Facilitating the LIBOR Transition Consistent With the LIBOR Act (Regulation Z)
Federal RegisterMay 11, 2023
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
CONSUMER FINANCIAL PROTECTION BUREAU
12 CFR Part 1026
[Docket No. CFPB-2023-0030]
RIN 3170-AB19
Facilitating the LIBOR Transition Consistent With the LIBOR Act (Regulation Z)
AGENCY:
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
ACTION:
Interim final rule with request for public comment.
SUMMARY:
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB or Bureau) is issuing an interim final rule amending Regulation Z, which implements the Truth in Lending Act (TILA), to reflect the enactment of the Adjustable Interest Rate (LIBOR) Act (the LIBOR Act or Act) and its implementing regulation promulgated by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Board). This interim final rule further addresses the planned cessation of most U.S. Dollar (USD) LIBOR tenors after June 30, 2023, by incorporating the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans into Regulation Z. This interim final rule conforms the terminology from the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation into relevant Regulation Z open-end and closed-end credit provisions and also addresses treatment of the 12-month USD LIBOR index and its replacement index, including permitting creditors to use alternative language in change-in-terms notice content requirements for situations where the 12-month tenor of the LIBOR index is being replaced consistent with the LIBOR Act. The CFPB requests public comment on this interim final rule.
DATES:
This interim final rule is effective May 15, 2023. Comments must be received on or before June 12, 2023.
ADDRESSES:
You may submit comments, identified by Docket No. CFPB-2023-0030 or RIN 3170-AB19, by any of the following methods:
•
Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://www.regulations.gov.
Follow the instructions for submitting comments.
•
Email: 2023-LIBOR-IFR@cfpb.gov.
Include Docket No. CFPB-2023-0030 or RIN 3170-AB19 in the subject line of the message.
•
Mail/Hand Delivery/Courier:
Comment Intake—LIBOR, c/o Legal Division Docket Manager, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, 1700 G Street NW, Washington, DC 20552. Because paper mail in the Washington, DC area and at the CFPB is subject to delay, commenters are encouraged to submit comments electronically.
Instructions:
The CFPB encourages the early submission of comments. All submissions must include the document title and docket number. Please note the number of the topic on which you are commenting at the top of each response (you do not need to address all topics). In general, all comments received will be posted without change to
https://www.regulations.gov.
All comments, including attachments and other supporting materials, will become part of the public record and subject to public disclosure. Proprietary information or sensitive personal information, such as account numbers or Social Security numbers, or names of other individuals, should not be included. Comments will not be edited to remove any identifying or contact information.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Krista Ayoub, Lanique Eubanks, Angela Fox, or Kristen Phinnessee, Senior Counsels, Office of Regulations, at 202-435-7700. If you require this document in an alternative electronic format, please contact
CFPB_Accessibility@cfpb.gov.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Summary of the Interim Final Rule
The CFPB is issuing this interim final rule amending Regulation Z, which implements TILA, for both open-end and closed-end credit to make changes consistent with the LIBOR Act and its implementing regulation issued by the Board and further address the planned cessation of LIBOR.
1
These changes amend and update the CFPB's Facilitating the LIBOR Transition (Regulation Z) final rule published in the
Federal Register
on December 8, 2021 (2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule).
2
In general, the interim final rule makes several conforming terminology changes to align with the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation. In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally had provided examples of certain indices, including spread-adjusted Secured Overnight Financing Rate (SOFR)-based indices, that may meet the applicable Regulation Z standards (referred to hereafter as SOFR-based replacement indices) for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but it reserved judgment about whether to include references to a 1-year (or 12-month) USD LIBOR index and its SOFR-based replacement index. The CFPB is now also conforming Regulation Z with the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation by adding such references with respect to the SOFR-based replacement for the 12-month tenor of LIBOR. This interim final rule does not in any way alter or modify the Bureau's determination in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule in relation to the prime rate as a replacement index. As discussed in part VI, this interim final rule will take effect on May 15, 2023. The CFPB solicits comment on this interim final rule.
1
When amending the Official Interpretations, the Office of the Federal Register requires reprinting of certain sections being amended in their entirety rather than providing more targeted amendatory instructions. The sections of regulatory text and the Official Interpretations included in this document show the language of those sections. In addition, the Bureau is releasing an unofficial, informal redline to assist industry and other stakeholders in reviewing the changes made in this interim final rule to the regulatory text and the Official Interpretations of Regulation Z. This redline can be found on the Bureau's website, at
https://www.consumerfinance.gov/compliance/compliance-resources/other-applicable-requirements/libor-index-transition/.
If any conflicts exist between the redline and the text of Regulation Z, its Official Interpretations, or this interim final rule, the documents published in the
Federal Register
are the controlling documents.
2
86 FR 69716 (Dec. 8, 2021).
A. Open-End Credit
The CFPB is amending several open-end credit provisions in Regulation Z. First, the CFPB is changing the terminology used in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule to make it consistent with terminology in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation. Specifically, as discussed in further detail below, the CFPB is replacing all references to the “index based on SOFR recommended by the Alternative Reference Rates Committee for consumer products” with “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and adding a new definition for that term in § 1026.2(a)(28). For this new definition and throughout this interim final rule, the CFPB is using the term 12-month tenor instead of the 1-year tenor with respect to the USD LIBOR index to align with the terminology used in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation. These changes are set forth in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii) and related comments for home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) and in § 1026.55(b)(7) and related comments for credit card accounts.
Second, the CFPB is revising the Official Interpretations to incorporate the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month LIBOR index, as prescribed by the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, as an index that has historical fluctuations
that are substantially similar to those of the 12-month USD LIBOR index it is intended to replace. Consistent with the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, the Bureau's prior determination of the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the Alternative Reference Rates Committee (ARRC) is obsolete given that “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to replace 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR indices is the same as the corresponding spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. These changes are set forth in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii) and related comments for HELOCs and in § 1026.55(b)(7) and related comments for credit card accounts.
Third, the CFPB is adding the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans that would replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index to the list of indices where a creditor is allowed to use an alternative method to disclose information about the periodic rate and annual percentage rate (APR) in change-in-terms notices for HELOCs and credit card accounts as a result of the replacement of the LIBOR index in certain circumstances. These changes are set forth in comment 9(c)(1)-4 for HELOCs and in comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii for credit card accounts.
Fourth, the CFPB is adding the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans that would replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index to the list of indices where a card issuer is allowed to use an alternative method for determining whether the card issuer can terminate its obligation under the credit card account rate reevaluation requirements where the rate applicable immediately prior to a rate increase was a variable rate calculated using a LIBOR index. The Bureau also deleted its prior determination in the Official Interpretations given that “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to replace 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR indices is the same as the corresponding spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. These changes are set forth in § 1026.59(f)(3) and comment 59(f)-4.
B. Closed-End Credit
The CFPB is also amending the closed-end credit provisions in Regulation Z. First, the CFPB is changing the terminology used in the CFPB's 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule to make it consistent with terminology in the LIBOR Act. Specifically, as discussed in further detail below, the CFPB is replacing the reference to the “index based on SOFR recommended by the Alternative Reference Rates Committee for consumer products” with a reference to “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Second, the CFPB is revising an illustrative example in the Official Interpretations to incorporate the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month LIBOR index, as prescribed by the LIBOR Act, as an index that is comparable to the 12-month USD LIBOR index it is intended to replace for purposes of the closed-end refinancing provisions. These changes are set forth in comment 20(a)(3)-ii.B.
II. Background
A. Introduction—Consumer Products Using LIBOR
Introduced in the 1980s, LIBOR (originally an acronym for London Interbank Offered Rate) was intended to measure the average rate at which a bank could obtain unsecured funding in the London interbank market for a given period, in a given currency. In the United States, financial institutions have used LIBOR as a common benchmark rate for a variety of adjustable-rate consumer financial products, including mortgages, credit cards, HELOCs, reverse mortgages, and student loans. Typically, the consumer pays an interest rate that is calculated as the sum of a benchmark index and a margin. For example, a consumer may pay an interest rate equal to the 12-month USD LIBOR plus two percentage points.
LIBOR is set to expire on June 30, 2023. Financial institutions have been developing plans and procedures to transition from the use of LIBOR indices to replacement indices for products that are being newly issued and existing accounts that were originally benchmarked to a LIBOR index. In some markets, such as for HELOCs and credit cards, the vast majority of newly originated lines of credit are already based on indices other than a LIBOR index.
B. CFPB's 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule
On December 8, 2021, the CFPB issued the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule generally to address the expected discontinuance of most U.S. Dollar (USD) tenors of LIBOR in June 2023.
3
The 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, among other things, amended open-end and closed-end provisions of Regulation Z to provide examples of replacement indices to USD LIBOR tenors that meet certain Regulation Z standards.
3
Id.
For each of these open-end and closed-end provisions, while the CFPB generally provided examples of certain indices, including SOFR-based replacement indices for 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, the CFPB reserved judgment about whether to include a SOFR-based replacement index for the 1-year (now being referred to as 12-month in this interim final rule) USD LIBOR index until it obtained additional information. The CFPB stated that once it knew which SOFR-based index the ARRC would recommend to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index for consumer products, the Bureau would consider determining whether the replacement index and replacement margin met the appropriate standards in Regulation Z and would then consider whether to codify that determination in a supplemental final rule, or otherwise announce that determination. Most provisions of the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule were effective on April 1, 2022.
4
4
October 1, 2023, is the effective date for an amendment that removes two “Legacy” post-consummation change-in-terms forms H-4(D)(2) and H-4(D)(4) in appendix H of part 1026 that still reference LIBOR, and prevents these two forms from being used to demonstrate compliance with part 1026.20.
C. The LIBOR Act
On March 15, 2022, Congress enacted the LIBOR Act as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2022.
5
Among other things, the LIBOR Act provides that the Board may identify a replacement index based on SOFR published by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York (or a successor administrator), including tenor spread adjustments, to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month tenors of USD LIBOR for any LIBOR contracts that do not otherwise specify a replacement rate fallback provision or method for selecting a fallback rate.
6
The LIBOR Act (and the Board's subsequent final rule, discussed below) identify these replacement indices as the “Board-selected benchmark replacement” index.
7
5
Public Law 117-103, div. U, 136 Stat. 825 (2022).
6
LIBOR Act section 104, 136 Stat. 828.
7
LIBOR Act section 103(6), 136 Stat. 826.
See also
12 CFR 253.2 and 253.4.
The LIBOR Act provides certain safe harbors for use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans, including stating that the Board-
selected benchmark replacements constitute replacement indices that have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of LIBOR for purposes of TILA
8
and regulations promulgated under that statute.
9
8
15 U.S.C. 1601
et seq.
9
Safe harbors provided by the LIBOR Act include, among other things, determination that use of the identified replacement indices constitute a reasonable, comparable, or analogous rate, index, or term for LIBOR, a replacement that is based on a methodology or information that is similar or comparable to LIBOR, and a replacement that has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of LIBOR for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations.
See
LIBOR Act section 105(a), 136 Stat. 830. Additionally, the safe harbors from the LIBOR Act provide that use of the identified replacement indices do not constitute, among other things, a breach of a LIBOR contract.
See
LIBOR Act section 105(b), 136 Stat. 830. Further, the LIBOR Act provides that creditors using the identified replacement indices under the specified conditions in the Act shall not be subject to any claim or cause of action in law or equity or request for equitable relief, or have liability for damages, arising out of the selection or use of the identified replacement index in the Act and the implementation of the identified changes in the Act.
See
LIBOR Act section 105(c), 136 Stat. 830.
D. Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule
The Board issued a final rule to implement the LIBOR Act on December 16, 2022, effective February 27, 2023 (Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule).
10
Among other things, the Board's final rule established benchmark replacements for contracts governed by U.S. law that reference certain tenors of USD LIBOR, including those of 1-month, 3-month, 6-month,
11
and 12-month tenors, that do not have terms that provide for the use of a clearly defined and practicable replacement benchmark rate following the cessation of LIBOR.
12
The LIBOR Act, and the Board's implementing regulation, provide for certain adjustments in general for LIBOR contracts and more specifically for LIBOR contracts that are consumer loans. Consistent with LIBOR Act, the final rule identified each of those indices as a “Board-selected benchmark replacement” for consumer loans, thereby meeting the safe harbor criteria in the LIBOR Act.
10
88 FR 5204 (Jan. 26, 2023).
11
While the Board uses “one-, three-, and six-month” to describe these tenors of USD LIBOR, for consistency with this interim final rule, this notice refers to those tenors as 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month tenors, respectively.
12
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2).
The final rule provided that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for LIBOR contracts that are consumer loans using 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month tenors of USD LIBOR during the one-year period beginning on the LIBOR replacement date shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus an amount that transitions linearly for each business day during that period from the difference between the relevant CME Term SOFR and the relevant LIBOR tenor determined as of the day immediately before the LIBOR replacement date to the applicable tenor spread adjustment identified in the final rule.
13
After expiration of that first-year period, the rule provided that the Board-selected benchmark replacements shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable tenor spread adjustment identified in the final rule.
14
Effectively, the Board-selected benchmark replacements for LIBOR contracts that are consumer loans as set forth in the Board's final rule are the indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products for the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month and 12-month USD LIBOR tenors.
15
13
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B).
14
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(ii)(B).
15
Alt. Reference Rates Comm.,
ARRC Recommended Fallbacks for Implementation of its Hardwired Fallback Language
(Mar. 15, 2023),
https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/Microsites/arrc/files/2023/ARRC-statement-on-1-3-6-12-month-USD-LIBOR.pdf.
III. Legal Authority
A. Section 1022 of the Dodd-Frank Act
The CFPB is issuing this interim final rule under Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act) section 1022(b)(1)
16
and TILA section 105(a). Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b)(1) authorizes the CFPB to prescribe rules “as may be necessary or appropriate to enable the Bureau to administer and carry out the purposes and objectives of the Federal consumer financial laws, and to prevent evasions thereof.”
17
Section 1022(b)(1) of the Dodd-Frank Act also authorizes the CFPB to prescribe rules “as may be necessary or appropriate to enable the Bureau to administer and carry out the purposes and objectives of the Federal consumer financial laws, and to prevent evasions thereof.”
18
Among other statutes, Title X of the Dodd-Frank Act and TILA are Federal consumer financial laws.
19
Accordingly, in issuing this interim final rule, the CFPB is exercising its authority under Dodd-Frank Act section 1022(b) to prescribe rules under TILA and Title X that carry out the purposes and objectives and prevent evasion of those laws.
16
Public Law 111-203, section 1022(b)(1), 124 Stat. 1376, 1980 (2010).
17
12 U.S.C. 5512(b)(1).
18
Id.
19
Dodd-Frank Act section 1002(14), 123 Stat. 1957 (defining “Federal consumer financial law” to include the “enumerated consumer laws” and the provisions of title X of the Dodd-Frank Act); Dodd-Frank Act section 1002(12)(O), 123 Stat. 1957 (defining “enumerated consumer laws” to include TILA).
B. The Truth in Lending Act
TILA section 105(a), as amended by the Dodd-Frank Act, directs the CFPB to prescribe regulations to carry out the purposes of TILA, and provides that such regulations may contain additional requirements, classifications, differentiations, or other provisions, and may provide for such adjustments and exceptions for all or any class of transactions, that, in the judgment of the CFPB, are necessary or proper to effectuate the purposes of TILA, to prevent circumvention or evasion thereof, or to facilitate compliance.
20
Pursuant to TILA section 102(a), a purpose of TILA is to assure a meaningful disclosure of credit terms to enable the consumer to avoid the uninformed use of credit and compare more readily the various credit terms available to the consumer.
20
15 U.S.C. 1604(a).
Historically, TILA section 105(a) has served as a broad source of authority for rules that promote the informed use of credit through required disclosures and substantive regulation of certain practices. Dodd-Frank Act section 1100A clarified the CFPB's section 105(a) authority by amending that section to provide express authority to prescribe regulations that contain “additional requirements” that the CFPB finds are necessary or proper to effectuate the purposes of TILA, to prevent circumvention or evasion thereof, or to facilitate compliance. This amendment clarified the authority to exercise TILA section 105(a) authority to prescribe requirements beyond those specifically listed in the statute that meet the standards outlined in section 105(a). As amended by the Dodd-Frank Act, TILA section 105(a) authority to make adjustments and exceptions to the requirements of TILA applies to all transactions subject to TILA, except with respect to the provisions of TILA section 129 that apply to the high-cost mortgages referred to in TILA section 103(bb).
21
21
15 U.S.C. 1602(bb).
For the reasons discussed in this document, the CFPB is amending Regulation Z with respect to certain provisions that impact the transition from LIBOR indices to other indices to carry out TILA's purposes, including such additional requirements, adjustments, and exceptions as, in the CFPB's judgment, are necessary and proper to carry out the purposes of TILA, prevent circumvention or evasion
thereof, or to facilitate compliance. In developing these aspects of this rule pursuant to its authority under TILA section 105(a), the CFPB has considered the purposes of TILA, including ensuring meaningful disclosures, facilitating consumers' ability to compare credit terms, and helping consumers avoid the uninformed use of credit, and the findings of TILA, including strengthening competition among financial institutions and promoting economic stabilization.
IV. Administrative Procedure Act
The Administrative Procedure Act (APA) does not require notice and opportunity for public comment if an agency for good cause finds that notice and public comment are impracticable, unnecessary, or contrary to the public interest.
22
Similarly, publication of this interim final rule at least 30 days before its effective date is not required where the CFPB has identified good cause for a different effective date.
23
22
5 U.S.C. 553(b)(B).
23
5 U.S.C. 553(d)(3).
The CFPB finds that prior notice and public comment are unnecessary given the specific nature of the changes contained in this interim final rule.
First, this interim final rule makes technical changes to conform the nomenclature of Regulation Z to the nomenclature of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation. Most notably, this interim final rule substitutes the phrase “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” for the phrase “spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products.” As discussed in part II, in the context of consumer loans, the two phrases are synonymous. In light of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, there is minimal, if any, basis for substantive disagreement regarding this replacement of superseded nomenclature.
Second, this interim final rule acknowledges the determinations made by Congress in the LIBOR Act that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are comparable indices and, for purposes of Regulation Z, have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar” to the LIBOR indices they replace.
24
The enactment of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing rule resolved the ambiguity that existed at the time the CFPB issued its 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule as to which, if any, SOFR-based replacement index for the 12-month (formerly called the 1-year) tenor would meet these standards. That is the issue that the CFPB needed to reserve judgment about at the time it issued its 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule because the ARRC had not yet recommended a SOFR-based replacement index for that tenor; thus, there was no such tenor for the CFPB to analyze at the time. In light of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, the applicable 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month tenor of the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans meet the relevant standards; there is minimal, if any, basis for substantive disagreement on this issue.
24
12 U.S.C. 5804(a)(2), (3), (5).
Third, and closely related to the first three changes, this interim final rule removes prior Bureau determinations that were rendered obsolete by the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation. These determinations concerned the comparability of, and the substantial similarity of the historical fluctuations of, the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products compared to the LIBOR index it would replace.
See
comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii, 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii, 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii., 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii, and 59(f)-4. But, as discussed above, the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products are the same as “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” In light of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, there is minimal, if any, basis for substantive disagreement on this issue.
Fourth, the CFPB's 2021 LIBOR Transition Proposed Rule already solicited comment on the substance of most of the provisions that are now amended by this interim final rule, making further notice and comment on them duplicative. Specifically, the proposed rule solicited comment on determining that the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products for 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 1-year or 12-month LIBOR would be comparable to, and have historical fluctuations that substantially similar to, the LIBOR index it would replace.
25
The CFPB's 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, promulgated after notice and an opportunity for public comment, made such determinations with respect to the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors, but explained in the preamble that the Bureau was reserving judgment on making such determinations with respect to the 1-year or 12-month tenor, leaving those determinations open until the CFPB obtained further information.
26
The need for further information has since been obviated by the determinations made by Congress in the LIBOR Act discussed above.
25
See
85 FR 36938, 36945-47, 36972, 36987, 36994 (June 18, 2020).
26
See
86 FR 69716, 69723, 69730 (Dec. 8, 2021).
The CFPB also finds good cause to waive the 30-day delay in effective date. The CFPB is cognizant of the need for these amendments to take effect quickly and thereby remove any confusion that may exist after the Board's regulations implementing the LIBOR Act became effective on February 27, 2023. In particular, making this interim final rule effective at least 45 days prior to the planned cessation of LIBOR on June 30, 2023, is necessary to ensure that consumers with credit card accounts currently using a LIBOR index can receive timely change-in-terms notices when their account is changed to the Board-selected benchmark replacement.
V. Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1026.2 Definitions and Rules of Construction
2(a) Definitions
2(a)(28) The Board-Selected Benchmark Replacement for Consumer Loans
This interim final rule adds “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” as a new defined term in § 1026.2(a)(28) to reference a specific replacement index for consumer products when LIBOR becomes unavailable. As discussed in part II above, the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation defined “Board-selected benchmark replacement” to mean a benchmark replacement identified by the Board that is based on SOFR, including any tenor spread adjustment by the Board.
27
The LIBOR Act, and the Board's implementing regulation, provide for certain adjustments in general for LIBOR contracts and more specifically for LIBOR contracts that are consumer loans. Accordingly, for purposes of promoting the informed use of consumer credit under Regulation Z, the CFPB is creating a new term that is specific to consumer loans. New § 1026.2(a)(28) defines “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” as the SOFR-based index selected by the Board, to replace, as applicable, the 1-month, 3-month,6-month, or 12-month tenors of USD LIBOR and uses the term 12-month tenor instead of 1-year tenor to align with the terminology used in the LIBOR
Act and the Board's implementing regulation. The definition references the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing rule for additional clarity. The Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are tenors of the USD IBOR Cash Fallback index for consumer products, which uses the same methodology that the ARRC recommended for SOFR-based replacement indices for consumer products.
28
As such, these terms identify the same index, and the addition of the new defined term and cross-references to it throughout this interim final rule are merely for consistency with the Act and ease of reading. The CFPB solicits feedback on these changes of the interim final rule.
27
LIBOR Act section 104(e), 136 Stat. 829 (codified at 12 U.S.C. 5803(e)); 12 CFR 253.4.
28
See
88 FR 5204, 5211-15 (Jan. 26, 2023);
see also
Alt. Reference Rates Comm.,
ARRC Recommended Fallbacks for Implementation of its Hardwired Fallback Language
(Mar. 15, 2023),
https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/Microsites/arrc/files/2023/ARRC-statement-on-1-3-6-12-month-USD-LIBOR.pdf.
Section 1026.9 Subsequent Disclosure Requirements
9(c) Change in Terms
9(c)(1) Rules Affecting Home-Equity Plans
Section 1026.9(c)(1)(i) provides that for HELOCs subject to § 1026.40 whenever any term required to be disclosed in the account-opening disclosures under § 1026.6(a) is changed or the required minimum periodic payment is increased, the creditor must mail or deliver written notice of the change to each consumer who may be affected. The creditor must mail or deliver the notice at least 15 days prior to the effective date of the change. The 15-day timing requirement does not apply if the change has been agreed to by the consumer; the creditor must give the notice, however, before the effective date of the change.
A creditor is required to disclose in the change-in-terms notice any increased periodic rate or APR as calculated using the replacement index at the time the change-in-terms notice is provided. The periodic rate and APR are terms that are required to be disclosed in the account-opening disclosures under § 1026.6(a) and thus, a creditor must provide a change-in-terms notice disclosing the new periodic rate and APR calculated using the replacement index if the periodic rate or APR is increasing from the rate calculated using the LIBOR index at the time the change-in-terms notice is provided.
29
29
See
12 CFR 1026.6(a)(1)(ii). Comment 6(a)(1)(ii)-3 provides that in disclosing the rate(s) in effect for a variable-rate plan at the time of the account-opening disclosures (as is required by § 1026.6(a)(1)(ii)), the creditor may use an insert showing the current rate; may give the rate as of a specified date and then update the disclosure from time to time, for example, each calendar month; or may disclose an estimated rate under § 1026.5(c).
Comment 9(c)(1)-4 provides that if: (1) a creditor is replacing a LIBOR index with the index based on “SOFR recommended by the Alternative Reference Rates Committee for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month U.S. Dollar LIBOR index”; (2) “the creditor is not changing the margin used to calculate the variable rate as a result of the replacement”; and (3) a periodic rate or the corresponding APR based on the replacement index is unknown to the creditor at the time the change-in-terms notice is provided because the SOFR index has not been published at the time the creditor provides the change-in-terms notice, but will be published by the time the replacement of the index takes effect on the account, then the creditor may comply with any requirement to disclose the amount of the new rate (as calculated using the new index), or a change in the periodic rate or the corresponding APR (as calculated using the replacement index), based on the best information reasonably available, clearly stating that the disclosure is an estimate. Comment 9(c)(1)-4 provides the example that, in this situation, the creditor may state that: (1) information about the rate is not yet available, but that the creditor estimates that, at the time the index is replaced, the rate will be substantially similar to what it would be if the index did not have to be replaced; and (2) the rate will vary with the market based on a SOFR index.
For the reasons discussed below, the CFPB is making several changes to comment 9(c)(1)-4. First, the CFPB is replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to align terminology in the rule with the LIBOR Act and the Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.2(a)(28), this interim final rule also defines the term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 9(c)(1)-4 includes a cross-reference to that definition. As discussed above, these terms identify the same index, and the change is merely for consistency with the Act and ease of reading.
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 9(c)(1)-4 to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. As discussed in the Background section, in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 12-month (formerly called the 1-year) USD LIBOR index in comment 9(c)(1)-4 until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. By operation of the LIBOR Act, all tenors of the Board-selected benchmark replacement constitute a “comparable index” to, and have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
30
Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 9(c)(1)-4 to also apply to the replacement of the 12-month USD LIBOR index with the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans, facilitating compliance with the advance notice requirements for change-in-terms notices.
30
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(2), (3) and (5), 136 Stat. 830.
While section 104(f) of the LIBOR Act provides that nothing in the Act “may be construed to alter or impair— . . . (5) any provision of Federal consumer financial law that—(A) requires creditors to notify borrowers regarding a change-in-terms,” the CFPB is not relying on the LIBOR Act for authority to revise comment 9(c)(1)-4. However, in this unique circumstance, the CFPB has previously stated a need to permit creditors permission to provide estimates for change-in-terms notices, and interprets § 1026.5(c) to be consistent with revised comment 9(c)(1)-4 in doing so. Section 1026.5(c) provides, in relevant part, that if any information necessary for accurate disclosure is unknown to the creditor, it must make the disclosure based on the best information reasonably available and must state clearly that the disclosure is an estimate. Because of the unique circumstances of the LIBOR transition, the CFPB previously amended comment 9(c)(1)-4 to provide permit creditors the ability to provide estimates for disclosures previously excluded from § 1026.5(c). The revisions to comment 9(c)(1)-4 in this interim final rule are consistent with this reasoning. Thus, the revisions to comment 9(c)(1)-4 are consistent with revisions discussed below that provide
that if a creditor uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace 12-month USD LIBOR and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the creditor will be deemed to be in compliance with the conditions in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) and (B) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index.
31
31
See
comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 and (B)-3;
see also
the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) for a discussion of the rationale for the Bureau making this determination.
Under § 1026.9(c)(1)(i), the change-in-terms notice for HELOC accounts subject to § 1026.40 generally must be mailed or delivered at least 15 days prior to the effective date of the change. Also, the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR, like the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR replacement tenors, will not be published until Monday, July 3, 2023, which is the first weekday after Friday, June 30, 2023, when LIBOR is currently anticipated to sunset for these USD LIBOR tenors. The revisions to comment 9(c)(1)-4 are intended to facilitate compliance with the 15-day advance notice requirement for change-in-terms notices by allowing creditors in the situation described above to provide change-in-terms notices prior to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace 12-month USD LIBOR being published, so that creditors are not left without an index to use on the account after the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace 12-month USD LIBOR is published, but before it becomes effective on the account.
As is the case for the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans for 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR tenors, the Bureau has determined that the information described in revised comment 9(c)(1)-4 sufficiently notifies consumers of the estimated periodic rate and APR as calculated using the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace 12-month USD LIBOR, even though the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans is not being published at the time the notice is sent, as long as the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans is published by the time the replacement of the index takes effect on the account. For example, in this situation, comment 9(c)(1)-4 provides that the creditor may state that: (1) information about the rate is not yet available, but that the creditor estimates that, at the time the index is replaced, the rate will be substantially similar to what it would be if the index did not have to be replaced; and (2) the rate will vary with the market based on a SOFR index. The CFPB solicits comment on these changes in the interim final rule.
9(c)(2) Rules Affecting Open-End (Not Home-Secured) Plans
9(c)(2)(iv) Disclosure Requirements
TILA section 127(i)(1), which was added by the Credit CARD Act of 2009,
32
provides that in the case of a credit card account under an open-end consumer credit plan, a creditor generally must provide written notice of an increase in an APR not later than 45 days prior to the effective date of the increase.
33
In addition, TILA section 127(i)(2) provides that in the case of a credit card account under an open-end consumer credit plan, a creditor must provide written notice of any significant change, as determined by a rule of the CFPB, in terms (other than APRs) of the cardholder agreement not later than 45 days prior to the effective date of the change.
34
32
Public Law 111-24, 123 Stat. 1734 (2009).
33
15 U.S.C. 1637(i)(1).
34
15 U.S.C. 1637(i)(2).
Section 1026.9(c)(2)(i)(A) provides that for open-end plans other than HELOCs subject to § 1026.40, a creditor generally must provide written notice of a “significant change in account terms” at least 45 days prior to the effective date of the change to each consumer who may be affected. Section 1026.9(c)(2)(ii) defines “significant change in account terms” to mean, in relevant part, a change in the terms required to be disclosed under § 1026.6(b)(1) and (2), an increase in the required minimum periodic payment, or a change to a term required to be disclosed under § 1026.6(b)(4). The index that is replacing the LIBOR index pursuant to § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) or § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) is a disclosure required under § 1026.6(b)(2)(i)(A) and (4)(ii)(B) and thus, is a term that meets the definition of a “significant change in account terms.” As a result, a creditor must provide a change-in-terms notice disclosing the index that is replacing the LIBOR index.
Section 1026.9(c)(2)(iv) provides the disclosure requirements for this written notice. Comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.i provides details about the general disclosure requirements if the creditor is changing the index use to calculate a variable rate. A creditor also is required to disclose in the change-in-terms notice any increased periodic rate or APR calculated using the replacement index at the time the change-in-terms notice is provided. The periodic rate and APR are terms that are required to be disclosed in the account-opening disclosures under § 1026.6(b) and thus, a creditor must provide a change-in-terms notice disclosing the new periodic rate and APR calculated using the replacement index if the periodic rate or APR is increasing from the rate calculated using the LIBOR index at the time the change-in-terms notice is provided.
35
35
See
12 CFR 1026.6(b)(4)(i)(A). Section 1026.6(b)(4)(ii)(G) provides that for purposes of disclosing variable rates in the account-opening disclosures, a rate generally is accurate if it is a rate as of a specified date and this rate was in effect within the last 30 days before the disclosures are provided.
Comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii provides additional details on how a creditor may comply with the disclosure requirements under § 1026.9(c)(2)(iv) when the creditor is replacing a LIBOR index with the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products in certain circumstances. This comment provides that if: (1) a creditor is replacing a LIBOR index with the “SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR index”; (2) the creditor is not changing the margin used to calculate the variable rate as a result of the replacement; and (3) a periodic rate or the corresponding APR based on the replacement index is unknown to the creditor at the time the change-in-terms notice is provided because the SOFR index has not been published at the time the creditor provides the change-in-terms notice, but will be published by the time the replacement of the index takes effect on the account, then the creditor may comply with any requirement to disclose in the change-in-terms notice the amount of the periodic rate or APR (or changes in these amounts) as calculated using the replacement index based on the best information reasonably available, clearly stating that the disclosure is an estimate. Comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii provides the example that, in this situation, the creditor may state that: (1) information about the rate is not yet available, but that the creditor estimates that, at the time the index is replaced, the rate will be substantially similar to what it would be if the index did not have to be replaced; and (2) the rate will vary with the market based on a SOFR index.
For the reasons discussed below, the CFPB is making several changes to comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii. First, the CFPB is replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to align terminology in the rule with the LIBOR Act and the Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.2(a)(28), this interim final rule also defines the term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii includes a cross-reference to that definition. As discussed above, these terms identify the same index, and the change is merely for consistency with the Act and ease of reading.
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. As discussed in the Background section, in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 12-month (formerly called the 1-year) USD LIBOR index in comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. By operation of the LIBOR Act, all tenors of the Board-selected benchmark replacements constitute a “comparable index” to, and have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
36
Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii to also apply to the replacement of the 12-month USD LIBOR index with the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans, facilitating compliance with the advance notice requirements for change-in-terms notices.
36
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(2), (3) and (5), 136 Stat. 830.
While section 104(f) of the LIBOR Act provides that nothing in the Act “may be construed to alter or impair— . . . (5) any provision of Federal consumer financial law that—(A) requires creditors to notify borrowers regarding a change-in-terms,” the CFPB is not relying on the LIBOR Act for authority to revise comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii. Instead, in this unique circumstance, the CFPB interprets § 1026.5(c) to be consistent with revised comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii. Section 1026.5(c) provides in relevant part, that if any information necessary for accurate disclosure is unknown to the creditor, it must make the disclosure based on the best information reasonably available and must state clearly that the disclosure is an estimate. Revised comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii also is consistent with revisions discussed below that provide that if a creditor uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the creditor will be deemed to be in compliance with the conditions in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) and (ii) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index.
37
37
See
comments 55(b)(7)(i)-2 and (ii)-3;
see also
the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) for a discussion of the rationale for the Bureau making this determination.
As described above, under § 1026.9(c)(2), the change-in-terms notice for open-end credit that is not subject to § 1026.40 (including credit card accounts) generally must be mailed or delivered at least 45 days prior to the effective date of the change. Also, the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index, like the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR replacement tenors, will not be published until Monday, July 3, 2023, which is the first weekday after Friday, June 30, 2023, when LIBOR is currently anticipated to sunset for these USD LIBOR tenors. This interim final rule provision is intended to facilitate compliance with the 45-day advance notice requirement for change-in-terms notices by allowing creditors in the situation described above to provide change-in-terms notices prior to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index being published, so that creditors are not left without an index to use on the account after the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index is published, but before it becomes effective on the account.
As is the case for the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans for 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR tenors, the Bureau has determined that the information described in revised comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii sufficiently notifies consumers of the estimated rate calculated using the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index, even though the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index is not being published at the time the notice is sent, as long as the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 12-month USD LIBOR index is published by the time the replacement of the index takes effect on the account. For example, in this situation, comment 9(c)(2)(iv)-2.ii provides that the creditor may state that: (1) information about the rate is not yet available, but that the creditor estimates that, at the time the index is replaced, the rate will be substantially similar to what it would be if the index did not have to be replaced; and (2) the rate will vary with the market based on a SOFR index. The CFPB solicits comment on these changes in the interim final rule.
Section 1026.20 Disclosure Requirements Regarding Post-Consummation Events 20(a) Refinancings
Section 1026.20 includes disclosure requirements regarding post-consummation events for closed-end credit. Section 1026.20(a) and its Official Interpretations define when a refinancing occurs for closed-end credit and provide that a refinancing is a new transaction requiring new disclosures to the consumer. Comment 20(a)-3.ii.B explains that a new transaction subject to new disclosures results if the creditor adds a variable-rate feature to the obligation, even if it is not accomplished by the cancellation of the old obligation and substitution of a new one. The comment also states that a creditor does not add a variable-rate feature by changing the index of a variable-rate transaction to a comparable index, whether the change replaces the existing index or substitutes an index for one that no longer exists. The comment also includes an illustrative example which provides that a creditor does not add a variable-rate feature by changing the index of a variable-rate transaction from the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR index to the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR index respectively because the
replacement index is a comparable index to the corresponding USD LIBOR index.
38
Comment 20(a)-3.iv provides examples of the types of factors that may need to be considered to determine whether a replacement index is comparable to a particular LIBOR index for closed-end transactions.
38
By “corresponding USD LIBOR index,” the Bureau meant the specific USD LIBOR index for which the ARRC recommended the replacement index as a replacement for consumer products. Thus, because the ARRC has recommended, for consumer products, a specific spread-adjusted 6-month term rate SOFR index for consumer products as a replacement for the 6-month USD LIBOR index, the 6-month USD LIBOR index would be the “corresponding USD LIBOR index” for that specific spread-adjusted 6-month term rate SOFR index for consumer products.
For the reasons discussed below, the CFPB is making several changes to comment 20(a)-3.ii.B. First, the CFPB is replacing references to the term spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to align terminology in the rule with the LIBOR Act and the Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.2(a)(28), this interim final rule also defines the term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 20(a)-3.ii.B includes a cross-reference to that definition. As discussed above, these terms identify the same index, and the change is merely for consistency with the Act and ease of reading.
Second, the CFPB is expanding language in the example set forth in comment 20(a)-3.ii.B to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. As discussed in the Background section, in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 12-month (formerly called the 1-year) USD LIBOR index in comment 20(a)-3.ii.B until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. By operation of the LIBOR Act, all tenors of the Board-selected benchmark replacements are considered to constitute a “comparable index,” and have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to,” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
39
As such, as with the existing examples in comment 20(a)-3.ii.B for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR tenors, in this interim final rule the CFPB is extending the example to also apply to the replacement of the 12-month USD LIBOR index with the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to facilitate the LIBOR transition. The example in revised comment 20(a)-3.ii.B provides a creditor does not add a variable-rate feature by changing the index of a variable-rate transaction from the 12-month USD LIBOR tenor to the applicable tenor of the Board-selected benchmark replacement.
39
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(2), (3) and (5), 136 Stat. 830.
Third, the CFPB is revising comment 20(a)-3.iv by adding an exception for the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, as defined in new § 1026.2(a)(28). When using the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans, a creditor need not consider the types of factors used to determine whether a replacement index is comparable to a particular LIBOR tenor for closed-end credit. Because the Board's final rule, in implementing the LIBOR Act, has determined that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are indices that are comparable to their respective LIBOR tenors, and the Bureau has determined in this interim final rule that this index meets Regulation Z's “comparable” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index, the factors need not be considered. While the CFPB had already applied the factors to the SOFR-based 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month LIBOR tenor replacement indices in its 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, by operation of law, the factors now also need not be considered with respect to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans for the 12-month LIBOR tenor in order for the index to satisfy Regulation Z's “comparable” standard. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes in the interim final rule.
Section 1026.40 Requirements for Home Equity Plans
40(f) Limitations on Home Equity Plans
40(f)(3)
40(f)(3)(ii)
TILA section 137(c)(1) provides that no open-end consumer credit plan under which extensions of credit are secured by a consumer's principal dwelling may contain a provision that permits a creditor to change unilaterally any term except in enumerated circumstances set forth in TILA section 137(c).
40
TILA section 137(c)(2)(A) provides that a creditor may change the index and margin applicable to extensions of credit under such a plan if the index used by the creditor is no longer available and the substitute index and margin will result in a substantially similar interest rate.
41
In implementing TILA section 137(c), § 1026.40(f)(3) prohibits a creditor from changing the terms of a HELOC subject to § 1026.40 except in enumerated circumstances set forth in § 1026.40(f)(3).
40
15 U.S.C. 1647(c).
41
15 U.S.C. 1647(c)(2)(A).
Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) provides that a creditor may change the index and margin used under the HELOC plan if the original index is no longer available, the replacement index has historical fluctuations substantially similar to that of the original index, and the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the original index became unavailable. Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) also provides if the replacement index is newly established and therefore does not have any rate history, it may be used if it and the replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect when the original index became unavailable. Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) contains LIBOR-specific provisions that permit creditors for HELOC plans subject to § 1026.40 that use a LIBOR index for calculating variable rates to replace the LIBOR index and change the margins for calculating the variable rates on or after April 1, 2022, in certain circumstances. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1 provides detail on the interaction among the unavailability provisions in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A), the LIBOR-specific provisions in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B), and the contractual provisions that apply to a HELOC plan.
As discussed in more detail below in this section-by-section analysis, this interim final rule makes a number of changes with respect to §§ 1026.40(f)(3)(ii), (f)(3)(ii)(A), (f)(3)(ii)(B), and related Official Interpretations. In general, it: (1) replaces references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new defined term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans”; (2) replaces references to the 1-year USD LIBOR index with the 12-month USD LIBOR index; (3) expands the Official Interpretations to include a
replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule; (4) provides that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans to replace 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month USD LIBOR indices have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace; (5) provides if the creditor selects to use the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans, the creditor must use the index value of this index and the LIBOR index from a specified timeframe in determining whether the APR is substantially similar; (6) updates guidance on determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices in relation to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans; and (7) explains when a creditor that uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans satisfies the condition that the replacement index and margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time LIBOR becomes unavailable or calculated using the LIBOR index.
Interaction among § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) and (B) and contractual provisions.
Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1 provides that a creditor may use either the provision in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) or § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) to replace a LIBOR index used under a HELOC plan subject to § 1026.40 so long as the applicable conditions are met for the provision used.
42
It provides examples of when a creditor may use these provisions. Each of these examples assumes that the LIBOR index used under the plan becomes unavailable after June 30, 2023. Specifically, comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1.i provides an example where a HELOC contract provides that a creditor may not replace an index unilaterally under a plan unless the original index becomes unavailable and provides that the replacement index and replacement margin will result in an APR substantially similar to a rate that is in effect when the original index becomes unavailable. In this case, comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1.i explains that the creditor may use the unavailability provisions in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) to replace the LIBOR index used under the plan so long as the conditions of that provision are met. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1.i also explains that the LIBOR-specific provisions in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) generally provide that a creditor may replace the LIBOR index if the replacement index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. If the replacement index is not published on October 18, 2021, the creditor generally must use the next calendar day for which both the LIBOR index and the replacement index are published as the date for selecting indices values in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. The one exception provided under comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1.i is that if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the creditor must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
42
For further details about these provisions,
see
the section-by-section analyses of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) and (B),
infra.
The CFPB is revising the example in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1.i by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to align terminology in the rule with the LIBOR Act and the Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule. As discussed above, this interim final rule also defines the term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” It means the SOFR-based index selected by the Board for consumer loans, as set forth in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, to replace, as applicable, the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month tenors of USD LIBOR. Revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1.ii includes a cross-reference to this definition. For this new definition and throughout this interim final rule, the CFPB is using the term 12-month tenor instead of 1-year tenor to align with the terminology used in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation. The Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans is the USD IBOR Cash Fallback index for consumer products, which uses the same methodology that the ARRC recommended for SOFR-based replacement indices for consumer products.
43
As such, these terms identify the same index, and the change is merely for consistency with the Act and ease of reading.
43
See
88 FR 5204, 5211-15 (Jan. 26, 2023).
See also
Alt. Reference Rates Comm., S
ummary of the ARRC's Fallback Recommendations
(Oct. 6, 2021),
https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/Microsites/arrc/files/2021/spread-adjustments-narrative-oct-6-2021. See also
Alt. References Rates Comm.,
ARRC Recommended Fallbacks for Implementation of its Hardwired Fallback Language
(Mar. 15, 2023),
https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/Microsites/arrc/files/2023/ARRC-statement-on-1-3-6-12-month-USD-LIBOR.pdf.
40(f)(3)(ii)(A)
Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) provides that a creditor may change the index and margin used under the HELOC plan if the original index is no longer available, the replacement index has historical fluctuations substantially similar to that of the original index, and the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the original index became unavailable. Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) also provides if the replacement index is newly established and therefore does not have any rate history, it may be used if it and the replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect when the original index became unavailable. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2 provides detail on determining whether a replacement index that is not newly established has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index used under the plan for purposes of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A). It provides that for purposes of replacing a LIBOR index used under a plan pursuant to § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A), a replacement index that is not newly established must have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index used under the plan, considering the historical fluctuations up through when the LIBOR index becomes unavailable or up through the date indicated in a Bureau determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar, whichever is earlier.
The Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
Comment
40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii provides a determination by the Bureau that effective April 1, 2022, the SOFR-based spread-adjusted indices recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices respectively.
44
It provides that the creditor also must comply with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) that the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable in order to use this SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products as the replacement index for the applicable LIBOR index.
44
86 FR 69716, 69743 & n.106 (Dec. 8, 2021) (acknowledging that while the spread-adjusted term SOFR rates have not always moved in tandem with LIBOR, the Bureau determined that: (1) the historical fluctuations of 6-month USD LIBOR are substantially similar to those of the 6-month spread-adjusted term SOFR rates; (2) the historical fluctuations of 3-month USD LIBOR are substantially similar to those of 3-month spread-adjusted term SOFR rates; and (3) the historical fluctuations of 1-month USD LIBOR are substantially similar to those of the 1-month spread-adjusted term SOFR rates).
The CFPB is making several changes to comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2, -2.i, and -2.ii. First, as discussed in more detail in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii) above, and for the reasons discussed therein, the CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii includes a cross-reference to this definition. Based on these changes, revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii provides that the creditor also must comply with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) requiring the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable.
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii does not discuss the 12-month (formerly called 1-year) USD LIBOR.
45
In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. Section 105(a)(5) of the LIBOR Act provides that, for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations, a Board-selected benchmark replacement and the selection or use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement as a benchmark replacement with respect to a LIBOR contract constitutes a replacement that has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index that it is replacing. The Board's regulation provides that for a LIBOR contract that is a consumer loan, the benchmark replacement shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable amounts or tenor spread adjustment.
46
The CFPB is relying on the determination in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation that the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the USD LIBOR tenor that it is replacing. Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii to also apply this determination of the historical fluctuations substantially similar standard to the replacement of the 12-month USD LIBOR index with the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.
45
See
85 FR 36938, 36972, 36994 (June 18, 2020) (proposing comment 59(f)-4 and noting the Bureau's 2020 notice of proposed rulemaking proposed and solicited comment on allowing use of a specific replacement formula where the index change involved the 1-year tenor in addition to the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors).
46
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B) and (ii)(B).
Third, based on the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, the Bureau is removing its prior determination that became effective April 1, 2022, concerning the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. By operation of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, all tenors of the Board-selected benchmark replacements have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
47
Thus, revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii provides that the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month USD LIBOR indices has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to USD LIBOR tenor they are replacing. The Bureau's prior determination is obsolete. The “spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products” are the same as “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and the LIBOR Act determined that the latter has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the LIBOR tenors they replace. Removing this obsolete determination will avoid confusion.
47
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(5), 136 Stat. 830.
Fourth, to facilitate compliance, this interim final rule revises comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2 by specifying that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans is an exception to the general requirement providing that the historical fluctuations considered when replacing a LIBOR index used under a plan are the historical fluctuations up through the earlier of when the LIBOR index becomes unavailable or up through the date indicated in a Bureau determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar. Accordingly, this interim final rule also revises comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.ii to provide that no further determination is required that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans meets the “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The changes to comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2 in relation to the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans do not alter or modify the Bureau's determination set forth in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.i in relation to the prime rate as the replacement index for the 1-month or 3-month USD LIBOR index, except to provide that no further determination is needed that the prime rate published in the Wall Street Journal meets this standard for these tenors. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes in the interim final rule.
Additional guidance on determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB noted that commenters on the proposed rule had asked for additional guidance on
how to determine whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index, including requesting that the CFPB provide a principles-based standard for making such determinations. The CFPB did not set forth a principles-based standard at that time because these determinations are fact-specific, and they depend on the replacement index being considered and the LIBOR tenor being replaced. Instead, to facilitate compliance with Regulation Z, the CFPB added comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.iii to provide a non-exhaustive list of factors to be considered in making these determinations. Specifically, comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)2.iii provides that the relevant factors to be considered depend on the replacement index being considered and the LIBOR index being replaced. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.iii also provides that these determinations may need to consider certain aspects of the historical data itself for a particular replacement index. In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB considered the relevant factors in determining that: (1) Prime has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month and 3-month USD LIBOR; and (2) the SOFR-based spread-adjusted indices recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices respectively.
The CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.iii by adding an exception for the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, as defined in new § 1026.2(a)(28). When using the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, a creditor need not consider the types of factors used to determine whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index. Because the Board's final rule, in implementing the LIBOR Act, has determined that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are replacement indices that have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to their respective LIBOR tenors, and the CFPB has determined in this interim final rule that this index meets the Regulation Z “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index, the factors need not be considered. While the CFPB had already applied the factors to the SOFR-based 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month LIBOR tenor replacement indices in its 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, by operation of law, the factors need not be considered with respect to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans for the 12-month LIBOR tenor in order for the index to satisfy Regulation Z's “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes in the interim final rule.
Substantially similar rate when LIBOR becomes unavailable.
Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) provides that the replacement index and replacement margin must produce an APR substantially similar to the rate that was in effect based on the LIBOR index used under the plan when the LIBOR index became unavailable. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 provides that, for comparing rates, a creditor generally must use the value of the replacement index and the LIBOR index on the day that the LIBOR index becomes unavailable. It provides that if the replacement index is not published on the day that the LIBOR index becomes unavailable, the creditor generally must use the previous calendar day that both indices are published as the date for selecting indices values in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. The one exception under comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 is that, if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the creditor must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 also states that for purposes of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A), if a creditor uses the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the creditor will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable.
The CFPB is making several changes to comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3. First, as discussed in more detail in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii) above, and for the reasons discussed therein, the CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.”
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 does not discuss the 12-month (formerly called 1-year) USD LIBOR. In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 until it obtains additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. Sections 105(a)(2), (a)(3), and (a)(5) of the LIBOR Act provide that, for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations, a Board-selected benchmark replacement and the selection or use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement as a benchmark replacement with respect to a LIBOR contract constitutes a “comparable index” and “has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar” to those of the USD LIBOR index they are replacing. The Board's regulation provides that for a LIBOR contract that is a consumer loan, the benchmark replacement shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable amounts or tenor spread adjustment.
48
The determination in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation applies not only to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans that is replacing the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR, but also to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans that is replacing the 12-month tenor of LIBOR. Thus, the
CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3 to provide that for purposes of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A), if a creditor uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the creditor will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable. The CFPB solicits comment on these changes of the interim final rule.
48
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B) and (ii)(B).
40(f)(3)(ii)(B)
Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) contains LIBOR-specific provisions that permit creditors for HELOC plans subject to § 1026.40 that use a LIBOR index for calculating variable rates to replace the LIBOR index and change the margins for calculating the variable rates on or after April 1, 2022, in certain circumstances. The CFPB explained in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule how as a practical matter, § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) allows creditors for HELOCs to provide the 15-day change-in-terms notices required under § 1026.9(c)(1) prior to the LIBOR indices becoming unavailable, and thus allows those creditors to avoid being left without a LIBOR index to use in calculating the variable rate before the replacement index and margin become effective. Also, § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) allows HELOC creditors to provide the change-in-terms notices, and replace the LIBOR index used under the plans, on accounts on a rolling basis, rather than having to provide the change-in-terms notices, and replace the LIBOR index, for all its accounts at the same time as the LIBOR index used under the plan becomes unavailable. The CFPB believes that this advance notice of the replacement index and any change in the margin is important to consumers to inform them of how variable rates will be determined going forward after the LIBOR index is replaced.
Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) provides that if a variable rate on a HELOC subject to § 1026.40 is calculated using a LIBOR index, a creditor may replace the LIBOR index and change the margin for calculating the variable rate on or after April 1, 2022, as long as: (1) the historical fluctuations in the LIBOR index and replacement index were substantially similar; and (2) the replacement index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. If the replacement index is newly established and therefore does not have any rate history, it may be used if the replacement index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. Section 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) also provides that if the replacement index is not published on October 18, 2021, the creditor generally must use the next calendar day for which both the LIBOR index and the replacement index are published as the date for selecting indices values in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. As set forth in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B), the one exception is that if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the creditor must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1 provides detail on determining whether a replacement index that is not newly established has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index used under the plan for purposes of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B). It provides that for purposes of replacing a LIBOR index used under a plan pursuant to § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B), a replacement index that is not newly established must have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index used under the plan, considering the historical fluctuations up through the relevant date. If the Bureau has made a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar, the relevant date is the date indicated in that determination by the Bureau. If the Bureau has not made a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar, the relevant date is the later of April 1, 2022, or the date no more than 30 days before the creditor makes a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar.
The CFPB is making two changes to § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B). As discussed in more detail in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii) above, and for the reasons discussed therein, the CFPB is revising § 40(f)(3)(ii)(B) by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and is using the term 12-month tenor instead of 1-year tenor with respect to the USD LIBOR index.
The Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii provides a determination by the Bureau that, effective April 1, 2022, the SOFR-based spread-adjusted indices recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices respectively. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii also provides that in order to use this SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products as the replacement index for the applicable LIBOR index, the creditor also must satisfy the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) that the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products and replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. Because of the exception in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B), the creditor must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially
similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) with respect to revised comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2, -2.i, and -2.ii, the interim final rule makes similar changes to comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1, -1.i, and -1.ii. First, the CFPB is revising comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii includes a cross-reference to this definition. Based on these changes, revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii provides that the creditor also must comply with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) requiring the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans and replacement margin to produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan.
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii does not discuss the 12-month (formerly called 1-year) USD LIBOR.
49
In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii. until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. Section 105(a)(5) of the LIBOR Act provides that, for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations, a Board-selected benchmark replacement and the selection or use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement as a benchmark replacement with respect to a LIBOR contract constitutes a replacement that has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index that it is replacing. The Board's regulation provides that for a LIBOR contract that is a consumer loan, the benchmark replacement shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable amounts or tenor spread adjustment.
50
The CFPB is relying on the determination in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the USD LIBOR tenor they are replacing. Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii to also apply this determination of the historical fluctuations substantially similar standard to the replacement of the 12-month USD LIBOR index with the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.
49
See
85 FR 36938, 36972, 36994 (June 18, 2020) (proposing comment 59(f)-4 and noting the Bureau's 2020 notice of proposed rulemaking proposed and solicited comment on allowing use of a specific replacement formula where the index change involved the 1-year tenor in addition to the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors).
50
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B) and (ii)(B).
Third, based on the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, the Bureau is removing its prior determination that became effective April 1, 2022, concerning the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. By operation of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, all Board-selected benchmark replacements have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
51
Thus, revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii provides that the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to the replace 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month USD LIBOR index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to USD LIBOR tenor they are replacing. The Bureau's prior determination is obsolete. The “spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products” are the same as “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and the LIBOR Act determined that the latter has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the LIBOR tenors they replace. Removing this obsolete determination will avoid confusion.
51
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(5), 136 Stat. 830.
Fourth, to facilitate compliance, this interim final rule revises comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1 by specifying that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are an exception to the general requirement providing that the historical fluctuations considered when replacing a LIBOR index under a plan are the historical fluctuations up through the relevant date set forth in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1. Accordingly, this interim final rule also revises comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.ii to provide that no further determination is required that the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans meets the “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The changes to comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1 in relation to the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans do not alter or modify the Bureau's determination set forth in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.i in relation to the prime rate as the replacement index for the 1-month or 3-month USD LIBOR index, except to provide that no further determination is needed that the prime rate published in the Wall Street Journal meets this standard for these tenors. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes of the interim final rule.
Additional guidance on determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) with respect to revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.iii, the interim final rule makes similar changes to comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.iii, which provides a non-exhaustive list of factors to be considered in whether a replacement index meets the Regulation Z “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index.
The CFPB is making two changes to comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.iii. First, the CFPB is making a technical correction in comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.iii to change “substantial” to “substantially” when considering the relevant factors in determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index. Second, similar to changes in revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.iii above, the CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.iii by adding an exception for the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, as defined in new § 1026.2(a)(28). When using the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, a creditor need not consider the types of factors that have historical fluctuations substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index. Because the Board's final rule, in implementing the LIBOR Act, has determined that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are indices that have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to their respective LIBOR tenors,
and the CFPB has determined in this interim final rule that this index meets the Regulation Z “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index, the factors need not be considered. While the CFPB had already applied the factors to the SOFR-based 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month LIBOR tenor replacement indices in its 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, by operation of law, the factors need not be considered with respect to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans for the 12-month LIBOR tenor in order for the index to satisfy Regulation Z's “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes of the interim final rule.
Substantially similar rate.
Pursuant to § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B), if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the creditor must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
Comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-3 also provides that for purposes of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B), if a creditor uses the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the creditor will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index.
For the same reasons discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) above for revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3, the CFPB is making several changes to comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-3. First, the CFPB is revising comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-3 by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.”
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-3 to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. This interim final rule revises comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-3 to provide that the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index for purposes of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) if a creditor uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the creditor will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index. Thus, a creditor that uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index still must comply with the condition in § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index, but the creditor will be deemed to be in compliance with this condition if the creditor uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes in the interim final rule.
Section 1026.55 Limitations on Increasing Annual Percentage Rates, Fees, and Charges
55(b) Exceptions
55(b)(7) Index Replacement and Margin Change Exception
TILA section 171(a), which was added by the Credit CARD Act, provides that in the case of a credit card account under an open-end consumer credit plan, no creditor may increase any APR, fee, or finance charge applicable to any outstanding balance, except as permitted under TILA section 171(b).
52
TILA section 171(b)(2) provides that the prohibition under TILA section 171(a) does not apply to an increase in a variable APR in accordance with a credit card agreement that provides for changes in the rate according to the operation of an index that is not under the control of the creditor and is available to the general public.
53
In implementing these provisions of TILA section 171, § 1026.55(a) prohibits a card issuer from increasing an APR or certain enumerated fees or charges set forth in § 1026.55(a) on a credit card account under an open-end (not home-secured) consumer credit plan, except as provided in § 1026.55(b).
52
15 U.S.C. 1666i-1(a).
53
15 U.S.C. 1666i-1(b)(2).
Section 1026.55(b)(7) provides a card issuer may increase an APR pursuant to certain exceptions. Section 1026.55(b)(7)(i) discusses the exception for index replacement and margin changes and provides that a card issuer may increase an APR when the card issuer changes the index and margin used to determine the APR if the original index becomes unavailable, as long as historical fluctuations in the original and replacement indices were substantially similar, and as long as the replacement index and replacement margin will produce a rate substantially similar to the rate that was in effect at the time the original index became unavailable. Section 1026.55(b)(7)(i) also provides if the replacement index is newly established and therefore does not have any rate history, it may be used if it and the replacement margin will produce a rate substantially similar to the rate in effect when the original index became unavailable.
Section 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) contains LIBOR-specific provisions that permit card issuers for a credit card account under an open-end (not home-secured) consumer credit plan that uses a LIBOR index under the plan for calculating variable rates to replace the LIBOR index and change the margins for calculating the variable rates on or after April 1, 2022, in certain circumstances. Comment 55(b)(7)-1 addresses the interaction among the unavailability provisions in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i), the LIBOR-specific provisions in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii), and the contractual provisions applicable to the credit card account.
As discussed in more detail below in this section-by-section analysis, this interim final rule makes a number of changes to §§ 1026.55(b)(7)(i) and (b)(7)(ii) and the Official Interpretations below. In general, it: (1) replaces references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new defined term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer
loans”; (2) replaces the reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index with the 12-month USD LIBOR index; (3) expands the Official Interpretations to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule; (4) provides that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans to replace 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month USD LIBOR indices have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace; (5) provides if the creditor uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans, the creditor must use the index value of this index and the LIBOR index from a specified timeframe in determining whether the APR is substantially similar; and (6) explains when a card issuer that uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans satisfies the condition that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable or calculated using the LIBOR index.
Interaction among § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) and (ii) and contractual provisions.
Comment 55(b)(7)-1 provides that a card issuer may use either the provision in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) or § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) to replace a LIBOR index used under a credit card account under an open-end (not home-secured) consumer credit plan so long as the applicable conditions are met for the provision used. It provides examples illustrating when a card issuer may use these provisions. Each of these examples assumes that the LIBOR index used under the plan becomes unavailable after June 30, 2023. Specifically, comment 55(b)(7)-1.i provides an example where a contract for a credit card account under an open-end (not home-secured) consumer credit plan provides that a card issuer may not unilaterally replace an index under a plan unless the original index becomes unavailable and provides that the replacement index and replacement margin will result in an APR substantially similar to a rate that is in effect when the original index becomes unavailable. In this case, comment 55(b)(7)-1.i explains that the card issuer may use the unavailability provisions in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) to replace the LIBOR index used under the plan so long as the conditions of that provision are met. Comment 55(b)(7)-1.i also explains that the LIBOR-specific provisions in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) provide that a card issuer may replace the LIBOR index if the replacement index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. If the replacement index is not published on October 18, 2021, the card issuer generally must use the next calendar day for which both the LIBOR index and the replacement index are published as the date for selecting indices values in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. The one exception provided under comment 55(b)(7)-1.i is that if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the card issuer must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3) with respect to revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)-1.i, this interim final rule makes similar changes to comment 55(b)(7)-1.i. The CFPB is revising the example in comment 55(b)(7)-1.i by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to align terminology with the LIBOR Act and the Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule.
55(b)(7)(i)
Section 1026.55(b)(7)(i) contains an exception to the general rule in § 1026.55(a) restricting rate increases for index replacement and margin changes. Section 1026.55(b)(7)(i) provides that a card issuer may increase an APR when the card issuer changes the index and margin used to determine the APR if the original index becomes unavailable, as long as historical fluctuations in the original and replacement indices were substantially similar, and as long as the replacement index and replacement margin will produce a rate substantially similar to the rate that was in effect at the time the original index became unavailable. Section 1026.55(b)(7)(i) also provides that if the replacement index is newly established and therefore does not have any rate history, it may be used if it and the replacement margin will produce a rate substantially similar to the rate in effect when the original index became unavailable. Comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1 provides that for purposes of replacing a LIBOR index used under a plan pursuant to § 1026.55(b)(7)(i), a replacement index that is not newly established must have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index used under the plan, considering the historical fluctuations up through when the LIBOR index becomes unavailable or up through the date indicated in a Bureau determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar, whichever is earlier.
The Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
Comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii provides a determination by the Bureau that effective April 1, 2022, the SOFR-based spread-adjusted indices recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices respectively. It provides that the card issuer also must comply with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) that the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products and replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable in order to use this SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products as the replacement index for the applicable LIBOR index.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) with respect to revised comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2, -2.i, and -2.ii, the interim final rule makes similar changes to comments 55(b)(7)(i)-1, -1.i, and -1.ii. First, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii includes a cross-reference to this definition. Based on these changes,
revised comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii provides that the card issuer also must comply with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) requiring the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans and replacement margin result would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable. The substantially similar standard for the APR is discussed in further detail below in relation to comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2.
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. Comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii does not discuss the 12-month (formerly called 1-year) USD LIBOR.
54
In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index in comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. Section 105(a)(5) of the LIBOR Act provides that, for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations, a Board-selected benchmark replacement and the selection or use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement as a benchmark replacement with respect to a LIBOR contract constitutes a replacement that has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index that it is replacing. The Board's regulation provides that for a LIBOR contract that is a consumer loan, the benchmark replacement shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable amounts or tenor spread adjustment.
55
The CFPB is relying on the determination in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the USD LIBOR tenor that it is replacing. Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii to also apply this determination of the historical fluctuations substantially similar standard to the replacement of the 12-month USD LIBOR index with the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.
54
See
85 FR 36938, 36972, 36994 (June 18, 2020) (proposing comment 59(f)-4 and noting the Bureau's 2020 notice of proposed rulemaking proposed and solicited comment on allowing use of a specific replacement formula where the index change involved the 1-year tenor in addition to the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors).
55
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B) and (ii)(B).
Third, based on the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, the Bureau is removing its prior determination, that became effective April 1, 2022, concerning the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. By operation of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, all tenors of the Board-selected benchmark replacements have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
56
Thus, revised comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii provides that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month USD LIBOR index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to USD LIBOR tenor they are replacing. The Bureau's prior determination is obsolete. The “spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products” are the same as “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and the LIBOR Act determined that the latter has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the LIBOR tenors they replace. Removing this obsolete determination will avoid confusion.
56
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(5), 136 Stat. 830.
Fourth, to facilitate compliance, this interim final rule revises comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii by specifying that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are an exception to the requirement providing that the historical fluctuations considered when replacing a LIBOR index under a plan are the historical fluctuations up through the relevant date set forth in comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii. Accordingly, this interim final rule also revises comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.ii to provide that no further determination is required that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans meets the “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The changes to comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1 in relation to the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans do not alter or modify the Bureau's determination set forth in comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.i in relation to the prime rate as the replacement index for the 1-month or 3-month USD LIBOR index, except to provide that no further determination is needed that the prime rate published in the Wall Street Journal meets this standard for these tenors.
Additional guidance on determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) with respect to revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.iii, the interim final rule makes similar changes to comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.iii, which provides a non-exhaustive list of factors to be considered in whether a replacement index meets the Regulation Z “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index.
The CFPB is making two changes to comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.iii. First, the CFPB is making a technical correction in comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.iii to change “substantial” to “substantially” when considering the relevant factors in determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index. Second, similar to changes in revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-2.iii above, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(i)-1.iii by adding an exception for the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, as defined in new § 1026.2(a)(28). When using the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, a creditor need not consider the types of factors that have historical fluctuations substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index. Because the Board's final rule, in implementing the LIBOR Act, has determined that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are indices that have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to their respective LIBOR tenors, and the CFPB has determined in this interim final rule that this index meets the Regulation Z “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index, the factors need not be considered. While the CFPB had already applied the factors to the SOFR-based 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month LIBOR tenor replacement indices in its 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, by operation of law, the factors need not be considered with respect to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans for the 12-month LIBOR tenor in order for the index to satisfy Regulation Z's “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes of the interim final rule.
Substantially similar rate when LIBOR becomes unavailable.
Section 1026.55(b)(7)(i) provides that the replacement index and replacement margin must produce an APR substantially similar to the rate that was in effect based on the LIBOR index used under the plan when the LIBOR index became unavailable. Comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 provides that, for comparing rates, a card issuer generally must use the value of the replacement index and the LIBOR index on the day that the LIBOR index becomes unavailable. It provides that if the replacement index is not published on the day that the LIBOR index becomes unavailable, the card issuer generally must use the previous calendar day that both indices are published as the date for selecting indices values in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. The one exception under comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 is that, if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the card issuer must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
Comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 also provides that for purposes of § 1026.55(b)(7)(i), if a card issuer uses the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the card issuer will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(A) with respect to revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(A)-3, the interim final rule makes similar changes to comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2. First, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.”
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. Comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 does not discuss the 12-month (formerly called 1-year) USD LIBOR. In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index in comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 until it obtains additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. Sections 105(a)(2), (a)(3), and (a)(5) of the LIBOR Act provide that, for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations, a Board-selected benchmark replacement and the selection or use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement as a benchmark replacement with respect to a LIBOR contract constitutes a “comparable index” and “has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar” to those of the USD LIBOR index they are replacing. The Board's regulation provides that for a LIBOR contract that is a consumer loan, the benchmark replacement shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable amounts or tenor spread adjustment.
57
The determination in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation applies not only to the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans that are replacing the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month USD LIBOR, but also to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans that is replacing the 12-month tenor of LIBOR. Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(i)-2 to provide that for purposes of § 1026.55(b)(7)(i), if a card issuer uses the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the card issuer will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate in effect at the time the LIBOR index became unavailable. The CFPB solicits comment on these changes of the interim final rule.
57
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B) and (ii)(B).
55(b)(7)(ii)
Section 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) contains LIBOR-specific provisions that permit card issuers for a credit card account under an open-end (not home-secured) consumer credit plan that uses a LIBOR index under the plan for calculating variable rates to replace the LIBOR index and change the margins for calculating the variable rates on or after April 1, 2022, in certain circumstances. The CFPB explained in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule how, as a practical matter, § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) allows card issuers to provide the 45-day change-in-terms notices required under § 1026.9(c)(2) prior to the LIBOR indices becoming unavailable, and thus allows those card issuers to avoid being left without a LIBOR index to use in calculating the variable rate before the replacement index and margin become effective. Also, § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) allows card issuers to provide the change-in-terms notices, and replace the LIBOR index used under the plans, on accounts on a rolling basis, rather than having to provide the change-in-terms notices, and replace the LIBOR index, for all its accounts at the same time as the LIBOR index used under the plan becomes unavailable. The CFPB believes that this advance notice of the replacement index and any change in the margin is important to consumers to inform them of how variable rates will be determined going forward after the LIBOR index is replaced.
Section 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) provides that if a variable rate on a credit card account under an open-end (not home-secured) consumer credit plan is calculated using a LIBOR index, a card issuer may replace the LIBOR index and change the margin for calculating the variable rate on or after April 1, 2022, as long as: (1) the historical fluctuations in the LIBOR index and replacement index were substantially similar; and (2) the replacement index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. If the replacement index is newly established and therefore does not have any rate history, it may be used if the replacement index value in effect on
October 18, 2021, and the replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index value in effect on October 18, 2021, and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. Section 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) also provides that if the replacement index is not published on October 18, 2021, the card issuer generally must use the next calendar day for which both the LIBOR index and the replacement index are published as the date for selecting indices values in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. As set forth in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii), the one exception is that if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the card issuer must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index. Comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1 provides detail on determining whether a replacement index that is not newly established has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index used under the plan for purposes of § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii). It provides that for purposes of replacing a LIBOR index used under a plan pursuant to § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii), a replacement index that is not newly established must have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index used under the plan, considering the historical fluctuations up through the relevant date. If the Bureau has made a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar, the relevant date is the date indicated in that determination by the Bureau. If the Bureau has not made a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar, the relevant date is the later of April 1, 2022, or the date no more than 30 days before the card issuer makes a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B), the interim final rule is making two changes to § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii). First, the CFPB is revising § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Second, the CFPB is using the term 12-month tenor instead of 1-year tenor with respect to the USD LIBOR index.
The Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
Comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii provides a determination by the Bureau that, effective April 1, 2022, the SOFR-based spread-adjusted indices recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices respectively. The Bureau made this determination in case some card issuers choose to replace a LIBOR index with the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. Comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii also provides that in order to use this SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products discussed above as the replacement index for the applicable LIBOR index, the card issuer also must satisfy the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) that the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products and replacement margin will produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. Comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii provides that because of the exception in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii), the card issuer must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) with respect to revised comments 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1, -1.i, and -1.ii and discussed below, the interim final rule makes similar changes to comments 55(b)(7)(ii)-1, -1.i, and -1.ii. First, the CFPB is replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii includes a cross-reference to this definition. Based on these changes, revised comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii provides that the card issuer also must comply with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) requiring the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans and replacement margin to produce an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index and the margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. The substantially similar standard for this interim final rule is discussed in further detail below in relation to comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-3.
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. Comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii does not discuss the 12-month (formerly called 1-year) USD LIBOR.
58
In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index in comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. Section 105(a)(5) of the LIBOR Act provides that, for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations, a Board-selected benchmark replacement and the selection or use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement as a benchmark replacement with respect to a LIBOR contract constitutes a replacement that has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index that it is replacing. The Board's regulation provides that for a LIBOR contract that is a consumer loan, the benchmark replacement shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-
month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable amounts or tenor spread adjustment.
59
The CFPB is relying on the determination in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the USD LIBOR tenor that they are replacing. Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii to also apply this determination of the historical fluctuations substantially similar standard to the replacement of the 12-month USD LIBOR index with the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.
58
See
85 FR 36938, 36972, 36994 (June 18, 2020) (proposing comment 59(f)-4 and noting the Bureau's 2020 notice of proposed rulemaking proposed and solicited comment on allowing use of a specific replacement formula where the index change involved the 1-year tenor in addition to the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors).
59
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B) and (ii)(B).
Third, based on the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, the Bureau is removing its prior determination, that became effective April 1, 2022, concerning the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. By operation of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, all tenors of the Board-selected benchmark replacements have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
60
Thus, revised comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii provides that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month USD LIBOR index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to USD LIBOR tenor they are replacing. The Bureau's prior determination is obsolete. The “spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products” are the same as “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and the LIBOR Act determined that the latter has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the LIBOR tenors they replace. Removing this obsolete determination will avoid confusion.
60
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(5), 136 Stat. 830.
Fourth, to facilitate compliance, this interim final rule revises comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1 by specifying that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are an exception to the requirement providing that the historical fluctuations considered when replacing a LIBOR index under a plan are the historical fluctuations up through the relevant date set forth in comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii. Accordingly, this interim final rule also revises comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.ii to provide that no further determination is required to determine that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans meet the “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The changes to comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1 in relation to the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans do not alter or modify the Bureau's determination set forth in comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.i in relation to the prime rate as the replacement index for the 1-month or 3-month USD LIBOR index, except to provide that no further determination is needed that the prime rate published in the Wall Street Journal meets this standard for these tenors. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes of the interim final rule.
Additional guidance on determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of certain USD LIBOR indices.
For the same reasons as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) with respect to revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.iii, the interim final rule makes similar changes to comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.iii, which provides a non-exhaustive list of factors to be considered in whether a replacement index meets the Regulation Z “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index.
The CFPB is making two changes to comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.iii. First, the CFPB is making a technical correction in comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.iii to change “substantial” to “substantially” when considering the relevant factors in determining whether a replacement index has historical fluctuations substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index. Second, similar to changes in revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-1.iii above, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-1.iii by adding an exception for the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans, as defined in new § 1026.2(a)(28). When using the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumers loans, a creditor need not consider the types of factors that have historical fluctuations substantially similar to those of a particular LIBOR index. Because the Board's final rule, in implementing the LIBOR Act, has determined that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are indices that have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to their respective LIBOR tenors, and the CFPB has determined in this interim final rule that this index meets the Regulation Z “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard with respect to a particular LIBOR index, the factors need not be considered. While the CFPB had already applied the factors to the SOFR-based 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month LIBOR tenor replacement indices in its 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, by operation of law, the factors need not be considered with respect to the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans for the 12-month LIBOR tenor in order for the index to satisfy Regulation Z's “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes of the interim final rule.
Substantially similar rate.
Pursuant to § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii), if the replacement index is the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the card issuer must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, in determining whether the APR based on the replacement index is substantially similar to the rate based on the LIBOR index.
Comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-3 also provides for purposes of § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii), if a card issuer uses the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the card issuer will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index.
For the same reasons discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.40(f)(3)(ii)(B) above for revised comment 40(f)(3)(ii)(B)-3, this interim final rule implements a number of changes to comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-3. First, the CFPB is revising comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-3 by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.”
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-3 to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. This interim final rule revises comment 55(b)(7)(ii)-3 to provide that for purposes of
§ 1026.55(b)(7)(ii), if a card issuer uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index and uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan, the card issuer will be deemed to be in compliance with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index. Thus, a card issuer that uses the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month USD LIBOR index as the replacement index still must comply with the condition in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) that the replacement index and replacement margin would have resulted in an APR substantially similar to the rate calculated using the LIBOR index, but the card issuer will be deemed to be in compliance with this condition if the card issuer uses as the replacement margin the same margin that applied to the variable rate immediately prior to the replacement of the LIBOR index used under the plan. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes in the interim final rule.
Section 1026.59 Reevaluation of Rate Increases
59(f) Termination of the Obligation To Review Factors
59(f)(3)
TILA section 148, which was added by the Credit CARD Act of 2009,
61
provides that if a creditor increases the APR applicable to a credit card account under an open-end consumer credit plan, based on factors including the credit risk of the obligor, market conditions, or other factors, the creditor shall consider changes in such factors in subsequently determining whether to reduce the APR for such obligor.
62
Section 1026.59 implements this provision. The provisions in § 1026.59 generally apply to card issuers that increase an APR applicable to a credit card account, based on the credit risk of the consumer, market conditions, or other factors. For any rate increase imposed on or after January 1, 2009, card issuers generally are required to review the account no less frequently than once each six months and, if appropriate based on that review, reduce the APR.
61
Public Law 111-24, 123 Stat. 1734 (2009).
62
15 U.S.C. 1665c.
Section 1026.59(f) provides that this obligation to review the rate increase ceases to apply if the card issuer reduces the APR to a rate equal to or less than the rate applicable immediately prior to the increase, or if the rate applicable immediately prior to the increase was a variable rate, to a rate determined by the same index and margin (previous formula) that applied prior to the increase. Once LIBOR is discontinued, it will not be possible for card issuers to use the “same index.” As discussed in the CFPB's 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, because the discontinuation of LIBOR means that after discontinuation, the card issuer will not have a LIBOR index for use in the “previous formula” to determine the rate that applied prior to the increase, the existing methods to terminate the obligation to review would not apply.
Section 1026.59(f)(3) provides, effective April 1, 2022, a replacement formula that card issuers can use to terminate the obligation to review factors under § 1026.59(a) when the rate applicable immediately prior to the increase was a variable rate with a formula based on a LIBOR index. Section 1026.59(f)(3) applies to situations in which a LIBOR index is used as the index in the “previous formula” (
i.e.,
the formula used to determine the rate at which the obligation to review factors ceases).
63
Under § 1026.59(f)(3), the replacement formula, which includes the replacement index on October 18, 2021, plus replacement margin, must equal the LIBOR index value on October 18, 2021, plus the margin used to calculate the rate immediately prior to the increase.
64
Section 1026.59(f)(3) also provides that a card issuer must satisfy the conditions set forth in § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) for selecting a replacement index. Under § 1026.59(f)(3), if the replacement index is not published on October 18, 2021, the card issuer generally must use the values of the indices on the next calendar day for which both the LIBOR index and the replacement index are published as the index values to use to determine the replacement formula. The one exception in § 1026.59(f)(3) is that if the replacement index is the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 1-year USD LIBOR index, the card issuer must use the index value on June 30, 2023, for the LIBOR index and, for the SOFR-based spread-adjusted index for consumer products, must use the index value on the first date that index is published, as the index values to use to determine the replacement formula.
63
Section 1026.59(f)(3) does not apply to rate increases that may result from the switch from a LIBOR index to another index under § 1026.55(b)(7)(i) or § 1026.55(b)(7)(ii) as those potential rate increases will be excepted from the provisions of § 1026.59. Section 1026.59(f)(3) does, however, cover rate increases that were already subject to the provisions of § 1026.59 and that use a formula under § 1026.59(f) based on a LIBOR index to determine whether to terminate the review obligations under § 1026.59.
64
For purposes of § 1026.59(f)(3) “replacement index,” as defined in comment 59(f)-4, refers to the index used in the replacement formula, which identifies the value for benchmark comparison to determine if the obligation to conduct rate reevaluations terminates.
Additionally, comment 59(f)-4 provides methods for identifying the replacement index to be used in the formula by providing instructions for determining the relevant date through which the card issuer must determine that historical fluctuations between the indices are substantially similar. Comment 59(f)-4 provides that if the Bureau has made a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar, the relevant date is the date indicated in that determination, but if the Bureau has not made such a determination, the relevant date is the later of April 1, 2022, or the date no more than 30 days before the card issuer makes a determination that the replacement index and the LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar. Comment 59(f)-4 states the Bureau's determination that the prime rate published in the Wall Street Journal has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month and 3-month USD LIBOR indices and that the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products to replace the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the 1-month, 3-month, or 6-month USD LIBOR indices respectively.
For the reasons discussed below, and as discussed in the section-by-section analysis of § 1026.59(f)(3) and comment 59(f)-4 below, this interim final rule implements several revisions related to rate reevaluation provisions. First, as discussed in more detail in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.55(b)(7) above, and for the reasons discussed therein, the CFPB is revising § 1026.59(f)(3) by replacing references to the spread-adjusted index based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products with the new term
“the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” to align terminology in the rule with the LIBOR Act and the Board's 2022 LIBOR Act Final Rule. As discussed in the section-by-section analysis for § 1026.2(a)(28), this interim final rule also defines the term “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans.” Revised comment 59(f)-4 includes a cross-reference to that definition. As discussed above, these terms identify the same index, and the change is merely for consistency with the Act and ease of reading.
Second, the CFPB is expanding comment 59(f)-4 to include a replacement index for the 12-month USD LIBOR, which was not previously addressed in the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule. Comment 59(f)-4 does not discuss the 12-month (formerly called 1-year) USD LIBOR.
65
In the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the CFPB generally provided examples of SOFR-based replacement indices for the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors of USD LIBOR, but reserved judgment about whether to include a reference to the 1-year USD LIBOR index in comment 59(f)-4 until it obtained additional information. Since the CFPB promulgated the 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule, the LIBOR Act was enacted, and the Board issued its final rule implementing the Act. Section 105(a)(5) of the LIBOR Act provides that, for purposes of TILA and its implementing regulations, a Board-selected benchmark replacement and the selection or use of a Board-selected benchmark replacement as a benchmark replacement with respect to a LIBOR contract constitutes a replacement that has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to those of the LIBOR index that it is replacing. The Board's regulation provides that for a LIBOR contract that is a consumer loan, the benchmark replacement shall be the corresponding 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, or 12-month CME Term SOFR plus the applicable amounts or tenor spread adjustment.
66
The CFPB is relying on the determination in the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the USD LIBOR tenor that they are replacing. While section 104(f) of the LIBOR Act provides that nothing in the Act “may be construed to alter or impair— . . . (5) any provision of Federal consumer financial law that—(A) . . . govern the reevaluation of rate increases on credit card accounts under open-end (not home-secured) consumer credit plans,”
67
the CFPB is not relying on the LIBOR Act for its authority to provide an alternative method for determining whether the card issuer can terminate its obligation under the credit card account rate reevaluation requirements where the rate applicable immediately prior to a rate increase was a variable rate calculated using a LIBOR index. Instead, the CFPB is revising § 1026.59(f)(3) and comment 59(f)-4 pursuant to its authority to implement TILA section 148, as discussed above.
65
See
85 FR 36938, 36972, 36994 (June 18, 2020) (proposing comment 59(f)-4 and noting the Bureau's 2020 notice of proposed rulemaking proposed and solicited comment on allowing use of a specific replacement formula where the index change involved the 1-year tenor in addition to the 1-month, 3-month, and 6-month tenors).
66
12 CFR 253.4(b)(2)(i)(B) and (ii)(B).
67
LIBOR Act section 104(f), 136 Stat. 829.
Third, based on the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, the Bureau is removing its prior determination, that became effective April 1, 2022, concerning the spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products. By operation of the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation, all tenors of the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans have “historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to” the LIBOR tenors they replace.
68
Thus, the CFPB is revising comment 59(f)-4 to provide that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans to replace the 1-month, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month USD LIBOR index have historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to USD LIBOR tenor they are replacing. The Bureau's prior determination is obsolete. The “spread-adjusted indices based on SOFR recommended by the ARRC for consumer products” are the same as “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and the LIBOR Act determined that the latter has historical fluctuations that are substantially similar to the LIBOR tenors they replace. Removing this obsolete determination will avoid confusion.
68
LIBOR Act section 105(a)(5), 136 Stat. 830.
Fourth, to facilitate compliance, this interim final rule revises comment 59(f)-4 by specifying that the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans are an exception to the requirement providing that the historical fluctuations considered when replacing a LIBOR index under a plan are the historical fluctuations up through the relevant date as set forth in comment 59(f)-4. Accordingly, this interim final rule also revises comment 59(f)-4 to provide that no further determination is required that the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans meets the “historical fluctuations are substantially similar” standard. The changes to comment 59(f)-4 in relation to the Board-selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans do not alter or modify the Bureau's determination set forth in comment 59(f)-4 in relation to the prime rate as the replacement index for the 1-month or 3-month USD LIBOR index, except to provide that no further determination is needed that the prime rate published in the Wall Street Journal meets this standard for these tenors. The CFPB solicits comments on these changes in the interim final rule.
VI. Effective Date
The final rule will take effect on May 15, 2023, which should be approximately 45 days before the expected discontinuation of LIBOR.
VII. Dodd-Frank Act Section 1022(b) Analysis
A. Overview
In developing the interim final rule, the CFPB has considered the interim final rule's potential benefits, costs, and impacts.
69
The CFPB requests comment on the analysis presented below as well as submissions of additional data that could inform the CFPB's analysis of the benefits, costs, and impacts. In developing the interim final rule, the CFPB has consulted with, or offered to consult with, the appropriate prudential regulators and other Federal agencies regarding consistency with any prudential, market, or systemic objectives administered by such agencies.
69
Specifically, section 1022(b)(2)(A) of the Dodd-Frank Act requires the Bureau to consider the potential benefits and costs of the regulation to consumers and covered persons, including the potential reduction of access by consumers to consumer financial products and services; the impact of proposed rules on insured depository institutions and insured credit unions with less than $10 billion in total assets as described in section 1026 of the Dodd-Frank Act; and the impact on consumers in rural areas. The applicability of section 1022(b)(2)(A) to this rulemaking is unclear, but the Bureau has performed the described analysis.
The CFPB is issuing an interim final rule amending Regulation Z, which implements TILA, to reflect the enactment of the LIBOR Act and its implementing regulation promulgated by the Board. This interim final rule further addresses the planned cessation of most USD LIBOR tenors after June 30, 2023, by incorporating the Board-
selected benchmark replacements for consumer loans into Regulation Z. This interim final rule conforms the terminology from the LIBOR Act and the Board's implementing regulation into relevant Regulation Z open-end and closed-end credit provisions and also addresses treatment of the 12-month USD LIBOR index and its replacement index, including permitting creditors to use alternative language in change-in-terms notice content requirements for situations where the 12-month tenor of the LIBOR index is being replaced consistent with the LIBOR Act.
The CFPB is making four categories of amendments to various provisions in Regulation Z to make changes consistent with the LIBOR Act to address the anticipated sunset of LIBOR.
First, (the “terminology amendments”) the CFPB is changing the terminology used in the CFPB's 2021 LIBOR Transition Final Rule to make it consistent with terminology in the LIBOR Act. Specifically, for both-open and closed-end credit as discussed in further detail below, the CFPB is replacing all references to the “index based on SOFR recommended by the Alternative Reference Rates Committee for consumer products” with references to the “the Board-selected benchmark replacement for consumer loans” and adding a new definition for that term in the Official Interpretations. The CFPB is also replacing all references to the “1-year” USD LIBOR with references to the “12-month” USD LIBOR.
Second, (“12-month historical fluctuations amendments”) for both open- and closed-end credit, the CFPB is revising the Official Interpretations to incorporate the Board-selected benchmark replac
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.