Affordable Housing Program Amendments
Federal RegisterNov 28, 2018
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
FEDERAL HOUSING FINANCE AGENCY
12 CFR Parts 1290 and 1291
RIN 2590-AA83
Affordable Housing Program Amendments
AGENCY:
Federal Housing Finance Agency.
ACTION:
Final rule.
SUMMARY:
The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA or Agency) is amending its regulation addressing requirements for the Federal Home Loan Banks' (Banks) Affordable Housing Program (AHP or Program). The final rule amends the regulation to: Provide the Banks additional authority to allocate their AHP funds; authorize the Banks to establish separate competitive funds that target specific affordable housing needs in their districts; provide the Banks additional flexibility in designing their project selection scoring systems to address affordable housing needs in their districts; remove the requirement for retention agreements for owner-occupied units where the AHP subsidy is used solely for rehabilitation; provide for a calculation of household subsidy repayment amount that prioritizes return of the household's investment in the housing to the household; reduce administrative burdens related to calculating and obtaining household subsidy repayments based on net proceeds of the sale of a home; further align certain project monitoring requirements with those of other federal government funding programs; clarify the requirements for remediating AHP noncompliance; clarify certain operational requirements; and streamline and reorganize the regulation.
DATES:
Effective date:
This final rule is effective on December 28, 2018.
Compliance dates:
For applicable compliance dates, see the discussions under §§ 1290.8 and 1291.2 in Section I. of the
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION
below.
FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT:
Ted Wartell, Manager, Office of Housing and Community Investment, 202-649-3157,
ted.wartell@fhfa.gov;
Marcea Barringer, Senior Policy Analyst, Office of Housing and Community Investment, 202-649-3275,
marcea.barringer@fhfa.gov;
Marshall Adam Pecsek, Senior Counsel, Office of General Counsel, 202-649-3380,
marshall.pecsek@fhfa.gov;
or Sharon Like, Managing Associate General Counsel, Office of General Counsel, 202-649-3057,
sharon.like@fhfa.gov.
These are not toll-free numbers. The mailing address is: Federal Housing Finance Agency, 400 Seventh Street SW, Washington, DC 20219. The telephone number for the Telecommunications Device for the Hearing Impaired is 800-877-8339.
SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION:
I. Sections 1291.2 and 1290.8—Compliance Dates
Section 1291.2 of the final rule provides generally, that through December 31, 2020, a Bank may comply with either the AHP regulation in effect immediately prior to this final rule's effective date, or this final rule. On and after January 1, 2021, a Bank must comply with this final rule. However, for the owner-occupied retention agreement requirements in § 1291.15(a)(7), the final rule provides that through December 31, 2019, a Bank may comply with either § 1291.9(a)(7) of the AHP regulation in effect immediately prior to this final rule's effective date, or § 1291.15(a)(7) of this final rule. On and after January 1, 2020, a Bank must comply with § 1291.15(a)(7) of the final rule. Regarding proxies for determining a subsequent purchaser's income, the final rule provides that a Bank shall comply with § 1291.15(a)(7)(ii)(B) of the final rule on the date set forth in the FHFA guidance on proxies referenced therein.
Similarly, § 1290.8 of the final rule provides that through December 31, 2020, a Bank must comply with either prior part 1290 (Community Support Requirements regulation) or this part 1290. On and after January 1, 2021, a Bank must comply with this part 1290.
The proposed rule did not address effective or compliance dates. The Banks requested that the final rule not become effective for at least two years. They stressed that the proposed substantive changes to the regulation, especially the proposed outcome-based scoring framework, would require extensive changes to their existing scoring, information and reporting systems, as well as education and training of Bank staff, members, and potential project sponsors. Bank staff indicated that they would need to consult with their Bank Advisory Councils, boards of directors, and board committees on changes to their Program, including systems and procedures. They would need to seek approval by their boards of changes to their policies for their General Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs, and for establishment of Targeted Funds, along with related changes to their AHP Implementation Plans and Targeted Community Lending Plans (TCLPs). The Banks typically hold their AHP funding rounds in the spring or summer of each year, and would need sufficient time to publish their revised AHP Implementation Plans and TCLPs, and announce their AHP funding allocations, well in advance of the start of that calendar year.
In view of the publication of the final rule late in 2018, FHFA recognizes that it may not be feasible for the Banks to complete all of the above actions in time for implementation of revised Programs for 2019 or 2020, even though the final rule does not adopt the proposed outcome-based scoring framework and instead adopts a scoring framework more similar to the existing scoring requirements of the Competitive Application Program. A January 1, 2021 compliance date for the final rule, thus, is warranted. However, there are certain changes in the final rule that will benefit households without requiring significant changes to the Banks' information systems and, therefore, can be implemented more quickly. In particular, the final rule establishes a compliance date of January 1, 2020 by which the Banks must implement the new owner-occupied retention agreement provisions in § 1291.15(a)(7), including the requirement to calculate AHP subsidy repayment based on net proceeds and household's investment (§ 1291.15(a)(7)(v)), the
de minimis
subsidy repayment exception of $2,500 or less (§ 1291.15(a)(7)(ii)(C)), and the elimination of the requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements for rehabilitation (§ 1291.15(a)(7)). Prior to January 1, 2020, or such earlier compliance date as the Bank elects, a Bank must continue to comply with the current regulation, including its requirement that subsidy be recovered only from “net gain,” a concept that in many respects resembles the more clearly articulated standards of “net proceeds” and “household's investment” in the final rule.
Because some Banks may find it feasible to implement certain provisions of the final rule before the applicable compliance dates, such as the provisions benefiting households, provisions easing operational burdens, or provisions for the establishment of Targeted Funds, the final rule provides that a Bank may choose to comply with any provision of the final rule before the applicable compliance date. A Bank that chooses to comply with a specific provision before the applicable compliance date must also comply with all other provisions related to that specific provision in part 1291 and § 1290.6. For example, if a Bank decides
to establish a Targeted Fund before January 1, 2021 pursuant to § 1291.20(b), the Bank must also comply with the funding allocation and phase-in requirements for Targeted Funds in §§ 1291.20(b)(1) and 1291.12(c)(1), respectively, must amend its AHP Implementation Plan to include its requirements for the Targeted Fund pursuant to § 1291.13(b)(3), and must amend its Targeted Community Lending Plan to include the specific housing needs to be addressed by the Targeted Fund pursuant to § 1290.6(a)(5)(vi).
II. Background
A. Overview of Current Program
The Federal Home Loan Bank Act (Bank Act) requires each Bank to establish a Program to provide subsidies for long-term, low- and moderate-income, owner-occupied and affordable rental housing. Each Bank is required to allocate annually 10 percent of its prior year's net income to fund its Program to help subsidize the purchase, construction, and rehabilitation of affordable rental and owner-occupied housing. Homeowners and homebuyers receiving AHP subsidies must be low- or moderate-income (incomes at or below 80 percent of area median income (AMI)). For rental housing, at least 20 percent of the units must be occupied by very low-income households (incomes at or below 50 percent of AMI) and must be affordable (rents charged do not exceed 30 percent of income).
1
1
See
12 U.S.C. 1430(j).
The current AHP regulation authorizes the Banks to establish and administer two programs for awarding AHP subsidies: a mandatory Competitive Application Program (referred to in the proposed and final rules as the “General Fund”); and an optional Homeownership Set-Aside Program.
2
Each Bank must allocate annually at least 65 percent of its required annual AHP contribution to its Competitive Application Program, and may allocate annually up to the greater of $4.5 million or 35 percent of its required annual AHP contribution to its Homeownership Set-Aside Program.
3
2
See
12 CFR part 1291.
3
Where a Bank allocates the alternative maximum amount of $4.5 million to its Homeownership Set-Aside Program, the Bank may allocate less than 65 percent of its total AHP funds to its Competitive Application Program.
Under the Competitive Application Program, members apply to the Banks for AHP subsidies on behalf of project sponsors, which are typically nonprofit affordable housing developers, but may include for-profit organizations. The Banks are required to develop and implement a scoring system subject to requirements in the regulation, which serves as a mechanism for evaluating and selecting the project applications to receive AHP subsidies. Under the Homeownership Set-Aside Program, members apply to the Banks for grants, which are provided to low- or moderate-income homebuyers or homeowners for purchasing or rehabilitating homes.
The AHP has played an important role in facilitating the Banks' support of their members' efforts to meet the affordable housing needs of their communities. Between 1990 and 2017, the Banks awarded approximately $5.8 billion in AHP subsidies to assist the financing of over 865,000 affordable housing units. AHP subsidies have proven particularly effective in leveraging additional public and private resources for funding affordable housing projects that present underwriting challenges, such as projects for homeless households and special needs populations. For example, project sponsors have used AHP funds in conjunction with a number of different federal and state funding sources, including Low-Income Housing Tax Credits (LIHTC or tax credits), to develop rental housing for very low-income households. For 2018, the Banks' combined required annual AHP contribution is approximately $384,310,000.
B. AHP Regulatory History
FHFA and one of its predecessor agencies, the Federal Housing Finance Board (Finance Board), have engaged in numerous rulemakings over the years to revise, clarify, and streamline the AHP requirements as the Program has evolved and housing markets have changed. Successive rulemakings progressively devolved specific AHP application approval and governance authorities from the Finance Board to the Banks in order to enhance the ability of the Banks to address specific affordable housing needs in their respective districts.
The genesis of the current AHP rulemaking was the Notice of Regulatory Review published in the
Federal Register
in 2013 requesting comment on FHFA's existing regulations for purposes of improving their effectiveness and reducing their burden. In response, the Banks jointly submitted a letter to FHFA commenting on the AHP and other FHFA regulations. The letter contended that prescriptive, outdated, or ambiguous provisions of the AHP regulation created inefficiencies and uncertain risk exposures, and recommended that FHFA review the regulation and consider clarifications and enhancements to further empower the Banks in the management of their Programs.
In response to the Banks' recommendations, FHFA undertook a comprehensive review of the AHP regulation, including AHP issues on which FHFA had provided regulatory guidance. To further inform the review, FHFA conducted outreach with the Banks and a wide range of AHP stakeholders. The Banks and stakeholders uniformly expressed support for the AHP, and noted the critical role it plays in affordable housing initiatives throughout the country and its longstanding reputation as a well-managed program. At the same time, the Banks and stakeholders offered a number of specific recommendations to improve the operation of the AHP. The recommendations were directed largely at: (1) Expanding the Banks' authority to allocate their AHP funds; (2) providing the Banks authority to devise their own project selection methods, including the use of non-competitive processes; (3) clarifying the requirements for determining a project's need for AHP subsidy; (4) aligning the project monitoring requirements with those of other major funding sources; (5) clarifying the Banks' authorities to resolve project noncompliance; (6) clarifying certain operational requirements; and (7) codifying FHFA regulatory guidance in the regulation. Based on FHFA's analyses of the recommendations and its review of the Program, FHFA published a proposed rule to amend the AHP regulation, which is discussed below.
C. Proposed Rule
On March 14, 2018, FHFA published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM or proposed rule) in the
Federal Register
to amend the AHP regulation.
4
Taking into account the Banks' and stakeholders' input and recommendations discussed above, the proposed rule would have significantly altered how the Banks approach and implement their AHP project selection responsibilities. The proposed rule would have replaced the current project selection scoring process, a front-end process that requires the Banks to allocate at least 50 percent of the total points for scoring applications to specific statutory and regulatory priorities set forth in the regulation, with a back-end process using a scoring process and “outcome-based approach” for project selection. Under the proposal, each Bank would have been
required to establish its own scoring system containing Bank-identified district housing needs priorities for awarding AHP subsidies, subject to meeting certain FHFA-prescribed outcome requirements for statutory and regulatory priorities set forth in the proposed rule. Each Bank would have been evaluated according to whether a certain percentage of its total AHP funds was awarded to projects or households that met the applicable priorities. The NPRM stated that the proposal would address many of the Banks' and stakeholders' concerns by providing the Banks greater flexibility to design their competitive application programs while continuing to ensure the programs fulfilled the statutory requirements.
4
See
83 FR 11344 (Mar. 14, 2018).
The NPRM also proposed additional options for the Banks to allocate their total annual AHP contributions. Each Bank would have been required to allocate at least 50 percent of its total annual AHP contribution to its General Fund, down from the current 65 percent. Each Bank also would have been authorized to allocate up to 40 percent of its required annual AHP contribution to a maximum of three “Targeted Funds,” a new type of competitive application fund under the AHP, to address specific affordable housing needs within its district, subject to a phase-in period. In addition, the proposed rule would have increased the maximum percentage of a Bank's total annual AHP contribution that could be allocated to its Homeownership Set-Aside Program from 35 to 40 percent, with the existing alternate threshold of $4.5 million retained.
The proposed rule also would have eliminated the current requirement for an owner-occupied unit retention agreement, under which AHP-assisted households must repay AHP subsidy to the Bank under certain circumstances if they sell or refinance their homes during the AHP five-year retention period. The NPRM discussed that this would ease the administrative burdens on the Banks of recovering subsidy repayments from households, and enhance households' ability to build wealth, which appear to outweigh the retention agreements' potential to deter rare instances of flipping.
In addition, the proposed rule would streamline the responsibilities of the parties involved in monitoring projects for compliance with AHP income targeting and rent requirements by aligning the AHP project monitoring requirements with those of certain other government funding programs. For example, the proposal would remove certain back-up documentation requirements for the initial monitoring of AHP projects that have received LIHTC, and for initial and long-term monitoring of AHP projects that have received funding from certain other federal government programs.
In addition, the proposed rule would clarify a number of operational responsibilities. For example, the proposed rule would clarify the process and responsibilities of the various parties for remediating AHP noncompliance. The proposed rule also would have clarified the process for determining a project's need for AHP subsidy.
Finally, the proposed rule would streamline and reorganize the regulation to enhance its utility and readability.
D. Overview of Comments Received on the Proposed Rule
The NPRM initially provided the public 60 days to submit comments on the proposed rule. The Agency received numerous requests from commenters to extend the comment period by an additional 30 days. FHFA also identified an error in the calculation of the outcome requirement in the proposed rule text and related preamble discussion. In response to the requests for an extension of the comment period and to correct the error in the outcome calculation and encourage comments on the corrected calculation, FHFA published a notice in the
Federal Register
containing the corrected calculation and extending the comment period by an additional 30 days.
5
The extended comment period ended on June 12, 2018.
5
See
83 FR 19188 (May 2, 2018).
FHFA received 394 comment letters in response to the proposed rule. Of those letters, 251 expressed unique comments and recommendations, with the remaining 143 being form letters or requests to extend the original 60-day comment period. The Presidents of the eleven Banks submitted a joint comment letter. Nine Banks also submitted individual comment letters. FHFA received 16 comment letters from the Banks' boards of directors, Affordable Housing Advisory Councils (Bank Advisory Councils), and Community Investment Officers (CIOs). Eighteen members of Congress representing the states of Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, New Mexico, and Texas co-signed a comment letter. A member of Congress representing the state of New Jersey also submitted a comment letter. FHFA received 99 letters from trade associations, nonprofit organizations, and state and local government organizations. Lenders such as banks, credit unions, and Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs) submitted 50 comment letters. Nonprofit and for-profit developers submitted 204 comment letters. Individuals submitted the remaining 13 comment letters.
FHFA also held a number of webinars and meetings with Bank representatives and stakeholders to describe the content of the proposed rule, discuss issues raised by the proposed rule, and obtain clarifications of specific comments made in the letters.
6
6
Summaries of each of these meetings are available on FHFA's website at:
https://www.fhfa.gov/SupervisionRegulation/Rules/Pages/Comment-List.aspx?RuleID=612.
Six proposals received the most comments: The outcome-based approach for project selection; the authority for the Banks to establish Targeted Funds; the increase in the maximum permissible annual funding allocation to a Bank's Homeownership Set-Aside Program from 35 to 40 percent; the removal of the requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements; a clarification of the “cure-first” requirement for project noncompliance; and the responsibility of the full board of directors to approve strategic AHP decisions. The comments on these six proposals and FHFA's decisions in the final rule are discussed in Section III., below. Comments on other provisions of the proposed rule are discussed under each applicable provision in the Section-by-Section Analysis in Section IV., below.
III. Discussion of Comments on Key Proposals and Decisions in the Final Rule
A. Proposed Outcome-Based Approach for Project Selection
Final rule.
The final rule does not adopt the proposal for an outcome-based framework for project selection. Instead, the final rule amends the current regulatory scoring framework for project selection to provide the Banks with additional flexibility in designing their project selection scoring systems to address affordable housing needs in their districts, similar to the recommendations made by the Banks in their joint comment letter, but with certain changes to reflect particular policy objectives.
Current regulation.
The current AHP regulation prescribes a scoring-based project selection system based on a 100-point scale, under which each Bank must allocate:
• At least 5 points each to two priorities derived from the statute (combined 10 points minimum);
• At least 5 points each to four regulatory priorities addressing specific housing needs set forth in the regulation, and at least 20 points for the regulatory priority for income targeting (a combined 40 points minimum for the five regulatory priorities).
• The remaining maximum of 50 points to one or more housing needs specified under the first Bank district priority (from 12 eligible housing needs specified in the regulation, and to one or more housing needs in the Banks' districts selected by the Banks under the second Bank district priority (with at least 5 points allocated to each Priority).
Proposed rule.
The proposed rule would have authorized the Banks to design their own scoring systems, subject to an outcome-based framework under which a specified percentage of each Bank's total annual AHP funds would be required to be awarded to projects meeting specific outcome requirements established by FHFA in the proposed rule. As discussed in Section II.B. and C. above, the proposal was intended to address the Banks' and stakeholders' input on the AHP by providing the Banks greater flexibility to design their competitive application programs to meet their district housing needs while continuing to ensure the Programs fulfill the statutory requirements. The proposed outcome requirements would have included the three statutory priorities for: (1) Projects sponsored by a government or nonprofit entity; (2) use of donated or conveyed government property; and (3) purchase of homes by low- or moderate-income households. Each Bank would have been required to award at least 55 percent of its total AHP funds to projects meeting the donated or conveyed government properties priority or government or nonprofit sponsorship priority, and to award at least 10 percent of its total AHP funds to households or projects meeting the priority for purchase of homes by low- or moderate-income households.
In addition, the proposed outcome requirements would have included four regulatory priorities, with specified eligible housing needs included under each of the regulatory priorities, for: (1) Very low-income targeting for rental units; (2) underserved communities and populations; (3) creating economic opportunity; and (4) affordable housing preservation. Each Bank would have been required to ensure that at least 55 percent of all rental units in rental projects receiving AHP awards were targeted to very low-income households (households with incomes at or below 50 percent AMI). In addition, each Bank would have been required to award at least 55 percent of its total AHP funds to projects, in the aggregate, meeting at least two of the three other regulatory priorities.
The proposed rule would have permitted the Banks to re-rank the order of applications, by replacing a higher scoring application that does not contribute to meeting the outcome requirements with a lower scoring project that does, in order to enable the Banks to meet the outcome requirements. If a Bank failed to fulfill the outcome requirements, FHFA would have the authority to require the Bank to develop and implement a housing plan for addressing the Bank's noncompliance, or to order the Bank to reimburse its AHP Fund in the amount of funds necessary to address the dollar shortfall.
Comments.
A large majority of commenters addressed the proposed outcome-based framework for project selection. Most commenters, including several Banks, several trade associations, numerous lenders, many nonprofit and for-profit developers, and some members of Congress, expressed reservations about, or opposition to, the proposed approach. Many of these commenters asserted that the proposal was too prescriptive and complicated, and would result in unintended consequences, such as increased Program complexity, preferences for certain types of projects, and reduced transparency of the AHP. While not explicitly expressing support for the proposal, several commenters acknowledged the potential benefits of the proposed outcome-based approach. For example, a nonprofit intermediary recognized that the approach may facilitate the Banks' ability to increase the diversity of populations receiving AHP funds, as well as fulfill a broader range of district affordable housing needs. Several commenters, including a number of Banks, also acknowledged that the proposed regulatory priorities under the outcome-based approach were germane to the affordable housing needs of their districts.
However, most of the commenters expressed concern that the proposal would or might restrict the Banks' and members' ability to address the particular housing needs of local communities, which some of these commenters described as a “hallmark” of the AHP, in favor of a national housing needs focus. Some Bank Advisory Councils also expressed concern that the proposal would diminish the role of the Bank Advisory Councils in identifying the affordable housing needs of the districts. Several commenters focused on the proposed percentages that the Banks would be required to meet under the outcome requirements, raising concerns that requiring mathematical calculations of dollar amounts and numbers of rental units would increase the Program's complexity. Many commenters, including the Banks, a Bank Advisory Council, and a trade association, strongly objected to the proposal to permit the Banks to re-rank the order of scored applications as a way to meet the proposed outcome requirements. Commenters expressed concern that the ability to re-rank scored applications would undermine the integrity, predictability, simplicity, and transparency of the AHP, and deter project sponsors from submitting applications to the Program.
Numerous commenters, including the Banks, a trade association, and lenders, strongly opposed the proposed enforcement provisions for Bank noncompliance with the proposed outcome requirements. Commenters stated that requiring a Bank to reimburse its AHP Fund in the amount of any dollar shortfall would impose a “penalty” and “undue and severe punishment” on the Bank. A Bank noted that requiring such reimbursement would result in a Bank contributing annually more than the statutorily required 10 percent of its net income to its AHP for the particular year. Commenters also suggested that a reimbursement requirement would lead to reductions in the diversity of the projects awarded AHP funds, as the Banks would select conventional and unchallenging housing needs as part of their scoring systems in order to ensure fulfillment of the proposed outcome requirements and avoid having to reimburse their AHP Funds.
The eleven Banks jointly submitted a proposal for project selection based on the current regulatory scoring system, with certain changes to the regulatory priorities and required minimum allocations of scoring points. The Banks' proposal is discussed further below under § 1291.26 (Scoring Criteria for the General Fund) in Section IV.
Decision in the final rule.
The final rule does not adopt the proposed outcome-based framework. Instead, the final rule amends the current regulatory scoring framework to provide the Banks with additional flexibility in designing their project selection scoring systems to address affordable housing needs in their districts, similar to the recommendations made by the Banks in their joint comment letter but with certain changes to reflect particular policy objectives. Revisions to the existing regulatory scoring system
include broader regulatory priorities encompassing more housing needs and additional discretion in allocating scoring points under the Bank district priority.
FHFA's analyses of the Banks' awards in recent years indicate that most, if not all, of the Banks would have readily met the proposed outcome requirements, especially with the correction to the calculation of the proposed outcome requirement for the three regulatory priorities, while having increased flexibility to target district housing needs. However, the Banks and other commenters expressed concern about the proposed outcome requirements, especially the prospect of accountability for noncompliance with the outcome requirements and the potential to have to reimburse their AHP Funds for any dollar shortfall. Because FHFA has decided not to implement the proposed outcome-based approach, the proposed enforcement provisions for Bank noncompliance with the outcome requirements (proposed §§ 1291.48 and 1291.49) are moot and, therefore, not adopted in the final rule.
The Agency finds the Banks' proposal for project selection, which is based on both the current scoring system and specific regulatory priorities in the proposed rule, to be a reasonable approach, subject to certain changes to achieve specific policy objectives. The revised scoring-based framework in the final rule is discussed in Section IV. below, under § 1291.25 (Scoring Methodologies), and § 1291.26 (Scoring Criteria for the General Fund).
B. Authority for the Banks To Establish Targeted Funds
Final rule.
Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule authorizes the Banks to establish funds targeted to address specific affordable housing needs within their districts that are either unmet, have proven difficult to address through the Bank's General Fund, or align with objectives identified in their strategic plans (referred to as “Targeted Funds”).
The final rule requires the Banks to adopt and implement parameters to ensure that each Targeted Fund is designed to receive a sufficient number of applicants for the amount of AHP funds allocated to the Targeted Fund such that administration of each Targeted Fund results in a robust competitive scoring process. These parameters include requirements that a Bank must specify the particular type of affordable housing needs the Bank plans to address through any Targeted Funds in its TCLP, and that a Bank must publish its TCLP at least 90 days before the first day that applications may be submitted for that Targeted Fund (unless the Targeted Fund is specifically targeted to address a federal or state-declared disaster). Further, the final rule requires a Bank to establish a minimum of three scoring criteria for each Targeted Fund that assist the Bank in selecting the projects that meet the specified affordable housing needs to be addressed by the Targeted Fund. In addition, the final rule provides that a Bank may not allocate more than 50 points to any one scoring criterion. The final rule also implements a phase-in period for establishing Targeted Funds. A Bank would be limited initially to establishing one Targeted Fund to which it could allocate up to 20 percent of its total annual AHP funds. In the second year, the Bank could establish two Targeted Funds with a maximum allocation of 30 percent, and in the third year three Targeted Funds with a maximum allocation of 40 percent.
Current regulation.
The current regulation does not authorize a Bank to establish Targeted Funds.
Proposed rule.
The proposed rule would authorize the Banks to establish up to three competitive Targeted Funds, and to allocate a maximum of 40 percent of their total annual AHP funds to establish such Targeted Funds, subject to the phase-in requirements described above. The Banks would use these funds to address specific affordable housing needs within their districts that are unmet, have proven difficult to address through the existing General Fund, or align with objectives identified in their strategic plans. FHFA's intent in proposing this authority was to help address challenges the Banks experience when trying to target specific affordable housing needs within their districts, especially in a single AHP funding round. Banks report that the existing regulatory scoring requirements can affect their efforts to fully address affordable housing needs within their districts. Establishing a Targeted Fund with a dedicated funding allocation to a particular housing need would enable competitive projects serving that housing need to receive awards pursuant to the competitive process under that Targeted Fund, while other projects would receive awards under the General Fund, thereby serving multiple housing needs in the same AHP funding round. The Banks would be required to adopt and implement controls to ensure that each Targeted Fund is designed to receive sufficient numbers of applicants for the amount of AHP funds allocated to the Targeted Fund to enable the Bank to facilitate a genuinely competitive scoring process.
Comments.
FHFA received a mix of comments in support of and opposition to the proposal to authorize Targeted Funds. A nonprofit organization commented that Targeted Funds would enhance the interaction between a Bank's board of directors and its Bank Advisory Council. The commenter also noted that Targeted Funds would provide each Bank greater opportunities to address varying market needs, reach more underserved communities, and possibly expand the geographical footprint of its AHP. The Banks and several Bank Advisory Councils stated that Targeted Funds would prove beneficial by providing the Banks with the ability to target specific affordable housing needs within their districts. The Banks also commented that the use of Targeted Funds would provide additional flexibility and responsiveness to changing housing needs by permitting the Banks to establish and tailor separate scoring priorities. The Banks and Bank Advisory Councils stated, however, that implementation of the proposed outcome-based framework would undermine the potential benefits of Targeted Funds. They also asserted that FHFA's proposed regulatory priorities under the outcome-based framework would drive the scoring process and overshadow the local needs of each district.
Several commenters, including the Banks, Bank Advisory Councils, a trade association, and a policy organization, supported the proposed maximum 40 percent funding allocation for Targeted Funds. In contrast, a nonprofit advocacy organization and a government entity expressed concern that the proposal would lead to a decrease in funding for affordable rental housing. A nonprofit intermediary supported Targeted Funds, but recommended that the Banks be permitted to allocate an unspecified percentage that is less than 40 percent to their Targeted Funds to ensure that a majority of the Banks' AHP subsidies remain available under the General Fund to address a broad spectrum of affordable housing needs within each district. A nonprofit developer asserted that Targeted Funds would compel project sponsors to apply for AHP subsidy under both the General Fund and the Targeted Fund, resulting in costly compliance and administration expenses for the Banks, members, and project sponsors.
The Banks expressed concern that the proposed regulatory language requiring each Bank to adopt and implement controls to ensure that each Targeted Fund receives sufficient numbers of applicants for the amount of AHP funds
allocated to the Targeted Fund is vague, complex, and undefined.
Decision in the final rule.
FHFA has considered the comments received on the proposal for Targeted Funds and continues to be persuaded that Targeted Funds may increase the flexibility of the Banks to emphasize multiple housing needs in a given year, thereby enhancing their ability to address specific affordable housing needs in their districts. The Agency also continues to be persuaded that the Banks should be permitted to allocate up to 40 percent of their total annual AHP funds to Targeted Funds. Although a number of commenters expressed concern that allocation of AHP funds to Targeted Funds would potentially reduce the total amount of AHP funds available for affordable rental housing, they offered no support to substantiate their concerns that the Banks would target their Targeted Funds for owner-occupied housing. The 40 percent limit would provide the Banks significant flexibility to allocate AHP subsidy to Targeted Funds, which could include Targeted Funds for owner-occupied housing or rental housing. In fact, the Banks indicated that they would likely use Targeted Funds for rental housing. The final rule requires that the Banks allocate at least 50 percent of their total annual AHP funds to the competitive General Fund. The final rule also allows a Bank to allocate up to 35 percent of its total annual AHP funds to optional, noncompetitive Homeownership Set-Aside Programs, which are discussed further under § 1291.12 (Allocation of Required Annual AHP Contribution) below. Thus, the final rule ensures that the Banks award a majority of their AHP funds through competitive processes (for example, 50 percent for the General Fund plus 15 percent for Targeted Funds, or 65 percent for the General Fund).
FHFA also considered the Banks' concerns about the proposed language that each Targeted Fund have controls for ensuring that it is designed to receive sufficient numbers of applicants for the amount of AHP funds allocated to the Targeted Fund. The requirement that the Targeted Fund be
designed
to receive sufficient numbers of applicants pertains to the scope and scoring methodology of the Targeted Fund, and is not a guarantee of the actual number of applicants received.
FHFA also acknowledges the commenter's concern that project sponsors may feel compelled to submit applications for the same project to both the General Fund and any applicable Targeted Fund at a Bank. While the final rule does not prohibit applicants from applying to both Funds in the same year, FHFA does not anticipate this becoming a significant problem for the Banks and project sponsors due to the limited scope of Targeted Funds, and the time involved in completing multiple applications. The specific requirements in the final rule for establishing and administering Targeted Funds are discussed under § 1291.20(b)(1) in Section IV., below.
C. Proposed Increase in the Maximum Permissible Annual Funding Allocation for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs
Final rule.
In a change from the proposed rule, the final rule retains the current maximum permissible annual funding allocation of 35 percent for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. The final rule also retains the current alternate maximum permissible annual funding allocation of $4.5 million for such Programs.
Current regulation.
The current regulation authorizes each Bank, in its discretion, to allocate annually up to the greater of $4.5 million or 35 percent of the Bank's annual required AHP contribution for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs.
Proposed rule.
The proposed rule would have increased the current maximum permissible annual funding allocation for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs from 35 to 40 percent, and would have retained the current alternate maximum permissible annual funding allocation of $4.5 million. The NPRM noted that the current regulation allows the Banks to establish more than one Homeownership Set-Aside Program to address the homeownership needs of different populations, such as military veterans or disaster victims. FHFA stated that the increase in the maximum percentage allocation amount would enhance the ability of the Banks and their members to meet the demand for set-aside funds and provide more assistance to low- or moderate-income homebuyers and homeowners, including first-time homebuyers. FHFA also noted that the increase would assist Bank members by enhancing their ability to access a wider customer base, originate new mortgages for low- and moderate-income households, and fulfill their obligations under the federal Community Reinvestment Act.
FHFA acknowledged that the increase could result in a smaller amount of funds allocated by the Banks to their competitive application programs, which could result in reduced funding for rental projects. However, FHFA considered the proposal to be reasonable given the significant demand for set-aside funds and stakeholder requests that the Agency provide the Banks additional flexibility to target specific housing needs in their districts.
Comments.
The commenters were divided over the proposal. The Banks, Bank Advisory Councils, several nonprofit organizations, and trade associations supported the proposal. Some nonprofit organizations and trade associations expressed support for the proposed amendments that would expand and enhance the reach of the Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. One trade association supported the proposed increase, expressing the hope that it would help increase the supply of entry-level homes, as well as improve the affordability of the homes. A nonprofit organization stated that the proposal would increase the number of low- and moderate-income homebuyers or homeowners that would be able to purchase or rehabilitate their homes. A trade association suggested that FHFA index the dollar cap for the $4.5 million alternate maximum allocation to address further erosion of the funds' purchasing power as mortgage rates and home prices rise.
Numerous nonprofit organizations opposed the proposed increase on the basis that it would effectively reduce AHP funding for rental housing. Commenters noted the important role the AHP plays in supporting the preservation and expansion of rental properties for very low-income and extremely low-income households. A nonprofit organization cited data derived from the American Community Survey describing the Nation's significant shortage of affordable rental housing, including for extremely low-income households (incomes of less than 30 percent of AMI or less than the federal poverty line). Another nonprofit organization acknowledged the importance of promoting homeownership for lower income households, but opposed the proposed increase without an offsetting increase in funding for affordable rental projects, to help address the significant need for such housing nationwide. Several nonprofit organizations that advocate for the development of multifamily housing also opposed the proposal on the basis that a reduction in the amount the Banks must allocate to their General Funds would run counter to the promotion, development, and preservation of rental housing. One of the nonprofit organizations urged FHFA to maintain the existing funding allocation cap of 35 percent because it ensures that a minimum 65 percent of each Bank's total annual AHP contribution is available to fund rental projects. The commenter also implied
that funding for the General Fund should have priority over funding for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs because rental housing projects must address the accessibility needs of future residents, while single-family homeownership programs do not.
Decision in the final rule.
In response to the commenters' concerns and the continued need for affordable rental housing, FHFA has decided to retain the existing maximum permissible funding allocation of 35 percent of a Bank's required annual AHP contribution for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. The final rule also retains the alternate $4.5 million threshold.
The continued need for affordable rental housing is supported by the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University in its annual overview of the housing conditions in the United States. The organization's report,
The State of the Nation's Housing 2018,
examined and assessed the Nation's progress in producing decent and affordable homes for all households.
7
The report found that more than 38 million households in the U.S. have housing cost burdens that leave little income to pay for food, healthcare, and other basic necessities. The report determined that more than 11 million renters are severely cost burdened because they pay more than half their incomes for housing. The report also found that for every 100 extremely low-income renters, only 35 rental units were affordable and available in 2016—a nationwide shortfall of more than 7.2 million units. Very low-income renter households also faced a shortfall of 56 affordable and available rental units per 100 households. The report concluded that conditions at the low end of the affordable housing rental market would probably remain exceptionally tight over the long term in the face of strong demand and diminishing supply.
8
7
See
Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University, State of the Nation's Housing 2018 (2018),
available at http://www.jchs.harvard.edu/sites/default/files/Harvard_JCHS_State_of_the_Nations_Housing_2018.pdf
(last accessed 11/15/2018).
8
Id.
In addition, under the new authority for the Banks to establish Targeted Funds for homeownership or rental projects, the Banks may increase their focus on homeownership needs by establishing Targeted Funds for homeownership. This mitigates the need to increase the maximum permissible annual funding allocation for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs.
The final rule does not adopt the commenter's recommendation to index the alternate $4.5 million maximum threshold. FHFA has analyzed whether revisions to the $4.5 million limit would be necessary and concluded that the Banks' need for, or use of, the $4.5 million maximum is unlikely to change.
The specific requirements for establishing, funding, and administering Homeownership Set-Aside Programs are discussed below in §§ 1291.12 and 1291.40 through 1291.44 of Section IV.
D. Proposed Elimination of the Requirement for Owner-Occupied Retention Agreements
Final rule.
In a change from the proposed rule, the final rule eliminates the current requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements where households use the AHP subsidy solely for rehabilitation of a unit, but retains it in other circumstances.
Current regulation.
The current regulation requires owner-occupied retention agreements where a household uses the AHP subsidy for purchase, for purchase in conjunction with rehabilitation, or solely for rehabilitation of a unit. Members must ensure that the AHP-assisted owner-occupied unit is subject to a five-year deed restriction or other legally enforceable retention agreement or mechanism requiring that, in the case of a sale or refinancing of the unit prior to the end of the retention period, the household repays the Bank an amount equal to a pro rata share of the AHP subsidy that financed the purchase, construction, or rehabilitation of the unit, reduced for every year the household owned the unit, from any net gain realized upon the sale or refinancing, unless either the unit is purchased by a very low-, or low- or moderate-income household or, following a refinancing, the unit remains subject to a retention agreement or other appropriate mechanism as described in the regulation.
Proposed rule.
The proposed rule would have eliminated the retention agreement requirement for all owner-occupied units, regardless of how the subsidy was used by the household. The NPRM did not specifically address or request comment on whether the elimination of owner-occupied retention agreements should apply only where the AHP subsidy is used for rehabilitation without an accompanying purchase of the unit.
FHFA noted in the NPRM that the purpose of retention agreements is to deter flipping of homes, and also discussed the moral hazard risk that may be associated with the use of subsidy intended to provide housing to low- or moderate-income households to flip properties. However, as also noted in the NPRM, homes purchased by AHP-assisted households are not typically located in neighborhoods with rapidly appreciating house prices that would encourage flipping, and most AHP-assisted households do not sell their homes during the five-year retention period. Moreover, the NPRM indicated that the underlying policy of the AHP is to enable low- and moderate-income households to receive the benefits of homeownership, including appreciation in the value of their homes, which would weigh in favor of a reduction in the amount of subsidy repaid by the household when selling or refinancing the unit.
Comments.
The NPRM specifically requested comments on the advantages and disadvantages of the AHP owner-occupied retention agreement, whether eliminating it would impact FHFA's ability to ensure that AHP funds are being used for the statutorily intended purposes, whether there are ways to deter flipping other than a retention agreement, and whether the proposed increase in the maximum permissible grant to households from $15,000 to $22,000 under the Homeownership Set-Aside Program should impact the decision on whether to eliminate retention agreements.
The majority of commenters who addressed the proposal to eliminate the requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements generally opposed it. A number of nonprofit advocacy organizations asserted that elimination of owner-occupied retention agreements would, by increasing homeowner equity, expose subsidy recipients to greater risks of fraud and abuse by predatory lenders and unscrupulous investors. These commenters also stated that the use of owner-occupied retention agreements has played an important role in preventing waste and abuse of AHP subsidies for homeownership.
Several nonprofit organizations asserted that retention agreements play an important role in deterring property flipping. These commenters noted that organizations that provide access for homeownership opportunities to lower-income families frequently employ retention agreements, often in the form of subordinate liens. They stated that this strategy has proven extremely effective in protecting homeowners from predatory lenders and preventing the loss of homeowner equity and subsidies through flipping. They suggested that FHFA provide the Banks with discretion on whether to use retention agreements as the Banks deem appropriate, to ensure protection of homeowner equity and AHP subsidies. A state housing
agency emphasized the benefits of having owner-occupied retention agreements when recipients receive substantial amounts of grant funds. Although one of the Banks discounted property flipping as a substantial risk, the Bank stated that predatory lending does pose risks for AHP-assisted households.
A nonprofit organization commented that while flipping in the AHP may be rare, it is rare precisely because of the retention agreement and not because homes purchased by AHP-assisted households are not typically located in neighborhoods with rapidly appreciating housing prices, as FHFA indicated in the NPRM. The commenter stated that it has seen evidence of flipping and other forms of fraud (specifically, the use of “straw buyers”), and that these material risks are largely unrecognized because of the effectiveness of retention agreements like those in the AHP.
Several commenters, including all of the Banks and a number of nonprofit organizations, recommended that FHFA authorize the Banks to use retention agreements in their discretion, based on criteria determined by each Bank, which would enable the Banks to address the different housing markets both across and within their districts, differences in eligible uses of AHP grants (
e.g.,
down payment, closing costs, rehabilitation), and grant amounts among the Banks' General Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. The Banks stated that their Bank Advisory Councils and boards of directors have the necessary experience, knowledge, and familiarity with local real estate markets to determine whether the need for retention agreements exists in each market. Several of the Banks indicated that, if given the discretion, they would choose not to use retention agreements.
One Bank and a commercial lender specifically opposed requiring retention agreements where AHP subsidies are used for rehabilitation of units for elderly households and special needs households, such as persons with disabilities. The Bank noted that changes in circumstances related to households' ages or health could affect their need to sell their homes, and retention agreements requiring repayment of AHP subsidy upon sale would unduly burden these households.
Decision in the final rule.
In a significant change from the proposed rule, the final rule retains the current requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements where a household uses the AHP subsidy for purchase, or for purchase in conjunction with rehabilitation, of a unit, but eliminates the requirement for an owner-occupied retention agreement where a household uses the AHP subsidy for rehabilitation without an accompanying purchase.
Many of the commenters tied their strong support for owner-occupied retention agreements to their view that the agreements help deter flipping or other types of fraud, although neither supporting data nor studies were provided to support those views. Due to the volume of comments FHFA received, particularly from organizations with extensive experience with the AHP and similar programs that offer comparable homeownership assistance, FHFA is persuaded that retention agreements may play a relevant role in deterring abuse and flipping, as well as protecting homeowners from predatory schemes. The use of retention agreements in connection with AHP subsidies provided for home purchase, and rehabilitation with an accompanying purchase, aligns with approaches of other down payment assistance providers that require retention agreements for purchase of homes, including the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development's (HUD) HOME Investment Partnerships Program (HOME), certain private lenders, and state and local agencies. However, as further discussed below under § 1291.15(a)(7) in Section IV., the final rule adopts several requirements for owner-occupied retention agreements that are intended to ease the operational burdens on the Banks and members, and reduce the financial burden on AHP-assisted households, by minimizing the frequency and amount of AHP subsidy repayments by such households.
In contrast, where the AHP subsidy is used solely for rehabilitation of homes, with no accompanying purchase, flipping of the homes is unlikely. Many of the recipients of AHP subsidy for rehabilitation are long-term homeowners, typically elderly households or persons with disabilities. These homeowners often need AHP funds for rehabilitation of their homes, such as installing a wheelchair ramp or repairing a leaky roof, to enable them to remain in their homes and, therefore, are less likely to move from their homes within a five-year period. In addition, the requirement to repay AHP subsidy may impose a financial burden on such households in the event that they are required to sell their homes to pay expenses associated with a change in life circumstances, such as the need to move to an assisted living facility or nursing home.
E. Clarification of the “Cure-First” Requirement for Project Noncompliance
Final rule.
The final rule adopts the sequence of remedial steps in the event of project noncompliance set forth in the proposed rule, with clarification of the “cure-first” step to indicate that a project sponsor or owner must make a reasonable effort to cure the noncompliance, and if the noncompliance cannot be cured within a reasonable period of time, the Bank must proceed to the next step of evaluating the project for a modification.
Current regulation.
The current regulation specifies three types of remedial actions to address AHP project noncompliance resulting from the actions or omissions of a project sponsor or project owner, but does not specify the order in which a Bank must pursue these remedies. The remedial actions are: (1) Cure by the project sponsor or owner of the noncompliance within a reasonable period of time; (2) modification of the terms of the approved AHP application; or (3) recovery of the AHP subsidy or settlement for less than the full amount of subsidy due. FHFA may require the Bank to reimburse its AHP Fund in the amount of the shortfall, unless: (1) The Bank has sufficient documentation showing that the sum agreed to be repaid under the settlement is reasonably justified, based on the facts and circumstances of the noncompliance; or (2) the Bank obtains a determination from FHFA that the sum agreed to be repaid under the settlement is reasonably justified, based on the facts and circumstances of the noncompliance.
Proposed rule.
The proposed rule would require the following sequence of remedial steps in the event of project noncompliance: (1) The project sponsor or owner must cure the noncompliance within a reasonable period of time; (2) if the project sponsor or owner cannot cure the noncompliance within a reasonable period of time, the Bank must determine whether the circumstances of the noncompliance can be eliminated through a modification of the terms of the approved application under proposed § 1291.27; and (3) if the circumstances of the noncompliance cannot be eliminated through a cure or modification, the Bank (or member if so delegated) shall make a demand on the project sponsor or owner for repayment of the full amount of the AHP not used in compliance with the AHP application commitments, and if that demand is unsuccessful, the member, in
consultation with the Bank, shall make reasonable efforts to collect the AHP subsidy from the project sponsor or owner, which may include settlement for less than the full amount due. The NPRM emphasized the importance of first requiring the project sponsor or owner to cure project noncompliance within a reasonable timeframe, stating that the objective of the AHP is to provide affordable housing for eligible households for the duration of the AHP retention period, so recovery of AHP subsidy should be the last resort. Cure of noncompliance is preferable to modification of the commitments in the AHP application or recovery of AHP subsidy as it holds the project sponsor to its AHP application commitments, which result in greater benefits to eligible households than if the commitments are reduced through modification or eliminated by recovery of the subsidy.
The proposed rule also would have added a new section addressing remedial actions that FHFA could take if a Bank failed to comply with the proposed outcome requirements and FHFA determined that compliance was feasible. The proposed remedial authority would have included: Requiring the Bank to develop and implement a housing plan approved by FHFA; describing the specific actions the Bank will take to comply with the outcome requirements for the next calendar year; or requiring the Bank to reimburse its AHP Fund for the difference in the amount of AHP funds required to meet the outcome requirements and the amount the Bank actually awarded.
Comments.
The Agency received numerous comments expressing concern about the proposed “cure-first” requirement for addressing project noncompliance. Commenters asserted that the Banks can address compliance issues more effectively and efficiently through modification of the project's application commitments. The Banks and a nonprofit homeless services agency stated that the “cure-first” requirement might increase costs and delay disbursement of funds, and the nonprofit organization indicated that it could result in termination of a project in a tight housing market like Boston. Other commenters expressed concern that a “cure-first” requirement would force developers to make “feigned attempts” to cure unresolvable issues. A nonprofit developer asserted that the proposal for subsidy repayment would not take into account the cause of the failure of a project, including fires or earthquakes. The Bank Advisory Councils commented that some projects naturally meet the “good cause” requirement for modification because the project sponsors, owners, or members have no control over the noncompliance.
A trade association stated that a “cure-first” requirement could cause problems for members that provide equity for projects or that have committed construction or permanent financing. A nonprofit organization commented that focusing on curing noncompliance first might result in displacement of residents from the project.
Decision in the final rule.
Modification of a project's AHP application commitments should not be the first option for a Bank to address project noncompliance. Inherent in a competitive application program is an award recipient's responsibility to fulfill the commitments in its application. A Bank should expect and require project sponsors or owners to make a reasonable effort to comply with their AHP application commitments before agreeing to modify a project. It is also preferable that recovery of AHP subsidy be the last option for curing noncompliance because the objective of the AHP is to provide affordable housing for eligible households for the duration of the AHP retention period. If subsidy is repaid for noncompliant units for the remainder of the AHP retention period, those units would no longer be subject to AHP income targeting and rent restrictions.
Commenters described, and FHFA acknowledges, that there are cases where sound reasons exist for why a project sponsor or owner may be unable to meet its AHP application commitments. Further, there may be cases where project sponsors or owners cannot cure noncompliance because it is beyond their control to cure. However, commenters appeared to misread the language of the proposed “cure-first” provision to require project sponsors or owners to cure noncompliance regardless of the causes of the noncompliance, including noncompliance beyond their control to cure, thereby preventing the Banks from moving to modifications as a remedy for the noncompliance. This was not the intent of the proposed “cure-first” provision, as indicated by the language in the following paragraph of the proposed rule stating that “[i]f the project sponsor or project owner cannot cure the noncompliance within a reasonable period of time, the Bank shall determine whether the circumstances of the noncompliance can be eliminated through a modification . . . .” If cure of the noncompliance is beyond the control of the project sponsor or owner, they may be unable to cure the noncompliance within a reasonable period of time. The project sponsor or owner does not have to try to cure noncompliance that is incurable; it would simply provide a reasonable written justification to the Bank indicating why it could not cure the noncompliance. If the justification is reasonable, the Bank would then evaluate whether it could approve a modification under the rule's modification requirements.
In view of the apparent misunderstanding of the “cure-first” provision, FHFA has clarified the language in §§ 1291.29(a)(1) and 1291.60(b)(1) of the final rule by adding that project sponsors or owners must “make a reasonable effort” to cure the noncompliance, and adding a statement immediately following that one that if the noncompliance cannot be cured within a reasonable period of time, the requirements for a modification in the next paragraph shall apply.
Because the final rule does not adopt the proposed outcome-based scoring framework, the proposed remedial actions for failure to meet the outcome requirements are moot and, thus, not adopted in the final rule. Other remedies provisions related to AHP noncompliance are discussed below under §§ 1291.60 through 1291.65 in Section IV.
F. Responsibility of Full Board of Directors for Strategic AHP Decisions
Final rule.
In a change from the proposed rule, the final rule retains the current authority for a Bank's board of directors to delegate to a board committee the responsibility to meet quarterly with the Bank Advisory Council, and to approve or disapprove applications for AHP subsidies and alternates. Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule adopts the proposed prohibition on a Bank's board delegating to a board committee the responsibility to approve General Fund, Targeted Fund, and Homeownership Set-Aside Program policies, the AHP Implementation Plan, and the TCLP.
Current regulation.
The current regulation provides that a Bank's Advisory Council shall meet with representatives of the Bank's board of directors at least quarterly to provide advice on ways in which the Bank can better carry out its housing finance and community lending mission, and permits that responsibility to be delegated to a committee of the board but not to Bank officers or other Bank employees. The requirement for board representatives to meet quarterly with
the Bank Advisory Council is a Bank Act requirement.
9
The current regulation also permits the board to delegate to a committee of the board, but not to Bank officers or other Bank employees, the responsibility to appoint the Bank Advisory Council members. In addition, the current regulation permits the board to delegate the responsibility for approving or disapproving AHP applications and alternates, and for adopting its AHP Implementation Plan, Homeownership Set-Aside Program, and conflict of interest policies, to a committee of the board, but not to Bank officers or other Bank employees.
9
See
12 U.S.C. 1430(j)(11).
Proposed rule.
The proposed rule would have extended the existing prohibition on the board delegating certain AHP responsibilities to Bank officers and other Bank employees to include a prohibition on delegating such responsibilities to board committees. Specifically, the full board, instead of a board committee, would have been required to meet quarterly with the Bank Advisory Council, to approve General Fund, Targeted Fund, and Homeownership Set-Aside Program policies, to approve and amend the AHP Implementation Plan and the TCLP, and to approve or disapprove applications for AHP subsidies and alternates. As stated in the NPRM, the goal of the proposed non-delegation provisions was to engage the full board in developing and adopting strategic decisions for the AHP, as part of the overall strategic planning of the Bank. FHFA noted that while it anticipated that the AHP responsibilities currently assigned to the board committees would remain largely unchanged in response to the proposal, the full board would have more engagement with board committee recommendations and decisions.
Comments.
A number of commenters disagreed with the Agency's rationale for encouraging full board engagement in AHP strategic responsibilities. They stated that involving more board members in the intricacies of AHP organizational planning and reporting would dilute the influence and housing expertise of the board committees tasked with AHP responsibilities. They stated that the proposal would create inefficiencies and could result in less integration of the board committees' contributions into the board's decisions on Bank housing activities than the existing practices employed by the Banks. One Bank stated that a board's ability to use board committees effectively, including the ability to delegate AHP responsibilities to a board committee, is a fundamental component of board governance best practices, and the proposal would be an unnecessary encroachment on the boards' ability to oversee Bank operations.
Several Banks and their Bank Advisory Councils described the Banks' board committee structures and corporate governance principles to demonstrate that their full boards are fully engaged and aware of all AHP responsibilities and initiatives. A number of commenters stated that the Banks' AHP governance structures and processes work effectively, with the board housing committees providing reports to the full board. A Bank cited FHFA's regulation at 12 CFR 1239.3, which authorizes the Banks to model their corporate governance and indemnification practices on the Revised Model Business Corporation Act (RMBCA), as support for maintaining the existing AHP regulatory requirements concerning board delegations. The Bank also referred to FHFA's regulation at 12 CFR 1239.5, which permits the boards to appoint board committees to carry out much of the board's responsibilities. The Bank stated that under the RMBCA, the full board must consider only those activities that “so substantially affect the rights of the shareholders or are so fundamental to the governance of the corporation.” The Bank further stated that delegation is a fundamental concept of efficient and competent corporate governance.
Numerous commenters opposed requiring a Bank's full board, rather than a committee of the board, to meet with the Bank's Advisory Council each quarter. The Banks focused on the challenges and inconveniences of requiring quarterly meetings of the full boards and Bank Advisory Councils. Some commenters stated that quarterly meetings with the full boards would be inefficient and unnecessarily costly, requiring Bank Advisory Council members to spend additional time away from their primary jobs in affordable housing and economic development.
Commenters also expressed concern that the proposal would reduce the influence and expertise of the Bank Advisory Councils. They pointed out that the board members who are not on the board housing committees possess different areas of expertise and, as a result, may not have the backgrounds necessary to engage fully in housing policy discussions with the Bank Advisory Councils. Commenters noted that some Banks hold annual meetings of the full board and Bank Advisory Council members, and their board housing committees meet quarterly with the Bank Advisory Councils and provide reports on the meetings to the full board. Commenters also stated that the proposed approach would be more restrictive than the governing statutory provision, which requires each Bank's Advisory Council to meet quarterly with “representatives of” the board of directors.
Decisions in the final rule.
After considering the comments, FHFA has decided to retain in the final rule the current authority for the Bank's board to delegate to a board committee the responsibility to meet quarterly with the Bank's Advisory Council. FHFA is persuaded by the comments about the costs, inconveniences, and inefficiencies of holding the quarterly meetings with the full board, the value of quarterly off-site meetings with board committees, and the language in the statute referencing “representatives of” the board. The final rule also retains the authority for the Bank's board to delegate to a board committee the responsibility to approve or disapprove applications for AHP subsidies and alternates. Approval or disapproval of AHP applications is based on scoring rankings under the Bank's scoring system and not on strategic policy decisions.
However, the Banks' full boards should be responsible for approving all strategic AHP policy decisions. Consistent with 12 CFR 1239.5, the board may rely on reports from board committees, but under the final rule, the authority to approve strategic policy decisions resides with the full board. As noted by commenters, the board committees, whose members have special housing expertise, perform an important role in the AHP strategic policymaking process by evaluating and developing policy recommendations, and FHFA expects their involvement in this process to continue. However, instead of the board committees approving strategic policy decisions on behalf of the full board, the board committees will need to report their policy recommendations to the full board for its approval or disapproval. The specific AHP strategic policy decisions that will need to be approved by the full board are approval of General Fund, Targeted Fund and Homeownership Set-Aside Program policies, and approval and amendment of the AHP Implementation Plan and the TCLP.
IV. Section-by-Section Analysis
Community Support Requirements Regulation
This section discusses the final rule's changes to the current Community Support Requirements regulation.
§ 1290.6 Bank Community Support Programs
Final rule.
The final rule requires the Banks to identify in their TCLPs the housing needs the Banks plan to address in their AHPs, including the particular housing needs they plan to address through any Targeted Funds. The Banks must publish their TCLPs at least 90 days before the initial date for submission of applications for the application funding round for the specific Targeted Fund. Targeted Funds addressing federal- or state-declared disasters are exempt from the 90-day requirement.
Current regulation.
FHFA's current Community Support Requirements regulation requires the Banks to adopt annual TCLPs in conjunction with their responsibility to establish and maintain community support programs.
10
The Banks' TCLPs must describe how each Bank plans to address identified credit needs and market opportunities in its district. The Banks are required to consult with their Bank Advisory Councils, members, housing associates, and public and private economic development organizations when developing and implementing their TCLPs. Although the Banks are required to provide an annual notice to their members about their community support programs, they are not required to make their TCLPs available to their members or to the public.
10
12 CFR 1290.6(b).
Proposed rule.
The proposed rule would amend § 1290.6(a)(5) to enhance the function and usefulness of the TCLPs, as well as improve the TCLPs' connection to the Banks' strategies for implementing their AHPs. The proposal would require the Banks to identify and assess in their TCLPs the significant affordable housing needs in their districts, reflecting market research and supported by empirical data, and would have required the Banks to specify, from among those housing needs, the specific housing needs the Banks would address through their funding allocations and scoring criteria under their General Funds and any Targeted Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs, as set forth in their AHP Implementation Plans. The Banks would continue to be required to develop their TCLPs in conjunction with the stakeholders referenced above. The Banks would also be required to publish their TCLPs on their public websites within 30 days of approval by the Bank's board of directors, and at least six months before the beginning of the Plan year. Proposed § 1291.20(b)(1) would have prohibited a Bank from establishing or administering a Targeted Fund unless at least 12 months had passed since publication of its TCLP. The purpose of the 12-month notice requirement was to provide potential project sponsor applicants with ample notice of the Banks' plans to target AHP awards to a narrower pool of potential applicants so that the project sponsors could prepare applications for submission to the Targeted Fund, with the goal being to generate sufficient numbers of applications for the Bank to be able to conduct a robust competitive scoring process for the Targeted Fund. The proposed rule would also prohibit a Bank's board of directors from delegating the responsibility for adopting or amending the TCLP to a committee of the board.
Comments.
FHFA specifically requested comments on the benefits of the proposed expansion of the contents of the TCLPs and their linkage to the AHP Implementation Plans. FHFA also requested comments on whether the proposed expansion would impede the Banks' ability to respond to disasters through the AHP. The commenters who responded to the proposal generally opposed it, stating that the proposed requirements would be overly prescriptive and burdensome. The Banks, a state government entity, and a nonprofit developer particularly criticized the seeming disconnect between the timing requirements for the TCLP and those of other sources of funding, such as housing finance agencies. Several commenters advised that the proposed 12-month and 6-month notice periods would conflict with the Banks' need for flexibility in responding to disasters. One Bank calculated that it would take approximately one to two years of advance work to meet the required lead time in the proposed rule when factoring in time for conducting research, obtaining the necessary internal Bank approvals, and publishing the TCLP.
The Banks commented that FHFA's proposed outcomes requirements for project selection would effectively establish each Bank's housing needs priorities, obviating any need to conduct market research, obtain empirical data, and expand the content of the TCLPs. Several Banks and a Bank Advisory Council expressed concern that the proposal could diminish the role of the Bank Advisory Councils, but indicated that it may add value to the process if FHFA abandoned the proposed outcomes requirements for project selection. The Banks and the Bank Advisory Councils also expressed concerns about the proposed requirement to obtain empirical data about the housing needs in the districts, which they viewed as diminishing the Bank Advisory Councils role in advising the Banks' boards of directors. Two Banks opposed the proposed notification requirement to obtain empirical data because gathering and assessing the data would prevent the Bank from responding quickly to use the AHP for disaster relief. A nonprofit affordable housing intermediary opposed the proposed requirement to obtain empirical data on the grounds that the requirement would add a burden to the Banks and would not prove useful in making decisions about how to direct AHP funding because of the extent of housing needs throughout districts. A national affordable housing policy and advocacy organization recommended that the Banks be required to consult with state housing finance agencies in developing their TCLPs.
Decisions in the final rule.
FHFA has considered the comments and remains of the opinion that the Banks's TCLPs should identify and assess the significant affordable housing needs in their districts. The changes to the current requirements for developing the TCLPs will help to ensure that the Banks identify such housing needs and guide the Banks in deciding how to design their AHPs.
The final rule requires the Banks to identify, from among the affordable housing needs addressed in their TCLPs, the housing needs they plan to address through the Banks' AHP, and including the specific needs to be addressed by any Targeted Funds. This differs from the proposed rule, which would have required each Bank to identify in its TCLP the specific housing needs it planned to address through the Bank's funding allocations and scoring criteria under its General Fund and any Targeted Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs in its AHP Implementation Plan. FHFA had proposed that the Banks expand the scope and specificity of their TCLPs in conjunction with the outcome-based approach for project selection. Because the final rule does not adopt the outcome-based approach, there is no longer a need to require the Banks to include detailed information about their General Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs in their TCLPs.
In addition, the final rule removes the proposed requirement that the Banks support the identification and assessment of significant affordable housing needs with empirical data, in response to commenters' concerns that this would be burdensome for Banks to implement. Many of the Banks were concerned that the word “empirical” implied that the Banks would be required to commission third-party studies to determine district affordable housing needs. However, the final rule continues to require that the Banks assess market research they conduct or obtain in order to identify significant affordable housing needs in their districts. Banks can also obtain information from their Advisory Councils to support their market research.
The final rule continues to require the Banks to consult with their Bank Advisory Councils, members, housing associates, and public and private economic development organizations in developing their TCLPs, which should ensure a robust process for obtaining input on the TCLPs. In response to the comment that the Banks should also consult with state housing finance agencies in developing their TCLPs, those entities likely are housing associates, as defined under FHFA's General Definitions regulation,
11
so the final rule makes no change to this language in the Community Support Requirements regulation. A Bank may also choose to consult with other parties not referenced in the regulation as appropriate.
11
12 CFR part 1201.
However, FHFA agrees with commenters' concerns about the proposed six-month requirement for publishing the TCLPs. The commenters stated that the proposed six-month requirement would inhibit the Banks' abilities to respond to district affordable housing needs, including disasters, in a timely manner. The six-month requirement was proposed in conjunction with the Agency's proposal for an outcome-based framework for project selection. Under the proposed outcome-based approach, a Bank would have been required to identify in its TCLP the specific housing needs the Bank intended to address through its funding allocations and scoring criteria under its General Fund and any Targeted Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs, as set forth in its AHP Implementation Plan. FHFA presumed that the Banks and other stakeholders would need additional time between the publication of the TCLPs and the beginning of the AHP application funding round to develop or revise AHP policies and procedures for inclusion in their AHP Implementation Plans, and conduct outreach to educate members, potential project sponsor applicants, and other AHP stakeholders about the Bank's revised scoring system. However, as discussed under Section III.A. above, the final rule does not adopt the proposed outcome-based approach. Therefore, there is no need to require the Banks to publish their TCLPs 12 months before the beginning of the TCLP year. Instead, the final rule requires the Banks to publish their TCLPs no later than the publication date of their AHP Implementation Plans. This should provide the Banks sufficient time to develop and publish their TCLPs, while underscoring the linkage between the TCLPs and the AHP Implementation Plans.
As noted above, the proposed rule would have required a Bank planning to establish a Targeted Fund to publish its TCLP at least 12 months before establishing and administering the Targeted Fund. FHFA finds commenters' concerns persuasive that this proposed timeframe would impede the Banks' ability to address pressing affordable housing needs, including natural disasters. Accordingly, the final rule sets the time period for publishing a TCLP that addresses the use of Targeted Funds as 90 days before the opening of the AHP application funding round, with an exemption for Targeted Funds addressing federal- or state-declared disasters, as they require expedited assistance. Because most Banks' TCLP years typically begin on January 1, the final rule does not tie the 90-day timeframe to January 1, which would result in the Banks having to publish their TCLPs by September 30 each year. Instead, the final rule ties the 90-day timeframe to the first day AHP applications can be submitted for the funding rounds for the Targeted Funds, which may be different dates throughout the year and be open for different lengths of time. This will provide the Banks more flexibility in administering their Targeted Funds. While significantly shorter than 12 months, the 90-day timeframe should still provide potential applicants with sufficient notice of the Banks' plans for their Targeted Funds so that applicants can prepare applications for submission to the Targeted Funds, with the goal being to produce sufficient numbers of applications for the Banks to be able to conduct robust competitive scoring processes for their Targeted Funds.
As discussed under Section III.F. above, the final rule adopts the proposal prohibiting a Bank's board of directors from delegating the responsibility for adopting or amending the TCLP to a committee of the board.
§ 1290.8 Compliance Dates
The dates by which the Banks must comply with these revised provisions are discussed above in Section I.
Affordable Housing Program Regulation
Reorganization of the Current AHP Regulation
The final rule adopts the proposed reorganization of the current AHP regulation, with some modifications to take into account certain changes from provisions in the proposed rule. The reorganization is intended to provide greater clarity for users of the AHP regulation. Current and new regulatory sections are grouped under new Subpart headings according to similar subject matter, resulting in renumbering of most sections of the current regulation. The numbering of the sections is not consecutive from Subpart to Subpart in order to reserve room within Subparts for the addition of new sections in the future, as necessary. FHFA received no comments on the proposed reorganization of the regulation.
The following discusses each section of the final rule amending the current AHP regulation in the order the sections appear in the final rule.
Subpart A—General
§ 1291.1 Definitions
As proposed, the final rule retains most of the definitions currently in § 1291.1. The final rule revises some of the current definitions and adds definitions, which are discussed below in the context of the related regulatory amendments.
In addition, as proposed, the final rule makes the following technical changes to certain definitions, which did not receive any comments:
• A definition of “AHP” is added, which means the Affordable Housing Program required to be established by the Banks pursuant to 12 U.S.C. 1430(j) and this part 1291.
• The definition of “Homeownership Set-Aside Program” indicates that establishment of such a program is in the Bank's discretion and is a noncompetitive program.
• The definition of “net earnings of a Bank” is revised by removing the requirement to deduct the Bank's annual contribution to the Resolution Funding Corporation, as the Banks are no longer required to make annual contributions to the Resolution Funding Corporation.
• In the definition of “rental project,” the term “manufactured housing” is
changed to “manufactured housing communities,” which more accurately describes this type of housing in the context of rental projects.
• References to the “competitive application program” are changed to the General Fund and any Targeted Funds. References to “homeownership set-aside programs” are capitalized.
The final rule also makes the following technical revisions and an addition to the definitions for greater clarity, which were not included in the proposed rule:
• Changes “funding period” to “funding round” to reflect the terminology commonly used by the Banks and AHP stakeholders. Adds a definition of “LIHTC” to mean Low-Income Housing Tax Credits under section 42 of the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. 42).
• In the definition of “visitable,” the reference to “2 feet, 10 inches” is changed to the equivalent “34 inches,” consistent with the use of “inches” later in the definition.
§ 1291.2 Compliance Dates
The dates by which the Banks must comply with the revised AHP regulatory provisions are discussed above in Section I.
Subpart B—Program Administration and Governance
§ 1291.10 Required Annual AHP Contribution
Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule relocates current § 1291.2(a) to § 1291.10. Section 1291.10 contains the Bank Act requirement stating that each Bank shall contribute annually to its AHP 10 percent of its net income for the preceding year, subject to a minimum annual combined contribution by all of the Banks of $100 million.
12
12
See
12 U.S.C. 1430(j)(5)(C).
§ 1291.11 Temporary Suspension of AHP Contributions
Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule retains current § 1291.11 on the temporary suspension of AHP contributions without change. FHFA did not receive any comments on this provision.
§ 1291.12 Allocation of Required Annual AHP Contribution
Allocation of AHP funds.
Consistent with the proposed rule, § 1291.12(a) of the final rule requires each Bank to allocate annually at least 50 percent of its required annual AHP contribution to its General Fund, and § 1291.12(c) permits each Bank to allocate up to 40 percent, in the aggregate, of its required annual AHP contribution to up to three Targeted Funds. The current regulation requires that at least 65 percent of each Bank's required annual AHP contribution be allocated to its Competitive Application Program. As noted in Section III.B. above, the current regulation does not authorize the establishment of Targeted Funds.
For the reasons identified above in Section III.C., § 1291.12(b) of the final rule retains the current limit that a Bank may allocate to its Homeownership Set-Aside Programs up to the greater of $4.5 million or 35 percent of its annual required AHP contribution. The proposed rule would have increased the 35 percent limit to 40 percent.
As discussed in the NPRM, the proposed rule would reduce the current annual required allocation to a Bank's General Fund (
i.e.,
Competitive Application Program) from 65 percent to 50 percent, but noted that the 50 percent threshold would still ensure that the Banks make at least half of their AHP funds available to address a broad spectrum of affordable housing needs within their districts through their General Funds. FHFA also stated in the NPRM that it is extremely important that a substantial portion of AHP funds continue to assist in the development of rental housing for lower income households given the need for more affordable rental housing throughout the Nation. The vast majority of awards under the Competitive Application Program serve rental housing. In 2017, the Banks awarded 90 percent of competitive funds to rental housing. The proposal would enable the Banks to target simultaneously additional specific affordable housing needs in their districts through the allocation of the remaining total AHP funds to Targeted Funds, as well as the optional Homeownership Set-Aside Programs.
Two nonprofit organizations that advocate for the development of affordable multifamily housing opposed any reduction in the minimum funding allocation to the General Fund because it would result in less funding for affordable rental projects. One of those commenters supported this position by referencing the NPRM discussion about the Banks' requests for additional funding allocation authority for Homeownership Set-Aside Programs, which the Banks find easier to administer than the General Funds.
After considering the comments, FHFA has decided to adopt the proposed minimum 50 percent funding allocation requirement for the General Fund in the final rule. FHFA's decision not to increase the maximum percentage allocation for the optional Homeownership Set-Aside Programs from 35 to 40 percent will continue to ensure that each Bank generally allocates a minimum of 65 percent of its total AHP funds to competitive application programs via the mandatory General Fund and any optional Targeted Funds.
13
Overall, FHFA intends the final rule to provide the Banks greater flexibility to allocate their total annual AHP funds to address the affordable rental and homeownership needs within their districts.
13
When a Bank allocates the alternate maximum amount of $4.5 million to its Homeownership Set-Aside Programs, the Bank may allocate, in the aggregate, less than 65 percent of its total AHP funds to its General Fund and any Targeted Funds.
Homeownership Set-Aside Programs
One-third funding allocation requirement for first-time homebuyers or owner-occupied rehabilitation, or a combination of both.
Consistent with the proposed rule, § 1291.12(b) of the final rule requires that at least one-third of a Bank's aggregate annual funding allocation to its Homeownership Set-Aside Programs be allocated to assist first-time homebuyers or households for owner-occupied rehabilitation, or a combination of both. The current regulation applies the one-third funding allocation requirement only to first-time homebuyers. In support of the proposal, FHFA noted in the NPRM that a substantial need for owner-occupied rehabilitation funds exists in many Bank districts, and the demand for such funds is likely to increase as the country's population ages.
14
FHFA reasoned that expanding the scope of the one-third funding allocation requirement to include owner-occupied rehabilitation could facilitate additional funding for home repairs and accessibility modifications for households including the elderly, persons with disabilities, and military veterans.
14
83 FR at 11348, citing Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies,
Housing America's Older Adults
(Sept. 2, 2014),
available at http://www.jchs.harvard.edu/sites/jchs.harvard.edu/files/jchs-housing_americas_older_adults_2014-ch4.pdf
(last accessed on 11/15/2018).
The Banks, Bank Advisory Councils, and an advocacy organization supported the proposal, stating that it would encourage the use of more Homeownership Set-Aside Program funds for owner-occupied rehabilitation at a time when the Banks have identified a substantial need for these funds.
Two nonprofit organizations opposed the proposal, emphasizing the scarcity of resources for low- and moderate-income first-time homebuyers and noting that alternatives to AHP funding
exist for rehabilitation. One of these commenters recommended that FHFA establish a separate funding allocation requirement for owner-occupied rehabilitation to ensure that a portion of Homeownership Set-Aside Program funds are provided for this purpose, while allowing the Banks to continue to fulfill the one-third allocation requirement by providing set-aside funds to first-time homebuyers.
Assisting first-time homebuyers is an important priority for the AHP, and the Banks' support for such homebuyers has greatly exceeded the required one-third funding allocation requirement. Since the inception of Homeownership Set-Aside Programs in 1995, over 80 percent of set-aside households have been first-time homebuyers. At the same time, a substantial need for owner-occupied rehabilitation funds exists in many Bank districts and the demand will likely increase over time. Expanding the scope of the one-third funding allocation requirement in the final rule to permit owner-occupied rehabilitation may help address this need by encouraging the Banks to increase their set-aside funding allocations for this purpose, while continuing to support the needs of first-time homebuyers. FHFA is not adopting the commenter's recommendation to establish a separate funding allocation requirement for owner-occupied rehabilitation, as this could limit the Banks' flexibility to determine how best to use their set-aside funds to meet the first-time homebuyer and owner-occupied rehabilitation needs within their districts.
The final rule also adopts a proposed technical revision to clarify that the one-third funding allocation requirement applies to the amount of set-aside funds “allocated” by the Bank to such households, not to the amount of set-aside funds actually used by them, because the Bank cannot control whether sufficient numbers of such households ultimately request set-aside funds in a given year. If an insufficient number of such households request set-aside subsidies, any unused funds would be provided to non-first-time homebuyers, and a Bank will not be considered in violation of the funding allocation requirement as long as it allocated the required amount. FHFA received no comments on this proposed technical change.
Phase-in funding allocation requirements for Targeted Funds.
As proposed, § 1291.12(c) of the final rule adopts a phase-in process for the allocation of funds to Targeted Funds in order to address the risks of Targeted Funds given their targeted nature. A Bank initially will be permitted to allocate up to 20 percent of its required annual AHP contribution to one Targeted Fund. This percentage limit increases to 30 and 40 percent in subsequent years, depending on the number of additional Targeted Funds established, up to a maximum of three Targeted Funds. The final rule makes a technical change to the references to the Targeted Funds being administered concurrently to refer to their administration in the same year instead. This change recognizes that the Banks may choose to administer their Targeted Funds at different times during the year. FHFA did not receive any comments on the proposed phase-in requirements for funding Targeted Funds. The phase-in requirements governing the number of Targeted Funds that a Bank may establish in any given year are discussed below under § 1291.20.
Transfer of uncommitted Targeted Funds amounts.
Proposed § 1291.12(c)(2) would have required a Bank to transfer any uncommitted Targeted Fund amounts to its General Fund for awards to alternates in the same calendar year. Section 1291.28(b) of the final rule makes approval of alternates under the General Fund and any Targeted Funds optional for a Bank pursuant to adoption of a Bank policy on approving alternates, and requires funding of the alternates if the Bank has such a policy and sufficient previously committed AHP subsidies become available within one year of application approval. Section 1291.70(b) of the final rule provides flexibility for the Banks to determine how to commit any uncommitted Targeted Fund amounts where the Bank does not have a policy to approve alternates under its General Fund or Targeted Funds.
Acceleration of funding.
Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule relocates current § 1291.2(b)(3), which contains the discretionary authority for a Bank to accelerate future required annual AHP contributions to its current year's Program, to § 1291.12(d), with certain clarifying technical edits. FHFA did not receive any comments on the technical revisions.
No delegation.
As discussed in Section III.F. above and consistent with the proposed rule, § 1291.12(e) of the final rule prohibits a Bank's board of directors from delegating to a committee of the board, Bank officers, or other Bank employees the responsibility for adopting the policies for its General Fund and any Targeted Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. The prohibition on delegating to a committee of the board is an expansion of the current prohibition on delegating to Bank officers or other Bank employees.
§ 1291.13 Targeted Community Lending Plan; AHP Implementation Plan
Targeted Community Lending Plan.
As discussed in § 1290.6 above and as proposed, the final rule amends § 1290.6(a)(5) of the current Community Support Requirements regulation to require each Bank to identify and assess in its annual TCLP the significant affordable housing needs in its district that it plans to address through its AHP, as well as any specific affordable housing needs it plans to address through any Targeted Funds. In a change from the proposed rule, §§ 1290.6(c) and 1291.13(a)(2) of the final rule require that if a Bank plans to establish a Targeted Fund, it must publish its TCLP at least 90 days prior to the opening of the application funding round for the Targeted Fund, unless the Targeted Fund addresses federal- or state-declared disasters. The final rule also provides that a Bank's TCLP must be published on or before the date of publication of its annual AHP Implementation Plan. A Bank is required to notify FHFA of any amendments to its TCLP within 30 days after their adoption by the Bank's board.
AHP Implementation Plan.
As proposed, the final rule relocates current § 1291.3, which contains the requirements for the Banks' AHP Implementation Plans, to § 1291.13(b), with changes to reflect the inclusion of new policies required under the final rule. The prohibition on delegating certain strategic responsibilities to a committee of the board is discussed below, as are certain requirements for the Plan meriting particular discussion.
No delegation.
As discussed in Section III.F. above and consistent with the proposed rule, § 1291.13(b) of the final rule prohibits a Bank's board of directors from delegating to a committee of the board, Bank officers, or other Bank employees, the responsibility to adopt, and make any amendments to, its AHP Implementation Plan. This is an expansion of the current prohibition on delegating such strategic responsibilities to Bank officers or other Bank employees.
Requirements for each Fund (§ 1291.13(b)(2), (b)(3), (b)(5)).
In the current regulation, each Bank must include in its AHP Implementation Plan its requirements for its Competitive Application Program, including its scoring guidelines, and any Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule requires a Bank to include
those requirements in its AHP Implementation Plan for its General Fund and any Targeted Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. The final rule also requires a Bank to include in its AHP Implementation Plan, the Bank's application scoring tie-breaker policy, and any policies adopted by the Bank, in its discretion, for approving AHP application alternates for funding under its General Fund and any Targeted Funds.
For any Targeted Funds, a Bank is required to include specific parameters that ensure that the Targeted Fund is designed to receive sufficient numbers of applicants for the amount of AHP funds allocated to the Fund to facilitate a robust competitive scoring process, as required in § 1291.20(b)(2)(i). In a change from the proposed rule, the final rule does not require a Bank to include in its AHP Implementation Plan the specific funding allocation amounts for its General Fund and any Targeted Funds and Homeownership Set-Aside Programs, including how the Bank will apportion the one-third funding allocation under its Homeownership Set-Aside Programs. This will accommodate any potential timing issues a Bank may encounter that could delay its ability to identify the specific amounts of its funding allocations.
Applications to multiple Funds (§ 1291.13(b)(4)).
Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule requires a Bank to include in its AHP Implementation Plan the Bank's policy on how it will determine under which Fund to approve a project that applies to more than one Fund and scores high enough to be approved under each of the Funds.
Retention agreements (§ 1291.13(b)(6)).
The final rule retains the current requirement that a Bank include its rental retention agreement requirements in its AHP Implementation Plan, and requires inclusion of the Bank's owner-occupied retention agreement requirements for households who use the AHP subsidy for purchase, or for purchase in conjunction with rehabilitation. Because the final rule eliminates the requirement for an owner-occupied retention agreement where the household uses the AHP subsidy solely for rehabilitation, nothing is required to be included in the AHP Implementation Plan regarding such agreements. This is a change from the proposed rule, which would have eliminated all owner-occupied retention agreements and, therefore, the requirement to address the agreements in the AHP Implementation Plan.
Relocation plans for current occupants of rental projects (§ 1291.13(b)(7)).
The final rule includes a requirement that a Bank include in its AHP Implementation Plan the Bank's standards for approving a relocation plan for current occupants of rental projects pursuant to § 1291.23(a)(2)(ii)(B).
Optional Bank district eligibility requirements (§ 1291.13(b)(8)).
Consistent with the current requirement in § 1291.5(c)(15) and the proposed rule, the final rule requires a Bank to include in its AHP Implementation Plan any optional Bank district eligibility requirements adopted by the Bank pursuant to § 1291.24(c).
Re-use of repaid AHP direct subsidy in same project (§ 1291.13(b)(12)).
In a change from the proposed rule, the final rule retains current § 1291.3(a)(7), which requires a Bank to include its requirements for re-use of repaid AHP direct subsidy in its AHP Implementation Plan, if the requirements are adopted by the Bank pursuant to current § 1291.8(f)(2), which is now § 1291.64(b). The proposed rule would have deleted § 1291.3(a)(7) because the requirements for owner-occupied retention agreements would have been eliminated in all cases, meaning there would be no repayments of AHP subsidy by households that could then be re-used under § 1291.8(f)(2). The final rule retains the current requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements where the household uses the AHP subsidy for purchase, or purchase in conjunction with rehabilitation, but not where the household uses the subsidy solely for rehabilitation. A household that uses the subsidy for purchase, or purchase in conjunction with rehabilitation, may be required to repay subsidy if the household sells or refinances the home within the AHP five-year retention period and none of the regulatory exceptions to subsidy repayment applies. Since the possibility of such subsidy repayments remains under the final rule, a Bank could adopt a subsidy re-use program under § 1291.64(b). Accordingly, the Bank's requirements for re-use of repaid AHP subsidy under any Bank subsidy re-use program adopted pursuant to § 1291.64(b) must be included in its AHP Implementation Plan.
§ 1291.14 Advisory Councils
Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule relocates current § 1291.4, which addresses the membership requirements and duties of the Banks' Advisory Councils, to § 1291.14, with the clarifications and change discussed below.
Representatives of for-profit organizations.
The Bank Act requires that each Bank appoint a Bank Advisory Council of persons drawn from “community and not-for-profit organizations” actively involved in providing or promoting low- and moderate-income housing in its district.
15
As proposed, § 1291.14(a)(1) of the final rule clarifies that “community organizations” include for-profit organizations, which is consistent with existing Agency guidance.
15
See
12 U.S.C. 1430(j)(11).
An organization that advocates on behalf of multifamily housing providers strongly endorsed including representatives of for-profit organizations on the Bank Advisory Councils, noting that such representation adds the voices of developers and owners with experience in affordable multifamily housing and increases the pool of applicants for the AHP.
In contrast, several nonprofit organizations expressed concern that for-profit organization representation on the Bank Advisory Councils could dilute the representation and importance of nonprofit or mission-driven organizations on the Bank Advisory Councils. The commenters urged FHFA to ensure that the Bank Advisory Councils are populated predominantly by nonprofit and public sector representatives, who have mission-driven commitments to serving the community.
FHFA acknowledges the important role that nonprofit organizations play in addressing the housing needs of low- and moderate-income households throughout the country. Nonprofit, as well as for-profit and public sector, organizations all bring important affordable housing perspectives to the Bank Advisory Councils. In 2018, 56 percent of the total membership of all eleven Bank Advisory Councils represented nonprofit organizations, and 15 percent represented for-profit organizations. The rest of the membership represented consulting firms and government entities. For-profit organization representation is consistent with § 1291.14(a)(3) of the final rule, which retains the current requirement in § 1291.4(a)(3) for a diverse range of membership on the Bank Advisory Council such that representatives of no one group constitute an undue proportion of the membership, giving consideration to the size of the Bank's district and the diversity of low- and moderate-income housing and community lending needs and activities within the district.
Recommendations on Bank Targeted Community Lending Plans.
FHFA's Community Support Requirements regulation
16
requires the Banks to consult with their Bank Advisory Councils and other groups in developing and implementing their TCLPs. As proposed, § 1291.14(d)(1)(ii)(A) of the final rule includes the parallel requirement for the Bank Advisory Councils to provide recommendations to the Banks on their TCLPs, and any amendments thereto.
16
12 CFR 1290.6(a)(5)(iii).
No delegation.
For the reasons discussed in Section III.F. above, the final rule does not adopt the proposed amendment requiring a Bank's full board of directors to meet quarterly with its Bank Advisory Council.
§ 1291.15 Agreements
As proposed, the final rule relocates current § 1291.9, which governs the AHP contractual agreements that must be in place between the Banks and members, and between the members and project sponsors or owners, to § 1291.15. The final rule makes a number of changes and clarifications to the provisions in this section from those in the proposed rule, as discussed below.
Notice to Bank of LIHTC project noncompliance (§ 1291.15(a)(5)(ii)).
Consistent with the proposed rule, § 1291.15(a)(5)(ii) of the final rule adds a monitoring agreement requirement for notices of LIHTC project noncompliance that is not contained in the current regulation. The Banks' AHP agreements with their members must require the members' monitoring agreements with project owners to include a provision requiring the latter to agree to provide prompt written notice to the Bank if an LIHTC project is in noncompliance with the LIHTC income targeting or rent requirements during the AHP 15-year retention period. However, in a change from the proposed rule, the final rule only requires that such notice be provided where the LIHTC noncompliance is material and unresolved, which may trigger a tax benefit recapture event and repayment of some of the AHP subsidy. If tax benefits are recaptured from a project, it may impact the project's financial viability. A corresponding monitoring requirement that the Banks review the LIHTC noncompliance notices received from project owners during the AHP retention period is included in § 1291.50(c)(1)(ii) of the final rule, as proposed.
Consistent with the current regulation and proposed rule, the final rule does not require the Banks to conduct long-term monitoring of AHP projects that received LIHTCs during the AHP 15-year retention period. Noncompliance with LIHTC income-targeting and rent requirements has been the same as or substantially equivalent to noncompliance with AHP income-targeting and rent requirements. Although LIHTC project noncompliance is rare, instances of noncompliance with LIHTC income targeting or rent requirements can occur during the AHP retention period, which would mean that the projects' incomes or rents likely are also in noncompliance with similar AHP requirements. However, the noncompliance generally would not come to the attention of a Bank during the AHP retention period because the Banks do not monitor LIHTC projects.
FHFA specifically requested comments on the practicality of the proposed notice requirement, and whether it should also be required in the event of noncompliance by projects with the income-targeting or rent requirements of the government housing programs discussed under § 1291.50(c)(1)(ii) below.
Several nonprofit intermediaries and an advocacy organization supported the proposed notice requirement as reasonable. A number of other commenters, including developers, a nonprofit affordable rental housing trade association, and an affordable housing developer, recommended that notice to the Banks only be required where the noncompliance is “unresolved.” The commenters noted that the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) requirements for notification of noncompliance result in the issuance of many notices for small, easily resolved operating issues, and only a small fraction of those notices remain unresolved for a substantial period of time. The notices that remain unresolved may involve projects with material noncompliance issues that could have an impact on the projects' financial viability. Commenters stated that the Banks should only be made aware of such material and unresolved problems.
In contrast, the Banks opposed the proposal. One Bank stated that implementation of the proposal would be impracticable because the Banks must defer to the state housing finance agency or the IRS in cases of noncompliance. A trade association and a developer of housing with supportive services suggested that the proposal would have limited effect because LIHTC projects rarely become noncompliant due to the nature of the private equity investments. Another Bank and a nonprofit developer stated that project owners may not remember their obligation to report LIHTC noncompliance to the Bank under their AHP monitoring agreements. Finally, several commenters stated that the proposal would place an additional 15-year regulatory burden to monitor the projects on members and the original project sponsors even if they had transferred ownership of the project after project development.
FHFA finds the comments about the infrequent instances of LIHTC project noncompliance and the minor nature of some of the noncompliance persuasive. The Banks do not need to receive notices of LIHTC noncompliance that will be easily resolved because these types of noncompliance will be cured within a reasonable period of time and do not jeopardize the long-term financial viability of the project. However, the Banks should be notified in the event of any material and unresolved noncompliance during the AHP 15-year retention period, which may trigger a tax benefit recapture event, so that the Bank can monitor the project's status and take remedial action as required by the AHP regulation. As noted above, the Banks likely would not become aware of material and unresolved noncompliance without notification because they do not monitor LIHTC projects during the retention period.
Concerning the comments asserting that the proposal would impose an additional 15-year regulatory monitoring burden on members, FHFA notes that only project owners would be required to report noncompliance to the Bank.
The final rule does not include a requirement that project sponsors or owners send notices to the Banks of noncompliance by projects with the requirements of the other specified government housing programs because a separate monitoring provision in the final rule addresses such noncompliance. Specifically, § 1291.50(c)(1)(i) and (ii) requires the Banks to obtain information annually from project sponsors or owners on their projects' compliance with other government funding sources, as well as the projects' on-going financial viability, as part of “enhanced certifications” to the Banks.
Owner-occupied retention agreements for purchase, or for purchase in conjunction with rehabilitation (§ 1291.15(a)(7)).
For the reasons discussed in Section III.D. above, § 1291.15(a)(7) of the final rule retains the current requirement for an owner-occupied retention agreement where the
household uses the AHP subsidy for purchase of a home, or for purchase of a home in conjunction with its rehabilitation, but eliminates the current requirement for an owner-occupied retention agreement where the household uses the AHP subsidy solely for rehabilitation of a home. The final rule makes accompanying conforming changes to various references to owner-occupied retention agreements throughout the final rule.
Notice to Bank or Bank designee.
Section 1291.15(a)(7)(i) of the final rule provides that the Bank, and in its discretion any designee of the Bank, shall be given notice of any sale, transfer, assignment of title or deed, or refinancing of an AHP-assisted unit during the AHP five-year retention period. This is a change from the current regulation, which requires notice to the Bank or its designee.
FHFA requested comments in the proposed rule on whether owner-occupied retention agreements, if retained in the final rule, should require that such notice be provided to both the Bank and its designee (typically the member), rather than to one or the other. FHFA indicated that such a requirement would facilitate Program operations by giving the Bank simultaneous notice with the Bank's designee (if the Bank has one), and could facilitate repayment of AHP subsidy to the Bank in cases where a member subsequently fails and is subject to receivership actions by other federal agencies.
One Bank favored requiring notice to both parties, noting that it includes this requirement in its standard retention agreements as it is beneficial to the Bank to know that a sale or refinancing of the property has occurred. A nonprofit organization also favored requiring notice to both parties, stating that the minimal cost of the extra notice is worth the additional layer of oversight. Another Bank indicated that it includes a requirement for notice to the Bank in its retention agreements, but opposed requiring notice to a Bank designee, stating that this requirement might cause confusion as to who is responsible for calculating and providing a payoff in the event of a sale of the property.
As the comments indicate, requiring notice to the Bank is sound practice to ensure that the Bank is aware of events that might trigger an obligation to recover AHP subsidy. Therefore, the final rule requires that the Banks receive such notice. However, FHFA is persuaded by the comments that requiring notice to both the Bank and a Bank designee could be disruptive to the Bank's established processes. Each Bank should have the discretion to determine whether to require notice to a designee as may be appropriate for that Bank's operations. Accordingly, the final rule allows a Bank to determine, in its discretion, whether to require notice to a designee of the Bank.
Sale, transfer, or assignment.
The final rule provides that the retention agreement applies not only to a sale of an owner-occupied unit, but also to a transfer or assignment of title or deed, during the retention period, as these forms of conveyance are the functional equivalent of sales.
Calculation of AHP subsidy repayment based on net proceeds and household's investment.
Consistent with § 1291.9(a)(7) of the current regulation, § 1291.15(a)(7) of the final rule requires an AHP-assisted household to repay a pro rata portion of the AHP subsidy if the unit is sold or refinanced during the five-year retention period, subject to certain exceptions. However, the final rule prescribes a “net proceeds” calculation for determining the amount of subsidy subject to recovery. This is a change from the current regulation, which requires repayment of a portion of AHP subsidy from any
net gain
realized upon sale or refinancing. The subsidy repayment calculation in the final rule also prioritizes return of the AHP-assisted household's investment in the home to the household. The pro rata subsidy amount subject to repayment cannot exceed what is available from the net proceeds of the sale or refinancing.
Although the current regulation does not define “net gain,” as FHFA noted in the proposed rule, a majority of the Banks calculate the net gain as the sales price minus the original purchase price, purchaser and seller paid closing costs, and capital improvement costs, and then apply the pro rata repayment requirement. Some of these Banks have also deducted the AHP subsidy amount from the original purchase price. Other Banks have calculated the subsidy repayment amount using net proceeds identified on the Closing Disclosure, by deducting the senior mortgage debt from the sales price and, depending on the Bank, crediting or not crediting the household with its investments in the home. Some of these Banks have also added the AHP subsidy amount to the total proceeds.
Because the proposed rule would have eliminated the requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements in all cases, it did not propose a specific method in the rule text for calculating the repayment of AHP subsidy. However, the NPRM noted that FHFA reviewed the subsidy repayment requirements of other government housing programs, and in particular, HUD's HOME Program. The NPRM discussed the Owner Investment Returned First approach under the HOME Program which, if applicable to the AHP, would calculate net proceeds available for recapture as the sales price minus outstanding superior debt and seller paid costs, with the seller recovering its entire investment first from the net proceeds, the Bank then recovering the AHP subsidy on a pro rata basis, and any remaining net proceeds returned to the seller. FHFA requested comments on the merits and disadvantages of this approach and the net gain approach from the standpoint of the AHP-assisted households and the Banks, and whether there are other subsidy repayment approaches FHFA should consider if a retention agreement requirement were retained in the final rule.
FHFA received a number of comments on whether it should require a net gain or net proceeds calculation for determining the AHP subsidy repayment amount. One Bank supported the use of the net gain calculation discussed in the NPRM as the appropriate basis for calculating a pro rata repayment. In support of this recommendation, however, the Bank cited the benefits of coordinating the AHP calculation methodology with those in other government programs, such as those used by HUD, without specifying these HUD programs. Because the NPRM specifically described only one HUD program—the HOME Program—in the context of the owner-occupied retention agreement repayment calculation, and the version of the HOME Program calculation described in the NPRM is more similar to the net proceeds approach than the net gain approach, this commenter appears to have mistaken the net proceeds and net gain calculations. Another Bank stated that the net gain calculation has been effective for AHP-assisted home sales, but noted that the calculation does not work effectively for AHP rehabilitation grants because the AHP-assisted homeowners are frequently elderly or disabled, have lived in their houses for decades, and generally are unable to recall or do not have documentation of the original purchase price of their homes, a necessary component of the net gain calculation. Several Banks indicated support for an approach that would minimize the need to obtain information from the AHP-assisted households or third parties, noting that they have experienced frequent difficulty
obtaining original purchase prices of the homes.
A nonprofit organization expressed support for using the net proceeds recapture approaches as prescribed under the HOME Program. The commenter characterized the HOME Program approach as fair, and emphasized the value of promoting alignment between multiple government subsidy sources often used together in projects. A nonprofit economic research organization supported using a net proceeds approach, with AHP-assisted households able to recover their capital improvement costs, noting that this could help incentivize such households to maintain their properties. A Bank similarly commented that a repayment calculation that allows for recovery by households of their capital improvement costs would incentivize households in distressed areas to invest in such improvements.
The final rule eliminates the requirement for retention agreements for AHP subsidies used solely for rehabilitation. This change will eliminate the administrative burden on Banks and members of attempting to obtain subsidy repayments from households and also relieve a financial burden on those households. For owner-occupied retention agreements where the household used the AHP subsidy for purchase, or for purchase in conjunction with rehabilitation, the final rule establishes a net proceeds calculation that addresses the above-described concerns with the net gain approach.
The subsidy repayment calculation in the final rule also prioritizes return of the AHP-assisted household's investment in the home to the household. Specifically, § 1291.15(a)(7)(v) provides that the household shall repay the Bank the lesser of: (i) The AHP subsidy, reduced on a pro rata basis per month until the unit is sold, transferred, or its title or deed transferred, or is refinanced, during the AHP five-year retention period; or (ii) any net proceeds from the sale, transfer, or assignment of title or deed of the unit, or the refinancing, as applicable, minus the AHP-assisted household's investment. Section 1291.1 of the final rule defines “net proceeds” as the sales price minus reasonable and customary costs paid by the household and outstanding superior debt, or, in the case of a refinancing, the principal amount of the new mortgage minus reasonable and customary costs paid by the household and the principal amount of the refinanced mortgage. This calculation uses only information that is available from the settlement documents. The calculation also does not incorporate the subsidy originally provided to the AHP-assisted household,
i.e.,
the subsidy is not added to the net proceeds or subtracted from any of the components of the net proceeds calculation. No AHP subsidy may be recovered by the Bank unless the net proceeds exceed the AHP-assisted household's investment.
FHFA is persuaded by the commenters that the subsidy recovery calculation should account for the AHP-assisted household's investment in the home. Households invest resources in their homes in the form of down payments, transaction costs (such as broker's commission and title search fees), capital improvement costs, and repayment of senior mortgage principal. The household's investment should be retained and prioritized in light of the purpose of AHP subsidies to provide households with the benefits of homeownership. The “household's investment” is defined in § 1291.1 to mean reasonable and customary transaction costs paid in connection with the purchase of the unit, down payment, cost of capital improvements made, and any mortgage principal repaid since the purchase of the unit until the time of sale or refinancing during the AHP five-year retention period where the household documents these costs to the Bank or its designee. For example, a household could produce documentation of its expenditures associated with the installation of a new roof.
Consistent with § 1291.9(a)(7)(ii) of the current regulation, the final rule requires that the AHP subsidy be reduced on a pro rata basis for the time that the household owned the unit until its sale or refinancing. However, whereas the current regulation provides generally for this reduction each year, the final rule requires a reduction each month, consistent with current Bank practice, as provided below:
ER28NO18.000
The final rule provides that the Bank shall recover the lesser of: (i) The pro rata subsidy amount; or (ii) the net proceeds minus the household's investment.
Exception where the subsequent purchaser is low- or moderate-income.
Consistent with § 1291.9(a)(7)(ii) of the current regulation, § 1291.15(a)(7)(ii)(B) of the final rule provides an exception to the AHP subsidy repayment requirement if the AHP-assisted unit is sold to a low- or moderate-income household. However, in contrast to the current regulation, the final rule provides methods of evaluating the subsequent purchaser's income in the absence of actual documentation. In such cases, the Bank or its designee shall determine the subsequent purchaser's income using one or more proxies that are reliable indicators of the subsequent purchaser's income, which may be selected by the Bank pursuant to guidance that FHFA will issue on proxies and which must be included in the Bank's AHP Implementation Plan. The requirement will become effective upon issuance of the guidance.
Neither the Bank nor its designee is required to request or obtain the subsequent purchaser's income, but must evaluate any income documentation if made available. As noted in the proposed rule, the subsequent purchaser of an AHP-assisted unit is under no obligation to provide income documentation to the Bank or member. This has made it difficult for the Banks and their members to determine subsequent purchasers' incomes in order to determine whether the subsidy repayment exception applies. The current regulation is silent on the use of proxies in evaluating a subsequent purchaser's income. At least one Bank, however, has applied a proxy, under limited circumstances, to evaluate subsequent purchasers' incomes, in light of these operational constraints.
FHFA requested comments on what approaches should be specified in the retention agreement, if retained in the final rule, that would provide a reasonable basis to assume that the subsequent purchaser of an AHP-assisted unit is likely to be low- or moderate-income, including proxies that could serve this purpose such as
the following: Certification from the subsequent purchaser or a third party that the subsequent purchaser's income is at or below the low- or moderate-income limit; evidence that the subsequent purchaser is receiving direct homebuyer assistance from another government program with household income targeting requirements substantially equivalent to those of the AHP; purchase price of the AHP-assisted unit is less than the median home price in the area; the AHP-assisted unit is located in a census tract or block group where at least 51 percent of the households are low- or moderate-income; or Federal Housing Administration (FHA) or other underwriting standards indicate that the income required to purchase the AHP-assisted unit at the purchase price is low- or moderate-income.
Commenters generally offered mixed opinions on the use of proxies, providing a variety of responses addressing which proxies would serve as acceptable methods for likely determining the income of the subsequent purchaser. A Bank supported the use of two proxies: Third-party certifications; and evidence that the subsequent purchaser was receiving direct homebuyer assistance from another government program. The Bank noted that using median home price and census tract income data may not be reasonable approaches as these data points would not adequately recognize or track areas affected by gentrification. The Bank asserted that gentrification occurs gradually and that median sales price and census tract data would not reflect investor purchases and sales to new or higher-income populations.
Another Bank supported the use of third-party certifications, evidence that the subsequent purchaser was receiving direct homebuyer assistance from another government program, and FHA or other underwriting standards. A nonprofit organization supported use of the latter two proxies.
The nonprofit organization objected to the use of geographically-based proxies, such as the purchase price of the AHP-assisted unit relative to area median home price, or location of the unit in a census tract or block group where at least 51 percent of the households are low- or moderate-income, because higher income homebuyers could purchase homes in low-income neighborhoods or census tracts. Another nonprofit organization stated that certain portions of distressed neighborhoods may be more upscale than nearby sections due to the presence of certain amenities, such as water features and golf courses. The commenter also opposed the use of third-party certifications, stating that it had witnessed significant unintended consequences of certification requirements in the context of FHA insurance and the foreclosure process.
A nonprofit organization encouraged the use of person-based proxies, such as evidence that the homebuyer received down payment assistance or participated in first-time homebuyer programs or family self-sufficiency programs, rather than geographically-based proxies, stating that geographically-based proxies fail to account for gentrification. The commenter stated, however, that self-certification or certain types of third-party certification (by the loan originator, for example) would be adequate.
One Bank expressed concern generally about the exception to the subsidy repayment requirement for sale to a low- or moderate-income purchaser, noting that the subsequent purchaser's income is not correlated to the AHP-assisted household's income. The Bank asserted that the subsidy repayment exception results in different treatment of similarly situated AHP-assisted households based on the subsequent purchaser's income. Another Bank objected to any requirement for a Bank or member to obtain sensitive income information from a subsequent purchaser with which neither institution has a contractual relationship.
FHFA has considered the comments regarding the use of proxies in the AHP and determined that the use of certain proxies will help ensure that Banks and members are not requiring repayment of subsidy by AHP-assisted households in cases where the subsequent purchaser is low- or moderate-income. Therefore, FHFA will require that Banks use one or more proxies that are reasonable indicators that the subsequent purchaser is likely a low- or moderate-income household, pursuant to Agency guidance. FHFA acknowledges commenters' discussions of the limitations of the proxies included in the NPRM. The Agency notes that as approximations, no proxy will be able to definitively determine the income of the subsequent purchaser.
AHP subsidy repayment exception for de minimis subsidy amount.
Section 1291.15(a)(7)(ii)(C) of the final rule provides for an exception to the AHP subsidy repayment requirement for AHP-assisted households where the amount of AHP subsidy subject to repayment pursuant to the calculation in § 1291.15(a)(7)(v) is $2,500 or less. Under that provision, if the pro rata subsidy amount is $2,500 or less, calculation of net proceeds is unnecessary. The current regulation does not provide for an exception to the AHP subsidy repayment requirement for “
de minimis
” amounts of AHP subsidy subject to repayment.
FHFA requested comments in the proposed rule on whether, if the owner-occupied retention agreement requirement were retained in the final rule, there should be an exception to AHP subsidy repayment where the amount of subsidy subject to repayment, after calculating the net proceeds or net gain, is $1,000 or less. A number of commenters specifically supported a $1,000
de minimis
threshold. For example, a state government housing authority, an individual commenter, and a Bank stated that at a net gain of $1,000, the administrative cost of ensuring repayment generally exceeds the value of any recaptured AHP subsidy. A national nonprofit intermediary recommended a
de minimis
threshold of greater than $2,000, stating that this amount constitutes a reasonable balance between the need for sound Program stewardship and asset building for low- or moderate-income families. An affordable housing policy organization and a national trade organization recommended a
de minimis
threshold of at least $5,000. A nonprofit consumer organization supported FHFA establishing the
de minimis
threshold amount for the Banks, and suggested that it be adjusted using an inflator based on the Agency's house price index so that it remains reasonable as home prices escalate.
The affordable housing policy organization stated that if the original AHP subsidy amount was $5,000 or less, there should be no subsidy repayment requirement, as such a small amount of subsidy would be unlikely to trigger flipping, and the transaction costs would nullify the value of the AHP subsidy. A community-based affordable housing financing organization and a community bank made a similar recommendation where the original AHP subsidy was $7,500 or less, or $10,000 or less, respectively, on the basis that the administrative expense was likely to exceed the value of the investment, and households should be entitled at a minimum to recover their required investment at the time of sale, net of AHP repayment so as not to impose financial injury.
The Banks supported a “
de minimis
” threshold exception to the AHP subsidy repayment requirement, but recommended that the amount of the threshold be determined by each Bank
based on the specific facts and circumstances of its district, rather than set by FHFA in the regulation. One Bank stated that the Banks should be authorized to adjust the
de minimis
threshold over time to account for housing market fluctuations and inflation. Another Bank suggested that the Banks be permitted to establish a
de minimis
amount based on a percentage of the original AHP subsidy amount, rather than a fixed dollar amount, because of the variations in the size of AHP subsidy amounts provided by the different Banks. A nonprofit organization recommended requiring each Bank to establish a
de minimis
threshold based on the Bank's and its members' actual administrative costs for assigning a lien on a property and calculating repayments of subsidy. The commenter stated that applying a
de minimis
threshold would avoid economic waste, but that support of a prescribed amount was impossible without further data.
FHFA has considered the comments and has decided to establish a
de minimis
threshold of $2,500 in the final rule. As discussed in the NPRM and underscored by the comments, establishing a
de minimis
threshold of $2,500 may deter flipping of AHP-assisted units, while at the same time minimize the financial burden on low- or moderate-income households of having to repay AHP subsidy if they sell their homes during the AHP retention period. The underlying policy of the AHP has always been that the purpose of the AHP subsidy is to enable low- or moderate-income households to receive the benefits of homeownership including appreciation in the value of their homes and, thus, to minimize any AHP subsidy repayments. A $2,500 threshold will also reduce the administrative obligations of the Banks and members associated with recovering AHP subsidies.
In response to the comments to adopt a
de minimis
threshold greater than $1,000, FHFA analyzed Bank data for set-aside grants awarded to households in 2012 and subsequently repaid during the five-year retention period ending in 2017. The data indicate that 1,080 grants of a total 10,203 set-aside grants awarded in 2012 were repaid during that time period. FHFA queried the data to determine how many of those grants would have been subject to
de minimis
thresholds of $2,000 or $2,500. The Agency's analysis revealed that at a $2,000
de minimis
threshold, 683 of the 1,080 repaid grants, which is approximately 2 out of every 3 repaid grants, or 65 percent, would have been exempted from repayment. At a $2,500
de minimis
threshold, 783 of the 1,080 repaid grants, which is approximately 3 out of every 4 repaid grants, or approximately 73 percent, would have been exempted from repayment.
Based on this data, FHFA has decided to set the
de minimis
threshold exception for AHP subsidy repayment at $2,500. This will result in fewer households subject to subsidy recapture, thereby enabling households to benefit more from appreciation in the value of their homes, and reduce the Banks' operational expenses associated with the subsidy repayment process. FHFA set the
de minimis
threshold at a fixed dollar amount, rather than a percentage that varies based upon the grant amount, for ease of implementation by the Banks, members, and households. FHFA considered requiring each Bank to establish a
de minimis
threshold based on the actual administrative costs incurred by the Bank and its members for assigning liens on properties and calculating subsidy repayments, but did not receive any comments or other information quantifying the actual administrative costs that FHFA could evaluate. FHFA also opted not to index the
de minimis
threshold to an inflator based upon the Agency's house price index, in order to provide a definitive
de minimis
threshold for AHP stakeholders. However, FHFA may consider adjusting the
de minimis
threshold in the future to account for house price fluctuations and Bank use of the new authority to establish higher set-aside grant amounts per household.
Other exceptions to subsidy repayment.
Consistent with § 1291.9(a)(7)(ii) of the current regulation, § 1291.9(a)(7)(ii) of the final rule provides that the obligation to repay a pro rata portion of the AHP subsidy amount upon sale or refinancing does not apply if the unit was assisted with a permanent mortgage loan funded by an AHP subsidized advance. Also consistent with the current regulation, the final rule provides an exception to repayment obligation if, following a refinancing, the unit continues to be subject to a deed restriction or other legally enforceable retention agreement or mechanism.
Termination of AHP subsidy repayment obligation.
Section 1291.15(a)(7)(iv) of the final rule clarifies that the obligation to repay AHP subsidy to a Bank terminates not only after any event of foreclosure, but also after transfer by deed in lieu of foreclosure, assignment of an FHA mortgage to HUD, or death of the owner(s) of the unit. This is consistent with guidance FHFA has provided to the Banks clarifying that transfer by deed in lieu of foreclosure is the functional equivalent of foreclosure, facilitating coordination of the AHP with FHA requirements, and clarifying that the heirs of the AHP-assisted homeowner are not subject to any AHP subsidy repayment obligation upon the death of such homeowner.
The proposed rule requested comments on whether this clarification should be made in the final rule if FHFA retained the current requirement for owner-occupied retention agreements in the final rule. The Banks and a trade organization favored including the clarifying language in the final rule. One Bank stated that the clarification would be useful for members and project sponsors using the AHP Bank in that it would help the Banks resolve ongoing issues with homebuyers using FHA loans as the underwriters flag the loans if this language is missing from the AHP retention agreements. The Bank also indicated that elderly owners are sometimes reluctant to sign the AHP retention agreement for fear that the potential AHP subsidy repayment obligation will fall on their beneficiaries upon their death(s).
Retention agreements for rental projects.
The final rule retains § 1291.9(a)(8) of the current regulation, which contains the requirement for AHP 15-year retention agreements for rental projects, with several changes that are discussed below. Current § 1291.9(a)(8) provides that if a rental project is sold or refinanced during the 15-year retention period, the full amount of the AHP subsidy must be repaid to the Bank, unless certain exceptions apply.
Notice to the Bank or Bank designee.
In a change from the current regulation and proposed rule, the final rule provides that the retention agreement for rental projects shall include a requirement that notice of a sale or refinancing of the rental project during the AHP 15-year retention period be provided to the Bank and, in its discretion, to a designee of the Bank. This is consistent with the change made for owner-occupied retention agreements discussed above. The current regulation requires that such notice be provided to the Bank or its designee. The proposed rule would have provided that the notice be provided to both the Bank and its designee. The NPRM stated that requiring notice to both the Bank and its designee (typically a member) would facilitate Program operations by giving the Bank simultaneous notice with the Bank's designee (if the Bank has one), and could facilitate repayment of AHP
subsidy to the Bank in cases where a member subsequently fails and is subject to receivership actions by other federal agencies.
A Bank and a nonprofit intermediary supported the proposal. The Bank stated that owners of multifamily properties often do not have other incentives to provide the Bank or its member with notice, and without notice to the Bank, the Bank might find it difficult to know the identity of the acquiring owner in the case of a sale, or whether the subsidy should remain with the property or the Bank should request repayment. A nonprofit lender recommended providing the Banks discretion regarding whether to require that project owners provide the notice to the Banks or designees. Two Banks opposed any change in the notice requirement because they address issues directly with the project sponsor. One Bank also stated that providing notice to the member may be viewed as imposing additional obligations on the member, which could discourage members' use of the AHP.
For the same reasons discussed above under the owner-occupied retention agreements, the final rule requires that notice be provided to the Bank and, in its discretion, to a designee of the Bank.
Sale, transfer, or assignment.
Consistent with proposed § 1291.15(a)(7), § 1291.15(a)(8) of the final rule clarifies that the retention agreement applies not only to a sale of the rental project, but also to a transfer or assignment of title or deed, during the AHP 15-year retention period, as these forms of conveyance are the functional equivalent of sales. FHFA received no comments on this provision.
Project sponsor qualifications.
The final rule relocates current § 1291.5(c)(10) on project sponsor qualifications to § 1291.15(b)(2), and makes a number of changes from the proposed rule. Specifically, the final rule requires the Banks to evaluate the qualifications of, and any covered misconduct by, the project sponsor at AHP application, and prior to each AHP subsidy disbursement. The Bank's AHP subsidy application form and AHP subsidy disbursement form (or other related documents) must include a requirement for the project sponsor to certify to this effect. The Banks will not be required to evaluate the qualifications and any misconduct of the project sponsor's affiliates and team members, including general contractors, as proposed. The final rule does not include the proposed rule's references to the project sponsor's affiliates and team members, including general contractors, in the sponsor qualifications and Agreements sections, as proposed, because the definition of “sponsor” is not being expanded to include such parties.
Section 1291.1 of the current regulation defines the “sponsor” of a project as a nonprofit, for-profit, or public entity meeting one of four specific criteria. Section 1291.5(c)(10) provides that for a project to be eligible to receive AHP subsidy, the project sponsor must be qualified and able to perform its responsibilities as committed to in its AHP application. Paragraphs (b)(4) and (g)(3) of § 1291.5 require a Bank to verify that the project meets its AHP application commitments at AHP application, and prior to each disbursement of AHP subsidy to the project, respectively.
The proposed rule would retain the definition of “sponsor” in current § 1291.1, but would have revised § 1291.5(c)(10) by extending the qualifications requirement to the project sponsor's affiliates and team members, including the general contractor. Thus, at AHP application, and prior to each AHP subsidy disbursement to a project, a Bank would have been required to determine whether the project sponsor, as well as all of its affiliates and team members, are qualified to perform the AHP project application commitments. The proposed rule would have added a requirement in the Agreements section of the regulation that, at AHP application, and prior to each disbursement of AHP subsidy to the project, the project sponsor must certify, or respond to specific questions about, whether it and its affiliates and team members have engaged in any misconduct as defined in FHFA's Suspended Counterparty Program regulation or by the Bank. The Bank's AHP subsidy application form and subsidy disbursement forms, or other related forms, would have been be required to include the qualifications criteria and certification or questions about any misconduct to be completed by the project sponsor.
Commenters who responded to this issue overwhelmingly opposed the proposal. A nonprofit intermediary commented that evaluating the qualifications of the general contractor and its team members at AHP application would be problematic because the project sponsor has yet to identify them at the AHP application stage. The nonprofit intermediary and a wide diversity of other commenters noted that project sponsors often select the general contractors after all funding sources are committed to the project and the project is ready to move forward to loan closings and construction. The nonprofit intermediary also stated that other financing sources frequently require that project sponsors conduct rigorous bidding processes in selecting general contractors, making a parallel evaluation by the Banks of the general contractors' qualifications unnecessary and overly burdensome.
The Bank Advisory Councils urged FHFA to maintain the current regulatory requirement for project sponsor qualifications and require that project sponsors certify compliance with the FHFA's Suspended Counterparty Program regulation only prior to AHP subsidy disbursement. The Bank Advisory Councils stated their preference for the Banks to be able to rely on the due diligence and capacity review by other funders of project sponsors and their affiliates and team members. The Bank Advisory Councils noted that the Banks currently have processes in place to monitor project progress and the project sponsor's performance.
The Banks asserted that requiring that the Banks' assessment of project sponsor capacity include compliance with FHFA's Suspended Counterparty Program regulation by all parties is unnecessary. They stated that the Banks lack privity of contract with general contractors and other parties and, therefore, cannot compel them to disclose such information. The Banks emphasized this point in particular with respect to owner-occupied rehabilitation grants that involve multiple contractors. They also commented that other funding sources perform due diligence reviews of the general contractor.
A Bank pointed out that while the term “sponsor” is defined in the current regulation and proposed rule as a nonprofit, for-profit, or public entity meeting one of four specified criteria, the proposal states in § 1291.15(b)(2) that “a project sponsor includes all affiliates and team members such as the general contractor.” The Bank stated that if the term “sponsor” is intended to include affiliates and team members, the Bank would need to consider whether its AHP subsidy collection efforts and settlements in the event of project noncompliance could extend beyond the assets of the project sponsor to include those of the project sponsor's affiliates and team members. A nonprofit intermediary noted that the proposed rule did not provide guidance on the definitions of “affiliate” and “team member.”
A nonprofit developer commented that the proposal would “cut out” team members that have yet to establish a track record in the industry from AHP
participation. Likewise, a housing authority stated that the proposal has the potential to unreasonably exclude, or discriminate against, AHP applicants with new or less tested team members, but who possess sufficient overall strength as a team to be successful.
FHFA's intent for the proposal was to ensure that, in addition to the project sponsor, the project sponsor's affiliates and team members have the necessary qualifications to perform the AHP application commitments. The proposal was also intended to enable a Bank to identify any misconduct by the project sponsor and any affiliates or team members so that the Bank could determine whether it should accept the project sponsor's AHP application or approve requests from the project sponsor for AHP subsidy disbursement. Banks would have the latitude to define “misconduct” to include types of misconduct beyond those specifically addressed by FHFA in the Suspended Counterparty Program regulation. Therefore, if a Bank subsequently determined that a project sponsor's certification was false and that the project sponsor or its affiliates and team members were not qualified to perform the AHP application commitments, the Bank would have a contractual basis to cancel the project sponsor's AHP application and deny its requests for disbursement of AHP subsidy. The Bank would also have a basis to reject future AHP applications from the project sponsor, or to reject AHP applications that include the project sponsor's affiliates or team members, on the basis that the project sponsor is not qualified to carry out its AHP responsibilities.
As noted by the commenters, however, project sponsors generally have not selected their general contractors at the time of AHP application. Thus, it would be impossible for project sponsors to evaluate and certify as to the qualifications and any misconduct of their general contractors and the general contractors' subcontractors at the time of AHP application. Concerning the comments on the Banks' lack of privity with the general contractors and that an evaluation by the Banks of the general contractors' qualifications parallel to that of other funders is unnecessary, FHFA notes that it did not propose that the Banks evaluate or underwrite directly the general contractors' qualifications, but rather that the Banks obtain certifications from the project sponsors on their general contractors' qualifications. The Agency's decision not to adopt the proposed requirement for evaluation of the general contractor's qualifications should alleviate commenters' concerns that projects with less experienced team members would be excluded where the project team as a whole possesses the capacity to successfully develop the project.
Accordingly, the final rule requires the Banks to obtain a certification from the project sponsor of only its own qualifications and lack of misconduct at the time of AHP application and at AHP subsidy disbursement.
The final rule makes two clarifications to the proposed rule language. First, it changes the reference to “misconduct” to “covered misconduct” to reflect the terminology in the Suspended Counterparty Program regulation. Second, it states that if a Bank adopts its own definition of “covered misconduct,” that definition must incorporate the definition of “covered misconduct” in the Suspended Counterparty Program regulation at a minimum.
Application to existing AHP agreements.
The final rule relocates § 1291.9(c) of the current regulation to § 1291.15(c), and revises the provision to make it applicable only to existing AHP agreements where the Bank is a party. The provisions of the AHP regulation, as amended from time to time, are deemed incorporated into all such agreements. This amendment recognizes that FHFA regulates the Banks and not third parties. FHFA will provide guidance, as necessary, for specific situations where a Bank is not a party to existing AHP agreements and questions arise as to applicability of AHP amendments to those agreements.
§ 1291.16 Conflicts of Interest
Consistent with the proposed rule, the final rule relocates current § 1291.10, which addresses conflicts of interest regarding financial interests of Bank directors, Bank employees, Bank Advisory Council members, and their family members, unchanged to § 1291.16. FHFA did not propose any changes to this section.
A Bank commented that the terms “financial interest” and “family member” were overly broad and should be defined in accordance with comparable terms in FHFA's regulation governing conflict of interest policies for Bank directors.
17
The Bank identified several ordinary course financial transactions that it said should not be considered “financial interests” for AHP conflict of interest purposes because they would not be expected to motivate Bank directors, Bank employees, or Bank Advisory Council members to influence decisions by the Bank regarding the evaluation, approval, funding, monitoring, or any remedial process for an AHP project. Examples cited included the purchase of an insurance product, an investment in a 401(k) account, and a retirement pension plan. FHFA notes that the scope of the AHP conflict of interest policy provision in § 1291.16 is limited to financial interests “in projects” that are the subject of a pending or approved AHP application and, thus, does not apply to the types of routine transactions cited by the Bank.
17
12 CFR 1261.11(f)(1), (2).
Subpart C—General Fund and Targeted Funds
§ 1291.20 Establishment of Programs
General Fund.
Consistent with the proposed rule, § 1291.20(a)(1) of the final rule replaces current § 1291.5(a) by requiring each Bank to establish a General Fund pursuant to the requirements of this part. “General Fund” is the new term for the current “Competitive Application Program.”
Eligibility requirements.
Consistent with the current regulation, § 1291.20(a)(2) of the final rule provides that a Bank may not adopt eligibility requirements for its General Fund except as specifically authorized in the regulation.
FHFA did not receive comments on these provisions.
Targeted Funds.
As proposed, § 1291.20(b)(1) of the final rule provides that a Bank may establish, in
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.