Small Business Lending Under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (Regulation B)
Federal RegisterNov 13, 2025
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION BUREAU
12 CFR Part 1002
[Docket No. CFPB-2025-0040]
RIN 3170-AB40
Small Business Lending Under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (Regulation B)
AGENCY:
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
ACTION:
Proposed rule; request for public comment.
SUMMARY:
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB or Bureau) proposes revisions to certain provisions of Regulation B, subpart B, implementing changes to the Equal Credit Opportunity Act made by section 1071 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act. The Bureau is reconsidering coverage of certain credit transactions and financial institutions; the small business definition; inclusion of certain data points and how others are collected; and the compliance date. The CFPB believes these proposed changes would streamline the rule, reduce complexity for lenders, and improve data quality, advancing the purposes of section 1071 and complying with recent executive directives.
DATES:
Comments must be received on or before December 15, 2025.
ADDRESSES:
You may submit comments, identified by Docket No. CFPB-2025-0040 or RIN 3170-AB40, by any of the following methods:
•
Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://www.regulations.gov.
Follow the instructions for submitting comments. A brief summary of this document will be available at
https://www.regulations.gov/docket/CFPB-2025-0040.
•
Email: 2025-NPRM-1071Reconsideration@cfpb.gov.
Include Docket No. CFPB-2025-0040 or RIN 3170-AB40 in the subject line of the message.
•
Mail/Hand Delivery/Courier:
Comment Intake—1071 Reconsideration NPRM, c/o Legal Division Docket Manager, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 1700 G Street NW, Washington, DC 20552.
Instructions:
The CFPB encourages the early submission of comments. All submissions should include the agency name and docket number or Regulatory Information Number (RIN) for this rulemaking. Because paper mail is subject to delay, commenters are encouraged to submit comments electronically. In general, all comments received will be posted without change to
https://www.regulations.gov.
All submissions, including attachments and other supporting materials, will become part of the public record and subject to public disclosure. Proprietary information or sensitive personal information, such as account numbers or Social Security numbers, or names of other individuals, should not be included. Submissions will not be edited to remove any identifying or contact information.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Dave Gettler, Paralegal Specialist, Office of Regulations, at 202-435-7700 or
https://reginquiries.consumerfinance.gov/.
If you require this document in an alternative electronic format, please contact
CFPB_Accessibility@cfpb.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Background
In 2010, Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act). Section 1071 of that Act
1
amended the Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA)
2
to require that financial institutions collect and report to the CFPB certain data regarding applications for credit for women-owned, minority-owned, and small businesses. Section 1071's statutory purposes are to (1) facilitate enforcement of fair lending laws, and (2) enable communities, governmental entities, and creditors to identify business and community development needs and opportunities of women-owned, minority-owned, and small businesses. Section 1071 directs the CFPB to prescribe such rules and issue such guidance as may be necessary to carry out, enforce, and compile data pursuant to section 1071.
1
Public Law 111-203, tit. X, section 1071, 124 Stat. 1376, 2056 (2010), codified at ECOA section 704B, 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2.
2
15 U.S.C. 1691
et seq.
The CFPB worked toward a section 1071 rulemaking for a number of years and has sought public comment from stakeholders numerous times. The CFPB held a field hearing on May 10, 2017, and published a request for information regarding the small business lending market.
3
On July 22, 2020, the CFPB issued a survey to collect information about potential one-time costs to financial institutions to prepare to collect and report data on small business lending.
3
The CFPB received 17 comments in response to the request for information.
See
CFPB,
Requests for Information: Small Business Lending Market,
Docket ID CFPB 2017-0011,
https://www.regulations.gov/document/CFPB-2017-0011-0001/comment.
On September 15, 2020, the CFPB released an Outline of Proposals Under Consideration and Alternatives Considered pursuant to the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996 (SBREFA). On October 15, 2020, the CFPB convened a Small Business Review Panel for the section 1071 rulemaking, and the Panel met with small entity representatives (SERs). The Panel Report, publicly released on December 15, 2020, was the culmination of the SBREFA process for the section 1071 rulemaking and included feedback from SERs and written feedback from other stakeholders as well.
On October 8, 2021, the CFPB published in the
Federal Register
a proposed rule (2021 proposed rule) amending Regulation B to implement changes to ECOA made by section 1071 of the Dodd-Frank Act.
4
The comment period for the proposed rule closed on January 6, 2022.
4
86 FR 56356 (Oct. 8, 2021).
The CFPB received approximately 2,100 comments on the proposal during the comment period. Approximately 650 of these comments were unique, detailed comment letters representing diverse interests. These commenters included lenders such as banks and credit unions, community development financial institutions (CDFIs), community development companies, Farm Credit System (FCS) lenders, online lenders, and others; national and regional industry trade associations; software vendors; business advocacy groups; community groups; research, academic, and other advocacy organizations; Members of Congress; Federal and State government offices/agencies; small businesses; and individuals.
On May 31, 2023, the CFPB published a final rule in the
Federal Register
to implement section 1071 by adding subpart B to Regulation B (2023 final rule).
5
Further details about section 1071, small business lending market dynamics, and the CFPB's rulemaking process leading up to the 2023 final rule can be found in the preamble to the 2023 final rule.
5
88 FR 35150 (May 31, 2023).
On July 3, 2024, the CFPB published in the
Federal Register
an interim final rule (2024 interim final rule)
6
to extend
the rule's compliance dates in accordance with orders issued by the United States District Court for the Southern District of Texas.
7
6
89 FR 55024 (July 3, 2024).
See also
Order Granting-in-Part & Denying-in-Part Pls.' Mot. for Prelim. Inj.,
Texas Bankers Ass'n
v.
CFPB,
No. 7:23-CV-00144 (S.D. Tex. July 31, 2023),
https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_pi_order_texas_bankers.pdf;
Order Granting Intervenors' Mots. For Prelim. Inj.,
Texas Bankers Ass'n
v.
CFPB,
No. 7:23-CV-00144 (S.D. Tex. Oct. 26, 2023),
https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_pi_second_order_texas_bankers.pdf;
Op. & Order,
Monticello Banking Co. et al.
v.
CFPB et al.,
No. 6:23-CV-00148-KKC (E.D. Ky. Mar. 11, 2025); Op. & Order,
Revenue Based Finance Coalition
v.
CFPB et al.,
No. 1:23-CV-24882-DSL (S.D. Fla. May 6, 2025).
7
Texas Bankers Ass'n
v.
CFPB,
No. 7:23-CV-00144 (S.D. Tex. July 31, 2023)
https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_pi_order_texas_bankers.pdf.
Challenges to the 2023 final rule filed by various plaintiffs remain ongoing in three jurisdictions; each of those courts stayed the rule's compliance deadlines for some market participants.
8
However, the courts did not stay the compliance dates for those who are not plaintiffs or intervenors in those cases.
8
See
Unpublished Order,
Texas Bankers Ass'n
v.
CFPB,
No. 24-40705 (5th Cir. Feb. 7, 2025) (tolling the compliance deadlines for plaintiffs and intervenors in that case, until further order of the court); Op. & Order,
Monticello Banking Co. et al.
v.
CFPB et al.,
No. 6:23-CV-00148-KKC (E.D. Ky. Mar. 11, 2025) (same).
On June 18, 2025, the CFPB published in the
Federal Register
an interim final rule (2025 interim final rule) to extend compliance deadlines by approximately one year
9
to facilitate consistent compliance across all covered financial institutions. The CFPB sought comment on the 2025 interim final rule.
9
90 FR 25874 (June 18, 2025).
On October 2, 2025, the CFPB published in the
Federal Register
a final rule (2025 compliance date final rule) that confirmed its findings in the 2025 interim final rule and determined upon a review of comments received that no further substantive changes were necessary.
10
The CFPB received 20 comments in response to the 2025 interim final rule. Most commenters addressed the 2025 interim final rule itself. Other comments addressed provisions of the 2023 final rule not addressed by the 2025 interim final rule, some of which are discussed below.
10
90 FR 47514 (Oct. 2, 2025).
Based on reactions to the 2023 final rule, including continued feedback from stakeholders and the ongoing litigation, the CFPB now believes that at the onset of a potentially long-term data collection regime, it should start with more modest requirements, focusing on core lending products, lenders, and data. The CFPB preliminarily believes that that reaction to the 2023 final rule, practically speaking, was in part based on its expansive approach, appearing to seek broad coverage of lenders, products, and information collected.
11
The CFPB does not believe that alignment with the statutory purposes of section 1071 requires the use of its discretionary authority to collect data with such a breadth of scope.
11
The CFPB had considered, in its SBREFA Outline of Proposals Under Consideration, a rule that was more limited in scope.
See generally
CFPB,
Final Report of the Small Business Review Panel on the CFPB's Proposals Under Consideration for the Small Business Lending Data Collection Rulemaking
(Dec. 14, 2020),
https://www.consumerfinance.gov/documents/9413/cfpb_1071-sbrefa-report.pdf.
The CFPB now believes that the 2023 final rule should have given more weight to qualitative differences among certain types of lenders and the likelihood that smaller lenders would face difficulties addressing the complexity of a rule of broad scope, both of which could potentially diminish the quality of the data they collect.
The CFPB believes, based on this experience, that a longer-term approach to advance the statutory purposes of section 1071 would be to commence the collection of data with a narrower scope to ensure its quality and to limit, as much as possible, any disturbance of the provision of credit to small businesses. The statutory purposes of the rule are not well served by an expansive rule that could create disruptions in small business lending markets.
Rather, the CFPB now believes that an incremental approach may better serve the statutory purposes of section 1071 in the long term. Such an approach would start with core lending products, core providers, and core data points. This approach would comply with section 1071 and further its statutory purposes but reduce the rule's initial impact on small businesses and lenders. Over time, as the CFPB and financial institutions learn from early iterations of data collections, the CFPB could consider amending the rule.
The gradual development of data collection under the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA)
12
and its implementing Regulation C
13
over the past 50 years provides precedent for an incremental approach. Congress passed HMDA in 1975,
14
and the Board Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Board) promulgated implementing regulations in 1976, requiring the collection of relatively few data points from relatively few lenders. At various points, HMDA amendments passed by Congress, among other things, expanded the breadth of financial institutions covered, as well as the number of data points collected from those reporting institutions.
15
Over time, rulemakings by the Board and the CFPB implemented these amendments, added and removed data points, and expanded and contracted the scope of Regulation C.
16
12
12 U.S.C. 2801
et seq.
13
12 CFR part 1003.
14
Home Mortgage Disclosure Act of 1975, Public Law 94-200, section 303(2), 89 Stat. 1124, 1125 (1975).
15
Congress amended HMDA in 1980, 1988, 1989, 1992, 1996, 2010, and 2018.
See, e.g.,
Housing and Community Development Act of 1980, Public Law 96-399, section 340(c), 94 Stat. 1614 (1980) (codified as amended at 12 U.S.C. 2809(a)); Housing and Community Development Act of 1987, Public Law 100-242, section 565(a)(l), 101 Stat. 1815 (1988) (codified as amended at 12 U.S.C. 2802); Financial Institution Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act, Public Law 101-73, section 1211(d)-(e), 103 Stat. 183 (1989) (codified as amended at 12 U.S.C. 2802(2)); Housing and Community Development Act of 1992, H. 5334, Public Law No 102-550, section 932(a)-(b) (1992) (codified as amended at 12 U.S.C. 2803 (a)-(b)); Omnibus Consolidated Appropriations Act, 1997, HR 3610, Public Law 104-208, section 2225, 110 Stat 3009 (1996) (codified as amended at 12 U.S.C. 2808(b)(2)); Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, Public Law 111-203, section 1094, 124 Stat. 1376 (2010); Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act, Public Law 115-174, section 104, 132 Stat. 1296 (2018).
16
See, e.g.,
46 FR 40679 (Aug. 11, 1981); 53 FR 31683 (Aug. 19, 1988); 54 FR 51356 (Dec. 15, 1989); 57 FR 56963 (Dec. 2, 1992); 60 FR 22223 (May 4, 1995); 67 FR 7222 (Feb. 15, 2002); 67 FR 43217 (June 27, 2002); 80 FR 66128 (Oct. 28, 2015); 84 FR 57946 (Oct. 29, 2019); 85 FR 28364, 28367 (May 12, 2020).
The CFPB believes that it should approach the section 1071 data collection regime as a longer-term project akin to HMDA. The CFPB believes that it is a proper use of its authority under 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2 to reconsider several portions of the 2023 final rule to commence data collection with a focus on core lending products, core lenders, and mostly statutory data points. The CFPB believes that this incrementalist approach—starting with a more modest rule with a limited set of products, lenders, or data points—will serve the long-term interests of section 1071.
In addition, on January 20, 2025, the President issued Executive Order (E.O.) 14168, “Defending Women From Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government” (Defending Women E.O.).
17
That order, among other things, directs Federal agencies to remove references and questions discussing gender identity. The order also identifies a binary of male/female sex, directing agencies to use those terms when seeking information about an individual's sex.
17
90 FR 8615 (Jan. 30, 2025).
The CFPB has consulted with the appropriate prudential regulators and other Federal agencies regarding consistency with any prudential, market, or systemic objectives administered by these agencies as
required by section 1022(b)(2)(B) of the Dodd-Frank Act.
II. Legal Authority
The Bureau is issuing this proposed rule pursuant to its authority under section 1071. As discussed above, in the Dodd-Frank Act, Congress amended ECOA by adding section 1071, which directs the CFPB to adopt regulations governing the collection and reporting of small business lending data. Specifically, section 1071 requires financial institutions to collect and report to the CFPB certain data on applications for credit for women-owned, minority-owned, and small businesses. Congress enacted section 1071 for the purpose of (1) facilitating enforcement of fair lending laws and (2) enabling communities, governmental entities, and creditors to identify business and community development needs and opportunities of women-owned, minority-owned, and small businesses.
18
18
15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(a).
To advance these statutory purposes, section 1071 grants the Bureau general rulemaking authority for section 1071, providing that the Bureau shall prescribe such rules and issue such guidance as may be necessary to carry out, enforce, and compile data pursuant to section 1071.
19
Section 1071, in 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(g)(2), also permits the Bureau to adopt exceptions to any requirement of section 1071 and to conditionally or unconditionally exempt any financial institution or class of financial institutions from the requirements of section 1071, as the Bureau deems necessary or appropriate to carry out the purposes of section 1071. The Bureau relies on its general rulemaking authority under 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(g)(1) in this proposed rule and relies on 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(g)(2) when proposing specific exceptions or exemptions to section 1071's requirements.
19
15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(g)(1).
See the 2023 final rule for a more detailed discussion of the CFPB's legal authorities.
20
20
See, e.g.,
88 FR 35150, 35173-74.
III. Discussion of the Proposed Rule
A. Summary of Proposed Rule
As set out above, the CFPB now proposes to reconsider certain provisions of the 2023 final rule. The CFPB believes that a potentially long-term data collection regime should start with a focus on core lending products, lenders, small businesses, and data points. The CFPB believes in retrospect that the approach it took in the 2023 final rule—a broad initial coverage of lenders, products, small businesses and data points—was not conducive to the long-term success of the data collection regime under section 1071. The CFPB now believes that a better, longer-term approach to advance the statutory purposes of section 1071 would be to commence the collection of data with a narrower scope to ensure its quality, and to limit, as much as possible, any disturbance of the provision of credit to small businesses. The CFPB believes that such an incremental approach would also comply with section 1071 and minimize any negative initial impact on small business lending markets and on data quality. In the future, based on CFPB and industry experience during the early years of data collection, the CFPB could consider amending the rule as appropriate to further the purposes of section 1071.
The CFPB also believes that the 2023 final rule has not created significant reliance interests that would dissuade the Bureau from reconsidering its position as to certain portions of the rule. Litigation challenging provisions of the 2023 final rule and delays in the compliance dates for this rule suggest that reconsideration of the specific issues below would not meaningfully change compliance obligations.
Covered credit transactions.
The CFPB believes that the initial iterations of data collection under the rule should focus on the core, widely used lending products most likely to be foundational to small businesses' formation and operation. The CFPB therefore proposes to exclude merchant cash advances (MCAs), agricultural lending, and small dollar loans from the definition of covered credit transaction.
Covered financial institutions.
The CFPB believes that the initial iterations of data collection under the rule should focus on larger core lenders. The CFPB therefore proposes two changes to the covered financial institution definition: first, to exclude FCS lenders from coverage; and second, to raise the origination threshold from 100 to 1,000 covered credit transactions for each of two consecutive years. The CFPB is also proposing conforming changes to the bona fide error portions of the enforcement provisions in the rule.
Small business.
The CFPB believes that the focus of the rule, at least initially, should be truly small businesses. The CFPB therefore proposes to change the gross annual revenue threshold in the rule's definition of small business from $5 million or less to $1 million or less.
Data points.
The CFPB believes that the initial iterations of data collection under the rule should focus on core data points and be consistent with other executive agency directives concerning the collection of demographic data.
The CFPB therefore intends to focus data collection on data points specifically identified in section 1071 and a limited number of other data points needed to facilitate the collection of these statutory data points. The CFPB proposes to remove the discretionary data points for application method, application recipient, denial reasons, pricing information, and number of workers. The CFPB also proposes changes to comply with an executive branch mandate, which would result in a modification of the collection of data concerning business ownership status of small business applicants and the format of demographic data collected concerning the principal owners of a small business.
Time and manner of data collection.
The CFPB proposes changes to the provisions on the time and manner of data collection, to remove certain requirements that are not statutorily required and appear to anticipate or presume non-compliance with the rule. The CFPB also proposes to add a provision that would emphasize for applicants their statutory rights under the rule.
Compliance dates.
Finally, in light of these other proposed changes to the rule, the CFPB proposes to extend the rule's compliance date provisions to January 1, 2028 for all financial institutions that remain covered by the rule, and to make other simplifying and streamlining changes.
The CFPB also addresses in this summary two other issues.
Privacy and data publication.
The CFPB does not address in this proposal the privacy discussions in the 2023 final rule or its statements about the eventual publication of data. The 2023 final rule did not purport to make any final or binding decisions concerning its privacy analysis, instead announcing only its “preliminary assessment of how it might appropriately assess and advance privacy interests by means of selective deletion or modification” of data. The 2023 final rule also did not reach conclusions regarding the procedural vehicle it would use to convey its decisions with respect to privacy.
21
Nor
has CFPB conclusively announced a timeline for the publication of application-level data, except for observing that it would need a full year's worth of data to conduct the necessary privacy analysis. The CFPB also suggested that it intended to publish aggregate data in the first year of receiving data, and before publishing any application-level data. The CFPB is currently reconsidering all of these issues and preliminary findings, will continue to engage with stakeholders, and will address these issues and findings going forward in a timely fashion.
21
Id.
at 35460 (“The CFPB is not determining its final approach to protecting such interests via pre-publication deletion and modification because it lacks the reported data it needs to finalize its approach and it does not see comparable datasets to use for this purpose. In light of comments received on the NPRM's privacy analysis, this part VIII offers a preliminary assessment of how it might appropriately assess and advance privacy interests
by means of selective deletion or modification. The CFPB is not at this point identifying the specific procedural vehicle for effecting its privacy assessment. With respect to both substance and process, it will continue to engage with external stakeholders; and it intends to invite further input on how it plans to appropriately protect privacy in connection with publishing application-level data.”).
As part of eventual data publication, as with HMDA data, the CFPB intends to note to data users that data alone are generally not used to determine whether a lender is complying with fair lending laws. The data do not include all the legitimate credit risk considerations for loan approval and loan pricing decisions. Therefore, when regulators conduct fair lending examinations, they analyze additional information before reaching a determination about an institution's compliance with fair lending laws.
Grace period.
The CFPB does not address the grace period policy statement in this proposal. The CFPB does, however, announce its intention to maintain the grace period for the same reasons articulated in the 2023 final rule, as amended by the 2025 interim final rule, and to alter the grace period to coincide with the new proposed compliance date, if it is finalized.
The Bureau seeks comments on the general approach taken in this proposal. The Bureau also seeks comment on its proposed exclusion or reconsideration of the products, lenders, small business definition, and data points identified below. Further, the Bureau requests comment on the likely change in cost and complexity of data associated with each of the specific proposed regulatory revisions identified below and whether changes to the quality of data (
e.g.,
better or worse data quality), advances or is contrary to the purposes of section 1071. Finally, the Bureau requests comment on whether the 2023 final rule has created any reliance interests not otherwise identified in this proposal.
B. Section 1002.104—Covered Credit Transactions and Excluded Transactions
The CFPB believes that at the onset of data collection under section 1071 the rule should focus on core, generally applicable, lending products that are most likely to be foundational to small businesses' formation and operation—loans, lines of credit, and credit cards—before determining whether to expand the scope of the rule to include more niche or specialty lending products. The CFPB therefore proposes to exclude MCAs, agricultural lending, and small dollar loans from the definition of covered credit transaction to better ensure the smooth operation of the initial period of data collection, while minimizing disruptions and regulatory complexity in the credit markets subject to section 1071.
1002.104(b)(7)—Merchant Cash Advance
Current § 1002.104(a) defines a “covered credit transaction” as “an extension of business credit that is not an excluded transaction under paragraph (b) of this section.” Section 1002.104(b)(1)-(6) enumerates six types of transactions that are excluded from covered credit extensions. The Bureau proposes adding MCAs to the list of excluded transactions in § 1002.104(b). Proposed § 1002.104(b)(7) would exclude MCAs, which it would define as an agreement under which a small business receives a lump-sum payment in exchange for the right to receive a percentage of the small business's future sales or income up to a ceiling amount.
22
Consistent with this proposed new exclusion, the CFPB proposes deleting several references to MCAs, and the related term sales-based financing, in commentary.
22
R. & R. on Cross Mots. for Summ. J. at 4,
Revenue Based Finance Coalition
v.
CFPB et al.,
No. 1:23-CV-24882-DSL (S.D. Fla. Feb. 17, 2025).
In the 2023 final rule, the CFPB explained its belief that the statutory term “credit” in ECOA is intentionally broad so as to include a wide variety of products without specifically identifying any particular product by name, such that all credit products should be included in the rule unless the CFPB specifically excluded them and concluded that “credit” encompasses MCAs. It further explained that MCAs should not be understood to constitute factoring within the meaning of the existing commentary to Regulation B subpart A or the definition in existing comment 104(b)-1, because factoring involves entities selling an existing legal right to payment from a third party, while no such contemporaneous right exists in an MCA. The CFPB also noted its understanding that, as a practical matter, MCAs are underwritten and function like a typical loan (
i.e.,
underwriting of the recipient of the funds; repayment that functionally comes from the recipient's own accounts rather than from a third party; repayment of the advance itself plus additional amounts akin to interest; and, at least for some subset of MCAs, repayment in regular intervals over a predictable period of time), although it also implicitly acknowledged practical differences between MCAs and conventional loans by including numerous provisions intended to capture MCA-specific data.
This proposal reconsiders the CFPB's previous conclusions, as illustrated in existing comment 104(a)(1)-1, which does not exclude MCAs from the definition of “covered credit transactions” under § 1002.104(a), for several independent reasons.
First, the CFPB believes that at the onset of the data collection under section 1071 the focus should be on core lenders and products before the CFPB considers expanding the scope of the rule. MCAs are structured differently from traditional lending products; traditional lending concepts like “interest rate” do not fit the way that MCAs are priced.
23
As a result, it is not clear that data collection on MCA transactions under section 1071 would yield information that advances section 1071's statutory purposes to the extent that some or many such transactions do not constitute credit. The CFPB believes it would advance the purposes of section 1071 at this time to exclude MCAs from the definition of covered credit transaction, and to focus on ensuring the smooth operation of data collection as to core lending products and providers most likely to be foundational to small businesses' formation and operation.
23
See
current § 1002.107(a)(12)(v) (providing for the collection of data only applicable to merchant cash advance and other sales-based financings subject to the rule).
Second, the CFPB believes it erred in prematurely determining that collection of data on MCA transactions would serve section 1071's statutory purposes by concluding that all MCAs constitute credit. The 2023 final rule's one-size-fits-all approach also does not take into account the varied terms and features of MCAs across the market that may be relevant to whether the products meet the definition of “credit” under ECOA, nor did it account for the fact that MCAs
are relatively new products whose features and practices may be evolving, including in response to State regulation. Moreover, while some State courts have analyzed whether some MCAs meet State law definitions of “debt” or “credit,” there is a dearth of case law analyzing whether MCAs meet ECOA's definition of “credit.”
Excluding MCAs from the definition of “covered credit transaction” would be consistent with the way the CFPB has already treated leases, which also present close questions as to whether they meet the definition of “credit” under ECOA. In the 2023 final rule's analysis of leases,
24
the CFPB acknowledged that some lease transactions could constitute “credit.” But rather than include all lease transactions in the 2023 final rule to ensure coverage of those leases that did actually constitute credit and credit disguised as leases, the CFPB determined that it would be able to monitor the market for such products without including them in the 2023 final rule. The CFPB proposes taking a similar approach to MCA transactions as it did to leases.
24
See, e.g.,
88 FR 35150, 35240 (“The Bureau is not covering leases under this final rule, as requested by some commenters. The Bureau agrees that some business leases are structured like loans and other credit but notes that a commenter's example of a small business being able to retain leased equipment is an example of the creation of a security interest, not a lease under final comment 104(b)-2.”);
id.
(“The Bureau appreciates commenters' concerns that not covering leases could open a door to potential evasion and lead to data gaps or fair lending problems. The Bureau believes that it can observe the small business financing market for such abuses and prevent them without including all leases in the rule. For example, in considering financial institutions' compliance with the rule, the Bureau intends to closely scrutinize transactions to ensure that companies are appropriately categorizing and reporting products as required by section 1071.”).
Further, the CFPB believes that the 2023 final rule's coverage of MCAs does not take into account State law developments addressing sales-based financing. Several States have legislation and/or regulations in place addressing the MCA market and requiring providers to disclose terms such as the total cost of capital and the financing rate. Such laws provide key protections for users of MCAs and may shape MCA terms and practices in ways that bear on the question of whether they meet ECOA's definition of “credit.”
25
While the 2023 final rule referenced these pieces of State legislation, it did not consider the extent to which the evolving landscape under State law rendered premature a determination that including MCAs in the definition of “covered credit transaction” for purposes of mandating data collection furthered section 1071's statutory purposes. The CFPB believes that it would be advantageous to observe how State laws address MCAs before the CFPB decides how, and whether, to collect data regarding MCAs pursuant to section 1071.
25
See, e.g.,
Conn. Pub. Act 23-201, Conn. Gen. Stat. sec. 36a-861
et seq.
(2024) (creating a disclosure regime specific to MCA and other sales-based financing transactions); Va. Code Ann. sec. 6.2-2230
et seq.
(imposing licensing and disclosure requirements); Utah Commercial Fin. Registration and Disclosure Act, Utah Code Ann. sec. 7-27-102 and 7-27-202 (imposing licensing and disclosure requirements).
Finally, while the final rule cited concerns about high costs and predatory practices in the MCA market,
26
those concerns may be addressed by Federal and State law enforcement agencies through their respective enforcement authorities.
26
At the same time the Bureau acknowledged that “information on merchant cash advance lending volume and practices is limited.” 88 FR 35150, 35220.
The CFPB believes that taking into account the factors listed above, the relative novelty and evolving landscape of the MCA industry and the ongoing changes at the State level concerning the regulation of MCAs, that excluding MCA transactions from coverage under the rule at this time is necessary and appropriate to carry out the purposes of section 1071. As explained above, MCAs differ in kind from traditional lending products, such that collecting data on MCA transactions under Section 1071 may not produce information that is comparable to data collected on other types of transactions. And because MCAs have not generally been regulated as credit, many smaller MCA providers may lack the infrastructure needed to manage compliance with regulatory requirements associated with making extensions of credit. Taken together, requiring MCAs to be reported could lead to data quality issues, which would not advance the purposes of section 1071.
The CFPB will continue to monitor developments in the markets for MCAs and other sales-based financing to determine whether over time a subset might be appropriately included in the definition of “covered credit transaction” for purposes of data collection.
The CFPB seeks comment on this proposed revision to the rule. It also seeks comment on topics including, but not limited to, the extent to which MCAs differ from or resemble traditional lending products; the diversity of MCA terms and practices and how they impact whether MCAs, or a subset of MCAs, meet the definition of “credit” under ECOA; whether certain types of MCAs are more or less appropriate for exclusion; and suggestions for how the 2023 final rule could be modified with respect to MCAs if the CFPB ultimately does not exclude them.
The CFPB further seeks comment on alternative definitions to the one proposed in § 1002.104(b)(7).
1002.104(b)(8)—Agricultural Lending
The CFPB proposes adding agricultural lending to the list of excluded transactions under § 1002.104(b). The CFPB proposes adding new § 1002.104(b)(8), which would define agricultural lending as a transaction to fund the production of crops, fruits, vegetables, and livestock, or to fund the purchase or refinance of capital assets such as farmland, machinery and equipment, breeder livestock, and farm real estate improvements. Consistent with this proposed addition, the Bureau proposes deleting references to agricultural credit in current commentary. This would simplify the rule by narrowing its scope to core, generally applicable, small business lending products and avoid covering a distinct and specialized lending sector that is already subject to a different regulatory reporting scheme.
27
27
See
proposed revisions to § 1002.105(b) discussed below that would also exclude FCS lenders from the definition of “covered financial institution.”
In the 2023 final rule, the CFPB declined to exclude agricultural credit from its definition of a “covered credit transaction.” It noted that ECOA itself has no exceptions for agricultural credit, that agricultural businesses are included in section 1071's statutory definition of small business (defined by cross-reference to the Small Business Act), and that there have been instances of discrimination in agricultural lending. It rejected comments asserting that agricultural credit is unique and not comparable to other types of small business lending, instead observing that “every small business industry has its own unique characteristics.”
28
In response to commenters expressing concern about the impact on local community financial institutions and an outsized effect on the cost of credit for farmers, the CFPB emphasized that it was increasing its institutional coverage threshold to 100 annual originations, from the 25 originations it had originally proposed. The CFPB mentioned that many agricultural lenders have already been required to
collect and report some form of data by HMDA, the Community Reinvestment Act (CRA), and/or the Farm Credit Administration (FCA), but did so only to note that lenders accordingly should be able to adapt to the CFPB's new data collection requirements.
28
88 FR 35150, 35227.
The CFPB now believes that excluding agricultural lending from the definition of “covered credit transaction” would advance the statutory purposes of section 1071 at this early phase as the CFPB begins the collection of small business lending data. Most notably, typical agricultural lending differs markedly from other types of commercial lending. Agricultural loans are often secured by biological-based assets such as crops or livestock, which are subject to variables and risk from weather and disease. These characteristics create unique underwriting challenges that make such loans difficult to compare to those in other industries. The 2023 rule did not adequately consider these distinctions and the quality of data stemming from such transactions. Indeed, other data collection regimes, such as CRA regulations, appear to acknowledge categorical differences between loans to small businesses generally and loans to small farms.
29
29
Compare, e.g.,
12 CFR 25.12(v) (OCC CRA regulations defining small business loans) with § 25.12(w) (OCC CRA regulations defining small farm loans).
Second, agricultural lending is already subject to an existing Federal data collection framework, one that is tailored to this particular sector. The FCA conducts a substantial amount of agricultural lending through a nationwide network of Congressionally chartered, borrower-owned cooperatives. This system is subject to extensive oversight by the FCA. Among other things, the FCA collects demographic data including race, ethnicity, and gender from applicants as part of its program oversight, in contrast to other forms of small business lending where such data collection was not permissible under § 1002.5 of Regulation B until the promulgation of the 2023 final rule.
30
Further, under CRA regulations, institutions must report data on lending to small farms alongside reporting their lending to small businesses. The 2023 final rule did not adequately consider these distinctions.
31
30
See
FSA Customer Data Worksheet (Form AD-2047).
31
As the CFPB acknowledged in the 2023 final rule, “many agricultural lenders have already been collecting and reporting some form of data by HMDA, the CRA, and/or the Farm Credit Administration.” 88 FR 35150, 35227.
The CFPB believes upon reconsideration that the fact that agricultural lenders are already reporting information to other agencies supports its conclusion that excluding agricultural lending is necessary or appropriate to carry out the purposes of section 1071 to avoid imposing new, overlapping reporting requirements on agricultural lenders at this point when the CFPB is commencing the collection of data under this rule. The Bureau believes that excluding agricultural lending would further the purposes of section 1071 because such an exclusion would limit potential issues with data quality. Compliance may pose greater difficulties for small agricultural lenders, which are often rural entities with less compliance infrastructure than other lenders, potentially impacting the quality of their data, and they may need to divert their limited resources from lending activities. Further, for lenders that provide both agricultural and non-agricultural loans that would still be subject to coverage, the CFPB believes that such lenders would be better situated to focusing their section 1071 reporting efforts on improving the quality of data for more core lending products.
Given these factors, the CFPB believes it would be appropriate to reconsider the rule's application to agricultural lending to focus on conventional, generally applicable small business lending at this time, and to use its exemption authority under 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(g)(2) to exclude agricultural lending from coverage under the rule.
The CFPB seeks comment on this proposed revision to the rule. It seeks comment on topics including, but not limited to, the definition of agricultural lending; the extent to which agricultural lending differs from or resembles other types of lending; and whether specific types of agricultural lending are more or less appropriate for exclusion.
1002.104(b)(9)—Small Dollar Business Credit
The CFPB proposes adding small dollar business credit to the list of excluded transactions under § 1002.104(b). Proposed § 1002.104(b)(9) would exclude from the definition of covered credit transaction a transaction in an amount of $1,000 or less, to be adjusted for inflation over time.
In the 2023 final rule, the CFPB declined commenters' suggestions that it exempt credit transactions below a certain threshold; commenters had suggested exemption thresholds ranging from $25,000 to $10 million, on the grounds that it would help smaller institutions continue to make credit available. The CFPB explained that it was not adopting an exemption because of the significant volume of small business lending involving credit amounts below the threshold levels proposed by commenters.
The CFPB now believes that an exclusion for the smallest loans—well under the thresholds suggested by commenters in the 2023 final rule—is necessary or appropriate to carry out the purposes of section 1071. Indeed, in considering comments regarding larger exemption thresholds, the 2023 final rule did not explicitly address an exemption for loans under $1,000.
The CFPB believes that the collection of data on such loans, to the extent that they exist, are more likely to result in poor data quality for purposes of any analyses in furtherance of the statutory purposes of section 1071, given that small businesses will generally require much larger loans to begin or operate their businesses. Typically, very small loans below $1,000 would be satisfied by consumer credit options and small non-profit lenders who lack infrastructure to support regulatory compliance. Consequently, data collected from smaller transactions may not provide meaningful insight into the practices of most core lenders to small businesses.
Further, requiring data reporting on loans of $1,000 or less may make offering such small credit products uneconomical for lenders. Detailed data collection and reporting requirements are likely to impose operational complexity, which would make producing quality data difficult for smaller financial institutions. The CFPB is concerned that this could impact data quality.
Moreover, the CFPB believes, based on its experience and understanding of the markets, that many lenders treat transactions under $1,000 as consumer credit, rather than business credit. Further, $1,000 is substantially lower than loan amounts already characterized as “microloans” to businesses. The CFPB understands that loans in such amounts are not material for the small business lending markets. For example, the Small Business Administration (SBA) offers business credit that it characterizes as “microloans,” which are generally for loan amounts under $50,000 and an average loan amount of $13,000.
32
Further, several commenters in the 2023 final rule requested that the CFPB carve out loans under $50,000 to
$100,000 as microloans.
33
Some State-run programs offer business credit that start at a minimum loan amount of $1,000.
34
The CFPB believes that it seems unlikely that many such small dollar loans under $1,000 to small businesses are made, and if so the collection of such data would not advance the statutory purposes of the rule.
32
See
Small Bus. Admin.,
Microloans, https://www.sba.gov/funding-programs/loans/microloans
(last visited Oct. 1, 2025).
33
88 FR 35150, 35245.
34
See, e.g.,
Md. Dep't. of Com.,
Military Personnel and Veteran-owned Small Business Loan Program (MPVOLP), https://commerce.maryland.gov/fund/programs-for-businesses/mpvolp
(last visited Sept. 10, 2025) (providing no interest loans, ranging from $1,000 to $100,000, for businesses owned by military reservists, veterans, National Guard personnel and for small businesses that employ or are owned by such person).
The CFPB seeks comment on this proposed revision to the rule. It seeks comment on topics including, but not limited to, the loan amount at which the exclusion for small dollar business credit should be set; whether the exclusion should be limited to certain types of loan products, financial institutions, or small businesses; the extent to which financial institutions lend to small businesses in amounts less than $1,000 and why they do so; and whether the exclusion should account for a lender extending multiple small dollar loans to a single small business.
C. Section 1002.105—Covered Financial Institutions and Exempt Institutions
The CFPB believes that at the onset of data collection under section 1071 the focus should be on larger core lenders before the CFPB considers whether it would be appropriate to expand the scope of the rule to specialty lenders and smaller lenders. The CFPB therefore proposes to exclude FCS lenders from the definition of covered financial institution and proposes to raise the origination threshold from 100 to 1,000 covered credit transactions to better ensure the smooth operation of the initial period of data collection.
105(b) Covered Financial Institution—FCS Lenders
The CFPB proposes excluding FCS lenders from the “covered financial institution” definition in § 1002.105(b). Consistent with this proposed exemption, the CFPB proposes deleting several references to FCS lenders in commentary.
As with the Bureau's proposal to reconsider the treatment of agricultural transactions as covered transaction under § 1002.104(a), this proposal would simplify the rule by narrowing its scope to core small business lending practices and lenders. The proposal would also avoid imposing reporting requirements on a category of specialized lenders that are already subject to a separate regulatory reporting scheme.
The CFPB believes that an exemption for FCS lenders would advance the statutory purposes of section 1071. FCS lenders have a unique mission-driven structure, and they operate in a specific regulatory environment.
FCS lenders differ from traditional financial institutions in several significant respects. The FCS is comprised of a nationwide network of borrower-owned, cooperative institutions with a statutory mandate to provide the agricultural sector with reliable credit. FCS borrowers include agricultural and related businesses as well as rural homeowners. As owners of the FCS lending associations, these borrowers can receive patronage dividends that can reduce borrowing costs and make FCS loans difficult to compare to loans issued by non-FCS lenders. Commercial banks, by contrast, are owned by shareholders, and credit unions, while member-owned, serve a wide range of customers, provide a wide range of products and services, and lack a specific charter that is exclusively focused on agriculture. These differences between FCS lenders and other types of lenders, which the CFPB did not meaningfully address in the 2023 final rule, make it difficult to easily compare loans made by FCS lenders with those of other non-cooperative lenders.
In addition to their unique nature and mission, as described above, FCS lenders are also already subject to an existing regulatory reporting framework through the FCA, including the collection of demographic data as part of its program oversight.
35
35
See also
88 FR 35150, 35227 (noting that many agricultural lenders currently required to collect and report data to FCA).
In issuing the 2023 final rule, the Bureau explained the decision not to categorically exempt any specific type of financial institution from the rule's coverage, stating that such exemptions “would create significant gaps in the data and would create an uneven playing field between different types of institutions.”
36
The CFPB did not appear to meaningfully consider the extent to which FCS lending differs in kind from general-purpose lending.
36
Id.
at 35258.
However, in light of the CFPB's reconsideration of the 2023 final rule and new focus on ensuring the consistent and smooth initial collection of data from core lenders and products, the CFPB believes it would further the purposes of section 1071 to commence the data collection without including FCS lenders.
The existing reporting requirements of FCS lenders further supports excluding FCS lenders.
37
Moreover, requiring compliance with a second set of potentially redundant reporting obligations may put FCA lenders at a competitive disadvantage relative to other lenders.
37
For instance, the FCA already tracks data on the credit needs of young, beginning, and small (YBS) farmers and ranchers. Farm Credit Admin., Young, beginning, and small farmer lending,
https://www.fca.gov/bank-oversight/young-beginning-and-small-farmer-lending
(last visited Sept. 28, 2025) (“[E]ach [FCS] institution is required to report to FCA yearly on operations and achievements under its YBS program and to disclose YBS data in its own annual report.”).
The CFPB believes that the rule's current application to FCS lenders risks imposing disproportionate regulatory complexity on them, many of which are small, rural cooperatives lacking the compliance infrastructure of large commercial lenders, which in turn risks diminishing the quality of the data they report to CFPB. Adding potentially redundant reporting requirements would do little to advance the goals of section 1071. Such a result would be counter to the Congressional goals behind the establishment of the FCS.
Based on the factors discussed above, the CFPB believes it would be appropriate to reconsider the rule's application to FCS lenders and to focus the rule's scope on conventional, general-purpose small business lending. Accordingly, the Bureau proposes to use its exemption authority under 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(g)(2) to exclude FCS lenders.
The CFPB seeks comment on this proposed revision to the rule.
105(b) Covered Financial Institution—Threshold Change
Current § 1002.105(b) defines a covered financial institution as one that has made at least 100 covered credit transactions to small businesses in each of the two preceding calendar years. The CFPB is proposing to change this definition by increasing this threshold from 100 covered credit transactions to 1,000 covered credit transactions because it believes that it would advance the statutory purposes of section 1071 to commence the data collection without including smaller lenders under a 1,000 originations threshold.
In the 2023 final rule, the CFPB explained its belief that a 100-loan origination threshold would best address widespread industry concerns regarding compliance burdens for the smallest financial institutions while also
capturing the overwhelming majority of the small business lending market. It noted that while its original proposal of a 25-loan threshold would have yielded more data than a 100-loan threshold, the 100-loan origination threshold “massively expands data availability relative to the status quo.”
38
The CFPB noted that a number of commenters on the 2021 proposed rule requested a higher threshold, such as 1,000 covered credit transactions. At that time, the CFPB was concerned that a threshold higher than 100 covered credit transactions would dramatically reduce the number of covered financial institutions that must report data under the rule. However, as the CFPB noted in the 2023 final rule, a large decrease in the number of covered financial institutions does not equate to a proportionately large reduction in the estimated number of small business credit applications reported.
38
88 FR 35150, 35257.
As a result, the CFPB believes that the proposed 1,000 originations threshold is justified for several independent reasons. First, the CFPB believes that at the onset of the data collection under section 1071 the focus should be on core lenders and products before the CFPB considers whether it would be appropriate to expand the scope of the rule. The CFPB believes that larger volume lenders are core to small business lending. Current § 1002.114(b), by way of comparison, prioritized the collection of data from the largest volume lenders first because they have more resources, and because they account for the bulk of small business lending volume.
39
39
See id.
at 35438-40.
Second, the proposed change better aligns with E.O. 14192,
40
which directs Federal agencies to review regulations for regulatory burden, and is responsive to feedback received from stakeholders following publication of the 2023 final rule. The CFPB has heard repeatedly from industry stakeholders that its estimates in the 2023 final rule were wrong, and that a 100-loan origination threshold is too low and captures too many smaller institutions, which they say originate fewer small business loans and also are less able to shoulder the costs and complexity of complying with the rule due to fewer resources and staff.
40
90 FR 9065 (Feb. 6, 2025).
The Bureau preliminarily determines that changing the originations threshold to 1,000 strikes a better balance by minimizing complexity for smaller entities while still collecting data on a large proportion of small business credit applications; indeed, as the Bureau observed with respect to the 100-loan threshold in the 2023 final rule, a 1,000-loan threshold would substantially increase data availability as compared to the status quo.
The CFPB believes a threshold of 1,000 originations, instead of 100, would be congruent with the statutory purposes of section 1071. The CFPB believes that the onset of data collection should commence with core products and lenders, as larger lenders are better resourced and can better sustain the complexities and cost of compliance with the rule. The CFPB believes that it should work with larger lenders to better understand potential difficulties associated with collecting data before considering whether to expand the rule to require that smaller lenders comply with the rule.
Further, the CFPB also notes from its research that the proposed change in the threshold for originations would result in a reduction in the number of smaller institutions covered by the rule without a proportionately large reduction in the number of loan application-level data collected by the rule.
41
While the proposed 1,000 originations threshold would carve out a large number of mostly smaller depository institutions, the rule would still cover the vast majority of small business loan originations (well over 90 percent).
41
See
part IV.D, tables 1 and 2 below.
Given this the CFPB believes increasing the threshold would remove regulatory burden from small entities, and therefore the proposed change would be responsive to E.O. 14192.
The CFPB believes that increasing the threshold is necessary or appropriate to carry out the purposes of section 1071 because the complexity of compliance may pose difficulties for smaller lenders, many of which have no previous experience at all with data collection rules such as HMDA or CRA. The new compliance complexity may result in decreased data quality for those institutions, which would not advance the statutory purposes of section 1071.
The proposed change to § 1002.105(b) would, in turn, require other changes. Current § 1002.112(b) provides that a bona fide error is not a violation of ECOA or Regulation B, subpart B. The provision cross-references numerical error thresholds in current appendix F. Under appendix F, a financial institution is presumed to maintain procedures reasonably adapted to avoid errors with respect to a given data field if the number of errors found in a random sample of a financial institution's data submission for a given data field do not equal or exceed the threshold in column C of table 1 of appendix F.
The CFPB proposes revising appendix F to conform to the proposed changes to § 1002.105(b), defining “covered financial institution,” based on a revised origination threshold of 1,000 covered credit transactions. Specifically, column A of existing appendix F lists ranges of small business lending application register counts. The CFPB proposes eliminating the rows in table 1 associated with application counts under 1,000, and revising the count in what is currently the 4th row to be “1,000-100,000” rather than the current “500-100,000.” The CFPB requests comment on these proposed changes.
The CFPB seeks comment on this proposed revision to the rule, in particular whether an originations threshold at 200, 500, 2,000, or some other number would be appropriate, and whether the associated changes to appendix F are appropriate.
D. Section 1002.106—Business and Small Business
106(b) Small Business
Current § 1002.106(b)(1) defines “small business” and provides, among other criteria, that a business is small if its gross annual revenue for its preceding fiscal year is $5 million or less. Section 1002.106(b)(2) provides procedures for inflation adjustments to that threshold. For the reasons discussed below, the CFPB is proposing to reduce the gross annual revenue threshold from $5 million or less to $1 million or less.
In the 2023 final rule, the CFPB explained that its definition reflected the need for financial institutions to apply a simple, broad definition of a small business across industries. It also explained its belief that a $5 million gross annual revenue threshold strikes the right balance in terms of broadly covering the small business financing market while meeting the SBA's criteria for an alternative size standard. It noted that it did not propose a $1 million gross annual revenue threshold out of concern that such a threshold likely would not satisfy the SBA's requirements for an alternative size standard across industries, while also observing that a $1 million threshold would better align with existing Regulation B adverse action notification requirements. It also concluded that a $1 million threshold would exclude many businesses that should be characterized as small.
The CFPB will retain the use of a simple, broad definition of a small business across industries but is
proposing to change the gross annual revenue threshold from $5 million or less to $1 million or less, and to make conforming changes throughout the regulatory text and commentary. The CFPB is seeking SBA approval for this alternate small business size standard pursuant to the Small Business Act.
42
42
15 U.S.C. 632(a)(2)(C).
Since the 2023 final rule was published, the President issued E.O. 14192.
43
As part of the CFPB's review of the 2023 final rule under this order, the CFPB identified that a $1 million threshold would help reduce regulatory burden on financial institutions because it would better align with other existing financial regulatory requirements and standard financial industry practices related to small businesses.
43
90 FR 9065.
Specifically, the CFPB believes several independent reasons justify a change of the gross annual revenue threshold to $1 million. First, as noted by commenters on the CFPB's 2021 proposed rule, a $1 million threshold would align with certain metrics in CRA regulations. Several CRA tests analyze lending to “smaller businesses” with $1 million or less in revenues.
44
The CFPB finalized the $5 million threshold in the 2023 final rule, and the Federal agencies responsible for implementing the CRA proposed and subsequently finalized amendments to their small business revenue threshold to $5 million, to conform with the CFPB's rule implementing section 1071, and to use data collected pursuant to that rule. Since then, however, the CRA agencies have proposed withdrawing those revisions, which never entered into force. The CRA agencies proposed reverting back to a $1 million or less definition, and no longer using section 1071 data in certain CRA tests concerning small businesses.
45
The CFPB believes that it should follow suit to reduce avoidable regulatory complexity for regulated entities by sharing where possible a uniform size standard with other Federal agencies.
44
“Smaller business” loans are a subset of “small business” loans as defined by CRA regulations before the 2024 amendments. “Small business” loans are those with a loan amount of $1 million or less to a business of any size under CRA regulations. 12 CFR 25.12(v) (“small business loan means a loan included in `loans to small businesses' as defined in the instructions for preparation of the Consolidated Report of Condition and Income”); Fed. Fin. Insts. Examination Council,
Schedule RC-C, Part II. Loans to Small Businesses and Small Farms General Instructions
(defining “loans to small businesses” as loans with original amounts of $1 million or less),
https://www.fdic.gov/resources/bankers/call-reports/crinst-051/2017/2017-03-051-rc-c2.pdf
(last visited Sept. 30, 2025). “Smaller business” loans are “small business” loans made to business with $1 million or less in revenues under the 1995 amendments to CRA regulations.
See
12 CFR 25.22(b)(3)(ii) (assessing the lending activity of an institutions of “small business and small farm loans to businesses and farms with gross annual revenues of $1 million or less”).
45
The Federal agencies responsible for implementing the CRA amended the regulations in 2024 to change the relevant threshold from $1 million to $5 million to conform with the CFPB's rule implementing section 1071. 89 FR 6574 (Feb. 1, 2024). These agencies have subsequently issued a joint notice of proposed rulemaking that would rescind the 2024 amendments to the CRA regulations, reverting back to the 1995/2001 version of the CRA regulations. 90 FR 34086 (July 18, 2025).
Second, the CFPB also believes that the revised threshold in proposed § 1002.106(b) would be more consistent with Regulation B, subpart A, further helping to reduce regulatory burden pursuant to E.O. 14192.
46
As noted in the 2023 final rule, Regulation B, subpart A uses a $1 million revenue threshold to determine what kind of adverse action notice a business credit applicant receives; those under the threshold receive a notification similar to one a consumer would receive.
47
As a result, many covered financial institutions likely already apply a $1 million threshold to determine which businesses are small. Here, the CFPB believes that using an existing size standard would reduce regulatory complexity for covered financial institutions.
46
90 FR 9065 (Feb. 6, 2025).
47
See
88 FR 35150, 35186.
Third, as many financial institutions have worked on implementing the 2023 final rule, the Bureau has received more feedback, including from a number of community banks and trade groups representing larger institutions, that a $1 million revenue threshold would more closely align with their internal thresholds that separate small and medium-sized businesses within their own institutions.
The CFPB notes that the 2023 final rule adopted a $5 million threshold in significant part because it believed that a $1 million threshold, discussed as an alternative to the $5 million threshold, would not satisfy the SBA's requirements for an alternative size standard and would exclude too many businesses designated as small under the SBA's size standards. Whether an alternative size standard satisfies the requirements for an alternative size standard is within the SBA's purview to determine, and as noted above the CFPB is seeking SBA approval for its proposed $1 million threshold.
Further, as commenters initially stated, a $1 million threshold would cover most (over 95 percent) of small businesses as defined by the SBA size standards in effect at the time of the 2021 proposed rule. The CFPB estimated in the 2023 final rule that among non-agricultural industries over 1.5 million small businesses (27 percent) would not be covered by an alternative $1 million gross annual revenue threshold.
48
The CFPB is now reconsidering the data provided by commenters and its final rule estimate. In any case, the CFPB believes that a change to $1 million is consistent with the alignment goals noted above given the E.O.s discussed throughout, even if a 27 percent decline in small business coverage would result. At a $1 million threshold, the proposed rule would still cover a supermajority of small businesses that the 2023 final rule covers.
48
Id.
at 35266.
The CFPB is proposing conforming changes also to the inflation adjustment provision in § 1002.106(b)(2), to require adjustment in $100,000 increments (rather than $500,000) every five years after 2030 (rather than 2025). The CFPB is concerned that, given the proposed change to a $1 million revenue threshold, inflation adjustments in $500,000 increments would not be granular enough for this provision to meaningfully track inflation.
The Bureau seeks comment on the proposed changes to § 1002.106(b)(1) and (b)(2), including whether revenue thresholds of $500,000, $2 million, $3 million, or some other amount would be appropriate.
E. Section 1002.107—Compilation of Reportable Data
107(a) Data Format and Itemization
107(a) Discretionary Data Points
Section 1071 provides for two types of data points, those statutorily required under ECOA section 704B(e) and those promulgated based on Bureau discretion provided for in ECOA section 704B(e)(2)(H), which are sometimes referred to as discretionary data points, and which the Bureau has authority to add if the “Bureau determines [they] would aid in fulfilling the purposes of this section.” In the 2023 final rule, the Bureau finalized several discretionary data points, determining the additional data would aid in fulfilling the purposes of section 1071 of the Dodd-Frank Act, as required by ECOA section 704B(e)(2)(H). The discretionary data points were for pricing information, time in business, North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) code, number of workers, application method, application recipient, denial reasons, and number of principal owners. The Bureau considered the additional operational complexity and
potential reputational harm described by commenters that collecting and reporting these data points could impose on financial institutions, but determined that the costs were only incremental and that the data points were designed to minimize additional compliance burden.
49
49
Id.
at 35278.
Notably, in the 2023 final rule the Bureau declined to add other discretionary data points sought by commenters, because the decision whether to include a discretionary data point necessarily also involves considering the relative utility of a data point and the operational complexity of adding it. For that reason, in 2023 the Bureau stated that it was adopting a “limited number of data points . . . that it believes will offer the highest value in light of section 1071's statutory purposes,” and it rejected additional data points on the grounds that they would pose “operational complexities.”
50
For example, the Bureau declined to include a data point on credit scores, even though the data would be useful for fair lending analyses, due to the complexity and operational difficulty of doing so.
51
50
Id.
at 35281.
51
Id.
at 35282.
In other words, to be included as a discretionary data point, a data point implicitly must satisfy two independent tests: (1) whether the data point would aid in fulfilling the purposes of section 1071,
and
(2) whether the CFPB believes based on the record before it that it is appropriate to adopt as a discretionary data point given factors such as operational cost and regulatory complexity. Accordingly, if the Bureau now believes that the relative utility of the data is not strong enough to justify the additional operational complexity for financial institutions, that is sufficient reason to propose removing the discretionary data point, even if the discretionary data point would otherwise advance the purposes of the statute.
After the publication of the 2023 final rule, two factors prompted reconsideration of the discretionary data points by the Bureau. First, as discussed above, pursuant to E.O.s. 14192 and 14219 (“Ensuring Lawful Regulation and Implementing the President's `Department of Government Efficiency' Deregulatory Agenda”), the Bureau is reviewing the 2023 final rule as part of its effort to streamline and simplify regulations.
52
The Bureau believes that removing some of the discretionary data points would meet the goals of these E.O.s. Second, subsequent to the publication of the 2023 final rule and through the implementation process, the Bureau received additional feedback about the number of data points total, and the logistical challenges associated with implementing some or all of the discretionary data points. The implementation feedback provided by stakeholders further supports reconsideration of certain discretionary data points, and the Bureau now believes that the 2023 final rule did not adequately consider the extent to which the value of the data point justifies the additional operational complexity in obtaining it.
52
90 FR 9065; 90 FR 10583 (Feb. 25, 2025).
Given this new information, the Bureau proposes to remove the discretionary data points for application method, application recipient, denial reasons, pricing, and number of workers in § 1002.107(a)(3), (4), (11), (12), (16), as well as the relevant commentary, and to make conforming changes throughout.
The data points identified for removal are not statutorily required and are not otherwise relied upon by or intertwined with the statutorily required data points.
53
In any case, because the identified data points were finalized pursuant to the Bureau's discretionary authority under 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(e)(2)(H), it is also within the bounds of that discretion to remove these data points. The CFPB believes that their removal at this time, at the start of a potentially long-term data collection regime, would advance the longer-term statutory purposes of the rule. Stakeholders attempting to implement the rule have suggested the addition of data points beyond those statutorily required had led to unnecessary complexity in implementing the 2023 final rule, and that such complexity might reduce data quality and lead to additional errors. The CFPB preliminarily concludes that initiating the data collection with an expansive rule that covered more data points would tend to make the initial collections more complicated and result in lesser data quality and integrity.
53
The Bureau is not proposing to remove NAICS code, time in business, and number of principal owners because those discretionary data points are generally integral to collection and understanding of statutorily required data points and the Bureau did not receive evidence during the implementation period of logistical challenges not previously considered.
The CFPB believes it prudent to focus on the collection of a more limited number of core data points (the statutory data points and a limited number of other data points needed to facilitate the collection of these statutory data points) to avoid complexity in the initial implementation of a rule to implement section 1071. This in turn would make it more likely that covered financial institutions face a smoother transition in the initial years of the rule in ramping up to the accurate, recurring collection of data.
54
54
The Bureau notes that in its experience with new regulatory regimes, especially new data collections such as the revisions to HMDA in 2015, covered institutions face initial difficulties with collecting and reporting data accurately, especially given the expansive changes required by the 2015 HMDA rulemaking.
Application method.
The 2023 final rule required financial institutions to collect data on whether applications were submitted in person, by phone, online, or by mail. It explained its belief that this data will improve the market's understanding of how different types of applicants apply for credit and provide additional context for the business and community development needs of particular geographic regions. The Bureau now believes that this information is of relatively low value in furthering the purposes of section 1071 while adding to the overall complexity of a lengthy data collection, and thus should not be included. Upon reconsideration, the Bureau believes that in the 2023 final rule, it had underestimated the potential complexity of this data point. The Bureau acknowledged that many lenders do not already collect this data point as such, and that many small business applicants have multiple interactions across the different methods listed (in-person, telephone, online) during the application process. However, current § 1002.107(a)(3) does not seem to address this but rather appears to reduce the potentially complex set of interactions to identifying only one means of collecting a covered application. The logic of the 2023 final rule justifying this provision suggests the futility of collecting this data point without capturing the full scope of interaction between applicant and lender for purposes of this rule. The Bureau believes, as a result, that at this time, this data point should be removed because its utility does not outweigh the cost and complexity of collecting it.
Application recipient.
In the 2023 rule, the Bureau required financial institutions to collect data on application method—whether the applicant submitted the covered application directly to the financial institution or its affiliate, or whether the applicant submitted the covered application indirectly to the financial institution via a third party. It explained
that this discretionary data point will improve the market's understanding of how small businesses interact with financial institutions when applying for credit, such as whether financial institutions making credit decisions are directly interacting with the applicant and/or generally operating in the same community as the applicant. The Bureau now believes that this information is of relatively low value in furthering the purposes of section 1071 while adding to the overall complexity of a lengthy data collection. Upon reconsideration, the Bureau believes that in the 2023 final rule, it overestimated the utility and underestimated the cost and complexity of this data point. The justification for this data point in the 2023 final rule suggested that it would help determine whether lenders were operating in the communities with applicants but did not offer details on why a data point on third-party submissions would advance such an understanding, above and beyond the other data points more apparently targeted to identify community development needs, such as census tract. Further, in response to a comment that lenders do not track data on application submissions by third parties because such data played no role in underwriting decisions, the Bureau summarily replied that it did not believe it would be difficult for lenders to track this information. The Bureau believes that submissions through third parties may not always be identified as such, and that its statement in the 2023 final rule justifying the inclusion of this data point did not account for this. The Bureau as a result believes that at the start of a potentially long-term data collection regime that this data point should be removed.
Denial reasons.
The Bureau explained in the 2023 rule that data on denial reasons will allow data users to better understand the rationale behind denial decisions, help identify potential fair lending concerns, and provide financial institutions with data to evaluate their business underwriting criteria and address potential gaps as needed. As the Bureau acknowledged in the 2023 rule, reasons for denial data could be harmful or sensitive for applicants or related natural persons. The Bureau now believes that the sensitivity of this information, combined with its addition to the overall complexity of a lengthy data collection, justifies proposing to remove it from the discretionary data points. The 2023 final rule did not explain how the marginal or added usefulness of denial reasons would justify the added cost and complexity above and beyond the collection of data on denials, already captured by the mandatory “type of action taken” data point. Further, to the extent that this data point was intended to assist lenders to analyze their own fair lending concerns, as the 2023 final rule stated, the data point is redundant as lenders already possess this information. To the extent that this data point was intended to assist applicants, under subpart A of Regulation B they are already able to access a statement of denial reasons. Section 1002.9(a)(3) in subpart A already requires lenders to inform applicants for business credit with $1 million or less in gross annual revenue of their right to receive a statement of denial reasons upon request. Upon reconsideration, the Bureau believes that it is sufficient at this time to collect data on denials via the action taken data point, as required under 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(e)(2)(D), and that this data point should not be included at the start of a potentially long-term data collection regime.
Pricing.
In the 2023 rule, the Bureau required reporting of an array of different pricing data: interest rate; total origination charges; broker fees; the total amount of all non-interest charges that are scheduled to be imposed over the first annual period; for a merchant cash advance or other sales-based financing transaction, the difference between the amount advanced and the amount to be repaid; and information about any applicable prepayment penalties. It explained its belief that because price-setting is integral to the functioning of any market, any analysis of the small business lending market—including to enforce fair lending laws or identify community and business development opportunities—would be less meaningful without this information. The 2023 rule acknowledge the potential complexity of collecting this data, and commenters noted the risk that it could reveal confidential business information or lead to incorrect inferences about discrimination. The Bureau now believes that the potential risk of harm to applicants and the substantial complexity of the data collection justify removing it from the discretionary data points. While the Bureau acknowledged comments “about the harmful consequences of potentially misleading data,” the Bureau addressed this concern in the 2023 final rule by stating that it would note “when disclosing the 1071 data that the data alone generally do not offer proof of compliance with fair lending laws.”
55
The Bureau upon reconsideration believes that such a statement may not be sufficient to address concerns about the misuse of pricing data. In adopting the pricing data point, the Bureau assumed that community groups would use data responsibly but did not address how other members of the public with access to the data might use it.
56
Further, the 2023 final rule stated that “the 1071 data need not reflect every determinant of credit pricing to provide value to users” but also acknowledged the relevant and importance of credit score of principal owners to “explain[] pricing differences between transactions.”
57
That is, the Bureau believes that the publication of pricing information absent certain other information may be incomplete and give rise to incorrect inferences concerning discrimination; however, the collection of sufficient data points to correct potentially erroneous inferences may make the data collection unduly complex. This combination of difficulties leads the Bureau to believe that this data point should not be included at the start of a potentially long-term data collection regime.
55
88 FR 35150, 35310.
56
Id.
at 35310.
57
Id.
Number of workers.
The 2023 rule required financial institutions to report the number of workers in ranges, and stated that data on the number of persons working for a small business applicant will provide data users and relevant stakeholders with a better understanding of the job maintenance and creation that small business credit provides. The Bureau now believes that this information is of relatively low value in furthering the purposes of section 1071 while adding to the overall complexity of a lengthy data collection. First, in the 2023 final rule, the Bureau acknowledged that “[t]he majority of small businesses are run by a single owner.” Given the proposed change to § 1002.106(b), revising the definition of small business to those businesses with $1 million or less in gross annual revenue, fewer small businesses with employees would be covered under the rule. Second, as acknowledged in the 2023 final rule, small businesses may encounter difficulties in providing this information to financial institutions, especially small businesses that use contractors, temporary or gig workers, or seasonal workers, or those that cycle through employees frequently. While the Bureau simplified a covered financial institution's reporting requirements for this data point, the Bureau believes that even as simplified this data point's complexity outweighs its potential utility. That is, the Bureau
now believes that it would be difficult to ensure consistency in reporting this data point across a variety of different small business applicants, making it likely that the data collected would be of poor quality or otherwise difficult to interpret. Further, the 2023 final rule justified this data point solely on community development grounds. It did not justify this data point on fair lending grounds because nothing in Regulation B, including subpart A, offers differential protection based on a business credit applicant's number of workers. Based on the Bureau's intention to commence this rulemaking regime focused on truly small businesses, the Bureau believes that this data point should not be included at the start of a potentially long-term data collection regime as it is not likely to result in the collection of useful data at this time.
LGBTQI+-owned business status.
The 2023 rule required financial institutions to inquire whether a small business applicant for credit is a minority-owned, women-owned, and/or LGBTQI+-owned business. This discretionary data point is addressed in more detail below in the section on the Defending Women E.O.
The Bureau solicits comment on these proposed changes, including whether any of the identified discretionary data points should be modified or retained, in part or in full.
Collection of Disaggregated Ethnicity and Race Categories
Current § 1002.107(a)(19) requires the collection of both aggregate and disaggregated race and ethnicity information on principal owners of small business applicants. However, 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(e)(2)(G) only requires covered lenders to collect and report the “race, sex, and ethnicity of the principal owners of the business.” This statutory provision does not explicitly call for the collection of disaggregated data on the race and ethnicity of principal owners. Given its concern about commencing a long-term data collection regime by asking for potentially complex and costly data points, the Bureau seeks comment on whether it should revise the rule's data collection requirements to require collection only of aggregate ethnicity and race categories.
As a result, and consistent with its reconsideration of discretionary data points, the Bureau also seeks specific comment on what utility there might be for carrying out the purposes of section 1071 in requiring the collection of disaggregated categories of ethnicity and race, in addition to the aggregate categories. The Bureau also seeks comment on the costs and burdens for financial institutions in requiring the collection of these disaggregated categories of ethnicity and race.
Defending Women E.O.
LGBTQI+-ownership.
Current § 1002.107(a)(18) requires financial institutions to inquire whether a small business applicant for credit is a minority-owned, women-owned, and/or LGBTQI+-owned business. The Bureau explained that, based on limited information available, it believed that LGBTQI+-owned businesses may experience particular challenges accessing small business credit, and used its discretionary authority under 15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(e)(2)(H) to require financial institutions to request information about whether an applicant is a LGBTQI+-owned business. In the time since the 2023 rule, the Bureau has heard repeated concerns from stakeholders, as well as members of Congress and the general public, that this question in particular is an invasion of privacy and risks damaging the relationship between small businesses and their lenders, particularly in smaller lending markets. The Bureau now believes that the sensitivities involved in this inquiry, which the 2023 rule did not address, exceed any utility this data point might provide, and that it adds to the overall complexity of a lengthy data collection.
58
58
The Bureau also notes that it has withdrawn its 2023 interpretive rule concerning LGBTQI+ discrimination under ECOA. 86 FR 14363 (Mar. 16, 2021) (clarifying that the prohibition against sex discrimination in ECOA and Regulation B encompasses sexual orientation and gender identity discrimination); 90 FR 20084 (May 12, 2025) (withdrawing the 2021 interpretive rule). That rule sought to extend to ECOA the Court's holding in
Bostock,
which found title VII's prohibition against sex discrimination includes discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity.
Bostock
v.
Clayton Cnty.,
590 U.S. 644 (2020). The Court has since declined to expressly extend the holding of Bostock beyond the title VII context.
United States
v.
Skrmetti,
605 U.S. __(2025).
In addition, the President issued the Defending Women E.O. (E.O. 14168) on January 30, 2025, which directs Federal agencies seeking information not to discuss gender identity and to refer to sex using a binary of male/female. Consistent with this E.O. and the feedback the Bureau received from stakeholders and members of Congress and the general public described above, the Bureau is proposing to make certain conforming changes to the rule and remove or rescind provisions in the current rule that do not comply with the order. These changes generally would include (1) removing references to and questions about “LGBTQI+”-owned business status, (2) requiring financial institutions to inquire about a principal owner's sex, rather than sex/gender, and (3) providing that the sex of the principal owners be selected from a static binary response option of male/female, rather than a free-form text field.
Specifically, the proposed changes would include removing the definition related to LGBTQI+-owned business status in § 1002.102(k) and (l) and removing references to LGBTQI+-owned business status in § 1002.107(a)(18) and (19) and associated commentary, and revising how principal owners' sex is to be collected in commentary accompanying § 1002.107(a)(19). The proposed changes would also include removing references to LGBTQI+-owned business status in Regulation B, subpart A, § 1002.5(a)(4) and revising commentary accompanying § 1002.5(a)(2). The Bureau is also proposing to make conforming changes elsewhere throughout the regulatory text and associated commentary, as well as the sample form in appendix E.
The Bureau seeks comment on these proposed changes.
Sex/gender.
Current § 1002.107(a)(19) requires financial institutions to ask a small business applicant to provide its principal owners' ethnicity, race and sex. Associated commentary further explains how financial institutions are to make these requests. Commentary to current § 1002.107(a)(19) requires financial institutions, when requesting principal owners' sex, to use the term “sex/gender” and to give applicants a free-form text field to provide a response.
Commentary accompanying current § 1002.107(a)(19) requires financial institutions, when requesting principal owners' sex, to use the term “sex/gender” and to give applicants a free-form text field to provide a response. In the 2023 rule, the Bureau explained its belief that this approach would allow applicants to self-identify as they see fit. Commenters had contended, however, that the free-form text approach would inhibit data analysis.
The Bureau now agrees with commenters who had asserted that, particularly in the context of a data collection rule, a free-form text field would inhibit robust data analysis, contrary to the purposes of the rule. The Bureau also now believes, based on feedback from stakeholders of all kinds, that a free-form text field would likely result in poor data quality, given the variety of possible responses to the sex question even for a single type of answer.
59
The potential for confusion is
exacerbated by the lack of clarifying instructions. The Bureau now believes that the most appropriate way to collect data on the sex of a principal owner is to ask the straightforward question of whether the owner is male or female.
59
Responses intended to indicate “female” sex could include “female,” “woman,” “feminine,”
“
mujer,
” “F,” “W,” and even “M.” Responses intended to indicate “male” could include “man,” “male,” “
hombre,
” “guy,” “M,” “m,” “H,” etc. Free-form text responses may also result in non-serious responses.
Additionally, this proposed change comports with the Defending Women order described above. Specifically, the changes consistent with E.O. 14168 would include revising how principal owners' sex is to be collected in commentary accompanying § 1002.107(a)(19). The Bureau is also proposing to make conforming changes elsewhere throughout the regulatory text and associated commentary, as well as the sample form in appendix E.
The Bureau solicits comment on these proposed changes.
Applicant's Right To Refuse To Provide Demographic Data
Current § 1002.107(a)(18) requires covered financial institutions to seek information from applicants about their women-owned, minority-owned, and LGBTQI+-owned business status and § 1002.107(a)(19) requires covered financial institutions to seek information from applicants about the ethnicity, race, and sex of the principal owners of the applicant business. Those provisions and associated commentary also include discussions of the statutorily provided right of an applicant to refuse to provide this information.
60
60
15 U.S.C. 1691c-2(c).
The Bureau is proposing to revise the applicant right to refuse discussions in § 1002.107(a)(18) and (19), as well as the related commentary. In addition, the Bureau is proposing corresponding changes to the sample demographic data collection form in appendix E. Currently, the regulatory text of § 1002.107(a)(18) and (19) provides that covered financial institutions must inform applicants that the financial institution cannot discriminate against the applicant based on the demographic information provided pursuant to the rule or on whether the applicant invokes the right to refuse to provide the information. Existing comments 107(a)(18)-1 and 107(a)(19)-1 state that a financial institution must permit an applicant to refuse (
i.e.,
decline) to answer the financial institution's inquiries regarding business status and ethnicity, race, and sex, and must inform the applicant that it is not required to provide the information. The Bureau is proposing to add the requirement to inform applicants of their right to refuse to the regulatory text of § 1002.107(a)(18) and (19), for clarity.
The Bureau is also proposing changes to the sample form in appendix E to further emphasize the right to refuse.
The Bureau seeks comment on these proposed changes.
107(c) Time and Manner of Collection
Anti-Discouragement and Related Provisions
In the 2023 rule, the Bureau explained that it was adopting the provisions in § 1002.107(c) in an attempt to provide a balance between allowing institutions flexibility in how they collect data and ensuring that institutions do not discourage or otherwise interfere with applicants' providing their data. Existing § 1002.107(c) requires a covered financial institution to (1) not discourage an applicant from responding to requests for applicant-provided data under final § 1002.107(a) and to otherwise maintain procedures to collect such data at a time and in a manner that are reasonably designed to obtain a response; (2) identify certain minimum components when collecting data directly from the applicant that must be included within a financial institution's procedures to ensure they are reasonably designed to obtain a response; (3) maintain procedures to identify and respond to indicia that it may be discouraging applicants from responding to requests for applicant-provided data, including low response rates for applicant-provided data; as well as (4) provide that low response rates for applicant-provided data may indicate that a financial institution is discouraging applicants from responding to requests for applicant-provided data or otherwise failing to maintain procedures to collect applicant-provided data that are reasonably designed to obtain a response.
The CFPB proposes to remove certain references to the discouragement prohibition in § 1002.107(c)(1) and (c)(2)(iii), as well as related commentary that the Bureau believes are redundant and add unnecessary regulatory complexity. It also proposes to remove § 1002.107(c)(3) and (c)(4) and related commentary; these provisions detail requirements to monitor for indicia of discouragement, such as low response rates from applicants, and explicitly provide that low response rates may be indicia of discouragement. Further, the CFPB proposes to revise commentary to § 1002.107(c)(2) which established specific restrictions on the time and manner of data collection that are similar to the anti-discouragement provisions.
Section 1071, as implemented by Regulation B, subpart B, creates binding obligations for covered financial institutions to ask small business applicants for credit for their demographic information, but it includes no requirements regarding how institutions must ask for the information.
61
By contrast, the 2023 final rule imposed numerous obligations in § 1002.107(c) on the basis of theoretical concerns that institutions would seek to evade compliance by discouraging applicants from providing their information or otherwise interfering with applicants providing their data. It did not provide any evidence in support of its concerns, such as evidence from past experience with HMDA or other similar situations. In addition, the Bureau now believes that comment 107(c)(2)-2.iii.A, which discusses financial institution statements that would violate the anti-discouragement provision, raises serious First Amendment concerns.
61
90 FR 20084, 20086 (May 12, 2025) (withdrawing the Statement on Enforcement and Supervisory Practices Relating to the Small Business Lending Rule Under the ECOA and Regulation B).
The 2023 final rule also describes in commentary several obligations related to anti-discouragement, such as the requirements that financial institutions maximize the collection of data, request applicant-provided data before a final credit decision is made, and ensure that applicants do not overlook requests for data.
The Bureau's belief that the anti-discouragement and other related provisions are unnecessary is also bolstered by feedback it has received from a number of stakeholders regarding difficulties with implementing these provisions, particularly with respect to the discussion in comment 107(c)(4)-1 as to comparison of response rates for demographic questions across similar financial institutions. Further, the provisions in § 1002.107(c) that would remain after these proposed revisions still impose affirmative obligations to maintain procedures reasonably designed to obtain a response from credit applicants.
Given the existence of these provisions, and in light of E.O.s 14192 and 14219 that require the CFPB to seek ways to increase efficiency in regulations, the CFPB now reconsiders existing § 1002.107(c) and preliminarily finds that its various prohibitions on discouragement are redundant and unnecessary. They are redundant in that
they appear to create obligations to comply with other existing obligations. They are unnecessary because the obligations to collect data and to maintain systems reasonably designed to elicit responses are already subject to the enforcement provisions of § 1002.112 in the event of non-compliance. Further, comments received in response to the 2025 interim final rule from a trade association suggested that these provisions were vague and did not make clear what would and would not constitute discouragement. All of this would add unnecessary regulatory complexity for lenders.
The CFPB observes that the other requirements in the current commentary to § 1002.107(c)(2)—concerning maximizing the collection of data, requesting applicant-provided data before a credit decision is made, and ensuring that applicants not overlook requests for data—should not have been framed as binding obligations because they are unnecessary obligations beyond those already established in § 1002.107(c). However, unlike the anti-discouragement provisions, these provisions identify practices likely to help covered financial institutions comply with the 2023 final rule. The CFPB proposes revising these provisions to provide guidance to financial institutions rather than contributing unnecessary regulatory complexity in the form of additional obligations. The CFPB believes that providing this flexibility will advance the statutory purposes of the rule by helping financial institutions collect better quality data without requiring them to follow rigid practices that may in some instances impede rather than encourage data collection. The CFPB further believes that making these practices guiding principles, rather than requirements, better conforms with the existing regulatory text of § 1002.107(c), which requires covered lenders to “maintain procedures to collect such data at a time and in a manner that are
reasonably
designed to obtain a response” (emphasis added).
For purposes of streamlining and simplifying the rule by removing unnecessary regulations, as discussed above, the Bureau proposes to remove provisions regarding or discussing a prohibition on the discouragement of applicants from providing data required under the rule, and proposes revising other provisions concerning the time and manner of collection to provide guidance rather than additional obligations.
The Bureau seeks comment on these proposed changes.
F. Section 1002.114—Effective Date, Compliance Date, and Special Transitional Rules
114(b) Compliance Date
The rule's compliance dates, as most recently amended by the 2025 compliance dates final rule, are set forth in current § 1002.114(b). That section looks to a financial institution's volume of covered credit transactions for small businesses to determine which of three compliance dates (currently July 1, 2026, January 1, 2027, and October 1, 2027) are applicable to a financial institution.
The CFPB proposes amending § 1002.114(b) to eliminate the system of tiered compliance dates in favor of creating a single compliance date. Mirroring the change to the rule's origination threshold set forth in proposed § 1002.105(b), proposed § 1002.114(b) would require that all covered financial institutions that originated at least 1,000 covered credit transactions for small businesses in each of calendar years 2026 and 2027 begin to comply with the rule starting on January 1, 2028. The CFPB proposes making corresponding updates throughout the commentary accompanying § 1002.114(b) and (c), which would provide additional guidance and examples regarding the compliance date.
The CFPB preliminarily believes that the extension of the single compliance date to January 1, 2028, is necessary and reasonable for several independent reasons. Those covered financial institutions that would reasonably expect to be above the new 1,000 origination threshold will need additional time to adjust their compliance systems to any changes to the rule the CFPB adopts after considering the comments submitted on this NPRM. The proposed revisions would not only reduce certain reporting requirements, such as the proposed elimination of many of the discretionary data points, but would also change existing requirements concerning statutorily required demographic data points, consistent with the Defending Women E.O. Such changes may require that financial institutions that may have already prepared to comply with the 2023 final rule to change forms, customer interfaces, or other compliance software or regulatory processes.
Further time would also be necessary for other institutions to determine whether they are covered at all under the rule, given the proposed modification of the threshold for covered financial institutions from 100 to 1,000 originations, as well as other proposed changes that would result in fewer transactions being counted toward the 1,000 origination threshold (such as the proposed removal of certain categories of credit transactions from § 1002.104(b), from the definitions of covered credit transaction, and the change to the definition of small business in § 1002.106).
The CFPB likewise believes it would be appropriate to adopt a single compliance date, to begin on January 1, 2028, that is applicable to all covered financial institutions. The need for a tiered compliance structure is diminished by the length of time that has passed since the adoption of the 2023 final rule as well as fewer covered financial institutions as a result of changes proposed to §§ 1002.104(b), 1002.105(b), and 1002.106. The CFPB has also heard feedback from stakeholders regarding difficulties for financial institutions in complying with the rule mid-year, which would be resolved by the proposed revisions to § 1002.114.
Finally, the CFPB believes that its proposed compliance date resolves any lingering concerns arising from previous compliance date extensions. As the CFPB explained in its 2025 interim final rule and 2025 compliance date final rule, those rules were necessary to avoid a subset of covered financial institutions remaining obligated to come into compliance with the 2023 rule, even though many of these institutions would be too small to qualify as covered financial institutions under this proposed rule, if finalized, meaning that they would likely incur significant compliance costs for only a single year's submission of data. Furthermore, this costly single-year submission of data—with costs inequitably imposed only on covered financial institutions that happened not to be plaintiffs or intervenors in litigation—would likely provide little benefit. For example, the data would be submitted in accordance with a different set of data points under § 1002.107(a), which could have caused analytical concerns in comparison with data submitted pursuant to this proposed rule, if finalized. Additionally, prior to releasing any data from the single-year submission, the CFPB would need to conduct an analysis under § 1002.110(a) to determine if deletion or modification of the data would advance a privacy interest, and due to the smaller size of the single-year data set, it is likely that more data would need to be deleted or modified, limiting its utility. Finally, if covered financial institutions were not given additional time to comply with the changes
proposed here, the Bureau is concerned that credit access and data quality might be affected in a manner that would not advance the purposes of the statute.
The CFPB seeks comment on these proposed changes. It also seeks comment on whether it would be appropriate to finalize this compliance date amendment in advance of finalizing the proposal's other changes, so that institutions currently covered by the 2023 rule could have earlier certainty as to the timing of their obligations, if any.
114(c) Special Transition Rules
In the 2023 final rule, financial institutions were instructed to determine their compliance tier based on their originations in 2022 and 2023. Subsequent changes to the rule added the time periods of 2023 and 2024, or 2024 and 2025, that financial institutions could choose to use instead. These alternatives are set out in existing § 1002.114(c)(3) and related commentary.
The CFPB is proposing revising § 1002.114(c)(3) and related commentary to require a financial institution to count its originations of covered credit transactions in each of calendar years 2026 and 2027 to determine whether it must comply with the rule on the proposed compliance date of January 1, 2028. This proposed change would simplify § 1002.114(c) and better align it with the proposed revisions to § 1002.114(b).
The CFPB believes that the range of options provided by current § 1002.114(c), intended to provide flexibility to potentially covered financial institutions, is no longer appropriate for a single compliance date with a single originations threshold. Further, proposed § 1002.114(c) would use calendar years closer to the new compliance date and would be a fairer time period to count originations. The compliance date in proposed § 1002.114(b) of January 1, 2028, would be nearly five years removed from some of the two-year time periods used to determine when a covered financial institution must begin to collect data. Originations in 2026 and 2027 would be controlling in any event; if a financial institution would be covered by the rule based on its originations in 2022 and 2023, but fell below the threshold based on 2026 and 2027, it would not be a covered financial institution for 2028. The CFPB thus believes that referring to the number of originations during calendar years 2026 and 2027 would be more appropriate and relevant to determining whether a financial institution must comply with the rule starting in January 2028.
The CFPB seeks comment on this proposed change.
IV. CFPA Section 1022(b) Analysis
In developing the proposed rule, the CFPB has considered the potential benefits, costs, and impacts as required by section 1022(b)(2) of the Consumer Financial Protection Act of 2010 (CFPA). Section 1022(b)(2) calls for the CFPB to consider the potential benefits and costs of a regulation to consumers and covered persons, including the potential reduction of consumer access to consumer financial products or services, the impact on depository institutions and credit unions with $10 billion or less in total assets as described in section 1026 of the CFPA, and the impact on consumers in rural areas.
In the Dodd-Frank Act, which was enacted “[t]o promote the financial stability of the United States by improving accountability and transparency in the financial system,” Congress directed the Bureau to adopt regulations governing the collection of small business lending data. Under section 1071 of that Act, covered financial institutions must compile, maintain, and submit certain specified data points regarding applications for credit for small businesses, with particular attention to women-owned and minority-owned small businesses, along with “any additional data that the Bureau determines would aid in fulfilling the purposes of this section.” Under the 2023 final rule, covered financial institutions are required to collect and report the following data points: (1) a unique identifier, (2) application date, (3) application method, (4) application recipient, (5) credit type, (6) credit purpose, (7) amount applied for, (8) amount approved or originated, (9) action taken, (10) action taken date, (11) denial reasons, (12) pricing information, (13) census tract, (14) gross annual revenue, (15) NAICS code, (16) number of workers, (17) time in business, (18) minority-owned, women-owned, and LGBTQI+-owned business status, (19) ethnicity, race, and sex of principal owners, and (20) the number of principal owners.
Under the 2023 final rule, financial institutions are required to report data on small business credit applications if they originated at least 100 covered credit transactions in each of the two preceding calendar years. Loans, lines of credit, credit cards, and merchant cash advances (including such credit transactions for agricultural purposes) all fall within the transactional scope of the 2023 final rule, with no limitations on loan amount. The Bureau excluded trade credit, transactions that are reportable under HMDA, insurance premium financing, public utilities credit, securities credit, and incidental credit. Factoring, leases, and consumer-designated credit used for business or agricultural purposes are also not covered credit transactions. For purposes of the 2023 final rule, a business is a small business if its gross annual revenue for its preceding fiscal year is $5 million or less. Finally, the 2023 final rule, as subsequently amended, establishes several compliance dates for financial institutions based on three origination size thresholds.
This proposed rule reconsiders certain provisions of the 2023 final rule. Under this proposed rule, covered financial institutions would no longer be required to collect and report the following data points: application method, application recipient, denial reasons, pricing information, number of workers, and LGBTQI+-owned business status. This proposed rule would make adjustments to some of the other data points (including minority-owned business status and ethnicity, race, and sex of principal owners) as well as the timing and methods to be used in the collection of data.
In addition, under this proposed rule, a financial institution would be required to report data if the financial institution originated at least 1,000 covered credit transactions in each of the two preceding calendar years, and one category of financial institutions (FCS lenders) would be excluded from coverage. The CFPB is also proposing to exclude merchant cash advances, credit transactions for agricultural purposes, and small dollar loans of $1,000 or less from the transactional scope of the rule. For the purposes of the proposed rule, a business would be a small business under this proposed rule if its gross annual revenue for its preceding fiscal year is $1 million or less. Finally, the proposed rule would change the compliance date provision to require a single compliance date for covered financial institutions.
A. Statement of Need
Congress directed the Bureau to adopt regulations governing the collection of small business lending data. Specifically, section 1071 of the Dodd-Frank Act amended ECOA to require financial institutions to compile, maintain, and submit to the Bureau certain data on applications for credit for small businesses, particularly
women-owned and minority-owned small businesses. Congress enacted section 1071 for the purpose of facilitating enforcement of fair lending laws and enabling communities, governmental entities, and creditors to identify business and community development needs and opportunities of women-owned, minority-owned, and small businesses. The Bureau is issuing this proposed rule to reconsider portions of the 2023 final rule in order to more effectively fulfill its statutory purposes.
As discussed in parts I and III, the Bureau believes, in retrospect, that its approach in the 2023 final rule was not conducive to fulfilling the long-term statutory purposes of section 1071 of the Dodd-Frank Act. The Bureau now believes that a more incremental approach would limit, as much as possible, any disturbance to the provision of credit to small entities. The Bureau expects that a more gradual approach to adding data points or expanding coverage, if needed, would more effectively serve both the fair lending and community development purposes of the rule in the long run.
In particular, the Bureau believes it should focus on core lending products, core lending providers, and core data points, rather than take the more expansive approach of its 2023 final rule. To accomplish this, the Bureau proposes multiple changes from the 2023 final rule. Among the most consequential changes, the Bureau proposes to exempt several categories of credit from the definition of covered transactions, including sales-based financing, loans for agricultural purposes, and small dollar loans. The Bureau now believes that application data collected on these types of transactions would be of lower quality while imposing collection requirements on institutions that issue them. The Bureau also proposes to raise the number of loans that trigger reporting requirement to 1,000 and exempt FCS lenders from coverage of the rule to focus on core providers in the small business lending space. The Bureau proposes to change the definition of “small business” in current § 1002.106(b) from $5 million or less to $1 million or less in annual gross revenue to ensure that data is collected on truly small businesses, rather than collect additional data on businesses that could be considered large in some contexts. Lastly the rule removes several data points from the collection, relative to the 2023 final rule, including pricing data, application method, application recipient, denial reasons, pricing and number of workers to limit the initial compliance costs for collecting and reporting data in compliance with section 1071.
The Bureau believes these changes help further the statutory purposes, for facilitating fair lending enforcement and community development, in several ways. By reducing the initial burden of the data collection on some institutions and removing the collection requirement from others, the Bureau believes that it will reduce disruption in the small business lending market compared to the more expansive 2023 final rule requirements. Disruption in the small business lending market could run counter to the community development purposes of the final rule. By focusing the data collection on core providers, transactions, and data points the Bureau expects the data collected under this proposed rule will be of higher quality and will be more useful for fair lending enforcement and community development.
B. Baseline for the Consideration of Costs and Benefits
In evaluating the potential benefits, costs, and impacts of this proposed rule, the Bureau takes as a baseline that all financial institutions covered under the 2023 final rule are in appropriate compliance with that rule, as codified in subpart B of Regulation B and amended by the 2024 interim final rule, the 2025 interim final rule, and the 2025 compliance date final rule.
62
Under this baseline, the Bureau also assumes that institutions are complying with other regulations that they are currently subject to, including reporting data under HMDA, CRA, and any State commercial financing disclosure laws.
63
The Bureau believes that this baseline provides the public with the most reasonable basis for analyzing the benefits and costs of this proposed rule. The Bureau seeks comment on the advantages and disadvantages of considering this baseline.
62
For example, many financial institutions would not be required to comply with the 2023 final rule as amended until 2027. The Bureau does not assume that such institutions would already be in compliance with the 2023 final rule. Instead, the Bureau assumes that some institutions have already spent some resources to implement the rule, as discussed more in part IV.E.1.
63
See, e.g.,
N.Y.S. 898 (signed Jan. 6, 2021) (amending S. 5470-B),
https://legislation.nysenate.gov/pdf/bills/2021/s898;
Cal. S.B. 1235 (approved Sept. 30, 2018),
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=201720180SB1235;
Va. H. 1027 (approved Apr. 11, 2022),
https://lis.virginia.gov/cgi-bin/legp604.exe?221+ful+CHAP0516;
Utah S.B. 183 (signed Mar. 24, 2022),
https://le.utah.gov/~2022/bills/static/SB0183.html.
C. Basic Approach of the Bureau's Consideration of Benefits and Costs and Data Limitations
Pursuant to section 1022(b)(2)(A) of the Dodd-Frank Act,
64
in prescribing a rule under the Federal consumer financial laws (which include ECOA and title X of the Dodd-Frank Act), the Bureau is required to consider the potential benefits and costs to “consumers” and “covered persons,” including the potential reduction of access by consumers to consumer financial products or services resulting from such rule, and the impact of final rules on covered persons as described under section 1026 of the Dodd-Frank Act
65
(
i.e.,
depository institutions and credit unions with $10 billion or less in total assets), and the impact on consumers in rural areas.
64
12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(2)(A).
65
12 U.S.C. 5516.
The Dodd-Frank Act defines the term “consumer” as an individual or someone acting on behalf of an individual. It defines a “covered person” as one who engages in offering or providing a “consumer financial product or service,” which means a financial product or service that is provided to consumers primarily for “personal, family, or household purposes.”
66
In rulemakings implementing section 1071, however, the only parties directly affected by the rule are small businesses (rather than individual consumers) and the financial institutions from which they seek credit (which may or may not be covered persons). Accordingly, a section 1022(b)(2)(A) analysis that considers only the costs and benefits to individual consumers and to covered persons would not meaningfully capture the costs and benefits of the rule.
66
12 U.S.C. 5481(4) through (6).
Below, the Bureau conducts the statutorily required analysis with respect to the proposed rule's effects on consumers and covered persons. Additionally, consistent with the approach in the 2023 final rule, the Bureau is electing to conduct this same analysis with respect to small businesses and the financial institutions that would be required to compile, maintain, and submit data under the proposed rule. This analysis relies on data that the Bureau has obtained from industry, other regulatory agencies, and publicly available sources. However, as discussed further below, the available data limit the Bureau's ability to quantify the potential costs, benefits, and impacts of the proposed rule.
The Bureau seeks comments on the basic approach discussed below and any
additional data sources that may be used to improve this approach.
1. Analysis With Respect to Consumers and Covered Persons
The 2023 final rule implemented a data collection regime in which certain covered financial institutions must compile, maintain, and submit data with respect to applications for credit for small businesses. This proposed rule amends that implementation. The proposed rule would not directly impact consumers, including consumers in rural areas, as those terms are defined by the Dodd-Frank Act. However, some consumers may be impacted in their separate capacity as sole owners of small businesses covered by the proposed rule. Some covered persons, including some depository institutions or credit unions with $10 billion or less in total assets, would be affected under the proposed rule not in their capacity as covered persons (
i.e.,
as offerors or providers of consumer financial products or services) but in their separate capacity as financial institutions that offer small business credit covered by the proposed rule. The costs, benefits, and impact of the proposed rule on those entities are discussed below.
2. Benefits to Impacted Financial Institutions
The proposed rule would modify the 2023 final rule with respect to which financial institutions and transactions are covered, and which data points are required to be collected and reported. Many financial institutions that would not be covered by the proposed rule will still be impacted by the proposed rule because they would have been covered under the 2023 final rule (as amended). The Bureau analyzes the impacts of the proposed rule relative to the baseline (1) on covered institutions and (2) on institutions that would no longer be covered and calls the combined group of institutions “impacted financial institutions.” The main expected benefit of the proposed rule to impacted financial institutions comes in the form of cost savings. The Bureau calculates these cost savings by estimating the change in compliance costs between the proposed rule and the baseline.
In order to precisely quantify the cost savings for impacted financial institutions, the Bureau would need representative data and information on the operational costs that financial institutions would incur to gather and report 1071 data, on one-time costs for financial institutions to update or create reporting infrastructure to implement requirements of the proposed rule, and on the level of complexity of financial institutions' business models and compliance systems. Furthermore, the Bureau would need this information under both the baseline and the proposed rule. Currently, the Bureau does not believe that data on section 1071 reporting costs with this level of granularity are systematically available from any source. The Bureau has made reasonable efforts to gather data on section 1071 reporting costs and primarily uses the same methodology that it used to analyze the 2023 final rule, unless otherwise noted. The Bureau continues to believe that its analysis here and in the 2023 final rule constitutes the most comprehensive assessment to date of the compliance costs associated with implementing section 1071 reporting by financial institutions and provides the most accurate estimates of costs given available information. However, the Bureau recognizes that these estimates may not fully quantify the costs to each covered financial institution, especially given the wide variation of section 1071 reporting costs among financial institutions.
The Bureau categorizes costs required to comply with the baseline and the proposed rule into “one-time” and “ongoing” costs. Similarly, the Bureau reports cost savings in these terms. “One-time” costs refer to expenses that the financial institution incur initially and only once to implement changes required in order to comply with the requirements of this rule. “Ongoing” costs are expenses incurred as a result of the ongoing reporting requirements of the rule, which the Bureau considers on an annualized basis. In considering the costs and impacts of the 2023 final rule, the Bureau has engaged in a series of efforts to estimate the cost of compliance by covered entities. The Bureau conducted a One-Time Cost Survey, discussed in more detail in part IX.E.1 of the 2023 final rule,
67
to learn about the one-time implementation costs associated with implementing section 1071 and adapted ongoing cost calculations from previous rulemaking efforts. The Bureau evaluated the one-time costs of implementing the procedures necessary and the ongoing costs of annually reporting under the proposed rule in part IV.F.1 below. The Bureau recognizes that costs vary by institution due to many factors, such as size, operational structure, and product complexity, and that this variance exists on a continuum that is impossible to fully represent. In order to conduct a consideration of impacts that is both practical and meaningful in light of these challenges, the Bureau has chosen an approach that focuses on three representative types of financial institutions. For each type, the Bureau has produced reasonable estimates of the costs of compliance given the limitations of the available data. Part IV.E.1 below provides additional details on this approach.
67
See
88 FR 35150, 35497 (May 31, 2023).
The Bureau understands that some financial institutions that are covered under the baseline have started implementing the 2023 final rule. Institutions that would be no longer covered as a result of the proposed rule may have already incurred some one-time costs to implement the baseline that would not have been necessary under this proposed rule. The Bureau does not count these expenditures as costs of the proposed rule because those costs have already been incurred and are discussed in more detail in part IV.E.1. Instead, the Bureau accounts for these expenditures through reductions in cost savings. If an institution becomes no longer covered as a result of the proposed rule, it will no longer be able to recoup all one-time implementation costs, as discussed in part IV.E.1.
3. Benefits to Small Businesses
Consistent with the 2023 final rule, the Bureau elects to estimate the benefits and cost savings to small businesses in addition to cost and benefit savings to impacted financial institutions. As with financial institutions, the Bureau expects that the main benefits of the proposed rule to small businesses would arise as a result of cost savings. The Bureau expects the direct cost savings of the proposed rule to small businesses would be negligible. However, the Bureau expects that there could be indirect cost savings of the proposed rule to small businesses if financial institutions pass on their cost savings. Therefore, the Bureau focuses its analysis on whether and how the Bureau expects impacted financial institutions to pass on the cost savings from the proposed rule to small businesses and any possible effects on the availability or terms of small business credit. The Bureau relies on economic theory to understand the potential for cost savings of financial institutions to be passed on to small businesses.
4. Costs to Small Businesses and Impacted Financial Institutions
The costs to small businesses and to impacted financial institutions associated with the proposed rule will primarily come from a decrease in the benefits associated with the 2023 final
rule. Quantifying benefits to small businesses presents substantial challenges. As discussed above, Congress enacted section 1071 for the purpose of facilitating enforcement of fair lending laws and enabling communities, governmental entities, and creditors to identify business and community development needs and opportunities of women-owned, minority-owned, and small businesses. The Bureau is unable to quantify any of these benefits, both because the Bureau does not have the data to do so and because the Bureau is not able to assess how effective the 2023 final rule would be in achieving those benefits. The same difficultly holds for the change in benefits associated with the proposed rule. As discussed further below, as a data reporting rule, most provisions of the baseline and the proposed rule will benefit small businesses in indirect ways, rather than directly.
Similar issues arise in attempting to quantify the decrease in benefits to impacted financial institutions. Certain benefits to impacted financial institutions are difficult to quantify. For example, the Bureau believes that the data collected under both the baseline and this proposed rule will reduce the compliance burden of fair lending reviews for lower risk financial institutions that are likely to be in compliance with ECOA by reducing the “false positive” rates during fair lending prioritization by regulators. However, the Bureau does not have the information to quantify such benefits.
In light of these data limitations, the discussion below generally provides a qualitative consideration of the reduction of benefits under the proposed rule relative to the baseline. General economic principles, together with the limited data available, provide insight into the loss of benefits. Where possible, the Bureau makes quantitative estimates based on these principles and the data that are available. Quantifying these benefits is difficult because the size of each effect cannot be known in advance. Given the number of small business credit transactions and the size of the small business credit market, however, small changes in behavior can have substantial aggregate effects.
In addition, financial institutions that remain covered under the proposed rule may incur adjustment costs. This would occur when institutions have already made efforts to implement the provisions of the 2023 final rule and would incur additional costs to modify their existing implementation to comply with this proposed rule. If a financial institution has not begun to implement the 2023 final rule, then it would not incur adjustment costs.
D. Coverage of the Proposed Rule
The proposed rule provides that financial institutions (both depository and nondepository) that meet all the other criteria for a “financial institution” in proposed § 1002.105(a) would only be required to collect and report section 1071 data if they originated at least 1,000 covered credit transactions in each of the two preceding calendar years. In addition, under the proposed rule, FCS lenders would not be required to collect and report section 1071 data, even if they meet this proposed new threshold.
As discussed above, market-wide data on small business lending are currently limited. The Bureau is unaware of any comprehensive data available on small business originations for all financial institutions, which are needed to precisely identify all institutions to be covered by the proposed rule or the 2023 final rule. To estimate the change in coverage as a result of the proposed rule, the Bureau uses publicly available data for financial institutions divided into two groups: depository (
i.e.,
banks, savings associations, and credit unions) and nondepository institutions. The Bureau employs the methodology used in the 2023 final rule to estimate the change in coverage as a result of the proposed rule and relies on updated data.
With respect to depository institutions, the Bureau relies on National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) Call Reports to estimate coverage for credit unions, including for those that are not federally insured, and Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council (FFIEC) Call Reports and the CRA data to estimate coverage for banks and savings associations. For the purposes of the analysis in this part IV.D, the Bureau estimates the number of depository institutions that would have been required to report small business lending data in 2023, based on the estimated number of originations of covered products for each institution in 2022 and 2023.
68
The Bureau accounts for mergers and acquisitions in 2022 and 2023 by assuming that any depository institutions that merged in those years report as one institution.
68
In the proposed rule, an institution would be required to report for a given year if it originated at least 1,000 covered originations in each of the preceding two years. For the purposes of estimating the impacts of the proposed rule, the Bureau assumes that a financial institution would be required to report information from the year 2023 if the institution made at least 1,000 loans in 2022 and 2023. The Bureau makes this simplifying assumption for two reasons. First, the Bureau does not rely on data from 2020 or 2021 to avoid the years where small business lending would have been most affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. Second, the Bureau requires CRA data to estimate coverage and those data are only available through 2023.
The NCUA Call Report captures the number and dollar value of originations on all loans over $50,000 to members for commercial purposes, regardless of any indicator about the borrowing business's size. For the purposes of estimating the impacts of the proposed rule, the Bureau uses the annual number of originated commercial loans to members reported by credit unions as a proxy for the annual number of originated covered credit transactions under the rule.
69
These are the best data available to the Bureau for estimating the number of credit unions that may be covered by the proposed rule. However, the Bureau acknowledges that the true number of covered credit unions may be different than what is presented here. For example, this proxy would overestimate the number of credit unions that will be covered if some commercial loans to members are not covered because the member is taking out a loan for a business that is not small under the definition of a small business in the proposed rule. Alternatively, this proxy would underestimate the number of credit unions covered by the proposed rule if credit unions originate a substantial number of covered credit transactions with origination values under $50,000 that are not counted in the data.
69
For this analysis, the Bureau includes all types of commercial loans to members except construction and development loans, loans secured by multifamily residential property, loans secured by farmland, and loans to finance agricultural production and other loans to farmers. This includes loans secured by owner-occupied, non-farm, non-residential property; loans secured by non-owner occupied, non-farm, non-residential property; commercial and industrial loans; unsecured commercial loans; and unsecured revolving lines of credit for commercial purposes.
The FFIEC Call Report captures banks' and savings associations' outstanding number and dollar amount of small loans to businesses (
i.e.,
loans originated under $1 million to businesses of any size; small loans to farms are those originated under $500,000). The CRA requires banks and savings associations with assets over a specified threshold ($1.609 billion as of 2025)
70
to report loans to businesses in original amounts of $1 million or less. For the purposes of estimating the impacts of the proposed rule, the Bureau follows the convention of using small loans to businesses as a proxy for loans to small businesses and small loans to farms as a proxy for loans to small farms.
71
These are the best data available for estimating the number of banks and savings associations that may be covered by the proposed rule. However, the Bureau acknowledges that the true number of covered banks and savings associations may be different than what is presented here. The Bureau acknowledges that it does not have sufficient information to meaningfully account for how the proposed change to the small business definition and the proposed minimum loan size threshold might affect the impacts of the rule.
70
See
Fed. Fin. Insts. Examination Council,
Community Reinvestment Act Reporting Criteria, https://www.ffiec.gov/data/cra/reporting-criteria
(last visited Oct. 4, 2025).
71
For a discussion of the small business lending proxy,
see
Jacob Goldston & Yan Y. Lee,
Measurement of Small Business Lending Using Call Reports: Further Insights From the Small Business Lending Survey
(Fed. Deposit Ins. Corp. Staff Rept. No. 2020-04, July 2020),
https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/cfr/staff-studies/2020-04.pdf.
Although banks and savings associations reporting under the CRA are required to report the number of originations of small loans to businesses and farms, the Bureau is not aware of any comprehensive dataset that contains originations made by banks and savings associations with assets below the CRA reporting threshold. To fill this gap, the Bureau simulated plausible values for the annual number and dollar value of originations for each bank and savings association that falls below the CRA reporting threshold for 2022 and 2023.
72
The Bureau generated simulated originations in order to account for the uncertainty around the exact number and value of originations for these banks and savings associations. To simulate these values, the Bureau assumes that these banks have the same relationship between outstanding and originated small loans to businesses and farms as banks and savings associations above the CRA reporting threshold. First, the Bureau estimated the relationship between originated number and balances and outstanding numbers and balances of small loans to businesses and farms for CRA reporters. Then the Bureau used this estimate, together with the outstanding numbers and balances of small loans to businesses and farms of non-CRA reporters, to simulate these plausible values of originations. The Bureau has documented this methodology in more detail in its
Supplemental estimation methodology for institutional coverage and market-level cost estimates in the small business lending rule
released with the 2023 final rule.
73
72
Based on FFIEC Call Report data as of December 2023, of the 4,587 banks and savings associations that existed in 2023, only about 14 percent were required to report under CRA. That is, only about 14 percent of banks and savings associations had assets below $1.503 billion, the CRA reporting threshold in 2023.
See
Fed. Fin. Insts. Examination Council,
CRA Reporting Criteria, https://www.ffiec.gov/data/cra/reporting-criteria
(last visited Sept. 23, 2025).
73
CFPB,
Supplemental estimation methodology for institutional coverage and market-level cost estimates in the small business lending rulemaking
(Mar. 30, 2023
), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/data-research/research-reports/supplemental-estimation-methodology-institutional-coverage-market-level-cost-estimates-small-business-lending-rulemaking/.
Based on 2023 data from FFIEC and NCUA Call Reports and the CRA data, using the methodology described above, the Bureau estimates that the number of depository institutions that would be required to report under the proposed rule is between approximately 172 to 181, as shown in Table 1 below. This comprises between 167 and 176 banks and savings associations and 5 credit unions that would be required to report under the proposed rule. These ranges represent 95 percent confidence intervals over the number of credit unions, banks and savings associations that would be covered under the proposed rule. The Bureau presents this range to reflect the uncertainty associated with the estimates and notes that the uncertainty is driven by the lack of data on originations by banks and savings associations below the CRA reporting threshold.
74
74
The Bureau acknowledges that these confidence intervals do not account for all uncertainty in the estimates. For example, the confidence interval does not account for how well number of small loans to businesses proxies for number of originations of covered products. The Bureau is unaware of information that could be used to quantify these additional sources of uncertainty.
Table 1—Estimated Depository Institution Coverage of the Proposed Rule
[In 2023, based on 2022-2023 data]
Coverage category
Estimated coverage
Institutions Subject to 1071 Reporting
172-181 depository institutions (1.85%-1.95% of all depository institutions).
Banks and Savings Associations (SAs) Subject to Reporting
167-176 banks and SAs (3.64%-3.84% of all banks and SAs).
Credit Unions Subject to Reporting
5 credit unions (0.11% of all credit unions).
Share of Total Small Business Credit by Depository Institutions (Number of Loans Originated) Captured
91.9%-92.8%.
Share of Total Small Business Credit by Depository Institutions (Dollar Value of Loans Originated) Captured
60.3%-62.0%.
The Bureau also estimates the number of institutions that would have been covered under the baseline but are no longer covered by the proposed rule, using the same methodology discussed above. A depository institution would have been covered at the end of 2023 by the 2023 final rule if that institution had over 100 small business and small farm loan originations in 2022 and 2023, accounting for mergers. The Bureau estimates that the number of depository institutions required to report under the 2023 final rule but that would not be required to report under the proposed rule is between approximately 1,421 to 1,570 institutions as shown in Table 2 below.
Table 2—Estimated Depository Institutions Covered Under Baseline but No Longer Covered by Proposed Rule
[In 2023, based on 2022-2023 data]
Coverage category
Estimated coverage
Institutions No Longer Covered
1,421-1,570 depository institutions (15.3%-16.9% of all depository institutions).
Banks and Savings Associations (SAs) No Longer Covered
1,301-1,450 banks and SAs (28.4%-31.6% of all banks and SAs).
Credit Unions No Longer Covered
120 credit unions (2.6% of all credit unions).
Share of Total Small Business Credit by Depository Institutions (Number of Loans Originated) by DIs No Longer Covered
5.0%-5.7%.
Share of Total Small Business Credit by Depository Institutions (Dollar Value of Loans Originated) by DIs No Longer Covered
24.1%-26.1%.
The Bureau does not have sufficient information to meaningfully estimate the change in the number of nondepositories relative to the analysis conducted for the 2023 final rule. For the purposes of the analysis of the impacts of this proposed rule, the Bureau assumes that the number of nondepository institutions that are active in the small business lending market has not changed since the 2023 final rule, except for Farm Credit System members, for which the Bureau relies on data from the Farm Credit Administration. See part II.D of the 2023 final rule for more detail on how the Bureau arrived at these estimates.
75
Consistent with the assumptions in the 2023 final rule, the Bureau also assumes that only online lenders and merchant cash advance providers originate more than 1,000 loans each year and the remaining nondepositories originate between 150 and 999 loans each year. Since merchant cash advances would not be covered credit transactions under the proposed rule, no merchant cash advance providers would be required to report. Based on these assumptions, the Bureau concludes that only online lenders would still be required to report under the proposed rule.
75
See
88 FR 35153.
The Bureau estimates that the 2023 final rule would have covered about 610 nondepository institution, consisting of: about 30 online lenders; about 140 nondepository Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs); about 70 merchant cash advance providers; about 240 commercial finance companies; about 70 governmental lending entities; and 60 Farm Credit System members.
76
The Bureau estimates that, of these nondepositories, only the 30 online lenders will continue to be covered under the proposed rule and the remaining will be impacted by the proposed rule because they are no longer covered.
76
Farm Credit Admin.,
Number of FCS banks and associations by type and district as of January 1, 2024, https://www.fca.gov/template-fca/bank/20240101NumberAssocs.pdf
(last visited Oct. 1, 2025).
The Bureau seeks comments on these estimates of coverage and changes in coverage. In particular, the Bureau seeks additional data and information that it could use to improve its estimates of nondepository institution coverage.
E. Methodology for Generating Costs and Benefits Estimates
In part IX.E of the 2023 final rule, the Bureau explained its methodology for generating estimates of one-time and ongoing costs associated with complying with the 2023 final rule. As discussed in the previous section, many financial institutions that were covered by the 2023 final rule would no longer be covered by this proposed rule. Thus, the proposed rule would confer a benefit in the form of cost savings for most impacted institutions. The Bureau also expects that institutions that continue to be covered will face a reduction in compliance costs from the proposed rule relative to the baseline. Generally, the Bureau estimates the benefits of the proposed rule by comparing the compliance costs under the baseline to those under the proposed rule. To generate cost estimates under the baseline and this proposed rule, the Bureau uses the same methodology as the 2023 final rule, unless otherwise noted. Throughout this section, the Bureau reproduces crucial parts of the methodology discussion where necessary but references the 2023 final rule for additional detail and background.
The Bureau expects that compliance costs vary with the complexity of a financial institution's compliance operations. Consistent with the 2023 final rule and for the purposes of this proposed rule, the Bureau categorizes impacted financial institutions (FIs) into Types A, B, and C in increasing order of compliance operations complexity. Based on its prior methodology, the Bureau assumes that this complexity is correlated with the number of small business loan applications received, and therefore categorizes institutions based on application volume. The Bureau assumes that Type A FIs receive fewer than 300 applications per year, Type B FIs receive between 300 and 2,000 applications per year, and Type C FIs receive more than 2,000 applications per year. The Bureau assumes that, for Type A and B FIs, one out of two small business applications will result in an origination. Thus, the Bureau assumes that Type A FIs originate fewer than 150 covered credit transactions per year and Type B FIs originate between 150 and 999 covered credit transactions per year. The Bureau assumes that Type C FIs originate one out of three small business applications and at least 1,000 covered credit transactions per year.
77
77
The Bureau chose the 1:2 and 1:3 application to origination ratios based on two sources of information. First see Biz2Credit,
Small Business Loan Approval Rates Rebounded in May 2020: Biz2Credit Small Business Lending Index
(May 2020),
https://cdn.biz2credit.com/appfiles/biz2credit/pdf/report-may-2020.pdf,
which shows that, in December of 2019, large banks approved small business loans at a rate of 27.5 percent, while small banks and credit unions had approval rates of 49.9 percent and 40.1 percent. Additionally, the Bureau's supervisory data supports a 33 percent approval rate as a conservative measure among these estimates for complex financial institutions (Type C FIs).
The Bureau recognizes that the proposed changes, as discussed in subsequent sections, will remove most Types A and B financial institutions from coverage. However, the Bureau maintains both these categorizations and assumptions in order to estimate compliance at baseline and compare it to coverage under the proposals.
The Bureau understands that compliance costs vary across financial institutions due to many factors, such as size, operational structure, and product complexity, and that this variance exists on a continuum that is very difficult or impossible to fully represent. Due to data limitations, the Bureau is unable to capture many of the ways in which compliance costs vary by institution,
and therefore uses these representative financial institution types with the above assumptions for its analysis. In order to aggregate costs to a market level, the Bureau must map financial institutions onto its types using discrete volume categories.
For the hiring costs discussion in part IV.F.1.i and ongoing costs discussion in part IV.F.1.ii below, the Bureau discusses costs in the context of
representative
institutions for ease of exposition. The Bureau assumes that a representative Type A FI receives 100 small business credit applications per year, a representative Type B FI receives 400 small business credit applications per year, and a representative Type C FI receives 6,000 small business credit applications per year. The Bureau further assumes that a representative Type A FI originates 50 covered credit transactions per year, a representative Type B FI originates 200 covered credit transactions per year, and a representative Type C FI originates 2,000 covered credit transactions per year.
1. Methodology for Estimating One-Time Compliance Costs
The one-time compliance cost estimation methodology for the proposed rule described in this section is the same methodology that the Bureau used in the 2023 final rule, unless otherwise noted.
The Bureau has identified the following nine categories of one-time costs that will likely be incurred by financial institutions to develop the infrastructure to collect and report data under the baseline and the proposed rule:
1. Preparation/planning.
2. Updating computer systems.
3. Testing/validating systems.
4. Developing forms/applications.
5. Training staff and third parties (such as brokers).
6. Developing policies/procedures.
7. Legal/compliance review.
8. Post-implementation review of compliance policies and procedures.
9. Hiring costs.
78
78
The Bureau added this category in response to comments on the 2021 proposed rule; it was not part of the 2020 survey discussed below.
The Bureau also conducted a survey in 2020 regarding one-time implementation costs for section 1071 compliance targeted at financial institutions who extend small business credit.
79
The survey collected information on the number of employee hours and non-salary expenses required to implement a section 1071 rule. The Bureau developed the survey instrument based on guidance from industry on the potential types of one-time costs institutions might incur if required to report under a rule implementing section 1071 and tested the survey instrument on a small set of financial institutions, incorporating their feedback prior to implementation. The Bureau worked with several major industry trade associations to recruit their members to respond to the survey. A total of 105 financial institutions responded to the survey.
79
The One-Time Cost Survey was released on July 22, 2020; the response period closed on October 16, 2020. The OMB control number for this collection is 3170-0032. CFPB,
Survey: Small Business Compliance Cost Survey
(July 22, 2020),
https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/cfpb_1071-survey_2020-10.pdf.
Estimates from the 2020 survey respondents continue to form the basis of the Bureau's estimates for one-time compliance costs in assessing the impact of this proposed rule. The survey was broadly designed to ask about the one-time costs of reporting data under a regime that only included mandatory data points, used a reporting structure similar to HMDA, used the Regulation B definition of an “application,” and used the respondent's own internal small business definition.
80
Therefore, the Bureau assumes that the tasks listed above are associated with implementing both the 2023 final rule and the proposed rule for institutions covered by each rule.
80
For more information about the 2020 survey and its respondents,
see
part IX.E.1 of the 2023 final rule.
The Bureau assumes that the number of employee hours required to implement each task has not changed but that the wages have changed to reflect labor market developments. The Bureau assumes that each task may require junior, mid-level, and senior staff hours to implement. For junior staff, the Bureau uses $18.51, the 10th percentile hourly wage estimate for “loan officers” according to the 2024 Occupational Employment Statistics compiled by the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
81
For mid-level staff, the Bureau uses $41.35, the estimated mean hourly wage estimate for “loan officers.” For senior staff, the Bureau uses $70.09, the 90th percentile hourly wage estimate for “loan officers.” To account for non-monetary compensation, the Bureau also scaled these hourly wages up by 43 percent.
82
81
See
U.S. Bureau of Labor Stat., U.S. Dep't of Labor,
Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics
(May 2024),
https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes132072.htm.
82
The June 2025 Employer Costs for Employee Compensation from the Bureau of Labor Statistics documents that wages and salaries are, on average, about 70 percent of employee compensation for private industry workers. The Bureau inflates the hourly wage to account for 100 percent of employee compensation ((100/70)−1) * 100 = 43 percent). Press Release, U.S. Bureau of Labor Stat., U.S. Dep't of Labor, USDL-25-1358,
Employer Costs for Employee Compensation—June 2025
(Sept. 12, 2025),
https://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/ecec.pdf.
Finally, the Bureau assumes that the non-salary expenses necessary to implement each one-time task have only changed according to inflation, as measure the by the Consumer Price Index.
83
83
The Bureau uses the CPI-U from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and adjusts non-salary expenses to account for inflation between December 2019 and June 2025. That is, the Bureau inflates non-salary expenses by 26 percent.
See
U.S. Bureau of Labor Stat., U.S. Dep't of Labor,
Databases, Tables & Calculators by Subject, Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPI-U)
(Oct. 4, 2025),
https://data.bls.gov/timeseries/CUUR0000SA0.
For hiring costs, the Bureau also assumes that a covered financial institution would need to hire enough full-time equivalent workers (FTEs) to cover the estimated number of staff hours necessary to comply with the either 2023 final rule or the proposed rule on an annual, ongoing basis. In part IV.E.2 below, the Bureau describes how it estimates the ongoing costs to comply with the 2023 final rule and the proposed rule, including the number of hours of staff time an institution needs per application. The Bureau assumes for the baseline and the proposed rule that an FTE will work about 2,080 hours each year (40 hours per week × 52 weeks = 2,080). The Bureau calculates that the total number of FTEs that a covered financial institution will need to hire as the number of hours per application multiplied by the estimated number of applications received per year divided by 2,080, rounded up to the next full FTE. For example, if an institution receives 500 applications per year and an employee spends one hour on each application, it will need to hire one FTE ((1 * 500)/2080 = 0.24, which is rounded up to the next full FTE,
i.e.,
1). In part IV.F.1.i, the Bureau also confirms that the estimated additional staff can cover the estimated staff hours required for implementing other one-time changes.
The Bureau calculates the hiring costs using the estimated cost-per-hire of $4,683, estimated by the Society for Human Resource Management.
84
This estimated cost includes advertising fees, recruiter pay and benefits, and employee referrals, among other categories. For each covered financial institution, the estimated hiring cost is
$4,683 multiplied by the estimated new FTEs required to comply with the requirements of the 2023 final rule or the proposed rule. The estimated total one-time costs are the sum of the estimated hiring costs and the other one-time costs for that institution discussed above.
84
See
Soc'y for Hum. Res. Mgmt.,
SHRM Benchmarking: Talent Access Report,
at 8 (2022),
https://www.shrm.org/content/dam/en/shrm/research/benchmarking/Talent%20Access%20Report-TOTAL.pdf.
The Bureau assumes that some financial institutions covered by the 2023 final rule have already incurred some one-time costs in order to comply with the rule. For institutions that would no longer be covered under the proposed rule, those costs are sunk and cannot be recouped. The Bureau believes that, while some one-time cost activities already underway could be used for complying with this proposed rule, some of those activities will need to be redone in order to comply. The Bureau makes this rough assumption to capture this possibility and potential sunk cost. As discussed above, the Bureau believes, to the extent this has occurred, this reduces the institution's potential benefits under this proposed rule. The Bureau does not have sufficient information upon which to base its estimate of how much the
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.