Unaccompanied Children Program Foundational Rule

Federal RegisterApr 30, 2024

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES

Administration for Children and Families

45 CFR Part 410

RIN 0970-AC93

Unaccompanied Children Program Foundational Rule

AGENCY:

Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), Administration for Children and Families (ACF), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS).

ACTION:

Final rule.

SUMMARY:

This final rule adopts and replaces regulations relating to key aspects of the placement, care, and services provided to unaccompanied children referred to the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), pursuant to ORR's responsibilities for coordinating and implementing the care and placement of unaccompanied children who are in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status under the Homeland Security Act of 2002 (HSA) and the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008 (TVPRA). This final rule establishes a foundation for the Unaccompanied Children Program (UC Program) that is consistent with ORR's statutory duties, for the benefit of unaccompanied children and to enhance public transparency as to the policies governing the operation of the UC Program. This final rule implements the 1997

Flores

Settlement Agreement (FSA). As modified in 2001, the FSA provides that it will terminate 45 days after publication of final regulations implementing the agreement. ORR anticipates that any termination of the settlement based on this final rule would only be effective for those provisions that affect ORR and would not terminate provisions of the FSA that apply to other Federal Government agencies.

DATES:

This final rule is effective:

July 1, 2024.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:

Toby Biswas, Director of Policy, Unaccompanied Children Program, Office of Refugee Resettlement, Administration for Children and Families, Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, DC, (202) 205-4440 or

UCPolicy-RegulatoryAffairs@acf.hhs.gov.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:

Table of Contents

I. Table of Abbreviations

II. Executive Summary

A. Purpose of the Regulatory Action

B. Summary of Select Provisions

C. Summary of Costs and Benefits

III. Background and Purpose

A. The UC Program

B. History and Statutory Structure

C. Statutory and Regulatory Authority

D. Basis and Purpose of Regulatory Action

E. Severability

IV. Discussion of Elements of the Proposed Rule, Public Comments, Responses, and Final Rule Actions

V. Collection of Information Requirements

VI. Regulatory Impact Analysis

A. Economic Analysis

B. Regulatory Flexibility Analysis

C. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act

D. Paperwork Reduction Act

E. Executive Order 13132: Federalism

F. Executive Order 12988: Civil Justice Reform

VII. Assessment of Federal Regulation and Policies on Families

VIII. Alternatives Considered

I. Table of Abbreviations

ACF—Administration for Children and Families

DHS—U.S. Department of Homeland Security

DOJ—U.S. Department of Justice

EOIR—Executive Office for Immigration Review

FSA—

Flores

Settlement Agreement

HHS—U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

HSA—Homeland Security Act of 2002

INS—Immigration and Naturalization Service

OMB—Office of Management and Budget

ORR—Office of Refugee Resettlement, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

TVPRA—William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008

UC Program—Unaccompanied Children Program

II. Executive Summary

A. Purpose of the Regulatory Action

On October 4, 2023, the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) published a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM or proposed rule), to replace and supersede regulations at 45 CFR part 410, and to codify policies and requirements concerning the placement, care, and services provided to unaccompanied children in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status and referred to ORR.

1

The NPRM was based on statutory authorities and requirements provided under the Homeland Security Act of 2002 (HSA)

2

and the William Wilberforce Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act of 2008 (TVPRA),

3

and proposed to implement the terms of the 1997

Flores

Settlement Agreement (FSA) that create responsibilities for HHS and ORR. ORR proposed in the NPRM that the requirements apply to all care provider facilities, including both standard programs and non-standard programs, as defined below, unless otherwise specified (88 FR 68909). ORR noted that the proposed rule was necessary to codify a uniform set of standards and procedures that will help to ensure the safety and well-being of unaccompanied children in ORR care, implement the substantive terms of the FSA, and enhance public transparency as to the policies governing the operation of the Unaccompanied Children Program (UC Program).

The proposed rule provided a 60-day public comment period, which ended on December 4, 2023. This final rule responds to comments received and adopts the proposed rule, with some changes as discussed herein. ORR thanks the public for commenting on the NPRM.

B. Summary of Select Provisions

This final rule codifies ORR policies and requirements for the placement, care, and services provided to unaccompanied children in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status and referred to ORR, as discussed in section IV of this final rule. In subpart A, ORR is finalizing its proposal to define terms that are relevant to the criteria and requirements in the NPRM and to codify the general principles that apply to the care and placement of unaccompanied children in ORR care. In subpart B, ORR is finalizing its proposals regarding the criteria and requirements that apply with respect to placement of unaccompanied children at ORR care provider facilities, including specific criteria for placement at particular types of ORR care provider facilities. In subpart C, ORR is finalizing policies and procedures regarding the release of unaccompanied children from ORR care to vetted and approved sponsors. In subpart D, ORR is finalizing the standards and services that it must meet and provide to unaccompanied children in ORR care provider facilities. In subpart E, ORR is finalizing requirements for the safe transportation of unaccompanied children while in ORR's care. In subpart F, ORR is finalizing reporting requirements for care provider facilities such that ORR may compile and maintain statistical information and other data on unaccompanied children. In subpart G, ORR is finalizing requirements and policies regarding the transfer of unaccompanied children in ORR care. In subpart H, ORR is finalizing requirements for determining the age of an individual in ORR care. In subpart I, ORR is finalizing its proposal to codify requirements for emergency or influx facilities (EIFs), which are ORR facilities

that are opened during a time of emergency or influx. In subpart J, ORR is finalizing requirements regarding the availability of administrative review of ORR decisions. Finally, in subpart K, ORR is finalizing its proposal to establish an independent ombud's office that would promote important protections for all children in ORR care.

C. Summary of Costs and Benefits

This final rule codifies current ORR requirements for compliance with the FSA, court orders, and statutes, as well as certain requirements under existing ORR policy and cooperative agreements. As discussed in section VII.A of this final rule, HHS and ORR expect these requirements to impose limited additional costs, including those costs incurred by the Federal Government to increase the provision of legal services to unaccompanied children in limited circumstances, to supplement costs incurred by grant recipients in order to comply with the finalized requirements (see below), to establish a risk determination hearing process, and to establish the Unaccompanied Children Office of the Ombuds (UC Office of the Ombuds) and other administrative staffing needs. In subpart D at § 410.1309, ORR is finalizing its proposal, to the greatest extent practicable, subject to available resources as determined by ORR, and consistent with section 292 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) (8 U.S.C. 1362), that all unaccompanied children who are or have been in ORR care would have access to legal advice and representation in immigration legal proceedings or matters funded by ORR. In subpart J, ORR is finalizing the establishment of a risk determination hearing process. To facilitate this process, ORR has developed forms for use by unaccompanied children, their parents/legal guardians, or their legal representatives for which we estimate the costs of completion to range from $10,187 to $56,589 per year. In subpart K, ORR discusses the establishment of an Office of the Ombuds for the UC Program. In addition to the Ombuds position itself, ORR anticipates the need for support staff in the office. ORR estimates the annual cost of establishing and maintaining this office would be $1,718,529, which includes the cost of 10 full-time personnel, as discussed in further detail in VII.A.2 of this final rule.

ORR also notes that all care provider facilities and service providers discussed in this final rule are recipients of Federal awards (

e.g.,

cooperative agreements or contracts), and the costs of maintaining compliance with these proposed requirements are allowable costs under the Basic Considerations for cost provisions at 45 CFR 75.403 through 75.405,

4

in that the costs are reasonable, necessary, ordinary, treated consistently, and are allocable to the award. If there are additional costs associated with the policies discussed in this final rule that were not budgeted, and cannot be absorbed within existing budgets, the recipient would be able to submit a request for supplemental funds to cover the costs.

III. Background and Purpose

A. The UC Program

The purpose of this rule is to codify policies, standards, and protections for the UC Program, consistent with the HSA and TVPRA, and to implement the substantive requirements of the FSA as they pertain to ORR. On March 1, 2003, section 462 of the HSA transferred responsibilities for the care and placement of unaccompanied children from the Commissioner of the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) to the Director of ORR. The HSA defines certain relevant terms and establishes ORR responsibilities with respect to unaccompanied children. The HSA defines “unaccompanied alien child,” a term ORR uses synonymously with “unaccompanied child,” as “a child who—(A) has no lawful immigration status in the United States; (B) has not attained 18 years of age; and (C) with respect to whom—(i) there is no parent or legal guardian in the United States; or (ii) no parent or legal guardian in the United States is available to provide care and physical custody.”

5

The TVPRA, meanwhile, added requirements for other executive branch departments and agencies to expeditiously transfer unaccompanied children in their custody to ORR's care and custody once identified, and together with HHS and other specified federal agencies to establish policies and programs to ensure unaccompanied children are protected from human trafficking and other criminal activities.

6

Both statutes are described in further detail in the paragraphs below. Pursuant to these statutory requirements, the UC Program provides a safe and appropriate environment for unaccompanied children in ORR custody. In most cases, unaccompanied children enter ORR custody via transfer from DHS. When DHS immigration officials, or officials from other Federal agencies or departments, transfer an unaccompanied child in their custody to ORR, ORR promptly places the unaccompanied child in the least restrictive setting that is in the best interests of the child, taking into consideration danger to self, danger to the community, and risk of flight. ORR considers the unique nature of each child's situation, the best interest of the child, and child welfare principles when making placement, clinical, case management, and release decisions. To carry out its statutory responsibilities, and consistent with its responsibilities under the FSA, ORR currently funds residential care providers that provide temporary housing and other services to unaccompanied children in ORR custody. These care providers have been primarily State-licensed and must also meet ORR requirements to ensure a high-quality level of care. These multiple providers comprise a continuum of care for children, including placements in individual and group homes, shelter, heightened supervision, secure facilities, and residential treatment centers. While in ORR custody, unaccompanied children are provided with classroom education, healthcare, socialization/recreation, mental health services, access to religious and legal services, and case management. Unaccompanied children generally remain in ORR custody until they are released to a vetted and approved parent or other sponsor in the United States, are repatriated to their home country, obtain legal status, or otherwise no longer meet the statutory definition of an unaccompanied child (

e.g.,

turn 18). Consistent with the limits of its statutory authority, and in accordance with current ORR policy, all children who turn 18 years old while in ORR's care and custody are transferred to DHS for a custody determination. Once transferred to DHS, that agency considers placement in the least restrictive setting available after taking into account the individual's danger to self, danger to the community, and risk of flight, in accordance with applicable legal authority.

B. History and Statutory Structure

1. HSA and TVPRA

The HSA abolished the former INS and created DHS. The HSA transferred many of the immigration functions from the INS to DHS, but it transferred functions under the immigration laws of the United States with respect to the care of unaccompanied children to ORR.

7

The HSA makes the ORR Director responsible for a number of functions with respect to unaccompanied children, including coordinating and implementing their care and placement, ensuring that unaccompanied children's interests are considered in actions and

decisions relating to their care, making and implementing placement determinations, implementing policies with respect to the care and placement of children, and overseeing the infrastructure and personnel of facilities in which unaccompanied children reside.

8

The HSA also states that ORR shall not release unaccompanied children from custody upon their own recognizance, and requires ORR to consult with appropriate juvenile justice professionals and certain Federal agencies in relation to placement determinations to ensure that unaccompanied children are likely to appear at all hearings and proceedings in which they are involved; are protected from smugglers, traffickers, and others who might seek to victimize or otherwise engage them in criminal, harmful, or exploitative activity; and are placed in a setting in which they are not likely to pose a danger to themselves or others.

9

ORR notes that under its current policies, such consultation is subject to privacy protections for unaccompanied children. For example, ORR restricts sharing certain case-specific information with the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) and DHS that may deter a child from seeking legal relief. Subject to such protections, ORR provides notification of the placement decisions to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and, if referred by U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), to CBP. ORR provides the following notification information: identifying information of the unaccompanied child, ORR care provider name and address, and ORR care provider point of contact (name and telephone number).

10

In 2008, Congress passed the TVPRA, which further elaborated duties with respect to the care and custody of unaccompanied children. The TVPRA provides that, except as otherwise provided with respect to certain unaccompanied children from contiguous countries,

11

and consistent with the HSA, the care and custody of all unaccompanied children, including responsibility for their detention, where appropriate, is the responsibility of the Secretary of HHS. The TVPRA states that each department or agency of the Federal Government must notify HHS within 48 hours upon the apprehension or discovery of an unaccompanied child or any claim or suspicion that a noncitizen individual in the custody of such department or agency is under the age of 18.

12

The TVPRA states further that, except in exceptional circumstances, any department or agency of the Federal Government that has an unaccompanied child in its custody shall transfer the custody of such child to HHS not later than 72 hours after determining such child is an unaccompanied child. Furthermore, the TVPRA requires the Secretary of HHS and other specified Federal agencies to establish policies and programs to ensure that unaccompanied children in the United States are protected from traffickers and other persons seeking to victimize or otherwise engage such children in criminal, harmful, or exploitative activity.

13

The TVPRA describes requirements with respect to safe and secure placements for unaccompanied children, safety and suitability assessments of potential sponsors for unaccompanied children, legal orientation presentations, access to counsel, and child advocates, among other requirements. HHS delegated its authority under the TVPRA to the Assistant Secretary for Children and Families, which then re-delegated the authority to the Director of ORR.

14

2. The Flores Settlement Agreement Terms and Implementation

On July 11, 1985, four noncitizen children in INS

15

custody filed a class action lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California on behalf of a class of minors detained in the custody of the INS (

Flores

litigation).

16

At that time, the INS was responsible for the custody of minors entering the United States unaccompanied by a parent or legal guardian. The

Flores

litigation challenged “(a) the [INS] policy to condition juveniles' release on bail on their parents' or legal guardians' surrendering to INS agents for interrogation and deportation; (b) the procedures employed by the INS in imposing a condition on juveniles' bail that their parents' or legal guardians' [sic] surrender to INS agents for interrogation and deportation; and (c) the conditions maintained by the INS in facilities where juveniles are incarcerated.”

17

The plaintiffs claimed that the INS's release and bond practices and policies violated, among other things, the INA, the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), and the Due Process Clause and Equal Protection Guarantee under the Fifth Amendment.

18

After over 10 years of litigation, the U.S. Government and

Flores

plaintiffs entered into the “

Flores

Settlement Agreement,” which was approved by the district court as a consent decree on January 28, 1997.

19

The FSA applies to both unaccompanied children, as defined in the HSA, and to children accompanied by their parents or legal guardians,

20

but ORR notes that this final rule is intended specifically to codify requirements regarding the care of unaccompanied children who have been transferred to the care and custody of ORR. As relevant to ORR, the FSA imposes several substantive requirements for Government custody of unaccompanied children, including requiring that they be placed in the “least restrictive setting appropriate to the minor's age and special needs,”

21

and establishing a general policy favoring release of unaccompanied children where it is determined that detention of the unaccompanied child is not required either to secure the child's timely appearance for immigration proceedings or to ensure the unaccompanied child's safety or that of others.

22

When release is appropriate, the FSA establishes an order of priority with respect to potential sponsors. If no sponsor is available, an unaccompanied child will be placed at a care provider facility licensed by an appropriate State agency, or, in the discretion of the Government, with another adult individual or entity seeking custody. Under the original terms of the FSA, unaccompanied children whom the former INS was unable to release upon apprehension and detention remained in INS custody, typically in a licensed program, until they could be appropriately released; currently, under the FSA, unaccompanied children who are not released remain in ORR legal custody and may be transferred or released only under the authority of ORR. The FSA also mandates that any noncitizen child who remains in Government custody for removal proceedings is entitled to a bond hearing before an immigration judge, “unless the [child] indicates on the Notice of Custody Determination form that he or she refuses such a hearing.”

23

The FSA contains many other provisions relating to the care of unaccompanied children, including the minimum standards required at licensed care provider facilities described in Exhibit 1.

The FSA states that within 120 days of the final district court approval of the agreement, the Government shall initiate action to publish the relevant and substantive terms of the Agreement in regulation.

24

In 1998, the INS published a proposed rule based on the substantive terms of the FSA, entitled “Processing, Detention, and Release of Juveniles.”

25

Over the subsequent years, that proposed rule was not finalized. The FSA originally included a termination date, but in 2001, the parties agreed to extend the agreement

and added a stipulation that terminates the FSA “45 days following defendants' publication of final regulations implementing t[he] Agreement.”

26

In January 2002, the INS reopened the comment period on the 1998 proposed rule,

27

but the rulemaking was ultimately terminated. Thus, as a result of the 2001 Stipulation, the FSA remains in effect. The U.S. District Court for the Central District of California has continued to rule on various motions filed in the case and oversee enforcement of the FSA.

3. The 2019 Final Rule

On September 7, 2018, DHS and HHS issued a joint proposed rule, entitled “Apprehension, Processing, Care, and Custody of Alien Minors and Unaccompanied Alien Children” (2018 Proposed Rule).

28

The purpose of the proposed rule was to implement the substantive terms of the FSA, and thus enable the district court to terminate the agreement. The rule proposed to adopt provisions that were intended to parallel the relevant substantive terms of the FSA, with some modifications to reflect statutory and operational changes put in place since the FSA was entered into in 1997, along with certain other changes.

29

A final rule was promulgated on August 23, 2019 (2019 Final Rule), which comprised two sets of regulations: one issued by DHS and the other by HHS. The HHS regulations addressed only the care and custody of unaccompanied children.

30

The DHS regulations addressed other provisions of the FSA that pertained to DHS, including the requirement that after DHS apprehends unaccompanied children it should transfer them to the custody of HHS.

31

After DHS and HHS issued the 2018 Proposed Rule and before the 2019 Final Rule was published, plaintiffs in the

Flores

litigation filed a Motion to Enforce the FSA. The court deferred ruling on the Motion, ordering DHS and HHS to file a notice upon issuance of final regulations, which DHS and HHS did in August 2019. Later that month, DHS and HHS also filed a Notice of Termination and Motion in the Alternative to Terminate the FSA, while Plaintiffs filed a supplemental brief addressing their Motion to Enforce. Plaintiffs' Motion to Enforce presented the following two separate but related issues: (1) whether the 2019 Final Rule would effectively terminate the FSA, and (2) if not, to what extent the Court should enjoin the Government from implementing the 2019 Final Rule. On September 27, 2019, approximately one month after the 2019 Final Rule was published, the District Court for the Central District of California entered an Order granting Plaintiffs' Motion to Enforce insofar as it sought an order declaring that the Government failed to terminate the FSA, denied the Government's Motion to Terminate the FSA, and issued a permanent injunction consistent with its order.

32

On December 29, 2020, in

Flores

v.

Rosen,

the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed in part and reversed in part the District Court Order.

33

Regarding the HHS regulations applicable to the care and custody of unaccompanied children in the 2019 Final Rule, the Court of Appeals held that the regulations were “largely consistent” with the FSA, with two exceptions.

34

First, it held that the HHS regulation allowing placement of a minor in a secure facility upon an agency determination that the minor is otherwise a danger to self or others broadened the circumstances in which a minor may be placed in a secure facility, and therefore was inconsistent with the FSA. Second, it held that provisions providing a hearing to unaccompanied children held in secure or staff-secure placement only if requested was inconsistent with the FSA's opt-out process for obtaining a bond hearing. Although the Ninth Circuit held that the majority of the HHS regulations could take effect, it also held that the District Court did not abuse its discretion in declining to terminate the portions of the FSA covered by those regulations, noting that the Government moved to “terminate the Agreement in full, not to modify or terminate it in part.”

35

Consistent with its findings, the Ninth Circuit held that the FSA “therefore remains in effect, notwithstanding the overlapping HHS regulations” and that the Government, if it wished, could move to terminate those portions of the FSA covered by the valid portions of the HHS regulations.

36

Separately, a group of states brought litigation in the District Court for the Central District of California seeking to enjoin the Government from implementing the 2019 Final Rule (

California

v.

Mayorkas

), based on other grounds including the APA.

37

The court stayed the case, given the related litigation brought by

Flores

plaintiffs, which culminated in the Ninth Circuit decision in

Flores

v.

Rosen.

After that decision, the plaintiffs in

California

v.

Mayorkas

filed a supplemental briefing requesting a narrowed preliminary injunction, alleging that several portions of the HHS provisions of the 2019 Final Rule violated the APA. Subsequently, the parties entered into settlement discussions. On December 10, 2021, the parties informed the court that HHS did not plan to seek termination of the FSA under the terms of the stipulation or to ask the court to lift its injunction of the HHS regulations. Instead, HHS would consider a future rulemaking that would more broadly address issues related to the custody of unaccompanied children by HHS and that would replace the rule being challenged in

California

v.

Mayorkas.

Based on this agreement, the court ordered that the

California

v.

Mayorkas

litigation should be placed into abeyance with regard to the Plaintiffs' claims against HHS while HHS engaged in new rulemaking to replace and supersede the HHS regulations in the 2019 Final Rule.

38

Further, among other things, HHS agreed that while it engaged in new rulemaking, it would not seek to lift the injunction of the 2019 Final Rule or seek to terminate the FSA as to HHS under the 2019 Final Rule, and that it would make best efforts to submit an NPRM to OMB by April 15, 2023, providing quarterly updates to the Court should it not meet that deadline.

39

In accord with the relevant order, ORR made best efforts to submit the NPRM to OMB, and ultimately sent the document to OMB on April 28, 2023.

40

The NPRM initiated that broader rulemaking effort, and reflected the stipulated agreement in

California

v.

Mayorkas.

The NPRM applied, as relevant, the findings of the Ninth Circuit regarding the 2019 Final Rule in

Flores

v.

Rosen.

Because the permanent injunction of the 2019 Final Rule was never lifted, and the FSA continued to remain in effect, ORR does not anticipate that any third parties would have developed reliance interests on the HHS regulations in the 2019 Final Rule. Differences between the 2019 Final Rule and this final rule are discussed in relevant portions of the preamble below.

4. Lucas R. Litigation

Another ongoing lawsuit involving ORR, filed in 2018, also has ramifications for this rule.

Lucas R.

v.

Becerra,

41

a class action lawsuit, was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, alleging ORR had violated the FSA, the TVPRA, the U.S. Constitution, and section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (section 504). Based on the plaintiffs' allegations, the court certified five plaintiff classes comprising all children in ORR custody:

(1) who are or will be placed in a secure facility, medium-secure facility, or residential treatment center (RTC), or whom ORR has continued to detain in any such facility for more than 30 days, without being afforded notice and an opportunity to be heard before a neutral and detached

decisionmaker regarding the grounds for such placement (

i.e.,

the “step-up class”);

(2) whom ORR is refusing or will refuse to release to parents or other available custodians within 30 days of the proposed custodian's submission of a complete family reunification packet on the ground that the proposed custodian is or may be unfit (

i.e.,

“the unfit custodian class”);

(3) who are or will be prescribed or administered one or more psychotropic medications without procedural safeguards (

i.e.,

the “drug administration class”);

(4) who are natives of non-contiguous countries and to whom ORR is impeding or will impede legal assistance in legal matters or proceedings involving their custody, placement, release, and/or administration of psychotropic drugs (

i.e.,

the “legal representation class”); and

(5) who have or will have a behavioral, mental health, intellectual, and/or developmental disability as defined in 29 U.S.C. [section] 705, and who are or will be placed in a secure facility, medium-secure facility, or [RTC] because of such disabilities (

i.e.,

the “disability class”).

42

On August 30, 2022, the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California granted preliminary injunctive relief concerning the allegations of the unfit custodian, step-up, and legal representation classes. As of October 31, 2022, ORR implemented new policies and procedures on issues identified in the Court's preliminary injunction order, which ORR is codifying in this final rule. As stated in the NPRM, as of September 2023, ORR remained in active litigation in the

Lucas R.

class action. The proposed rule stated that depending on developments in the case, ORR may incorporate additional provisions in the final rule (88 FR 68913).

On January 5, 2024, the Court issued an order preliminarily approving settlement agreements that the parties negotiated regarding the legal representation, drug administration, and disability classes.

43

A final approval hearing is scheduled for May 2024. As discussed in this final rule, ORR is finalizing some proposals from the NPRM as modified to account for developments in the

Lucas R.

litigation. As described herein, in this final rule, ORR intends to codify the requirements of the

Lucas R.

preliminary injunction. In addition, in this final rule, ORR is incorporating the terms of the anticipated legal representation settlement, among other enhancements to legal services for unaccompanied children. However, ORR is not incorporating in the final rule all of the various detailed provisions in the settlements concerning the drug administration and disability classes, although ORR is incorporating many commenters' recommendations in these areas. The drug administration and disability settlements themselves contemplate implementation over time, thereby affording ORR an opportunity to see how the terms of those settlements work in practice as they are implemented, and to assess whether changes may be needed over time due to evolving circumstances. The disability settlement in particular requires that ORR work with experts to undertake a year-long comprehensive needs assessment to evaluate the adequacy of services, supports, and resources currently in place for children with disabilities in ORR's custody across its network, and to identify gaps in the current system, which will inform the development of a disability plan and future policymaking that best address how to effectively meet the needs of children with disabilities in ORR's care and custody. Therefore, while ORR is not codifying all the terms of the anticipated disability and drug administration settlement agreements in this final rule, ORR is implementing terms in this rule that broadly reflect its commitment to ensuring that unaccompanied children are protected from discrimination and have equal access to the UC Program, as is consistent with section 504, and that psychotropic medications are administered appropriately in the best interest of the child and with meaningful oversight.

C. Statutory and Regulatory Authority

As discussed above, under the HSA and TVPRA, the ORR Director

44

is responsible for the care and placement of unaccompanied children. Under the HSA, ORR is responsible for “coordinating and implementing the care and placement of [unaccompanied children] who are in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status,” “identifying a sufficient number of qualified individuals, entities, and facilities to house [unaccompanied children],” “overseeing the infrastructure and personnel of facilities in which [unaccompanied children reside],” and “conducting investigations and inspections of facilities and other entities in which [unaccompanied children] reside, including regular follow-up visits to such facilities, placements, and other entities, to assess the continued suitability of such placements.”

45

Under the TVPRA, Federal agencies are required to notify HHS within 48 hours of apprehending or discovering an unaccompanied child or receiving a claim or having suspicion that a noncitizen in their custody is under 18 years of age.

46

The TVPRA further requires that, absent exceptional circumstances, any Federal department or agency must transfer an unaccompanied child to the care and custody of HHS within 72 hours of determining that a noncitizen child in its custody is an unaccompanied child. The TVPRA requires that HHS and other specified Federal agencies establish policies and programs to ensure that unaccompanied children are protected from traffickers and other persons seeking to victimize or exploit children.

47

Among other things, it also requires HHS to place unaccompanied children in the least restrictive setting that is in the best interest of the child, and states that in making such placements it may consider danger to self, danger to the community, and risk of flight. As previously discussed, the Secretary of HHS delegated the authority under the TVPRA to the Assistant Secretary for Children and Families,

48

who in turn delegated the authority to the Director of ORR.

49

It is under this delegation of authority that ORR now issues regulations describing how ORR meets its statutory responsibilities under the HSA and TVPRA and implements the relevant and substantive terms of the FSA for the care and custody of unaccompanied children.

In addition to requirements and standards related to the direct care of unaccompanied children, HHS is establishing a new UC Office of the Ombuds to create a mechanism that allows unaccompanied children and stakeholders to raise concerns with ORR policies and practices to an independent body. The Ombuds will be tasked with fielding concerns from any party relating to the implementation of ORR regulations, policies, and procedures; reviewing individual cases, conducting site visits and publishing reports, including reports on systemic issues in ORR custody, particularly where there are concerns about access to services or release from ORR care; and following up on grievances made by children, sponsors, or other stakeholders. As stated in the NPRM, at 88 FR 68913, HHS has authority to establish this office under its authority to “establish policies and programs to ensure that unaccompanied alien children in the United States are protected from traffickers and other persons seeking to victimize or otherwise engage such children in criminal, harmful, or exploitative activity.”

50

D. Basis and Purpose of Regulatory Action

The purpose of this rule is to finalize a regulatory framework that (1) codifies policies and practices related to the care

and custody of unaccompanied children, consistent with ORR's statutory authorities; and (2) implements relevant provisions of the FSA. The FSA describes “minimum” standards for care of unaccompanied children at licensed care provider facilities, but Congress subsequently enacted legislation establishing requirements for the UC Program. This final rule implements the protections set forth in the FSA and broadens them consistent with the current legal and operational environment, which has significantly changed since the FSA was signed over 25 years ago.

E. Severability

This is a comprehensive rule containing many subparts that address many distinct aspects of the UC Program. To the extent any subpart or portion of a subpart is declared invalid by a court, ORR intends for all other subparts to remain in effect. For example, ORR expects that if a court were to invalidate Subpart B (or any of Subpart B's discrete provisions) relating to the placement of a child, all other subparts—such as Subpart C (release of the child), Subpart D (minimum standards and services), Subpart E (transportation), etc.—may continue to operate and should remain operative independently of the invalidated subpart.

Additionally, each Subpart also contains many distinct provisions, many of which may also operate independently of one another; thus, the invalidation of one particular provision within a particular subpart would not necessarily have implications for other aspects of that subpart. For example, within Subpart D, the provision of access to routine medical and dental care, and other forms of healthcare at § 410.1307 would not be impacted by the invalidation of the provision of structured leisure time activities at § 410.1302(c)(4) or provision of legal services under § 410.1309. ORR intends that if one or more provisions within a subpart are invalidated, that all other provisions of that subpart (and all other subparts of the rule) remain in effect.

IV. Discussion of Elements of the Proposed Rule, Public Comments, Responses, and Final Rule Actions

Subpart A—Care and Placement of Unaccompanied Children

ORR proposed in the notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) to codify requirements and policies regarding the placement, care, and services provided to unaccompanied children in ORR custody (88 FR 68914). The following provisions identify the scope of this part, the definitions used throughout this part, and principles that apply to ORR placement, care, and services decisions.

ORR received many comments on the proposed rule that were not directed at any specific proposal and will address those here.

Comment:

Many commenters supported the proposed rule, stating that it improved public transparency as to the policies governing the program and provided rights and protections for unaccompanied children. Many commenters supported codifying practices based on the HSA and TVPRA and implementing and enhancing the terms of the FSA and stated that a uniform set of standards and procedures would create conformity and clarity to provide for the well-being of unaccompanied children in ORR care. Several commenters cited ORR's efforts to clarify, strengthen, and codify these requirements and ensure the consistent implementation of child welfare principles and protections for children in ORR's custody. Another commenter commended ORR on its efforts to incorporate child-centered, trauma-informed principles into the regulatory standards for the UC Program and adopting more inclusive language. Other commenters appreciated that the provisions are tailored to the individualized needs of unaccompanied children and ensure protection from individuals who seek to exploit or victimize unaccompanied children.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their support.

Comment:

One commenter encouraged ORR to provide clarity and more specifics in areas where appropriations would impact the ability to carry out the proposed rule.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter. As discussed in Section VI, funding for UC Program services is dependent on annual appropriations from Congress. The regulations specifically mention that post-release services (PRS) and funding for legal service providers are limited to the extent appropriations are available. The availability of child advocates and the enhancement of certain services, such as the transition to a community-based care model, are also impacted by appropriations. ACF's Justification of Estimates for Appropriation Committees provides additional information regarding the impact of its requested budget.

51

Comment:

One commenter indicated that sections within this document do not align with the latest policy updates.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter and has included discussion of policy updates throughout this final rule as applicable.

Comment:

Some commenters expressed that the rule would circumvent accountability, provide less transparency, and harm children.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their comments. ORR believes that codifying these requirements will provide more accountability and will strengthen the UC Program to better protect children. The NPRM notice and comment process provided additional transparency and provided the public an opportunity to comment on ORR's processes and policies.

Comment:

Many commenters expressed opposition to the rule and cited concerns that the proposed regulations did not do enough to prevent child trafficking.

Response:

ORR appreciates and shares the public's concern for the welfare of unaccompanied children that come through its care, as well as the need to mitigate and prevent human trafficking. Among other similar responsibilities, HHS, together with other specified agencies, has a duty to “establish policies and programs to ensure that unaccompanied alien children in the United States are protected from traffickers and other persons seeking to victimize or otherwise engage such children in criminal, harmful, or exploitative activity. . . .”

52

Accordingly, these agencies, including ORR, have developed extensive policies and procedures to protect unaccompanied children and that are memorialized in subregulatory guidance and memoranda of agreement (MOA).

53

This rule contains provisions that are consistent with HHS's statutory responsibilities, many of which codify and strengthen current policy. For example, this rule codifies ORR's historic practice of screening all unaccompanied children for potential trafficking concerns, including during intake, assessments, and sponsor assessments, and its use of Significant Incident Reports to report such concerns. The rule also codifies the requirement that ORR refer concerns of human trafficking to ACF's Office on Trafficking in Persons (OTIP) within 24 hours in accordance with reporting requirements under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act of 2008. OTIP reviews the concerns to assess whether the unaccompanied child is eligible for benefits and services. Concerns of human trafficking are also reported to OTIP by post-release service providers, the ORR National Call Center (NCC),

legal services providers, law enforcement, child welfare entities, healthcare providers, other child-serving agencies, and advocates.

Under this rule, if ORR care provider staff, such as a case manager or clinician, suspect that a child is a victim of trafficking or is at risk of trafficking at any point during their interaction with an unaccompanied child, they must make a referral to HHS's ACF OTIP and to DHS's Homeland Security Investigations Division and DHS's Center for Countering Human Trafficking for further investigation. OTIP provides further assistance to ensure that victims can access appropriate care and services. Such care is then coordinated with ORR to provide direct referrals for grant-funded comprehensive case management services, medical services, food assistance, cash assistance, and health insurance tailored to the child's individual needs. While ORR does not retain legal custody of unaccompanied children post-release, ORR considers what, if any, additional action should be taken consistent with its legal authorities, including but not limited to: reporting the matter to local law enforcement; child protective services; or state child welfare licensing authorities; providing PRS to the released child and their sponsor, if the child is still under 18; requiring corrective action to be taken against a care provider facility to remedy any failure to comply with Federal and state laws and regulations, licensing and accreditation standards; ORR policies and procedures, and child welfare standards; or providing technical assistance to the care provider facility, as needed, to ensure that deficiencies are addressed.

Comment:

One commenter stated their belief that the proposed rule was subject to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and argued that ORR must conduct an environmental assessment prior to finalizing this rule or it will be in violation of NEPA. The commenter pointed to the location of a facility in a community as having an environmental impact.

Response:

ORR disagrees that an environmental assessment is necessary under NEPA for two reasons. NEPA applies when there are “major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment.” 42 U.S.C. 4332(C). However, in this rule, HHS is not taking any Federal action that would “affect” the quality of the human environment because it is essentially memorializing aspects of existing UC Program procedures in a regulation, rather than where they reside now, in a settlement agreement, statutes, and the ORR UC policy guide. Because the rule, as a general matter, does not materially change the UC Program, it does not significantly affect the quality of the human environment to implicate NEPA. With respect to the “risk determination hearings” described at § 410.1903, ORR notes that those hearings already occur, but at DOJ instead of at HHS, as set forth in this rule.

With respect to the creation of the Office of the Ombuds, as described in subpart K, HHS has determined that the Ombuds Office falls under a categorical exclusion as delineated in the HHS General Administration Manual,

54

which describes certain categories of actions that do not require environmental review. Specifically, the Office of the Ombuds falls under Section 30-20-40(B)(2)(g), which excludes “liaison functions (

e.g.,

serving on task forces, ad hoc committees or representing HHS interests in specific functional areas in relationship with other governmental and non-governmental entities).” To carry out its responsibility to confidentially and informally receive and investigate complaints and concerns related to unaccompanied children's experiences in ORR care, the Office will liaise with stakeholders in the UC Program, including both governmental and non-governmental entities, and as such it is subject to the HHS categorical exclusion.

In general, HHS has determined that the rule falls under a categorical exclusion in section 30-20-40(B)(2)(f) of the HHS General Administration Manual, which provides that environment impact statements and environmental assessments are not required for “grants for social services (

e.g.,

support for Head Start, senior citizen programs or drug treatment programs) except projects involving construction, renovation, or changes in land use.” The UC Program provides grants for social services. Although the commenter points to locating a facility as having environmental impact, the rule does not in any way address issues relating to site selection for ORR facilities (

i.e.,

the rule does not describe projects involving construction, renovation, or changes in land use). To the extent the UC Program going forward may engage in such activities, ORR would engage in proper environmental review for each such activity. This rule, however, does not implicate environmental review.

Comment:

One commenter stated their belief that the proposed rule did not include a cost estimate or financial analysis of what the burden would be to American taxpayers, and stated that before the rule is finalized, the Office of Management and Budget should review the rule.

Response:

The proposed rule, and this final rule, provide a cost estimate in the section titled Economic Analysis. The Office of Management and Budget reviewed the proposed and final rules before publication.

55

Final Rule Action:

ORR will finalize the majority of the proposals, with some changes as discussed throughout this rule.

Section 410.1000 Scope of This Part

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1000(a), that the scope of this part pertain to the placement, care, and services provided to unaccompanied children in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status and referred to ORR (88 FR 68914). As described in section III of this final rule, ORR's care, custody, and placement of unaccompanied children is governed by the HSA and TVPRA, and ORR provides its services to unaccompanied children in accordance with the terms of the FSA. ORR also clarified that part 410 would not govern or describe the entire program. For example, part 411 (describing requirements related to the prevention of sexual abuse of unaccompanied children in ORR care) would remain in effect under this rule. ORR notes that its current policies and practices are described in the online ORR Policy Guide,

56

Field Guidance,

57

manuals describing compliance with ORR policies and procedures, and other communications from ORR to care provider facilities. ORR will continue to utilize these vehicles for its subregulatory guidance and will revise them in connection with publication of the final rule as needed to ensure compliance with the final rule. The provisions of this part would, in many cases, codify existing ORR policies and practices. Further, ORR will continue to publish subregulatory guidance as needed to clarify the application of these regulations.

ORR also proposed, at § 410.1000(b), that the provisions of this part are separate and severable from one another and that if any provision is stayed or determined to be invalid, the remaining provisions shall continue in effect (88 FR 68914). Additionally, ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1000(c) that ORR does not fund or operate facilities other than standard programs, restrictive placements (which include secure facilities, including residential treatment centers, and heightened supervision facilities), or EIFs, absent a

specific waiver as described under § 410.1801(d) or such additional waivers as are permitted by law (88 FR 68914).

Comment:

One commenter questioned the consistency of the level of detail used in the NPRM, stating that some parts of the proposed regulation were very detailed while other requirements were more general. The commenter suggested that the rule should include either a statement of general guiding principles from which specific policy and operational directives will be drawn or, conversely, should include all specific operational directives for all requirements, thus replacing existing or significantly modifying the existing ORR Policy Guide.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter for their comment. As clarified in the NPRM, part 410 will not govern or describe the entire program (88 FR 68914). Where the regulations contain less detail, subregulatory guidance will provide specific guidance on requirements. By keeping some of the requirements subregulatory, ORR will be able to make more frequent, iterative updates in keeping with best practices and to allow continued responsiveness to the needs of unaccompanied children and care provider facilities. The requirements codified in this rule, on the other hand, may in the future be amended only through future notice and comment rulemaking or changes in law.

Comment:

One commenter stated that while they appreciated the Administration's work to codify standards, they believe it is also important to preserve ORR's ability to nimbly respond to emerging issues through updates to its policy guide, as ORR did during the COVID-19 pandemic. The commenter recommended that ORR include language making it clear that nothing in the final rule precludes ORR from updating policy and guidance to address emergent situations while prioritizing the best interests of children.

Response:

ORR reiterates the clarification that part 410 will not govern or describe the entire program and that further guidance will be provided through subregulatory guidance in order to remain nimble to changing circumstances as the commenter suggests.

Final Rule Action:

After consideration of public comments, ORR is finalizing § 410.1000 as proposed.

Section 410.1001 Definitions

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1001, to codify the definitions of terms that apply to this part (88 FR 68914 through 68916). Some definitions are the same as those found in statute, or other authorities (

e.g.,

the definition of “unaccompanied child” is the same as the definition of “unaccompanied alien child” as found in the HSA, 6 U.S.C. 279(g)(2)). Notably, for purposes of this rule, ORR updated certain terms and definitions provided in the FSA (

e.g.,

the definition of “influx”). In the NPRM, ORR provided an explanation for certain definitions, to further explain ORR's rationale when the rule applies the relevant terms. As discussed in this section, ORR is revising some of the proposed definitions.

ORR proposed in the NPRM the definition of “care provider facility” to generally describe any placement type for unaccompanied children, except out of network (OON) placements, and as a result is broader than the term “standard program,” provided below, which, for example, does not include EIFs (88 FR 68914). ORR also noted that this definition does not reference “facilities for children with special needs,” a term used in the definition of “licensed program” in the FSA and 45 CFR 411.5. ORR considered not using the term “facilities for children with special needs” within the part for the reasons set forth below in this section at the proposed definition of “standard program.” Moreover, ORR considered this definition for “care provider facility” to encompass any facility in which an unaccompanied child may be placed while in the custody of ORR, including any facility exclusively serving children in need of particular services and treatment.

ORR proposed in the NPRM a definition of “disability” that is distinct from the NPRM's proposed definition for a “special needs unaccompanied child,” discussed later in this section and which is derived specifically from the FSA (88 FR 68914). Although some unaccompanied children may have a disability and have special needs, the terms are not synonymous. For example, an unaccompanied child exiting ORR custody may be considered to have a disability within the definition set forth in section 504 even if the child does not require services or treatments for a mental and/or physical impairment.

ORR proposed in the NPRM a definition of “emergency” that differs from the definition previously finalized at 45 CFR 411.5, which defines the term as “a sudden, urgent, usually unexpected occurrence or occasion requiring immediate action” (88 FR 68914). “Emergency,” for purposes of the proposed rule, would reflect the term's usage in the context of the requirements proposed in the NPRM.

With respect to the definition of the proposed term “EOIR accredited representative,” ORR noted in the NPRM that DOJ refers to these individuals simply as “accredited representatives,” see 8 CFR 1292.1(a)(4), but for purposes of the NPRM, ORR adopted the term “EOIR accredited representative” (88 FR 68914).

ORR proposed in the NPRM that the definition of “heightened supervision facility” incorporate language consistent with the definition of “medium secure facility” provided in the FSA at paragraph 8 (88 FR 68914). This term replaces the term “staff secure facility” as used under existing ORR policies. ORR decided to change its terminology because it had become clear that the prior term was not well understood and did not effectively convey information about the nature of such facilities.

ORR proposed in the NPRM that the definition of “influx” would change the threshold for declaring an influx, for ORR's purposes, from the FSA standard, which ORR believes is out of date considering current migration patterns and its organizational capacity (88 FR 68914 through 68915). The FSA defines influx as “those circumstances where the INS has, at any given time, more than 130 minors eligible for placement in a licensed program.” ORR's definition, however, would not impact the rights, and responsibilities of other parties of the FSA. ORR believes that the proposed definition more appropriately reflects significantly changed circumstances since the inception of the FSA and provides a more realistic, fair, and workable threshold for implementing safeguards necessary in cases where a high percentage of ORR's bed capacity is in use. The 1997 standard of 130 minors awaiting placement does not reflect the realities of unaccompanied children referrals in the past decade, in which the number of unaccompanied children referrals each day typically exceeds, and sometimes greatly exceeds, 130 children. To leave this standard as the definition of influx would mean, in effect, that the program is always in influx status. Accordingly, ORR provided a more realistic and workable threshold for implementing safeguards necessary in cases where a high percentage of ORR bed capacity is in use.

With respect to the definition of “post-release services,” ORR noted in the NPRM that assistance linking families to educational resources may include but is not limited to, in appropriate circumstances, assisting with school enrollment; requesting an English language proficiency assessment; seeking an evaluation to determine whether the child is eligible

for a free appropriate public education (which can include special education and related services) or reasonable modifications and auxiliary aids and services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act or section 504; and monitoring the unaccompanied child's attendance and progress in school (88 FR 68915). ORR noted that while the TVPRA requires that follow-up services must be provided during the pendency of removal proceedings in cases in which a home study occurred, the nature and extent of those services would be subject to available resources.

ORR noted, in the NPRM, with respect to the proposed definition of “runaway risk,” the FSA and ORR policy currently use the term “escape risk” (88 FR 68915). See FSA paragraph 22 (defining “escape risk” as “a serious risk that the minor will attempt to escape from custody,” and providing a non-exhaustive list of factors ORR may consider when determining whether an unaccompanied child is an escape risk—

e.g.,

whether the unaccompanied child is currently under a final order of removal, the unaccompanied child's immigration history, and whether the unaccompanied child has previously absconded or attempted to abscond from Government custody). ORR proposed in the NPRM to update this term to “runaway risk,” which is a term used by state child welfare agencies and Federal agencies to describe children at risk from running away from home or their care setting (88 FR 68915). Rather than basing its determination of runaway risk solely on the factors described in the FSA, ORR proposed in the NPRM that such determinations must be made in view of a totality of the circumstances and should not be based solely on a past attempt to run away. This definition of runaway risk is consistent with how the term is used in the FSA to describe escape from ORR care,

i.e.,

from a care provider facility. ORR noted throughout the proposed rule that the TVPRA uses the term “risk of flight,” stating HHS “may” consider “risk of flight,” among other factors, when making placement determinations.

58

ORR understands that in the immigration law context, “risk of flight” refers to an individual's risk of not appearing for their immigration proceedings.

59

ORR proposed in the NPRM, with respect to its responsibilities toward unaccompanied children in its custody, to interpret “risk of flight” as including “runaway risk,” thereby adding runaway risk to the list of factors it would consider in making placement determinations. Runaway risk often overlaps with concern that an unaccompanied child may not appear for the child's immigration proceedings. ORR also noted that runaway risk may also relate to potential danger to self or the community, given the inherent risks to unaccompanied children who run away from custody (88 FR 68915).

With respect to the proposed definition of “secure facility,” ORR noted that the FSA uses but does not provide a definition for this term (88 FR 68915). Nevertheless, the proposed definition is consistent with the provisions of the FSA that apply to secure facilities. ORR also noted that the proposed definition differs from the definition in the 2019 Final Rule, which could have been read to indicate that any contract or cooperative agreement for a facility with separate accommodations for minors is a secure facility. Such a definition risks erroneously confusing other types of ORR placements that are not secure with secure placements and, therefore, ORR proposed in the NPRM an updated definition in the NPRM.

ORR proposed in the NPRM to change the definition of “special needs unaccompanied child,” to the term “special needs minor” as described within the FSA at paragraph 7 and by using the phrase “intellectual or developmental disability” instead of “mental illness or retardation” as used in the FSA (88 FR 68915). ORR understands that this update reflects current terminology which has superseded the terminology used in the FSA (“retardation”). Although an unaccompanied child with a disability, as defined in this section, could also be a “special needs unaccompanied child” as incorporated here, the definition of disability is broader and thus the terms are not synonymous. To further this clarification, ORR proposed in the NPRM a separate definition for disability earlier in this section that incorporates the meaning of the term across applicable governing statutory authorities. ORR also considered not defining and not using the term “special needs unaccompanied child” within the part for the reasons set forth below at proposed §§ 410.1103 and 410.1106.

ORR proposed in the NPRM a definition of “standard program” that reflects and updates the term “licensed program” at paragraph 6 of the FSA (88 FR 68915 through 68916). The FSA does not discuss situations where States discontinue licensing, or exempt from licensing, childcare facilities that contract with the Federal Government to care for unaccompanied children because such facilities provide shelter and services to unaccompanied children as has happened recently in some States.

60

ORR proposed in the NPRM a definition of “standard program” that is broader in scope to account for circumstances wherein licensure is unavailable in the State to programs that provide residential, group, or home care services for dependent children when those programs are serving unaccompanied children. ORR notes that most States where ORR has care provider facilities have not taken such actions, and that wherever possible standard programs would continue to be licensed consistent with current practice under the FSA. However, ORR considered substituting the term “licensed program” with the proposed updated term “standard program” in order to establish that the requirement that facilities in those States must still meet minimum standards, consistent with requirements for licensed facilities expressed in the FSA at Exhibit 1, in any circumstance in which a State will not license a facility because the facility is housing unaccompanied children.

61

ORR solicited comments on using the proposed definition of “standard program” in lieu of the term “licensed program.”

ORR proposed in the NPRM a definition for “standard program” to encompass any program operating non-secure facilities that provide services to unaccompanied children in need of particular services and treatment or to children with particular mental or physical conditions (88 FR 68916). Given this, ORR believed the continued use of language such as “facilities for children with special needs” and “facilities for special needs minors,” as used in the FSA definition of “licensed program,” was unnecessary for this regulation, and potentially problematic for reasons discussed elsewhere within this section and at proposed §§ 410.1103 and 410.1106. ORR included this language to ensure consistency with the FSA, but it considered not using the term “special needs unaccompanied child” or specifying that facilities for special needs unaccompanied children operated by a standard program are covered by the requirements that apply to standard programs in the part. Therefore, ORR also solicited comments in this section on its proposal to not include in the definition of “standard program” the FSA terminology used in the term “licensed program” referencing facilities for special needs unaccompanied children or a facility for special needs unaccompanied children.

ORR proposed in the NPRM to define “trauma bond” consistent with how the Department of State's Office to Monitor and Combat Trafficking in Persons defines the term in its factsheet, Trauma

Bonding in Human Trafficking (88 FR 68916).

62

ORR proposed in the NPRM to define “trauma-informed,” based upon its belief that a trauma-informed approach to the care and placement of unaccompanied children is essential to ensuring that the interests of children are considered in decisions and actions relating to their care and custody (88 FR 68916).

63

ORR interprets trauma-informed system, standard, process, or practices consistent with the 6 Guidelines To A Trauma-Informed Approach adopted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and developed by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA).

ORR received comments on the following definitions.

Attorney of Record

Comment:

One commenter recommended changes to the definition of “attorney of record.” The commenter recommended that ORR revise the definition to specifically define an “attorney” as “an individual licensed to practice law in any U.S. jurisdiction” but then make clear that non-attorneys may represent a child in their immigration proceedings. The commenter also urged ORR to remove reference to the requirement that an attorney “protects [unaccompanied children] from mistreatment, exploitation, and trafficking, consistent with 8 U.S.C. 1232(c)(5),” explaining that the statute cited requires that HHS ensure counsel because that will protect unaccompanied children from mistreatment, exploitation, and trafficking, but not that counsel is required to protect the child. The commenter continued, that although in many instances having counsel will ensure a child's protection, the duty to protect, as outlined in the proposed definition, may conflict with an attorney's duty to represent the child's expressed interests as required by the rules of professional conduct.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter. The definition of attorney of record states that the attorney represents the unaccompanied child in legal proceedings, so ORR does not think it is necessary to also indicate that the attorney is licensed for such representation. ORR does agree with the commenter that the addition of the referenced language from the TVPRA improperly implies that the attorney is required to protect the child and that it should remove that language from the definition.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is revising the proposed definition of “attorney of record” to remove the phrase “and protects them from mistreatment, exploitation, and trafficking, consistent with 8 U.S.C. 1232(c)(5).”

Best Interest

Comment:

Many commenters commented on the definition of “best interest.” Commenters recommended expanding the definition of “best interest” to more explicitly address the following factors: the impact of family relationships and importance of family integrity, the impact of Federal custody on an unaccompanied child's well-being, their safety, and their identity including their race, religion, ethnicity, sexual orientation, and gender identity.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters. ORR notes that the rule provides a non-exhaustive list of factors ORR may consider in evaluating what is in a child's best interest. ORR understands the listed factors to already encompass additional factors suggested by the commenters. Further, ORR notes that some of the factors recommended by commenters are also already provided as considerations for placement under § 410.1103. Having said that, ORR will further consider whether to expand on the definition of best interest in future policymaking.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the definition of “best interest” as proposed.

Care Provider Facility

Comment:

One commenter supported the proposed term “care provider facility,” stating that by making it broader than “standard program,” it will help clarify the meaning of influx or emergency facilities. Another commenter recommended that the definition of “care provider facility” meet the definition of “child care institution” at section 472(c)(2)(A) of the Social Security Act in order to align all institutions and facilities serving vulnerable children residing within and across states, including but not limited to unaccompanied children.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter for their support. Regarding the definition in the Social Security Act, section 472(c)(2)(A) defines “child care institution” as “a private child-care institution, or a public childcare institution which accommodates no more than 25 children, which is licensed by the State in which it is situated or has been approved by the agency of the State responsible for licensing or approval of institutions of this type as meeting the standards established for the licensing.” Although ORR appreciates the comment, section 472 of the Social Security Act is specific to State payments to foster care programs and does not govern the ORR UC Program. Although ORR strives to place children in care settings with small numbers of children, it is not always possible to do so. Additionally, ORR has further requirements that care provider facilities must meet in addition to those relating to State licensing.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the term care provider facility as follows:

Care provider facility

means any physical site, including an individual family home, that houses one or more unaccompanied children in ORR custody and is operated by an ORR-funded program that provides residential services for unaccompanied children. Out of network (OON) placements are not included within this definition.

Case File

Comment:

One commenter supported the inclusion of home study and PRS records as part of the case file definition and, by so doing, including such records as protected information, agreeing that unaccompanied children's case files and related information should receive strong safeguards from unauthorized access, misuse, and inappropriate disclosure. However, the commenter requested clarity regarding the meaning of “correspondence” within the definition, asking if it was meant to cover a limited set of materials regarding the child's unification, such as any correspondence with parents and sponsors done by ORR staff or provider case managers. The commenter expressed concern that this is not consistent with the other use of “correspondence” in the NPRM at § 410.1304(a)(2)(ii), where the word “correspondence” appears to be meant to include personal correspondence between the unaccompanied child and whomever the child wishes to correspond with, including a friend, relative, parent, attorney, or child advocate. Such materials should be the child's personal property and not the property of ORR.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter. ORR notes that the definition of case file is “the physical and electronic records for each unaccompanied child that are pertinent to the care and placement of the child.” Accordingly, personal correspondence that is not pertinent to the care and placement of the child would not be part of the case file. However, for the sake of clarity, ORR will revise the proposed definition to state that the case file includes “correspondence regarding the child's case.”

Comment:

One commenter did not support the statement within the proposed definition of case file that “[t]he records of unaccompanied children are the property of ORR.” The commenter acknowledged the importance of strong, universal standards governing children's records in order to consistently protect the confidentiality of their Personally Identifiable Information (PII) but stated that the ownership of children's records is a more complicated issue. The commenter stated, as an example, that when a child brings documents such as a birth certificate into custody, the Federal Government holds that document, but does not own it. The commenter stated that the birth certificate belongs to the child and the child's parent and legal guardian, and the document and its content can be shared with the child's or parent's consent.

Response:

ORR notes that, consistent with UC Program's System of Records Notice (SORN), unaccompanied children have access to, and are entitled to copies of, their own case file records, consistent with the provisions of the Privacy Act, codified at 5 U.S.C. 552a.

64

An unaccompanied child's attorney of record also has the ability to request the child's full case file at any time. With respect to original documents such as a child's birth certificate, ORR notes that it is amending the definition of “case file” to note that it includes “copies of” birth and marriage certificates.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is revising the proposed definition to add that case file materials include “but are not limited to” the materials listed in the definition. ORR is also adding the phrase “regarding the child's case” after “correspondence.” ORR is also adding “copies of” before birth and marriage certificates. Additionally, in order to be consistent with finalized § 410.1303(h)(2), ORR is adding “except for program administration purposes” at the end of the definition. ORR is otherwise finalizing the definition as proposed.

Close Relative

Final Rule Action:

As discussed in § 410.1205, ORR is finalizing the definition of “close relative” as a type of potential sponsor, as follows: “

Close relative

means a brother, sister, grandparent, aunt, uncle, first cousin, or other immediate biological relative, or immediate relative through legal marriage or adoption, and half-sibling.”

Community-Based-Care

Comment:

One commenter did not support the proposed definition of community-based care, believing that it is overly broad. The commenter recommended retaining “traditional foster care” instead.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter for their comment. ORR notes that it is planning to transition to a community-based care model that will restructure ORR's existing transitional foster care and long-term foster care programs to operate within a continuum of care including basic and therapeutic foster family settings as well as supervised independent living group home settings, to more effectively place and support children in non-congregate settings. However, ORR plans to describe this transition in future policymaking, and therefore is not finalizing the term “community-based care” in this rule. ORR will consider this commenter's feedback as it continues transitioning to this model. Additional details and responses to public comments on community-based care are described in subpart B.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is not finalizing codification of the definition for the term “community-based care,” though ORR has sought to provide further details relating to the broad standards applicable to the term in subpart B.

Disposition

Comment:

One commenter stated that the proposed rule uses the term “disposition” as a term of art but does not define what disposition signifies, includes, or excludes.

Response:

The term “disposition” appears three times in the regulation, twice as “case disposition” and once as the “disposition of any actions in which the unaccompanied child is the subject.” ORR believes that the meaning of disposition is clear in context and so the term does not necessitate a definition.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is not finalizing a definition for “disposition.”

Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) Accredited Representative

Comment:

One commenter recommended that ORR change the term “EOIR accredited representative” to “DOJ accredited representative,” stating that the term is commonly referred to as “DOJ accredited representative” and that adopting a different term in these proposed regulations will cause unnecessary confusion and be inconsistent with how representatives are referred to elsewhere.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter and agrees to revise the term to “DOJ Accredited Representative.” ORR is updating this term throughout the rest of this final rule, even where summarizing NPRM language which used the term “EOIR accredited representative.”

Final Rule Action:

ORR is revising the term to “DOJ Accredited Representative” and otherwise finalizing the definition of such term as proposed.

Emergency

Comment:

Some commenters did not support the proposed definition of “emergency,” believing that it relaxes standards and changes a commonly understood term.

Response:

The FSA defines emergency, for purposes of paragraph 12 of the FSA, as “an act or event that prevents the placement of minors pursuant to paragraph 19 within the timeframe provided.” In turn, paragraph 19 of the FSA describes the requirement to place unaccompanied children in licensed programs until they can be released to a sponsor—“provided, however, that in the event of an emergency a licensed program may transfer temporary physical custody of a minor prior to securing permission from the INS but shall notify the INS of the transfer as soon as is practicable thereafter, but in all cases within 8 hours.” The FSA states at paragraph 12B that emergencies include “natural disasters (

e.g.,

earthquakes, hurricanes, etc.), facility fires, civil disturbances and medical emergencies (

e.g.,

a chicken pox epidemic among a group of minors).” In the NPRM, ORR proposed to define “emergency” as “an act or event (including, but not limited to, a natural disaster, facility fire, civil disturbance, or medical or public health concerns at one or more facilities) that prevents timely transport or placement of unaccompanied children, or impacts other conditions provided by this part (88 FR 68979). ORR is therefore codifying the term emergency as used in the FSA.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the term “emergency” as proposed.

Emergency or Influx Facility (EIF)

Comment:

One commenter expressed concern that the proposed rule defined emergency or influx facility as “a type of care provider facility that opens temporarily to provide shelter and services for unaccompanied children” but does not define temporary. Another commenter urged ORR to incorporate additional language that unlicensed placements, such as emergency and influx sites, should only be utilized as a last resort.

Response:

As stated in the NPRM, ORR has a strong preference to house unaccompanied children in standard programs (88 FR 68955). However, ORR notes that in times of emergency or influx, additional facilities may be needed on short notice to house unaccompanied children. Consistent with current policy, ORR intends that under this rule it will cease placements at EIFs if net bed capacity of ORR's standard programs that is occupied or held for placement of unaccompanied children drops below 85 percent for a period of at least seven consecutive days.

Final Rule Action:

For consistency and clarity, ORR is replacing the proposed second sentence of the definition, which read “These facilities are not otherwise categorized as a standard or secure facility in this part” with “An EIF is not defined as a standard program, shelter, or secure facility under this part.” ORR is also replacing the phrase “they may not be licensed” with “they may be unlicensed” to remove any possible implication that they are not allowed to be licensed. ORR is otherwise finalizing the term “emergency or influx facility (EIF)” as proposed.

Family Planning Services

Comment:

A few commenters suggested that ORR amend the list of family planning services to include abortion, arguing that abortion should be included in the definition of family planning services to avoid stigmatizing abortion.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their comments. ORR notes that its proposed definition of “family planning services” is consistent with other HHS regulations and publications.

65

As noted in the NPRM, ORR has included abortion in the definition of medical services requiring heightened ORR involvement (88 FR 68979). One commenter suggested revising the definition by updating “pregnancy testing and counseling” in the list of family planning services to “pregnancy testing and non-directive pregnancy counseling.” ORR accepts the recommendation to update “counseling” to “non-directive options counseling” in the definition of Family Planning Services in the regulatory text, as it aligns with ORR's intended meaning and aligns with corresponding language in Field Guidance #21.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is adding the phrase “non-directive options” before “counseling” and otherwise, finalizing the term “Family Planning Services” as proposed.

Heightened Supervision Facility

Comment:

One commenter supported the inclusion in the term's definition that “heightened supervision facilities” “provide supports” to children with higher needs. The commenter encouraged ORR to eliminate the definition's focus on security and replace text with reference to additional personalized and intensive service provision.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter for their comment. ORR notes that the definition merely defines the facility and how it differs from a shelter facility. Heightened supervision facilities are required to meet the minimum standards for standard programs. ORR notes that it is important to describe the level of restriction at these facilities because certain requirements need to be met for children to be placed in heightened supervision facilities under subpart B and children have a right to review placement in these facilities under subpart J.

Final Rule Action:

As further discussed at the preamble text for § 410.1302, ORR is adding the phrase “or that meets the requirements of State licensing that would otherwise be applicable if it is in a State that does not allow state licensing of programs providing care and services to unaccompanied children,” after “licensed by an appropriate State agency.”

Influx

Comment:

Many commenters supported the proposed definition of “influx,” noting that the updated definition is more realistic in light of recent immigration trends and would reduce the placement of unaccompanied children in emergency facilities. One commenter recommended that the definition be amended to account for the trajectory of incoming unaccompanied children to reach or exceed 85 percent of bed capacity within 30 days in order to trigger EIFs from cold to warm status.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters. ORR intends through this final rule to update the FSA definition of influx to account for current circumstances at the southern border. However, because migration patterns are unpredictable, ORR believes it is appropriate to maintain subregulatory procedures with respect to preparing for the use of EIFs, based on the definition of influx codified in this rule.

Comment:

One commenter supported ORR's proposal to adopt a definition of “influx” that differs from the FSA, agreeing that the FSA standard set forth in 1997 does not reflect the realities of unaccompanied children awaiting placement that have been experienced in the last decade. However, the commenter expressed their view that ORR has consistently underutilized available licensed beds in its network and placed unaccompanied children in active influx care facilities when licensed facilities were available. The commenter stated further their concern that the proposed definition would have an influx hinge entirely on ORR's network capacity, as opposed to the actual numbers of unaccompanied children entering the agency's care. Another commenter requested clarification regarding the safeguards referenced in the definition of influx.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters. ORR appreciates the commenter's concern about basing the definition of influx on the net bed capacity of standard programs, however basing it on numbers of unaccompanied children proved insufficient as migration numbers greatly increased and the static number became outdated. The original intent of the FSA definition was to identify circumstances in which there is a sudden need to expand capacity and not sufficient time to use the ordinary supply-building process. Looking at referrals in relation to current net bed capacity of ORR's standard programs that is occupied or held for placement of unaccompanied children is a better way to reflect that need and sets the definition of influx at a level vastly higher than what would have been required had ORR maintained the FSA definition. ORR also notes that standard capacity beds may be unavailable for a variety of reasons including staffing shortages; licensing restrictions on age, gender, or ratios; or building issues (

e.g.,

water leaks) that prevent the safe placement of children. These causes of unavailability are not controlled by ORR, but are examples of issues that may restrict ORR's access to standard beds in its network of care on a given day. ORR will continue to monitor the numbers of unaccompanied children and the number of available standard placements to determine if further updates are needed in the future.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is replacing the term “for purposes of this part” with “for purposes of HHS operations” and otherwise finalizing the definition of “influx” as proposed.

Least Restrictive Placement

Comment:

One commenter expressed concern that “least restrictive placement” is not defined, and that it may be inferred that the least restrictive placement is by default, anything that is

not a “restrictive placement,” which is defined. The commenter expressed concern that the proposed regulations do not recognize the commenter's belief that some non-restrictive placements are more restrictive than other non-restrictive placements.

Response:

ORR notes that it intends the term “least restrictive placement” be read consistent with the TVPRA requirement that unaccompanied children in the custody of HHS be “promptly placed in the least restrictive setting that is in the best interest of the child,” and that in making such placements HHS “may consider danger to self, danger to the community, and risk of flight,” among other requirements. 8 U.S.C. 1232(c)(2)(A).

Final Rule Action:

ORR is not adopting a definition of “least restrictive placement.”

LGBTQI+

Comment:

A few commenters recommended expanding the definition of LGBTQI+, which the NPRM defined as meaning “lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer or questioning, intersex,” to include an explanation of the “+” symbol. The commenters stated their belief that expanding the definition would make the definition more complete and would better encompass the many other identities that make up the LGBTQI+ community.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters. ORR appreciates that the term LGBTQI+ is an umbrella term that is broader than the term LGBTQI, and accordingly has revised the regulatory definition to say that the term “includes” lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, questioning or intersex, as defined at 45 CFR 411.5. This change helps to make clear that the term LGBTQI+ includes additional identities such as non-binary.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is revising the definition to replace “means” with “includes” and is otherwise finalizing the definition of LGBTQI+ as proposed.

Mechanical Restraints

Final Rule Action:

For the reasons discussed in the preamble discussion of § 410.1304(e)(1), ORR is clarifying the definition of mechanical restraints by adding a second sentence to the definition, as follows: “For purposes of the Unaccompanied Children Program, mechanical restraints are prohibited across all care provider types except in secure facilities, where they are permitted only as consistent with State licensure requirements.” ORR is otherwise finalizing the definition as proposed.

Medical Services Requiring Heightened ORR Involvement

Comment:

A few commenters recommended that ORR revise the definition of medical services requiring heightened ORR involvement to clarify that the heightened involvement is only to ensure quick transportation or transfer for abortion, as needed, and not to create obstacles to impede access to abortion.

Response:

ORR acknowledges the importance of not creating obstacles to needed medical services, including but not limited to abortion, but does not believe that the definition of medical services requiring heightened ORR involvement needs to be modified in order to make this point clear. ORR is revising § 410.1307 to further clarify that ORR will not prevent unaccompanied children in ORR care from accessing healthcare services, including medical services requiring heightened ORR involvement and family planning services, and ORR must make reasonable efforts to facilitate access to those services if requested by the unaccompanied child.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the definition of “medical services requiring heightened ORR involvement” as proposed.

ORR Long-Term Home Care

Comment:

One commenter stated they had no objection to the proposed change from “long-term foster care” to “long-term home care.” Another commenter suggested that the definition of “ORR long-term home care” be clarified to indicate whether children need to have viable legal cases in the particular State to be placed in that program versus the “legal proceedings” that all children in ORR care are in.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters. Part of the proposed definition reads that “[a]n unaccompanied child may be placed in long-term home care if ORR is unable to identify an appropriate sponsor with whom to place the unaccompanied child during the pendency of their legal proceedings.” ORR clarifies that the legal proceedings referenced are immigration legal proceedings and is amending the definition accordingly.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is adding the word “immigration” before “legal proceedings” and is otherwise finalizing the definition of “ORR long-term home care” as proposed.

Out of Network (OON) Placement

Comment:

Some commenters expressed concern that OON facilities were excluded from the definition of care provider facility and that the definition of OON placements does not require they are State licensed or follow the requirements of a standard program. Commenters requested clarification regarding standards applicable to OON placements. One commenter recommended that the definition of OON placement be revised to state that during an OON placement, the responsibility for reporting incidents related to the child, assessments, and ongoing case management would remain with the care provider facility.

Response:

In response to the comments, ORR is adding to the definition of OON placement that OON placements are “licensed by an appropriate State agency.” ORR will vet the program to ensure that the program is in good standing with State licensing and is complying with all applicable State child welfare laws and regulations and all State and local building, fire, health, and safety codes. ORR further reiterates that an unaccompanied child may only be placed at an OON placement when such placement would be in the unaccompanied child's best interest. As stated in the NPRM, consistent with existing policies, in these circumstances, even though an unaccompanied child would be physically located at an OON placement, the unaccompanied child would remain in ORR legal custody (88 FR 68924). ORR also clarifies that an OON placement is not defined as a standard program under this part. However, as provided under ORR policy, the unaccompanied child's case manager would monitor the unaccompanied child's progress and ensure the unaccompanied child is receiving services.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is adding the phrase “that is licensed by an appropriate State agency” after “means a facility” to the definition of out of network placement. ORR is also stating that such a placement is not defined as a standard program under this part. ORR is otherwise finalizing the definition as proposed.

Placement Review Panel

Comment:

One commenter suggested revising the definition of “placement review panel (PRP)” to include additional information regarding timeframes for decision and specificity regarding the term “ORR Senior Level Career Staff” by including the job title or designation.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter for their feedback. Requirements for the PRP are addressed by ORR under § 410.1902, rather than in the definition of the PRP. ORR clarifies that “ORR

Senior Level Career Staff” means ORR staff at a senior level or above that is not politically appointed.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the definition of “placement review panel” as proposed.

Qualified Interpreter

Comment:

One commenter suggested that the definition of a “qualified interpreter” for an individual with a disability be modified to include adherence to generally accepted ethics principles, including client confidentiality, to make it clear that individuals with disabilities are entitled to the same confidentiality and ethical protections as limited English proficient individuals.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter for catching a drafting error. ORR will restructure the proposed paragraph, moving former subparagraph (2)(iii) to become new paragraph (3), so that the ethical protections provision applies to the overall definition of “qualified interpreter.”

Comment:

One commenter suggested that the definition of “qualified interpreter” requires that interpreters are not only proficient in the language but also culturally competent.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter but notes that the definition of qualified interpreter for a limited English proficient individual includes a requirement that the interpreter be able to interpret “effectively, accurately, and impartially to and from such language(s) and English, using any necessary specialized vocabulary or terms without changes, omissions, or additions and while preserving the tone, sentiment, and emotional level of the original oral statement.” This definition is consistent with another HHS regulation

66

and captures a requirement that the interpreter understand the cultural nuances of the language.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is revising the proposed definition to move former subparagraph (2)(iii) to become new paragraph (3) such that the requirement to adhere to generally accepted interpreter ethics principles, including client confidentiality applies to both qualified interpreters for an individual with a disability and for a limited English proficient individual. ORR is finalizing the rest of the definition as proposed.

Runaway Risk

Comment:

One commenter supported the proposed definition of “runaway risk,” noting that it is consistent with the FSA. The commenter also supported the proposed rule's clarification that this determination must consider the totality of the circumstances. Another commenter also supported replacing the term “escape risk” with a term such as “child at risk of running away,” stating that other terms are used in criminal or enforcement settings and are not appropriate to use in a child welfare setting.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their support for not using the term “escape risk” and instead using a term that relates to runaway risk, given that escape risk is relevant to a criminal setting. ORR notes that the definition of runaway risk requires a finding that it is “highly probable or reasonably certain” that a child will attempt to abscond from ORR care, whereas the FSA defines “escape risk” as meaning there is a “serious risk” that a minor will attempt to escape from custody. Per §  410.1105(b)(2)(ii) of this final rule, one of the factors ORR may consider for placement of children in heightened supervision facilities is whether a child is a runaway risk. Because a determination that a child is a runaway risk can result in their placement into a restrictive placement, ORR intends through this updated language to establish a clearer and higher standard than required by the FSA to determine such risk.

Comment:

One commenter did not support the proposal to replace the term “escape risk” with “runaway risk” stating their belief that it was not consistent with the FSA because the FSA requires that a prior escape from custody lead to a more restrictive placement, while the proposed rule allows ORR to disregard that factor in determining whether an unaccompanied child is a runaway risk.

Response:

ORR disagrees with the commenter that the proposal is inconsistent with the FSA. Section 410.1003(f) states that ORR will consider runaway risk in making placement determinations. The definition of runaway risk states that a prior attempt to run away cannot be the sole consideration but does not require ORR to disregard this factor in determining runaway risk. As finalized at § 410.1107(b), ORR considers whether a child has previously absconded or attempted to abscond from State or Federal custody when determining, in view of the totality of the circumstances, whether a child is a runaway risk for purposes of placement decisions.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the term “runaway risk” as proposed.

Seclusion

Comment:

A few commenters asked for additional clarity in the definition of “seclusion” concerning what seclusion involves and how it works in practice.

Response:

ORR emphasizes, as established at § 410.1304(c), that seclusion is prohibited at standard programs and RTCs, and as established at § 410.1304(e)(1), that seclusion is permitted at non-RTC secure facilities only in emergency safety situations. Further, ORR notes that, consistent with current policies, seclusion is permitted only after all other de-escalation strategies and less restrictive approaches have been attempted and failed; must involve continued monitoring or supervision by staff throughout the seclusion period; must never be used as a means of coercion, discipline, convenience, or retaliation; must be performed in a manner that is safe, proportionate, and appropriate to the severity of the underlying emergency risk to the safety of others necessitating the seclusion; must be appropriate and proportionate to the child's chronological and developmental age, size, gender, as well as physical, medical, and psychiatric condition, and personal history; must be utilized in the most child-friendly, trauma-informed way possible; and must only be utilized for the short amount of time needed to ameliorate the underlying emergency risk to the safety of others.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is updating the definition of “seclusion” by adding “is instructed not to leave or” before “is physically prevented from leaving” while otherwise finalizing the definition as proposed.

Secure Facility

Comment:

Some commenters did not support that the definition of “secure facility” states that secure facilities do not need to comply with the requirements for minimum standards of care and services applicable to all other standard programs under § 410.1302. The commenters stated their belief that exempting children in secure facilities from the right to receive the minimum standards of care afforded to children in all other placement types is unwarranted and would formalize differential treatment of children as to their basic needs. Some commenters encouraged ORR to eliminate the use of secure detention, with one commenter stating their belief that placement in secure facilities is out of step with ORR's mandate and inappropriate for any child not placed there under the authority of a juvenile court judge. That commenter recommended that ORR be explicit in the definition of and criteria for placement in secure facilities.

Response:

ORR is revising its proposed regulation text to remove the

statement that a secure facility “does not need to meet the requirements of § 410.1302.” As discussed in the responses to comments in §§ 410.1301 and 410.1302, ORR is finalizing § 410.1302 such that the requirements of that section apply to secure facilities. ORR notes that this is consistent with current and historic practice, whereby ORR has required secure facilities to comply with FSA Exhibit 1 requirements even though the FSA itself does not require that. And as a practical matter, ORR currently has no secure facilities in its network of care provider facilities. As a result, ORR does not anticipate that this revision will implicate any reliance interests. Additionally, in response to commenters' concerns about the use of secure detention facilities, ORR is revising the definition to remove the explicit mention of “a secure ORR detention facility, or a State or county juvenile detention facility”.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is revising the definition of “secure facility” to remove the phrases “a secure ORR detention facility, or a State or county juvenile detention facility” and “does not need to meet the requirements of § 410.1302.” ORR is otherwise finalizing the definition as proposed.

Significant Incidents

Comment:

One commenter stated that significant changes were made to reporting of significant incidents in policy updates in 2022 and 2023 and suggested that these changes should be incorporated into the final rule.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter. In the NPRM, ORR incorrectly included “pregnancy” in the list of significant incidents. Pregnancy is no longer reported as a significant incident but is instead documented in the Health Tab of the UC Portal. Accordingly, ORR is updating the definition of “significant incidents” to remove pregnancy. With regard to other policy updates, ORR reiterates that it is not codifying all of its policies and choosing for some policies to remain subregulatory such that they can be more easily updated as needed.

Final Rule Action:

After consideration of public comments, ORR is removing pregnancy from the definition of significant incidents, but otherwise finalizing the term as proposed.

Special Needs Unaccompanied Child

Comment:

Many commenters supported the proposal to not define or use the term “special needs unaccompanied child” and instead refer to children's individualized needs. Commenters agreed that the term is disfavored and is seen as degrading. One commenter stated the term individualized needs is more specific to the child rather than confusing that the child might have a disability. Some commenters further supported the proposal to remove “facilities for children with special needs” from the definition of standard program. Some commenters stated support for changing the term disability to special needs unaccompanied child.

Response:

ORR is finalizing the use of “individualized needs” in many places in the regulations in lieu of the outdated term “special needs.”

Final Rule Action:

ORR is removing the term “special needs unaccompanied child” from the regulation.

Standard Program

Comment:

One commenter was concerned that the definition of “standard program” in the NPRM requires all homes and facilities to be “non-secure,” whereas paragraph 6 of the FSA requires them to be “non-secure as required by State law.” The commenter expressed concerns that ORR could adopt a definition of non-secure that permits much more restrictive conditions than are currently permissible. The commenter contended further that, for the same reasons, if ORR chooses to retain the reference to “a facility for special needs unaccompanied children” in the definition of “standard program” it would be impermissible to replace the FSA's paragraph 6 reference to the “level of security permitted under State law” with undefined “requirements specified by ORR if licensure is unavailable in the State.”

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter and notes that it is revising the definition of “standard program” to include “non-secure as required by State law.” ORR is also revising the definition of “standard program” to not reference “facilities for special needs unaccompanied children” given the term “special needs” has become stigmatized. Instead, the definition of “standard program” includes “facilities for unaccompanied children with specific individualized needs.”

Final Rule Action:

ORR is revising the proposed definition of “standard program” by replacing the proposed phrase “or that meets other requirements specified by ORR if licensure is unavailable in the State” with “or that meets the requirements of State licensing that would otherwise be applicable if it is in a State that does not allow State licensing,” and by moving this language to the end of the relevant sentence. ORR is also revising the proposed definition so that the final rule states that all standard programs shall be “non-secure as required under State law.” ORR is also revising the proposed definition so that the final rule does not include the language “facility for special needs unaccompanied children” and instead includes the language “facility for unaccompanied children with specific individualized needs.” ORR is also revising the definition such that a facility for unaccompanied children with specific individualized needs may maintain that level of security permitted under state law and deleting the phrase “or under the requirements specified by ORR if licensure is unavailable in the State.” ORR is otherwise finalizing the term as proposed.

Transfer

Comment:

Regarding the proposed definition of “transfer,” a few commenters had differing opinions on the statement in the NPRM that a transfer from a community-based placement to a shelter is not a step-up. The proposed rule stated that such transfer does not constitute a step-up because neither a community-based placement nor a shelter would be considered a secure placement. One commenter did not support the statement, stating that it fails to recognize that a large shelter facility is more restrictive than a foster care setting. However, another commenter supported the statement, but requested the addition of clarifying language that if the least restrictive placement for an unaccompanied child has been determined to be a shelter level of care, a community-based care facility shall also be considered an appropriate placement, without the need for a child in a restrictive placement to be first “stepped down” to a shelter level of care.

Response:

As stated in the definition of “transfer” at § 410.1001, ORR uses the terms “step-up” and “step-down” to describe transfers of unaccompanied children to or from restrictive placements. All standard programs are non-restrictive settings. Because standard programs are non-restrictive settings, a transfer between those settings is not by definition a “step-up” or “step-down.”

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the definition of “transfer” as proposed.

Trauma-Informed

Comment:

Some commenters supported ORR's inclusion of a trauma-informed approach, citing the importance of taking such an approach with the unaccompanied children population. A few commenters

recommended this approach be culturally and linguistically appropriate to better accommodate unaccompanied children's diverse experiences and to ensure continued connection to their language, culture, traditions, and community. However, one commenter warned that a trauma-informed approach is not accomplished through any single particular technique or checklist and requires ongoing organizational change and assessment.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their support. This rule establishes a definition of “trauma-informed” that ORR believes can accommodate the commenters' concerns, and ORR will consider their feedback as it develops additional guidance implementing a trauma-informed approach in relevant circumstances.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing the term “trauma-informed” as proposed.

Unaccompanied Child/Children

Comment:

Some commenters requested clarification of aspects of the definition of “unaccompanied child,” such as what constitutes an “available” parent or legal guardian, or whether children in particular circumstances meet the definition of “unaccompanied child.”

Response:

ORR notes that this final rule applies the statutory definition of “unaccompanied alien child” as provided in the HSA for purposes relevant to ORR. Other federal agencies also apply the HSA definition as relevant for their purposes. The statutory definition has three prongs: the child must have no lawful immigration status in the United States; the child must be under 18 years old; and the child must have no parent or legal guardian in the United States, or no parent or legal guardian in the United States available to provide care and physical custody. The rule itself tracked the statutory definition and did not purport to interpret it, and accordingly, discussions of application of the statutory definition in particular circumstances are beyond the scope of the rule. ORR notes that it is not an immigration enforcement authority and would not go out into the community to take custody of any child. Rather, unaccompanied children enter ORR custody upon transfer of custody from another Federal department or agency. As discussed at the portion of the NPRM's preamble addressing § 410.1101, ORR may seek clarification about the information provided by the referring agency as needed to determine appropriate placement and how the referred individual meets the statutory definition of unaccompanied child (88 FR 68917). In such instances, ORR shall notify the referring agency and work with the referring agency, including by requesting additional information, in accordance with statutory time frames for transferring unaccompanied children to ORR.

Comment:

One commenter recommended not using the term “unaccompanied alien child,” arguing that the word “alien” is dehumanizing.

Response:

ORR agrees with the commenter and did not use the term “alien” in the proposed rule unless directly quoting the HSA or TVPRA. Similarly, in the final rule, ORR has updated the defined term “unaccompanied alien child,” as used in the HSA and TVPRA, to “unaccompanied child.”

Final Rule Action:

After consideration of public comments, ORR is finalizing the definition of “unaccompanied child/children” as proposed.

Section 410.1002 ORR Care and Placement of Unaccompanied Children

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1002, a description of ORR's authority to coordinate and implement the care and placement of unaccompanied children who are in ORR custody by reason of their immigration status (88 FR 68916). ORR notes that this substantive requirement is aligned with the requirement established in the 2019 Final Rule at 45 CFR 410.102(a), concerning the scope of authority of ORR regarding the care and placement of unaccompanied children. That section of the 2019 Final Rule was not found to be inconsistent with the FSA by the 9th Circuit in

Flores

v.

Rosen,

but as discussed in section III.B.3 of this final rule, the 2019 Final Rule in its entirety is currently enjoined and will be superseded by the standards implemented in this final rule. Changes throughout this subpart to the standards set by the 2019 Final Rule are explained where relevant.

Comment:

One commenter recommended that ORR include additional language to § 410.1002 to mention particular attention and respect for human rights for extremely high-risk populations and explicitly stating that ORR takes into consideration the child's Indigenous identity, membership, and or citizenship of a Native Nation.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter. Under § 410.1003(a), ORR requires that within all placements, unaccompanied children shall be treated with dignity, respect, and special concern for their particular vulnerability, which would include any considerations which would make the child high-risk. Additionally, under the definition of “best interest,” ORR is required to consider the unaccompanied child's cultural background, which would include membership or citizenship of a Native Nation.

Final Rule Action:

After consideration of public comments, ORR is finalizing § 410.1002 as proposed.

Section 410.1003 General Principles That Apply to the Care and Placement of Unaccompanied Children

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1003, to describe principles that would apply to the care and placement for unaccompanied children in its custody (88 FR 68916 through 68917). These principles are based on ORR's statutory duties to provide care and custody for unaccompanied children in a manner that is consistent with their best interests.

67

ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1003(a), that for all placements, unaccompanied children shall be treated with dignity, respect, and special concern for their particular vulnerability as unaccompanied children. In addition to ORR's statutory authorities, finalizing this proposal is consistent with the substantive criteria set forth at paragraph 11 of the FSA, and current ORR policies.

ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1003(b), that ORR shall hold unaccompanied children in facilities that are safe and sanitary and that are consistent with ORR's concern for the particular vulnerability of unaccompanied children. Finalizing this proposal is consistent with the substantive requirement from paragraph 12A of the FSA that “[f]ollowing arrest, the INS shall hold minors in facilities that are safe and sanitary and that are consistent with the INS's concern for the particular vulnerability of minors.” ORR noted that although this provision applies to the arrest and detention of unaccompanied children prior to their placement in an ORR care provider facility, and not to unaccompanied children after they are placed in ORR's care, ORR proposed in the NPRM to adopt this standard for its facilities and custody of unaccompanied children as well. ORR also noted that it proposed in the NPRM the phrasing “the particular vulnerability of unaccompanied children” as opposed to “the particular vulnerability of minors,” as it believed that the specific vulnerability of the population of unaccompanied children should be considered when providing them with safe and sanitary conditions.

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1003(c), that it would be required

to plan and provide care and services based on the individual needs of and focusing on the strengths of the unaccompanied child. As a complementary provision, ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1003(d), to encourage unaccompanied children, as developmentally appropriate and in their best interests, to be active participants in ORR's decision-making process relating to their care and placement. ORR believes that these collaborative approaches to care provision allow for the recognition of each child's specific needs and strengths while providing opportunities for unaccompanied children to become more empowered, resilient, and self-efficacious.

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1003(e), to codify a requirement that care of unaccompanied children be tailored to the individualized needs of each unaccompanied child in ORR custody, ensuring the interests of the child are considered, and that unaccompanied children are protected from traffickers and other persons seeking to victimize or otherwise engage them in criminal, harmful, or exploitative activity,

68

both while in ORR custody and upon release from the UC Program. ORR recognizes the utmost importance of protecting unaccompanied children from traffickers and other persons seeking to victimize or otherwise engage in harmful activities, including unscrupulous employers. ORR believes the provisions that were proposed at § 410.1003(e) reinforce ORR's commitment to ensuring the best interests of unaccompanied children are considered and actions are taken to safeguard them from harm. ORR also believes that codifying the requirement to consider each unaccompanied child's individualized needs reinforces that unaccompanied children will be assessed by ORR to determine whether they may require particular services and treatment while in the UC Program, such as to address the ramifications of a history of severe neglect or abuse, as provided for in paragraph 7 of the FSA.

Consistent with the substantive criteria set forth in the TVPRA, 8 U.S.C. 1232(c)(2)(A), ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1003(f) to require that unaccompanied children be promptly placed in the least restrictive setting that is in the best interest of the child, with placement considerations including danger to self; danger to the community; and runaway risk, as defined in § 410.1001. In addition to ORR's statutory authorities, finalizing the proposal is consistent with the substantive criteria set forth at paragraph 11 of the FSA, and current ORR policies.

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1003(g), to require consultation with parents, legal guardians, child advocates, and attorneys of record or DOJ Accredited Representatives as needed when requesting information or consent from all unaccompanied children.

Comment:

One commenter generally supported § 410.1003, stating that the provisions are tailored to the individualized needs of unaccompanied children and ensure protection from individuals who seek to exploit or victimize unaccompanied children like human traffickers and employers.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter for their comment.

Comment:

A few commenters noted that the proposed rule alternated between stating what ORR “shall” do and state what ORR does in the present tense. Those commenters noted in § 410.1003, paragraph (a) states that “unaccompanied children shall be treated with dignity, respect, and special concern” while paragraph (f) states “ORR places each unaccompanied child in the least restrictive setting that is in the best interests of the child.” The commenters recommended that the Final Rule should consistently use “shall” rather than the present tense.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their comment. Although ORR intends for statements in the present tense in the regulation to be mandatory, for the sake of clarity, ORR will revise § 410.1003(f) to include the mandatory language “shall.” This revision makes the language consistent with § 410.1103(a). ORR further notes that it has made this revision throughout the finalized regulation text for consistency, clarity, and explicit alignment with ORR's statutory authorities and the FSA.

Comment:

One commenter requested more clarity as to what standards are applicable to what types of programs, stating that in some sections the document is specific that principles are for standard and restrictive placements, inferring they are not applicable to emergency intake sites (EIS) and influx care facilities (ICF) but that in other sections the document is silent as to types of programs, leaving areas of ambiguity.

Response:

As stated in finalized § 410.1301, the standards in subpart D apply to standard programs and secure facilities, and to other care provider facilities and PRS providers where specified. The standards for EIFs are in subpart I. If a requirement or standard states that it is for “all care provider facilities,” then that includes standard programs, restrictive placements, and EIFs. Additionally, the principles articulated in § 410.1003 refer to “all placements,” and therefore apply to all ORR placements without regard to the type of facility.

Comment:

One commenter recommended that ORR add language to make clear that requirements for ORR to treat children with dignity, respect and special concern for their vulnerability under paragraph (a), applies to ORR staff, the staff of ORR subcontracted facilities, and any other stakeholder or interested person who interacts with the child while the child remains in the custody of ORR, or during the child's transport to or from an ORR care provider.

Response:

ORR appreciates the commenter's comment. ORR notes, however, that these are general provisions that relate to ORR. Specifics about the requirements of care provider facilities, transportation, and other interested parties are in other parts of the regulation, such as §§ 410.1302, 410.1304, 410.1401, 410.1801. Those specific requirements are to ensure that unaccompanied children are treated with dignity, respect, and special concern for their particular vulnerability.

Comment:

One commenter expressed concern that the proposed rule did not provide clear guidance on how to determine the best interests of the child in various situations, such as when there are conflicting preferences or claims from different sponsors, when there are concerns about the safety or suitability of a sponsor, or when there are special needs or circumstances of the child. The commenter expressed concerns that this would lead to confusion and inconsistency in decision-making, and potentially compromise the rights and well-being of the child. The commenter recommended that the final rule provide clear and comprehensive guidance on how to determine and apply the best interests of the child principle in various situations, taking into account the views and preferences of the child, the characteristics and circumstances of the sponsor, and the relevant legal and policy frameworks. The commenter also stated that the rule should provide for independent review and oversight of best interests determinations by qualified professionals.

Response:

The definition of best interest includes a non-exhaustive list of factors to consider, as appropriate, when evaluating a child's best interests. The list is necessarily non-exhaustive because each child is unique and has

individual needs, background, and circumstances but the rule is explicit in emphasizing the importance of making decisions in the child's best interest.

Regarding the recommendation for independent review and oversight of determinations of best interest, ORR notes that it may appoint child advocates for victims of trafficking and other vulnerable children who are independent, qualified professionals who provide best interests determinations (BIDs). ORR considers such BIDs when making decisions regarding the care, placement, and release of unaccompanied children. Additionally, the rule provides for review of placement decisions, in subpart J, and an independent Office of the Ombuds, in subpart K.

Comment:

Several commenters recommended that ORR include language affirmatively stating ORR's obligations to protect unaccompanied children in its care from discriminatory treatment and abuse, expressing concern over States adopting legislation that dismantles anti-discrimination protections for LGBTQI+ people.

Response:

ORR agrees with the need to protect LGBTQI+ individuals from discrimination and believes that the language finalized at § 410.1003(a) protects unaccompanied children in its care from discriminatory treatment and abuse because it establishes the general principle that unaccompanied children shall be treated with dignity, respect, and special concern for their particular vulnerability. Further, as provided in current policy, ORR requires care provider facilities to operate their programs following certain guiding principles, including ensuring that LGBTQI+ children are treated with dignity and respect, receive recognition of their sexual orientation and/or gender identity, are not discriminated against or harassed based on actual or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity, and are cared for in an inclusive and respectful environment.

Comment:

Some commenters expressed support for the proposal in paragraph (d) that unaccompanied children be active participants in ORR's decision-making process related to their care and placement.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their support.

Comment:

One commenter recommended that ORR require that Indigenous cultural and language experts be required in the consultation process for Indigenous children to provide their free, prior, and informed consent.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter but notes that the suggestion is not required by statute or the FSA. ORR notes that it is finalizing language access requirements in § 410.1306.

Comment:

One commenter recommended that ORR collaborate with non-governmental organizations and advocacy groups that are actively working in the field of child protection as they often have valuable insights and resources that can contribute significantly to the cause.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenter and notes that it currently collaborates with and seeks input from advocacy groups and service providers, and that it intends to continue that practice under this final rule.

Comment:

One commenter recommended that ORR prioritize identifying and adding facilities throughout the United States in more populous areas to ensure adequate access for children to legal, medical, and other services and to ease the burden on community organizations.

Response:

ORR appreciates the commenter's recommendation and does consider whether the area is populous and the availability of services among many other factors when adding facilities through the United States. ORR notes, however, that it is limited by the grant and contract applications it receives and the locations in which qualifying proposals are located. ORR further notes that this rule does not address site selection for care provider facilities, and therefore it does not believe a change to the rule text concerning site selection is appropriate.

Comment:

A few commenters recommended ORR have local law enforcement, county oversight, and State oversight regarding the nature of their operations in respective jurisdictions.

Response:

ORR notes that local law enforcement and county and State Governments do have oversight into aspects of the care of unaccompanied children. For example, local law enforcement agencies investigate and prosecute State crimes, and State and local Governments license and investigate care provider facilities with respect to licensing requirements and allegations of child abuse and neglect. ORR notes that the role of local law enforcement and child protective services and licensing entities in the context of the UC Program is also discussed in the preamble to the Interim Final Rule, Standards to Prevent, Detect, and Respond to Sexual Abuse and Sexual Harassment Involving Unaccompanied Children, codified at 45 CFR part 411.

69

Accordingly, ORR does not believe a revision to the rule is needed to specifically describe the role of State and local Governments as suggested.

Final Rule Action:

After consideration of public comments, ORR is revising paragraph (f) to read “In making placement determinations, ORR shall place each unaccompanied child in the least restrictive setting that is in the best interests of the child, giving consideration to the child's danger to self, danger to others, and runaway risk.” All other paragraphs will be finalized as proposed.

Section 410.1004 ORR Custody of Unaccompanied Children

ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1004 to describe the scope of ORR's custody of unaccompanied children (88 FR 68917). Consistent with its statutory authorities and the FSA, the provision specifies that all unaccompanied children placed by ORR in care provider facilities remain in the legal custody of ORR and may be transferred or released only with ORR approval.

70

The provision also provides that in the event of an emergency, a care provider facility may transfer temporary physical custody of an unaccompanied child prior to securing approval from ORR but shall notify ORR of the transfer as soon as is practicable thereafter, and in all cases within 8 hours.

71

Comment:

One commenter expressed concern that § 410.1004 uses the term “legal custody” without defining it. The commenter noted that custody can include actual, constructive, or legal custody and argued that if ORR claims legal custody over unaccompanied children, not just actual or constructive custody, it should outline all legal responsibilities owed or held over the child whether pursuant to Federal or State law.

Response:

ORR interprets the term “legal custody” consistent with its statutory authorities and with its usage in the FSA. The TVPRA makes HHS responsible, consistent with the HSA, for the “care and custody” of unaccompanied children.

72

The HSA makes ORR responsible for “coordinating and implementing the care and placement of unaccompanied alien children who are in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status.”

73

The FSA uses the term “legal custody” to define the scope of the agreement and of specific provisions.

74

ORR notes that in these contexts, it is assumed that ORR has the ability to provide care and supervision for children. So, consistent with a prior ruling interpreting the FSA, ORR understands the term “legal custody” to signify “the right and responsibility to

care for the well-being of the child and make decisions on the child's behalf.”

75

Final Rule Action:

After consideration of public comments, ORR is finalizing § 410.1004 as proposed.

Subpart B—Determining the Placement of an Unaccompanied Child at a Care Provider Facility

In the NPRM, ORR proposed in subpart B to codify the criteria and requirements that apply to the placement of unaccompanied children at particular types of care provider facilities (88 FR 68917 through 68927). The HSA makes ORR responsible for, among other things, “coordinating and implementing the care and placement of unaccompanied alien children who are in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status,” “making placement determinations for all unaccompanied alien children who are in Federal custody by reason of their immigration status,” “implementing the placement determinations,” and “implementing policies with respect to the care and placement of unaccompanied alien children.”

76

In addition, ORR stated in the NPRM that proposed subpart B clarifies and strengthens placement criteria to better ensure appropriate placement based on each unaccompanied child's individual background, characteristics, and needs. ORR stated that it believes that these provisions can help to protect the interests of unaccompanied children in ORR care by supporting safe and appropriate placement in the least restrictive setting appropriate to the child's age and individualized needs, consistent with existing legal requirements and child welfare best practices.

Section 410.1100 Purpose of This Subpart

ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1100 that the purpose of subpart B is to set forth the process by which ORR receives referrals from other Federal agencies and the factors ORR considers when placing an unaccompanied child in a particular care provider facility (88 FR 68917). In addition, ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1100 to clarify that, as used in this subpart, “placement determinations” or “placements” refers to placements in ORR-approved care provider facilities during the time an unaccompanied child is in ORR care, and not to the location of an unaccompanied child once the child is released in accordance with provisions in subpart C.

ORR did not receive any comments on proposed § 410.1100.

Final Rule Action:

ORR is finalizing this section as proposed.

Section 410.1101 Process for the Placement of an Unaccompanied Child After Referral From Another Federal Agency

ORR proposed in the NPRM, at § 410.1101, to codify the process for accepting referrals of unaccompanied children from another Federal agency and for placement of an unaccompanied child in a care provider facility upon such referral (88 FR 68917 through 68919). The TVPRA at 8 U.S.C. 1232(b)(3) requires any department or agency of the Federal Government that has an unaccompanied child in its custody to transfer the custody of such unaccompanied child to HHS no later than 72 hours after determining that the child is an unaccompanied child (unless there are exceptional circumstances ).

77

ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1101(a) to accept referrals of unaccompanied children transferred to its custody pursuant to the TVPRA (88 FR 68917). Further, consistent with existing policy and in cooperation with referring agencies, ORR proposed in the NPRM that it would accept such referrals at any time of day, every day of the year. In addition, ORR stated in the preamble to the NPRM that it may seek clarification about the information provided by the referring agency. ORR notes that it may seek such clarification as needed to determine appropriate placement and how the referred individual meets the statutory definition of unaccompanied child. ORR stated that in such instances, it shall notify the referring agency and work with the referring agency, including by requesting additional information, in accordance with statutory timeframes for transferring unaccompanied children to ORR.

ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1101(b) and (c), timeframes for identifying and notifying a referring Federal agency of ORR's identification of an appropriate placement for an unaccompanied child, and for accepting transfer of custody of an unaccompanied child after the determination that the child is an unaccompanied child who should be transferred to ORR (88 FR 68917 through 68918). ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1101(b) to codify its current policy that upon notification from any department or agency of the Federal Government that a child is an unaccompanied child and therefore must be transferred to ORR custody, ORR must identify an appropriate placement for the unaccompanied child and notify the referring Federal agency within 24 hours of receiving the referring agency's notification whenever possible, and no later than 48 hours of receiving the referring agency's notification, barring exceptional circumstances (see paragraph below). ORR stated in the NPRM that it believes that setting a maximum timeframe of 48 hours for ORR to identify a placement and notify a referring Federal agency of ORR's identification of a placement would help to expedite transfer of unaccompanied children from the referring Federal agency to ORR care, but also that certain exceptions to this timeframe may be necessary in certain circumstances, as discussed in the following paragraph. ORR further proposed in § 410.1101(c) that it would be required to work with the referring Federal department or agency to accept transfer of custody of the unaccompanied child, consistent with the statutory requirements at 8 U.S.C. 1232(b)(3).

As noted above, the TVPRA provides that referring Federal departments and agencies must transfer custody of unaccompanied children to HHS within 72 hours of determining the child is an unaccompanied child unless there are exceptional circumstances. In order to help facilitate this requirement in coordination with referring departments and agencies, ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1101(b) and (c) internal timeframes for ORR to identify and notify referring Federal departments and agencies of placements and to accept transfer of custody from referring departments and agencies (88 FR 68917 through 68918). ORR also noted that it may, in certain “exceptional circumstances,” be unable to timely identify placements for and help facilitate other departments' and agencies' timely transfers of unaccompanied children to its custody. For purposes of § 410.1101(b) and (c), ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1101(d) circumstances which would prevent ORR from timely identifying a placement for an unaccompanied child or accepting transfer of custody. At proposed § 410.1101(d), ORR described these exceptional circumstances consistent with those described in paragraph 12A of the FSA, even though, as ORR further explains below, it believes that paragraph 12A primarily concerns responsibilities of the former INS that now apply to immigration enforcement authorities and not ORR. Some of these circumstances were also incorporated into the 2019 Final Rule at § 410.202. The proposed “exceptional circumstances,” for ORR's purposes,

included the following: (1) any court decree or court-approved settlement that requires otherwise; (2) an influx, as defined in proposed § 410.1001; (3) an emergency, including a natural disaster, such as an earthquake or hurricane, and other events, such as facility fires or civil disturbances; (4) a medical emergency, such as a viral epidemic or pandemic among a group of unaccompanied children; (5) the apprehension of an unaccompanied child in a remote location; and (6) the apprehension of an unaccompanied child whom the referring agency indicates (i) poses a danger to self or others; or (ii) has been charged with or convicted of a crime, or is the subject of delinquency proceedings, a delinquency charge, or has been adjudicated delinquent, and additional information is essential in order to determine an appropriate ORR placement. Notably, ORR stated in the preamble to the proposed rule that the unavailability of documents will not necessarily prevent the prompt transfer of a child to ORR. In addition, ORR proposed in the NPRM that “exceptional circumstances,” for ORR's purposes, would include an act or event that could not be reasonably foreseen that prevents the placement or accepting transfer of custody of an unaccompanied child within the proposed timeframes. Given the mandate under the TVPRA, 8 U.S.C. 1232(c)(2), that ORR place an unaccompanied child in the least restrictive setting that is in the best interests of the unaccompanied child, subject to consideration of danger to self, danger to the community/others, and risk of flight, additional time may be needed in some circumstances to determine the most appropriate and safe placement that comports with the best interests of the unaccompanied child. Thus, ORR stated that it believes that this general exception for acts or events that could not be reasonably foreseen is appropriate to afford additional time to assess these considerations, though ORR is mindful of avoiding prolonged placements in DHS facilities that are not designed for the long-term care of children. As discussed previously, ORR proposed in the NPRM that these exceptional circumstances would modify the timeframes applicable to ORR under proposed § 410.1101(b) and (c).

In the NPRM, ORR noted that the FSA also includes an exception to these timeframe requirements for unaccompanied children who do not speak English and for whom an interpreter is unavailable. However, ORR did not propose to include this as an exceptional circumstance for purposes of § 410.1101(b) and (c). ORR stated that because ORR is able to serve unaccompanied children regardless of their primary language through the use of interpreters, ORR did not view this as an insurmountable impediment to the prompt placement of unaccompanied children. In addition, ORR noted that the FSA includes an exception in which a reasonable person would conclude that an individual is an adult despite the individual's claim to be an unaccompanied child. However, ORR did not propose to include this as an exceptional circumstance for purposes of § 410.1101(b) and (c) because ORR did not believe that such a situation poses the type of urgency inherent in exceptional circumstances as described above. For further information on ORR's proposed policies regarding age determinations, ORR referred readers to its discussion of subpart H.

In the NPRM, ORR stated that it seeks to accept transfer of unaccompanied children as quickly as possible after a placement has been identified within this timeframe (88 FR 68918). In identifying placements for unaccompanied children, ORR balances the need for expeditious identification of placement with the need to ensure safe and appropriate placement in the best interests of the unaccompanied child, which necessitates a comprehensive review of information regarding an unaccompanied child's background and needs before placement. ORR stated in the NPRM that, under existing policy, to determine the appropriate placement for an unaccompanied child, ORR requests and assesses extensive background information on the unaccompanied child from the referring department or agency, including the following: (1) how the referring agency made the determination that the child is an unaccompanied child; (2) health related information; (3) whether the unaccompanied child has any medication or prescription information, including how many days' supply of the medication will be provided with the unaccompanied child when the child is transferred into ORR custody; (4) biographical and biometric information, such as name, gender, alien number, date of birth, country of birth and nationality, date(s) of entry and apprehension, place of entry and apprehension, manner of entry, and the unaccompanied child's current location; (5) any information concerning whether the unaccompanied child is a victim of trafficking or other crimes; (6) whether the unaccompanied child was apprehended with a sibling or other relative; (7) identifying information and contact information for a parent, legal guardian, or other related adult providing care for the unaccompanied child prior to apprehension, if known, and information regarding whether the unaccompanied child was separated from a parent, legal guardian, or adult relative after apprehension, and the reason for separation; (8) if the unaccompanied child was apprehended in transit to a final destination, what the final destination was and who the unaccompanied child planned to meet or live with at that destination, if known; (9) whether the unaccompanied child is a runaway risk, and if so, the runaway risk indicators; (10) any information on a history of violence, juvenile or criminal background, or gang involvement known or suspected, risk of danger to self or others, State court proceedings, or probation; (11) if the unaccompanied child is being returned to ORR custody after arrest on alleged gang affiliation or involvement, ORR requests all documentation confirming whether the unaccompanied child is a

Saravia

class member and information on the

Saravia

hearing, including the date and time;

78

and (12) any particular needs or other information that would affect the care and placement of the unaccompanied child, including, as applicable, information about services, supports, or program modifications provided to the child on the basis of disability (88 FR 68918 through 68919).

Furthermore, the TVPRA places the responsibility for the transfer of custody on referring Federal agencies.

79

ORR custody begins when it assumes physical custody from the referring agency. ORR proposed in the NPRM at § 410.1101(e) to codify this practice, which is also consistent with current policies (88 FR 68919).

Note, ORR typically assumes physical custody when the unaccompanied child arrives at an ORR care provider facility (usually via transport by DHS). However, as described in current policies,

80

under certain extenuating and exceptional circumstances, ORR may assume physical custody of an unaccompanied child, and thereby legal custody, to facilitate release to a vetted sponsor without first placing the child at an ORR care provider facility. In these cases, federal partner agencies may notify ORR that a child will likely be determined to be unaccompanied. ORR may request additional information from the referring agency, or third-party partners, regarding any potential sponsors for the child, to begin the sponsor vetting process.

81

Comment:

A few commenters generally expressed support for the timeframes at proposed § 410.1101(b) and (c). These commenters supported the proposed timeframes for ORR to work with the referring department or agency to accept custody of unaccompanied children (within the 72 hour requirement applicable to the transferring agency under the TVPRA) and identify an initial placement (no later than 48 hours) because the proposed timeframes ensure that unaccompanied children are not held in detention in a restrictive setting at DHS or other referring agencies and recognize that children are best cared for by social welfare officers and not by immigration officials.

Response:

ORR thanks commenters for their support of the proposed timeframes at § 410.1101(b) and (c). ORR notes that it is making a clarifying edit to add the phrase “in its custody” to the first sentence of paragraph (b) to clarify that, consistent with the TVPRA, a referring Federal department or agency must transfer unaccompanied children “in its custody” to ORR. This sentence now states, “Upon notification from any department or agency of the Federal Government that a child in its custody is an unaccompanied child and therefore must be transferred to ORR custody . . .”.

Comment:

Two commenters made recommendations regarding the notification and transfer process. One commenter recommended “vigorous” collaboration between ORR and other agencies and a clear description of responsibilities of these agencies to ensure effective implementation. Another commenter suggested that ORR consider codifying potential border unifications of children. The commenter noted that cases have recently been started while children are still in CBP custody, and that co-location of ORR providers with CBP could allow many parent and legal guardian sponsors to reunify with unaccompanied children without transferring the child to an ORR shelter. The commenter further stated this could also allow non-parent family members who are traveling with the child (grandparents, aunts, etc.) to submit the necessary documents to sponsor the child without ever needing to be separated.

Response:

ORR thanks the commenters for their recommendations. With regard to the recommendation that there be “vigorous” collaboration between ORR and other agencies and a clear description of responsibilities to ensure effective implementation, ORR notes that ORR does in fact collaborate closely with referring agencies, including CBP, during the referral of unaccompanied children to ORR custody. For example, as specifically set forth at § 410.1101(c), as finalized in this rule, ORR works with the referring department or agency to accept transfer of custody of the unaccompanied child, consistent with the timeframe set forth in the TVPRA.

82

Furthermore, under existing policy, and as reflected in the NPRM, to determine the appropriate placement for an unaccompanied child, ORR requests and assesses extensive background information on the unaccompanied child from the referring agency, which ORR takes into consideration in placing a child in an ORR care provider facility. In addition, as ORR stated in the preamble to the NPRM, it may seek clarification about the information provided by the referring agency as needed to determine appropriate placement and how the referred individual meets the statutory definition of unaccompanied child (88 FR 68917). In such instances, ORR shall notify the referring agency and work with the referring agency, including by requesting additional information, in accordance with statutory time frames for transferring unaccompanied children to ORR. ORR has added language to the regulatory text at § 410.1101 to make more explicit the nature of this coordination.

Moreover, DHS and ORR are continuing to work together to improve information sharing and will collaborate on improved procedures for making age determinations, as required by the TVPRA, and other standards for determining whether an individual meets the statutory definition of unaccompanied child. The Departments will update existing memoranda of agreement, as appropriate. Seeking clarification will not preclude transfer of individuals determined by the referring agency to be unaccompanied children in accordance with statutory time frames, except in exceptional circumstances.

In regard to the suggestion to codify potential border unifications of unaccompanied children, ORR notes that this final rule codifies existing interagency practices regarding notification and transfer of unaccompanied children to ORR custody from other Federal agencies, consistent with requirements set out in the TVPRA. ORR is also currently operating an initiative to facilitate unification of unaccompanied children with their sponsors while minimizing the child's time in ORR custody. Because the standards codified in this final rule accord with current practices and are consistent with the statutory framework established by the HSA and TVPRA, ORR will finalize the current sections as proposed. But ORR notes that it may in the future consider alternative approaches, including approaches like the one raised in the comment.

Comment:

Two commenters made recommendations or raised questions to clarify the language at proposed § 410.1101(d), which addresses exceptions to the timeframes at proposed § 410.1101(b) and (c). One commenter stated that proposed § 410.1101(d) is ambiguous, noting that while “exceptional circumstances” may be valid explanations for slower-than-required placements, an exceptional circumstance should not give license for ORR to place a child in care more slowly after a referral. The commenter stated that ORR should move with all due haste to place children in safe placements even in “exceptional circumstances” and recommended that ORR refine the rule to clarify that it always attempts to identify an appropriate placement within 48 hours but that such a timeframe may not be possible to achieve during exceptional circumstances. This commenter also noted that the proposed rule preamble states that “the unavailability of documents will not necessarily prevent the prompt transfer of a child to ORR.” The commenter recommended that this assurance be binding on ORR as it is minimally burdensome and suggested that ORR add language to this effect to any final rule.

One commenter asked whether § 410.1101(d)(6) means that secure and staff secure placements do not have to fall within the 48-hour placement timeline.

Response:

ORR notes that § 410.1101(b) already provides that ORR shall identify an appropriate placement for the unaccompanied child and notify the referring Federal agency within 24 hours of receiving the referring agency's notification “whenever possible,” and “no later than within 48 hours of receiving notification, barring exceptional circumstances” (88 FR 68918). As a result, the rule already contemplates that ORR seeks to identify a placement as quickly as reasonably possible upon notification from a referring department or agency that a child is an unaccompanied child, including in situations where exceptional circumstances may apply. ORR does not view the proposed exceptional circumstances as a license to act more slowly in identifying an appropriate placement, but only as reasonable explanations for why it may not be possible to meet the proposed

timeframes despite ORR's efforts to do so in those exceptional cases.

In addition, as one commenter noted, the proposed rule preamble states, with respect to proposed § 410.1101(d)(6), that “the unavailability of documents will not necessarily prevent the prompt transfer of a child to ORR.” In proposed § 410.1101(d)(6)(ii), ORR added language at the end of the provision to qualify when the exceptional circumstance in paragraph (d)(6)(ii) would apply—that is, when “additional information is essential in order to determine an appropriate ORR placement” (88 FR 68918). To further clarify and qualify the application of this exception, ORR noted in the NPRM preamble that “the unavailability of documents will not necessarily prevent the prompt transfer of a child to ORR.” This language was intended to recognize the fact that in some cases, lack of appropriate information or documentation may not prevent ORR from timely identifying a placement or facilitating transfer of custody, and in those cases, ORR must comply with the proposed timeframes at § 410.1101(b) and (c). Thus, this language was intended to make clear ORR's limited use of this exception. As ORR believes the intent is sufficiently clear from the preamble text, ORR does not believe it is necessary to add language to this effect to the final rule.

Given these clarifications, ORR emphasizes that proposed § 410.1101(d)(6) does not mean that secure and heightened supervision placements do not have to meet the timeframes established in this section. First, as discussed above, this exception is not a license to act more slowly in situations that may fall within this proposed exception—ORR must still act expeditiously to identify placement within 48 hours to the extent possible. Second, not all secure or heightened supervision placements may meet the criteria set forth in proposed § 410.1101(d)(6)—for example, since as noted above and in the proposed regulation, in order to qualify for the exception at § 410.1101(d)(6)(ii), additional information must be essential in order to determine an appropriate ORR placement, and where it is not essential, as discussed above, the unavailability of documents will not necessarily prevent the prompt identification of a placement.

Comment:

A few commenters expressed concern about the proposed timeframes at § 410.1101(b) and (c), stating that speed should never take priority over the safety and well-being of the children. One commenter also expressed concern with ORR's ability to meet the proposed timeframes.

Response:

ORR does not agree that the proposed timeframes at § 410.1101(b) and (c) will result in expediency taking priority over the safety and well-being of unaccompanied children. As an initial matter, ORR notes that the timelines described in this section are consistent with statutory timelines provided in the TVPRA.

83

In addition, ORR believes that the proposed timeframes are reasonable and achievable while transferring custody and identifying placements in the best interests of the unaccompanied child. ORR notes that, in fiscal year 2023, ORR placed 99 percent of unaccompanied children in standard programs within 24 hours of receiving notification of their referrals. As noted in the NPRM, ORR balances the need for expeditious identification of placement with the need to ensure safe and appropriate placement in the best interests of the unaccompanied child, which involves a comprehensive review of information regarding an unaccompanied child's background and needs before placement. As further discussed in the NPRM, additional time may be needed in some circumstances to determine the most appropriate and safe placement that comports with the best interests of the unaccompanied child. Thus, ORR proposed in the NPRM to codify at § 410.1101(d) certain “exceptional circumstances” where it may be unable to timely identify placements for or facilitate other agencies' timely transfers of unaccompanied children to its custody in accordance with proposed § 410.1101(b) and (c) (88 FR 68918). ORR believes that codification of these exceptional circumstances will provide ORR the flexibility necessary to ensure the safety and well-being of each child are fully taken into account before a child is placed with a care provider facility.

Comment:

Many commenters expressed concerns regarding specific exceptional circumstances set forth at proposed § 410.1101(d).

One commenter stated that ORR inappropriately defined influx as an “exceptional circumstance” at proposed § 410.1101(d)(2) that allows ORR to relieve itself of the duty to receive a child from other Federal agencies within 72 hours. The commenter stated that promulgating this proposal would allow ORR to absolve itself of the responsibility to comply with the terms of the FSA when it presents challenges to the agency, directly risking the safety of unaccompanied children. The commenter believed that ORR should be held to higher scrutiny, not less, when its facilities are overwhelmed because it is at these times that unaccompanied children are at heightened risk for exploitation, abuse, and mismanagement. The commenter requested that HHS make data available to the public regarding how frequently “emergency” or “influx” conditions are present.

A few commenters opposed the proposed exception at § 410.1101(d)(3) because it includes language that is beyond what is enumerated in the FSA. Specifically, the commenters noted that proposed § 410.1101(d)(3) states that an emergency would include “a natural disaster, such as an earthquake or hurricane, and other events, such as facility fires or civil disturban

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Unaccompanied Children Program Foundational Rule · 89 FR 34384 | Frix