surveys and blackout dates. While we understand unannounced survey activities can pose a challenge, this has been a long-standing requirement. Unannounced survey activities are intended to assess a facility's quality of care provided on any given day and to prevent the provider or supplier from making special preparations for the survey that would not represent the ongoing typical condition of the provider and true nature and quality of care provided, such as increasing staffing that would not usually be scheduled; adjusting records and practices; and unusual cleaning or changes to its physical environment. We do not want to provide an opportunity for facilities to demonstrate a different picture to surveyors from how the facility normally operates. Additionally, we expect that facilities are survey-ready, meaning always in compliance with the Medicare conditions, at all times. Therefore, allowing facilities to choose dates that they wish not to be surveyed further compromises a true depiction of how the facility operates on any normal business day. Related to the commenter's suggestion that announced surveys allow for continuous improvement and ensure high standards of care, we believe by adding the definition of “unannounced survey” and continuing the requirement for unannounced surveys should have no bearing on facilities providing high-quality care to patients.

Comment:

We received two comments raising concerns specific to our discussion and restriction of blackout dates. One commenter stated that prohibiting blackout dates would make it very difficult for organizations to successfully support survey activities while maintaining day-to-day operations. The commenter stated that organizations may not always have the bandwidth to support multi-day regulatory surveys, as staff or leaders must escort surveyors, answer questions, and attend meetings all while supporting and providing patient care. Another commenter voiced significant concerns with the prohibition of blackout dates, highlighting the drastic workforce shortages as the result of the COVID-19 pandemic and a strained health system. This commenter implied the burden associated with staff having to provide care to patients while providing support to surveyors and that the ability for a facility to request blackout dates, as well as pre-survey contact with the AO, ensures that the facility has the necessary resources, to include staff, files, manuals, and policies, when the survey team arrives. Additionally, the commenter raised concerns related to unannounced surveys, as some facilities may be supported by individuals who cover multiple locations.

Response:

We appreciate the commenters' concern related to blackout dates and the challenges which could arise regarding adequate staff to support the survey teams. The existing regulations 42 CFR 488.5(a)(4)(i) require unannounced surveys, as well as our long-standing instructions in Chapter 2, Section 2700A of the SOM. If a provider or supplier knows the exact time a surveyor will be onsite, even shortly before their arrival, it may temporarily adjust its potentially noncompliant and typical practices (for example, regarding staffing). This can lead to findings that are not representative of the quality and the safety typically provided to the facility's patients. Allowing facilities to request dates when they wish not to be surveyed is not consistent with our survey expectations. Furthermore, some AO blackout date policies provide the caveat that the wishes of the facility may not be guaranteed, we believe this practice is inconsistent with the requirements and policies for unannounced surveys and the expectation that a provider/supplier must be always “survey ready”. If an AO learns that a facility has a situation that would decrease the efficacy of an onsite survey (such as a sole practitioner who will not be at an ASC and no surgeries will be performed that day), the AO may pick an alternate date. This decision, however, rests with the AO and should not be driven by the facility. We appreciate the commenter's concerns surrounding staffing shortages in a post COVID-19 environment and the challenges for supporting survey activities. Surveys are intended to assess the normal day-to-day operations of a facility and are not intended to be disruptive. We recognize staff participating in survey activity may need to pause assisting surveyors to provide patient care or manage the facility's operation. Surveyors and processes are intended to be flexible when onsite and patient care and safety is our number one priority. However, it is imperative to use unannounced surveys to assess the daily operations at the facility, and to also ensure that patients receive quality care and sufficient staff are available to the patients to provide a safe environment.

Comment:

We received several comments raising concerns related to the physical security and safety of staff. One of the commenters noted that AOs had adopted pre-arrival notifications because health systems experienced incidents of individuals impersonating surveyors accessing a facility with fake credentials; the commenter also cited Bureau of Labor Statistics data showing an increase in the number of healthcare workers physically attacked. Another commenter noted that violence against healthcare workers is on the rise, and pre-arrival notification would allow proper identification of surveyors. A few commenters also stated that a 30-minute to 60-minute pre-arrival notice would not allow sufficient time for usual preparations to be made. Another commenter echoed the comment regarding safety risks and stated that The Joint Commission's process for pre-notification includes a survey agenda, letter of instruction, biography, and picture of the surveyors for facilities to verify and validate the surveyors are legitimate. Another commenter stated that pre-survey notifications allow facilities to maintain the physical security of the facility. This commenter stated that notification ensures that health systems can inform their security personnel and receptionists to expect the survey team.

Response:

We appreciate the concerns related to unauthorized individuals who may attempt to gain entry using fake credentials, however, we note that this occurrence has not been reported by any non-deemed facilities under various SAs' jurisdictions. SAs present credentials at the time of arrival for authentication and entry into the facility. We would expect AOs present their credentials as is currently customary upon arrival. Furthermore, allowing a one-hour notification to the facility could provide sufficient time for the facility to adjust schedules or make certain environmental changes which would not represent the true picture of the facility. Additionally, with respect to the one AO's process for notification (including photographs, biographies, and a survey agenda), AOs may implement these types of processes upon arrival and entry to the facility. Facilities are not restricted from verifying the survey team, whether the survey team is from the SA or an AO; facilities may request that surveyors wait until identification and verification is complete. Furthermore, we note that complaint surveys are unannounced, therefore arrival procedures and processes should not be different for initial or reaccreditation surveys. We encourage AOs to develop processes to ensure the integrity of unannounced surveys is maintained, while accounting

for processes which allow facilities additional time to verify surveyor identities.

Comment:

One commenter, while in general support of the proposed provision, also urged CMS to include instructions or guidance to surveyors to be prepared with all the necessary identify verification documentation immediately upon arrival and to allow some period of time for hospitals to verify those identities before commencing the survey. This commenter emphasized the importance of safety of patients and staff.

Response:

We appreciate the commenter's general support of unannounced surveys, and we appreciate the commenter's concerns on verification of identities. As outlined in the SOM program appendices, surveyors are already expected to present their identification upon entry at the facility. For example, Hospital Appendix A, Task 2 states “The entire survey team should enter the hospital together. Upon arrival, surveyors should present their identification.” AOs must have comparable processes. Furthermore, we note that some AOs have already put identify verification processes in place, such as upon entry of the surveyor, the surveyor lead uploads identification information and survey notifications into portals accessible by their deemed facilities. We encourage AOs to develop processes that ensure identity verification and arrival procedures that align with CMS' expectations of unannounced surveys.

Comment:

We received several comments related to the predictability of surveys and the requirement that AOs conduct surveys at least every 36 months. One commenter suggested that facilities roughly are aware of the timeframe of their reaccreditation window. Multiple commenters observed that the requirement for surveys every 36 months makes surveys somewhat predictable.

Response:

We thank the commenters for their concerns, and we agree that while an accreditation/deeming cycle provides some level of predictability, surveys must be unannounced with no prior notice of arrival to the facility to maintain the integrity of the survey process. The intent of the proposed provision and definition of “unannounced survey” is to ensure an AO's administrative contact with facilities is variable and does not specifically address or imply the survey dates or month.

Comment:

We received several comments related to pre-survey contact for administrative purposes. One commenter also stated that administrative contact an AO has with its deemed facility is critical to ensuring that the size and complement of survey teams, and the length of surveys, are appropriate. This commenter stated that contact prior to survey ensures that the AO has the facility's application information, list of documents that will be required during the survey, contact information, hours of operation, and surgical schedules. The commenter stated that this maximizes the efficiency of the survey process. Another commenter stated that small, solo practitioner, and low-volume ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs) may operate with significantly smaller staff or may be closed during regularly scheduled hours due to illnesses of staff or due to vacations or personal matters of the practitioner. The commenter suggested CMS did not account for these operational challenges for pre-survey contact and pre-arrival notifications. One commenter stated that the proposed definition of “unannounced survey” is counterproductive and penalizes responsible providers from engaging with the AO for a productive survey. This commenter stated that communication between the AO and the provider is crucial to seamless execution of an unannounced survey and that surveys are resource-intensive, therefore by prohibiting preparatory dialogue would waste valuable time during the survey. The commenter also stated that pre-communication does not compromise the integrity of the survey process; operational preparations, including the logistical and operational scope of the survey should occur in advance for an efficient survey process.

Response:

We appreciate the commenters' concerns related to pre-survey contact, specifically administrative contact with a facility. Our proposal aims to ensure administrative contact with facilities prior to surveys is variable. We are not restricting AOs from contacting facilities to verify application details or request additional information, such as their current operating hours, upcoming surgical schedules, any extension locations, or providing the facilities with an agenda. However, contact prior to survey to gather additional information must not suggest when the survey will occur. For example, facilities due for a survey in December (near the end of their accreditation cycle), should not be contacted each September and surveys should not always be scheduled exactly in the same weeks of November or December. We note that the proposed provisions do not intend to limit an AO from communicating with their respective organizations prior to the survey to gather certain administrative information, such as operating hours and surgery schedules. The intent is for AOs to vary their preparatory contacts in a manner which is unpredictable and to ensure onsite surveys are unannounced. AOs must survey facilities at least every 36 months; therefore, we would expect any contact to be made 6 months, 3 months, 1 month or 2 weeks prior to onsite surveys randomly. We also appreciate the commenter's concerns and those challenges which may present due to small volume provider types with limited hours of operation, such as ASCs that operate once a week or a few times a month. We believe these requirements would not inhibit an AO from gathering needed information to facilitate planning for an unannounced survey.

Comment:

We received one comment that the proposed definition for “unannounced survey” does not reflect the flexibility of Section 2700A of the SOM. The commenter stated that flexibilities allowed by the SOM include a provision stating that non-long-term care facilities (other than home health) may be given advance notice in certain situations; and that our proposed definition does not reference the SOM, furthering the concern that the advance notice provision could be removed from future SOMs (for example, in effort to align with regulatory text). Another commenter recommended that CMS retains a window for notice of the survey the morning of and retain blackout dates to protect time for emergency preparedness and key activities requiring staff and resources.

Response:

We appreciate the commenter's concern related to the proposed definition of “unannounced survey” and our subregulatory guidance in Chapter 2, Section 2007A of the SOM. The subregulatory guidance provides for exceptions in limited circumstances. We recognize that in emergency events, a survey could disrupt the facility's ability to appropriately respond. However, CMS believes that emergency events would be unforeseen and not predicted and SAs and AOs will generally assess whether any survey activity would be feasible; the facility would not need to provide blackout dates in such cases.

Comment:

We received one comment suggesting inconsistent implementation of unannounced surveys with one AO, which has led to confusion. The commenter urged CMS to clarify its requirement for unannounced surveys, including recognition that some

inpatient facilities could experience crisis scenarios that would not allow leadership to concurrently respond to an on-site survey in a timely manner.

Response:

We appreciate the commenter's concerns, and we note that the proposed provisions aim to clarify expectations for unannounced survey activities across all AOs. We recognize that in managing emergency events or crises that leadership may not be available during the survey. However, we expect facilities to designate an individual for daily operations should leadership be unavailable.

Comment:

While generally supportive of the definition and proposals, we received three comments which provided further recommendations for improving the unannounced survey process and encouraged CMS to consider these additional areas in subregulatory guidance. For example, two commenters stated to ensure the unannounced process works effectively, that CMS consider requiring providers to ensure a “duly authorized W-2 employee member of management” or a designated alternate be onsite at all times the office/facility is open. These commenters suggested that this would ensure an individual knowledgeable of company operations that has access to materials needed by surveyors is present, in turn limiting the potential for independent consultants to appear and act as the representative of the owner. Finally, the commenters also suggested that CMS consider “adding authorized W-2 employee” on the CMS-855 enrollment application as another category for management which could allow SAs and CMS to identify and monitor those individuals who appear as managing employees for multiple facilities and identify potentially fraudulent operations. Another commenter recommended CMS set clear expectations that an authorized employee be onsite when the facility opens to ensure survey activities are not delayed, as delays could limit the surveyor's ability to conduct a robust survey which could benefit lower performing agencies. This commenter suggested promoting prompt start times.

Response:

We appreciate the commenter's support for our definition of “unannounced survey.” We agree that leadership and a representative knowledgeable of the facility is important during the survey process and during the daily operations of the facility. We believe that when facility leadership is not onsite or on personal time off, the facility's governing body or leadership should appoint a knowledgeable individual able to provide continuity of care and operations for the facility; this individual should be able to provide SA and AO surveyors with the information needed and guide the survey processes. As noted in many CMS program appendices of the SOM, such as Appendix A Task 2 for hospitals, CMS guidance to survey teams states “If the Administrator (or person in charge) is not onsite or available (for example, if the survey begins outside normal daytime Monday through Friday working hours), ask that they be notified that a survey is being conducted. Do not delay the survey because the Administrator or other hospital staff is/are not on site or available.” We expect surveyors to begin survey activities upon arrival, and to notify staff and management that a survey is currently taking place. Surveyors may delay the entrance conference of the survey for leadership to arrive and begin requesting documentation from the facility while waiting. As for requiring prompt survey start times, we agree with the commenter, yet we also recognize the need for flexibilities to allow staff who may not be present at the time of the survey team arrival to travel to the facility. Surveyors aim to be flexible to ensure robust surveys are conducted with the appropriate staff. We encourage healthcare facilities to have the appropriate leadership and staff present during a survey.

Comment:

We received one comment, while in general support of unpredictability and unannounced surveys, that recommended unannounced surveys only apply to follow-up surveys when a provider or supplier has been previously cited for deficiencies. This commenter suggested that this approach would work for a common purpose to achieving excellence and that unannounced surveys as part of a follow up survey of a corrective action would be more appropriate. This commenter suggested this would build a level of trust and support, encourage facilities to excel in quality and allow a safe space for exploration to ensure health and safety standards are met, as opposed to penalizing poor performance or actively seeking mistakes.

Response:

We agree with the commenter that the intent of an unannounced survey is not to give the impression that surveyors are there to observe mistakes. The intent of an unannounced survey is to ensure the facility is always providing quality and safe patient care and to assess the daily operations of a facility against the Medicare requirements. Surveys by both SAs and AOs are not punitive but rather are an opportunity to identify deficiencies and mitigate potential harm to patients as well as staff. Unannounced surveys will provide a better assessment of the day-to-day operations at the facility. Furthermore, without an accurate assessment during an initial or recertification/reaccreditation survey and only requiring unannounced surveys as part of the plan of correction process for condition-level deficiencies (45-day revisit to the facility) would not accurately capture the normal daily operations of the facility and allow for unusual preparations hindering the integrity of the survey process.

Final Decision:

The requirement for unannounced surveys has been a long-standing requirement that ensures the integrity of the survey process and provides surveyors a clear depiction of the day-to-day operations of the facility without preparatory adjustments which may not reflect the true quality of care being provided to patients. While we appreciate some of the commenter's concerns surrounding physical security as well as the need for preparation for the survey, both at the facility level as well as from AOs gathering necessary information pre-survey, we are hereby finalizing the definition of “unannounced survey” without changes.

D. Conflicts of Interest

In the proposed rule, we cautioned that AOs that provide fee-based consulting would not be allowed to raise their accreditation fees or otherwise raise costs for the provider or supplier because of the provision of survey-related education (90 FR 12009).

We proposed changes to § 488.5(a)(10) to require AOs to have policies and procedures for the prevention and handling of conflicts of interest, and to notify CMS when those conflicts of interest arise, because on several occasions, AOs have failed to notify CMS of such conflicts of interest. These changes would broaden our oversight of the AOs' handling and reporting of conflicts of interests. Additionally, by requiring the AOs to provide CMS with more specific information about their conflict-of-interest policies and procedures, CMS would be afforded a more comprehensive look at how the AOs plan to handle specific scenarios that CMS would deem to be conflicts of interest. These proposed requirements would require those AOs that did not have policies and procedures to prevent, address, and handle conflicts of interests to develop and use them.

The proposed requirements at § 488.5(a)(10)(iii) for the submission of the AO's policies and procedures to

avoid conflicts of interest (as defined in paragraph (a)(10)(v) of this section) included more detailed examples of possible scenarios that could be conflicts of interest for accrediting organization owners, surveyors, or other employees than those examples currently set forth in section 4008 of the SOM, which provide examples of potential conflicts of interest for SA surveyors.

A more detailed conflict-of-interest requirement is not necessary for the SA surveyors because SA surveyors, who are State employees, are generally required to report incidences of conflicts of interest to the SA management, who is tasked with taking the appropriate action. Additionally, State employees are generally prohibited from taking certain types of conflicting outside employment as a matter of course, so it is much less likely for such conflicts of interest to be an issue for them and their management. By contrast, AOs are more likely to encounter conflicts of interest. For example, AO owners, board members, surveyors and other employees might also be employed by healthcare facilities that are surveyed and accredited by that AO. Therefore, the proposed requirements for AOs were more detailed and prescriptive than those for SAs.

We also note here that we proposed two, slightly different, definitions of “immediate family member” at § 488.5(a)(10)(iii)(I) and at § 488.8(k)(2) (89 FR 12060 and 12062 through 12063). While we believe that the two definitions are legally and functionally equivalent, to avoid confusion over the minor language differences we have decided to standardize the definition in both provisions so that the language is the same. Therefore, we are making minor changes to the definition of “immediate family member” at § 488.8(k)(2) to now conform with the language we are finalizing at § 488.5(a)(10)(iii)(I). We do not believe that these minor changes to § 488.8(k)(2) in this final rule with comment period are substantively different than what we proposed, and therefore do not require a new round of public comment or a waiver of proposed rulemaking.

We received the following general comments about the conflict-of-interest proposals made in the proposed rule that are not associated with a specific conflict-of-interest proposed provision. We have grouped these comments by general topic.

Comments Stating General Support for the Conflict-of-Interest Proposals

Comment:

Many commenters supported the proposals that would prevent conflicts of interest, streamline survey processes, and ensure more consistency between AOs and CMS or SA surveyors. Commenters also voiced strong support for ensuring that organizations responsible for issuing standards, guidelines, education, training, and evaluations of performance are not adversely affected by competing interests in real or perceived conflicts of interest.

Response:

We thank the commenters for their support of our AO conflict-of-interest proposals.

Comments Expressing General Opposition to the Conflict-of-Interest Proposals

Comment:

One commenter stated that CMS has made multiple proposals intended to prevent conflicts of interest and recommended that CMS limit its conflict-of-interest (COI) proposals to sharing COI policies and the COI log during a corporate onsite review or at the agency's request. One commenter opined that the AOs should have the opportunity to investigate and verify the existence of a conflict of interest before providing notification to CMS.

Response:

Limiting our proposals to only requiring that AOs share their conflict-of-interest policies during application reviews would be insufficient to fully identify and address AO conflicts of interest. We agree that the AOs should be allowed to investigate and verify conflicts of interest before reporting them to CMS. No proposals included in the proposed rule prohibit an AO from verifying conflicts on the part of its owners, surveyors, and other employees before notifying CMS of these conflicts.

Comment:

One commenter stated that they were perplexed as to why CMS is not proposing the same conflict-of-interest requirements for SAs. This commenter also pointed out that, in the proposed rule, CMS stated that it believes a more detailed conflict-of-interest requirement is not necessary for the SA surveyors because SA surveyors, as State employees, are generally required to report incidences of conflicts of interest to the SA management, who are tasked with taking the appropriate action. CMS also opined that AOs are more likely to encounter conflicts of interest.

This commenter further stated that, while they agree that the nature of the business relationship between AOs and providers inherently creates greater opportunity for conflicts of interest, they believe nearly all the same situations CMS proposes as conflict-of-interest definitions are potentially present with SA surveyors.

This commenter also pointed out that in the proposed rule, CMS defined “conflict of interest” as a situation in which an AO, its owner(s), surveyors, or other employees, or the AO's successors, transferees, or assigns, or the immediate family members of the AO owners(s), surveyors, and other employees, have an employment, business, financial or other type of interest in or relationship with a healthcare facility the AO accredits. CMS would deem a conflict of interest to have occurred if one of the stated parties either knowingly or unknowingly exploited their interest in or relationship with that provider or supplier.

Response:

We agree that there are potential conflicts of interest for surveyors or other employees of the SA division conducting surveys, and for the immediate family members of these individuals, if there is an employment, business, financial or other type of interest in or relationship between a health facility the SA surveys and its surveyors and other SA employees and/or their applicable immediate family members. However, in response to the comment questioning why CMS did not propose the same conflict-of-interest requirements for SAs, CMS does not believe that additional Federal conflict-of-interest requirements are necessary for SAs as they are for AOs because individual State laws, rules, and regulations regarding conflicts of interest apply to each SA and its employees.

Comment:

One commenter appreciated CMS' diligence in preventing conflicts of interest during the accreditation process and agrees that the proposed language will mitigate inappropriate biases from affecting the survey processes. However, this commenter also recommended that CMS establish language that prohibits SA surveyors from surveying any facility where they were employed the previous 2 years, including facilities that are part of a larger health system. This commenter further opined that this is imperative in eliminating all conflicts of interest from surveyors, regardless of the agency that employs them.

Response:

SAs make their own policies and procedures regarding staff matters such as the handling of staff conflicts of interest and the Federal government typically does not interfere in internal State decisions.

Nevertheless, consistent with Agreements between states and CMS under section 1864 of the Act, CMS holds the SAs responsible for assuring that any surveys for Medicare/Medicaid certification meet all Federal requirements, including conflict of interest requirements. Also, Chapter 4, Sections 4008 and 4008A of the SOM address the issue of conflicts of interest on the part of SA employees. Section 4008 of the SOM contains suggestions as to how the SA could handle such conflicts of interest. Section 4008A provides examples of conflict-of-interest scenarios on the part of SA employees that are similar to those we set forth in the proposed rule (89 FR 12005).

Comment:

One commenter stated that they have been proactive in taking steps to prevent real or perceived conflicts of interest to maintain the integrity and rigor of the accreditation process. This commenter also stated that they implemented strong firewall and COI policies to prevent any perceived or actual conflict of interest between its fee-based consulting company and accreditation divisions. This commenter stated that they strongly disagree with CMS' proposals to place limitations on fee-based consulting services provided by AOs to Medicare-certified providers and suppliers they accredit because of concerns related to conflicts of interest.

Response:

We note that in this final rule with comment period we have not prohibited AO fee-based consulting in its entirety; we have placed some limited restrictions on this service to help mitigate the conflicts of interest associated with specific AO consulting services and the timing of those services.

Comment:

One commenter observed that the restricted periods, prior to the initial survey and 12 months prior to each reaccreditation survey, are exactly when education is needed. This commenter further stated a belief that: (1) healthcare providers new to healthcare should attend workshops that provide the interpretation of regulations; (2) these workshops serve as a guide for businesses looking to navigate the complex world of healthcare regulations; (3) by attending these workshops, organizations could gain valuable insights and knowledge on compliance requirements; and (4) this knowledge would enable them to operate efficiently and effectively within the healthcare industry. This commenter further stated that, in addition to attending the workshops, the healthcare providers could also purchase workbooks and tools that could further assist them in understanding and implementing regulatory requirements.

Another commenter stated their view that the proposed rule would prohibit AOs from providing support and guidance to the facilities that they accredit in the months directly preceding a reaccreditation survey, when it is most needed. The commenter argued that AOs provide the most effective guidance to the facilities that they accredit because they are intimately familiar with the specific requirements of their standards. The commenter believed that the proposed rule would seek to disadvantage a facility by preventing the accrediting AO from providing valuable education during a critical period. In the commenter's view, the proposed rule places unnecessary obstacles in a facility's path to the provision of high-quality care.

Response:

The restrictions on consulting do not prohibit the AOs from providing consulting services or workshops to the providers and suppliers they accredit prior to a re-accreditation survey. Consulting services, as defined in § 488.1, must not be provided within 12 months prior to the next scheduled re-accreditation survey pursuant to § 488.8(i)(2). This means, for example, that the AOs would still be able to provide consulting, including workshops, to the providers and suppliers it accredits during the 24 months after each accreditation survey was completed in a 36-month accreditation cycle.

We believe that, after an accreditation survey, an AO's consulting services would be geared towards helping the facility correct deficiencies and non-compliance with the AO's accreditation standards that were detected during the survey. We further believe that the best time for an AO to provide such consulting services would be within the 24-month period after an accreditation survey has been completed. During this period, the survey findings are fresh in the minds of the facility management and compliance team and there would be an impetus to address and correct the deficiencies cited. We further believe if the AO provides consulting services to address deficiencies and compliance concerns early in the 3-year accreditation period, the AO could work with the affected provider or supplier, at their own pace, to implement long-lasting and sustainable changes that would address the deficiencies identified. On the other hand, if the AO waited until 12 months prior to the next accreditation survey due date to provide consulting, it might only result in the implementation of quick temporary solutions or corrective action just prior to the next accreditation survey.

Comment:

One commenter stated that CMS' proposal to prohibit receiving fee-based consulting services from an AO at any time before an initial accreditation survey or in the 12 months before a re-accreditation survey would restrict the ability of many health systems to receive necessary education and could delay their ability to be accredited in a timely manner.

Response:

We respectfully disagree with this commenter's contention that our restrictions on AO consulting, as finalized, will prohibit providers and suppliers that are seeking accreditation by an AO that provides consulting from seeking consulting prior to the initial survey. This is because these providers and suppliers would be permitted to seek fee-based consulting from a third party at any time, without restrictions. Also, any provider or supplier already accredited by any AO can seek consulting services from another AO provided that AO does not accredit the provider or supplier at the time the consulting services are furnished.

Comment:

One commenter noted that, under the proposal, providers would not have the benefit of receiving education from the creator of the standards who could best teach the requirements of compliance. The AO standards include not only regulatory language but also AO-specific requirements. Many organizations seek Medicare certification through an AO versus the State Agency because of the valuable education that the AO provides. The type of education provided often distinguishes one AO from another. Restricting the provision of fee-based education diminishes competition, and forces each AO to provide the exact same product.

Response:

General education provided by an AO would not necessarily constitute a conflict of interest and is not entirely prohibited under this rule, regardless of whether it is fee-based education. Section 488.8(i)(4) finalized here allows AOs to provide general education as well as fee-based consulting services at specific times and under certain conditions. However, any AO fee-based education that meets the definition of fee-based consulting services finalized here and does

not

meet the timing and condition requirements at § 488.8(i)(4) would be prohibited by this rule.

Comment:

One commenter opposed the proposals that would limit the ability of health systems to receive fee-based consulting services from their AO for the following reasons:

• AOs are uniquely situated to provide consulting services with firewalls in place that prevent conflicts of interest.

• Fee-based consulting services can include educating health system staff on the CoPs and guiding them on how best to comply with them.

• Fee-based consulting services play an important role in assisting providers with their compliance with CoPs and their quality and patient safety improvement efforts.

• Fee-based consulting can assist health systems in improving the safety and quality of the care they provide to their patients.

Response:

In our view, the restriction on fee-based consulting will not completely prohibit providers and suppliers accredited by the AOs from obtaining fee-based consulting. These providers and suppliers will only be restricted from receiving AO fee-based consulting from their AO prior to their initial survey and during the 12 months immediately preceding their reaccreditation survey. The accreditation period for most providers and suppliers is 36 months; therefore, the providers and suppliers would be able to receive AO fee-based consulting during the first 24 months of the 36-month accreditation period. In addition, providers and suppliers may seek fee-based consulting at any time from third party consultants because there is no conflict of interest associated with the fee-based consulting provided by third parties.

Comment:

One commenter stated that if CMS' proposals are finalized, overall survey costs will increase, due to factors such as limited consulting resources or increased interruptions in hospital operations.

Response:

We disagree that these requirements as finalized in this rule will inevitably lead to increased overall survey costs due to the factors the commenter noted. While the rule puts specific limitations on an AO that provides consulting services to a facility that the AO accredits, the rule does not prohibit an accredited facility from using the consulting services provided by other AOs that do not accredit the facility or by third-party consultants, and thus does not limit the overall consulting services that might be available to facilities. Without further clarification by the commenter, we are not clear why they believe that this rule would cause interruptions in a hospital's or other facility's operations.

Comment:

One commenter supports the proposed definition of conflict of interest.

Response:

We thank this commenter for their support of our proposed definition.

Comment:

One commenter noted that proposed § 488.5(a)(10)(iii)(I) would provide that an immediate family member of an AO surveyor who was employed in a healthcare facility that was accredited by the AO would be deemed a conflict of interest. This commenter further observed that, by contrast, the United States (U.S.) Federal government does not restrict immediate family members from working in different facets of the government or as a contractor to the government.

Response:

This commenter is correct that the proposed regulations would prohibit an AO owner, AO surveyor or other AO employee from having any involvement in the survey process for the healthcare facilities in which they, or their immediate family members, have a relationship or interest that existed within 2 years prior to the AO owner's, surveyor's or other employee's employment by the AO. If such a situation were to exist, it would be a conflict of interest. We have proposed to add the provisions at §§ 488.5(a)(10)(iii)(I) and 488.8(k) to prevent such conflicts of interest, including those involving immediate family members as defined at § 488.8(k)(2), from occurring. The commenters' reference to multiple family members working for governmental entities is not comparable to the scenario in which an AO surveyor might be expected to change his assessment to benefit the facility family member because family members working for different government agencies generally are not able to provide benefits for each other.

Comment:

One commenter disagreed with the proposed definition of “immediate family member”. This commenter noted that this proposed definition closely resembles that used in reference to the professional courtesy exception for physician and healthcare entity referral prohibitions, Securities and Exchange Commission restrictions on transactions with related persons, and laws related to campaign contributions.

This commenter stated that such an expansive definition of “immediate family member” as used for the purposes of securities transactions and campaign contributions would be inappropriate for application to healthcare conflict-of-interest considerations.

Response:

We used the same definition of “immediate family member” that we finalized for hospices in the CY 2022 Home Health Prospective Payment System Rate Update (86 FR 62368 and 62426), which is codified at § 411.351. While this definition may be the same or similar to other rules for other subject matter, this does not make it inappropriate for use in a healthcare setting.

A definition of “immediate family member” is necessary because, at § 488.5(a)(10)(iii), we proposed to require the AOs to provide policies and procedures for the prevention and handling potential or actual conflicts of interest that could arise from situations in which an AO owner, surveyor, or other employee has a business, employment or financial interest in or relationship with another survey agency or healthcare facility to which the AO provides accreditation services.

At proposed § 488.5(a)(10)(iii), we stated that such interests or relationships would include but not be limited to, “(I)

Having members of their immediate family engaged in any of the above stated activities.”

Moreover, at § 488.8(k), we proposed that it would be a conflict of interest if AO employees, surveyors, and other employees have a member of their immediate family employed at a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO. We made this proposal because it is possible that one of the subject individuals could either consciously or unconsciously exploit their interest in or relationship with that provider or supplier. Also, allowing an AO owner, surveyor or other employee that has an interest in or relationship with or that has an immediate family member that is employed by or has an interest in or relationship with (as defined by proposed § 488.5(a)(10)(iii)) a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO would not only be inappropriate but could result in inaccurate survey results and/or preferential treatment of the facility. We say this because if an AO owner, surveyor or other employee has a family member employed at a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO, that AO owner, surveyor or other employee may have a bias towards or against that facility which could have an effect on the survey results.

An AO surveyor, owner, or other employee that has an interest in or relationship with a healthcare facility the AO accredits might have additional motivation to improperly give that healthcare facility notice about the survey ahead of the scheduled survey date. Surveys are required to be unannounced to prevent the facility from preparing for the survey by activities such as unusual cleaning activities, painting, clearing obstructions from halls and entrances,

covering up and hiding deficiencies, coaching staff, and otherwise preparing in advance for the survey. If the survey is unannounced, the healthcare facility is not able to make advance preparations so that the survey team is able to assess the facility in its usual condition and observe the typical standard of care provided.

If an AO owner, surveyor or other employee has an immediate family member that is employed by a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO, that immediate family member might provide confidential or proprietary information about the healthcare facility to the AO owner, surveyor or other employee that the AO would not otherwise be entitled to receive. The immediate family member employed at a healthcare facility accredited by the AO could also provide information about incidents that have occurred at the facility, safety and quality concerns or other issues. This would be a problem because this unfiltered information may be damaging to the facility for several reasons. First, this person may have incomplete or inaccurate information. Second, the information provided by the family member could affect the course of the survey, the survey findings and objectivity of the survey results.

Comment:

One commenter stated a concern that the conflict of interest on the part of some extended family members included in the definition of “immediate family member” are unlikely to be known in many instances.

This commenter was concerned that, while a potential conflict could exist if conflicts with immediate family members are known to the AO, there is no requirement within this proposed rule that the information

actually

be known for a conflict to exist because the proposed rule (89 FR 12005) says “unknowingly exploited interest”.

To illustrate their concern, the commenter provided the following scenario:

• An AO surveyor resides in Washington and has a brother-in-law that resides in Georgia.

• The surveyor only speaks to her brother-in-law every other year at Thanksgiving.

• The AO at which the surveyor is employed accredits a small ASC in Tennessee (fictional “Anytown ASC”).

• The AO surveyor performs a survey of Anytown ASC in Tennessee in May 2024.

• The surveyor's brother-in-law has an ownership interest in Anytown ASC in Tennessee that his sister-in-law is surveying. This interest was obtained in January 2023.

• The AO surveyor was not aware that her brother-in-law obtained an ownership interest in Anytown ASC in January 2023.

This commenter requested that CMS reconsider the definition of “immediate family member” to address its appropriateness, reasonableness, and applicability.

Response:

We have proposed to require AOs provide annual surveyor declarations of conflicts of interest and also that AO owners, surveyors, and other employees be prohibited from having involvement in the survey process for any healthcare facility accredited by the AO with which they or their immediate family members have an interest or relationship. While these proposals are silent on this issue, it is implied that the AOs will only be required to report and act on known conflicts of interest. We certainly cannot hold AOs, their owners, surveyors, and other employees accountable for any conflicts of interest of which they are unaware. Therefore, we do not believe that it is necessary to revise the proposed definition of “immediate family member.”

This does not mean that the AOs, their owners, surveyors, and other employees can ignore such potential conflicts of interest. AOs, owners, surveyors, and other employees have a duty to investigate whether they or their immediate family members, as defined in the proposed rule at § 488.5(a)(10)(iii), might have applicable conflicts of interest. AOs will be required to obtain surveyor conflict-of-interest information on an annual basis. AO surveyors and other employees will be required to take reasonable steps to determine whether they have interests in or relationships with healthcare facilities accredited by the AO, both on their part and on the part of their immediate family members.

If an AO, AO owner, surveyor, and other employee should reasonably have known about a conflict of interest on their part or the part of an immediate family member and it is not reported to CMS on a surveyor declaration, or an AO owner, surveyor, or other employee was permitted to have involvement with the survey process for a healthcare facility for which they reasonably should have known they had an interest in or relationship with, CMS has the option to place the AO on a CMS-approved accreditation program review pursuant to § 488.8(c).

Comment:

One commenter requested that CMS clarify the applicability of the proposed requirement for information to be submitted with the AOs' conflict-of-interest policies and procedures to different types of AO employees.

Response:

Our proposal for information to be submitted with the AOs' conflict-of-interest policies and procedures applies to the AO and not any specific individual or group of AO employees. This proposal requires that the AO provide more specific information with the conflict-of-interest policies and procedure it provides to CMS with the initial and all subsequent renewal applications for CMS approval of the AOs accreditation programs.

However, § 488.5(a)(10)(iii) does require an AO to submit information to CMS regarding its policies and procedures for the prevention and handling of potential or actual conflicts of interest and it does specify that these conflicts of interest are those that could arise from situations in which an accrediting organization owner, surveyor, or other employee has an interest in or relationship with a SA or with a healthcare facility to which the accrediting organization provides accreditation services. In response to the commenter's request for clarity as to whom the requirements for such information would apply, § 488.5(a)(10)(iii) provides examples of the interest and relationships with a healthcare facility that would be a conflict of interest on the part of an AO owner, surveyor or other employees, including:

• being employed as a SA surveyor;

• being employed in a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO;

• having an ownership, financial or investment interest in a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO;

• serving as a director of or trustee for a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO;

• serving on a utilization review committee of a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO;

• accepting fees or payments from a health facility or group of health facilities that is/are accredited by the AO;

• accepting fees for personal services, contract services, referral services, or for furnishing supplies to a healthcare facility that is accredited by the AO;

• providing consulting services to a healthcare facility that the AO accredits;

• having members of their immediate family engaged in any of the stated activities; and

• engaging in any activities during the course of the survey of the facility that would be or cause a conflict of interest.

Section 488.8(k) provides that it would also be a conflict of interest if an AO owner, surveyor or other employee

has an immediate family member that has an interest in or relationship with a healthcare facility accredited by the AO. In such a scenario, the AO owner, surveyor, or other employee should not be permitted to have any involvement with the survey process for the healthcare facility at which their family member is employed or has an interest or relationship.

2. Comments Generally Supporting the Proposal for Information To Be Submitted With an AO's Conflict-of-Interest Policies and Procedures

Comment:

Five commenters supported the proposed requirement that the AOs provide, as a part of their initial and renewal application, specific policies and procedures that would address how the AO addresses and prevents conflicts of interest. One commenter stated that proposed revision to § 488.5(a)(10) for information to be submitted with the AOs' conflict-of-interest policies and procedures are common sense updates on unintended gaps in the accreditation ecosystem. This commenter further stated that if these unintended gaps are not fixed, opportunities for conflicts of interest will persist in the system. One commenter stated that the requirement that the AOs provide, as part of their initial and renewal applications, specific policies and procedures that would address how the AOs prevent and address conflicts of interest would put pressure on AOs to create firewalls to address these concerns. One commenter expressed support for the proposed requirements for AOs that do not have policies and procedures to prevent, address and handle conflicts of interest to develop and use them. One commenter expressed support for the proposal for expansion and revision of conflict-of-interest policies and procedures. This commenter stated that these AO conflict-of-interest improvements would secure the overall fairness and transparency of the survey process. One commenter supported CMS' efforts to increase oversight of AO conflicts of interest while providing a requirement that does not impose additional burden on providers. One commenter stated that § 488.5(a)(10) is already a requirement for approval of an AO. This commenter further opined that the proposed requirement could strengthen our policies to reflect the high standards of their AO. One commenter fully supported our proposal to require the AOs to provide more specific information in the conflict-of-interest policies and procedures they submit to CMS. This commenter stated that the requirement will protect the integrity of the survey process and provide guidance to surveyors.

Response:

We thank these commenters for their support of our proposal at § 488.5(a)(10) to require the AOs to submit more specific information with their conflict-of-interest policies. Robust and strictly enforced firewall policies and procedures can help mitigate the effects of conflicts of interests. We believe that it is important for the AOs that provide fee-based consulting to have fee-based consulting firewall policies and procedures. We thank these commenters for their support of our proposed requirement at § 488.5(a)(10) that the AOs submit policy and procedure to address conflicts of interest.

3. Comments Generally Opposing the Proposal for Information To Be Submitted With an AO's Conflict-of-Interest Policies and Procedures

Comment:

One commenter stated that requiring AOs to turn over their conflict-of-interest policies and logs over to CMS would require the AOs to share proprietary information and internal business operations.

Response:

We respectfully disagree with this commenter. We are not sure what this commenter considers to be proprietary information and internal business operations. However, we do not consider the AOs conflict-of-interest policies and procedures or information about AO conflicts of interest to be proprietary information. AOs are already required by our regulations to provide their accreditation standards and all policies and procedures related to the accreditation and survey processes (including those related to detecting and handling conflicts of interest) to CMS as part of their initial and renewal applications they submit seeking approval for their accreditation program. For example, § 488.5(a)(10) already requires AOs to provide their

“

policies and procedures to avoid conflicts of interest, including the appearance of conflicts of interest, involving individuals who conduct surveys or participate in accreditation decisions.”

Although we do not believe that the surveyor declarations and reports containing information about the fee-based consulting services provided would fall under the category of proprietary information or internal business operations, we have no plans to publish this information. It is our intent, to the extent permissible by law, that the information collected be for internal CMS use only.

Comment:

One commenter requested clarification on how the revised requirements at § 488.5(a)(10), if finalized, will be different from the existing requirement of this regulation.

Response:

In the proposed rule (89 FR 12005), we discussed the difference between the existing regulation and the revised requirements at § 488.5(a)(10). Section 488.5(a)(10) currently requires that the AO submit

“the organization's policies and procedures to avoid conflicts of interest, including the appearance of conflicts of interest, involving individuals who conduct surveys or participate in decisions.”

This requirement does not require the AO to address any specific areas or issues in their conflict-of-interest policies and procedures. In addition, the AOs only need to submit this information to CMS with their initial and renewal applications, which is currently every 6 years or less, as established by CMS.

Comment:

One commenter recommended that CMS ensure that the new policies the AOs will need to develop do not unintentionally result in disruptions to providers seeking to become accredited or maintain accreditation.

Response:

We do not anticipate that the accreditation process will be disrupted by the revised requirements at § 488.5(a)(10)(i) to § 488.5(a)(10)(v). All AOs that accredit Medicare-certified providers and suppliers will be required to submit conflict-of-interest policies and procedures that comply with the requirements of proposed § 488.5(a)(10)(i) to (v). To be approved by CMS, all AOs are required to have some type of conflict-of-interest policies and procedures; however, prior to this proposed rule CMS did not have any minimum requirements for the contents of these COI policies. This means that the AOs will simply need to update their existing COI policies and procedures to comply with the new requirements.

Final Decision:

After consideration of all comments received regarding the proposed requirement for AOs to submit specific information with the conflict-of-interest policies and procedures they submit to CMS with their initial and each subsequent renewal application, we have decided to finalize the requirements with a minor clarifying revision to § 488.5(a)(10)(iii) to change the proposed language of “... potential or actual conflicts of interest that could arise from situations in which an accrediting organization owner, surveyor, or other employee has an interest in or relationship with

another State survey agency or a healthcare facility

to which the accrediting organization provides accreditation

services” [emphasis added] by changing the word “another” to “a” and adding the words “with a” so that the finalized provision reads “... situations in which an accrediting organization owner, surveyor, or other employee has an interest in or relationship

with a State survey agency or with a healthcare facility

to which the accrediting organization provides accreditation services” [emphasis added]. We are making this revision in this final rule with comment period to clarify the requirement.

Additionally, commenters requested that we establish a clear definition of the AO consulting services on which we will be placing the proposed restrictions and provided us with an example of such a definition for purposes of this rule. We have used this definition from the public comments as the basis for the definition of “fee-based consulting services” that we are including in this final rule with comment period. We discuss this definition in more detail in section III.D.3. of this final rule with comment period.

E. Comments on the Proposed Requirement That AOs Obtain and Submit Surveyor Declarations of Any Interest in and Relationships With Healthcare Providers the AO Accredits to CMS on an Annual Basis (Proposed § 488.5(a)(22))

A conflict of interest may exist when an AO surveyor has interest(s) in or relationship(s) with a healthcare facility the AO accredits. We believe that requiring AOs to obtain and submit declarations detailing such interests and relationships would ensure that CMS would be notified of potential or actual conflicts of interest AO surveyors might have with the providers and suppliers the AO accredits. Such notice would allow CMS to be aware of the existence of these potential or actual conflicts of interest, some of which would preclude a surveyor from participating in survey activities (see § 488.8(j) discussion at section IV.B.6. of the proposed rule) and some of which would not.

We proposed to add a new provision at § 488.5(a)(22) that would require the AO to obtain declarations from all surveyors employed or contracted to the AO regarding any employment, business, financial or other interests in or relationships they have with the healthcare facilities the AO accredits. We proposed that AOs would initially be required to submit the surveyor declarations with their initial application for CMS approval of their accreditation programs. We further proposed to require that the AOs update the surveyor declarations on an annual basis, and that the information from the annual updated surveyor declarations be submitted to CMS no later than December 31st each year. Annual updates would be necessary because a surveyor's interests in and relationships with healthcare facilities the AO accredits could change over time. This requirement would ensure that the information contained in the surveyor declarations remains up-to-date and accurate. We proposed that this provision at paragraph (a)(22) would be become applicable beginning 1 year after the effective date of the final rule with comment period. We further proposed to require the AOs to begin submitting their surveyor declaration information on or before the December 31st date that occurs after the proposed applicable date of this requirement.

We received the following comments regarding this proposal. We group the comments and our responses by topics for clarity.

a. General Comments About the Proposal To Require AOs To Submit Surveyor Conflict-of-Interest Declarations

Comment:

One commenter supported our proposal to require AOs to obtain and submit surveyor declarations of any interest in and relationships with healthcare providers the AO accredits to CMS on an annual basis for the following reasons:

• Organizations entrusted with the public's well-being must disclose their affiliations to ensure impartiality and maintain public trust.

• Any suggestion of impropriety or conflict of interest could compromise the integrity of the accreditation process, emphasizing the paramount importance of full transparency.

• Prioritizing excellence, quality, and integrity over financial interests is crucial.

Response:

We thank this commenter for their support of this proposal.

Comment:

One commenter stated that they have always required the completion of conflict-of-interest statements from all their staff as a standard compliance practice. The commenter further stated that they are diligent in managing and enforcing their conflict-of-interest processes as a first-line measure in controlling any threat to their accreditation program's integrity. Another commenter stated that they require the completion of a conflict-of-interest statement in the following instances:

• All staff complete a COI statement at the time of hire; senior leadership staff additionally sign a COI statement annually.

• Board of Director members sign a COI statement at the time of board appointment and annually throughout their term.

• Surveyors sign a COI statement at the time of hire, annually, and if new conflicts of interest arise.

Response:

We thank this commenter for their comment. We further commend this commenter on their commitment to preventing, detecting, and managing conflicts of interest.

b. Comments in Support of the Proposal for AOs To Submit Surveyor Conflict-of-Interest Declarations

Comment:

Two commenters supported our proposal to establish processes for ensuring that AO surveyors do not have conflicts of interest in the review process, including surveyor relationships with a healthcare facility or another survey agency.

Response:

We thank these commenters for their support of this proposal.

Comment:

One commenter stated that they already have a strict surveyor conflict-of-interest process. The commenter further stated that requiring a declaration from each surveyor is unnecessarily burdensome to their established process.

Response:

We thank this commenter for their comment and note their concern about the burden related to this proposal. Please see section VI. Collection of Information of this final rule with comment period for more information about the burden associated with this rule.

Comment:

One commenter supported our proposal to require the AOs to provide conflict-of-interest information on past employees and other areas.

Response:

We believe this commenter is referring to our proposal to require the AOs to collect surveyor conflict-of-interest declarations and submit them to CMS on an annual basis. If so, we thank this commenter for their support of this proposal. We would like to point out that this requirement, as finalized, doesn't require the AOs to collect conflict-of-interest information about past employees or areas other than current interests in or relationships the AO's surveyors may have in any healthcare providers or suppliers accredited by the AO.

Comment:

One commenter had several questions about this proposal including:

How are new hires and terminated surveyor declarations to be handled throughout the year? Are the submissions to be electronic? What does CMS intend to do with this information? For instance, would CMS review each

one of the declarations annually and would declarations of “no conflict of interest” be confirmed? If so, how would this be accomplished?

Response:

We will provide subregulatory guidance on submission and compliance when this requirement becomes effective.

Comment:

One commenter stated that they require all employees to complete annual COI declarations regarding any employment, business, financial, or other interests in or relations they have with healthcare facilities that this AO accredits. The AO expressed concerns with the proposal to require AOs to submit surveyor COI declarations to CMS because these declarations have personal information that may violate employee confidentiality or other privacy laws if shared publicly. This commenter recommended that CMS modify this proposal to require only a review of AO surveyors' COI declarations at the time of the CMS corporate onsite review for each AO. This commenter stated that their suggested alternative would still allow CMS to achieve its stated goal and that there was no reason for CMS to require AOs to unnecessarily disclose sensitive information. This commenter also stated that the AO should not be required to submit the surveyor conflict-of-interest disclosures to CMS because they would contain sensitive information.

Response:

Our rule, as finalized, will require the AO to submit declarations from all surveyors the AO employs, describing any employment, business, financial or other interests in or relationships they have with the healthcare facilities the AO accredits. Even if this is sensitive or confidential information, it is necessary for enforcement of our policy and, to the extent permitted by law, we would keep this information internally and not publish it or provide it to any outside source. Proprietary commercial information and trade secrets are protected from public disclosure under FOIA Exception 4 (5 U.S.C. 552(b)(4)).

e. Recommended Changes to Proposal That AOs Submit Surveyor Declarations

Comment:

One commenter recommended that CMS modify this proposal to allow the AOs to submit 100 percent of surveyor COI declarations for year one after the final rule with comment period implementation date. Thereafter, for each calendar year, AOs would only submit COI declarations for new surveyors and updated COI declarations for surveyors where a baseline COI declaration was submitted in year one.

Another commenter suggested that implementing and managing a COI declaration process might complicate the survey process and increase the administrative burden on AOs and complicate the survey process by requiring additional resources. This commenter recommended that CMS make the implementation of the surveyor declaration process as minimally burdensome as possible on all entities.

Several commenters expressed support for the proposed requirement for collection of surveyor declarations on an annual basis but requested that AOs be allowed to keep the declarations and not be required to submit them to CMS. One of these commenters suggested that CMS review them during the corporate office visit as part of each AO's initial/renewal application rather than requiring the AO to submit them to CMS on an annual basis.

Response:

After consideration of the comments received regarding our proposal to require the AOs to submit surveyor conflict-of-interest declarations to CMS on an annual basis, we have decided not to finalize this proposal as proposed. We are not finalizing our proposal to require the AOs to obtain and submit the surveyor declarations to CMS annually. We will instead require the AOs to submit the surveyor conflict-of-interest declarations for CMS to review upon request and during each application review process.

Comment:

One commenter stated that receiving and maintaining the declarations could be unnecessarily burdensome to CMS. This commenter requested that the surveyor declarations be handled on an exceptions basis whereby the declaration would only need to be reported to CMS if it indicated a conflict of interest. In the alternative, CMS could conduct audits of the AOs annually to ensure the declarations are obtained and maintained as required.

Response:

We have also considered the burden to CMS associated with the receipt and review of these declarations and have decided to modify our proposal related to surveyor declarations as stated in the “Final Decision” section.

Final Decision:

After consideration of the comments received regarding our proposal at § 488.5(a)(22) to require the AOs to submit surveyor conflict-of-interest declarations to CMS on an annual basis, we have decided not to finalize this as proposed. We will instead require the AOs to maintain the surveyor conflict-of-interest declarations, to be provided to CMS to review upon request and during each application review process. We are also modifying the provision as proposed by removing the sentence from applicable regulations text, “This provision will become applicable beginning [DATE 1 YEAR AFTER THE EFFECTIVE DATE OF THE FINAL RULE].” We are making this modification for the final rule with comment period since we have decided that all provisions of the rule will become effective 1 (one) year after the publication date and individual provisions will no longer need to be specified in the regulatory text.

F. Proposed Restrictions on Fee-Based Consulting Services Provided by AOs to the Medicare-Certified Providers and Suppliers They Accredit (Proposed § 488.8(i))

CMS recognizes the value of consulting services provided by independent, third-party consultants who provide insight and expertise to assist facilities in achieving and maintaining compliance with the AO and Medicare health and safety standards. These interventions are beneficial and often tailored to meet a facility's specific compliance needs. Consulting services also may assist a provider or supplier in identifying quality concerns, whether based on the Medicare requirements or standards of practice, and therefore these services may improve the safety of patient care. AO consulting activities are not prohibited by Federal law and there are no current CMS regulations prohibiting AOs from providing consulting services.

However, AOs assume a public trust role when voluntarily applying to CMS for deeming authority. This authority, once granted, conveys Medicare certification for those entities accredited by the AO and it is essential that the integrity of the AO oversight process be above question. A number of AOs with CMS-approved accreditation programs currently provide AO consulting services to the Medicare-participating healthcare facilities they accredit as well as to facilities that they do not accredit. When an AO provides consulting services to a provider or supplier it accredits, it may create a conflict of interest for several reasons.

First, AOs provide deeming surveys to providers or suppliers on behalf of CMS. AOs are required to use accreditation standards that are comparable to or exceed the Medicare standards and survey processes in the performance of deeming surveys. A potential or actual conflict of interest arises from allowing a CMS-approved AO with deeming authority the ability to charge a provider or supplier to conduct a deeming survey to identify non-compliance (for

Medicare participation) and also charge for providing AO consulting services to help the provider meet Medicare requirements.

Second, providers and suppliers often choose AO consulting specifically for the additional resources and assistance provided. Some AOs publicly advertise the ability of their consulting services to simulate what to expect from the actual AO survey. It is possible that providers and suppliers found to be non-compliant by their AO may assume that the most direct path to compliance is to hire the AO's consulting services. Such an assumption would provide AOs with consulting services an unfair advantage over other, third-party consulting services.

Finally, by charging for accreditation services (for example, deeming surveys) and also for the subsequent consulting services, for the purpose of remediating deficiencies identified by the same AO, there may be an expectation from providers and suppliers that the AO would demonstrate the effectiveness of their consulting services for such deficiencies on subsequent compliance surveys. In other words, the provider or supplier may expect to receive a favorable survey report because they have paid the AO not only for accreditation but also for consulting services which are promoted by the AOs to help the provider or supplier do well on their survey. In addition, this expectation may push AOs to ignore significant deficiencies found during survey of its consulting clients to demonstrate the efficacy of its consulting and to promote these services.

In short, an AO's business model is geared toward retention of its accredited providers and suppliers. AOs that provide both regulatory oversight through Medicare deeming surveys and also consulting services, which are geared towards assisting clients comply with the requirements required to pass the surveys, invite concerns about the integrity of their final compliance determinations.

CMS issued an AO Conflict-of-Interest RFI (83 FR 65331) in 2018 to gather feedback related to AO conflict-of-interest practices. We received 128 public comments in response to the RFI. Many commenters stated that consulting provided by an AO or its associated consulting division or company to the healthcare facilities it accredits is a conflict of interest. These commenters stated that this conflict of interest arises from granting the inherently governmental function of monitoring patient safety, by regulating healthcare providers through accreditation, to a private entity, especially when that private entity profits from those who are regulated.

Several commenters alleged that AOs that provide fee-based consulting may have the incentive to ignore deficiencies detected during the accreditation survey, to provide a “good” survey report to demonstrate the apparent efficacy of their AO consulting services and also to keep the paying customer(s) happy. Many commenters also suggested that if an AO provides poor survey results to a healthcare facility that has paid a significant fee for accreditation, it is unlikely that the facility would continue to retain that AO as a service provider.

After careful review and analysis of the public comments received in response to the RFI, we agree that a conflict of interest arises from the contractual and financial relationship between the healthcare provider and the AO, which is a private entity that profits from the performance of regulating healthcare providers through accreditation. AOs that provide consulting services generate additional revenue beyond the fees realized for accreditation services by providing consulting services to the same facilities they accredit.

We proposed at § 488.8(i) several restrictions on fee-based consulting provided by these AOs, their consulting divisions, or separate business entities. By “fee-based consulting division,” we mean a separate division within the AO that provides consulting services. This division of the AO would have a separate manager and staff. By “separate business entity,” we mean a business entity, such as a company or corporation, that is separate and apart from the AO and that has been established by the AO, either under a similar or different name, for the purpose of the providing consulting services.

The proposed regulation at § 488.5(i) would still allow AOs to provide fee-based consulting services to the providers and suppliers they accredit with restrictions that address the conflict-of-interest issues associated with this service.

We proposed at § 488.8(i)(1) that, unless excepted under proposed § 488.8(i)(4), AOs and their associated consulting divisions or companies would be prohibited from providing fee-based consulting services to any healthcare provider or supplier to which the AO provides accreditation services prior to an initial accreditation survey. However, the healthcare provider or supplier may seek fee-based consulting services from an entity entirely uninvolved in that provider's or supplier's accreditation process. This option allows these providers and suppliers support they may believe necessary to meet Medicare standards and requirements prior to serving patients while eliminating any conflict of interest for their AO.

For purposes of proposed § 488.8(i)(1), the term “initial survey” would mean the first accreditation survey of a healthcare provider or supplier performed by an AO. The term “prior to the initial accreditation survey” would mean the time period beginning on the day the provider or supplier enters into a contract with the AO to provide accreditation services and continuing until the date that the initial accreditation

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Medicare Program; Strengthening Oversight of Accrediting Organizations (AOs) and Preventing AO Conflicts of Interest, and Related Provisions · 91 FR 36370 | Frix