Appropriations for FY2001: Foreign Operations, Export Financing, and Related Programs

Congressional research reportApr 4, 2001

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Order Code RL30511

CRS Report for Congress

Received through the CRS Web

Appropriations for FY2001: Foreign Operations,

Export Financing, and Related Programs

Updated April 4, 2001

name redacted

Specialist in Foreign Affairs

Foreign Affairs, Defense, and Trade Division

Congressional Research Service ˜ The Library of Congress

Appropriations are one part of a complex federal budget process that includes budget

resolutions, appropriations (regular, supplemental, and continuing) bills, rescissions, and

budget reconciliation bills. The process begins with the President’s budget request and is

bound by the rules of the House and Senate, the Congressional Budget and Impoundment

Control Act of 1974 (as amended), the Budget Enforcement Act of 1990, and current program

authorizations.

This report is a guide to one of the 13 regular appropriations bills that Congress considers

each year. It is designed to supplement the information provided by the House and Senate

Foreign Operations Appropriations Subcommittees. It summarizes the current legislative

status of the bill, its scope, major issues, funding levels, and related legislative activity. The

report lists the key CRS staff relevant to the issues covered and related CRS products.

This report is updated as soon as possible after major legislative developments, especially

following legislative action in the committees and on the floor of the House and Senate.

NOTE: A Web version of this document with

active links is available to congressional staff at

http://www.loc.gov/crs/products/apppage.html

Appropriations for FY2001:

Foreign Operations, Export Financing, and Related

Programs

Summary

The annual Foreign Operations appropriations bill is the primary legislative

vehicle through which Congress reviews the U.S. foreign aid budget and influences

executive branch foreign policy making generally. It contains the largest share —

over two-thirds — of total U.S. international affairs spending.

President Clinton asked Congress initially to appropriate $15.1 billion for

FY2001 Foreign Operations, plus $1.25 billion in FY2000 supplemental funds.

Congress approved some of the supplemental spending in P.L. 106-246, but in

October 2000 reconsidered and approved as FY2001 emergency appropriations

portions of the FY2000 supplemental rejected earlier. Consequently, the combined

FY2000 supplemental/FY2001 regular Foreign Operations request, as it stood when

Congress debated the FY2001 Foreign Operations conference report in October,

totaled $15.45 billion. The largest program increases for FY2001 were those for the

Export-Import Bank (+26%), USAID development aid (+18%), nonproliferation,

terrorism, and demining (+44%), voluntary contributions to international

organizations (+45%), and multilateral development bank contributions (+24%).

S. 2522, as approved by the Senate on June 22, provided $13.4 billion for

FY2001 Foreign Operations Appropriations. The measure was about $65 million less

than FY2000 enacted and about $1.7 billion, or 11%, below the President’s initial

FY2001 request. A major new initiative in S. 2522 was the creation of a Global

Health account ($691 million). Population aid would have increased by $110 million

and a new set of conditions on family planning programs would have effectively

eliminated the FY2000 abortion-related restrictions.

H.R. 4811, as approved by the House on July 13, provided $13.3 billion, about

$200 million less than the FY2000 enacted, and 13% less than the President’s original

request. The bill maintained the FY2000 funding level and abortion-related

restrictions for family planning programs. At $238 million, the bill provided most of

the Administration’s FY2001 request for debt relief, but still fell well short of the

combined FY2000/2001 debt reduction request of $472 million.

On October 25, Congress approved the conference report on H.R. 4811

(H.Rept. 106-997), increasing FY2001 Foreign Operations spending to $14.9 billion,

well above levels passed earlier by either the House or Senate. The enacted

legislation (P.L. 106-429) falls about $550 million, or 3.5% below the President’s

combined FY2000 supplemental/FY2001 requests, but fully funds several top

Administration priorities, including international debt relief and global health

programs. For international family planning, Congress increased spending to $425

million, but restricted the obligation of funds until after February 15, 2001. Prior to

the release of these funds, President Bush reimposed the so-called “Mexico City”

abortion restrictions that apply to FY2001 and future U.S. family planning

appropriations

Key Policy Staff

Area of Expertise

Name

CRS Division

Tel.

Coordinator

Africa Aid

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Raymond Copson

FDT

7-....

Agency for Intl Development

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Agency for Intl Development

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

AIDS

Raymond Copson

FDT

7-....

Bosnia

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Central Asia

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Debt Relief

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Development Assistance

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Development Assistance

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Diseases

Lois McHugh

FDT

7-....

Drug Control Programs

Raphael Perl

FDT

7-....

Export-Import Bank

James Jackson

FDT

7-....

Family Planning Programs

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

International Affairs Budget

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

International Monetary Fund

Jonathan Sanford

FDT

7-....

Kosovo aid

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Middle East Assistance

Clyde Mark

FDT

7-....

Military Aid/Arms Sales

Richard Grimmett

FDT

7-....

Multilateral Development Banks

Jonathan Sanford

FDT

7-....

Nagorno-Karabakh

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Nonproliferation

Robert Shuey

FDT

7-....

North Korea/KEDO

Larry Niksch

FDT

7-....

Overseas Private Investment Corp

James Jackson

FDT

7-....

Peace Corps

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Peacekeeping

Marjorie Browne

FDT

7-....

Refugees & Humanitarian Aid

Lois McHugh

FDT

7-....

Russia/East Europe Aid

(name redacted)

FDT

7-....

Terrorism

Raphael Perl

FDT

7-....

Trade and Development Agency

Susan Epstein

FDT

7-....

U.N. Voluntary Contributions

Lois McHugh

FDT

7-....

CRS Division abbreviation: “FDT” = Foreign Affairs, Defense, and Trade Division.

Contents

Key Policy Staff . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

Most Recent Developments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1

Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1

Status . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

Foreign Operations Funding Trends . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4

Foreign Operations, the FY2000 Budget Resolution, and Section

302(b) Allocations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5

Foreign Operations Appropriations Request for FY2001 and

Congressional Consideration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7

Major Changes to Funding Proposed for FY2001 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8

Congressional Debate on Foreign Operations Spending . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

Summary of Debate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

Major Policy and Spending Issues in the

Foreign Operations Debate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15

Development Aid Policy Priorities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16

FY2001 Request . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18

Congressional action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19

Population and Family Planning Assistance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21

Family Planning and Abortion Restrictions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22

UNFPA Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25

Coercive Family Planning Practices and Peru . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25

Congressional Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25

Regional Allocations of U.S. Foreign Aid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27

Creation of the Development Fund for Africa Account . . . . . . . . . . . 29

Increased Funding for Asia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29

Modest Increases for Most Latin America Programs;

Major Counternarcotics Initiative for Colombia . . . . . . . . . . . . 30

Middle East Aid Reduced Slightly for FY2001 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30

Flat Budget Request for Russia and Other Former Soviet States;

Increase for Kosovo . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 31

Congressional Action . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33

Debt Reduction Initiatives for Poor Countries . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35

For Additional Reading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40

Selected World Wide Web Sites . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41

Appendix — Detailed Foreign Operations Accounts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42

List of Figures

Figure 1. International Affairs Budget, FY2001 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

List of Tables

Table 1. Status of Foreign Operations Appropriations, FY2001 . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

Table 2. Foreign Operations Appropriations, FY1994 to FY2000 . . . . . . . . . . . 5

Table 3. Summary of Foreign Operations Appropriations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7

Table 4. USAID Goals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17

Table 5. Funding for Selected USAID Programs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20

Table 6. Regional Allocations of U.S. Aid . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28

Table 7. Leading Recipients of U.S. Foreign Aid: FY1999 - FY2001 . . . . . . . 32

Table 8. Foreign Operations Appropriations: Discretionary Budget Authority . 42

Appropriations for FY2001:

Foreign Operations, Export Financing,

and Related Programs

Most Recent Developments

For the most controversial FY2001 Foreign Operations issue – international

family planning – Congress increased spending to $425 million. Lawmakers,

however, restricted the obligation of funds until after February 15, 2001. On

January 22, 2001, two days after taking office, President George W. Bush issued a

Memorandum to the USAID Administrator directing him to “reinstate in full all of

the requirements of the Mexico City Policy in effect on January 19, 1993.” A

separate statement from the President’s press secretary stated that President Bush

was “committed to maintaining the $425 million funding level” for population

assistance “because he knows that one of the best ways to prevent abortion is by

providing quality voluntary family planning services.” On February 15, 2001,

USAID released specific policy and contract guidelines to implement the President’s

directive. These guidelines were re-issued by the White House on March 28 in order

to block an early congressional vote to overturn the Mexico City restrictions.

Previously, on November 6, 2000, President Clinton signed into law a $14.9

billion Foreign Operations Appropriations for FY2001 (P.L. 106-429; H.R. 4811).

The spending measure includes both regular FY2001 requested programs as well as

selected FY2000 supplemental funding proposals that Congress had rejected earlier

in the year. The enacted legislation falls about $550 million, or 3.5%, below the

President’s combined FY2000 supplemental/FY2001 requests, but is substantially

higher than the roughly $13.4 billion spending measures passed by the House and

Senate during the summer. Moreover, P.L. 106-429 fully funds several top

Administration priorities, including $435 million for international debt relief under

the Heavily Indebted Poor Country (HIPC) initiative. Congress further boosted

funding for several global health programs, including $315 million for HIV/AIDS

and $60 million for malaria control.

Introduction

The annual Foreign Operations appropriations bill is the primary legislative

vehicle through which Congress reviews and votes on the U.S. foreign assistance

budget and influences executive branch foreign policy making generally.1 It contains

1

Although the Foreign Operations appropriations bill is often characterized as the “foreign

(continued...)

CRS-2

the largest share — about two-thirds — of total international affairs spending by the

United States (see Figure 1). The legislation funds all U.S. bilateral development

assistance programs, managed mostly by the U.S. Agency for International

Development (USAID), together with several smaller independent foreign aid

agencies, such as the Peace Corps and the Inter-American and African Development

Foundations. Most humanitarian aid activities are funded within Foreign Operations,

including USAID’s disaster program and State Department’s refugee relief support.2

Foreign Operations includes separate accounts for aid programs in the former Soviet

Union (also referred to as the Independent States account) and Central/Eastern

Europe, activities that are jointly managed by USAID and the State Department.

Security assistance (economic and military aid) for Israel and Egypt is also part of the

Foreign Operations spending measure, as are smaller security aid programs

administered largely by the State Department, in conjunction with USAID and the

Pentagon. U.S. contributions to the World Bank and other regional multilateral

development banks, managed by the Treasury Department, and voluntary payments

to international organizations, handled by the State Department, are also funded in the

Foreign Operations bill. Finally, the legislation includes appropriations for three

export promotion agencies: the Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC),

the Export-Import Bank, and the Trade and Development Agency.

From the perspective of congressional oversight and involvement in U.S. foreign

aid policy making, the Foreign Operations bill has taken on even greater significance

during the past 15 years. Congress has not enacted a foreign aid authorization bill

since 1985, leaving most foreign assistance programs without regular authorizations

emanating from the legislative oversight committees. As a result, Foreign Operations

spending measures developed by the appropriations committees increasingly have

expanded their scope beyond spending issues and played a major role in shaping,

authorizing, and guiding both executive and congressional foreign aid and broader

foreign policy initiatives. It has been largely through Foreign Operations

appropriations that the United States has modified aid policy and resource allocation

priorities since the end of the Cold War. The legislation has also been a key tool used

by Congress to apply restrictions and conditions on Administration management of

foreign assistance, actions that have frequently resulted in executive-legislative clashes

over presidential prerogatives in foreign policy making.

1

(...continued)

aid” spending measure, it does not include funding for all foreign assistance programs. Food

aid, administered under the P.L. 480 program and managed by USAID, is appropriated in the

Agriculture appropriations bill. Furthermore, the Foreign Operations measure includes funds

for one activity—the Export-Import Bank—that is not regarded as “foreign assistance,” but

rather as a U.S. government activity promoting trade opportunities for American businesses.

In recent years, funding for food aid and the Eximbank have been about the same, so that the

Foreign Operations appropriation and the official “foreign aid” budget are nearly identical.

Throughout this report, references to Foreign Operations and foreign aid are used

interchangeably.

2

Another international humanitarian aid program – food assistance or P.L. 480 title II grants

– is funded under the Agriculture appropriations bill.

CRS-3

Figure 1. International Affairs Budget, FY2001

Status

Table 1. Status of Foreign Operations Appropriations, FY2001

Subcommittee

Conf. Report

House House Senate Senate Conf.

Pres.

Markup

Approval

Report Passage Report Passage Report

Action

House Senate

House Senate

June

20

—

Nov. 6

June 27

May 11

Oct. 24

July 13

June 22

Oct. 25 Oct. 25 PL 106106-720

106-291

106-997

429

President Clinton submitted his FY2001 federal budget request to Congress on

February 7, 2000, including funding proposals for Foreign Operations Appropriations

programs. Subsequently, House and Senate Foreign Operations Subcommittees held

hearings, including testimony from Secretary of State Albright, Treasury Secretary

Summers, and USAID Administrator Anderson. The Senate Appropriations

Committee bypassed subcommittee markup, and ordered reported S. 2522 on May

9. Because of disputes over scheduling and the opportunity by the minority to offer

amendments to other legislation, the Senate delayed taking up S. 2522. Those

problems were settled and the Senate approved S. 2522 on June 22. The House

Foreign Operations Subcommittee marked up its companion bill, H.R. 4811, on June

20, followed by full Committee approval on June 27. The House approved H.R. 4811

on July 13 (239-185). House and Senate conferees filed a conference report for H.R.

4811 on October 24 (H.Rept. 106-997). Congress approved the report on October

CRS-4

25, the House by a vote of 307-101 and Senate by a vote of 65-27. President Clinton

signed into law H.R. 4811 on November 6, 2000 (P.L. 106-429).3

Foreign Operations Funding Trends

As the United States has adjusted its foreign and defense policy to a post-Cold

War environment, one of the major foreign assistance challenges for Congress and

executive branch policymakers has been to formulate the most effective foreign aid

program amidst a tightening resource base. A dominant characteristic of Foreign

Operations funding trends in the most recent years has been the degree to which

foreign policy contingencies and international disasters have created demands for

additional resources beyond those originally requested by the President. Congress

approved substantial amounts for FY1999 and FY2000 through “emergency” or

supplemental appropriation mechanisms, amounts that are over and above what is

enacted in “regular” Foreign Operations bills.

After peaking at $20.7 billion in FY1985, Foreign Operations appropriations

began a period of decline, falling to about $12.3 billion in FY1997. Foreign aid

spending cuts were especially sharp in FY1996 when Congress cut funding by $1.15

billion, nearly 9% from the previous year. Many government and non-government

experts argued that these budget reductions seriously undermined U.S. foreign policy

interests and limited the ability of American officials to influence overseas events.

After Foreign Operations funding levels fell again in FY1997 — although by

much smaller amounts — the State Department and other executive agencies

launched an aggressive campaign to reverse the decade-long decline in the foreign

policy budget. This effort coincided with congressional approval of a near $1 billion

increase for FY1998, setting Foreign Operations appropriations at $13.15 billion.

Foreign Operations funds rose again to $15.4 billion in FY1999 when lawmakers, at

the urging of the White House, added nearly $900 million in the final days of the 105th

Congress and another $2.1 billion for Central American hurricane relief and Kosovo

emergency assistance in supplemental funding.

Amounts enacted for FY2000 – $16.5 billion – were also augmented by late-year

“emergency” add-ons recommended by the President, including $1.8 billion for the

Wye River/Middle East peace accord and $1.1 billion supplemental assistance, mostly

for a new counternarcotics initiative in Colombia. As shown in Table 2, the amount

for FY2000 is the highest in six years and the largest funding level, in nominal terms,

for Foreign Operations since FY1985. Nevertheless, when calculated using constant

3

Subsequently, Congress enacted two additional Foreign Operations funding items as part

of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, FY2001 (H.R. 5666 enacted by reference in H.R.

4577). The first earmarks $1.35 million of funds appropriated in P.L. 106-429 for the

Protection Project to continue its study of international trafficking in women and children.

H.R. 5666 further permits the President to utilize Economic Support Funds in P.L. 106-429

for compensating China for the May 1999 U.S. bombing of its embassy in Belgrade. H.R.

4577 also requires a 0.22% reduction in most appropriations that lowers the final Foreign

Operations appropriations by about $33 million.

CRS-5

dollars – taking into account the effects of inflation – FY2000 Foreign Operations

amounts are 47% less than the high point of FY1985, 15% less than the annual

average appropriation during the late 1980s, and 3% less than FY1992, a year that

might be considered the first post-Cold War foreign aid budget. FY2000 Foreign

Operations spending level represents 0.91% of the entire federal budget and 2.8% of

total discretionary budget authority. By comparison, these same figures in FY1985

were 2% and 4.6%, respectively.

Table 2. Foreign Operations Appropriations, FY1994 to FY2000

(discretionary budget authority in billions of current dollars)

FY1995

FY1996

FY1997

FY1998

FY1999*

FY2000

FY2001

13.611

12.456

12.267

13.147

15.439

16.410

14.897

* FY1999 excludes $17.861 billion for the IMF.

Data Notes

Unless otherwise indicated, this report expresses dollar

amounts in terms of discretionary budget authority. The Foreign

Operations Appropriations bill includes one mandatory program

that is not included in figures and tables — USAID’s Foreign

Service retirement fund. The retirement fund is scheduled to

receive $44.6 million for FY1999.

In addition, funding levels and trends discussed in this

report exclude U.S. contributions to the International Monetary

Fund (IMF), proposals that are enacted periodically (about every

five years) in Foreign Operations bills. Congress approved $17.9

billion for the IMF in FY1999, the first appropriation since

FY1993. Including these large, infrequent, and uniquely “scored”

IMF appropriations tends to distort a general analysis of Foreign

Operations funding trends. Although Congress provides new

budget authority through appropriations for the full amount of

U.S. participation, the transaction is considered an exchange of

assets between the United States and the IMF, and results in no

outlays from the U.S. treasury. In short, the appropriations are

off-set by the creation of a U.S. counterpart claim on the IMF

that is liquid and interest bearing. For more, see CRS Report 96279, U.S. Budgetary Treatment of the IMF.

Foreign Operations, the FY2000 Budget Resolution, and Section

302(b) Allocations

Usually, Appropriation Committees begin markups of their spending bills only

after Congress has adopted a budget resolution and funds have been distributed to the

Appropriations panels under what is referred to as the Section 302(a) allocation

process, a reference to the pertinent authority in the Congressional Budget Act.

Following this, House and Senate Appropriations Committees separately decide how

CRS-6

to allot the total amount available among their 13 subcommittees, staying within the

functional guidelines set in the budget resolution. This second step is referred to as

the Section 302(b) allocation. As noted above, foreign policy funds are appropriated

within four bills with Foreign Operations having the largest share of around 67-70%

in most years.

How much foreign policy money to allocate to each of the four subcommittees,

and how to distribute the funds among the numerous programs remain decisions

exclusively reserved for the Appropriations Committees. Nevertheless, overall

ceilings set in the budget resolution can have significant implications for the budget

limitations within which the Foreign Operations subcommittees will operate when

they meet to mark up their annual appropriation bills.

The FY2001 budget resolution that cleared Congress on April 13 (H.Con.Res.

290) strongly indicated that the Foreign Operations subcommittees would receive a

significantly reduced Section 302(b) allocation from that assumed in the President’s

budget. H.Con.Res. 290 sets a $20 billion target for total international affairs

discretionary budget authority, a figure about 12% below the request.4

On May 4, House and Senate Appropriations Committees released Section

302(b) funding allocations for each of their 13 appropriation bills. In the House,

Foreign Operations programs received $13.28 billion, sharply below the President’s

$15.1 billion request ($14.8 billion if Plan Colombia funds were enacted, as they were,

in FY2000; see footnote 3). The allocation was over $3 billion less than total

amounts approved for FY2000 and $213 million below the “base” FY2000

appropriation, after deducting the Wye River/Middle East peace money. The Senate

panel approved a slightly higher Foreign Operations level – $13.39 billion. But this

would still be insufficient to fund increases sought for FY2001, and at best, would

result in an overall total slightly below a “freeze” as compared to the FY2000 “base”

amount.

Practices in the past few years suggest, however, that the initial 302(b) allocation

for Foreign Operations, as well as other spending bills, would change significantly,

especially at the latter stages of the appropriations debate. In 1999, for example,

House and Senate Foreign Operations Subcommittees received allocations of $12.6

billion and $12.7 billion, respectively, levels which established the ceiling for House

and Senate passed bills (H.R. 2606 and S. 1234). Nevertheless, following a

Presidential veto of H.R. 2606 because of low funding levels and continued White

House pressure to raise foreign aid spending, during end-of-the session negotiations,

Congress agreed to $15.3 billion for Foreign Operations. Much of the additional

funds were designated as “emergency” appropriations, amounts that did not count

against allocation limits.

4

The FY2001 budget resolution assumed that Congress, would enact, as it did, funding for

the entire Plan Colombia counternarcotics initiative as an FY2000 budget item, including the

$256 million proposed for FY2001. Using this assumption, the $20 billion for International

Affairs was 11% less than the President’s request.

CRS-7

Although the early 302(b) allocation for Foreign Operations resulted in House

and Senate bills of around $13.3 billion, the Administration pressed for additional

funding throughout the process. Between June and October House and Senate

Appropriations Committees filed numerous revisions to the original 302(b)

allocations, culminating on October 25 in a new Foreign Operations level of $14.9

billion. This subsequently allowed Congress to approve on the following day a $14.9

billion Foreign Operations appropriations for FY2001.

Foreign Operations Appropriations Request for

FY2001 and Congressional Consideration

In February 2000 President Clinton asked Congress to appropriate $15.1 billion

for FY2001 Foreign Operations. There were two basic ways in which to compare the

proposal with existing spending for FY2000. The first was to make a straight

comparison between enacted FY2000 Foreign Operations levels and the FY2001

request. Using these reference points, the FY2001 budget recommendation was

about $1.4 billion, or 8% less than total FY2000 appropriations. Another means of

comparison, and one that was frequently used by congressional Budget and

Appropriations Committees, was to compare funding for foreign aid programs

continuing from year to year, that would deduct appropriations provided under special

circumstances, such as emergency requirements, one-time, unique initiatives, or

supplemental funding. For FY2000, Congress approved under an emergency

designation a one-time, $1.8 billion aid package for Israel, Jordan, and Palestinians

in support of the November 1998 Wye River/Middle East peace accord. Congress

further enacted in P.L. 106-246 an additional $1.1 billion in FY2000 Foreign

Operations supplemental spending, mostly for counternarcotics in Colombia. Under

this second comparison approach, which adjusts the FY2000 appropriation level from

$16.5 billion to $13.5 billion, the FY2001 Foreign Operations request was 12%

higher than FY2000 spending.

Table 3. Summary of Foreign Operations Appropriations

(Discretionary funds – in millions of dollars)

Bill Title & Program

Title I - Export Assistance

FY2000 FY2001 FY2001

Enacted Request Senate

599.0

845.0

9,520.6

2,179.4

9,313.9

2,740.0

737.8

837.0

1,676.4

1,535.0

Former Soviet Union

839.0

830.0

775.0

740.0

810.0

Debt reduction**

123.0

472.0

75.0

238.0

448.0

Intl Narcotics control

305.0

312.0

220.0

305.0

325.0

1,018.5

–

–

–

–

Title II - Bilateral Economic Aid

Development aid

Africa aid

Israel/Egypt economic aid

Plan Colombia

636.0

FY2001 FY2001

House Enacted*

606.5

741.0

7,982.3 8,266.0

2,428.3 2,519.0

9,061.9

2,625.5

–

–

1,535.0 1,535.0

–

1,535.0

CRS-8

Bill Title & Program

Title III - Military Assistance

FY2000 FY2001 FY2001

Enacted Request Senate

FY2001 FY2001

House Enacted*

4,992.0

3,742.9

3,659.0 3,433.2

3,760.9

3,160.0

3,280.0

3,280.0 3,280.0

3,280.0

Title IV - Multilateral Aid

1,298.0

1,550.0

1,205.9

996.2

1,332.9

Intl Organizations

183.0

206.0

178.0

188.0

191.0

Israel/Egypt

Total Foreign Operations

16,409.6 15,451.8 13,459.2 13,301.9 14,896.7

Total, without FY2000 Supp.

13,491.1 15,451.8 13,459.2 13,301.9 14,896.7

Note: For comparative purposes and to conform to the account structure of the FY2000 and FY2001

enacted Foreign Operations, some funding in the FY2001 request and Senate bill have been shifted:

UNICEF, GAVI, Inter-American Foundation, and African Development Foundation amounts

requested for FY2001 are included in development aid under title II. Senate funding for UNICEF,

approved in title IV, is also shifted to development aid in title II.

* Pursuant to the Consolidated Appropriations Act, FY2001 (H.R. 4577), signed into law on Dec.

21, 2000, most FY2001 appropriation bills, including Foreign Operations, are reduced by 0.22%.

For Foreign Operations, there will be a cut of about $33 million from the $14.897 billion level.

** FY2001 includes combined FY2000 supplemental and FY2001 requests for debt relief.

Major Changes to Funding Proposed for FY2001

The President’s budget plan raised funding levels for nearly every Foreign

Operations account. Those receiving the largest increases or which represented

special Administration initiatives included:

!

Export-Import Bank – The $214 million, or 26% funding increase

for Eximbank activities in FY2001 might have actually supported a

smaller level of U.S. exports than in FY2000, according to the

Administration. OMB issued a new risk assessment methodology,

effective for FY2001, which determines the amount of appropriated

funds necessary to back Bank lending and insurance operations.

Because of higher risk levels for some potential countries, Eximbank

estimated that the FY2001 appropriation would fall 14.5% below the

equivalent current appropriation.

!

USAID development assistance – Overall bilateral development aid

would have grown by nearly $350 million, or 18%. Most of the

increase would support Administration initiatives to bolster family

planning programs (+45%), HIV/AIDS funding (+39%), and

democracy promotion (+24%), and to launch two new

environmental activities protecting tropical forests and promoting

cleaner energy sources. (See more below under special issues.)

!

Debt reduction for poor developing nations – The FY2001

request included $262 million for debt reduction, $238 million of

which supported U.S. participation in the Heavily Indebted Poor

CRS-9

Country (HIPC) initiative. This was more than double debt relief

appropriations for FY2000, although Congress rejected a $210

million supplemental request for a U.S. contribution to the HIPC

Trust Fund. For the FY2000 supplemental and FY2001 regular

appropriation combined, the Administration sought $435 million for

HIPC (See more below under special issues.)

!

Nonproliferation, Anti-terrorism, Demining, and Related

Programs account (NADR) – The Administration sought a $136

million, or 63% increase for an assortment of counterproliferation

and anti-terrorism programs in FY2001. Of special note was the

doubling of resources for activities aimed at fighting terrorists,

including money to establish a new anti-terrorism training facility for

foreign officials. The account also projected a $20 million increase

– to $55 million – for payment of heavy fuel oil to North Korea as

part of the Korean Energy Development Organization (KEDO)

designed to block North Korea’s nuclear weapons development

program. A June 5, 2000 budget amendment added $41.2 million to

the account for a contribution to the costs of the trial in the

Netherlands of the Lockerbie bombing suspects.

!

Voluntary contributions to International Organizations – The

FY2001 request increased U.S. contributions to about 20

organizations by $83 million, or 45%. Nearly all of the additional

resources would support the U.N. Development Program (+$10

million) and a new Global Alliance for Vaccines and

Immunizations (GAVI) initiative ($50 million). The U.N.

Population Fund (UNFPA) contribution would remain the same at

$25 million.

!

Multilateral Development Bank contributions – Overall, the

budget proposed a $235 million, or 24% increase for U.S.

commitments to the World Bank and regional multilateral

development banks (MDBs). Most of the additional funding ($140

million) would go to the Global Environment Facility, an

organization for which the United States had fallen into significant

arrears due to congressional reductions in recent years.

Congressional Debate on Foreign Operations Spending

Summary of Debate. The first congressional action on the Foreign

Operations Appropriations for FY2001 occurred on May 9 when the Senate

Appropriations Committee marked up and reported S. 2522. The legislation also

included FY2000 supplemental funding for various Foreign Operations programs.5

5

FY2000 supplemental funds were deleted from S. 2522 during subsequent action. The

House earlier had approved a separate supplemental funding measure – H.R. 3908 – but

(continued...)

CRS-10

The full Senate approved the measure on June 22. The House Foreign Operations

Subcommittee marked up its companion bill, H.R. 4811, on June 20, followed by full

Committee endorsement on June 27. The full House approved the measure on July

13. Subsequently, the Senate took up H.R. 4811 on July 18, deleted the Housepassed text, and inserted the text of S. 2522. On October 24, House Foreign

Operations Subcommittee Chairman Callahan introduced a new bill – H.R. 5526 –

reflecting agreements reached during informal Foreign Operations conference

committee discussions. On the same day, the full conference committee met and

issued a report (H.Rept. 106-997) incorporating the text of H.R. 5526 into H.R.

4811. Congress approved the report on October 25, the House by a vote of 307-101

and Senate by a vote of 65-27. President Clinton signed the legislation on November

6 – P.L. 106-429.6

FY2000 Supplemental. On June 29, Congress passed an $11.2 billion

supplemental spending measure (P.L. 106-246; H.R. 4425), including $1.094 billion

in Foreign Operations funds. Most of money – $1.019 billion – supported the full

FY2000/2001 Administration request for a counternarcotics initiative in Colombia.

The legislation also provided $50 million in additional economic aid to Kosovo,

Croatia, and Montenegro ($251 million requested), and $25 million for southern

Africa flood relief ($200 million requested). H.R. 4425 further rejected the

President’s supplemental request for a $210 million contribution to the HIPC Trust

Fund, an initiative to provide multilateral debt relief to the world’s poorest nations.

Congress reconsidered and approved HIPC funds and portions of other rejected

supplemental requests, however, in October when lawmakers made final decisions on

FY2001 Foreign Operations spending levels.

Senate action. As approved by the Senate, S. 2522 provided $13.4 billion for

Foreign Operations programs in FY2001. The amount was about $110 million less

than FY2000 enacted, after subtracting from FY2000 the one-time, $1.8 billion

emergency aid package for Israel, Jordan, and the Palestinians in support of the Wye

5

(...continued)

Senate leaders decided to attach all supplemental proposals to regular FY2001 appropriation

bills, including Foreign Operations. On June 29, Congress cleared for the White House H.R.

4425 (P.L. 106-246), the FY2001 Military Construction Appropriation, including $1.094

billion in Foreign Operations supplemental money. The conference negotiations on H.R. 4425

reflected Senate positions taken in S. 2522 regarding supplemental funding.

6

Following enactment of the regular Foreign Operations Appropriations, FY2001, President

Clinton asked Congress to provide an additional $750 million for supplemental economic and

military assistance for Israel, Egypt, and Jordan. While Congress did not approve the Middle

East request before adjourning, lawmakers enacted two additional Foreign Operations funding

items as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, FY2001 (H.R. 5666 enacted by

reference in H.R. 4577). The first earmarks $1.35 million of funds appropriated in P.L. 106429 for the Protection Project to continue its study of international trafficking in women and

children. H.R. 5666 further permits the President to utilize Economic Support Funds provided

in P.L. 106-429 for compensating China for the May 1999 U.S. bombing of its embassy in

Belgrade. The President had requested $28 million in his FY2001 Foreign Operations request.

H.R. 4577 further requires that most FY2001 appropriation bills, including Foreign

Operations, are reduced by 0.22%. For Foreign Operations, there will be a cut of about $33

million from the $14.897 billion level.

CRS-11

River/Middle East Peace Accord, and the recently approved supplemental. 7 The

Senate recommendation fell about $1.7 billion, or 11%, below the President’s (at that

time) $15.1 billion FY2001 request. Nearly every account was funded below the

Administration’s request, and several were reduced from FY2000 enacted amounts:

7

!

USAID operating expenses ($510 million) was $10 million below

enacted and requested amounts. At this level, USAID would most

likely face the choice of reducing plans for growth in either staff

salaries and benefits, overseas support costs, or information

technology enhancements.

!

Former Soviet Union aid ($775 million) declined by about $65

million compared with enacted and proposed levels. But because

earmarks in S. 2522 for Ukraine ($175 million), Georgia ($94

million), and Armenia ($89 million) were slightly higher than

amounts requested, the overall account shortfall likely would have

fallen most heavily on aid to Russia, proposed at $162 million.

!

Inter-American Foundation received no funding in S. 2522 for

FY2001. The legislation further authorized, but did not require, the

President to abolish the Foundation. Last year, Congress also

authorized the President to terminate the Inter-American Foundation,

appropriating $5 million for the small, grassroots development

organization, an amount believed to be sufficient to cover existing

grants and contract obligations, and to conclude any other

outstanding operations of the Foundation. The President, however,

did not exercise this authority, and requested $20 million for FY2001

programs. The Senate Appropriations Committee believed that there

would be enough funds carried forward into FY2001 that would

cover Foundation termination costs.

!

Peace Corps. As proposed by the Committee bill, Peace Corps

funds ($220 million) would have fallen below FY2000 enacted ($245

million) and FY2001 requested ($275 million), and would undermine

Administration efforts to achieve a 10,000 Peace Corps volunteer

target. During floor debate, an amendment (Dodd) was approved,

providing an additional $24 million to be drawn from other parts of

the bill and allowing Peace Corps levels to remain at roughly the

FY2000 level.

!

Debt reduction resources to support the Heavily Indebted Poor

Country Initiative (HIPC) – $75 million – were significantly less than

the combined $475 million FY2000 supplemental/FY2001 request.

The most immediate effect would have been to delay final debt relief

for Bolivia because of funding shortfalls in the HIPC Trust Fund.

(See below under Major Spending and Policy Issues.)

Without adjusting for the FY2000 Wye River aid and the supplemental amount, S. 2522

was about $3 billion less than the current level.

CRS-12

!

International narcotics control appropriations ($220 million) were

roughly $90 million below enacted and requested amounts. This

would not affect Plan Colombia, which was funded elsewhere, but

would cut by nearly one-third continued funding for other anti-drug

initiatives.

!

Peacekeeping operations funds ($85 million) were well below

FY2000 ($153 million) and FY2001 proposed ($134 million)

amounts. The Senate Appropriations Committee assumed no

funding for operations in Haiti ($4 million). Cuts recommended in

S. 2522 might also have jeopardized Administration plans to support

OSCE activities in Kosovo and train and equip an African crisis

peacekeeping force.

!

World Bank, International Development Association (IDA)

contribution of $750 million would have added about $85 million to

arrears owed by the U.S. S. 2522 further cut funding for the Global

Environment Facility, Asian Development Bank, African

Development Fund, and other multilateral organizations.

In a few areas, S. 2522 increased Foreign Operations spending over enacted

amounts, supporting in some cases Administration priorities. The major Senate

Committee initiative was the creation of a Global Health account within

development assistance spending. This account, which incorporated much, although

not all, of the Child Survival and Infectious Disease fund, represented a

comprehensive funding approach to protect global health, attack poverty, and shield

Americans from infectious diseases easily transmitted across borders. The $691

million appropriated in S. 2522 (including a Senate floor amendment adding $40

million to the Committee recommendation) provided earmarks for HIV/AIDS ($255

million), malaria ($65 million), tuberculosis ($51 million), and a U.S. contribution

($50 million) to the Global Fund for Children’s Vaccines. For another key economic

aid issue – population assistance – S. 2522 earmarked $425 million within

development program funding which, when combined with resources from other

accounts, would total about $482 million. This was $110 million higher than FY2000

spending, but below the request of $541 million. S. 2522 further replaced abortionrelated restrictions that applied to FY2000 funds with language that would permit the

White House to restore previous family planning policy in which no U.S. funds can

be used for performing or promoting abortions, but no conditions are imposed on how

foreign organizations spend funds raised from non-U.S. Governments sources. (See

below under Major Funding and Policy issues for more discussion of development

assistance population aid.)

House action. As approved by the House on July 13, H.R. 4811 provided

$13.3 billion, about $200 million less than the FY2000 Act (after subtracting from

FY2000 the one-time, $1.8 billion Wye River/Middle East peace aid package and the

enacted supplemental), and $1.8 billion, or 12%, below the President’s (at the time)

$15.1 billion FY2001 request.

CRS-13

As is the case with the Senate bill, many accounts fell below the Administration

request:

!

USAID development assistance (other than Child Survival)

($1.258 billion) was roughly $250 million below the request.

!

USAID operating expenses ($509 million) was $11 million below

enacted and requested amounts. As noted above, USAID would

confront several options to cut operations in order meet the reduced

appropriation.

!

Former Soviet Union aid ($740 million) declined by about $95

million compared with enacted and proposed levels. The House

panel allocated a percentage (12.5%) of the account total for

Armenia and Georgia, resulting in similar amounts as earmarked by

the Senate. The House bill, however, did not earmark funds for

Ukraine, providing somewhat more flexibility for the State

Department in making its country allocations for Russia and other

former Soviet states.

!

Foreign Military Financing (FMF) was reduced during House

debate by $242 million to $3.268 billion, $270 million below the

request. The cuts were part of off-set packages that allowed for an

increase in debt reduction and HIV/AIDS funding. Not only would

the House-passed amount squeeze FMF requests for new members

of NATO, Partnership-for-Peace nations, and Jordan, but also falls

$12 million below the combined $3.28 billion request for Israel and

Egypt.

!

World Bank, International Development Association (IDA)

contribution of $566.6 million was about $270 million below the

requested amount. The House measure further reduced by

significant levels proposed U.S. contributions to the Global

Environment Facility, Asian Development Bank, African

Development Fund, and other multilateral organizations. Overall, the

House measure included $1 billion for multilateral assistance, onethird less than requested and 25% below FY2000 amounts.

As has been the case in House Foreign Operations spending bills since 1995, the

legislation placed priority on child survival and infectious disease activities. The

House bill approved $886 million, $74 million above the request and $117 million

higher than FY2000 levels.

Initially, H.R. 4811, as reported, had provided $82.4 million in debt reduction

resources to support the Heavily Indebted Poor Country Initiative (HIPC), a level

that, like the Senate’s, was well below the combined $475 million FY2000

supplemental/FY2001 request. During floor debate, the House adopted an

amendment (Waters, 216-211) that raised this amount to $238 million, $24 million

below the FY2001 request, but still far less than the combined request.

CRS-14

Conference agreement. As enacted, Congress approved $14.9 billion for

Foreign Operations spending in FY2001.8 The total, however, includes not only

amounts requested for this year, but also several items proposed as FY2000

supplementals. Prior to reaching agreement, House and Senate conferees

reconsidered some of the FY2000 supplementals that lawmakers rejected earlier in the

year, and included about $470 million as part of the $14.9 billion total. After

adjusting the combined President’s request to include both FY2000 supplementals and

regular FY2001 proposals, the $14.9 billion Foreign Operations appropriations falls

about $500 million, or 3.5% below the Administration’s request. Nevertheless, P.L.

106-429 represents a substantial increase over the roughly $13.35 billion funding bills

passed previously by the House and Senate. Moreover, P.L. 106-429 fully funds

several top Administration priorities, including HIPC debt relief contributions. Major

items enacted in the FY2001 Foreign Operations bill include:

8

!

HIPC debt relief is set at $435 million, as requested in both FY2000

supplemental and FY2001 requests. In addition, H.R. 4811

authorizes the United States to support the full IMF gold revaluation

transaction which provides the Fund with the necessary resources to

cancel debt owed by HIPC qualifying countries.

!

Global health programs receive substantial funding increases under

the enacted legislation, with spending on HIV/AIDS activities

climbing to $315 million. Malaria ($50 million), tuberculosis ($45

million), and GAVI ($50 million) are also funded at or well above the

requested amounts.

!

The Child Survival and Disease Program Fund is funded at $963

million, nearly double the level of six years ago and one-third more

than in FY2000. Child survival programs are earmarked at $295

million, UNICEF at $110 million, and basic education at $103

million.

!

USAID development assistance falls about $200 million, or 13%

below the President’s request, but $90 million, or 7% higher than in

FY2000.

!

Family planning assistance is set at $425 million, the highest level

since FY1995, but below the President’s $541.5 million request.

None of the funds, however, could be obligated until February 15,

2001. As many expected, President Bush elected, on January 22,

2001, to apply abortion restrictions as a condition of eligibility for

foreign organizations to receive USAID grants. On February 15,

USAID announced guidelines for implementing the re-imposed

Subsequently, Congress approved the Consolidated Appropriations Act, FY2001 (H.R.

4577), signed into law on Dec. 21, 2000,that requires a reduction of 0.22% in most FY2001

appropriation bills. For Foreign Operations, there will be a cut of about $33 million from the

$14.9 billion level.

CRS-15

Mexico City policy conditions under which all FY2001 population

aid funds will fall.

!

USAID operating expenses increased in the enacted legislation to

$520 million, the same as FY2000 and requested for FY2001.

!

Inter-American Foundation receives $12 million, less than the $20

million requested, but higher than last year’s $12 million

appropriation.

Once again, Congress grants the President

discretionary authority to abolish the Foundation.

!

Serbia aid is funded at up to $100 million, but cannot be obligated

after March 31, 2001, unless the President certifies that, among other

things, the Yugoslav government is cooperating with the

International Criminal Tribunal regarding the investigation and

transfer of those indicted.

!

Peace Corps receives $265 million, up $20 million from FY2000.

!

Foreign Military Financing (FMF) is restored to $3.545 billion,

slightly above the requested amount and $125 million higher than

FY2000. This will provide full funding for Israel, Egypt, and Jordan.

Conferees further added $31 million for southeast Europe that had

originally been requested as an FY2000 supplemental.

!

Multilateral Development Bank contributions increase

significantly over earlier House and Senate-approved amounts,

although the total falls about $200 million below the request. The

World Bank IDA receives $775 million, the same as in FY2000, but

$60 million less than proposed.

Major Policy and Spending Issues in the

Foreign Operations Debate

In addition to funding decisions made by Congress in the Foreign Operations

appropriation bill, the annual spending measure also includes a wide range of policy

provisions that frequently raise contentious foreign policy disagreements between the

President and Congress. As mentioned above, because Congress has not enacted

foreign aid authorization bills for over a decade, the Foreign Operations

appropriations legislation often becomes the vehicle for debate on the conduct of U.S.

foreign policy more generally. Many of these policy provisions take the form of

conditions or restrictions on how the President can use money included in the

spending bill. Many of these provisions are opposed by the Administration as

excessively limiting its ability to manage American foreign policy. The legislativeexecutive policy differences have in the past delayed the enactment of the Foreign

Operations bill or have prompted a presidential veto.

CRS-16

Among the most significant funding and policy issues raised during congressional

debate in 2000 on the Foreign Operations appropriation measure were conflicting

executive-legislative branch development assistance strategy priorities and new

Administration initiatives, restrictions on international family planning programs,

regional and country aid allocations, and efforts by the Administration to secure

funding to reduce debt burdens of the poorest developing countries.

Development Aid Policy Priorities

Since the end of the Cold War, a recurring debate has focused on what should

replace the anti-communist foreign aid rationale of the past 50 years. A more

fundamental question raised by some, especially critics of development assistance, is

whether the United States needs to maintain an active, globally focused economic aid

program. Many of these critics argue that aid can be transformed into a smaller, more

targeted, and often privatized instrument to support only the highest priority U.S.

foreign policy interests.

Although there has been no definitive consensus on priorities, the Clinton

Administration has strongly supported the retention of an activist foreign aid policy

which can be used to bolster a variety of U.S. foreign policy initiatives around the

world. In early 1994, USAID released its blueprint for a post-Cold War development

aid policy, based around the goal of “sustainable development,” and its four strategies

of promoting economic growth, stabilizing global population, protecting the

environment, and advancing democracy. More recently, USAID added a fifth strategy

aimed at developing human capacity through education.

Since adopting these strategies in 1994, USAID has maintained that they operate

as inter-linked, mutually reinforcing elements of an overall U.S. effort to promote the

advancement of market economies and democratic transitions in developing nations.

Officials argue that U.S. aid is justified until countries reach a point of sustainability

that no longer requires external aid. Funding reductions, congressional restrictions,

and fluctuating Administration priorities, however, have required USAID to alter the

mix of resources devoted to each of the strategies, raising questions over whether the

integrative, mutually reinforcing rationale can be maintained. Congress, for example,

limited development aid for population programs in FY1996-FY2000 to roughly twothirds of the amount provided in FY1995. (See below for more discussion on family

planning restrictions.) Further, the State Department’s Bureau of Global Affairs has

in the past placed a high priority on environment programs and pressed USAID to

allocate the maximum amount possible to such activities. As a result, the environment

sector of sustainable development has not declined as much as it might have

otherwise.

CRS-17

Table 4. USAID Goals

(in millions of dollars)

FY1999

Actual

FY2000

Estimate

FY2001

Request

3,392

3,443

3,181

Israel cash transfer

1,080

949

840

Agriculture

309

299

281

Microenterprise

135

135

135

Private markets

1,702

1,958

1,818

Population/Health

1,030

1,098

1,222

Child Survival

341

299

274

HIV/AIDS

135

176

244

Family Planning

385

373

542

Infectious Diseases

62

70

63

Human Capacity/Education

330

287

268

122

120

114

522

600

596

74

102

128

Democracy

506

539

627

Total USAID Goals

5,780

5,967*

5,894

Goals/Targets

Economic Growth

Basic Education

Environment

Biodiversity/Trop. Forests

Source: USAID. Amounts in this table represent total USAID economic assistance funded across

several Foreign Operations accounts, including Development Assistance, Child Survival and

Diseases, Economic Support Fund, Eastern Europe, and Independent States of the former Soviet

Union.

* Includes a one-time, $450 million Wye River/Middle East Peace economic package for Jordan and

the Palestinians. Excluding this special supplemental, FY2000 totals $5,517 million. The FY2000

estimate does not include supplemental funds approved in P.L. 106-246 for counternarcotics

programs in Colombia and Balkan assistance.

A central theme for the past five years has been differences between Congress

and the executive branch regarding funding levels for programs supporting child

survival, basic education, and efforts against HIV/AIDS and other infectious diseases.

Despite cutting overall development aid in FY1996-FY1997 by about 23% from

FY1995 levels, Congress earmarked children and disease programs at amounts equal

to or somewhat greater than those allocated in FY1995, making the cuts on all other

elements of sustainable development closer to 30%. Congress reduced the President’s

FY2000 development aid request by $80 million overall, but lawmakers set funding

targets for child survival and infectious disease activities $18 million higher than

proposed. As a result, USAID cut funding for economic growth programs by $49

CRS-18

million, environment projects by $37 million, and democracy promotion activities by

$18 million below what the agency had planned for FY2000.9

Congressional proponents of the child survival priority argue that even though

budget pressures require the United States to reduce or hold the line on foreign aid

spending, the protection of children remains a core American value demanding that

cuts should be implemented without putting at risk the lives and well-being of small

children in developing nations. They further point out that the spread of infectious

diseases poses a direct threat to U.S. citizens, and that American national interests

require continued support for global efforts to reduce or eliminate such illnesses.

Although agreeing with the importance of child survival and infectious disease

programs, USAID officials apply a broader definition to the terms, arguing, for

example, that efforts to protect small children go well beyond immunizations and

access to other health services. The quality of a child’s life, they assert, also is

determined by an array of other factors, including the degree of relative stability in

society, protection of the surrounding environment, access to adequate shelter, and

implementation of sound economic policies that will ensure jobs and economic

opportunities in the future. Consequently, they contend, that the “squeeze” that these

targets place on other areas of sustainable development partially undermines the

success of other programs that benefit children.

FY2001 Request. As has been the pattern the past few years, USAID’s

economic assistance request for the Agency’s five main objectives in FY2001 reduced

or maintained at FY2000 levels funding for several congressional priorities while

increasing aid overall by $377 million, or 7% (after excluding from FY2000 the onetime Wye River/Middle East peace package). The $5.9 billion request would have cut

funds for child survival programs by $25 million and infectious diseases, other than

HIV/AIDS, by $7 million from FY2000 appropriations.10 The proposed budget

further held spending steady for microenterprise and reduced amounts for agriculture

and food security programs by $18 million.11 Both of these latter activities are targets

of special congressional interest.

USAID requested significant increases for several other sustainable activities,

plus funding to launch a few new initiatives:

!

Programs combating the spread of HIV/AIDS, especially in Africa,

were a major priority of the Administration, both within USAID and

9

Selected elements of economic growth programs that have broad congressional support,

such as microenterprise and agriculture activities, were unaffected by reductions elsewhere

in this sector.

10

USAID’s child survival budget, however, when combined with appropriations for UNICEF

and a planned $50 million U.S. contribution to the Global Alliance for Vaccines and

Immunization (GAVI) initiative that is funded under the multilateral assistance title, would

boost overall U.S. funding for child health and survival efforts by about 10%.

11

The reduction in agriculture funding was largely due to a shift in program emphasis in

Egypt, where less ESF funding in agriculture is projected. Congress recommended a $305

million target for agriculture resources across all accounts the past two years.

CRS-19

across other Federal agency budgets, including Health and Human

Services, Center for Disease Control, and DOD. Vice President

Gore announced in January 2000 that the United States would

increase spending to $325 million in FY2001, up $100 million from

existing levels, for AIDS education, prevention, and treatment in

Africa, India, and other areas. HIV/AIDS funding from USAID

development aid accounts would grow by nearly $50 million, or 28%

in FY2001. Congress has also made AIDS funding a priority in

recent years. Numerous bills were introduced in 2000 supporting

and/or expanding the Administration’s initiative, and one – H.R.

3519; P.L. 106-264 – was enacted into law authorizing $300 million

for HIV/AIDS programs.12

!

Population assistance represented the largest single funding

increase for FY2001, rising by $169 million, or 45% from FY2000

amounts. Last year, the White House reluctantly accepted new

congressional restrictions on abortion and eligibility of foreign family

planning organizations implementing USAID population programs.

The Administration wanted to restore family planning assistance

funding to levels enacted for FY1995, the year before Congress and

the President began to engage in contentious debates over abortion

and international family planning. (See next section for further

discussion on this issue.)

!

Environmental funding would have grown significantly in two

environmental sectors under the Administration’s request – for

biodiversity and for a new clean energy initiative. Last year,

Congress directed USAID to restore biodiversity funding to the same

proportion of development assistance funds it received in FY1995.

While USAID met the roughly $100 million congressional target for

FY2000 under the proportional requirement, the Administration

sought a $26 million, or 27% increase for FY2001. USAID also

planned to launch a new, $30 million clean energy initiative.

Congressional action. The Senate approved bill, S. 2522, set USAID

economic assistance – combining all accounts supporting the Agency’s development

goals – at $5.8 billion, about $100 million below the request. For sustainable

development assistance specifically, the Senate measure set the budget roughly midway between FY2000 enacted and FY2001 requested levels. The $2.17 billion

sustainable development appropriation (an amount that for comparative purposes

includes UNICEF contributions), was nearly $230 million, or 12%, higher than

FY2000 spending. The centerpiece of the Senate proposal was the creation of a new

$691 million account for Global Health. The Global Health account replaced the

Child Survival and Infectious Disease line-item in the FY2000 measure, incorporating

12

For other bills, see H.R. 3826/S. 2387, H.R. 4039/S. 2030, H.R. 4038/S. 2032, S. 2026,

H.R. 4140, and subtitle D, title 2 of S. 2382. For more information regarding these

initiatives, see CRS Issue Brief IB10050, AIDS in Africa, by Raymond Copson.

CRS-20

most, although not all, child-related programs.13 In several respects, the new

account supported many of the funding initiatives proposed in other legislation (see

footnote 9) and in the Administration’s request. Committee earmarks and report

recommendations allocated resources for several priorities, including HIV/AIDS,

tuberculosis, malaria, polio and maternal health. For other non-health development

activities, S. 2522 directed that USAID allocate at least $310 million (across all

accounts) for agriculture programs, $11 million higher than FY2000 amounts.

Population assistance also would have increased under S. 2522, although not to the

level proposed by the Administration. (See Table 5 below for specific amounts and

comparisons with House, Administration, and enacted levels.)

Although earmarks and directives in S. 2522 protected and increased resources

for Senate priorities, especially in the health area, the overall funding level for USAID

sustainable development programs would have resulted in cuts for other, nonearmarked activities, such as those for private markets and democracy promotion.

USAID calculated that development programs not earmarked in S. 2522 would fall

by about 21% from FY2000 allocations and by nearly one-third from the FY2001

request.

Table 5. Funding for Selected USAID Programs

(tentative estimates across all accounts – in millions of dollars)

Program

FY2000 FY2001 FY2001

Estimate Request Senate

FY2001 FY2001

House Estimate

Health:

Child Survival/Maternal Health

HIV/AIDS

355

176

314

244

GAVI

–

Malaria

a

255

345

254

350

315

50

50

37

50

27

26

65

27

50

Tuberculosis

21

20

51

55

60

Polio

25

25

30

25

Agriculture

299

274

310

American Schools/Hospitals

15

15

17

Family Planning

373

542

482

Biodiversity

100

126

Basic Education

120

114

b

119

a

a

a

310

17

385

425

b

b

119

122

a. No earmark.

b. No earmark, but recommendation for higher spending.

13

Basic education, for example, was not included in the Global Health account, but was

funded at $100 million ($98 million enacted and requested) within regular development aid

resources.

CRS-21

As passed by the House, H.R. 4811 would provide $5.63 billion across all

economic aid accounts for USAID goals, a level about $266 million, or 4.6% below

the request. For sustainable development activities specifically, the House measure

approved $2.144 billion, nearly $200 million less than requested and about $25 million

less than the Senate. The House measure maintained the Child Survival/Disease

account at $886 million, an increase of $159 million over amounts enacted in FY2000,

and, like the Senate measure, included a number of earmarks and directives increasing

a number of priorities, especially in health and children programs. (See Table 5 for

specific amounts and comparisons with Senate, Administration, and enacted levels.)

Although the House continued its practice of recent years of providing higher

funding for children activities and cutting requests for other development objectives,

the Committee’s report acknowledged the need for broader social and economic

development. The Committee encouraged USAID to increase spending on economic

growth and private sector programs aimed at increasing the number of jobs, educating

the population, and providing better health care in developing nations. The House

panel further encouraged increased funding for agriculture activities and a

microenterprise program of $152 million. Nevertheless, with the number of earmarks

and priorities in the children and health sectors endorsed by the House panel, USAID

would most likely need to make substantial reductions in a variety of non-health

program areas.

Enacted legislation increases USAID funding above levels approved earlier by

the House and Senate, and protects, and in some cases adds to amounts for activity

of special congressional interest. Overall USAID administered programs in support

of its five key goals are set at $5.835 billion, about $60 million, or 1% less than

requested, but $200 million and $35 million higher than passed by the House and

Senate, respectively. Sustainable development funds total $2.268 billion, also more

than $100 million higher than approved earlier by the House and Senate.

Nevertheless, congressional directives and earmarks allocating USAID funding will

alter, in some cases significantly, how the Agency distributes appropriated resources

among the five core goals. Child survival, health, including HIV/AIDS, and basic

education will receive substantially higher amounts than requested. Because of

overall reductions, protection for priority activities, and some spending limitations,

funding for private sector, environment, family planning, and democracy programs

will fall below proposed levels, and possibly under FY2000 amounts. USAID

decisions on how to allocate FY2001 appropriations are underway, but will not likely

finalize until early next year. Table 5, however, provides a tentative estimate of how

some of the key USAID programs will be funded, especially those for which Congress

has included specific earmarks in P.L. 106-429.

Population and Family Planning Assistance

Another aspect of the discussion regarding policy priorities of U.S. development

aid is the continuing controversy regarding international family planning restrictions.

For FY2001, the President sought $541.6 million for USAID population programs,

a $169 million, or 45%, increase over FY2000 levels. The White House further

proposed a $25 million U.S. contribution to the U.N. Population Fund (UNFPA), the

same as appropriated for FY2000. U.S. international family planning programs had

been one of the largest growth areas of the foreign aid budget in the early 1990s.

CRS-22

From an average of about $250 million in the late 1980s, FY1995 spending across all

Foreign Operations accounts totaled approximately $541 million. In the following

years, when Congress deadlocked over abortion-related restrictions and U.S.

population aid policy, a situation that blocked movement of the entire Foreign

Operations bill, lawmakers adopted interim provisions that, among other things,

strictly limited the amount of funding for USAID family planning programs. The

appropriation cap of $385 million enacted in each of FY1997-FY2000 is roughly twothirds the amount provided in FY1995.

The principal dispute over population assistance, however, goes well beyond

funding issues, centering more directly on abortion-related activities of foreign

recipients of USAID grants. For over 15 years, Congress has engaged in contentious

debates over U.S. international family planning policy, often as part of the Foreign

Operations Appropriations.

Family Planning and Abortion Restrictions. The debate over

international family planning policy and abortion began nearly three decades ago when

Congress added a provision to the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 prohibiting the use

of U.S. appropriated funds for abortion-related activities and coercive family

planning programs. During the mid-1980s, in what has become known as the

“Mexico City” policy (because it was first announced at the 1984 Mexico City

Population Conference), the Reagan, and later the Bush, Administrations restricted

funds for foreign non-governmental organizations (NGOs) that were involved in

performing or promoting abortions in countries where they worked, even if such

activities were undertaken with non-U.S. funds. Several groups, including

International Planned Parenthood Federation-London (IPPF-London), became

ineligible for U.S. financial support. In some years, Congress narrowly approved

measures to overturn this prohibition, but White House vetoes kept the policy in

place. President Clinton in 1993 reversed the position of his two predecessors,

allowing the United States to resume funding for all family planning organizations so

long as no U.S. money was used by those involved in abortion-related work.

During the past five years, the House and Senate have taken opposing positions

on the Mexico City issue that in each case held up enactment of the final Foreign

Operations spending measure. The House position, sponsored by Representative

Smith (N.J.) and others, supported reinstatement of the Mexico City policy restricting

U.S. aid funds to foreign organizations involved in performing abortions or in

lobbying to change abortion laws or policies in foreign countries. The Senate, on the

other hand, has rejected in most cases House provisions dealing with Mexico City

policy, favoring a position that leaves these decisions in the hands of the

Administration. Moreover, Administration officials routinely said that President

Clinton would veto any bills that included the House-passed Mexico City restrictions,

a threat he carried out in October 1998 when he rejected legislation authorizing family

planning programs that included Mexico City policy (H.R. 1757).

Unable to reach an agreement satisfactory to both sides, Congress adopted

interim arrangements for FY1996-FY1999 that did not resolve the broad population

program controversy, but permitted the stalled Foreign Operations measure to move

forward. The annual “compromise” removed House-added Mexico City restrictions,

CRS-23

but reduced population assistance to $385 million, and in several years, “metered” the

availability of the funds at a rate of one-twelfth of the $385 million per month.

The FY2000 debate, however, concluded far differently than the previous four

years. As Congress and the White House searched in November 1999 for a final

FY2000 budget agreement, international family planning and population aid issues

became one of the last and most contentious aspects of the negotiations.

Congressional leaders insisted that if the President wanted Congress to approve

legislation authorizing the payment of nearly $1 billion of U.S. arrears owed to the

United Nations, the White House must also accept revised Mexico City language

adding abortion restrictions to U.S. population assistance policy. In order to remove

the obstacles to U.N. arrears payments, a reluctant President Clinton agreed to the

abortion restrictions, marking the first time that Mexico City conditions had been

included in legislation signed by the President. (Enacted in the Foreign Operations

Act for FY2000, H.R. 3422, incorporated into H.R. 3194, the Consolidated

Appropriations Act for FY2000, P.L. 106-113).

Under the terms of Section 599D of H.R. 3422, private foreign nongovernmental and multilateral organizations must certify that they neither perform

abortions nor lobby to change abortion laws in foreign countries in order to receive

USAID population aid grants in FY2000. Section 599D allows the President to

waive the certification requirement for up to $15 million in grants to groups that

would otherwise be ineligible, but with the penalty that $12.5 million of the $385

million population aid appropriation would be transferred to child health programs.

The restrictions apply only to FY2000 and expired on September 30, 2000.

One day after signing the legislation, the President exercised his waiver authority

(November 30, 1999), thereby reducing FY2000 population aid funds to $372.5

million. He further instructed USAID to implement Section 599D in a way that will

minimize the impact on U.S. funded family planning programs. Under agency

guidelines, all non-U.S. NGOs (whether non-profit or for-profit) and multilateral

organizations that are prime contractors, grantees, and cooperative agreement

recipients must certify (and collect the same certification from their sub-contractors)

that they will not engage in three types of activities with either USAID or non-USAID

funds from the date they sign an agreement to receive FY2000 USAID population

funds through September 30, 2001:

!

perform abortions in a foreign country, except where the life of the

mother would be endangered, or in cases of forcible rape or incest;

!

violate the laws of a foreign country concerning the circumstances

under which abortion is permitted, regulated, or restricted; or

!

attempt to alter the laws or governmental policies concerning

circumstances under which abortion is permitted, regulated, or

restricted.

If an organization declines to certify, or does not return the certification form, it will

be ineligible to receive FY2000 USAID population funds.

CRS-24

Except for the loss of $12.5 million in funding, it appears that on a programmatic

basis, the certification requirement has not had a significant impact on USAID family

planning programs. A key issue has been whether the $15 million in total grants

allowed under the waiver authority was sufficient to cover all foreign organizations

that declined to certify regarding their involvement in abortion-related activities.

Although there is still some uncertainty about how many groups have not responded

because they disagree with the certification terms, IPPF-London and the World

Health Organization have refused. At some point, USAID will review the cases of

all foreign organizations that have not responded or declined to certify – nine

currently – and decide how to allocate the $15 million available to such groups.

Agency officials believe that they will not exceed the $15 million cap.

Critics of the certification requirement oppose it on several grounds. From an

administrative standpoint, they say it will increase USAID costs to manage family

planning programs because of the additional paperwork and will delay implementation

of projects. (USAID has contracted with John Snow, Inc. to track the certification

process.) They further believe that family planning organizations will cut back on

services because they are unsure of the full implications of the restrictions and do not

want to risk losing eligibility for USAID funding. Opponents also believe the new

conditions will undermine relations between the U.S. Government and foreign NGOs

and multilateral groups, creating a situation where the United States challenges their

sovereignty on how to spend their own money and imposes a so-called “gag” order

on their ability to promote changes to abortion laws and regulations in developing

nations. The latter, these critics note, would be unconstitutional if applied to

American groups working in the United States. Supporters of the certification

requirement argue that even though permanent law bans USAID funds from being

used to perform or promote abortions, money is fungible; that organizations receiving

American-taxpayer funding can simply use USAID resources for permitted activities

while diverting money raised from other sources to perform abortions or lobby to

change abortion laws and regulations. The certification process, they contend, stops

the fungibility “loophole.”

President Clinton said he would oppose any attempt to extend the abortion

restrictions beyond September 30, 2000. Supporters of his position introduced

several bills in 2000 that would effectively reverse the Mexico City language, by

either:

!

making the eligibility requirements for NGOs and multilateral

organizations no more restrictive than those that apply to foreign

governments (H.R. 3634 and S. 2380);

!

subjecting foreign groups (concerning the use of non-USAID funding

for advocacy and lobbying activities) to the same restrictions

imposed on U.S. NGOs, and maintaining their eligibility so long as

these groups do not engage in health or medical services in violation

of the laws of the country in which they operate or which would

violate U.S. law if provided here (H.R. 4211).

Supporters of the certification process pressed for continuation of the restrictions in

the FY2001 funding bill in order to further institutionalize them.

CRS-25

UNFPA Issues. Congress further enacted for FY2000 restrictions on U.S.

contributions to the U.N. Population Fund (UNFPA). During the Reagan and Bush

Administrations the United States did not support UNFPA, a policy reversed by

President Clinton in 1993. At issue are UNFPA programs in China, a country where

there have been continuing reports for many years of coercive family planning

practices. During the mid-1990s, Congress reduced UNFPA contributions by the

amount the organization spent in China, but when UNFPA ended its China program

in 1997, the controversy subsided. UNFPA, however, reinstituted activities in China

soon thereafter, resulting in the withholding in FY1998 of $5 million for UNFPA and

the enactment for FY1999 of a total prohibition on the U.S. $25 million contribution,

so long as the organization remained active in China. Congress restored the $25

million earmark for UNFPA in FY2000, but under terms that required a deduction of

$3.5 million (the cost of UNFPA’s 2000 program in China).

Coercive Family Planning Practices and Peru. A new element in the

family planning issue added during the FY1999 debate emerged following reports that

Peru, where USAID has population aid programs, had established national targets for

tubal ligations and vasectomies. There were also allegations that some Peruvian

health workers may have conditioned the receipt of food and medical care on the

acceptance of sterilizations. USAID maintains a policy of strict voluntarism for family

planning programs it supports, and opposes the use of performance-based quota

systems. The Agency says that Peru’s government has instituted significant reforms

in its family planning programs, including criteria that ensure voluntary informed

consent. To reinforce U.S. policies opposing programs based on coercive practices

or quota systems, Congress adopted for FY1999 an amendment by Representative

Tiahrt that more precisely defines the term voluntary family planning programs, and

establishes criteria for USAID to apply regarding the voluntary nature of its

population projects. These same provisions were continued in the FY2000

appropriation.14

Congressional Action. S. 2522 earmarked $425 million for population

assistance out of development assistance funding, a level which, when combined with

resources from other accounts, would provide about $482 million for family planning

activities.

This is significantly higher than for FY2000, but below the

Administration’s $541 million request.

On the issue of abortion conditions, section 590 of S. 2522 deleted restrictions

applying to FY2000 funds, substituting language that would have the effect of

restoring previous Clinton Administration policy on foreign NGOs and multilateral

organization eligibility for USAID population aid grants. Specifically, the conditions

stipulated that such organizations:

!

14

shall not be subject to requirements regarding how they use non-U.S.

Government funds for advocacy or lobbying activities that are more

restrictive that those that apply to U.S. NGOs which receive

economic aid grants; and

For more information, see CRS Issue Brief IB96026, U.S. International Population

Assistance, Issues for Congress, by (name redacted).

CRS-26

!

shall not be ineligible for USAID grants solely on the basis of health

or medical services provided with non-U.S. Government funds so

long as such services do not violate the laws of the country in which

they are provided or would not violate U.S. Federal law if provided

in this country.

It is generally held that under the Constitution, U.S. NGOs cannot be restricted from

using their own funds to advocate policy positions they support. The first new

condition would essentially extend that protection to foreign NGOs and multilateral

organizations. The second condition would not disqualify an organization from

receiving USAID grants for performing abortions with its own money if abortion or

whatever medical service it provided was legal in the country in which it operated,

and that the service would be legal in the United States if performed here.

H.R. 4811 made no change in current law, allowing the restrictions established

in the FY2000 appropriations to continue. During subcommittee markup, the Foreign

Operations panel rejected (7-8) an amendment by Representative Lowey to remove

the abortion restrictions from the bill. A similar amendment during full Committee

mark-up also failed 26-34, and, on the House floor, another amendment was rejected

(Greenwood, 206-221) that would have removed the restrictions. H.R. 4811 further

continued current conditions on UNFPA contributions. The bill provided $385

million for population assistance, far below the President’s $542 million request.

Based on reports of continuing coercive family planning practices in Peru, the House

measure required a series of new investigations and reports by USAID and its

Inspector General in an effort to strengthen application of the Tiahrt amendment, not

only in Peru, but in all countries where USAID maintains family planning programs.

Foreign Operations, as enacted, met the Administration’s requirement for

removal of the abortion-related restrictions, a policy, however, that has subsequently

been altered through executive action by President Bush. None of the $425 million

appropriation could be obligated until after February 15, 2001, a provision that

allowed the new President to decide which policy to apply. On January 22, 2001, two

days after taking office, President Bush issued a Memorandum to the USAID

Administrator rescinding the 1993 memorandum from President Clinton and directing

the Administrator to “reinstate in full all of the requirements of the Mexico City Policy

in effect on January 19, 1993.” The President further said that it was his “conviction

that taxpayer funds should not be used to pay for abortions or advocate or actively

promote abortion, either here or abroad.”15 A separate statement from the President’s

press secretary stated that President Bush was “committed to maintaining the $425

million funding level” for population assistance “because he knows that one of the

best ways to prevent abortion is by providing quality voluntary family planning

services.” The press secretary further emphasized that it was the intent that any

restrictions “do not limit organizations from treating injuries or illnesses caused by

15

White House. Memorandum for the Administrator of the United States Agency for

International Development.

January 22, 2001.

Found at

[http://www.whitehouse.gov/press/releases/20010123-5.html].

CRS-27

legal or illegal abortions, for example, post abortion care.”16 On February 15, the day

on which FY2001 population aid funds became available for obligation, USAID

issued specific policy language and contract clauses to implement the President’s

directive. The guidelines are nearly identical to those used in the 1980s and early

1990s when the Mexico City policy applied.17

For UNFPA, the FY2001 appropriations includes an earmark of $25 million, as

requested, but with the requirement that the amount will be reduced by however much

UNFPA spends in China. Conferees did not address the issue of coercive practices

in Peru or strengthening the Tiahrt provisions.

Regional Allocations of U.S. Foreign Aid

Although the Middle East has received by far the largest proportion of U.S.

assistance over the past three decades — 55-60% of bilateral aid appropriated in

Foreign Operations spending measures in most years — allocations to other regions

have fluctuated considerably, especially since the end of the Cold War. Asia, which

received substantial assistance in the 1980s associated with the presence of U.S.

military bases in the Philippines, had its share drop from 16% to 4% by the late 1990s.

Latin America, had its share fall from 16% to 6% following the end of conflict in

Central America in the early 1990s. Africa’s proportion has remained about the same

— 7 to 9% — a development that disappointed those who argued that the world’s

poorest region should receive higher priority, especially with the reduction in

emphasis on security assistance. U.S. aid to the emerging democracies and marketoriented economies in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union, where the United

States had no programs prior to 1990, grew to represent over 16% of American

bilateral assistance funded in the Foreign Operations bill by the end of the decade.

A number of observers, including some Members and congressional committees,

believed these shifts in regional aid allocations had swung too far. This was

particularly true in the cases of Asia and Latin America, given the Asian financial

crises and significant U.S. interests in promoting economic development in Latin

America in order to counter the trend of rising illegal immigration to the United

States. Foreign Operations appropriation measures in recent years have emphasized

the need to maintain or increase assistance especially to Latin America, and more

recently, to the Philippines, Thailand, and Indonesia which were most directly affected

by the regional economic downturn. Others argued that not enough has been

reallocated to Africa to meet the region’s unmet needs and to promote future U.S.African trade opportunities.

16

White House. Restoration of the Mexico City Policy. January 22, 2001. Found at

[http://www.whitehouse.gov/press/releases/20010123.html].

17

For more background on the Mexico City policy, see CRS Report RL30830, International

Family Planning: the Mexico City Policy. President Bush re-issued the Mexico City policy

guidelines on March 28 as an Executive memorandum. Some lawmakers introduced

legislation (S.J.Res. 9) to reverse the policy and have Congress take an early vote on the

USAID guidelines under the process allowed by the Congressional Review Act (CRA)

regarding agency rules and congressional review. The new White House memorandum would

not fall under the CRA.

CRS-28

When the share of bilateral Foreign Operations funding for the Middle East

exceeded 60%, some in Congress began promoting the view that there should be

some limits to the amount provided. If the Administration wanted to pursue new

Middle East peace initiatives using foreign aid as an implementing tool, they argued,

resources should be found either within existing Middle East programs or provided

on top of overall aid appropriations, rather than being taken from other regions.

Table 6. Regional Allocations of U.S. Aid

(In millions of dollars; % of bilateral total in Foreign Operations)

FY1999

Actual*

FY2000

Estimate**

FY2001

Request

$s

% of total

$s

% of total

$s

% of total

Africa

884

8.9%

899

7.6%

1,018

11.1%

Asia

367

3.7%

431

3.7%

568

6.2%

E. Europe/former Soviet

1,653

16.7%

1,586

13.4%

1,643

17.9%

Latin America

1,535

15.5%

1,786

15.1%

754

8.2%

Middle East

5,463

55.2%

7,103

60.2%

5,216

56.7%

Total, Bilateral Aid

9,902

100.0%

11,805

100.0%

9,199

100.0%

Source: USAID.

Amounts in the this table exclude food aid funded in the Agriculture

Appropriations measure.

* FY1999 includes Central America hurricane reconstruction ($613 million).

** FY2000 includes supplemental funding for Plan Colombia ($1.1 billion), Balkan aid ($50

million), and southern Africa flood relief ($25 million).

Accordingly, for FY1998 Congress took steps to legislate a cap on Foreign

Operations resources for the Middle East. At the initiative of Representative

Callahan, Chairman of the House Foreign Operations Subcommittee, lawmakers

stipulated in the FY1998 funding measure (Section 586 of P.L. 105-118) that selected

Middle East nations and regional programs could not receive more than $5.4 billion

of the total appropriation. For FY2000, the Middle East aid cap was lowered to $5.3

billion. Shortly after Congress initiated a Middle East aid ceiling, Israel put forth in

January 1998 a plan to cut aid received from the United States over the next 10 to 12

years. Under the Israeli plan, the United States would reduce economic aid by $120

million each year for about ten years, while increasing military assistance by $60

million annually. At the end of the period, Israel would be receiving an annual

appropriation of $2.4 billion in military aid but no longer receiving any economic

assistance. If done over a 10-year period, U.S. aid to Israel would fall $60 million

each year in net terms, with a total savings of $600 million by 2009. Since FY1999,

Congress has supported the $60 million net reduction of aid to Israel, also adding a

similar $40 million economic aid cut for Egypt.

The President’s FY2001 Foreign Operations request reflected several of these

regional allocation views expressed by Congress in recent years. Highlights of the

Administration’s recommendations included the following.

CRS-29

Creation of the Development Fund for Africa Account.18 After a 5year absence, the President proposed to re-establish a separate Foreign Operations

account for African aid and to increase bilateral funding (including economic and

military assistance) by 16% over FY2000 levels. In the late 1980s, Congress and the

Administration launched a joint initiative to create special legislative authority for U.S.

economic aid to Africa. The Development Fund for Africa (DFA — authorized in

Chapter 10 of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961) was intended to extend more

flexibility to USAID program managers and to protect aid resources for Africa from

being transferred to other regions as new foreign policy crises unfolded. At its peak,

the United States channeled about $800 million annually through the DFA.

Although the DFA authorization law remained in force, Congress ended the

practice of a direct DFA appropriation in FY1996, funding Africa’s assistance out of

worldwide development aid and child survival accounts. Following President

Clinton’s visit to Africa in 1998, during which he pledged to restore U.S. aid to higher

levels provided in previous years, the Administration proposed a direct DFA

appropriation account for FY2000. Congress rejected the DFA recommendation but

approved sufficient development funds so that Africa’s level grew from $703 million

in FY1999 to $737 million estimated for FY2000.

The FY2001 request once again sought the restoration of the DFA account, that

when combined with child survival funds would allocate $836 million to Africa, an

increase of $99 million. Although some of the additional assistance would support

the HIV/AIDS initiative, family planning and other health activities would receive

substantial increases. The request for activities financed under the Economic Support

Fund, an aid account used for political and security purposes, rose by one-third over

FY2000, largely for democracy and economic growth initiatives for countries in

transition. Military aid would have grown from about $20 million in FY2000 to $27

million, with the largest increase for stabilizing regional security situations through the

promotion of democratic transition within the militaries of countries such as Nigeria,

and to assist African forces participate in regional peacekeeping operations. Nigeria,

which is one of the State Department’s four worldwide aid “focus” countries for

FY2001 (along with Ukraine, Indonesia, and Colombia) would be the largest ($81

million) African recipient of economic and military assistance (excluding food aid),

followed by Uganda ($54 million), Mozambique ($47 million), and Ethiopia ($41

million).

Increased Funding for Asia. The FY2001 foreign aid budget proposed

significant increases in assistance programs throughout the Asian region. The $568

million requested was nearly $137 million, or 32% higher than allocations for

FY2000. This follows a 17% increase in FY2000 year for Asia compared with

FY1999. The higher amounts would be drawn in roughly equal levels between

development and ESF accounts. Of particular priority were economic growth

programs aimed at helping economic recovery in southeast Asia. Indonesia, another

of the Administration’s four aid “focus” countries, would be by far the largest

recipient of U.S. economic assistance ($130 million). Another $10 million was

18

For more details on U.S. assistance to Africa, see CRS Issue Brief IB95052, Africa: U.S.

Foreign Assistance Issues, by Raymond Copson.

CRS-30

scheduled for East Timor. India ($72 million), Bangladesh ($69 million), and the

Philippines ($45 million) follow as other leading economic aid recipients in the region.

For each of these three, the FY2001 proposed allocations were roughly 50% higher

than those for FY2000.

Modest Increases for Most Latin America Programs; Major

Counternarcotics Initiative for Colombia. Aid allocations for Latin America

surged in FY1999, largely due to the $613 million emergency relief package approved

to aid the victims of Hurricane Mitch that struck Central America in late 1998.

Assistance to the region increased again for FY2000 due to a $1.1 billion add-on for

counternarcotics in Colombia. For FY2001, regular economic, anti-drug, and military

assistance for Latin America would total $754 million. Counternarcotics aid

continued to be a primary focus of assistance to Latin America, accounting for 29%

of total resources in the FY2001 request.

Overshadowing continuing Latin American aid programs has been the

FY2000/2001 $1.1 billion counternarcotics initiative for Colombia and other drugproducing nations in the region. (Including resources requested from Defense and

Justice Department budgets, “Plan Colombia,” as the initiative has been labeled, totals

$1.272 billion over two years.) The major, and arguably most controversial,

component ($600 million) of the initiative is “Push into Southern Colombia,” designed

to help the Colombian government extend anti-drug efforts throughout southern

Colombia where coca cultivation is expanding and where Colombian guerrillas

operate. This would include training and equipping two new army counternarcotics

battalions and purchasing Black Hawk and Huey helicopters to transport them. On

June 29, Congress cleared for the White House (P.L. 106-246) a $1.3 billion

supplemental for Colombia ($1.1 billion in Foreign Operations funds) that closely

matched the President’s funding request but imposed a number of policy changes and

conditions on the assistance.19

Peru and Bolivia, each scheduled to receive $98 million in FY2001, top the list

of Latin American aid recipients. Haiti ($51 million) and Guatemala ($50 million)

were also prominent aid recipients planned for FY2001. Colombia, however, has

emerged in recent years as one of the main benefactors of U.S. assistance worldwide,

representing the fifth largest recipient in FY1999 behind Israel, Egypt, Jordan, and

Ukraine. With passage of the counternarcotics initiative, Colombia has become the

third top aid recipient worldwide for FY2000.

Middle East Aid Reduced Slightly for FY2001. The President’s FY2001

foreign aid request for the Middle East reduced slightly – from $5.278 billion to

$5.216 billion – U.S. assistance to the region when compared with regular programs

for FY2000 (excluding Wye River accord funding). This is largely the result of

continuing for the third year a ten-year plan to downsize aid to Israel and Egypt. The

$2.82 billion for Israel would be $60 million less than earmarked for FY2000, and the

19

For more on Plan Colombia, see CRS Report RS20451, Colombia: Fact Sheet on U.S.

Assistance and Legislation, by Nina Serafino.

CRS-31

$1.996 billion for Egypt was $40 million below FY2000 levels.20 Enactment for

FY2000 of a one-time, $1.8 billion Wye River/Middle East peace accord aid package

supporting Israel, Jordan, and the Palestinians, pushed total Middle East aid levels far

higher in that year. No equivalent initiative was proposed for FY2001.21 Palestinian

assistance in FY2001 was scheduled for $100 million, up from the FY2000 $85

million regular program.

Another element of the FY2001 Middle East recommendation concerned

Egypt’s request to receive part of its military assistance early in the fiscal year rather

than over a much longer period of time as payments become due for defense

purchases. For a number of years, Congress has directed that economic and military

aid for Israel be disbursed within the first month of a new fiscal year, allowing Israel

to invest the funds and earn interest prior to using the money to service debt owed to

the United States and make payments on military procurements. Last year, the

Administration asked Congress to allow Egypt to receive $475 million in “early

disbursements,” an action that would have increased Foreign Operations outlays by

an equivalent amount. With extremely tight limits on outlays for FY2000, the

Appropriation Committees could not accommodate the request. Instead, however,

Congress added $25 million for Egypt under the Wye River aid package, an amount

roughly equal to the interest Egypt would have gained from an early disbursement.

For FY2001, the Administration proposed a somewhat different mechanism to

achieve the same purpose: that Egypt receive by October 31, 2000 (or within 30 days

of enactment of the appropriation, whichever is later) the amount of military aid that

OMB estimates will be disbursed to Egypt throughout FY2001. Egypt would place

the funds in an interest-bearing account at the Federal Reserve, and earn about $25

to $30 million during the course of the year. The advantage of this plan from a

budget standpoint was that it would not increase outlays over current projections.

Flat Budget Request for Russia and Other Former Soviet States;

Increase for Kosovo. After several years of disputes between Congress and the

President over proposals to sharply increase assistance to Russia and the other nations

comprising the former Soviet region, the Administration’s FY2001 request of $830

million for economic assistance was nearly identical to amounts allocated for FY2000.

Distribution among recipients, however, changed somewhat from FY2000. Russia’s

bilateral aid would fall from $178 million to $162 million, while Ukraine, another

Administration aid “focus” country, would see its assistance rise from $160 million

to $171 million. U.S. assistance to Armenia and Georgia, countries which have

received higher levels in the past because of congressional earmarks, would be cut in

20

Because of a 0.38% across-the-board rescission for FY2000, aid to Israel and Egypt was

reduced slightly below what was earmarked in the Foreign Operations Appropriations, 2000.

The cuts in aid proposed for FY2001 are actually somewhat less after deducting the FY2000

rescission amounts.

21

However, on November 14, 2000, shortly after signing the FY2001 Foreign Operations

Appropriations bill, President Clinton sent to Congress a $750 million supplemental request,

including $450 million for Israel’s withdrawal from southern Lebanon and its strategic missile

defense, $225 million for Egypt to enhance its defense capabilities, and $75 million in

economic and military aid for Jordan. Congress, however, did not approve the supplemental

prior to adjourning for the year.

CRS-32

FY2001, to $75 million and $86 million, respectively. These reductions, as well as

those for Russia and Moldova, would be offset by increases for most other former

Soviet states, with Azerbaijan growing from $31 million to $55 million.22

Table 7. Leading Recipients of U.S. Foreign Aid: FY1999 FY2001

(Appropriation Allocations; $s in millions)

FY1999

Actual

FY2000

Allocation

FY2001

Estimate

Israel

2,940

4,069*

2,820

Egypt

2,076

2,054*

1,988

Colombia

210

894

48

Jordan

298

427*

226

Ukraine

212

179

176

Russia

165

188

169

Kosovo

80

165

150

Indonesia

58

95

123

Georgia

93

112

97

Armenia

81

103

90

Peru

109

115

86

Bosnia

197

101

85

West Bank/Gaza

75

485*

85

Bolivia

91

195

81

Nigeria

24

58

81

India

45

49

59

Bangladesh

48

49

57

*Includes regular amounts for Israel, Egypt, Jordan, and the Palestinians, plus the Wye River peace

accord: Israel–$1.2 billion; Egypt–$25 million; Jordan–$200 million; Palestinians–$400 million.

** Once allocated, FY2000 supplemental funds will increase amounts for these countries.

Note: Data exclude food aid, a program not appropriated in the Foreign Operations bill. With food

aid included, the rank order above would change somewhat. Food aid for FY2001 includes Peru–$30

million; India–$92 million; Bangladesh–$43 million; and Bolivia–$22 million. Moreover, because

of a large food aid programs, Ethiopia and Haiti would also rank among the lower 5 of this top 17

list.

For other former eastern bloc and European countries, the FY2001 request

proposed an increase of $57 million, or 10% in economic aid, primarily to extend

additional support to Kosovo, Croatia, and Montenegro. Foreign Military Financing

grants would nearly double to $95 million, with levels for new NATO members

22

For more information, see CRS Issue Brief IB95077, The Former Soviet Union and U.S.

Foreign Assistance, by (name redacted).

CRS-33

Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic rising by 50%. Partnership for Peace countries

were scheduled to receive $62 million in FMF grants for FY2001, up from $33 million

in FY2000. 23

Congressional Action. House, Senate, and enacted bills for FY2001 made

several changes to the Administration’s regional and country aid proposals.

Africa. Congress rejected the President’s request to re-instate the Development

Fund for Africa, as requested, but funds development programs for sub-Saharan

Africa out of the worldwide development assistance and child survival accounts.

Because Congress increased health and child survival funding levels, most of which

target Africa, and made only modest cuts for other bilateral development spending,

Africa development aid allocation of $794 million fell close to but below the proposed

$837 million level. The House-passed bill had required USAID to allocate the same

proportion of development aid to Africa in FY2001 that it did for FY2000. Although

the conference report made no mention of this requirement, if applied to the enacted

development assistance funding totals, Africa would have received about $900 million

in FY2001.

Asia. Based on initial Administration aid allocations, Asia will receive slightly

more – about $600 million of the funds in P.L. 106-429 – than what had been

requested. The enacted measure further includes directives for specific countries and

activities.

23

!

Burma – directs that $6.5 million, as requested, be provided to

Burmese exiles and refugees for education, health care, and political

initiatives.

!

Cambodia – recommends $20 million (up from $16.8 million

requested) addressing HIV/AIDS, education, and environmental

needs, but avoiding direct assistance to the central government.

!

Indonesia – earmarks $5 million for economic rehabilitation in the

Aceh region, and encourages USAID to support economic

restructuring and decentralization programs throughout Indonesia,

and especially in the Moluccas.

!

East Timor – earmarks $25 million for reconstruction and incomegenerating projects, higher than the $10 million request.

!

North Korea – urges the State Department to support $250,000 for

South Korean NGOs involved in democratization efforts in North

Korea. This would be in addition to the $55 million approved for the

Korean Energy Development Organization (KEDO).

For more information, see CRS Report RL30453, Kosovo: Reconstruction and

Development Assistance, by (name redacted).

CRS-34

Latin America. H.R. 4811, as enacted, limits additional assistance to the

Haitian government until the Secretary of State reports that Haiti has held free and

fair elections to seat a new parliament. The House bill had placed high priority on

Latin American funding levels, directing that the Administration allocate at least the

same amounts in FY2001 for the region as it did for FY2000. Conferees, however,

did not discuss this issue. Initial allocations for Latin America, excluding

counternarcotics aid, suggest that the region will be slightly higher than for FY2000

but about $10 million less than the $750 million request.

Middle East. The enacted FY2001 Foreign Operations spending bill continues

the 10-year phased reduction in aid to Israel and Egypt, as proposed, and authorizes

that a portion of Egypt’s military assistance be transferred to an interest bearing

account. H.R. 4811 also directs that $25 million be provided for programs benefitting

the Iraqi people, $12 million of which must go for food, medicine, and other

humanitarian purposes.

Israel’s planned $250 million sale to China of an airborne early warning aircraft

became a significant issue during House Committee consideration of the

appropriations measure. Because of the proposed transfer of the Phalcon airborne

radar system, delivery of which was expected in October 2001, Chairman Callahan

offered a provision withholding $250 million in FY2001 aid to Israel until the

Secretary of State certified that the sale was terminated or it did not pose a national

security threat. The amendment was defeated (6-9). Chairman Callahan proposed the

same amendment at full Committee markup, but the House panel approved a

substitute amendment expressing the “sense” of Congress that the China sale could

threaten both Taiwan and the United States and urged Israel to terminate the sale.24

On July 12, Israel announced it had cancelled the sale.

Independent States of the Former Soviet Union and East Europe.

As enacted, H.R. 4811 reduces slightly – to $810 million – the former Soviet aid

account, representing an increase from the $775 million and $635 million passed

earlier by the Senate and House, respectively. Amounts for Eastern Europe are set

at $600 million, about mid-way between House and Senate-passed levels. These

regional totals have resulted in higher allocations for Croatia, Montenegro, and Serbia

than requested, but reductions for several former Soviet states including Azerbaijan,

Kyrgystan, and Moldova. The Administration allocated slightly more to Russia –

$168 million – than had been requested, although the level is down from $187 million

in FY2000. The legislation includes several country earmarks that set funding at or

above amounts proposed by the President:

Ukraine – $170 million, down slightly from the $173.5 million

request.

! Armenia – $90 million, up from the $75 million proposal.

! Georgia – $92 million, higher than the $85.8 million request.

!

24

For more discussion of this issue, see CRS Report RS20583, Israel’s Sale of Airborne

Early Warning Aircraft System to China, by Clyde Mark.

CRS-35

Unlike the Senate bill, the conference agreement does not earmark funds for

Montenegro or Croatia, but encourages the Administration to allocate at least $89

million for Montenegro and $65.7 million for Croatia. These totals would include

regular FY2001 funding, plus portions of the $75.8 million Congress also approved

for the Balkans that had earlier been considered but rejected as an FY2000

supplemental. Lawmakers also added $34 million in military aid for the region that

had also been proposed as an FY2000 supplemental. Reflecting recent changes in the

political leadership of Serbia, the bill provides that up to $100 million in assistance

may be used for Serbia. Nevertheless, the funds cannot be obligated after March 31,

2001, unless Congress is notified that the Yugoslav government is cooperating with

the International Criminal Tribunal regarding the investigation and transfer of indicted

war criminals.

For other countries, H.R. 4811 limits aid allocations or attaches conditions that must

be met prior to distributing the funds:

!

Russia – maintains conditions on aid to Russia if it does not terminate

sales of nuclear reactor and related technology to Iran, and adds a

new condition withholding assistance if Russia is not cooperating

with international investigations of war crimes in Chechnya or

providing access to Chechnyan refugees. These conditions affect

60%, rather than last year’s 50%, of aid allocated to the Russian

central government.

!

Kosovo – no assistance can be made available for Kosovo until the

Secretary of State certifies that U.S. obligations and expenditures of

funds do not exceed 15% of total amounts from all donors.

!

Bosnia – limits to $80 million ($90 million requested) FY2001

assistance.

Debt Reduction Initiatives for Poor Countries25

Providing debt relief to poor developing nations that borrowed in the past from

the United States, other creditor governments, and international financial institutions

emerged as one of the key foreign aid issues in 1999 and continued as a White House

priority in 2000. At the Cologne Summit in June 1999, G-7 leaders endorsed a

substantial expansion of the Heavily Indebted Poor Country (HIPC) Initiative largely

along the lines of policy changes recommended by the United States and Britain. The

World Bank and IMF, institutions that manage HIPC debt relief, adopted these

enhancements in September. In late 1999, Congress approved some of the legislation

requested by the Administration for full U.S. participation in HIPC, but left several

matters incomplete, primarily those associated with the cancellation of multilateral

25

For more extensive analysis of debt relief issues, see CRS Report RL30214, Debt

Reduction: Initiatives for the Most Heavily Indebted Poor Countries, by (nameredacted);and

CRS Report RL30449, Debt and Developing in Poor Countries: Rethinking Policy

Responses, by (name redacted).

CRS-36

debts. In 2000, the White House sought congressional approval for authorizing and

appropriating issues left over from 1999.

For the past decade, the United States has engaged in various forms of debt relief

for developing nations, resulting in the cancellation of about $14.7 billion of foreign

debt. Much of it — $10.1 billion — resulted from special cases involving key U.S.

national interests: for Egypt in 1990 ($7 billion), for Poland in 1991 ($2.5 billion), and

for Jordan in 1995 ($635 million). U.S. debt reduction policy for other nations based

strictly on need has been guided by the principle that eligible countries must have

demonstrated a strong and sustained commitment to economic policy reforms prior

to receiving debt relief. Under budget rules instituted in 1992, Congress has had to

appropriate funds in advance representing the costs of canceling debt. The cost

determination methodology is based on a complicated formula that takes into account,

among other things, the loan’s net present value, its interest rate, and the likelihood

the loan will be repaid. For especially poor countries with particularly large debt

overhangs, the appropriation requirement may be quite small relative to the loan’s

face value — perhaps 10% or less.

When it was introduced in 1996, HIPC was hailed as the first arrangement that

included relief from debts owed to the World Bank, the IMF, and other international

institutions, organizations that hold over 25% of debt owed by the most heavily

indebted nations. Previously, multilateral organizations had declined to participate in

debt cancellation, arguing that it would increase their costs of raising new money to

lend, expenses that would have to be passed on to borrowers. Forty-one countries

— mostly in Africa — are eligible for HIPC, although only those determined to have

“unsustainable” debt would qualify for HIPC terms.

The initial HIPC framework came under heavy criticism in early 1999, especially

among non-governmental organizations and religious groups working in developing

countries. They charged that HIPC terms were not deep enough — that 90% or

100% of bilateral debt owed should be canceled, and that six years was a far too long

qualification period for full HIPC relief. They further believed that the nonsustainable debt criteria, based largely on a ratio of a country’s debt-to-exports, was

too high and therefore excluded many countries that were also in need of debt relief.

Some critics opposed the economic reform requirements and argued for unconditional

debt reduction. A number of organizations further advocated instituting mechanisms

that would ensure that savings realized by debtor governments would be channeled

into spending on basic services, such as health and education, that would improve the

quality of life of the very poor. Many of these arguments were reflected in legislative

initiatives launched in 1999, including H.R. 1095 (Debt Relief Poverty Reduction Act

of 1999), H.R. 772 (Hope for Africa Act), H.R. 2232 (Debt Relief and Development

in Africa Act of 1999), and S. 1690 (Debt Relief for Poor Countries Act of 1999).

Complicating the expansion of HIPC and enactment of these bills, however, was the

large additional costs that would be associated with efforts to broaden, deepen, and

accelerate HIPC or U.S. bilateral debt reduction policies.

Following agreement to expand HIPC and insert a strong poverty reduction

requirement, President Clinton amended in September 1999 his pending FY2000

foreign aid request, increasing debt relief from $120 million to nearly $1 billion over

four years. Congress agreed to $123 million for bilateral debt cancellation at the Paris

CRS-37

Club in 2000 but rejected the $600 million proposed for HIPC Trust Fund

contributions, FY2000-FY2003 (H.R. 3422, as incorporated into P.L. 106-113).26

The President had also asked Congress to allow the United States to support an IMF

plan to draw on resources in a contingency fund and to re-value some of its gold

holdings at current prices through an off-market gold sale that would allow the IMF

to cancel HIPC debts owed to the Fund.27 Congress authorized the use of the

contingency fund but placed a restriction that the IMF could only use 9/14ths of the

gold transaction “profits” for HIPC debt relief (H.R. 3425, as incorporated into P.L.

106-113).

Legislative Issues in 2000. The Administration asked Congress to approve

items carried over from 1999:

HIPC Trust Fund $210 million contribution as an FY2000

supplemental appropriation;

! HIPC bilateral and multilateral debt relief request of $225 million for

FY2001;

! Tropical forestry debt relief initiative of $37 million;

! HIPC bilateral and multilateral debt relief advance appropriation

(FY2002/2003) of $375 million;

! Authorization for the U.S. to participate in the HIPC Trust Fund; and

! Authorization permitting the U.S. to support the full use of the IMF

for gold transaction profits for debt relief.

!

Administration officials were especially concerned about appropriations for the HIPC

Trust Fund contribution. They argue that the absence of a U.S. payment had

convinced other creditor governments to hold back their own pledges until the U.S.

acted. They further contended that while most of the existing Trust Fund pledges

were earmarked for African nations that would be among the earliest qualifiers,

resources for Latin American debt relief – for Bolivia and Honduras – were not

available. Without a U.S. contribution, they said, a debt workout for Bolivia had been

delayed because of inadequate resources. Critics of multilateral debt relief, including

26

The HIPC Initiative has two major components: cancellation of bilateral debt owed to the

United States and other creditor governments, and reduction of debt owed to the World Bank,

the IMF, and other regional IFIs. Creditor governments cover their own expenses individually

for the forgiveness of bilateral debt at the Paris Club, an informal arena for negotiating debt

reschedulings and reduction of publicly held loans. To finance the cancellation of multilateral

debts, the World Bank and IMF created the HIPC Trust Fund into which IFIs and aid donor

governments would deposit contributions. The Bank and the Fund will cover their own costs,

but other IFIs – especially the African Development Bank – do not have enough resources to

cover the losses of cancelled loan repayments. Donor governments have agreed to make up

the gap for those IFIs with insufficient funds.

27

The actual process by which the gold was re-valued involved several steps. First, the gold,

which is carried on the IMF books at the original price of $48 per ounce, was purchased at

current market value (over $270 per ounce) by a member country about to make a large

payment on an IMF loan. After buying the gold, the country immediately made its loan

payment to the IMF, but in gold that it just purchased, rather than hard currency. The IMF

invests the “profits” of its gold transaction in a security instrument and uses the earned interest

to pay for the costs of canceling HIPC debt over a 20-year period.

CRS-38

some in Congress, argued, however, that before the U.S. contributes to the Trust

Fund, multilateral institutions should agree to suspend new lending to HIPC countries

for a period of time once they received debt relief so that they would not return to a

severely indebted state.

Congressional Action. Prior to consideration of the FY2001 Foreign

Operations spending measure, lawmakers dealt with other aspects of the HIPC

requests. In the FY2000 supplemental appropriation (H.R. 4425), Congress rejected

the President’s request for the HIPC Trust Fund. Supporting other Administration

requests, however, the Senate Foreign Relations Committee reported on April 7

legislation (S. 2382) authorizing U.S. participation in the HIPC Trust Fund and U.S.

approval of the entire IMF off-market gold sale mechanism. That bill, after referral

to the Senate Banking Committee, did not receive full Senate consideration.

S. 2522 provided $75 million in debt reduction for FY2001, far below the

combined FY2000/2001 requests for $472 million. The legislation permitted the

Administration to use the resources for either bilateral debt relief or contributions to

the HIPC Trust Fund. Because several HIPC countries were nearing consideration

for HIPC eligibility, it was possible that reduced funding in S. 2522, if enacted at that

level, would have resulted in further delays for debt workout negotiations.

H.R. 4811 provided $238 million for debt reduction. The House Appropriations

Committee bill had provided $82.4 million for debt reduction, well under the

Administration’s request. During floor debate, however, the House adopted an

amendment (Waters, 216-211) that increased the debt relief allocation by $155.6

million. As reported by the Committee, however, H.R. 4811 required that before any

U.S. contribution to the HIPC Trust Fund, the Administration must report to

Congress that the HIPC beneficiary country would not receive any new market-rate

loans from international financial institutions for 30 months or concessional loans for

9 months. The Administration opposed these limitations. The House Committee

expressed support for economic reforms undertaken by Bolivia and Mozambique, and

its expectation that all of the debt reduction funds for HIPC would go to these two

countries. The House measure further indicated that $13 million of the debt reduction

appropriation was reserved for the Tropical Forestry debt initiative.

The enacted bill provides a total of $448 million for debt reduction, consisting

of $435 million for HIPC (the combined FY2000 supplemental and FY2001 regular

request) and $13 million for the Tropical Forestry initiative. Of the HIPC funds,

roughly $75 million will be used for bilateral debt relief and $360 million as a Trust

Fund contribution. Countries which will receive benefits from U.S. contributions

must first agree not to borrow at market rate terms for two years. The limitation on

concessional financing, as passed by the House, was dropped from the conference

agreement. Instead, conferees endorsed consideration of a policy in which the World

Bank’s International Development Association would expand grant assistance to

HIPC countries. The legislation further includes new reporting requirements

regarding implementation of the HIPC initiative that will allow Congress to monitor

actions taken in the coming year more closely.

P.L. 106-429 does not, however, approve the full U.S. pledged commitment to

the HIPC initiative. The Administration is asking Congress in the FY2002 Foreign

CRS-39

Operations budget for an additional $224 million HIPC Trust Fund contribution.

Because Congress authorized in H.R. 4811 only $435 million of the total $600 million

Trust Fund pledge, additional authority may be sought in the 107th Congress.

CRS-40

For Additional Reading

Foreign Operations Programs

CRS Issue Brief IB88093. Drug Control: International Policy, by Raphael Perl.

CRS Report RL30830. International Family Planning: The “Mexico City” Policy,

by (name redacted).

CRS Issue Brief IB96008. Multilateral Development Banks: Issues for the 106th

Congress, by Jonathan Sanford.

CRS Issue Brief IB86116. U.N. System Funding, by (name redacted).

CRS Issue Brief IB96026. U.S. International Population Assistance: Issues for

Congress, by (name redacted).

Foreign Operations Country/Regional Issues

CRS Issue Brief IB95052. Africa: U.S. Foreign Assistance Issues, by Raymond

Copson.

CRS Issue Brief IB95077. The Former Soviet Union and U.S. Foreign Assistance,

by (name redacted).

CRS Issue Brief IB85066. Israel: U.S. Foreign Assistance, by Clyde Mark.

CRS Issue Brief IB91141. North Korea’s Nuclear Weapons Program, by Larry

Niksch.

CRS-41

Selected World Wide Web Sites

Asian Development Bank

[http://www.asiandevbank.org/]

CRS Current Legislative Issues: Foreign Affairs

[http://www.crs.gov/products/browse/is-foreignaffairs.shtml]

Export-Import Bank

[http://www.exim.gov/]

Inter-American Development Bank

[http://www.iadb.org/]

International Monetary Fund

[http://www.imf.org/]

Peace Corps

[http://www.peacecorps.gov/]

Trade and Development Agency

[http://www.tda.gov/]

United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF)

[http://www.unicef.org/]

United Nations Development Program (UNDP)

[http://www.undp.org/]

United National Population Fund (UNFPA)

[http://www.unfpa.org/]

U.S. Agency for International Development

[http://www.info.usaid.gov/]

U.S. Department of State

[http://www.state.gov/]

World Bank

[http://www.worldbank.org/]

World Bank HIPC website

[http://www.worldbank.org/hipc/]

CRS-42

Appendix — Detailed Foreign Operations Accounts

Table 8. Foreign Operations Appropriations:

Discretionary Budget Authority

(millions of dollars)

FY2000

Enacteda

FY2001

Request

Senate

FY2001

House

FY2001

FY2001

Enacted*

Title I - Export and Investment Assistance:

Export-Import Bank

799.00

1,011.0

811.0

782.5

912.0

Overseas Private Investment Corp.

(244.0)

(220.0)

(221.0)

(222.0)

(221.0)

Trade & Development Agency

44.0

54.0

46.0

46.0

50.0

Total, Title I - Export Aid

599.0

845.0

636.0

606.5

741.0

727.5

769.3

–

886.0

963.0

984.8

1,478.3

1,258.0

1,305.0

Program

Title II - Bilateral Economic:

Development Assistance:b

Child Survival/Disease/UNICEF

Development Asst Fund

Development Fund for Africa

1,215.5

c

c

[512.5]

532.9

–

–

–

–

–

691.0

–

–

1,943.0

2,337.0

2,169.3

2,144.0

2,268.0

[110.0]

[372.5]

[175.0]

–

[5.0]

[14.4]

202.9

[110.0]

[484.0]

[244.0]

[50.0]

[20.0]

[16.0]

220.0

[110.0]

[425.0]

[255.0]

[50.0]

–

[14.4]

220.0

[110.0]

[385.0]

[254.0]

[37.5]

[10.0]

[16.0]

165.0

[110.0]

[425.0]

[300.0]

[50.0}

[12.0]

[16.0]

165.0

Southern Africa flood supp.

25.0

175.0d

35.0d

160.0d

135.0d

Transition Initiatives

[40.5]e

[55.0]e

–e

40.0

50.0

Development Credit Programs

8.5

8.0

4.0

10.0

7.5

Subtotal, Development Aid

2,179.4

2,740.0

2,428.3

2,519.0

2,625.5

520.0

520.0

510.0

509.0

520.0

Global Health

Subtotal

Of which:

UNICEF

Population aid

HIV/AIDS

GAVI contribution

Inter-American Foundation

African Develop. Foundation

International Disaster Aid

USAID Operating Expenses

USAID Op. Exp. supplemental

–

22.0

–

–

13.0d

USAID Inspector General

25.0

27.0

25.0

27.0

27.0

2,345.5

2,313.0

2,220.0

2,208.9

2,295.0

450.0

–

–

–

–

g

Economic Support Fund (ESF)

f

ESF-Wye River Accord

International Fund for Ireland

d

g

19.6

[19.6]

–

25.0

25.0

a

535.0

610.0

635.0

535.0

600.0

Kosovo/Balkans supplemental

50.0

d

145.0

–

–

75.8d

Former Soviet Union (IS/FSU)

839.0

830.0

775.0

740.0

810.0

Treasury Dept. technical asst

1.5

7.0

5.0

2.0

6.0

East Europe

CRS-43

Program

FY2000

Enacteda

FY2001

Request

123.0

262.0

Debt reduction

d

Senate

FY2001

House

FY2001

FY2001

Enacted*

75.0

238.0

238.0

Debt reduction supplemental

–

210.0

–

–

210.0d

US Community Adjustment Credit

10.0

10.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

Peace Corps

245.0

275.0

244.0

258.0

265.0

International Narcotics

305.0

312.0

220.0

305.0

325.0

1,018.5

—

h

—

—

—

Migration & refugee asst

625.0

658.2

615.0

645.0

700.0

Emergency Refugee Fund (ERMA)

12.5

20.0

15.0

12.5

15.0

Non-Proliferation/anti-terrorism

216.6

352.7

215.0

241.6

311.6

Total Title II-Bilateral Economic

9,520.6

9,313.9

7,982.3

8,266.0

9,061.9

Title III - Military Assistance:

Intl Military Education & Training

50.0

55.0

55.0

47.3

55.0

Intl Mil Ed/Training Supplemental

–

2.9d

–

–

2.9d

3,519.0

3,268.0

h

Intl Narcotics – Plan Colombia

Foreign Mil Financing (FMF)

3,420.0

3,538.2

3,545.0

–

31.0

–

–

31.0d

1,375.0

–

–

–

–

Special Defense Acquisition Fund

(6.0)

–

–

–

–

Peacekeeping Operations

153.0

134.0

85.0

117.9

127.0

–

(18.2)

–

–

–

4,992.0

3,742.9

3,659.0

3,433.2

3,760.9

World Bank-Intl DevelopmentAssn

775.0

835.6

750.0

566.6

775.0

World Bank-Environment Facility

35.8

175.6

50.0

35.8

108.0

World Bank-Mult Invst Guaranty

4.0

16.0

4.0

4.9

10.0

Inter-American Development Bank

41.6

59.9

10.0

18.0

35.0

Asian Development Bank

90.7

125.0

100.0

72.0

72.0

African Development Fund

128.0

100.0

72.0

72.0

100.0

African Development Bank

4.1

6.1

6.1

3.1

6.1

European Bank for R & D

35.8

35.8

35.8

35.8

35.8

Intl Fund for Ag Development

[5.0]i

[5.0]i

[5.0]i

5.0

5.0

j

j

j

FMF supplemental

FMF-Wye River Accord f

FMF loans rescission

Total, Title III-Military Aid

d

Title IV - Multilateral Economic Aid:

Intl Organizations & Programs

183.0

196.0

178.0

183.0

186.0j

Total, Title IV - Multilateral

1,298.0

1,550.0

1,205.9

996.2

1,332.9

TOTAL, Foreign Operations k

16,409.6

15,451.8

13,459.2

13,301.9

14,896.7

TOTAL, without FY2000 Supps.

13,491.1

15,451.8

13,459.2

13,301.9

14,896.7

CRS-44

* NOTE: Pursuant to the Consolidated Appropriations Act, FY2001 (H.R. 4577), signed into law on Dec. 21, 2000,

most FY2001 appropriation bills, including Foreign Operations, are reduced by 0.22%. For Foreign Operations,

there will be a cut of about $33 million from the $14.897 billion enacted level.

a. FY2000 enacted includes $1.1 billion in supplemental FY2000 Foreign Operations funds approved in P.L. 106-246

(H.R. 4425).

b. The account structure for development aid differs among versions of the bill. This table shows a consistent and

comparable account structure based on the FY2001 conference agreement. For the Administration’s request,

this means adding amounts to development aid for the Inter-American and African Development Foundations,

GAVI, and UNICEF, which are requested in other accounts. For the Senate it means the addition of $110

million for UNICEF which S. 2522 funded under the International Organizations account in title IV.

c. For FY2001, the Administration requested a separate account under development aid for Africa (the Development

Fund for Africa, or DFA). Africa aid is also proposed within the Child Survival account. The total amount

requested for Africa — DFA plus Africa/Child Survival — is $837 million. This compares to $738 million

appropriated for Africa in FY2000 within the Child Survival and Development Assistance Fund accounts.

d. Initially requested and/or approved by the House or Senate as an FY2000 emergency supplemental appropriation.

Included in Title VI of P.L. 106-429 as an emergency FY2001 appropriation.

e. Transition Initiative funds included in Disaster Assistance account for FY2000, FY2001 request, and Senate

FY2001 bill. Approved by the House and enacted for FY2001 as a separate account.

f. Congress approved for FY2000 a one-time supplemental ESF ($450 million) and FMF ($1.375 billion) package

supporting the Wye River/Middle East peace accord with aid for Israel, Jordan, and the Palestinians.

g. The Administration request and Senate bill included the Ireland Fund as part of the Economic Support Fund.

h. FY2000 supplemental enacted in P.L. 106-246. The President’s FY2001 request included $256 million for Plan

Colombia. Congress incorporated portions of the follow-on $256 million FY2001 Plan Colombia proposal in

the FY2000 supplemental. Because additional Plan Colombia funding had already been accommodated and was

not part of the final FY2001 debate, the $256 million has been removed from the President’s FY2001 request.

i. IFAD was funded in FY2000, FY2001 request and the Senate bill out of development assistance and international

organizations and programs accounts. The House and FY2001 enacted bills established IFAD as a separate

account.

j. For comparative purposes and to conform to the account structure enacted for FY2000 and FY2001, UNICEF funds

($110 million) have been deducted here and added in the development aid subtotal in title II. The

Administration’s $50 million FY2001 request for GAVI has also been shifted from here to title II, as enacted.

k. Pursuant to sequestration requirements in P.L. 106-113, the amounts for FY2000 are reduced by $19 million.

EveryCRSReport.com

The Congressional Research Service (CRS) is a federal legislative branch agency, housed inside the

Library of Congress, charged with providing the United States Congress non-partisan advice on

issues that may come before Congress.

EveryCRSReport.com republishes CRS reports that are available to all Congressional staff. The

reports are not classified, and Members of Congress routinely make individual reports available to

the public.

Prior to our republication, we redacted names, phone numbers and email addresses of analysts

who produced the reports. We also added this page to the report. We have not intentionally made

any other changes to any report published on EveryCRSReport.com.

CRS reports, as a work of the United States government, are not subject to copyright protection in

the United States. Any CRS report may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without

permission from CRS. However, as a CRS report may include copyrighted images or material from a

third party, you may need to obtain permission of the copyright holder if you wish to copy or

otherwise use copyrighted material.

Information in a CRS report should not be relied upon for purposes other than public

understanding of information that has been provided by CRS to members of Congress in

connection with CRS' institutional role.

EveryCRSReport.com is not a government website and is not affiliated with CRS. We do not claim

copyright on any CRS report we have republished.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.