Student Assistance General Provisions, Federal Perkins Loan Program, Federal Family Education Loan Program, and William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program.
Federal RegisterJul 13, 2022
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
34 CFR Parts 600, 668, 674, 682, and 685
[Docket ID ED-2021-OPE-0077]
RIN 1840-AD53, 1840-AD59, 1840-AD70, 1840-AD71
Student Assistance General Provisions, Federal Perkins Loan Program, Federal Family Education Loan Program, and William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan Program.
AGENCY:
Office of Postsecondary Education, Department of Education.
ACTION:
Notice of proposed rulemaking.
SUMMARY:
This notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) covers student loans and affordability issues. This rulemaking specifically discusses issues involving loans under the William D. Ford Direct Loan (Direct Loan) Program, the Federal Perkins Loan (Perkins) Program, and the Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL) Program. The Secretary proposes to amend the regulations governing seven topics related to student loans administered by the U.S. Department of Education. First, we propose to amend the regulations governing the William D. Ford Federal Direct Loan (Direct Loan) Program to establish a new Federal standard and process for determining whether a borrower has a defense to repayment on a loan. We also propose to prohibit the use of certain contractual provisions regarding dispute resolution processes by participating institutions, and to require certain notifications and disclosures by institutions regarding their use of arbitration. Additionally, we propose to amend the Perkins, Direct Loan, and FFEL Program regulations to improve the process for granting total and permanent disability (TPD) discharges by eliminating the income monitoring period and expanding allowable documentation allowing additional health care professionals to provide a certification that a borrower is totally and permanently disabled. We further propose to amend the closed school discharge provisions in the Perkins Loan, Direct Loan, and FFEL programs to expand borrower eligibility for automatic discharges and eliminate provisions pertaining to reenrollment in a comparable program. We further propose to amend the Direct Loan and FFEL regulations to streamline the regulations governing false certification discharges. We propose to amend the Direct Loan regulations to eliminate interest capitalization in instances where it is not required by statute. Finally, we propose to amend regulations governing Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) in the Direct Loan program to improve the application process, and to clarify and expand definitions for full-time employment, qualifying employers, and qualifying monthly payments. The proposed changes would bring greater transparency and clarity and improve the administration of Federal student financial aid programs to assist and protect students, participating institutions, and taxpayers.
DATES:
We must receive your comments on or before August 12, 2022.
ADDRESSES:
For more information regarding submittal of comments, please see
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
. Comments must be submitted via the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
Regulations.gov
. However, if you require an accommodation or cannot otherwise submit your comments via
Regulations.gov
, please contact Mr. Jean-Didier Gaina, U.S. Department of Education, 400 Maryland Ave. SW, Room 2C172, Washington, DC 20202 or by phone at (202) 453-7551 or by email at
jean-didier.gaina@ed.gov.
Federal eRulemaking Portal:
Please go to
www.regulations.gov
to submit your comments electronically. Information on using
Regulations.gov
, including instructions for finding a rule on the site and submitting comments, is available on the site under “FAQ.”
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
For assistance to individuals with disabilities for reviewing the rulemaking record, contact Valerie Lefor at (202) 453-7724 or
valerie.lefor@ed.gov.
For further information related to interest capitalization, contact Vanessa Freeman at (202) 453-7378 or by email at
vanessa.freeman@ed.gov.
For further information related to borrower defenses or pre-dispute arbitration, contact Rene Tiongquico at (202) 453-7513 or by email at
rene.tiongquico@ed.gov.
For further information related to TPD, closed school, and false certification discharges, contact Brian Smith at (202) 453-7440 or by email at
brian.smith@ed.gov.
For further information related to PSLF, contact Tamy Abernathy at (202) 453-5970 or by email at
tamy.abernathy@ed.gov.
If you are deaf, hard of hearing, or have a speech disability and wish to access telecommunications relay services, please dial 7-1-1.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
Submission of Comments
The Department will not accept comments submitted by fax or by email or those submitted after the comment period. To ensure that the Department does not receive duplicate copies, please submit your comments only once. Additionally, please include the Docket ID at the top of your comments.
The Department strongly encourages you to submit any comments or attachments in Microsoft Word format. If you must submit a comment in Adobe Portable Document Format (PDF), the Department strongly encourages you to convert the PDF to “print-to-PDF” format, or to use some other commonly used searchable text format. Please do not submit the PDF in a scanned format. Using a print-to-PDF format allows the Department to electronically search and copy certain portions of your submissions to assist in the rulemaking process.
Privacy Note:
The Department's policy is to make all comments received from members of the public available for public viewing in their entirety on the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
www.regulations.gov.
Commenters should not include in their comments any information that identifies other individuals or that permits readers to identify other individuals. If, for example, your comment describes an experience of someone other than yourself, please do not identify that individual or include information that would allow readers to identify that individual. The Department will not make comments that contain personally identifiable information (PII) about someone other than the commenter publicly available on
www.regulations.gov
for privacy reasons. This may include comments where the commenter refers to a third-party individual without using their name if the Department determines that the comment provides enough detail that could allow one or more readers to link the information to the third party. If your comment refers to a third-party individual, to help ensure that your comment is posted, please consider submitting your comment anonymously to reduce the chance that information in your comment about a third party could be linked to the third party. The Department will also not make comments that contain threats of harm to another person or to oneself available on
www.regulations.gov.
Therefore, commenters should be careful to include in their comments only information that they wish to make publicly available.
Executive Summary
Purpose of This Regulatory Action: College affordability and student loan debt have been significant challenges for many Americans. Student loan debt has
risen over the past 10 years as student loan repayment has slowed, while the inability to repay student loan debt has been cited as a major obstacle to entry into the middle class.
1
1
R. Chakrabarti, N. Gorton, and W. van der Klaauw, “Diplomas to Doorsteps: Education, Student Debt, and Homeownership,” Federal Reserve Bank of New York
Liberty Street Economics
(blog), April 3, 2017,
http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2017/04/diplomas-to-doorsteps-education-student-debt-and-homeownership.html.
This NPRM proposes several significant improvements to existing programs authorized under the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA), 20 U.S.C. 1001,
et seq.,
that grant discharges to borrowers who meet specific eligibility conditions. Despite the presence of these discharge authorities for years, if not decades, the Department is concerned that too many borrowers have been unable to access loan relief through these opportunities. In some situations, this has been due to regulatory requirements that have created unnecessary or unfair burdens for borrowers.
These proposed changes relate to discharges available to borrowers in the three major Federal student loan programs: Direct Loans, Federal Family Education Loan (FFEL), and Perkins Loans. The most significant effects would be in the Direct Loan program, which has been the predominant source of all Federal student loans since 2010. In this program the Department makes loans directly to the borrower and then contracts with private companies known as student loan servicers to manage the borrower's repayment experience on behalf of the Department. Several of the components of these proposed regulations, such as interest capitalization, borrower defense to repayment, the ban on the use of mandatory pre-dispute arbitration, the prohibition on class action waivers, and the Public Service Loan Forgiveness program are only related to Direct Loans. Other provisions, such as closed school discharge, total and permanent disability discharges, and false certification discharges, would affect Direct Loans as well as loans previously issued under the FFEL Program and the Perkins Loan Program.
2
In the FFEL program, private lenders issue Federal student loans using their own funds, then receive both a Government guarantee against most of the losses in the case of default and quarterly Federal subsidies. In the Perkins program, institutions of higher education (institutions) issue Federal student loans using a combination of Federal and institutional funds.
2
No new student loans are currently issued under either the FFEL and Perkins Loan programs. There have been no new FFEL loans issued since June 30, 2010, and the Perkins Loan program stopped issuing new loans on September 30, 2017.
Borrower Defense to Repayment, Arbitration, and Class Action Waivers
The proposed regulations for the borrower defense to repayment program, which applies only for Direct Loan borrowers, would expand the current basis for a borrower to receive a discharge for loans obtained to attend a particular institution. As proposed, a borrower defense discharge would occur when the Department determines an institution engaged in substantial misrepresentations or substantial omissions of fact, breached a loan contract, engaged in aggressive academic recruitment, or was subject to a judgment based on Federal or State law in a court or administrative tribunal of competent jurisdiction for any of the above behaviors. The proposed changes to the regulations governing borrower defense discharges are designed to further protect student loan borrowers from the financial effects of certain predatory practices. Where a borrower defense discharge is warranted, the proposed regulations would also enhance the Department's recoupment authorities, making it easier for the Department to hold institutions accountable for costs, reducing the financial impact to taxpayers. It would also include a process for the Department to recoup the cost of these discharges from institutions. The proposed changes are in direct response to numerous instances observed by the Department over time in which students borrow to attend an institution only to find that the institution's promises were untrue, leaving the borrower with a loan for a substandard education and often lacking the ability to obtain the employment they were promised. The proposed changes to the borrower defense regulations would apply to both public and private institutions. To date, much of the concerning evidence of unacceptable institutional practices comes from private for-profit colleges and universities; a large share of whose enrollment is Black students, Latino students, students who are older, students who are working full-time while enrolled in college, and students who did not enroll in postsecondary education directly from high school. However, the regulations would not be limited to only private for-profit schools but would cover conduct at public and private nonprofit institutions as well.
As proposed, the regulations would also prevent institutions wishing to participate in title IV programs from requiring either the use of mandatory arbitration or waiver of class action lawsuits, including prohibiting putting such requirements within the loan contract for a Direct Loan.
Interest Capitalization
The proposed regulations would eliminate most interest capitalization on Direct Loans by removing the current regulatory provisions that require capitalization under circumstances when capitalization is not required by statute.
3
As proposed, accrued interest would no longer be capitalized when: a borrower enters repayment; upon the expiration of a period of forbearance; annually after periods of negative amortization under the alternative repayment plan or the ICR plan; when a borrower defaults on a loan; when a borrower who is repaying under the income-driven repayment Pay as You Earn (PAYE) plan fails to recertify income or chooses to leave the plan; and when a borrower who is repaying under another income-driven repayment the Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE) plan fails to recertify income or leaves the plan. These proposed changes would decrease the rate at which a borrower's principal loan balance grows over time.
3
Currently, accrued interest is added to the outstanding principal balance and the new principal balance is used for future accumulation of interest.
Public Service Loan Forgiveness
The Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program authorizes Direct Loan borrowers engaged in public service to receive a discharge of remaining loan balances after making the equivalent of 10 years of qualifying payments.
4
The Department, however, is concerned that the current regulations around this program are too restrictive, particularly in the requirements for a payment to qualify toward forgiveness. For instance, the Limited PSLF Waiver announced in October 2021 has helped more than 1 million borrowers receive on average an additional year of credit toward PSLF by addressing many of the same challenges in regulations that these proposed regulations would seek to fix. Accordingly, the regulations propose to improve the PSLF application process and allow borrowers to receive credit toward PSLF for months during which they are in certain deferment and forbearance periods while working for a qualified employer.
4
Section 455(m) of the HEA.
Total and Permanent Disability Discharges
The Higher Education Act provides for borrowers to receive a student loan discharge if they have a total and permanent disability. The proposed regulations would allow more borrowers who meet the statutory requirements for one of these discharges to receive a discharge by allowing additional categories of disability determinations by the Social Security Administration to qualify for a discharge. They would also allow additional types of medical professionals to certify that a borrower has a total and permanent disability. The regulations would also allow more borrowers who received a discharge to avoid having their loans reinstated by removing the 3-year income monitoring period that currently exists in regulation. The net effect of these changes would be a program that is simpler for eligible borrowers to access and navigate.
Closed School Discharges
Borrowers whose college closes while they are enrolled or shortly after they have left can receive a closed school discharge so long as they have not graduated. The Department proposes to clarify and streamline the eligibility requirements for closed school discharges by providing more automatic discharges for borrowers within one year of their college closing. The proposed regulations would also clarify existing rules that limit discharges for borrowers who enroll in a comparable program to only apply in instances where a borrower accepts and completes an approved teach-out program.
False Certification Discharges
Borrowers are eligible for a false certification discharge under the HEA if the institution that certifies the borrower's eligibility for the loan does so under false pretenses, such as when the borrower did not have a high school diploma or equivalent and did not meet alternative criteria; when the borrower had a status that disqualified them from meeting legal requirements for employment in the occupation for which they are training; or if the institution signed the borrower's name without authorization. A confusing web of regulations has established different standards and processes for false certification discharges depending on when the loan was disbursed. Furthermore, some borrowers who may be eligible for a discharge have not received it because the requirements are difficult to navigate. The proposed regulations would streamline the false certification discharge process for student loan borrowers by establishing standards that apply to all claims, regardless of when the loan was first disbursed, and providing for a group discharge process.
Summary of the Major Provisions of This Regulatory Action
The proposed regulations would—
• Amend the Direct Loan regulations to establish a new Federal standard for borrower defense claims applicable to applications received on or after July 1, 2023. Applications pending before the Secretary on July 1, 2023 would also be considered under the proposed new standard. In addition, the NPRM would expand the existing definition of misrepresentation, provide an additional basis for a borrower defense claim based on aggressive and deceptive recruitment practices, and allow claims based on State law standards.
• Establish processes for group borrower defense claims that may be formed in response to evidence provided by State requestors or based on prior Secretarial Final Actions identifying conduct that could lead to an approved borrower defense claim under the Department's regulations if application were made. Secretarial Final Actions would include, but not be limited to, program reviews, suspension, or termination actions.
• Stop interest accrual on borrowers' loans 180 days from the initial grant of forbearance or stopped collections if the Department does not make a determination on the borrower defense claim within certain timeframes. Interest accrual would resume once a decision on the claim is made.
• Establish a reconsideration process for review of denied borrower defense claims.
• Require schools to disclose publicly and notify the Secretary of judicial and arbitration filings and awards pertaining to a borrower defense claim.
• Prohibit schools that wish to participate in title IV programs from requiring borrowers to agree to mandatory pre-dispute arbitration agreements or waiver of class action lawsuits.
• Eliminate interest capitalization on Direct Loans where such capitalization is not required by statute to address growth in principal balances.
• Modify the Perkins, FFEL, and Direct Loan regulations to streamline the application process for a TPD discharge by expanding the Department's use of Social Security Administration (SSA) codes beyond “Medical Improvement Not Expected” when deciding if a borrower qualifies for TPD discharge.
• Revise the Perkins, FFEL, and Direct Loan regulations to eliminate the 3-year post-discharge income monitoring period for borrowers eligible for TPD discharge to allow borrowers to retain their discharges to retain their discharges without unnecessary paperwork burden.
• Allow borrowers to receive a TPD discharge if the onset of their disability as determined by SSA was at least 5 years prior to the application to better align the regulations with statutory requirements for a TPD discharge.
• Expand the list of health professionals who may certify that a borrower is totally and permanently disabled to include licensed nurse practitioners (NPs), physician's assistants (PAs), and clinical psychologists to help borrowers more easily complete the application for a TPD discharge.
• Amend the Perkins, FFEL, and Direct Loan regulations to simplify the closed school discharge process by expanding access to automatic discharges and eliminating the requirement that borrowers who reenroll in a comparable program lose eligibility for a discharge.
• Streamline the FFEL and Direct Loan false certification regulations to provide one set of regulatory standards that would cover all false certification discharge claims.
• Clarify that the Department would rely on the borrower's status at the time the loan was originated for a Direct Loan, and at the time the loan was certified for a FFEL loan, to determine eligibility for a false certification discharge.
• Revise the regulations for PSLF to improve the application process, expand what counts as an eligible monthly payment, expand the definition of “full-time” employment, and provide additional clarifying definitions of public service employment to reduce confusion and to clearly establish the definitions of qualifying employment for borrowers.
Please refer to the
Summary of Proposed Changes
section of this NPRM for more details on the above proposals.
Costs and Benefits:
As further detailed in the
Regulatory Impact Analysis,
the benefits of the proposed regulations include: (1) a clarified process for borrower defense discharge applications assisted by the creation of a single upfront Federal standard to streamline the Department's consideration of applications, while affording institutions an opportunity to respond to allegations contained in borrower
defense claims; (2) increased opportunities for borrowers to seek relief from institutional misconduct by prohibiting the use of mandatory pre-dispute arbitration and class action waivers; (3) improved school conduct and reduced cost to taxpayers, by holding individual institutions financially accountable for borrower defense discharges and deterring misconduct; (4) increased automated discharges for borrowers and additional flexibilities in establishing eligibility for PSLF and other loan discharges; and (5) improved access to and expanded eligibility for, where appropriate, closed school, TPD, and false certification discharges.
Costs to taxpayers in the form of transfers include borrower defense claims that are not reimbursed by institutions; additional relief through closed school, PSLF, TPD, and false certification discharges to borrowers through programs to which they are legally entitled in the HEA; and the foregone interest where capitalizing interest is not required. The paperwork burden associated with reporting and disclosure necessary to ensure compliance with the proposed regulations represents an additional cost to institutions.
Invitation to Comment:
We invite you to submit comments regarding these proposed regulations. To ensure that your comments have maximum effect in developing the final regulations, we urge you to clearly identify the specific section or sections of the proposed regulations that each of your comments addresses and to arrange your comments in the same order as the proposed regulations.
We invite you to assist us in complying with the specific requirements of Executive Orders 12866 and 13563 and their overall requirement of reducing regulatory burden that might result from these proposed regulations. Please let us know of any further ways we could reduce potential costs or increase potential benefits while preserving the effective and efficient administration of the Department's programs and activities. During and after the comment period, you may inspect all public comments about these proposed regulations by accessing
Regulations.gov
.
Assistance to Individuals With Disabilities in Reviewing the Rulemaking Record:
On request we will provide a reasonable accommodation or auxiliary aid to an individual with a disability who needs assistance to review the comments or other documents in the public rulemaking record for these proposed regulations. If you want to schedule an appointment for this type of accommodation or auxiliary aid, please contact the person listed under
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT
.
Background
The Department seeks to address longstanding concerns regarding Federal student loan debt by improving, streamlining, expanding, and strengthening regulations governing the title IV, HEA programs. Specifically, we propose to modify the regulations for loan discharge programs to strengthen institutional accountability, expand program access for eligible borrowers, and provide more efficient and borrower-friendly processes overall. After analyzing the public's input provided during public hearings and written comments submitted in response to the notice of our intent to establish negotiated rulemaking committees, the Department identified 12 issues for consideration by a negotiated rulemaking committee. These 12 issues are: improving the process for TPD discharges, improving borrower access to closed school discharges, eliminating interest capitalization where it is not required by statute, improving the PSLF application process, clarifying employer eligibility and full-time employment under PSLF, improving the borrower defense adjudication process, strengthening borrower defense post-adjudication processes, ensuring accountability by recovering borrower defense claims from institutions, prohibiting institutional use of pre-dispute mandatory arbitration clauses or class action waivers, improving borrower access to false certification discharges, creating a new income-driven repayment plan, and establishing regulations for institutions to maintain a prison education program. Proposed regulations addressing 10 of the 12 issues listed above are included in this NPRM. Proposed regulations relating to a new income-driven repayment plan and to establish Pell Grant eligibility for incarcerated individuals enrolled in qualifying prison education programs will be published in a future NPRM or NPRMs.
Throughout this NPRM, the Department is proposing changes that would allow the Secretary to use automated application processes for granting discharges as well as leverage other information available to the Secretary, consistent with regulations and statute governing the use and sharing of borrower data. The proposed regulations would also result in more borrowers receiving discharges for which they are eligible by eliminating the need for individual applications where possible, expand eligibility categories for TPD discharges, authorize use of additional documentation for TPD and false certification discharges, clarify eligibility requirements for PSLF and closed school discharges, and expand and clarify ways in which a borrower can establish a borrower defense claim. Increased discharges reduce repayments from borrowers, resulting in a transfer from taxpayers to the affected borrowers. For some discharges, especially borrower defense and closed school discharges, the Department will seek to recover funds from the institutions involved, but that is not expected to reimburse the full amount. Increased discharges are expected to increase the cost of the student loan programs to taxpayers, as detailed in the Regulatory Impact Analysis. Despite these increased costs in the form of transfers, the Department believes the benefits of these changes exceed the costs. The discharge programs addressed by these proposed regulations were all authorized by Congress. The Department does not believe it would be reasonable to presume that when Congress created those programs, it intended to limit the cost of those programs through the types of operational and administrative barriers the Department is proposing to remove in this notice of proposed rulemaking. The proposed changes would thus make these discharge programs more successful at delivering promised benefits under the HEA.
Public Participation
The Department engaged the public in developing this NPRM through analysis of written comments submitted by the public outside of this NPRM comment solicitation, three public hearings, and three negotiated rulemaking sessions.
On May 26, 2021, the Department published a notice in the
Federal Register
(86 FR 28299) announcing our intent to establish multiple negotiated rulemaking committees to prepare proposed regulations on the affordability of postsecondary education, Federal student loans, and institutional accountability.
The Department developed a list of proposed regulatory provisions for the Affordability and Student Loans Committee (Committee) from advice and recommendations submitted by individuals and organizations in testimony at three virtual public hearings held by the Department on June 21, June 23, and June 24, 2021. Transcripts of the public hearings are
available at
https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2021/index.html?src=rn.
In addition to oral testimony, the Department accepted written comments on possible regulatory provisions from interested parties and organizations. You may view the written comments submitted in response to the May 26, 2021
Federal Register
notice on the Federal eRulemaking Portal at
www.regulations.gov,
within docket ID ED-2021-OPE-0077. Instructions for finding comments are also available on the site under “FAQ.”
Negotiated Rulemaking
Section 492 of the HEA requires the Secretary to involve the public in the development of proposed regulations prior to publication for programs authorized by title IV of the HEA. After obtaining advice and recommendations from the public, including individuals and representatives of groups involved in the Federal student financial assistance programs, the Secretary must establish a negotiated rulemaking committee and subject the proposed regulations to a negotiated rulemaking process. All proposed regulations that the Department publishes on which the negotiators reached consensus must conform to final agreements resulting from that process, unless the Secretary reopens the process or provides a written explanation to the participants stating why the Secretary has decided to depart from the agreements. Further information on the negotiated rulemaking process can be found at:
https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/hea08/neg-reg-faq.html.
On August 10, 2021, the Department published a notice in the
Federal Register
(86 FR 43609) announcing its intention to establish the Committee to prepare proposed regulations for the title IV, HEA programs. The notice set forth a schedule for the Committee meetings and requested nominations for individual negotiators to serve on the Committee. In the notice, the Department announced the topics that the Committee would address.
The Committee included the following members representing their respective constituencies:
• Accrediting Agencies: Heather Perfetti, Middle States Commission on Higher Education, and Michale McComis (alternate), Accrediting Commission of Career Schools and Colleges.
• Dependent Students: Dixie Samaniego, California State University, and Greg Norwood (alternate), Young Invincibles.
• Departments of Corrections: Anne L. Precythe, Missouri Department of Corrections.
• Federal Family Education Loan Lenders and/or Guaranty Agencies: Jaye O'Connell, Vermont Student Assistance Corporation, and Will Shaffner (alternate), Higher Education Loan Authority of the State of Missouri.
• Financial Aid Administrators at Postsecondary Institutions: Daniel Barkowitz, Valencia College, and Alyssa A. Dobson (alternate), Slippery Rock University.
• Four-Year Public Institutions: Marjorie Dorime-Williams, University of Missouri, and Rachelle Feldman (alternate), University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.
• Independent Students: Michaela Martin, University of La Verne, and Stanley Andrisse (alternate), Howard University.
• Individuals with Disabilities or Groups Representing Them: Bethany Lilly, The Arc of the United States, and John Whitelaw, (alternate) Community Legal Aid Society.
• Legal Assistance Organizations that Represent Students and/or Borrowers: Persis Yu, National Consumer Law Center, and Joshua Rovenger (alternate), Legal Aid Society of Cleveland.
• Minority-serving Institutions: Noelia Gonzalez, California State University.
• Private Nonprofit Institutions: Misty Sabouneh, Southern New Hampshire University, and Terrence S. McTier, Jr. (alternate), Washington University.
• Proprietary Institutions: Jessica Barry, The Modern College of Design in Kettering, Ohio, and Carol Colvin (alternate), South College.
• State Attorneys General: Joseph Sanders, Illinois Board of Higher Education, and Eric Apar (alternate), New Jersey Department of Consumer Affairs.
• State Higher Education Executive Officers, State Authorizing Agencies, and/or State Regulators: David Tandberg, State Higher Education Executive Officers Association, and Suzanne Martindale (alternate), California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation.
• Student Loan Borrowers: Jeri O'Bryan-Losee, United University Professions, and Jennifer Cardenas (alternate), Young Invincibles.
• Two-year Public Institutions: Robert Ayala, Southwest Texas Junior College, and Christina Tangalakis (alternate), Glendale Community College.
• U.S. Military Service Members and Veterans or Groups Representing Them: Justin Hauschild, Student Veterans of America, and Emily DeVito (alternate), The Veterans of Foreign Wars.
• Federal Negotiator: Jennifer M. Hong, U.S. Department of Education.
The Committee agreed to add an additional constituency for Departments of Corrections during its second session and approved the membership of Anne L. Precythe of the Missouri Department of Corrections. In addition, there were two non-voting advisors available during the negotiations: Rajeev Darolia, advisor on Economic and/or Higher Education Data, University of Kentucky, and Heather Jarvis, advisor on PSLF Issues, co-founder of FosterUs.
The Committee met to develop proposed regulations during the months of October, November, and December 2021.
At its first meeting, the Committee reached agreement on its protocols and reviewed the 12 issues on the agenda. The facilitators reminded the Committee that consensus means that there is no dissent by any member of the Committee and that consensus checks would be taken issue-by-issue.
At its final meeting in December 2021, the Committee reached consensus on the proposed regulations addressing four of the 12 issues on its agenda: eliminating nonstatutory interest capitalizing events, improving the process for TPD discharges, streamlining the processes for false certification discharges, and establishing a framework for Pell Grant Eligibility for Prison Education Programs. This NPRM includes proposed regulations on the first three of these consensus items, as well as the remaining seven items on the Committee's agenda, summarized generally above. Proposed regulations for the fourth item on which consensus was reached, Pell Grant Eligibility for Prison Education Programs will be included in a later NPRM. We will also include Income-Driven repayment, on which consensus was not reached, in a future NPRM.
The proposed regulations also include technical changes to the regulations that are needed to reflect recent amendments to the HEA and to correct certain technical errors. These types of changes are not normally subject to the statutory requirements for negotiated rulemaking and public notice and comment. However, since these changes affect the proposed regulations, the Secretary included them in the material considered by the Committee to ensure that the Committee evaluated the full scope of the proposed changes.
More information on the work of the Committee can be found at:
https://
www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2021/index.html?src=rn.
Summary of Proposed Regulations
We group major issues according to subject, with appropriate sections of the proposed regulations referenced in parentheses. We discuss other substantive issues under the sections of the proposed regulations to which they pertain. Generally, we do not address proposed regulatory provisions that are technical or otherwise minor in effect. Any such change not explicitly mentioned in this summary remains open for public comment.
1. Borrower Defense to Repayment
Background:
Section 455(h) of the HEA authorizes the Secretary to specify which acts or omissions of an institution of higher education a borrower may assert as a defense to the repayment of a Direct Loan (
i.e.,
a borrower defense). 20 U.S.C. 1087e(h).
The Department first issued borrower defense regulations in 1994, which went into effect in 1995. The 1994 borrower defense regulation at § 685.206(c) provided that any act or omission of the institution attended by the student that relates to the making of a Direct Loan for enrollment at the school or the provision of educational services for which the loan was provided, giving rise to a cause of action against the institution under applicable State law (the “State law standard”), is a “borrower defense.”
In response to the precipitous closure of Corinthian Colleges, Inc. (Corinthian) in 2015 and the related influx of borrower defense claims submitted by individuals who attended institutions owned by Corinthian, the Department realized the need to update the borrower defense regulations. The Department developed new borrower defense regulations in 2016 that were supposed to take effect in 2017 to establish a more accessible and consistent borrower defense standard (the “Federal standard”). We issued the final regulations on November 1, 2016, and those final regulations generally applied to borrowers with new loans that were made on or after July 1, 2017. 81 FR 75926 (Nov. 1, 2016). The new Federal standard clarified and streamlined the borrower defense claim process. While the Federal standard only applied to loans issued after July 1, 2017, the borrower defense claim process applied to loans regardless of their disbursement date. The 2016 regulation also enhanced protections for borrowers and improved the Department's ability to hold institutions financially accountable for their actions and omissions that resulted in loan discharges.
In accordance with the master calendar, the 2016 borrower defense regulations were originally scheduled to be effective on July 1, 2017. However, these regulations did not take effect on their original effective date. After a legal challenge was filed, the Department took several actions to delay the effective date. See,
e.g.,
82 FR 27621 (June 16, 2017). In addition, the Department initiated a new negotiated rulemaking process to develop new regulations, and on July 31, 2018, the Department published a NPRM (2018 NPRM). 83 FR 37242 (July 31, 2018). Soon thereafter, in September 2018, a Federal court invalidated the Department's actions delaying implementation of the 2016 regulations, and the 2016 regulation went into effect in October 2018.
Bauer
v.
DeVos,
325 F. Supp. 3d 74 (D.D.C. 2018).
See California Ass'n of Private Postsecondary Schs.
v.
DeVos,
344 F. Supp. 3d 158 (D.D.C. 2018). Meanwhile, the Department did not withdraw the 2018 NPRM and on September 23, 2019, following consideration of public comments on the 2018 NPRM, the Department published new final borrower defense regulations that applied to loans made on or after July 1, 2020. 84 FR 49788 (Sept. 23, 2019). Those regulations became effective on July 1, 2020, for loans disbursed on or after that date.
The 2019 regulations established a more limited Federal standard for borrower defense claims by (1) requiring borrowers to prove that the institution engaged in a misrepresentation that was made with knowledge of its false, misleading, or deceptive nature or with a reckless disregard for the truth, (2) eliminating the possibility of using common evidence to adjudicate claims on a group basis, (3) requiring the borrower to document the amount of harm suffered, and (4) setting a 3-year limitation period on filing a claim.
5
The 2019 regulations do not include a reconsideration process. The 2019 regulations only applied to loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2020.
5
In
New York Legal Assistance Group (“NYLAG”)
v.
Cardona,
Case No. 20-CV-1414 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 17, 2021), the District Court found that the Department did not comply with rulemaking standards in promulgating the 3-year statute of limitations for affirmative claims and remanded consideration of that rule to the Department for further consideration.
The three borrower defense regulations are hereinafter referred to as “1994 regulation,” “2016 regulation,” and “2019 regulation” after the respective years in which the final regulations were issued.
The Department believes that the more restrictive standard for approving a borrower defense claim and the relatively narrow statute of limitations for filing claims under the 2019 regulations created a standard that placed burdens on borrowers to obtain relief that were far more onerous than any State standard, and went far beyond evidentiary requirements and argumentation that a reasonable borrower could be expected to provide. In particular, the Department is concerned that expecting a borrower to independently document and corroborate the misrepresentation and specifically show the amount of financial harm they suffered in the manner contemplated in the 2019 regulations would require borrowers to possess a level of data and knowledge about local and national labor market trends that would be unrealistic for an individual to possess, and would result in overly subjective judgments by the Department into how a borrower should conduct a search for employment. Moreover, without being able to rely upon evidence generated from in-depth investigations that other oversight bodies possess, including the ability to demand documents, borrowers face unreasonable set of requirements. The result would be that many borrowers who were subject to misrepresentations or other wrongdoing by their institutions would fail to receive an approved claim and discharge because they were being judged under an unreasonably high standard. The Department's experience reviewing borrower defense applications shows that many of the schools' substantial misrepresentations are made orally, and/or relate to high pressure sales tactics. Additionally, many schools do not provide enrolling or enrolled students with written evidence of the misrepresentations, which could result in the Department denying borrowers' claims due to a lack of documentation, despite the fact that many borrowers do not and cannot keep such documents over years. When the Department issued the 2019 regulations, the Regulatory Impact Analysis with that rule estimated that only 7.5 percent of the volume of borrower defense claims would ultimately be approved. This was a decline from 65 percent under the 2016 regulation. The Department believes that such a significant change in approval amounts suggests that the 2019 regulation would result in denials for too many claims that should have a reasonable prospect of being meritorious
upon consideration of evidence from additional oversight entities. Moreover, the anticipated low approval rate is an added concern because the 2019 regulations did not contain a reconsideration process, meaning that any borrower whose claim was unfairly denied, including through an administrative or technical error, would have to go to court to have their claim properly addressed.
While the 2019 regulations went into effect for new loans disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, the Department has yet to adjudicate any claims under the 2019 regulations. This is due to several factors. First, the Department is still in the process of adjudicating significant numbers of claims covered by the 1994 and 2016 regulations, which represent a larger share of currently pending claims. Second, repayment of and interest accrual on all Federal loans held by the Department have been paused since March 2020, so borrowers who may have been subject to conduct that may give rise to a borrower defense claim may not have felt the need to apply yet because they do not currently have to make loan payments.
Over the last several years, the Department has gained significant experience and expertise through its adjudication of claims and review of evidence. Doing so has put the Department in the best position to understand how to manage the borrower defense program efficiently. This includes identifying areas for improvement and refinement that would not have been apparent in prior rulemakings when the Department had not had as much experience reviewing claims.
In this current NPRM, the Department proposes to build upon the lessons learned from implementation of those previous borrower defense regulations and a review of the 2019 regulation to construct a borrower defense process that is simpler and fairer for all affected parties. This process would maintain what was available to borrowers during the more than two decades between the 1994 and 2016 regulations; build on the clearer processes in the 2016 regulation to ensure more consistency for borrowers; and, incorporate some further refinements of elements from the 2019 regulation such as including institutional responses and clarifying certain types of allegations that would not lead to a valid borrower defense claim. The proposed process would be simpler by establishing a single upfront Federal standard so that borrowers are not subject to differential treatment, varying from a full discharge to a complete denial, for enrollment at the same institution depending solely on the date their loans were issued. The proposed process also would be fairer by establishing claim approval requirements that recognize all possible sources of evidence, including information gleaned from State attorneys general, rather than relying on the borrower to prove their entire case on their own.
While the Department has modified the regulations several times in recent years, based on our ongoing and growing experience reviewing and adjudicating borrower defense claims, we have determined that the current 2019 rules are too limiting to fairly and accurately adjudicate claims, and that further regulations are needed to address issues that have continued to arise during the Department's claim review. The current rules require evidence that is highly unlikely to be available to the borrower, especially within the timeframes following their departure from the institution that the borrower must meet to have their claim considered. The current rules also exclude evidence of school activity in the Department's possession, gleaned from other Department activity, that would support borrowers' claims. These proposed regulations would incorporate additional information about the nature of claims that the Department receives, the types of evidence received from borrowers, and procedural improvements to help ensure timely decisions for borrowers. They would also more clearly establish the importance of the institutional response process and leverage existing procedures used for establishing and collecting liabilities to seek recoupment from institutions.
To achieve these goals, the Department proposes to streamline multiple regulatory requirements, establish a new Federal standard for the initial adjudication of a borrower defense claim that would be easier for borrowers and affected parties to understand, and clarify the conduct that could result in an approved borrower defense claim. The Department believes that this approach, and the proposed use of common evidence, would facilitate a clearer and faster process for adjudication of group claims. The Department also proposes to clarify how discharge amounts will be determined for approved claims, including establishing a rebuttable presumption of full discharge; designing a structured process for reconsidering decisions; eliminating the limitations period for borrowers; and adopting a revised limitations period for institutional recoupment. These proposed regulations would incorporate additional information about the nature of claims that the Department receives, the types of evidence received from borrowers, and procedural improvements to help ensure timely decisions for borrowers. They would also more clearly establish the importance of the institutional response process and leverage existing procedures used for establishing and collecting liabilities to seek recoupment from institutions.
Finally, to protect the title IV programs and ensure accountability, the Department believes it is critical that borrower defense regulations contain a process for the Department to recover the cost to the taxpayer caused by discharging all or a portion of loans associated with approved claims from institutions, separate and apart from the borrower claim adjudication process. The Department proposes to administer this recoupment process through its existing procedures for collecting other institutional liabilities. Separating the recoupment process from the borrower defense approval process also ensures that institutions will not face financial consequences from claim approvals tied to loans issued prior to July 1, 2023, unless the claim would have been approved under the borrower defense regulation in effect at the time the loans were issued.
The recoupment efforts described above complement other executive and regulatory actions contemplated by the Department to increase institutional accountability. The Department anticipates that efforts to dissuade institutions from harmful behavior as well as increases in other forms of oversight would result in a reduction in future conduct that could lead to a borrower defense approval, thus reducing instances in which the Federal taxpayers would assume the costs of discharging loans. These action items include reinstating the Office of Enforcement within the Department's Federal Student Aid office and changes announced earlier this year to increase the frequency with which entities that own institutions are required to sign Program Participation Agreements and thus potentially face financial consequences if there are liabilities against the institution.
6
The Department is also currently in the process of proposing new regulations around the 90/10 rule to implement a requirement included in the American Rescue Plan that proprietary institutions derive at
least 10 percent of their revenue from non-Federal sources.
7
This is a change from previous requirements, which allowed Federal money for veterans and servicemembers to count toward the 10 percent revenue minimum. The inclusion of those benefits had in turn been a contributing factor toward aggressive recruitment of veterans and servicemembers.
6
https://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/us-department-education-announces-steps-hold-institutions-accountable-taxpayer-losses-0.
7
See 90/10 resources under “Institutional and Programmatic Eligibility Committee”
https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2021/index.html.
During the public hearings and negotiated rulemaking sessions in 2021, the Department heard from a broad range of constituencies on the elements of an appropriate borrower defense framework. At the negotiated rulemaking sessions, negotiators expressed interest in developing a regulation that would provide for fair treatment of borrowers who had been harmed by an institution's act(s) or omission(s). Some negotiators expressed support for reviving the group claims process and establishing a reconsideration process that is fair for all affected parties.
One negotiator expressed concern about the potential reputational harm to institutions from frivolous and unsubstantiated borrower defense claims. This negotiator also did not support recovering funds from institutions when a borrower defense claim is successful.
Areas proposed for negotiation during the negotiated rulemaking sessions included the Federal standard under which a borrower may assert a defense to repayment; the applicable evidentiary standard; creating a group process for the adjudication of borrower defense claims; consideration of adverse Department actions against an institution as grounds for a group borrower defense claim; the ability of individuals to bring borrower defense claims; the borrower's status during adjudication of a claim, including a pause on interest accrual for a borrower with an individual application after 180 days if the Department fails to make a decision on the claim by that time; a defined limitations period for bringing borrower defense claims; an opportunity for the institution to respond to borrower defense claims filed against it; the time frames associated with adjudicating a claim; and issues pertaining to loans made under the FFEL Program.
In the first session, the Department reviewed the issue papers with negotiators and provided a high-level summary of borrower defense issues with proposed solutions. In the second session, the Department provided proposed regulatory text to negotiators. In the final session, the Department provided revised and additional regulatory text based on negotiator feedback and explained the substantive changes made between sessions two and three. By the end of the negotiated rulemaking sessions, most negotiators expressed general support for the proposed changes to the borrower defense regulations. At the final consensus check, 16 negotiators indicated they would agree to the proposed borrower defense regulations, while one negotiator dissented. Because the committee's protocols required agreement from all negotiators, consensus was not reached. Materials from the borrower defense negotiated rulemaking sessions may be found on the Department's website at:
https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2021/index.html.
Borrower Defense to Repayment—Adjudication (§§ 685.206, 685.222)
Statute:
Section 455(h) of the HEA (20 U.S.C. 1087e(h)) requires the Secretary to specify in regulations which acts or omissions of an institution a borrower may assert as a defense to repayment of a Direct Loan, except that the borrower may not recover from the Secretary more than the amount the borrower has repaid on the loan.
Current Regulations:
The current borrower defense regulations provide different acts or omissions that could lead to an approved borrower defense claim, depending on when a borrower's loan was first disbursed:
• Claims pertaining to loans first disbursed before July 1, 2017, are adjudicated according to the substantive standard set forth in the 1994 borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(c), and use the State law standard. The 1994 borrower defense regulations do not contain a definitions section.
• Claims pertaining to loans first disbursed between July 1, 2017, through June 30, 2020, are adjudicated according to the substantive standard set forth in the 2016 borrower defense regulations in § 685.222 and uses the regulatory process for claims pertaining to loans first disbursed prior to July 1, 2017. These claims use definitions in § 685.222, which defines the terms “borrower” and “borrower defense,” and apply the Federal standard.
• Claims pertaining to loans first disbursed after July 1, 2020, are adjudicated under the borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(e), using definitions set forth in § 685.206(e)(1).
Proposed Regulations:
Proposed 34 CFR part 685, subpart D would establish a framework for uniform borrower defense discharges based on applications received following, or already pending with the Secretary on, the effective date of these regulations, rather than based on a loan's disbursement date. Under the proposed rules, institutions would not face recoupment for conduct approved solely under the new Federal standard if the conduct occurred prior to July 1, 2023. Nor would they face larger amounts of recoupment if the amount of a discharge is greater than it would have been under the applicable prior regulation.
The scope and purpose section of proposed subpart D is in proposed § 685.400 and would set forth the provisions under which a borrower defense could be asserted. Subpart D would apply to borrower defense applications received on or after July 1, 2023, and to borrower defense applications pending with the Secretary on July 1, 2023. These are the dates the regulation would become effective under the master calendar requirements in the HEA.
Proposed § 685.401 contains the general definitions applicable to subpart D, including definitions for the following terms: “borrower,” “borrower defense to repayment,” “Department official,” “Direct Loan,” “school/institution,” and “State requestor.”
Proposed subpart D also includes regulations regarding the adjudication of a borrower defense claim, which are described in greater detail below.
Finally, §§ 685.109 and 685.499 would make clear that, if any part of the proposed regulations is held invalid by a court, the remainder would still be in effect.
Reasons:
The Department heard from representatives of a broad range of constituencies, including the non-Federal negotiators in the negotiated rulemaking meetings, on what they thought was an appropriate basis for a borrower defense. The Department believes a general definitions section to this new subpart D is critical to ensure clarity in these proposed regulations. For these proposed regulations, the Department incorporates the following terms wholly or in part as those in the 2019 regulations: “borrower,” “borrower defense to repayment,” and, “Direct Loan.” Because these proposed regulations envision a new borrower defense framework, it is necessary to develop some additional new terms. The Department first proposes a definition of “Department official,” which would be a senior Department official or their designee to administer
the borrower defense process. The Department also proposes to expand upon the definition of “school/institution” to include principals of the institution, or of an institution under common ownership, who exercised substantial control over the institution. Finally, the Department proposes a definition of “State requestor” to clarify which entities may suggest the formation of a group claim as described in other sections of this NPRM.
Direct Loans and FFEL
Section 455(h) of the HEA provides that the Secretary may discharge a loan pursuant to a borrower defense for a loan made “under this part,” a reference to the Direct Loan Program. This includes Direct Consolidation Loans made under § 455(g) of the HEA. Under the statute, borrowers may not recover more than they have repaid. During negotiated rulemaking, the Department received inquiries about whether the borrower defense process applies to FFEL Program loans, in which private lenders issued Federal loans using their own funds and receive a Federal guarantee against most losses in the case of default as well as quarterly Federal subsidies. FFEL Program loans are authorized in a different part of the HEA. As the Department noted in the preamble of the 2016 regulations, the HEA generally requires that Direct Loans be made under the same “terms, conditions, and benefits” as FFEL Program loans. 20 U.S.C. 1087a(b)(2), 1087e(a)(1). See 81 FR at 75930. In 1995, the Department clarified the relationship between Direct and FFEL Program loans in a Dear Colleague Letter:
Congress intended that schools participating in either FFEL or Direct Loan programs should receive parallel treatment on important issues, and the Department has already committed during negotiated rulemaking to apply the same borrower defense provisions to [both] the Direct Loan and FFEL programs. Therefore, schools that cause injury to student borrowers that give rise to legitimate claims should and, under these proposals, will bear the risk of loss, regardless of whether the loans are from the Direct Loan or FFEL Program.
Dear Colleague Letter GEN-95-8 (Jan. 1, 1995).
8
8
See
https://fsapartners.ed.gov/knowledge-center/library/dear-colleague-letters/1995-01-01/gen-95-08-direct-loan-program-schools-will-not-face-greater-potential-liabilities-ffelp-schools.
In the 2016 and 2019 regulations, the Department took the position that a FFEL borrower could raise a defense to repayment claim and have that claim reviewed and approved, but that receiving any relief tied to an approval of such a claim would require the borrower to consolidate any FFEL Program loans associated with the approved claim into a Direct Consolidation Loan. However, the time limits on filing a claim in the 2019 regulation plus the terms of the new consolidation loans determining the applicable borrower defense regulation meant that it would be almost impossible for FFEL borrowers to receive any borrower defense relief after July 1, 2020, regardless of when they originally borrowed. For instance, under the 2019 regulation, a FFEL borrower who took out a loan in 2009 and left school in 2010 could have a claim approved today under the standards of the 1994 regulation but would have no way to access the associated relief under that regulation because as soon as they consolidate their claim, they would fall under the 2019 regulation and be denied under the three-year limitations period. The Department is concerned that the 2019 regulation results in the application of a stricter regulation to their claim that was not in effect at the time their original loans were disbursed. Applying the standard proposed in these regulations regardless of disbursement date would both solve this problem going forward and address the inequitable situation that would otherwise exist for FFEL borrowers from July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2023.
The Department is also proposing sub-regulatory improvements beyond the regulations that would help FFEL borrowers more easily receive a discharge for approved borrower defense claims, further streamlining and simplifying the process for borrowers. The Department has the authority to make Direct Consolidation Loans under §§ 451 and 455(g) of the HEA. FFEL borrowers must consolidate their loans into a Direct Consolidation loan to obtain a borrower defense discharge; however, the Department would allow FFEL borrowers to file and receive a decision on their borrower defense applications before their loans are consolidated. The 1994 and 2016 regulations allow borrowers with FFEL Program loans to have their claims reviewed and approved by the Department, but they must consolidate their FFEL Program loans into a Direct Loan through a separate process to receive the benefit of any loan discharges associated with an approved claim. The Department has heard, both from borrowers and from their representatives at negotiated rulemaking, that the separate consolidation requirement creates confusion and roadblocks for borrowers. The requirement also results in unequal treatment for borrowers with different types of loans. To address this concern, the Department proposes to streamline the borrower defense application process by having the application for borrower defense also serve as a Direct Loan consolidation application for borrowers with FFEL and Perkins loans, which would only be executed if the borrower's claim is approved, giving the borrower a streamlined process for receiving discharge of their loans.
State Requestor
State requestors, such as State attorneys general, have been a significant and important source of evidence for many of the Department's approvals of borrower defense claims and the Department anticipates they will continue to be an important source of evidence. For example, while investigating student complaints, State attorneys general may find institutions engaging in patterns of misrepresentation. The Department believes State partners are critical in providing evidence that—as part of an independent assessment by the Department that also includes evidence in its possession, submissions from borrowers, responses from institutions under proposed 485.405, and other relevant sources—could result in approving borrower defense claims. Because this evidence often includes information about widespread institutional policies or practice, evidence from State requestors could be particularly beneficial for decisions around whether to form and/or approve a group borrower defense claim, which is when the Department makes a decision about whether to approve borrower defense relief for a set of similarly situated borrowers, including those who have not applied. These State requestors have fostered, and could continue to foster, a more efficient borrower defense adjudication process by supplying needed evidence to support the potential approval of claims or expanding the Department's ability to quickly develop the facts in cases by identifying systemic issues at an institution resulting in several borrowers potentially being eligible for relief.
To give these State requestors regulatory recognition in the consideration of whether to establish a group process, the Department proposes to define “State requestors” to include States, State attorneys general, or State oversight or regulatory agencies with authority from the State (such as a State consumer financial protection agency with civil investigative demand
authority from that State). The Department proposes limiting requestors only to State requestors based on the Department's experience that State parties have been the sources of the highest-quality evidence in past adjudications of borrower defense applications. Additionally, the Department believes that inviting States to share information is consistent with the HEA's expectation that States, accrediting agencies, and the Department will conduct shared oversight through the program integrity “triad.” Already, States and the Department share considerable information about institutions through oversight and enforcement work; these established relationships have yielded critical support for the Department's work to ensure institutions comply with Federal laws and regulations, including those that could give rise to borrower defense claims for discharges of Federal student loans.
The proposed position is a change from the Department's conclusions in the 2019 regulation and is based upon the agency's experience in continuing to review and approve borrower defense applications. In 2019, the Department dismissed the importance of State enforcement actions on the grounds that they cover broader issues than what may be allowed under borrower defense. This conclusion discounted the role of evidence from State parties in processing borrower defense claims. The evidence generated from State investigations and enforcement actions has repeatedly given the Department important information to conduct a thorough and rigorous review of borrower defense claims against institutions such as Corinthian Colleges, Inc., ITT Technical Institute, the Court Reporting Institute, Minnesota School of Business and Globe University, and Westwood College.
9
In several of these instances the Department received from State attorneys general internal company documents, presentations, emails, and memos that assisted in establishing that these institutions engaged in misrepresentations. In all these instances, the Department is not proposing to simply accept the State-offered evidence unquestioned and issue approvals based on it. It is recognizing the importance of considering evidence from all available sources and creating a simpler process for receiving such information from States.
9
See U.S. Department of Education press releases:
https://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/department-education-announces-approval-new-categories-borrower-defense-claims-totaling-500-million-loan-relief-18000-borrowers; https://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/education-department-approves-415-million-borrower-defense-claims-including-former-devry-university-students; https://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/department-education-approves-borrower-defense-claims-related-three-additional-institutions.
Effective Date of Regulations, Claims Covered Under Proposed Regulations
Statute:
Section 455(h) of the HEA authorizes the Secretary to specify in regulation which acts or omissions of an institution of higher education a borrower may assert as a defense to repayment of a Direct Loan. Section 410 of the General Education Provisions Act (GEPA) provides the Secretary with authority to make, promulgate, issue, rescind, and amend rules and regulations governing the manner of operations of, and governing the applicable programs administered by, the Department. 20 U.S.C. 1221e-3. Under Section 414 of the Department of Education Organization Act, the Secretary is authorized to prescribe such rules and regulations as the Secretary determines necessary or appropriate to administer and manage the functions of the Secretary or the Department. 20 U.S.C. 3474.
Current Regulations:
The “1994 regulations” at 34 CFR 685.206(c) cover loans first disbursed before July 1, 2017 and became effective July 1, 1995 (see 59 FR 61664, December 1, 1994); the “2016 regulations” at 34 CFR 685.222 cover loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2017 and before July 1, 2020 and became effective July 1, 2017 (see 81 FR 75926, November 1, 2016); and, the “2019 regulations” at 34 CFR 685.206(e) cover loans first disbursed on or after July 1, 2020 and became effective July 1, 2020 (see 84 FR 49788, September 23, 2019).
Proposed Regulations:
Proposed 34 CFR part 685, subpart D would establish a framework for uniform borrower defense discharges based on applications received following or already pending with the Secretary on the effective date of these regulations, rather than based on a loan's disbursement date. However, institutions would not be subject to recoupment actions for applications that are granted based upon this regulation that would not have been approved under the standard applicable based upon the loan's disbursement date, which could be the 1994, 2016, or 2019 regulations. Institutions would also not be subject to recoupment for amounts greater than what would have been approved under the applicable regulation at the time the loans were disbursed.
Reasons:
Tying the applicability of borrower defense regulations to the date of a loan's disbursement can create significant complexity for administering the program and create inconsistent outcomes for borrowers. With regulations tied to a loan's disbursement date, it is possible for a single borrower to submit a single borrower defense to repayment claim that is covered by all three sets of regulations, despite involving the same act or omission at the same institution. The confusion is further exacerbated if a borrower consolidates their loans, since borrowers may have had original loans disbursed under one set of regulations, but the Department treats the date of the consolidation loan as the one used to determine what regulation their claim should be adjudicated under.
To streamline and simplify the process, the proposed regulations provide uniform borrower defense regulations for applications pending with the Secretary on or after the effective date of these regulations. This approach would ensure that all borrowers whose claims are filed or pending within this timeframe are subject to the same regulatory framework. In promulgating the prior borrower defense regulations, the Department did not choose to apply this single standard because it would have changed the types of claims that could be approved in ways that might have left some borrowers worse off than the regulation in place at the time they took out their loan. For example, borrowers with loans issued prior to July 1, 2017 could bring a claim under a State law standard, which includes some instances where a borrower might not have to show they relied upon a misrepresentation depending on the relevant State law being applied. The 2016 regulation, however, included a requirement that a borrower demonstrate reliance on the misrepresentation without a presumption of reasonable reliance for an individual claim. Applying that standard to those prior loans would thus be more restrictive in certain circumstances. The same is true of the 2019 regulation and its effect on loans issued on or after July 1, 2020. That regulation requires borrowers to produce a more individualized documentation of harm and eliminates the prospect of adjudicating similarly situated claims as a group, in contrast to what is available under the 2016 regulation. It would thus not have been feasible to have the 2016 regulation cover claims from loans that would have previously been associated with the 1994 regulation, nor would the 2019 regulation have been able to cover
claims previously associated with either the 1994 or the 2016 regulations. This proposed regulation would permit borrowers to bring claims under a series of acts or omissions that not only encompasses what would have been available to them under any of the three prior applicable regulations, but also under some additional circumstances. The result is that no borrower would be worse off under this regulation than they would be under the regulation in place at the time they borrowed. Given that, the Department believes it is appropriate to adopt a single standard that applies to all claims pending with the Secretary or submitted on or after July 1, 2023. As discussed in greater detail in the
Recovery from Institutions
section, the Department does not propose to apply this single framework for the purposes of institutional recoupment in all cases. The Department does not think it would be appropriate to hold an institution financially liable when the standard in place at the time the loan was disbursed would not have resulted in an approved claim, since the institution would not have had a way of knowing that certain types of conduct could later lead to financial consequences. The Department believes that this approach would also protect against any concerns institutions might raise related to the reputational consequences of an approved borrower defense claim. The approval of a borrower defense claim concerns the legal interaction between the Department and the borrower, not the institution. Moreover, the Department is unaware of any evidence demonstrating reputational harm to institutions that are still operating resulting from approved borrower defense claims. Given that lack of evidence, the Department believes whatever reputational harms to the institution might occur based on this regulatory change are outweighed by the benefits to the borrower. This is because this proposed change makes the borrower defense program more administrable and therefore overall better able to serve both borrowers and institutions through more efficient and effective adjudication.
While the proposed coverage of this regulation could lead to some increased costs to the Federal Government in the form of greater transfers to borrowers, the Department notes that this regulation is just one component of a larger set of executive and regulatory efforts aimed at increasing institutional oversight and accountability that should deter future conduct that could lead to approved borrower defense claims. These efforts include the re-establishment of an Office of Enforcement within Federal Student Aid, which is tasked with conducting in-depth investigations of institutions. Releasing the results of investigations will teach institutions what types of risky conduct to avoid in the future. The Department also announced earlier in 2022 that it would start increasing the number of entities that sign Program Participation Agreements to include more outside owners of institutions. Doing so will make more entities and individuals responsible for liabilities against an institution, further deterring harmful behavior. The Department is also currently conducting separate rulemaking efforts to implement a statutory change included in the 2021 American Rescue Plan to require private for-profit institutions to derive 10 percent of their revenue from non-Federal sources, not just Federal student aid programs administered by the Department. That change will reduce incentives for institutions to aggressively pursue veterans and service members in particular, which had been a source of aggressive recruitment in the past.
Federal Standard (§§ 685.206, 685.222, & Part 668)
Statute:
Section 455(h) of the HEA authorizes the Secretary to specify in regulation which acts or omissions of an institution a borrower may assert as a defense to repayment of a Direct Loan, except that a borrower may not recover from the Secretary an amount in excess of the amount that the borrower has repaid.
Current Regulations:
In the current regulations, three different regulatory standards and limitations periods apply, depending on when a borrower's loan was first disbursed:
• Loans first disbursed prior to July 1, 2017, are addressed under the 1994 borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(c). That section provides that a borrower may assert a defense to repayment under applicable State law. The borrower may bring a claim at any point during the period in which the loan is being collected.
• Loans disbursed between July 1, 2017, and June 30, 2020, are adjudicated under the 2016 borrower defense regulations in § 685.222, which explains the acts or omissions that could give rise to a borrower defense claim are judgments against the institution, breaches of contract, and substantial misrepresentation. Further, the borrower may bring such a claim at any time but may only assert a right to recover amounts previously collected by the Secretary on the grounds of that same breach of contract or substantial misrepresentation within 6 years of the alleged breach or of the date on which the substantial misrepresentation reasonably could have been discovered.
• Loans disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, are adjudicated under the 2019 borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(e), which allow a borrower to assert a defense to repayment if the institution at which the borrower enrolled made a misrepresentation of material fact upon which the borrower reasonably relied, and the borrower was financially harmed by such misrepresentation. Claims adjudicated under these regulations have three years from the date the student is no longer enrolled at the institution to file a claim with the Department.
Proposed Regulations:
In proposed § 685.401(b), a claim could be brought on any of five grounds:
• Substantial misrepresentation,
• Substantial omission of fact,
• Breach of contract,
• Aggressive and deceptive recruitment, or
• A Federal or State judgment or Departmental adverse action against an institution that could give rise to a borrower defense claim.
Also, as proposed, a violation of State law could form the basis for a borrower defense claim, but only if the borrower or, in the case of a group claim brought by a State requestor, that State requestor requests reconsideration of the Secretary's denial of a claim. Each is discussed further below. Borrowers would not be subject to a limitations period.
The proposed Federal standard in § 685.401(b) would incorporate the existing description of misrepresentation in part 668, subpart F, which currently defines and sets forth three categories of misrepresentation, each containing examples of violative conduct. However, the Department proposes to expand the examples in those categories, relating to the nature of educational programs, the nature of financial charges, and the employability of graduates. Proposed § 668.75 also would establish a new misrepresentation category in the regulations that separately would give rise to a borrower defense claim under the Federal standard: “omission of fact.”
Proposed § 668.79 would make clear that, if any part of the proposed regulations is held invalid by a court, the remainder would still be in effect.
We propose to add a new subpart R to part 668, which would define and prohibit aggressive and deceptive recruitment tactics or conduct
(aggressive recruitment). As proposed, aggressive recruitment would be one of five types of acts or omissions that comprise the Federal standard for borrower defense claims such as: obtaining the borrower's contact information through websites that falsely present themselves as providing assistance with finding a job or obtaining government benefits, falsely claiming that enrollment spots are limited, taking advantage of a student's lack of understanding to pressure the student to enroll, pressuring the student to make an immediate loan decision, discouraging the student or prospective student from consulting with an independent party prior to signing documents, failing to respond to a student's request for additional substantive information on enrollment or loan obligations, using threatening or abusive language, or engaging in repeated unsolicited contact.
Finally, proposed § 668.509 would make clear that, if any part of the proposed regulations is held invalid by a court, the remainder would still be in effect.
Reasons:
The Department has issued three different sets of regulations in the past on borrower defense: 1994, 2016, and 2019. Those regulations include different acts and omissions as the basis for borrower defense claims and included different processes. Even where some similarities appear to exist across the three regulatory structures—for example, all generally list misrepresentation as a basis for a borrower defense—the regulations set different requirements for what a borrower must prove to have their application approved. For example, in the 1994 regulations, a borrower could have their application approved because their State had a standard for misrepresentation that did not require a demonstration of reliance. That same borrower under the 2016 regulation could also receive an approval due to a misrepresentation but would have to show that they relied upon that misrepresentation in making the decision to enroll. For both the 1994 and 2016 regulations, the borrower's claim could be supported by common evidence in the Department's possession, such as records from a college obtained by a State attorney general and shared with the Department. Under the 2019 regulation, that borrower not only has to show they relied upon the misrepresentation but that the institution had knowledge the misrepresentation was false, misleading, or deceptive, or acted with reckless disregard for the truth. The borrower must also document the specific amount of financial harm suffered. As a consequence, an identical misrepresentation by the same institution could yield different outcomes solely based upon the loan's disbursement date.
In reviewing the hundreds of thousands of claims received from borrowers across the country, as well as different State laws that could be applied to bring a defense to repayment application under the 1994 regulations, the Department has identified other categories of improper actions that it believes should give rise to a defense to repayment, and examples of the types of common misrepresentations that fall within those categories.
As listed above, the proposed Federal standard identifies five categories of acts or omissions as bases for a borrower defense claim: (1) substantial misrepresentation, (2) substantial omission of fact, (3) breach of contract, (4) aggressive recruitment, and (5) State or Federal judgment or Departmental adverse action against an institution that could give rise to a borrower defense claim. For substantial misrepresentations and substantial omissions of fact, the Department proposes to use a presumption of reasonable reliance for both an individual and group claim.
Each element of the proposed Federal standard is discussed in greater detail below.
Substantial Misrepresentation and Omission of Fact
The Department proposes returning to the 2016 regulations' use of substantial misrepresentation where a misrepresentation is defined in 34 CFR 668, subpart F, instead of a standalone definition in the borrower defense regulation. But, as part of adopting that framework from the 2016 regulation, we also propose adopting a presumption of reasonable reliance for all borrowers.
Misrepresentation was a component in both the 2016 and 2019 regulations and has been a common source for approving claims under the 1994 regulation. Substantial misrepresentations constitute most of the claims that the Department has approved to date and have consistently served as a basis for borrower defense discharges across the several sets of regulations.
The Department believes requiring borrowers to prove a substantial misrepresentation occurred is a more reasonable standard to use than the stricter one required in the 2019 regulation that also required a borrower to show that an institution's misrepresentation was made with knowledge that it was false, misleading, or deceptive or with reckless disregard for the truth. In constructing the proposed standard, the Department considered what evidence it sees borrowers regularly provide, based upon its review of hundreds of thousands of claims. This allows the Department to gauge what is a reasonable expectation of borrowers and what types of information that most claims are likely to include. Those reviews demonstrate that even the most detailed and extensive information provided by borrowers rarely if ever includes information on whether an institution had knowledge that a misrepresentation was false or misleading, nor an ability to gauge if the institution acted with a reckless disregard for the truth.
When the Department obtains such information, it generally comes through internal company records that require the authority to require institutions to turn over documents, such as through a civil investigation demand, a lawsuit, or a request by a Federal agency. The use of such a strict standard for a borrower thus exceeds what even the most detailed individual applications received to date are able to include. While the Department has in the past indicated that this standard could be met by showing information provided by employees does not match information in formal marketing materials, the Department is concerned that such an approach does not provide a reasonable path for a borrower subject to the more common situation the Department has found in which the official placement rates are themselves false or calculated in a way that produces a misleading result.
Moreover, the Department does not believe the intent of the institution is relevant when determining whether to provide the borrower with relief due to a misrepresentation. Intentional or not, the actions by the institution have resulted in harm to the borrower and the Department's obligation is to provide relief to ameliorate that harm when the evidence warrants. Issues related to institutional knowledge are better suited for considerations about the extent of the school's liability. As between the school and the borrower, the school is better equipped to prevent, and, where appropriate, to bear the cost of, a misrepresentation that turns out to be inadvertent.
To meet this proposed substantial misrepresentation threshold, the borrower would have to articulate to the Department the misrepresentation made by the institution (
e.g.,
they were told credits would transfer and they did not, they were guaranteed to get a job, they
were told the job placement rate was 90 percent, etc.). That misrepresentation would then have to be one that they would have relied upon to make the decision to take out a Direct Loan. A borrower can achieve that goal by relaying with some detail the story of their recruitment experience or some other interaction with the school.
The Department similarly proposes to remove the requirement that a borrower demonstrate individualized harm from the definition of a misrepresentation and instead to require that the borrower demonstrate that the misrepresentation caused the borrower to take out a loan to their detriment. The Department is concerned that the requirements to demonstrate financial harm in the 2019 regulation created a requirement far beyond what a reasonable borrower should have to do. This concern outweighs the taxpayers' risk that a borrower could receive relief even without significant financial harm, particularly given the Department's statutory obligation to provide access to defenses to repayment for borrowers affected by the acts or omissions of the institutions in which they enroll. For instance, the 2019 regulation requires borrowers to prove that they could not get a job for reasons besides local or national recessions, or the borrower would have to document the quality of their job search and subsequent inability to find employment. The Department does not believe it is reasonable for a borrower to have to act as a labor economist to show they were harmed by an institution's misrepresentations. Moreover, the approach of individualized harm required in the 2019 regulations has the unintended effect of potentially penalizing a borrower who succeeds despite their program. The Department has received many borrower defense applications from individuals who asserted under penalty of perjury that they were more likely to find employment when removing the institution they attended from their resume. Under the 2019 regulations, these individuals would risk having a claim not approved because they did obtain a job, even if the institution was a hindering factor in their ability to do so.
Reliance is the final component of the substantial misrepresentation standard. This requires a borrower to show that they were not only subject to the misrepresentation but that they relied upon it in their decision to take out a Direct Loan. While the Department believes reliance should be an element of a successful borrower defense claim that alleges a misrepresentation, we are concerned that an overly narrow view of what a borrower had to do in order to demonstrate reliance could result in a borrower's application being denied for lack of the use of specific phrasing. In particular, we are worried that there could be instances where a borrower lays out a misrepresentation that from the narrative provided by the borrower was a key factor in their decision to take out a loan but because the borrower did not directly specify they relied upon it their claim is denied. To address this concern the Department proposes that if the claimant does not demonstrate reliance, then the Department would find reasonable reliance if a prudent person would believe and act upon the misrepresentation if told it by another person.
The Department also proposes to use a similar presumption of reasonable reliance for group borrower defense claims. The removal of requirements for borrowers to demonstrate individualized harm and that they could personally prove that an institution engaged in a misrepresentation that the institution made with the knowledge that it was false, misleading, or deceptive or made with reckless disregard for the truth means that the Department can and should consider claims from similarly situated borrowers who attended the same institution as a group. Because the idea behind a group claim is that all the borrowers in the group may have been affected by the same misrepresentation or omission, the Department believes it is also reasonable to use an assumption of reasonable reliance for group members.
The Department has determined based on reviews of claims that, particularly where misrepresentations were especially widespread, the benefits of reduction in burden by presuming reliance, rather than individually determining it, exceed the costs. Efforts to individually evaluate these claims have substantially delayed—by years, in some cases—the provision of relief to borrowers. This has negative ramifications for borrowers whose financial circumstances are affected by their outstanding student loan debt in the meantime.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) follows a similar approach to the Department's proposal to allow the Secretary to establish a presumption of reliance, whereby it can establish a rebuttable presumption that all purchasers relied on the defendant's material misrepresentations or omissions if they were widely disseminated and “were of a kind usually relied upon by reasonable prudent persons.”
FTC
v.
BlueHippo Funding,
762 F.3d 238 (2d Cir. 2014);
FTC
v.
Kuykendall,
371 F.3d 745, 765 (10th Cir. 2004);
FTC
v.
Figgie Int'l, Inc.,
994 F.2d 595, 605-06 (9th Cir. 1993);
FTC
v.
Sec. Rare Coin & Bullion Corp.,
931 F.2d 1312, 1316 (8th Cir. 1991). Once the FTC establishes the presumption, courts typically accept the total revenue from the sale of the good or service as the amount of monetary relief. Accordingly, while the Department proposes a substantial misrepresentation standard to bring a successful borrower defense claim, the Department proposes to incorporate a presumption of reasonable reliance into that standard to reflect natural consumer behavior that the reasonable and prudent consumer would “usually” rely on.
Substantial Misrepresentation—Definitions
With regard to the specific types of actions that could be considered a misrepresentation, the Department believes using the definition of a misrepresentation in subpart F instead of a separate definition of the term in borrower defense would reduce confusion for both borrowers and institutions and ensure a more consistent approach. In the 2019 regulation, the Department chose to include its own definition of misrepresentation. However, it did so with a non-exhaustive list of 11 items, many of which bear significant resemblance to requirements that already exist in subpart F. This creates unnecessary ambiguity for borrowers and institutions. Since the list in the regulation is non-exhaustive it is unclear whether that would mean anything else in subpart F might also still qualify as a misrepresentation, providing other requirements are met. Using the single consistent definition from subpart F thus removes that ambiguity and ensures that there is a clear message to borrowers and institutions how borrower defense and other oversight and enforcement activities can interact.
In reviewing the definition of misrepresentation in subpart F, the Department has identified other types of misrepresentations that it believes should both serve as potential grounds for approving a borrower defense application as well as possible future enforcement actions. These changes address areas of concern the Department has identified in the course of adjudicating borrower defense claims in recent years.
The Department proposes to revise the regulations in § 668.72, which covers misrepresentation based on the nature of the educational program or
institution. The Department proposes to amend the leading text by adding the phrase “which may be included in the institution's marketing materials, website, or communications to students,” to clarify where misrepresentation could occur and to ensure congruence with the other types of misrepresentation in § 668.73 and § 668.74. The Department also proposes to remove sub-section (h) in § 668.72, which relates to misrepresentations of the nature and availability of equipment needed for educational programs, because that element is effectively incorporated into § 668.72(f), which addresses facilities and equipment. The Department proposes to remove sub-section (j) in § 668.72, related to the availability of employment or other financial assistance, because that element would be effectively covered in § 668.73, which governs misrepresentations related to the nature of financial charges.
In new § 668.72(m), the Department proposes to add false, erroneous, or misleading statements concerning institutional selectivity rates or rankings as a form of misrepresentation, because it has observed institutions leveraging false data reported to widely recognized national rankings that result in a higher institutional or program rank than they would otherwise have received, inducing enrollment under false pretenses. Accordingly, the Department believes it is in the public interest to include misrepresenting selectivity rates or rankings or misrepresenting the data underlying the selectivity rates or rankings, as a form of misrepresentation.
In new § 668.72(n), the Department proposes to add misrepresenting the classification of the institution as nonprofit, public, or proprietary for purposes of its participation in the title IV programs as another basis for a borrower defense claim. An institution would be deemed to misrepresent its classification if it leads students or parents to believe that its status for purposes of title IV participation is something other than the institution's official classification on file with the Department for purposes of the title IV programs. The Department believes that obfuscating the classification of the institution for purposes of the title IV programs should be considered a misrepresentation because there are meaningful distinctions between the governance and treatment of revenue in excess of expenses at for-profit and nonprofit businesses. A student who chooses a college that markets itself as nonprofit may believe they are entering into a transaction in which additional revenue will be reinvested in the college and that those leading the institution do not have a direct financial stake in it. Institutions may not represent to students that they are a nonprofit institution for purposes of title IV when they have not met the applicable legal standards for nonprofit status. This also would apply to institutions that are in the process of converting from for-profit to nonprofit status; such an institution may not represent itself as nonprofit until the Department has confirmed it meets the standards for a nonprofit institution and memorialized that determination in the classification on file with the Department. An institution that acts inconsistently with this requirement would have misrepresented its classification for purposes of a borrower defense claim.
In new § 668.72(o), the Department proposes to add misrepresenting the existence of certifications or other approvals for the institution and/or its programs that were not actually obtained, and the institution's failure to remove such certifications or approvals from marketing materials after they are revoked or withdrawn. These certifications and other approvals include approvals from the State to offer certain programs, such as approval to offer a nursing program. They also include certifications for occupations such as medical assisting where a license may not be required but there are certifications that carry greater labor market value. The Department has observed that some institutions lagged in updating their marketing materials with the latest certifications or approvals or promised students that they would obtain certain certifications or approvals by the time the student graduated but where the institution never in fact obtained these items. The result is that when the student went to find employment, they discovered they were either unable to find a job or would be less competitive in the workforce than they expected to be when they enrolled in the program.
Similarly, the Department proposes to add new § 668.72(p), which would address misrepresentations about student externships or other similar opportunities, because the Department has observed that some institutions have made false promises about the availability of externships for their students or falsely represented that they held contracts with externship sites. The Department has observed that students relied on these marketing materials to inform their decision about whether to enroll at the institution.
The last two proposed changes to § 668.72 are new § 668.72(q), misrepresentation about the institution offering assistance to obtain a high school diploma or General Education Development certificate (GED), and new § 668.72(r), misrepresentation about the pace of completing the program or the time it would take to complete the program contrary to the stated length of the educational program. With the rise of eligible career pathway programs and use of “ability to benefit” mechanisms to provide for title IV aid eligibility for qualifying students without a high school diploma or its recognized equivalent, the Department has observed an increase in the number of institutions making false promises of assistance to obtain a high school diploma or GED, including through program reviews and other oversight mechanisms in which a large number of students at the institution make similar allegations. Finally, the Department has seen that some institutions engage in widespread substantial misrepresentations about the time it would take to complete an educational program, including misrepresentations related to programs that require completion of an externship or similar program, and programs that are self-paced and rarely completed in the advertised time. These institutions wrongly characterize the necessary pace or time commitment, such as presenting program cost over four years when it takes 5 years to finish under the schedule set by the institution. Accordingly, the Department believes it is in the public interest to include these additional misrepresentation elements because greater enforcement and oversight of institutions' unlawful practices would both ensure such behavior is investigated and ended more quickly and provide borrowers with clearer regulations governing the borrower defense discharge standards and, at least in some cases, better evidence. Including these misrepresentations in the regulations would also ensure that borrowers have more accurate information about the costs of their programs.
We also propose changes to § 668.74. In the course of adjudicating borrower defense claims, the Department has persistently seen misrepresentations about the employability of graduates. These include job placement rate (JPR) misrepresentations, which are reflected in § 668.74. The Department is explicitly including, as a form of JPR misrepresentation, placement rates that are inflated through manipulation of data inputs. This would help ensure that students have access to accurate information about the employability of graduates and provide access to relief
when they do not. These additions highlight the Department's concerns about how institutions calculate job placement rates, which students often rely on in making an informed decision about enrolling in an institution or program.
The Department sought input from negotiators as to whether our proposed language addressed known examples of JPR manipulation and how the proposed language could interact with existing placement rate requirements used by accreditors and/or States. One negotiator supported a required disclosure of information regarding graduate employability but expressed concern that there is no standardized metric for institutions to use. To be clear, the Department does not propose to create a standardized JPR metric. Instead, we outline examples of past problematic institutional JPR calculations because they were misleading to students. These include institutions that, for example, excluded students who were searching for work from the denominator of the placement rate calculation if those students did not conduct a job search in the exact manner set by the institution, or published a JPR that included large numbers of students who obtained employment well before graduating from the institution, many of whom likely found such employment or were already employed even before enrolling. These also include institutions that disclosed an employment rate, as required by their State or accreditor, but calculated the rate in a manner inconsistent with the applicable State or accreditor methodology. Proposed § 668.74 also contains a provision that allows the Department to verify that an institution correctly calculated its JPR; an institution must furnish to the Secretary documentation and other data that was used to calculate the institution's employment rate calculations.
Substantial Omission of Fact
The 2019 and 2016 regulations included an omission of fact as a component within the definition of misrepresentation, meaning that either false information provided or true information omitted could give rise to an approved borrower defense claim.
The Department proposes to continue allowing omissions to give rise to a borrower defense claim, but to expressly provide it in a separate category by adding § 668.75 to address substantial omissions of fact. Doing so recognizes that omissions of fact have the same misleading effect on borrowers as other forms of misrepresentation, except that it occurs through the absence of information that would otherwise have affected the borrower's decision to enroll or take out loans. The Department proposes to list it separately from misrepresentation to assist borrowers and institutions in better understanding the Federal standard for initial adjudication, but because it would remain closely tied to misrepresentation, we propose adding it within subpart F.
The addition of more text to clarify an omission of fact allows the Department to provide borrowers and institutions greater clarity about what must be disclosed to avoid an omission of fact. The Department proposes moving to “substantial omission of fact” in place of the 2019 treatment of omission of fact for the same reasons we are proposing to shift from misrepresentation to substantial misrepresentation as outlined above. Similar to substantial misrepresentation, an omission of fact would be substantial if a borrower would not have otherwise enrolled at the institution, obtained a loan, or chosen that program. We believe that omissions of fact should include a reliance requirement to identify whether an omission is serious enough to have influenced a borrower's decision to enroll. As with substantial misrepresentations, we propose to include a presumption of reasonable reliance, which ensures that claims by borrowers—who relied in fact on the omission—are not denied simply because their applications fail to include the specific statement that the borrower relied upon the omission. We propose to apply this presumption of reasonable reliance to both individual and group claims.
The Department derives its definition of omission of fact, in part, from the 2016 amendments to § 668.71(c), where the Department refers explicitly to the ways in which omissions are considered in the regulations. See 81 FR at 76072. The Department also sought feedback last year from negotiators on the parameters of omission of fact, including a review of States' unfair, deceptive, and abusive acts or practices (UDAP) laws. The Department also consulted with the FTC and thoroughly analyzed Federal laws on UDAP that could help inform the Department's formation of a definition of an omission of fact. The Department consulted with FTC because of that agency's long-standing enforcement work regarding unfair and deceptive acts and practices under Sec. 5 of the Federal Trade Commission Act (FTC Act). After considering the States' use of omission of fact in consumer protection contexts, and the FTC's authorizing statute under the FTC Act, the Department is proposing to adopt language that appears in similar forms in Delaware, Illinois, Iowa, and New Jersey consumer laws. These States have the most comprehensive language related to omission and state that the “concealment, suppression, or omission of any material fact with intent that others rely upon such concealment, suppression, or omission” is an unlawful act.
10
We propose to adopt, in part, that concept of omission of fact, but without the elements of “intent,” which appears in all the states' statutes cited above; or “knowing,” which is only included in New Jersey's statute. As discussed earlier in justifying the movement away from the 2019 definition of misrepresentation that included a requirement that the borrower show the institution had knowledge that a misrepresentation was false, deceptive, or misleading or given with a reckless disregard for the truth, the Department is concerned that it is unreasonable to expect a borrower to be able to document the intent or knowledge possessed by an institution. While there are circumstances where a borrower could potentially meet this bar if the information provided by a recruiter, such as placement rates, is different from information provided in other public materials, the Department has seen to date that most circumstances where an institution misrepresents student outcomes such as placement rates it does so in such a way that all the public numbers used are wrong and only the private internal numbers reflect the actual results. That type of information would only be obtainable through some way of accessing institutional employees or records, which is something that takes years of work by Federal and State regulators to acquire.
10
This language is taken from Delaware's definition of an unlawful practice, but the phrasing is similar for the other states with minor wording changes. Delaware Code Ann. Title 6, § 2513
https://delcode.delaware.gov/title6/c025/sc02/index.html;
815 Illinois Comp. Stat. Ann. § 505/2), from Ch. 121 1/2, par. 262,
https://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs3.asp?ActID=2356&ChapterID=67;
Iowa Code § 714.16,
et seq. https://www.legis.iowa.gov/docs/code/714.16.pdf;
New Jersey's Consumer Fraud Act, New Jersey Statutes Annotated. 56:8-2
et seq. https://www.njconsumeraffairs.gov/Statutes/Consumer-Fraud-Act.pdf.
The 2019 regulations required that misrepresentations were those “made with knowledge of its false, misleading, or deceptive nature or with a reckless disregard for the truth” (see 34 CFR 685.206(e)(3)). Upon further consideration of these policies and their
implications both for borrowers and taxpayers, the Department does not believe that misrepresentations or omissions that are made without knowledge or a reckless disregard should be exempt from the Department's oversight. Borrowers who relied on such misrepresentations, even if they were made unintentionally, may still have experienced the harm of attending a particular institution or borrowing Federal student loans on the basis of untruths or omissions. Similarly, institutions are not permitted under Section 487(c)(3) of the HEA to make misrepresentations, even if unintentional. And an unintentional omission of fact still can result in harm for the borrower.
As proposed, the definition of omission of fact would include a non-exhaustive list of examples that could amount to an omission of fact in the borrower defense context. Examples include, but are not limited to, concealing, suppressing, or failing to provide material information regarding the entity that is actually providing the educational instruction; the availability of slots, or requirements for obtaining admission, in a program where the institution places students in a preprogram at the time of enrollment; and factors that would prevent an applicant, for reasons such as a prior criminal record or preexisting medical condition, from qualifying to meet requirements that are generally needed to be employed in the field for which the training is provided. In its oversight and compliance work, the Department has found some institutions omitted material information about the nature of their educational programs that, if disclosed upfront, could have resulted in a different outcome for the student and forgone the need for a defense to repayment. The Department invites comments on this proposed definition and whether the proposed definition is sufficiently expansive to address known types of omissions in which some institutions engage.
Finally, the Department believes that each of the proposed borrower defense provisions discussed in this NPRM pertaining to misrepresentation serves one or more important, related, but distinct, purposes. Each of the requirements provides value to students, prospective students, and their families; to the public, taxpayers, and the Government; and to institutions separate from, and in addition to, the value provided by the other requirements. In particular, we believe that including more examples of misrepresentations in the regulations would more accurately reflect the Department's experiences in overseeing institutions; and would inform institutions about their obligations, as well as provide clearer indications to borrowers about what may constitute a borrower defense claim. If the Department is able to cite to these additional regulatory provisions in its enforcement work, it will also be able to protect taxpayer interests and end unlawful behavior more quickly and effectively. To best serve these purposes, we propose including an administrative provision in the regulations to make clear that the regulations are designed to operate independently of each other and to convey the Department's intent that the potential invalidity of one provision should not affect the remainder of the provisions.
Breach of Contract
The 2019 regulations removed breach of contract as an element that could give rise to an approved borrower defense to repayment application even though it was included in the 2016 regulation. The 2019 regulation argued that the majority of defense to repayment applications submitted to the Secretary did not allege breach of contract, concluding that the borrower defense standard should be tailored to the types of claims borrowers alleged. See 84 FR 49810-12. The 2019 regulations further rationalized that a standard breach of contract claim was potentially overbroad, and thus inappropriate as a basis for relief since it is not necessarily limited to the provision of educational services.
With the benefit of reviewing additional borrower defense claims, and considering additional input from negotiators, including a request from a negotiator to be more definitive as to what constitutes breach of contract,
11
for the reasons discussed below the Department believes that breach of contract should be restored as a part of the Federal borrower defense standard. As an initial matter, the 2019 concern with overbreadth is inapplicable, because the Department proposes to clarify in new § 685.401(a) (the definition of “borrower defense to repayment”) that an act or omission supporting a borrower defense must be related to the making of a Direct Loan or the provision of educational services for which the Direct Loan was intended. With that appropriate qualification, inclusion of a breach of contract is appropriate. As explained in 2016, breach of contract may be an appropriate basis for borrower defense relief when an institution fails to fulfill a specific contractual promise to provide certain training or courses. 81 FR 39341 (June 16, 2016). Breach of other terms of the contract that relate to the making of a Direct Loan or the provision of educational services may also serve as an appropriate basis for borrower defense relief. The Department would grant relief commensurate with the specific contractual injury alleged. For example, the Department is aware of students bringing loan-related breach of contract claims against postsecondary institutions or for provisions of educational services for which those loans were intended. See,
e.g., Supplee
v.
Miller-Motte Bus. Coll., Inc.,
768 S.E.2d 582 (N.C. Ct. App. 2015);
Eckols et al.
v.
Earle et al.,
No. 2016CI18165 (37th Jud. Dist., Bexar County), Pltfs.' Orig. Pet., Applic. for TRO and Applic. for Temp. Inj. at 10 (Oct. 18, 2016). This type of claim would clearly be appropriate for borrower defense adjudication if the breach is related to the making or provision of educational services intended for the Direct Loan but may not fall under the other four elements of the Federal standard depending on the nature of the contract and its breach. Moreover, even if there is some overlap between the types of conduct that would constitute a breach of contract and would otherwise constitute a basis for a borrower defense claim, in some instances, borrowers may be able to allege breach of contract claims more readily. The Department would investigate and adjudicate claims related to breaches of contract to determine whether a claim meets the requirements for a defense to repayment.
11
https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2021/nov3pm.pdf.
Aggressive Recruitment
The Department is also proposing to add a new category related to aggressive and deceptive recruitment to capture other types of acts it believes should serve as a basis for a borrower defense claim. While this category was not included in the 2019 regulation, the Department considered aggressive recruitment as a factor in the 2016 regulations in determining whether a misrepresentation was substantial enough to merit approval. It was not, however, conduct that could lead to approval on its own in that regulation. In other words, the conduct had to be a substantial misrepresentation in the form of aggressive recruitment to qualify for relief pursuant to the 2016 rule.
The Department first raised the proposal for aggressive and deceptive recruitment during negotiated rulemaking. Some negotiators agreed
with including aggressive recruitment as a basis of a borrower defense claim and indicated that some institutions aggressively recruit certain specific groups of vulnerable students, such as students who are older, are the first in their families to attend postsecondary education, are attending while working full-time and or caring for families, or who come from low-income backgrounds. To date, the Department has received applications from well over 100,000 borrowers who have made allegations relating to admissions and urgency to enroll. This includes allegations that institutions recruited students who lack the basic tools needed to succeed in their courses, such as recruiting students for online programs who have no access to the internet because they are homeless. The Department has also seen institutions discourage students from consulting family and friends for additional information if they raise concerns about enrolling by calling them “dreamkillers.” And, it has received allegations detailing situations where recruiters tried to shame borrowers into enrolling by criticizing them for not providing more for their families.
Because many existing State consumer protection laws include this sort of claim in different forms, the Department reasoned that including it in the Federal standard would ensure a more comprehensive Federal standard and ensure equitable treatment for borrowers regardless of where they live.
In developing its proposed definition of aggressive recruitment, the Department incorporated negotiators' proposals and language from the 2016 regulations. The Department also consulted with the FTC and thoroughly analyzed Federal laws on UDAP. The Department consulted with FTC because of that agency's long-standing enforcement work regarding UDAP under Sec. 5 of the FTC Act. Similar to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and other Federal banking regulators, the Department remains convinced that UDAP can cause significant financial injury to consumers, erode consumer confidence, and undermine the financial marketplace. The FTC Act has also helped other Federal banking regulators in crafting their oversight and enforcement activities over UDAP. Thus, the Department believes that consulting with the FTC which has applied its standards through case law, official policy statements, guidance, examination procedures, and enforcement—actions could help inform the Department's work regarding UDAP, to include elements of aggressive recruitment.
Most negotiators supported the idea of including aggressive recruitment in the Federal standard. Some negotiators, however, expressed concern with the potential subjectivity of the concept and the risk of sweeping in innocuous encouragement or other similar recruiting contact by admissions representatives, enrollment management professionals, or other contractors engaged by an institution. These negotiators indicated that in the course of an admissions representative's day-to-day work, contact with prospective students may include something as simple as reminding them of a May 1 enrollment deadline, and there was some concern that such a reminder may be considered a form of aggressive recruitment. The Department believes the clarity of this definition demonstrates that isolated instances of well-intentioned recruiter behavior would not result in an approved claim. Rather, this definition would capture the types of sustained and aggressive behavior the Department has seen across more than 100,000 borrower defense applications.
The Department is proposing to include aggressive and deceptive recruitment as its own category that could lead to an approved borrower defense claim because it captures an important type of behavior that the Department has seen institutions engage in where the way a borrower is coerced into enrolling is so aggressive that even if the information presented to them was accurate and without omissions the borrower is not able to make a full and informed choice. The result of that is often a borrower enrolling in a program that is not providing them what they were expecting—such as a certificate in an allied health field when they wanted to become a nurse—or comes at a price that they cannot possibly afford and did not freely and fairly take on. The Department has seen instances, discussed above, where these aggressive recruitment tactics prevented or strongly discouraged students from being able to make an informed choice. Other Federal regulators have also seen instances where students were affected by aggressive recruitment practices that played a role in borrowers' decisions to take out private educational loans.
12
Borrowers were told not to worry about concerns that they voiced, such as whether they would graduate or get a job. They were pressured to enroll either through artificial time constraints (such as falsely claiming there were a limited number of seats or the only opportunity to enroll would expire in just a few days) or by exploiting the borrower's lack of experience with higher education. Because the recruiter has greater information at their disposal than the potential borrower and is acting in a position of authority and power, the recruiter is in a position to influence the prospective student's decision to enroll. In these circumstances, even absent a misrepresentation, such as a falsified job placement rate, the entire recruitment experience can impede the ability of the borrower to understand and appreciate what they are signing up for and the financial and educational implications of their decision.
12
https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/cfpb-sues-for-profit-college-chain-itt-for-predatory-lending/.
The Department also thinks it is important to include aggressive recruitment in order to clarify the interaction between what a recruiter may tell a prospective student who later enrolls, and the information the student may receive in written form. All institutions are required to disclose various information (see §§ 668.41, 668.47, and 668.164, among others) providing students with disclosures and information when they enroll, including through course catalogs. These printed or digital materials may contain factually accurate statements that differ from what prospective students have been told by a recruiter—such as a more accurate presentation of job placement rates, the role of accreditation, the ability to transfer credit, or other issues that would be important to prospective students and their families. In responding to the allegations in borrower defense claims, some institutions have asserted that written statements, even if buried in material provided to the students, are sufficient to correct inaccurate information from recruiters. The Department disagrees with this view. As a practical matter, the recruiter is providing personal support to the borrower. The recruiter is often the borrower's first interaction and gateway to apply for and eventually obtain Federal student aid, including Federal student loans. Even if the borrower examines the written disclosures closely before enrolling, the information from the recruiter may overshadow the disclosures.
13
Given the information asymmetry between the recruiter and the borrower, and that perceived relationship of trust, the aggressive tactics of the institution may
themselves constitute a valid claim for borrower defense.
13
https://www.help.senate.gov/imo/media/for_profit_report/PartI-PartIII-SelectedAppendixes.pdf.
Moreover, the Department acknowledges that the statutory ban on incentive compensation for recruiters or admissions employees has not fully achieved the intended result which was to protect students from the harms of aggressive recruitment. The incentive compensation rule bans incentive payments to recruiters based on their enrollment success because such payments might lead recruiters to mislead students in order to earn a financial bonus. 20 U.S.C. 1094(a)(20). Aggressive recruitment continues to proliferate in institutions as the pressure for increased enrollment, and in turn, receipt of Federal student assistance, drives institutions' continued use of such tactics. The Department believes enrollment that stems from such tactics should provide a path to an approved borrower defense claim as a form of aggressive recruitment.
The Department is aware of instances where institutions will, either directly or through a third party, falsely appear to help individuals seeking Federal, State or local benefits. For example, in the FTC's action against Career Education Corporation (CEC), CEC obtained individuals' contact information from websites where the institution presented itself, through lead generators, as a portal for receiving other government benefits, such as unemployment insurance, or for job seeking.
14
These individuals unwittingly provided their personal information to the lead generator believing submission of their information was a portal for government benefits. Those individuals, in some cases, later enrolled at the institution after providing their information under the guise that they would obtain government benefits. An individual could not reasonably be expected to understand that such websites were lead generators that the institution used to increase their enrollments.
14
Federal Trade Comm.
v.
Career Educ. Corp., et al.,
Case No. 1:19-cv-05739 (N.D. Ill. Eastern Dist. Oct. 9, 2019).
The Department considered including an aggressive recruitment provision in the 2016 regulations, but at that time was concerned about the potential difficulty of developing clear, consistent standards for aggressive conduct. 81 FR at 39343. The 2016 regulations did, however, include aggressive recruitment as an aggravating factor in determining whether a borrower relied, or reasonably would have relied, on a misrepresentation, an indication of the Department's degree of concern about such behavior and its likelihood that borrowers' decisions would be affected by it.
Id.
After five more years of receiving borrower defense claims, and addressing concerns raised by non-Federal negotiators during negotiated rulemaking,
15
the Department is confident that an appropriate standard can be articulated and enforced in the borrower defense context and that such an element is a necessary addition to address gaps in the Federal standard. Additionally, as described above and through program reviews, audits, and other investigations, the Department has seen that institutions engage in aggressive tactics. Such tactics include imposing pressure on potential students to make enrollment or loan decisions immediately, taking advantage of a student's lack of understanding of the process, stifling efforts for the borrower to consult with a third party, persistent and unsolicited contact with a prospective student, and other actions under which an institution exerts unreasonable pressure to induce a student to enroll or obtain Federal student financial aid. These abuses have been well documented and result in findings against the institution under State or Federal laws,
16
but they currently do not meet the standards for a borrower defense claim. In light of the Department's discovery of extensive acts of aggressive recruitment and the harm to students, the Department is proposing to include aggressive recruitment in the Federal borrower defense standard.
15
https://www2.ed.gov/policy/highered/reg/hearulemaking/2021/transc103pm.pdf.
16
See, for example,
https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2019/08/operator-colorado-technical-university-american-intercontinental-university-will-pay-30-million.
The Department modeled the proposed aggressive recruitment provision in part 668, subpart R, after the misrepresentation regulations in part 668, subpart F, because the subpart F framework was the most logical structure already in place: it had a definitions section and outlined a non-exhaustive list of factors that could lead to a misrepresentation. In defining the types of aggressive recruitment under the subpart, § 668.501, the Department balanced the need to establish specific guidelines to curb institutions' exertion of unreasonable pressure on prospective students with the need for general standards that broadly cover other forms of aggressive recruitment. Placing the standard for aggressive recruitment in its own subpart instead of within borrower defense also would ensure the Department applies consistent standards for aggressive recruitment across its other oversight and compliance work, which could in turn result in an approved borrower defense claim. Additionally, this increased oversight and compliance may help to deter such behavior from institutions going forward, helping to ultimately reduce the need for borrowers to submit defense to repayment claims.
To ensure that institutions and the public have clear standards for what constitutes aggressive recruitment, for purposes of borrower defense, the Department seeks the public's input on how the Department can identify the extent to which an institution engages in any form of aggressive recruitment and the means to document this misconduct through program reviews and audits. Policies and procedures that law enforcement uses to curb these actions would be especially helpful. The Department also provides a non-exhaustive list of acts that could warrant an aggressive recruitment claim in proposed § 668.501.
Finally, the Department believes that each of the proposed provisions discussed in this NPRM pertaining to aggressive recruitment serves one or more important, related, but distinct, purposes. Each of the requirements provides value to students, prospective students, and their families; to the public, taxpayers, and the Government; and to institutions separate from, and in addition to, the value provided by the other requirements. To best serve these purposes, we would include this administrative provision in the regulations to make clear that the regulations are designed to operate independently of each other and to convey the Department's intent that the potential invalidity of one provision should not affect the remainder of the provisions.
Judgments Against Institutions and Department Actions
In the 2016 regulations, the Department included as a basis for a borrower defense claim a nondefault, contested judgment obtained against an institution based on any State or Federal law, whether obtained in a court or in an administrative tribunal of competent jurisdiction. Under those regulations, the borrower has a defense to repayment if the borrower was personally affected by the judgment; that is, the borrower must have been a party to the case in which the judgment was entered, either individually or as a member of a class that obtained the judgment in a class action lawsuit, and the act or omission must have pertained to the making of a Direct Loan or the provision of educational services to the borrower. The Department believes retention of
this provision is in the public interest for the reasons discussed below.
We believe the Department did not fully consider the importance of the lawsuits students brought against institutions when it removed this provision in the 2019 regulation. Although judgments are not as common as allegations of misrepresentation, they are a clear finding by a court that the institution engaged in misconduct. See,
e.g., Supplee
v.
Miller-Motte Bus. Coll., Inc.,
768 S.E. 2d 582 (N.C. Ct. App. 2015).
In its rationale to include a judgment against an institution as part of the Federal standard, in 2016 the Department stated that including judgment against an institution would allow for recognition of State law and other Federal law causes of action, but would also reduce the burden on the Department and borrowers of having to make determinations on the applicability and interpretation of those laws. See 81 FR 39340-41. To ensure that the scope of the judgment relates only to borrower defense claims, the favorable judgment against an institution would still be required to relate to the making of a Federal student loan.
Finally, the Department proposes to include Departmental final actions as part of a judgment against an institution standard. Institutions that participate in the title IV programs sign a Program Participation Agreement (PPA) with the Secretary. If the Secretary or auditor identifies through Final Program Review Determination (FPRD) or Final Audit Determination (FAD), for example, that an institution breached its PPA, a borrower who was impacted by that final action could have a defense to repayment claim.
It is important for the Department to consider all information available to it, including its own prior investigation and oversight work, to reach findings. FPRDs are not only the result of the Department's own findings, but schools would have also had an opportunity to respond to the findings therein. But more importantly, where the Department has evidence that schools have engaged in conduct that constitutes the basis for a borrower defense, the Department would act on its own evidence rather than requiring borrowers to independently produce this information, which is not available to them.
State Law Standard (§§ 685.206, 685.222)
Statute:
Section 455(h) of the HEA authorizes the Secretary to specify in regulation which acts or omissions of an institution a borrower may assert as a defense to repayment of a Direct Loan, notwithstanding any other provision of State or Federal law, except that a borrower may not recover more from the Secretary than the amount that the borrower has repaid on the loan.
Current Regulations:
In the current regulations, three different regulatory standards and limitations periods apply, depending on when a borrower's loan was first disbursed:
• Loans first disbursed prior to July 1, 2017, are addressed under the former 1994 borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(c). That section provides that a borrower may assert a defense to repayment under applicable State law.
• Loans disbursed between July 1, 2017, and June 30, 2020, are adjudicated under the former 2016 borrower defense regulations in § 685.222, which does not provide for any adjudications under applicable State law.
• Loans disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, are adjudicated under the current borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(e), which does not allow any adjudications under applicable State law.
Proposed Regulations:
In proposed § 685.401(b), a violation of State law could form the basis for a borrower defense claim, but only if the borrower, or a State requestor in the case of a group claim brought by a State requestor, requests reconsideration of the Secretary's denial of a claim.
Reasons:
Achieving the goal of a uniform Federal standard that could be applied to all claims pending or filed after July 1, 2023 requires crafting a regulation that covers all borrower defense claims that are pending as of that date and claims that could be filed in the future. However, claims filed under the 1994 regulation are based upon violations of State law. To ensure that no borrower risks losing access to the State law standard as a result of the uniform Federal standard, the Department proposes allowing borrowers to seek reconsideration of a claim under a State law standard if their initial claim is denied or approved only for a partial discharge. This approach covers the range of acts or omissions that the Department has determined should form a basis for a valid borrower defense to repayment application. It also ensures institutions are not unfairly subject to the costs of approvals for conduct that occurred prior to this regulation by indicating that the Department may only seek to recoup the cost of claims that would have been meritorious under the borrower defense regulation that would have been in effect at the time of the conduct that led to the approval.
Limitations Period (§§ 685.206, 685.222, & Part 668)
Statute:
Section 455(h) of the HEA authorizes the Secretary to specify in regulation which acts or omissions of an institution of higher education a borrower may assert as a defense to repayment of a Direct Loan, except that a borrower may not receive more relief than the borrower has repaid.
Current Regulations:
In the current regulations, three different limitations periods apply, depending on when a borrower's loan was first disbursed:
• Loans first disbursed prior to July 1, 2017, are addressed under the former 1994 borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(c). The borrower may bring a claim at any point during the period in which the loan is being collected.
• Loans disbursed between July 1, 2017, and June 30, 2020, are adjudicated under the former 2016 borrower defense regulations in § 685.222. The borrower may bring such a claim at any time but may only assert a right to recover amounts previously collected by the Secretary on the grounds of that same breach of contract or substantial misrepresentation within 6 years of the alleged breach or of the date on which the substantial misrepresentation reasonably could have been discovered.
• Loans disbursed on or after July 1, 2020, are adjudicated under the current borrower defense regulations in § 685.206(e), which require borrowers to file a claim within 3 years from the date the student is no longer enrolled at the institution to file a claim with the Department.
Proposed Regulations:
The Department proposes that borrowers with outstanding loans would not be subject to a limitations period.
Reasons:
The Department proposes to remove the limitations period for a borrower to assert a borrower defense claim under these regulations or to receive refunds of amounts previously paid on loans still outstanding. This is a change from the 2019 regulation, which required borrowers to file claims within 3 years of the date the borrower left the institution. The 2019 regulation imposed this limit primarily because of the time period institutions would be expected to keep records. However, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York held that the 3-year limitations period for claims that were subject to a collections proceeding (referred to in the 2019 regulation as “defensive claims”) was not a logical outgrowth of the rulemaking and
remanded that provision to the Department.
17
17
New York Legal Assistance Group (“NYLAG”)
v.
Cardona,
Case No. 20-CV-1414 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 17, 2021).
The Department believes removing any limitations period on loans that are still outstanding is appropriate for several reasons. First, as discussed in the section on record retention, the records limitation discussed by the Department in the 2019 regulation relates to specific financial aid records that are unlikely to be relevant to the allegations most borrowers raise based upon what the Department has seen in applications for borrower defense to date. Most borrower defense applications to date relate to allegations around what an institution promised during the recruitment process and how that aligned with either the education the borrower ultimately received, such as whether they were able to get a job, if they could transfer credits, or if key data provided during the recruitment process such as job placement rates were accurate. The typical financial aid records that have a three-year retention requirement would not have any bearing on those allegations since they do not include records of recruitment activities, but rather cover items like the disbursement record of aid. Similarly, the Department does not believe it would be appropriate to set statutes of limitations on loans that are still outstanding the way many State laws do by tying them to the date that a borrower knew or could reasonably have been expected to know the misconduct occurred. As noted in the 2019 regulation, properly enforcing such a statute of limitations is administratively burdensome. It would entail information that may not be included in a borrower's application and could also rely on other factors such as when a State opened an investigation or publicized its findings. Moreover, the concept of limitations tied to when a borrower could reasonably have known about misconduct would not align with the Department's proposal to allow group claims. Since one of the purposes of a group claim is to not require an individual application, the Department would not be receiving information from a borrower about when they knew about misconduct.
The Department also considered whether it would be appropriate to establish separate statutes of limitations for forgiving balances that are still outstanding versus refunding amounts previously paid on loans that are still outstanding. The Department does not believe it would be appropriate to place a limitation on discharging remaining loan balances. Since there is no statutory time limit on repayment or collections activity, the Department does not want to create a situation where a borrower is still obligated to repay a loan on which the Department has concluded that the borrower should have received a discharge due to the institution's misconduct solely because the individual did not fill out an application in time. Such an approach is not in keeping with any of the Department's other discharge authorities, such as closed school discharge, false certification discharges, or total and permanent disability discharges, none of which require borrowers to apply for a discharge within a set period of time.
Similarly, the Department does not believe it would be appropriate to set a separate statute of limitations for refunding amounts previously paid on loans that are still outstanding. None of the Department's other discharges limit the refunding of amounts previously paid based on when a borrower applies, and the statute does not specify a separate treatment for borrower defense. There are no limitations on the issuing of refunds when a borrower receives a closed school discharge. Other discharges limit refunds to the point at which the borrower became eligible for the discharge, which is also not tied to applying within a certain period. For false certification, refunds are limited to the point after the borrower meets the eligibility criteria for a discharge, though in essentially all cases this means refunding all payments since most borrowers meet the eligibility criteria for a discharge prior to taking out a loan. Similarly, a borrower may receive refunds when approved for a TPD disability discharge back to the date the borrower's eligibility for a discharge was established. Refunds for PSLF and Income-Driven Repayment, meanwhile, are provided for payments made beyond the 120, 240, or 300 qualifying payment threshold, depending on the program. Finally, applying a statute of limitations only to refunds of amounts paid would create significant operational challenges for the Department.
Exclusions
Statute:
Section 455(h) of the HEA authorizes the Secretary to specify in regulation which acts or omissions of an institution a borrower may assert as a defense to repayment of a Direct Loan, except that a borrower may not receive more relief than has been repaid.
Current Regulations:
The 1994 borrower defense regulations do not explicitly address the acts or omissions that are excluded from a borrower defense to repayment claim. The 2016 regulations at § 685.222(a)(3) explicitly provide that an institution's violation of the title IV regulations alone does not constitute a basis for a borrower defense claim unless that violation would fulfill one of the bases for a borrower defense claim. Similarly, under the 2019 borrower defense regulations at § 685.206(e)(5), the Department explicitly excludes an institution's violation of an HEA requirement or Department regulation as a basis for a borrower defense claim unless the violation would otherwise constitute the basis for a successful borrower defense to repayment. Under current regulations, misrepresentations related to civil rights violations are not a basis for a borrower defense claim.
Proposed Regulations:
Proposed § 685.401(d) would provide exclusions that would not constitute a basis for a borrower defense claim. Specifically, an institution's violation of institutional eligibility or compliance rules under the HEA or other laws would not form the basis for a defense to repayment claim unless the violation would constitute a defense to repayment under the Federal standard and occurred in connection with the making of a loan or provision of educational service for which the loan was intended. For example, an institution's failure to meet the Constitution Day requirements in 36 U.S.C. 106 would not form the basis for a borrower defense to repayment claim.
Reasons:
The Department's consistent position since 1994 has been that the Department will acknowledge a borrower defense to repayment only if the act of omission of the institution directly relates to the loan or to the institution's provision of educational services for which the loan was provided. See 60 FR 37768, 37769 (July 21, 1995); 81 FR at 75941, 75944.
As a result, the Department consistently has not considered claims such as personal injury torts, harassment, or a violation of Federal civil rights laws to be grounds for alleging a defense to repayment. In the 2019 regulations, the Department provided a non-exhaustive list of circumstances that would not constitute, in and of themselves, borrower defenses to repayment that were directly related to the borrower's loan or the provision of educational services. This list included, among others, slander or defamation, property damage, and allegations about the general quality of the student's education or the reasonableness of an educator's conduct in providing
educational services. See 84 FR at 49802, 49824. The Department emphasizes that, although the current regulations and the proposed regulations exclude a violation of civil rights as a basis for alleging a borrower defense to repayment, the Department's Office for Civil Rights (OCR) enforces several Federal civil rights laws related to education, including Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. Individuals who believe that a recipient of Federal funds or a public entity that is subject to Title II has violated these Federal civil rights laws can file a complaint with OCR. OCR's authority includes obtaining reimbursement of tuition and other costs for injured parties when appropriate. The availability of this form of relief encourages individuals to file promptly with OCR. The Department believes that OCR's enforcement authority is better suited to addressing civil rights harms than including them as a new basis for a borrower defense to repayment.
The proposed regulations reflect these positions.
Group Process and Group Timelines
Statute:
Section 455(h) of the HEA authorizes the Secretary to specify in regulation which acts or omissions of an institution a borrower may assert as a defense to repayment of a Direct Loan, except that a borrower may not receive more relief than has been repaid.
Current Regulations:
The current borrower defense regulations under § 685.206 require an individualized review of every borrower defense application and thus do not permit a group review process. Under the 2016 standard, § 685.222(f) outlined a process for evaluation of a group claim. Upon consideration of factors including, but not limited to, common facts and claims, fiscal impact, and the promotion of compliance by the institution or other title IV, HEA program participant, the Department could initiate a process to determine whether a group of borrowers identified by the Secretary, has a borrower defense. Members of the group may be identified from individual applications or from any other source. The Department may consolidate applications that have common facts and claims and resolve the borrowers' claims as group claims. The Department established separate group process procedures with respect to loans made by institutions that have closed in § 685.222(g) and for those that remain open in § 685.222(h). The 1994 regulations did not specify a group process, though the Department did employ a group process using those regulations, including in granting a group claim for students who attended American Career Institute in early 2017.
Proposed Regulations:
The Department proposes two processes for pursuing group claims in new § 685.402. Under the first process, in proposed § 685.402(a) and (b), the Department reserves the right to determine if a group of borrowers it identifies have a common defense to repayment at the same institution, including multiple campuses of the same institution. Under such a Department-initiated group process, the Department would have the discretion to create a group based on any of the following borrower defense basis: actions by the Federal Government, State attorneys general or other State agencies/officials or law enforcement activities; class action lawsuits related to educational programs at one institution; or State or Federal judgments against institutions awarded to several borrowers for reasons related that could give rise to a defense to repayment claim; or a group of individual borrower defense claims.
Under the second process, in proposed § 685.402(c), the Department may initiate a group process upon request from a State requestor, on the condition that the State requestor submit an application and other required information to the Department to determine if it should form a group. Such an application ensures the Department has a consistent and clear process for addressing requests to form a group but does not confer the ability of the State requestor to otherwise represent the group during the Department's process of reviewing and adjudicating the claims. The Secretary would further be able to consolidate multiple group applications related to the same institution or institutions. The proposed provision would require the Department to respond to a materially complete State requestor's submission within 365 days. That response would indicate whether the Department decided to form the requested group and, if not, would provide the State requestor an opportunity to seek reconsideration of the group formation decision. In both group processes, the Department would include any individual claims submitted by a borrower under new proposed § 685.403 if that borrower is deemed part of the group. That borrower's claim would then be treated as part of the group claim, including with respect to timelines for adjudication.
If the Department agrees to form a group under this proposed section, the Department would designate a Department official to adjudicate the borrower defense claim.
For group claims, the Department proposes placing those loans in forbearance if they are in repayment and stopping collection activity if they are in default. While every effort would be made to identify the group members during the initial group formation stage, in some cases that may not be possible. Any borrower who was not initially identified
18
could opt into the group, however, and would be granted forbearance or stopped collection, as appropriate. The Department would retroactively apply forbearance or stopped collections to the loans of any such borrower, and no other consequences would apply to any borrower that the Department adds to a group after the group's initial formation.
18
It may not be possible to initially identify the full number of borrowers in every potential group due to data limitations. For example, the Department does not have reliable data on program-level enrollment prior to the 2015-16 financial aid award year. That means the Department would not be able to accurately identify all members of a group claim based on enrollment in a specific program prior to that year. In situations where data quality prevents the Department from identifying all group members, for example, the Department would make every effort to identify all members of the group and would reserve the opportunity for individuals who the Department could not initially identify to be included in an opt-in basis.
Reasons:
Upon its review of all three borrower defense regulations the Department believes it is better to return to allowing group processes, as was permissible for more than two decades under the 1994 regulation and explicitly allowed under the 2016 regulation. The 2019 regulation excluded the ability to conduct a group process on the grounds that each borrower defense claim had to be subject to a highly individualized review. This included requiring a borrower to prove that a misrepresentation was made with the knowledge that the statement was false, deceptive, or misleading, or made with reckless disregard for the truth. It also required the borrower to make an individualized showing of harm. As already discussed under the
Substantial Misrepresentation and Omission of Fact
section, the Department is proposing to remove both of those requirements for a misrepresentation out of concerns that expecting a borrower to prove knowledge of a misrepresentation's falsity or disregard for the truth sets a bar that would be essentially impossible for any reasonable individual to meet because they are not going to have inside knowledge of the way an institution was operating. Similarly, the
Department is concerned that the harm documentation as required in the 2019 regulation risks penalizing borrowers for success achieved regardless of their education or to prove a level of employment analysis best reserved for labor economists.
Removing these two components of the definition of a misrepresentation allows the Department to then determine the effects of a misrepresentation across a group of borrowers as opposed to an individual approach. While the Department does not believe that every instance of an alleged type of behavior that may result in an approved claim should be reviewed for a group of borrowers, the flexibility to do so when appropriate would result in a process that is more efficient for borrowers, institutions, and the Department.
As discussed in the 2016 final regulations, Congress authorized the Department to determine subordinate questions of procedure for borrower defense cases, including but not limited to the scope and nature of alleged acts or omissions that satisfy borrower defense requirements, how to process borrower claims, and whether claims should be heard successively or as a group. See 81 FR at 75965 (generally citing
FCC
v.
Pottsville Broad. Co.,
309 U.S. 134, 138 (1940)). The Department thus has general authority to adjudicate claims as a group.
The Department believes that, where appropriate, the most efficient way to evaluate borrower defense claims is to jointly adjudicate the claims of similarly situated borrowers that are based on common evidence. This is consistent with how the Department has adjudicated and approved claims to date under the 1994 and 2016 regulations. Considering the applications of similarly situated borrowers as a group rather than reviewing all of them individually allows addressing the conduct that is often pervasive and affects many borrowers at once. At the same time, a group process may benefit the institution by allowing it to present its response to the same allegations by a group of borrowers once rather than having to respond to numerous individual claims.
The Department is mindful of the privacy of borrowers' financial information. Under these proposed regulations, information about a borrower's individual financial circumstances would not be shared with other borrowers that are part of the group claim. Many negotiators supported the Department's creation of a new group process for considering borrower defenses to repayment claims. They asserted that groups of borrowers who were all subject to the same act or omission by an institution should have their defenses considered as a group, and that a group process would be more efficient and result in more equitable treatment of similarly situated borrowers.
In the 2016 regulations, the Department reserved the sole right to form groups for purposes of borrower defense adjudication. Although the Department welcomed cooperation and information from non-Federal partners, including State attorneys general and legal assistance organizations, the Department did not extend the right to request group formation to these external entities. The Department's recent experience with borrower defense, however, particularly the influx of individual borrower defense applications, has convinced the Department that State partners can provide critical assistance in assessing borrower defense claims. For instance, every set of appr
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.