Federal Regulatory Reform: An Overview

Congressional research reportFeb 7, 2005

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Order Code RL32356

CRS Report for Congress

Received through the CRS Web

Federal Regulatory Reform: An Overview

Updated February 7, 2005

Curtis W. Copeland

Specialist in American National Government

Government and Finance Division

Congressional Research Service ˜ The Library of Congress

Federal Regulatory Reform: An Overview

Summary

Over the past several decades there have been numerous attempts in Congress

and elsewhere to modify the federal rulemaking process. Underlying many of these

“regulatory reform” efforts is a perceived need to reduce the burden associated with

regulatory compliance. Proponents of reform contend that federal regulations are

too costly, time consuming, complex, and intrusive for businesses and other regulated

parties, and that better crafted rules can be developed through, among other things,

the use of sophisticated analytical tools and greater oversight by the President and

Congress. On the other hand, some contend that these reform efforts focus too much

on the costs of regulations and do not adequately recognize the benefits that the rules

provide. They also argue that additional requirements will have the effect of eroding

existing regulatory protections or lengthening an already lengthy rulemaking process,

thereby depriving the public of needed health, safety, and environmental

improvements.

The purpose of this report is to provide Congress with a broad overview of

significant congressional and presidential regulatory reform efforts within the past

20 to 30 years. Those efforts have generally centered on one or more of the

following themes or categories: (1) requirements that agencies use various forms of

regulatory analysis (e.g., cost-benefit analysis, cost-effectiveness analysis, and risk

assessment) when developing regulations; (2) the development of presidential or

congressional offices or procedures for the external review of agencies’ rules; (3) the

development of regulatory accounting statements reflecting the costs and benefits of

all agencies’ rules, possibly leading to the development of a regulatory budget; (4)

efforts to encourage agencies to use alternatives to traditional “command and

control” regulations, such as market incentives and performance standards; (5) the

imposition of moratoriums on the development of new regulations, particularly at the

change of presidential administrations; (6) “look back” reviews of agencies’ existing

rules to determine whether they should be revised or eliminated; (7) reforms focusing

specifically on paperwork burden; (8) reforms focusing on small businesses and other

small entities; (9) efforts to improve the quality of information used in rulemaking

or disseminated to the public; (10) the use of information technology to improve

public participation in rulemaking and regulatory transparency; and (11) other

regulatory reform efforts (e.g., to ensure that agencies recognize the effects of their

rules on federalism and private property rights). Some of these initiatives have been

adopted, while others have not.

The report references numerous statutes and executive orders governing the

federal rulemaking process. For a report describing those statutes and executive

orders and the rulemaking process in general, see CRS Report RL32240, The Federal

Rulemaking Process: An Overview, by Curtis W. Copeland.

This report will be updated if significant changes to the federal regulatory

process are proposed.

Contents

Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1

Origins of Regulatory Reform . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1

Themes in Regulatory Reform . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

Regulatory Analysis Requirements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

Presidential Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

Congressional Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

Presidential and Congressional Review of Rules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

Presidential Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

Congressional Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15

Regulatory Accounting and Regulatory Budgets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17

Regulatory Budgets . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19

Alternatives to Traditional Regulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19

Emission Trading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20

Information Disclosure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20

Presidential Encouragements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

Moratoriums on New Regulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22

Reviews of Existing Regulations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24

Presidential Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24

Congressional Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25

Paperwork Reduction Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26

Paperwork Reduction Act . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26

Other Paperwork Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27

Initiatives Focusing on Small Entities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28

Compliance Guides and Other Guidance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29

Penalty Relief . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29

Ombudsman and Fairness Boards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30

Equal Access to Justice Act Amendments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30

Advocacy Review Panels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31

Information Quality and Peer Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31

Implementation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33

Judicial Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33

Peer Review . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34

Electronic Rulemaking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36

Presidential Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36

Congressional Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37

Other Regulatory Reform Initiatives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38

Federalism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38

Private Property Rights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39

Negotiated Rulemaking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40

Plain Language . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41

Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42

For Additional Reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44

CRS Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44

Other Readings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44

Selected Websites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45

Federal Regulatory Reform: An Overview

Introduction

Federal regulation can be defined broadly as requirements, directives, standards,

or procedures, backed by the use of penalties or other sanctions, intended specifically

to modify the behavior of state and local governments, private institutions,

businesses, and individuals. Regulations generally start with an act of Congress and

are the means by which statutes are implemented and specific requirements are

established. The terms “rule” or “regulation” are often used interchangeably in

discussions of the federal regulatory process. The Administrative Procedure Act

(APA) of 1946 defines a rule as “the whole or part of an agency statement of general

or particular applicability and future effect designed to implement, interpret, or

prescribe law or policy.”1 The procedures that federal agencies are required to follow

in writing regulations is called the rulemaking process. (For a description of the

federal rulemaking process and the statutes and executive orders that govern that

process, see CRS Report RL32240, The Federal Rulemaking Process: An Overview,

by Curtis W. Copeland.) Although the term “regulatory reform” can refer to efforts

to deregulate certain industries (e.g., airlines or telecommunications), in this report

the term refers to efforts to change the rulemaking process.

Origins of Regulatory Reform

The federal government has regulated economic activity since the nation was

formed. For example, in the late 1700’s, Congress gave the president the authority

to develop regulations that set duties on foreign goods and to determine who traded

with Indian tribes. Subsequently, economic regulation often occurred as a result of

historical events and was often implemented through independent regulatory agencies

established separate from executive departments and independent agencies.2 For

example, Congress created the Interstate Commerce Commission in 1887 in response

to public dissatisfaction with the railroad industry. The Securities and Exchange

Commission was created in 1934 to address fraud and corruption in the securities and

financial markets.

1

2

5 U.S.C. 551(1)(4).

As used in this report, the term “independent regulatory agencies” refers to the boards and

commissions identified as such in the Paperwork Reduction Act (44 U.S.C. 3502(5)),

including the Federal Communications Commission, the Federal Energy Regulatory

Commission, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission, and the Securities and Exchange

Commission. The term “independent agencies” refers to other agencies that answer directly

to the President, but are not part of Cabinet departments (e.g., the Environmental Protection

Agency).

CRS-2

In contrast, social regulation in such areas as environmental quality, workplace

safety, and consumer protection is a relatively recent phenomenon. Beginning in the

1960s, a number of new statutes were enacted in those areas, including the Clean Air

Act and the Clean Water Act, the Toxic Substances Control Act, the Resource

Conservation and Recovery Act, the Occupational Safety and Health Act, the Truth

in Lending Act, and the Consumer Product Safety Act. Those and other statutes,

reorganization plans, and executive orders created new regulatory agencies such as

the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Occupational Safety and Health

Administration (OSHA), the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

(NHTSA), and the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC).

By the late 1970’s, an array of federal economic and social regulations were in

place that affected many of the decisions made by American businesses. Strong

concerns then began to be raised about whether the benefits that these regulations and

regulatory agencies were attempting to achieve were worth the costs associated with

compliance. Concerns were also being raised about the cumulative effects of all

federal regulations on individual businesses. In 1980, President Reagan was elected

on a platform critical of government’s role in society in general and of federal

regulations in particular. During his administration, substantial changes were made

in how federal agencies develop and publish rules, and in the degree to which federal

regulations were overseen by the Executive Office of the President. Each subsequent

President has also made changes in the regulatory process a focus of activity within

his administration, imposing moratoriums on new rules, attempting to focus on

results, or trying to reduce regulatory burden or “red tape.” Congress has also made

several attempts to reform the rulemaking process, enacting such statutes as the

Paperwork Reduction Act of 1980, the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980, the

Unfunded Mandates Reform Act of 1995, and the Small Business Regulatory

Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996. (Each of these statutes is discussed later in this

report.) Additionally, Congress passed legislation deregulating specific sectors of the

economy (e.g., airlines, telecommunications). Other efforts in the mid-to-late 1990s

to enact more comprehensive regulatory reform bills were not successful.3

Proponents of regulatory reform contend that federal regulations are often too

costly, time consuming, and intrusive. They argue that the public and private

resources needed to address problems in health, safety, and environmental areas are

limited, and that these resources must be allocated more efficiently to address the

greatest needs of society in the most cost-effective manner, and that the costs of

regulations should not exceed the benefits. They also contend that the existing

regulatory system tends to be overly risk averse, and question a perceived lack of

stringent analytical guidelines in the methodology used to assess risk hazards as well

as costs and benefits when developing regulations. Reform proponents also contend

that the scientific and technical information underlying regulations is often of poor

quality. These perceived shortcomings, they argue, result in rules that are not well

designed and that impede economic growth and development.

3

See, for example, S. 343, the Comprehensive Regulatory Reform Act of 1995, in the 104th

Congress; S. 981, the Regulatory Improvement Act of 1997, in the 105th Congress; and S.

746, the Regulatory Improvement Act of 1999, in the 106th Congress.

CRS-3

Others, however, have expressed concerns regarding regulatory reform efforts,

and believe that at least some of the reforms focus too much on regulatory costs and

do not adequately recognize the benefits that federal regulations provide to the

public. They argue that the real motivation behind many of the reforms is a

relaxation or roll-back of regulatory requirements and a reduction in the costs

associated with regulatory compliance, not improvements in net benefits, cost

effectiveness, or information quality. They also maintain that the addition of new

analytical or procedural requirements to the rulemaking process would have the

intended or unintended effect of blocking new regulations and reducing the ability

of regulatory agencies to safeguard the public’s health and safety and to protect the

environment in a timely manner.

Several factors make it difficult to resolve these disputes regarding the need for

regulatory reform. First, the contending parties often represent vastly different

interests and constituencies, with business groups often advocating for reforms (in

the hope that regulations will be less burdensome) and environmental groups often

resistant to those efforts. Second, the empirical information needed to permit science

or economics to resolve those differences of opinion regarding the need for regulation

or the best way to regulate is rarely available, requiring decision makers to use

assumptions or judgement to make public policy determinations. Finally, resources

are rarely available for regulatory agencies to systematically examine the

implementation of their regulations and to determine whether they should be

continued without change, strengthened, altered to reduce compliance costs, or

eliminated entirely.

Themes in Regulatory Reform

This report provides a broad overview of significant congressional and

presidential regulatory reform efforts within recent decades. Those efforts

encompass a wide range of issues and constituencies, ranging from how agencies

design regulatory requirements to the review and possible elimination of those

requirements after they have been put in place. The report is not intended to be a

comprehensive summary of all regulatory reform initiatives, focusing instead on

general themes that seem to underlie many of them. In general, efforts to reform the

regulatory process seem to have focused on the following areas:

!

requirements that agencies use various forms of regulatory analysis

when developing regulations, including cost-benefit analysis, costeffectiveness analysis, and risk assessment;

!

the development of offices or procedures within the Executive

Office of the President and the Congress for the external review of

agencies’ rules;

!

the development of regulatory accounting statements reflecting the

total costs and benefits of agencies’ rules, and ultimately the

development of a regulatory budget;

CRS-4

!

efforts to encourage agencies to use alternatives to traditional

“command and control” regulations;

!

the imposition of moratoriums on the development of new

regulations, particularly at the change of presidential

administrations;

!

reviews of agencies’ existing rules to determine whether they should

be revised or eliminated;

!

reform efforts focusing specifically on paperwork burden;

!

reform efforts focusing specifically on small entities;

!

attempts to ensure the quality of the information used to develop

rules or otherwise disseminated to the public;

!

efforts to increase the use of information technology in rulemaking

to improve public participation and regulatory transparency; and

!

other reform initiatives (e.g., efforts to protect property rights and

the rights of state and local governments, and to encourage the use

of negotiated rulemaking and plain language).

Regulatory Analysis Requirements

A common (and some would say the primary) concern voiced by proponents of

regulatory reform in recent decades has been that the costs associated with

regulations often outweigh the benefits that those regulations are intended to provide.

Another, and somewhat related, view is that more intelligent regulatory policies

could achieve the same social goals (e.g., cleaner environment, safer workplaces) at

much less cost (or achieve more ambitious goals at the same cost).4 To improve the

quality and effectiveness of federal rules and minimize burden, regulatory reform

proponents have frequently advocated greater use of a range of analytic tools during

the rulemaking process, including cost-benefit analysis (sometimes referred to as

benefit-cost analysis), cost-effectiveness analysis, and risk assessment.

Cost-benefit analysis, in this context, involves the systematic identification of

all costs and benefits associated with a forthcoming regulation, including

nonquantitative and indirect costs and benefits, and how those costs and benefits are

distributed across different groups in society. A proposed regulatory requirement is

judged to pass the “cost-benefit test” if the sum of its anticipated benefits outweighs

the sum of its present and future costs in present value terms.

4

See, for example, Tammy O. Tengs and John D. Graham, “The Opportunity Costs of

Haphazard Social Investments in Life-Saving,” in Risks, Costs, and Lives Saved: Getting

Better Results from Regulation, Robert W. Hahn, ed. (New York: Oxford University Press,

1996). For a counter argument, see Richard W. Parker, “Grading the Government,” The

University of Chicago Law Review, vol. 70 (Fall 2003), pp. 1345-1486.

CRS-5

These prospective (also known as ex ante) estimates of benefits and costs that

are done before rules are issued are necessarily uncertain and heavily dependent on

numerous assumptions. Particularly difficult to quantify are long-term or uncertain

effects of rules where subtle interactions between various factors are often not well

understood or directly measurable. Cost-benefit analysis is particularly controversial

when it seeks to rationalize inherent value trade-offs and to place a value on benefits

not traded in the market (e.g., health or lives).5 Also, as the Supreme Court affirmed

in 2001, some statutes prohibit the consideration of costs when setting certain health

standards.6 These concerns notwithstanding, most economists believe that, when

used carefully and with adequate data, cost-benefit analysis can be an effective tool

in regulatory decisionmaking.7

Cost-effectiveness analysis seeks to determine how a given goal can be achieved

at the least cost. In contrast to cost-benefit analysis, the concern in cost-effectiveness

analysis is not with weighing the merits of the goal, but with identifying and

analyzing the costs of alternatives to reach that goal (e.g., dollars per life saved).

Cost-effectiveness analysis has been referred to as a “bang-for-the-buck” exercise in

which the payoff is measured in health units rather than dollars. It is commonly seen

as a better tool than cost-benefit analysis for uncovering cases in which large

incremental costs result in minor gains. A disadvantage of this type of analysis is that

misjudgments in determining the goal or the budget may go undetected.

Risk assessment, in this context, is the systematic evaluation of the probability

of certain hazards occurring and their adverse effects, and can serve as the starting

point for regulatory activity and for estimates of regulatory benefits. For example,

risk assessment is often used to estimate the expected rate of illness or death in a

population exposed to a hazardous chemical. The quality of the analysis depends on

the adequacy of the underlying data and the validity of the methods and assumptions

used. Advocates state that risk analysis may be used as an objective, scientific basis

for planning, identifying management strategies to promote risk reduction.

Conversely, critics argue that risk analysis is often not entirely objective, in part

because of inadequate data regarding the health and ecological effects of most

chemicals.8 Major concerns are that risk analysis may oversimplify problems, that

its conclusions can be easily manipulated, and that when used in cost-benefit analyses

it may undervalue benefits, especially when projected over time. Another concern

is that risk analyses often focus on relatively small risks to the population as a whole,

rather than larger risks to smaller groups. These concerns notwithstanding, many

5

See, for example, Lisa Heinzerling and Frank Ackerman, Pricing the Priceless: CostBenefit Analysis of Environmental Protection (Washington: Georgetown University, 2002).

6

Whitman v. American Trucking Associations, 531 U.S. 457 (2001).

7

See Kenneth J. Arrow, et al., Benefit-Cost Analysis in Environmental, Health, and Safety

Regulation: A Statement of Principles (Annapolis: The Annapolis Center, 1996).

8

For example, EPA concluded that the full set of basic toxicity data was available for only

about 7% of approximately 3,000 high-production-volume chemicals. See U.S.

Environmental Protection Agency, Chemical Hazard Data Availability Study: What Do We

Really Know About the Safety of High Production Volume Chemicals? (April 1998).

CRS-6

observers believe that risk analysis, carefully used and supported by adequate data,

can be a valuable management tool in developing and directing regulatory programs.9

Presidential Initiatives. Each President within the past 35 years has required

some form of regulatory analysis before rules are published in the Federal Register.

For example:

!

In 1971, President Nixon required agencies to develop a summary

of their proposals, a description of the alternatives that they

considered, and the costs of those alternatives.

!

In 1974, President Ford required agencies to develop an “inflation

impact statement” for each major proposed rule.

!

In 1978, President Carter required agencies to prepare a regulatory

analysis that examined the cost-effectiveness of the alternative

regulatory approaches for major rules.

Current cost-benefit analysis requirements in the rulemaking process are

primarily traceable to President Reagan’s Executive Order 12291, issued in February

1981.10 Under that executive order, covered agencies (those other than independent

regulatory agencies) were generally required to (1) refrain from taking regulatory

action “unless the potential benefits to society for the regulation outweigh the

potential costs to society,” (2) select regulatory objectives to maximize net benefits

to society, and (3) select the regulatory alternative that involved the least net cost to

society. The order also required covered agencies to prepare a “regulatory impact

analysis” for each “major” rule, which was defined as any regulation likely to result

in (among other things) an annual effect on the economy of $100 million. Those

analyses were required to contain a description of the potential benefits and costs of

the rule, a description of alternative approaches that could achieve the regulatory goal

at lower cost (and why they weren’t selected), and a determination of the net benefits

of the rule.

These analytical requirements remained in place until September 1993, when

President Clinton issued Executive Order 12866.11 The new executive order, which

is still in effect, revoked Executive Order 12291 but established analytical

requirements that are similar (although not identical) to those it replaced. For

example, regulatory principles under Executive Order 12866 include adoption of

regulations only upon a “reasoned determination that the benefits of the intended

9

For a more in-depth discussion, see CRS Issue Brief IB94036, The Role of Risk Analysis

and Risk Management in Environmental Protection, by Linda-Jo Schierow.

10

11

Executive Order 12291, “Federal Regulation,” 46 Federal Register 13193, Feb. 19, 1981.

Executive Order 12866, “Regulatory Planning and Review,” 58 Federal Register 51735,

Oct. 4, 1993. To view a copy of this order, see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/

omb/inforeg/eo12866.pdf].

CRS-7

regulation justify its costs”12 and tailoring regulations to impose the least burden on

society needed to achieve the regulatory objective. The order also requires a costbenefit analysis for all “economically significant” rules (essentially the same as

“major” rules under Executive Order 12291) containing an assessment of the

anticipated costs and benefits of the regulatory action and an assessment of the costs

and benefits of alternatives to the regulatory action (with an explanation of why the

planned action is preferable).

In January 1996, the Office of Management and Budget’s (OMB) Office of

Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA) published a document that described

“best practices” for preparing the economic analyses called for by the executive

order.13 In essence, the best practices document said that the analysis should (1)

clearly state the need for the proposed action (e.g., market failure) and make clear

why federal regulation (as opposed to other methods such as state regulation or

subsidies) is the appropriate solution, (2) clearly show that the agency considered the

most important alternative approaches (e.g., performance-oriented standards or

market incentives), and (3) assess the incremental costs and benefits of the proposed

action (taking into account such factors as the appropriate baseline and the use of

discount rates when benefits and costs occur at different times). The best-practices

document also stated that cost-effectiveness analysis should be used where possible

to evaluate alternatives, and says that estimating the benefits and costs of risk

reducing regulations requires a risk assessment that, in part, characterizes the

probabilities of occurrence of outcomes of interest.

The Government Accountability Office (GAO; formerly the General Accounting

Office) and others have examined agencies’ economic analyses of rules under the

executive order and the 1996 best practices guidance.14 Several of the studies

indicated that the agencies’ analyses are not always consistent with the requirements

in the order or the guidance. For example, in 1998 GAO reported that some of the

20 economic analyses that it examined did not discuss alternatives to the proposed

regulatory action and, in many cases, it was not clear why the agencies used certain

assumptions.15 Also, five of the analyses did not discuss uncertainty associated with

the agencies’ estimates of benefits or costs or document the agencies’ reasons for not

12

As previously mentioned, the standard in Executive Order 12291 was that regulatory

benefits “outweigh” costs, not just that there be a “reasoned determination” that they

“justify” those costs.

13

This “best practices” document was developed by an interagency group co-chaired by the

Administrator of OIRA and a member of the Council of Economic Advisors. The document

was revised and issued as guidance in 2000. To view a copy of the best practices document,

see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/riaguide.html]. As noted later in this report,

this document and the 2000 guidance was later replaced by OMB Circular A-4.

14

See, for example, Richard D. Morgenstern,ed., Economic Analyses at EPA: Assessing

Regulatory Impact (Washington: Resources for the Future, 1997); and Robert W. Hahn, ed.,

Risks, Costs, and Lives Saved: Getting Better Results from Regulation (Washington: AEI

Press, 1996).

15

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Reform: Agencies Could Improve Development,

Documentation, and Clarity of Regulatory Economic Analyses, GAO/RCED-98-142, May

26, 1998.

CRS-8

doing so. Other studies have criticized agencies for not providing quantitative

information on net benefits in their analyses.16 Still other studies have examined the

accuracy of agencies’ regulatory cost estimates, often concluding that costs are

overestimated.17

GAO and others have also examined agencies’ use of risk assessment in

regulation. In 2001, GAO described selected agencies’ chemical risk assessment

procedures, noting (among other things) that the statutory and legal context in which

the assessments are conducted and how the agency plans to use the information play

an important role in determining why certain risk assessment approaches are used.18

For example, some statutes require regulatory decisions to be based solely on risk,

while others require standards to be based on the “best available control technology.”

In general, GAO concluded that the agencies followed the four-step risk assessment

process recommended by the National Academy of Sciences in 1983.19 The report

also indicated that assumptions are an unavoidable part of risk assessment because

science cannot always provide definitive answers to questions raised at various stages

of an assessment.

President George W. Bush retained the general analytical requirements in

Executive Order 12866. In September 2003, though, OMB and the Council of

Economic Advisors finalized new guidance on regulatory analysis, refining and

replacing the 1996 best practices document. Among other things, the new guidance

(which has been formally issued as “OMB Circular A-4, Regulatory Analysis”) (1)

places more emphasis on cost-effectiveness analysis as well as cost-benefit analysis,

(2) requires formal probability analysis of future rulemakings with more than a $1

billion impact on the economy, and (3) requires more systematic evaluation of

qualitative as well as quantified costs and benefits.20 The new guidance took effect

on January 1, 2004, for regulatory analyses in support of proposed rules, and takes

effect on January 1, 2005, for analyses in support of final rules. Industry groups

have been generally supportive of the new guidance, but public advocacy groups

have expressed concerns that it may result in less regulation protecting public health

and the environment.

16

See, for example, Robert W. Hahn and Patrick Dudley, How Well Does the Government

Do Cost-Benefit Analysis?, Working Paper 04-01 (Washington: AEI-Brookings Joint Center

for Regulatory Studies, Jan. 2004).

17

For a summary of this literature, see Winston Harrington, Richard D. Morgenstern, and

Peter Nelson, “On the Accuracy of Regulatory Cost Estimates,” Journal of Policy Analysis

and Management, vol. 19 (2000), pp. 297-322.

18

General Accounting Office, Chemical Risk Assessment: Selected Federal Agencies’

Procedures, Assumptions, and Policies, GAO-01-810, Aug. 6, 2001.

19

National Research Council, National Academy of Sciences, Risk Assessment in the

Federal Government: Managing the Process (commonly referred to as the “Red Book”)

(Washington: National Academy Press, 1983).

20

To view a copy of OMB Circular A-4, see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/

circulars/a004/a-4.pdf].

CRS-9

In addition to the broadly applicable analytical requirements in Executive Order

12866 and related guidance, a number of other presidential actions have required

analyses of regulations for particular purposes. For example, Executive Order 13132

on “federalism” requires agencies to prepare a “federalism summary impact

statement” whenever they issue a rule that has “significant federalism implications.”21

The order goes on to say that the assessment is to contain “a description of the extent

of the agency’s prior consultation with State and local officials, a summary of the

nature of their concerns and the agency’s position supporting the need to issue the

regulation, and a statement of the extent to which the concerns of State and local

officials have been met.” Other executive orders specifically require agencies to

assess the effect of their rules on children and on energy supply, distribution, or use.

However, most of these orders give agencies substantial discretion to determine when

the analytical requirements are triggered.

Congressional Initiatives. Congress has also required federal regulatory

agencies to analyze the effect of their rules before they are issued. Some of the

requirements are potentially applicable to a range of regulations while others are

focused on particular types of rules. Perhaps the broadest of these requirements are

in title II of the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act (UMRA) of 1995 (2 U.S.C. 15321538).22 Before promulgating a rule containing a mandate that may result in the

expenditure of $100 million or more by the private sector or state, local, and tribal

governments in the aggregate, UMRA requires agencies (again, other than

independent regulatory agencies) to prepare a written statement containing a

“qualitative and quantitative assessment of the anticipated costs and benefits...as well

as the effect of the Federal mandate on health, safety, and the natural environment.”

These requirements are not triggered, though, if the agency issues a final rule without

a previous notice of proposed rulemaking. (About half of all final rules do not have

a prior proposed rule.) Also, as GAO pointed out in a 1998 report, the UMRA’s

analytical requirements do not apply to most economically significant rules, give

agencies substantial discretion regarding their implementation, and do not require

much more than is already required in Executive Order 12866.23

Other statutory analytical requirements have been enacted with regard to

particular issues or constituencies, such as the environment or small entities. For

example, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 43214347) requires all federal agencies to include in every recommendation or report

related to “major Federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human

environment” a detailed statement on the environmental impact of the proposed

action. The environmental impact statement must delineate the direct, indirect, and

cumulative effects of the proposed action. Agencies are also required to include in

the statement (1) any adverse environmental effects that cannot be avoided should

the proposal be implemented, (2) alternatives to the proposed action, (3) the

21

Executive Order 13132, “Federalism,” 64 Federal Register 43255, Aug. 10, 1999.

22

Title I of UMRA contains requirements applicable to congressional consideration of bills

containing mandates. For a more complete discussion of UMRA, see CRS Report RS20058,

Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Summarized, by Keith Bea and Richard S. Beth.

23

General Accounting Office, Unfunded Mandates: Reform Act Has Had Little Effect on

Agencies’ Rulemaking Actions, GAO/GGD-98-30, Feb. 4, 1998.

CRS-10

relationship between local short-term uses of the environment and the maintenance

and enhancement of long-term productivity, and (4) any irreversible and irretrievable

commitments of resources that would be involved if the proposed action should be

implemented. The adequacy of an agency’s environmental impact statement is

subject to judicial review.

The Regulatory Flexibility Act (RFA) of 1980 (5 U.S.C. 601-612) requires

federal agencies to assess the impact of their forthcoming regulations on “small

entities,” which the act defines as including small businesses, small governmental

jurisdictions, and certain small not-for-profit organizations. The RFA requires the

analysis to describe, among other things, (1) the reasons why the regulatory action

is being considered; (2) the small entities to which the proposed rule will apply and,

where feasible, an estimate of their number; (3) the projected reporting,

recordkeeping, and other compliance requirements of the proposed rule; and (4) any

significant alternatives to the rule that would accomplish the statutory objectives

while minimizing the impact on small entities. The RFA’s analytical requirements

are not triggered, though, if the head of the issuing agency certifies that the proposed

rule would not have a “significant economic impact on a substantial number of small

entities.” The RFA does not define “significant economic impact” or “substantial

number of small entities,” thereby giving federal agencies substantial discretion

regarding when the act’s analytical requirements are triggered. Also, as in UMRA,

the RFA’s analytical requirements do not apply to final rules for which the agency

does not publish a proposed rule. GAO has examined the implementation of the

RFA several times within the past 10 to 15 years, and a recurring theme in GAO’s

reports is the varying interpretation of the RFA’s requirements by federal agencies.24

In 2001, GAO testified that the promise of the RFA may never be realized until

Congress or some other entity defines what a “significant economic impact” and a

“substantial number of small entities” mean in a rulemaking setting.25

In the mid-to-late 1990s, Congress considered several comprehensive regulatory

reform legislative proposals that were intended to increase or improve the use of costbenefit analysis, cost-effectiveness analysis, or risk assessment by federal agencies.26

The bills’ particular requirements varied substantially, but all of them would have

generally required federal agencies to analyze risks as well as costs and benefits when

developing major rules. Some of the bills would have also required a costeffectiveness analysis, and some required specific studies of how the rules would

effect small businesses. Most of the bills would have required that benefits justify

costs or that the agency select the most cost-effective alternative. On the other hand,

most of the bills (particularly those in the 105th and 106th Congress) also indicated

24

See, for example, General Accounting Office, Regulatory Flexibility Act: Agencies’

Interpretations of Review Requirements Vary, GAO/GGD-99-55, April 2, 1999; General

Accounting Office, Regulatory Flexibility Act: Implementation in EPA Program Offices and

Proposed Lead Rule, GAO/GGD-00-193. Sept. 20, 2000.

25

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Flexibility Act: Key Terms Still Need to Be

Clarified, GAO-01-669T, April 24, 2001.

26

For a thorough discussion of many of these bills, see CRS Report RL30031,

Environmental Risk and Cost-Benefit Analysis: A Review of Proposed Legislative Mandates,

1993-1998, by Linda-Jo Schierow.

CRS-11

that these analytic requirements and decision criteria would not supercede the

provisions in existing law (e.g., the Clean Air Act or the Safe Drinking Water Act)

regarding whether, and if so, how agencies should weigh costs and risks in

developing regulations.27 One of the most controversial aspects of some of these bills

were provisions that would have made agencies’ cost-benefit analyses and risk

assessments subject to judicial review. If these analyses were found to be deficient,

the rules on which they were based could have been reversed.28 Some expressed

concerns that the courts were ill-equipped to assess the quality or importance of such

analyses to the underlying rules, and also indicated that the judicial review process

could prohibit the speedy adoption of health, safety, and environmental rules. None

of these comprehensive regulatory reform bills was enacted.

Bills requiring some type of regulatory analysis continue to be introduced. For

example, in the 108th Congress, H.R. 338 (the “Defense of Privacy Act”) would, if

enacted, require agencies to prepare and make available to the public a “privacy

impact analysis” describing the effect of the rule on the privacy interests of

individuals. The bill specifies that the analysis should describe the extent to which

the rule provides notice of the collection of personally identifiable information,

allows access to and permits correction of that information by those individuals, and

provides security for the information. As in UMRA and the RFA, though, the

analysis is not required if the agency issues a final rule without an associated

proposed rule.

Presidential and Congressional Review of Rules

Other regulatory reform initiatives have established systematic processes by

which agencies regulations are scrutinized by oversight bodies outside of the

rulemaking agencies. Such oversight bodies and review processes have been

established for both the President and the Congress.

Presidential Initiatives. As was the case regarding the previously mentioned

analytic requirements, every President in recent decades has established some type

of process within the Executive Office of the President by which regulatory agencies’

rules would be reviewed before their publication in the Federal Register. For

example:

!

President Nixon established a “Quality of Life Review” program in

which agencies submitted all “significant” draft proposed and final

rules pertaining to “environmental quality, consumer protection, and

27

As noted previously, some statutes forbid any consideration of costs in setting a health

standard (e.g., national ambient air quality standards under the Clean Air Act). Other

statutes establish other requirements (e.g., requiring agencies to regulate to the extent

“feasible” or “achievable”) whose effect on the use of cost-benefit analysis in

decisionmaking is less clear.

28

In some cases(e.g., S. 746, the “Regulatory Improvement Act of 1999”), these bills

permitted courts to remand or invalidate a rule if an agency had failed to perform a required

analysis, but could not do so because of the perceived inadequacy of the analysis.

CRS-12

occupational and public health and safety” to OMB, which then

circulated them to other agencies for comment.

!

President Ford required agencies to prepare an “inflation impact

statement” for each “major” proposed rule before publication, and

to send those statements to the Council on Wage and Price Stability

for comment.

!

President Carter established a “Regulatory Analysis Review Group”

to review the economic analyses prepared for certain major rules,

and to submit comments during the comment period. He also

established a “Regulatory Council” to coordinate agencies’ actions

to avoid conflicting requirements and duplication of effort.

According to many observers, the most significant development in this

evolution of presidential review of rules occurred in 1981, when President Reagan

issued Executive Order 12291.29 In addition to the previously discussed analytical

requirements, the executive order required Cabinet departments and independent

agencies to send a copy of each draft proposed and final rule to OMB before

publication in the Federal Register, and authorized OMB to review “any preliminary

or final Regulatory Impact Analysis, notice of proposed rulemaking, or final rule

based on the requirements of this Order.” The scope of this requirement was,

therefore, much broader than its predecessors, covering every proposed and final rule

developed by the covered agencies, regardless of its significance or subject matter.

The review responsibility within OMB was given to OIRA, which had been created

by the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA) of 1980 and whose primary responsibility

had been to review agencies’ paperwork requests.30 After Executive Order 12291

was issued, OIRA also began reviewing the substance of between 2,000 and 3,000

federal rules each year. OIRA’s influence over agencies’ rules under this order was

substantial. Unless a rule was required by Congress or the courts, the order allowed

OIRA to effectively block the rule’s promulgation until the rulemaking agency

responded to its concerns. OIRA’s influence was underscored by its location within

OMB — the agency that reviews and approves rulemaking agencies’ budget requests.

In 1981, President Reagan also created a “Task Force on Regulatory Relief,” headed

by Vice President Bush, whose mission was to review pending regulations, study past

regulations with an eye toward revising them, and recommend appropriate legislative

remedies. OIRA also supported the work of this task force.

In 1985, President Reagan extended OIRA’s influence even further by issuing

Executive Order 12498, which required agencies to submit a regulatory program to

OMB for review each year that covered all of their significant regulatory actions

29

See Erik D. Olson, “The Quiet Shift of Power: Office of Management & Budget

Supervision of Environmental Protection Agency Rulemaking Under Executive Order

12291,” Virginia Journal of Natural Resources Law, vol. 4 (Fall 1984), pp. 1-80.

30

For a more complete discussion of OIRA’s role in this process, see CRS Report RL32397,

Federal Rulemaking: the Role of the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, by Curtis

W. Copeland.

CRS-13

underway or planned.31 This executive order expanded on similar requirements in

Executive Order 12291, noting that OIRA could generally return any rule to the

issuing agency for “reconsideration” if it was not in the agency’s regulatory program

for that year or was “materially different” from what was described in the program.

As a result, OIRA could block the issuance of a rule even if it was otherwise

consistent with the requirements in Executive Order 12291.

The expansion of the President’s, and more specifically OIRA’s, role in the

rulemaking process via these executive orders and other actions was highly

controversial. Members of Congress, public advocacy groups, and others raised a

number of concerns, including whether OIRA’s role violated constitutional

separation of powers and the effect that OIRA’s review had on public participation

and the timeliness of agencies’ rules. In 1983, GAO concluded that the expansion

of OIRA’s responsibilities under Executive Order 12291 had adversely affected the

office’s ability to carry out its PRA responsibilities, and recommended that Congress

consider amending the act to prohibit OIRA from carrying out other responsibilities

like regulatory review.32 Additional concerns focused on the lack of transparency of

OIRA’s reviews, specifically whether OIRA had become a clandestine conduit for

outside influence in the rulemaking process. In 1987 the National Academy of Public

Administration published a report that summarized the criticisms of the OIRA review

process as well as the positions of its proponents.33 Both this report and a similar

1988 report by the Administrative Conference of the United States supported the

concept of presidential review of rulemaking, but also offered suggestions to improve

the transparency of the process.

Nevertheless, congressional concerns regarding OIRA’s influence on rules and

opposition to some of its actions continued. In 1989, President George H. W. Bush’s

nominee to head OIRA was not confirmed — in part because of lingering concerns

about the office’s previous actions. In response to congressional inaction and

because of continuing concerns about the costs of regulations, President Bush

established the President’s Council on Competitiveness to review regulations issued

by agencies. Chaired by Vice President Quayle, the council oversaw and was

supported by OIRA, and reviewed particular rules that it believed would have a

significant impact on the economy or particular industries. Many of the

Competitiveness Council’s actions were highly controversial, with critics assailing

both the effects of those actions (e.g., rolling back environmental or other

requirements) and the secrecy in which the council acted.

Executive Order 12866. The current process of presidential review of

rulemaking was established by President Clinton in 1993 through Executive Order

12866 on “Regulatory Planning and Review.” The executive order revoked

Executive Orders 12291 and 12498 and abolished the Council on Competitiveness.

31

Executive Order 12498, “Regulatory Planning Process,” 50 Federal Register 1036, Jan.

8, 1985.

32

General Accounting Office, Implementing the Paperwork Reduction Act: Some Progress,

But Many Problems Remain, GAO/GGD-83-35, April 20, 1983.

33

National Academy of Public Administration, Presidential Management of Rulemaking in

Regulatory Agencies (Jan. 1987).

CRS-14

While retaining the overall concept of presidential review of draft regulations, the

order limited the scope of OIRA’s review to “significant” rules issued by Cabinet

departments and independent agencies. The order defined a “significant” regulatory

action as one that may, among other things, have a $100 million impact on the

economy, create a serious inconsistency with actions by another agency, or raise

“novel legal or policy issues arising out of legal mandates.” As a result of this

limitation, the number of rules that OIRA reviewed fell from between 2,000 and

3,000 each year to between 500 and 700 each year.

Executive Order 12866 differs from its predecessors in other respects as well.

For example, the order generally requires that OIRA complete its reviews of

proposed and final rules within 90 calendar days, and requires both the agencies and

OIRA to disclose certain information about how the regulatory reviews were

conducted. Specifically, the order says that agencies should identify for the public

(1) the substantive changes made to rules between the draft submitted to OIRA for

review and the action subsequently announced, and (2) changes made at the

suggestion or recommendation of OIRA. OIRA is also required to provide agencies

with a copy of all written communications with parties outside of the executive

branch, and to maintain a public log of all regulatory actions under review. The

executive order retained a regulatory planning function, but did not explicitly permit

OIRA to return rules that were not included in the issuing agency’s plan.34

During the Clinton Administration, concerns were raised that agencies’ rules

were not being critically reviewed by OIRA.35 For example, critics pointed out that

from 1994 through 2000, OIRA returned only seven rules to the agencies for

reconsideration (less than one-half of 1% of the rules the office reviewed), and

returned no rules during the last three years of this period. OIRA said that the

number of returns was a poor measure of OIRA’s performance, and said it was

working with agencies to improve their rules before they were formally submitted.

Congress held oversight hearings and legislation was introduced (but ultimately not

enacted) that would have codified and strengthened OIRA regulatory review

function.

President George W. Bush retained Executive Order 12866 and the review

process it delineated. He also nominated John Graham to head OIRA, whose

confirmation was highly controversial. Shortly after taking office in July 2001,

Graham instituted a number of changes in OIRA’s review practices, including greater

use of return letters (21 returns in his first eight months), the issuance of “prompt

letters” encouraging agency action in a particular area, an increased emphasis on

economic analysis, stricter adherence to the 90-day review period, and improvements

in the transparency of the review process. Underlying many of these changes was a

34

Specifically, the order required all agencies (here, including independent regulatory

agencies) to prepare an agenda of all regulations under development or review and a

regulatory plan of the most important significant regulatory actions. Agencies’ agendas and

plans are published in the Unified Agenda of Federal Regulatory and Deregulatory Actions.

35

See, for example, Susan E. Dudley and Angela Antonelli, “Congress and the Clinton

OMB: Unwilling Partners in Regulatory Oversight?,” Regulation, vol. 20 (Fall 1997), pp.

17-23.

CRS-15

shift in how Graham viewed OIRA’s role (i.e., as a “gatekeeper” guarding against the

issuance of ill-advised rules) compared with his predecessors during the Clinton

Administration (i.e., as a “counselor” to regulatory agencies in the development of

their rules). In 2003, GAO completed a major review of OIRA’s regulatory review

function, describing these and other changes in detail.36 GAO also reported on the

extent to which OIRA’s reviews resulted in rules being changed, withdrawn, or

returned to the agency. GAO concluded that although some improvements had been

made in the transparency of the OIRA review process during Graham’s tenure, more

improvements were needed.

Congressional Initiatives. Congressional influence on regulatory agencies

and the rulemaking process can take many forms, including drafting legislation

specifically delineating the scope of the agencies’ rulemaking authorities, advice and

consent regarding nominees to head those agencies, reviews of the agencies’

performance during the annual appropriations process, and hearings on specific

regulatory issues. During the late 1970s and early 1980s, Congress also used the

“legislative veto” process to overturn some of the agencies’ final regulations. In that

process, statutes applicable to several agencies and some programs were written to

make final regulations subject to either a one-house or two-house veto before they

could take effect. In 1983, however, the Supreme Court held in Immigration and

Naturalization Service v. Chadha (462 U.S. 919) that a one-house veto of a

deportation order by the Attorney General violated the separation of powers doctrine

and was therefore unconstitutional. The Court subsequently applied the same logic

in rulings regarding two-house vetos and vetos of rules issued by administrative

agencies.37

Congressional Review Act. In March 1996, the statutory provision

commonly known as the “Congressional Review Act” (CRA) (5 U.S.C. 801-808)

was included as part of the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act

(SBREFA). The CRA established expedited procedures by which Congress may

disapprove agencies’ rules by enacting a joint resolution of disapproval, with

subsequent presentation to the President for signature or veto (thereby avoiding

Chadha problems).38 Under the CRA, before any final rule can become effective it

must be filed with each House of Congress and GAO. The act also requires federal

agencies to submit to GAO and make available to each House of Congress a copy of

any cost-benefit analysis prepared for the rule and a report on the agency’s actions

related to the RFA, UMRA, and any other relevant act or executive order. The

definition of a “rule” under the CRA is very broad, and the act applies to rules issued

by Cabinet departments and independent agencies as well as independent regulatory

agencies.

36

General Accounting Office, Rulemaking: OMB’s Role in Reviews of Agencies’ Draft

Rules and the Transparency of Those Reviews, GAO-03-929, Sept. 22, 2003.

37

For more information on the legislative veto, see CRS Report RL30808, Government at

the Dawn of the 21st Century: A Status Report, by Harold C. Relyea, pp. 36-38.

38

For a detailed discussion of CRA procedures, see CRS Report RL31160, Disapproval of

Regulations by Congress: Procedure Under the Congressional Review Act, by Richard S.

Beth.

CRS-16

If OIRA considers the issuing agency’s rule to be “major” (e.g., has a $100

million impact on the economy), the agency must delay the rule’s effective date by

60 days after the date of publication in the Federal Register or submission to

Congress and GAO, whichever is later. Within 15 calendar days of receiving a major

rule, GAO is required to provide Congress with a report on the rule assessing the

issuing agency’s compliance with the procedural steps required by the various acts

and executive orders applicable to the rulemaking process.39 Although the CRA

establishes these special requirements for major rules, the CRA procedures for

disapproving regulations apply to all rules, whether or not they are declared to be

major.

Within 60 days after Congress receives an agency’s rule, excluding periods

when Congress is in recess or adjournment, a Member of Congress can introduce a

resolution of disapproval that, if adopted by both Houses and enacted into law, can

nullify the rule, even if it has already gone into effect. Congressional disapproval

under the CRA also prevents the agency from proposing to issue a “substantially

similar” rule without subsequent statutory authorization, but this provision is not

intended to vitiate the agency’s power to establish regulations in the area in question.

The CRA provides that Senate action on a disapproval resolution under the act

must occur within 60 days of session after the regulation is submitted, and makes

available during that period an expedited procedure intended to ensure that the Senate

can take up and vote on the measure before the period expires. The act establishes no

such expedited procedure for the House. If Congress adjourns less than 60 days of

session after a rule is submitted, a new 60 day period for disapproval under the act

begins on the 15th legislative day of the next session. If a disapproval resolution is

rejected by either House of Congress, the rule can take effect immediately (or as

provided by other governing law or rule).

As of March 2004, federal agencies had submitted nearly 34,000 rules to GAO

(and presumably, Congress) since the CRA took effect in March 1996, including 535

major rules. Approximately 30 CRA joint resolutions of disapproval have been

introduced regarding more than 20 rules, but only one rule has been overturned

through CRA’s procedures — OSHA’s ergonomics standard in March 2001. One

other rule — the Federal Communication Commission’s rule related to broadcast

media ownership — was disapproved by the Senate, but had not been acted upon by

the House as of the date of this report.40

39

GAO’s major rule reports under the CRA can be found on GAO’s website at

[http://www.gao.gov]. The reports are located under the “GAO Legal Products” heading,

and generally describe (but do not critically evaluate) agencies’ actions under various

statutes and executive orders.

40

A related CRS analysis of the implementation of the CRA describes several possible

factors affecting the law’s use. See CRS Report RL30116, Congressional Review of Agency

Rulemaking: An Assessment After Nullification of OSHA’s Ergonomics Standard, by Morton

Rosenberg,. See also Morton Rosenberg, “Whatever Happened to Congressional Review

of Agency Rulemaking?: A Brief Overview, Assessment, and Proposal for Reform,”

Administrative Law Review, vol. 51 (Fall 1999), pp. 1051-1092.

CRS-17

Truth in Regulating Act. Congress attempted to put in place another type

of congressional oversight of federal agency rulemaking, but the reform was never

implemented. In October 2000, Congress enacted the Truth in Regulating Act

(TIRA) (P.L. 106-312), which was intended to improve the quality of the information

that Congress receives about certain rules. Under TIRA, the chairman or ranking

member of any committee of jurisdiction could have requested that GAO conduct an

in-depth review of an agency’s estimate of a proposed or final economically

significant rule’s costs and benefits, an analysis of the alternatives that the agency

considered, and the agency’s compliance with relevant procedural and analytical

requirements. Federal agencies were required to “promptly cooperate” with GAO in

carrying out the act. TIRA established a three-year pilot project (starting in January

2001) that became effective upon the specific annual appropriation to GAO of $5.2

million (or the prorated portion thereof). Congress never provided that appropriation,

though, so the three-year pilot project ended in January 2004 without being activated.

Like presidential review, congressional review of regulations is controversial.

Proponents of congressional review believe it better ensures that Congress has an

opportunity to reject unnecessary, overly intrusive, or excessively costly regulations.

Critics argue that congressional review encroaches on agency independence, can

politicize rulemaking, delays the timely issuance of regulations, and requires an

expertise in subject areas that Congress does not have readily available to it (one of

the reasons Congress delegates regulatory authority to agencies in the first place).

Proponents respond, however, that congressional review enables Congress (to whom

regulatory power is constitutionally given) to make the final decision on the need for

specific regulations, and makes regulatory agencies more sensitive to congressional

intent and Congress more accountable for regulators’ actions. They also argue that

the mere presence of a congressional review process can prevent poorly-conceived

rules from being developed.

Regulatory Accounting and Regulatory Budgets

Regulation, like taxing and spending, is a basic function of government. Unlike

taxing and spending, though, the costs that nonfederal entities pay to comply with

federal regulations are not accounted for in the federal budget process. Some

researchers have estimated those off-budget costs in the hundreds of billions of

dollars, and the estimates of aggregate regulatory benefits are even higher.41

Congress decided that it needed more information on regulatory costs and

benefits, so for several years it included language in appropriations bills that required

OMB to submit annual reports to Congress. Most recently, section 624 of the

Treasury and General Government Appropriations Act, 2001, (31 U.S.C. 1105 note),

sometimes known as the “Regulatory Right-to-Know Act,” put in place a permanent

requirement for an OMB report on regulatory costs and benefits. Specifically, it

requires OMB to prepare and submit with the budget an “accounting statement and

41

See, for example, W. Mark Crain and Thomas D. Hopkins, The Impact of Regulatory

Costs on Small Firms (Washington: Small Business Administration, 2001). The study

estimated the total costs of federal regulations at $843 billion in 2000, of which $497 billion

fell on business and $346 billion fell on consumers or governments.

CRS-18

associated report” containing an estimate of the costs and benefits (including

quantifiable and nonquantifiable effects) of federal rules and paperwork, to the extent

feasible, (1) in the aggregate, (2) by agency and agency program, and (3) by major

rule. The accounting statement is also required to contain an analysis of impacts of

federal regulation on state, local, and tribal governments, small businesses, wages,

and economic growth.42

From 1997 through 2001, OMB provided estimates of the total costs and

benefits of federal rules, but presented those estimates with strong caveats. For

example, in its 1998 report OMB said there was not a professional consensus on how

regulatory costs and benefits should be measured, and discussed a number of

methodological problems (e.g., determining what costs and benefits would have

occurred in the absence of the regulation). OMB’s estimates (particularly of

regulatory benefits) varied substantially from year to year,43 and also varied from

estimates provided by other researchers.

Since 2001, OMB has not presented cost or benefit estimates for all rules.

Instead, the office has reported information for all regulations that it reviewed within

a particular time-frame (1) that had costs or benefits of at least $100 million annually

and (2) whose costs and benefits had been monetized by either the rulemaking agency

or OMB. In its 2002 report, OMB said its decision to present data for only certain

rules during a limited time-frame was driven by the inconsistent and increasingly

aged nature of many of the studies used to develop aggregate estimates. OMB went

on to say that “we do not believe that the estimates of the costs and benefits of

regulations issued over ten years ago are reliable or very useful for informing current

policy decisions.” Therefore, OMB said that it decided not to provide aggregate

estimates “in keeping with the spirit of OMB’s new information-quality

guidelines.”44

In its September 2003 report, OMB provided estimates of the costs and benefits

of 107 regulations that it reviewed during the 10-year period from October 1992 to

September 2002.45 OMB’s estimate of the cost of these rules ranged from $36 billion

to $42 billion, and the estimated benefits ranged from $146 billion to $230 billion

42

For a discussion of these requirements and other researchers’ efforts to measure regulatory

costs and benefits, see CRS Report RL32339, Federal Regulations: Efforts to Estimate Total

Costs and Benefits of Rules, by Curtis W. Copeland.

43

For example, OMB’s estimate of regulatory benefits was $298 billion in 1997 and

between $260 billion and $3.5 trillion in 1998. By 2000, OMB’s upper-end benefit estimate

declined to nearly $1.8 trillion.

44

As discussed later in this report, section 515 of the Treasury and General Government

Appropriations Act for Fiscal Year 2001, generally known as the “Data Quality Act” or the

“Information Quality Act,” amended the Paperwork Reduction Act and directed OMB to

issue government-wide guidelines that “provide policy and procedural guidance to Federal

agencies for ensuring and maximizing the quality, objectivity, utility, and integrity of

information (including statistical information) disseminated by Federal agencies.” OMB

issued a final version of those guidelines in February 2002.

45

To view a copy of this report, see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/

2003_cost-ben_final_rpt.pdf].

CRS-19

(all in 2001 dollars). OMB said that it recognized that this information was not a

complete accounting of the costs and benefits of all federal regulations, or even for

all rules issued during the 10-year period, and said that the total costs and benefits of

all federal rules in place “could easily be a factor of ten or more larger than the sum

of the costs and benefits reported (for the 10-year period).” Nevertheless, OMB said

that estimates prepared for rules adopted prior to the 10-year period “are of

questionable relevance now.”

Regulatory Budgets. In addition to better informing Congress and the public

about the costs and benefits of regulations, some observers have suggested using

regulatory accounting information to create a “regulatory budget” to improve

regulatory accountability and control.46 A regulatory budget might limit the total

volume of regulatory programs, expenditures, and compliance costs, by setting a cap

on the compliance costs each agency could impose on the economy. Therefore, an

agency proposing to add additional compliance costs would be obligated to remove

a commensurate amount of existing cost. Implementing a regulatory budget,

however, can present many conceptual and empirical problems, including the scope

of regulations to be covered (almost all federal programs involve some degree of

regulation, the amount depending to some extent upon one’s definition of

“regulation”); the accuracy of cost estimates (direct and indirect, including the impact

on firms, industries, and consumers beyond compliance costs); the accuracy of

benefit estimates (generally regarded as more difficult to determine than estimating

costs); and redundancy or overlap with state and local regulations.47

Legislation was introduced in the 108th Congress that could lay the groundwork

for regulatory budgeting in the future. H.R. 2432, the “Paperwork and Regulatory

Improvements Act of 2003,” would, if enacted, require OMB to designate at least

five agencies (including at least EPA and the Departments of Labor and

Transportation) as pilot projects in regulatory budgeting for fiscal years 2006 and

2007. The bill provides that the budgets “shall present, for one or more of the major

regulatory programs of the agency, the varying levels of costs and benefits to the

public that would result from different budgeted amounts.” The bill directs OMB to

issue a report by February 2009 on the pilot project and “recommend whether

legislation requiring regulatory budgets should be proposed.” During testimony in

July 2003 on the bill, OMB suggested reducing the scope of the pilot projects, and

clarifying that the budget levels set by OMB were not legally binding.

Alternatives to Traditional Regulations

Federal agencies have traditionally issued “command and control” regulations

that specify what individuals and firms must do to meet an established standard or

goal. For example, environmental regulations may require the use of specific

pollution control devices, and inspection systems may require the performance of

specific procedures. Although traditional command-and-control regulations are

46

In fact, the creation of a regulatory budget was contemplated in section 6(a)(6) of

Executive Order 12291 in 1981.

47

Samuel Hughes, “Regulatory Budgeting,” Center for the Study of American Business,

Washington University, Working Paper 160, June 1996.

CRS-20

appropriate in some circumstances (and may, in fact, be required by statute), other

more market-oriented or performance-based rules may permit the achievement of the

regulatory objective at lower cost. Some statutes encourage the use of nontraditional

regulatory approaches in specific areas or, more generally, across a range of

regulations. For example, the Trade Agreements Act of 1979 (19 U.S.C. 2531-2533)

requires, where appropriate, the use of performance standards rather than design

standards and the consideration of international standards as the basis of domestic

standards.

Emission Trading. A commonly cited example of the market approach to

regulation is emission allowance trading under the Clean Air Act. Title IV of the act

allows electric utilities to trade allowances to emit sulfur dioxide with other utilities.

After setting the overall reductions in sulfur dioxide emissions to be achieved,

Congress defined each source’s specific emissions limits for all sources combined

to meet a total emissions cap. Utilities that reduce their emissions below the required

levels can sell their extra allowances to other utilities to help them meet their

requirements. Otherwise, utilities that exceed their emissions allowances must pay

fines that are set at several times the estimated average cost of complying with the

emissions limits. Emissions trading has also been used in other environmental

programs. For example, the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990 addressed the use

of market-based approaches to attain and maintain the National Ambient Air Quality

Standards for other pollutants, particularly ozone. Section 11(a)(2)(A) of the act says

that in their implementation plans, states can use “economic incentives such as fees,

marketable permits, and auctions of emissions rights” to meet the statutory

requirements.

Information Disclosure. Another nontraditional approach to regulation

involves information disclosure. Specifically, Congress and regulatory agencies may

attempt to affect the behavior of regulated entities or others by simply revealing the

nature of their actions rather than directly attempting to limit them. The EPA “toxics

release inventory” (TRI) program is one of the most established examples of an

information disclosure program. The TRI program is essentially a database created

through collections of information imposed on businesses in order to inform the

public about chemical hazards in their communities. TRI reporting is required by

section 313 of the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act of 1986

(42 U.S.C. 11001-11050, 11023).48 The act generally requires certain types of

facilities to report the amounts of various toxic chemicals that they release to the

environment above certain thresholds, and requires EPA to make this information

available to the public. The expectation is that these facilities would reduce their use

of these chemicals, thereby avoiding the disclosure requirements.49 Other examples

of regulation by disclosure include food labeling requirements and requirements that

medical errors be disclosed. Increased use of information technology could make

48

TRI reporting is also required under the Pollution Prevention Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C.

13101-13109, 13106), which added reporting requirements beginning in 1991.

49

For a discussion of the TRI program in this context, as well as a critique of information

disclosure, see William F. Pederson, “Regulation and Information Disclosure: Parallel

Universes and Beyond,” The Harvard Environmental Law Review, vol. 25, no. 1 (2001), pp.

151-211.

CRS-21

this form of nontraditional regulation more prevalent in the future.50 However,

concerns in the wake of the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, have also led to

restrictions on the disclosure of certain types of information.

Presidential Encouragements.

In addition to these legislative

requirements, most recent Presidents have also advocated the use of alternatives to

traditional regulations. For example, in 1980 President Carter directed agencies to

find areas where alternative techniques could be used in both existing and new

regulatory programs. The President’s Regulatory Council created a project on

alternative regulatory approaches, which published a series of guides on those

approaches. Presidents Reagan and George H.W. Bush also supported the use of

market approaches as an alternative to traditional regulation.

In September 1993, the National Performance Review (NPR), headed by Vice

President Gore, published a report to the President containing 384 recommendations

intended to make the government work better and cost less.51 One set of NPR

recommendations was directed at improving regulatory systems, including the use

of “innovative regulatory approaches” such as performance standards, marketable

permits, monetary incentives, and information disclosure. Executive Order 12866

was issued later that month, and one of the “principles of regulation” included in the

order was that each agency “shall identify and assess available alternatives to direct

regulation, including providing economic incentives to encourage the desired

behavior, such as user fees or marketable permits, or providing information upon

which choices can be made by the public.” Another executive order principle says

each agency “shall identify and assess alternative forms of regulation and shall, to the

extent feasible, specify performance objectives rather than specifying the behavior

or manner of compliance that regulated entities must adopt.”

OIRA’s September 2003 guidance on economic analysis under Executive Order

12866 recommends that alternatives to traditional regulatory action be explored. For

example, the guidance states that performance standards “are generally superior to

engineering or design standards because performance standards give the regulated

parties the flexibility to achieve the regulatory objective in the most cost-effective

way.” The guidance also says that market-oriented approaches that allow for

averaging, banking, or trading of credits for achieving emissions reductions beyond

the required standards “can be extremely valuable in reducing costs or achieving

earlier or greater benefits,” but cautioned that they should not be used if they produce

“unacceptable local air quality outcomes (such as ‘hot spots’ from local pollution

concentration).” Finally, the guidance says that informational remedies such as rating

systems, labeling requirements, and government publications “will often be

preferred” when intervention is contemplated to address a market failure caused by

inadequate or asymmetric information.

50

Mary Graham, Democracy by Disclosure: The Rise of Technopopulism (Washington:

Brookings Institution Press, 2002).

51

Office of the Vice President, From Red Tape to Results: Creating a Government That

Works Better and Costs Less, Report of the National Performance Review (Washington:

Government Printing Office, Sept. 1993).

CRS-22

Moratoriums on New Regulations

Imposing a moratorium on new rulemaking is a technique that has been used to

assert control over the rulemaking process, particularly for an incoming presidential

administration.52 For example, on January 29, 1981, shortly after taking office,

President Reagan issued a memorandum to the heads of the Cabinet departments and

the EPA Administrator directing them to take certain actions that would give the new

administration time to implement a “new regulatory oversight process,” particularly

for “last-minute decisions” made by the previous administration. Specifically, the

memorandum said that agencies should, to the extent permitted by law, (1) postpone

for 60 days the effective date of all final rules that were scheduled to take effect

during that 60-day period and (2) refrain from promulgating any new final rules.

Executive Order 12291, issued a few weeks later, contained another moratorium on

rulemaking that supplemented, but did not supplant, the January 29, 1981,

memorandum. Section 7 of the executive order directed agencies to “suspend or

postpone the effective dates of all major rules that they have promulgated in final

form as of the date of this Order, but that have not yet become effective.” Excluded

were major rules that could not be legally postponed or suspended, and those that

ought to become effective “for good cause.” Agencies were also directed to refrain

from promulgating any new final rules until a final regulatory impact analysis had

been conducted.

In January 1992, President George H.W. Bush imposed a 90-day moratorium

on new regulations in response to criticisms that regulatory burden was increasing

rapidly during his administration. The President instructed agencies to identify

existing regulations and programs imposing unnecessary regulatory burdens and to

develop programs to reduce or eliminate those burdens. Regulations that were issued

in response to emergency situations, had statutory or judicial deadlines, dealt with

military or foreign affairs, or were related to agency administrative matters were

exempted from the moratorium. The moratorium was later extended, and remained

in force until the end of the Bush Administration.

On January 22, 1993, the Director of OMB for the incoming Clinton

Administration sent a memorandum to the heads and acting heads of Cabinet

departments and independent agencies requesting them to (1) not send proposed or

final rules to the Office of the Federal Register for publication until they have been

approved by an agency head appointed by President Clinton and confirmed by the

Senate, and (2) withdraw from the Office of the Federal Register all regulations that

had not been published in the Federal Register and that could be withdrawn under

existing procedures. The requirements did not apply, however, to any rules that had

to be issued immediately because of a statutory or judicial deadline. The OMB

Director said these actions were needed because it was “important that President

Clinton’s appointees have an opportunity to review and approve new regulations.”

52

The volume of rulemaking typically increases at the end of a presidential Administration.

See Jay Cochran, III, The Cinderella Constraint: Why Regulations Increase Significantly

During Post-Election Quarters (Arlington, VA: Mercatus Center, Oct. 5, 2000).

CRS-23

Most recently, on January 20, 2001, Andrew H. Card, Jr., Assistant to President

George W. Bush and Chief of Staff, sent a memorandum (often referred to as the

“Card memo”) to the heads and acting heads of all executive departments and

agencies generally directing them to (1) not send proposed or final rules to the Office

of the Federal Register, (2) withdraw from the Office rules that had not yet been

published in the Federal Register, and (3) postpone for 60 days the effective date of

rules that had been published but had not yet taken effect.53 The Card memo

instructed agencies to exclude any rules promulgated pursuant to statutory or judicial

deadlines, and to notify the OMB Director of any rules that should be excluded

because they “impact critical health and safety functions of the agency.” The memo

indicated that these actions were needed to “ensure that the President’s appointees

have the opportunity to review any new or pending regulations.”

In February 2002, GAO reported on the delay of effective dates of final rules

subject to the Card memo.54 GAO indicated that 371 final rules were subject to the

Card memo, and federal agencies delayed the effective dates of at least 90 of them.

As of the one-year anniversary of the Card memo, most of the 90 rules had taken

effect, but one had been withdrawn and not replaced by a new rule, three had been

withdrawn and replaced by new rules, and nine others had been altered (e.g., different

implementation date or reporting requirement). The agencies generally did not

permit the public to comment on the delays or changes.

All of these presidential moratoriums on rulemaking have generally exempted

regulations issued by independent regulatory boards and commissions, as well as

regulations issued in response to emergency situations or statutory or judicial

deadlines. Critics claim that moratoriums disrupt the regulatory process and delay

the implementation of important regulations. They have also raised concerns about

changes in the effective dates of published rules without permitting public

comment.55 In fact, some of the delays and changes initiated by these presidential

moratoriums were later overturned by the courts.56 Supporters, on the other hand,

assert that moratoriums help to block undesirable regulations and enable the new

administration and federal agencies to revise or eliminate less desirable regulations.

53

U.S. White House Office, “Regulatory Review Plan,” Federal Register, vol. 66, no. 16,

Jan. 24, 2001, p. 7702.

To view a copy of this memorandum, see

[http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/regreview_plan.pdf].

54

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Review: Delay of Effective Dates of Final

Rules Subject to the Administration’s Jan. 20, 2001, Memorandum, GAO-02-370R, Feb.

15, 2002.

55

See, for example, William M. Jack, “Taking Care That Presidential Oversight of the

Regulatory Process is Faithfully Executed: A Review of Rule Withdrawals and Rule

Suspensions Under the Bush Administration’s Card Memorandum,” Administrative Law

Review, vol. 54 (Fall 2002), pp. 1479-1518.

56

See, for example, Natural Resources Defense Council v. Abraham, 2d Cir., No. 01-4102,

Jan. 13, 2004.

CRS-24

Reviews of Existing Regulations

Each year, federal agencies issue more than 4,000 final rules, which are then

codified in the Code of Federal Regulations. Although most of the attention of

regulatory reformers has been focused on new rules, reexamination of the large body

of existing rules can reveal that they are no longer needed, or that improvements in

the regulatory approach can make the program more effective or less burdensome.

Reviews of existing regulations were recommended by the Administrative

Conference of the United States,57 and have been initiated by both recent Presidents

and the Congress.

Presidential Initiatives. Most recent Presidents have directed agencies to

reconsider their existing regulations. For example, in 1979, President Carter issued

Executive Order 12044, which required agencies to review their existing rules

“periodically.”58 One of the missions of President Reagan’s task force on regulatory

relief was to identify existing regulations and recommend changes. During the

previously-mentioned moratorium on new rules during the administration of

President George H.W. Bush, agencies were instructed “to evaluate existing

regulations and programs and to identify and accelerate action on initiatives that will

eliminate any unnecessary regulatory burden or otherwise promote economic

growth.”

Section 5 of Executive Order 12866, issued in September 1993, required

agencies to submit to OIRA a plan for periodically reviewing their existing

significant regulations to determine whether any should be modified or eliminated.

According to the executive order, the purpose of the review is to make the agencies’

regulatory programs more effective, less burdensome, or better aligned with the

President’s priorities and the principles specified in the order. In its report on the

first year’s implementation of the executive order, OIRA said this review of existing

rules was intended to be “a fundamental reengineering of entire regulatory systems,”

not just “tinkering with regulatory provisions to consolidate or update provisions.”

Because of concerns that all agencies were not “taking the steps necessary to

implement regulatory reform,” President Clinton sent a memorandum to the heads

of Cabinet departments and independent agencies in March 1995 directing them to,

among other things, conduct a page-by-page review of all their regulations in force

and eliminate or revise those that were outdated or in need of reform. In June 1995,

the President announced that this effort had resulted in commitments to eliminate

16,000 pages from the CFR. GAO later reported, however, that four agencies’ page

elimination totals did not take into account the pages that they had added to the CFR

57

The Administrative Conference cautioned that such reviews should not be “one-size-fitsall,” but should be tailored to the agencies’ individual needs. For the specific

recommendations, see Jeffrey S. Lubbers, A Guide to Federal Agency Rulemaking, 3rd ed.

(Washington: American Bar Association, 1998), pp. 274-276.

58

Executive Order 12044, “Improving Government Regulations,” 43 Federal Register

12661, Mar. 24, 1978.

CRS-25

while the eliminations were taking place.59 GAO also said that about half of the

actions were likely to result in little or no reduction of regulatory burden.

The most recent OIRA-directed reviews of existing rules have involved the

general public in the review process. In May 2001, OIRA asked the public to

nominate rules that it believed should be modified or rescinded.60 In response, OIRA

received 71 nominations from 33 commentators, and decided that 23 of the rules

nominated merited “high priority review.” In March 2002, OIRA again solicited

public comments on regulations in need of reform, and in response received more

than 300 suggestions from about 1,700 commentators, some of which suggested

making rules more stringent or developing new rules. This time, OIRA forwarded

the suggestions to the relevant federal agencies for review and prioritization. In

February 2004, OIRA requested public nomination of promising regulatory reforms

relevant to the manufacturing sector. Specifically, OIRA requested that commenters

suggest reforms to regulations, guidance documents, or paperwork requirements that

would “improve manufacturing regulation by reducing unnecessary costs, increasing

effectiveness, enhancing competitiveness, reducing uncertainty and increasing

flexibility.”

Congressional Initiatives. Congress has also directed agencies to review

the effects of their existing regulations. Some of these congressionally-initiated

review requirements focus on rules issued under specific statutes. For example,

section 812 of the 1990 amendments to the Clean Air Act required EPA to provide

information about the economic costs and benefits and the health, welfare, and

environmental impacts of the Clean Air Act.61 The 1990 amendments also directed

an interagency group to report every four years, beginning in 1996, on the costs,

benefits, and effectiveness of the acid rain program.

Other congressionally-directed regulatory reviews are more crosscutting,

although still focused on particular types of rules. Section 610 of the Regulatory

Flexibility Act requires each federal agency to develop a plan for the review of its

existing rules that have or will have a “significant economic impact on a substantial

number of small entities.” The purpose of this “look-back” review is to determine

whether the rules should be continued without change or should be amended or

rescinded to minimize their impact on small entities. GAO reported in 1999,

however, that regulatory agencies differed in how they interpreted this requirement.62

59

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Reform: Agencies’ Efforts to Eliminate and Revise

Rules Yield Mixed Results, GAO/GGD-98-3, Oct. 2, 1997.

60

OIRA said it requested the nominations in response to a requirement in section 628(a)(3)

of the FY2000 Treasury and General Government Appropriations Act that required OMB

to submit “recommendations for reform” with its report on the costs and benefits of federal

regulations.

61

For a discussion of reviews of EPA rules, see General Accounting Office, Environmental

Protection: Assessing the Impacts of EPA’s Regulations Through Retrospective Studies,

GAO/RCED-99-250, Sept. 14, 1999.

62

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Flexibility Act: Agencies’ Interpretations of

Review Requirements Vary, GAO/GGD-99-55, April 2, 1999.

CRS-26

For example, it was not clear whether agencies are supposed to review rules that

currently have an impact on small entities, or those that had that impact at the time

the rules were issued. In any event, it was clear that few section 610 reviews were

being conducted.

Several of the comprehensive regulatory reform bills that Congress considered

(but did not enact) during the mid- to late 1990s would have required agencies to

review virtually all of their existing rules, not just those issued under certain statutes

or that affected small entities. For example, the “Regulatory Sunset and Review Act

of 1995” (H.R. 994) would have required agencies to review each existing significant

rule (and other rules upon request by affected parties or congressional committees)

within four to seven years after the bill’s enactment and then to either issue a report

continuing the rule or take action to modify, consolidate, or terminate it. Later, the

“Regulatory Improvement Act of 1997” (S. 981) would have required agencies to

review existing rules identified by an advisory committee representing a balanced

cross section of public and private interests. The agencies would have then had to

decide whether to retain, amend, or repeal the rules it reviewed.

Paperwork Reduction Initiatives

Other regulatory reform initiatives have focused specifically on controlling the

paperwork that often accompanies regulations. Many information collections,

recordkeeping requirements, and third-party disclosures are contained in, or are

authorized by, regulations as monitoring or enforcement tools. In fact, these

paperwork requirements are the essence of many agencies’ regulatory provisions.63

A large amount of federal paperwork is necessary, and is how many agencies carry

out their missions. For example, IRS needs to collect information from taxpayers

and their employers to know the correct amount of taxes owed. EPA uses

information requirements to ensure compliance with its regulations, to evaluate the

effectiveness of its programs, and for other purposes. Nevertheless, federal agencies

are expected to minimize the paperwork burden that they impose.

Paperwork Reduction Act. The most notable of the various reform

initiatives to control federal paperwork is the Paperwork Reduction Act (PRA) (44

U.S.C. 3501-3520), which was originally enacted in 1980 but was subsequently

amended in 1986 and again in 1995. The original PRA replaced the ineffective

Federal Reports Act of 1942, and established OIRA within OMB to provide central

agency leadership and oversight of government-wide efforts to reduce unnecessary

paperwork and improve the management of information resources. Currently, the act

requires OIRA to maintain a government-wide strategic information resources

management plan. Such a plan could help ensure that federal paperwork is the

63

For example, EPA’s Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) program is essentially a database

created through collections of information imposed on businesses in order to inform the

public about chemical hazards in their communities. TRI reports require businesses in

certain industries to report the quantity of any of more than 600 chemicals entering each

environmental medium on site, transfers of the chemical in wastes to off-site locations, onsite treatment methods and efficiency, and source reduction and recycling activities.

CRS-27

minimum necessary and is well integrated into agencies’ missions and objectives.64

GAO reported in February 2002, though, that OMB had not fully developed and

implemented an information resources management plan that articulated a

comprehensive federal vision for all aspects of government information.65

The PRA also requires agencies to receive OIRA approval (signified by an

OMB control number) for each information collection request before it is

implemented. Under the PRA’s “public protection” provision, no one can be

penalized for failing to comply with a collection of information subject to the act if

it has not been approved by OIRA within the previous three years. Each year,

however, OIRA reports that agencies impose hundreds of paperwork requirements

without OIRA approval (although the number of such PRA violations have declined

in recent years).66 OIRA can disapprove any collection of information (and generally

stop any associated regulation) if it believes the collection is inconsistent with the

requirements of the PRA.67

The 1995 amendments to the PRA required OIRA to set a goal of at least a 10%

reduction in the government-wide burden-hour estimate for each of fiscal years 1996

and 1997, a 5% goal for each of the next four fiscal years, and annual agency goals

that reduce burden to the “maximum practicable opportunity.” Therefore, if these

goals had been met, the amount of federal paperwork would have fallen by 35% —

from about 7 billion burden hours at the end of FY1995 to about 4.6 billion hours at

the end of FY2001. This anticipated reduction did not occur, though. In fact, by the

end of FY2002, the government-wide paperwork estimate stood at more than 8.2

billion hours — a 17% increase since the PRA amendments took effect at the end of

FY1995. The agencies often contend that they cannot reduce their paperwork

requirements without changes in their authorizing statutes, many of which require the

collection of certain types of information.

Other Paperwork Initiatives. In addition to the PRA, Congress has enacted

other statutes in an attempt to reduce or at least control federal paperwork burden.

For example, in June 2002, Congress enacted, and the President signed, the Small

Business Paperwork Relief Act of 2002 (P.L. 107-198). The act amended the PRA

to, among other things, require each agency to establish a single point of contact to

act as a liaison for small business concerns with regard to information collection and

64

CRS Report RL30590, Paperwork Reduction Act Reauthorization and Government

Information Management Issues, by Harold Relyea, and CRS Report RL30795, General

Management Laws: A Selective Compendium — 107th Congress, by Ronald C. Moe.

65

General Accounting Office, Information Resources Management: Comprehensive

Strategic Plan Needed to Address Mounting Challenges, GAO-02-292, Feb. 22, 2002.

66

For a summary of this trend, see General Accounting Office, Paperwork Reduction Act:

Record Increase in Agencies’ Burden Estimates, GAO-03-691T, April 11, 2003.

67

Independent regulatory agencies can, by majority vote, void any OIRA disapproval of a

proposed collection of information. Also, OIRA disapproval does not overrule a specific

statutory requirement that certain information be collected.

CRS-28

paperwork issues.68 It also directed agencies to make a special effort to reduce

information collection burdens for small businesses with fewer than 25 employees,

and established a task force to study the feasibility of streamlining information

collection requirements on small businesses. The task force delivered its first report

in June 2003,69 and its final report is due in June 2004.

Statutory reforms have been introduced in each Congress in an attempt to

address paperwork requirements in particular areas. For example, in the 108th

Congress, H.R. 464, the “IDEA Paperwork Reduction Act of 2003,” was intended to

“provide relief to teachers, administrators, and related service providers from

excessive paperwork burden”required under the Individuals with Disabilities Act.

Other bills have focused on such issues as the suspension of fines under certain

circumstances for first-time paperwork violations for small businesses.

Initiatives Focusing on Small Entities

A number of regulatory reforms implemented in recent decades have attempted

to get agencies to recognize the effect that their rules can have on small businesses

and other small entities. Advocates of these initiatives note the important role that

small entities play in the economy (e.g., about 50% of the gross domestic product)

and point to research indicating that small entities are disproportionately affected by

federal regulations.70 Others indicate, however, that special regulatory treatment of

small entities is “both unjustified and socially destructive.”71

Although there have been some presidential initiatives in this area,72 most of the

significant rulemaking requirements affecting small entities have been imposed by

Congress. As noted previously, the Regulatory Flexibility Act of 1980 requires

agencies to examine the effects of their rules on small entities and, if the agency

concluded the rule had a “significant economic effect on a substantial number of

small entities,” to conduct a regulatory flexibility analysis. The act gives regulatory

agencies substantial discretion to decide when these analytical requirements are

triggered. Other previously mentioned reforms focusing on small entities include the

“look back” requirement in section 610 of the RFA and the requirements in the Small

68

OMB posted compliance assistance resources and points of contact on its website at

[http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/infocoll.html#sbpra].

69

To view a copy of this report, see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/

sbpr2003.pdf].

70

U.S. Small Business Administration, Office of the Chief Counsel for Advocacy, The

Changing Burden of Regulation, Paperwork, and Tax Compliance on Small Business: A

Report to Congress (Washington: GPO, 1995).

71

Richard J. Pierce, Jr., “Small Is Not Beautiful: The Case Against Special Regulatory

Treatment of Small Firms,” Administrative Law Review, vol. 50 (Summer 1998), pp. 537578.

72

For example, Executive Order 13272 on “Proper Consideration of Small Entities in

Agency Rulemaking” (67 Federal Register 53461, Aug. 16, 2002), among other things,

required agencies to issue written procedures and policies to ensure that the potential

impacts of draft rules on small entities are properly considered during rulemaking.

CRS-29

Business Paperwork Relief Act (e.g., a single point of contact for small businesses

regarding paperwork).

A number of statutory reforms directed at small entities’ concerns were included

in the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act of 1996 (SBREFA).

Perhaps most notably, SBREFA amended the RFA and permitted judicial review of

agencies’ compliance with initial and final regulatory flexibility analysis

requirements, their use of the “no significant impact” exclusion, and compliance with

the “look back” requirement in section 610. (The original RFA prohibited judicial

review.) As discussed below, other SBREFA provisions included requirements that

agencies develop compliance guides for small entities, provide small entities with

penalty relief, permit more equal access to justice, and ensure that small entities’

interests are represented on boards and panels involved in the rulemaking process.

Compliance Guides and Other Guidance. Section 212 of SBREFA

requires agencies to publish one or more compliance guides for each rule or group

of related rules for which the agency is required to prepare a final regulatory

flexibility analysis under the RFA. Because this provision in SBREFA was built on

the RFA, all of the discretion inherent in the RFA regarding whether to do an analysis

also applies to whether compliance guides must be developed. For example, if the

agency concludes that the final rule would not, in its opinion, have a “significant”

impact on a “substantial” number of small entities, the agency is not required to

prepare a compliance guide. When they are prepared, section 212 requires the guides

to be published, to be designated as “small entity compliance guides,” and to explain

the actions a small entity is required to take to comply with the associated final rule.

In other areas, though, section 212 gives agencies broad discretion. For example, the

statute says agencies “may” prepare separate guides covering groups or classes of

similarly affected small entities, and “may” cooperate with associations of small

entities to develop and distribute the guides. Agencies are given “sole discretion” in

the use of plain language in the guides, and the statute does not indicate when the

guides must be developed or how they must be published. Therefore, under section

212, an agency could develop a compliance guide years after a final rule is published

with no input from small entities. In 2001, GAO reviewed agencies’ implementation

of section 212 and concluded that the requirement did not appear to have had much

of an impact on agencies’ rulemaking actions.73

Section 213 of SBREFA requires federal agencies regulating the activities of

small entities to establish a program for responding to inquiries concerning

compliance with applicable statutes and regulations. The section also says that in any

civil or administrative action against a small entity, such guidance “may be

considered as evidence of the reasonableness or appropriateness of any proposed

fines, penalties or damages sought against such small entity.”

Penalty Relief. By the mid-1990s, concerns were being expressed about the

impact that civil penalties can have on small businesses and other small entities,

particularly for infractions that may be relatively minor in nature. In April 1995,

73

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Reform: Compliance Guide Requirement Has Had

Little Effect on Agency Practices, GAO-02-172, Dec. 28, 2001.

CRS-30

President Clinton issued a memorandum directing the heads of 27 departments and

agencies to modify the penalties for small businesses “to the extent permitted by

law.74 For example, the memorandum said agencies “shall exercise their enforcement

discretion to waive the imposition of all or a portion of a penalty when the violation

is corrected within a time period appropriate to the violation in question.” The

memorandum also directed each agency to submit a plan to the Director of OMB

describing the actions the agency would take, and said the plans should identify how

notification of the agencies’ policies would be given to frontline workers and small

businesses.

Similar requirements were included in SBREFA, which was enacted less than

a year later in March 1996. Section 223 of SBREFA, entitled “Rights of Small

Entities in Enforcement Actions,” requires agencies to provide small entities with

some form of relief from civil monetary penalties. Specifically, the statute requires

federal agencies regulating the activities of small entities to establish a policy or

program by the end of March 1997 for the reduction and, under appropriate

circumstances, the waiver of civil penalties on small entities. It also required

agencies to submit a one-time report to four congressional committees by the end of

March 1998 on the scope of their programs or policies and the implementation of

their penalty reduction efforts. Section 223 also gave federal agencies substantial

discretion in how these requirements were to be carried out. In 2001 GAO examined

the implementation of section 223 and determined that the agencies were using that

discretion extensively.75 For example, some of the agencies’ policies covered only

certain civil penalty enforcement actions, and some of the policies gave small entities

no more penalty relief than large entities. The agencies also varied in how key terms

were defined and in their conditions and exclusions. GAO made several

recommendations to strengthen penalty relief and improve congressional oversight.

Ombudsman and Fairness Boards. Section 222 of SBREFA amended

the Small Business Act (15 U.S.C. 631 et seq.) to require the SBA Administrator to

designate a “Small Business and Agriculture Regulatory Enforcement Ombudsman,”

who was directed to work with each agency to ensure that small business concerns

have an opportunity to comment on agencies’ enforcement actions. The ombudsman

was directed to annually evaluate and report on each agency’s enforcement activities,

including a rating of the “responsiveness to small business” of each agency’s regional

and program offices. Section 222 also required the Administrator to establish a

“Small Business Regulatory Fairness Board” in each SBA regional office to report

to and advise the ombudsman on “excessive enforcement actions of agencies against

small business concerns.

Equal Access to Justice Act Amendments. The Equal Access to Justice

Act (28 U.S.C. 2412 and 5 U.S.C. 504) was originally enacted in 1980 to allow

certain parties to recover attorney’s fees from the government in civil actions and

74

U.S. President (Clinton), “Regulatory Reform-Waiver of Penalties and Reduction of

Reports,” Memorandum of April 21, 1995, Code of Federal Regulations, vol. 3 (1996), pp.

474-475.

75

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Reform: Implementation of Selected Agencies’

Civil Penalty Relief Policies for Small Entities, GAO-01-280, Feb. 20, 2001.

CRS-31

administrative adjudication. Subtitle C (sections 231 and 232) of SBREFA amended

this act in three ways: (1) raising the hourly cap on attorneys fees to $125 per hour,

(2) generally permitting eligible parties to claim fees and other expenses related to

defending against demands “substantially in excess of the judgment finally obtained”

(not just if they prevailed in the case) and, (3) in these “excessive demand” cases,

expanding the definition of an eligible party to include small entities as defined in the

RFA.76

Advocacy Review Panels. Section 244 of SBREFA put in place special

requirements for proposed rules issued by EPA and OSHA. EPA and OSHA are

required to convene “advocacy review panels” before publishing a regulatory

flexibility analysis for a proposed rule. Specifically, the agency issuing the regulation

(OSHA or EPA) must notify the SBA Chief Counsel for Advocacy and provide

information on the draft rule’s potential impacts on small entities and the type of

small entities that might be affected. The Chief Counsel then must identify

representatives of affected small entities within 15 days of the notification. The

review panel must consist of full-time federal employees from the rulemaking

agency, OMB, and SBA’s Chief Counsel for Advocacy. During the panel process,

the panel must collect the advice and recommendations of representatives of affected

small entities about the potential impact of the draft rule. The panel must report on

the comments received and on the panel’s recommendations no later than 60 days

after the panel is convened, and the panel’s report must be made public as part of the

rulemaking record. An agency may or may not adopt the panel’s recommendations.

GAO examined the initial implementation of these requirements and reported that the

participants generally agreed that the panels were worthwhile, but suggested several

changes to make them work better.77

Information Quality and Peer Review

A relatively recent emphasis from advocates of regulatory reform has been a

focus on the quality of the underlying information that federal agencies use to

develop their rules or otherwise disseminate to the public. The most significant

development in this area has been the enactment of section 515 of the Treasury and

General Government Appropriations Act for Fiscal Year 2001, generally known as

the “Information Quality Act” (IQA) or the “Data Quality Act.”78 The IQA amended

the Paperwork Reduction Act and directed OMB to issue government-wide

guidelines that “provide policy and procedural guidance to Federal agencies for

ensuring and maximizing the quality, objectivity, utility, and integrity of information

76

See SBA Office of Advocacy, The Equal Access to Justice Act and Small Business —

Analysis and Critique, Aug. 10, 2001.

77

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Reform: Implementation of the Small Business

Advocacy Review Panel Requirements, GAO/GGD-98-36, Mar. 18, 1996.

78

For a more complete discussion of the IQA, see CRS Report RL32532, The Information

Quality Act: OMB’s Guidance and Initial Implementation, by Curtis W. Copeland and

Michael Simpson.

CRS-32

(including statistical information) disseminated by Federal agencies.”79 OMB’s

guidelines define “dissemination” as “agency initiated or sponsored distribution of

information to the public,” and specifically indicates that this includes risk

assessments prepared by an agency to “inform the agency’s formulation of possible

regulatory or other action.” The guidelines also define such terms as “quality,”

“utility,” “objectivity,” and “integrity.”

The IQA also instructed all agencies (both Cabinet departments and independent

agencies as well as independent regulatory agencies) to issue their own guidelines not

more than one year after the issuance of OMB’s government-wide guidelines, and to

establish administrative mechanisms allowing affected persons to seek and obtain

correction of information maintained and disseminated by the agency.80 Finally, the

act required agencies to report periodically to the Director of OMB on the number

and nature of complaints received and how such complaints were handled by the

agency. The first agency reports were due by January 1, 2004.

The IQA builds upon existing agency responsibilities to assure the quality of

information collected, used, or disseminated to the public.81 Proponents of the act

contend that the law and the OMB and agency guidelines will improve the quality of

agency science and regulation and force agencies to regulate based on the best

science available. Some of these proponents also maintain that the act will help

agencies defend their regulations against lawsuits and reduce the number of lawsuits

filed. They also point out that, in any requests for correction of information, the IQA

places the burden of proof on the affected parties making the request; they must

demonstrate that a specific dissemination does not meet the standards of either the

OMB guidelines or the agency-specific guidelines.

On the other hand, opponents of the act and the guidelines contend they may

have a chilling effect on agency distribution and use of scientific information. These

opponents foresee a flood of data quality challenges, correction requests, and court

suits on a wide range of scientific issues, which may tie up agency resources and

significantly delay health, safety, and environmental regulations. Opponents have

also noted that, since “quality” is a subjective term and some regulations are based

on “best available data,” regulations could be arbitrarily rejected under this new law.

79

OMB published those government-wide guidelines in interim form on Sept. 28, 2001, and

in updated final form on Feb. 22, 2002. See Office of Management and Budget, “Guidelines

for Ensuring and Maximizing the Quality, Objectivity, Utility, and Integrity of Information

Disseminated by Federal Agencies; Republication,” Federal Register, vol. 67, no. 36, Feb.

22, 2002, p. 8452. To view a copy of these guidelines, see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/

fedreg/reproducible2.pdf].

80

Links to agencies’ guidelines are available at [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/

agency_info_quality_links.html].

81

For example, Public Law 105-277 (popularly known as the Shelby amendment) directed

OMB to revise its Circular A-110 to make data from federally funded research governed by

the circular available to the public through the Freedom of Information Act. For a

discussion of this requirement, see CRS Report RL30376, Public Access to Data From

Federally Funded Research: OMB Circular A-110 and Issues for Congress, by Eric A.

Fischer and Genevieve J. Knezo.

CRS-33

Implementation. The conference report on H.R. 2673, the Consolidated

Appropriations Act of 2004, indicated that the conferees were “concerned that

agencies are not complying fully with the requirements of the [IQA],” and directed

OMB to submit a report to the House and Senate Committees on Appropriations by

June 1, 2004, on whether agencies had been “properly responsive” to public requests

for correction of information pursuant to the IQA.82 The conference report also said

that OMB should suggest changes to the act or to OMB’s guidelines to “improve the

accuracy and transparency of agency science.” In April 2004, OMB provided

Congress with a report on the implementation of the IQA during FY2003.83 The

report said that agencies received only about 35 substantive correction requests

during the year, and said it was “premature to make broad statements about both the

impact of the correction request process and the overall responsiveness of the

agencies.” Many other correction requests listed in the report were on minor issues

or involved matters that had been dealt with before the IQA was enacted. OMB

indicated that the correction requests came from all segments of society, and said

there was no evidence that the IQA had affected the pace of rulemaking. However,

OMB Watch (a public interest group) said OMB’s report was “seriously flawed” in

that it understated the number of correction requests and did not disclose that nearly

three-quarters of the requests were from industry.84

Judicial Review. Some observers see judicial review as the crucial test of the

act’s future effectiveness. If judicial review is permitted, agencies may find

themselves subject to potentially endless legal challenges to their regulations and

other types of information disseminations, which could make them less likely to issue

similar regulations in the future. On the other hand, the absence of judicial review

may encourage agencies to pay less attention to the IQA and make them more subject

to administrative directives provided by OMB. In the first IQA-related case to be

addressed by a court, on June 21, 2004, a U.S. District Court ruled that the act does

not permit judicial review regarding an agency’s compliance with its provisions.85

On June 25, 2004 — four days after the above court decision — the Department

of Justice filed a brief recommending the dismissal of a lawsuit filed under the IQA

by the Chamber of Commerce and the Salt Institute against the National Heart, Lung,

and Blood Institute within the National Institutes of Health. The brief said that the

plaintiffs lacked standing to challenge the agency’s underlying study on sodium

consumption, and also said that there was no statutory basis for the court to review

the agency’s action because the IQA does not permit judicial review.

On November 15, 2004, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of

Virginia (Alexandria Division) ruled in this case that the Salt Institute and the

82

“Implementation of the Federal Data Quality Act,” Congressional Record, daily edition,

vol. 149 (Nov. 25, 2003), p. H12699.

83

For a copy of this

fy03_info_quality_rpt.pdf].

84

85

report,

see

[http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/

For a copy of this report, see [http://www.ombwatch.org/infor/dataqualityreport.pdr].

In re: Operation of the Missouri River Sys. Litig., No. 03-MD-1555 at 49 (D. Minn. June

21, 2004) (order granting motions for summary judgment).

CRS-34

Chamber of Commerce lacked standing to sue (e.g., they had suffered no “injury in

fact”), and that judicial review of the agency’s decisionmaking was not available.

Specifically, the court ruled that there is no private right of action under the IQA,

saying that the “language in the IQA reflects Congress’s intent that any challenges

to the quality of information disseminated by federal agencies should take place in

administrative proceedings before federal agencies and not the courts.”86 The court

also said that judicial review under the APA was not available because the agency’s

actions did not constitute a “final agency action,” and because the agency decisions

were within the discretion provided to the agency by law.87

Peer Review. In a development closely related to the issue of data quality,

OMB published a proposed bulletin in September 2003 on “Peer Review and

Information Quality” that would have, if made final, provided a standardized process

by which all significant regulatory information would be peer reviewed.88 The

authorities that OMB cited for this action were the IQA, the PRA, and Executive

Order 12866. “Regulatory information”was defined in the bulletin as any scientific

or technical study that “might” be used by federal, state, local, or international

regulatory bodies.

Specifically, the bulletin proposed requiring each federal agency (each executive

agency and independent regulatory agency) to take three actions: (1) have all

“significant regulatory information” that it intends to disseminate peer reviewed

(with information defined as “significant” if OMB determines that it will have a

clear and substantial impact on important public policies or private sector decisions);

(2) have “especially significant regulatory information” subject to the above

requirements peer reviewed according to even higher standards (with information

deemed “especially significant” if, among other things, it supports a regulatory action

with a $100 million or more impact on the economy or “is relevant to an

Administration policy priority”); and (3) provide OMB at least once each year with

information about upcoming significant regulatory disseminations and the agency’s

plans for conducting peer reviews. The proposed bulletin also said agencies that are

likely to disseminate “significant” or “especially significant” regulatory information

must supplement or amend their data quality guidelines to incorporate the

requirements of the proposed peer review bulletin for “significant” and “especially

significant” information. The proposed bulletin indicated that OMB could waive the

requirements for peer review if an agency makes “a compelling case” that a waiver

is necessary (e.g., an imminent health hazard or homeland security threat).

OMB received 187 comments from the public and other agencies on its August

2003 proposed peer review bulletin, with some supporting its issuance in final and

86

Salt Institute and the Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America v. Tommy

G. Thompson, Secretary, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Civil Action No.

04-359, Nov. 15, 2004, p. 24.

87

The APA (5 USC701(a)(2)) expressly prohibits judicial review when the agency action

is “committed to agency discretion by law.”

88

Office of Management and Budget, Executive Office of the President, “Proposed Bulletin

on Peer Review and Information Quality,” Federal Register, vol. 68, no. 178, Sept. 15,

2003, p. 54023.

CRS-35

others calling for its withdrawal and reconsideration. On April 15, 2004, OMB

published a revised bulletin, and again asked the public for comments.89 The

revisions would, if made final:

!

focus the bulletin’s coverage on “influential” scientific information,

not just “regulatory” information;

!

narrow the scope of the section describing the characteristics of peer

review for the most important types of information so that it covers

only “scientific assessments” (not all influential information) that,

among other things, have a $500 million annual impact (rather than

a $100 impact on the economy).

!

clarify that regulatory impact analyses are not covered by the

bulletin, but the models and data underlying them are covered;

!

clarify that the bulletin does not cover information products released

by government-funded scientists unless it represents an official view

of a federal department or agency;

!

specify that the responsibility for determining the need for a waiver

from the bulletin’s peer review requirements in the event of an

emergency or otherwise “compelling need” rests with the agencies;

!

provide agencies with greater flexibility (e.g., in determining the

appropriate intensity of peer review, when the comments of specific

reviewers should be disclosed, and in the use of alternative scientific

procedures); and

!

clarify that researchers that receive research grants based on

“investigator-initiated, peer reviewed competitions” can still serve

as peer reviewers.

On December 15, 2004, OMB published a final version of the peer review

bulletin on its website.90 The final bulletin was published in the Federal Register on

January 14, 2005.91 OMB said this version reflects “minor revisions” made in

response to more than 50 comments from the public on the revised bulletin. For

example, the final bulletin requires agencies to disclose the names of peer reviewers

89

For a copy of the revised peer review bulletin, see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/

omb/inforeg/peer_review041404.pdf]. For a summary of the public and agency comments

provided regarding the first bulletin, see [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/

peer_review_comment.pdf]. Copies of the comments can be viewed at [http://www.

whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/2003iq/iq_list.html].

90

Office of Management and Budget, Final Information Quality Bulletin for Peer Review,

Dec. 15, 2004, available at [http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/inforeg/peer2004/peer_

bulletin.pdf].

91

Office of Management and Budget, Final Information Quality Bulletin for Peer Review,

70 Federal Register 2664 (Jan. 14, 2005).

CRS-36

to the public and adds an annual reporting requirement to allow OMB to track how

agencies are using the bulletin. However, agencies are still afforded substantial

discretion to determine when and what type of peer review is required. OMB also

retains substantial discretion in certain areas.

OMB and supporters of the peer review bulletin indicate that peer review

standards across the government are currently inconsistent, and that more consistent

use of peer review can increase the technical quality and credibility of regulatory

science.92 They also assert that peer review can protect science-based regulations

from political criticism and litigation. Opponents view the bulletin as an effort to

inject political considerations into the world of science and to use the uncertainty that

inevitably surrounds science as an excuse to delay new rules that could cost regulated

entities millions or even billions of dollars. They also expressed concerns regarding

the need for the bulletin and OMB’s authority to issue it.

Electronic Rulemaking

Federal agencies have recently initiated a number of efforts to use information

technology (IT) in their rulemaking and other regulatory processes. The impetus for

some of these efforts were congressional or presidential directives to better utilize IT

in a range of administrative areas, but many were started at the initiative of career

officials involved in the rulemaking process.

Presidential Initiatives. In its September 1993 report, the National

Performance Review recommended increased use of information technology to

increase opportunities for early, frequent, and interactive public participation in the

rulemaking process. Shortly thereafter, an interagency Regulatory Working Group

(established by Executive Order 12866) created a subgroup on information

technology and rulemaking. By December 1994, several agencies (including the

Nuclear Regulatory Commission and the Department of Agriculture’s Animal and

Plant Health Inspection Service) were accepting comments on proposed rules through

electronic bulletin boards. For example, the Department of Labor (DOL) used

electronic bulletin boards to support a negotiated regulatory process developing rules

to protect workers building steel structures.

In the next several years, many federal agencies used IT in the rulemaking

process to varying degrees. Many of these efforts centered on the facilitation of

public participation in rulemaking.93 Most notably, the Department of Transportation

developed its “Docket Management System,” an electronic, image-based database

covering every agency and every rulemaking within the department. The system

permitted electronic comments and access to regulatory supporting materials (e.g.,

92

In a September 20, 2001, memorandum to the President’s Management Council, the OIRA

Administrator previously indicated that, during its reviews of agencies’ draft rules under

Executive Order 12866, it would give a “measure of deference” to regulatory analyses that

had been peer reviewed.

93

For a discussion of these as of June 2000, see General Accounting Office, Federal

Rulemaking: Agencies’ Use of Information Technology to Facilitate Public Participation,

GAO/GGD-00-135R, June 30, 2000.

CRS-37

economic analyses, comments of others) for all rules. Other agencies’ IT initiatives

focused on other aspects of regulatory management (e.g., compliance assistance,

information collection and dissemination, and regulatory enforcement).94 For

example, DOL developed a sophisticated set of interactive advisors on the Internet

to help workers and small businesses understand their rights and responsibilities

under federal employment laws and regulations.

In July 2001, President Bush identified the expansion of e-government as one

of the five priorities of his management agenda. To support this priority, OMB

developed an implementation strategy that identified 24 e-government initiatives, one

of which was e-rulemaking. This initiative is intended to provide a single portal for

businesses and citizens to access the federal rulemaking process and comment on

proposed rules. In May 2002, the Director of OMB sent a memorandum to the heads

of executive departments and agencies advising them of “our intention to consolidate

redundant IT systems relating to the President’s on-line rulemaking initiative,” and

indicated that consolidation of those systems could save millions of dollars. In late

2002, EPA was named lead agency for the e-rulemaking initiative. In January 2003,

the Bush Administration launched the “Regulations.gov” website as the first module

of its e-rulemaking initiative. The website permits the public to identify proposed

rules that are open for comment government-wide, and permits the public to

comment electronically on those rules.95 Although OMB indicated in March 2004

that Regulations.gov was being accessed by the public more than 15,000 times per

month (e.g., to locate rules open for comment), other data indicated that fewer than

50 electronic comments per month were received from the public via the website in

its first 10 months of operation.

The second module of the e-rulemaking initiative is intended to create one or

more electronic dockets for proposed and final rules, thereby allowing the public to

access regulatory supporting materials and the comments of others from one website.

EPA indicated that the e-rulemaking team would test a centralized, governmentwide

online docket in the fall of 2004 in four or five agencies, with full implementation

expected in early 2005.

Congressional Initiatives. Congress has also taken numerous steps in recent

years to encourage federal agencies to use IT in carrying out their missions. Some

of these efforts have been specifically directed at the regulatory process, while others

had an indirect effect on that process. For example, in 1998, Congress enacted the

Government Paperwork Elimination Act (GPEA) (44 U.S.C. 3504 note), which

required that, by October 21, 2003, Federal agencies provide the public, when

practicable, with the option of submitting, maintaining, and disclosing information

electronically, instead of on paper. GPEA makes OMB responsible for ensuring that

federal agencies meet the act’s implementation deadline. Although the act did not

94

For a discussion of the use of IT in regulatory management as of February 2001, see

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Management: Communication about TechnologyBased Innovations Can Be Improved, GAO-01-232, Feb. 12, 2001.

95

For a comparison of the Regulations.gov website with individual agency systems, see

General Accounting Office, Electronic Rulemaking: Efforts to Facilitate Public

Participation Can Be Improved, GAO-03-901, Sept. 17, 2003.

CRS-38

specifically mention rulemaking, both OMB and rulemaking agencies have indicated

that its requirements provided an impetus for developing IT-based approaches to

regulatory management.

The E-Government Act of 2002 (44 U.S.C.A. 3601 note) has been described as

“the most far-reaching federal government effort to date for promoting online public

involvement,”96 and contains requirements specific to rulemaking. Section 206 of

the act requires agencies, to the extent practicable, to accept public comments on

proposed rules “by electronic means.” That section also requires agencies (again, to

the extent practicable) to ensure that a publicly accessible federal website contains

“electronic dockets” for their proposed rules containing all comments submitted on

the rules as well as “other materials that by agency rule or practice are included in the

rulemaking docket under (the APA), whether or not submitted electronically.” The

E-Government Act also requires agencies to conduct a “privacy impact assessment”

before initiating a new collection of information that uses information technology and

contains individually identifying information. In addition, the act established an

Office of Electronic Government within OMB, headed by an Administrator

appointed by the President. It requires the Administrator of that office to work with

the Administrator of OIRA in establishing the strategic direction of the e-government

program, and to oversee its implementation.

Other Regulatory Reform Initiatives

A number of other regulatory reform initiatives have been undertaken in recent

decades, including efforts to encourage agencies to (1) recognize the effect that their

rules have on federalism and private property rights, (2) develop rules through

negotiations with affected parties, (3) write their rules using plain language.

Federalism. Both Congress and various Presidents have put in place reforms

intended to ensure that federal agencies take the interests of state, local, and tribal

governments into consideration as they develop rules. The effectiveness of these

requirements, however, is questionable. As mentioned in an earlier section of this

report, the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act requires federal agencies to analyze their

rules and prepare a written statement when their rules require $100 million in

expenditures by state, local, or tribal governments, in the aggregate. GAO

concluded, however, that this requirement applies to few rules and requires little

beyond what the agencies were already required to do.97

In 1987, President Reagan issued Executive Order 12612 on “Federalism,”

which established a set of fundamental principles and criteria for executive

departments and agencies to use when formulating and implementing policies that

96

Thomas C. Beierle, Discussing the Rules: Electronic Rulemaking and Democratic

Deliberation, Discussion Paper 03-22 (Washington: Resources for the Future, 2003).

97

GAO/GGD-98-30, Unfunded Mandates: Reform Act Has Had Little Effect on Agencies’

Rulemaking Efforts.

CRS-39

have federalism implications.98 The executive order also required federal agencies

to prepare a “federalism assessment” whenever the responsible agency official

determines that a proposed policy had sufficient federalism implications to warrant

the preparation of the assessment. The assessment was required to contain certain

elements (e.g., identifying the extent to which the policy would impose additional

costs or burdens on the states), and was to accompany any rule submitted to OMB for

review under Executive Order 12866. GAO examined the implementation of

Executive Order 12612 and concluded that, like UMRA, it had little effect on agency

rulemaking.99 Agencies prepared few federalism assessments, even when the rules

preempted state or local law. In 1999, President Clinton issued Executive Order

13132 on “Federalism,” which revoked Executive Order 12612. Like its predecessor,

though, the new executive order provides agencies with substantial flexibility to

determine which of their actions have “federalism implications” and, therefore, when

they should prepare a “federalism summary impact statement.”

Private Property Rights. Each year federal agencies issue a number of

regulatory actions that can affect the use of private property, such as limiting the

development of land that includes critical wildlife habitat or wetlands. In such

“takings” cases, the property owner may be owed just compensation under the Fifth

Amendment to the Constitution. To obtain compensation, a property owner claiming

that a regulatory action has effected a taking must initiate a lawsuit against the

government.

In 1988, President Reagan issued Executive Order 12630, which addressed this

subject.100 The stated purpose of the order was to ensure that regulations and other

government actions are undertaken on a well-reasoned basis with due regard for the

potential financial impacts imposed on the government by the just compensation

clause of the Fifth Amendment. The executive order requires executive branch

agencies, among other things, to (1) consider the potential takings implications of

their proposed actions and to document significant takings implications in notices of

proposed rulemaking, (2) designate an agency official responsible for implementing

the order, (3) prepare annual compilations of awards of just compensation resulting

from landowner lawsuits alleging takings, and (4) account for takings awards levied

against them in their annual budget submissions. The order also required the

Department of Justice to issue guidelines on the implementation of its requirements.

In December 1998, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) reported that of the

thousands of actions that agencies take each year that could affect property rights or

values, agencies prepare only a few takings analyses.101 CBO concluded that

agencies have considerable discretion in preparing the analyses, and rely on only a

few arguments to justify their conclusions. As a result, CBO concluded that the

98

Executive Order 12612, “Federalism,” 52 Federal Register 41685, Oct. 30, 1987.

99

General Accounting Office, Federalism: Previous Initiatives Have Little Effect on Agency

Rulemaking GAO/T-GGD-99-131 (Washington: June 3, 1999).

100

Executive Order 12630, “Governmental Actions and Interference with Constitutionally

Protected Property Rights,” 53 Federal Register 8859, Mar. 18, 1988.

101

Congressional Budget Office, Regulatory Takings and Proposals for Change, Dec. 1998.

CRS-40

requirements in Executive Order 12630 for takings analyses “does little to assuage

the public’s concerns that agencies may fail to consider the effects of their proposed

actions on private property rights.”

In September 2003, GAO examined the implementation of this executive order

and reported that some agencies and judicial experts believed that the Justice

Department’s 1988 guidelines needed to be updated.102 GAO also reported that OMB

issued guidance in 1994 informing agencies that information on just compensation

awards no longer needed to be compiled or reported, and that the executive order’s

requirement that agencies consider the takings implications of their actions applied

to relatively few cases and often were not documented.103

In the mid-1990s, several bills were introduced (either as part of comprehensive

regulatory reform legislation or separately) that would have required the federal

government to compensate property owners if a regulation restricted the use of the

land by a certain amount (e.g., 10% or 50%). These bills were not enacted.

Negotiated Rulemaking. The concept of negotiated rulemaking (sometimes

referred to as regulatory negotiation or “reg-neg”) emerged in the 1980s as a

supplement to the traditional procedure for developing regulations.104 In 1982, the

Administrative Conference of the United States established criteria identifying

rulemaking situations in which negotiated rulemaking is likely to be successful.105

In 1990, Congress enacted the Negotiated Rulemaking Act of 1990 (5 U.S.C. 561570a), and the act was amended and permanently authorized in 1996 (110 Stat.

3870). The act encourages (but does not require) agencies to consider convening a

negotiated rulemaking committee before developing and issuing a proposed

regulation under the Administrative Procedure Act. The committee, composed of

representatives of the agency and the various interest groups that would be affected

by the proposed regulation, addresses the issues involved in the hope that it can reach

agreement on the contents of a proposed regulation. The agency can, if it agrees,

then issue the agreement as a proposed rule, and eventually a final rule under existing

APA requirements. Any proposal agreed to by the negotiated rulemaking committee

is not, however, binding on the agency or other parties. The act also generally

requires that the committee consist of at least one member of the agency and no more

than 25 members, that the agency select an impartial “facilitator” to chair meetings,

and that an agreement on any negotiated rulemaking must be unanimous. The act

102

General Accounting Office, Regulatory Takings: Implementation of Executive Order on

Government Actions Affecting Private Property Use, GAO-03-1015, Sept. 19, 2003.

103

For related reports, see CRS Report RL31796, The Endangered Species Act and Claims

of Property Rights “Takings”: A Summary of the Court Decisions, by Robert Meltz; and

CRS Report 97-122, Takings Decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court: A Chronology, by

Robert Meltz.

104

For a more complete discussion of negotiated rulemaking, see CRS Report RL32452,

Negotiated Rulemaking, by Curtis W. Copeland.

105

See Office of the Chairman, Administrative Conference of the United States, Negotiated

Rulemaking Sourcebook (Washington: GPO, Sept. 1995). This volume also contains a

wealth of other information related to negotiated rulemaking.

CRS-41

allows agencies to pay reasonable travel and per diem expenses, and reasonable

compensation, to committee members under certain conditions.

Negotiated rulemaking has also been encourage through presidential initiatives.

For example, in September 1993, Executive Order 12866 directed agencies to

“explore and, where appropriate, use consensual mechanisms for developing

regulations, including negotiated rulemaking.” Also in September 1993, the President

ordered executive branch agencies to submit to OIRA within 90 days a list of

regulations for which they planned to use negotiated rulemaking.106

Although the use of negotiated rulemaking was expected to improve rulemaking

timeliness and reduce litigation, an examination of agencies’ efforts in this area

indicates that those expectations are not being fulfilled.107 Another study, however,

indicated that negotiated rulemaking can improve participants’ perception of the final

rule and of the overall process.108

Plain Language. One problem that regulated entities have frequently cited is

a lack of clarity in the rules that federal agencies publish. The rules often use legally

precise but sometimes unintelligible language to convey what they require and how

to comply. Several regulatory reform initiatives in recent decades have attempted to

address this problem. For example, section 1 of President Carter’s Executive Order

12044 said that regulations should be “as simple and clear as possible.” More

recently, one of the “principles of regulation” in Executive Order 12866 is that “each

agency shall draft its regulations to be simple and easy to understand, with the goal

of minimizing the potential for uncertainty and litigation arising from such

uncertainty.” On June 1, 1998, President Clinton reemphasized this issue by sending

a memorandum to the heads of executive departments and agencies directing them

to use “plain language” in all proposed and final rulemaking documents published

in the Federal Register for the first time after January 1, 1999. The memo also

suggested that the agencies rewrite existing regulations in plain language “when you

have the opportunity and resources to do so.” The Office of the Vice President and

the Office of the Federal Register subsequently developed guidance on how to

comply with the memorandum and provided a list of related resources. Some

individual agencies have published revised “plain language” regulations, sometimes

in a “question and answer” format designed to facilitate understanding of the rules’

requirements.

106

U.S. President (Clinton), “Negotiated Rulemaking,” Memorandum of Sept. 30, 1993,

Code of Federal Regulations, vol. 3 (1994), p. 776.

107

Cary Coglianese, “Assessing Consensus: The Promise and Performance of Negotiated

Rulemaking,” Duke University Law Journal, vol. 46 (1997), pp. 1255-1349.

108

Laura I. Langbein and Cornelius M. Kerwin, “Regulatory Negotiation versus

Conventional Rulemaking: Claims, Counterclaims, and Empirical Evidence,” Journal of

Public Administration Research and Theory, vol. 10 (2000), pp. 599-632.

CRS-42

Conclusion

Regulatory reform has taken a number of different forms in recent decades, from

requirements that agencies conduct analytical reviews in advance of a rule’s

publication to the retrospective examinations that agencies are sometimes required

to do after their rules are codified in the Federal Register. Some of the reforms were

initiated by Congress, some by Presidents, and many were prompted by both.

Regardless of the type or source of reform, an underlying theme in many of these

efforts is the minimization of regulatory burden in its various forms. The costs

associated with federal regulations are formidable, and it is generally accepted that

compliance costs should be the minimum necessary to accomplish the rules’

objectives. As OMB’s recent regulatory accounting reports indicate, though, the

benefits of federal regulations are generally viewed as greater than their costs in the

aggregate and for most of the agencies’ individual major rules. Nevertheless, it is

often unclear whether greater net benefits could be achieved through other regulatory

methods, or even whether alternatives to federal regulation would have been more

effective or efficient.

Debates concerning regulatory reform are likely to continue. Profound

differences of opinion exist among those for and against reform regarding the merits

of such analytical tools as cost-benefit analysis and risk assessment, often because

of the assumptions that underlie the analyses. Those assumptions are often necessary

because empirical data are not available to provide definitive answers to such

questions such as the extent to which humans are exposed to a particular chemical

or the level of toxicity associated with human exposure. Philosophical differences

also exist between such groups regarding the degree to which agencies should

exercise precaution in proactively regulating potential risks, from bioengineered food

to the transport of nuclear waste. The groups also differ regarding the extent to

which the health and ecological benefits expected from regulations can or even

should be monetized, and whether future health benefits should be discounted.109

Possible areas for future reform of the regulatory process are numerous but

difficult to predict. Some have mentioned the possibility of examining the statutes

that currently limit agencies’ ability to consider costs when developing rules.

Another possibility is extending the reach of executive review of rules to those issued

by independent regulatory agencies. These and other possible areas of reform are

highly controversial and likely to generate strong resistence. As mentioned

previously, regulatory reform legislation introduced in the 108th Congress includes

additional analytical requirements (privacy) and pilot tests of regulatory budgets.

Future efforts to reform either the substance of regulations or the processes by

which they are developed can be greatly informed by previous efforts. For example,

many of the analytical requirements in the statutory reforms that have been enacted

(e.g., the Regulatory Flexibility Act, the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement

109

Discounting can have a significant effect on the present value of future health benefits.

For example, in a February 2003 speech the OIRA Administrator noted that the present

value of 1,000 lives saved 50 years in the future is only 34 lives in present value when

evaluated at a 7 % discount rate.

CRS-43

Fairness Act, and the Unfunded Mandates Reform Act) focus on proposed rules or

final rules for which a notice of proposed rulemaking has been developed. About

half of all final rules, however, do not have a corresponding proposed rule, including

many of the agencies’ significant and major rules.110 Therefore, the reform

requirements automatically do not apply to about half of all rules. Also, many of the

regulatory reform statutes and executive orders do not define key terms (e.g.,

“significant economic impact” or “significant federalism implications”), thereby

permitting the agencies broad discretion to determine when the requirements apply

to their rules. Care in crafting these requirements can ensure that they achieve the

results that were intended.

Finally, the cumulative weight of federal rulemaking requirements is substantial.

Currently, dozens of statutes and executive orders govern the federal rulemaking

process, requiring numerous forms of analyses and processes before rules can take

effect. Those analytical and procedural requirements are not free,111 and the

requirements sometimes overlap or even conflict with one another (e.g., requirements

to increase public participation and to speed the development of rules). Some

observers have called for a rationalization of these rulemaking requirements,

integrating them in such a way that the overlaps and conflicting provisions are

recognized and the burden that they impose on regulatory agencies does not prevent

them from carrying out their missions. On the other hand, advocates of reform have

more commonly expressed concerns about the burden that regulatory agencies

impose on the public through their rules than the burden that reforms place on the

agencies.

110

General Accounting Office, Federal Rulemaking: Agencies Often Published Final

Actions Without Proposed Rules, GAO/GGD-98-126, Aug. 31, 1998.

111

See Congressional Budget Office, Regulatory Impact Analysis: Costs At Selected

Agencies and Implications for the Legislative Process, Mar. 1997.

CRS-44

For Additional Reading

CRS Reports

CRS Report RL32240. The Federal Rulemaking Process: An Overview, by Curtis

W. Copeland.

CRS Report RL32339. Federal Regulations: Efforts to Estimate Total Costs and

Benefits of Rules, by Curtis W. Copeland.

CRS Report RL32397. Federal Rulemaking: The Role of the Office of Information

and Regulatory Affairs, by Curtis W. Copeland.

CRS Report RL32532. The Information Quality Act: OMB’s Guidance and Initial

Implementation, by Curtis W. Copeland and Michael Simpson.

CRS Report RL31160. Disapproval of Regulations by Congress: Procedure Under

the Congressional Review Act, by Richard S. Beth.

CRS Report RL30116. Congressional Review of Agency Rulemaking: An

Assessment After Nullification of OSHA’s Ergonomics Standard, by Morton

Rosenberg.

CRS Issue Brief IB94036, The Role of Risk Analysis and Risk Management in

Environmental Protection, by Linda-Jo Schierow.

CRS Report RL30031. Environmental Risk and Cost-Benefit Analysis: A Review of

Proposed Legislative Mandates, 1993-1998, by Linda-Jo Schierow.

CRS Report RL30795. General Management Laws: A Compendium, coordinated by

Clinton T. Brass.

CRS Report RL30590. Paperwork Reduction Act Reauthorization and Government

Information Management Issues, by Harold Relyea.

CRS Report RS20058. Unfunded Mandates Reform Act Summarized, by Keith Bea

and Richard S. Beth.

CRS Report RL32452. Negotiated Rulemaking, by Curtis W. Copeland.

Other Readings

Lubbers, Jeffrey S., ed. Developments in Administrative Law and Regulatory

Practice. Chicago: American Bar Association, 2001.

——. A Guide to Federal Agency Rulemaking. Chicago: American Bar Association,

1998.

CRS-45

Selected Websites

Information regarding current and past regulatory policies and administrative

procedures is available at the following websites.

AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies

[http://www.aei.brookings.org]

Center for Regulatory Effectiveness

[http://www.thecre.com]

Government Accountability Office (GAO)

[http://www.gao.gov]

Government Printing Office (GPO)

[http://www.access.gpo.gov/nara]

OMB Watch

[http://www.ombwatch.org/regs]

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.